#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 576 of 1

pliant ruin
#

lol ?

fair pelican
#

Why Yharim didn’t get the devourer to go after her then

pliant ruin
#

Yharim fucking hates Xeroc

wanton pendant
#

Xeroc is practically unkillable.

pliant ruin
#

Silva can't be killed

wanton pendant
pliant ruin
#

She is literally Life

#

like. the very concept of Life

split mortar
#

Yeah xerocs ascension was different to most others
He did it perfectly and thus has same domain as the dragon king

wanton pendant
#

Well, she's nature.

cloud ibex
#

silva can't die unless you kill all other life on the planet including yourself

pliant ruin
#

the only way to kill her is killing every living being

#

ever

wanton pendant
#

She's also the goddess of life.

pliant ruin
#

😭

cloud ibex
#

and that's not happening

fair pelican
#

What I mean is that most likely Xeroc was a willing ascension on the dragon part that would explain why he’s so strong

split mortar
#

Silva isnt the concept of nature

She just cant be killed if theres nature tho

pliant ruin
#

Yeah but

#

that isn't relevant at all here

#

Whether Xeroc was a willing ascencion or not

#

Yharim dosen't care

split mortar
#

Yharim doesnt care if it was consensual

pliant ruin
#

He wants to kill all gods

wanton pendant
#

Silva also has a perfect one, and she can't die for an unrelated reason.

pliant ruin
#

All of them

#

If morals were a factor here

cloud ibex
#

no xeroc is strong because they ascended with the soul of the most powerful dragon and has been working to get stronger for the last eight centuries

wanton pendant
#

It's a genocide. It's over when every last one is dead.

pliant ruin
#

Yharim woundn't have killed the multiple gods that were just straight up good, kind-hearted people

#

And he wouldn't have destroyed a entire civilization using his Child Soldier

wanton pendant
#

And Xeroc's power is the literal sun.

pliant ruin
#

Killing thousands of civilians in the process

cloud ibex
#

we don't know for sure if the ascension was with consent or not and even if we did we don't know if it matters at all

split mortar
#

We also dunno the circumstances of the other gods ascending (other then provi) afaik
So
We cant say if rhe other gods didnt have consent either

fair pelican
#

Isnt his argument for killing gods that they were complicit in genocide?
How it’s genocide if the dragon gives their soul willingly?

cloud ibex
#

well observed

split mortar
#

Yharims delusional

pliant ruin
#

here's the thing!

#

yharim is a bad person!

wanton pendant
#

And he doesn't care.

cloud ibex
#

yharim doesn't give a shit if it was willing or not

split mortar
#

Yeah yharims a bad person he isnt being
Logical

wanton pendant
#

His source was a dragon, who didn't know either.

cloud ibex
#

all he cares about is that a dragon died, in his eyes that makes you worthy of death

wanton pendant
#

Good thing I made this chart, listing their crimes and motivations. And it's quite apparent that Yharim is completely out of his mind.

pliant ruin
#

Me when i have to manipulate the child who just lost her entire family overnihgt into my reusable nuclear bomb and then send her to destroy a entire civilization filled with thousands of innocent civilians including mothers and children and the elderly aswell as irreparably damaging the incredibly diverse ecosystem and causing the extinction of several species all because there were two gods in there i wanted to kill and said gods were loved by their people and one of them managed to literally stop a civil war

split mortar
#

You dont end up with the creation of skeletron prime by being reasonable

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

Yeah prob closer to tens or hundreds of thousands

wanton pendant
#

If it had a similar population to say, Italy, that's nearly 60 million.

cloud ibex
#

yharim's goals aren't logical because he's some dude and people aren't logical

wheat walrus
#

I am beyond logic

wanton pendant
#

Although, as far as I know we don't know any census data for any nation.

#

It should be noted that, for the size of Ilmeris, tens of thousands would make it very sparsely populated.

wheat walrus
#

depends

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

The unmatched power of the sun.

wheat walrus
#

1, we will never have a real size value
2, even if we did, we would never have an official size value for the world, nor a population count for it

#

and im not counting dev statements atp they're inconsistent as hell

split mortar
#

We know like 300 million is more then 20% iirc

#

From devs

wheat walrus
#

that was from like 2 years ago

wanton pendant
#

The only thing that could fight Xeroc would be something with anti-Primordial Light powers. Hence, Moon's Haunted Theory. The Moon can beat Xeroc.

wheat walrus
#

and the size of ilmeris has changed a trillion times

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

You are the youngest person ever.

wheat walrus
#

way before u appeared in lore discussion

split mortar
#

Im on about 300m being more then 20%
Still dubious

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

p

#

whatever

split mortar
#

Dev stuff on population weird anyways

wheat walrus
#

more fuel to the dev statements shouldn't be taken that seriously fire

wanton pendant
#

If that was accurate then the population of Terraria was extremely low.

#

Like, this is a post-industrial revolution society.

#

Population should be massive.

split mortar
#

Fuck it make 300 million people be in ilmeris

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Now that would be exceedingly dense in population, 500% that of Italy's.

wheat walrus
#

how it feel when ppl measure fictional population progress 1:1 to real humanity 😔

wanton pendant
#

They have magic healthcare, it should be way higher than our own.

#

Unless Terraria is a really small planet, or something?

wheat walrus
#

they have magic, it should be way different from our own

#

they prolly didnt have an industrial revolution as we would know it in the first place

#

different world, different resources, different circumstances and different needs

wanton pendant
#

They had robots 660 years ago.

distant smelt
#

Yeah
It’d be better atctually

wheat walrus
#

yall missing my point

#

like

#

flew over head completely

split mortar
split mortar
#

Magic healthcare magic damage

wanton pendant
wheat walrus
#

we are not on the same line

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

I'm not sure how that contradicts what I said? I'm using my knowledge on what causes population growth and decline, and claiming that based on the societal development of Terraria they should have a very high population.

wheat walrus
#

you're basing it on real humanity

#

when ppl in calamity have existed in a noticeably different world under different circumstances, and thus would have different origins, bit too much to use real humanity's own progress as a measuring stick

#

i disagree with taking into consideration dev statements in most cases, esp about things like "their population was 300 million"

#

but it not being realistic is the least of my complaints in that regard

#

instead, one should wonder what makes it so different from us

#

maybe they did deal with something dangerous, yharim aside

wheat walrus
#

the different forms of life, so do they

#

the dragons for the longest time, and now gods also do

#

even the environments as a whole

distant smelt
#

I mean things like the wulfrum prosthesis exist. Its not like the existence of mana makes regular tech obselete

wheat walrus
#

wasn't saying that

#

i am saying that factors like these make differences

#

both for humans but for non-humans too

wanton pendant
#

Unless there's a good reason why reducing mortality wouldn't increase the population, I don't see how my assumptions that the population would greatly outpace our own wouldn't make sense?

wheat walrus
#

the lifeforms are clearly stronger than irl, that alone helps explaining a lower population

wheat walrus
#

we are not on the same line

#

there is no outpacing each other when we're clearly going on different progress routes

wanton pendant
#

Then I have no clue what line you are on since I don't see how our arguments aren't related.

wheat walrus
#

sob

wheat walrus
#

but the progression they're taking is not the same as ours

#

so there's no "deeper than ours", they're in an entirely different world to begin with

#

the progression they took is not the same as real humanity

#

the stuff they deal with also isn't

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

humans irl didn't exist under the auric dragons for god knows how long

wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

I'm aware of that, my argument is that based on their resources and capabilities, they should be making us look like amateurs.

split mortar
distant smelt
#

They have bigger threats but more ways to deal with them

wanton pendant
#

As far as I can tell, your argument is that their environment should limit their population, right?

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
#

the other is that comparisons to real us are kind of obsolete

#

because of that

#

because we're different in different worlds

wanton pendant
#

Isn't the whole point of narrative to compare to real life, so you can learn from the messages and themes?

wheat walrus
#

specifics about the world are another

split mortar
#

Theres a difference between “dont cling to the past” and population

wheat walrus
#

you can have realistic messages in what otherwise is an absurd story in an absurd world

cloud ibex
#

Dark souls is completely unrealistic but it still rings true irl that it would be fucked up if a skeleton had a sword

wanton pendant
#

Exactly.

wheat walrus
#

leon moment

distant smelt
#

The world might be different but (largely) humans are pretty much the same. They’re like the one thing in the world we should be able to reasonably speculate history and conditions for population growth.

wanton pendant
#

Now you're speaking my language.

wheat walrus
#

humans irl weren't basically under a species of god-like dragons

#

for as recently as less than 1000 years ago

wanton pendant
#

And biologically, organisms with a high mortality rate reproduce faster, so while yes you can say that biology is different in Calamity's world it isn't unreasonable for me to use my prior knowledge with no real reason to believe it wouldn't apply.

cloud ibex
#

I think it’s a fair read that it’s hard to compare the world of cal and the real world

wheat walrus
#

since the population thing was a dev statement, another dev statement is that for the longest time the sun was too tough for humans to stay in the surface, wasn't it

#

hundreds of years are lots of growth, but under these conditions there would be a lot to grow to reach the numbers we have irl

#

if you can't even be in the surface of your own world, and what's below it is hell

wanton pendant
#

There were at least 1500 years where humans could be exposed to the surface.

wanton pendant
#

Chrysadia was founded around then.

#

Unless I'm misremembering.

wheat walrus
#

yea, chrysadia, which collapsed before the first god came to be

wanton pendant
#

It was also in the sky.

distant smelt
wanton pendant
#

Not sure what gods have to do with my argument.

wheat walrus
split mortar
#

The sun got weaker after xeroc ascended according to the quote iirc

Also chrysadia had fucking VETRASYL helping em

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
cloud ibex
#

The existence of magic, the existence of some robot dude chilling in the background with technology centuries if not a millennia ahead of the rest of the world, the surface being unlivable until less this a thousand years ago, inexplicable giant chunks of ice that go (presumably) miles into the ground and create entire regions of the land existing less than a day’s walk away from deserts and jungles, inexplicably floating islands, fish people

wheat walrus
#

and for all we know, they were alone in being outside before gods came to be

cloud ibex
#

All of these things would have an effect on how the world develops and how populations grow and all that nerd shit

wheat walrus
#

even still, that is 1 civilization

#

the rest would still be underground dealing with hell for all we know

#

i think these conditions would make for a terribly low population, until xeroc regulated the sun for all

#

then the hundreds of years they had after that would've led to a population growth

#

but even if it's a major growth, it's easy to imagine that they still wouldn't reach giant numbers like we have here after that time

wanton pendant
#

That's still like, 700 or something about for the population to grow, which is a very long time.

wheat walrus
#

not all gods were bad, but some were quite bad

#

and one of the strongest gods being hellbent on wiping out living things doesn't help it either

#

so, even prior to yharim, there still would've been turmoil tampering growth

wanton pendant
#

Providence probably is a big contributor to the mortality rate.

wheat walrus
#

ya

cloud ibex
#

Killing people is generally bad for population counts

wanton pendant
#

Genocide is really bad for it, there are places that haven't recovered to their population numbers even after like, 200 years.

wheat walrus
#

yea

#

so, with all this in mind

#

it's reasonable for the population to have been low prior to yharim

cloud ibex
#

And then funny auric man halved it again

#

Thanks Yharim very cool

wanton pendant
#

That's fair, but as this isn't something we're likely to get a concrete answer on, at least not for some time, this can only be reasoned as speculation.

wheat walrus
#

yep

pulsar ocean
#

Gods probably deserved it for animal cruelty

pulsar ocean
#

But civilian casualties aren't cool

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
wanton pendant
cloud ibex
#

Yea he would say that

#

Well maybe minus the “innocent” part but other than that

wanton pendant
#

Yharim probably sees all dragons as pure and innocent guardians. Even the ones that were jerks.

wheat walrus
#

guardians

#

like

#

monster hunter wilds constructs

wanton pendant
#

I didn't play that one.

wheat walrus
#

they made artificial monsters

#

imitating life

wanton pendant
#

Like some kind of Undertale...

wheat walrus
#

and the dragontorch, their source of limitless energy, is embedded in the earth, and wyrmways allow it to diverge its energy across the entirety of the eastlands

split mortar
#

Asriel dreemurr vs all of calamity

wheat walrus
#

me

wanton pendant
#

Which form?

wheat walrus
#

id win

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

Not quite how his final form works.

wheat walrus
#

what is undertale scaling abt

#

💔

cloud ibex
#

Friendship I think

wanton pendant
#

His weakness is wanting to win harder. Because Determination is the source of strength.

wheat walrus
#

wall level until further notice

wanton pendant
#

Wanting to win more means he can't beat you. But you can't beat him as he's nigh invincible.

#

So Calamitas wins, because she wants to make a better world?

#

Yharim fights him forever.

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

i destroyed the timeline

split mortar
#

You are a goat flower child

wanton pendant
#

Monsters are physically very weak in structure, and believing in yourself is their weakness.

wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

Asriel and Calamitas would bond over their genocides.

split mortar
pulsar ocean
#

Omega flowey no diffs the verse cuz he can load in the save and try again

wanton pendant
#

But the souls rebel.

#

So Calamitas wins again.

wheat walrus
pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

Yharim would have a hard time getting help, yeah.

distant smelt
#

What the hell did i miss

wanton pendant
#

But he's also really strong. Have you considered that?

wheat walrus
#

and killed capital G

wanton pendant
#

Calamitas specifically beats everyone in Undertale.

wanton pendant
wheat walrus
#

also gaster tho

split mortar
#

Gaster already shattered like glass

cloud ibex
#

Lore discussion

wheat walrus
#

melon im gonna shatter you like one

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

This is important.

wanton pendant
pulsar ocean
#

Yharim isn't winning

wheat walrus
#

kozz is kozzing like crazy

distant smelt
#

Powerscalers hurt my brain

wanton pendant
#

Asriel Dreemurr couldn't even out-will a young child.

#

His entire power is having will.

wheat walrus
pulsar ocean
distant smelt
#

Frisk is a very willful child and should not be considered

wanton pendant
#

Even with seven souls, he's not unbeatable, since the source of power is literally Determination.

#

Most Green Lanterns wipe the floor with Asriel.

distant smelt
#

Frisk is an outlier in every sense of the word tbh

wheat walrus
#

me too

distant smelt
#

Wait omg
Frisk green lantern

cloud ibex
#

If you’re gonna do Undertale powerscaling could you please move it to gen media or something

distant smelt
#

Yeah i was thinking this was derailing a bit too far

pulsar ocean
distant smelt
#

So anyway uhh

wheat walrus
#

calamity struck

wanton pendant
distant smelt
#

You like
Dragons?

wanton pendant
#

Yeah!

pulsar ocean
#

no

distant smelt
#

Hmm

wheat walrus
#

what's your favorite calamity, storms or earthquakes

distant smelt
#

War

wanton pendant
#

Famine, Pestilence is also good...

pulsar ocean
wheat walrus
wheat walrus
pulsar ocean
distant smelt
cloud ibex
#

I still like to imagine that perfect ascensions allow the dragon to live on in the mind of the god

wheat walrus
#

both storms and quakes are terrible dont get me wrong but earthquakes are kinda

wanton pendant
cloud ibex
#

Cause I think it would be neat if Xeroc has a tiny mind Zeratros with him that they can talk to

wanton pendant
wheat walrus
#

I love War

#

my favorite of em all

wanton pendant
wanton pendant
pulsar ocean
#

calamity is not a force for good nor does it care about evil

cloud ibex
#

I guess venom but more in like a friendship sense

wanton pendant
#

Venom's gay, it's the whole point!

pulsar ocean
#

is he tho

wanton pendant
#

At that point it's just... uh... can't think of any other mind backseat gamers.

wanton pendant
#

Venom's gay.

pliant ruin
wanton pendant
#

Gods of Plurality.

#

Commited pluralism (having multiple parishes) and was put to death by the Godseeker.

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

Yeah.

wheat walrus
#

venomous

wanton pendant
#

Gay people eat brains, they teach you this in gay class where you learn about gay.

#

Everyone knows that.

wheat walrus
#

waterwraithgaming statement

cloud ibex
#

Now I’m imagining Silva and the Dragon of Life nerding out over cool bugs together

wheat walrus
pulsar ocean
#

isnt it ironic that the dragon of life died

mighty zenith
#

it works because xeroc and piccolo are both lonely guys who sit in the middle of nowhere

#

so at least they get to talk to someone

wanton pendant
pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

Them's the breaks.

pulsar ocean
#

can yharim beat five nights at freddys

wanton pendant
#

Yes.

split mortar
#

Which bosses can or cant grill a chees

wanton pendant
#

Calamitas risks burning it. And she doesn't have a grill.

#

Draedon has no issues.

#

Does the Aerie have a grill?

pulsar ocean
wanton pendant
#

He can fist-fight Freddy.

leaden bridge
#

Tomorrow this is a silksong lore channel just so yk

split mortar
#

Tomorrow i vanish off the internet and play the game

wheat walrus
#

rest in peace melon gun

leaden bridge
#

First we sing

#

And then we solk

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

you bad melon

#

dont do that

wanton pendant
#

I have a meeting tomorrow, can we postpone Silksong? I also need to beat Hollow Knight, so another delay?

split mortar
wheat walrus
wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

Yeah, don't be British.

wheat walrus
#

also that

split mortar
wheat walrus
split mortar
#

Why is calg the bad emote

wheat walrus
#

from the containment chamber

#

what is in the containment chamber, must stay in the containment chamber

#

for it can spread the mold to the outside world

split mortar
#

Omni my pfp is an emote there

wanton pendant
#

Yeah, and it's purple, which is cringe.

wheat walrus
#

nonetheless

#

calg could very well be molded

#

the mold must be contained

split mortar
#

But spread it…

#

Would be silly

wheat walrus
#

bad melon

#

that means i will have to cleanse calmain with flame

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

I played a game about spreading mould.

wheat walrus
#

bad bad melon

wanton pendant
#

Is that Goku?

split mortar
#

Its a ms paint drawing of the character in my pfp as the bwaa emote

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Tiny baby arms.

wheat walrus
split mortar
#

Yes the character is
9

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

bad melon

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Why don't they hit the gym, are they stupid?

#

Get bigger arms.

split mortar
#

I don wanna be buff

wheat walrus
#

youll be crushed and cleansed by a flame to cleanse the very eons

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

Im currently being crushed in a vote on if im a catboy or not

wanton pendant
#

I wonder why, British Longhair.

wheat walrus
split mortar
#

Well theres me voting no and all 20 other people having voted yes

wheat walrus
#

dang i thought they were stupider than that over there

wanton pendant
#

Can't argue with democracy.

#

You're a furry now.

wheat walrus
#

one good choice at least

#

would catboys count as furries

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Depends on how cat the boys are.

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

how cat is melon gun

wanton pendant
#

Computer, pull up the furry scale.

wheat walrus
#

is it just ears

split mortar
#

According to multiple irl friends my resting face is kinda like :3
and i often pronounce r in words as w…

wheat walrus
#

dang

#

so you'd say "waah" instead of "raah"

split mortar
#

Idk i dont pay attention to how i say water

wanton pendant
#

Bwitish?

#

Doesn't have the same ring to it.

wheat walrus
#

dang melon

wanton pendant
#

How's the trial going?

pliant ruin
#

you know what would be funny

wheat walrus
#

next time im making a palico in monster hunter it's gonna be cat melon gun

split mortar
pliant ruin
#

gfb hive mind had a dogma balls joke

wheat walrus
#

shouldn't have said what catlon gun

#

brug

#

sigmaballs

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Foreboding.

wheat walrus
#

did you say it was 20v1 yes

split mortar
#

It the add waterwraith

wheat walrus
#

what's the other one

#

poor wwg

wanton pendant
#

They're killing me later. I dare them to try.

wheat walrus
#

at least the roleplay was decent ig

wanton pendant
#

Catboy roleplay?

wheat walrus
#

bro

cloud ibex
#

lore discussion

split mortar
wheat walrus
split mortar
wheat walrus
#

remove img rights again

cloud ibex
#

no

wheat walrus
#

calmain aint what it used to be 😔

pliant ruin
#

omni someone should boil you alive

wanton pendant
#

Louie!

wheat walrus
cloud ibex
#

killing images would do absolutely nothing

wheat walrus
#

hm no wym

pliant ruin
#

dogma balls

wheat walrus
#

it would solve the problem of offtopic

split mortar
wheat walrus
split mortar
#

I dont see much images doing that

wheat walrus
#

all these messages

#

they're imaginary!!!

#

like images

split mortar
#

🤯

wheat walrus
#

wake up melon gun

wanton pendant
#

An image speaks a thousand words.

wheat walrus
#

been 16 years

wanton pendant
#

So one off topic image is a thousand off topic words.

cloud ibex
#

this channel doesn't go offtopic because of people posting memes or whatever it goes offtopic because people start rambling about shit that has nothing to do with the channel

wheat walrus
#

yep

#

know what that means

#

remove texting perms

wanton pendant
#

We can use hieroglyphics.

split mortar
#

Remove all oerms
Look in this place you get auto banned

wheat walrus
#

melon finally making sense

#

cook more melon gun

split mortar
#

Throw people into blenders

cloud ibex
#

no what i should do is start throwing rocks at people who go too far offtopic

wheat walrus
#

delete calmain

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

Chat

wheat walrus
#

leon is mean and throws my lunch at ppl

pliant ruin
#

how it feels

wanton pendant
#

The hell is that?

wheat walrus
#

see cheese posted an image

#

mute her immediately

split mortar
#

Could there have been other pillars that the dragons killed

wanton pendant
#

Kill!

wheat walrus
wanton pendant
wheat walrus
#

cheese shouldnt be promoting smoking

cloud ibex
wanton pendant
#

Smoking is bad.

cloud ibex
#

nothing that i can think of at least

wheat walrus
#

true

#

i mean maybe there were like

#

a bagillion pillars

#

and the dragons killed most of them

split mortar
#

So theoretically possible but also nothing against it

#

Thorium fragments had pullars

wheat walrus
#

so to put value on the dragons

#

rn they kinda fraudulence

pliant ruin
#

thrower pillar was real guys

wanton pendant
#

Thorium Pillars are canon, they're just dead.

wheat walrus
#

green pillar

pliant ruin
#

what the fuck even r the pillars anyways

#

sso give me new bestiaryentries and my ife is yours

wanton pendant
#

They're Pillars.

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

And they're not men.

wheat walrus
#

moonlord eggs

split mortar
#

So

wheat walrus
#

baby fovi

pliant ruin
#

the fovean empire

split mortar
#

I think they help fovos by being a army generator

wanton pendant
#

Minecraft Mob Spawner.

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

they're all baby fovos, fovos is an adult one clearing a space for them to grow

pliant ruin
#

does moon lord just like make them or

#

can he just do that

wheat walrus
#

they all grow off the energy of terraria and as they do they kill each other

#

then there's 1 big fovos from it all

wanton pendant
#

We don't need to know of the Moon Lord's eggs.

wheat walrus
split mortar
wheat walrus
#

the big fovos now coming to us to raise the pillars

#

or at least, leave them to grow on their own

#

and kill each other

pliant ruin
#

ok theroy what if the pillars are like

#

made out of other planet's world soul

wanton pendant
#

Like Moon Lord killed the martians Theory.

pliant ruin
#

ml eats them

#

turns into pillar

#

yum

wheat walrus
#

that implies they're powerful as fuck

split mortar
#

Would explain why fovos nuked the aurics

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

maybe they're like a fragment

split mortar
#

Endless army

wheat walrus
#

like

#

like auric souls

wheat walrus
pliant ruin
#

tbf maybe other planets just have skill issue and have worse world souls 🥀

wheat walrus
#

dont you think if a pillar was a world soul converted that it'd beat the shit out of even xeroc

wanton pendant
#

Fovos is secretly alternate timeline Xeroc where instead of Primordial Light it was Squid.

pliant ruin
#

Like

wheat walrus
#

why is our planet the chosen one

#

ok ok actually

split mortar
#

Solar pillar means there was/is possibly another sun out there

wheat walrus
#

that'd be like irl

wanton pendant
pliant ruin
#

Terraria has a ton of life diversity and different biomes and lotsa stuff

#

Then you have like

Uranus

wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

Pluto.

pliant ruin
#

theres uh

ice

gas

yep

wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

We even have an antagonist (England).

pliant ruin
#

omni

wheat walrus
real silo
#

urmomni

wheat walrus
real silo
#

No earth's superboss is israel

wheat walrus
#

france is the hidden super boss

wanton pendant
#

That's Providence.

real silo
#

what the fuck..

wheat walrus
#

providence isn't on earth

split mortar
real silo
#

Providence rhode island

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
#

trust me

leaden bridge
#

moonlord is actually secretly yharim's like third removed cousin

real silo
#

You're not real

leaden bridge
#

hes got like a wild family history because of that time a distortion creature arrived in terraria

split mortar
leaden bridge
#

you dont really want to know about that its kinda ugly

wheat walrus
#

Neko! Enderpikmin Endlessvoid 🌌 is onto something

wanton pendant
#

Moon Lord's Gay Theory and 'Lord' is short for Gaylord.

wheat walrus
#

moonlord is only the son of gaylord

split mortar
#

This chat was good for 2 minutes 💔

wanton pendant
#

Not my fault.

wheat walrus
pliant ruin
#

world soul of planetr 359X-B20

it has the domains of uh

gray rock

slightly darker gray rock

wheat walrus
#

bad melon

leaden bridge
#

the notion this chat is good 💔

wheat walrus
#

Neko! Enderpikmin Endlessvoid 🌌 onto something again

wanton pendant
#

It's good when we discuss the psychology of Yharim and Calamitas and how they are narrative parallels of eachother.

pliant ruin
#

I enjoy talking here when i don't feel like i can say things without it being derailed into nonsense

wanton pendant
#

Kill.

wheat walrus
#

domain expansion

leaden bridge
#

well yeah it's what all the mountains r made of

wanton pendant
split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Jacob 'Primordial' Light.

leaden bridge
#

well obviously theres another sun out there is does calamitys world not have other solar systems now

wheat walrus
#

it doesnt because i eat them for breakfast

wanton pendant
#

There may be stars, but suns are harder to prove.

leaden bridge
#

thats acceptalbe

wanton pendant
leaden bridge
#

well cant there be suns that just arent like terrarias

#

maybe its just like special boy

wanton pendant
#

Then they'd be stars?

#

Or something else entirely.

wheat walrus
#

how it feel having known what the sun is in calamity for like a year and it still not being pbulic

leaden bridge
#

yeha so, theyd still be suns because a sun is defined by being a sun and not primordial light magic like is what we're saying

split mortar
#

I imagine a sun not having primordial light would be noteworthy enough to classify it as something else

wanton pendant
wheat walrus
leaden bridge
#

well we wouldnt know that because terraria's sun might be the anomalous one

wheat walrus
#

ill just say it is

leaden bridge
#

the world soul itself is already assummedly pretty anomalous on its own

wanton pendant
wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

Is that Goku?

split mortar
#

Solar fragments are primordial light or contain it so another source outside our sun exists

wanton pendant
#

Green Lantern.

leaden bridge
#

is this like true though

split mortar
leaden bridge
#

wdk lore every time we look at this channel there's something else we're just supposed to assume is objectively correct and

#

oh!

#

well then thats awkard

#

wouldnt solar fragments be assumedly much stronger than the rest then

#

the rest r just normal star power and whatever vortex is

wanton pendant
#

The best lore is the stuff I make up and pass off as real. Nobody has noticed 'Noxus' isn't a real thing in the lore yet.

wheat walrus
#

yea

#

noxus hasnt been mentioned once ingame

leaden bridge
#

its true

wheat walrus
#

just hinted at like

#

a few times

#

name was just given to us by devs since it's the one major thing from old lore that wasn't namedropped ingame

leaden bridge
#

it's really exactly like john wulfrum

wheat walrus
#

truly

wanton pendant
#

I made him up, all mentions are references to Xeroc, actually.

wheat walrus
#

john wulfrum will be mentioned ingame before noxus

#

call it

cloud ibex
#

i mean if you count internal things he technically is

wanton pendant
#

Johnathan Wulfrum III, on the other hand, is integral to the lore.

cloud ibex
#

with the wulfrum set easter egg thing if your character name is john wulfrum

leaden bridge
#

we mean we all remember his contributions to like, the war

wanton pendant
#

He fought Yharim himself, in a desperate last stand to save his people. I remember how he watched Yharim kill his father, Johnathan 'Johnny' Wulfrum II.

#

Cinema.

long bloom
#

✋😐 🤚

leaden bridge
#

anyways if suns and stars are like completely different types of celestial objects then like do calamity stars not generate warmth or can life only develop with primordial light or are stars not dense enough to get planets around them or are there indeed suns that are just stars instead of suns and it doesnt really matter it's just suns are primordial light things anf i you get a bitch baby star solar system youre just in low power baby hell

wheat walrus
#

welp

wanton pendant
#

I think Calamity stars are small.

wheat walrus
#

stars in calamity are much smaller

leaden bridge
#

surely not all of them

fallen kindle
#

how do we know

wanton pendant
#

I think in Embers it's mentioned that one isn't that much bigger than Providence.

leaden bridge
#

unless terraria's night sky is illuminated by stars infinitely closer than ours

wheat walrus
#

for all we know, they can range from literally just being the fallen stars we pick up, all the way to the astral meteor for the larger ones

split mortar
#

iirc cei revealed the sun orbits the planet

wanton pendant
#

And also, Astrum Deus flings one at us.

leaden bridge
#

alternatively all those stars are suns

#

which is fun!

fallen kindle
wheat walrus
wheat walrus
split mortar
leaden bridge
#

yeah but irl stars come in plenty of sizes

fallen kindle
#

Oh ok

wanton pendant
#

Not a few meters across.

leaden bridge
#

well yeah but still wouldnt mean there are not big stars

wanton pendant
#

That's called a black hole when stars do that.

wanton pendant
#

Stars are regularly eaten by space worms

#

Probably.

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
wanton pendant
#

Therefore, space is filled with mana to keep producing stars. Therefore, Space's Haunted Theory.

wheat walrus
#

melon's haunted

leaden bridge
#

well space is clearly haunted

#

it's got like aliens on it

wanton pendant
#

Only a few.

leaden bridge
wanton pendant
#

And aliens aren't ghosts, silly.

wanton pendant
leaden bridge
#

do the martians live in a planet with a fucking stupid as hell orbit

split mortar
#

Sun orbit planet

wanton pendant
#

Mars orbits Terraria, obviously.

split mortar
#

More

split mortar
leaden bridge
#

clearly mars orbits the sun which orbits terraria

split mortar
#

💔

leaden bridge
#

except the universe isnt geocentric as a whole its just that specific arrangement

split mortar
#

The distortion orbits terraria

wanton pendant
#

Distortion is in the Moon Theory.

leaden bridge
#

thats not even in conventional space

wheat walrus
#

terraria orbits my planet

split mortar
#

Still orbits terraria
Somehow

Gotta say it for the agenda

wanton pendant
#

Xeroc has to push the sun around the planet every day, and nobody says thank you.

leaden bridge
#

ah that's why they couldnt do anthign about the wars and shit

#

too busy doing that

wanton pendant
#

Exactly.

#

If you leave the sun in one spot too long, bad stuff happens.

#

So Xeroc is busy Sisyphusmaxxing.

leaden bridge
#

well yeah it gets too hot and the other side too cold

split mortar
#

This why jared not jump us

wanton pendant
#

We still need to nail down what the hell Chaos Elementals are.

tropic oak
#

the solar pillar is clearly the dragon of flame

wanton pendant
#

Solar Pillar killed my grandma, ok?

split mortar
tropic oak
#

who gaf about providence

#

all my homies love The Dragon of Flame

wanton pendant
#

Someone does.

tropic oak
#

fuck ive got to add the dragon of wrath now

#

sighhhhhh

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Dragon of Bureaucracy.

split mortar
leaden bridge
#

We're confused now

wanton pendant
#

They're voting on entombing me.

#

Either that or the catboy poll has had a change in course.

violet sparrow
#

me when i love overcomplicating pointless details that only create more pointless questions because of my insistence on mistakenly establishing worldbuilding details

wanton pendant
#

What?

split mortar
#

Wha

split mortar
violet sparrow
#

why does the sun orbit the

#

planet

#

is it even a planet

wanton pendant
#

Sun's magic.

split mortar
#

Terraria is a planet

violet sparrow
wanton pendant
#

Because it's made of magic light.

violet sparrow
#

not how in universe

split mortar
#

Idk i dont have the devs notes and we will get info of that in sso so we cant really judge its impact on the narrative till then

wanton pendant
#

Because it's cool.

violet sparrow
#

thats how most of it seems to go

wheat walrus
#

starting to have a bit of criticism for the current state of lore info handling icl

tropic oak
#

well, it is two years old now

wanton pendant
#

Yharim paid Calamitas in Robux.

tropic oak
#

true

wheat walrus
# wheat walrus starting to have a bit of criticism for the current state of lore info handling ...

i know that there was a refusal to drop real info because it's meant to be kept for big updates and spoiling things isn't great, but also these updates to add lore are not coming at all and haven't for a year and a half (no blame on anyone for this)

and i think the "dev statement epidemic" as ill call it now only makes it worse, because it's nothing set-in-stone, they tend to be inconsistent across devs and become dated quickly, and in cases tend to raise questions rather than answer, not the speculative kind of question but the consistency kind of questions
i know there were always dev statements left and right, but it definitely intensified with the drought

i dont think devs suddenly have to start spoiling future update stuff, unless they really want to, but i find lore discussion to be kind of annoying as it is bc it's turning into a game of stating thing, "source?", and it's not from the game and instead is a random msg from a dev on discord months ago that will likely be contradicted by several more because nothing about them is set-in-stone

#

just becomes very confusing

cloud ibex
#

even if dev statements weren't kinda inconsistent sometimes i think it's kinda unfortunate that so much shit has been revealed exclusively in here

wheat walrus
#

yes

#

i think the inconsistency because they're not definitive only makes it worse

cloud ibex
#

cause there's no way to know about a Lot of things currently other than happening to be here when a writer goes off

wheat walrus
#

i dont want them to do big spoiling for what's actually set-in-stone

strange stump
#

hi omni

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
strange stump
#

@mighty zenith hi garbo!

mighty zenith
#

haiii

young socket
#

@strange stump hi space!

#

@mighty zenith hi stinky!

strange stump
#

hello!

mighty zenith
#

hi tsupid!

young socket
#

GO BACK TO UR HK RANDOMISER

#

TUPID

wheat walrus
# wheat walrus so i think

either seal the furnace or only release what's full-baked and not half-baked to be contradicted by another half-baked

split mortar
wheat walrus
#

but also

#

that doc would become obsolete

#

would also have to be updated very regularly, that's not the biggest issue though

#

id talk about straight up crossing dev statements out of discussions about what is set-in-stone

#

but also gl doing that

wanton pendant
#

But without dev statements... where does that leave Birthday Theory!?

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
#

anyways as i said

#

either close the dev statement furnace or open it only to release smaller chunks of stuff that is set-in-stone

#

dialogue teasers are one thing

split mortar
#

Cei release the entire perma dialogue tree

wanton pendant
#

My theory is that the devs are also going insane trying to keep things under wraps.

wheat walrus
wheat walrus
#

yep

#

definitely

#

i would not be able to keep things under wrap for that long with how slow development has been

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

Much as I'm going insane trying to figure out if the year is 1887 or not.

leaden bridge
#

😌

cloud ibex
#

yea no i think i remember one of them stating outright that they hate not being able to talk about the shit they've been doing for the last year+

split mortar
#

No one happy

leaden bridge
wanton pendant
#

That could work, I guess.

#

I have considered it before.

brazen swallow
wanton pendant
#

Luckily, Birthday Theory is here to back me up. May God have mercy if it's wrong.

brazen swallow
cloud ibex
#

i tend to imagine it takes like

#

a couple years maybe

split mortar
wanton pendant
#

I was getting like, six months.

cloud ibex
#

gives some time between boss fights so everything gets some breathing room

leaden bridge
#

Draedon says Yharim is probably dying before someone else like us raises to power, if it truly only took a year then Yharim is dying in like 5 months and that's pretty funny

leaden bridge
#

just wait for him to pass bro

wanton pendant
#

Yeah but then we don't get to make OUR idealogy rise from the ashes.

#

By taking his place in the ensuing power vacuum.

wheat walrus
# wheat walrus yea

honestly i think it's fine if they start revealing more info that's meant to come with this update, set-in-stone info that is, like make a smaller doc with some of the complete stuff they're fine w revealing instead of vague discord statements

i get the not wanting to spoil things but 1, this update is looking like it's meant to be huge on lore, so there should be lots of room, 2, it's been years, i remember this update being talked about as early as 2023, 3, it's one update out of multiple future updates, meaning even more room, 4, the dev statements half-do that while also causing confusion in the long run

leaden bridge
#

You do because you're the strongest thing around anyways

split mortar
#

Waterwraith im throwing you against the wall like a spamton olush

wanton pendant
split mortar
#

You will have milk jugs poured on thee

wanton pendant
#

That won't slow my roll.

leaden bridge
#

They're probably out the continent anyways

wanton pendant
#

Unnamed God 12 has got a great power! (Automobiles.)

leaden bridge
#

Ah that's why 1.4.5 adds a car

split mortar
icy veldt
#

God of piss. Responsible for the Piss Moon that's added by the World of Piss mod

wanton pendant
#

Ivo.

cloud ibex
#

☹️

leaden bridge
#

We mean

icy veldt
#

It's a real mod

leaden bridge
#

A god of waste isn't an unreasonable domain

cloud ibex
#

i suppose

thick slate
#

god of poop

leaden bridge
#

Yeah

cloud ibex
#

though the only real thing i can imagine Waste being derived from is Gluttony

robust osprey
thick slate
#

is there a calamity version of dionysus

cloud ibex
#

and that one's already taken

robust osprey
#

goddess of poop

icy veldt
#

Was there ever just a god of disease or pestilence, or like, a god of resilience to disease?

wanton pendant
thick slate
icy veldt
#

Thinking of something like Nurgle

wanton pendant
#

There were like, under three thousand gods so, yeah.

cloud ibex
#

if there was they'd probably be among the first to be tossed in the meat grinder

wanton pendant
#

God of Treachery threw the others under the bus.

icy veldt
wanton pendant
#

'Flesh of Infidelity' is a weapon dropped by the Perforators. What does this mean for God of War?

icy veldt
#

He cheated on his wife?

wanton pendant
#

Wife?

icy veldt
#

Or husband?

icy veldt
#

Or NB spouse???

zenith geode
wanton pendant
robust osprey
#

no

icy veldt
robust osprey
#

Xeroc cheated on the god of war

zenith geode
#

moral? fuck no
but effective? probably

wanton pendant
#

God of Pyramids (shemes).

zenith geode
#

giving everyone super cancer and then giving the people who worship me chemo

thick slate
#

some cancer cant be cured by chemo

wanton pendant
#

God Chemo.

robust osprey
#

super chemo

zenith geode
#

its not regular cancer though

icy veldt
#

I'm gonna have Draedon do the same thing with the Plague just to fund rebuilding

thick slate
#

okay?

#

chemo still dont

icy veldt
#

Pretty sure it was a metaphorical description

thick slate
#

no care

wanton pendant
#

Mean.

thick slate
#

mhm

icy veldt
#

I will vaporize you

thick slate
#

oki

robust osprey
#

Taylor, you will be smashed to death with hammers

wanton pendant
#

Yay!

thick slate
#

like mallets

#

or

#

sledgehammer

tropic oak
#

hi

wanton pendant
#

Hello.

long bloom
#

ball peen hammers

thick slate
#

or normal hammer

#

oki

#

that works

robust osprey
#

all 3

cloud ibex
#

lore discussion

thick slate
#

why they call it ball peen

robust osprey
#

loreus

tropic oak
#

lore discussion

thick slate
#

what the fuck

#

ball peen

wanton pendant
#

Meat Mallet, you're lunch.

long bloom
#

the ball is idk

thick slate
#

ball peen

#

i ripped the epidermis of my thumb off

#

problem

wanton pendant
#

That's bad.

thick slate
#

yea

wanton pendant
#

Don't do that in future.

thick slate
#

thanks

icy veldt
#

I'm going to fund the rebuilding of society by having Draedon make a pain-inflicting version of the Nanoplague, and then sell temporary treatment for the money to finance my empire!

robust osprey
#

I dont think draedon needa to do that

icy veldt
#

No, I need him to do that

robust osprey
#

just sell futuristic machines to non-dead continents

thick slate
#

draedon is a clanker

zenith geode
#

wouldnt he be able to make exocash

#

and then its so good that everyone starts using it

icy veldt
#

If I just had Draedon make infinite exocash, then exocash would lose its value and become worthless

robust osprey
#

then dont make infinite exocash

#

simple

wanton pendant
#

Make a finite supply, and hoard most of it.

thick slate
#

theres blood in m y alcohol system

wanton pendant
thick slate
#

ikr

#

get it out

icy veldt
#

I'll need to incentivize obedience, so I guess I could tie the treatment to a social credit score XD

wanton pendant
#

More Guinness.

robust osprey
thick slate
#

i unfortunately had no guinness tonight

robust osprey
#

so your alcohol system is fine

long bloom
#

lore discussion

wanton pendant
#

What else is there to drink?

thick slate
#

mhm

thick slate
icy veldt
thick slate
#

cosmos

#

long islands

#

midori

wanton pendant
#

Blood ain't Guinness, won't substitute.

thick slate
#

vodka rebull

wanton pendant
#

Your heart is going to explode.

thick slate
#

if beer is piss then guinness is shit

wanton pendant
#

What!?

icy veldt
#

Coffee with hard stimulants mixed into it

cloud ibex
#

if you're gonna talk about alcohol can you take it to gen talk or something please

icy veldt
#

True!

long bloom
#

lore discussion

thick slate
wanton pendant
#

Can we talk about Calamity alcohol?

icy veldt
#

Um, no

long bloom
tropic oak
#

source?

#

source?

long bloom
#

mitosis

icy veldt
#

Probably still a sore topic, I think

wanton pendant
#

I never really used any of the Calamity alcohol.

thick slate
#

mi love mitosis

icy veldt
#

Me when I have Draedon build a second cloning biolab so I can build a new Azafure and populate it entirely with 500,000 new Calamitas clones

wanton pendant
#

Why can Terrarian only have three drinks before getting alcohol poisoning? That implies they are a lightweight, and as such is inalienable proof that Terrarian has lore, that being can't handle alcohol.

cloud ibex
#

they're kinda just

#

alcohol

wanton pendant
long bloom
#

not to worry, i know exactly how to get us back on topic

#

what does yharon taste like

wanton pendant
#

Chicken.

cloud ibex
#

☹️

wanton pendant
#

Next question.

icy veldt
wanton pendant
#

Also, the obvious violation of autonomy, but you don't really care.

icy veldt
#

Have the cloning machines running continuously to keep up the population XD

wanton pendant
#

At that point just promote immigration, it'd be cheaper probably.

robust osprey
icy veldt
#

An entire city of people with the exact same face would be funny to me

icy veldt
wanton pendant
#

Depends on how the power transfer works.

#

Which we don't know.

robust osprey
#

highly doubt Scal did it on purpose tbh

icy veldt
#

Source?????

wanton pendant
#

We don't know that.

#

It could be accidental, Calamitas may have been trying to empower her clone, maybe the clone tried to take her power for herself for safety.

robust osprey
#

I like the later

icy veldt
#

Maybe she was like "Go. Be free! Have some of my power... aw shit AW SHIT"

wanton pendant
#

'I can taste my own blood and it's on fire!'

long bloom
#

burning blood debuff

icy veldt
wanton pendant
#

Not without the handy dandy power Draedon left right next to her holding cell.

icy veldt
#

Uh huh

#

I think Cal1 tried to empower Cal2 and went a bit too hard and/or encountered unexpected consequences

thick slate
#

cal3

wanton pendant
#

Calamitas' powers work on Bluetooth logic and it tried to pair with the clone.

#

That's the one people will be saying is totally real for years.

icy veldt
wanton pendant
#

Then they make Mega Calamitastwo and people think it's Calamitasthree.

tropic oak
#

all magic is bluetooth

icy veldt
#

Bones are like teeth but blue???

tropic oak
#

you know if you take the concept of Wifi / Bluetooth and swap around the terminology used to describe it with fantasy vernacular, you could make a pretty good magic system outta that

limpid saddle
#

I've always thought it was an accident, like how Calamitas siphoned power from the Brimstone Elemental

wanton pendant
#

I mean, Wifi exists in Calamity.

icy veldt
#

Blue tooth, yellow femur, red spine, green collarbone, barbecued ribs

wanton pendant
limpid saddle
#

Because how could Calamitas know how to 'bestow' her magic?

long bloom
thick slate
#

ribs are overratedf

icy veldt
#

You need to try human ribs, then XD

wanton pendant
#

Ribs grow back.

thick slate
limpid saddle
long bloom
#

that's awfully presumptuous

icy veldt
#

Me omw to blood-eagle Yharim as punishment

wanton pendant
#

Second Brimstone Elemental gave her the power, obviously.

tropic oak
#

timeline

icy veldt