#suggestions-discussion
1 messages · Page 260 of 1
mechs even get buffed as you progress
it'd be a prime area to make you do refights
a WHAT

yeah I remembered wrong
Kinda wish you could create concepts for accessories and post them on the suggestion page
why
what exactly did you plan on doing if that was the case
what does it do
maybe reading the suggestion rules can help clear some questions?
@drowsy plank It generates a field that grants 25 defense and 25% damage reduction, as well as dealing damage to enemies that are in the field and slowing them down (much like the glacial state)
that seems powerful and unnecessary to be honest
It’s calamity, a lot of accessories are powerful and unnecessary
this is pointless and broken yes
what exactly are you trying to do with this?
25% DR is broken as a stat alone, but you also just sort of tacked on 25 defense (more than any other accessory in the game to my knowledge) and a free tesla potion effect
You never let me explain how the shell is made
wtf...
25 is 5 less than yharims gift, the stat stick to ever stat stick
awesome
25 defense is actually less than like 3-4 accessories, like DSR, Sponge (if you consider conditionally), Yharim's Gift and maybe some others
Also Draedon's Heart gives 48
accessory balance DOES exist in one form or another
and this is not it yall
oh my god fr?
25 is 5 more than ursa sergeant
Oh wait DSR is 20 nvm
yeah its ludicrous
but dheart as a whole is ludicrous so i cant say that
par for the course tbh
that's kinda the point anyway lmao yeah
The accesory is made with 15 Tesla potions, 5 armored shells, and The Sponge
bad
no.
yeah okay what exactly was the point of this accessory
what were you trying to accomplish
stat stick, clearly
as if the sponge isn't good enough
no i genuinely want to know
oh i know
they want it to be upgraded into rampart!!!
what niche is this trying to fill
sponge needs an insta sidegrade that just is extremely strong obviously
why do you want this to exist
Auric tier Absorber
because as we all know, rampart needs to include every defensive accessory
okay guys fr dont dogpile
In theory you can get far over 100 defense solely via Laudanum debuff converts but that's so conditional it's not really worth mentioning
laudanum when i fucking kill it
i want to know why he wants this to exist
how do you kill a beer bottle
or whatever
smash it, duh
Do not the bottle
chuck it
Honestly I just think it would look cool, maybe reducing the defense and damage reduction could fit the bill for the accessory
incredible
preferebly at someones head
Laudanum is an extract of Papaver somniferum latex containing approximately 10% powdered latex by weight. It is useful as an Analgesic and Antidiarrheal.
okay you cant fault me for trying i was hoping there was an actual thought behind this but i guess not
truly the killer of calamity improvement ideas
at least you tried
"it would be cool"
Make it work only in OOA so you can afk it even better
remember
at the core of every SIS there can be a genuine issue with the game
but sometimes it's just
"it would be cool"
if you're gonna do anything to OOA, delete it
i just completed OOA, can confirm actually pressed a movement key, unacceptable
It's better than boss rush though
@drowsy plank picture it tho, a barrier with a moving sprite of an atom
no, make it only work on pumpkin and frost moon, but only make it available until after the events
yeah i can picture how awful tesla potion looks already i dont need a reminder
this is a reference

Rover drive chilling in the corner
i get the joke!!!!!!!!!
Tbf they do need to dial down the size of the Tesla potion aura, it’s way too big
rover drive already upgrades into sponge i dont see the issue
tesla potion aura isnt that big it's just gaudy
inferno at least tries to be subtle
How the hell is inferno subtle
It doesn't fill the entire circle
It's just a border
Unlike Tesla which is a full shader with effects the entire circle
mhm
not to mention inferno is much more transparent last i checked
tesla is a pretty strong white border
Well with the Shell, I was thinking of a circle border with a moving atom inside of it
You know what that looks like, right
I’m guessing not
yes i know what atoms look like
Oh mb thank goodness



If you don't know what an atom looks like I think I would have Many Questions
Fr lol
the actual answer is that that isnt even what atoms actually look like
this is kind of the whole point of schrodinger's cat, you cant know where it is AND how fast it's moving, so more recent models use the electron cloud, which is more accurate
Pal, microscopes exist

electron orbital accessory when 🔥
lmao
Damn you have a point
because a light microscope (even an electron one) is definitely gonna be able to see an atom clearly
microscopes dont get that magnification unless they're electron microscopes in which case you get solid orbs
which
as i said
is more accurate to the electron cloud model than those concentric circles they talk about in high school
electrons move extremely fast you arent getting any concentric rings
I know, I’m not going off of what actual atoms looks like
Im basing the design off of what they look like in pop culture
Call me stupid for that, but it’ll look much better than clumps of balls
at most you're getting things that stay somewhat the same distance away from the nucleus but even then i dont think that has any actual proof to it
i realize, but you sure were being condescending about it
regardless this doesnt redeem your accessory idea at all. a mildly unique idea for a visual for Inferno Potion Two doesnt make the accessory or the idea good. you admitted yourself it doesnt have any purpose beyond "it would look cool"
im fine with moving on, i already said this isnt going to go anywhere
Like I said before, the accessory isn’t going to have the same effect as the inferno potion, as the rings are incredibly huge
The rings are about as big as the rover drive’s circle
...

isnt that smaller than both inferno AND tesla...?
yes
Its supposed to encircle the player, so yes
"the rings are incredibly huge"
okay i still dont
It needs to be scaled to the player’s size
that seems more visually cluttering than inferno and tesla combined
You don’t have to, this idea was something I did for fun, just wanted to know what everybody else thought of it
Guess it doesn’t pass the test, but I have to thank you for your feedback on the idea
not to mention that an enemy would basically need to be inside of you for it to do anything (ignoring the 25% DR and 25 defense
)
yeah alright well, make sure to review the rules next time. the purpose of this is to find issues with calamity and suggest improvements, not just to be a terraria fan ideas wiki importer
ideas are a dime a dozen, the point here is to address things you find unfun, annoying, or underwhelming about the game
I understand
is it just me or infernal suevites are easy to miss
incredibly so
They are
black ore in black stone when i
Spelunker potions are a must
Even though they sparkle when you drink a splunker, just use ore excavator for the mining job
who needs excavator when you have the drill
but anyway, unless you know anything about suevites they're pretty obscure
could make em brighter
one of the biggest issues in general is how out of the way crags are atm
at least abyss eats an ocean so you prolly go to check it out at least once
Isn't the suevite also placed somewhat far down in the crags or am I misremembering
It's kinda deep
yeah
Literally anyone who uses a pickaxe, not a lot of people use drills
See what I mean
I don't
Nobody uses drills, proved when you said you forgot vanilla drills existed
I meant this thing but ok?
Oh
My point still stands tho, not a lot of people use drills
I was talking about regular handheld drills
Like the lunar fragment drills
I fail to see what's the issue here
There is no issue, I’m simple stating that not a lot of people use drills, what part of that do you not understand
drills are just plain bad
Ok, how
I understand for ore excavator they are, but how are they bad in vanilla
pros of the drills:
- a bit higher mining speed (considering no mining speed boosts)
cons: - can't get mining speed boosts (which makes them slower than pickaxe if you just equip ancient chisel)
- (minor) lower reach
Wait seriously?
They don’t get mining speed boosts from potions and food buffs?
That can’t be the case
That is the case
uh i wanted to link wiki page but it seems that it's only small notes in random pages
Tbh it's not like anchient chisel is easy to get
it is just one of the options
there are also mining potion, mining armor, cake, food and ambrosia
Ambrosia is just 5%, minng armor and cake are unrealistic early on, the other two can check out considering cal just gives you mining potions in the starter bag and food can be obtained relatively early in lower tiers
Also ignoring Ambrosia's low speed, it requires shimmer in the first place
aren't we talking about drills, (mostly) hardmode tools?
someone uses wulfrum tools?
I mean I just stated why Wulfrum Drill is not actually bad
Well for hardmode, you can get t3 food, mining potions... maybe mining armor but definitely a very low chance of getting cake, and ambrosia would be relatively available so yeah there is not really any reason to use hardmode drills
wulfrum drill is incredibly fast for when you get it
REAL
i literally thought it would do this when i got it
i was so disappointed when it didn't 
how is cake a low chance
all u need is a party and party girl
which is not hard at all
Party girl is complete rng
It is definitely not free
what
Also it needs to be a natural party so if you miss out on it, you don't get it until another one
She has a random chance to spawn unlike other npcs which just spawn in when the conditions are set
Party girl is pure rng after you have enough town npcs
ok?
she isnt that rare considering how long people spend time in their worlds
I don't think so at all and it isn't without reason as I've explained
Unlike other town NPCs, the Party Girl only has a 1/40 (2.5%) chance to be eligible for spawning every 2-minute interval, during which she is subject to regular NPC spawn rate, once the criteria below are met. In other words, she will take on average 40 times longer to spawn than regular NPCs. Along with this percentage chance, she will move in once the following criteria are met:
- There is an available vacant house.
- 14 other town NPCs are in the world. Note that while the Old Man, Traveling Merchant, and town pets count towards this total, the Skeleton Merchant does not.
yes ik how she works
im saying it isnt that rare considering u have like from nearly pre boss to hm (where this drill vs pickaxe thing actually becomes relevant) for her to spawn

fyi
cal mega buffs drills
you do need significant buffs now
which can be a pain to always upkeep
@echo leaf removing defense calc's impact on dodges will never work, post ML they will almost always be max duration barring some specifically low base damage attacks. This wouldn't achieve what the buff was trying to do which is to also make MNG line more viable, and that wouldn't work if later on in the line it just never gained anything
I think the nerf to min duration is a good idea tho
That makes sense
The MNG upgrades could have that minimum duration creep down with each one- or at least with Statis’ Ninja Belt
im not sure why counter scarf lost its "counter" boosts in favor of
10% true melee damage?
it feels weird
then make the upgrades scale
this is just a problem with every dodge being completely identical with the only differences being the accessories throwing on other effects
That could work
like imagine if brain of cthulhu was still the only dodge accessory, it would be broken since it’s an amazing offensive option for the entire game
my suggestion was to remove or reduce the stat boosts from most and make the dodge power and cooldown scale better
The only one I can see that working for is The Amalgam and Statis’ Void Belt since those don’t include any other accessories in their recipes
hm
i mean lunarian needs changes but
im not sure if this is the right place for this or the right way to phrase it
I couldn't really think of other ways to phrase it. I honestly think that it's just a relatively bland weapon especially with it being a counterpart to the Night's Edge
i dont like thinking about it as night's edge counterpart at this point lol
That's why I suggested changing it
It doesn't feel in place
At least not with the way it currently works
the point is more it shouldn't be an equivalent to night's edge
that said lunarian is still really boring with it's effects not really. doing anything
it's a neat concept of sliding along blocks, but it doesn't have a tanglible gameplay effect
Yep
yeah agree
It's basically just a bow that shoots two arrows if you're not using wooden arrows
i think it should convert wooden arrows into flaming bees that inflict brain rot
so they convert into you
OOOOOOO
that Spadefish suggestion is probably my best I've ever made
It is really good
i pitched the new menu themes idea to fabsol earlier and he said that's a really good idea lol
Awesome

the main issue will be art
...just do the normal boss
boss rush variants are changed heavily to be much harder
like scal has a lot more projectiles and the arena is much smaller
not scal
isnt scal specifically made to be easier
just do her in death mode that's more accurate
pretty sure yeah
well its not easier for me!
practice death mode scal
and besides its still an issue with every boss, lets say for some reason you can't beat golem in bossrush, you have to go through like half the entire boss rush to practice against it
Toasty's QoL's Broken Rune exists
oh i don't have that installed
and still would be nice to have in the offical mod
I don't think there really is any way to implement it without it looking out of place
you could do a similar thing to fargos overloaders
have a specific item that you can combine with boss summons to make a summon of the boss rush version
Fargo's Overloaders are a different thing
i know im saying they could do a similar thing to them
First, Fargo doesn't have a complex lore of an actual book
Second, it doesn't let you practice the bosses on a higher difficulty, it in fact spawns them with regular AI
yeah im saying do a similar thing to how you make the summon
also why would having lore items change things?
Not lore items, lore in general
A lot of items have some lore reasoning to exist. Adding whatever you're proposing, at least in my opinion, would clash with that policy
yeah but there are many items which completely ignore lore or anything, why do these have to be any different?
Because they'd be neither from vanilla nor dedicated content
this isn't a vanilla item nor dedicated content either
where does it say they are
Look I'm not the lore guy, plus I said "if I'm not mistaken", which I probably am
especially because this doesn't say who its dedicated to or anything
and its not even anything like an oc or someones pet
i think the idea is that
it summons the previous summon of the yharons kindle staff
aka this good chap
but that still isn't really dedicated to anyone
Okay I pull up my secret files
Q: What is not canon?
A: Game mechanics, such as respawning, Dedicated content (Crossover, dev, and donor items), the vanilla bestiary (being reworked eventually™), Torch God, the frost & pumpkin moons, refights of most bosses, and any item that is an obvious reference.
McNugget is a reference to actual McNuggets, plus the pet itself is a reference to old Yharon Kindle which were called nuggets
So it falls into that category
anyway even if it doesn't make sense or anything, it would still be insanely helpful and nice QOL
why would the practicing not fall into that as well?
again, it would still be nice to have in the og mod
don't know why you're repeating the same arguement but ok
You did it yourself
Want QoL? You have outside mods
Want it in the mod? It doesn't make sense for it
If you want you can wait for a dev to actually say anything on it
because it became important to tell you again cause YOU said the similar thing
You literally did it first lad
you said BEFORE that it wouldn't make sense in the canon lore, and i said why would it have to be canon
Because why add something to be non-canon? Dedicated content doesn't count because people literally paid for the items to appear in the game
they've added things before that were not canon
How long ago?
whats the canoncity of the murasama
its supposed to be an obvious ref but like
theres another item ingame that references it
at least maybe like 10%
If you're talking about long time ago then your argument crumbles
There are plans to make the Murasama canon if I'm not mistaken
why does it matter how long ago was it
Although how is still unclear to me
it doesn't mean they can't do it again
Because this is an old mod we're talking about it
That's not how it works?
then how does it work
If something doesn't fit/make sense then why add it
because the mod's development process has likely changed
Also yes
again with repeating arguements
i've already told you
I mean literally, you can look like at 2018 #suggestions-voting and compare it to today's
back in the old days, specific item suggestions were allowed and were EVERYWHERE
now? they're completely frowned upon
yeah but at least weapons could have like negative things about it (unbalanced, unfun, etc)
what negative would allowing you to get better at a boss rush version of a boss bring, all it does is make it so you don't have to repeat the boss rush over and over to slowly get better and better at a fight

uh, it might be a lot of effort for no reason
why would it not have a reason?
the changes that boss rush does to the bosses arent really enough to justify having basically an entire difficulty akin to ffxiv's savage version of its raids
Boss rush is already something I think a portion of the player base overlooks
now, that said
a savage-type mode for calamity that properly elevates all the bosses to endgame status and is generally well implemented
that would be neat
but uh
it might be too much for a suggestion to add
you gotta keep the scope of your suggs a little limited
they are faster, deal more damage, have different attacks, and are over-all tougher, that isn't enough?
and why would it have to be an entire difficulty
it doesn't have to be
But that's what it ends up being
You either have items that spawn BR AI bosses which don't make sense on the grand scheme of things
Or an entirely new-not-so-new difficulty which is a Suggestion Don't
Doesn't the boss rush have some fundamental changes to game mechanics too? Like defense damage. And damage in general
damage wouldn't really matter, the point is learning the new attacks and getting better at that specific verion of the boss
defense damage is not locked to boss rush
It's tweaked to function differently
Just make boss rush calzone and scal not bullshit, like the bullet hells really dont need the extra projectile speed
But in the meantime, consider using a mod to get godmode then practice her until you're confident
wdym boss rush calzone
Does he know
not trying to be rude, just don't understand what you're saying

like, a giant pizza roll
i know what a calzone is
I'm hungry now you bastards...
🧌
oh why didn't you say so
Presumably the calzone is the SCal arena
the natural evolution goes
pizza roll
Hot pocket
Calzone
Calzone = calamitas clone
Spreading misinformation my beloved 
calamitas clone isn't really that bad because you have a large amount of room to dodge and run around
boss rush scal locks you in a really really tiny room
Party pooper
i guess they could just like, return the box size to its original form and that would be fine
There was a mod that did that, stuck on 1.3 lol
Huh?
Made by Dom
Malice mod?
The old CalTesters?
Was an addon for 1.3 CalTesters
Toasty’s was made based on CalTest iirc
what if to make the terminus you had to find a specific rock (found in the same place as terminus originally was) and you combined it with a large amount of souls of night and light, and if you did that with normal boss summons it would make a summon for a bossrush ai version
Why
idk just throwing out ideas which aren't an entire difficulty
also i feel like it could be kinda cool idk
That's too specific plus probably breaks whatever plans there are plus WHY
“It would be cool” suggestion invalid
True
how would it break the plans for whatever
How would we know? Dev plans are not public
i say the same thing to you
But there are some plans for Boss Rush, I'm sure of that
but that doesn't exactly mean that doing that would break anything
really depends on what they add, with most outcomes not really messing with anything
They definitely aren't making Terminus craftable from random rocks and sticks
"It would help" is not enough of justification
because it is annoying to go through the entire boss rush just to practice a little with a specific fight
External mods
again, it would be nice to see it in the actual mod, so you don't have to download a bunch of external things just to remove 1 annoying feature
Has no reason to exist in the main
You already modded the game to get Calamity
Terraria on Steam is probably the easiest game to add mods to, anyways
and why not?
theyve explained this like 5 times btw
and i've said why their explanation doesn't really work\
anyway im getting bored
bye bye
Your problem
¯_(ツ)_/¯
"Please add this feature"
"There are addons that add this already"
"But I want it in the main mod"
"There's no reason for it to be"
"Why not?"
That's all I'm getting
What do you all think of removing death mode
If your argument is "why not" then it's a SIS
What if we removed you 🫵
this is like the second sugg argument today 

Like just take all the death changes and put them in master rev
this is what will make calamity great
Eh, more difficulty options is always a plus
nah just expert rev
Just don't
Disagree disagree disagree-
Seems like a lot of work for a net negative
if you suck you just shouldnt play calamity!!!
It would be cool if they added Malice back 
if you suck you shouldn't play master death
It would be cool if they made the game worse 
Ture...
minor spelling error:
You're a minor spelling error 🫵
malice exclusive drops...........
(all future arguments are now void)
calamity classic malice run coming soon
God if cal classic ever gets to that point it’ll be so funny
completely unrelated to anything else
but i'd also like to point out this mod also adds several cheats, like godmode, fullbright, infinite flight, and infinite potions, all accessible from the start of the game, which isn't really bad but it makes me doing stuff like beating the bossrush a whole lot more suspicious when you have godmode easily accessible
also getting the item that allows you to practice boss rush ai versions completely removes your normal terminus so now i have to make an entirely new world to get another one
other than those kinda weak arguements, great mod
That's because it's mostly a testing mod tbh
So it kinda implies that you'd be quote-unquote cheating
oh
its fine, i would really like if you could toggle the crazier things (godmode, infinite flight, etc) from showing up though, just to make it less suspicious when you do beat bosses and stuff with the mod, idk
everybody can tell if you do a fight with godmode and infinite flight
Not to discount your concerns, but I doubt anyone would question the accomplishment should you provide footage
oh wait i could just show that its off
That UI thing on the corner
like after the fight
It shows if you have Godmode enabled
i didn't know that because i haven't used the godmode
I lied
...night guardians
i think this specific issue is exclusively br scal being very unfair lol
i did br testing earlier and new new fireblasts do NOT work well with malice bullet hell bullshit speed
nobody’s ever actually had this issue until just now, except for nohitters who don’t count
Smh my head lying to the public
I AM GOING TO SKIBIDILL YOU
oblivion yo-yo too loud
basically has the same problem as OG wingman
too many lasers
Lillies of finality doesnt teleport with you like most summons, would that be a sugg or a bugfix?
More like a #1052323733961977947 thing
Huh, actually an interesting sugg
My only concern with this is balance, right
Because if you can do yharon before moon lord you've earned that fucking gear, its balanced around skill and skipping progression
you earned that rogue drop from yharon when you're playing ranger
But prov isnt too much of a jump, my main thing is skill or something???? I cant put it into words why but I think it's relevant to balance
june have you heard of this excellent feature called the shimmer fair sugg, probably unintentional but its also been like 3 years?
clearly its the solution.
You can already skip moon lord in getfixedboi
And providence and profaned guards aren't even necessary bosses
GFB is a different beast 
If that's in response to my point then its GFB
They said "even an obscure method"
You get light discs from EoW I dont think balance is at all a concern there
Its just kind of dumb in my opinion
you should be able to summon exo mechs and supreme witch calamitas in pre hardmode
Cuz terratomere is in exo blade ig
Yeah, that would just make you shimmer zenith
Shimmer zenith
Get Earth and Exo Blade
Profit 
No, it uses terratomere
Thought about this, doesn't feel right to suggest it
Though its just my opinion
Soo... you want to make Exo Blade even more grindier, sure 
exo weapons arent grindy unless you treat the game like a boss rush
Maybe making Terratomere a part of Zenith and Zenith a part of Exo blade would make more sense
I feel like the consensus from devs is to just leave Zenith alone outside of balance
Very fair consensus
#suggestions-posting message btw heres what I mean for my suggestion
im not sure actually
i dont think its actually official
there's a mod with a glowmask fix iirc
I want to complain about life regen tooltips
Many of them don't even state a number
And those that do use different metrics
It's just confusing to the player when increasing life regen by 1 and 1hp/s is different
most of the inconsistencies likely stem from vanilla
there have been a few attempts to overhaul the tooltips at this point
i feel like we'll get there eventually
I certainly hope so
I think out of the "systemic" tooltip inconsistencies, life regen is the most egregious
Calamity should have changed every vanilla and Calamity life regen tooltip to list it in terms of HP/s
If there is a tooltip that does not do this, that's an oversight
Okay, should I list any I find in #1052323733961977947?
that would be very helpful i think
ah ok thx
@deep wedge Infernum shouldn't be mentioned; it's not made by Calamity.
sorry but i think the problem at hand still stands
(infernum)
she is much slower in base cal because she literally keeps up with you
and guns have plenty of velocity at this stage of the game to just be point and click
also, dso is a donor item, it cant be changed without permission
and even then, why do u want to change it for just one sniper weapon
its meant to provide that flexibility to the entirety of the ranger class
things like clockwork bow and heavenly gale are examples of non sniper weapons that heavily benefit from dso
also, dynamo stem cells were just recently buffed
(I should probably mention that concerns about balance would go to #1178515062030348308, not even touching upon the large amount of work this suggestion is asking for outside of a rebalance)
those were just ideas that came to mind as examples
also youre right
Ranger is already very viable post ML
#suggestions-posting message we have a thing called hitscan weapon,,,,,,, dragon breath,,,, luminite bullet,,,,,,
GS bullet even
Its literally better luminite
Also like several of the rocket launchers got changed and there’s many homing ones, flamethrowers too
There’s also ol’ reliable Magnomally Cannon
Just kill Exos first
Altho Gale’s arrows also home iirc
Plasma rifle also got a huge glow up last patch
It has some homing now too
Surviving few hits on Infernum is normal
The dmg values in that mod are ridiculous
Daawnlight is meant to be a tradeoff, your dmg is increased drastically if you have good aim, otherwise it cripples your dmg instead
maybe its just a skill issue on my part, so should i delete it?
alr
Honestly they do feel like death-master sometimes
Sometimes less
Sometimes even more
I’ll have to check and see
I didn’t know that, huh
DoG head being like 1400
#suggestions-voting message Abitlity moment.
I fucking hate infernum DoG 
Btw, 10 minutes till the suggestion pass, ig
I can't wait to see how these last few suggestions do
I like this, every single wing in the game does not need a material tag
Skill issue
Should have made it better than mine then
hmmm, I suddenly feel the urge to write a suggestion

hmmm, i suddenly feel the urge to punch you in the face
that doesn't sound nice
Parry him.
She can't parry me, I'm too tall
How tall.
I'm not tall, noob is just short
Can't be shorter than me.
how short
5’3 for freedom units.
Only blue attacks are unparriable - John Ultrakill
At least I fit into overhead storage on flights.
yoooo, life hack
free seating lets go
umm i should fit in the overhead storage too it just wouldnt be as comfortable
Parents put handles on me and I’m carryon luggage.
?
oh
they did say the wrong one
@fervent orbit smh
imagine living in the past
I wish they renamed and resprited all of the tracers
I think they will, eventually
But I might be in a nursing home by then
This sugg tho
It's a little funky
Cuz Angel Treads use the mech souls, which are a higher-tier soul than souls of flight
But I guess it's fine, I'm sure there are other such recipes
Also the body text still says seraph tracers
AAAAAAA
_ _
I get it
I dislike this suggestion because it makes the recipe go further away from Celestial Tracers being a material for Celestial Tracers
what
It's my DREAM to eventually have a version of Calamity in which Celestial Tracers become a possible component for themselves
ok?
Infinite craft loop that deletes resources, fantastic.
Now this is modding
Now hear me out what if the Cosmic Anvil was used to craft itself
ok hear me out
delicious meat should be either buffed or reworked
deleted
oright
Ok
But
Who will supply the Delicious Meat if it gets removed
Crabulon
@hollow shell sorry for the ping, but I was looking to make a suggestion on the Prideful Hunter's Planar Ripper. Do you have the donor's username so I can ask them permission?
Sure, gimme one sec
there should be a channel for list of donor's discord username and their in game donor item so people can easily contact them to make a suggestion
@spark ravine They are @foggy slate 200504618352902145
doesn't Cog or anyone regular here have a google doc with all the donor names + the ways of contacting them?
I've heard about it here long ago
that thing should be pinned here
The mods and devs both have a spreadsheet
(the same spreadsheet)
iunno if it'd be considered undesirable attention to have them all accessible directly
If a username's easily accessible people will ping them, intentionally or not
(This is truer in some regards than others, I can say this as I have experience with something like that)
I think it's fine just asking a mod for the @, and if it's an issue being in public, there's always asking through modmail
just make their in-game item show their contacting way when pressing shift 
welp... Can't see the Thank You donor anymore,
make it replace the == Donor Items == lines 
Those lines appear at the bottom right?
i dunno
probably considering Uber got recently a hate message regarding his donor item
so its best to not make it easily accessible
Jesus. How does that... even happen?
What was his item? It can't be that bad.
anomalys nanogun. the one that was talked about earlier
yea
He made an unironic sugg to remove it straight up
Its not a far assumption to assume its the same guy
oh that guy
Why does he hate it so much I wonder
Thats kinda sad, just like dont use it if you dont like it?
I struggle to see how a single weapon in the mod decreases the quality of his life by merely existing
Uhhh they don't know what that is, or ignoring it
harass someone online for literally no reason...
Oh, it's ranged? That explains why I didn't know about it
Me too, some people are genuinely crazy
Its the one with recoil right? Cause thats cool af
Rclick has recoil and shoots 3 bombs, yea
the line between trolls and numbnuts gets thinner every day
Sick weapon and a reference to a game I've never heard of, probably a childhood game of the donor if I had to guess
Iji, according to the wiki
2008, not a far off assumption
to be honest, we all want to implement a sick weapon and a reference to a game that we love dearly that isn't referenced enough
if its any consolation monster hunter's one reference in calamity mod is fucking "je suis Monte"
I think there should be a Peggle reference
You go to the mod configs and active "Peggle Mode"
Whenever you kill a boss for the first time Peggle's Ode to Joy starts playing for its entire duration
there should also be a reference to a black hole where you turn on black hole mode and then it deletes your game files and everything on your computer
The idea of deleting pc files is overrated imo
Gearsaw mode, makes your character 1.4 blocks tall, have a wiki page open ingame and makes random critical exploits appear.
@echo leaf - Your suggestion has received an updated status!
[Have Tax Collector give a bonus for defeating Brimstone Elemental (or a quote as to why he doesn't)]
It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message
@fervent meadow - Your suggestion has received an updated status!
[Stop Lunatic Cultists from naturally spawning after progressing enough]
It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message
@outer sandal - Your suggestion has received an updated status!
[Add acidwood fences]
It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message
that fine
time to learn how to sprite in calamity artstyle and maket his
Calamity style…….
sugg given 👍
look inside
artist requirement
Classic
I lost the sound of walking. What is the reason for this?
???
add team projectile hide option
Install Fargo’s mutant perhaps, it has something like this
Altho that works on projectiles and not shaders iirc
yeah mutant lets you adjust friendly projectile transparency, but it doesn't work for everything
terraprisma is entirely visible with full transparency, so i assume anything that shares the property that makes it visible will remain visible
Funny but should be its own mod
Like the “yipee” mod
i think the fireballs from wrathwing doesnt get effected by the fargo transparancy
why does the wulfrum acrobatics pack hook disable smart cursor upon unlatching from the hook?
Prideful Hunter’s Planar Ripper tweaks
The Prideful Hunter’s Planar Ripper (PHPR) is a post-ML gun that converts musket balls into lightning bullets. These lightning bullets with the unique quirk to boost movement speed on critical hits, up to 20%. However, while this is stated in the tooltip, there is no clear indication that shows the player this effect taking place while actually using the weapon. Adding some sort of visual indicator when getting a speed boost and/or reaching the max speed boost would improve the clarity of the weapon and make the effect more satisfying.
I have permission from the donor to make this suggestion.
This good?
He did DM me for permission. I agree that a better indicator is required
looks good to me
k thanks
🎉
Oh that Planar one doesn't seem too bad to do right now
true
WE LOVE BUILDERS
ill mark it as complete when it reaches voting
#suggestions-voting message should I try reposting this?
With some rewording, of course
@bright spade is this not a problem with paladin's shield? I think it might need elaborating on how different the two of them are compared to one another, and why it's more of a problem with Deities
though honestly I could see cal adding an indicator for both
They said rampart and similar
Its not about the shield but the buff you get from paladin shield
Shouldn't this be a terraria suggestion
Like this has a good chance at getting through to Red
There should be a unique hit sound
Like a clang or something
As well as a visual difference, ofc
strikes me more as a plague thing than a miracle matter thing
Thanks CIT, very cool
imagine you can toggle an ai to a super dummy, with their defense and dr but no damage
basically the lorde but harmless
patchwork..,.,.,.
what that.,....,.
back in 1.3 there was a mod that added some entity that would cycle through every boss AI but without it being able to move
so you they would have the correct hitbox size and DR/Defense
hmm wait a second
that was a thing??
mhm
I think it does but one thing I wasn't sure about was like
does it inherit the defense and DR of cal
Is there any way to check defense and DR of an enemy ingame?
i cannot remember
Bestiary might have defense but I don't know about DR
after some testing, there isn't a way to pause the boss it's on, and it doesn't seem like the DR / Defense is changed as they are switching sprites
Pretty sure it's just visual change
F
true
You are correct but it's only the defense stat
ah not dr
Ye no DR
I didnt make this a bug report because while its effect is probably unintended, removing hive minds contact damage was in fact a very deliberate change.
lol
wait here i was dodging his teleports in my playthrough lmao
didn't think about that
The sprite is chomping so I agree with this suggestion
#suggestions-posting message this is really funny lol
XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

Hive Hug
befriend the hive
hive glomp
i think im the first person to use that term in years
wpuld be neat if like
instead of it getting contact added back
hive mind attempts to stay at a distance
feels suited to its thematic
yeah, that would probably be better
but obv you cant sugg that
maybe it shoots a cursed flame or something
every little bit
thats not a new attack though
Keeping distance isn't an attack either
if you have an idea for a new attack for hm, then cool
yeah but youd need to add something to compensate
ud just need to justify why it needs to exist
Because hive mind is the easiest boss in the game

thats subjective
I do 
Please no, we don’t need another plantera phase 1
If it's as slow as it is now, it shouldn't be that bad if it just tries to float away
nah dont change the movement speed
so hes still slow as a snail
but when hive mind is just floating around its because you're like fighting adds usually
so it makes sense itd float away from you
if you approched
ill replay the fight later and write up a sugg
dont want to make it and im forgetting something that makes it not work
me when the hive mind teleports halfway across the map (the ai wanted to get as far away as possible)
It's shy that's why
Nah, it'll just pick a location a few blocks away and try to approach there. 20-25 sounds good to me.
other bosses can stick to the screen, make hive mind do that but it has a way slower move speed so it can't actually stick like they can, idk
ofc im making an assumption on how exos function there
my assumption is they pick a spot relative to the player and match their velocity
hive mind isnt exactly a "passive" boss, it has 1 projectile attack and any projectiles other than that exclusively come from additional enemies, making it move away from you doesnt really work with the majority of the bosses attacks imo
as i said id need to replay the fight
im clearly misremembering the fight
if thats the case
the comedy of timing has that hive mind was a brief dev topic today
:O
Bot should be back now
ur child returned
can... can we have official calamity whips...
planned
it'll arrive soon
LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
cal whips have been a planned addition for a long fucking time
the problem is that current summoner isnt even balanced
they cant spend time developing something that wont work in the near future at all
(also vanilla is adding more whips in 1.4.5 right?)
yes
🔥
At least 6, yes
@dense locust you gotta press Enter to separate the headline and the article to make the bot not 🗜️ you
@drowsy plank I know reposting rules are weird am I allowed to delete the current suggestion to replace it with the same suggestion but with a shorter clip
yeah as long as you delete it and it isn't in voting yet
👍
Would suggesting a reduction to the brittle star staff’s defense bonus be done here or #1178515062030348308 ?
balanc
:(
A... reduction?
It's already not impactful, and relies on you disabling their ability to attack at range
I could see wanting it to be reduced if you're holding a non summoner weapon so that it's not a free 15 defence
Yeah, that what I was going to suggest
I’m using a fat melee build right now and I feel immortal
Ah, fair
You can build pretty damn tanky even without abusing that lol, but it's a pretty big boost for 0 cost at that stage
I can play like I have a concussion and still take nothing in return
Yeah, exactly
Although I’m in early hardmode
it’s literally +10/15 defense for everybody for free
Except summoners
defense should probably just not apply while the summon damage reduction is in effect
It should be reduced, not removed imo
There are plenty of great helper summons usable at all points in the game by anyone, and the brittle star staff shouldn’t have that removed from it
honestly yeah, just get rid of 25% of the defense gained
no need to remove it, you are missing out on a lot of damage by forgoing offensive minions
Well, someone might need to check since it might be a mod conflict or oversight or something
wait no
no... nvm. Reducing it from 5 to 3 is reasonable to me
It literally just get buffed
2.0.4.001: Orbiting brittle stars now orbit slightly farther away and at a faster speed, and each brittle star now grants 5 defense instead of 3.
But yeah i agree its a bit too strong
The tooltip wasn't even changed
nah @dusky ore
:9
server suggestions go to staff mail bot
ahhh
but
thank you
adding a text channel solely for vanity sets is, eh?
why? I feel like it would be cool
you can share those in #general-media / #calamity-mod-talk
it's not important enough to have a channel dedicated for one
fair
#suggestions-voting message this should be like ultrakill 4-4 where Duel(Versus Reprise) stop for a moment just before v2 hit the ground and final note play after v2 died
#suggestions-posting message fatal mistake of not getting inside the circle
#suggestions-posting message this is not a good way to approach an issue the fight has. If the problem is with Hive Mind having no contact damage on a moment that it always follows you then you should focus on that, a wide suggestion to give it contact at all times doesn't really make any sense especially if the goal of those changes were to make the bosses not have contact damage on times they shouldn't. This is counter-intuitive to that idea @dense locust but basically just focus down on the actual issue and not the entire fight. For example, phase 1 having contact damage wouldn't work
I'd say the problems with that suggestion are that it doesn't end with : and that it never mentions phase 2.
(non-existent message) shouldn't this be in #1178515062030348308
oh well nevermind then
it wasn't the hive mind thing
someone said to nerf vile feeder because it is too strong
but it got deleted
👆
Damned bots
i didnt read sorry
wrong channel 😭
Remember to read the guidelines as well
not the $50 steam give away
I am getting rich off these bots I have hundreds of dollars of Steam now 
Dont forget the extreme amount of egirl leaks
you have enough egirl leaks to kill god
Not me, I’m pure.
contraversial statement
What's rungodding?
hold left or right
ah
hey its hurt when you accidentally hit something while running 
martian distress remote sugg:
wym
i made a sugg on retiering martian distress remote a bit ago
it got like
40 votes

uh, the remote makes a sound now
oh
i thought you meant the sugg
to add a sound to it
damn i didnt know you were the average calamity player,,,,
using discord at work? Based as fuck
i work from home
Based as fuck
Reporting you to your employer so you will be fire
What if I want to be water
I'm water ench
You can't take this from me
I lied, I'm actually heart
The 5th element
You're WHO
Smh, non captain planet understander
jokes on my employer
my supervisor has had their mic unmuted by accident and was listening to a yt video

While we're on the topic of Ravager suggestions
Oh
Um
@inland saddle Sorry for ping but the bot died again
i dont think the bot will ever be truly alive
One must imagine suggestion bot happy
:sisyphus:
I haven’t had the opportunity to bring it back yet lol
Oh
Wait
This is suggbot not art bot
Oh good lord discord hates me today
Okay I’ll do full VM restarts in a bit

So how many votes do people need to have a chance to get to the devs?

pick 10 suggs from last week, sum the amount of stars and then divide the amount you get by the amount of suggs you picked
easy....
Bot should be back
thx
@spark ravine - Your suggestion has received an updated status!
[Prideful Hunter’s Planar Ripper tweaks]
It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message
yaaaaay
Epic indeed
The thing just says that it has to reach a certain amount of ratings, but doesn't say how many


