#The Grand Auction of 5123 (Part 1)
1 messages · Page 11 of 1
great thank you so much! I look forward to it.
is this time locked in yet or are we still in a maybe state?
The threat of the hammer in that vid cracks me up, EDIT - gah I was way scrolled back 
Yeah, I either need to have a somewhat delicate conversation about not going to my son's soccer practice, or a very delicate conversation about who's picking up my inlaws at the airport, depending on start time.
it sounds like Wyrom is waiting to hear back on his support team before he can provide confirmation.
The answer to the inlaws is Uber my friend
Wyrom, would you mind pinning the date and time when it's set please? I don't want to miss it 🙂
#general-announcements message
this used to be prime teaser time 😦
Sorry?
prime is a loaded word for gs, i just meant there was a period last week before the auction folks were dropping early morning teasers around this time and it was fun 😛
just being whistful for the late night degen crew, the hawaii life
this is my latest teaser and no you won’t find it in the list of things for auction.
Oh I forgot to add a second 
sk tentacle familiar twins!
Not that cool. Lol
haha
It is a legit teaser though.
ooooo!
like eonak arm but a tentacle?
actually solid guess
Hah no
BUT IT WAS A GOOD GUESS
Baby kraken pet obviously
Release the kraken!
I have a severed head for this. Just in case. Think I’ll have it altered to snakes for hair 😂
Since the next auction is nothing more than finishing the previous one. I think all the teasers had already gone out that were going to go out?
People were hoping for a teaser on one of the two unknowns of the list, although seems there could be at least one other unknown based in khorbins tease
Yeah they gave out over 50 teasers so I figured they were kinda all teased out. They being staff.
Khorbins teaser is that halfway through he's unleashing a horde of violent octopii on the crowd
Hah, no. It's nothing newly added, I just never teased it beforehand.
new level 60-70 hunting ground with undead octopi?

I don't think people would like something like though. Visually it sounds appealing but constant grapples probably doesn't play well.
ultros greatrune
Keel octopi before grapple.... or have grapple not work on spiked armor because... yeah owie
although I guess undead 🐙 might not feel pain
undead 🐙 might revel in pain.
Queries to staff or the highly informed bidder:
Can I “bid next” to have the block move me up to the next increment?
Can I type bid 25m without adding any zeroes, with the m there to signify millions, and have that work?
Yes that is how I was bidding last time (60m 70m, etc. ). The "bid next" thing though... I thought that wasn't implemented on purpose, i.e. they didn't want someone to accidentally go over their maximum internal price
K and m work after number to signify thousand and millions. As to next i do not think so
When someone bids, you see the "next minimum bid is X" amount on the room output
Awesome. Thank you both muchly for the prompt and detailed reply! 
If you type HELP in the bidding room, it has the options (obviously not available at the moment) - here's the blurb from my logs:
BID {amount}
Amount may be shortened to ###k (for thousands) or ###m (for millions). Bid will also be recognized if you use a decimal point or commas.
Examples of valid bids:
BID 1000 - 1000 silver
BID 25k - 25000 silver
BID 1m - 1,000,000 silver
BID 4.5k - 4,500 silver
BID 2,500 - 2,500 silver```
The m works with decimals too yeah from what Mandan posted. All my bids of the night were like bid 20m or bid 111.8m. Or whatnot
Made it pretty easy
Where is the list of what's left?
I miss have missed that one, second attempt time
not sure anyone has compiled a what's left yet, but shouldn't be too hard to go through using
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12AqaOnUrvbpk8xmNePBoX3CbfaznbByggPqrNJjRo7o/edit#gid=526297517
I see, a sold tab
Just don't BID BLOCK 😬
the last 3 items on the auction #1 there, will be re-added as they were all broken, so we'll see those along with the other items that hadn't come up for bid yet
I think Wyrom said they fixed that
a jagged obsidian backslasher
a white-feathered grey silk cloak
a split-sleeved gown of lapis silk braced in a cincher of ivory-carved snow drops
a high-collared nacre velvet gown enveloped in a mantle of pale mink
a tiny tag-affixed key
a spherical milky white eyeball caught in a lattice of thin chains
a floor-length jet black cloth-of-veniom duster with a voluminous silver-edged hood
a cracked faewood amulet
an enruned white ora scarab
a glaes-hilted dark ghezyte claidhmore with scintillating chromatic edges
a burnished golvern still affixed with a drakar plate
an annular medallion of blue-tinted lacewood
a burled mesquite disc set with a spiral of picture jasper
an odd-looking plant
a white and green jade teapot
a mottled grey leather tome stamped with a stylized mushroom
a sand-worn pale leather tome emblazoned with a stylized sun
a dark blue leather tome bordered with stylized arctic brambles
a rectangular cedar and maple humidor
an intricately etched lintilia wand inlaid with anemone coral xan'ayra
a grey-spotted narwhal hide tricorn edged with scrimshaw
a strand of polished copper prayerbeads
a polished steel shield stickpin
an ebon burnt velvet cloak patterned with sheer runic shapes
a pearlescent purple philter
a sky blue crystal globe charm
a horseshoe-embossed blue property voucher
a shell-painted red property voucher
a tightly woven leather harness
a temporal warblade
some sinewy monster flesh
a tiny silver cat's bell tied to a red ribbon
a glowing urnon pie box painted with prancing roltons
That seems to be the remaining list, at least according to the computer
I would be very worried about a BID NEXT command. I think you’re quickly going to be paying more than you think you are. I can imagine safeguards, but each one makes the command less useful
Agree. Way too easy for someone to sneak a huge bid in before yours is processed
I hope they absolutely do not try and add features to BID at all between now and Sunday, please let's not introduce potential new bugs
if they did that, which i think its just safest to limit peoples ability to accidentally bid from 0 to whale prices for something they were just shooting their shot on, i'd say it would need to require a max value. i.e. bid next 25m so bid the minimum amount, not to exceed 25 million.
but i also would say that would potentially encourage a lot of people to just keep face rolling on the next cheapest bid and slow things down vs getting to more realistic prices quicker.
Agreed. I don’t think any feature creep has been mentioned or suggested! 😅 Wasn’t trying to alarm anyone in asking if that was a bid command already in existence.
What's the plant.
Makes plants that you graft to it for crafting stuff
Can't be used for bounties.
Oh neat.
its a grow your own foragable
But great for stills/cooking!
Veolas
Can you bid more than you have on you?
No
Bid block all day then
do bid block 300m yakushi that means if you win yakushi has to pay for it
If you read the fine print it’s only after you hit your deductible for the year
he'll still outbid you after.
Has the date for the rest of the auction been established?
Yes, it's in general announcements, but Sunday at noon edt
It sure is. I just skipped over it.
but does that mean you can graft foraged item prop plants to it too or just actual forageables
Is the March auction part 2 tomorrow going to be automated? i.e. run concurrently in Plat?
Didn't plats auction actually finish? If so, there wouldn't be a need to run anything again for them.
It did not! Doenay went on a bender for us as well
we just got a bit further
auction
so tomorrow at noon elven?
Do the elves respect DST?
What has dst done for the monarchy? Nothing! Elves are also against arbitrary time changes that make you feel tired and off kilter for a week afterwards.
It's unnatural, unhealthy, and generally disliked. It ironically increases fuel usage (lamp oil) for those without magic illumination too, which was actually one of the reasons it was introduced - to save such.
We only do it to minimize confusion since the rest of the world does. We'd love to change it, really. We totally will someday, when we get around to it. Blame our -DIS modifier.
I can’t help but feel partly responsible
Does the disk tilt
i thought this was the Christian mingle discord

this actually explains a lot......
Would it be negative of me to assume this is the scedule?
9am - Auction starts
9:01 Auction breaks
10:13 auction starts
I know the ||redacted || is happening tomorrow.
Does it start with a g?
Actually, I do have an update. The entrance into the auction will break groups. Luckily it was not a concern last week (we had enough concerns, amirite??), but F2P was able to enter in a group.
9 am??
He’s a west-coaster
oh he's one of those
those still exist? I thought they'd been burnt, flooded, and buried under snow to the point they went extinct.....
they all fled to texas and florida
as a sleep deprived west coaster, i too am debating if i want to even try to get up or just sleep =p
im torn! i want to attend - but my realistic chances of being able to purchase something are slim to nil - its fun to watch VS sleeping
decisions decisions
Can we move the auction back to 7 pm? I don't want to get up in 5 hours.
brute is my spirit animal
Don't go to sleep, problem solved Brute
^
Casil, on the spider bracer, is it going to remain a limited offering, or will it be offered at DR or another pay event in the future?
If you are going to offer it at a pay event I think it would be cool and worth the time to add some fluff interaction with the spider bags, if possible.
Also found it amusing that the loresong value of it was the price paid at auction. Is that a new mechanic? Or I just haven't noticed it before?
It's intended to be very limited! No plans to add to pay events.
is there a list of what remains and what the item properties are?
where was the auction at again? and it's at 12 est?
ent in WL at noon EST
it's off the wedding glade near WL, go warehouse
thanks! forgot where it was already. heh
2.5 hrs from now, right?
yes
Yes.
I'm just going to spectate at this point. already got my one account item and broke. 🤣
#1083646503429603448 message
thanks, I see the list on the wiki- I got confused because I looked at the calendar and it said April and I looked at the April auction page...
Yea, I just did it in the spreadsheet and pulled out anything in the sold list that matched in the opposite array
At what time will silver passing be disabled?
20 minutes ago
Can someone please pin today's starting time and location and get rid of the few old date/times? Thank you
ohh this is a good question
Probably right at noon, the expected start time, like last week was done at the expected start
Wyrom — 03/30/2023 6:11 PM
The Grand Auction of 5123's reschedule will take place April 2nd at roughly noon ET. See you then! Same rules will apply from before! Nothing has been reset, so if you already won a bid, you won't be able to buy something new until the auction later in April.
Since that was never put in here?
It was not.
the one you pinned says 11am
sounds like we start when wyrom wakes up, huh?
I removed the old pin and pinned the above, Rinualdo.
Thanks Thandiwe
does it need to be landing notes?
Glad to see there weren't any delays for right now! It's any notes.
I used FWI last sunday
ty
Im excited, heh
what will you bid on? one of those icy gowns?
the gown or the nail press.. got a pal with me tho 😉
first nail press for this auction went out already, second in the RoL auction though
but there were two on the list.. I knew I shoulda gone for first.. darn wand harness lol
Who knows what surprises await!
the shadow knows
I know
surprise me with a nail press
/hands you a nail press. It's just a couple wooden blocks with iron nails in between.
instructions unclear now you have an eel press
oooh eel press.
press them eels
Eels press back
my frigatebird familiar will make short work of them
:locks Xynwen in with a bunch of drunk CHE officers as revenge:
LOLOL
I miss Plur heh, he did the diaper dance at the fashion show once.. was a riot!
Plur is around
well I keep missing him! lol
various bits of graffiti dot the landing:
PLUR LIVES!
WHO IS JOHN PLUR?
One of my favorite things is when he accidentally logs in Plur, streaks through TSC and logs out
There isn't one until the RoL auction I think
:grumbles
that means you can buy a dress AND a nail press next weeken... whenever the RoL auction is
gasp!
This warehouse has Dispel tier 9000
Wow everyone has way too many spells
Maybe we should have realized that my spells surviving it last time was a harbinger of woe
this should be fun
That's... not over 9000
man I'm excited for the next 7 hours, this is gonna be a great auction
alright I'm ready for everything to go super smooth and be outta here in like 90 minutes
Hopefully we can keep the game crashing to <1 this round
Im just going to sob at all the silvers being flaunted around
I for one anticipate 0.3 crashes this time.
Usage:
EVENT BOX - Check for event boxes being offered.
EVENT STATS {event name} - provides stats for the specified paid event.
Current valid options include DUSKRUIN, RUMOR WOODS, EBON GATE.
The Auction Event is not open at this time. It is scheduled to open at 3/26/2023 19:00:00 eastern.```
and it begins....

Nice - I’m stuck in traffic so still have a chance of getting in…
ARE YOU READY TO RUMBLLLLE
it's the final countdown
plays lively keyboard melody
Remember, if you lose. Take it personally.
In the blue corner, we have Wyrom and team. Their opponent in the red corner, the insatiable and implacable GS Players
G'luck all! Here's a classic ritual pic for luck
We got the auctioneer hooked up and ready to go
Must cast 906 to activate it
Just remember the do-hickey plugs into the whatchamacallit, not the thingamabob
15 min in
As long as the RPA is coursing through my veins..... 🤤
That electrical setup looks positively safe compared to the one where I work
We wanted to see how a Platinum item went. They didn't bid on the first item.
😂
oof
lol
For the next one, it would really be good if you logged out and logged in in the room. My computer crashed immediately at the start and I missed the RPA and am locked out, it sucks.
Its was a +2000 enchant potion
First up, a golvern still!
Well it’s good that you tested that possibility
starting off strong
event isn't working
Gingerette says, "Doenay is examining the still for a moment."
it wasn't for us at the beginning either, it did as soon as the first item went up
Event worked for me.
not me it just shows usage
It worked for me once, then stopped. But Gingerette says it's paused and hang tight.
they are fixing "event" I believe
event didn't work for me either heh but inspect did
Just silence us
oooh am I missing drama?
They need to say "next person who moves gets deleted". It would be fun to see who moves.
next person to move gets their inventory max item cap set to 150
You know there'd be an instant dozen "duck|wince|gasp"
Would be appreciated if the warehouse could be opened again briefly when the technical issues are fixed
ADHD prevalence
worldwide: 2.8%
GS Auctions: 79%
Event is functional again.
whats the verbage to bid?
bid <amount> block
you can use shorthand like 55m etc
No block necessary 😛 too soon
unless you want to bid in billions
just make every action at auction cost 25 health, problem solved
If you type HELP in game:
BID {amount}
Amount may be shortened to ###k (for thousands) or ###m (for millions). Bid will also be recognized if you use a decimal point or commas.
Examples of valid bids:
BID 1000 - 1000 silver
BID 25k - 25000 silver
BID 1m - 1,000,000 silver
BID 4.5k - 4,500 silver
BID 2,500 - 2,500 silver```
This is racist against gnomes, sir.
slowly creeping towards the Plat cost
Examples of valid bids:
BID 1000 - 1000 silver
BID 25k - 25000 silver
BID 1m - 1,000,000 silver
BID 4.5k - 4,500 silver
BID 2,500 - 2,500 silver
Sophye wins the still for 130m!
Next up... MK Mug backslasher!
congrats!
surprised it went for more in PLAT
Only 130m on that? oof
Plat clearly has more of a drinking problem.
look at that difficulty
why does that backslasher have such a difficulty?
Interesting how this was pointed out as having picking locks enhancive last week, but wasn't fixed 😛
obsidian is -500
probably was in lockdown in the auction hopper so couldn't change it
Current Bid/Cost: 375,000 silvers
You note the following details about a white-feathered grey silk cloak:
It appears to weigh about 6 pounds.
It is estimated to be worth about 350,000 silvers.
It is a container with a maximum interior capacity of 200 pounds with room for any number of items.
It is predominantly crafted of cloth.
A white-feathered grey silk cloak is intended for a devout follower of Gosaena and will basically "turn off" if worn by one who is not. Clerics have a broader benefit in the teleport ability in that the location options are expanded to include Gosaena's prayer room in the local cleric guild, if one exists. This white-feathered cloak may be altered as long as "white feathers" remains in the item description.
Ambient messaging is currently inactive. PROD the CLOAK to turn it on.
USAGE:
EXHALE, PULL, SCRATCH, TURN, WEAR/REMOVE (fluff)
FOLD - Activate Gosaena's Resolve for 10 seconds. Can be used while incapacitated. Remaining Uses Today: 2
PONDER - See available transport locations
PROD - Toggle ambient messaging on/off
WHISPER [CLOAK] HELP - Get some information about the cloak.
WHISPER [CLOAK] SHRINE - Immediate travel to the nearest Gosaena shrine in this realm. You must be outside in order to harness this power.
This cloak was created for the 2023 Auction.```
MK Mug.
What did the last MK mug item go for?
lesser transmute will get make it 600ish
How many mugs does it take to recoup 200m? 😆
is 1099 difficulty correct there?
Falicor wins the MK Mug backslasher for 200m!
Next up... polished copper prayerbeads, +5 Cleric Base enhancive.
That difficulty is brutal
it basically needs a lesser transmute
can that get lesser transmuted away from obsidian?
is obsidian an organic material? lol
Jahira says, "1099... because the wielder of that sword works for themself."
What is Gosaena's Resolve?
to stuff everyone behind the gate-eventually
It's new, and related to the cloak.
A special buff!
Dhairn wins the Cleric Base enhancive for 100m!
Next up... the pie box!
how did the empath spellbook item go for the most of any spellbook item yet and they don't even have a service
You can lesser to glaes for those who wondered
Oh yes, finally the good stuff. 😍
oh god... it's the pie box...
C'moooooooooon Gutstorm. 🤣
has to change his name to Piestorm if he wins
otherwise it's entrapment
Clown wins the pie box for 110m!
Next up... Tintinabar!
very fitting
ok... I cannot even argue with the pie thrower going to Clown
hoping thats starchitin heh
live debate, this item better than troll heart?
porque no los dos?
Kysari wins the Tintinabar for 126m!
Next up... a property!
better functionally...except worse because you have to sound like a cat all the time
The cat part is the only thing I cared about! Got Symbol of Restoration for health needs!
I only cared about the HP
the cat part was the best part
i wouldn't mind a mana version
Mana or stamina would be way, way more attractive. HP is so easy to quickly regain
especially if we can turn off the cat part
Balekia wins the property for 135m!
Next up... ultra sanctify potion.
the overcoat go out yet?
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12AqaOnUrvbpk8xmNePBoX3CbfaznbByggPqrNJjRo7o/edit#gid=1025328053
for today's auction in prime
lol well balanced player service
judging by how much these single pour elixirs go for I think simu should really consider bringing back GUB
This is the item catering to the last chance GUB buyers, heh.
They knew what they were doing with Sanct and then a bunch of ascension undead hunting grounds
drain that silver
If this item doesn't end up in the HESS or Spellbound by August, I literally never want to hear accusations of greed toward the staff again. 😛
Still waiting on a 60-70 undead hunting ground tho
lol
Could you imagine chugging the potion and then fumbling the cast?
we need to price match this thing...
omg
Exdeo wins the Sanctify potion for 466m!
Next up... the Gosaena cloak!
how much for a bundle deal for 6 of these? heh
It appears to weigh about 4 pounds.
It is estimated to be worth about 600,000 silvers.
It is a container with a maximum interior capacity of 200 pounds with room for any number of items. It appears to reduce the weight of its contents by 66%.
It is predominantly crafted of cloth.
The duster can be worn, hanging it from the shoulders. The duster appears to serve some purpose.
The leather duster is a garment that changes messaging depending on the climate you're in, or whether it is raining/snowing outside. This item can be altered, it just needs to remain the basic essence of what the item is (no changing a cloak into a dress, but a cloak into a coat is fine).
The duster is fully unlocked with feature concealer ability. It has 16 verbs.
This is currently set to be a coat of some sort.
The duster is currently hooded with the following custom hood: voluminous silver-edged hood.
The duster currently has the following for custom fastenings: ghostwood knot buttons.
The duster currently has default pockets, but it could have custom ones added by a skilled merchant. Options are a small pocket, a large pocket, small scabbards, weapon loops, large pouches, and small pouches.```
I can also imagine forgetting to pour enhancive prep potions
beauty
these heavy weight loss cloaks always kill me
I was just going to say "I respect sticking to item conformity" but not even 0.5 weight drama cloaks at auction 😦
You do not have to be a cleric to teleport -- being a cleric allows you to teleport to the cleric guilds, otherwise, it's only teleporting to the Gosaena shrines
"reduces weight by 33%" "weighs 12 lb"
33% of 200 is a lot more than 12lbs
but its less than 33% +10lbs
it's also 12 lb more than 0.5 lb
what is the resolve ability?
a mystery
tele to shrine?
a new ability
Siduine says, "Resolve = It will restore 100% of your missing health, 10% per second over 10 seconds, 2.5 percent of your mana, and 2.5 percent of your stamine, it also boosts your DS and TD by a bunch."
That's a neat item, Haliste!
Yo can we get the archaic Fash'no'lae teleport cloak updated to that standard, haha
Emyle wins the Gosaena cloak for 200m!
Next up... a property!
we clearly need more deity cloaks like this one
Fash'lo'nae cloak would go for 500m haha
would be cool if there was one for each deity - with its own unique flavor/flare - but one-of-a-kind
Wish I hadn't bought something last week now.
everyone is restocked with coins so the prices are big
Ronan cloak, easily INT_MAX
Less deals because more competetion for less items, sucks for people who didn't buy last weekend
Wish the door would open!
JOMO
door only opens if you have more than 100mil on you
Idk, that mug short sword went for way less than I expected considering it pays for itself lol
People are going big for this, but the smart money would wait until the next 6 come out next month
you probably could have got it for half, lol
interesting to see the middle class property prices creeping up. not sure I believe its because more silvers. Maybe a new crop of people able to attend earlier in the day
Erykk wins the property for 140m!
Next up... Water familiar talisman!
The HoA people got to redistribute coins to their alts
Maybe. I doubt it though
Any chance on letting more people in? I thought it started at 1pm est
They are opening every once in a while
ALERT. my mind is fresh and clear. please send exp
oh wow, this have jumped way higher than I thought it would go
i'd bid on this if my wizard was a water build, this is really cool
the enhancives are very good
its a cool snake, which is what turned me off, but its a popular animal so v0v
I am all about water lore though 😦
MOAR water
makes it just a bit easier to get that familiar anchoring with water lore lol
Raythiel wins the Water familiar for 137m!
Next up... a humidor!
i don't even know what to say
is that just unlimited cigars? for 100m?
I have one of these I paid 11m for like a decade ago, but the new cigars from EG and the like are so much better
Yeah, I wish the old ones could be updated to be wearable, at least
Lunatick wins the humidor for 100m!
Next up... a tiny tag-affixed key!
did we learn what this is?
semi custom portable property
This key entitles the winner to a semi-custom temporary home, which can be activated once per week, allowing the structure to stand for 24 hours. Further details will be discussed with the winner.```
thanks all, stunned from the last round
The pause really inflated what a lot of these would have gone for last week I think
Yep
Especially at 2 AM haha
That's why I wanted to forge ahead, there would have been some good deals at 2am on a Sunday night
I legit might walk out of this auction with no wins, but we'll see. 😂
Archsenex wins the semi-custom temporary property for 160m!
Next up... a teapot!
Honestly though there are player-owned weapons that are similar to these or even better for 100-300mil floating around, share the love and buy player owned. Need to boost the secondary market.
thats the boat I am in, but maybe next auction. There are also things that are like so close to being perfect for Ordim but off just enough that I would feel bad putting my whole effort behind them and either winning and not appreciating it enough as someone else, or just driving the price up needlessly on a whim
is there a store that sells coffee beans/tea leaves?
Starbucks?
several tea stores, I think coffee beans are a bit rarer outside events?
Most cafes will have it up front or in backroom for tea leaves
coffee is somewhat hard to find outside of an event
so we need a special item that converts RL items into GS items?
a credit card?
Topps wins the teapot for 63m!
Next up... the Earth familiar talisman!
Casu's Cafe in Vaalor sells coffee/tea
fire version probably go for a lot
Nidal wins the Earth familiar for 100m!
Next up...the +5 AS monster flesh!
I'm really happy with that, my wizard is an earth guy and it's perfect for him. didn't expect to get an alt anything
Earthd +5 DS went for 60mil, be interesting to see what 5 AS goes for
To be fair, he didn't realize it was the DS one and thought it was a pick-your-benefit thing.
Ahh
Roblar wins the 5 AS monster flesh for 200m in one of the most perfect wins yet!
Next up... the temporal warblade!
Mirth wins it for 250m!
Next up... an herblore tome!
Perigourd wins it for 130m!
Next up... an ice gown!
knife fight!
'nother shot of exp?
Melivn wins the the ice gown for 225m!
Next up... 20x/day 518 wand.
Prettiest rolton in Elanthia
Faerinn wins the wand for 40m!
Next up... 66% weight reduction ClimateWear!
that just sold in plat a few minutes ago for 78m and change.
66% is a lot of dolla
did the gosaena cloak have wr?
no
No
If I ever get called a whale again, this is the auction I'm pointing to as refutation. This one and no other. 🤣 People are regularly paying 5-20 times more than I would for this stuff, heh.
These prices are low compared to DR equivalents thiugh
An unfortunate benchmark, if we're being honest
(Yeah, the above just goes even more to my point since I'd even less pay the bloodscrip equivalent. 😛 )
Mither wins the WR ClimateWear for 225m!
Next up... an odd-looking plant!
Lots more people have tons of BS than tons of silver
Aren't +5 spell circles like 500k bs or something?
200, or 150 attuned
if you "could" outbid everyone.. you're still a whale
seems I disconnected
If you assume DR prices are good, then yes - these are great deals. I'm not sure that's universally agreed upon though 😬
There's only 50b silver in the game. Probably half belongs to 3 people, heh.
Do we know what time the warehouse will be opened next?
any idea how many items are left?
It was opened at 1:30 I think? So probably 2:30 if it's not sold out by then
I'd love to know how much silver is present at the auction in platinum
like 10? not that many
Kayse wins the plant for 95m!
Next up... auction quality OSA wand!
(There are about 20 items left.)
Aww man. Disconnect punted me out 😦
those wands get you ships to fight?
I enjoy my new addition to my weird Xday item collection
I thought the same... which is why I thought I'd be safe to change networks. Alas...
Can we get a Raelee summon up in here?
Carcalda wins the wand for 74m!
Next up... an herblore tome!
Thank you for opening it again! I am back in
it's not supposed to, we tested it in Plat and everyone who logged out logged back in in the warehouse.
Has anything broached 1b? Most of these items are surprisingly low amounts, haven't seen any big hitters
Highest was the T5 tome for 650mil, I believe
probably in the RoL auction for billion+ items - doubt they want to limit the market on those
Lunok wins the tome for 76m!
Next up... lesser Amulet of the Arkati!
...Tintinbell is up in plat...
Tahlaer says, "Put this on Vyrshkana so she can't sneak up on people."
I think all of the alts bidding hundreds of millions puts that theory to rest, heh, reality is that there's only so many people who -can- bid a billion+
That was the other item I wanted. Be interested to see what it guess for
And the people that can bid a billion+ can probably do it 7 or 8 times
There's nothing worth 1 billion though to test it out
but do you think they also have 7-8 accounts at the auction? maybe I dunno
I fully believe there's at least 1 or 2 people here with 7-8 accounts with at least 250m on each of them
I was just thinking you could add a number to this... Also here: A large crowd (455).
Kryllix takes the amulet for 318m!
Next up... an ice gown!
Double drama included for free.
what I learned from this auction is it's all about gowns and private properties
If I were GS staff, I'd never offer a fire gown or ice gown at a raffle again. 🤣 Clearly this is where the real money is.
If I were GS staff I would stuff them both in a t-shirt cannon and fire upon a crowd. Then I would no longer be staff.
like I would never have guessed that a one of a kind +5 AS would go for 200m and some fluff gown is at 510m already
Barbies b crazy
Two of a kind
Katara wins the ice gown for 510m!
Next up... ghezyte claidhmore!
Monsterflesh went for 60m last week.
it was a +DS one
the DeSoLaToR
Ok you got me there. Is AS really that’s more valuable?
than DS, definitely
If you play BigNumberStone, yes
Also by its script properties I think more monster flesh is going to be out. A lot of this things are available or will be available OTS at pay events.
hell yeah
Yorvo wins the claidhmore for 250m!
Next up... +5 Paladin Base ranks!
solid price for the claidh really
Whoever made my rat familiar, I love him. This item is awesome. I couldn't be more stoked with what I ended up deciding to buy.
I'm glad! I hoped those would go to people who would love them.
those familiar talismans are all really cool
me talking to my custom familiar when i was helping nidal understand how familiar talismans work:
"This is your cousin" <point rat>
There's one ambient in particular for the sand rat that gives me a chuckle.
ahhh I wish there was an upgrade for your current familiar
i had never landed on one i was attached to with my wizard, another reason the rat was perfect
Semi-custom DR talismans would be interesting, pick a creature type, get it altered, have some basic ambients and stuff
The ambients on that are 🔥 Gyres
Fulmen wins the Paladin Base enhancive for 75m!
Next up... a reptilian glamour pin thingy!
Myharl wins it for 130m, having gone from ice gown contender to lizardman!
Next up... a weather charm!
what even is this charm
It changes the weather in one room for a little while.
why?
for funzies?
People like crazy things
You can also set the weather in an area for a bit (I think?)
make all of WL blood rain if you want, call up a thunderstorm to RP putting out fires
I would make it a heat wave in HW
955,140,000 silvers total
Platinum's auction finished
that sounds like a lot for plat
Vishra wins the weather charm for 100m! I... am perfectly content with mine that only does rain and snow and cost a third of the price.
Next up... the white ora scarab! This is a big one, +10 health/mana/stamina recovery with infinite charges.
we almost done here too
Were there any surprise items?
No
nononononononono there's a high priest from the griffin sword saga up there, frozen, don't let him thaw
Gyres, these new custom familiars are amazing!
Azanoth wins the scarab for 450m!
Next up... an herblore tome!
Yessss!
What's so special about custom familiars?
Upon discovery of a stray bit of edible flotsam, the sand rat grips it tight in his tiny paws and methodically nibbles it down. hes perfect 🐀
they have custom stuff
They like very rarely every happen?
I like having neat stuff?
Different ambients? How are they different
I think we're under a double digit number of items left now, barring any duplicates that might have gotten added after the snafus last week.
I am so happy for you, but also kinda jelly. Def wanted to bid! 
Aside from the enhancives on the talismans, they're just interesting flavor. They've got six unique ambients and a custom look.
When the snake went I thought to myself, I'd bid on an Earth one, and welp
one more gown, dramatic drapery cloak, chain mana armor... and I think one more thing I'm forgetting is whats left
OSA tricorn hat, leather harness.
Merelle wins the herblore tome for 110m!
Next up... mana-infused hauberk aug chain!
haubergeon != hauberk
Xelleon wins the aug chain for 140m!
Next up... a harness!
Jet pack harness
oh I thought this already sold last week welp there goes my counts hah
(FYI, the scarabs can be inspected now)
Im poor now, if you see me, give me food lol
the scarabs are adorable
WEAR/REMOVE - Stylized to work with cloud armors, ShadowDeath armor, and Mist armor. Is this a thing on all pirate harnesses?
Gossan wins the hover harness for 150m!
Next up... an ice gown!
Yes.
Thanks! Now I need one!
As the sand rat gives a sudden, body-shaking sneeze, a cloud of bright bronze dust billows from his sandy fur.
never have I ever considered the sound of a rat sneeze
Ganalon wins the ice gown for 295m! Apparently differences in description mean all the world even though they can be altered!
Next up... an herblore tome!
where's the sea of fire?
If altering them is anything like altering a Girl on Fire gown ... worth the difference.
SOS
The Sea of Fire is the Sanctum area. Which had foraging bounties for like... a week after release and then never again. 😢
that's too cute!
not all of solhaven?
No, the Sea of Fire is its own whole area geographically. Right now, the only parts of it we see are the Sanctum of Scales and the surrounding desert and oasis.
This has gone nice and smooth. Nice job to staff
Orlicks wins the herblore tome for 79m and some change!
Next up... the Dramatic Drapery cloak! Only two items left!
Kitton wins the Dramatic Drapery for 220m!
Next up and last up... the OSA hat!
repair a ship once every 2 hours eh?
they also make you look like a spookyghost
Congrats to the staff for running a very smooth auction. The new auction system, now that the kinks are worked out, is fantastic
Maeveline wins the final item, the OSA hat, for 100m!
Next up is see you in four weeks or so!
We have a whole four weeks!?
And thanks for working the weekend for us
shoot some tshirts into the crowd!
staff being able to run simultaneous auctions in plat and prime is really cool, glad to see things progress and improve. And thanks to everyone who made really neat and cool items!
One last RPA for the road? 🥺
This auction went much smoother than the last time, thank you!!
seemed smooth from this side!
It was definitely smoother on our side. 😛
An old memory bubbles up, and you wonder what happened to that jack-o'-lantern of yours from last year.
the audacity
An old memory bubbles up from your past, and causes you to reflect a moment. With a flash of insight, you realize that it was just gas. The sudden feeling of warmth is a pleasant one.
An old memory bubbles up from your past, and causes you to reflect a moment. With a flash of insight, you realize that it was just gas. The sudden feeling of warmth is a pleasant one.
GOLD
:jeer:
It's a real nice system once the kinks got worked out
time for a good old landing goodbye (set the room on fire)
Well, that was fun. Time to get some breakfast, then campaign appeal to reason for the RoL event boxes to be cheaper since clearly there's far less silver in the world now!
LOL
Unleash unspeakable evil?
surprise?
A powerful warhorn thrums from nearby, followed by the unmistakably handsome voice of a giantman calling out, "Blacksmith Grawlix will be drinking from his famous keg and hosting Dragon Bones in the Wedding Glade!" The voice begins to fade as you hear mention of a dusty brown tent.```
come spend your leftover silvers
But not selling kegs huh?
cant play dragonbones with an empty mind
GIFTBOX isn't active right now.```
😢
Question about the weather charm. Push/Point is supposed to create weather right?
Additionally, you can PUSH and POINT twice per day to create rain, snow, or blood rain. It's not doing anything. Also is this supposed to be realm wide? (Rub is obviously in the room only)
Did I miss the gift box. Or just not released yet?
I threw them all out.
I'm not aware of weather charms having a realm ability, only room.
dark plum-hued leather tome with gilded edging
get my tome appears broken 🙂
Yeah they're still fixing the herb tomes.
for some reason I thought the 2016 ones were realm-wide ooops. But mine isn't creating weather even in the room
If 15B coins got removed, and say that is 15-25% of all current coins... does that mean Monday silver prices up 25%? (supply and demand!)
Push/Pull is messaging, not a cycled storm.
Verbs: WAVE, TAP, TOSS, and KISS. Once per day you may RUB your crystal globe charm to create a rain or snowstorm in the room. You can TURN it to cycle through the available types of storms.
Additionally, you can PUSH and POINT twice per day to create rain, snow, or blood rain.
I thought that meant 1x/day was just in the room and the other 2x/day were realm-wide
@silver imp I submitted a BUG, but I think the analyze on this was maybe wrong
that'll show me to make an analyze for something that doesn't have one! 😂
ha
Thank you Tivvy, I was trying to type out but caught in the timer -- I think the analyze is wrong, because the two verbs predate the analyze for this item. It also was only ever room wide, never realm wide. By all means tho, feel free to make them all realm wide ;D
point:
Naamit points her charm at you and its surface begins to swirl with grey, violet, and crimson. Suddenly, a bolt of lightning shoots out of the charm directly at you, disappearing just before it reaches you.
push:
Naamit pushes her charm out in front of her. Violet bolts of energy fly from its surface in her direction, spiraling around her before fading away.
I just copied the info from the information GMs can see so that's possible.
I don't anticipate the functionality being changed but I'll see about updating the analyze to be clearer.
Push and point just zap people. 🤨
Shouldn't there be movement messaging with the herblore tomes when held and open or is that only limited to the specific terrain the tome relates to?
Limited to the realm.
Ah, thank you. That's a shame.
When Vanah made the update it was the first thing I tested. Heh.
If I'd known that, I probably wouldn't have gone all out for it 😕
I wonder if that could be revisited
i would be up for that!
I think the fluff should work in all realms 🙂
@neat nexus Please could the realm limitations on the herblore tome movement messaging be revisited and opened up to work everywhere since it's purely RP?
I can double check that part specifically but it was intended that all features work in the realm only
Thank you for the consideration. I completely understand that everything else should be realm specific
I wrongly assumed that movement was part of the fluff aspects of the tome
I dunno who made this but it's beautiful:
You lightly graze your fingertips along the fabric of your nacre velvet gown, creating complex patterns of crystalline snowflakes that overlap as they evaporate into a mist of brilliant silver and gold.
Alright. Time to pause this and see how they are adding 15 a day rubs to the brooches in RoL!
Am i doing this right with the sea of fire herblore tome? It doesn't seem to be working in any rooms I try it in ```[Sea of Fire, Kanchoco Oasis - 25144] (u4216102)
Sand gives way to richer earth near the shining verges of the water, which begins not far from the base of a long ramp of hard-packed sand. The shoreline is dappled in blinding light and stark shadow, the former from the persistant pounding of the sun, and the latter, a blessing from leaning date palms that have sprung forth from the fertile soil. The trees are stunted little things, whipped at all times by the sere desert wind, but their shadows are cool and deep and welcoming.
Obvious paths: northeast
look at my tome
The sand-worn tome is open to the Table of Contents.
read my tome
You cannot do that right now.```
what can be foraged in the Sanctum, anyway? not even seeing anything with FORAGE SENSE, except for a few things in the desert proper
the oasis has some mushrooms and other cave stuff
There's about 5 things--oh in the desert, yes.
didn't even work in the desert
I think the table of contents is broken on the tomes. I meant to bug it but forgot.
@silver imp Any chance the jump jet could be passive. Signed, rocket man
I can't look at it again right now
yeah I agree. I think to table of contents doesn't work
So much I want teased for the next one.
🥺
any gms able to fix hoy outside dragon bones?
ASSIST or REPORT in game please.
Thanks to all the GMs for the auction(s).
https://gswiki.play.net/Grand_Auction_of_5123/March_List
Has been updated with the final results. (Just a little easier for me to read vs the spreadsheet.)
Are there any reasons with the odd looking plant a foraged item wouldn't work? Tried a red winterberry and it gave me the RT of attempting to graph, but wouldn't take it. Anything else that hasn't been forgable I have gotten different messaging on:
As you bring the red winterberry near the twisted stalk of your odd-looking plant, in an attempt to coax the red winterberry onto the plant, nothing seems to happen.
That was an unsuccessful attempt.
Can you threaten the plant into being more successful, perhaps with fire?
Surreptitiously placing it on the ground when Maylans chinchilla is running amok?
You're a bad bad man.
Imagine the chinchilla getting into the still….chinchAlea
A sand elemental flayed my hand once, I put it in a locker for 27 years to think about it's actions
They are neat when they're fully trained! Big emphasis on when
(Sand elementals that is, not Chinchillas, chinchillas are pretty neat 24/7)
i like that trick they do, i think its called "being a coat"
Ah! Thank you. I am only having unsuccessful attempts with the winterberry so that's interesting.
There are lots of herbs there, especially in the several safe areas outside the desert. There used to be herb bounties, but they were disabled at some point. Forageables vary greatly from daytime to nighttime. Good variety of health point herbs, including strigae cactus and yabathilium fruit.
Yeah, the yabathilium fruit from the desert is nice
It took me several tries to get some things to take, but succeeded eventually.
Anyone able to help me find that map of Nereid's Cradle? I'm going to add it to the mapdb.
#krakenʼs-fall message
Thank you!
hey @hollow elm can you map my KF? 🙏
I charge 1 key for my keyring!
deal.
...I'm hiding from Tivvy and...a couple of other GMs.
Ah, levels 60-70 undead Voln hunting, where my character advancement goes to die.
I'm sorry!
I know its a ton of work for everyone involved in the auction backend, making sure everything goes right, and I wanted to thank each and every one of you for knocking this one out of the park. ❤️
Super cool event. Trouble with the auctioneer sucked but it was awesome to see it get fixed.
That was smooth as butter this time around
Yeah, I'm optimistic for the one in a few weeks!
Ok, had a few entries wrong in my platinum auction google sheet. Verified my logs.
Platinum Drained 1,017,515,000 silvers. We did cross that billion threshold.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1URbqQ34PQaW8K6XfPjchhVYiRfRuFc-MaZ22pvzQCgE/edit?usp=sharing
Looks like y'all had a good time.
I'd like an economic update from Wyrom! Although I suppose he might want to wait until after RoL.
What's the date for the next auction?
I'm always curious about silver totals. Would be interested to hear how much was left in the various instances
nothing firm yet...one of the last two weekends of april
4/22 pls kthx! 😄
Will he raise interest rates!? Stay tuned!
...can the nail presses please be made to work like face painting and monk tattoos? Where the recipient gets a message "So and so is trying to do whatever, accept in the next 30 seconds"?
because otherwise I see it becoming extremely an expensive locker resident.
There's no confirmation of acceptance? I kinda figured that was a given at this point.
you have to be holding it.
point my press at [name]
If [name] would like her nails painted, she will need to use the press on her own.
Yes, this was changed recently. For the last week it had worked by just pointing it at someone else. I’d also like this option to remain, even if you need to accept or wait a few seconds to continue, please.
Yes, please allow it to work on others! My spa would thank you!
(Different item, same issue: I would also love it if hair-braiding tools were updated to allow point/accept usage.)
So, the option to use it on other people WILL work in the future; it was not supposed to be working, but I missed part of disabling it. I'm just waiting on some other stuff to be done, then I'll activate it. 🙂
👍
Please make an announcement as to when that functionality goes live?
Hurrah, thank you Casil! It's a ballertastic item, very much more fun to play with even than anticipated.
Thank you!
so wyrom, what's the thinking after the 1st auction set is completed with what? 15 billion silver drained? meet expectations/exceed/underperformed?
it was rigged.... some clown came and swipped my pie box 🤣
There was an emergency meeting about how the direction of dev is going to move solely into to a full blown gown review all other work has been put on hold for this to put out new amazing gowns and dresses, its the new silvers drain/micro tran money maker.
And from the Barbies, there was much rejoicing!
I welcome this new direction in development
I mean, Estild is already the Master of the Shimmer, what would you expect?
One noticeable difference was that it 'seemed' (I haven't checked the numbers) like the final sale price for most everything on this Day 2 of the auction was north of 100m. I think the cone of elements wand and the teapot were the only items that sold for less than 75m?
Not sure why that trend occurred, but it was a stark difference to Day 1.
its always best to try and get in early on an auction, prices always go up as they wind down
I expected that. It was just the idea that the 100m is enough was sort of completely untrue on day 2.
As you approach the end, people who have been saving for something but missed might start to get the "well I might as well win something" mindset
people become more willing to go high "to get something at all" and also there's less reason to hold out to save your one slot once you reach a certain point. I'm sure being able to move money did impact but it was a combination
this is completely subjective but I think the second half of the auction had better items too.
Some of the items I valued at no more than 5-20m went for 100+. I still don't see the value others did.
well, some of it is just "I have silver, and it's worthless if I don't spend it"
Fair point. I don't want to call anyone out on any particular item, but some of those I was like ....you could just run a script for a free.
All that said. To me, the exciting items aren't the one off scripts that will never see the light of day again. I was most intrigued by stuff that is getting an auction preview ahead of general sales at the next DR. Those tomes look amazing. Seeing them in action definitely is making me want one
such as what out of curiosity?
also day two saw OSA wand, KF herblore tome, teapot, 518 wand, +5 paladin ranks, sea of fire herbtome, go for under 100m
By tomes you mean the herb tomes or the fancy eat a scroll tome? because the later is T5 which they said wont be for sale.
The T5 is just the major sanct feature. They did indicate that up to T4 would be available off the shelf, albeit pricey
The weather charm I don't get, honestly. I guess thats a 'i can blood mage now' thing? The OSA hat I don't value really at all. ;damagecontrol takes care of that.
All that said, I'm not knocking anyone else for the value they see in something.
I thought the Thamauturge tomes are going up for sale with expensive upgrades
yeah, the tomes, up to T4, will be OTS but 'spensive
I can live with a combat pet being expensive. I also adore the idea of feeding it scrolls instead of pawning things
I do appreciate that the "we will pay just as much, if not more, for fluff" crowd was proven correct.
I do think part of that relates to the fact that the mechanical gear in this auction had a LOT of caveats
for me, my valuation is probably off-kilter because I have most things I "want" already, and don't have a typical playstyle, so I mostly bought my thing because I thought it would end up being cool/fun and the price was mostly "is this comically overpriced? if no, then I'll buy it" I'm not completely crazy like some people... I seriously have a capped character using a 2x weapon right now because I'm too lazy to enchant it up
My personal notice was that almost all of it would have a 'wasted' feature on my warrior. I don't have spells or use mana. So any mana recoveries, etc are all just me hurling silver into the void
very much this.
I would also add a sense of fatigue is a relevant sentiment from some players as well when it comes to mechanics and itemization
the thaumaturge ones are and listed as being "Expensive" whatever that means but no t5, it is just the private sanct part but that comes with a personal mailbox and two more of the fluff verbs from the tome unlocked for what thats worth.
The OSA hat was a proxy buy for me, its 100% covered by a script I completely agree. It's more of a this is neat and RP thing and very much falls into the I have silvers that are useless to me otherwise, I stopped running DR and thusly stopped dumping all my silvers into books during these events. Which means I am sitting on an ungodly amount of silvers, between my normal hunting which I started to focus on silver gaining with the auction announced and flipping services on 7 alts, I was in the what am I going to do with these billions of silvers. TLDR I agree the hat was a dumb over priced buy but I have nothing better to waste my silvers on in gemstone which is the real problem.
I really enjoyed the wide array of prices. Also that nothing was lost to not hitting the reserve.
prices on things always goes up towards the end of these types of auctions, remember all of this also was supposed to be one whole auction, so you really have to take last week and yesterdays as two parts of the same whole
I was talking to someone last night about this. The best compliment I can say is that most of the ots scripts for weapons and such in DR these days are more interesting and fun than any of the auction equivalents in almost all cases. If only one ever Animal weapon had been built and put up for auction, i'd be a legendary one off. The fact that its available to all, alongside fun and effective ones like Valence and others means that truly legendary primary gear is not gated to auctions
Prices did seem to go up on day 2. The cone of elements wand was an outlier in that it stayed the same.
The bungalow prices are kind of the best indicator of how auction pricing works.
all of the items I was interested in just happened to be in the second half of the auction too.
That's relevant, but I was more referring to the great effort that's involved in starting a new project, the strong negative sense that comes from abandoning an existing project, the near non-existence of a secondary or resale market, and the near impossibility of project transfer.
These are solvable problems, but nothing I've seen leads me to believe this is a current team interest.
I see this point for sure. After all...for me 5-20m probably matters as much as 200m does to someone else.
I'd love to see a lot of this stuff sold OTS at base line prices vs only being in an auction, those neighborhood houses being first on that list really. like you noted a lot of it is just covered with a script and it just falls into a this is a fun item category at the end of the day.
I find it really really gratifying to see that these MCPs are likely to stay in the 80k-120kbs range. Thats very reasonable. Some will be more expensive in more desirable towns, I'd guess, though I also expect that people will leap on any that are in a desirable 'region'.
I continue that champion the idea that these auctions are great, but it's not really a sustainable model. I hope that a large effort is being placed into sustainable, desired, and well conceived in game silver sinks.
I think they have those, with the event boxes, the problem really has been that doesn't deal with the 50b stockpile on 10ish total people
went 10 folks basically have more silver than the rest of the game population combined, you are VERY limited in options
I would really love to see the auctions be a way to introduce and preview upcoming things that are going to be OTS at some point. I think that is the part that is most interesting for the wider audience who cannot likely ever get that 100-200m price point covered. It would also help isolate bugs on the one or two people who have them before its a game wide problem among 200 players.
Event boxes aren't quite what I'm referring to. They are effective in draining silvers from the overall pool, but they don't have the same mass appeal and are tied to events themselves.
I'm talking about permanent fixtures. Multiple ideas have been expressed elsewhere that I don't recall getting much, if any, feedback on
but that's basically exactly opposite from what Wyrom told us about event boxes, that they have been incredibly successful at draining 90% of the population's silver. That is pretty much mass appeal.
But yeah, that doesn't solve the other 10%, which is why they did things like auctions, to try and make a dent in those stored up silvers. I know a lot of things have been talked about, but besides something like what was talked about with rerolling the ascension zone trinket stats w/silvers (whenever those are implemented), not too much do I think is really targeted to that 10% either.
Yeah, this happened to me right at the start, super frustrating, I missed the things I was planning to bid on. That really needs to be fixed.
I think I'm not making my point here.
To drain the maximum amount of silvers in the population, event boxes seem to be somewhat effective, although waning in popularity. Since this is a direct revenue hit, I'm not sure this is a sustainable model either. More to the point, I don't know many event box sellers that are happy to pass along their boxes to buyers, particularly as the included RPA orbs have dwindled and the event box price event considered a value from resellers. They are also limited by the events themselves and account based- so if you can generate more in a period than the boxes come around, you are still left with the feeling of nothing to spend your money on.
The types of things I'm referring to would be ideas that most, if not all, players would find continued and perpetual value in. Not every idea would hit every player, but enough ideas have been expressed to cover a wide range of playestyles
I don't want to rehash every idea here- Wyrom asked for some a few months ago and lots of ideas were posted- With all the effort that went into these one time drains, my ask is that a similar future effort be made for sustainable silver sinks outside an auction that occurs twice a decade.
Wyrom was pretty clear that event boxes have more or less drained the middling player dry. Not sure that it has had a big impact on the big dogs.
From a personal standpoint, the likes of OTS DR gear are both a blessing and a curse. I absolutely love that DR has brought accessibility and normalization to "fancy" gear (in terms of mechanical scripts for this context). I've enjoyed the process of building up and customizing my animal spirit gear over the last several years and it's very fulfilling to my GS goals. But it also means that my scope of what might drive me to purchase mechanical gear at an auction is much narrower. For the most part, it'd have to be a completely unique style of weapon (example: elemental gauntlet, spirit glove bow, chainspear-esque) AND be thematically on point (e.g. MonstrFlesh is a super neat idea, but not something I ever envision my characters utilizing. Similar for the spider bracer). To be clear, this isn't a complaint in any shape or form, I don't mean to imply any dissatisfaction with the offerings - some very fun things went out the door. It just didn't happen to align 100% for me this time around, which again is absolutely okay. All of my bids were of the "well, I would use that at this price point, but I don't need it"
I also think that previous decisions have secondary impacts. No ensorcell and sanct certs at HESS, for example, make me value a -2200 difficulty item way less and I put mechanical things in relative comparison to DR type offerings. Unless it's on an unallowed base, most things get compared to a somnis/low steel/xaz thing. Which is fine, but then they get moved, in my mind, from main type item to fun fluff, which also impacts value
And to my point above, there is a diminishing number of players who are paying for those fun fluff type things.
In think that was a lot of this. Many of the times are things you can or will be able to get OTS. Some of these are previews. I know we’re going to see wandaliers, thaumaturgy tomes, punch bowls, and nail presses ots. I bet instant teapots and humidors will be too. I suspect Middle Class housing will look like stall sales at some point, maybe. Ice dresses and monstrflesh probably just the auction/raffle level.
If you aren't in possession of a super easy to sell player service, the "secret" to having silver is the same as weight loss. Stop checking the scale bank account every day. It's an "every day adds a little" thing, which adds up over a year or more.
There is no silver bullet. I think that people are looking at some of these prices with a very pessimistic assessment of their own ability to generate a basic income. You might not hit the ludicrous levels some people do, but you can easily get over the initial hump.
Wyrom was also pretty clear - maybe on multiple occasions - that other new silver sink projects were in the works.
The tickets to the NPE island and Phyon are going to be super expensive
Want to drain silvers, give us a one time only magic box that we can feed silvers into for ATP's
My gut feeling is that the 1-per limit definitely added some weight to the "most people have less than 100 million" comment. Between all the changes we've seen in the last few years to income and item availability, there's definitely been a pretty significant impact.
At an unlimited auction not that long ago, I would not have been surprised to see all those mana armors snapped up at twice the price as just-in-case project pieces. The t5 surita sigil in 2020 went for more than twice as much as Goat's did last week.
An idea I had....with Wyrom offering Event Boxes outside of events now....Id be interested in a 1/mo event box that maybe includes a base model of what would otherwise be an OTS level purchase of an event item. Maybe even those items that are now retired from events.
Imagine an event box that lets you spend ...dunno. 10m. You get orbs, some simustore stuff and a morphing cloak, or a discrete script cloak. Or whatever. I dunno exactly what you would put in there, but I'm sure others could come up with ideas.
A monthly fluff box could be interesting
Yeah. I was even thinking like a subscription box model. You pay X million and you get 3 months of stuff. Ever box has a ticket that lets you pull from a prize pile that's got 100 items with X scripts on them.
Enhancive rerolling was teased. I think that will drain a lot depending on how it is eventually implemented
Event boxes would be a good way to reintroduce trove tokens.
I think a monthly violet experience orb for silvers would be a good drain. Offer the 4 levels for different silver amounts.
Green 100k
Blue 500k
Indigo 1 mil
Violet 10 mil
Put trove in WL, add 52 items, event boxes give out tokens, 1/x pull a week type of thing?
Yeah, maybe not even trove? Like the 25k shell pull pile level of stuff?
It’s gonna cost 100 million silvers to leave Phyon.
Alternatively a GM could devlop a Gold Saucer from FFXIV with lots of silver or alternate currency gambling (Including USD derived tokens if so inclined) for prize tickets with lots of different fluff to choose from. Could have an entrance in every town and stash the Invoker there. Maybe those Sea of Fire nomad Tehir are looking for a tax credit and want to build a Casino?
I mean all we need to do to drain silvers is apparently have a one time only unlimited buy 2000k sanct potion buy for 500m each
For the GUB regret.
Shoot let's cut out the middle man, just add holy fire flares to an existing t5 sanct 500m each. 1 day only get it while it's hot
speaking of which, I whispered into Modrian's ear about making a rolton racetrack with the wind up roltons, pennant racers
there's been at least one. One of the racing rolton shops had one out back.
Btw, did emails go out to the private property voucher winners with the Rules & Regulations like previous property owners? Or is that not a thing anymore and new PP owners are meant to just understand that https://gswiki.play.net/Private_property/Property_Rules_%26_Regulations exists for them to know about the rules and regulations that govern their new purchase?
Oh did I miss the conversation that fluff sells?
Cuz it does.
Well yeah. Much of it is far more rare
What I wanna know is wear is my fancy ice/ fire tuxedo/suit
Yasssssssss
Equality for Menswear!
And yeah I know suits are more of a pain as they are technically multiple items, shirt, jacket, pants, but I k own we could totally have something sweet there at some point. I swear it'd prolly sell for as much as a gown.
This doesn't always have to be the case and I'll share my favorite example of extremely high level fluff distribution.
Nalea gowns which I believe debuted either at Artisan Faire or the Wavedancer 2004ish had such an incredible model. Nalea would say she was taking customers and then people would flood to her. Once people were chosen they would give her a color and then she'd bring out two gowns. The customer got to pick one and it was still pretty high priced for back then I want to say it was like flat 500k or a million which felt weighty but not out of reach.
The other one though would then be auctioned off to anyone who is present. No matter if they had already gotten a gown or what.
So if you were selected you were guaranteed a gown, but then it was still causing the fluff to be driven up in prices.
Enhancive rerolling could be a huge drain, depending on how it’s implemented
Or enhancive combining but priced closer to 1 billion per.
The shirt, pants, vest, sash/cummerbund if we have those could be sold off the shelf and the jacket could be the fancy schmancy expensive auction thing that activates special messaging with the rest of the set if it's there.
I want to say at EG there seemed to be like three GMs who said they were working on more high end masculine clothing.
I've got something in the works, if I can find time to come up with messaging before EG. LotusWear does the erithi-themed shirt/jacket combo, and some day, I'll add the pants to that hopefully (but it's a lot of messages to come up with for those scripts)
Some of the groom clothing for the chapel weddings have interaction messaging. It's just like 6x the work
crowd source it!
BriarWear has already started, kind of - could be a fun area to expand into cloaks and such. Painful, but fun 😄
Yep, i know. That's why I mentioned why I know there's not a lot out there because it isn't just one item like a dress or a gown.
One idea I had were jackets that had cool fluff, but also did a inventory concealer like dramatic drapary or such, but then showed the rest of the outfit, so it looked like you were in the full cool suit and all. That way the verbs fluff could be concentrated on the single script and item.
The concealer could be a toggle in case you had things to mix match.
...this sounds like a job for premium contest entries.
Adventure wear!
I struggle with clothing scripts myself. Often the verb traps are nice, but its a hard juice/squeeze calculation with dealing with removing a bunch of enhancives, shimmer trinket adjustments and so on. Its like a 20-30 min process for me
This is why you make use of an F2P mannequin!
I was in this boat until Elysia was like "just have an alt on another account wear the clothes, set your shimmer trinket and hand it back." I was like "WHAT!?"
That was a game changer for me. To make it easy, level that guy a bit and he can recharge the trinket too
Thats a great idea, lol.
I need to dump all my outfits on a dummy char now.
....this is a good idea
Tivvy's going to change all this with her mannequin implementation, aren't you Tivvy! dreaming this into reality
I assume this alt would be named Skipper
This is how I ended up with two baby monks.
BradyBunch.gif
1212 + tattoo = amazing
To be fair there's no reason we couldn't just make a suit item that isn't 6 items and just references them, like Avalukas animal armor, which is one piece but references individual components in the script, just hurl 40 verbs at it like Naelea.
Pull suit > You reach down and unfasten each of your sigil-crested gold cufflinks, quickly rolling up the sleeves of your gold threaded cream flyrsilk shirt.
I screwed up and attuned my shimmer trinket
This doesn't cover layered clothing but...
foreach in worn; remove item; do thing with item;
I tried the armoire thing....that item just isn't up to modern standards.misses way too much
What do you mean? The only thing it doesn't work with are scripted items.
It's all fun and fluff until DoppleErek decides he's the real Erek and does something about it.
Analyze suit:
Your suit is made up of the following components, each of which can be altered by a willing merchant.
Suit: A fitted flyrsilk suit accented with gold.
Jacket - A gold threaded ebon flyrsilk jacket.
Shirt - A slim sable sea silk shirt
Handkerchief: A fan folded scarlet linen handkerchief
Belt: a brown leather belt boasting a large gold buckle
Pants: some sable sea silk trousers boasting gold threading
Boots: some brown boots buckled with gold
Etc
well now Lydil has given me nightmare material
Well my work here is done.
I have a bunch of scripted items that are also premie enhancives. It fails on a few of those, plus some other clothing items it won't snatch up.
I didn't do any clothing. I change clothes too much. I was sad that it wouldn't work with an undershirt though.
hair bauble would be my first choice.
the scripty hand things from EG!
It's an interesting thing. I threw 650 million silvers or more at last year's RoL buying other people's event boxes. On the other hand, I've never bought a Duskruin event box or Rumor Woods event box because players offer them for less... and while I don't yet have an 11x/day brooch, one day I will (probably not this year) and then I won't need RoL entries either. That leaves only Ebon Gate, where I buy some event boxes, but not many.
Honestly, I'm not sure what could be done to get me to spend silver directly, so I've been content to just trade for Duskruin entries and the like, funneling silvers to other players who do know what they want to spend silvers on. (Or are just hoarding for auctions like these!)
Clearly we need breakage, with an NPC-only expensive repair cost. (WHAT??!)
Breakage just creates the UAC-and-magic-only meta!
Yup, for sure. It's an interesting conundrum. Even these auctions are obviously designed for a fairly wide range appeal with the different offerings. Vs say the last mania with all. The custom mk ans sk items that kinda obviously targeted the whale crew
So real question. What would staff have to offer or make to get you to part with a huge sum of silver?
a bell
I mean, for the bell, I didn't even beat the 140m bid or whatever it was! 😛 (...but I'd totally do 100m for just the bell, no health recovery.)
The serious answer is probably a slew of MKs and SKs, but the trouble is that I probably wouldn't end up parting with loads of silver because others would want them even more.
Edit: to be more specific, any out of: Burst of Swiftness, Combat Mobility, Coup de Grace, Hamstring, Sweep, True Strike, Weapon Specialization, Dauntless, Elemental Targeting, Empathic Focus, Intensity, Patron's Blessing, Phoen's Strength, Strength, Zealot. But, again, pretty sure I'd be royally destroyed on most of these. I'm still amazed I got Surge of Strength at Mania, which was also on my list.
Follow up question, what would a band of gnomes have to do for a huge sum of silver? 😆
It definitely did about what we expected before we split this into 2 auctions. We'll see how the second part goes given it has a lot more information about the items now. After part one, we were at about ~43bil, after part two we were at ~39bil. These are some of the lowest numbers we've seen in my time as staff.
That bell is my lamentation. Is there a duplicate in the next one? 👀
'High value, low cost linear power increases that also have a unique novelty about them" is almost always a winning answer to that
Silvers now to the mooooon 🌕
The cat's bell will remain unique. There might be future plans to offer different resource pools, but it would be one of each forever plus one day.
Of course haha. Respect.
I get concerned about the gap in wealth. Feels very real after these events. Charms being a thing with supposed silver costs, i worry about being priced out of such systems
Mana and Stamina versions will go crazy.
I was actually surprised at the MonstrFlesh prices, I expected them to be higher. I assume the attunement factor was more significant
in an auction setting it's hard to distinguish between "this item was unappealing" and "this item was appealing but my valuation was lower than the valuation of other players"
One ice gown = all my items (so far)
...there was a lot of stuff in Plat where I was like..."This is very appealing but doesn't fit my RP so other people can have it." But that's just me.
Stamina tintinibar would probably bring in a substantial sum.
@frigid crane definitely won at most silvers drained among all the things she made.
Would need to figure out a different type of item, like instead of a cats bell, a talking parrot that sits on your shoulder in a feature slot and just announces your arrival everywhere you go. Restores mana cause you are converting your sanity into it by listening to it all day
MonstrFlesh v2 - BionicImplants
She made a lot of things though I imagine. Did she also win per item average?
honestly the perm feature change was a major turn off for me, and I know a few other people too.
Stamina tintinibar on a GOS empath or a PSM3-heavy build square, oh baby. Or a mana one on... any pure.
There were four or so items i would have valued no higher than 20m that went for 4x that
Elysani understands a segment of the playerbase very very well
Next auction, monster gowns
Perm feature change was 10000% the reason why I had no interest whatsoever, but there are people out there who like that stuff.
Custom movement items can totally sell, though I hope they tend more toward an OTS Duskruin/Rumor Woods/Ebon Gate context than auctions. So far they mostly have, what with Dramatic Drapery (and mounts, technically? 😛 ), but then along comes this auction...
I joked yesterday. I'm going to make FleshGowns
These numbers - 43b and 39b - are the # of active silvers in the lands that you're tracking?
Just cobbled together from random monster skins.
Yeah, it makes sense for sure. I think I just underestimated that factor because I am one of those attunement crazies.
Make them so you can add your own monster skins and parts to it
Active users. These are comparing active users over 2 years though (when I started tracking it separately). There are sleeper accounts out there with silver though.
I still think a universal win that would sell like crazy is combat messaging customs/cman customs. Just dont lock it behind auctions.
The fashion shall become horror
like thematically cool but forever is a deal breaker, like even among us who are RP lite these days we still have themes and ideas about our chars, just something to consider for the future I'd have perked up if that feature was togglable off and on for sure.
Just make a Top Hat and a Pocket watch watch people toss silvers are you.
...the meat gowns and chocolate couture gowns that were actualfax RL things. Just sayin'. (Doubled up on the gowns because I KNOW you guys would...)
Thanks - that's a lot less than what we were thinking since Estild at State of Elanthia saying less than 100 billion.
Do you have a target # that you think is a healthy place to try and maintain long-term as far as active silvers in the lands?
RoltnWool, perm but CS buff. Yay or nay? 😆
The scarabs being toggleable definitely upped their value for me at least, so agree that the feature part of the monster skin being forever was kinda a non starter for my characters
I mean that fits the theme! so yes! but if it was one of those monsters ones I wouldnt do it for +3 CS. I'd lose my barbie card
fleshclothing = appearance change based on using furs/skins/etc would be awesome and something people have been asking for in various ways.
Like the bug costume script
Yeah, there's nothing the monster flesh could even possibly have offered that would have made me go for it. Even something utterly stupid like 100 AS, I'd be like "nah, think it's time I put together a full enhancive set."
I think perhaps showing while the buff is active rather than 100% of the time could of been an interesting compromise
EVENT BOX (I saw it mentioned earlier) is probably the single best repeatable drain we've done. It does come with a real cost though, and it's not something we can maintain indefinitely as is. But each event hits between 5bil and 8bil in drains since we launched it. I think overall, silver drains were a huge success. I don't know how the secondary market will do after RoL, we'll see, but as far as I'm concerned, we did everything we set out to do.
I mean, if nothing else MonstrFlesh opened up the door for a new category of power improvement, distinct from all existing ones. Whether or not something follows the same path with different flavor we'll have to wait and see, but I still think it's a victory
It's a very similar vibe to the black ora jewelry. If it doesn't fit your character, there's no way to like, kind of fudge it.
Yeah I always figured you'd reach a "silvers outstanding" number that you deemed acceptable then you'd scale it back to simply try to maintain silvers in=silvers out.
So you're saying whatever we wind up with after RoL you consider a good number? Probably like 20-25b I'd guess?
yea but now what? I think as Ptolemy has pointed out there still a pretty big wealth gap between the haves and the have nots.
Look pretty in an ice gown = 510m.
Get +5 AS with no upkeep costs, but look ugly in monster flesh = 200m.
The message is clear. Create items that increase stats and make you pretty!
clothing that gathers and changes appearance based on the amount of defensive or offensives mana you've cast in the past X hours
It then echos offensive or defensive spells randomly. Offensive as additional flares, defensive as automatic recast
The shrinking of the middle class... Yup.
i will adorn nidal with the most insane looking visuals for a perm +3 CS. there is a market for everything
Can you speak to any efforts beyond EVENT BOX for sustained silver drains? The (discord) community has provided a ton of ideas over the last year. Any there any that are feasible and in the works? The only thing I recall was something to do with Enhancives- which I think is a great starting point.
I have 45m. Im hunting 30 mins a day exclusively for silver in HW. I make about 150k a day.
So what's the value of a +5 AS fire gown or a +5 CS ice gown? 1b+? lol
Easily 1b+. Easily.
Whole auction that is just enhancive veolas
I'm not terribly in love with this idea, but I get what you're saying. But putting something powerful on something like a gown just opens up a ton of people trying to buy it for mechanics. which feels bad if your in it for the fashion.
I wore a very ez scripted corset for a long time because it was like +3 AUR and WI bonus, it felt bad because I didnt care about the wonderful description and ezscripts on it. (its in a much better home now too just fyi there)
My personal goal was about ~30bil active at our current size. If we grow again, obviously I'll need to reevaluate. One thing to consider though is auctions aim for the top wealth. They aren't the best representation of the wealth gap. We really didn't touch the top 2% wealth at the auction. Maybe for the RoL auction we will. We aren't selling services though, which is a big value.
+5 CS cloak-worn keg, dwarven use only.
I mean the gowns having combat stats does nothing because they take your armor slot don't they?
I like keeping those things kinda separate tbh
if 39b is logged in, there is a good chance 2-3 accounts make up 20-30% of that total count though eh
Wait, the gowns are functional? Heh, I had edited out a thing suggesting to make ice gown cloth armor after realizing people wouldn't want to give up their mana-infused or whatever, but if they're functional then I guess that's a different story.
There isn't much that can be done there. Auctions and service offers will always target the top. And even if they are made for the middle class silver player, the top can still buy them out. Raffles help here, and I think we have plans to offer silver drains at higher stake raffles. The RNG element does have problems though.
Its why i go on about cman messaging and the like. Everyone wants things like that at every price point
I'm predicting a lot of unhappy posting during the ROL auction when four people are buying 75% of the items (which from my perspective is fine - the goal at the ROL auction appears to be maximum silver drain, not maximum item distribution)
I mean as far as "but what now" - there's RoL coming up with probably EVENT BOXes and the auction to train 10-20b more maybe?
We may actually be reaching the point where prices for items at the next auction are LESS than expected because not as many people have as much silvers to spend.
So if I'm following all this correctly, the auction has drained an amount of silver within expectations so far, but it whiffed on getting said silver from the intended audience (the top) and instead got most of its silver everywhere else?
frozen wealth nodules aren't harmful to the economy though. if those people will literally never spend, the wealth is dead
Dreading the answer, but will this rings of lumnis have event boxes at 15 for 50?
I dont feel like the reduction in the overall silvers of the game has done anything, other than make me angry about loot cap. Thats just my personal feelings on it. Like nothing has changed for me. I'm still in that middle upper pack. I cant pin point anything and be like oh this is so much better now.
Just sell more Rift Boots
If the goal is to drain the silvers from the top X% of users, couldn't you ask the top X% of users what they'd spend their silvers on and then auction some subset of that, within reason?
I would like to know, as the below 100m silver player, what does draining silver do for me? Honest question. My boat still cost 250m silver
there are so many things that could be offered for silvers that would have real, sustained drains across all income levels
It's hard to believe that people buying items for 200-600m silvers, in an economy containing 39b, are not at or near the top.
Melivn: keep in mind that economics do not adjust instantly - especially when there's less liquidity/volume - there is always a lag time between changes in one part of the economy affecting the entire economy.
That wouldn't also in turn hurt revenue? Even event boxes cost them revenue each pay event.
Would certainly hope not, considering that Rings of Lumnis entries are slightly cheaper in Simucoins than other events! Last year's were the best value of any event box for me by far at 11m if I remember correctly 12.5m and I could often buy gift boxes from other people at an even lower rate than that, which is part of why they got all my silvers. 😂
We've taken a lot of ideas from player feedback here. But I also don't think a lot of it is sustainable (from previous lists anyway, I may have missed more suggestions). But OSA is also another big drain.
well, yes. As I said earlier and Wyrom also spoke on, event boxes isn't really sustainable.
In the macro sense, it seems like every good idea gets turned into revenue.
Wyrom: I must say I am glad to hear we are nearing the point you're happy with. I knew you were in an unsustainable mode to drain things and I was kind of holding my breath hoping you'd get to the finish line on that goal.
I'm glad you can now take the foot off the brakes a bit and aim for balance, costing Simu less $$ and hopefully being in a happy place lol
I hope you'll still offer some EVENT BOXes but maybe less - whatever it takes to balance but not further drain the economy of silvers.
Im still hoping to hear an end goal. Once silver totals are down, we can do X. What is the X?
Can you speak to any projects that are moving forward?
I can't speak to others, but here's some ideas I had previously
Revamp player shops so that all players have access to. Sell expansion and info for silver
Player service increase potions for silver
Sell private workshops
Sell workshop bonuses, increased bonus, for silvers- Also rent based- +30 days
Sell lower/mid term armor/weapon/shield script for silvers. Tier upgrades for silver
Sell reim access for silver. Create new reim like instance for silver with long term rewards
Create rogue like dungeon for silver access
Perm enhancive recharge for silver
Enh combining for silver
Enh gambling (add, remove bonuses) for silver
New hunting area with monthly silver based access- FWI type thing for silver with no racial nonsense```
I would drain so much more if osa had some modest Enhancements like permanent hold, slightly better enemy valuation, and a bounty like system
Silver goes only one way in osa. Out
The point is to make the economy healthier as a whole, part of this was the loot cap, the other is draining the excess. It however will probably take months or years for things to normalize out for players after that's done, due to generally the wealth distribution and small player base
I've been waiting, I'll still be waiting, there's no choice but to wait. But I don't think anything will change honestly people who farm out loot cap will have more silvers people who buy silvers for cash will have more silvers people who play more and focus on merchanting will have more silvers, unless you bring the top end(loot cap) WAY down it wont really do much imo. Time will certainly tell though. This assumes no other drains come into play.
To end up with what though? Id like to see a tangible goal pointed to. There is alot of work and effort in and around the issue of loot cap, silver drain, auctions to drain silver, etc. I assume there is an opportunity cost on other projects there. So what is the game wide benefit to all this?
this is good to know, especially in advance of the event haha
Like do i want cheaper auctions? Or do i want more systems/classes/charms/etc. im not saying they are mutually exclusive, but loot cap angst hasnt been good for the game. And im saying this as someone who has less than 50m silver.
we've discussed this in the loot cap thread, but 2+ years later, including 4 additional months since that thread, I can see no discernable difference in what players can buy or do with their silver. EVENT BOX creation aside, which didn't exist prior, I don't see anything that shows any impact. On the surface, it appears that we're reducing silver for the sake of reducing silver without any end state listed.
Yes all the people who make/buy the most silvers will have the most silvers. I'm not exactly sure what's wrong with this aside from not liking that people can buy silvers for $$...but that ship has long sailed and isn't all that different from buying vouchers to earn BS to buy uber gear.
I'm not sure the wealth gap will ever go away, as rich players will continue to spend $$ to gobble up silvers so they can get what they want...but at least the players selling those silvers to them should be getting a better rate for whatever effort they took to earn those silvers in the first place.
Economics says the game wide benefit is that eventually the silvers market will be in a place where it's much harder to accumulate silvers, driving up the price in $$. Meanwhile, many won't be able to afford current prices on services like 6m/week on sanctification. Sure the rich will be able to, but they can't buy enough devotion to wipe out all the capped clerics, so prices of services will have to drop.
Essentially economics says inflation should turn into deflation - but as Melivn hates to hear, it is still going to take some time. I'm not sure how much of a difference there is - for many - whether there's 99b or 39b out there - but I expect we're reaching a point where that makes a difference...if not now, after RoL/auction #3.
So….all of this has an end goal of lowering sanct prices? I can get sanct for 3m a week now. Heck, i sell it for that
I mean its weird you think I hate to hear it, I want it to be true. like I want all of this to be for something I can point at be like oh this.
Honestly though, do you really feel like you've impacted the silver? Those who generate massive amounts of silver still will do so on a monthly basis. Those who don't still won't. I find he auctions whether Wyromania or the silver auctions pretty frustrating. Most items went for far over 100mil a handful went for under but mostly if you didn't show up with a couple hundred million silver plus you weren't likely to get something you truly wanted for your character(s). I've long recognized that if I truly want something I need to seek out the secondary market ask around until I find what I'm looking for an buy it.
The only exception to that is at least with DR I can buy directly from Simu via the 250 count ticket books and sell them in game for Bloodscrip or silver to help me pay for things and the cash goes directly to Simutronics. For an event like the silver auction and with what I saw with bidding, I truly should have went and bought a billion silvers or at least 500 million silvers (I had 70 million silvers personally) so I could snag something I wanted. I personally don't feel like the major silver generators will be impacted at all by this and what we see is the frustrated players who couldn't really purchase anything.
On top of that I feel like mental drain on GMs to create items takes it's toll. I don't understand why more of each type of item wasn't sold, which might bring prices down but in the end would probably generate a similar amount of silver drain because more players could afford to bid and win an item they might want. I think that offering 3 to 5 of each item wouldn't be a bad thing in other words with slight changes between the items. It require a lot less creative burn out by GMs to come up with new and varied items every event. Heck, for the life of me I don't know why more items from the past 30 years don't make an appearance with variations in them to save GM creative burn out.
Anyhow that's just my take, I know without a doubt though if I do want something in the future I'll be continuing to go via the secondary market. (Edit note: gotta love the wall of text medium that is Discord for organized communication lol) (Edit edit: Thanks Nitos for the tip on line breaks)
goal is deflation - in general - and a future, going forward, where runaway inflation does not happen again
Shift enter will allow you to put line breaks.
Like this.
well heck now I need to use "frozen wealth nodule" in a sentence at least once today.
Im here. Im happy to always take a ‘wait and see’. But…i dont see anything pointed to as an eventual change in the game, staffside, that will happen once goal x is reached. Wyrom more or less said that continuing to let people farm event currency on event boxes isnt sustainable. Deflation of what though? We have a 4-5 currency economy. Im a professor of econ and even i dont track the actual goals here
Thanks Nitos! Now to remember that. eh
Has inflation been a rampant problem in GS? Is there something that used to cost X silvers 2 years ago, and now costs 5X silvers?
In any economy, there will always be those with more and those with less, but that's not the same thing as inflation. As long as the "haves" can spend their currency without affecting the pricing of things needed by the "have nots" (or "have lesses"), I'm not sure there's a huge problem to solve.
Sanct service is an interesting example, but prices are already falling from where they were 6 months ago, and they'll continue to fall.
Your new skinsuit should come with SK 1212 or a shimmer trinket feature. 😎
you must see the benefits of deflation? Cheaper services for players to buy from each other, so the people making not-so-much silvers can actually afford more stuff. Raffles can be cheaper. Everything that has ticked up in price over the decades of inflation can start to settle back down into a better place. Even the silvers farmers can be happier making more $$ farming silvers.
And it doesn't matter whether people think this will affect certain people or not...what matters is that at the end of the day - or month or whatever - the amount of silvers generated is drained, so that there is no balloon again.
in terms of inflation/deflation, many game economies run into the problem where the primary soft currency becomes worthless for player to player transactions because there are always infinite sources of it and the sinks are not appealing enough. I assume the goal is to ensure that this doesn't happen to silvers. It's easy to imagine a world where most service transactions are handled in bloodscrip/raikhen or even currencies not tradable in game, and that would make it very difficult for a lot of players to participate meaningfully, not just because silvers would be valueless, but because the barrier to entry will rise.
I dont think your player service problem exists. Most people i know discount services for friends and a little circle of helpme/helpyou player services forms. Raffles cheaper is irrelevant. They could be free and id probably skip. The odds are awful and favor people with many accounts already. I dont see what I get, as the person supposedly benefiting from all the dev that goes into this. Nothing in a pay event is going to come down as a result. And i dont think they’ll release major scripts outside of pay events for silver with very very rare exceptions. So, again, whats the specific things i cant access now that i can then?
Player service is all saturation of the service and skill of the player
I love my bell!!!! MEOW
Go go gadget passive jet pack
Upwardward!
+1 spirit per room walked! grand poohbahs everywhere rejoice!
As somebody probably at the old 90% line, I at least now feel I have a chance. So it's helped the lower upper class I suppose?
i am sure i am in the upper % with the fact that i hit some form of loot cap monthly but am also well aware that i have no chance bidding against MAX_INTEGER bank account players. it is what it is
A lot of these we've talked about though.
If we did something like permanent WPS, the windows would have to go away. I was never onboard with the windows. I think it completely defeats the purpose of what we wanted to do with it. When we left it out for awhile, it really drops off hard, so us doing a smithy outside Duskruin once or twice a year keeps it where it serves a purpose.
Playershops thing won't happen unless we have a significant change in the game engine to have all those items loaded. I was just talking about all these private properties the other day. Item storage in them will eventually hit performance.
The enhancive stuff is/was in the works. I'll have to see where we're at there.
I don't think a lot of the other things would drain billions, let alone tens of millions. Like Adv Guild for silver doesn't really drain 100mil. They just aren't very effective silver drains. If we did a roguelike dungeon for silver, if you couldn't make back what you spent, I don't think anyone would do it.
breakage and repair!
Breakage and repair would drain silvers but just be immediately added to eloot and create tedium for anyone who doesn't script things.
you would need a progressive tax version of breakage
I've talked about it before, but tedium is the real silver drain. And no one wants that.
breakage is a regressive tax...yeah, Tikba hit it
I honestly forget to charge for silvers... every year. I probably would if my lazy was catered to but it's probably not make or break on income
You can compare the last few silvers auctions and see some pretty interesting shifts and trends over the last two years.
May 20 - https://bit.ly/2ZLrboT
July 22 - https://bit.ly/3Q31WFf
Apr 23 - https://bit.ly/3K8ZPzK
Obviously the most interesting datapoints are the ones where there's a huge jump in price or a huge decline in price.
help game engine please, please to be fixing item limits
Tedium annoys everyone and won't even dent the top tier accounts. Seems like hassle (for staff and for players) for negligible tangible benefits. Like, the npc herbalist is on everyone's post-hunt routine and it's not taking much out of silver generation lol
Yeah, I am curious if the requirement to find the one programmer still active in STL with the language knowledge is up for budging. .
Family vault may help here
Yeah...or Astral Vault. But true on family vault
I don't think the value of auction items is a great indicator of inflation. It's like how real-world inflation is measured by the price of milk and not the price of yachts. For how long has 1.5-3m per week been a reasonable rate for ensorcell?
I respect that. Not all my ideas are feasible or winners- but I think some things like hunting areas, reim, etc... may not drain billions on their own, but they would be applicable to the entire player base, which has it's own appeal.
I think all economic levels want to see something to do with their silvers, even those who do not want to engage in player services.
Even if my ideas suck, I implore staff to come up with things that everyone can and wants to spend their in game currency on.
Thank you for responding. I appreciate it
Item storage in them will eventually hit performance. -- shhhh! 😎
Perhaps I'm jaded, (that's probably a yes) but I always assumed that the motivation behind cries to drain silvers were not-so-lowkey because people want to sell their silvers for higher RL cash.
I attuned my trinket as well, but will leverage the family vault for a mannequin
you legit could sell RPA orbs for silvers and if priced correctly, it would drain silvers in perpetuity
Enchanting might be more stable as a measurement, since it's been available so long. Ensorcell value plummeted when Sanctify came out. Could probably dig through logs and old PC posts to see how silvers:dollars fared over time and get a pretty solid graph if somebody wanted to.
I'm perfectly okay with forever sales on Exp orbs. I could care less how fast people gain xp
even exp orbs for silvers, wouldn't drain much, you right now today, can buy pretty much as many 3x RPA orbs as you want for 10m a pop, maybe cheaper.
eventually you'd buy so many you true cap and then quit!
Have you seen some peoples stables of alts?
That's probably true but there's also a segment that just have silvers, won't sell them, and want something to spend them on. I'd rather have things to spend them on myself over selling them.
For some of the loudest voices in this topic, that is almost certainly true.
It's not hard to cross reference the people and their silver sales.
I think that happened when Event boxes were popping out exp orbs like pez
I'm sure you're right, but I can't see a reason why Simu would care, and they're the ones calling the shots.
I mean to say: I'm 100% certain Wyrom isn't trying to remove silvers from the GS economy so silver farmers can sell at higher rates.
Also, silver prices would only go up so far, because it's easy enough to earn more rather than paying somebody. And if the prices rise the farmers can ratchet up farming to conpensate
exp orbs from event boxes were always attuned, but yes RPA orbs going down in price is a result of event boxes, and that generally the people whom would buy those, don't have the silvers to afford the ones outside of event boxes
people with 2b silvers, don't need rpa orbs, they are making like 100k+ xp a day on every character
Gift boxes used to dump violet orbs. I haven’t seen one in many a fortnight
A weekly 2.5m silver box with an attuned 3x orb. One per account, once per week.
Any time new ascension abilities come out will almost certainly cause a spike in orb prices, at least briefly. Could do a combo sink by releasing new ascension abilities and putting out a stack of yellow orbs for silver at the same time.
I assure you they're not making 100k+ xp a day on every character.
GIFT boxes never had violet orbs. Some EVENT boxes did. Unless I'm missing a wonderful gift box, lol
a character on each account
RPA orbs are interesting, because at post-cap a 4x orb does very little for me other than make me feel good. I do like feeling good. And then you have a brand new character and a 4x orb is huge
Those chia pets had orbs
We got violets from the gift boxes around the web anniversary. Two or three orbs at 2 rubs each
When I came back last year-ish I had a bunch of unopened gift boxes sitting in my locker with violet orbs. YMMV
what about you can toggle extra experience gain/absorb vs loot just like DR arena?
Not this either. Without an orb running, except on lumnis days, very few people are hitting 50k per day, even if they hunt every waking hour of their day, let alone 100k.
you had to really work to get those orbs though. couldn't miss a single day
It rules that I almost certainly got all of these orbs and just have zero recollection of it 
GIFTBOX has a tracker on the wiki that has been maintained by players.
point to like 6 ranks of dodging on your empath and go "those were the violet orbs, good times"
GIFTBOX isn't active right now.``` giftboxes should be like the lich king. there must always be one active, or the hordes of players go out of control
"This gift box contains a shimmering violent orb with two rubs, that is account attuned." "OrbRubber just learned the value of reading"
We have a GIFTBOX planned for the auction chaos. We're including 2 new items.
I got feature creeped yesterday, so I need to update it.
At the risk of reverting the convo, I think an enhancive reroller could scale pretty darn high. In Terraria the way it works is it's relatively cheap to reroll low-tier attributes, but increasingly expensive to reroll high-tier attributes. And I end up rerolling a lot of high-tier attributes to get top tier attributes.
are RPA orbs for silvers permanently something you guys would consider?
I really don't think that RPA orbs would be an effective silver drain, as the event box has already drained that audience
enhancive reroller is in the "this year's plan" document, and yeah, I do see that as a good idea that hopefully will gacha up a lot of silver
free T5 thaumaturge book and greater arkati amulet in each giftbox would be nice...
To whom do we owe our thanks?
Do we all get a squeaky auctioneer's gavel? (Did I just feature creep you again? Please?)
I strongly disagree, depending on pricing.
charms were also described as a serious silver sink in a gacha-style "mash stuff together" kind of way but not a clear ETA there, people do like mashing stuff together though
That's usually what happens though. People say something would be very popular, then the price happens and people live without.
Keep in mind, EVENT BOX is not priced where it should be. It's priced to compete at the player market. At no point should it be cheaper to pay in silvers than SimuCoins. So getting 10 entries to a pay event AND an exp orb at 2.5mil silver is the part that isn't sustainable. The pricing should always be double/triple of the actual worth when using in-game currency because it's 100% worthless to the business.
gacha pokemon pets + farmville
And what is the Simucoin rate for exp orbs going to be?
I just hope I can slot Jah Ith Ber into something and learn Teleport
Right now, it's free in the EVENT BOX as long as you buy the entries.
That's why boxes in games have bloat. They know the bloat isn't worth much, it's the only way to get the value where someone buys in.
Event boxes do have value if you can get somebody to plunk down 50 or 100 they wouldn't otherwise to close the gap on a purchase. There are people that open the wallet and use the box the be more efficient on a purchase they wouldn't otherwise make
In GS, the exp orb is the bloat.
Keep the entries, sell me the orbs (in the Simucoin store)!
We limit the purchases, which is the only way we are staying alive.
I definitely did my part to remove silvers from the economy by buying other people's event boxes last year. 😆
Can you talk a little bit more about this? I'm not sure I follow
I think the implication is that people with unlimited silver would buy unlimited event currency out of event boxes
yea a lot of people bought event boxes last rol
Staying alive, meaning with selling them.
every event box is potential lost revenue basically, as it includes entries that normally you can only obtain by spending simucoin
So they have to have limits or... well bad things
I will say I don't really think that analysis is perfectly on point because it's probably not the case that people would 1:1 replace with hard currency and in fact getting the taster probably helps motivate more spending, but that doesn't mean the price point is optimized
Are there any brooch or brooch-like updates this RoL? My wallet says please say no
RoL also has a pretty hard drop off the way its designed
I dropped over 1b in event boxes for RoL. I think I met my goals though so don't forsee doing that again.
(until they add the next shiny new upgrade to the brooches)
And yet it still manages to be the greatest event in the world (said to the tune of Tenacious D)
Another thing is when I'm talking about a healthy secondary market, I'm mostly talking about items exchanging hands for in-game wealth. I'm not talking about anything you do outside of the game, whether cash sales, trading lambos, etc. It's important to any multiplayer game. Bigger companies hire big brains for that stuff.
(on mobile, my brain is smooth)
Your DR model of self-competition is the largest harm to that, from where I sit. The in game currency secondary market is nearly non-existent now.
how do u tel/trackl if they exchanging via in-game wealth?
whoa whoa whoa, i made like 10k in tips/hustles sheparding people into vornavis, the system works
oh hey auction is done, that means we can start teasing for the next auction
What is the Tomb of Secrets!
not really true that the in-game currency secondary market is nonexistent, people trade player services literally constantly. the silver-based secondary market for high-investment items does seem to be mostly stagnant (although I heard that MK shield moved). my view is still that this reflects a failure to update prices more than anything
It's like the Comb of Secrets, but underground.
sure- I meant it as Wyrom said- item exchanging for in-game wealth
Tomb of secrets (to toe-hair grooming) provides owner with a new feature slot for toe-hair design
I have bought and sold several items over the last 6 months for 50m+.
Yeah, HESS definitely moved the needle to item improvements and losing in-game worth. HESS was also a player idea that grew and grew. Crux was the first person to really push on the idea of HESS on the forums in a way that we took on.
I tried to retire HESS a few times.
So it's his fault!
Nobody wants to buy your certified pre owned sigil staff when they can make their own at DR twice a year, unless you take a L the size of the one on the Hollywood sign on your selling price
Haha I bet you if I put a sign in a shop that said certified refurbished items that it would do poorly because the idea of someone already using the item would be a huge let down.
(I'm going to test it, after this conversation fades from our minds)
I see the failure as an simu creating items that competes with other items and sales, and not recognizing the player investment in those items post sale- to include other DR items/scripts, player services, etc... there's a strong disincentive to start a new project because there's no reliable way to move from one project to another. I see this as the single largest failure and opportunity lost for simu.
It hurts economics via in game currency because it makes people only invest in player services for the best, it hurts secondary sales because people only want to invest in top-end items, etc.
The frustrating part is that, as I see it, simu could increase revenue, stimulate the economy, and provide confidence in purchases by allowing swaps, etc
Certified preowned nerve staff
"Unloved old scripted gear"
I think the other problem is that there is a roughly static number of characters (optimistically speaking), and an evergrowing number of midrange+ items
I don't understand why people selling items act like they've been in the shrink wrap the whole time. Did you get nothing from using it?
A prime factor in me not bidding on the 1408 staff (other than Goat wanting it lol) is I have no meaningful use for Nidal’s existing staff. No alt needs that type of firepower and I couldn’t sell it for anything I would deem close to worthwhile. It’s why I ended up not buying a piece of gear but instead something that I had no competition for on my wizard.
That was your idea, you know. That staff.
the 1408 staff was great but when u remember u got to start upgrading everything again it really isn't worth it. u could just buy an sk 1408 for about the same price and still use your existing staff
lol who else didn't bid on items they suggested - call everyone out
(I threw out so many ideas I legit wouldn't remember anyway)
Exactly this. If I could take a DR item script, and put those player services and components on another DR item script, I would happily pay a small surcharge for that service on top of paying for the unlocks on the new item script, and would not be hesitant about future purchases knowing they aren't a full sunk cost.
Think how conflicted I felt when I didn’t end up bidding!!! 😭 I’m still having FOMO and second guessing my call. I was so hype to see it made though ❤️
If I could destroy an item and swap its coraesine relic to my weapon I would do it. The part that I haven't fully thought out is how this is good for simu revenue. Maybe if I had to pay BS to do it? But the BS cost would have to be much cheaper than what I would pay for the relic outright, because I'm also buying this other item to destroy, so it seems like a loss for simu
throw a monthly event where all money goes directly into fixing the game engine and allowing more storage and properties and player shops and things that can be sold down the line.
Corasine I think fits into a different category than what I mean, but there's a market there too.
I'm talking about specifically DR items. If you bought a sigil staff, player serviced it up, add HESS flares, subflares, etc... there's no way that you would look at the new spore staff and start over. if you could swap DR for DR, and then still had to buy the unlocks on the spore staff, that's a revenue gain directly. It would also inspire confidence in those extra HESS purchases
I would donate! LOL
Yeah, auctions really aren't aimed at the super high end anymore when it comes to gear. It's those weird items that are complete different that I think auctions really need to move to.
Yeah I think that makes more sense. Isn't that what the "Add x script to item" certs accomplish though?
The gown cannon would be very weird
