#suggestions-discussion

1 messages · Page 369 of 1

remote maple
#

I wanna suggest an Auric Waffle’s Iron

indigo yacht
#

Die

remote maple
#

Fair

#

I still kinda wanna suggest it tho

indigo yacht
#

can't

#

it breaks the document rules

remote maple
#

Wait is it straight up against the rules

indigo yacht
#

no reference suggestions

remote maple
#

Oh no meme suggestions

remote maple
#

It’s a reference?

indigo yacht
remote maple
#

Oh right I honestly forgot about that

#

Lmao

#

…I knew it would be a dumb idea

drowsy plank
#

an auric waffle's iron would require base waffle's iron to actually be good

remote maple
#

I was thinking you would combine Waffle’s Iron with Lava Chicken Broth, 49 Auric Bars, and 1 shadowspec bars. It would throw chicken and waffles that inflict the same debuffs as the broth

remote maple
drowsy plank
drowsy plank
oblique birch
#

still exclusive to GFB?

drowsy plank
#

yes

#

also it's bad because it's short range and has dogshit damage

remote maple
# drowsy plank

…why did I think the weapon exclusive to the meme seed would be anywhere near good

#

IT DOES 50 FUCKING DAMAGE?

oblique birch
#

meme weapon

remote maple
#

AND IT ONLY INFLICTS HELLFIRE. AND ONLY 33.33 GODDAMN % OF THE TIME

#

Now I feel silly for including an Auric Waffle’s Iron into my superboss concept

#

Then again it is an alt universe player

drowsy plank
#

lmfao??

remote maple
#

You heard me

#

Did I fuckin stutter?

half imp
#

I should buff waffles iron

remote maple
#

Yes.

crude geode
#

Buff waffle iron with 5 damage

frail fox
#

You should nerf it

remote maple
frail fox
#

That’s too much

remote maple
lucid marsh
#

Give it 69 damage

celest olive
celest olive
#

why do you care about balancing

fleet grotto
mild thistle
#

A

obsidian nova
obsidian nova
ripe owl
#

The projectile is quite short-ranged

lucid marsh
#

Make it longer range

indigo yacht
tepid crown
#

no

#

no

#

its totally way too strong

#

it needs to be nerfed by 1 damage

severe sparrow
#

than it might actually be decent

dire warren
#

kill this bot

hybrid snow
#

is this real guys should i go on this website guys

hybrid snow
#

liar. i will win my mr beast money

indigo yacht
#

mr breast

hybrid snow
#

mr breast give me money

fleet grotto
#

lol

#

@unkempt umbra im telling you this because you give me good vibes, this is really not the right place to self promo

humble scarab
#

aint this a bot?

#

i had seen smth like this before

fleet grotto
#

oh maybe

#

that would be sad

#

but it wasn't spammed in every single channel

weary bane
#

maybe but it's probably best to see if they even respond

humble scarab
#

ye

thin hill
fleet grotto
#

It's so sad

hybrid snow
#

probably just didnt understand the channel

errant wren
#

unfortunately that's uh

#

not a great indicator

hybrid snow
#

is this common bot behavior now

#

oh

fleet grotto
#

their youtube pfp is ai coded as fuck

#

which is strange

hybrid snow
#

truth,.

indigo yacht
#

maybe hacked

errant wren
#

it's also the exact same description most of these bots have

#

like

fleet grotto
errant wren
#

definitely a hacked account

fleet grotto
errant wren
#

it tends to happen

#

honestly one of the bigger tells for me is just the inconsistent usage of ' and ’

#

and how no real person ever says bespoke

dense locust
#

Iirc the way it’s programmed rn it wouldn’t be able to go over 60 naturally anyway since it caps the respawn time rather than setting it

#

Still a good sugg though

thin hill
fleet grotto
#

sad

thin hill
#

they could've picked any AI anime girl art and they chose hololive members moyaigaze

whole tundra
grave zincBOT
#

@kind laurel - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Switch Monk/Shinobi Infiltrator Armors to be Rogue]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

remote maple
#

Fuck yeah!

#

Good job man

half imp
#

that was actually the first change I ever saw as a dev

#

Shinobi/monk being rogue armor

drowsy plank
#

8 morbillion points to pre-mech excalibur

#

it's more like true excalibur will get bumped to post-clone

#

still works since plant needs to be dead to get broken hero swords anyway since u need mothrons right

oblique birch
#

instant upgrade after 1 boss twice from Excalibur to Terra Blade 😨

fleet grotto
#

it feels weird because like anything you do to true excalibur you also kinda have to do to true nights edge. they're counterparts, they should be on the same tier

drowsy plank
#

if it was my choice id spread them out even more but terraria already has 8 morbillion swords

lucid marsh
#

They're a tier apart now I think

gilded citrus
lucid marsh
#

Oh wait I guess that makes them the same tier

gilded citrus
#

Which is same tier

novel belfry
#

and well in order to get chlorophyte... you gotta craft a pick that requires all mech souls

#

that said, they pushed Terra Blade a lil later so uh

lucid marsh
#

Mech souls and chlorophyte being the same tier always felt weird

#

That reminds me

#

Perennial should just be chlorophyte

indigo yacht
pure verge
lucid marsh
#

True Nights edge requiring ashes of calamity does feel right, as Calclone is supposed to be roughly equal to plantera

#

Although that means that it needs to be stronger than true Excalibur, which is pre plantera

olive saddle
#

true nights is ass and imo always will be

lucid marsh
#

Then buff it

#

Make it inflict brimstone flames and cursed flames

olive saddle
#

i dont mean damage wide

#

the damn thing is so clunky

#

which is probably intended on vanillas part

#

which is very fair

pure verge
#

cal fixed it

lucid marsh
#

Oh

olive saddle
#

they removed it following the screen and not the second windup for it

#

hell they completely missed why it was clunky

lucid marsh
#

Just because a weapon is slow doesn't mean it is bad

fleet grotto
olive saddle
#

demon scythe at least does stupid damage for phm which justifies its slow projectile

#

also it mimicks the demon already which is silly

#

i personally dont really like demon scythe but its way more justifiable than true nights edge

#

true excal is generally way stronger anyways

pure verge
olive saddle
#

generally good luck hitting anything with true nights edge though but yea it is at the cost of range objectively

#

also! demon scythe works way differently! it stays in the position you cast it and doesnt awkwardly follow you

hollow shell
#

shifting the 1000 char limit pin down a slot

remote maple
#

Dang

hollow shell
#

Added voice acting to the Frequently Suggested section, sorry I'm late

drowsy plank
errant wren
#

if i learn how to mod, i'll make it a joke add-on

echo leaf
#

Voice acted Calamity

#

But it's just Microsoft Sam

#

For everyone.

errant wren
#

prikki believe me when i say that i would just have ytp-esque word smashing

humble scarab
#

My mrbeast money

keen zodiac
#

vanilla issue

gilded citrus
#

Yeah

whole tundra
gilded citrus
#

Oh

#

Nvm then

indigo yacht
#

why does calamity add this

fleet grotto
#

@languid lava

#

i knew i made a suggestion about this before

languid lava
#

nice

#

i knew i couldnt have been the first one

olive saddle
gilded citrus
olive saddle
#

yea there was a vanilla spoiler a while ago called "you fell for it" where they talk about the retiering of teleporters and pylons

royal tapir
#

what

#

Not concerned about random upcoming 1.4.5 spoilers if they're even true

#

All that matters is that in vanilla 1.4.4 they are sold by Mechanic

indigo yacht
#

1.4.5 tomorrow

#

sso delayed for another year

drowsy plank
#

for the current implementation, they're on mechanic

brittle mist
#

Calamitihh

lucid marsh
#

Vanilla already has a bajillion contradictory lines of NPC dialogue

indigo yacht
#

this is cal actually

remote maple
#

Counterpoint. Who actually plays old ones army. (Me. I do. 😭)

tepid crown
#

smthn smthn when summoner rebalance is doneish theyll will decide if this would be a good idea or not or watever

indigo yacht
#

pretty sure this already has been rejected

#

ok nvm

#

or at least it wasn't officially rejected

#

i have memories of Talking about this before and devs saying they wouldn't do it because of balancing issues

tepid crown
#

iirc they said they def wont do it now

grizzled shuttle
#

ah I see, apoligies then, wasnt aware of that lol

tepid crown
#

and whether or not its fine after rebalance depends on wat exactly theyre doing to ooa and sentries as a whole

indigo yacht
#

i see

drowsy plank
grizzled shuttle
#

really? I wouldnt have thought iit would be, but that goes to show what I know lol

misty lichen
#

theoretically this existing isn’t a problem with the armor set but the weapons using it being too good

#

like it wasn’t ever the armor sets fault really

indigo yacht
#

i think the penalty should be inverted

#

summon does full damage, the held weapon only does 0.75x or something

#

idk if that would make more sense though or be more balanced

worthy lintel
#

more sense yes, more balanced no

#

because then held weapon would turn into actual free dps

dense ferry
#

Would probably need to be WAAAAAAAAAAAAY weaker

#

To justify using Whips

indigo yacht
#

but yeah

worthy lintel
#

thats the consequence of summoner being integrated as an intended standalone class

#

it loses free dps perms

indigo yacht
#

💔

#

fucked up

worthy lintel
#

bizzare world we live in

lucid marsh
#

Hey so like

#

Why the hell not just...

#

Make summon weapons have worse base damage, and make whips and other summon gear buff them back up

north oracle
north oracle
indigo yacht
#

what if summoner deal more dmage

#

and then

#

buff

#

the weapon

gritty plaza
#

what if

#

hear me out

#

we balanced the summoner class

#

and we made it into a big update

indigo yacht
#

no

misty lichen
#

not drake gif

errant wren
#

what if

#

stay with me here

#

we removed classes altogether

indigo yacht
#

if

half imp
lucid marsh
oblique birch
#

finally?

lucid marsh
#

Oh. Maybe

lucid marsh
cinder patrol
#

hes saying thats how summoner is balanced anyway

#

(i.e: they already did do that)

lucid marsh
#

The minions can still be most of the damage, just indirectly by being buffed

#

This can happen instead of the nerf

#

If they already did that, the nerf wouldn't be necessary

distant gyro
#

what

#

first off that assumes the current balance is perfect that its possible to knock 20 base damage off every summon weapon and turn them into 20 tag

#

spoilers: its very much not

#

the point of summoner balancing now is precisely that summoner in its current state is not balanced

#

you can do that and summoner is just as unbalanced as before

lucid marsh
#

Who said anything about tag damage?

distant gyro
#

second off calamity is a mod and there is an established baseline for how much minions and whips should be doing??

lucid marsh
#

all you have to do is make the combination of all summon gear (perhaps the armors and tag) to buff summon damage by some percentage

#

you don't need a specific numerical value

distant gyro
#

the idea is the same

lucid marsh
#

yes, but it should be doable

distant gyro
#

summoner currently is not balanced

lucid marsh
#

oh, of course

distant gyro
#

contribution shifting is not solving it

lucid marsh
#

nothing gets around that

#

you still need to balance summoner

novel belfry
#

yknow

lucid marsh
#

but you can do it in a more consistient and easy way

novel belfry
#

maybe we should just stop randomly yelling at the devs about our cool new way of actually balancing summoner once and for all

#

its a bit

#

annoying at this rate

lucid marsh
#

one way or another, summoner will need to be balanced someday

#

you're best off making it as easy for yourself as possible by not relying on some bizarre conditional nerf

distant gyro
#

its gonna hinge on 1.4.5 (or whatever that updates gonna become)

lucid marsh
#

fair enough

distant gyro
#

thanks to its slew of new whips

#

and whatever fabled modifier is

#

please dont make it stupid???

#

i hope relogic is not causing some insane disaster right now

#

theres a non zero chance fabled is something like +1 minion slot while you hold the summon item and i dont see how that reality pans out

lucid marsh
#

haha yeah fair enough

lucid marsh
distant gyro
#

that one is a complete wildcard

coral carbon
novel belfry
#

i mean, if he was dying constantly to Messmer the Impaler in the background, I'd certainly understand.

#

(This is me rn)

#

FINALLY

#

IM FREE

north oracle
crude geode
#

Fans when the reference isn’t completely accurate

grizzled dome
#

but what if it's actually a reference to Sakuya's World?

crude geode
#

It still wouldn’t be accurate

umbral gazelle
#

homing knife, uhm idk what can it reference to actually

#

closest i could think of is this weapon from Soul Knight because it does home on enemy and jump between them

coral carbon
#

holy semantic suggestion

errant wren
#

i won't get too far into it but stellar knife works more like hol horse's and/or mista's stand(s)

#

but uh

#

we're not doing that

#

ever

remote maple
#

Who the hell cares. It’s funny, let it be

umbral gazelle
#

❗ jumpscare

#

what might the reason be, maybe because the manga panel i used wires

keen zodiac
#

idk why it got flagged but a full summoner rebalance is already happening in sso 2

keen zodiac
#

where

umbral gazelle
keen zodiac
#

if you just wait someone will tell you

umbral gazelle
#

a

errant wren
#

something something uhhhhh

#

not sure how i'd've gone about it

umbral gazelle
#

so, can the suggestion to remove reference use an original source image

errant wren
#

that i don't know

#

but you could maybe suggest to remove it

umbral gazelle
#

ill try it sometime soon but without using original source

errant wren
#

post the sugg here for now

#

someone will probably help

umbral gazelle
# errant wren post the sugg here for now

Remove or change the tooltips "ZA WARUDO" from Stellar Knife

I assume the lines is meant to be a reference to JJBA Part 3, in which DIO use timestop, throws a knifes, unstopping the time and cause a knifes to be accelerated, this however is vastly different to what Stellar Knife does, as in the original show, knifes dont spread, home in at enemy nor spin and instead being threw directly at enemy. I'd suggest to Remove or Change the tooltips because it is inaccurate to the original show.

#

i attached a manga panel demonstrating how the knife work in the original show but idk if that is a reason for ❗

crude geode
#

Do you remember who it was that put it on

umbral gazelle
crude geode
#

Ah

#

Byeah, this is probably the reason it got flagged

#

likely falls under the latter

umbral gazelle
# crude geode

oh i see, maybe the Change tooltips was likely the reason

drowsy plank
#

i dont remember flagging that one

umbral gazelle
#

the one with terraria shark as pfp

errant wren
#

you mean CiT?

umbral gazelle
keen zodiac
#

yeah that's cit

errant wren
#

sorry cit you've been relegated to cog 2

indigo yacht
#

what does cog stand for then

#

congrats on gaming or smth

#

congrats on gay

north oracle
keen zodiac
#

yeah that has to be it

tepid crown
lucid marsh
north oracle
#

and then hear me out again the whips could make the summons stronger

olive saddle
#

what if you just removed summoner

tepid crown
north oracle
#

ok they now deal 1/8th the damage of summons preboss

#

(RBP has 1 base damage and no debuff)

fleet grotto
#

this suggestion was accepted previously can it be like marked or something

tepid crown
#

the steampunk one?

distant gyro
#

uhm yeah

#

the rarest one

grave zincBOT
#

@languid lava - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Move the quote "Just what is that contraption? It makes my Teleporters look like child's play!" from the Steampunker to the Mechanic]

Your suggestion has already been previously passed and voted upon; if it isn't already implemented, the devs may reconsider their verdict.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

distant gyro
#

whens the last time youve seen that

tepid crown
#

uhhh

#

idk

#

quite a while

dense locust
#

this suggestion quite literally came to me in a dream

indigo yacht
#

rename to magical worm

umbral gazelle
#

rename it to Scourge of The Universe...,,,,

ripe owl
#

chat am i cooked

humble scarab
#

that might be decent

indigo yacht
#

makes no sense thematically and imo is completely unnecessary but isn't invalid as far as i know

ripe owl
#

I mean I would've gone with the labs but 1. there's virtually no overlap between Draedon's tech and wulfrum tech and 2. by the time you find the labs you don't need wulfrum

#

and idk, it feels natural to me to have it in chests

hybrid snow
#

i think this would be cool for all 5 minutes until you get sick of seeing wulfrum scrap
i guess chests are like this anyway though wires

open inlet
#

im ngl this sounds like you got unlucky and decided it was the game's fault instead of just run of the mill bad luck

ripe owl
#

nah

#

I got unlucky, recalled all the times I got unlucky and thought "hmmm this might be a decent idea"

#

but I definitely should reword the suggestion

tepid crown
#

i dont think ive ever not had scrap

ripe owl
#

yeah but have you ever not had enough scrap?

#

actually you know what, the scraps problem is easily solved with a thing you literally craft with scraps

#

I forgot about the wulfrum pylon or whatever that thing was called that summons hordes of wulfrum enemies

tepid crown
ripe owl
#

yeah, the lure

errant wren
gilded citrus
#

Arent bricks like the only consumable rogue item staying consumable

indigo yacht
#

i think they just mean the starter bag

dusty atlas
indigo yacht
#

ok nvm

dusty atlas
indigo yacht
#

idk i didnt add them

errant wren
#

i see no real reason to

#

replace the bricks in the bag

remote dune
#

i think its funny how, if i recall correctly, in the next major update, all the consumable rogue weapons are getting changed to non-consumable.. except the brick lol

keen zodiac
#

correct

pulsar barn
#

hey im new to this server so i dont really know if this is a common discussion or anything but, how do we feel adding base stealth to demonshade armor?

plush flame
#

demonshade already has plans

pulsar barn
#

oh i didnt know mb

plush flame
#

nah its fine

pulsar barn
#

ty tho

plush flame
#

it requires some looking

pulsar barn
#

👍

gilded citrus
fleet grotto
errant wren
#

honestly pretty based to have asked before doing anything

hybrid snow
#

Love a respectful question

pulsar barn
#

ok thank you guys!

hollow shell
#

holy shit I was right

#

If anything I undershot it, it's been 2 and a half

tardy geyser
#

Orderbringer is getting reworked anyway

idle dagger
#

It’s now post yharon and there’s a new animation shown in #spoilers

oblique birch
#

begone dust spam

#

Fluffy do not bring it back

errant wren
#

dust spam is now gfb exclusive

hollow shell
#

Your wish has been granted

drowsy plank
hollow shell
#

lock or even checkered flag depending on the interpretation of the dev applying it

#

or, an exclam in posting depending on the patience of the dev applying it

#

((checkered flag looks better, makes it seem like they're listening hdflr )) /joke

remote maple
#

I’m probably never going to post a suggestion.

#

Mainly cause the only suggestion i think isn’t stupid as hell/against the rules is an upgrade to Tundra Leash

distant gyro
#

i used ymd and i feel called out

keen zodiac
#

altix robot confirmed??

gloomy pivot
#

Hello guys, I am new to Calamity and I noticed that some items have "donor item" tag. I have googled it and it is said that those items are meant for players that have donated for this mod and non-donor cannot get those items. I am using also that magic storage mod and in that magic storage there is option to craft items from those boxes and I have the ability to craft those donor items. I have no idea if that is a bugg or it is known thing.

indigo yacht
#

you misunderstood

#

the items were dedicated to the patreon donors and made according to their specifications

#

but that's all

#

they're just normal items

gloomy pivot
#

Ohhhh. Sorry english is not my native speaking language so when I have read that "donor item" were made for Patreon donators I thought that only those people can get those items.

frail mantle
#

nah there's no restriction on that

#

the closest to that would be like

#

a select few weapons having different visual effects depending on your character name

#

well i say "a select few" but i don't think there's more than one in cal

indigo yacht
#

also starter bags

#

meow

indigo yacht
gray bone
#

meow

gilded citrus
hybrid snow
royal tapir
olive saddle
#

he tripped and fell in the back of mcdonalds

remote maple
#

I’ve posted in suggestions posting for the first time

tepid crown
#

u prob shouldnt mention previous iterations of your suggestion

keen zodiac
#

also there's uh

#

no reasoning

#

at all

tepid crown
#

also i would make it a lot more generalised

remote maple
#

Edited

hybrid snow
#

this could be pretty dope

remote maple
#

I just want mounts to be more useful and to get a tundra leash upgrade

drowsy plank
#

i dont know what this is asking for

#

we already have stronger versions of flying and falling mounts

drowsy plank
remote maple
drowsy plank
#

you just want a mount vanity slot

remote maple
#

I want my big doggy

remote maple
#

That’d also work

drowsy plank
#

sadly this is a Red Issue for Vanilla

remote maple
#

Damnit.

drowsy plank
#

unless someone really wants to make a mod for it lol

#

id say it's out of scope for calamity

remote maple
#

Still, I wish mounts were more useful. And more active in combat

remote maple
drowsy plank
#

reverting the mount nerfs would be nice yeah

remote maple
#

Wait they got nerfed

#

By red or by calamity

drowsy plank
#

calamity

remote maple
#

WHY

drowsy plank
#

too strong or smthn

#

i dunno if this was from fab or someone else tho

distant gyro
#

who

#

i mean which

drowsy plank
#

mount nerfs, like removing dash into unicorn, and the slime mount horizontal nerfs

distant gyro
#

i dont think those exist anymore

drowsy plank
#

good

distant gyro
#

except slime

drowsy plank
#

fair

distant gyro
#

but slime kinda had it coming

drowsy plank
#

this is true! i love overcentralizing metas

idle dagger
#

What about slime mount was nerfed anyway

fleet grotto
#

Horizontal speed

indigo yacht
#

this suggestion bad imo

#

i would prefer just making mounts passably useful rather than an upgrade system

remote maple
#

That would also work

#

The suggestion started as an upgrade to tundra leash then expanded

#

That’s why it’s upgradable mounts instead of actually decent mounts

indigo yacht
#

i think calamity should make Minecart Upgrade Kit an accessory instead of a permanent upgrade

#

that would save calamity

remote maple
#

Mehhhh

#

What about a perm upgrade that buffs mounts in general

#

Like making honeyed goggles mount able to shoot stingers

#

JUST FUCKING ARM THE MOUNTS

fleet grotto
#

just something you put in vanity and swap on whenever you do a minecart

indigo yacht
#

you dont understand

#

it would be incredible

remote maple
#

Instead we need either a perm boost or accessory that makes the mounts able to attack

drowsy plank
#

why

drowsy plank
remote maple
fleet grotto
#

Yes

#

Santank

remote maple
#

Or charging

fleet grotto
#

The fucking

#

Scutlix

remote maple
#

We need more that can attack then

remote maple
#

I meant more active attacks tbh.

fleet grotto
#

Why does it refuce fall damage to 1...

#

Just negate it bro

remote maple
#

Like shooting stingers with honeyed goggles

#

Or having Rimehound roll

drowsy plank
remote maple
#

You have control

lucid marsh
remote maple
#

Exactly

indigo yacht
#

I'd prefer the automatic attacks

errant wren
#

item that upgrades specific mounts to be ever so slightly better for movement

indigo yacht
errant wren
#

slime gets a miniscule amount of horizontal speed

indigo yacht
#

gelatinous pillion for scal

lucid marsh
#

This all seems very unnecessary

errant wren
#

the bee mount gets one extra second of flight time

lucid marsh
#

Just... Keep mounts as they are in vanilla and balance them a little better

indigo yacht
#

you know, if i had a nickel for how many times i died to sepulcher because of gelatinous pillion, I'd have two nickels. which isn't a lot but its weird that it happened twice

errant wren
#

i don't know any case where someone would use the bee mount over normal wings

lucid marsh
#

Yeah true

indigo yacht
#

mounts should have a niche of movement that can't be emulated by other accessories

#

like, witch's broom and all the mounts that work like that

errant wren
#

golf ball type mount that isn't capped in speed but you have to hit it each time like a worse version of getting over it

indigo yacht
#

bc mounts like honeyed goggles are just "what if wings but dogshit"

errant wren
#

if it's a bee i feel like it should have draedon chair movement on some walls

#

but that'd be dumb and

indigo yacht
#

it should spawn honey behind it as it flies

errant wren
#

flood the world

indigo yacht
#

calamity isnt realistic enough

#

we need to fix that

errant wren
#

mounts should have small and/or niche mechanics

#

that aren't running fast

tepid crown
#

honeyed goggles should give u honey buff

errant wren
#

equipping full bee set and bee wings makes honeyed goggles give summons knockback

indigo yacht
#

add this to the game immediately

half imp
#

@wide hull this has already been done

wide hull
#

Oh??

half imp
#

And was suggested earlier this week in here too

wide hull
#

I searched for shinobi infiltrator

#

That's amazing!

half imp
#

did you search in suggestions voting

wide hull
#

Yeah, in whole server lol

half imp
#

the posting channel is automatically cleared

#

Ah

wide hull
#

yeah anyhow lol that's really cool!

half imp
#

infiltrator is literally the title

wide hull
#

i just thought this up and you guys already did it before i even suggested it

#

amazing development speed

half imp
#

true!

hearty yew
#

I agree with this

#

I wrote a lot of draedon's dialogue initially (shayy did the rest iirc?) and I feel like an idiot for not making him use ISO format by default

#

Like why did I not think of that

indigo yacht
#

welcome back uninspired stat sticks

#

rampart has no precedent for debuff immunities, and i do not consider the names being thematically similar reason enough to worm it in there

#

the 50% health thing is alright i guess they are similar design choices

#

oh, and also just because an accessory doesn't combine with other accessories doesn't mean it needs to. this isnt fargos souls

frail fox
#

Frost Flare is one of the accessories to exist

indigo yacht
#

can we just rework it into being interesting

#

instead of trying to cram it into an accessory with next to no relationship

remote dune
#

I really dont get the idea behind the Frost Flare + Rampart suggestion. Just merge a boss-drop accessory from early hardmode into a post-Yharon one? By that point in the game, the player already has the Asgardian Aegis, and there are several more accessories that grant immunity to the same effects. The cold-resistance and frostbite infliction mean next to nothing at that stage of the game.

golden sonnet
#

wait frost flare merged with Rod of Discord?

frail fox
#

Took me a second to realize also

fleet grotto
hearty yew
#

throwing in more shit is definitely not going to help lol

frosty trellis
#

On one hand rampart does need something

#

But on the other hand I don't think this is the correct way to approach it

#

Conceptually it's fine but I also don't like just Conditional Effects The Accessory for something fucking post dog

frail fox
#

Rampart of Deities Parry or something

drowsy plank
#

why

errant wren
#

rampart of deities has a ram that works exclusively on projectiles

glass arch
#

this is called a scarf dodge

drowsy plank
#

did you know every debuff is actually just a reskin of every other debuff bc they're all just mild damage over time

errant wren
#

reflect the projectiles then

idle dagger
frail fox
grave zincBOT
#

@austere citrus - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Change and lower the particle effects of the Orderbringer]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

half imp
#

Orderbringer is being reworked

#

so that's why this has been locked

#

@glass arch I have already changed the star projectile on both Deific and Rampart to be significantly better

#

they actually do stuff now

#

I won't lock this even if it gets to voting though, but I did want to note that the stars being a useless remnant is not the case anymore

hollow shell
half imp
#

@thorn dock Frost Flare is slated for a rework in the future, although not in 2.1

#

it's not a super set in stone plan so I won't lock this suggestion when it gets to voting, but note that it is very likely to be locked or vetoed once it gets to dev server due to this

remote maple
ashen warren
#

how dare you not be able to tell the 5 cryogen themed accessories apart

frail fox
#

Unforgivable

kind laurel
drowsy plank
#

im just saying sometimes that's done for flavor

#

im not sure why you'd want to make one better than the other unless ur saying to make brain rot deal more damage or something? but the fights already seem fine

#

i guess maybe for player inflicted sources that change could be made, but otherwise i dont really get it

kind laurel
#

I just feel like it’s pointless to have two different symbols for the same debuff

errant wren
#

one rots your brain irl and the other burns your blood irl

#

obviously

remote maple
#

Sorry, I just went to the gym, I’m sweaty and cranky

idle dagger
#

that's awesome

half imp
#

yeah I changed them a while back

#

they now fire a ring of homing stars from the player

idle dagger
#

ooo

#

very cool

half imp
#

similar stars to what astral pike uses

#

it's not a huge glow up but at least you can both actually see the stars and they actually have meaningful contribution

oblique birch
#

okeee

idle dagger
#

i assume their damage was buffed

hybrid snow
indigo yacht
#

when is hook vanity

keen zodiac
indigo yacht
#

when

#

this bow suggestion is so stupid lmao

#

well, the suggestion itself is fine i guess

#

but the reasoning is circular and also complete nonsense 😭

#

@ashen warren you need to format your suggestion properly

indigo yacht
# bold crown wdym?

you're saying that it should have another weapon in its recipe because it's a night weapon (it's not), then you're also saying it needs to be renamed into being a night weapon presumably (in part) because of the former point

bold crown
#

Is it not meant to be a night's weapon? It follows the same style of recipe by needing previously obtained weapons, which in this case are also obtained the same as the components of nights edge (crimitane/demonite, hellstone, queen bee). Additionally, it's made with purified gel and at a crimson altar.

#

Also, you craft it into a post plantera weapon with living shards, a fact the other three night's weapons share

errant wren
#

ok so

#

__lunar__ian

#

and i think that falls a bit into srs territory

#

only a little

#

not quite

indigo yacht
bold crown
# errant wren __lunar__ian

I do get that, it's by no means a large problem, it's just weird the other two weapons added by calamity have the word night in their name but this one doesn't

errant wren
#

it just doesn't really seem like an issue

bold crown
#

True, it really isn't a big one, just weird

keen zodiac
#

many things in calamity are just weird

bold crown
indigo yacht
#

i think a weapon's sprite, name, and method of attacking is more important for its theming than it's crafting recipe

#

anyways i should mention that rogue doesn't have any sort of "night" weapon (unless I'm forgetting it) so the precedent isn't as weighty as it might be

indigo yacht
keen zodiac
#

it's obviously different for night/terra weapons cmon

indigo yacht
#

my argument is that the name and design and sprite of a weapon are what makes it some arbitrary "night" or "terra" weapon, not its crafting recipe

bold crown
#

It's clearly following the same theme. I mean, it's one of the only pre hm weapons that are crafted at an altar.

#

It's something it shares with the other night weapons

drowsy plank
#

we should remove a bow from it and remove lunar from its name

#

fuck the night weapon set

#

it sucks

#

me when we NEED to have a purple weapon made of one previous weapon from world evil, jungle, hell, and dungeon each

#

what if instead of that we made something actually interesting instead of just copying melee's homework again

tepid crown
indigo yacht
#

it's yellow and blue with a tiny smidge of magenta

tepid crown
#

it shoots green

#

close enough

#

wait thats only part of true nights isnt it

indigo yacht
#

yeah night's edge is just purple and black

tepid crown
#

also i love how the only night weapon to get true versions are stabber and bloody edge

#

both of which are dead now

hybrid snow
#

so for it to actually even fit with the rest of the night weapons youd then also have to add another weapon purely for the crafting recipe

#

which uh, seems unnecessary

#

and probably a reason why its not a night weapon in the first place

olive saddle
#

i think the concept of night weapons as a penultimate weapon of phm is super cool but i do think they should all have different theming.

ive always been of the opinion that if there are more zenith weapons then they shouldn't look like the zenith, but take on their own style

tepid crown
#

i agree

#

which is why lunar bow, even if a bit boring, is at least slightly better than the rest of the night weapons

olive saddle
#

i do agree with that

#

i do think mage can kinda get away with it because nights ray sounds cool but definitely not the summoner weapon

#

does rogue even fucking have one

tepid crown
#

no

olive saddle
tepid crown
#

even tho they could have one

olive saddle
#

rogue is very much something

tepid crown
#

and next update theyre getting spore knife

#

so a dagger orientated rogue night weapon could work

undone cedar
#

The night set is the shadow lance, night’s edge, and demon scythe

indigo yacht
#

this suggestion is probably invalid but ngl i kinda like it

lyric depot
#

I had multiple play throughs having HotE but they've only been sitting in the vanity after I defeated the first boss (which was dragonfolly)

errant wren
#

explode this individual

lyric depot
#

Idk if anyone uses it other than extra dmg or unknown buffs I dont know about

errant wren
#

oh that was fast

errant wren
#

"focus"

#

(man that sugg was wild)

dire warren
#

i've never used hote after my first playthrough

remote maple
#

Compress ur shit dude

indigo yacht
dire warren
#

the novelty wore off quick

indigo yacht
#

the... earlier one right

lyric depot
#

Ok cool, but like seriously, I want to use HotE and be useful for once

Like, please tell me they're you're gonna buff them or smth

errant wren
dire warren
#

i'm reluctant to even say that because the amount of time i used hote amounts to 0,2

lyric depot
plush flame
#

what if hote was 5 rare sands but they spawned orbs that healed 3hp instead of 15

errant wren
#

it was actually kind of crazy

dire warren
errant wren
#

anyways

dire warren
#

(just move around longer)

lyric depot
indigo yacht
dire warren
#

i'm a sucker for sand elemental to become ancient monolith from ebf

#

rare sand can stay, or outright removed, i don't care

dire warren
#

the others' fates are sealed, so i also don't care

lyric depot
#

I should've suggested it to be pets or smth

Making it weapons would be too much for ya'll

keen zodiac
dire warren
#

miniature elementals exist as pets

lyric depot
dire warren
#

yeah sure

lyric depot
#

Whats the word limit?

keen zodiac
#

pins google doc

dire warren
#

having 2 levitating ancient monoliths'd be funny

errant wren
lyric depot
#

Ok I tried reducing it as much as possible

fleet grotto
#

definitely under the limit now

lyric depot
#

Ok thx

#

You think it's still a valid suggestion?

indigo yacht
#

I'm pretty sure the reason only summoners use it is because it deals summon damage

errant wren
#

maybe get rid of that last sentence

dire warren
#

never used it though so i'm skeptical

lyric depot
indigo yacht
#

how so

lyric depot
#

Like, I know there are other accessories that has minions to attack for you, but it's not as bad as HotE

dire warren
#

maybe i should try using hote solo against moon lord

fleet grotto
#

Would you say Statis'' Curse, an accessory on the same tier, is redundant because it is only for summoners?

errant wren
#

i don't think that's the point they're making

dire warren
#

i think hote is ok

lyric depot
#

Statis curse actually gives you buffs, HotE? No, not that I know of

dire warren
#

it's fine, i don't think hote warrants changes

errant wren
#

passive dps in what could also just be a weapon

lyric depot
#

Ok I wouldnt say redundant as it's not the word I'm looking for

dire warren
#

damage is fine for an accessory and it does have utility that isn't clogging up your screen

errant wren
#

the one counterpoint i could raise would be fungal clump

lyric depot
#

It's more of "it should be something else"

lyric depot
errant wren
#

what even is the dps output of HotE?

dire warren
#

so you want hote to be an infected remote-esque weapon right?

indigo yacht
lyric depot
dire warren
#

anyways imma just sleep, have fun discussing this

#

goodbye

errant wren
lyric depot
#

I feel like it would fit

indigo yacht
#

it's only a summoner accessory because of its damage type

lyric depot
#

It would act like mirror of Kalandra as a single summon that consumes certain amount of slots

indigo yacht
#

if you change it to be classless then it can be an all-class accessory

lyric depot
indigo yacht
#

realistically, all the classes fight in the same way

#

certain weapons switch up the formula but there's not exactly sweeping differences between classes

#

except for like

#

true melee

lyric depot
#

Except summoner, in which has your minions fight for you unless you're a whip build

indigo yacht
#

that genuinely changes nothing

lyric depot
#

When elementals of an accessory fights for you, it definitely sounds more like a summoner item than multiclass.

#

It even has changelogs changing it into a pure summoner item, might as well make it a weapon atp

#

Unless it has future plans, I don't see a reason why not to make it a weapon except for little extra dmg/decorational purposes.

Emphasis on LITTLE

glass arch
#

oh its got future plans

lyric depot
#

Oooooo

#

Tell me

remote maple
glass arch
indigo yacht
#

why only deep diver and none of the other rams

thorn dock
#

Legitimate question

#

You think giving rams in general the true melee property is a good idea?

crude geode
#

Isn’t true melee dying soon™ anyways

thorn dock
#

Is it?

crude geode
#

Being replaced with “heroic”

#

Meant to be a more all class thing to help weapons that struggle against bosses

keen zodiac
errant wren
#

hence the ™

indigo yacht
#

I'm asking why you think only deep diver should

remote maple
#

How the hell does my dumbass suggestion have 10 stars

drowsy plank
#

why dont we make it classless

#

why is it even typed damage in the first place

indigo yacht
#

trueless

indigo yacht
drowsy plank
#

dumb

#

we've generalized plenty of damage types for other classes already

indigo yacht
#

it's just a shame we won't have funny rogue stealth around to play with it, if the type is removed

bold crown
glass arch
#

nights ray was also not initially directly a nights weapon considering it was added during the time we still had crimson variants

#

(also mage does in fact have a hellstone wand lol so that statement isnt correct anyways)

drowsy plank
#

i hope night's ray gets a name change

#

i think that is the plan anyway

glass arch
novel belfry
#

lunarian bow is a very nice name

glass arch
#

and if you wanna go really semantically petty mage also has a jungle wand in mana rose (though the argument of it being added after does apply there)

novel belfry
#

switches up the whole night weapon theming into a moon based one

#

actually

#

they should just do that

glass arch
#

no!!

#

let them all be uniquely themed!!!!!!!!!!!!

novel belfry
#

moonlight for night's ray

#

also here's the first image for moonlight on wikipedia

glass arch
glass arch
#

yes

bold crown
#

oh, it is a wand

novel belfry
glass arch
#

nights weapons ARENT CORRUPTION THEMED

drowsy plank
#

it's not even corruption

novel belfry
#

or at least being SEEMINGLY corruption themed

half imp
glass arch
#

we agreed on this WHEN WE REMOVED THE CRIMSON VARIANTS ALMOST TWO YEARS AGO

drowsy plank
#

night's is part of dark lance's hell themed set

half imp
glass arch
#

solar makes sense its directly part of a melee armor set
soc is the odd one out

half imp
# half imp Questionable

Specifically: True Melee might not be dying entirely, but still used for some things to differentiate effects

#

a la Hide of Deus stars

#

Heroic would be separate

half imp
#

Dang it plaguebringer armor does summon damage with the ram

#

it would have been hilarious was it melee

remote maple
#

Make it melee

drowsy plank
#

dont do that

indigo yacht
#

yeah, dont make it melee make it true melee

drowsy plank
#

make it deal thrower damage but not rogue

fleet grotto
#

WOAH MR BEAR

royal tapir
#

@fleet grotto Altix did this already when they adjusted Blood Orb recipes in general

bold crown
#

Isn't it still 40 though?

distant gyro
#

that reminds me why do alcohols even have blood orb recipes like half of them are ale

frail fox
#

When you're too lazy to farm unicorn horns so you get 40 blood orbs instead

bold crown
#

oh

#

i forgot you can still make them like that

frail fox
#

Bless you Sunny

distant gyro
#

whatever go my brewery system

frail fox
#

Go my cloth drink

distant gyro
frail fox
#

It's convenient if you have a surplus of blood orbs but very little glass to spare!

umbral gazelle
distant gyro
#

mineral water

umbral gazelle
#

true

distant gyro
#

Literally

umbral gazelle
bold crown
#

lol

indigo yacht
#

Add more cats to calamity

I see no way this could possibly backfire

keen zodiac
#

your wish is my command

catboy xeroc

novel belfry
#

canonically xeroc was a catboy before he became god

gilded citrus
#

Catlamitas

gray bone
celest olive
#

why is the dark spark not aimed right its angering me

#

its not shooting the beams out of the tip

fleet grotto
olive saddle
#

kinda based donor

#

make copy of weapon

#

aim it the wrong way

#

literally two tiers later

#

done

#

master of ragebating

keen zodiac
indigo yacht
#

@pulsar burrow read the suggestions document in pins/channel description

half imp
#

how did I never know this

#

That's so obvious

keen zodiac
#

tbf i didn't either until someone pointed it out but i'm very much not a music person

indigo yacht
#

i love music but i only listen to artists nobody has heard of or video game soundtracks

pulsar burrow
keen zodiac
#

that's like
the main thing

#

also your suggestion is improperly formatted

#

and you don't really explain what you want

half imp
#

I do agree this would be cool but I'm not up to the task of making it work

#

Fighting vanilla code yikes

keen zodiac
#

john code my gravity globe

hybrid snow
#

who is john code

indigo yacht
#

my brother

royal tapir
#

Wow it's John Code and John Cat

ripe owl
indigo yacht
indigo yacht
indigo yacht
#

good suggestion i think

glass arch
#

very good suggestion

#

can we get a citfix on this clueless

obsidian nova
tepid crown
#

so like

#

that whole thing was unintentional lmao

obsidian nova
#

Yeah but you gotta agree that it fits your idea pretty much perfectly AnahitaAwe

obsidian nova
tepid crown
#

yes

#

its their previous message

indigo yacht
#

i wonder if anyone will actually vote for this

#

i hope so it frustrates me immensely

#

just feels like an ancient relic from like 2017

#

or something

indigo yacht
#

ok apparently it was from 2018

tepid crown
#

2018 boss design...

frail fox
#

Well actually

tepid crown
#

that does not make it better

frail fox
#

2023 boss design

indigo yacht
gilded citrus
#

fabsolian boss design

indigo yacht
#

fabsol boss design

#

damn i was way too slow on that one

frail fox
indigo yacht
#

we need to make defiled great again

errant wren
#

fabsolian is a great synonym for bad

#

anyways

#

make weak petrification completely remove wing time XD

drowsy plank
#

make weak petrification reach through the screen and break your hands

#

good luck moving now idiot

royal tapir
#

It pretty much did everything it could to destroy vertical movement in the past already

drowsy plank
#

@pure verge what does this mean

pure verge
#

playing 2 classes at once

#

pretty much

drowsy plank
#

i know what multiclassing is what is this suggestion even asking for

pure verge
#

encouraging it

indigo yacht
#

seems too broad/too much effort

drowsy plank
#

there's already generic armor sets like reaver and accessories, explicit multiclass sets like forbidden, frost, gem tech, and you can just like. use more than one weapon if you want so like

pure verge
drowsy plank
#

what are you trying to say

pure verge
#

idk

#

add more of those?

drowsy plank
#

single classing is what needs the incentivizing that's why everything is designed around it

otherwise you could just use whatever weapons you want

pure verge
#

honestly thinking about it I have no idea what I was thinking lol

drowsy plank
#

like you can already multi class and it's strong bc u can say fuck class limitations

#

use summon staff with a mage weapon and armor while also having a high velocity gun to apply ichor with bullets or something

#

like that's already good

indigo yacht
#

tbf that's mostly just summoner + mage

drowsy plank
#

you do regen mage and use the gun while ur mana is recharging

indigo yacht
#

fair

pure verge
drowsy plank
#

i dont know it

thorn dock
#

Asgardian aegis is kimda the only lategame acc and must have for resistances.
I think adding resistances to another lategame dash acc could be beneficial/ balancing?

#

It holds tons of resistances and nothing comes close

indigo yacht
thorn dock
#

Not another

#

Thought about adding laudanum to statis void sash? Ninjas a master in the craft of poisons and therefore also beeing educated in antidotes

#

Would perfectly fit the design and could help getting closer to asgardian aegis

indigo yacht
#

that would make it locked behind revengeance mode which i don't think the developers like the idea of

thorn dock
#

Activating rev mode is easy right? You could just farm slime King for example

#

It easily obtainable

indigo yacht
#

that's besides the point and anyways you still can't get it on classic

#

i don't think the developers want people swapping difficulties but only temporarily for an accessory that's meant to be accessible

thorn dock
#

Do ppl even play classic

#

again you could just open another map and farm it super fast there

#

I dont see an struggle

indigo yacht
#

quite a significant number actually, more than i expected

thorn dock
#

Again I see no struggle

#

The benefits seem to overweight

indigo yacht
#

laudanum is already part of a crafting recipe anyways

#

you can go ahead and suggest it but I'm 90% sure it will be shot down by developers

thorn dock
#

It would grant resistances to another late game dash acc + it perfectly fits the ninja theme

#

I like your opinion but I would like to get another one on this

indigo yacht
#

how does an addictive painkiller fit the ninja theme

grizzled shuttle
oblique birch
#

Summoner is the strongest class right now

drowsy plank
#

will admit, aegis being the bandaid for vanilla debuff design and also just having a million billion resistances is kinda fuckin weird

indigo yacht
#

why the fuck does glove of recklessness give stealth regen

#

isnt it the spam one

#

ok actually it could maybe swing either way now that i think about it

misty lichen
#

no it’s the spam one

#

it sucks

frail fox
#

Rog 💔

indigo yacht
#

Rove of Glecklessness

glass arch
#

the only reason its really considered a must have for resistances is because some of the effects it gives immunity to suck complete and utter ass

#

which is something that can be changed

#

its a lot less of a bandaid to make stoned a not horrible debuff than it is to add immunities to a different lategame accessory

thorn dock
#

For some reason it offers 33(?) Resistances?

#

2nd place offers 15, but isnt even close to an endgame item

#

Adgards valor aside, since its the same line

#

Without considering the aegis line or the rev items,
hide of astrum deus makes the 3rd place, offering 4 resistances... 😅

lucid marsh
#

Hey, idea: what if the aegis line made you just very resistant to debuffs, instead of immune to them

#

While specialized accessories and/or armors provided full immunity

#

For a basic idea, it could be something like...
Aegis:
Debuffs that modify controls, vision, or stats (blindness, confusion, broken armor, ect.) have their duration reduced to 1 second and you gain temporary immunity to each one after recovering from it.

Debuffs that deal damage over time have 75% reduced damage and no longer nullify your life Regen.

#

How does that sound?

crude geode
#

Sounds like people would still just default to it at every opportunity

crude geode
mystic sandal
#

i think itd make most sense to have the asgards line make you immune to like, the annoying debuffs youd really rather just not deal with at all

#

stuff like confused, mighty wind, poisoned, silenced, stoned, etc

#

while other accessories could have the more impactful immunities like holy flames

glass arch
#

because its not the debuff immunities that make it good

#

it would still be ridiculous even without the debuff immunities because of the simple fact that knockback immunity and a ram