#calamity-update-talk
1 messages · Page 394 of 1
a good chunk of items got removed
also FOURTY FIVE MINUTE DESERT SCOURGE FIGHT
thanks, that was a quick answer, much appreciated!
new update. no more trapper bulb

I am regretting so much here
why did desert scourge pull a 2020 dog
I'm betting the Murasama Rework in the suken sea update
because it kinda is?
whats the best mage weapon for plantera rn
hey is the murasama rework can be usable in post-moonlord instead of post-Devourer?
I think that's the plan? With several unique buffs after certain bosses
murasama rework will include swinging the sword
why did you reply discord aghhh
murasama will be a sword that kills things
wrong
because im deleting the murasama from existence (the good ending)
this is true because i said so
i could make that false
so sso is gonna release along with tmod 1.4.5?
murasama now leaves any enemy at 1hp
sso is not neccessarily the next update
ohhh alr
murasama just gives every enemy the sturdy ability from pokemon
or focus sash or whatever
murasama heals enemies and kills the player
js remove the murasama
murasama has a chance every swing to slip out of your hand and kill you
Murasama kills enemy and kill player at the same time
not possible because i am
also i still think murasama should be renamed
goodbye lame ass reference item number 213!
exploding you in 5
i hate how its fucking martyred by certain people who aren't exactly the most rational to be around
It should js be re sprited, reworked, and put in a diff part of progression
sadly all that would do is spike cal overhaul's popularity
cuz we all know it would readd it in a heartbeat
we all hate cal overhaul
all that would do is piss off its fanboys
and make cal look tyrannical
ok then
that is, assuming in the affirmative that cal overhaul is already wiped off the planet
you realize they would swarm this server right?
well
and direct more hate towards the devs than ever before in the mod's history
what would people say the best way to obtain potions are in this mod?
just classic herb farm?
also retier it
dawg im ngl most of the time when cal is mentioned outside of any cal server its almost never positive
that’s also very true
to the point where its just kind of grating
like reddit exists
As long as calamity is a good mod Idc what people say
i dont really see it that much im ngl
there’s entire platforms that just absolutely hate cal so i dont think a bunch of dorky fanboys whining about murasama being removed would matter
Murasama def shouldnt be removed
i know you see the world through shit-tinted glasses but things arent that bad
idrc whether ppl like the mod or not i just think its weird to have a burning hatred for a terraria mod of all things
you can still dislike something and not be a grating asshat abt it is the way i see it
it was a joke statement this conversation is hypothetical
Murasama is too deeply rooted into this mod to be removed
calamity became the big popular terraria mod and everyone knows its cool to hate whats big and popular
ive had plenty of positive cal conversations outside of this server/terraria servers
murasama obviously isnt ever being removed
but id appreciate a renaming
just to disconnect it from the original reference
im not saying its all negative but ive definitely seen some uh
interesting convos
in the bigger picture yeah
anyway, its still not a good look for the mod if it starts taking down other mods
especially one as popular as cal overhaul
even if its for a good reason
it really should have just been shot dead as soon as the stolen code stuff was discovered
it’s not really a good look to steal code and assets from other mods either what’s your point
what's the issue with murasama being a reference?
it shouldnt have been given a second chance
the kind of people it attracts
fabsol
I really dont get the love for murasama
those both feel like nothingburger statements to me
its just kind of annoying that the mods most iconic weapon is from another game
well my issue with it is that it’s known as the most iconic cal weapon when it definitely does not deserve that spot considering its concept is owned and was created by another game
theres so many better options for weapons post dog
omg the 3921949th metal gewar reference in calamity!!1!!!
irdc ab it being a ref
it also just steals the spotlight from a lot of other amazingly designed weapons
for like.. what
“OMG COOL ENERGY KATANA” like dude
really
wished it was never in the mod to begin with tbh
the only reason i care is bc the reference was made by the horse himself
I do wonder, without fabsol would a different weapon have gotten the developer variants?
oh wait hold on lemme beat dog first so i can unsheathe a cool katana!!!
mage hammer of might variants would be awesone
probably not
i wish that too, but hindsight is 20/20 and i dont think its fair to say it was a bad decision at the time
who knows
because it was dia who wanted to do those along with the murasama rework
someone honesty should call out caloverhaul in a video
unless fab like paid dia to rework murasama too
I don't get the issue with having references to other games
gp is planning on it I think
we should start a petition to add mage hammer of might dev skins
when i purposefully spread misinformation on the internet
absolute cinema
exoblade skins
one day...
Oh okay
the Ark of the Cosmos deserves this more
it’s PEAK
nah I feel like exoblade lowk isnt iconic enough
THE CALAMITY OVERHAUL MOD IS TRASH... (WORSE THAN YOU KNOW WHO????)
this would be the best video on cal trust
definitely wasnt yeah
Everyone knows mage hammer
I'm still waiting for the day I can have a working multiplayer playthrough
the main problem with dev variants is its a lot harder to make a bunch of them when the weapon isnt primarily one color
exoblade is a billion times more popular/iconic than mage hammer wdym
cappp
Anyways this would be huge cuz it's always YT that glazes Overhaul. Would be fun to challenge that on the very same platform.
-10000 subs
as much as i want to make this video, i know if i want it to actually be effective, it needs to be very well researched and well written, with high production effort
more than any video ive made before
-20000, even
eh
billions of john cal fans must post cal overhaul hate videos
I've never heard of that mod before
you're definitely capable of it
maybe
I wonder how many people have
It's def an undertaking
if i ever do make it though, its not coming any time soon
but it's worth giving a shot
you could collab with someone else if that's daunting enough
and I would probably talk to a lot of ppl about it to put together the script
this is one video idea that i would happily have stolen from me
spends 2+ years researching, scripting, editing, etc
cal overhaul gets deleted somewhere at the end of that time frame
all work wasted
won but at what cost lmao

cuz i really dont want to do it, but i feel like i have to
that would be a W
I don't think you have to
if you dont do it someone will eventually lol
i hope jay leaves infernum behind in 1.4.4 🙏 🙏
suprirsed it hasn't happened yet actually
Mage weapons rlly dont get any dev skin love
they arent even in the conversation usually
cal overhaul has wormed its way into this community's heart, and i dont see it being dislodged in any way other than it losing support directly from the fanbase
you probably don't even need to script a video trashing a mod for it to be effective
i disagree
idk how trusted i really am
I've never heard of cal overhaul
That's exactly why it would need to be well researched
it should be an objective video anyways
New shpc is... Something
i disagree bc ppl will then say "this guys is just starting drama for no reason" cuz it makes it look like he'd just be ranting and what not
without a script
^
Its a weapon alright
if youre gonna bring up how bad the mod is why would you just start spewing things without research
every day people come here asking about issues with their game and its entirely too often that the cause is calamity overhaul
I feel like calamity community sometimes takes things (including itself) way too seriously
it does
good point for the vid
but yes the calamity overhaul hate is exaggerated here a bit
yeah but a discord isn't necessarily a representative sample of an overall communitg
I feel like the majority of people don't gaf
some stuff is definitely hearsay, which would make research even harder
or don't know what it is
idk man someone ranted about a certain mods update a couple months ago and literally nothing happened to them
but this could be me projecting my own personal experience too
like the world corruption thing, for example. I don't think its actively been a thing that cal overhaul has been known to do for a very long time
maybe
a lot of ppl tend to blow out of proportion how toxic the cal community actually is and they try and use old ass inconsequential drama as evidence of that (most of these ppl have never actually interacted with any part of the cal community)
the majority find the mod through youtubers showing off the cool reworks and try it without realizing its problems
has the team behind overhaul ever addressed that
idk dude
thats the other thing, i dont know 
this felt like a "takes itself too seriously" moment to me
i swear someone said it happened to them last month
idk the reddit is kinda bad
at a first glance it looks like the perfect mod for all your murasama wielding dreams
freak ass weirdos will exist in any community. at the end of the day, your experience is what you want to make of it
do we know for certain that it was the cause though
ay man I js stated my opinion on a weapon respectfully and calmly
you're fine
the unsheathe thing seems to unnecessary tbh
but the reddit is abit extreme
imo murasama is fine overall but I'd like to rename it
and also the cal reddit is NOT the majority of the cal community. i can tell you that much lol
arent you guys retiering it too?
neither is cal main tbh or any cal related discord server
I feel like calamity is the hype moments relatively middling substance mod
or is that a rumor
again but it is a loud part of the community
idk
putting it at post moon lord and having it scale through the rest of the game is what ive heard but honestly who knows
it's getting better substance though
Burrower my beloved
they get over things eventually
best idea ever
even if they are very whiny in the process
I'm also in a strong minority of thinking terraria as a whole is kinda lame
ah that'd do it
(and has been degraded with updates)
most of the time yeah
but...
kid named dm dokuro:
why are you playing it😭
it was fun for a time
well thats a first
calamity was cool
I actually agree with this
bud why are you here
That's literally why roots exists
shhhhh
well I mean you dont gotta keep playing if you dont want to
however I don't think it's lame now, just it was better before in a lot of ways
1.4 "the final update" (just kidding) "hey we content bloated the game!!!"
let him cook
DOG IS DEAD. KUS MAGGOT
calamity was rad! I liked it
really was not that hard in rev mode ngl
Since 2.1.1 came out does anyone have issues joining multiplayer worlds?
I do agree that base terraria really didnt need anymore updates
the gun no one uses wow...
havent had any personally
five hundred crossovers !
but they js went on and kept doing it
kinda agree
it felt complete
Crossover slop
I would have been okay with 1.4 being the final version but i will admit the new stuff does add a fair amount that i love
terraria 1.6 should be a complete rewrite of the game 
And weapons we never really needed
hows the dog summon? any worth in it over sirus?
the final final final final final final update
I can understand how Terraria has gotten worse in some aspects but I do think the game is overall better than it was a long time ago
I feel like everyone says "wow they keep updating the game because they love it! :)" while not noticing relogic has failed every other project they've tried to make

shimmer 😻
the calamity mod was better when I was younger and more impressionable
elaborate
You don't need to change much to make it even better again
I'd like to hear your thoughts on the mod Roots I've been working on actually
what is roots?
Roots is a mod that seeks to re-imagine the Terraria experience by building on core concepts from older versions of Terraria that were lost in the modern game into a new, modernized experience.
Roots does not add any new content of it's own, but greatly adjusts vanilla terraria content. It currently makes changes to 33 armor sets, 19 accessories, 17 weapons, 4 enemies, two bosses, and multiple core mechanics.
All changes are adjustable in configs.
These changes fall under these sweeping changes:
- Removal of class-specific damage, and rebalancing of all gear to match
- Review and adjustments of all weapons to fit into a more tightly-planned weapon design philosophy
- Changes to the Mana system to be a more valuable resource
- Adjusting enemy and boss AI to be more unique, interesting, and purposeful
- Removing natural life regeneration, but increasing the value of Healing Potions
like whats in it
calamity mod was better when i was young and didnt have enough emotional maturity to form my own opinions and instead followed what everyone else's opinions were
text wall in chat mods ban him

maybe I'm still spiteful about how much of a shit on the concept of good game design mastermode was
Cal was better when I didn't realize the wiki theme is ugly
the only other project ive heard relogic work on was otherworld. you could say that did fail, but yeah
mods, smash his cranium 
I feel like im the only one that still rlly likes calamity
calamity was better when scal was a big floating eye and had ten million health and every weapon did millions of damage
but, still
explode
maybe im the minority
definitely not
honestly though? my perhaps #1 annoyance with current calamity?
I wanna make a better wiki theme
BURROWER WIKI THEME
calamity was better when it utilized its music more effectively
ill pay you
definitly in this chat
doze make a burrower wiki theme trust
the way the yharon and dog phase changes were modified over the years is a travesty
I'll pay someone to make updated class guides
people here might be a bit jaded because a great number of us have played 500 hours of calamity and enjoyed all the good parts while noticing everything bad over time
to just not work with the music at all
definitely some truth to this
I have like 550 hrs recorded and def miss pre upd death but I still like the new update
also dokuro's interludes getting added to the game finally but just... playing at the wrong time???
if yharons rework doesnt bring back his healing with the music transition we RIOT!
I do like calamity as a whole even overall. Personally i dislike the seemingly endless number of reworks/adjustments in the days ahead rather than making progress towards finishing the pack and working from there. as i think it'd be fair easier to adjust and balance things as a whole if it was complete first.
also this definitely might be a younger vs older thing but when me and my friends first did calamity beating rev DoG for the first time took hours of practice and now we did it deathmode like first try
even if we don't want to admit it I think a lot of us feel like this on some level
do you like the new scal arena then
haven't seen it actually
you'll probably like it a lot
I must say you guys rlly cooked on the cal clone fight
I'm referring to the phase changes from a cinematic perspective
isnt it a square
and how they don't use the music
can i see a picture of the arena?
The arena and visual changes for cal clone is rlly cool
Yeah, scal arena does that
It changes color to match the music video of the song
it also made the fight much more difficult
like yharon just fades from infernal catharsis into roar now
yeah yharon phase transition needs to come back
DoG phase transition is still good and music synced
nice
yharon revive is still coming back right
Although rip sentinels type D
it wasn't last I checked
yharon reboot card
It has been for years and years
no way it doesn't...
If you're lagging it might desync
the death fakeout has been gone for a while I missed that
hopefully it does
Yeah the death fakeout is gone
CAN WE PLS GET A PROF GUARDIAN REWORK
Fabsol wanted all bosses to be more clear in information
I don't think dog needs a revive tbh
i like spiders
It made sense with sentinel phase more than it does now
well
i really want yharon to come back after a fakeout death and he’s just fucking completely engulfed in flames like an actual phoenix
Yharon revive really really needs to come back though
Like he's literally a rebirth Phoenix dragon
Old duke should get a revive
why was the revive cut out? to buggy or?
like im imagining the new yharon sprite but it’s made out of fire
make 10 new yharon fights :genius:
Thematically I did, mechanically it sucked
I don't mind yharon not having the moon and eclipse phases though that was strange
Yesh
I think yharon should randomly decide that I'm not worth fighting and run away so I can do the buffed events and THEN fight him using the dark sun ring so he doesn't run away
That was kinda silly
True actually
old calamity was such a strange time
I really think the game should be willing to sacrifice some things for the sake of cinema
like how celeste does theirs
I think it's what draws a lot of people to modded terraria in the first place
that's when you get poorly designed bosses that just look cool
and it sucks ass and people hate it
I definitely think gameplay 100% comes first
But that both can integrate together
like new dog laser walls especially in death phase 3
if they attempt to retire dokuro's osts they might get thrown rocks at now that im thinkin about it
the biggest thing for me is I still feel like the standard dokuro set has yet to be matched
REAL
and that places a specter over my entire experience with the mod
my favorite cal song is not a dokuro song actually
shit goes crazy and it's cool and hard and GUH
It's abyss layer 3
to be fair there hasn't been many opportunities for new tracks since then, at least in the main music mod
I like abyss 3
Hydrothermophobia is SO good
isn't exo mechs like the only non dukoro theme?
My fave is the Aether theme
is exo mechs theme done?
dont think so
got I love the aether theme
unless there were new ones i don't know about
Like this is SUCH a vibe
Lowk a big upd of signus, stormweaver, void, and polterghast reworks would be so cool
ik it would take forever tho
ok but
abyss 1 and 3, draedon and exo mechs, boss rush themes, maybe sulfurous sea night
these would fall under distortion update i think
this is a remix of a dokuro theme
No
abyss is pretty cool
especially ceaseless since hes the gateway to the distortion
scary
the new darkness system makes it fit a lot better
im ngl idk what that is
like I feel like I'm yet to see someone really evolve on the musical ideas
it does
dog's crib
have you heard the boss rush themes
we team up with infernum and use their sentinels
rather than just yoink a motif or throw the calamity bells in it
boss rush themes are very good
bells
is that a future upd?
i think we also retire infernum
DoG phase 1 -> sentinel bosses -> DoG phase 2
Yharon first battle; "You are not worthy" -> Yharon second battle -> fully heals and phase 2 after he reached 1%
Cal Clone but with Boss 2 music -> after reaching 70%, the background turns black, she heals back to full and starts Raw, Unfiltered Calamity track
they're just the bells
eh fair
part of the issue is you can't really replicate someone else's style
t2e please save us
existing lore
Nah they're fine
their fight is one of the better ones in cal
I hate them
people write fan music for that game all the time but I feel like I've never heard a fan ultrakill song that could fit in the game
imagine being overwhelmed by total darkness and high pressure level and then you hear a worm roaring and going at your location im shitting my pants ong
....yeah something like that
They are fine
Old one was a lot worse
anyway back to complaining about calamity...
the evil donuts from hell
terraria, and by extension calamity, feels to me like it should be a multiplayer game
thankfully it can be
I've tried
you're never going to believe this...
its a horrible experience
perhaps you were on bad servers
boss aggro is a fucking nightmare
I've literally never had problems with mp
boss aggro is a mess
the boss is off the screen of all but 1 player at all times
multiplayer feels like it makes everything 10x more fun except the bosses
and because terraria has diarrhea in the code somewhere the amount your game physically renders is fucking based on your monitor size
because they arent designed with more than one player in mind
so you can't even use a mod to zoom out without it derendering all the terrain
which contributes to that
i think it depends on like how many people
with a group of 4, 3 would be standing still or chasing after the boss
i wish bosses could be instanced so each player is fighting their own copy and the damage is just minused from a health pool. at least as an option. i wouldn't know how to best fix multi at all but something like that would be okay.
horrible
will nucleosynthesis get new visuals eventually
yup but there are mods to only render your projectiles
considering its using elemental ray visuals currently
doesnt solve the core issue
who decided that multiple bosses needed to be locked to schematics?
but seriously why the fuck is frames capped to 60 and the amount your game renders is BASED OFF THE PHYSICAL SIZE OF YOUR MONITOR, like not your resolution settings the ACTUAL SIZE
i think the worse experience is exo mechs multiplayer 💀
ye olde game
exo mechs already barely comprehensible in singleplayer
isn't terraria still also only able to run single core?
I would like someone to fix that shit and then design terraria bosses around multiplayer
ares.png
i kinda wish if relogic ever does a 1.5, it would be a rewrite of the engine
New BoC was designed with multiplayer in mind!
It has some attacks that target multiple players
terraria extremely gives off the vibe of something that would be best with friends and yet the experience is just blah
and this is why we love BoC
prehm is less vulnerable
terraria with friends is so fun when ur not fighting bosses
multiplayer empress of light is always an experience
once the bosses and players get fast enough everyone except the melee player is forced to use boss cursor and homing for the rest of the game
make that daytime EoL
i am a bit miffed that odd mushroom no longer gives a damage buff. Having to learn to play with the crazy effect to get a solid dmg buff was a fun risk reward but now its just a joke item and i dont see for what benefit?
I understand that it doesnt always work so the 'risk reward slider' was skewed to reward but why not nerf the dmg boost instead of outright removing it?
in cal this largely remains the same but it leads to late HM and especially post ML to be a fucking snore in multiplayer
I think old duke is pretty cool in mp
yeah late hm is just cycling between respawns and running at the boss until it dies in like 2 mins
it's like they saw calamity and went "oh wow players like bullet hells and high difficulty" and just made it one-shot you with insane vomit projectiles
honestly I feel like relogic forgot how to design their own game somewhere down the line
how does multiplayer old duke do? i dont like duke fishron already in mp cuz of the way his aggro works
erm the charge bosses (duke, old duke, yharon) i think are pretty okay in mp
I mean yeah everyone loved it 😭
shoutout torch luck
multiplayer just could use work or heck it wouldn't be as bad with a smoother connection my friend just can't do stuff to help much in hard mode.
mastermode felt literally offensive to play through
i dont like duke cuz like, he will target one person and wont stop til they die
basically duke fishron but he launches lik huge attacks so you cant js off screen him
I actually felt like I was being insulted
the easter egg seeds also feel crazy why are you locking so much content behind this goofy system
I guess I'm just a cynical terraria player in general
Yeah and eol’s the best boss in vanilla terraria lol
at least the update is making the secret seed system better.
genuinely? i think the largest drawback of cal not having much in the way of face tanking is that bosses like providence would be so much more fun in mp if she actually stuck to one place
So ig it works
ithink u can argue for fishron
Fishron is def top 2
I think fighting prov in her arena area is so fun on mp
Post Plantera Mage Rework Opinion
5/10
Still very generic.
Flare Bolt is nice and Frigidflash is cool combining the differences
SHPC is a weapon for sure!
Death Valley Duster and Primordial Earth are nice
Vulcan is a magic gun alright!
Ion Blaster.
Maybe better but I think sharknados make the fight worse than normal for me
It's decent, mediocre as of now
I liked calamity when they didn't try to be masters of game design and just made stuff sound and look neat
But I do expect post anahita and golem to give it a shove
i like duke fishron a lot
am i insane for saying. closest thing to infernum in base terraria
Yeah most people like Fishron I think
so you wanted a game with poorer quality?
third phase is probably the highlight for me
maybe I am just annoyed by terraria as a whole
really?
I wanted a game that wasn't pretending to be better quality than it was
that's like the easiest part
yeah! its easy! but its fun to get right
your points are valid but i think its soured by your burnout/dislike for the kind of game terraria is now
yeah I get what you mean
being easy isnt mutually exclusive with it being fun yk
yo figured id ask here too, but this update broke my friends ability to join my world. any known conflicts?
does it break with just calamity on
esp cuz it doesnt rly feel like dumb fun like its a rly consistent phase but its also a very intense one
"1"
"1 2"
"1 2 3"
I feel honestly a rhythm the moment that background changes
this is happening to me too
And when you're pre mech it feels like a reward
i love the rhythm
untested, but im halfway through a world so im scared to turn other mods off haha
this one is the one i agree with
just gen a different one and test there
a small world
I really like shield dashing comparably to the ninja gear on fishron
Feels more controllable
oh using soc iframes on duke is satisfying
that's an apt summary. I think I'm also annoyed by some of the elements of recent development, like this update took 2 years and 2 dev sex offender exilings and that's a lot to get through
Those iframes carry
But also duke fishron just has a massive skill issue with featherfall
also there was that whole element of "finally the evil monster is gone we can develop the game our own way" (quote from the second evil monster, a month before getting yeeted themselves)
i mean the difference is featherfall on duke is so much more impactful compared to a lot of others
lot o frickin drama in this community
It's a free fight winner compared to helping the fight a lot
while the statement came from shay im pretty sure it does still ring through for the whole team and its evident given the stuff theyve done for this update
it's been around for a long time. drama is an inevitability
but yeah the amount of drama this mod makes is wild lmao
it is? I still haven't played it cause im trying to organize a multiplayer
2.1 is a good feel of the new direction
BoC especially
Should be noted that shayy had almost nothing to do with calamity at all aside from managing social medias, his drama was mostly in the UT/DR community
calamity will be reborn as a lotus in the year 2050 🪷
it does seem odd to remove qol stuff both in this update and over the last few months with relatively little explanation as to why
it's also like the biggest mod so of course it gets the most attention and there for drama
but my knowledge on that is relatively surface level
if you like BoC youre gonna like the rest of the reworks going forward
Because the mod is trying to stay closer to vanilla terraria
what the fuck does that mean
cal is a content mod. not a qol mod
are we nostalgic for rod of discord grinding now?
I think grinding is Good, Actually
you can't craft X accessory in vanilla so they removed it from calamity.
dialing back scaling to be more inline with vanilla and prevent the mod from being a boss rush and put emphasis on other parts of the game, like grinding, which many people dislike but it is a core part of the game
scaling is nice
cal shouldnt be the "everything mod". if ur looking for qol check out fargos, prismas etc
no man
If anything I’d remove the rod of discord recipe because that item is way, WAY too good to be a simple shop or crafting item
i like the grinding...like oh no more terraria
I want qol not a slippery slope into cheating
Then use qot and config it
all of the big qol mods are configurable
if terraria was coded better i'd agree to just adding more mods. ideally you wanna keep it as few as you can. that and it's not like the qol recipes were hurting anything. same with fishing.
its still hard to claim that the mod is removing qol to try to stay closer to vanilla when one of the main things it doesn't do is iterate on vanilla design
elaborate?
Fishing definitely did assuming we’re talking about golden fishing rod
like are there any 10 hour grinds for 0.5% drop items in calamity yet
You shouldn’t have access to the best item for fishing before you get a single piece of bait
if not, they're not staying close to vanilla, and if so, why the fuck are we doing that
alot, though its alleviated by zerg
closer to vanilla i think is the wrong word i dont think cal devs want to "fix everything thats wrong w vanilla" anymore
If you’re grinding for 10 hours in any version of terraria something has gone horribly wrong
nobody said theyre fixing vanilla though
fishing is also boring. i can count one hand the number of times i've ever seen somebody personally advocate for using it to be your primary way to progress.
I think its really difficult to justify removing anything from a sandbox game
Brainstorm did increase drop chances for the very recipes it removed
we want to not trample on vanilla
I love fishing
this a good approach
That's not the whole reasoning ofc
there was definitely a feel of that in older cal ngl
But that's part of it
so it being worth it was fine for the minority that used to progress.
wonder why 
I do think there's elements to the calamity gameplay loop that were annoying
jumping from arena to boss to arena to boss etc felt very draining
multiplayer is working wtih just calamity it seems
i really think people while okay to voice their opinions, are just over egging the pudding
so i guess its a random conflict, and ill just have to wait for other stuff to update
then its one of your other mods yeah
Also, if we wanna talk about fishing viability pre-2.1
Literally half the people I saw in cmt were fishing for reaver sharks
Fishing for abyssal amulets
what's cmt?
Fishing for a bunch of utility items
idk if its just me but a lot of older cal stuff felt like "oh i think that part of vanilla sucks so im removing it"
sometimes I get the impression large-scale changes in design philosophy are made less because of data and research and more from vibes
Because fishing just is extremely extremely strong
And you shouldn’t have access to fishing at its fullest potential unless you put in the work via fishing
who cares
This is why you don’t get access to digging claws pre-boss
not like getting any of these even requires a golden rod lawl
I care
Nothing requires a golden rod, golden rod does make things a hell of a lot easier though
Not to mention buff fish
fiber glass, even fucken reinforced make do just fine
I feel like you have to show me your research that shows that statistically players who abuse fishing end up having less fun overall than those that don't in order to justify removing it
i mean if you feel like you wanna do it you can. but like it being there out of the way wasn't hurting anything. if you wanted to progress normally you could if you wanted to min max/try hard make things easier than you could
I absolutely believe people will optimize the fun out of a game
you need to know that is what's happening before you remove it
I've always seen fishing this way, modded or not
wait why is my Ankh Shield no longer in the asgards valor 
why did my shimmer js not spawn
It might eventually get its own upgrade line
Don’t worry asgards still has knockback immunity
removed from asgard line. it still keeps knockback immunity etc just doesnt have the debuff immunities anymore
this is how i felt about berserkers greaves and power glove iw as so sad
Valor was very, very over centralizing and needed to be cut down to size. It still has everything that was actually important for it though
iirc its now obsidian shield right?
see like this
Show map?
It's just ornate and some materials
how do you justify making balance changes in a game like this?
the only dislike i have is i feel like Ankh Shield is just omega usless is it not?
I go out of my way to find the angler, set him up, make all those biome lakes, do all those quests, all over the course of my playthrough. I find it rewarding. The rewards make my fishing abilities stronger.
I hesitate to call it overpowered or anything. More like an alternate way to play the game. Fun for some, not for others. Definitely not fun for others.
this isn't an accusation btw it's just an insanely difficult design challenge
its same as vanilla. good for exploration, good for duke fishron
Asgards Valor was
- used by almost every player active in the community
- actively inhibiting boss design
so it got changed
i feel ankh sheild on it's own is a wasted slot unless they just have a debuff that ends you/makes you useless.
thats a good reason
but generally (just like vanilla) its not worth the grind
yeah im ngl i was using it in any build i cant lie
it was my baby
boss design is already really constrained by movement items
Valor change I think was a change with some of the most reasoning in 2.1
wait i gotta ask
does cal duke inflict feral bite
The goal is to encourage people to use a diverse set of accessories and weapons, and allow at least most of those combinations to reasonably overcome the challenges the player faces, whether that be bosses, events, regular enemies, etc
Any balance changes that encourage this are, to me, fundamentally good balance changes
i would hope so i wonder what they would do
THAT BEING SAID, fishing still shouldn't be able to tier skip. That I consider overpowered.
Yes
You can’t have accessories or weapons that are too good or centralizing because people will use those too often, and therefore won’t be inclined to use other weapons or accessories
Fishing should have more unique stuff in it to make it worth doing past tier skips
imo
personally I might give the player permanent movement abilities after doing certain things, and that way you can scale boss design reliably knowing what the player will have access to
Cal also makes feral bite not do much though iirc
even if vanilla re added pre boss hellstone?
It was definitely that
anybody else having buggs with ceaseless void?
WHAT HAPPENED TO MY SHIMMER
ahh ok so ankh on fishron still good rite :3
I don’t actively do angler quests but I do quite like setting up little lakes near my pylons, esp in hardcore
also did bosses get easier? im doing revengence rn and i feel like im running through it?
one last go if anybody has figured out multiplayer not workign ;-;
One of the best parts of hardcore is having to interact with all these different parts of the game to maximize your chances of survival imo
yea
idk if im a weirdo but, i love fishing. i dont like setting up artifical lakes
i just use whatever the game gives me
i make lakes in the biomes
Bladetongue? Crystal Serpent? Frog Leg? Tsunami/Sandstorm? SUNDIAL???
Fishron and Cultist
i was gonna say i though melee was being "perfectly ballanced"
Vanilla sundial lowkey got a 1000% buff in 1.4 just because beds exist
the point I'm making is so what? and who gets to decide whether that's okay? the goal isn't to get players to utilize a variety of weapons, it's to get them to have fun. and unless you can really provide evidence that the playerbase as a whole believes those two things actually coincide, it's just being based off a series of personal assumptions
Oh, AND dungeon lock boxes
Those are HUGE in multiplayer
also what the hell is the issue with tier skips
the devs because they make the mod imo but i digress
me and the rest of the dev team get to decide what's okay based on what we see in the playerbase and other games in general
It's always going to be subjective
cant please every1
How would you go about collecting the evidence necessary to either prove or disprove this
Game design is subjective
yeah I'm just asking is it more subjective than people think
How would you keep this evidence up to date
game design is fucking tough
How would you do this reasonably when calamity has 10 million subscribers on steam
cultist for chilled immunity?
teir skips as long as they require more in depth knowledge and aren't something a player is likely to just walk into on accident should be fine.
he freezes you? yikes
add a new npc that knocks on players doors and asks them to fill out a survey!
game design is tough but calamity doesn't want its design to be different from terraria's anymore
I think if you make changes that inhibit player strength and especially ones that inhibit player agency, you have to have a really good series of reasons
is the wiki updated?
barely
It's cuz of this that I rarely argue with dev decisions lul
That's why I think it's perfectly fine to tell people "just install qol" if you miss it so much or don't like certain aspects of Terraria
because it was NEVER calamity's job to change that. it's a content mod first and foremost
ultimately I do think that vanilla terraria very clearly is doing a lot of things right considering it's sales and ratings
like it's your mod I'll just figure out your reasoning most of the time
inhibitting player's agency to...?
If I'm torn between doing something like vanilla and doing it not like vanilla without reason to pick one or the other otherwise
I'll side with vanilla off that alone
I'm of the much more cynical opinion that terraria did a lot right and has coasted off that initial lightning in a bottle
can i ask if it's still planned to spit up cryo bars into 3 seperate sub ores?
if it wasn't for the fact that steam ratings still climb higher now I might agree
tier skip? change the time of day? go fishin'?
i mean there's a fucking reason i always come back
but it just barely after 1.4.5 climbed above Stardew Valley for #1 rated steam game
ITS A GOOD GAME
the masses are simply wrong and I am correct
in reality, this is the place where I concede to being in the minority
you can still...do all these?
not for me anymore perhaps
^
Yeah I actually agree with you
i think its fine for interest to fall off of games
i reckon its because its still a good game ngl
god i fucking hated mastermode though
I don't like terraria as much now
it doesnt matter if you play master mode the basis is good
my favorite version of terraria is 1.0.5
I mean no one ever really forced you to play it
but I can't help but acknowledge that it is still growing very well
i would 101% never play terraria solo ever again, i would rather play something else, but i do still like it when it comes to multiplayed
and besides, i reckon a good portion of the playerbase is going to play modded terraria anyhow instead of vanilla
not the point i think
i love terraria :)
i think its a flawed if good and fun game
I'm one of the few nuts in this world who hasn't burnt myself out and finds myself enjoying Terraria every single damn time I come back to it
the exclusive content in the hardest difficulty of a final update to a game i loved forced me to play it
Like terraria steam concurrent players has not been dropping or anything
still I've gotten my 250h out of terraria and calamity each so time and money well spent
its a cute pet collecting game with some bossfights as progression
still uh before I go to bed shoutout to games I still like
thats how i like playing terraria atleast
I've gotten my 5000h out of terraria and 1000 out of writing mods so yeah
shoutout scp sl shoutout ror2
shout-out roots mod go play roots
can you tell i like hollow knight chat
i wanna be a better builder but i suck.
damn wtf
never could have guessed
shoutout silksong which I'm gonna get the 100% speedrun achievement for once I stop raging at unraveled
5000 was a conservative estimate it's probably like 7000
stardew valley with lots of weapons but every couple hours you fight a big guy
i wish starbound wasnt left in the dust
stardew valley but maybe ill make it past year 1 on a new playthrough this time
silk song i love. but goddamn i just cannot get through the steel soul run
I'm dreading jt
and then after killing the big plant guy i stop being conscious and when i wake up the game is suddenly over and a weird tentacle man is dead
accurate
you know what the stardew valley comparison is apt
terraria is a cozy game disguised as an action game to me
stardew is fun.
if u cant tell im not very fond of post plant lol
the action drew me in and the cozy burnt me out
literally the opposite
terraria is my favorite building simulator occasionally interrupted by boss fights
yeah playing terraria and not being into building is rough
the action drew me in too but the cozy is the only thing that didnt make me burn out
i would be more into building but am bad
I get very bored building singleplayer stuff because who am I doing this for
I had a fun time building a sick af minecraft base once
lemme try to find a photo
its ok to be bad at building! im pretty bad but its always satisfying to have an idea and see it realized
half the players in terraria will get mad at you for rushing bosses and the other half will be mad if you dont rush bosses
the one thing i wanna do is a proper trophy room with the music bosses from each respective boss.
i think those numbers need to be tweaked a lil, i see way more people on that boss grindset tbh
i should get into wiring
fighting bosses is my main draw for sure.
the most complex thing ive done genuinely is like. draining stuff for my underwater bases lol
they just are fun and do cool things. also having banger ass themes helps a lot
Should I keep waiting on a calam whip update to do a summoner run
i've never done one
if youre willing to wait a year or more sure
current cal summoner is balanced around not using whips so ull probably get two distinct feeling classes lol
you don't need wait. but it is a bit silly when your fighting yharon and the exo's and still are using the kalidescope was youre best whip
if you already feel like playing summoner id say just go for it
otherwise
mage and rogue are the current highlights IMO
i love old duke sentry
?
hard
pic of a minecraft build i made once
goes hard
i dont build much with minecraft cuz my brain has a rly hard time w three dimensional spaces haha
the tism. or something
i got a question did all the wings lose their perks?
yes most of them
they got different wing stat related perks
some of them still have abilities
damn autism is an excuse for anything these days
i am on my first wrath of the gods run just have scal left for calmity bosses.
damn... 
you live in 3d space. you should probably be pretty okay at it at least
unless you're a pirate i suppose
then things are a little more on the 2d side of things
yeah most wings kinda lost their uniqueness
theyre mostly just differences in horizontal accel flight time but a couple of em have unique perks
and lost what made them good
bee wings have build in featherfall
anyway I gotta go the fuck to sleep i got work at 5
all lunar wings have specific synergies with their armor sets
I will miss that bc they were actually unique
yup
stat stick wings 💔
christmas wings throw out spheres that restore flight time
theyre still unique they just wont give u random aaa benefits like defense and damage
like losing flight time for dmg was kinda worth and balanced
bee wings giving honey buff was fun
I feel like the vertical flight speed on a lot of wings were nerfed too
not rly. the actual thing people did was just angel wings until they sucked then flight time
it feels so slow
only seeing two wings that vertical speed nerfed lol
basically, a bunch of weapons were resprited and reworked, boc rework, and all bosses nerfed
and all the accesories give like zero defense now
only specter and butterfly, were u using any of these?
Quick question: What's the point of the arc flash ring? Isn't a 5% chance for 4x damage just a 15% damage increase with extra steps?
lets go gambling
what
❤️
motherfuckers dont read patchnotes
this is a hell of a lot more unique than random stats
Oh shoot the wings have weird boosts and only lunar wings
a lot of earlier wings have (notable) stat differences but theres quite a few that are unique
star beam rye rework cooked my build what do i do
never used starbeam rye and never will
as far as i can see. christmas wings, bee wings, tattered fairy wings, demon wings...
Ohhhh some of them have weird effects yea
i ve only ever played calamity once and just followed the guide tbh
and its told me to get it everytime
🥀
WE ROCKIN' ANGEL WINGS TILL PLANTERA 
surely ur build is still workable w/o star beam rye right? iirc before it was just stats right
no yeah its still works and at elast i can use some other alc buff now :/
I sent a message here lemme find
Lunar wings here outdated
Update it
so would you consider butterfly as better than fairy?
Might get bat
why did they make death mode so much easier
are some of the other wings planned to get little non stat gimmicks? these stat differences are fair enough tho
i just first tried yharon wtf???? am i goated
booooo so many nerfs
is anyone else having issues with multiplyer
or am i just tweakin?
How DoG rework made yharon a easier boss:
No, yharon is just incredibly outdated and needs a rework
It is easier yes
they js nerfed every boss
Probably because you can't do an Expert Death anymore
i always did master death

aawwww i remember when i last played that mf HURT
So master Death being the only option, they kinda nerf it so death mode players can... Thrive
i think i know why u found it easy u might have gotten used to bullshit
Good luck surviving from Yharon summoning Dragonfolly
thats fair tho a lot of the phm bosses were aids but now they just feel too easy idk
Yes
wayyyyy too easy
when eoc didnt send like little guys to eat my butt i was flabbergasted
tbf I upped my boss health to +50% so the hardmode bosses are a lil harder
but still easy to pre upd death
old masdeath golem:
its js a joke mode
there are quite a few changes it seems
its just death ai
interesting
dog is different though because they found it funny
ahhh mb is wiki outdated?
do the vanilla bosses also keep their ftw changes tho along with the death ai?
i think so
thats kinda neat
You guys dont know how painful this was
Give me sec
oh trust me ik
i wish i didnt
🐟
underwater arena is so real
The Old Lord Claymore rework was incredible, but it is way weaker 😭
atleast its actually true melee now tho
it was kind strange that a pre boss melee weapon was like a multiclass tool
Any ideas on how to get fish finder now that the desert & aquatic scourge don't drop the sandy angling kit?
fish
dev team is gatekeeping fishing this update
a bit sad that they remove things that people got used to
i just wish the angler thresher cheese was still in
It was just broken
you was able to do Mechs with it
No sense
old lord pairs so fucking well with bladecrest
put them in place and they are forced to take a full ass swing
my lobster is so juicy
they were ranged meele
and you was able to obtain them just starting the world
talking about the rework for both
Beat wall of flesh
i havent tried melee yet

The bladecrest rework is so cool
in the rework
Protagonist class
its such a good way to lock down an enemy
devs favorite class
its horrible with groups but thats not what its for anyways
terraria and calamity
mage is up there too
it is
thats what im running rn
calamity makes all of the fish finders components guaranteed drops if you complete enough fishing quests, it takes 14 to get them all
Vanilla mage is really nice, and calamity mage is just wonderful
i barely play either so i wanted to see if early game is nearly as bad as vanilla but frostbolt is so gas
genuinley used it until skeletron comfortably
ive actually started doing them and got all three almost back to back
took 6 quests and three of them gave me the components
🔥
wondering if i got lucky here
Meoiw
anger quests in calamity are always set right?:
I don't think all of them are
there are milestones
well up to a certain point?
I know that in previous updates, they were
but outside of milestones its still rng yeah
i feel like akato is a weird pet, its like hey i just slimed out your dad. wanna tag along
Good thing it isn't canon!
real

my friend just got 200 plat from bandit refund
Will they respite akato after yharon gets resprited
yeah that sounds about right
saros possesion is so fucking cool
holy cow
Moooooo
i alt tabed while world was loading
and then i was loaded all my npc was shaking
crepy
almost first tried scal fuck man
which goblin on the dev team decided to make all of ankh shield ingredients not craftable
W timewaste
What makes you think you need Ankh in the first place
ankh now not in the ram shield tree, so
just ignore it
the year is-
Meow
This is true
first time beating DoG as Mage in Rev mode, any notable changes post-update to weapons I should (or n't) be looking at for Yahron ?
u still play the game btw

