#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 717 of 1

wanton pendant
#

Xeroc/Evil Xeroc.

spare pier
#

Draedon/Permafrost

onyx river
#

Ay so I have a question
If the Wall Of Flesh was created by alchemists in the underworld how does the guide fit into the creation. You kill him to spawn the wall. We he part of its creation

reef wigeon
onyx river
#

I've been wondering this for a while

woeful karma
spare pier
#

^

onyx river
#

Ahh ok

spare pier
#

Demons saw the Guide doing that and were like

split mortar
pulsar ocean
#

if Cthulhu means great beast does “eye of a great beast” imply a greater beast

spare pier
#

"HOLY SHIT HE'S SO FUCKING COOL we have to worship him"

onyx river
#

That makes sense

spare pier
#

And then did what they did

onyx river
#

Yeaaaaahhh

woeful karma
spare pier
#

The Wall of Flesh comes for the Guide's soul since it recognizes his master

pulsar ocean
onyx river
#

Lowkey cooked with that one

woeful karma
#

connected folklorically

#

not actually

spare pier
woeful karma
onyx river
#

Yeah I can only imagine lol. With so much ingame lore from vanilla its hard to make it work

spare pier
#

Yeah that's why sacrificing the Guide summons the Wall

woeful karma
#

that makes sense.... esp since human souls :sevenhumansouls: were already in wof anyways

onyx river
#

The Guide must have seen some shit lmao

spare pier
#

The Wall can also be lured by normal souls

#

But it's less reliable

#

The Demons did that in attempts to see and worship it

pulsar ocean
#

Why is noxus pursuing god essence instead of just absorbing 7 human souls

woeful karma
#

SEVEN human souls?

#

in THIS economy?

onyx river
#

I havent been in this discord in 6 years

#

Are yall still.making patron weapons

wanton pendant
#

No.

spare pier
#

Nah

onyx river
#

I made mine in like late 2020

#

And donated to the patron

reef wigeon
onyx river
#

I just started getting back into this mod. I like the nee Calamitas sprite. Better than the eye of cthulu lookin ahh

#

😂

woeful karma
#

god i hope calclone gets her new sprite soon

pulsar ocean
onyx river
#

It was some post DOG magic weapon

woeful karma
#

like shes actually the only boss whose sprite does not reflect her lore in the slightest

onyx river
#

Or rouge I dont remember

woeful karma
#

"it was post dog" buzz lightyear gif

split mortar
#

Ravager rework when

simple tangle
woeful karma
#

rav at least looks like what hes meant to be

pulsar ocean
simple tangle
#

theyre pretty bad

#

post dog is already filled to the brim with shit you'll only use on yharon :/

cosmic minnow
#

Hai

woeful karma
pulsar ocean
cosmic minnow
#

No

heavy zenith
#

Lucky

wanton pendant
#

Yharim's stronger soldier.

eager bluff
#

only 4 if we arent counting nadir because that was originally post dog

reef wigeon
simple tangle
#

backlog

eager bluff
#

yeah the backlog is massive

#

its like 30 ish weapons long currently iirc

spare pier
#

Yeah, backlog

eager bluff
plucky juniper
#

yknow what they have to do

#

make Starmageddon auric tier

reef wigeon
#

Guys Have U Played Clamity Mod? It's Really Good LMAO

plucky juniper
#

like come on man

#

it was intended by its patreon to be auric

#

its name is clearly a successor to Starmada

#

and also

#

post-dog got too many ranger options

#

we dont need another

reef wigeon
#

Do U Like My Capitalization? LOL

simple tangle
#

what are ru doing??

reef wigeon
#

Im Lifing My Enjoy LMAO

reef wigeon
#

Oh Thats Right: I Only Play On Mobile LOL

#

(No, Im joking, I've been playing Terraria on PC since I got a PC)

reef wigeon
spare pier
#

You missed my Kanaya era

reef wigeon
spare pier
#

That's fucked up man

reef wigeon
#

Oh right, I remember the scene where Xeroc completely Obliterates Nameless Deity

#

Clearly, that does not contradict the enormous gap between power scales

heavy zenith
#

I had no idea you rewrote some lore items in this update, im loving it! Thank you for all that you do @spare pier

spare pier
#

Thank you! :D

reef wigeon
#

Laura, I'll try to make a design for the swap ascended Yharim on paper tomorrow

spare pier
#

Alright

reef wigeon
#

I will most likely base the design on mythological figures

wanton pendant
#

I think an ascended Yharim would resemble a Phoenix, if we're going the perfect Ascension route.

reef wigeon
#

I was also thinking on Garunix from Yu-Gi-Oh! It's a card based on both Garuda and the Phoenix, and i love their design

#

I noticed that surprisingly his palette and appearance are similar to Yharon's

wanton pendant
#

...because they're both Phoenices.
Take a look at Ho-oh.

glacial wolf
#

Ok this is M.O.R. and Calamity related

is Girus's mechs as advanced (NOT STRONGER) as Draedon's Exo mechs or are they on very different levels

reef wigeon
glacial wolf
#

note: this isnt strength this is how technologically advanced are they

#

something can be more advanced but be weaker

spare pier
#

Idk how to answer that I never played MoR

reef wigeon
agile matrix
sinful adder
#

Or like, a kind of reincarnation

spare pier
#

Nah

#

I think that just undercuts the fact that Yharon swapping with Zeratros should obviously make Yharon wise

#

Yharon would directly oppose that idea because it'd just make so Terraria becomes stagnant. Death and change have to exist in a world

#

Also it'd make writing anything impossible because there'd be basically no stakes

wanton pendant
#

I've begun writing my own take.
Some of these swaps lead to very interesting possibilities.

reef wigeon
#

I think I'll make my own version too

#

Like what if Xeroc were truly evil at the beginning of the story

raven brook
#

laura what have you unleashed on this realm

wanton pendant
#

I don't know but I'm writing sentences that haven't been sentenced before.

woeful karma
#

can we make dancecal

#

like dancetale but for calamtiy

wanton pendant
#

WHAT HAVE I DONE!?

wanton pendant
#

I am sorry Otonilou fans for what I've done.

leaden bridge
#

still think calamitas tyrant swap is the most interesting one u can do with ehr

wanton pendant
#

I presently am.

pulsar ocean
#

Who’s otonilou

wanton pendant
#

Imagine Jay from Ninjago was a jellyfish and a woman and also dead.

long bloom
#

imagine libber from ninjago was a jellyfish and also dead

#

(jay's mom)

pulsar ocean
#

So not lore relevant

sinful adder
#

The lore on the blossom flux makes it sound like Silva had plantera attack the village but then misunderstood why they made it

#

Though I might be misunderstanding

#

'...I see... So frightened by the Godseeker were my children they chose to defile death for a warden in my image.
I am sorry. I could not gaze unto your hearts. The despair I inflicted upon you... I should have forseen the consequences of taking away your guardian.
But you shan't be neglected any longer.
Heed me, floral beast, on my authority. Ravage this place no longer, stand guard of the home and memories of the people who once lived here.
Channel all the might of this canopy and of the dead within you, so that no Godseeker, lowly or high, will ever trespass into this settlement.
Defend it till the last rays of the sun, so my hero shall yet have a home.'

plucky juniper
#

Plantera's yharim whisper got rewritten too

That floral beast hailed from a grove known as the Vernal Pass, home of Silva's champion Braelor.
Once I learned of his origins, I sought the Pass myself. Alas, it seemed the very grass I tread on kept me from finding it.
I gave up my pursuit, but the hubris of the Pass's citizens was ultimately their own downfall.
So intimidated were they by my search that they fashioned themselves an appalling guardian.
Shackling the souls of once free creatures could only have one result. The revolt of this floral beast was well justified.
Now that you have slain it, even greater disorderly spirits have taken root in the lands.
The village's shortsightedness was shameful in its own right, but the consequences of this may be worse still.

#

my guess is that plantera existed as a replacement for Braelor, since he was probably called away by Silva

#

and since that turned out poorly, silva felt guilty of doing this so she got the plantera to actually guard the vernal pass

sinful adder
#

I see

primal bluff
#

what if calclone got reworked to be calamitas in a weaker state or holding back or whatever and the current scal fight would be a rematch

#

it would bring her a lot closer to brim in progression to where that boss is still fresh in people’s minds, and we’d have more time with her as a instead of having her being all the way at endgame

magic epoch
#

that would not work at all with lore in any way

primal bluff
#

lol

#

how though?

#

i haven’t read the doc

magic epoch
#

why or how would she be weakened for that fight

primal bluff
#

i brought up weakened as an example, but i meant to have her be introduced earlier

magic epoch
#

calclone is a clone of calamitas that attempted to duplicate her power, but it didn't fully work because calamitas' power is largely not her own and mostly gained through brimstone elemental

primal bluff
#

yeah

primal bluff
#

it just seems like a weird one-off thing to have her be cloned like that

magic epoch
#

it makes sense

primal bluff
#

i mean, it always has when i’ve played

magic epoch
#

draedon wanted to replicate her power because she's strong as fuck

primal bluff
#

true

#

why did the devs change birb to not be a clone? i’m not being rhetorical when i ask that, i’m just curious

young socket
#

didnt need two clone characters

magic epoch
#

i think the new lore surrounding dragons also worked well for it

primal bluff
#

i think it was a little weird and convoluted, but i’m just a guy

primal bluff
plucky juniper
#

mind you, i don't really care anymore if birb isnt a clone or not

#

but if it remained a clone, i dont think it would greatly affect the setting that much

#

ACTUALLY

#

Calclone riding a dragonfolly

thick slate
timid girder
#

Do u guy think what boss next nameless avatar of emptiness full form or something?

real glen
#

those arent canon

scenic olive
pulsar ocean
primal bluff
#

no shit sherlock

pulsar ocean
primal bluff
#

why so serious (beatboxes)

worldly spindle
#

Had this channel muted ever since Brainstorm’s release cuz I didn’t wanna get spoiled on all the new ✨lore✨

#

but DAMN

#

I didn’t expect to stumble across some in the very first bestiary entry

#

Fuckin GUIDE LORE??? That rocks

long bloom
worldly spindle
#

Oh boy

pulsar ocean
#

Does bringer of order have lore

jaunty wraith
#

I think all vanilla npcs are planned to get lore at somepoint

For now the guide and dryads are the only one with a bestiary entry

wanton pendant
#

If I recall, I heard that Dragonfolly not being a clone was due to it making Draedon look incompetent.

warm gull
#

good morning

pulsar ocean
raven brook
#

The vanilla npcs are meant to be largely unimportant characters, they're mostly just regular people that exist to sell you stuff

The guide and the dryad get some additional lore to tie them better into calamity given their supernatural nature

#

liek

#

merchant lore

#

hes a guy that likes money nad sells stuff

#

nurse lore

#

shes a nurse that hates her fucking job

#

arms dealer lore

#

hes running away from the fbi after multiple accounts of illegal trafficking

#

the vanilla "lore" for alot of npcs fit perfectly fine as is, adding lore onto them isn't really a necessity as much as it's just.. "hey, what if this one npc was connecred to this one thing? wouldnt that be cool?"

pulsar ocean
#

Tax collector lore

wanton pendant
#

He's from Catalonia I guess.

jaunty wraith
#

Lore doesnt need to be directly tied to yharim and the big narrative

#

It can still have small little tibets that ad worldbuilding

scenic olive
#

terrarian lore

#

my terrarian has asthma

pulsar ocean
#

Xeroc was a tibetan monk

thick bluff
#

I wonder what Yharim think about Torch God?

sacred pilot
#

Is Torch God even canon?

reef wigeon
#

Drawing of Xeroc (maybe will be the design of Swap Xeroc)

#

Main difference: armor and now he has hair

split mortar
split mortar
sacred pilot
#

Huh.

split mortar
#

Its bestiary entry was shown a while back and if that got in bs then its not explicitly a god
Could still be one but its up to YOU (🫵) iirc

#

Wha

jaunty wraith
#

I posted a question but I put it in the wrong channel, it was meant to go in update talk

split mortar
#

Oki

thick bluff
#

I wonder if Ocram was part of Calamity's lore, then it could have some connection to the plague and Draedon? Like, this thing drops the plague soul.

#

And it looks like a plague mutant.

split mortar
#

It looks fucked up yeah but not the specific draedon nano plague type of fucked up

thick bluff
#

And it looks like some kind of creature between Crimson and Corruption.

split mortar
#

itd prob be a god essence creature like eoc perfs hivemind boc and eow then

thick bluff
split mortar
#

Blight soul could just be a super god essence infected soul simple
Light and night souls already show god essence can influence souls

wanton pendant
#

Clearly, Ocram hates potatoes.

thick bluff
#

Ok

green prairie
split mortar
#

Wha

green prairie
#

(i dont think azafurians look like. that but i do believe him at least being related to demons. it would explain the scythes)

raven brook
#

That dosen't make much sense unless he's like

#

a horrible mutated abomination of an azafurian or it's like

#

a magical construct for a body

#

or something

#

Tying him to demons would probably make more sense yea

green prairie
#

maybe thats why the brain is there? someone needed somewhere to put their brain after death

raven brook
#

big ass brain

green prairie
#

idk ocram is just a silly little abomination

raven brook
#

i think he could be justified as an attempt of the demons to replicate something like WoF

#

given they worship it

#

bcuz whatever ocram is he absolutely isnt a natural being yeah

#

hes an Abomination

raven brook
#

plus the demon scythes

split mortar
#

But thrn what is the blight soul

raven brook
#

just another type of soul caused by divine essence

#

Just like all the others

#

well except the mech souls but yk

#

exception

green prairie
raven brook
#

rather than being explicitly used as a tool to contain essence ocram is designed as a ritualistic worship figure and also as a war machine

raven brook
#

they dont have any ties to draedon

#

tying it to WoF makes much more sense imo like the connection is right there

#

(plus more draedon stuff is.... uneeded

raven brook
green prairie
#

i think my brain instinctively tries to connect ocram and mechs because of 12 years of muscle memory associating him with that one yrimir video

real glen
#

Imagine removed vanilla bosses still existed in morden version
hell to write

green prairie
green prairie
raven brook
#

Ehhh not really

split mortar
#

Draedon does all science no exception

raven brook
#

Well,

#

i suppose you could say so far he has specialized in machinery and engineering

#

but i feel like thats more of a byproduct of

#
  1. Being a part of the Yharmy
  2. The fact we don't see much of the stuff he does outside of the fuckass robots we figh
#

He's just a general science guy yeah

#

I'm sure towards the world at large he has studied/progressed research on like

#

alot

#

ingame you can see him show a interest in zoology, evolutionary science and social sciences for one

thick bluff
raven brook
#

Like the entire reason he wants to see you kill yharim is not out of any moral reasons due to yharim being evil as shoit or anything

#

he simply wants to study the effect this will have on society at large

#

that's literally social sciences

#

he's not just the robot that makes big robots, hes the robot that kinda just studies any form of science he is interested in at a given moment

#

making big robots is just one of the many things he does

thick bluff
#

Lepus - just weird big rabbit. Turkey boss - idk

raven brook
#

i ain't making lore for those bruh 😭 😭

#

turkor is actually satan

#

straight up

gentle osprey
#

Do we have any lore details about the abyss?

raven brook
#

thats his lore

#

biblical satan

green prairie
raven brook
#

The only notble part of lore i can sway is

split mortar
#

Turkor: HEYY SHADOW ITS ME

raven brook
#

Silva (The Goddess of Life)'s remains were dumped in the abyss

#

which is why there's planty mush growing everywhere and why the fauna can grow to unnaturally big sizes

split mortar
#

She likes taking abyss baths

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

yeah xeroc threw the terminus i nthe abyss so no one else could use it

split mortar
#

Well yeah who is gonna go in the super deep sea trench where the top layer is acidic and then the bottom layers have animals that could eat the average auric dragon

gentle osprey
#

especially the primal wyrm thing

raven brook
split mortar
gentle osprey
#

hmmm Now I got two lore behind that

real glen
raven brook
#

snail reaction i already MADE ocram lore

#

smh

green prairie
#

the chefs of Terraria wanted to reach new heights. they should've been happy where they were. there you go thats turkor's backstory

raven brook
#

lepus and turkor are more binding of isaac bosses than terraria bosses im ngl

#

;sob

split mortar
#

Turkor is biblical satan this was already established

thick bluff
#

Fr

raven brook
#

yeah turkor is just the devil straight up

gentle osprey
#

so the Terminus is already been there, and the primordia wyrm is protecting it from xeroc, or like the first one someone stated that xeroc threw it to the abyss?

raven brook
#

strongest character in the entire lore btw

raven brook
#

xeroc threw it there

the wyrm protectsi t

split mortar
#

Lepus is uhh

The child of the divine swine

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

He threw it down there so he obtained it at some point yes

thick bluff
raven brook
#

You generally need to be able to obtain something to be able to throw it somewhere

young socket
#

we dont know the origin of the terminus

split mortar
#

Terminus is needed for perfect ascension so yes xeroc had it since they perfect ascended

#

Same with silva

young socket
#

for all we know the terminus couldve been a well known artefact in the aerie

#

could also be made by someone

gentle osprey
#

ahh that clear thing up for me now

proper fog
young socket
#

just cuz xeroc threw it in the abyss doesnt mean it came from there

gentle osprey
#

I thought the abyss just existed there and doesn't have any history at all

raven brook
#

I mean

#

the abyss itself yes

#

it's a natural thing

#

but stuff happens on it

raven brook
proper fog
#

agnus is ravager right

raven brook
#

Which i mean

#

checks out for the 2nd strongest god we know of

gentle osprey
#

yeah that a valid point

raven brook
#

agnus my beloved

split mortar
#

Ravager is agnus revived zombie corps

gentle osprey
#

I still don

#

I still don't agree with them changed the mechanic from being the one that make the trio mech bosses to Draedon was the one that made them

proper fog
raven brook
#

I mean

#

literally none of vanilla lore is canon

#

to calamity

proper fog
#

mechanic's just a random girl lmao

gentle osprey
#

they should rewritten the story by mixing the vanilla lore instead

split mortar
#

No

raven brook
#

No

split mortar
#

Thats not what they are trying to do

proper fog
raven brook
#

Vanilla lore is effectively nonlore

#

It was not made with the intent of being narratively interesting or anything

gentle osprey
#

imagine the possibility of the multiverse

raven brook
#

it was made purely as fan service

#

the what

split mortar
raven brook
#

🥹

real glen
#

making mech cthulhu

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

if yall like the multiverse idea like me you guys would have understand my point here

raven brook
split mortar
#

Oh right those

mighty zenith
#

what multiverse 😭

dusk laurel
#

theres a multiverse??

raven brook
#

dude im being so mean and rude and evil

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

imagine the alt universe

raven brook
#

does it

#

lmao

mighty zenith
#

wait really

raven brook
#

i didnt even remember that

mighty zenith
#

yeah neither do i

split mortar
#

I think? That or just other planets idr

raven brook
#

forcibly inserting a multiverse in a story that dosent need it at all is sloppy storytelling

#

calamity dosent need one in the slightest

gentle osprey
#

like our main protagonist existed in every universe but facing different cosmology

mighty zenith
#

the lore pages are like 90% about the evil biomes

#

and some other stuff gets like a sentence or two

raven brook
#

it will not contribute to the story in any meaningful way and just make it worse by taking away narrative weight

split mortar
raven brook
#

if you want a multiverse in a story, watch invincible or the spiderverse movies

dusk laurel
#

whenever the concept of another universe gets introduced i just assume its slop unless theres actual meaning behind it thats interesting

real glen
#

dont star at astrageldon
rude and not canon

mighty zenith
#

i guarantee that was added because red thought it would be cool and didnt think past it at all

raven brook
#

yes

#

it definitely was

#

again

#

terraria lore is nonlore

#

its not a proper story that had muc hthought put into it

#

its fan service

gentle osprey
young socket
raven brook
#

true!

dusk laurel
raven brook
#

limbus company kinda has a multiversal thing going on but, not really, kinda, its complicated

real glen
#

So true

mighty zenith
#

i will play lobcorp never

#

which is sometime in the future

raven brook
#

ok garbo question

#

do you know about any of the abnormalities

#

cuz if u dont

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

i wanna make sure u dont get spoiled

mighty zenith
#

i know like

young socket
mighty zenith
#

absolutely nothing about lobcorp

dusk laurel
#

leviathan

raven brook
#

ok good

mighty zenith
#

i know its kind of like scp

#

and theres like a white haired woman

raven brook
#

theres some

#

very funny abnormalities

#

that i dont want you to discover anything about

raven brook
proper fog
#

can armless and legless statis beat up duke fishron

raven brook
#

shes bobot

mighty zenith
#

WHAT

#

i must play this game.

young socket
dusk laurel
#

garbo theres so many clankers

#

you gotta play

mighty zenith
#

you shouldve started with that

real glen
#

im crying

split mortar
mighty zenith
raven brook
#

Brainstorm had the statis upscale

young socket
raven brook
#

He went on the dungeon and fucking killed yharims guards

proper fog
raven brook
#

They couldn't even see who was killing them

#

Ok no spamming

proper fog
#

ok

split mortar
#

I keep on thinking your pfp is steven universe i dont know why

raven brook
#

Statis upscale

#

whose

split mortar
#

Falena

dusk laurel
#

wowzer

raven brook
#

i can kinda see it

young socket
#

tupid

split mortar
#

I know but when im not paying much attention to it it just registers as steven universe

raven brook
#

i can see why it might look like it from a far glance

#

vanillins pfp registers as sayaka miki

#

to me

#

but its not

young socket
#

chee ur just as tupid

dusk laurel
#

who is sayaka miki...

pulsar ocean
#

can old duke beat xeroc limbless deaf blindfolded sick

raven brook
#

madoker

dusk laurel
#

oe

dusk laurel
pulsar ocean
#

Punctuation is for losers

proper fog
#

so silva gets dunked into the abyss TWICE

gentle osprey
#

I never check the lore from the wiki page though, were it acceptable or not?

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

considered the lore from the wiki page is canon or not?

split mortar
split mortar
gentle osprey
#

I heard many peoples said the the lore from the wiki is complicated to follow up the time line

pulsar ocean
#

Is silva still immortal outside terraria

dusk laurel
#

only thing i have against the lore page of the wiki is that it calls the whispers the lore items which yk

split mortar
proper fog
pulsar ocean
#

What if silva was betrayed and thrown in a hyperbolic time chamber for 10000 years

gentle osprey
#

like which event is happened first, and follow up later with what next and what come first, and does that related to the main events or not

split mortar
#

Good thing i can confirm atleast one document has a timeline

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
proper fog
pulsar ocean
#

Why has yharim never tried recruiting jared

gentle osprey
proper fog
wanton pendant
split mortar
pulsar ocean
split mortar
#

Waterwraith is not they them so no

pulsar ocean
#

Right mb

wanton pendant
wanton pendant
#

It quite literally is.

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

It's like Skyrim.

#

Beyond being the Dragonborn, your motive and backstory is up to you.

split mortar
#

The terrarian is left blank for us to put headcanons and OCs there

pulsar ocean
gentle osprey
#

yeah maybe because the calamity's lore is ended right at we (terraian) show up to clear thing that left behind

wanton pendant
gentle osprey
split mortar
#

Im british

pulsar ocean
#

Are we playing as a draconic offshoot calamity mod in skyrim

wanton pendant
split mortar
gentle osprey
#

yeah I can imagine Yharim colonialism the world

wanton pendant
gentle osprey
raven brook
#

terraria is a sandbox where you can do whatever the fuck you want

#

Trying to insert a character onto that would be a bit counterintuitive

#

thus the terrarian can be whatever the fuck you want them to be

#

they are effectively not a character, they are a template

split mortar
#

Hence the image

gentle osprey
#

you don't get it

split mortar
#

???

#

The devs have said this thenselves

wanton pendant
gentle osprey
#

a character have purpose

wanton pendant
#

Your purpose is KILL YHARIM.

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Past that you can do whatever the hell you want.

gentle osprey
#

I know The Terrarian is whatever you want him to be depend on us

#

Don't you understand one thing is that the character have his own purpose?

#

like what we been do is us doing, but the Terrarian himself should have his own purpose, except that we don't do what he did

thick bluff
#

Deerclops and Old One's Army lore in Calamity?

thick bluff
wanton pendant
gentle osprey
#

like we play as a character dies a lot, but when in actual plot the character is unstoppable

wanton pendant
#

They don't exist.

raven brook
#

what is your terrarian's goal? What is their backstory?

#

idk man

#

make it up

#

it's up to you YOUdecidetheloreoftheterrarian

gentle osprey
raven brook
raven brook
#

It is a personal choice of the developers to not consider content explifitly from other media canon as it does not fit their vision for the story

gentle osprey
#

example You play god of war, you at least die a few time, but in actual story was Kratos ever been kill by a low life mob?

raven brook
#

dude

#

that's called It's a Video Game

gentle osprey
thick bluff
raven brook
#

you're incomprehensible

raven brook
#

What point are you trying to make

#

This has nothing to do with the terrarian's "lore" whatsoever

manic coral
#

Yeah I genuinely can't understand what your point is either

gentle osprey
thick bluff
raven brook
#

I assume english isn't your first language which already dosen't make it very easy to understand what you mean which like that part isn't really your fault but i genuinely cant understand how this correlates to anything we've been talking about

split mortar
raven brook
#

The terrarian dosen't have predefined lore, this isn't a "gameplay" thing

#

The writers explicitly have stated multiple times that the terrarian is a blank slate and their lore is whatever you want it to be

#

There is no set backstory or goals or personality

#

You make it up

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Yeah except it does

#

That's not a gameplay thing

#

it has nothing to do with gameplay whatsoever

#

respawning is a gameplay thing

#

It's there because generally you don't want to lose all progress on your game after dying once unless the game is intentionally designed around that mechanic ex: Hardmode Minecraft, Don't Starve

#

It has nothing to do with narrative

gentle osprey
#

I don't say anything relate to the narrative

manic coral
#

When it's involving your character, it's all up to you. It is your character that you make, after all. Respawning is the only real exception.

raven brook
gentle osprey
raven brook
#

You are talking about the Terrarian's Lore

gentle osprey
#

no I don't

raven brook
#

Brother

#

We are all Trying To

manic coral
#

In my opinion, it wouldn't feel right if you had a pre-determined background in a game like this.

raven brook
#

We are not stopping you from speaking

#

the problem is that what youre speaking is incomprehensible

thick bluff
wanton pendant
#

I'd say the exception to Terrarian being up to you is that they can't explicitly contradict the narrative.

gentle osprey
thick bluff
raven brook
#

Tailor is a different word for Clothier so i assume its just a diff language moment

#

like me calling a blender a liquidifier a while back

#

lol

manic coral
wanton pendant
#

I assume you're using a translator.

wanton pendant
gentle osprey
wanton pendant
#

They do.

#

You determine it.

gentle osprey
#

see

wanton pendant
#

Like, you know, how many games have it.

#

Like Skyrim.

#

Ever play Skyrim?

gentle osprey
#

idk is I am suck at putting up words or

#

why is no one understanding my point?

raven brook
#

I'm sorry but respectfully

#

You're communicating your point horribly

#

It's extremely hard to understand yes

gentle osprey
#

yeah I kinda agree with that

wanton pendant
#

Being honest, half your sentences aren't comprehensible.

manic coral
#

Am I correct?

gentle osprey
#

because the progression in terraria was in order after all

raven brook
#

A large point of Calamity's story is to have you as the player come up with your own conclusion on things

#

Not to be guided by anyone else's hand

#

Having your player have a predetermined goal and backstory would not only go against that,

#

But also inherently go against the sandbox aspect of terraria aswell

gentle osprey
manic coral
#

Yeah, that's the main reason why they do not

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

it has nothing to do with the vanilla

raven brook
#

It is not about it being vanilla or modded

#

Regardless

#

it is still a sandbox game

split mortar
raven brook
#

Arguably Calamity makes the progression more nonlinear if anything

gleaming swallow
gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Yes?

split mortar
#

What is that point????

raven brook
#

Sandboxes can have lore.

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

No, not really

split mortar
#

No

#

Since the terrarian doesnt

gentle osprey
#

stop saying it "depend on us"

raven brook
#

Do you want to know how many different games that have stories don't have their characters have a predefined goal

raven brook
#

literally how the story is written

#

That is the Canonical Explanation

raven brook
#

Ask literally any of the writers

split mortar
manic coral
#

There are plenty of sandbox games filled with lore and story that have your character not have a pre-determined background

split mortar
#

It is irrefutably up to us what the terrarian is like

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

No

#

No they don't

#

Not every games does

gentle osprey
#

then a role play game is different story

raven brook
#

Cei

#

you have a patience i do not have

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

I really am trying my best to keep my composure here

#

I really am

split mortar
gentle osprey
split mortar
#

there are plenty of sandbox games filled with lore

raven brook
#

If you saw that clearly it did not register in your brain in the slightest

#

You don't seem to know how storytelling works and how there are thousands of different ways one can write a story

thick bluff
#

I'd say the original Terraria has almost no lore of its own, unless you count the non-canonical official lore that was made for fun.
But Calamity has proper lore.

raven brook
#

Calamity has lore

raven brook
#

The terrarian dosen't

raven brook
#

I'm a writer

manic coral
# gentle osprey because they don't have lore

But they do. Again, take a game like Skyrim as an example. Your character has absolutely no pre-set background aside from being arrested somehow. Yet it's filled with plenty of lore and story, and even though it only has one ending, there's a lot of lore and story related stuff to explore.

raven brook
#

Skyrim protagonist lore

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Ah, you're finally awake.

languid otter
#

I am not a very good writer but I know damn well my terraria character would have their own lore

split mortar
raven brook
wanton pendant
raven brook
#

That's why the writers haven't done it

#

Because it does not fit their vision for the story

#

And it is not needed

#

Sorry everyone

#

The terrarian now is the chosen hero of legend that exists to vanquish evil

#

Truly a incredible characterization

#

makes the story far better

#

😌

raven brook
#

Uhhh uhhh

#

uhhhhhhhhhhh

#

well they uhhhhhh

#

they had a cold.

#

couldnt fight at the time. sorgy

eager bluff
obsidian plume
#

providence ran away!

eager bluff
#

graaaah

manic coral
wanton pendant
raven brook
#

The Dark Souls games all sorta lean onto this too (I'd say notably Dark Souls 2 is a fairly big exception)

Besides a vague template the protagonists don't really have

#

much of a characterization

manic coral
#

Yeah, Dark Souls games are like this as well

raven brook
#

just go out there and kill things man idk

dusk laurel
raven brook
#

Dark Souls 2 like always is the exception because you have a much more defined motive and backstory

#

Neither of which is a worse or better approach btw! It depends on the story you want to write!

#

Having a defined backstory for a protagonist is not inherently better or worse

#

Different stories are told differently

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Calamity's story is told without a protagonist with a predfined backstory

gentle osprey
#

but in this case is different

obsidian plume
manic coral
raven brook
#

Calamity's story is largely about exploring the world and discovering about its past

#

So like, how is that different :p

#

If anything what you described fits calamity's narrative perfectly

#

There is a world out there with its own lore and story already, and the story comes frou you exploring and discovering about it

#

Not about your personal goals or backstory

gentle osprey
manic coral
raven brook
#

It

#

dosen't have to do

#

In fact it won't

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Yeah

#

Yharim's the final boss

#

you kill him

split mortar
#

You uh fight yharim and he dies

raven brook
#

That's how the story ends, not counting the "epilogue" content with Xeroc and Noxus

gentle osprey
wanton pendant
#

Like Skyrim.

obsidian plume
languid otter
#

fight yharim
refuse to elaborate
go home and sleep

that's one of my terraria character :3

limpid saddle
#

what happened here?

#

oh

manic coral
wanton pendant
#

We need someone bilingual.

limpid saddle
#

i see its still happening

split mortar
languid otter
#

ah

limpid saddle
raven brook
#

Well the why seems to be that uhhh

#

the mod has a story so the player needs one to question mark

raven brook
#

And it'd make the ending of the story "easier" to figure out...?

#

Even though that's just wrong

gentle osprey
languid otter
#

"why uhh the character I create should be up to myself?"
something like this

obsidian plume
wanton pendant
gentle osprey
gentle osprey
#

this is my whole point here

obsidian plume
#

yeah ok, just look at the terraria visual novels

raven brook
#

So your point is entirely based on a borderline impossible hypothetical that even if it were to happen

wanton pendant
raven brook
#

You know how movie adaptations work, right?

#

You know they change things?

zenith geode
#

the terrarian should be predefined just in case there might be some sort of story based on calamity mod?

raven brook
#

To fit the structure of a movie?

obsidian plume
gentle osprey
split mortar
wanton pendant
split mortar
wanton pendant
final bison
#

In a way calamitys worldbuilding is similiar to smthin like dark souls or elden ring

raven brook
#

Id say its more like silksong personally funnily enough

obsidian plume
raven brook
#

Cuz dark souls's world is very much doomed

obsidian plume
#

You can make a calamity character matter in a movie sure, does not mean u have to sacrifice the ingame version

raven brook
#

While Silksong's is kinda fucked up but has a glimmer of hope for the future which throughout the story you make brighter

#

And Calamity's more like that

split mortar
#

Commit a second crusade

raven brook
obsidian plume
#

yes, that, thanks

split mortar
#

Cheese commit the second crusade

raven brook
#

Can't rn

wanton pendant
split mortar
raven brook
#

I need to repair my Crusade Gun before i can

zenith geode
final bison
#

If ego from project moon suddenly existed in the world of terraria

#

Who would manifest it?

#

At least in calamity lore

raven brook
#

now thats my jam

#

anyawys uhhh

final bison
#

I'd say braelor

wanton pendant
#

Must. Resist. DoG joke.

raven brook
#

Yharim

zenith geode
#

dragonfolly and nobody else

raven brook
#

Definitely Yharim for one

gentle osprey
#

I hope some of you guys understand my point here a bit...

final bison
#

I can see that

#

But I can see him distorting once we fight him

split mortar
#

I dont

raven brook
#

I can see Braelor getting ego too

split mortar
#

He still holds his beliefs

wanton pendant
raven brook
#

Yharim is literally like Ahab

zenith geode
#

they made a minecraft movie without giving steve defined lore
that's my counterargument

split mortar
final bison
gentle osprey
raven brook
#

You don't need to be happy to manifest ego

final bison
#

He probably regrets what he's done

magic epoch
raven brook
#

Nah not really

split mortar
young socket
raven brook
#

He's depressed for other reasons

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

He would do the crusade again if he got sent back in time

raven brook
#

He's less so depressed because he committed genocide

#

and more so

zenith geode
#

yharim regrets that he sent a child to go nuke ilmeris instead of doing it himself

raven brook
#

he's depressed because he couldn't finish the genocide

final bison
#

LMAO

split mortar
#

Hes sad he didnt get to do genocide better basically

final bison
#

Well damn

#

Yharim really is deplorable

zenith geode
#

because the child did her job improperly (let tyrian get away)

split mortar
#

He is the most set in stone in his beliefs i dont see a universe where he distorts

raven brook
#

I'm so sorry Calamitas, i shouldn't have sent you to genocide those fish people as a child.

#

That was truly deplorable.

wanton pendant
#

He also thinks that he MIGHT have gone too far with hiring children and evil murder worms.

raven brook
#

I should've just went there and genocided them myself.

#

Will you forgive me?

#

He then gets hit with 50 brimstone gigablasts

dusk laurel
#

3 star golden hitler

gentle osprey
final bison
#

I think he might uhh

raven brook
#

yeah no yharim is genuinely like ahab

final bison
#

Fix his mistakes

split mortar
raven brook
#

He's so fucking stubborn in his beliefs that i think he'd just skip the convo with carmen

#

go straight into ego

split mortar
final bison
#

As in not dumping the corpses of God's on terraria

mighty zenith
#

"Child soldiers are terrible. They're too weak to do anything"

raven brook
# final bison Fix his mistakes

He has 10 years left in his lifespan and what he's doing is actively training to genocide better and trying to manipulate you into following along his footsteps of genociding

cloud ibex
#

if yharim had a second attempt at the crusade he would do the exact same thing again but more efficiently and with less "innocent" casualties

raven brook
#

Also mind you

split mortar
raven brook
#

He could've put all of the evil biomes in WoF if he wanted to

#

And entirely fixed that problem

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

Case in point:

#

He did it with the Hallow

#

Now

#

Think about that for a moment

wanton pendant
cloud ibex
#

(innocent in quotations cause really he'd probably still kill any god worshippers that otherwise haven't actually done anything)

raven brook
#

A little bit of the disgusting, foul, corrupt evil biomes

#

Was left outside of wof

#

for everyone to see

#

Meanwhile, the hallow

final bison
#

We gotta kill yharim Holy shit

raven brook
#

which is a much more beautiful and hospitable place ,despite some hostile fauna

#

was enetirely sealed within wof

#

Now i WONDER why thats the case

#

It seems

split mortar
raven brook
#

VERY

#

CONVENIENT

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

to have the evil foul horrible dead god biome

split mortar
#

The lore documents

raven brook
#

be the only one left

#

for the guy who wants to get everyone to think gods r inherently evil and bad

#

VERY. CONVENIENT

final bison
#

I remember some dumbass comment on yharims theme from yomi hustle

wanton pendant
cloud ibex
#

also very interesting how he doesn't comment on the hallow at all

#

ever

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

YEAH

#

HE DOSEN'T HAVE A LORE WHISPER ON THE HALLOW

#

AT ALL

wanton pendant
obsidian plume
split mortar
raven brook
#

do you think devs just forgot about it?

#

no that shit is intentional

cloud ibex
#

like he doesn't even attempt to be like "guys this is bait don't feed the trolls"

raven brook
#

hate that guy

cloud ibex
#

he's just silent

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

bum ass piss hitler

final bison
#

Where they said smthin like "maybe this could play when Xeroc awakens and yharim helps us beat Xeroc with yharon clutching us last minute!"

#

Like fuck offfff

raven brook
#

no bruh we killing yharim

#

we killing his ass

#

hes DYING

languid otter
final bison
#

He gotta go

raven brook
#

dude

zenith geode
#

happy sunshine rainbows land where the worst thing there is somewhat aggressive horses vs the biomes of festering and rotting flesh that infect things and bring them into it like a virus

raven brook
#

its so funny to me

#

when people say

#

XEROC IS THE TRUE VILLAIN!!!!@

#

And once again

wanton pendant
raven brook
#

xeroc crimes. killing 1 guy

#

for morally dubious intentions

#

yharim crimes

#

geneva convention

gentle osprey
#

I almost believe Yharim was a good guy btw

languid otter
#

nah Yharim has to go 😭 🥀

cloud ibex
#

oh boy

#

here we go

obsidian plume
#

rip chat

final bison
#

This shits diabolical

raven brook
#

Xeroc's probably a guy with good intentions who's just not handling things very well

#

He's definitely not evil

#

At best he's just a flawed, but benevolent individual

#

At worst he's just kinda neutral

#

I personally believe him to be more of the former

manic coral
raven brook
split mortar
gentle osprey
#

Xeroc is on fraud watch

split mortar
#

Is literally the strongest cal character

cloud ibex
#

xeroc is too busy tending to the garden of primordial zaza left behind by zeratros

manic coral
#

He uses it see what thing he HASN'T done in whatever city he takes over yet to make sure he's done all of them to "The Bad People"™

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

no he literally could smite us with the unmatched power of the sun if he wanted to

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

ngl I really love the idea of people getting god like power from taking a dragon hearth

raven brook
#

its a soul

gentle osprey
raven brook
#

yeah

#

its literally their soul

wanton pendant
raven brook
#

idk why ther " "

cloud ibex
#

you know now that i think about it the whole concept of absorbing auric soul is kinda elden ring esque

#

with the whole dragon communion thing

raven brook
#

to me its dark souls esque

#

because

#

yk

#

absorbing the power of ancient dragons to ascend to godhood and lal that

gentle osprey
#

before I play calamity mod and know some lore behind it, you know what I think about Yharim?

cloud ibex
#

in my defense i haven't played ds1

raven brook
#

yeah the entire story revolves around gods usurping dragons and stealing their power

gentle osprey
#

I thought he was evil Terrarian in the future or in the alt timeline or some sort

raven brook
#

the gods are generally a unified faction there though

#

and theres alot less of them

mighty zenith
#

this is just like the movie lightyear

cloud ibex
#

guy who has only seen lightyear

thick bluff
#

I saw a review of this thing.

gentle osprey
#

for me it have the best theme song in the game

cloud ibex
#

garbo hates aureus

raven brook
#

astrum aureus more like uhh

#

astrum... aur.. uhh

#

astrum auric

#

haha

cloud ibex
#

i get the joke

split mortar
#

Asstrum aureus

cloud ibex
#

😁

spring helm
#

1233popcorn

dusk laurel
#

boaric

split mortar
spring helm
#

another day another hitler comparison

#

has the cannonball jellyfish lore been changed with the update

gentle osprey
#

didn't know everyone using hitler joke here

split mortar
gentle osprey
#

where is the origin of the auric ore come from?

wanton pendant
wanton pendant
gentle osprey
midnight citrus
#

Tbh I'm confused with calamity lore...

I heard everything started from goozma or smt...

wanton pendant
#

?

gentle osprey
#

no I'm asking

split mortar
midnight citrus
wanton pendant
#

Pins.

split mortar
#

Pins

midnight citrus
#

They keep changing it

#

I'm sorry

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

They don't.

split mortar
#

Not since the rewrite like 3 years ago

worldly spindle
gentle osprey
#

I love Yharon in game still have the same look since 1.2

#

the mods like worm more than bird

midnight citrus
#

If yharim's a god slayer why hasn't he killed most of the gods still presence in calamity mod

#

One of them being providence

split mortar
#

We come across the few that survived his global genocide

#

Or well a few if those few

tough sentinel
#

whatever happened to Xeroc

midnight citrus
worldly spindle
#

Used to be

split mortar
split mortar
worldly spindle
#

WotG has no bearing on Calamity’s lore

tough sentinel
split mortar
#

Wotg is a fan made project that used to loosely be based on old outdated plans

midnight citrus
# split mortar No

It's just that when I search up xeroc on wiki it's an image of nameless deity that pops up

split mortar