#alpha competition

66 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

dusty moat
#

100%

pastel wharf
#

Do you mean like early game to cuz thay wouldnt make sense

lapis magnet
pastel wharf
#

I mean you can get wiped within an hr

#

Of wile

lapis magnet
#

yeah and as a tribe going for alpha you should be able to protect and build enough to not get wiped

dusty trout
lapis magnet
#

would you call the starter on 6man that?

dusty trout
#

fair

#

but idk who ever won that got wiped anyways

lapis magnet
#

Should be a rule about it ngl

#

Like if u had fully wiped and cleared us from that spot we shouldn't been able to go for alpha

modest dagger
undone heath
#

Doesnt sound like you can enforce it. How will anyone find out that the person who applied for alpha got wiped in first hour of wipe in starter base? Also what should be considered a base? What if you had a starter, which you abandoned and went for different spot and you simply don't care anymore - is it even your base then? I assume so, but who cares that someone broke your smithy and fabricator?

lapis magnet
#

If you left the spot and moved to a new spot its obvious

undone heath
#

What if you had multiple bases?

lapis magnet
#

theres common sense in this

#

multiple starters?

#

thats on you then

undone heath
#

Don't apply common sense in these terms when making rules, there have to be boundaries so its clear, otherwise people will get upset.

#

Because it sounds like you are trying to create a rule, which would be very vaguely defined

lapis magnet
#

A tribe who gets wiped shouldn't be allowed to apply for alpha

#

im not talking about someone putting a smithy and forge to craft a maeguana saddle

undone heath
#

Define wiped

lapis magnet
#

wiped

#

destroyed

undone heath
#

If you have base on two servers and one of them gets wiped

#

Did you get wiped as a tribe?

lapis magnet
#

brother thats on you now if you have two starters fully built

undone heath
#

I am just asking a question

#

Its a yes/no question btw

lapis magnet
#

how often do people have two starters with turrets and crafters

undone heath
#

I am not saying how often

#

I am asking what if

lapis magnet
#

You're like strawmanning rn

undone heath
#

Define the rule

lapis magnet
#

Like its always you

undone heath
#

You can make a rule saying how farming outpost should look like - its 4x4, certain amount of turrets, beds etc. You don't just vaguely define it.

lapis magnet
#

Brother if one of ur starters with turrets get wiped idc if u had 1-10 starters with turrets and crafters you should get eliminated

undone heath
#

You should be able to define what getting wiped means, if you have one base with all the loot and stuff and then you have some breeding outpost and someone wipes that.

#

Does it mean you got wiped?

lapis magnet
#

you're talking about late game now with breeders

#

which is completely different

undone heath
#

I was putting up two examples, you didn't answer any of those yet

lapis magnet
#

like why do youe ven comment bro

undone heath
#

You just said "Oh thats on you" or "Oh common sense"

lapis magnet
#

im being deadass

#

u have zero iq about the game u play

#

like we moving goal posts rn

undone heath
#

I am throwing different examples, because you threw in your definitive rule "if you get wiped at any point in time, you should be disqualified"

#

But you don't seem to know what it means

#

And you can't define it

lapis magnet
#

base

undone heath
#

Which makes the rule worthless

lapis magnet
#

crafters / turrets / props / beds

#

how do u even mention a breeder base

undone heath
#

Ok, so if the base doesn't have props its not a base?

#

Or if the base doesn't have turrets at that point, its not a base yet?

lapis magnet
#

people like you should be muted from suggestions

#

argumentative for no reason

undone heath
#

You are just mad, because you are trying to make up suggestion, which would be hard to enforce and to even define.

#

Because someone would apply for alpha and some random Joe would say - nono, they shouldn't apply for alpha, because I wiped their starter base day 1

#

And then admins would have to decide who is right and who is wrong, potentially on very vague proofs

#

Sounds like tons of mess