suggestions-discussion

[echo leaf]

They do...

[teal yarrow]

unlike some others like murky paste

just imagine a solar veil cape that acts as wings
or just plain silk furniture

[drowsy plank]

why dont we just kill the overhead

i know perennial is getting a significant rework we could just replace the perennial stuff with interesting items instead

also like i dont think chloro and reaver need MORE overlap

[fleet echo]

does the rework include the armor

[worldly saffron]

reaver helm and headgear are really nice sets as is tbh, but pretty much everything else perennial is in some desperate need of reworking

so I hope not

[echo leaf]

visage is also peam

the entire reaver set is great

[prisma sedge]

I feel like this has been suggested before

[whole tundra]

Figured I slightly edit the post and repost it as Fabsol is gone now

It got posted over half a year ago and did not make it to voting anyway

[worldly saffron]

yes paintings 💗

love the idea of depicting locations and characters before the events of the game

[indigo yacht]

something something #1178515062030348308

[drowsy plank]

if perrenial dies can we just make chloro post-plantera

also im not sure if this is because the weapon is weak i think it is because it is an instragrade

[indigo yacht]

although they're still both tmelee

so it would be weird to try and give one a niche

[drowsy plank]

yeah they're literally identical but one is just Better

pheonix blaster...

2!!!!

[indigo yacht]

give excalibur projectiles

[analog nest]

It’s more the issue of it being completely obsolete, I think it needs a progression change or something

[tepid crown]

make excal drop from the first mech you kill (and also make it unshimmerable until all 3 r dead)

done

[analog nest]

Yes

Great idea

[severe sparrow]

i find it funny that Excalibur in Calamity is completely pointless

[analog nest]

But it’s so sad 😭

[indigo yacht]

deja vu

[drowsy plank]

it's just like handgun in vanilla

[indigo yacht]

why do we care about excalibur though

honestly

[severe sparrow]

because they nerf its speed dramatically (i think for more damage)

[severe sparrow]

fair enough

[analog nest]

It’s more about the hollowed weapons in general, a lot of them have chlorophyte upgrades and so there’s no point in making them

[indigo yacht]

I'm not sure that's true

[drowsy plank]

nah i mean the rest of them are fine

they do different things

chloro shotbow and hallow repeater are different

[severe sparrow]

i like Gungnir

an upgrade to it would be cool

[drowsy plank]

yeah and gungnir is true melee while chloro partisan is a projectile weapon

[indigo yacht]

do we really need excalibur to be a viable weapon when it would probably just end up being upgraded after you kill mechs, rather than letting other true melee weapons shine

[drowsy plank]

gungnir already upgrades into botanic piercer

[indigo yacht]

i know that it's just filler right now but like

[analog nest]

Hallowed repeater

[drowsy plank]

anything to get less people to use avalance for it

[indigo yacht]

you already know the solution I would suggest

[drowsy plank]

yeah it's a repeater and chloro is a shotbow they're different

[analog nest]

Damn

Well

I’m just an Excalibur fan girl

I gotta do more research next time, I thought I was so smart walking in here

I love the feedback though

[indigo yacht]

why not just make excalibur a boss/mod drop or something and remove the crafting recipe

i know that cal doesn't like doing that to vanilla items and frankly I don't either

but it would be less jank than some of the other solutions

[drowsy plank]

actually looking at post-mech1 melee maybe the excalibur from first mech thing isn't a bad idea............

[indigo yacht]

submarine shocker my beloved

[analog nest]

Ik there’s already a sword in the stone but you could totally put it in a stone maybe when the hallowed generates? Like a structure, or next to the shimmer, and your only worthy after you defeat one mech boss or defeat wof

[frail fox]

Vanilla actually clearing the cal weapons in quality

[drowsy plank]

brimstone sword is good but even the vanilla ones are kinda like

man what are we even doing here

yelets

[indigo yacht]

king arthur tried to kill destroyer and then died horribly and you pry his sword from the boss' armor when you kill it

[drowsy plank]

mushroom spear

[indigo yacht]

also wtf mushroom spear

[frail fox]

Mushroom Spear my goat

[drowsy plank]

truffle shop

[indigo yacht]

i have not seen that weapon in ages

actually insane

is it even good in vanilla? I don't remember

[drowsy plank]

every time i see inferna cutter on here i die a little on the inside

no i dont think so

[indigo yacht]

😭

[severe sparrow]

garbage
Gungnir forever!!

[indigo yacht]

post mechs i fear...

[tepid crown]

no because its competing with other post mech 1 stuff

which is

hallowed

[severe sparrow]

Gungnir is pretty much better in most ways than MS spear

thats why it is almost never used

[indigo yacht]

so then it would be good if hallowed wasnt real

[analog nest]

I have included feedback in the suggestion

[muted geyser]

Oh crap you are a genius, honestly I forget about the vanity slot , 5 stars for genius on you dude, and also it wouldn’t require that much (or any) farming you gotta kill yharon like 8 times to get every weapon and accessory for your class anyways

[thorn dock]

Thinking about a suggestion for the unused forbidden armor

Iirc it doesnt even appear once in the class setup guide for the entire HM

I think it soley has some place for invasions and thats it

Saw the reaver minion suggestion and thought that might be a good idea for forbidden armor too, giving its minion any kind of attack, to somehow get atleast close to mollusk armor (since the sandstorm doesnt really cut anything for these fights), in terms of early HM Boss Fights

These are its bonuses, calamity add non summon damage penalty if a magic weapon is used

Niche active skill paired with overall low set bonuses

[hollow shell]

Do you think you should clarify that the sandstorm tornado ability doesn't "count" as the kind of attack you're thinking of?

I assume you mean an active automatic attack like the Chlorophyte Crystal

[thorn dock]

Think that was obvious

[hollow shell]

Maybe

[thorn dock]

Should I rewrite it to some kind of passive attack perhaps?

[crude geode]

Yeah

[thorn dock]

👌 done

[hollow shell]

Aight nice thank you

[thorn dock]

Youre welcome

[novel belfry]

or honestly

[thorn dock]

Mollusk just does too well over a decent span, also embracing beeing used on different classes. Kinda direct competition

[novel belfry]

make the sandstorm actually last instead of disappearing when hitting an enemy 3 times

make it a real sentry

[drowsy plank]

tornado is already good but yeah i think that would make it actually like

not a pain in the ass to use

the tornado projectile could probably die too just make it spawn at the cursor

[thorn dock]

Any Kind of adjustment is appreciated, competition is just too good. Ppl just leave the set behind in current state

[dense locust]

forbidden is fine as a hybrid set

[thorn dock]

It kinda isnt really nice to use in my opinion, other sets outclass it easily.. atleast what I think

[dense locust]

I mean are you using a hybrid build?

[thorn dock]

It also has no mention in the class progression guide, other vanilla sets are frequently listed

[thorn dock]

Yes I have tried it in such setups

[dense locust]

in said setups its comperable if not outright better than daedalus even without using the storm

at least from what I tested

[grim tusk]

at first i thought it was forbidden circlet and was like this is exclam, but forbidden in general is fine

altho this is probably a 🔒

[crude geode]

Suggestion bingo returns

[grim tusk]

im surprised we recently got a sugg that literally fucking beat exolotl in terms of rule breaking

and exolotl was doing it intentionally

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/720282640795828405/889604323368140880/unknown.png

[keen zodiac]

which one

[gilded citrus]

Which one

[grim tusk]

was on monday i think

[keen zodiac]

i remember it happened but forgot specifically what it was

[grim tusk]

i remember it was a SIS, SRS, multiple suggestions at once, no reasoning, recipe, specific values, reversion, Zenith sugg

[gilded citrus]

Oh that kinda rings a bell with zenith sugg

[frail fox]

Gonna say there’s a 95% most of these changes get removed eventually anyway

[novel belfry]

okay all i hope for is early hm enemy nerfs get removed becuase it completely neuters why i like early hm

which that its a massive difficulty spike anyways

[echo leaf]

I think I can concur with a lot of these

[novel belfry]

that said "respawn timer being 3 seconds when no boss is active, vanilla tool (mining) speed changes" being on the chopping block scares me because uh

these changes are nice

[echo leaf]

blood orbs and accelerated respawn time are very welcome

[amber rover]

don't have to disable them if you like them, thats the point of a config :)

[novel belfry]

true

[echo leaf]

oh, oh I misread the suggestion

[novel belfry]

now that i think about it

[echo leaf]

YUeah if there's a config option to turn that sorta thing on or off then I'm much more interested in letting them go

[frail fox]

Also can’t you already set your respawn timer in the configs or is that something else, or is it just stupid

[novel belfry]

something else probs

[amber rover]

yeah, i get theres loads of people who like this and people like me are in the minority. i just enjoy the progression between bosses and building more, and im coming back to the mod now that fabsol is gone and seeing all these changes is just a bit much. no hate if you like them, and the weapon differences and stuff like that are cool n all

[amber rover]

this is only true for the respawn timer during a boss fight

[echo leaf]

yeah, even if blood orbs were fabsol's idea i'd really hate to see them go

[amber rover]

idk why, i just like the longer respawn during normal gameplay as well

[echo leaf]

(ask me about my blood orb farm!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

[willow widget]

i wouldn't FUCK BLOOD ORBS

i hate them with a burning passion

[crude geode]

No

[echo leaf]

it makes dying in normal gameplay actually feel problematic

[willow widget]

[novel belfry]

you are lame

anywhow

[willow widget]

mr i afk 42 hours for free pots.. smhmmm

i'd rather fishing be more involved

[echo leaf]

why afk for 42 hours when i can afk for 42 seconds...........

[willow widget]

than having blood orbs, cuz blood orbs are like peak lazy imho

[frail fox]

Just fish for blood orbs all month

Very fun

[echo leaf]

it was fun to optimize a blorb farm

plus it makes getting them in really big quantities easier

for a normal playthrough getting the important ones normally would probably be faster

[crude geode]

Ok but blood orbs are inherently replacing two other activities in the game

[novel belfry]

Okay but, currently the best farm for blood orbs is blood moon fishing

also, gotta mention this again

NOT EVERYONE LIKES FISHING

[echo leaf]

really?

[willow widget]

i think fishing should have like some use

[echo leaf]

how many blorbs/hr can a strong bloon fishing farm get?

[novel belfry]

as in you can just fish out the blood fish enemies and they drop more blood orbs

[willow widget]

like even if its JUST for potions

[echo leaf]

I really like fishing, I use it for money and resources

[novel belfry]

especially dreadnautilus

dreadnautlius drops a metric ton of blood orbs

[echo leaf]

I do not like mining for Cryonic and stuff

[echo leaf]

but he hurty and owww and like, thinking and stuff

[novel belfry]

im fine with fishing sure, but i also like fighting enemies and especially bosses to farm a resource en masse

[echo leaf]

i built a blorb farm which kills enemies. gets around 3,000 blorbs per night, plus sellable drops for extra cash

[novel belfry]

thats the cool shit

[gilded citrus]

How many blorbs per second is this

[echo leaf]

about 60

[idle dagger]

I think dreadnautilus drops like 160+

[gilded citrus]

50 second bloodmoon nights be crazy

[idle dagger]

maybe more

[dense locust]

you could remove the true melee boost entirely and nothing would change

[echo leaf]

hold on my math is like

really, really bad

[novel belfry]

true, but i think removing something out right is a bit sad

[echo leaf]

uhh

[novel belfry]

especially since... yknow

[echo leaf]

okay my math was really bad

[tepid crown]

replace it with nothing scarf doesnt deserve it

[echo leaf]

it's not 60 blorbs/s, it's 5.55 blorbs/s

[novel belfry]

issues with one particular dash accessory being busted not just because of its dash being especially op, but also because its pretty much a must-have defense accessory

[echo leaf]

i do agree that the scarf's true melee damage is kinda ???

[novel belfry]

thats it
6% crit chance

[echo leaf]

especially since true melee can use rams to make close combat free-er

[tepid crown]

explode

[echo leaf]

but is a counter scarf sugg okay? it's dedicated content

[novel belfry]

no thats the upgrade

[tepid crown]

ur thinking of evasion scarf

[novel belfry]

thats actually why i avoided mentioning evasion scarf

[echo leaf]

Ah

[novel belfry]

cos

yknow

[echo leaf]

Okay I'm like

brainless

[novel belfry]

(also why is it still called counter scarf)

[crude geode]

Holdover probably

[indigo yacht]

L

[willow widget]

#1 blood orb HATERS

ong

[indigo yacht]

The only part of blood orbs i like is that you can get them from blood moon fishing

i think thats cool

[novel belfry]

I think we need to have ravager drop blood orbs clearly

[drowsy plank]

blood orbs are now a dedicated blood moon fishing enemy drop does this fix it

[willow widget]

post polter and we're good

[indigo yacht]

anyways...
#suggestions-posting message i dont think forbidden needs a buff, and also i think minion set bonuses are incredibly tired
#suggestions-posting message uhhh ngl this seems like an excessive effort suggestion but i dont have a problem with it
#suggestions-posting message FUCK true melee ALL my homies hate true melee

[indigo yacht]

mostly

[willow widget]

it'd be so cool if fishing was awesome

[indigo yacht]

i don't mind terraria fishing

i think it's well overhated

it's definitely not good by any stretch of the imagination but it's fine enough

[willow widget]

i think the issue is that you start with absolute dogshit

[indigo yacht]

just boring

[errant wren]

i'm like one of the 6 fishing players

[willow widget]

which pushes you away from actually doing the good fishing

[indigo yacht]

i think that's probably part of it

[willow widget]

like really

eater of souls is like not good

[indigo yacht]

calamity just hands you really good bait and a super good fishing rod right off the bat

[willow widget]

and thats why everyone skips to golden

honestly

just buff fishing rods in general

i think that'd be a pretty good change

[dense locust]

golden rod should be like 65 tbh

[willow widget]

honeslty more maybe

[indigo yacht]

personally

[willow widget]

100 ong

[indigo yacht]

i would make fishing power less effective, but then... i guess give the player a base fishing power? if that makes sense

idk how to word this

fishing power does less but you also catch fish faster and better by default

[willow widget]

ways to get more bobbers

[indigo yacht]

i was making a fishing overhaul mod

[errant wren]

10 base fishing power, then make the actual power less powerful

[willow widget]

cuz one is soooo sooooo sooooo slow

[indigo yacht]

except it doesnt actually make fishing better it just makes it worse

[willow widget]

[indigo yacht]

how do you feel about summoning every boss duke fishron style

[willow widget]

silly

[errant wren]

the nefarious battle rods mod

is that even still relevant?

it's been years since i've played with it

[willow widget]

no clue

like if i want to fish i need mutant mod

cuz holy shit one bobber is so painfully slow

[indigo yacht]

i fish without any qol

[willow widget]

awful

[errant wren]

it's slow with no fishing power

[indigo yacht]

i don't fish without golden rod

I'll say that

[willow widget]

so true

[indigo yacht]

i wish alluring bait was vanilla

[willow widget]

but thats just true tho

alluring bait is awesome, being able to catch multiple potion fish is awesome

[indigo yacht]

it's dumb for them to add staff of regrowth and alchemy table but not have an equivalent for fishing

yeah

maybe I'll make an actually serious fishing mod sometime idk

[willow widget]

add stardew fishing bar to terraria....

or something along those lines

[indigo yacht]

i was thinking about it

maybe a config option, it'd be good practice for making guis

[golden sonnet]

#suggestions-posting message I did remove it from pierce resistance which helps a decent bit, but I didn't test it super thuroughly

[misty lichen]

why would you do that

i think that’s a terrible idea for balance sobs

[golden sonnet]

it already has a hit cap

and a duration limit

[thorn dock]

Best way to get an astral desert if the Meteor didnt hit the desert?

[willow widget]

clentaminator + astral solution

[prisma sedge]

Something worth noting is that the repair unit is going to get a cage in the future, presumably in the next update

I'd assume that'll extend to nanodroids, but I'm not as sure about that

[sleek sable]

i see

do i need to compress it more

[glass arch]

no

checking it rn its at ~880 characters which is under the limit

[thorn dock]

Oh, forgot that thing exists. Ty

[willow widget]

[sleek sable]

alright

#suggestions-posting message
for this one i can agree with, but some vanilla changes are good
though if people don't see that, they can always disable it

[fleet grotto]

i think the contact damage change is strictly a good change but idk

[sleek sable]

same

makes it make sense

[fleet grotto]

it allows for more fun and interesting gameplay

strategies

running through crabulon for instance (i always do that)

[sleek sable]

yea but it is wonky at points
like the armed zombie can't hit you when in the air

[prisma sedge]

Wait, really?

[sleek sable]

it may have been fixed

[fleet grotto]

ipointed that out once eand made an (unpopular) suggestion about it

still not fixed no

[fleet grotto]

#suggestions-voting message

[sleek sable]

oh

[sleek sable]

i kinda thought this would actually pass votes

[olive saddle]

i dont

its jarring and weird and throws me off so much

its also explained no where and can leave people confused as to why they didnt die

and then die because they're confused

i very much wish there was an option to turn that shit off

[novel belfry]

i think the real issue is that its so ubiquitous

and yet theres ZERO indication that an enemy is able to contact damage you or not

[olive saddle]

that too

[novel belfry]

IMO uncontact damage should be a boss-specific feature

[olive saddle]

its weird and jarring and theres no indicator as to when and its explained no where and its just a mess of a feature

[prisma sedge]

Personally, I appreciate it on slimes

Getting randomly hit by them while running across terrain is just more annoying than anything

[misty lichen]

and it still happens

all the change did is make them not a threat 80% of the time

[indigo yacht]

i mean like

if it's moving towards you usually it will deal damage

i think contact damage changes make survival outside of boss fights more dynamic since now there's an extra dimension to enemy encounters

at least, in earlygame

it doesn't really matter later in the game

[errant wren]

the whole contact damage thing is kinda eh because like

[misty lichen]

it’s whatever it was just way overdone

[errant wren]

you can also just not get close enough to experience it

i don't remember the last time the no contact damage thing saved me, if it ever did

[lavish condor]

I feel like at it's best it's "oh neat" and at it's worst it causes confusion and maybe mod conflicts

[novel belfry]

I appreciate it for stuff like Crabulon, but like

ye

[errant wren]

maybe if it was just, better, or something

[lavish condor]

it doesn't really have a purpose for existing other than "it's not realistic for these enemies to have contact damage" in a game where there's a rainbow biome with pixies and unicorns

[errant wren]

i mean for enemies that stand still i get it

[misty lichen]

it’s another calamity vanilla change that’s like

“ok i guess?”

[errant wren]

i think the problem is mostly just that it's not... visually apparent?

i don't really know what the problem is with it

i mostly just stay away from everything either way

[lavish condor]

unless you like spend the time to learn when an enemy has contact damage and when it doesn't then treating it like a dark souls boss it's better to just treat it as always having contact damage

and cal gives you enough strong weapons and defense and enemy nerfs that learning enemies isn't at all necessary except for very very early game

[indigo yacht]

that's not true

regardless of implementation the reasoning for it was obviously not about fucking realism

[gritty plaza]

What's the problem with 3s respawn time

"oh yeah I love staring at my screen doing literally nothing for 15s, riveting gameplay"

[errant wren]

doesn't give the enemies enough time to run away with your money, obviously

[hybrid snow]

Not sure if this is still a thing but I remember there being issues with bosses not despawning in time with a shorter respawn time

Which kinda defeats the purpose of like

Losing the fight

Other than that though i can't think of a single reason to have a 15 second respawn time 😭

[gritty plaza]

But boss respawn timer is longer than normal anyway

Last time I played it was 15s until the boss despawned then it jumped to 3

[hybrid snow]

Wait the default timer is 15 seconds?

Ohh

Yeah that's what I'm saying

if the respawn time while a boss is alive was only 3 seconds a lot of bosses wouldn't despawn in time

But I agree 15s is annoying in any situation

[mystic briar]

Hey guys, is there any good mod to make my world seem beautiful? Like remnants mod. Just heard that remnants mod is risky and can delete some of the calamity biomes

[gritty plaza]

#other-mod-talk

And yeah remnants does mess up the calamity world gen iirc

[hybrid snow]

elemental blaster is shit it deserved the axe more than anything in this mod ❤️

[olive saddle]

^

boring ass weapon

also this is a reversion suggestion

[amber rover]

personally I don't like it, I think it makes dying in regular gameplay feel less impactful, in multiplayer even more so as you can die during exploring with a friend, respawn, then come right back (with full hp!) to help, which might not be possible in vanilla. I get if this isn't a big deal for some people who are more focused on boss fights but that's why I suggested this being a config option. no other big content mod does this change, and obviously vanilla is balanced around those things which calamity changes

[gritty plaza]

How does being forced to wait for 15 seconds make it impactful

It's just boring

[amber rover]

I've just given an example? it makes it impactful the same way you aren't able to respawn instantly as soon as you die - time passes, enemies move, gameplay gets affected during that time

[olive saddle]

i wouldnt mind if the respawn time was 10 seconds but three deels a bit much

15 is a while but 3 feels too quick

[amber rover]

i get it if you feel this way. a config slider wouldn't change this for you

[olive saddle]

i will say respawning was a bit annoying later down the line, mostly with moon events in a no calamity playthrough

otherwise respawning being 15 is fine

[amber rover]

all the more reason why there should be room for personal preference - i never suggested one way to be preferred over the other, just the ability to choose what you want your gameplay to be like

[river lily]

"add the removed thing" suggestion

@main oxide Your suggestion dosen't provide any actual tangible objective reason why re-implementing the blaster would be good other than your subjective liking of it. Removed content was removed for a reason

..How'd they even "Readd" it? Superradiant slaughterer is quite literally a rework of it.

[fleet grotto]

second elemental ranger weapon!!!

i will admit that i like the elemental blaster

feels like a remnant of old calamity that was satisfying

[distant gyro]

i will remember elemental blaster for blasting your eyes with that one use sound

i mean ears

fuck

functionally you

use sdmg with chlorophyte bullets i guess

[severe sparrow]

yeah my ears wanted to die whenever i used that thing

it also had terrible visuals and was incredibly boring

[fleet grotto]

i liked the visuals

it just felt nice to use

(but this is no way me supporting this suggestion i just liked the weapon)

[severe sparrow]

it was easy to use
I'll give it that

[severe sparrow]

the visuals were... fine but very dated

[fleet grotto]

it was one of those good dated things imo

like storm surge (literally my favorite ranger weapon)

[severe sparrow]

i agree storm surge is pretty decent

its visuals arent bad

it isnt a bad weapon overall

[drowsy plank]

okay yeah this; please read the rules in the pins @main oxide

also imo homing dust blaster looked awful and played awful

i do not know why you would want it back

[frail fox]

Adding it back to annoy cit

[hybrid snow]

He specifically commented on my use of it on guardians

[hybrid snow]

Sounded awful too...

[drowsy plank]

3 for 3 on being terrible

it just needed a bad sprite and it would be completely irredeemable

[fleet grotto]

redeemable to me...

[hybrid snow]

Perhaps the least controversial weapon rework in calamity history

Except for this guy I guess

[fleet grotto]

if there are 10,000 elemental blaster fans, i am one of them
if there is one elemental blaster fan, i am that fan
if there are no elemental blaster fans, consider me dead

[hybrid snow]

The worst hill to die on

This has to be rage bait

[olive saddle]

im an elemental blaster fan too...

except the sound

weapon and sprite were cool though

the newer version is better but id be lying if i said i didnt appreciate the old one

[hybrid snow]

The weapon was just a dust gun 😭 😭

[olive saddle]

the mindless homing for free was so nice

[hybrid snow]

I guess that was a redeeming quality

[fleet grotto]

i just liked the weapon

superradiant slaughterer is just better though lol

[gilded citrus]

Chlorophyte sdmg with rainbow dust over it

[whole tundra]

I liked Elemental Blaster

Was it interesting enough to stay? No

[royal tapir]

Exploding

[frail fox]

I escaped thankfully

[royal tapir]

I’d win

[hybrid snow]

❤️ love ❤️ 💥

[olive saddle]

exactly how i feel

it was uninteresting and mindless fun

hold m1 and look in the vague direction

stupid and dumb weapon

[hybrid snow]

hence good riddance

[indigo yacht]

isn't the respawn time already a config option in calamity?

oh only for boss fights

Nycro's Nohit Efficiency has an override that works at all times

[tepid crown]

@formal arrow u shouldnt mention previous suggestions in your suggestion

[indigo yacht]

^ technically future content

[formal arrow]

word? mb

[indigo yacht]

this suggestion is fine but the reasoning rn is kinda just "it would be cool" so you should probably fix that as well

[formal arrow]

main reasoning was “there really ain’t much here rn” but i’ve adjusted to accentuate that point

[drowsy plank]

that is the opposite of a redeeming quality why would we want MORE options where you turn your brain off terraria is already such a "hold m1 and a horizontal movement key to win" game

actually the more i think about this the more i believe ele blaster might've been one of the worst weapons in the game

[hybrid snow]

lowkey true 😭

4 for 4 on things that made this weapon dogshit

[tepid crown]

its peak cuz i said so wdym

[grim tusk]

also why tf do you want blaster back?

just use sdmg with chlorophyte or smth if you want to turn off your brain

[grim tusk]

pretty sure no one complained about Animosity rework

[hybrid snow]

its one thing to like the blaster, its batshit to me to prefer it over the rework 😭

[tepid crown]

i havent seen anyone complain about butcher being turned into buzzkill

or speed blaster rework

[indigo yacht]

butcher was dumb as fuck im glad Its dead

[hybrid snow]

i forgot what it even used to do icl

[idle dagger]

I'm crafting a sugg right now to make bloody worm tooth generalized to all classes instead of melee only
There isn't a severe lack of melee accessories pre hard mode is there? I feel like there isn't

[indigo yacht]

i complain about this one but that's just because i think the dash should be tweaked so it's more practical bc otherwise the weapon is super fun

[hybrid snow]

hasnt someone already written this

nevermind i hallucinated that

[idle dagger]

not that I'm seeing

[indigo yacht]

technically 4, counting counter scarf

[tepid crown]

it used to have a rifle burst as a right click, now the right click is the sniper shot (which only got slightly changed i think) and its left click is a shotgun

[indigo yacht]

it's now occurring to me how many fucking accessories rogue has

jeez

[hybrid snow]

id say theres a few too many pre hardmode melee accessories

[indigo yacht]

there's 4

[hybrid snow]

oh you said

[indigo yacht]

one of which is counter scarf

so that's basically all class

[hybrid snow]

are there any ranged accessories pre hardmode?

[indigo yacht]

1

it's ass

[hybrid snow]

right

[indigo yacht]

well, it's probably fine for preboss but not much later

[hybrid snow]

i think melee has a bit of an overallocation of accessories rn

[drowsy plank]

rusty is like

fine

it's ok

it's not dogshit anymore but there's no real reason to use it over just like. shark tooth. or luxor's

[tepid crown]

just make it look good

duh

[drowsy plank]

it's really funny
ranger's accessory situation is so bad that even the few it does have are like. actively detrimental to run

like rusty is just mid, quiver is actually worse than most generic damage boosts because it doesnt effect ammo like they do, etc.

[tepid crown]

magic quiver?

[idle dagger]

how many accessories does mage have prehardmode

[hybrid snow]

quiver doesnt affect ammo????

[idle dagger]

Isn't like an immense amount technically speaking

[drowsy plank]

yeah it's only the bow itself

[hybrid snow]

if i post a suggestion thats just "buff ranger" is that too vague

because holy 😭

[drowsy plank]

yeah ele quiver is fine bc it's generic but the rest of the quivers are kinda just Bad lmao

[hybrid snow]

pov quiver of nihility

perhaps the most niche accessory thats actually not terrible

[tepid crown]

didnt vanilla make it additive instead of multiplicative in 1.4.4 or smthn

[drowsy plank]

idr

[idle dagger]

I was gonna say to not count nature's gift seperately from mana flower but I feel like there's definitely people who use nature's gift and not mana flower to avoid using potions

Idk I've never played mage in calamity

[hybrid snow]

good dont

[tepid crown]

yea lol

its just 10% dmg (on specifically bows) and 1 extra update (on specifically arrows n stakes)

[hybrid snow]

its just... so bad

[tepid crown]

does cal even make stalker quiver an upgrade like wat they do to recon

[idle dagger]

yes

normal quiver's % boost is lower than vanilla

[tepid crown]

oh ok

does uhh

[idle dagger]

the fire quiver is like 7% and then stalker is 10%

while base is 5%

[hybrid snow]

five???

[idle dagger]

instead of 10 across the board, I believe

[tepid crown]

this extra update also stack with archery potion

[hybrid snow]

why is this a thing

[tepid crown]

oh no the velocity on archery isnt done with extra updates

thankfully

[idle dagger]

the same thing happens with sniper scope and the upgrade to that

the putrid scent one has the normal 10%

[hybrid snow]

would this be a #1178515062030348308 thing or a #suggestions-posting thing

because why is this even a thing

[idle dagger]

Probably balance? Since asking to change it would be since they're 'too weak' or somesuch

You don't have to beat a boss to instantly upgrade it or anything but you do have to fight a corruption/crimson mimic (and then ecto tinkerer if crimson)

I think it's less of an issue for sniper scope since you'll be very well equipped to deal with mimics at that stage of the game

Something similar happens for all the mana accessories
flower, cloak, etc

[indigo yacht]

i think that most of these exist bc they don't want to give ranger a lot more crit/damage than other classes

which honestly why not

[tepid crown]

@idle dagger YOUR LONG

[idle dagger]

Ultimately if this gets passed onto the devs and then accepted I will then suggest an upgrade to Bloody Worm Scarf

[tepid crown]

🎃

[idle dagger]

did I use the wrong your

OH

IT'S TOO LONG LOL

thanks I genuinely didn't even notice

wait this is too long? I must've not been around for another word lenght limit

lemme check pins

oh characters not words

guh

There we go

[thorn dock]

Question actually is, is it rather balanced around its unconditional bonuses?

[weary bane]

victide armor is being reworked next update

[thorn dock]

Taking it down, ty

[indigo yacht]

i dont like this suggestion

I'm not sure it really has reasoning, either

[misty lichen]

no it’s true

there is no reason it should only work while also on the ground

really it should also probably work while moving very slowly

[indigo yacht]

the suggestion lacks reasoning written into it

it wouldn't exactly be hard to add it but it doesn't really have any rn

literally just "it doesn't make sense"

[dense frost]

It needs reasioni

[indigo yacht]

i just hate the "increased stealth regen when standing still"

[misty lichen]

ok ill do it better

Allow stealth's "generates faster while stationary" mechanic to work while airborne
Despite how useless on bosses it sounds, this mechanic is actually very nice to use when bosses are stationary or not firing projectiles at the player, or any other situation where the player can stand still generally. However it won't work while stationary and airborne at the same time, like when using a hovering wing or flight mount. This effectively kills the mechanic by Post-ML where most fights are fully spent in the air, and the only reason it doesn't work in the first place is due to jank in terraria code with how it calculates player velocity. Allowing the increased generation to work in these situations would make aggressive stealth play at these stages more interesting and accessible, alongside just making sense for what the "stealth" mechanic is supposed to be.

@teal yarrow hey

[teal yarrow]

sup

wo

ill take it down

[misty lichen]

oh i thought youd just edit the original message to it but that works too

[teal yarrow]

eh ok

yk maybe a semi-easy fix for this would be to link the standstill mechanic to the in-game speedometer

charges faster while speed is 0

charges slower the faster you move

very simple
i think

[misty lichen]

i think its under the same rules as shiny stone rn

as in it copies the vanilla thing for that

[half imp]

If we used shiny stone logic for stealth it would work when hovering

[teal yarrow]

so u have a separate line of code just for stealth standstill

[main oxide]

Sorry Cog, my bad

[sleek sable]

a little thing i would hope for is to how stealth generation based on movement speed rather than moving in general

you may have already implied that and i just misread but idk

[lucid marsh]

Hey, random idea I had when I saw the phrase "true melee bonus"
What if you had an accessory that boosted your damage or crit chance the closer you are to an enemy, or the closer you are to something that would damage you by touching it?

This would be sort of like a "bullet grazing" bonus from some games

[tepid crown]

warbanner

[echo leaf]

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1112873622562947104/1367885914801569792/Warbanner_of_the_Sun.gif

[half imp]

That is literally warbanner

And also Rage

[lucid marsh]

That's not very similar. Those give you a bonus that increases gradually, right? This would exclusively be if you almost touch a bullet

Like deltarune's tension thing

[gritty acorn]

@idle dagger #suggestions-posting message

no

there arent enough melee accessories in prehm

although imo bloody worm scarf, it being viable until devourer of gods is crazy

[misty lichen]

bloody worm tooth is just like feral claws but slightly different

and having an accessory dropped by a boss only work for one class is lame

[dense locust]

bloody worm tooth is really funny because if it wasnt melee specific it would just be kinda blatently overpowered

[misty lichen]

itd just be a shitty emblem

scarf would be overpowered yeah

but tooth not rlly

[dense locust]

10 damage 7 def is like almost a cshell

[frail fox]

True, evil2 has maybe the worst 2 expert accessories currently in terms of, idk overall design and being interesting

[misty lichen]

you mean moon stone

[dense locust]

I mean cshell for any class that isnt melee (10 damage 2 crit 7 def + some regen)

moon stone is 10 + 2 and then less defense

[idle dagger]

I had it as a note at the bottom of the suggestion originally but I deemed it unecessary to state what is probably the obvious, but I expect them to alter the numbers of bloody worm scarf if the change goes through and am not asking for it to be directly changed from 10% melee attack to 10% attack

I honestly don’t know how much 10% dr is in calamity but 10% attack as a boost holds up way longer than I remember and 7 defense is rather respectable

[drowsy plank]

so tin enchant?

[ripe owl]

Tin Ench is deal crit and get more crit

[lucid marsh]

So also completely unrelated

[errant wren]

deviantt heart or whatever

idk what we're talking about

[lucid marsh]

Let me try and explain it very clearly, because nothing else in the game works like this:
Each time you get close to an enemy but don't get hit, you gain some kind of stacking buff. If you actually get hit, you stop gaining the buff while you have I frames.
This buff might get used up as you attack, that's probably the best way to do it.

This incentivises you to get close to attacks without actually hitting them. For example, weaving between bullets like a touhou player instead of running away to make dodging easier. This only works because the buff stacks for each thing you "graze" in this way and is kept for a bit after you gain it

With other things in the game, you just get a simple bonus for being at close range, and it is gradual, so you're encouraged to just tank things

[drowsy plank]

Graze attacks to gain up to x1.25 increased damage
Damage bonus decreases over time and is fully lost on hit
https://fargosmods.wiki.gg/wiki/Sparkling_Adoration

[lucid marsh]

I guess gameplay wise it's most similar to adrenaline, but even then it's not the same thing, just has a few similarities

[drowsy plank]

okay sorry wrong fargos item its sparkling adoration

[lucid marsh]

Oh. Ok probably that

Yep. Something like that would be a much better way for various "when near enemies" effects to work

In deltarune instead of a stacking buff you basically gain their equivalent of mana (which doesn't regenerate on its own)

And use that for special attacks

Oh lol the one in Fargos uses the deltarune sound effect

Anyways yeah I think calamity should do this too. It might fit best on something like counter scarf

[indigo yacht]

why

[misty lichen]

no

[lucid marsh]

It makes for good gameplay

[misty lichen]

it’s the touhou sound effect

both steal the touhou sound

the gimmick also doesn’t work effectively in calamity which doesn’t have interesting projectile patterns

dlc already proves this slightly

[lucid marsh]

Oh

Well then, make calamity have interesting projectile patterns

[indigo yacht]

https://tenor.com/view/my-goodness-what-an-idea-why-didnt-i-facepalm-the-simpsons-gif-17489109

[drowsy plank]

coming 20XX

[hybrid snow]

add another x to that

[errant wren]

XX20

[elfin crescent]

why they made blightet cleaver so dog shit

how im supose to kill golem

[humble scarab]

Use a diff weapon

[elfin crescent]

alr

[dire warren]

[indigo yacht]

@jolly oracle is this an actual serious suggestion

[jolly oracle]

Yes

[indigo yacht]

okay read the suggestions document in pins/channel description

this breaks a couple rules

mostly the specificity and the suggestion scope ones

[stable kiln]

its kinda peak actually

[oblique otter]

12504

[indigo yacht]

nobody is going to get that reference

[stable kiln]

um i got it

[indigo yacht]

you're done twenty two underscore that doesnt count

[crude geode]

Yeah I have no clue what this is referencing

[indigo yacht]

its nohitcord lore

[drowsy plank]

terraria minigame bosses real lmao

[echo leaf]

whenever someone mentions exo box

you need to say 12504

it references an old calamity bug where exo box could hit a speed of 12504 mph

[crude geode]

Ty nohitcord

[frail fox]

So true

[fleet grotto]

this honestly feels like a nothingburger suggestion

[tepid crown]

what?

they should be named

[drowsy plank]

what

@lapis canyon why

oh wait what

they're labelled as providence??

that does not sound right

[lapis canyon]

yes

[tepid crown]

theyre asking for provis guardian summons to be renamed when they should already be

[lapis canyon]

they are

[drowsy plank]

i dont think that's true

im pretty sure the guardians have their own names and hp bars which are properly labelled

this sounds like some kind of bug or something

[keen zodiac]

def a bug

[drowsy plank]

do you have a screenshot bc this should probably go in #1052323733961977947

[drowsy plank]

oh they're still labelled with their appropriate titles

[fleet grotto]

providence healer

(it heals providence)

The only one that doesn't make sense is providence offense imo

[drowsy plank]

i mean tbf the only one that doesnt make sense is "providence offense"

[fleet grotto]

other two are fine

[lapis canyon]

ill prob edit the suggestion later. could word it better but its 3am now here

[echo leaf]

The internal name for the Guardian Commander is ‘OffenseGuardian` iirc

It confused me when I first saw it

[indigo yacht]

(they're lying)

i don't mind this suggestion

don't really care but it would be neat for guardians to be less of a "fuck you i have stat boosts too" phase and more interesting

[crude geode]

Guardians is certainly a phase that exists

[indigo yacht]

tbh

I'd rather just ask for a guardians rework because I'd be surprised if the names weren't changed alongside their role in the fight

I'm not sure what it would be reworked to

maybe something similar to scal brothers or the more popular suggestion of just enabling her to do more attacks

personally i wouldnt mind moving the biome attack differences to the guardians, healer already does crystal rain and commander does the big laser

[gilded citrus]

Aint the biome stuff exploding eventually

[indigo yacht]

everything ever is exploding eventually i fear

[gilded citrus]

well yeah like everything of calamity is outdated

[errant wren]

#suggestions-posting message ... huh.

i uh

hm

you see i just don't see anything wrong with the sugg

but i also just feel like something's off about it

[keen zodiac]

it's treading the line of SIS

[errant wren]

but at the same time it's not really doing that either

[fleet grotto]

honestly

i think this is a better role for an alcohol

[errant wren]

maybe it's the reasoning...

actually yeah

would stop alcohol from being stat sticks

[keen zodiac]

alcohol's already being overhauled

[errant wren]

anyways

[keen zodiac]

ping doze in cst for more info

[errant wren]

i don't think something that buffs a random niche would be too bad

-# (why are there multiple laser pointers on me)

[fleet grotto]

don't worry

old fashioned and screwdriver already exist

[gilded citrus]

is removing an item allowed by the rules doc iforgor if so

[fleet grotto]

i believe so

it's about bringing back removed items that's not

[misty lichen]

i’ve gotten things removed from suggestions in the past so

[frail fox]

Yeah it’s happened

[olive saddle]

are there any other plain and generic phm rogue damage accessories

[ashen warren]

dogtooth now upgrades into vamp talisman pretty sure

[indigo yacht]

🥀

i was hoping it could die

can it be replaced 🥺

[echo leaf]

dogtooth is pretty cool

makes some attacks deal 1 more damage than they would otherwise

[fleet grotto]

Wulfrum Battery

[whole tundra]

#suggestions-posting message I feel like this post could get some better writing

[echo leaf]

Deefinitely

I'm not really a fan of the suggestion but I think it's possible nonetheless

[misty lichen]

even then it can probably still go

like whats it gonna inherit, one debuff?

doesn’t change much of the reasoning

[misty lichen]

sheath

sheath is really boring

but you take these steps one by one

bloodstained and filthy glove too

all of these items are just stats in uninteresting ways (raiders tali is stats in an interesting way)

[indigo yacht]

in concept i disagree because i think the idea of more increasing max stealth is interesting, but it's not really done much with

[drowsy plank]

i thought a lot of the bad rogue accessories were become all class anyway

and i thought vamp talis was one of those

[misty lichen]

i was told it’s rogue

[frail fox]

It’s still rogue yeah, Shade mentioned it maybe becoming non-class a few months ago but it’s just rogue still

Sand Cloak and Feather Crown will stop being rogue next update though

[idle dagger]

Vampiric talisman feels like rogue’s version of deadshot brooch, fire gauntlet, sigil of calamitas, etc

Despite that it’s not used in nanotech

I made a suggestion about that a few months back

[idle dagger]

Feather crown will stop being rogue?
What…will it do instead?

[crude geode]

Spam projectiles

Same thing it’s always done

[idle dagger]

Huh, fair enough

[frail fox]

Mage

[idle dagger]

Oh what

[indigo yacht]

take from rogue,

give to mage (or ranger I suppose)!

[lucid marsh]

Awesome

Rogue sucks ass and should never have existed

It's basically fabsol's nepo baby, right?

[novel belfry]

No that's Sprime

[lucid marsh]

How many hours of dev time spent fleshing out a replacement for a class that relogic removed for good reason?

[indigo yacht]

i think there's a minor difference between half a class with no interesting mechanics and a full class with a unique gimmick that separates it from every other class

[lucid marsh]

The difference is an extra year of work

Calamity shouldn't be "the rogue class mod"

But it is

[novel belfry]

Well, it's not that.

[lucid marsh]

Could have fooled me with how much work went in to it

[indigo yacht]

and this is a bad thing why

[novel belfry]

Why is it a bad thing to create an entire new class?

You also have to factor in that Rogue was a thing BEFORE throwing got nuked from terraria

It IS TRUE that Rogue has an awful lot of pointless accessories

However, it's likely that the devs will prune them significantly. i mean, one of them was just discussing that.

[lucid marsh]

Which is why I meant that it shouldn't have been added in the first place. Everything that rogue has would be better implemented on other classes to make them more interesting

It's just ranger but with another fancy meter

[novel belfry]

a fancy meter for a fun mechanic

[lucid marsh]

Now that it exists the best option is to give those mechanics all to the other classes

Including the meter thing

[novel belfry]

i think it's a neat class-defining mechanic, altho it def needs to be updated to be available at all times without armor

[lucid marsh]

But hey, I might just be insane

[indigo yacht]

is this like sarcasm or something

maybe i really do need tone tags

[novel belfry]

he seems serious

[indigo yacht]

huh

okay then

maybe i dont need tone tags after all

[idle dagger]

I feel like calamity is more well known for the bosses and music than rogue

But I can't really say since I'm not outside perspective

[novel belfry]

I sincerely doubt that Rogue is what Calamity is known for

Calamity is known for bosses and music, indeed

[indigo yacht]

rogue is definitely significant but yeah it's much more well known for the music and like dog and maybe yharon

[novel belfry]

not "Hey we brought back a dead class and reworked it"

[idle dagger]

I guess it's moreso that the bosses and music are something you are guaranteed to interact with while playing it while rogue is another class option

[novel belfry]

which btw

OTHER MODS

HAVE DONE THIS TOO

Thorium does this

[indigo yacht]

thorium isnt real sorry

[indigo yacht]

you hallucinated it all

[novel belfry]

i dont even need to say it

[indigo yacht]

this mushroom is very odd

[novel belfry]

mayhap

it could be housing unusual radioactive elements...

like...

like...

[indigo yacht]

oddness

[errant wren]

the element

of surprise

[grim tusk]

@misty lichen this sugg is an insta lock

1- I should really give a hint to use spam strikes while the armor crunch is up since the duration of it is short as fuck (intentionally so stealth goesnt benefit from crumbling)
2- Combines with Raider’s Talisman into Vampiric Talisman next patch

[misty lichen]

1 is not much of a reasoning at all

2 already got mentioned but i still don’t see how that makes it invalid

[lavish condor]

the sugg isn't invalid but it would get a lock because removing dogtooth would conflict with current dev plans (combining with raider's)

[grim tusk]

not invalid suggestion

^

[misty lichen]

sorry mispoke

don’t see how that makes it a lock if the only thing that happens is the upgrade inflicts a debuff

that can just as easily go

[grim tusk]

Raider’s got buffed a lot next patch

New Vamp Talisman is like this:
Critical Strikes Heal you
Rotten Dogtooth’s Crumbling is upgraded into Armor Crunch + Hemorrage
Raider’s boost has synergy with both Rotten Dogtooth and Talisman’s life steal

[idle dagger]

Shade is vampiric ever plausibly going into nanotech or is that like extra unlikely now that it has additional effects

[grim tusk]

plausibly in rogue update when Moonstone fucking dies

we are still discussing

[idle dagger]

Good to know

Thanks

[grim tusk]

but Vamp talisman being absorbed is likely

[frail fox]

Isn't moonstone dying like

Soon

[grim tusk]

™️

[echo leaf]

good

[errant wren]

clearly vamp talisman should add 1 flat damage against vampires

[grim tusk]

Nanotech’s rework will depend on other accessories being reworked

but next patch as it is rn Nano is losing Raider’s temporarily

Plagued fueled pack (and thus blunder booster) will get a glow up; likely absorbed into Nanotech

[frail fox]

(Becoming mage)

[idle dagger]

Makes sense
When in the timeline is the 'rogue update'? Or can I find that in spoiler talk somwhere

[idle dagger]

Oh that's dope

OH extra dope

I liked using those when I tried out rogue but it was hard to justify over other things

[grim tusk]

blunder atm is mostly used cuz of the dmg boost, i can clearly see why

plagued fueled is not used at all

[errant wren]

might finally do a rogue run when that happens

[idle dagger]

I enjoyed my time as rogue

I've tried out melee ranged and rogue in calamity

I'm not gonna do summoner until SSO since it's going to be majorly changed anyway

[grim tusk]

summoner will be in SSO part 2 if it aint delayed further by 1.4.5 taking too long

if 1.4.5 takes too long we’ll see if rogue is done first

[olive saddle]

your taking too long...

[idle dagger]

Oh yeah I forgot SSO is being split into parts now
Where can I find info about what's in each part, if there is any? Somewhere pinned in spoiler chat?

[grim tusk]

Probably

[ashen warren]

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/406493898341613568/1375362852357144587/2025-05-22_23-38-41.mp4?ex=68599fb9&is=68584e39&hm=26e2dfb66128023afc4e6e72e72fdf70bd2f20ea212585dd4d19094001c3401b&
i made a mockup of it just for fun

should still be sitting on a private branch somewhere

[grim tusk]

this wont do

or well this partially can help

but boosters will not work like that

they give too little control atm

[ashen warren]

it was just a reskin of the current dash

but it works as a baseline

[grave zinc]

@thorn dock - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Terragon Spawn Rate Decrease Removal]

It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@smoky jewel - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a way to prevent the Cultists from spawning at the Dungeon]

It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[thorn dock]

🎉🤗

[misty lichen]

isn’t this a lock anyways

[hybrid snow]

is it? i genuinely dont know i tried searching for someone talking about it but didnt find anything

[gilded citrus]

Dog is getting quite a bunch if touchups by doze to make the fight tolerable
Idk if sounds was one of them tho

[indigo yacht]

a sound cue wouldn't even be helpful

[hybrid snow]

now how does that make sense

😭

[indigo yacht]

"with this sound i now know that the boss has shot a fireball during the phase where it constantly shoots fireballs"

[hybrid snow]

its just a timing thing

like with lasers you have a visual and a sound to know when the lasers are coming

with fireballs you have no sound and barely any visual

so youre just guessing as to when the fireball is actually going to ram into you and kill you

[indigo yacht]

just circle

[gilded citrus]

I do agree sound would be nice to have

[hybrid snow]

just add a sound 😭

[indigo yacht]

it's not going to make the fight any better

it will do nothing except potentially make it more annoying bc now you have a sound playing every 3 seconds

[gilded citrus]

It would be better to have then not

[hybrid snow]

i mean it wouldnt make it good but it would make it better 😭

[indigo yacht]

.

[hybrid snow]

as if lasers dont already do that

[indigo yacht]

lasers dont happen every 3 seconds

[gilded citrus]

Or hitting dog with the metal hit

[hybrid snow]

literally

[indigo yacht]

i also hate both of those what's ur point

[hybrid snow]

[indigo yacht]

the boss already having a problem doesn't excuse adding another of the same fiber

[hybrid snow]

tbh i feel like a sound design problem is distinctly less of a problem than genuinely bad gameplay

[gilded citrus]

Eh i think it depends on the sound they would use if it would be annoying or not

[hybrid snow]

like you can have not annoying sounds

[indigo yacht]

you are vastly overestimating how helpful a sound cue for this would be

[hybrid snow]

it doesnt have to be metal pipe clanging.mp3

[hybrid snow]

perhaps

still would be better to have than not

its definitely not a big change that would dramatically change the tune of the fight

its just a little annoying that its not already a thing

[indigo yacht]

(because the fireballs are stupid

[hybrid snow]

this is true

maybe just remove fireballs

[gilded citrus]

This would be better but as i said dogs already getting touchups on gameplay

[stable kiln]

removing dog tooth makes sense but i will forever miss the old dog farm

[keen zodiac]

just remove rotdogs entirely atp

they suck

[misty lichen]

yeah

[stable kiln]

but the dog farm

real ones remember

[fleet grotto]

Am I going crazy or does he literally do?

[hybrid snow]

he does not unfortunately

if he does its like inaudible

[astral sage]

just replace fireballs with more lasers
problem solved

[hybrid snow]

just remove dog

[indigo yacht]

TRUE

[fleet grotto]

shit I need to get my dog challenges done before that happens

[fleet grotto]

the quiet

[tepid crown]

IS THAT LIKE

FLAMELASHES SOUND

😭

[misty lichen]

terraria woosh sound

[indigo yacht]

[tepid crown]

OH MY GOD IT IS

[indigo yacht]

i was going to ask whether or not dog actually already did have a sound cue but i havent fought that boss in like i think a full year

[misty lichen]

it’s probably just not audible when he’s offscreen so

shoutout to Item20

[fleet grotto]

They definitely are!

You just need to turn of all music.

:)

[tepid crown]

and also

[tepid crown]

not use any item

at all

[fleet grotto]

true!

[hybrid snow]

Oh wow okay i didn't know that

Might have to delete the sugg lol

[fleet grotto]

Probably not.

It's incredibly quiet regardless.

[hybrid snow]

The fact that I've never heard it before right now is probably not a great sign

Might just change it to be like "make it louder" instead

Like the lasers are deafening compared to it and music just completely drowns it out

And God forbid you're like using a weapon and doing damage

[keen ore]

magic storage has released an update that simplified adding custom storage unit tiers, so will suggesting adding those in Calamity be a good idea?

[echo leaf]

Custom storage unit tiers as in, like... higher tier chests with greater capacity, for example?

[tepid crown]

no the storage units for the magic storage system

the boxes u need to place

[echo leaf]

still not really sure what it is about

[errant wren]

i mean

[echo leaf]

regardless, double check the rules and if you don't think it breaks any, suggest it anyways. Worst case scenario it just gets no traction

[keen ore]

instead of multiple chests with different capacity you have a system that unifies all chests into a single storage

[errant wren]

beyond the base magic storage tiers

[echo leaf]

Ah, I understand that

[errant wren]

i just don't think it's really necessary for cal to add anything above

i do remember that i had something that made it so you could craft the terra tier with cosmolite bars

not sure what mod did that though

[keen ore]

alright then, I guess then it's not really required

[errant wren]

yeah honestly

getting like 4 blue chlorophyte is pretty good

beyond that starts being overkill

[keen ore]

dude by the end of my latest walkthrough I had 10k+ capacity of MS and it still wasn't enough

[echo leaf]

i have no earthly fucking idea what the hell you are storing

[keen ore]

that says a lot about our society

[echo leaf]

I have a quarter million blocks of dirt and over a hundred thousand blocks of stone

I have almost four stacks of dungeon bricks and plenty of miscellanea, like statues and banners and...

one block of disenchanted aerilate

crabulon plushie... two announcement boxes... three hundred money troughs... ninety five titanium crates...

[keen ore]

I'm actually surprised you don't know about MS mod, it's among the most popular mods for terraria

[echo leaf]

i do have magic storage

[keen ore]

kek

[echo leaf]

my entire storage unit is 1,014 once I cleaned up those money troughs

actually how many stacks of dirt do i have

just 29?

does the dirtiest block count

[drowsy plank]

if you want

anyway yeah i cant see any reason calamity would do this

if magic storage wants to make custom tiers for calamity mats, sure, but like

once you have like 20 terra storage units wtf are you gonna need more for

maybe if one of those fuck off big modpacks actually worked it could be useful but

[errant wren]

you'd have to be going out of your way to make the storage get that full

[indigo yacht]

maybe im weird but i feel like you deserve to be punished if you're holding on to so many thousands of items that even the best magic storage storage tiers arent enough for you

like holy fuck

there's a trash slot for a reason

[echo leaf]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

I right now think I have too much shitty junk around

like a Deus mask and a.. diamond ring for some reason. some dyes... the entire butcher set???

[indigo yacht]

🔥

i like hanging on to cute vanity tbf

[indigo yacht]

like yeah whatever organization takes effort i wont argue about that but literally just getting rid of things that are completely useless to you is NOT something you need your hand held for

[gritty plaza]

But hoarding is funny

[indigo yacht]

how are you hoarding over 10000 items

[echo leaf]

having like, 2,000? okay a little excessive but whatever

[tepid crown]

mfs who have never heard the sell duplicates button

[errant wren]

i have autotrash on for like

pointless items

so i guess i never have that problem

[echo leaf]

thank you video game for giving me more blinkroot seeds i really need more blinkroot seeds game thank you

[indigo yacht]

honestly if there was one qol mod (besides the two i already use) that i would consider using it would be autotrash

[indigo yacht]

me and my ceaseless hunger potion

[errant wren]

i don't need a second boss mask

[echo leaf]

what do you do already? QoT covers autotrash

[indigo yacht]

boss checklist and recipe browser

:ombg

[echo leaf]

boss checklist spotted

https://tenor.com/view/hammer-nope-hit-gif-25244680

[indigo yacht]

yeah whatever i swapped it to lite in like half of my modlists

[tepid crown]

boss checklist lite