#Mod/Plugin Suggestions for the Pre-Clockwork Server

1 messages · Page 3 of 1

pulsar star
#

why not meeee :(

astral rapids
#

you can

#

can you not?

pulsar star
#

oh

#

nvm

ripe robin
#

alright

#

gamers

#

we must unite

#

its time to start modpacking

pulsar star
#

lets go

ripe robin
#

someone find me a way to nerf cgm

cinder marten
#

I don't own a Minecraft account so this is where we part

ripe robin
#

and that create guns resource pack

vale vigil
#

man, I'm far too happy that Do A Barrel Roll and HexCasting got in

pulsar star
ripe robin
#

and all the mods that dont have links rn

pulsar star
#

you shall be missed my Hurdellia friend

astral rapids
#

is there a link for create robotics

ripe robin
#

their github

astral rapids
#

link?

ripe robin
#

though outcraft said hed add survival recipes once i finish the new model

#

and juan is most certainly finished

pulsar star
#

im adding a few links

ripe robin
pulsar star
#

maybe a new channel should be made for this now that all the mod suggestions are done

#

maybe in #1020804379491709068

ripe robin
#

hmm

#

an offtopic channel for Sundial would be nice

pulsar star
#

i mean it is by one of the devs so its the offical server. would fit well

#

also more players

ripe robin
#

@native harness clueless

astral rapids
#

@pulsar star can you add all the mods potato said not to on the unwanted mods list, so less people would see why their mod isnt in the server
or @ripe robin can also do it

#

also the confirmed name for this is sundial?

ripe robin
#

Sundial is the official clockwork server (rn it's without clockwork for fun purposes)

native harness
ripe robin
#

they wish for a channel

native harness
#

ah

#

yea #1020804379491709068 maybe

ripe robin
#

kk

astral rapids
pulsar star
#

speedrunning modpacks

#

dodododo

#

holy

#

2043 messages

native harness
#

I've been on a crusade to remove channels from this server not add more lol

pulsar star
#

in this one channel

native harness
#

we have too many channels

astral rapids
#

imma add back mods you removed, so ppl can search for them with CRTL + F

ripe robin
#

#1073431287043461250

cinder marten
ripe robin
astral rapids
#

rip forum 2055 messages lol

slow wyvern
#

guys

#

hear me out

#

Draconic Evolution

pulsar star
#

Last

quartz garnet
#

Laster

golden lagoon
#

Lastest

chilly nebula
#

How bout we switch When dungeons arise to integrated dungeons and structures

#

The mod has dungeons with create mechanisms

vale vigil
#

Ooooh, I like the sound of that

#

Hmmm, requires quark and Alex's mobs though, so we'd have to add those

chilly nebula
#

Yeah but those mods are unintrusive

jaunty jasper
#

Effortless building

#

Add this

chilly nebula
#

also Framed blocks

unkempt jacinth
#

I think it’s becoming too many mods

#

If we added the most suggested

jaunty jasper
#

Guys

chilly nebula
jaunty jasper
#

FRAMED blocs

echo vigil
#

supplementaries has framed blocks

unkempt jacinth
jaunty jasper
#

@ripe robin FRAMED blocks

chilly nebula
echo vigil
#

yes it does

#

it has block frames

#

tahat you can put blocks in

unkempt jacinth
#

Yh

#

I think so

echo vigil
#

yes

chilly nebula
chilly nebula
echo vigil
#

oh yea fb is worse

chilly nebula
#

How so

robust crane
#

You have:

  • Mahou Tsukai
  • Pneumaticraft
  • Recycler
  • Tinker's levelling
  • Hexcasting

This puts Botania on a squarely average power level
It doesn't make you literally invincible or allow you to deal tens of thousands of damage, after all...

teal obsidian
#

add

chilly nebula
#

Replace cgm with alloyed guns

tiny crag
pulsar star
astral rapids
astral rapids
# chilly nebula Replace cgm with alloyed guns

add it to the list but i think its been vetoed already
also any mods you add should have a summary, link, and a reason to want it, optionally with any config settings and notes you wanna add,

eternal meadow
#

are there any biome or structure-adding mods that are okay to use?

robust crane
#

BOP and OTBYG have been denied

#

But When Dungeons Arise has been approved

astral rapids
#

No, it wasnt

robust crane
#

What

#

I'm reading this off the table

eternal meadow
#

What about Better-end + Better-nether

#

Wait those are fabric...

chilly nebula
#

Think there should be a vast terrain to actually have a reason to build airships/ships

eternal meadow
#

Thought they had forge

astral rapids
#

Confirmed or suggested mods

chilly nebula
#

I'm thinking William wythers' overhauled overworld

#

With large biomes setting

#

It's beautiful and also feels big

#

Maybe terraforged but there's only a few early builds out for 1.18.2

eternal meadow
# chilly nebula It's beautiful and also feels big

I agree with your take on it. I'd like to add that I think the server would for sure benefit from mods that add new biomes, structure, and spice up the world and make exploration cooler in general. Players will be going places, after all, since the norm will basically be to have a mobile base

#

Of course, if they're approved

#

I understand the reasons for not wanting the "usual" ones

chilly nebula
#

WWOO+integrated dungeons and structures is one hell of a combo

#

IDAS has some crazy interesting structures

eternal meadow
#

Reminds me of Ancient Warfare 2

#

I like it

#

Okay im adding WWOO to the suggested mod list, help me out with why that one specifically since you're more familiar

#

to flesh out the suggestion

chilly nebula
#

Yeah sure but only through discord

#

Not that keen with Google products

eternal meadow
#

That's fine

#

i'll paste what you type

chilly nebula
#

Things to note for WWOO:
• Best experienced with Force large biomes option,
• Andesite is rare and only present in a few biomes most notably Andesite Crags, which will make players actually travel to get their fix of andesite for create mechanisms or come up with other sources(configurable),

#

It's terrain is very multi-dimensional so to say

#

It has Highlands over y150 and lowlands as low as y60, river generation is altered, making them a viable means of travel

#

Also has integration with Towns and Towers mod, which adds vanilla+ villages and small structures that fit in really well with the game

#

Also WWOO doesn't add any new blocks

astral rapids
#

Keep it simple

chilly nebula
#

Integrated Dungeons and Structures (IDAS)
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/idas

A worldgen mod adding interesting structures unlike any other dungeon mod, utilizes other mods' features, such as Supplementaries for decor, Create for mechanisms and dungeons, Alex's mobs for structure population etc.

Structure shortlist:
• Different taverns/inns populated with villagers(also Guard Villagers if the mod is present),
• Several dungeon types (wizard's castles, illager fortress),
• Several rare huge dungeons (ancient mines, necromancers spire etc.),
• Some ambient structures like the fisherman's hut, manors, hunter camps etc.

Notes and config:
Has a separate config datapack that allows editing structure gen frequency etc, recommended to raise spacing and separation of structures ~7 times so they feel more unique

#

@eternal meadow would you mind adding that to the spreadsheet

eternal meadow
#

of course

chilly nebula
#

Tysm

eternal meadow
#

that one's already there but no one filled out the other columns

#

Also we're missing one column for WWOO

#

the "Why" column

chilly nebula
#

ok sec

#

WWOO makes the world feel bigger(especially with large biomes set to true in mod's settings), promoting exploration and airship/ship building

#

There's also Tectonic which is a lightweight alternative but with much much longer rivers that even stretch underground, don't know if anyone would want underground rivers tho

chilly nebula
eternal meadow
#

gotcha, adding it

chilly nebula
#

The 'why' for IDAS:
Makes the world feel more alive and exploration more interesting and rewarding by adding structures that pose an interesting challenge to explore, or just are aesthetically pleasing to come by

astral rapids
#

And should short

chilly nebula
#

Is that a stock market call

eternal meadow
#

But i'll add on to it 🙂

chilly nebula
eternal meadow
#

lmao sure

eternal meadow
#

Both IDAS and WWOO have been added to suggestiosn and fleshed out

chilly nebula
chilly nebula
eternal meadow
#

Ah it's another worlden mod

pulsar star
#

Can you send me the link to wwo or whatever

eternal meadow
pulsar star
#

Btw post that you added some new suggestions in #1073431287043461250

eternal meadow
#

oh

chilly nebula
pulsar star
chilly nebula
#

Ty

eternal meadow
#

@chilly nebula it wouldn't hurt to have some screenshots ready of what the world looks like with both IDAS and WWOO, if you have a world with them or anything

#

To make your case

#

As worldgen mods are fairly big additions and thus do require a fair bit of consideration

#

But i do hope one of them goes through, or both AhriCopium

finite wraith
#

I've been playing with terratonic, terralith, and regions unexplored

#

Peak world gen

eternal meadow
#

terralith was denied already sadge

ripe robin
#

Terralith is not peak

#

Acacia

finite wraith
#

People here have a strange taste in mods

eternal meadow
#

I haven't played with it myself so idk

finite wraith
#

It basically mixes tectonic with terralith

#

Also idk what acacia you're talking about

ripe robin
#

Regions unexplored looks sex

ripe robin
#

It is all acacia

finite wraith
#

I guess I've been on 1.19

ripe robin
#

All of it

#

The entire thing

finite wraith
#

I forgot about that

ripe robin
#

The world is acacia and Mesa

#

@quartz garnet back me up here

#

The terror

finite wraith
#

1.18 terralith has stupid temperature zones

#

Nah I remember now

ripe robin
#

Yeah

#

There’s like no anything other than acacia

#

It’s pain

eternal meadow
#

That sounds terrifying

finite wraith
#

1.19 is amazing tho

ripe robin
#

We ain’t on 1.19

finite wraith
#

Albeit slow

quartz garnet
#

Terralith needs to adjust biome chances

finite wraith
#

Ik

quartz garnet
#

Iirc we added the 1.19 backport

finite wraith
#

I forgot 1.18 world gen is kind of ass

ripe robin
#

Didn’t mean to send that

#

Lol

finite wraith
#

I almost joined

quartz garnet
#

Almost had kt

eternal meadow
#

I almost got in

ripe robin
#

Meant to send this

finite wraith
#

I would've but I hesitated

ripe robin
#

Lol

finite wraith
#

Regions unexplored is really good tho

ripe robin
#

Phone copy paste pensive

quartz garnet
#

I was in 100 servers lul

finite wraith
#

The dev is also really open to feedback

eternal meadow
#

That one adds new biomes?

ripe robin
#

What about continents

finite wraith
eternal meadow
#

i love this

2023-01-30_01.png
ripe robin
#

Is that one compatible with it

finite wraith
#

It should be yeah

#

I suggest William wythers overworld

#

It's better than terralith on 18

eternal meadow
#

that one has been added to the suggestion list already

#

Just recently :3

#

Maybe you can comment about it

#

to add your support of it

ripe robin
finite wraith
#

I've gotten a lot of experience with making modpacks recently tbh

ripe robin
#

Hmm

eternal meadow
ripe robin
finite wraith
#

Yes

#

Should be

ripe robin
#

So far I think a combo of wythers and regions unexplored would be best

finite wraith
#

RU is compatible with anything that uses terrablender

#

I think malum could be cool also

#

It's a nice modern magic mod

ripe robin
#

Suggest it

finite wraith
#

?

eternal meadow
#

It's been in the suggestions already and partially greened but idk if that was someone else or if it means confirmed kek

pulsar star
#

If smtn is green i think its confirmed or at least generally accepted

finite wraith
#

Are y'all gonna make this a cf pack?

ripe robin
#

Yeah

eternal meadow
#

Gotcha, was just wondering tho cuz Waystones mod was partially green earlier but now it's not so 🤷

ripe robin
#

Waystones is weirdchamp with our modlist

pulsar star
#

Waystones may make airships useless or at least less useful

ripe robin
#

Yeah

finite wraith
#

Potato are you gonna set the redstone link range really high so we can use create

eternal meadow
#

Waystone on ships are fun, but I do see your point

#

and respect it

finite wraith
#

The issue is you can't restrict that

#

And a single block can count as airship anyway

#

Im a little worried for the server performance tho lol

jaunty jasper
#

Potato you should add FRAMED BLOCJS

eternal meadow
#

Do we know what the budget for server specs are kek

finite wraith
#

Framed blocks is kinda wacky

eternal meadow
#

Is that like a chisels n bits?

finite wraith
#

It's less ass than that

#

But it's got wacko blocks still

eternal meadow
#

Ohhh framed blocks

#

i remember em now

finite wraith
#

You can have like

#

20 degree slopes

eternal meadow
#

i remember it cuz i mega crashed my world when i made an archimedes ship with em kek

finite wraith
#

Which would be cool tbh for launching ships

#

Make ramps n shit

pulsar star
#

Yea I dunno how antilag will work

finite wraith
#

Without c2me it won't

robust crane
#

Any updates on Botania?

finite wraith
#

You'll need to pregen

#

A lot

#

Literally only hope

pulsar star
#

Il add it

eternal meadow
#

wait adding what

pulsar star
#

I dont even think c2me has forge 1.18. Also where doing tests for wg

finite wraith
#

This works on 1.18

#

It kind of doubles for continents

eternal meadow
pulsar star
#

#1073431287043461250 i think there testn

robust crane
pulsar star
#

For sundial let’s do a test run

Of 3 possible worldgen configurations

And see if we like them

  1. William Wythers Overhauled Overworld + Regions Unexplored

  2. 1, + Continents

  3. Vanilla Worldgen

robust crane
#

^

eternal meadow
#

May I suggest a 4th. trial

#

1 + 2 + integrated dungeons and structures

robust crane
#

Probably worth suggesting in the other chat

last portal
#

I saw that MrCrayFish's gun mod was added to the list, what if I suggest create alloyed guns, it's MrCrayFish's gun mod but with create style gun models and textures, it also adds a couple extra guns

robust crane
#

Tho dungeons are structures, not terrain gen

eternal meadow
#

Oh true

#

thought we were just doing general worldgen

robust crane
#

I'm now daring to hope Yaro's "I'll add it" was about Botania
But actually no idea what they meant.

eternal meadow
#

I think Botania is currently being contested

#

it's in the unwanted mods tab currently

pulsar star
#

I think botania depends on the other magic mod

#

The circle one

robust crane
#

Wait what

pulsar star
#

Malsou tsosi or whatever

robust crane
#

It's an independent mod 🤔

pulsar star
#

No i mean not litteryl depend

robust crane
#

Ah

#

I see what you mean

pulsar star
#

Like the other magic mod is OP. Botania was removed for being op

robust crane
pulsar star
#

So if the other mod stays botania can prob be added

robust crane
#

They're not nearly on the same level of op tho

#

Botania is OP relative to vanilla

#

Mahou is OP relative to Draconic Evolution

pulsar star
#

Yea its powerscaling

robust crane
#

Also
Botania adds a lot to VS

#

Mahou doesn't rly

pulsar star
#

Yea im not sold on Mahou

robust crane
#

Also like
Just so we are on the same page

#

What Botania features does the statement "Botania too op" come from?

pulsar star
#

Botania was removed before mahou was added

#

Kinda odd

#

Dunno why

#

Well i know why botania was removed

#

But no why mahou was added

robust crane
pulsar star
#

Not at all

robust crane
#

Then please

#

Do tell

pulsar star
#

Its overused and gets boring. its to OP often as well and the mana system is flawed - mod sheet

robust crane
#

"Overused" seriously doesn't go together with a mod some VS devs never even played with

#

And I actually wanna know what do the other two things actually mean

#

"to OP often" (sic) and "mana system is flawed"

pulsar star
#

Alright

#

To OP is due to the powerful player modifications with rings that can massively change combat for a relatively cheap price like that far reach ring or whatever. The mana system being flawed I guess is up to people

eternal meadow
#

Individual OP items can always be disabled

earnest terrace
#

2300 messages

#

what the fuck

eternal meadow
#

Hey people are excited about server auriPog

robust crane
#

Far reach ring only works on blocks tho, unless Vazkii changed that since 1.12 🤔

#

The only ring with ANY combat relevance was Odin
And that's nullified by "everybody gets one"

robust crane
pulsar star
#

Yea im thinking bout it. Its less powerful the circle mod so its not broken op

#

The argument against it was made becore circle mod

robust crane
#

Alright thanks.

BTW according to issue tracker Far Reach ring MIGHT now apply to combat 🤔
Easy to test tho, and to disable if needed.

#

Either way I am hard pressed to think of another mod with more useful applications for VS

pulsar star
#

I may try to get circle mod replaced with botania

robust crane
#

Sounds like a win win trade to me XD

pulsar star
#

Vote in #1073431287043461250 about the weather mod btw

eternal meadow
#

🌪️

#

Has anyone thought to suggest bewitchment?

pulsar star
#

Nobody has suggested it yet

#

Mostly cuz its impossible

#

Its on fabric

eternal meadow
#

oh

robust crane
#

I've THOUGHT of suggesting it, yes

chilly nebula
hybrid rain
#

create: steam and rails

pulsar star
sweet sinew
#

Security craft or u like stinky.

valid stone
quartz garnet
valid stone
#

Then I’d definitely suggest just altering the ocean size a bit. Then you have room to sail without it being nothing but ocean

vale vigil
#

big oceans definitely sound great for sailing

pulsar star
#

And for airships makes them more useful

#

Cant just ride a horse

vale vigil
#

and we got the "Do a Barrel Roll" mod to make elytras more difficult(and more fun)

#

although it doesn't change how useful they are for travel

pulsar star
#

It makes it skill

vale vigil
#

yeah, I tried it with terra swoop force one time( had to jump through hoops to get it to work, don't recommend), and it was nigh impossible

#

btw, are we still able to suggest mods?

pulsar star
#

Ye

vale vigil
#

ah sweet

pulsar star
#

And if you know packwiz/github you can just push a pr

vale vigil
chilly nebula
#

We should definitely add optifine

vale vigil
#

lmao

#

oh, somebody already suggested antique atlas

pulsar star
#

If you want a higher chance of smtn getting accepted make a PR

vale vigil
#

oh btw, I was meaning to ask, did amplified nether get vetoed?

pulsar star
vale vigil
#

ah, fair

#

what's a PR?

pulsar star
#

Github

#

Modpack. Adding the mod yourself basicly

#

You need to know packwiz tho

#

You could ask someone to do it for you

vale vigil
#

well, I don't know packwiz, and bothering someone to add it for me sounds like a nightmare, so I'll just wait for now

pulsar star
#

Ask walksanator. B⃢ot.#2369

#

They know how

#

Already pushed 2 accepted prs

vale vigil
#

hmmm

#

maybe

pulsar star
#

Well you can easily do multiple mods in 1 pr

#

So just compile a list and maybe if you ask nicely

void geode
vale vigil
#

ah, so it's you

pulsar star
#

/ban

vale vigil
#

lmao

void geode
cloud turtle
#

ah crap that's kinda sucky 😦
would be good to be able to see distant stuff

eternal meadow
eternal meadow
#

nvm sorry i actually scrolled up and read the convo

#

brb learning packwiz

#

Why didn't i know of that before

#

that woulda saved me so much time for helping my friends with private modpacks

pulsar star
#

Lmao

#

Its great

eternal meadow
#

dang it avg

image.png
pulsar star
#

Lmao

#

Windows 🤢

eternal meadow
#

it is what it is

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

pulsar star
#

linux is

yay -S packwiz-git

eternal meadow
#

simple

pulsar star
#

Well doing

yay -Ss packwiz

Will give you a list of possible installes named packwiz

eternal meadow
#

ah

quartz garnet
#

Me and him use arch

sweet sinew
#

wait this is gonna have plugins?

#

oh lord

shut swan
sweet sinew
#

is uh tinkers in?

sweet sinew
shut swan
sweet sinew
shut swan
#

i could do that

#

but also

#

i would need to learn lua

fringe thorn
#

mcmmo guys?

eternal meadow
#

And Create too, while we're at it?

proven pike
hybrid knot
#

how will the server run with so many mods

eternal meadow
#

It's not the number of mods, but rather the content of the mods

#

100 mods that each add one single item are prob more lightweight to load than 2 mods with robust systems that each add 100+ blocks/structures and mechanics and stuff

hybrid knot
#

true

ripe robin
#

"so many mods?"

#

thats like

#

less than a hundred

#

skyfactory 4 has like 400

pulsar star
#

We do have 100

jaunty jasper
#

Easy

#

🥸

hybrid knot
#

ok

quartz garnet
shut swan
#

before playing modpacks I thought like 30 mods was a lot

#

I had a forge server with some friends and we just started adding more mods over time

earnest terrace
#

Less than 400 mods? DIESOFCRINGE

modern compass
#

We need this

image.png
fringe thorn
#

p sure we have it

sweet sinew
#

WE NEED GRAPPLING HOOK MOD + STORAGE DRAWERS OR MID

#

AND MORE PERIPHERALS

#

i swear if someone says "we have ae2"

#

like thats not early game

#

plus deep storage unit with upgrades

#

and also

#

works well with ae2 so

sweet sinew
#

mod / plugins suggestions?

#

so is there plugins on this server?

#

if so

#

what are you using?

#

also

#

should get multiverse plugin so we can have a survival and creative world

#

if

#

plugins do exist

echo vigil
#

tally hall jumpscare

lethal bobcat
#

tournament is in its latest snapshot...

sweet sinew
#

since the universal reset of the server, next update, add pneumaticcraft

#

and corpse

echo vigil
#

remove pneumaticcraft

#

🤢

halcyon axle
#

Hbm mod currently only available on github as nucleartech

#

Computer craft

shut swan
sweet sinew
shut swan
severe gorge
#

create stuff and additions

#

mr crayfish furniture and mr crayfish guns

#

just imagine unloading a whole clip on someone while flying by on an airship

halcyon axle
#

Computer Craft

sweet sinew
sweet sinew
#

At least guns

eternal meadow
#

furniture not in

#

gib heck foxxos

humble vault
sweet sinew
#

what? keep inventory?

#

💀

humble vault
#

no just a grave mod that isnt terrible

#

corpse has like no compatibility with modded inventories

#

wait

#

im thinking enigmatic graves

#

nvm corpse is fine

#

im just a dumbass

shut swan
#

is adding botany pots a good idea

quartz garnet
#

Yes

shut swan
#

yeah

#

i have a small airship so having small sources of food is good

fringe thorn
#

I strongly recommend a local chat plugin for people who cant use the plasmo mod. Or at least some kind of party chat for privately messaging multiple people

sweet sinew
quartz garnet
#

No essentials

#

Need something lighter

#

Infact @ripe robin you should setup Plasmo voice
It is kinda useless rn

ripe robin
#

I should

finite wraith
#

does server exist now or

finite wraith
quartz garnet
finite wraith
#

yeah i found it shortly after asking ngl

ripe robin
#

Smh

finite wraith
#

Dam

#

Well it also doesn't connect clientside so the port isn't working

minor sparrow
#

corpse

shut swan
winged bolt
#

quick question is ae2 confirmed or removed cause too op ?

image.png image.png
#

second thing why citing reasons for removing mods as too op when having Mahou Tsukai

dark sparrow
robust crane
#

It's green so it's in... Server is long gone tho.