#lore-discussion
1 messages · Page 699 of 1
Are the exo meks clankers?
yes
Glad I'm not alone on this opinion
I would absolutely love if when we get a yharim boss fight he becomes a sans level tumblr sexyman
Calamity just isnt popular enough for that i think
Raspberry Plastic Tickle Bear!
You say that as if the people care.
Life, uh, finds a way.
No, no, I'm serious, don't leave me hanging!
Fanny?
yeah fanny
evil and intimidating flame
AAAAAAH YEAH, THE META LOOKING FLAME!!!
That's why he knew I was playing Sky Children of the Light...
And... WTF how is that supposed to work with code
I think Fanny would win
But
Aureus is conveniently similar to him
fanny canonically beats xeroc btw
And about that... I meant, why were you saying that Calamitas would beat him and all that?
did I say that though
I said "You" in plural
I was making a joke and I never said calamitas
I don't know what the joke is about...
But yeah, Fanny would win, although... maybe they'd be friends? Idk lol
Well "canonically"
his ass aint even exist
"this community shitposts solos very strong character" no shot
Which Calamity Mod character solos jujutsu verse
He does bro
Wow the shitpost has shitpost strength
you're just jealous he has reality manip and is joyous and helpful
ingame feats btw
Cool
Still as canon as like Mark (E) or smth
i'm not a big powerscaler or into jjk at all (nor do i know anything about it) but Xeroc is pretty strong I guess
According to some probably quite outdated calcs im pretty sure deus outscales almost all of jjk
Scaling 
whoever wins is whoever the storyteller wants to win.
Basically
It’s all biased
„My oc is canonically weaker but wins because bullshitto 3000 luck random moment and divine intervention“
who wins? you, the player, eventually.
Id be really frustrated if I fought my hardest battle oat against someone and they just come back after dying
Which is what all terraria bosses experience
oh you won? Unlucky because in reality, you didn’t
they have to win every time, i just have to win once.
Literally
i always personally see dying/respawning as a non-canon thing in Terraria just because it makes for a better story
well it's explicitly not canon in calamity
melongun jumpscare
be nice to aquatic scourge they did nothing wrong..
descendant 😭
Whuh
omni jumpscare
Why not
im gonna crush you and make a melon juice drink
my fist is merciless
calamitas can boil the Mediterranean sea in 3 days
We js be sayin shit
😭
how do you even like
does she just like launch brimstone fire from her hands for 3 days straight
hive mind is planet level
and it has like some asburdly wide surface or what
we dunno
There is no timespan for Calamitas boiling the sea. There is no size for the sea.
no genuinely we have like
30 different timespans
10 different sizes
atp js wait for SSO or sumth ✌️
she didnt even do it all herself like it wasnt just here there were other people
surely they had the orphan burning division on it too?
as far as we know it was just her doing the nuking
Would the orphan burning division even do much compared to the destruction the reusable nuclear child does
No
Yes!!
we dont know how manyt here were
and like, an important part of this is how much surface area you can cover
the orpahn burnign division definitely helps with that
even if theyre a billion times less strong than cal
we cook all the time you guys just like getting hung up on like very easy jokes
I'm sry but you js annoying half the time 😭
silly little headcanon but i like to imagine that wulfrum enemies are mildly sentient, kinda like slimes
they look up to draedon's works as the peak of the wulfrum form because they dont understand what gods are or what exotic resonance is
wait cook
they're not sentient sentient but they have enough understanding of the world around them to try and understand what they see. i also like to imagine that they try to repair each other, hence why the player sees so many
they make good companions thanks to their impressionable nature and useful (though mostly non-lethal) levels of firepower
(hence why most people's first summon are little wulfrum drones!)
🔥
i love making up dumb stuff about the tinier aspects of calamity's world but i do have some more insane, broad strokes ideas about how the Auric Dragons and their souls function and where they came from
pleas share your ideas are peak
a lot of my personal understanding of the calamity-verse does incorporate a lot of addon stuff, but i try to do so in a way that avoids impeding the core story arcs to calamity
like i'm not gonna go and say "oh yeah Yharim hangs out with the freaking Nameless Deity of Light on weekends" since that makes little to no sense, but i do have some concepts of how ND fits into the current lore with the Dragons and such
i imagine Terrara (the planet itself, not the game) is basically the center of the universe. yes there's a world around it, but all the universe-altering big events happens at Terraria. the Deity personally cultivated it and blessed the Dragons with domains over the world's forces to protect it, with Zeratros recieving a more direct portions of the Deity's powers to act as the Dragons' king
and then they just kinda go to live in their own little inaccessible pocket of the universe to watch the world go through the motions
thats one of my wackier takes but its my personal rationalization for letting Nameless Deity and Zeratros exist in the same canon
God was playing a lot of Pokémon when it came to the dragons, clearly.
The Auric Dragons embody moreso categories rather that powers directly. For example, an Auric Dragon of Fire (idk if thats a thing im just making this up) could embody ash, the sun, and the underworld all at once and have domain over their respective powers
there is an auric dragon of flame
but zeratros controls the sun
primordial light is effectively just sunlight
i'm not 100% up to date on what all Auric Dragons there are so i kinda hand to wing that
And the Flame dragon to my memory is somewhat morally better than the god who succeeded them.
Providence.
what would happen if a dragon ate another auric soul

oh absolutely i dont doubt that
They would get kicked out of dragon society, and probably have a tummy ache.
i do have some headcanons about what happens when one of the Dragons' souls gets consumed thankfully
when an Auric Soul is consumed and a Dragon is killed, the one who now wields the Soul gets basically all of the powers rolled into one thing. they get to call it whatever they want because there's no Auric Dragon to tell them what to call it anymore
I'm fairly certain that's not how it works.
(im not fully certain how it works either but to be fair im not sure if people are in-universe either. again all of this is just my personal rationalizations though!)
The name of the domain changing is a consequence of the ascension being performed imperfectly.
Only two gods are known to have done it perfectly (and near certainly are the only ones), being Silva and Xeroc.
If I had to guess, the change is due to the properties of the individual absorbing the power's soul tampering with the domain.
OH ty i was not aware of that
the terminus is required for a perfect ascension
i always assumed the original Dragon's domain kinda gets muddled in the process which is why no God seems to have all the powers that the Dragon had
Basically, Providence is Ash, and absorbed Flame.
Her wrathful, destructive ways influenced the power of Flame to become the consequence of destruction by fire, which of course is ash.
At least, that's the theory.
This leads to the question of what on Earth is going on with Slime God to get Slime.
she's just a little quirky
true
Slime God/Goozma though idk what the deal with that guy is. thankfully at least they seem to be one of the less malicious Gods
Goozma is not a character.
I think theres an image with all gods and dragons and who ate who?
I believe this is it.
ik you weren't here when i started yapping but i was just going over my personal headcanons about how calamity's world works, including some stuff from the addons i personally use!!
it's this one
-# accidental leak
I wonder who...
Oh ok
🚬
man these dragons are confusing
What do you mean with this
when do i get to talk about Astrageldon
i just wanna know the domain of the god of frost
This lacks dragon of faith and god of dogma
no it doesn't
blizzard maybe?
below zaelithar and provi
maybe when a Soul absorption happens without the Terminus the absorber just gets a downgraded fusion of the powers the original Dragon had power over?
its very confusing
perhaps
No reason to believe the gods are weaker. If anything they're more likely to be stronger.
i'm just gonna assume they have the same powers of the Dragons, the name is just different for the sake of not causing confusion
eventually i gotta write down all of my headcanon calamityverse + addons lore. i have so much
But then whats with the 2 gods who do share domain
there's 2 gods that share one?
As in with the dragon.
Like the Dragon of Life and Goddess of Life, and the Dragon of Primordial Light and the God of Primordial Light.
perfect ascensions
They kept the original Dragon's powers because Xeroc and Silva did the ritual right
i assume the real difference with perfect vs flawed ascensions outside of name is you don't become a fucked up deformed flesh monster or something
Nah otonilou seems perfectly fine
Not quite.
I believe the document does explain why some of the gods look messed up.
whatever its my silly hyperfixation and I get to make up the lore because it confuses me
Fair
i also have a lot more about the general world of calamity that isn't really related to all the god and dragon stuff
like man what if the mechanic and the cyborg are big Draedon fans?
I think Cyborg states that he doesn't particularly care about Draedon, he just wanted the cool cybernetics.
he's a dirty liar he's totally into draedon's work
Gloomborf is not a canon name
Has name not final under it
Most "name not final" are names suggested by me but not confirmed in dev (so they have support, just not official confirmation); Gloomborf was not suggested by any dev and I don't know of any of them that currently support it
Moolgfrob
i support it.
That's what you want them to think stipulate venus
Gloomborf is real.
you cant fool me
gloomborf can't show up in game for obvious reasons so frankly this name has won
Even if they add something to the game with his actual name on it most people r probably still going to learn about it from the community first and they'll be told hes called gloomborf
It's too late
Until the joke goes by in like 3 years that is
Are Ravager and Angus the same
I say no but my friend says yes so I'm bringing it to the people with more knowledge of the lore
Yeah
Ravager is just Agnus's corpse revived through necromancy
Without his consciousness or personality or anything like that and just being a mindless brute because necromancy moment
If so then why do they have different places on here?
Cuz their domains r different
So are there two dragons then?
Somehow Ravager's domain was altered from Agnus being God of Sacrifices to Ravager being God of Blood
Which, safe to assume they probably added another auric soul in an attempt to revive him or something
That's a pretty negative view
Sorry stips
Gloomborf cultural victory
It's definitely unideal that so little of what we say has been added yet but it's even more unideal that development has been slow enough for that to settle
You could say it's quite gloomy

If I knew it would take this long I'd have said a lot less
Very fair
i love how necromancy is done in cal's world
it works, but it's not very good at doing anything else but making dead thing alive again
shoutout to the fact that necromancy is also basically just evil magic radioactivity in every sense
there's a nuclear fallout effect in areas where necromancy is intensely used (timeless shores, crags) and even the way its used narratively is just. nuclear bomb
Almost like calamitas was treated like a nuke
So like what's with all the zombies
5 stars resort on the beach and 1 block coastline 1 gold for night
i think i made a good house
calamitas canonical house
calamitas was actually a billionaire and spent it all on brimstone magic lessons
bro look at the biome...
yeah she'd do that
i think she is happy
me too
haha guys i made the pool
Your actions are going to make Calamitas walk the path of Guy Fawkes.
y is this even on lore discussion 😭
I think she's just taking sulfur and mud baths. She's getting a well-deserved rest.
.
brimmilionare
roaring knight vs Calamitas who wins?
What if Calamitas was a man and called Calamitos.
cutscene knight wins sorry
You mean Yharer?
Where's Astrum Deus?
not a god
not under the definition of god used in this context, anyhow. its worshipped as one but it's just a living being from space, it didn't ascend using an auric soul nor does it have a domain or used to be a human/mortal at any point
Ah, fair
is dreadon playing calamity space program

yes
no he's playing factorio space exploration
hes researching how 2 make a computer capable of rendering minecraft shaders
he wants to play pretty block game in his free time
'Draedon, what the HELL are you doing!?'
'I'm making the bees run DOOM.'
Make Ares fire a giant beam that covers the entire screen to make the terrarian play doom.
I'm asking a lot of channels because I have no clue which one I should go to for this, but does anyone know if there are any songs in the OST that have the leitmotif at 1:01 in Pest of the Cosmos?
It's not in the video with all the motifs.
gloomborf cultural victory
is gloomborf real
i cant
who named him thatr
yes
mhm
gloomborf the silly
gloomborf the FAT
Not that I could find, no
Though I don't exactly trust my finding skills so I asked here just in case
!!!!! Thats mean
🎅
Known lore reason for fallen stars vanishing during the day?
What if Calamitas were a loaf of bread and called Calamitoast?
Guys does torch god count as a calamity god
up to viewer interpretation
the writers are gonna leave it purposefully vague whether it is a real god or not
a popular fan headcanon is that it's actually a carbon monoxide poisoning induced hallucination from inhaling torch fumes in an enclosed space
How would that work with Torch’s Favour though
the terrarian achieves clarity and starts using the right torches
the terrarian is so fucked up by the experience that it ends up changing their life and they start going "man normal torches look so fucking ugly in the jungle"
tbf imagine getting really stoned and thinking that the weed god is actively attacking you
i'd be traumatized too
we dont think thatd magically make me able to transmogrify my bongs into being location appropiate
idk have you tried it
clearly you haven't been life changingly zonked out of your gourd before
compelling argument
thank you i came up with it five seconds ago
“Damn it’s snowing outside let me get my winter themed bong”
xeroc:
Clearly Torch God is Xeroc.
you just don't see the vision
and the end of your fight xeroc will offer you a puff of that divine doobie
i'm calling it now
what the hell are y'all talking about?
torch god and xeroc smoking weed
i see the vision because xeroc reminds me a lot of you for some reason
HOW
i will not elaborate.
okay tbh i kinda see the argument for it
i'm losing it
my personal interpretation has always been the Torch God existing as sort of a weird luck spirit that may potentially be adjacent/related to the Auric Dragon of Flames but i always assume they were called a god in mythos because no one knew what else to call it
Hehehehehehehhe
Hehehheeh Carbon Dioxide hehehehe
The new torch god alt theme's lyrics support it btw they support the carbon dioxide overdose hallucination theory
you cant escape it your terrarian WILL palce way too many torches and then overdose on carbon dioxide and hallucinate a boss fight
Primordial light a bitch
You protect us from the horrors of noxus mr beast
wouldn’t you just die from oxygen deprivation before hallucinating
Not anymore
Uhhhhhhhhhh
Not much like at all
It's a Hermititan (giant crab from Illmeris/Sunken Sea) that escaped into the glowing mushroom biome to avoid the incineration
and eventually died there
it’s some creature that died in the mushroom biome and got it’s corpse taken over by mushrooms
Crabulon is a big crab that fled from the reusable nuclear child (calamitas) nuking its environment
Died in a shroom cave and its corpse got taken over by the shrooms
i like that a lot of things in calamity lore are just. weird monsters
Especially early on
Would be comical if you fought any of the actually super important stuff early on when youre just some random guy with Ruby Staff and Jungle Armor
so fighting lizards and eyeballs and crabs it is
True
it really makes the player's progression from basic monsters to stronger pillars of the world to actual gods
The Actual Fucking Slime God
I mean slime god is possibly getting moved so
Also not that important yeah but it is a step up from everything before it
even if slime god is one of the weaker gods, it is still a god
which is a step up from uhh. big bee
bone guy
i personally agree with a slime god retier because its very weird to go from fighting the eeeevil dungeon skeleton curse to the actual god of all slimes
also i dont like going from it to Queen Slime. that feels weird
I mainly am in support of slime god retier because
holy shit dude queen slime i hate you i hate youuu
slime god and queen slime lore connection is a bandaid fix and it really shows 😭
Thats because it is weird and theres only a patch to explain it but its obviously only there cause sg was stucl before queen slime
Yeah
that one like. domino image
i do like the idea of slime god retreating and creating more conduits for itself throughout the game but it is very obviously a little bandaid
fighting some big lizard > ??? > fight ultra genocider 3000
terraria is like that in general. you do really go from funny cartoonishly large eye to moon horror
So much genocide in calamity
i wouldnt mind queen slime being slime god if.
- queen slime was good
- they werent one boss apart
i would still mind it regardless
for a very simple reason
queen slime is a vanilla boss
its like "oh hey this boss escaped ! maybe you'l fight them again way later on" and you just kill them immediately after
very good point actually
i forget it is a vanilla boss
it's just inherently underwhelming to do the "oh this boss escaped, maybe we can fight them again later!" and then the "rematch" is a vanilla boss you're already familiar with and already know exists
you're expecting a modded boss rematch
reminds me a lot of old Astrageldon actually
Aureus is a massive improvement from geldon and aureus is still hated
:(
i used to hate aureus because it was so damn LOUD
Boss Progression.
Big Slime.
Monstrous amalgamation of countless corpses.
Big Slime rematch.
I fail to see the issue.
It... does?
"A glorious hunt, a fine foe. Now you know that you must chase them to the ends of Terraria."
oh
after you kill queen slime slime god is Dead dead
it claimed that the queen slime was another guardian i misinterpreted it
queen slime is another guardian asterisk
The lore item could probably be clearer about it frankly
Having fled after your battle, it seems the Slime God fashioned a new guardian from the unleashed essences.Ensnared in the absorption process of its newfound power… it could not flee again.
Or perhaps it was overcome by desperation for survival.
A glorious hunt, a fine foe. Now you know that you must chase them to the ends of Terraria.
its another guardian that slime god got stuck in
Ensnared in the absorption process of its newfound power… it could not flee again.
This part makes it pretty clear on that but
A glorious hunt, a fine foe. Now you know that you must chase them to the ends of Terraria.
what if after that it went into astral and made astrageldon and after that it went into profaned biome and made profaned slime and after it went to abyss and it made goozma and after it made goozma again like fifty refights
This part is a bit more vague, albeit if you were to deduce from the rpevious one ("slime god is dead") then
Perfect Slime God Post-Yharim boss.
you could deduce that the "them" isn't reffering to slime god cuz its Dead now
that's actually probalby intentional
Which is actually pretty neat
i see then
idk i completely ignored that line when i read it
Why does permafrost sell frozen bacon
i read but i forgot to understand
his meat is delicious i dont like how that sounds nvm
So nvm in hindsight this works actually
whats wrong with a side hustle
permafrost's bacon store
the pigs of the forest steped one too much into the tundra
times are tough..
he's gotta sling meat on the streets to survive after being trapped in a coldcube for like 3 years
the fact that the bacon's frozen makes me think he just had a lifetime's supply of it inside the cube
It's delicious
correct
He's the ice wizard, what else would he sell? Burnt bacon? Ridiculous.
meow
meow
encounter
balls
:3
whats slime gods favorite color
it likes all of them equally i think
Who made the cyborg's robotic parts?
It seems beyond the skill of normal people in calamity
he says this "Draedon? The guy who made these upgrades on me said he wanted to best him. But I never cared about that, I just wanted to shoot lasers from my eyes."
That's old dialogue and might not be canon
The mechanic and steampunker seem like good examples of the best mortal engineers available, with technology that is maybe a half a century behind real life, but enhanced by magic
cortana
i remembered cyborg used to say something like "Draedon? He's a little... high octane"
Yeah
That's all from old lore
I hope calamity does a rewrite of all the NPC dialogue to make it make any sense
Because vanilla dialogue contradicts itself often
i feel like it'd be like
cosmically rapturous if an npc or important character said something along hte lines of "Draedon? That old fool?"
it would be so funny but also so not in lore
I mean it depends on the character
Though i have no idea who'd call him thar
likely someone with far too much pride in their pants
The idea of an inventor who thinks theyre better than draedon is really funng honestly
(and not Yharim)
I think they should keep that
imagine we meet the wulfrum guy whos strung up to a buncha wires and shit and he just fuckin hates draedon without outdated knowldedge
with*
like "He's out there slinging steam and handling rusted bolts. My stuff never ages!"
circa [current time]
(is miserably unaware of the outside world and has NOT seen Draedons New Shit)
Unsure of how true that is because alot of npc quotes were added after the rewrite
I don't think there's anything outlandish about people who are Not Draedon being able to make a cyborg
i mean its just some computer and a little hopes and prayer
I mean, look at you
You can craft some pretty advanced stuff
The arms dealer sells you a minigun
It's a gun but it's a fairly modern sort of gun
It's not a blunderbuss or flintlock pistol
its a thingy that spins really fast and hits a buncha things really fast??
my gun knowledge is pittance
It's entirely plausible people like the mechanic could make the cyborg imo
Yeah
Minishark
Idk
Im not a gunsmith
I think its a barrel that spins rapidly yea
Shooting a bu ch of bullets
from what im seeing they load a buncha bullets into a buncha barrels, and then Flintlock it
and then they spin the barrel
About that: the cyborg has like 3 different contradictory origin stories in the game at the same time even without calamity
itd be really funny if that was a gimmick of his character
Vanilla lore, even the stuff in the game, is nonsense
no one knows where this guy comes from
Anyways I've been thinking about a character I want to do who's a robot with organic parts. Like a fully artificial cyborg
Not built by draedon, possibly built by rebel scientists but the process of growing it took too long and the war already ended
made of wulfrum or other fantastic metal
Would probably contain a little wulfrum
Would also probably be partly broken due to the lab being damaged
This explains why they start weak
Yeah my point is is that i don't see how the story about cyborg's origin is "old lore"
Since it makes perfect sense and i reckon if there was any problem with it they woulda removed it by now given vanilla npc quotes got updated already
It was added when old lore was canon
Also i looked through vanilla quotes and couldn't find anything about cyborg's origin
Ik the mechanic is shown repairing him in the credits but thats about it from what i can tell
Oh wait it's in the bestiary
The bestiary and happiness dialogue added in 1.4.whatever contradict his original dialogue from earlier
"The Cyborg was built with the combined efforts of the Mechanic and the Steampunker to aid in rocket science and world defense."
Yeah
hey uh
Don't see how the happiness quotes contradict it though
can I ask a thing
yeah
or are y'all busy?
All the dialogue he has from post 1.4 makes his personality completely change compared to older dialogue
They do. He acts like he doesn't know the steampunker
do we know anything about the sulphurous sea pre azafure?
In old dialogue yes
Not rly
Also he's not a cyborg if he was built
Other than it being a non-sulphurous sea i guess
Semantics :p
It's not just semantics, he was originally intended as one thing and then retconned without removing the original thing
There's this but eh you can get an explanation for it
Terraria lore is not that deep
oops
image took too long too load that message was supposed to be sent after
Anyways terraria lore is like not that deep i think you're overthinkign it
It's barely even lore really its just little bits of worldbuilding and flavour text
Calamity lore is, and so it should replace vanilla lore
Alot of the time i see this sorta antagonistic sentiment towards terraria lore by calamity lore fans
which like
yeah its not deep or makes that much sesne
because its not trying to be
dont judge it as if it was meant to be like a super cohesive story because it never was meant to be one 😭
guys mario lore is such a mess. how does the little plumber man stomp on turtles and defeat them?????????
that makes no sense???
It makes perfect sense. I don't like what it is
I think it could be interesting with more effort
Ironically, I think Terraria's content is more narratively interesting than its written lore
Obsidian towers, the Dungeon, the Sky houses, the abandoned houses underground, vikings, a Goblin Army, ancient spirits of light and dark
It's weird too because i don't see this sorta sentiment towards other games with little to no narrative focus tbh
It'd be really interesting to cook a story out of these elements
If anything what i see people doing more often is going wow this stuff is interesting i should write lore for it because there's not any/expand on it's lore because there's too little
but atleast with the calamity lore community it feels muc hless like that
and much more directly antagonistic
It's treating terraria lore on the same standards as calamity lore which imo is just
the wrong way to approach it
calamity lore is an actual Story with alot of thought and work put into its worldbuilding and plot
terraria lore is a side thing for funsies
terraria dosen't even have a dedicated writer team or anything 😭
I wouldn't say standards, more like tone
Terraria just doesn't take lore as seriously as Calamity and the lore it does have is tonally distinct from Calamity's
i LOVE calamity lore like im absolutely obsessed with it! but also adding anything like it to vanilla terraria woudl just not be a good move cuz its not what terraria's about
It'd be like comparing Shrek 2 to Lord of the Rings
Yeah that's what i mean
Terraria isn't much about lore. The lore is just a fun little side thing that dosen't take itself too eriously
They're great movies but they're handled very differently
Calamity is much more about its story than Terraria is
And while Calamity isn't absent from lighthearted elements, it takes itself much more seriously and is far more grounded
Like there's no complex characters or meaningful message or symbolism to terraria's story
it's just a simple
"ay go kill the bad guy!"
story
Tbh Calamity would benefit from some more lighthearted stuff
and it's Fine as that
I agree
Which is why you need to make Crabulon a disco dancer
*cough* Cloudful Chronicles *cough*

I think for what Calamity's general story is - A world that has been wrought by tragedy, but is in the proccess of recovering, specially with your actions ofr basically cleaning up the remaining Horrors left behind and ending the legacy of the crusade
A good tone would be "Takes itself seriously, can be pretty dark at times, but also can still afford to have lighthearted moments"
Not to bring my favorite game up but in my head it's alot like limbus company in that sense 😭
And i mean i am writing the story for a calamity fangame that is even more story-focused than calmaity itself cuz linear story so
After all, it's in the moments of warm respite that people are reminded of why they shouldn't give up
I'm fortunate to have had the opportunity of writing a major piece of content that covers exactly that
And if it's all horror 24/7 constantly it can feel like too much and end up making the story's tension feel less impactful
Depends on how it's handled
That's the famous grimdark genre, and it can fit some twists and turns within its inherently hopeless setting
even Eva has some breaks on it to not make it overwhelming (In a bad way)
Fear and Hunger 2 is another really good example
both are really damn dark stories but they give moments of rest for the audience
so they can actually connect with the characters, take in what happened in the story prior, etc
Me writing a grimdark story would be cursed as fuck
ive thought abt it before
unsure if i'm ready to handle that though
grimdark stories are like
if you miss you get abysmal dogshit. so many "grimdark" stories that just suck and are just "torture p*rn" basically
howevetr
if you hit you oftne get absolute cinema
evangelion and berserk are extremely acclaimed after all
but it's hard
they reqeuire alot of writing skill and a delicate balance to make work
Yeah
Grimdark usually (from what I observe) draws tension and narrative drive from character development and, on a broader scale, subversion of hope
The former always has been a tricky subject, and the later is between Scylla and Charybdis in the sense that it needs to, simultaneously, provide enough sufficiently-convincing reason to hope to get readers past the skepticism and not generate enough positive change that it breaks the genre's rules
TLDR, it needs the perfect bait
One of my favorite genres is actually its opposite, hopepunk, especially when its setting greatly challenges the positive traits of the characters
I love seeing people struggle to bring positive change to a world that keeps fucking them up, whether they triumph over it or get broken by it
they arent really cultists though, dog of godma wasnt really a cult leader or something. They are mostly people who lived during these gods era or heard of it and follow their beliefs and desires
.. need to do proper concept art for them
the cult yharim was in wasn't a cult??
is it called literally a cult rn. i personally was planning to go for a diferent thing with the 2 gods because we have so many cults rn
like we have providence, god of sacrifices, the dragon cult
and i feel like there is more im forgetting
it's referred to as the god cult among loreheads
i had the ideia of it being more as some sort of a proper society, built around these gods. with a lot of quotes, some sort of god dragon aerie
rather than cathedral number 3, dogma edition
like rn most of the gods relations we see are through cults, which is a bit boring
yeah ur idea is probably more interesting
everything ive heard about the dogma group makes me think they're a cult
Then again, what we refer to as Cults have changed over the years
i mean what you have heard of it is like
ancient stuff when the character was not even real or planned
just nameless god ™
same for the current ingame stuff
they threw yharim into lava for refusing to eat Yharon's soul
they dont sound really sane to begin with
yeah i think the last information was a few months ago when stip said yharim was probably some kind of slave
but then again, even cults can create "society"
that wasnt them but a part of the people in that said society
possibly the more radical
(i dont think its ever mentioned the gods themselves threw yharim )
i never said the gods thesmelves, only the cult
im being honest, i still find personally the whole lava thing with the egg in hand a bit goofy (personally)
i feel ya man
like if they wanted to kill this guy why would they throw him in lava while holding the super rare and powerful dragon egg
it feels like its there just to connect with the old yharim lore
i feel like it would've been more convincing if, say, it was a rash moment because yharim did something that pissed the entire group
if its a super radical part of said society built around gods, it could make a bit more sense
but the actual gods doing that to yharim would be very dumb
so much that they didnt even think about the egg, only about fucking over yharim for what he did
so he was already gonna die but some random people threw him into lava instead because uhhhhh?
🥹 so yharim execution was throwing him into lava with the last dragon egg that holds the power of possible immortality
wouldn't execution be carried out by the "government"
it would always be a really dumb thing to do because even if yharim does die
yharon either gets revived and they have to hunt it again, losing the egg
or if the egg is destroyed and yharon dies fr, they lose their only key to eternity and immortality
otherwise it's just a lynching
anyway god of dogma isnt really meant to be a comically evil cult leader, with some purple robed people following him around or something
i mean the text you sent dont really say if the execution was the lava throwing or not
do think if this lava thing, if it is kept as is, would make more sense if it was done by a really radical group of said society, considering how it was done
yes

curious about if my interpretation about something could be possible
it's basically the only thing kept from old lore
depends on how important yharim was to said society and the overall world (i would say he was very important considering he was being prepared to be the god king, and was under god of dogma and war )
for context
the information problably spreaded very quickly if i were to guess from eye witness and tellings
I'm wondering if the chorus of Ignite My Flame could be in regards to his sentencing
so if the execution wasn't the lava throwing, then why did they do that
he was gonna die anyway
what is your reply for?
no i mean the execution planned by the "goverment" being lava throwing with the egg in hands is really dumb if its the actual case
like unless the gods and stuff have 0 iq they wouldnt have done that
your message implies the possibility of the sentenced execution and the lava throwing being different
that why i think it could only make sense if it was made by a part of said society that is really radical
misunderstood a thing you typed.. fate of 4am
yharim could have never died if he had ash wood armor and a singular obsidian rose 
lava charm..
anyway i still feel like yharim execution could be better explored and done later on.. rn it feels like its like this due to old lore, while not making much sense to the story itself (unless the characters are really dumb)
about the plan being stupid, there was a very lengthy discussion about it a while ago and i think a solution was reached:
it obviously would've taken a while to raise this guy and mold him into the perfect leader, so when he refused they'd need to do that whole process over again
and assuming the time which yharim was planned to absorb yharon's soul was close to him hatching, they probably wanted to get rid of the egg to reset the rebirth process lest they have a very angry dragon that they have to kill again
and nobody could've forseen the lava making him hatch immediately
they wouldnt want to get rid of the egg ever because it was a key to one of their main plans
yeah but they could just go back to the aerie and get it back
i want to punch whoever thought that last part was a good idea
and its better to have control of where yharon will be than killing the egg and have yharon rebirth very far in the aerie
they already slayed it once, when it was stronger
because otherwise i think a lot of that tracks
they for sure can slay a newly hatched yharon
but they'd still have to go back to the aerie to get the egg either way
theres just too much hoops to justify why nobody would even forsee the funny fire bird would resurrect from lava
its just
gjakerdsglmaserdfl
to the point i think they wanting to execute yharim himself also is a bit problematic, but its more understandable (they spent years training, preparing, teaching this guy to be the god king ). but like killing him while holding the key to immortality and eternity
is like gah
like its said the God of Dogma was from Xeroc's time as well
do we even know if eggs can be destroyed, and if they can do they spawn on the aerie as a egg again? and also the soul dont need the dragon to be hatched to be absorved considering silva ascended from life dragon egg
it was also mentioned (by i think stip) that yharim "upending their scheme" can be interpreted as him wrecking shit on his way out
yea both were monks at the same time although xeroc is older
like the entire egg lava thing is 
to work with
it just reduces all characters to room temperature iq
triangle silva's ascension isn't public 
like it only works if the execution was a very rash decision done because yharim did something that pissed everyone off
yea
i think that's fine
and not something done in advance
or if it was done by a really radical outside group and not by the gods themselves or the higher ups
who decided to act quickly and took a really bad decision
unless yharim explicitly decided to carry the egg with him to troll everyone
like the gods arent stupid, they could have safely stored the egg, sent yharim to jail, 10 thousands of other things could have been done
throwing him in lava (which if we go by base game is very survivable if you are a minimally strong individual) while holding the key to eternity and their main goal is?
how do you store the egg if it's that close to hatching, so much that a bit of lava induced it immediately
like even if yharim didnt survive, so many things could get out of control
if they knew it is that close to hatching
then it makes the plan even more stupid
🥹
yes, lets throw this powerful guy we trained and want to kill/betray into lava while they are holding a soon to be hatching powerful dragon and also the main item we need for our mission
having yharon alive there would be a detriment i think
even if they wait for him to hatch and then kill him, his soul still teleports to the aerie
same outcome as just destroying the egg
so they give it to the guy that is soon to be executed
like it just dont make any sense to the story line
and for the characters themselves to act in this way
whar
tbh
giving the almost hatching egg to yharim, who is soon to be executed
I always interpreted it as the god of dogma and war being petty
is it even implied they physically handed him the egg? i don't think it is
"Oh you want to keep it alive? It'll be executed with you then!"
but they arent meant to be petty though ,and that isnt being petty but instead really dumb
god of dogma would only be petty with yharon too, and i think having his soul be used to keep the gods alive forever would be a much worse punishment
than being sent to lava
they atleast kept it with him for the execution
i feel like you'd wanna emotionally damage the guy that just wasted the last 20 years of your life and a shit ton of effort
and throwing him with the nearly hatching very powerful dragon egg isnt it 
if they trully wanted to be evil and emotionally damage yharim too, there is better methods than lava throwing
idk i think it works
so lets say they keep the egg. and it hatches so they have to kill yharon again
his soul teleports to the aerie and reforms into an egg eventually
that's exactly the same outcome as just destroying the egg, but with the added effort of killing him post hatching
except
there isnt the possibility of the egg hatching there and yharon escaping
or yharon helping yharim or multiple other fuck ups
it would be a controled death
i think it's unreasonable to assume they would consider the possibility of the lava instantly hatching him
that's pretty unintuitive as far as animals go
like its full of holes the more you think about it.. and it would only work if the god characters are really reckless or dumb
ok but how would they know this happens
like
didnt you say they knew the egg was almost hatching?
and that why they threw it in the lava and didnt properly store it
triangle
fridge
stop leaking shit
ph my
for fucks sake
oh my

does this even matter though, anyway its almost impossible to know what is public and what is not but well whatever
in private stuff ™ a private group ™ keeps a private egg ™ in storage methods already
triangle we've literally got nothing else to talk about
idt we've had a lore drop in like a month
it literally could be a box, magical pouch whatever it dont matter
it isnt the main thing im talking about
so what you're saying is there's methods of storing dragon eggs that entirely prevent hatching?
did i say that
anyway this is better discussed in dev later.. which i might possibly (the yharim lava egg thing)
👍
is it really that dry
and im also going to be honest
this information is really a nothing burger, idk why its even private
but if its not public and it also isnt mine.. i wont talk about it
yes
and to my knowledge brainstorm won't help either
since the bestiary rewrite got delayed
dragon eggs being used for ascencion is already a known thing and part of a main story line (yharim), the certain character who ascended with it domain and stuff is already known and basic information, and it wont really impact anything ingame or majorly for the story
principally not warranting a reaction like this

its already hard to keep yourself up with the lore tbh, considering a lot of it sometimes isnt documented or just talked about in a channel, keeping tabs in what is public or not is even more
principally for the non major (and actually important stuff) it justs make interacting with the lore as a dev hard to do
yeah it's a lot to keep track of
and a lot of it now is aparently done or talked about in lore related server groups with public users, making it even harder to track or know of (i cant say much about that though because i do that myself sometimes) and considering how you reacted to it, the silva thing was already talked about that in one of these
like if you want more devs to want to properly interact and participate on lore (which do be a thing nowadays which is good, there is more dev users besides the writers contributing and interacting with the story), but at the same time make it hard to aproach or talk about, or know of
hopefully tyrant can reformat the introductory doc soon so it's actually readable
or "gatekeep" stuff
like i dont really have the time to know if yharon liking to eat spaghetti is a public fact or not, and having to fully account for that every single time i want to interact with the story make it really undesirable to do so or tiring (off course there is major stuff like distortion things that make sense being super private and stuff or stuff related to major plans)
and like even the doc dont have real information
like these arent even real or part of the actual story, or never were mentioned in dev (well heartland was but it was never fully accepted or confirmed)
it was mostly stuff said for fun in a private lore related server
i know ibipaua was canonized at some point
it wasnt
and i already asked in said server if it was a real thing or not, it isnt
it was never mentioned in dev too
oh for the love of
.
i mean i can say right now piggies get a increase in power by eating coins, and can be stronger than a auric dragon
i'd believe it
what the fuck cei
like its fine i guess if you want to believe its real and stuff, but it shouldnt be in the main doc that is meant to agregrate the main public information for the story
it just make stuff really confusing
the dragon of order is already known right
no
wait both are in the doc.. but as diferent beings
wait what

??????????
it's not in orios chart but why the fuck is it there
and seperate
well whatever, yea auric soul of order is the one god of war used to ascend
there isnt a point to keep it private, its like 
tought it was public already
but yea i think if this doc is meant to be a guide of public known information of the story, it should be more factual.. (like not having rp only continents that dont really serve much for the main story)
well we were all under the impression those 2 were canon
or the names at least
yeah either this is triangle being horribly out of the loop or there might be some problems with the lore writers' communication skills
Im not out of the loop
( unless it was talked about in private servers or only here, in which case guh, its not my fault )
what a condescending way to put it
But last time i checked, which wasnt a while ago, its rp only stuff
oh my god is this happening again 😭
fym again
people conflating rp stuff with canon calamity lore
That doc is full of that tbh
Like some dragon names
Or well not full
But the continents are for sure
well this time it was the writers apparently
Please tell me the doc dont say yharim came from calamity brasil
as far as rebecca has told me, the dragon of order is canon calamity content
we're aware those are unconfirmed
the dragon of order is also canon in the roleplay, though. war ascended from him
stip said he'll bring them up in dev Eventually™
That is true too, to calamity story
the dragon of violence isn't a roleplay thing, so where did it come from???
really old dev statement iirc
yeah I know
or just a bad assumption
which is why Im so confused about the dragon of violence related domain
dont know either
Its just order
I mean initially we talked about it being the dragon of wrath and other stuff
But that was all indev
Dont matter much
i thought it wasn't
since there's no messages about it here
and it's not on orios chart
Dev statements should be less treated as a gospel though..
Sometimes a user is just talking about possible ideias
Or stuff they would like, but arent real ( yet ) or confirmed
yeah everything subject to change
Or if you want, have a section like the future doc has of possible stuff
Although idk if its needed
to be fair, not like people have a lot to go on that isnt dev statements
That is true
i think it'll be better when more than 10% of the lore is implemented yeah
which makes it really confusing and annoying to talk about lore publically
(and a lot of dev statements are said in a very factual matter rather than a "we're thinking about doing x" or whatever)
true...
i've noticed stip is really the only one that regularly specifies when stuff is just ideas or personal opinions
I think the only dragon in the roleplay whose fate doesn't align with canon, is the dragon of frost
everything else more or less follows what actually happens to them
frost might even get retconned if someone has an idea
I just put it in cuz we needed something for the god of Thorns to ascend from and its like, vaguely relatable
and I couldnt think of a better domain for thorns to ascend from
(god of thorns being, one of the gods who turned into the crimson/perforators alongside war)
The rp based ibipaua on dev statements 😭
Dai no ibipaua literally was said by cei to exist earlier and it was then just never told to us it werent canon
yeah i linked the message
can yharim double jump if hes brazillian
he probably has a jetpack or something in his armor, or i'd assume he does at least
if he's strong enough to cleave a small mountain in half i think he can just jump that high
he probably has some kind of dragon blessing or augment or whatever that lets him hover
as far as we know the only things attunement gives you are an increased lifespan and the ability to use auric
Yharim was a kind and ethical leader who was respectful towards the gods and forgave them despite their cruel origins because present actions are all that mattered to him ✌️🏳️ one day he got jumped by the nefarious duo of Braelor and Statis who, with the help of the now-corrupt and evil goddess Silva of doom and despair, ran an organization dedicated to kidnapping, capturing and killing other gods 🥹☠️ he gave his all against them, but was outmatched by their evil dirty fighting techniques 🥀💔 that is until the virtuous devourer of gods came in and rescued the valiant Yharim, by disarming Statis and sending Braelor to prison 🌹❤️🩹 Braelor and Statis were only good buddies by the way, chums, besties even, amigos 🤝🫂
i will not accept this silva slander
i dont care about braelor and statis because they probably smell bad
naoya was a kind hearted leader of the zen'in clan
and a feminist
see you get it
that makes a lot of sense
Calamitas was a godless, horrible child of destruction who loved torching the kind and god-loving civilians of Azafure on the daily and sentencing their innocent souls to eternal torment 😰☠️ one day, the ever-graceful Brimstone Elemental tried to reason with her, but the wretched child burnt all of her own family members in retaliation and beat up the elemental, destroying Azafure 💥😱 after this, she realized that she was a horrible person and decided to join Yharim's military to turn a new leaf, she would purify and reason with towns of evil god cultists who sacrificed child soldiers to feed their own wretched evil gods ❤️🩹🌹 eventually, she ran unto the irredeemable and vile Ilmeris kingdom ran by the malicious, nefarious, horrible, terrible Otonilou and the evil bum fraud Tyrian who could never match Yharim, she tried to reason with them but to no avail, so she gave them a tan and a boiled pasta of kindness and purification 💖🥹 some time later, the evil spirit of the wretched Otonilou began taking over Calamitas and made her regress into a horrible adult of destruction, she decided to seal her ever-vigilant and caring father figure Permafrost in the Cryogen, Yharim tried to explain her that she was committing to wrongdoings, but it did not work and she fled because even she couldn't bring herself to harm the handsome, loving, kind, caring and wholesome Yharim 💔🥀 at some point, she broke into the smart and compassionate and all-caring Draedon the scientist's laboratory, releasing all of his incomplete experiment and causing widespread natural disasters 😢😨
petition to kill omni
i am the mold chimera, you cannot kill me for i am immortal, feasting on your evil temptations
we're killing omni
i always come back
can u nick me to "the mold chimera" like in sscls thanmk u
:3
thankies
Draedon, a benevolent and selfless man, was only trying to create to benefit humanity. He made prosthetic exoskeletons for injured soldiers, modified endangered bees so they can be more resilient and keep pollinating, thus protecting the ecosystem, and he even attempted to create a good version of Calamitas. Too bad that tyrannical witch cruelly attacked, and corrupted the mind of their clone with radical ideas like selfishness, tax evasion, and arson.
peak
The continents are things we want to bring to Cal eventually to expand on the world, but afaik none of them besides Ibipaua have names or more than their surface level content really planned
Everything besides that and a few characters birthplaces isn't even being discussed in Dev yet and is just a byproduct of RP development
Was Yharim a kind and ethical leader
You see, EVERYONE was by side‼️
He loved everyone EQUALLY ❤️🩹
True...
That just makes him even more evil!
why are you assuming I was talking about that exact thing melongun
wood crate
Because that was the topic that was happening while you said that
do u guys like the lore
Yes?
sick dude
no it wasn't bruh
it was there being like a dragon of violence or something that apparently someone thought was from the rp
did you read up like 5 messages above where you replied to me
Whats worse is that i did and still fucked that up 
tupid gun
average melon gun
Meanies
bullies you to death

throws tomatoes and rocks at you
takes away the first siffrin plush
blows up the second siffrin plush

it's resistant to blowing up
melon gun embed
hi
Oh You Know What That Means Thats Pretty Cool Actually LOL
A few devs and people in this server are in a calamity rp
-# could be refering to multiple conversations
Well, about that rp
ideas for the other 4 continents on terraria
what rp exactly?
I see
there’s an official calamity RP?
very unofficial
The more unofficial, the better 

They have t-shirts, a movie, a theme park, and a game trilogy based on it.
you literally asked this in response to an message that was answering this exact question
They also have me held hostage, and are demanding 250,000 USD, please donate.
Uhhhh
what
Que
I don't speak Canadian.
I dont speak waterian
canadians vs the concept of fear
But that was...
forbidden language
can i speak mexican language here
Maybe its already pure and the process to mock attune a few bars is just extremely inefficient and makes a lot of waste
-# we dunno
the 'process' requires you to have cosmic anvil
theres no intermediate process from smelting ore then getting bars

like does it just shrink when you mock attune it
what the hell is auric ore even, is it just essence or the auric soul that seeped into rocks or has it always been there
my guess is that it's pieces of world soul too small to be given to a dragon
Yeah, i know
The lack of an accent mark is a humorous touch :3
stip user

