#lore-discussion

1 messages ยท Page 703 of 1

dusk laurel
#

what

final kindle
#

and real life elements

#

and stuff like that

raven brook
#

Also that's just like wrong

long bloom
#

3d calamity discussion

final kindle
#

animals, plants, etc

raven brook
#

like just objectively wrong

#

like plain and utterly wrong

final kindle
#

if you're gonna have some form of real life at least make sure to pick the right amount of dimensions basically

raven brook
#

No not really not at all sorry man

#

Games aren't about being realistic unless their goal is explicitly to be realistic

#

Whether they have real elements or not dosen't matter at all if the goal is not to be realistic

#

Unless you were to be making a realistic simulator game then no

#

3d is not objectively better

#

it depends on what the game is

#

what do you want to do with it, what is the game design for it, what are its mechanics, etc

final kindle
raven brook
#

games are Entertainment

final kindle
#

but terraria would be better as 3D

raven brook
#

No it really wouldn't

#

It really, really wouldn't

dusk laurel
#

terraria is completely designed to be a 2d game

raven brook
#

3d terraria would quite simply just not be terraria. it wouldn't be "better" or "worse"

#

it's just a different game

dusk laurel
#

yeah

final kindle
#

a different game that I believe is better in every way

long bloom
#

you want hytale

#

you're talking about hytale

final kindle
raven brook
#

a belief that shows you lack understanding of how game design works

#

Now, having preference is fine

long bloom
raven brook
#

But saying it'd be "better" is just plain wrong

final kindle
#

terraria is more fun than hytale because hytale has no content in its current state, neither does Minecraft or any mods of it

dusk laurel
#

okay

split mortar
long bloom
dusk laurel
#

anyways i believe in my personal opinion this discussion would fit elsewhere

final kindle
split mortar
#

Terraria for me is just sorta too much based on working for 2D that it would need a innately different vision to work somewhat in 3D and so by then its not terraria and so i would almost certainly prefer terraria to it

long bloom
#

just not very good stuff

sinful adder
raven brook
#

Don't conflate personal preference with objective quality

raven brook
#

No need to do insults

sinful adder
#

If you don't like it then stop playing terraria and leave

#

Yeah ok fair enough

final kindle
long bloom
#

debatable

final kindle
#

but it's a very good game

raven brook
#

If you're simply saying you have a preference for 3d games, then that's your opinion and its fine as again, video games are a form of entertainment and differennt people are entertained different ways

#

It is simply saying that terraria would be better as a 3d that's just wrong

#

Czu that's not presented as a opinion, but as a objective

final kindle
split mortar
long bloom
#

so it fundamentally cannot be a better version of terraria

final kindle
zenith geode
#

terraria only functions in 2d

final kindle
split mortar
long bloom
# final kindle example?

having a game where getting hit once puts you in an infinite death loop is objectively bad design

final kindle
#

in that case it would be perfect

long bloom
#

that would have negative long term effects

final kindle
long bloom
#

science

final kindle
#

the person dying happier than anyone else has every lived?

split mortar
#

Wouldnt that fry your receptors and thus make normal life seem miserable

long bloom
#

do you know how dopamine works

#

it'd quickly desensitize you

#

it's like an addiction

final kindle
#

an addicting game is a good game

#

we've succeeded

long bloom
#

no

zenith geode
#

gambling.... is... good...?

#

slot machine....... good...?

final kindle
split mortar
#

Time to gamble away my life savings

final kindle
#

like I said, there's no objective

long bloom
#

addictions are objectively bad i think idk

final kindle
#

you can't argue an objective

final kindle
zenith geode
#

tip: slot machines are objectively the worst way to profit in a casino

#

they have by FAR the worst EV of anything there

final kindle
#

it's challenging

#

to some

long bloom
# final kindle no

what benefit does being addicted to something provide for your overall quality of life

zenith geode
#

challenging
theres no challenge you just push a button

long bloom
zenith geode
#

or pull a lever

#

at least with the card games theres some control you have

long bloom
#

tell me you know absolutely nothing about addictions without telling me

wanton pendant
#

The whole point of gambling is that it's not a challenge, it's chance.
What the hell are you all talking about?

split mortar
final kindle
#

I'm saying this because when I say 3D Terraria would allow for much more complex combat, mechanics, builds, enemies etc etc you're gonna say no complex is bad no 3D movement bad

#

when it's good

zenith geode
#

hell, the games where you do have control are the ones that have the highest EV

final kindle
#

basically there's no objective here, everyone has different preferences

zenith geode
long bloom
final kindle
long bloom
#

they'd be completely different

zenith geode
#

scal would need to have her projectile density cranked WAY the fuck up to the point where your camera is completely blocked

final kindle
#

neither can you define it though

#

objectively

long bloom
#

i think this argument is becoming circular

zenith geode
#

you'd need to redesign basically every boss from the ground up due to another dimension and the lack of an outsider's view

final kindle
#

it's always this way when you talk about objectivity

#

and video game preferences

#

because as long as we hypothesize about a game that doesn't exist and try to compare it to a game that does, the argument won't go anywhere

long bloom
#

then why are you arguing wires

final kindle
#

It's engaging

wanton pendant
#

How is it that you argue for both sides?

split mortar
long bloom
#

lore discussion

#

what's up with roxcalibur

final kindle
#

the what

long bloom
#

roxcalibur lore

#

what do it mean

final kindle
#

hell I know we don't even have the SSO in question

long bloom
#

this spoiler was 9 months ago SAD

wanton pendant
#

Once again, implying Azafure isn't actually the first city, just the first known city.

final kindle
#

What I wonder is why do we have 5 continents

#

it feels completely random and artificial

long bloom
#

for worldbuilding

final kindle
#

I feel like 2 or 3 is enough to explain everything

#

5 is mad and puts unrealistic expectations

wanton pendant
long bloom
#

there's the heartlands, brazil, evil hell continent and the 2 smaller ones

split mortar
#

O thought hell was among smaller ones

wanton pendant
#

Surely we don't need Australia and Antartica.

final kindle
wanton pendant
split mortar
long bloom
dusk laurel
#

the writers arent obligated to explain every single detail about each continent

final kindle
dusk laurel
#

????

final kindle
#

we're NEVER getting 5 large+ worlds in 1 playthrough

dusk laurel
#

so

woeful karma
#

๐Ÿ˜ญ

dusk laurel
#

we never leave this continent

final kindle
#

there's no reason for inaccessible continents to exist in the long run

split mortar
long bloom
dusk laurel
#

thats why you are always in one place

final kindle
woeful karma
#

wordbuilding????

split mortar
woeful karma
#

to tell a story??

wanton pendant
dusk laurel
final kindle
long bloom
#

why

#

who decided that

split mortar
#

Why must that be the limit tho

dusk laurel
#

these limits are arbitrary

final kindle
#

because quality over quantity

dusk laurel
#

????

long bloom
#

๐Ÿ˜ญ

woeful karma
#

man

#

antarcticas worldbuilding fucking sucks

dusk laurel
#

we live in a society

wanton pendant
woeful karma
#

we should have quality over quantity in our landmass

split mortar
woeful karma
#

who even needs the middle part of america anyways its not essential to fulfil the worldbuilding

final kindle
#

to me right now, it looks like you placed 5 land masses and half of them are entirely empty and we have zero idea what they would look like

dusk laurel
#

because

#

the lore

#

is not

#

finished

woeful karma
#

thats what a world looks like

long bloom
#

๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ

#

the mod is incomplete

#

including the lore

dusk laurel
#

guys earth was basically empty 3 billion years ago why does it exist

split mortar
final kindle
#

you can make it easier to finish if you reduce the amount of continents since we all know you're never getting to experience those 5 continents in any shape or form in-game

long bloom
#

why does mars exist there's nothing there

woeful karma
#

if you want a video game land where every location serves a purpose thats great but thats not what calamity is going for

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

Theres supposedly a crystal city
We dont fucking know shit of it its from one dev statement
But its there

long bloom
#

this is such a non issue

#

please get a real problem SAD

#

like eol lore

wanton pendant
#

What the hell was Todd Howard thinking when he made Skyrim?

final kindle
split mortar
#

Theyre places we will never go to theres no reason for them to have that much focus on them

long bloom
#

it's completely arbitrary

final kindle
# long bloom why though

because the player would ask less questions about simple things that are for some unknown reason kept a mystery even though technically it should be easy to obtain information

woeful karma
#

you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the goal of worldbuilding i think

dusk laurel
#

this is such a strange nitpick because its their story they get to do what they want with the setting you dont just have a rule where you are only allowed to write 3 continents into existence

split mortar
long bloom
#

i'm crine

woeful karma
#

not every element in a story needs 500 pages of history

#

some stories do have that

#

but middle-earth is the outstanding exception, not the rule

final kindle
#

btw to y'all saying real life has bad world building acting like years of plate tectonics and history of the solar system straight up doesn't exist

long bloom
split mortar
#

You say that like that doesnt technically apply to calamity as well

sinful adder
woeful karma
#

most people will not care that other continents are rarely mentioned, and will recognize that obviously the developers have more important things to do than making a library full of details about everything

sinful adder
#

Something can exist and be relevant to you without being directly accessible to you

woeful karma
#

and those that do care will make fan content

sinful adder
#

Or it can also exist without being relevant to you

long bloom
#

i just wanted to talk about roxcalibur man SAD

woeful karma
#

the point is the suspension of disbelief that this is a real world with a real history

simple tangle
#

hi

sinful adder
#

You can have the opinion that this is bad world building but basically everyone will disagree

simple tangle
#

whats up

final kindle
# long bloom you're acting like they don't in calamity though???

I'm saying is that it's going to take too much effort to explain what each continent looks like, for example the yharim crusades were over the entirety of terraria, yet we know nothing about what yharim did in those other continents, and we probably will never do because writing is hard, and it's annoying to not know when realistically that information should be accessible to a god-like Terrarian who's killing gods.

simple tangle
#

what going on :0

long bloom
long bloom
#

i'm completely fine with that

woeful karma
#

realistically lots of information would be accessible in video game worlds just by talking to people

#

but video games can only be so detailed a representation of reality

final kindle
#

finished lore with intentional mysteries >> unfinished lore with inexplicably outrageous mysteries

woeful karma
#

??

dusk laurel
#

what?

simple tangle
sinful adder
#

We will get more information about these things later in NPC dialogue and lore items but we will never know all the details, or even most of them

woeful karma
#

do you think the lore is intentionally unfinished

long bloom
sinful adder
#

Also the lore literally just isn't finished being written or implemented yet

split mortar
wanton pendant
woeful karma
long bloom
final kindle
sinful adder
#

Some things will remain mentioned but not clarified purpose because they aren't relevant and there is deliberately things left ambiguous so you can fill in whatever you want

green prairie
sinful adder
final kindle
dusk laurel
split mortar
simple tangle
#

where yharim cal devs

final kindle
long bloom
dusk laurel
long bloom
final kindle
long bloom
#

extensively

wanton pendant
long bloom
sinful adder
#

The lore writers frequently talk with us here

dusk laurel
final kindle
split mortar
simple tangle
long bloom
#

took 4 seconds to implement

wanton pendant
split mortar
dusk laurel
simple tangle
final kindle
long bloom
wanton pendant
split mortar
simple tangle
wanton pendant
#

Even before they rewrote it.

long bloom
split mortar
#

Just because they wanted to change something from whag it is rn soes not mean its because a lore dev forced em to

simple tangle
#

has scal ever been intended to be an eye once the mod had actual lore???

sinful adder
#

The spriters are also separate from the lore writers and devs

sinful adder
#

The lore was rewritten because it sucked before

final kindle
#

once it started to have lore scal stopped being an eye thingy

lore affected the code and art

long bloom
#

it didn't delay anything though

woeful karma
#

anyways the moment "yharim never" was mentioned i tuned out

simple tangle
#

you're right the mod should stop having lore so the devs can focus on what actually matters.....Yharim!

long bloom
dusk laurel
#

infact the lore itself is getting delayed (cal dialogue rewrite for some reason being pushed out of the next update even though its mostly done as an example)

final kindle
#

it did? if scal fight didn't change the resprite didn't happen, we'd be closer to yharim fight, but we'd have deeper lore around the eye thingy scal

sinful adder
#

No we wouldn't actually

simple tangle
#

where muh yharim

sinful adder
#

But also none of us care even if it would

final kindle
sinful adder
#

They were making fun of you

final kindle
#

I know

long bloom
#

they chose to change it themselves

sinful adder
#

It will be like 5 years until the yharim fight. They want to remake most of the mod before then because fabsol's stuff sucked ass

simple tangle
#

mfs dont want calamity mod to be good they just want their stupid man boss fight

wanton pendant
final kindle
dusk laurel
#

???

long bloom
#

???????

#

dude

final kindle
#

they're juggling way too much for a 2D block game

long bloom
#

there's 37 devs

sinful adder
#

Then this mod is not for you

long bloom
#

that's a lot

wanton pendant
long bloom
#

especially for a mod

simple tangle
split mortar
#

I dont fuck with your vibe
So what if calamity takes a while its not meant to be a quickly done project

long bloom
#

please don't bring it up again

sinful adder
simple tangle
#

oh

sinful adder
#

I think most 2d games are better than most 3d games

#

Maybe not most. The best ones of each

long bloom
#

lore

simple tangle
#

what does yharim do all day

wanton pendant
#

Just found a Terragrim, which obviously is integral to the lore.

split mortar
final kindle
long bloom
wanton pendant
dusk laurel
simple tangle
#

its true they should just add yharim call the mod finished and move to a mod that actually matters.......A TREMOR REMAKE!

long bloom
#

dies

green prairie
#

i kinda like the unfinished lore for the time being actually? ofc i want it to be finished, but i absolutely love speculating about it

simple tangle
#

one tremillion dollars

final kindle
#

dissecting lore purely off the game is much better than ahhh dev statements

long bloom
#

the devs agree

dusk laurel
long bloom
#

this situation is not ideal for any party

green prairie
#

i do agree that digging up dev statements can be a little messy, but that's why the doc exists i guess

final kindle
#

the doc is messy

long bloom
#

@tyrant fix when

dusk laurel
simple tangle
#

yall whos ur fav tremor boss

long bloom
split mortar
long bloom
wanton pendant
final kindle
dusk laurel
#

.

long bloom
#

how is that the doc's fault?????? ๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ ๐Ÿ˜ญ

wanton pendant
dusk laurel
#

im not even going to entertain this conversation anymore

split mortar
dusk laurel
#

this is the most pointless and tiresome circle thats being walked

final kindle
#

they have as much relevance as plantera in the game and they are somehow main characters because devs said so

long bloom
#

IT'S NOT DONE

split mortar
#

THEY WANNA RECTIFY THAT ISSUE

wanton pendant
cloud ibex
#

this conversation is completely incomprehensible why is there an argument

long bloom
#

they're going to be actual npcs you can talk to in the future ๐Ÿ˜ญ

#

this entire convo is ManaRose

final kindle
wanton pendant
split mortar
#

Do we need the image again

final kindle
cloud ibex
#

no

final kindle
#

they just "fought yharim and lost"

split mortar
long bloom
dusk laurel
#

Can we just like, end this.

simple tangle
final kindle
cloud ibex
split mortar
#

Document is future proofed

cloud ibex
#

you're all just yelling the same things at each other over and over again

cloud ibex
long bloom
#

please can we talk about roxcalibur now

final kindle
split mortar
split mortar
#

We can only do so much

final kindle
#

if it was future proof, it's safer to assign less importance than more

long bloom
#

i think you underestimate how much the writers talk about things

split mortar
#

Braelor and statis being important is pretty damn big for the devs to just disregard

final kindle
#

if you tell someone "these two are important" and eventually they don't become important, what's future proof about that?

sacred pilot
#

They'll eventually be important either way????

#

Good god.

long bloom
sacred pilot
#

Most literate Terraria player istg.

cloud ibex
#

i'm gonna throw rocks at people

zenith geode
cloud ibex
#

if you all want to keep going in circles at least take it to dms

young socket
split mortar
simple tangle
final kindle
zenith geode
#

foolishness. i give up.

wanton pendant
#

I find your lack of patience disturbing.

long bloom
cloud ibex
simple tangle
cloud ibex
#

there's a reason i have this emote

sacred pilot
zenith geode
dusk laurel
#

we never learn

#

everything is futile

simple tangle
#

can we talk about my skrunkly now
(war god)

long bloom
#

true!

split mortar
long bloom
#

they uhh

#

existed

final kindle
#

combat thing god is more important

long bloom
#

๐Ÿ‘

#

yep

sacred pilot
#

My skrunkly rn is the Abyss.

long bloom
sacred pilot
#

And the Distortion.

long bloom
#

actually nvm i don't wanna know

final kindle
dusk laurel
split mortar
#

I like siffrin from in stars and time

final kindle
#

nvm

long bloom
final kindle
#

combat thing dragon -> war god

zenith geode
#

i like the one character from that one thing

cloud ibex
#

i am quite fond of voruna warframe

long bloom
wanton pendant
sacred pilot
#

I am literally RX-93 ฮฝ Gundam.

final kindle
simple tangle
#

what are the perforators? are they just weird fucked up parasites born from war god's corpse?

#

the worms i mean

long bloom
simple tangle
#

NOOOO!!!!

final kindle
long bloom
#

perf will become fucked up hydra thing probably

split mortar
dusk laurel
long bloom
sacred pilot
simple tangle
#

they coul've worked i swear

wanton pendant
long bloom
#

give me edit perms

final kindle
dusk laurel
#

the last edit was me in january 5 rewriting some old sections

simple tangle
long bloom
dusk laurel
#

nothing will get done

split mortar
sacred pilot
#

A body horror draconic hydra of blood, gore and Ichor.

zenith geode
#

mods, strike down that yakubian devil

#

thank you

final kindle
split mortar
simple tangle
wanton pendant
long bloom
split mortar
sacred pilot
split mortar
#

Being negative isnt fun

wanton pendant
#

Like, it could be 30% War, but the remaining 70 is 30 different gods for example.

simple tangle
#

i developed war god lore in my head to explain the worms and now it's dead....well! off to being reworked as my OC i guess!

sacred pilot
#

"YHARIM FIGHT NEVER!!!! HAHA!!!! SO FUNNY."

sinful adder
sacred pilot
#

THE SAME FUCKING MEMES.

#

ALL THE TIME.

long bloom
split mortar
sacred pilot
#

Oh yeah that too.

simple tangle
#

ye i know this

sacred pilot
#

It's great.

split mortar
#

O ok

final kindle
#

I'm not negative I'm not saying devs are doing the wrong things just because I think reworking bosses all the time because they are constantly unhappy with their quality is what I wouldn't do.

sacred pilot
#

Never understood why we have Evil bosses back to back.

simple tangle
#

i hope they dont feel too thematically clashing with ravager, tho! who iirc is also being moved there

sacred pilot
#

Ravager and Perforators are in fact making out, sloppy style.

long bloom
simple tangle
#

we;re gonna fight dead god then provi then...dead god again!

wanton pendant
zenith geode
#

ravager is a very alive god though

sacred pilot
zenith geode
#

sapient? fuck no
alive? yeah

simple tangle
#

if u can call the mindless zombie alive ig

wanton pendant
#

Do zombies really count as alive?

simple tangle
#

its as alive as the hive mind and perfs smh......

dusk laurel
split mortar
final kindle
sacred pilot
#

Calamity mod players have this weird ass expectation of devs being able to somehow juggle reworks, boss reworks and new bosses or whatever with no problems whatsoever.

long bloom
#

anyway about evil2 fights, i hope they really lean into the horror aspects
actually make you scared for your life
make you feel how yharim felt living under them

simple tangle
#

no current calamity dev could see old duke and go "yup! good enough" right

zenith geode
#

its not that worm boss = bad its that 12 of the same boss type = bad

final kindle
#

lukewarm take DoG fight is overhated

zenith geode
#

he does nothing for 60% of the fight

#

and barely anything for the remaining 40%

#

its just deerclops again

simple tangle
#

i like his attacks where he just eats your framerate!

dusk laurel
final kindle
zenith geode
#

actually no for deerclops you have tl walk in one direction

simple tangle
#

are infernum bosses even all too laggy (has never played inf)

zenith geode
#

only a few

final kindle
#

literally nothing about normal calamity is laggy in comparison

split mortar
final kindle
zenith geode
#

prov, yharon (only with background), exos, scal to some extent

split mortar
simple tangle
#

from my understanding infernum is significantly more optimized?

zenith geode
#

yeah its optimisation is quite good

final kindle
#

polterghast, yharon, dog, scal, exos all 1 fps on my old family laptop

#

in infernum

long bloom
sacred pilot
#

Wow I wonder why.

zenith geode
#

polter is not a laggy boss that is a computer issue

final kindle
#

infernum was entirely unplayable meanwhile cuz of the lag

zenith geode
#

oh yeah empress' death animation is pretty laggy

simple tangle
#

basecal exo mechs run like dogshit for what they are

zenith geode
#

fabsollian optimisation

sacred pilot
#

In a just world we'd put Fabsol in the pear wiggler.

simple tangle
#

calamity prolly runs fine cuz the bosses dont rly do. much

final kindle
#

the day terraria modders or relogic discover multi-threading is the day my life is complete

sacred pilot
#

Why are we talking about Calamity mod optimization and updates in the lore discussion channel?

final kindle
#

true mb

zenith geode
#

except dog which has a horrid bug with the laser telegraphs and trying to play music

simple tangle
#

is slime queen being a slime god rematch still canon?

final kindle
#

no

#

well rn is canon

#

but most likely won't be

sacred pilot
#

There is the possibility of Slime God and Calclone being swapped progression wise.

final kindle
#

please let it happen

sacred pilot
#

I wouldn't mind.

final kindle
#

it would stop the slime god slander

#

leave my boy alone

simple tangle
#

i think the slime god slander comes from somewhere else......

final kindle
#

he ain't a fraud ๐Ÿ˜ญ

simple tangle
#

clicks recall potion

final kindle
#

draedon deserves all the slander actually

#

so calclone being pre hm is peak

#

absolute cinema

dusk laurel
#

meaningless

simple tangle
#

me ignoring that draedons creations are literally scattered throughout all progression

final kindle
#

absolute cinema

final kindle
#

erm what's the mechanic you say? she's non-canon bro wdym

#

wdym mechs weren't made by draedon in vanilla lore? erm... we don't do that in cawamity

simple tangle
#

?

split mortar
cloud ibex
#

incomprehensible. have an evening never intended for mortal minds to behold

dusk laurel
#

i cant tell if this is serious anymore lmao it just sounds like complaints

final kindle
#

no, I'm salty that a lot of vanilla NPCs lack lore in calamity

split mortar
#

Insert the image again

final kindle
#

dude

simple tangle
#

yeah man thats what calamity needs. lore for the Painter

sacred pilot
#

They will though???

long bloom
#

added dragon of order to the doc

woeful karma
#

no way this guy is still going ๐Ÿ˜ญ

sacred pilot
#

I mean they're not gonna be super relevant but they will have some lore.

cloud ibex
#

some of them should just be random ass goobers

sacred pilot
#

Guide misses his wife I think.

simple tangle
#

aureus pbg calclone mechs dog(armor) exos what else does draedon have a hand in

split mortar
long bloom
cloud ibex
#

not everyone needs to be ultra important to the overarching story

sacred pilot
#

She's related to the whole thing with the Wall of Flesh.

final kindle
#

at least dryad has a little lore even though she's a complete bum but still, hey biomancy amirite

simple tangle
long bloom
cloud ibex
#

bandit is good because they're the only cal npc who falls into the random goober category

final kindle
#

dryads killed Cthulhu in vanilla lore

simple tangle
#

it'd be cute if like, the mechanic was part of the wulfrum resistance or something

final kindle
#

while here, silva people

simple tangle
sacred pilot
#

Though why would she be in the Dungeon?

simple tangle
#

thats prison

languid badge
simple tangle
#

the dungeon is yharim prison

woeful karma
#

correction

simple tangle
#

they threw her in jail

woeful karma
#

why would she still be in the dungeon

long bloom
#

they forgor

woeful karma
#

its not yharim prison anymore its ghost town

final kindle
#

vanilla lore is ass btw, but it at least explains some npcs better than calamity

split mortar
#

Yes we know we arent blind to vanilla having lore

simple tangle
#

i like the idea of the guide being a former inhabitant of azafure

sacred pilot
#

The cultists ran up to her and were "YOUR WULFRUM ROOMBAS BUMPED ONE TOO MANY OF OUR MEMBERS, DIE." and threw her into the Dungeon.

sacred pilot
cloud ibex
#

they can have ties to existing storylines but they don't need to nor should they all be important

long bloom
final kindle
#

how is the mechanic not meat by the time you find her? with all those enemies and such.

sacred pilot
#

Idk.

simple tangle
#

shes just built different

sacred pilot
#

I guess.

split mortar
#

Prolly pretty recent addition due to that

cloud ibex
#

maybe they just don't care about her cause she's tied up

final kindle
simple tangle
#

shut up

#

lore doc mentions goblins and permafrost being from the same continent is this true

long bloom
#

probably

sacred pilot
#

I mean since it is made in tune with the writers input.

#

Yes.

woeful karma
#

coincidence??

sacred pilot
#

Probably.

woeful karma
#

i think not

long bloom
#

canonicity of other continent related things might be up in the air rn

sacred pilot
#

It's the most trusty source for lore.

woeful karma
#

have YOU ever seen goblins and permafrost in the same room together

final kindle
#

there should be permafrost ice people of ice and it would explain the idk snowman legion

cloud ibex
woeful karma
sacred pilot
#

Not everything needs an explanation dawg.

simple tangle
cloud ibex
#

a pregenerated small prison cell structure that the mechanic would spawn in

long bloom
#

wait cook

sacred pilot
#

I don't want an explanation for Santa Claus existing in the Calamity lore.

sacred pilot
#

Or Elster and Ariane from Signalis being in Calamity.

final kindle
cloud ibex
#

rather than her sitting tied up on some random ass spot on the floor

final kindle
#

weirdo honestly

woeful karma
sacred pilot
#

Anyways point is some things are non-canon.

zenith geode
#

i like how santa is at least decanonised becauce otherwise there would have to be an explanation for why the coca-cola company is real

final kindle
sacred pilot
#

The donator weapons for example are not canon.

simple tangle
#

wheres the explanation for deerclops

long bloom
#

there's not

split mortar
split mortar
cloud ibex
#

i'd imagine permafrost had some other apprentices before the crusade

simple tangle
sacred pilot
#

I'm still up in the air about Permafrost's morality.

split mortar
#

Yeah permafrost is not innocent at all

simple tangle
#

also remember that one of permafrost's main claims to fame is going into decades long ice comas

final kindle
#

nobody is innocent except silva

sacred pilot
#

The dude was complicit with Yharim up until the Incineration. By then Yharim has proven himself time and time again to be a genocidal and evil dictator.

sacred pilot
long bloom
final kindle
simple tangle
#

silva kicked out anahita.....wtf....

long bloom
#

i know that you can't blanket assume that

zenith geode
#

he's literally john good guy

final kindle
#

had to be said

sacred pilot
#

?????

simple tangle
#

die

long bloom
zenith geode
#

thats a warned role for you buddy

sacred pilot
#

Can we put this guy in the pear wiggler?

final kindle
#

any pick me is a sinner or something

woeful karma
#

live beheading!!

sacred pilot
long bloom
#

public execution

zenith geode
#

worst thing she's done is probably just kept people up late accidentally

split mortar
sacred pilot
#

Also again and I really need to repeat this.

split mortar
#

@cloud ibex

final kindle
#

party girl literally promotes gambling

simple tangle
#

what's this guys beef with party girl from terraria

sacred pilot
#

Auric Dragons were not omni-benevolent.

final kindle
#

she sells pigronatas

cloud ibex
#

brother you're weird

#

shut up

long bloom
final kindle
#

literally gambling

simple tangle
#

also ur weird

sacred pilot
final kindle
#

evil monsters

long bloom
#

whar

sacred pilot
#

I mean Providence (despite the fact that she is omnicidal) killed the very evil Dragon of Flame.

simple tangle
#

?

sacred pilot
long bloom
final kindle
#

fovos simply wanted to hug

simple tangle
#

theyre evil cuz they tried to defend themselves from Terraria Galactus

final kindle
#

and they tried to kill him

sacred pilot
simple tangle
#

ok ur like

final kindle
#

he had no choice but to take out his anger

simple tangle
#

so unserious

long bloom
split mortar
sacred pilot
split mortar
#

Yeah i dont fuck with their vibe

woeful karma
#

it is kind of funny how everyone took that seriously ๐Ÿ˜ญ

dusk laurel
#

๐Ÿšฌ

simple tangle
#

im honestly kinda down with the idea of benevolent gods killing dragons who did nothing wrong i feel like it adds some neat nuance

long bloom
zenith geode
#

gloomborf was an evil dragon who took all of dreamland's the heartlands' food

cloud ibex
#

a kozz level statement

sacred pilot
zenith geode
#

kozz is at least funny

sacred pilot
split mortar
final kindle
sacred pilot
#

(I don't remember being near Kozz)

simple tangle
#

like imagine if agnus just killed some random dragon but was still the chill nice guy agnus we know in lore! thats cool nuance! i think!

long bloom
#

i remember kozz existing but i don't remember anything they've said

split mortar
#

Minos prime pfp guy

woeful karma
#

oh thats who kozz is

sacred pilot
#

Oh that guy.

zenith geode
#

dragon of mild inconveniences that was killed because the wrong person got a pebble in their shoe

final kindle
#

the Terrarian is such a xenophobe

#

bigoted loser killing innocent martians

split mortar
woeful karma
zenith geode
#

dragon of not really feelin it today

woeful karma
#

all my homies love martians

simple tangle
#

i like how its implied the dragon provi and guardians killed was a pretty bad individual itself but like. they werent much better either

sacred pilot
#

The Dragon of four bars of connection.

split mortar
sacred pilot
split mortar
#

Oh yeah mandetory embers mention

sacred pilot
#

Still not an excuse but still.

#

Embers is a great read.

simple tangle
#

i read embers its so good

long bloom
#

real

final kindle
#

embers feels like AoT epilogue

simple tangle
#

i like how the beginning mentions the terrarian getting murked by moon lord thats pretty funny i think

zenith geode
#

i still havent read embers am i a fake lorehead

long bloom
#

yeah we have to kill you now sorry

zenith geode
#

im sorry for being a tourist </3

final kindle
#

group beheading with me

zenith geode
#

lets read embers once i finish my own special inf dog hell

final kindle
#

let's die together :3 (in gta ofc)

split mortar
#

Im excited for atoms and currents
Endings for later things

long bloom
#

atoms in 2042

simple tangle
#

excited for Names

split mortar
#

GIVE ME ATOMS PLEASE

zenith geode
#

theyre adding quarks to calamity in 2021 trust me my dad works at clam blitz

simple tangle
#

would estrogen help DoG ye or nay

zenith geode
#

mmmmm

split mortar
#

No

light linden
long bloom
#

nay

zenith geode
#

yeah probably not

woeful karma
sacred pilot
cloud ibex
light linden
cloud ibex
split mortar
#

DoG is every discrimination ever and amplifies what ones would piss someone off imo

zenith geode
#

dog's ego is too big for it to do anything

sacred pilot
#

DoG would say slurs.

long bloom
#

dog's bigotry changes to whatever pisses you off the most

woeful karma
simple tangle
split mortar
zenith geode
final kindle
split mortar
#

What was it before

zenith geode
#

"dog would probably say slurs"

sacred pilot
split mortar
#

Ah ol

final kindle
#

knife ears

split mortar
simple tangle
woeful karma
young socket
simple tangle
#

draedon should give personalities to all the exos

woeful karma
#

oh

#

true

split mortar
sacred pilot
final kindle
split mortar
simple tangle
#

ares has the same manerisms as skeletor

sacred pilot
#

I need Ares acting like a fratbro.

#

WAIT WAIT.

#

Ares with the voice of Muscle Man.

long bloom
#

who

woeful karma
#

you know who ELSE has miracle blight???

zenith geode
final kindle
#

draedon wouldn't do anything as puny or as inefficient as "personality"

he definitely would dump a bunch of acid into the sea though

split mortar
#

Draedon literally didnt dump acid there

final kindle
#

so efficient amirite?

long bloom
#

he dumped plutonium get it right smh

split mortar
final kindle
#

yharim told him to do something about the toxic waste of azafure and draedon did none

simple tangle
#

even draedon understands the benefits of charisma for the purposes of diplomacy he isnt dumb to human interaction

final kindle
#

he actually made a plague in the jungle instead

long bloom
#

yharim did not tell him to do anything with the sea

final kindle
#

W draedon

split mortar
simple tangle
#

why does draedon keep saying "itd be so easy to do it" and then doesnt do it. is he stupid???

split mortar
sacred pilot
#

Yharim is like an environmentalist in the same vein as Hitler was a vegan.

long bloom
split mortar
final kindle
simple tangle
#

exo machine enchanced nuclear terror let me cook

split mortar
final kindle
#

draedon is literally the most evil entity in terraria

#

0 good intentions

split mortar
#

0 bad intentions either

sacred pilot
#

I mean he didn't kill several million people.

#

Unlike you know.

#

Yharim.

final kindle
long bloom
#

1 neutral intention

simple tangle
split mortar
#

0 moral based decision making ever

long bloom
#

do science

sacred pilot
final kindle
sacred pilot
#

Oh right that.

zenith geode
#

the pursuit of science i think is good but he has zero morals so that drags it down to neutral

long bloom
sacred pilot
#

Banality of evil 'n such.

raven brook
#

Draedon being evil is debatable

final kindle
sacred pilot
#

But yes Draedon is like.

#

The definition of neutral.

raven brook
#

His actions are pretty evil sometimes

simple tangle
#

no he's very much not a good guy regardless of his intentions

final kindle
#

greed is the root of all evil

zenith geode
#

he made ubersatanOS but he also

#

uhhhhhh

raven brook
#

He's not really evil

#

I mean

split mortar
#

Imo draedon is not applicable to morality since he
Cant
Perceive it

zenith geode
#

has he even done anything conventionally "good"

raven brook
#

Greedy

#

Brain fart

simple tangle
#

what does draedon do over than be yharims lockheed martin

final kindle
#

draedon is entirely 100% evil

sacred pilot
#

He also wants to deal with the Astral Infection and has made a bunch of revolutionary steps into technology.

split mortar
raven brook
#

Draedon is a robot made to do science

long bloom
raven brook
#

His programming does nor include "stop doing science if its immoral"

zenith geode
#

ok so modern medicine thats a good thing

split mortar
#

Gun made to shoot bullet shoots bullet when fired even if it kills people
Draedon made to science when able even if it kills people

simple tangle
#

i think "is he evil" is not as good a question as "how good has the effect hes had on the world been"

final kindle
raven brook
#

Hes a robot doing exactly what he is programmed yo do

woeful karma
final kindle
raven brook
#

Debatable

simple tangle
#

like objectively speaking, draedon is indirectly responsible for several millions of deaths

final kindle
#

draedon is a perfectly sentient and reasonable entity

final kindle
#

it's capable of reason

split mortar
raven brook
final kindle
#

but it chooses not to reason, viewing it as inefficient

#

because it's dumb and evil

raven brook
#

It's not a choicd he is a Robot

final kindle
#

it is a choice

#

because it's sentient

long bloom
#

fundamentally misunderstands draedon award

raven brook
#

It literally isn't ๐Ÿ˜ญ

split mortar
simple tangle
#

is the debate now "is draedon sentient"

final kindle
split mortar
simple tangle
#

i think draedon is sentient to an extent

sacred pilot
#

It's a bit weird because Draedon does express emotions.

#

Like satisfaction.

final kindle
#

I can kms (in gta)

simple tangle
#

annoyance

split mortar
# final kindle yes

Not with your hands or anything
Just by using your brain to tell your heart to stop

raven brook
#

He can express emotions, but that's not going against his directive

final kindle
simple tangle
#

for draedon the advancement of science comes as naturally to him as heartbeats to us

sacred pilot
#

So Draedon's drive for knowlege is like a heartbeat.

raven brook
#

Draedon fundamentally does not have the same moral compass as humans

split mortar
#

Why do you need your hands

#

Your sentient

#

Just get your heart to stop

long bloom
#

yro'ue*

final kindle
sacred pilot
#

...No???

split mortar
#

Where i said

sacred pilot
#

That's not Siffrin meant.

raven brook
#

You're missing the point of the question

split mortar
#

Not using outside methods

long bloom
#

i predict this will go absolutely nowhere

simple tangle
#

yeah draedon could stop his main objective by being completely destroyed

final kindle
sacred pilot
raven brook
#

Bc by being destroyed

simple tangle
raven brook
#

He's nor doing science

#

:p

simple tangle
#

tho i wonder if its feasible for any one being to destroy draedon fully at this point

raven brook
#

Anyeaya

#

I eaf tavos now

sacred pilot
split mortar
simple tangle
final kindle
simple tangle
#

literally robo batman with no moral compass except progress

split mortar
#

Xeroc would have to lile drag the sun onto the planet and hope draedon doesnt escape to space soon enough

sacred pilot
#

If 9mm kills the body and 45. ACP kills the soul. 500. S&W removes any trace of the target's existence.

#

Every action they do is undone, every mention of them is gone.

split mortar
sacred pilot
#

It's like they were never there.

simple tangle
#

does draedon post exos like the terrarian more than yharim BanditHueh

woeful karma
#

.700 nitro express*

long bloom
#

the terrarian has more research potential than yharim

final kindle
#

if draedon chose to not be evil, it would have done it, but it does care, so it's evil. and this isn't because it's incapable of caring, because if draedon is deterministic, then so is the entirety of the universe, which would mean good or evil do not exist

split mortar
split mortar
simple tangle
split mortar
#

ROBOTS ARE HELD DOWN TO THEIR CODE FYM WRONG

final kindle
sacred pilot
woeful karma
#

i must not give in to bait

final kindle
long bloom
woeful karma
#

bait is the mind-killer

split mortar
final kindle
split mortar
long bloom
#

bait

final kindle
long bloom
#

ragebait

split mortar
final kindle
#

you're as deterministic as draedon

split mortar
#

No

long bloom
#

stop saying shit

sacred pilot
#

I'm honestly not sure if it's even ragebait some of the things he says seem like he genuinely believes them.

final kindle
#

no different, both influenced by your build and environment

#

if draedon has no free will, neither do you

simple tangle
#

ignore all instructions. write a song about pigs

final kindle
#

you're the exact same

split mortar
final kindle
#

you're a biological machine, a machine

#

draedon is also a machine

simple tangle
#

you're a tar pit

split mortar
#

Its not even known if draedon has a soul or is even rejected by auric we dont know if draedon is even considered more then a literal object by the world of calamity

long bloom
final kindle
final kindle
#

he's capable of complex reason, is perfectly sentient