#suggestions-discussion

1 messages · Page 1112 of 1

eternal escarp
#

who knows

#

maybe they will keep it as a plan or smthn

#

if it gets to mod corner, that is

muted osprey
#

e

frail mantle
#

i believe the devs (or at least ozz) wanted to make OD look in the direction he's about to dash as an indicator

golden narwhal
#

Yes, very epic not biased, since closest out of the 2.5 related suggs to 200 is photo's

cobalt pewter
frail mantle
#

byeah

winged linden
#

how good is the cosmic bolter?

#

since its pretty much a terra weapon its kinda lacklustre honestly

#

its outclassed by weapons like the chloro shotbow which you get before

warm scarab
#

ah

warm scarab
winged linden
#

yeah

#

obviously it shouldnt be like, blossom flux level

warm scarab
#

even darkecho deals more damage

winged linden
#

yeah its really weak for a terra weapon

cobalt pewter
#

Lunarian and Cosmic Bolter's gimmick is just a bit weird imo, it's not really rewarding to use it

winged linden
#

lunarian bow is good though

#

just the cosmic bolter just hasnt got any damage

#

well its not terrible

#

but its outclassed by bows you get pre-plantera

warm scarab
#

it IS terrible wdym

winged linden
#

its at least usable

warm scarab
#

it's out-classed by everything in ranger class post plant

#

sniper rifle, tactical shotgun and rocket launchers are all better

winged linden
#

it can definitely do with a buff imo

#

its unnecessary to make a whole suggestion for it so ill just leave it here

#

but yeah someone should take a look and compare it to things like the chloro shotbow and arbalest

#

which you can get before

earnest cape
#

the only thing cosmic bolter's got for itself is a cool gimmick of shooting 3 sliding bolts but that's about it

winged linden
#

through a playthrough ive tried it and the sliding really doesnt do much

#

its hard to find a situation in which it can be useful

earnest cape
#

yeh

warm scarab
#

the sliding is only useful when you wanna play around with it HahaYes

winged linden
#

ibstead of shooting those weird projectiles

#

maybe it will be useful if it just shot terra arrows

#

like turn arrows shot into terra arrows

crude geode
#

I have never found a situation where the sliding bolts are better than just shooting at the enemy.

winged linden
#

exactly

earnest cape
#

yeah as I said, just a gimmick

#

it should definitely be buffed

#

or be reworked

winged linden
#

are terra weapons meant to be like one of the can best weapons you should have post plantera

#

it doesnt matter too much since blossom flux will always outclass it as a bow

#

but if youre not on revengeance it should be your best bet

earnest cape
#

comparing it to a legendary from the same stage is pretty unfair

winged linden
#

of course

#

im aware legendary weapons are meant to be really strong

earnest cape
#

feedza is ahead of us

winged linden
#

i dont mind the lunarian bow too much as that bow is pretty strong

#

it can do really well against wof

earnest cape
#

I'd beg to differ cause it doesn't pierce and hungries are always in the way

#

byeah

cobalt pewter
#

Archerfish is quite meta on WoF cus of pierce

#

Or I guess beenades but lol

earnest cape
#

lol!

winged linden
#

i didnt use the archerfish since im only using bows HDfailure

winged linden
#

it was better than the goobow at least

warm scarab
earnest cape
#

we were talking about bows.

winged linden
#

i mean archerfish isnt a bow either

#

anything that uses arrows as ammo i count as a bow

warm scarab
safe oasis
#

but it says archer therefore its archer

warm scarab
#

but feed brought up the topic HDfailure

warm scarab
sleek turret
#

This sugg is very specific.

golden narwhal
#

@valid oxide needs a reason and less specifics

valid oxide
#

uh let me change it

gray nebula
#

why does the fact that she's easier to beat after being defeated once matter

#

that's like

#

litterally every boss

#

boo hoo we spend time making a boss that is then able to get re killed more easily

crude geode
#

Twins are easier to defeat once they’ve been beaten once, should we add eye of Cthulhu to their fight?

swift wharf
#

yeah lmao

crude geode
#

@valid oxide see Ivan’s reasoning

#

Iban*

rain basalt
#

Ichor Bullet and Ichor Arrow damage should be lowered a little bit

grim tusk
#

#suggestions-posting message
1- sounds unreasonable and unnecesary
2- fight will not be consistent
3- you know that brothers would be real stupid if you had to move a lot durning em

cobalt pewter
#

The reason seems absurd

sleek turret
#

8 direction shots.

#

why

#

literally becoming DoG lasers but slow proyectiles.

grim tusk
#

Yea and considering the dart explosions its just NO

#

The Scal’s brother’s strat in nohits is to not move much

#

Cuz then all the projectiles will tear you appart

#

Adding a moving agressive, ramming target will just make it unfair

sleek turret
#

Frame perfect, even.

grim tusk
#

Yea imagine if the only viable strategy was just melt em before they kill you

#

Its just a big NO

sharp prism
#

guardians

grim tusk
#

this is why we either shred them with adren or do night provi

sharp prism
grim tusk
#

Making guardians more chill during cocoons would be nice

sharp prism
#

just remove guardians phase after you do it once

#

me thinks

grim tusk
#

Inconsistent fight

#

Specially cuz unlike DoG, Provi is there while you fight em

sharp prism
#

yeah

#

sadly

cobalt pewter
#

Just remove Guardians

#

Bad design when melt or be melted is the only strat

#

(or in provi's case, do a challenge ver just to get rid of that bad design)

hot zephyr
#

I think they could be reworked

#

Maybe provi stays in a constant, but weaker cocoon phase, and guardians are slower

cobalt pewter
#

That is an option

sharp prism
#

Original idea isnt it?

#

oh

grim tusk
#

making them fuck off durning cocoon would also work

sleek turret
#

They could serve as their purpose.

#

i.e Defensive Guardians protects Provi.

#

Offesive could stop ramming into the player and shoot 8 directional spear or do something else that isn't ramming.

grim tusk
#

Yea like defensive gives provi a ton of DR while its alive and attack you, offensive just tries to murder you but yea currently its too bland, and healing is fine atm

sleek turret
#

They could switch into patterns and depending who is helping Providence does something I guess.

#

i.e example;
Defensive gives defense/dr bonus to Provi, Offensive increases damage or fire rate of Provi's proyectiles, Healer could heal but not at the rate it is today (aka: heal almost every 1s)

grim tusk
#

Maybe

safe oasis
#

isnt it literally in the mod list

velvet locust
#

most people dont check that

#

and also people go to the title screen much more

#

(i mean, it is the first thing you see when you boot up the game)

safe oasis
#

it doesnt take very much effort to check

sharp prism
#

^

safe oasis
#

unless you want something yelling at you constantly that you are currently version 1.4.5.007

velvet locust
#

i would prefer that than not knowing what version im on

#

also it doesnt have to be in big letters

safe oasis
#

you can already check what version you're on though

sharp prism
#

You

#

Check

#

you modlist

#

its not hard

safe oasis
#

literally click a single button and scroll

sharp prism
#

^

velvet locust
#

no one wants to do that every second

safe oasis
#

what?

sharp prism
#

Huh

#

You

safe oasis
#

do you have amnesia?

velvet locust
#

no

grim tusk
#

It literally takes no effort bruh

sharp prism
#

Then why are you clicking every single second

grim tusk
#

Also yes, if you know what ver you in you dont need to check again

sharp prism
velvet locust
#

im just saying, putting it in something as frequently checked as a title screen is better then a mod list

sleek turret
#

if you can hit the select "Singleplayer" screen you can also hit the "Mods" and "Mod Browser" screen.

velvet locust
#

also changing the mod name can confuse players

safe oasis
#

lets say, theoretically, that this change is implemented ok

how would knowing that you're on something like 1.4.5.002 tell you whether you're on the latest or not

#

people who dont have the latest versions often think they're on the latest version anyway

sleek turret
#

YEAH

velvet locust
safe oasis
#

tell what

velvet locust
#

what version you are on and if your version is outdated

safe oasis
grim tusk
#

That what the mods screen fucking does

safe oasis
#

what

sharp prism
#

how would it do that without updating the version youre on

grim tusk
#

Your sugg doesnt have any logic

sleek turret
#

1- if you can click the tmod shortcut to game you can also click every single option on the menu

grim tusk
#

Also ^

sharp prism
#

telling you if its outdated i mean

velvet locust
#

it helps

sharp prism
#

you

safe oasis
#

you're just repeating yourself without adding any further reasoning

sharp prism
#

didnt answer my question

grim tusk
#

^

sleek turret
#

2- how the fuck people with old versions will know that they are on a old version if this was implemented on the latest version in first place

grim tusk
#

Your sugg hasnt logic, isnt possible and the solution is already fucking there in the mod list

velvet locust
#

but it helps

grim tusk
#

How tf

sleek turret
#

ugh

grim tusk
#

Like mod screen already exists

velvet locust
#

and putting it in something as frequently looked at helps

grim tusk
#

Your sugg will be 100% rejected for fucking unreasonable and too much effort

safe oasis
#

ok we're getting no where

grim tusk
#

^

safe oasis
#

just move on he's repeating himself

velvet locust
#

fuck

sleek turret
#

3- If you can fucking click the tMod Steam Shortcut or something to open tMod that means that you can:
Click every single option selection screen on the menu.
Update all mods.

velvet locust
#

most people dont know about it

safe oasis
#

what

velvet locust
#

like the people who just downloaded the mod

crystal iron
#

You just have to "update all"

velvet locust
#

or the people who are new to tmodloader

safe oasis
#

the people who just downloaded the mod already have the latest version

#

???

grim tusk
#

They literally have to get to mod browser which tells the version and what psychic said

velvet locust
#

but that version will eventually get updated

crystal iron
#

Then you just have to update??? It will say in mod browser

sleek turret
#

And if they are exploring the entire menu screen they will eventually touch the Mod Browser section and Mods section.

grim tusk
#

if only Rover was online

sleek turret
#

And a million youtube tutorials of how to use tMod exists.

safe oasis
#

free trial mod points HDfailure

grim tusk
#

~~hes also sugg administrator HDfailure ~~

safe oasis
#

same thing

#

anyway tl;dr
delete the suggestion and move on

velvet locust
#

no

grim tusk
#

Yes

crystal iron
#

Literally everyone is telling you why this feature is useless

velvet locust
#

im not deleting it

#

end of story

sleek turret
#

Mods will if they find a valid reason to.

sharp prism
#

byech no reason to add it if it already exists in another place

safe oasis
#

and what is your reason for not deleting it

zenith hazel
#

yea, as stated already, the version number exists in the mods menu

#

I don't see a reason to add it

velvet locust
#

some people dont know about that

sharp prism
#

bruh

zenith hazel
#

what makes you assume that?

velvet locust
#

it is not as frequently talked about as 1.5

#

or vanilla 1.4

zenith hazel
#

that has no correlation

grim tusk
#

You literally can see the mod version on mod browser as you are going to download it bruh

crystal iron
sleek turret
#

Ooh, and also one thing.

velvet locust
#

what

sleek turret
#

The curiosity about: "What is this <selection screen>" that people will always be wondering about.

#

"Where do I download mods?"
"Where do I check my mods?"

zenith hazel
#

how would some people not know what version they're on?

#

that's their job to look at the mods menu

#

this just seems like unnecessary spoonfeeding

safe oasis
#

all of this isnt even counting the fact that tmod literally says "Loading Calamity (No Music) Version 1.4.5.7"

#

when booting up

sleek turret
#

^

zenith hazel
#

^

sleek turret
#

Sandboxing <mods>
Loading <mod name and version>

velvet locust
#

fine

#

i will delete it

#

idiots

grim tusk
zenith hazel
#

insulting people doesn't help either

grim tusk
#

Specially when everyone is against your idea

zenith hazel
#

that goes for all of you here

#

but insulting people regardless will harm your credibility

#

byeah, you get my point

#

why?

#

I thought it was established balancing suggestions are discouraged + lacerator's already been balanced

grim tusk
#

We literally discused yesterday with him to not sugg that bruh

zenith hazel
#

sigh

#

@signal glade ^

grim tusk
#

Heck even Piky stepped in and told him that was already done

zenith hazel
#

and as for the scal sugg

#

that's a hard no for me

sleek turret
zenith hazel
#

the gap between pre-scal gear and post-scal gear is not that significant

#

I don't see any point in buffing her for the next fights

#

it seems unnecessary and makes grinding for shadowspec bars even more of a chore

#

@valid oxide please provide a better reason as to why this is needed, because this just unnecessarily makes farming scal even more tedious

frozen hornet
#

SCal is already hard enough imo

grim tusk
signal glade
#

does that apply specifically only to scal?

grim tusk
#

It applies to providence too

#

With the guardians

signal glade
#

i almost said polter but its getting revamped right?

#

no more bs dash/ram?

grim tusk
#

Polter is fine atm, his tile enrage is the only problem which has gotten addressed next patch

pure dust
#

One shot dragonfooly and nothing bad happended lol

grim tusk
pure dust
#

btw I forgot that this is suggestion discussion

signal glade
#

oh yeah what balance is given to lacerator?

safe oasis
#

buff

#

thats all we know, ask the testers

hollow shell
#

Should I make a pin telling people to not make any balance suggestions for post-ML content

distant gyro
#

yes

dapper coral
#

yes pls

#

hell, balance suggs in general
because pre-ML also won't be touched for like 2 months

hollow shell
#

(It is actually already a Don't for people to not make balance suggestions, even pre 1.5 development
With the alternative being just telling the testers directly, to save time

but uhh iunno how easy that is for people, s'not like we provide a list of testers)

dapper coral
#

i feel like this was brought up before but idr
we can absolutely provide a list of testers, but i feel like right now we shouldn't even encourage asking for balance at all

#

so maybe once post-ML is done, we can put up a list

hollow shell
#

Yeah

#

... I don't think it's too fair to say no to all balance suggs tho during this timeframe
Even if they can't get done immediately, they will be delivered and the testers can look back at them once they're free to

zenith hazel
#

what’s the point when we’re going to look through every single cal wep anyway?

hollow shell
#

With PostML stuff, yeah that's guaranteed to be changed
but PreML stuff would just be forgotten and slip through the cracks if we disallow them too

dapper coral
#

^ what brav said

zenith hazel
#

we’re not forgetting pre-ml stuff

dapper coral
#

it's kinda funky because everything is gonna be looked at, period

hollow shell
#

You're doing the entire game?

zenith hazel
#

we’re gonna go all the way back to pre-boss after post-ml

#

yes

hollow shell
#

I thought it was just PostML because of the flattening

zenith hazel
#

so yes, suggesting weapon rebalancing is redundant

dapper coral
#

no flattening is happening in pre-ML but we're still gonna go through everything

zenith hazel
#

we’re looking into everything so that people would stop praising some shit as the holy grail of op weapons

hollow shell
#

Aight, that's cool then

dapper coral
#

byeah even if they are technically already not bueno it would be good to just reiterate it with a pin since that's especially important rn

zenith hazel
#

also bot's down, notified amber

ancient mirage
#

profaned rage and holy wrath boost all classes

crystal holly
#

Wait a minute do they

dapper coral
#

yeah

crystal holly
#

If they do I fucked up real bad

dapper coral
#

they're rage and wrath upgrades

#

shattering is a better example

distant gyro
#

the melee and rogue thing is indeed shattering

#

mage technically has aureus cell as a magic power duration upgrade

crystal holly
#

Ah shit they do

zenith hazel
#

bot has resurrected

crystal holly
#

Fuck
Should've done my research
Curse my sleepy brain

distant gyro
#

summoner will not get one because 2 minion slots in 1 potion is a sin

crystal holly
#

..why is it a sin though

distant gyro
#

we don't like to balance around minions being en masse

crystal holly
#

Oh
Oh, I remembered the statis cheese

distant gyro
#

statis cheese is gone for that reason

crystal holly
#

You mean is gone or will be gone in Drae update?

distant gyro
#

will be

crystal holly
#

Ay then it's alright I already nearly passed the game on summoner

#

Aight but ranger

#

Why doesn't ranger have like
An upgrade of the ammo reservation potion

distant gyro
#

maybe

#

that could be a thing

#

if you find a good enough reason for it to be suggested

#

usually 1 reason won't cut it for item suggestions

crystal holly
#

..balance?
I mean, it's not exactly from my experience since I play summoner (which from the experience is pretty damn weak at least in terms of defence, fearmonger is op though)
But calamity ranger players I know say their class is weak
Maybe that's just self deprecation though

hollow shell
#

I think the fact that none of our potions touch ranged, not even Cirrus's drinks, is a fine reason

#

From what I've heard, ranged is a very strong class

crystal holly
#

None of Cirrus' drinks touch ranged?

distant gyro
#

I think ammo reservation is alright to touch on

crystal holly
#

I thought one of them increased all damage

hollow shell
#

Well
Anything that boosts all damage does, yes

#

I meant specifically

crystal holly
#

Yeh that's kind of a problem

distant gyro
#

Endgame forms of ranger ammo QoL is just outright granting most ranged weapons chance to not consume ammo

#

Photoviscerator has a whopping 90%

crystal holly
#

Also I wanted to suggest a summoner potion which made summons inflict an effect but I then realized that it would be buggy and kind of overpowered

#

Photo is broken and we all know that

#

Alright
Terribly sorry, phone's dying and I need to sleep

hollow shell
#

Aight
Maybe remove the sugg for now and repost a new one when you wake up?

dapper coral
#

if not tens of thousands

#

byeah

glass sentinel
#

wrong channel

distant vault
#

gone

slate turtle
#

tawny garden
#

eh

#

the argument isn't great

gray nebula
#

speed runge

hollow shell
#

..... mmmmm

safe oasis
#

"allow me to toggle literally exploiting the game"

tawny garden
#

because everybody would turn it on if they wanted to use it

hollow shell
#

Very unlikely that we will allow people to have such an abusable exploit by choice

broken trellis
#

thr whole point is ti exploit the game

hollow shell
#

They can exploit the game with what they have

broken trellis
#

sorry im terrible at writing

gray nebula
#

and thats what we dont want yea

hollow shell
#

If we fix it, tough shit, find something else

#

(imo)

broken trellis
#

to exploit like the duping glitch

gray nebula
#

Also a part of speedrunning is having to find new ways to exploit the game when previous glitches get fixed

broken trellis
#

and it can be a persons choice to toggle it on

#

if they want to ruin thei expirence

tawny garden
#

it's an exploit that doesn't ruin experience

#

quite the opposite HDfailure

safe oasis
#

if you want pseudo godmode that bad just get cheat sheet

tawny garden
#

unless you want to play fair

#

yeah

fossil finch
#

also this does not help speedrunning at all
that's not how speedrunning with glitches works on the first place
Iban said it

broken trellis
#

i just rathered spend 5 hours at my computer rather than 16 hours

zenith hazel
#

then use cheat sheet

#

nobody's stopping you

safe oasis
#

yeah or just find something else to speedrun

broken trellis
#

that's not the point

zenith hazel
#

is that not the argument you're trying to make?

fossil finch
#

calamity is not much speedrunneable lol
it allows for any% but not for speedruns

#

"This change would primarily would help speed runners that want to speed run calamity with glitches and its a pain not getting to use one of the most overpowered glitches which would shave hours off their times." yes it is the point

broken trellis
#

the type if speedruns im talkin about is

#

the ones

fossil finch
#

™️

broken trellis
#

hectique did

safe oasis
#

the one like 2 years ago?

broken trellis
#

yh basically

safe oasis
#

you expect the mod to be the same as 2 years ago basically? HDfailure

#

just download that version of the mod

broken trellis
#

just that one mechanic like what

fossil finch
#

still there's no real reasoning, and it is a sugg about readding a glitch

safe oasis
#

hectique also used several strategies and weapons that wouldnt be viable in current clam

#

if you want to have a similar styled run download an older version of the mod

broken trellis
#

im not talkin about his stratiges

#

im just talking about the glitch

fossil finch
#

then your point is re add a glitch so i can copy something hectique did 2 years ago or what

robust lava
#

Even just the concept of "yes, let's re-add a glitch" is a weird idea

fossil finch
#

^

broken trellis
#

that you can toggle on and off

fossil finch
#

that does nothing

robust lava
#

That's basically saying "add a godmode toggle"

broken trellis
#

in settings how does that not do anything

fossil finch
#

because people will turn it off
yeah
sure
HDfailure

robust lava
#

Even if this gets to voting and gets to devs, I don't see an outcome where they would choose to implement this

tawny garden
broken trellis
#

that not my problem tho they are the ones that decided to not expirence the fun of calamity

wooden wedge
#

hasn't re-adding bugs and things back into the game something that has been turned down before

crude geode
#

You’re the one doing that tho.

fossil finch
#

the fun of calamity is cheesing bosses
ultimatesmug

robust lava
#

Does the "fun of calamity" include sitting still and being immune during all boss fights? HDfailure

tawny garden
#

readding an exploit only lowers the integrity of the mod

sleek turret
tawny garden
#

HDfailure ye

broken trellis
#

speed running like did you read my thing

wooden wedge
#

does anyone even speedrun this game though

novel belfry
#

hmm

fossil finch
#

that does not help speedrunning
and, again, the mod is not for speedrunning

sleek turret
tawny garden
broken trellis
#

just because you say its doesnt mean it trye

sleek turret
#

And most of them are on King Slime category.

novel belfry
fossil finch
wooden wedge
#

and like, if you want to speedrun the mod with the bug why dont you just downgrade the mod

broken trellis
#

how do you do that

crude geode
#

Download an old version of the mod

whole sedge
#

Speedrunning content mods is just a bad idea because they're content mods

broken trellis
#

i didnt know that was a thing lol

sleek turret
#

downpatching is banned on calamity speedruns.

#

lol

#

you can't use older versions of the mod for speedrunning.

broken trellis
#

oh

sleek turret
#

its banned as specified to rule 8: "No downpatching."

wooden wedge
#

isee

fossil finch
sleek turret
#

why KS exactly?

#

because you don't need to basically go all over with the mod

broken trellis
#

i just like to speedrun the mod and many other do also and i think this would increase the enjoyment

fossil finch
#

"many other do" speak for yourself
don't put others that do not exist on this

wooden wedge
#

if the majority of speedruns are to king slime then your sugg would like literally just be for yourself

fossil finch
#

unless you have like
a consistent prove people think that

whole sedge
#

Yeah, nobody wants to speedrun 100%ing a content mod that can take upwards of 20 hours hence why 100% categories and super long speedruns like that are usually the least used category and even so just find a new bug or something if it gets patched, that's part of the fun of speedrunning from my experiences echdistort

broken trellis
#

i do my friend does and many others ive done thiss with

wooden wedge
#

which at that point you could just make a mod to do trhat

#

or ask someone else to

sleek turret
fossil finch
#

don't get too overboard with the speedrun part kaizo

#

suggdiscussion
minimodding HDfailure

sleek turret
#

not going to explain how low% works ender

wooden wedge
#

the sugg is literally about speedrunning

fossil finch
#

yes but they are talking about unrelated

whole sedge
#

either way having your reasoning be based on a very niche community is no bueno

crude geode
#

@hollow shell Can you exclaim the sugg? It’s literally adding a toggle for a pseudo godmode Bc “speedrun” even tho it kinda goes against the speed running community

safe oasis
#

why specifically rover

sleek turret
#

tbf people who did speedruns when speedrunner server existed in first place** are lower than 10**

safe oasis
#

jhin is right there

fossil finch
#

point was uh
-No this does not make speedruns more enjoyable
-this does not help glitch% speedruns either
-People don't do speedruns in general
-it is adding an unintended and exploitable aspect of the game back that was patched for a reason

wooden wedge
#

the only reason i think it'd need an ❗ would be for the last reason but i dont know if that's actually a dont or not

#

i havent read the suggs doc in like a year

tawny garden
#

do

fossil finch
#

it really lacks reasoning and i think re-adding patched stuff is not allowed overall, can't remember if the sugg doc mentions stuff like this, however

sleek turret
#

tbf it would fall into the don't category: "Any suggestions involving re-adding removed features or sprites" honestly.

crude geode
#

Byeah

wooden wedge
#

purple.

crude geode
#

Purple indeed

safe oasis
#

it counts as this technically

#

a glitch can be a feature

broken trellis
#

Now i think over it its kinda stupid

wooden wedge
#

yeah that would count

safe oasis
#

damn we on a whole ❗ spree

tawny garden
#

there was a talk here earlier about pins

#

I think the Emote sugg pin should be unpinned

#

it's been a month

crude geode
#

Wasn’t it still being discussed or smthn

tawny garden
#

most similar pins here last for 2 weeks at most

dapper coral
crude geode
#

Like what to do regarding emote suggs

dapper coral
#

they're not coming back here, that's for sure
idk how they're going to be implemented but it's not through the sugg channels for the foreseeable future

#

so the pin could maybe go

tawny garden
#

if they are somehow coming back, there would be a new pin

#

here or somewhere else

dapper coral
#

mhm

hollow shell
#

Yeah emote pin can be unpinned. It's in the Don'ts now and s'been a month

tawny garden
crude geode
#

Wonderful

hollow shell
#

This look good for the balance pin?

grim tusk
hollow shell
#

For the time being, do not post any Post-Moon Lord balance suggestions.
The Post-Moon Lord stage of the game is going through a 'stat flattening' for the 1.5 update. The health and damage numbers of everything in that stage is getting adjusted significantly into a less extreme curve.
As such, posting any balance suggestions regarding this tier would be useless, as the numbers are already being changed and re-tested to fit the new curve. Please wait for 1.5's release, and see how your subject of concern performs under the new system.

tawny garden
dapper coral
#

yeah that's cool

#

cheers

broken trellis
hollow shell
#

Cool

grim tusk
hollow shell
#

Drop rate isn't balance as far as I'm concerned

dapper coral
#

that's a different kind of balance

tawny garden
#

these are fine

hollow shell
#

Enemy and bosses, I am unsure about

grim tusk
#

provi guardians

distant gyro
#

enemy stat can be a balance suggestion

hollow shell
#

Is that in the testers scope?

distant gyro
#

ie. "Nerf Scorn Eater's health"

hollow shell
#

Or is it only items?

#

for 1.5

distant gyro
#

which is already handled

hollow shell
#

@zenith hazel

zenith hazel
#

weapons only imo

dapper coral
#

^

hollow shell
#

Alright

#

What about armor and accs?

dapper coral
#

there are a couple that are being rebalanced

distant gyro
#

weapon is the biggest one

dapper coral
#

reaver obv, godslayer/silva

#

etc

grim tusk
#

I was refering to things like “Make Old Duke tooth balls slower”, “make guardians more agressive during prof guardian fight”, “make provi’s guardians be more chill during a cocoon” or things like that

distant gyro
#

armor and accs, whatever

zenith hazel
#

they're both grey areas

dapper coral
#

but weapons is the biggest deal

zenith hazel
distant gyro
grim tusk
hollow shell
#

Alright
I'll specify it to just weapons

distant gyro
#

they don't concern stats

grim tusk
#

What would they count as then? (Also pretty sure movement speed is a stat)

distant gyro
#

but rather how things do stuff

#

in dev tag terms it'd probably be a Function Change

grim tusk
distant gyro
#

NPC movement speed isn't a global stat

#

unless you count a vector that goes 2 to the left and 2 upwards as one

grim tusk
#

Like that time with Scal moons in Acid rain HDfailure

hollow shell
#

How's the pin look now?

grim tusk
#

Good

distant gyro
#

idk if it is redundant to clarify what a balancing suggestion is

grim tusk
#

also does anyone call Brimstone monsters by their actual name rather than moons

tawny garden
#

Feedza did

#

in a sugg

#

once

distant gyro
#

ie. "Make Belladonna do more damage but shoot less projectiles" should be valid under an item functional change

hollow shell
#

I usually call them "Brimstone Monster Orbs"
I only call em moons when everybody else in the convo is, to prevent confusion

#

And uhhhh

distant gyro
#

Whereas "Nerf Belladonna and here's 34 million reasons why" blatantly isn't

hollow shell
#

Prolly best to just disallow the former one as well

#

Tell em to save it for after 1.5 releases

distant gyro
#

I think the former is completely fine, even though we might think of that as a solution

grim tusk
#

Yea now it looks good

red anvil
#

Why isn’t this server in discovery yet

hollow shell
#

iunno
I think cuz it'll involve administrative changes that we're not ready to handle yet, or that we're fine with our place currently?

red anvil
#

Maybe

earnest cape
#

new pin nice

crude geode
warm scarab
earnest cape
#

.....water arenas aren't intended for any fights

crude geode
#

^

#

Good for you, I still don’t like water arenas and am not going to use them.

earnest cape
#

you fight them normally meaning no water arena

#

no bosses are tested with water arenas in mind

crude geode
#

Bc abyss exists

earnest cape
#

ye

crude geode
#

and is like a point in progression 3 times, and is necessary for auric armor iirc

warm scarab
earnest cape
#

I am taxevasion stop using water arenas they're cringe

warm scarab
#

^

#

can't agree more

crude geode
#

New Sugg Idea: Provi destroys water with her projectiles

?

What do you expect to happen when a Sun goddess comes near your pool of water

warm scarab
#

first of all, why are you not fighting her normally

warm scarab
#

it's not

#

the cringe thing is water arena

earnest cape
warm scarab
#

ok

dapper coral
#

as much as you guys hate water arenas it's not exactly relevant, yes

crude geode
#

Ye

warm scarab
#

the thing is

crude geode
#

shhhhh this is not really about suggestions

warm scarab
#

@vale hare why not suggest "make provi's box not remove liquid inside instead of drying everything"

#

that just sounds better

#

we get to keep the box
you get to keep your water

crude geode
#

Box is cringe anyways, it has no purpose outside of hell.

warm scarab
#

it's not cringe

#

it's only purpose is in hell

#

not now

dapper coral
#

don't post it yet, correct

warm scarab
#

^

earnest cape
#

wait for like

#

a week? or so

#

idr

crude geode
#

Ye

warm scarab
#

should be enough

dapper coral
#

there's no hard limit on what someone else can suggest the same thing about, but if it seems like the sugg already there won't make it to 200 (probably after about a week) then you can post your version

earnest cape
#

believe me it's been suggested multiple times already

warm scarab
#

what

crude geode
#

The game can already tell if she is in hallow or hell, it’s how the unique attacks work.

warm scarab
crude geode
#

Just into voting today

fossil finch
#

And a totally different, and more valid reason tbh, was used

signal glade
#

Why not just remove the box itself or make it small like WoF?

#

its annoying to clean up

earnest cape
#

(personal solution: veinminer)

signal glade
#

I do use veinminer

#

But what if some doesnt use mods like that

earnest cape
#

not a counterargument, just a suggestion on how to deal with them

signal glade
#

and fabsol even added luminite as a spawn while their is operator npc from alch

#

nonetheless just use veinmine

fossil finch
#

I mean alch npc is much more intrusive and unused mod than veinminer

muted osprey
#

od prob gonna get lore tho

tawny garden
#

it's going to happen eventually

ashen warren
#

sweet

hollow shell
#

It's in progress yeah

tawny garden
#

so that's future content

#

again a don't

hollow shell
#

That's not what that means

earnest cape
#

isn't lore already being worked on so this sugg is kinda obsolete

hollow shell
#

That's just him suggesting something that happened to be already planned

#

ain't him suggesting a change to an upcoming feature

golden narwhal
#

@ashen warren yo

tawny garden
#

ah

hollow shell
#

(he's already here, AsianMan)

ashen warren
golden narwhal
#

oh taxevasion

earnest cape
#

galaxy brain

tawny garden
hollow shell
#

Okay it may not be as imminent or in-progress as I thought

earnest cape
tawny garden
earnest cape
#

welp

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

hollow shell
#

It's come eventually
but

tawny garden
#

tbf, all of lore is like that

rotund tree
#

poor od

hollow shell
#

I don't think we have... anything yet

earnest cape
eternal escarp
#

byeah

hollow shell
#

ODech indeed.

earnest cape
#

perish blast

#

bad emote ech

eternal escarp
tawny garden
#

the real question is: will the OD lore sugg somehow speed things up, or will it have no effect?
I'm inclined to believe that it's the latter

eternal escarp
#

~~i just really want building to be easier boohoodust ~~

dapper coral
#

yeah you're good blast

hollow shell
#

Yeah you can sugg that again

dapper coral
#

it's been over a week

eternal escarp
#

aight cool wegud

tawny garden
#

2 weeks, even

hollow shell
#

The rule's 1 week

#

It's been almost exactly 2 weeks

eternal escarp
#

ah lmfao

earnest cape
#

one hour till its officially 2 weeks

#

I can't count

tawny garden
eternal escarp
#

byeah

#

if theres anything i should add or fix then lemme know

hollow shell
#

Yeah considering the previous one didn't even get close to the req actually
Prolly should have edits

#

I noticed the previous one had a video that didn't embed
Maybe you should re-send the sugg with it as a direct attachment?

eternal escarp
#

o, yeah thats true

#

i already forgot i had the video

hollow shell
#

Suggs with visual accompaniment usually do well

#

That's been a fact since the SIS days

eternal escarp
#

so ill resend the sugg with the video then

hollow shell
#

Ye

#

Once the cooldowns over

tawny garden
#

slowmode ech

#

why can't files be attached to a message after it's been sent?

bitter drift
tawny garden
#

pisscord

hollow shell
#

Pretty crusty yeah

eternal escarp
#

yeah lol

hollow shell
#

Good demo video
Some of those are quite slow

tawny garden
dapper coral
#

considering it's blossom pick, i would agree those are pretty surprisingly slow

eternal escarp
#

prty sure these were all of them unless silva crystal also takes more then once

#

a counter-arguement could be to use crystyl crusher ig, but its just not really built to work like an actuall pickaxe due to it being wayy too fast

tawny garden
#

crystyl is bad

muted osprey
#

why doesn't crystyl crusher right click work with veinminer

#

dum

tawny garden
#

cuz the right click is some crap

earnest cape
#

crusty? it's at least 720p for me

#

i am dumb

tawny garden
earnest cape
tawny garden
#

with the block-breaking functionality being added in

#

the right click isn't a pickaxe

#

so veinmeiner doesn't treat it as one

#

it doesn't pick, it destroys tiles

earnest cape
#

thanks terraria

hollow shell
tawny garden
#

Pisscord, inc.

hollow shell
#

(lack of file upload on edit)

earnest cape
#

sad

tawny garden
#

it is possible to do

#

considering that messages are edited by sending over the entire message again

earnest cape
#

ye

tawny garden
#

they just don't do it boohoo

warm scarab
#

crystyl crusher right click work with veinminer right

#

if you're close enough

eternal escarp
rotund tree
#

the right click can even break progression-locked ores

eternal escarp
#

does it matter tbh

warm scarab
rotund tree
#

you can technically get astral ore in low% HDfailure

warm scarab
#

it's a projectile breaking blocks

eternal escarp
#

for the most part, byeah

sleek wadi
#

And only in scal low%

cobalt pewter
hollow shell
#

Hol up

earnest cape
#

holding up

hollow shell
#

Crystyl Crusher's right-click, as in the swing, is a projectile?

warm scarab
#

i think they meant left click kekw

rotund tree
#

oh it's left ?

warm scarab
#

because right click is normal pickaxe

#

it's left

hollow shell
#

The laser is on left-click

warm scarab
#

^

rotund tree
#

oh ok

warm scarab
#

lol

rotund tree
tawny garden
#

Ah, was I foiled by thinking of older versions or smth

#

CompleteFailure le dumb

earnest cape
#

were you thinking of crystyl crusher that shoots pink dusts that destroys stuff

tawny garden
#

ye HyperFailure

earnest cape
tawny garden
#

tbf the last time I used Crusher was before it got an alt use

earnest cape
#

byeha

warm scarab
#

this sugg is LETSFUCKINGGOOOO quality

frail mantle
#

doesn't Confused just, like,

#

not work on some enemies at all for no real reason

safe oasis
#

In boss fights it does nothing, because most boss minions and all bosses are immune to it, meaning it does nothing
kinda redundant here

tawny garden
#

most enemies are immune to the debuff

earnest cape
#

for 1.4 boc

tawny garden
#

in 1.4 BoC went from useless to OP

earnest cape
#

once again don't quote me on it

#

ye

safe oasis
#

talking about the accessory or the boss

tawny garden
#

acc

frail mantle
#

the accessory

earnest cape
#

acc

frail mantle
#

except the reason it's so strong in JE is purely because of the dodge

crude geode
#

yep LUL

tawny garden
#

aha

#

Confusion still sucks ass

frail mantle
#

the on hit confusion could be removed and not a single person would give a shit because the on hit confusion does not matter

earnest cape
#

didn't it also increased some stats when you dodge taxevasion

frail mantle
#

yes

safe oasis
#

its like counter scarf but RNG

earnest cape
#

wdym counter scarf is also rng

#

it never works half the time

safe oasis
earnest cape
#

byeah

crude geode
#

Byech

#

Confusion bad

tawny garden
#

get 285 stars on this

earnest cape
cobalt pewter
#

Despite the major immunity removal of many debuffs on NPCs in 1.4.1, Confused didn't get this treatment as apparently each of the AI needs to be recoded to be able to be affected by Confused

tawny garden
#

sign of bad coding

#

no way to easily reverse the directions for an npc

cobalt pewter
#

I would love for Confused to actually work beyond Fighter AI, but that'd actually take a shitton of work

gray nebula
#

bbrreaking the boss rush with

#

ores

robust lava
#

New event falls under "large amount of work" in the don'ts doc

golden narwhal
#

Calamity already adds a lot of ores/dug-up block things tbh

#

Should at least acknowledge those

fossil finch
#

Mmyes more ores
There's not like 6 already

golden narwhal
earnest cape
#

@meager tangle

#

oh you already deleted the sugg

crude geode
#

That or some mod murdered

earnest cape
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

i need help

#

Make Golem Head behave the same way as SCal when holding a true melee weapon
When you hold a true melee weapon scal's movement will be sloppier i.e. having a harder time to lock on to the side of the player making it easier to hit with true melee.

When golem's body is under 44%, the golem head(in phase 2) will change its movement pattern and starts firing explosive fireballs behaving similarly to scal where it locks on to various positions around the player. Making golem head slower when holding a true melee weapon would make true melee users have an easier time during the fight and would make

#

help me improve this

#

im having a hard time to word it correctly while also making sense of it

sleek turret
#

'true melee-rs' could be replaced by 'true melee users'

cobalt pewter
#

Imagine not bursting the body down

frail mantle
#

i feel like this would fall under a subclass suggestion

sleek turret
#

oh

frail mantle
#

but then again calamity does try to make sure its bosses are possible for people playing true melee so i'm not sure

crude geode
#

Yeah it’s confusing

sleek turret
#

and also capitalize Golem and SCal when they are mentioned

crude geode
#

True melee is both a subclass and not one.

earnest cape
earnest cape
golden narwhal
crude geode
#

“When Golem’s body is under 44% (in Phase 2), his head will change movement patterns, locking onto various positions around the player while firing explosive fireballs. This is similar to SCal’s movement, and as such should be nerfed in a similar manner while holding a true melee sword, to make the fight easier.”

earnest cape
#

(also the sugg is a bit incomplete)

#

aight thanks wegud

crude geode
#

np

earnest cape
#

now to hope people will actually star it CompleteFailure

golden narwhal
earnest cape
#

#lovefortruemelee

crude geode
#

And for @radiant meadow to not consider nerfing golem’s head while holding a true melee weapon a subclass suggestion

earnest cape
crude geode
#

I feel like defining that don’t more is kinda needed at this point in time, considering stealth rogue and true melee. Whether it is specifying them as subclasses or something else, it probably should happen.

earnest cape
#

setalth is probably a subclass while true melee imo isn't

#

true melee is pure neutral, ranger melee is chaotic neutral and ranger left click and true melee left click+ranger right click is chaotic evil

crude geode
#

Except stealth is something that has an endgame accessory in the eclipse mirror, and has tons of support and changelogs dedicated to it.

#

Similar to true melee.

earnest cape
#

thats true

crude geode
#

except true melee doesn’t have a endgame accessory

earnest cape
#

dog lore

#

i may be dumb

crude geode
#

accessory

earnest cape
radiant meadow
#

what's happening now?

crude geode
#

Is the current suggestion a subclass suggestion?

radiant meadow
#

I think it's fine

crude geode
#

Can we update the subclass don’t to specify it doesn’t apply (at least as much) to stealth rogue and true melee?

#

Since those two are practically half of their respective classes’ identities.

radiant meadow
#

Isn't that more like about adding specific weapons to those subclasses?

crude geode
#

It’s kinda vague to be honest. That’s the example given, but it’s not specific in the title.

#

It just says “making a subclass (weapon type) more viable”

cobalt pewter
#

Stealth rogue and true melee are playstyles rather than subclasses

#

imo

earnest cape
warm scarab
#

mis are you suggesting this to make you able to get past golem in your tru meme no hits taxevasion

sleek turret
#

how do you even do true melee no-hits

cobalt pewter
#

It's a sacred art

sleek turret
#

🤫

earnest cape
#

a normie can not learn how to do the scared art of true meme nohits

cobalt pewter
#

scared art

earnest cape
#

:)

cobalt pewter
#

Remove mana on summon weapons

warm scarab
#

the disclaimer is HahaYes

crude geode
#

Isn’t resummoning things actually kinda like a balance point or something. Swapping minions mid fight and that kinda stuff.

warm scarab
#

what

#

who tf do that

tawny garden
#

It is kinda, though it's minor

tawny garden
warm scarab
#

ech

safe oasis
#

i do HDfailure

#

the mana is a good balancing thing for that

#

reducing it wont hurt though

crude geode
#

Ye

#

That said, minions staying across lives should help alleviate some of this problem

shell grotto
earnest cape
#

mmyes igneous

tawny garden
#

summoner is just mage in disguise

#

that's why it uses mana

earnest cape
#

Damage says itself too 👀

grim tusk
earnest cape
#

Was about to ping you brav CompleteFailure

zenith hazel
ashen warren
#

ok

eternal escarp
#

melee and rogue variants are dying next update anyways

safe oasis
#

^

eternal escarp
#

corpus will be rogue only iirc

dapper coral
#

@silk garnet ^

distant gyro
#

Corpus will be rogue only and have a stealth strike

dapper coral
#

i'll remove the sugg in that case since, well, it no longer applies

silk garnet
#

ah alright, thanks

silk garnet
eternal escarp
#

nanoblack wikl stay rogue, while hammer is becoming melee iirc

#

so there will be 2 rogue dev tier weapon iirc

silk garnet
#

ah aight

dapper coral
#

that is correct

eternal escarp
#

prty sure the list is somewhere pinned in cal talk? or draedon FaQ? cant rmember lol

frail mantle
#

the latter

safe oasis
#

this should just be in general

#

not just BR

worn dagger
#

Normal rav jumps through platform and despawn is annoying af

#

Especially doing defiled rav and needed higher arena

earnest cape
#

there it is CompleteFailure

languid quartz
#

yeah I agree with this suggestion

cobalt pewter
worn dagger
crude geode
#

Fairly common sugg, but tbfh it's very understandable. Donut phase is annoying.

cobalt pewter
#

Indeed

earnest cape
#

tbh annoying is probably an understatement

mystic cloak
#

Big ol' goofy donut causes great pain during providence's cocoon phase. Agreed.

grim tusk
#

When players prefer to do night provi over dealing with guardians or the strat around them involves melting them as fast as possible you know something is wrong

cobalt pewter
#

Sound effect on flex is a good idea

#

Lemme add that

warm scarab
#

@cobalt pewter you do realize dumbbell is patron item right HDfailure

cobalt pewter
#

So?

warm scarab
#

perhaps less specific suggs would be better

cobalt pewter
#

@hollow shell is my last sugg worth contacting the donor? (Dumbbell)

warm scarab
#

good one

#

i would make some patron item suggs as well ig HDfailure

#

some of those are interesting

hollow shell
#

May as well.

warm scarab
mystic cloak
#

That's probably the thing that pisses me off about that phase the most. The god damn healer.

hollow shell
mystic cloak
#

Fookin brootal

tawny garden
#

(Should the sugg have a ❗ until the patron responds?)

dapper coral
#

yee

tawny garden
cobalt pewter
#

My first ❗ in a while

earnest cape
#

:jaja:

tawny garden
warm scarab
sharp prism
#

ashen warren
#

Would it be a valid suggestion to ask for DoG not to switch into his "A GOD DOES NOT FEAR DEATH!" phase while laser walls are still active? I've had it multiple times now where some lingering homing projectiles would make him switch phases and kill me while i was still doding a laser wall

crude geode
#

Sounds fine. Maybe instead of not switching instead deleting those projectiles.

ashen warren
#

The problem is that the player is standing still at that moment. It happens so suddenly. DoG is also still moving around while laser walls are active. When he switches phases and the head is right in front of the player... no chance.

worn dagger
#

Or just make him invincible during laser wall all together

fossil finch
#

Isn't he already

worn dagger
#

Kind of

warm scarab
safe oasis
#

you can still hit him

#

which is kinda weird

warm scarab
#

^

#

weird indeed

mint orchid
#

Whoever made that spectre armor upgrade suggestion forgot that prismastic exists

crude geode
#

Prismatic kinda isn’t tho?

#

It’s like entirely separate thing, and a dono set at that

mint orchid
#

What I mean is that mage does not need another armor

#

The class is already broken enough

crude geode
#

?

tawny garden
#

is it broken?

#

(also if it is, everything is gonna be rebalanced anyhow)

crude geode
#

Indeed

cobalt pewter
#

It is broken

#

But that's no excuse for no armor iirc

tawny garden
#

It's not

crude geode
#

Absolutely

#

“Summoner is broken so we don’t support it”

fossil finch
#

Prismatic is also another tier so ye

remote crystal
#

I killed Doggo in prismatic because I thought bloodflare was still post provi

fossil finch
#

Bloodflare is post provi AND Polter yea

#

And dog is leagues ahead of provi

safe oasis
#

You could use a ceaseless hunger potion, but why would someone use a potion just to get loot?
not a very good rebuttal here

#

ceaseless hunger potions are literally for getting loot

#

"why would you use a potion for its intended use?"

edgy pagoda
#

yeah but just for boss drops

safe oasis
#

then phrase it differently ig

edgy pagoda
#

mainly more used for farming

#

there that better?

safe oasis
#

better yeah

edgy pagoda
#

ight thx

cyan lagoon
#

if i'm not wrong they should have a rarity that prevents them from burning in lava, yeah?

edgy pagoda
#

yes

tawny garden
#

Ye

edgy pagoda
#

but like i said boxes can also help one find loot

eternal escarp
#

atleast they will be in a loot bag iirc

#

so itll be easier ig

edgy pagoda
#

signust doesnt have a bag

robust lava
fossil finch
#

wouldn't it be funny if, after it was introduced, people complained because of how much time they had to take to remove their boxes to farm signus for cosmilamp or idfk

safe oasis
#

they already do that for wof emblems and whatever

dapper coral
#

so that they know their specialty.
who's they?

safe oasis
#

the users

fossil finch
#

yeah "they" should be specified

safe oasis
#

alr fixed

dapper coral
#

rn it sounds like you want the devs to know what their own specialty is

#

cool

gray nebula
#

why do u need to know doe

#

more so, why is it so incredibly necessary to know peepothink

#

that roles are needed

#

just ask the dev in question if you want to know, i dont think theyd lie

safe oasis
#

yeah but the roles prevent having to bug them about it when you can just click their name

dapper coral
#

i don't see the harm

gray nebula
#

:/ but with specific roles i cant lie to people about being a coder

eternal escarp
#

🤔

dapper coral
#

iban is an enigma

eternal escarp
#

the paradox has begun

hot zephyr
#

"hey dev do you code"
"no, i sprite"
"ok"

The end

safe oasis
#

we just proved how this is unreliable

eternal escarp
#

mfw joke is now valid KEKW

hot zephyr
#

Role bloat time

gray nebula
#

Doing a little trolling in real time

safe oasis
#

dont they have walls anyway

#

not like you could see them

tawny garden
#

this sugg is

fossil finch
#

no he

tawny garden
#

smol

fossil finch
#

he does not mean backgrounds

#

he means map backgrounds

safe oasis
#

wdym