#Pink Floyd
184 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
- Animals
- Wish you were here
- Dark side
- Meddle
- Atom heart mother
i just wanna say i listened to wish you were here for the first time yesterday
that is one of the best things i have ever heard in my lifetime ngl
“and then one day you’ll find 10 years have got behind you, no one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun” has got to be one of the saddest lyrics ever written
that line is incredibly good
wish you were here is their best album
TRUE
Agree with saucer
i dont even like pf anymore tee bee eich
i havent been on this server besides a few messages in like almost two years
Roger waters is redoing dark side of the moon
sad
Ikr
OH SHIT I DIDNT KNOW THAT THERE WAS A PINK FLOYD CHAT
ME neither
Whoever did deserves a veteran’s award, which is me ig
But then the person said they dont like Pink Floyd anymore I thought
U cant simply unlike Pink Floyd
Atom heart mother is their most underrated album
real
pink floyds alright
i havent really listened to that many songs but they remind me if the drums and led zepplin had a baby
Animals is literally peak music
underrated tbh
Animals is Floyd’s warning
Not really underrated in the fan base
But outside of the fan base yea definitely
hey yall
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1WnX9A9Tid3fttDX-iO4xjfxx2Z9luMDwZo-SZniCqNM/edit?usp=sharing
dthe ranking
10/10,Album,Average Rating,Average Place
1,Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Pts. 1-5),The Piper At The Gates of Dawn (1967),7.363636364,85.27272727
2,Us and Them,A Saucerful of Secrets (1968) ,7.785714286,72.85714286
3,Sheep,More (1969),4.269230769,141.5384615
4,Wish You Were Here,Ummagu...
i ranked every pink floyd song
i have a therory gamers
wakey wakey
Is thtis chat full of uncs
Pink floyd is from the 60's
Ahh yes
My brother likes pink floyd alot
He got real good taste
The dark side of the moon i tink
probably
.fm
Pink floyd the wall
We don't need no Pink Floyd threads
14: The Final Cut (F)
13: AMLOR (C)
12: Dark Side (C)
11: Division Bell (B+)
10: WYWH (A)
9: Animals (A)
8: The Wall (A)
7: OBC (S)
6: Ummagumma (S)
5: Saucer (S)
4: More (S)
3: AHM (S)
2: Piper (S)
1: Meddle (S)
F = garbage
C = not bad but also not good
B = good
A = really good
S = absolutely amazing
has a billion conceptual and execution problems
🖐️
what
The wall and wywh as anything other than S is a travesty
Dark side is a solid B if not an A
The list just looks like some elitist self wankery
these lists are based off of how much i genuinely like each one
i tried pretty hard to like dark side but i just couldnt
ah yes one of the best selling albums of all time has gems that arent well known
money would be boring as fuck if it didnt have the solo
theres some really rocking songs on their earlier albums
the nile song, one of these days, and the gold its in the especially
also i'm a sucker for psychedelic folk
Tbh, my favourite songs are the classics
my favorite pf song is echoes
Wywh and shine on you crazy diamond are just chef's kiss
cymbaline, interstellar overdrive, summer '68, alans psychedelic breakfast, and let there be more light are up there
and fearless
The live version of comfortably is the most beautiful performance in history tbh
havent seen or heard any live pf
Listen to comfortably numb in the pulse live
It's moving
ok
The Wall has filler
i find the wall's filler to be acceptable because they're needed for the story
Don't Leave Me Now is
Eh to get through
my main complaint with the wall is that it never sticks to one tone
sometimes it feels serious and sometimes it feels cartoonish
Guess the movie exists but still
- AMLOR
- The Final Cut
- More
- Ummagumma
- A Piper At The Gates of Dawn
- The Division Bell
- Obscured by Clouds
- A Saucerful of Secrets
- Dark Side of The Moon
- Atom Heart Mother
- Meddle
- Wish You Were Here
- The Wall
- Animals
not including the endless river, cause quite literally it's b-sides/jams that were too shitty to be part of previous albums
why the more disrespect
top 10 pf songs
1: Echoes
2: Wot's Uh... The Deal? (one of the few truly moving pf songs)
3: Cymbaline
4: Interstellar Overdrive
5: Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
6: Summer '68
7: Fearless
8: Cirrus Minor
9: Bike
10: One of These Days
Why the Animals Disrespect?
i gave it an a
Looks like your're a fan of the earlier stuff
yes
they have some really good post-obc stuff but creatively none of it matched their early output
i got an irl friend to set their status to "mother, do you think they'll try to break my balls"
(the do not listen to pf
none of my irl friends listen to pf
a lot of people wear the nirvana shirt at my school but dont listen to the band
my irl friend likes green day tho
Tell them "UNBASED"
what albums do you guys think are the best?
aside from dark side of the moon
i really like animals
i dont like dark side
meddle is my favorite
do you like diversion bell?
Marooned is one of their great instrumentals
i love time
i do not
i listened to the first two tracks of animals today
gonna listen to the rest tomorrow
i really like the guitar solos on dogs
listen to meddle
I listened to all of animals and meddle and am now listening to atom heart mother
ba sed
agreed
bro the moment that it switches from 6/8 to 4/4 is genius
I listened to it last night and my god it was good
I’ve only listened to animals, meddle, and some of atom heart mother. Haven’t listened to dark side or the wall all the way through
have you heard pigs?
my fav from animals
that's cool though
forget what wet leg is saying about wywh dsom and the wall that shit is s tier
yeah I listened to all of animals like three days ago
nice
i like wywh and the wall
dsotm however
idk what you're on about bro
no offense
this server has got hands down the worst takes out of any music server I've joined (respectfully)
like that one weezer dude who thinks that pinkerton is b-tier and the white album is f-tier
I agree with this take though
thats me
im in a led zeppelin server with worse takes
like what
led zeppelin 4 being a shit album?
no
most of their hot takes arent actually lz takes
oh ok
but a lot of them there hate grunge (they've probably only heard nevermind)
yeah but nevermind isn't a bad album right?
and one despises the velvet underground
right?
oof
they dont like it
i dont either due to both overplaying and not a fan of the production but i can respect it
ok whatever
in utero is better anyways
I can get behind that take even if I don't entirely agree with it
true
although I don't understand how you can say in utero is better than nevermind and not that pinkerton is better than blue
pinkerton and in utero are quite similar
pinkerton isnt that good so im glad we agree
the lyrics are creepy imo and the production is bad
fair
it sounds like someone left their phone recording while they were playing in a room
well I think it's nice and crunchy
guitar tone is nice but thats the only thing i really like about it
i think blue has some of the best weezer songs as well with some stuff from white but im not that big of a weezer fan
goddamnit we turned the pink floyd channel into weezer
fuck
ok back to pink floyd
and eclipse starts playing 😄