suggestions-discussion

[royal tapir]

Top 10 biggest lies

[ashen warren]

See above for an example of lying

[frail fox]

Glad we both agree cit is lying

[royal tapir]

That’s what a liar would say

[novel belfry]

whats gotd?

[frail fox]

Cit’s favorite weapon

[ashen warren]

The best attunement

[royal tapir]

Game of the Day

[royal tapir]

https://tenor.com/view/will-you-change-your-ways-or-will-you-weep-for-forgiveness-to-an-audience-of-deaf-ears-scone-gif-24806421

[frail fox]

help.

[stable kiln]

I TRIED COME ON

[royal tapir]

It doesn’t matter how hard you try if the weapon at its core is unusable

[stable kiln]

yeah but i still did

[ashen warren]

It is good for Aureus now

[stable kiln]

youre a real one gps

[ashen warren]

Just needs a ridiculous setup noone would possibly use

[wide river]

Give it 7 million damage
This will make it good

[royal tapir]

I commend you for trying to repair a totaled car with Elmer’s glue

[stable kiln]

sometimes you have to fit a circle inside a square

thats a lie dont do that

[ashen warren]

Extra updates are the answer to balancing every weapon

[royal tapir]

https://tenor.com/view/genius-scott-the-woz-ikea-waffle-iron-genius-waffle-iron-gif-22093637

[ashen warren]

If you give it extra updates it's magically balanced

[frail fox]

Hey cmon, it’d maybe be viable for calclone on a water floor if you could aim it

And yeah super Viable aureus weapon please nerf!

[royal tapir]

Yeah I’ll nerf it by fucking deleting it so I never have to hear its name again

[novel belfry]

OHH

its gesture of the drowned

poor lad

[stable kiln]

its not poor, it steals from the poor and gives it to the rich

[wide river]

Robin lad

[stable kiln]

you get me

[frail fox]

Not if my change.org petition has anything to say about it

[novel belfry]

well, Done.

I'm Overdone.

Do what you will with that knowledge.

[wide river]

Where's underdone

[royal tapir]

Image of running faucet with pair of scissors trying to cut the water

[stable kiln]

i'll make 1 million alt accounts and vote with each of them

wait nevermind i misread

i will not vote for it even once

[frail fox]

Too late

[stable kiln]

worst day ever?

[copper turret]

wait isnt gotd gesture for the drowned

oh yeah that one is annoying cuz you cant aim upward

[north oracle]

Terrifying sentence

[drowsy plank]

what if instead of being bad we made gestures good instead

[dense locust]

why is it taking so long to delete

did the bot fall asleep

[echo leaf]

I was about to suggest an acidwood toilet, but then I realized Calamity only adds three toilets

[wide river]

There has been a suggestion about this somewhat recently #suggestions-discussion message
However, suggestions that involve adding furniture or tiles often rely upon someone making the sprite for them, which can take a while

[echo leaf]

You're right! Thank you for pointing that out

Now would it be a good idea to suggest someone shrink the acidwood chair? It's 2x2 instead of 1x2

[distant gyro]

if someone makes toilets ill get it in

somehow theres one coming up in the next update

[drowsy plank]

any furniture gets in by some generous soul spriting them in calart

[drowsy plank]

fair point on the anvil thing

it made more sense when they were made at a mythril anvil still

[echo leaf]

[wide river]

The whole suggestion being full of comma splices hurts the writer in me

[echo leaf]

It just got fixed :)

But I like the suggestion

[frail fox]

Blood Boiler is post-Providence not polterghast just to be clear

[celest nymph]

Mb

But for devourer of gods that is what i typically use

Ranged

[wintry gale]

what does the oversight tag in bug reports means?

[wide river]

Stuff like "this buff gives 10% damage but the buff tooltip says 20% increased damage"

[wintry gale]

outdated information basically

[golden sonnet]

Or shimmer skips

[wintry gale]

shimmer skips?
like, the decraftation progress breaks?

[golden sonnet]

For example the now patched ability to get a hardmode weapon in pre hardmode by using shimmer to decraft things

Oversights is just anything that is technically working as intended, but causes issues

[wide river]

It's also used to point out minor inconsistencies and oversights that got overlooked from changes, often unintentionally
Before, these would get sent in suggestions, but they got moved to #1052323733961977947 because that means they don't have to get through a voting period to achieve the same result

[golden sonnet]

Like the now patched ability for gem tech armor to never lose gems with chalice of the blood god

[median scaffold]

Well, should the staff thingy from Deus in GFB be reported as an "oversight"?

[golden sonnet]

GFB is intentionally full of skips

[median scaffold]

Fair enough

[golden sonnet]

GFB isn't real

[median scaffold]

GFB is real and I will force you to play it

Without progression skips

[golden sonnet]

I've already played it, still not real

[golden sonnet]

Oh hell no.

[median scaffold]

So, you basically played a black screen?

[wintry gale]

so
lets say that theres a gimmick which works based off a variety of items
but theres a specific item that in theory should be included taking into acoount its functionality, but currently isnt
that would be tagged as oversight
correct?

@golden sonnet

[golden sonnet]

Uhhh, wanna just say specifically what it is?

[fervent orbit]

it would be more useful if u stopped saying hypothetically

[wintry gale]

superheated blood/lavashark not being counted as water physics ignoring stuff

meanwhile shrimpy truffle/baby fishroon and hardy saddle/turtle are

[golden sonnet]

Not counted as for what?

[median scaffold]

[golden sonnet]

Abyss breath?

[median scaffold]

Uhh, am I the stupid one?

[wintry gale]

ye

[median scaffold]

I saw that

[wintry gale]

wasnt for you

[golden sonnet]

Pretty sure superheated does reduce breath loss

[wintry gale]

[median scaffold]

I know

[wintry gale]

it doesnt

i already tested

[golden sonnet]

At least it says so on the tooltip iirc

[median scaffold]

I think that's an oversight, then?

[golden sonnet]

But yes, if it doesn't reduce loss that's an oversight

[median scaffold]

Wait

[wintry gale]

aight

[median scaffold]

You mean I could just do a #1178515062030348308 oversight thing and not a suggestion back in pre-2.0.4.001?

[fervent orbit]

does superheated blood work in water?

[median scaffold]

It should be

[fervent orbit]

o

it does

interesting

[golden sonnet]

Bug report not balance issue, but yes

[wintry gale]

it is a shark

[median scaffold]

...uhh, could I transfer this to bug reports as an oversight, too??
#suggestions-voting message

[fervent orbit]

no

[median scaffold]

Oh, wait a second, not the right suggestion

The keybind one:
#suggestions-voting message

[golden sonnet]

In my opinion yes

But I know shade has stated they don't entirely like the forum being used for oversights as the line for what is one is more blurred

So that's entirely up to them

[median scaffold]

I just feel like people will get sick of me because of this one suggestion. That's just some... "wow" self-confidence

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, I feel like that suggestion does have a ton of grounds

[wintry gale]

actually
nevermind
it used to not be included
i just thought it was still untouched bc of wiki

[median scaffold]

Well, I got one hour with cents left

[golden sonnet]

Alright, update it on the wiki or I can for you

[median scaffold]

Opening up the russian wiki rq

[wintry gale]

do the honors
i dont mess with this kind of thing yet

[fervent orbit]

i feel like the oversight tag for bug reports is for more minor stuff

that really do not need to go thru suggestions

[wintry gale]

that is a minor stuff

[golden sonnet]

Alright, should be done. Thanks for making me aware of the issue

[wintry gale]

[echo leaf]

i guess The Sponge extends your abyss breath

[dense locust]

Would a suggestion regarding enemy damage numbers go in here or balance

[echo leaf]

Good question… I think here.

Write it out here in discussion just in case

[median scaffold]

[dense locust]

Reduce the damage scal deals in master mode

Master mode damage values are frankly absurdly inflated in calamity endgame. This is perhaps at its most noticeable with supreme Calamitas,
For reference:

A defense stat of 272 and an effective damage reduction of around 15% is fairly reasonable to obtain post yharon for a tankier melee build. With these stats in death mode, a brimstone fireblast will deal approximately 251 damage, a fairly high but reasonable amount of damage.
Under these same conditions in master mode it would instead deal around 482. Nearly double the damage, even taking into account the increased defense effectiveness.
Master damage should be higher than death, but this is absurd.

[copper turret]

block parry dodge

[median scaffold]

Would say it's a balance issue, but, idk

[dense locust]

Using means to ignore the overtuned damage does not make the damage not overtuned

[copper turret]

mf going socrates over a video game

[sleek turret]

the kind of person to get a 26/100 on an english essay:

[echo leaf]

[copper turret]

what

[wide river]

#suggestions-posting message
So, provided I'm interpreting this correctly, you want lifesteal to work like this:

• Lifesteal can't heal the player if the player is at max HP
• Lifesteal only heals the player for up to their missing HP
  Correct?

[echo leaf]

Exactly, yeah

That’s a… much simpler way of putting it

I’m just tired of seeing that stupid cooldown when I’m at full health

[harsh echo]

you would be surprised at how much strategy video games can entail

[drowsy plank]

my man got called out

anyway yeah i

dont know why lifesteal works like this

feels like an oversight lmao

bc like
what is it doing at max hp lmao

[dense locust]

Overheal obviously

[fervent orbit]

wat is it doing was that its cooldown used to be so short that no one noticed this problem until now

[echo leaf]

Even if the cooldown was super short, you’d still not quite get full value from it

[median scaffold]

TF2 overheal?

[calm dock]

Ok, hear me out. What if the “LAUNCHING PLAGUE NUKES” text in the Plague Bringer Goliath fight created a plague biome. It could be another threat and possibly take over the jungle biome unless you stop it

[glass arch]

plague minibiome is a massive maybe with generally a small chance of being implemented

[echo leaf]

That’d probably go under ‘significant effort’

You’re free to mod it in yourself

[copper turret]

that exists in the calamity community remix and i dont rlly like it but it does sound pretty cool

[calm dock]

Hm, that’s cool

And yeah I know this is a very big stretch for base calamity, but it could be cool for a future update to plague bringer

[drowsy plank]

plague minibiome could/should exist but that is NOT how it should go about being done

[calm dock]

Yeah

[drowsy plank]

jungle has had it too good for too long, but having an NPC spread infected tiles is the worst

[calm dock]

It would probably be pre existing and I 100% agree on another evil biome

[sand marlin]

Evil Androomba

[drowsy plank]

lo

[calm dock]

Honestly imo terraria without evil biome spread is better because i start tweaking from anxiety of it

[drowsy plank]

SO true

[echo leaf]

If I ever played Terraria with biome spread I’d just completely ignore it and build everything in the sky

[drowsy plank]

gfb type beat

[echo leaf]

no on gfb I excavated a chunk of land on the surface and filled it in with dirt to create an artificial forest

[drowsy plank]

neat

[dense locust]

Old corruptor moment

[drowsy plank]

im pretty sure this has been done to death as a suggestion, but im quite confident asking for more gels for flamethrowers falls under excessive work @wintry frigate due to the nature of how flamethrowers function

they're similar to star cannons in the respect that, due to their unique functionality, and the nature of their ammo, that that just can't really be done easily

maybe rocket launchers would be a better example just in the fact that. every type of rocket requires new unique projectiles for EVERY rocket launcher which is just
miserable
and considering the number of flamethrowers, even just trying to pink gel alone would be

awful

[wintry frigate]

ah well that’s kinda a shame, totally understand that it would be too much to add tho

[echo leaf]

Classify pink gel as fuel but don’t give it any new effects

[drowsy plank]

trueeeeeeee

[echo leaf]

blighted gel- world’s most expensive fuel

[drowsy plank]

you could technically give it higher base damage but like. what. would the point of that be

you'd just be nerfing flamethrowers

[echo leaf]

how’d that be a nerf? Unless flamethrowers that use gel would be nerfed to compensate

[drowsy plank]

yes obviously

you'd just be moving the goalposts, otherwise you'd make pink/blighted gel flamethrowers the meta

better to keep the damage on the weapon, in my opinion

[echo leaf]

yeah, that would just be unnecessary balancing pain

[drowsy plank]

it's already bad enough with bows and guns

converts are so ubiquitous for more reasons than just that bullet hoses and firing more arrows per shot is lame as fuck after the 12th time

[echo leaf]

Makes sense to me

[spice jacinth]

purified gel should be the most expensive right?

[copper turret]

what about pink gel

[spice jacinth]

Not so expensive
Fuel but no effects as prikki said

[golden sonnet]

Farming queen slime and gastropods makes it pretty easy to get

[echo leaf]

I was almost certain that the lifesteal suggestion would be turned down for balance reasons

[grim tusk]

Actually it required giving bools to every rocket to check the type

[drowsy plank]

oh awesome

[buoyant idol]

These link bots need a better solution, maybe an auto mute if three blocked links are sent within a specific timeframe to make sure it doesn't reach the posting channel if a spammer goes down the list of channels? It's annoying to see it lit up and get a ping for it only to see nothing.

[tardy geyser]

The post dog moons are getting removed @spring sky

And eclipse

Replaced by the distortion subworld

[spring sky]

What

@tardy geyser explain

[golden sonnet]

Wdym

Explain what

It's as they said, once the distortion sub world is added the events will no longer be buffed by dog or drop materials

[drowsy plank]

^

yeah also flagging for kind of specific + like. yknow. removal anyway so it doesnt matter lol

[spring sky]

Where was this mentioned? Is this an official thing confirmed to be in the next update or something?

[golden sonnet]

Instead endothermic energy and nightmare fuel (under a different name) will be obtained in the sub world, possibly through an event there, possibly not

[drowsy plank]

not the next update

it has been confirmed many times by devs in this discord

[spring sky]

I still think that they should add new minibosses to the events

It's still a valid suggestion imo

[errant wren]

it would be a lot of effort either way

[golden sonnet]

Why would they spend valuable dev time on something that would not need any reason to exist in the future

[spring sky]

They already have the sprites and animations for several of them

[drowsy plank]

there is already a yeti in frost moon

that one is the funniest

[spring sky]

Yeah but like a BIG yeti

[drowsy plank]

...

[spring sky]

[golden sonnet]

Back in my day we had a big yeti, its name was deerclops

Smh

[drowsy plank]

the yeti in the event is already the same height as deerclops anyway 💀

[spring sky]

Yeah but like a BIG BIG yeti

Make the Yeti WIDE

Boom, new enemy

[drowsy plank]

a pointless enemy

[spring sky]

He chucks ice chunks at you or something idfk

[spring sky]

Agreed, very pointless. But cool

[glass arch]

well

[drowsy plank]

unsurprisingly "cool" is one of the reasoning donts

also this does not sound cool at all

[spring sky]

That wasn't my original reason

[drowsy plank]

i know

[glass arch]

it would be cool is the worst reasoning ever

[spring sky]

I'm just making excuses as to why this wasn't a terrible suggestion after I already deleted it

Guys it would add variety

You could have tall yeti and wide yeti

Why have a new dimension when you can have two yeties?

[errant wren]

i saw the intent but ultimately it would have been better to just not brought up most of those example

not that the sugg hadn't been flagged

[spring sky]

I deleted it anyway

[glass arch]

theres already like 60 slimes and nobody is asking for more variety does not fix everything

[spring sky]

Great, glad you caught onto the sarcasm

[errant wren]

anyways ima go back to lurking as per usual

see y'all in 7

[golden sonnet]

Clearly you haven't seen the auric ore slime suggestions

People want more slimes....

[spring sky]

😭

[golden sonnet]

Wrong people but still

[royal tapir]

Wish I could add a lock to stuff in suggestion-posting

[drowsy plank]

actually yeah a sugg like this already passed anyway lol

hilarious how this tends to happen

[echo leaf]

to my knowledge, the slimes just exist so there’s a renewable source of clamity ores, yeah? They’re all either fishable or slimable- except Perennial and Cryonic which have both for some reason

[golden sonnet]

Pretty sure they are literally all fishable

They just also have ore slimes

[echo leaf]

Aerilate might not be? Not sure.

It’s shimmerable from Cobalt, though

Nope, they are fishable

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, like literally every calamity ore can be from crates

So the ore slimes just seems redundant

[celest nymph]

do you guys think the post-dog buffed event drops (endothermic energy, nightmare fuel, darksun fragment) should show on the map

just out of curiosity

since boss checklist can show lunar fragments

[sand marlin]

I mean you can just use Ceaseless Hunger Potion at that stage so probably not

[celest nymph]

oh ok

yeah that makes a lot of sense

[golden sonnet]

It would be a good idea if calamity already made other items do that

But as that's mostly just an other mod thing it wouldn't make a ton of sense

[celest nymph]

oh ok

[copper turret]

seeing calamity polish itself up and remove the unncessary and out of place bloat with actually cool shit (like the new subworld dimension which replaces the buffed moons) is so cool

[olive saddle]

Ore slimes have dev plans right? So any sugg regarding ore slimes will be locked?

[drowsy plank]

most likely yes

depends on what the suggestion is

[frail mantle]

hopefully the dev plans are ceremonial execution

🙏

[drowsy plank]

im pretty sure the idea was just to turn them into more interesting non-slime mobs

[frail mantle]

i'm counting that if it means the slime part dies

[drowsy plank]

p much

[misty lichen]

ore slimes should turn every block they touch into ore ithink

[drowsy plank]

hm

i think this is a bad idea actually

[olive saddle]

If it was a certain block like mud or something then it'd be so much more interesting and unique than "kill slime. get ore"

[misty lichen]

guys that was a joke 😭

[drowsy plank]

my response was also a joke lmao but elliott's response is funny

[sand marlin]

Auric Slime

🔥

[gray bone]

that one shadowspec slime suggestion just erasing every block it touches because it isn't canon

[sand marlin]

Hellavator Slime

[olive saddle]

Except the hellevator is at like a 22.5 degree angle cuz of how slimes fall

[royal tapir]

Wait this is peak

[gray bone]

can this be a gfb thing

[echo leaf]

an auric slime would make the world fucking unplayable and I’m so down for that

[harsh echo]

dev said it was peak
upcoming feature confirmed ⁉️

[copper turret]

what if u have an underground base and all the slimes come and turn it to goo

[gray bone]

my cavern layer bases are mainly made from stone-based blocks

so turning them into ores is just straight profit

reverse shimmer even

[copper turret]

my wonderful builds being turned to auric ore

[echo leaf]

Curse of Midas

[harsh echo]

fun

[lunar nest]

queen bee mech boss

[drowsy plank]

i guess hitscan lasers would be more accurate

to call them that i mean

since i dont think this is an in universe tooltip

[vestal lark]

I genuinely really like the idea that someone mentioned here a little while ago to turn them into minibosses like the Ascended Astral Slime from Catalyst.

Probably not all of them but like

one or two.

🥺

[drowsy plank]

as long as they arent slimes anymore idc

[wide river]

Noted, ore slimes are now Demon Eyes

Auric Demon Eye 🔥

[vestal lark]

Eye of Perennial Bar.

[frail fox]

Cryonic worm

[hollow verge]

why do i keep getting pings in the suggestions channel without any posts in there?

[gray bone]

bots send a wave of messages in every channel they can

but the message gets deleted almost instantly

[hollow verge]

makes sense

[echo leaf]

who deletes them? mods or another bot?

I think there’s a moderation bot which has a setting to kill anyone who sends the same message in different channels too quickly

[frail mantle]

mod notifs

it checks for non-whitelisted links

which is why sometimes you get bots slipping through like "anyone interested in earning $50k a month? we will not be scamming people we will be selling crack, dm me for details" because they don't actually post a link

[wide river]

Sometimes they have the grand idea to do an everyone ping, but fortunately this place has that permission disabled for like.... just about everyone

[hybrid steeple]

oo
thats a good one,,

[echo leaf]

Ah, neat

[novel belfry]

Counterpoint: draedon the type of person to make lasers go beyond the speed of light

[echo leaf]

Draedon has used magic before

At that point he’d just teleport the lasers forwards

just give them a thousand extra updates

[harsh echo]

that would be the speed of light in a vacuum 🤓

[novel belfry]

draedon the type of guy to exceed speeed of light in a vaccum

[copper turret]

Unrelated to the discussion but why is it possible to dodge sulfuric poison

If you have a dodg eaccessory you can just... dodge radiation (?)

[golden sonnet]

Skill solution

[olive saddle]

Terrarian is so powerful he can sidestep radiation

"Nah."

[copper turret]

aquatic scourge seeing me dodge the radiation in the wster

[golden sonnet]

Aquatic scourge seeing you under water while fighting it

That's more outlandish

[copper turret]

infernum aquatic scourge enrages unless you are in water

[golden sonnet]

This isn't addon talk smh

[fleet grotto]

luck issue

[hollow verge]

oh, that's not a bad idea. though i suppose you could also make a dummy character, slap it some good armor and wings, and just get it that way

or clone the favor

[hollow verge]

@stiff swallow silva has wings

i do not think bloodflare does though

[echo leaf]

It does not

[hollow verge]

do people use wings that arent the yeezys?

[echo leaf]

Omega Blue wings 👁️ 👁️

[stiff swallow]

i mean

[echo leaf]

Oh yes!

[stiff swallow]

im mainly asking for bloodflare and maaaaybe omega blue

[echo leaf]

I don’t like the tracers at all

[stiff swallow]

i find tier 1 tracers insufferable

[echo leaf]

I can’t be fucking bothered to make angel treads

[stiff swallow]

also

its even more important ig

cause silva has wings

god slayer doesnt why

[echo leaf]

use silva wings

[hollow verge]

thats wild, i love the shoes. the movement speed is so nice...

[stiff swallow]

not thematic

also yknow

they buff silva armor

[hollow verge]

it also doesnt give set bonus

[echo leaf]

You can get a lot of speed by short hopping instead of running on the ground

[stiff swallow]

not god slayer armor

[hollow verge]

idk how to do that, i am a casual

[sand marlin]

God Slayer Hoverboard is a concept I believe

[echo leaf]

Just tap the space bar for a li’l tiny bit to get a teeny bit of air

[hollow verge]

ive learned how to dodge for rev+master playthru but i am still a casual.

[echo leaf]

Then you can fly at a low altitude or just hop again

[sand marlin]

Not sure when it'll be done but it's a thing that exists

[echo leaf]

Pretend you’re a frog! A very, very fast frog!

[hollow verge]

i dont think its bad to re-suggest something tho, at least the pins say. it tells the devs that this is a high priority item

[echo leaf]

A god slayer hoverboard would be cool as hell though

[hollow verge]

i'll def vote for this suggestion if it gets to voting

[sand marlin]

I mean it wouldn't actually change anything but sure

[stiff swallow]

ngl for some reason i swear remebering that god slayer booster was an item

[hollow verge]

also i want a bloodflare set of wings

[echo leaf]

But I could get behind bloodflare wings

[hollow verge]

i love bloodflare armor a lot, enough that i will fight polterghast early for it 🧍‍♂️

[umbral gazelle]

lets see how long can "consistency with vanilla" go

[hollow verge]

#suggestions-posting message cirrus kite that's just the boob couch

im only half-joking. i think itd be funny.

[echo leaf]

Cirrus shitposts turned into items are always funny

[grave zinc]

@worldly sparrow - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Remove Signus' title of "Envoy of the Devourer"]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[glass arch]

hold on wait they're cooking

[tardy geyser]

Signut, distortion denizen

[novel belfry]

EPIC ANTI-SPAM BOT W

[misty lichen]

i hope this doesn’t get beat out by “add calamity kites”

[crude geode]

it will

[misty lichen]

the most common complaint i hear from a lot of my friends about cal is rev/death being way too easy (they are the same difficulty) but ftw/gfb or infernum being way too hard

i wouldn’t even say death mode is having an identity crisis, it’s just a complete identity failure

[frail fox]

Best I can do is boss rush exclusive ai

[misty lichen]

i can’t believe malice has been gone for almost 2 years and it’s ai is still just reused for boss rush

[stiff swallow]

indeed

[stiff swallow]

i'm in this boat

i feel like part of the issue is bosses and content needing heavy reworks or additions

(namely post ML non-boss enemies, reworking a lot of bosses that are on the simple or not really good difficulty typesetc)

(that's another thing, having more interesting stuff going on outside of boss fights)

[hollow verge]

your friends think it's easy?

i agree that master mode's ai changes should go into death mode, i do think that makes sense. but jesus what kind of game are you playing that im not

[frosty trellis]

There are

Some master mode changes

That would be cool in death mode

But in all honestly

A lot of them are just not proper difficulty mode changes

And half of them feel like something out of ftw anyways

[olive saddle]

I assume death mode expansion will come eventually

[hollow verge]

what is ftw?

[echo leaf]

For The Worthy

It’s the secret seed that makes the game more difficult

[vestal lark]

Are Godspeed Boosters or whatever they're called a CalVal thing?

[gray bone]

yeah they are

[vestal lark]

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1138960073440374795/1228010392295313458/sad_asd.png?ex=662a7ccc&is=661807cc&hm=ae4d4743e9aab134f6952c7bec5cac776db8fc6af27c3d32b1de1d029a0fa7e5&

Also if I remember correctly they don't synergise with anything anyway.

[gray bone]

i think their flight stats are also just worse than silva's

[echo leaf]

A lot of the Calamity Vanites wings are just generally worse than Calamity wings

The only one I found use out of is the Wulfrum Hoverpack which has a longer flight time than Fledgling Wings and therefore perform better without Rocket Boots

Chicken Wings also have a faster vertical speed than Drew’s Wings, I do believe

[gray bone]

generally they are just for vanity though

surprisingly enough

[echo leaf]

Deadass???

[gray bone]

nah i'm kidding

they're actually there as a hidden message to the playerbase

[harsh echo]

erm really? the hoverpack looked so shit

[echo leaf]

It has inferior flight stats but about .55 seconds longer of flight

If I didn't have Rocket Boots, the Hoverpack is just a tad better since it's more than a glorified double jump

[drowsy plank]

to be fair i

dont think the effects of master mode are communicated

anywhere, ever

the same could be said of expert mode actually too

vanilla doesnt explain what you're getting into at all

im not going to say the difficulty situation isnt an utter shitshow right now but

it's not like this has ever been terraria's strong suite

[high nest]

I feel like master mode should be mostly outside of calamity's scope, but I mean I'm not calamity devs. Just would make sense to me to think of it as classic: easier mode, expert: intended balancing with rev or whatever, master: extra numbers on enemies if you want things to be harder.

calamity difficulties complicate things kinda, but I feel like overall it works out that expert is calamity default, master is added by relogic for extra numbers/vanilla boss changes, but not really part of the mod

this could just be entirely coloured by my personal experience/bias tho

[drowsy plank]

i dont exactly disagree lol

[misty lichen]

you need to fix that regardless of what mode it’s in

arguably having it in master is worse

[olive saddle]

I made a sugg about this that got a ton of votes that never went anywhere. Ill find it rq

Oh nevermind it got sent to the server the fuck

Dont know if the bot pinged me or not apologies

[echo escarp]

largely agree, while vanilla master mode is bland and boring, its still something that is a part of vanilla and falls under them to do something about it. people coming off of a vanilla playthrough or another terraria experience likely already have some idea or semblance on what to expect from master mode from that, and the boss AI changes are nowhere in those previous expectations

also think that more utilization of the difficulty indicator UI as a separation for large game and AI changes would be nice. this is something i think that malice mode, despite its image as "a huge mistake from beginning to end" to the devs, was good on as it was a change that was more clearly communicated to the player. in addition, it could decide on after world generation while the master mode changes lock you in from the start of world generation and does not let you know what you're getting yourself into

[worldly sparrow]

i disagree with this, master death is great

[misty lichen]

refuses to elaborate

[echo escarp]

i also never said anything here about changing the AI, as much as im not a huge fan on some of the changes, but if there is a change, it should either be 1) communicate to the player somewhere in game 2) something the player can opt in and out of or 3) both of the above

its liek if you sign a contract, but everything but the signature on the bottom was blocked out for you

like you have no idea what youre getting yourself into

and have no way of backing out

cuz the world is already generated

[golden sonnet]

It can still be master death without the AI changes being in master

[misty lichen]

this too is another big issue

just the disorganization of difficulty modes is the fucked up part i want addressed

there’s zero good reason for everything to be split up the way it is

[wide river]

I expect this suggestion to get 40 stars in voting because it's not "add random furniture item pls"

[misty lichen]

i just want devs to look at it in general, i know it’s literally impossible to get suggs like this past voting

i might even just repost it until something gets addressed (with minor edits to the text of course)

[frail fox]

Difficulty and boss suggestions vs acidwood furniture 3

[sleek turret]

when i'm in a not completing a something competition and my opponent is calamity furniture

[drowsy plank]

i cant diss the spriters it's not like vanilla sets are completely consistent either

i know vanilla was missing a bunch of walls for the longest time

[golden sonnet]

Smh, where is stone accent slab walls

[drowsy plank]

coming 200never

[echo leaf]

I keep having to tell myself not to suggest an acidwood toilet

[olive saddle]

still waiting for the auric fart kart

[harsh echo]

fr

[sleek turret]

Calamity if it was Goooooooood

[drowsy plank]

that scourge one in voting is... weird

i somehow missed it completely

[crude geode]

It’s something that could be applied to like. half the bosses in the game

[drowsy plank]

yeah

i should've probably flagged it

@stiff swallow i can tell you exactly why there is no god slayer wing and it's because they still cant pick a sprite for it

that fucking request has been in calart for 4 fucking years at this point

[crude geode]

Probably the most infamous shit in Calgary

Autocorrect wtf

[misty lichen]

it’s also just incorrect? scourge weapon drop logic is the exact same as all other calamity bosses

it should be deleted because it’s just, not even true

[dense locust]

why does every boss need to have weapon drops anywayt

[crude geode]

bc weapons are clearly the only thing that matter duh /s

[drowsy plank]

im never not going to be mad that i spent like a month making a sprite, submitted it, it got accepted, and then i learnt through being friends with devs that it wasn't going to be added. did leave a bit of a bad taste in my mouth ngl

[wide river]

Acceptn't

[coral carbon]

thats wild wtf 😭

[grave zinc]

@copper turret - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Increase the number of weapon drops from Aquatic Scourge.]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, I feel like there should have been more communication there

[copper turret]

ts shit so sad

[drowsy plank]

like i know why now but

it still fucking pisses me off that it was allowed to happen

especially because for a while i thought it was because i upscaled it to the wrong size which is

such an easy issue to fix and i got mad no one ever contacted me about it

[coral carbon]

wtf

i dont understand how that happens

[drowsy plank]

i guess it was considered unimportant because of the other reason it got rejected but that being the only thing i was told was infuriating for sure

i mean i understand how

they're busy people

and explanations would probably count as half leaks and i don't believe i was a mod yet at the time?

so i understand why they wouldn't trust a rando with it

[hollow verge]

@scarlet musk #1178515062030348308 is a place to put that innit?

[dense locust]

#1178515062030348308

[scarlet musk]

oop thank you

[drowsy plank]

lol

[dense locust]

but also you should probably have numbers to back your claim up

[olive saddle]

I got so excited thinking it was a $50 steam giftcard and it wasn't :(

[distant gyro]

yeah i wasnt super happy about that one

i fixed it myself and later got the message "no that's not going to be added anymore"

[drowsy plank]

rip

[distant gyro]

you'd thought no one put in the hassle of adding it but no the item itself just got shelved

[olive saddle]

Probably distortion/dog rework stuff

[drowsy plank]

i will say finding out you did fix it... im not sure if i feel better or worse because of it

[scarlet musk]

if you must know,

[distant gyro]

fixing stuff is kinda run of the mill for me so it's fine

[olive saddle]

Fixing stuff sounds like 10-40% of game dev depending on how the engine is feelin

[drowsy plank]

i moreso meant im glad someone cared enough to do that, but im also annoyed that the work was put it just for it to still get racked anyway
but like i said i get it

also true

[novel belfry]

THE GODSLAYER WINGS IS NOT COMING?

what the fuck

[scarlet musk]

all warding except for two menacing
both summons ruthless
elemental axe consistently gets 3000-3200 dps, compared to virid vanguard's more inconsistent 2500-2900 dps

[olive saddle]

It is probably its just not getting implemented now

As in it got racked for distortion/dog rework

[dense locust]

I see
just as a general question
is this dummy numbers or is this vs a specific boss
because that changes things a lot especially with minions

[scarlet musk]

super dummy numbers

[dense locust]

yeah uhh
I would grab that vs actual bosses

much more acurate

[scarlet musk]

which boss should i test on

[olive saddle]

Dont use super dummies. Use bosses as DPS generally doesnt mean shit unless its like 500 vs 2000

[dense locust]

sentinals and polter

[scarlet musk]

im... not that far yet

[dense locust]

valid

test worlds

[scarlet musk]

i meant like a control boss

[stiff swallow]

honestly Godslayer wings would be faster if I just made em myself and I've never programmed nor modded a game lol

And calamitys sprites are rather high quality compared to what I'm used to so making one might be tough

[drowsy plank]

yeah multiple people have already done that
like me
i could go throw the item together in 5 minutes, that's obviously not the issue

[olive saddle]

Its not the programming thats the issue its probably throwing them in not in the distortion/dog rework update

[drowsy plank]

future distortion/DoG plans are obviously the issue with adding wings that comply to the previous aesthetic since that will likely be completely changing with all of these plans

[stiff swallow]

I get that

though I mainly referenced Godslayer wings as a dumb absence, gameplay wise personally I want post Polter wings more

[olive saddle]

Post polter wings is valid tbh

[drowsy plank]

yeah ^

[dense locust]

void wings

[olive saddle]

You get nothin from prov to dog i think

[wide river]

Mhm

[dense locust]

-50 max health and +15% damage while wearing omega blue

[olive saddle]

Tbf elysian are very good

[drowsy plank]

one of many reasons why polter doesn't feel like a real tier

[golden sonnet]

Based

[olive saddle]

Extremely dumb and op sounding though I'd honestly want something to synergize with the tentacles on omega blue

[stiff swallow]

I feel like the big issue is Polter is a joke boss

[dense locust]

polter is a joke boss

[stiff swallow]

CV wings would make sense for Prismatic since it's A. Donor item, and B. Niche for one class

And it would be on tier

But eh

CalVal has it for vanity

I don't feel like it's needed really

Plus it's not like mages can't just wear the 2 main armor sets

[olive saddle]

Ok im not the only one with this opinion

It feels like a nothing tier despite having a ton of stuff

[drowsy plank]

i used to do polter before provi because i used to find provi hard
i no longer find provi hard enough to need that

[dense locust]

bloodfire wings
much better stats comparitively but you have your health drained while flying

[stiff swallow]

Also all the post Polter weapons have the same aesthetic unless they're sentinel weapons generally

[olive saddle]

Neat concept actually

[stiff swallow]

Lose hp while grounded regen while flying

[olive saddle]

Bloodflare ye

[stiff swallow]

That would be hilarious considering DOG

[novel belfry]

...why is that so necessary? It's just a pair of wings, it can be resprited for when the new aesthetic shows up

[stiff swallow]

The current plantera fight is definitely mechanically harder and more interesting and ironically makes polter feel less of a clone

[novel belfry]

baroclaw and slagsplitter pauldrons were introduced with some odd sprites that the community almost immediately put out good resprites for

[stiff swallow]

Since (master) plantera is all about all the other bullshit in addition to simple charge

[harsh echo]

lmao yeah

[novel belfry]

you don't need to put out "new aesthetic"-accurate sprites, the community will just provide one if an actual item is released and they think it doesnt look right

[stiff swallow]

Like she has spore gas, p1 spirals, seed shotguns/blaster in p1, Thorn balls, radial exploding balls

Coming from all directions

[drowsy plank]

idk (this is it) ¯_(ツ)_/¯

[harsh echo]

was that rejected becasue of the planned gs armor resprite

[drowsy plank]

p much i believe so

[harsh echo]

so sad

[scarlet musk]

so vanguard is better, but it still doesn't matter because dazzling stabber staff (which you can get directly from providence instead of having to mine ore for it) more than doubles its damage. the only reason you would use vanguard is grinding for dazzling stabber

[novel belfry]

imo just implement the goddamn wings

it shouldn't matter too much that it'll be outdated

just that it should be resprited when the time for the gs armor resprite comes

okay, maybe im getting too heated over a pair of wings

[sleek turret]

I mean

Just add them lol lmao xddddddddddd

This is the same mod that added a recolor of a hardmode enemy for a boss enemy

So it shouldn't hurt for a while, I think

[dense locust]

from my own testing this doesnt seem to be true, if anything vangard seems to be better than stabber is vs multitarget bosses like weaver and void

[novel belfry]

im probably really annoyed because it seems like the simplest of things being not added for reasons that don't really seem to matter too much

[buoyant idol]

What boss?

[novel belfry]

like its just a pair of wings
sure, we're no longer at that calamity phase where it added a bajillion recolored enemies and items

[harsh echo]

pbg?

[dense locust]

in fact virid might be a little too good vs multitarget

[harsh echo]

that's insanwe

[novel belfry]

but the fact that the bajillion recolors were done should show that these wings literally do not need to wait that long to be implemented

[dense locust]

master eye's spawns are litterally just recollored wandering eyes

[buoyant idol]

Oh, right.

[novel belfry]

thats like

literally just a week or two ago that enemy got added

[dense locust]

that was over a month ago

[harsh echo]

a

[novel belfry]

yeah my timing is wrong

but my point should stand

or actually

maybe we're getting a bit off track about it

its a pair of wings

[drowsy plank]

i mean logs said they've already been resprited anyway lol

[novel belfry]

you have a literal submission

[scarlet musk]

so maybe a 1:3 ratio of vanguards to stabbers is optimal in general

[scarlet musk]

oop

[novel belfry]

why be so stringently beholden to a potential future resprite to prevent the addition of a really noticable missing piece of a armor set

[misty lichen]

im just gonna mention that drew’s wings are still a complete recolor of solar wings

[harsh echo]

[misty lichen]

all they did was take solar wings and then turn on the greyscale button

[sleek turret]

See? It's obvious you can add them

It's ever more obvious because after all the Calamity I played I learn now that Drew wings are a recolor of Solar Wings

[stiff swallow]

tbf who uses drews wings like ever

[fleet grotto]

like 50% of the playerbase

[dense locust]

more probably

[sleek turret]

considering the entire drew wings vs celestial tracers sentiment surged from some parts of the community probably

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, now they iframes are gone from tracers they are just better

[hollow verge]

why would i use drew wings when i could have the fanciest yeezys known to mankind

[wide river]

Auric jordans

[hollow verge]

exactly

it's not about being optimal, it's about the statement

[buoyant idol]

The true solution is to use the minecart.

[stiff swallow]

well its do you want better wings or do you want another accessory slot

[dense locust]

I can have both

just dont use boots

[stiff swallow]

and i find elysian and seraph good enough, mostly for that tradeoff

tier 1 just isnt enough

[fleet grotto]

i only use celestial if I'm ranger or mage

since they have bad wings

[stiff swallow]

wanting to die the milisecond i have to walk

[fleet grotto]

Hear me out: Don't

[dense locust]

just grapple to reset flight time smh

[golden sonnet]

You don't need boots at all post moon lord

It doesn't save a slot

[stiff swallow]

ppl weir..

[golden sonnet]

Wdym, that's pretty normal to not wear boots after moon lord

[stiff swallow]

personally i feel like going down in general movement speed is like removing a permanent upgrade lol

[golden sonnet]

Flying horizontally is faster

[golden sonnet]

Wings are faster in the air, which you should be for bosses

Boots are only for ground speed

You aren't going down in speed

[dense locust]

frankly you dont need boots at all after like, mechs

maybe for like 1 or 2 bosses

[golden sonnet]

I don't use them after golem yeah

[fleet grotto]

boots still increase your horizontal movement speed a considerable amount by then

[stiff swallow]

also ynow

the entire rest of everything else still exists

[dense locust]

I still use them for most of hardmode because fairy boots are disgustingly broken but if those didnt exist I'd be dropping them by plant

[stiff swallow]

and idgaf enough to every single time i try a boss

dequip boots

and equip after

[golden sonnet]

Calamity increases you base speed which boots override

So you don't need them for other stuff too

[stiff swallow]

yeah and boots are still way faster

[dense locust]

the mobility matters way less when you're not fighting a boss
its a minor inconvenience at most

• pylons exist so like

[stiff swallow]

idk maybe im just too seperated from active discussion and meta talk..

[fleet grotto]

momentum incapacitator

[stiff swallow]

ah yes pylons those things i totally setup every single time

[dense locust]

real

[stiff swallow]

cause im like i want to make pylon houses not suck and not be boxes

but those get deferred and never built

[echo leaf]

this

if fairy boots weren't real then I'd drop terrasparks once I beat Skeletron

but 10 defense and 2 regen is just so unfathomably juicy

[dense locust]

the fact that fairy boots are a better defensive acc than most actual defensive accessories at that tier while also still being better spectre boots is absurd

[drowsy plank]

well

fairy got moved to hardmode

along with hellfire

so terra is like

ur only option now

[copper turret]

thats where youre wrong

[dense locust]

fairy boots had been hardmode for awhile

[copper turret]

water walking boots

🗣️🔥

[wide river]

Nah Flower Boots sweep

[dense locust]

amphibian boots:

[copper turret]

water walking boots sweep

[wide river]

Rocket Boots 🔥

[golden sonnet]

Rox my beloved

I love getting 3 accessories from rox

Hellfire treads + amalgamated brain + bloody worm scarf

[drowsy plank]

rox shimmer is dying you know this

[golden sonnet]

Wait fr?

[drowsy plank]

amphibian are the only alternative to terra preHM

why would it not be??

[dense locust]

I was unaware of this

[golden sonnet]

[wide river]

Just have to
Actually find it
(Ignore the fact I usually just cheat it in after Evil 2 because I can't be arsed to find it myself)

[dense locust]

I mean it survived the last god knows how many patches

[drowsy plank]

rox shrine fucking when

lmao

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, I expected it to be changed when it gets a shrine

But that's been in dev limbo for awhile

When the shrine build was "completed" 7 months ago

[forest grove]

i really like this one because it can be annoying to be on cooldown because you were given health that you didnt need

[echo leaf]

I like this one too

[wide river]

Hmm I wonder why

[vestal lark]

Best few sprites are chosen and give class-specific buffs.

[drowsy plank]

im not sure if you're trying to give a solution but it's not like they dont not exist because of too many options bc otherwise they would've used one of them already

oh lmfao the emoji refused to load

thanks discord

[median scaffold]

Make the extra health a defense bonus

Totally won't be helly abused by everyone

[harsh echo]

add overheal

[urban mortar]

how tho

[harsh echo]

whatever amount you heal will be added as temporary hp

on top of max

[urban mortar]

hmm

[urban mortar]

Same response to that one as well

[worthy lintel]

I get what you mean but if lore and gameplay contradicts, gameplay prevails

Exceptions are best kept minimal

||NPCs taking damage in the first place is cringe anyways||

[gray bone]

that's why i always have them be invincible with a mod

[harsh echo]

hurdur

[gray bone]

destroyer murking all of them was a nice jumpscare in my first playthrough that made me scared of it

but intensely annoying afterwards

[median scaffold]

OVERHEAL FROM (insert any game with overheal. I want TF2 to be here), YOOOOOOOO

[drowsy plank]

thorium kind of has that with their shields

[median scaffold]

With Calamity's ability to set NPC's spawn rate to 10x and make them move even in night, is it really that necessary?

[urban mortar]

Me who has his main arena away from all npcs: I have no such weaknesses!

[gray bone]

not qol is "necessary"

but i prefer it

so i use it

simple as that

[median scaffold]

Nah, I mean making SCal and Permafrost immune to ice constructs in Calamity, not QoL mods

[gray bone]

oh

idk why you replied to me then

me talking about the destroyer was not to do with the suggestion

[median scaffold]

Well, yeah, my bad here

[olive saddle]

Suggestion: make the destroyer the only thing able to destroy NPCs. Its in his name

[buoyant idol]

ULTRAKILL

[forest grove]

But it only lasts a short time because I would just get to 100000 hp before starting a fight if I could

[harsh echo]

ye

[frail fox]

There’s just so much wrong here

[worthy lintel]

The suggestion is not mechanically wrong

But Ark of the Cosmos has already caused enough damage as it is

[terse crypt]

idk, as soon as i craft triactis' hammer i just dont need to use anything else
and its really sad because i love ark B(

its the only pml melee weapon with a unique swing animation

(aside from some others, this one is just the most unique imo)

[frail fox]

Weapons that come later tend to be stronger than the ones that came before yes

[novel belfry]

crackpot sugg:
ark booster accessory: grants 45% increased dmg to ark of the cosmos, but requires shadowspec bars

[frail fox]

This but for every weapon

[crude geode]

Compared to how much melee received every update I don’t really feel like it needs more, especially since harvest added a bunch more reworked weapons

[drowsy plank]

@terse crypt shadowspec tier items cannot be suggested and also this doesnt make any sense

scal and exos are literally the end of the game til yharim, and after he gets added shadowspec will moved to be after him

[terse crypt]

that would be if i suggested a specific item (which this suggestion isnt)

and well aotc isnt an 'endgame' weapon by definition, since endgame weapons are all shadowspec tier
im basically suggesting an upgrade for it, nothing more, nothing less

[frail mantle]

no you also just Can't suggest shadowspec items in general

shadowspec is reserved for dev items

[terse crypt]

even if they aren't specific?

[frail mantle]

yeah

[terse crypt]

where's that written? sorry if the tone of the question is rude, just need to be extra sure

[frail mantle]

maybe i'm blind but i can't seem to find a rule about it in the doc? i guess the best answer i can give you is that's just how shadowspec tier is handled

[terse crypt]

i can take that, thanks

[frail mantle]

it's the dev "what the fuck is thematic consistency 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥" tier

[terse crypt]

maybe that earth rework might do shadowspec tier justice

[median scaffold]

Earth
And Temporal Umbrella
And Endogenesis
And Scarlet Devil
And... uhh, what

[drowsy plank]

the explict shadowspec rule was removed but i just

this isn't going to pass

ever

i can tell you right now that it isn't

[median scaffold]

If only devs want it... if only...

[drowsy plank]

you literally just got ark the tier before and there is ONE boss left after this there is no point

[median scaffold]

(You technically get Galaxia in post-dog, so three upgrades in three tiers is too much)

[drowsy plank]

what would you even want? what would it do?

yeah

[frail mantle]

something about overstaying its welcome

the more things like it you add, the less cool and unique it feels

[drowsy plank]

plus like

ark and biome blade side by side end up covering like 99% of the game

[median scaffold]

And, personally, I would like to have more options for other classes than melee

It already has the most shadowspec tier weapons (tmelee has one, but that's besides the point)

6, I think?

[hollow verge]

i want ranged weapons that arent either dogwater damage or extremely slow but we dont all get what we want (this isnt that srs dont yell @ me)

[frail mantle]

too late

town criers already on their way

[median scaffold]

King's Bane?

[hollow verge]

[drowsy plank]

Broken Biome Blade (post-Evil2)
Fractured Arc (post-Slime God)
Biome Blade (post-Mechs)
Ark of the Ancients (post-Plant)
True Biome Blade (post-Deus)
Ark of the Elements (post-ML)
Galaxia (post-DoG)
Ark of the Cosmos (post-Yharon)

like this is the whole game the only point that's missing is providence-polter (but polter isnt a real boss anyway so )

[median scaffold]

Yes, 6 melee shadowspec weapons. And you want a 7th one?

And Providence isn't necessary to defeat, so you can just go straight up to DoG

[hollow verge]

AotC does feel super underwhelming but thats mostly a me thing, i just dont like how it feels to use. but it is a full game carry, yeah

[drowsy plank]

how is aotc underwhelming

[median scaffold]

AotC without parries, maybe?

[crude geode]

Bad opinions

[median scaffold]

I didn't use them the first time around and was really underwhelmed with it, so just sticked up to Dragon Pow

[frail fox]

Biome blade is post-3 mechs and I doubt you’d use frark on mechs but who knows

[crude geode]

I thought you said frank for a second

[median scaffold]

Someone did an "AotC" only run, but... yeah

Frark isn't particular good for WoF even, iirc

[drowsy plank]

lol whoops

[frosty trellis]

It got nerfed but it's fine now

It used to obliterate wof byeah

[frail fox]

No more 25 second WoF, billions must perish

[novel belfry]

wait

WTF

[dense locust]

are you on .gg

huh

so it is

neat

[drowsy plank]

yeah idk why it says reworked lol

that thing was dead

[frail fox]

It was always there we just never noticed

Just like Arietes

[dense locust]

I imagine it was probably still sitting around somewhere in the files just unobtainable
anyway why wasnt grand dads crit chance 7%

[echo leaf]

It's gonna get reimplemented

[drowsy plank]

amazing

[grave zinc]

@fleet ember - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Change the criteria for the "Stealth full" sound to play]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@cloud socket - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Don't let Calamitas move in if you beat the boss rush before you beat her normally]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@frosty trellis - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add post Moonlord Alcohol's]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@fervent orbit - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Move PBG's Repetitive Drops to Infected Armour Plating Crafts]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fleet ember]

damn

[stiff swallow]

MASSIVE W

i hope its a bit more thematic

can i/should i rerun a suggestion if it was relatively recent but still aged-out?

[echo leaf]

I think this is already gonna get implemented

[distant gyro]

yeah its already done ill try to get the bot to pry

(no, it's not responsive)

[frosty trellis]

Just gotta hope now 🙏

[royal tapir]

If Suggestions Bot had WhatsApp

[drowsy plank]

wait if it's already done i can just 🔒 it right

[distant gyro]

i guess the correct one to use would be 🏁

but also doing that doesn't remove the sent message

so you'll turn it into a triple ping

[drowsy plank]

i

dont remember

[crude geode]

It would only be the like 5th version of that meme in this channel

[stiff swallow]

calamitky kites is too strong

[misty lichen]

i am beating “add wings” somehow

[stiff swallow]

would like uh

idk what they would be

first thought is artemis/apollo

dog worm kite

bumblebirb/dragonfolly kite but that might be a bit too much into calval territory

but kites kinda are calval -y

[frail fox]

You’ll beat kites too if you just believe

[royal tapir]

Me summoning 178 unnamed accounts to vote on the "Add wings" suggestion

[obtuse roost]

so figure I should throw out, if anyone ever planned on it, I wouldn't mind seeing
prismatic breaker getting reworked to be more up to date with calamity standards
if that was ever in the cards, if not that is fine too, figure I should put that out there
in case anyone was afraid of touching it cause I'm the donor

[distant gyro]

i will keep that in mind, thanks

[grave zinc]

@cloud socket - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Don't let Calamitas move in if you beat the boss rush before you beat her normally]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fervent meadow]

i got beat out by a compass qol recipe (granted it didnt get sent either but)

[sand marlin]

Donor W

[ripe owl]

#suggestions-posting message
@dusty path the argument crumbles quite easily: there is either the Hive trying to ram you or his worms trying to chomp on you. Standing still is simply not an option most of the times

[dusty path]

In expert mode

It doesn't attempt to ram you

It just hovers over you

[ripe owl]

Probably should mention it then

[hollow verge]

im so sad it didnt get sent

PLEASE i hate grinding the compass out so badly

[fervent meadow]

truee

i really wanted ammo hotkeys tho

[hollow verge]

god was ammo hotkeys in that batch

[fervent meadow]

yeah 😭

[hollow verge]

[fervent meadow]

#suggestions-voting message

[hollow verge]

i had 97 votes.... 4 off to be equal to the stealth guy

god, ammo hotkeys wasnt even close

[fervent meadow]

gotta recycle near the start of a batch in like a month

and pray 🙏

[harsh echo]

this must be added...

[harsh echo]

yea fucking hate cultsit!11

[safe pine]

pfft okay, strong reaction

[grim tusk]

It was swallower by the sea of suggestions

[misty lichen]

no way

[buoyant idol]

I don't like the idea of the compass, or even other accessories in vanilla for that matter being craftable. Why should that be Calamity's responsibility?

[serene vapor]

I got like 95 for making harpy wings craftable with a regular anvil

[frail fox]

Achieved the impossible

[hollow verge]

so just dont craft them. it's not calamity's "responsibility", but it's an added QoL thing, and grinding the compass is mind numbing + silly that it cant be made when a lot of other things can be. including some of the traveling merchant's shellphone stuff.

either way, the suggestion lost out. i might repost it when enough time passes because i do want to see it, it's like my one of very few gripes w calamity, but complaining about it at this point feels a little redundant

[hollow verge]

anyone who doesnt vote for kites isnt a real fan /j

[hollow verge]

if arrow hotkeys doesnt get an eventual repost i may also do that one because im so sad it didnt get approved. mid-fight arrow management is literal hell.

[frosty trellis]

Does it need to be cal's responsibility? No

But locking out, say, information accessories, by the literal worst rng mechanism (Traveling Merchant) is just horrible vanilla design

And cal doesn't like that design, so they made an alternative

For consistency reasons, if the other components are craftable, why should cal not make compass?

Makes sense with calamity's design philosophies

[hollow verge]

thank you, that is very articulate of my thought pattern

i appreciate your words

[frosty trellis]

:thumb

Fuck

Mobile discord moment

[harsh echo]

epic

[fervent orbit]

:thumb

[hollow verge]

[frosty trellis]

Henlo noob

[fervent orbit]

hiiii

[misty lichen]

compass is a monster drop

compass, depth meter are consistently obtainable while traveling merchant items are not

[crude geode]

and yet radar is craftable despite being obtainable from crates

[lavish condor]

well like it's 1% so I can see why

Also calamity makes enemy grinding super easy with zerg, blood moons, and chaos candle

[drowsy plank]

fishing isnt real

[crude geode]

So true

[echo leaf]

fishing is funny

fishing solves every problem

[grim tusk]

Terraria fishing:
Basically gambling, lootboxes included

[vestal lark]

Are the damage types of consumable ranged weapons hard-coded?

[fervent orbit]

no, why

[harsh echo]

change to rogue real

[vestal lark]

I was going to make a suggestion to change at least some of them to Rogue damage.

[ripe owl]

No

[vestal lark]

Fair enough.

[misty lichen]

been denied before i’m pretty sure

[harsh echo]

They'd kinda be useless though is what ive heard

as a reason

[ripe owl]

Yeah, and it's pretty much effort for nothing, Rogue is quite fleshed out early game, why add more

[fervent orbit]

no, calamity isnt going to change any damage from one class to another of any vanilla items

[harsh echo]

wut?

[harsh echo]

chronomancer scythe ?

[ripe owl]

Uuuuuh

Donor weapon

[fervent orbit]

clarified the message

[ripe owl]

They're a whole nother story since it depends on the donor

Also yeah vanilla cause they're fine as is

[fervent orbit]

i was talking about vanilla stuff specifically being changed

not content in general

[ripe owl]

(hey guys remember that one Thorium Calamity mod that makes Face Melter a bard weapon for some fucking reason?)

[fervent orbit]

this is also why ninja set isnt rogue

but gladiator is

[stiff swallow]

yeah why would they make a guitar a bard weapon

[fervent orbit]

rogue would require changing the stats, but gladiator is simpled added onto

[stiff swallow]

that's stupid

[ripe owl]

Ninja set is... A multiclass set, isn't it?

[fervent orbit]

indeed

[harsh echo]

alright then

[stiff swallow]

it saves them from having to develop another bard weapon at that tier and it's not like mage is starving for weapons

[harsh echo]

ong??

[ripe owl]

Well uh...

Whatever tbh

I question bringing it up in the first place now

[fervent orbit]

all the mages who wanted to use stellar tune in that one specific mod:

[harsh echo]

face melter doesnt even play like the other musical weapons

[fervent orbit]

@golden sonnet i saw u not making the title bold initially,,,

[golden sonnet]

most necessary suggestion ever. This information is based on the order of worldgen previewer, but if there are errors with the statements about generation order let me know

[golden sonnet]

it's cuz I accidentally posted it here first, and when I copied it from here it didnt keep the bold

[fervent orbit]

dummy

[dense locust]

every suggestion is 110% necessary trust

[golden sonnet]

ur so mean

jk, I know you're joking ♥️

[royal tapir]

hammers

[echo leaf]

nah the nitpicky, super specific and easy to implement suggestions are EXACTLY what this channel is for

I’m pretty sure, at least

[stiff swallow]

peak

[north oracle]

Can't wait for this change to be bugged for it to never generate and noone notices for 3 years

[wide river]

[glass arch]

raesh will notice it

[bright crag]

I should add a Muddiest Mud Block to the Vernal Pass schematic...,.,.,..,...

For the shits and giggles

[glass arch]

real

[north oracle]

The only person to ever collect it intentionally

[bright crag]

That said
While this is very specific, I do think it has merit

So go on

[north oracle]

Yeah no it's a reasonable suggestion
It's just also extremely specific to just Raesh

[golden sonnet]

I totally don't get it every single playthrough i do

it's a rite of passage

[grim tusk]

Dirtiest block recipe when? (it needs 10^36 blocks of dirt)

[echo leaf]

(it's not physically possible to craft without outside mods)

[distant gyro]

terraria equivalent of 10th power compressed cobblestone

[echo leaf]

It's possible to break with anything, it just takes too damn long

[hollow verge]

simply import a crystyl crusher and you'll find it eventually

[golden sonnet]

Cheating, ruins the point of the pursuit

[echo leaf]

the dirtiest block is a rare surprise, not something to grind like that

[hollow verge]

yeah that post was meant to be like, a joke

[echo leaf]

Ah, sorry. Fell for the bait 😔

[drowsy plank]

@restive wharf https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Voodoo_Demon_Voodoo_Doll

[restive wharf]

interesting

I still think minions shouldnt target voodoo demons though

[drowsy plank]

that doesnt make any sense

they're still enemies and arguably pretty big threats even if killing them can sometimes cause WoF to spawn unexpectedly

like you should