suggestions-discussion

[proper granite]

i have a feeling the contrib might be better on an earlier boss

mechs already have less health than calamitas but post1mech they also have 10% less health

[misty lichen]

even if it goes all the way up to like 8% that’s still really bad

• brim is intended post2

[golden sonnet]

Why is a very strong defensive option having 5% contribution a bad thing

[misty lichen]

that’s me spamming it every single time it goes off cooldown

[fervent orbit]

i wonder how much star cloak does in natural play

[wide river]

It will probably deal at least 1 damage

[fervent orbit]

thanks

[dense ferry]

And that's you negating, what?

10 hits?

Yes, the offensive capabilities of Flame Licked Shell and Blazing Core suck

But that's not what they are made for

Their damage is just a bonus

[fervent orbit]

then wat about smthn like star necklace?

[misty lichen]

but the offensive part of blazing core doesn’t suck

[dense ferry]

It's another story

[fervent orbit]

lo

[dense ferry]

Star Cloak is a mistake already

[misty lichen]

@proper granite just had an idea, what if instead of increasing their own damage per tier, their damage was based on how much damage the parried attack does before defense calcs? that would make it scale with tiering and the risk of the attack without directly changing its damage to be higher at later tiers

[fervent orbit]

owo

[misty lichen]

dont owo me

[fervent orbit]

okk

[misty lichen]

[fervent orbit]

AJSFVAJNIKZGNVBJKZEDIKBINKEDHIKNNJIKBHKSDZNIKBGHHjkfhbgjgkfdbhmhb,vn

[dapper apex]

Not true

[misty lichen]

dangerous misinformation

[sand marlin]

👁️

I was wondering why it wasn't already like that

[drowsy plank]

@tall furnace too specific; please read the rules in the pins

[tall furnace]

I read it over like five times

[fervent orbit]

we already have an npc to guide you to calamity bosses

its called amidias

[drowsy plank]

just because it isnt an item doesnt mean this doesn't fall under specific item suggestions

also the guide, arguably

[fervent orbit]

its also high effort

and about future content

[drowsy plank]

if we wanted the guide to guide you more you could just. you know. improve him

[fervent orbit]

the guide doesnt cover much of calamity content

its more like

a few lines

[drowsy plank]

yeah but like

[fervent orbit]

amidias is meant to be calamitys guide

[drowsy plank]

he Could

yeah i get that

you get what im saying too tho right

[fervent orbit]

yea

[hollow shell]

No, it isn't.
But it is too specific.

[fervent orbit]

theyre asking for an npc to guide u through the entire game

[hollow shell]

Don't throw around high effort as an invalidity reason

[fervent orbit]

and also give it a questing system

[hollow shell]

It is just fine being invalid with specificity

afaik it's basically just asking for what the Sea King already does

[fervent orbit]

and also uhh

yharim literally tells you where he is

in the cyonosure item

[tall furnace]

This is aparently all amidas says about progression (of what i could easily find on the wiki)

[fervent orbit]

help dialogue

[hollow shell]

Look for the expandable section labelled "Help"

[fervent orbit]

its

in the name

[tall furnace]

oh

[hollow shell]

(tbf it also grants the bubble)

(coulda thought that that was the "Help" it was referring to)

But yeah

Sea King is the one who directs you towards new things in the world during progression, including bosses

[tall furnace]

I always thought the help was just the bubble and the text was just about the bubble lol

[fervent orbit]

this is why terraria dialogue sucks and needs a revamp

people never read it

who knew people wouldnt read an irrelevant infodump that automatically appears

[grim tusk]

Depends but most take all dmg bonuses

[fervent orbit]

thats classless

which is usually an average of all dmg bonuses

typeless is taking the best one

[grim tusk]

Oh got em mixed up

[fervent orbit]

"Damaging classless weapons require special ammo to be fired and are not boosted by damage increasing accessories, potions, and debuffs. " does anyone know where type 1 classless is used tho

afaik all the examples shown on the wiki page are of type 2 classless

[gaunt needle]

who knew people wouldnt read an irrelevant infodump that automatically appears

[fervent orbit]

this is true actually

calamity players dont read

[hollow shell]

I did not realize there was a distinction between "classless" and "typeless"

if there is indeed a consistent one

[fervent orbit]

unfortunately, there is

fuc k

i keep reading slagslplitter pauldron as cauldron

wait

or?

[hollow shell]

That needs clarification for sure, like probability numbers if it's like a 50/50 chance

[fervent orbit]

aaaa

ok

[hollow shell]

It also doesn't seem like it's "flat" damage like the page says, I can see right here "GetBestClassDamage",
being "applied to" both the 67 and the 175

It looks like the 67 is just for the first frame of the dash, while the 175 is used for the rest of the dash? Weird.

[fervent orbit]

a

u alr found it

a yes i see

that is quite odd indeed

[tulip vortex]

Yo does someone knows if the ultrakill weapon marksman bullets and a sniper thing nerfed??

[golden sonnet]

nerfed in reference to what

[grim tusk]

that was several patches ago

[fervent orbit]

its been nerfed since release

[grim tusk]

Pre-nerf it was fucking comedy especially with DSO

[fervent orbit]

if ur looking at an outdated video and expecting it to perform the same way that may be why

[grim tusk]

Hmm yes I’d like to 3 shot Yharon lol

[golden sonnet]

Statements of the utterly unbalanced

[tulip vortex]

:(

it was op

[fossil finch]

Folly should be renamed to Bumblefolly because it's funny

[grim tusk]

Dragonbirb

[umbral gazelle]

dragonfolly should be renamed to makram because one of my dog is named makram

[grim tusk]

Clearly it should be renamed to Punishing Bird

[crude geode]

True

[novel belfry]

i know this is a joke but hilariously enough i think there is an upcoming critter thats called this

[haughty salmon]

Dragonfolly should be renamed to Dragonfolly

[sleek turret]

fatFUCK

He should be renamed to fatFUCK

[misty lichen]

rude

[bitter hazel]

folly should be now dragonbird

[echo leaf]

No I like Fat Fuck

[misty lichen]

good sugg

i guess she does have the dialogue and that’s the point of acceptance but like she yaps the entire fight so you don’t actually pay attention to that

[torpid mural]

yea thats another part abt it

whenever you talk to her at the end of the fight, she COULD go into more detail or sum if theres a dialogue option to see that if u wanted

or just a button to skip all the dialogue for speedrunners

[misty lichen]

for speedrunners 🔥

[torpid mural]

the reason why i wrote this is bc whenever i beat her for the first time a month or 2 ago i was like

REALLY dissapointed it ended that way

it ruined the feeling of beating her

or

i was still happy ofc but i didnt feel like

idk how to describe it but i think u know what i mean

[misty lichen]

i guess draedon has his own special thing so it sets up some expectation

[torpid mural]

it felt underwhelming for an ending

also

why do exo mechs/draedon get a good ending when scal just randomly poops out loot 5 seconds after the fight and walks away

[drowsy plank]

they literally do like the exact same thing

they both stop moving and talk at you and then leave
or in SCal's case she turns into a town NPC i guess

[torpid mural]

what i mean is

fight ends after you talk to her with a right click

when u right click on her it opens up a dialogue box

instead of it automatically just ending, because it makes the ending really underwhelming imo

its like way too short lived to be the ending of one of the biggest boss fights in the game

[coral carbon]

i
dont understand this

[torpid mural]

a

its hard to explain hold on

so you get her to 1%, where she's on her acceptance phase right

and it should end after you right click on her, (either opening up a dialogue box or reusing what she said previously in chat)

also lets be fair

acceptance takes time u cant accept someone in 2 seconds 😭

[coral carbon]

this doesnt make that much sense to me

isnt this just what already happens, minus the right clicking

[torpid mural]

you know how when u right click a town npc it opens up a dialogue box right

kinda like that

[torpid mural]

yeah basically, but the reasoning is like

itll use the remaining 90% of the song that was wasted, and will make the ending more cenimatic, especially for first timers

[coral carbon]

having her monologue be in terraria dialogue boxes will not make it more cinematic or climactic

i would say it would do the opposite actually

i dont see the vision here

[torpid mural]

sorry what i meant is

it keeps her current monologue after u right click her 😭

im not good at wording stuff srry

[coral carbon]

so its

just the same thing that happens now

but you right click on her

[torpid mural]

but after u right click her

yes

[coral carbon]

there is zero point to this

[torpid mural]

for the new players killing scal is actually like

exciting

and the ending lasting ~4 seconds is severely underwhelming

[coral carbon]

to me it seems like what you're saying is that it would just be the ~4 seconds but after you right click on her and its really not underwhelming the first time around

or repeated times

this feels like you're trying to solve a problem that isnt there or is so miniscule that it doesnt really matter

[torpid mural]

its not a big problem sure

yk what nvm

u keep wording it like its bad

😭

i cant do this no more

[coral carbon]

its impossible for me to tell what you mean because of how strangely explained and worded the suggestion and subsequent explanation was
like I cant envision it in my brain because I really have no clue what you're even trying to solve here

[odd geyser]

Ngl the Acceptance soundtrack is very underused considering it only lasts a few seconds ingame

[torpid mural]

this is exactly my point

thank you

[torpid mural]

also i feel like everyone else understand what i mean other than u ima be honest

[coral carbon]

yeah i got that part

[torpid mural]

o

well

it also doesnt HAVE to be a right click like ur talking to an npc

[coral carbon]

.

[torpid mural]

there could be an other way but i dont know how else it would work

[torpid mural]

exo mech's end actually like

lasts awhile to be fair

honestly WAY better than scal's

[coral carbon]

idk what else I can say to you

[glass arch]

yeah because draedon actually has a lot of dialogue there

scal acceptance would last a lot longer if she had the same amount of dialogue as draedon

[torpid mural]

thats true

[worldly sparrow]

yes

[sturdy basin]

true

[royal tapir]

@verbal jasper Already implemented as part of the sweeping contact damage fairness changes
CV now only deals contact damage during succ phases

[verbal jasper]

Ah, that’s good then

(That’s gonna be part of a future update I’m assuming then)

[sturdy basin]

Contact damage fairness was last update wasn't it?

[golden sonnet]

no

they are all in #changelogs

[sturdy basin]

Damn my sense of time is messed up, for some reason I thought all those were a while ago

[crude geode]

Did this not pass the first time you posted it

[fervent orbit]

no

it never got sent to dev in the first place either

[winged fiber]

Asking this in case it's not a bug

Would a configuration option to make the Calamity biome waters look like what they used to look like before they were made basically invisible be a decent option

[winged fiber]

Just gonna post a comparison of what I mean

[lucid marsh]

Oh. Yeah that looks weird

[sand marlin]

That does look like a bug

[winged fiber]

The old aesthetic for the Sunken Sea was one of my favorite biomes in the game

[fleet flume]

It's a bug

[hollow shell]

Also asking for a config option for a change is bad practice. Better to be confident and ask for the change outright. Lotta people have hang-ups about hyper-specific config options.

[drowsy plank]

that is definitely a bug so im flagging it

i suggest you go to #1052323733961977947 @winged fiber bc it doesnt look like that for me

[grim tusk]

Please redirect them to #1052330262492631071 so that they at least read the pins

[drowsy plank]

ah okay

[winged fiber]

Alright, thanks

Was asking if it was an intended feature because apparently in 2.0.2 or somewhere around there there was an update that "made the Sunken Sea water clearer"

When it looked perfect before that

[winged fiber]

Out of curiosity, though

What is the water in Calamity supposed to look like atm

Because I heard there was an update that made the water more clear

And I'm used to the first image of the two I posted

[kind marsh]

Is polterghast ever gonna get a resprite?
The current Sprite is by no means BAD, and no disrespect to the artist
however I feel like with how long ago it was made it doesn’t really fit in with the rest of the more recent calamity sprites

[olive saddle]

Its on the enormous todo list, yes

#suggestions-voting message calamitas joining me after i tell her to fortnite boogey dance on yharims corpse

[kind marsh]

Epic

[olive saddle]

Please do understand that it will take a while but an enormous polterghast rework is planned eventually

[novel belfry]

That’d actually be really cool, because she becomes an town npc after the fight

Itd be a great way to segue into that

[drowsy plank]

not this shit again

they're not going to do that

@hollow shell can we put this this back on the frequent don'ts after this considering it's already been rejected like 3 times or something

[novel belfry]

out of curiosity why is this not going to happen?

[lucid quartz]

nevermind then, apologies

[golden sonnet]

Technical limitations due to marksman rounds

[novel belfry]

wait, i thought this was balancing

[golden sonnet]

no

[novel belfry]

i thought this entire time, it was an infuriating balance decision

[golden sonnet]

it worked with pig pre midas rounds

[novel belfry]

but if its an technical limitation then i understand

[golden sonnet]

but due to some technical stuff I don't know the full logic behind, midas rounds fail to work when it was from pig

At least I'm pretty sure...... but looking at message history I can't find where this was stated

[fervent orbit]

dw i know one way to solve this conundrum

midas prime cant take coins from piggy bank because of technical limitations. true or false? @grim tusk

[grim tusk]

Idk ask Ozz

[fervent orbit]

damn

ozz scary tho

[grim tusk]

@hearty yew see above question

[fervent orbit]

wha

[golden sonnet]

I swear I remember this being stated, but I looked through message filters and couldn't find it. If I somehow entirely constructed that reasoning I will be confused and concerned

[fervent orbit]

its the government implanting false memories in u

[golden sonnet]

Big Calamity doesn't want you to know the truth

[hearty yew]

Define "take coins" and I may be able to answer this question

I do not understand what this is about

[fervent orbit]

shoot coins with the rclick

from piggy bank

yes i just realised i skipped 2 words because of ur message

or 3 actually

[hearty yew]

Okay, so you're asking:
Why doesn't Midas Prime use Gold Coins from the Piggy Bank?

(Likewise, why can't Crackshot Colt use Copper Coins from the Piggy Bank, I guess)

[fervent orbit]

yes

[hearty yew]

let me quickly look at the code and see if there's a reason why

[worldly sparrow]

umm iirc not even the coin gun can take from the piggy bank

[hearty yew]

the vanilla wiki actually doesn't say whether it can take items from the piggy bank

i just checked

https://terraria.wiki.gg/wiki/Coin_Gun

here's the relevant source code for Crackshot Colt

[worldly sparrow]

ok wait no the coin gun DEFINITELY cannot take from the piggy bank

[hearty yew]

public override bool CanUseItem(Player player)
{
    // Two things are checked for right click:
    // 1) The player has at least 1 copper coin to toss
    // 2) The player doesn't have 4 ricoshot coins (of any type) in the air already
    if (player.altFunctionUse == 2)
    {
        // player.CanBuyItem() breaks if the player has more than 2,147 platinum coins and was never fixed
        // This alternative method works no matter how much money the player has
        long cashAvailable = Utils.CoinsCount(out bool overflow, player.inventory);
        if (cashAvailable < 1 && !overflow)
            return false;

        return player.GetActiveRicoshotCoinCount() < 4;
    }
    return true;
}

public override bool? UseItem(Player player)
{
    // Remove 1 copper from the player's inventory when using right click
    if (player.altFunctionUse == 2)
        player.BuyItem(1);

    return base.UseItem(player);
}```

[golden sonnet]

it can't but midas and crackshot used to

[worldly sparrow]

imagine if you run out of money mid-fight and start shooting all your platinum, your life savings

that'd be horrible

[hearty yew]

yes

there's a very good reason coin gun can't draw from piggy bank

they explicitly want it to be limited to inventory coins

[worldly sparrow]

the coin gun is certainly a weapon

[lucid quartz]

to be fair, with 200 damage for plat coins, if you've got a good enough farm, you can melt through vanilla content for where you get it

[golden sonnet]

So any reason marksman rounds would fail to work when it takes from the pig? or was there an intentional decision to not have it take from pig?

[worldly sparrow]

yes i know that it carries till its direct upgrade all the way at post-signus with plat

[hearty yew]

checking the source of Utils.CoinsCount, it ONLY checks your inventory, NOT your piggy bank

[fervent orbit]

yea

i was gonna say, thats only checking inventory

[hearty yew]

and here's the official documentation of BuyItem

so technically speaking

crackshot colt checks whether you have enough cash in hand

then buys using your cash in hand + piggy bank + safe etc

However, since you always have at least 1 copper coin in hand, it only uses copper in your inventory

[fervent orbit]

if its intentional, or not going to be changed, it should be put in frequently suggested imo

[hearty yew]

considering crackshot colt costs 1 copper

I am going to consider this intentional and not bother changing it

[lucid quartz]

didn't know this had been suggested so frequently before, apologies o.o;

[hearty yew]

however you asked about midas prime so let me go look at that

[fervent orbit]

its probably done the same way

[hearty yew]

Please excuse the wall of text

public override bool CanUseItem(Player player)
{
    // Two things are checked for right click:
    // 1) The player has at least 1 silver coin to toss
    // 2) The player doesn't have 4 ricoshot coins (of any type) in the air already
    if (player.altFunctionUse == 2)
    {
        // player.CanBuyItem() breaks if the player has more than 2,147 platinum coins and was never fixed
        // This alternative method works no matter how much money the player has
        long cashAvailable = Utils.CoinsCount(out bool overflow, player.inventory);
        if (cashAvailable < 100 && !overflow)
            return false;

        return player.GetActiveRicoshotCoinCount() < 4;
    }
    return true;
}

public override bool? UseItem(Player player)
{
    // Remove either 1 gold (if possible) or 1 silver (otherwise) when using right click
    if (player.altFunctionUse == 2)
    {
        long cashAvailable = Utils.CoinsCount(out bool overflow, player.inventory);

        // If the player has at least 1 gold in their inventory, spend it and use a gold coin
        if (overflow || (cashAvailable >= 10000 && (Main.LocalPlayer.InventoryHas(ItemID.GoldCoin) || Main.LocalPlayer.InventoryHas(ItemID.PlatinumCoin))))
        {
            player.BuyItem(10000);
            nextShotGoldCoin = true;
        }

        // Otherwise, spend 1 silver and use a silver coin
        else
        {
            player.BuyItem(100);
            nextShotGoldCoin = false;
        }
    }

    return base.UseItem(player);
}```

Here is the relevant source code of Midas Prime

[fervent orbit]

ozz banned for wall of text

[golden sonnet]

It hasn't been rejected before as far as I can see, so if midas cannot work with piggy bank due to technical limitations then this suggestion is valid

[hearty yew]

Similarly,

Midas Prime checks whether you have at least 1 silver coin in inventory

However, it will always use gold coins if you have them, by spending 1 gold if it can directly confirm that you either have 1 gold coin in your inventory or 1 platinum coin in your inventory

[fervent orbit]

yea but if devs are gonna say theyre not gonna change it

[hearty yew]

Midas Prime is very explicitly coded to not check your piggy bank or safe for money to spend, yeah

Just because it is intentionally written this way, does not mean it cannot be changed

Has this been suggested before? What was the fate of such a suggestion?

[lucid quartz]

I checked this; had about 100+ stars, but nothing else to it

[golden sonnet]

never made it to dev server

not enough stars

[lucid quartz]

okay, let me ask this then- should I repost the suggestion to use coins from the players banks, but only for the midas prime? (previously included both crackshot and midas)

[golden sonnet]

I see no issue with having both if there isn't a technical reason piggy bank and safe was removed from the in the past

as they used to have that feature, but it was removed. So unless it was very intentionally removed, or had to be removed because of technical limitations, i see no issues with asking to add it back. And based on what Ozz has said, it doesn't seem to be based on technical limitations

[hearty yew]

I will now go look at the change history of Midas Prime to see when the piggy bank interaction was removed

To see if I can figure out why

[golden sonnet]

2.0.2.2 according to wiki

[lucid quartz]

The important parts listed on the wiki for the crackshot, midas, and marksman rounds-
Buffed the damage of both guns, crackshot can throw 4 coins at once, changed how coin multipler damage is calculated, nerfed coin firing rate, 100% crit rate for coin hits, nerfed daawnlight spirit origin interaction, removed increased coin damage multipler based on the coin's lifetime

[hearty yew]

I am ignoring the wiki and looking at actual changes to the source code.

From most recent to the longer ago:

1. CIT fixed a bug where Midas Prime couldn't toss Gold Coins if you had Platinum Coins but no Gold Coins.
2. CIT fixed a bug where Midas Prime could duplicate money if they had 1 Platinum Coin in their inventory and no Gold Coins (it would toss Gold Coins for free).
3. I completely remade Crackshot Colt and Midas Prime, but even the old versions before this were using Utils.CoinCount and not checking piggy bank at the time.
4. IbanPlay, on July 10th, 2022, changed from player.CanBuyItem to Utils.CoinCount because Midas Prime ceased functioning if you had more than 2,147 platinum coins. This unintentionally removed its ability to check for money contained in the Piggy Bank and/or Safe.

There's the full history

oh, also?

midas prime was created on July 10th, 2022.

The first commit which added it was that same day.

The file did not exist before that day.

I have no idea where people are getting the idea that this item could take money from the piggy bank

From what I can see, before it was ever publicly released, it lost that ability

The only other option is that people aren't tripping, and Utils.CoinCount used to also count your piggy bank and safe (and that was changed in a TML update)

meaning that Midas Prime and Crackshot Colt lost the ability to siphon money from piggy bank due to a TML update

But I do not feel like digging into this further to confirm or deny whether that is the case

[lucid quartz]

hmm, okay

[hearty yew]

So, I see nothing preventing Midas Prime and Crackshot Colt from pulling coins from piggy bank

And it is not a technical issue.

[lucid quartz]

Not sure if this counts as more of a feature suggestion or a bug report then

[hearty yew]

I could... probably... write a utility or dig up a vanilla or TML function that counts coins across all your coin-sale-able inventories

in about 5 minutes

and then use that for both crackshot colt and midas prime

[golden sonnet]

I remember it working personally, and this post backs that up a little #1064128178525835264 message but I could just be crazy

[hearty yew]

so to circle back around to the initial question,

midas prime cant take coins from piggy bank because of technical limitations. true or false?

FALSE

(it is explicitly coded to not check the piggy bank)

/// <summary>
/// Attempts to "purchase" something that costs the given <paramref name="price"/>.<br/>
/// Items will be taken from all of the player inventories and banks combined.<br/>
/// If <paramref name="customCurrency"/> is provided, the price will be in terms of the custom currency instead of coins.<br/>
/// If the player has enough currency, the currency will be taken from the inventories.<br/>
/// </summary>
/// <param name="price"></param>
/// <param name="customCurrency"></param>
/// <returns>true if the player had enough currency to pay the price.</returns>
public bool BuyItem(long price, int customCurrency = -1)
{
    if (CanAfford(price, customCurrency))
        return PayCurrency(price, customCurrency);
    return false;
}```

there's a CanAfford function?

well fuck me sideways there's already a function for this

nevermind "5 minutes" this would take 5 seconds

literally replace instances of Utils.CoinCount with Player.CanAfford(n)

so now the question is,

is this a bugfix / regression fix of unintentionally removed behavior?

or is it a suggestion?

[lucid quartz]

Should I post the suggestion again, then? Or is it very explicitly something that's not being done, even if it can be done- or, rather, would it just automatically be denied (like what I assumed after what Cog said earlier)

oop, seems like you already asked,

[hearty yew]

Hm

If there was a time, at which Crackshot Colt did use the Piggy Bank and Midas Prime didn't

That would be an oversight (on Midas Prime's part)

That's a type of bug

I will treat this as a bug and fix it right now

[lucid quartz]

to summarize, then,
They SHOULD be pulling from the piggy bank, but aren't because of a bug

correct me if I'm wrong

[hearty yew]

it seems to be most accurate to say

Crackshot Colt and Midas Prime have been intended to pull from the piggy bank since they were added, but are not doing that currently due to changes in either vanilla or TML code

[lucid quartz]

Thank you for the clarification and assistance, then <3

[hearty yew]

The bug is now fixed

[kind marsh]

Yeah I understand it’ll take a long time, sounds awesome though I’m looking forward to it

[hearty yew]

New behavior is:

• Crackshot Colt checks your inventory, Piggy Bank, Safe, Defender's Forge and Void Bag (IN THIS ORDER) for 1 copper coin

• If you have at least 1 copper coin total between all those locations, 1 copper coin is spent exactly as if you purchased an item from an NPC, and you toss a copper coin.

• Midas Prime checks your inventory, Piggy Bank, Safe, Defender's Forge and Void Bag (IN THIS ORDER) for 1 silver coin

• If you have at least 1 silver coin total between all those locations, you are capable of using the right click

• Midas Prime then checks again (same way as above) to see if you have at least 1 gold coin total

• If you have at least 1 gold coin total between all those locations, 1 gold coin is spent exactly as if you purchased an item from an NPC, and you toss a gold coin.

• Otherwise, 1 silver coin is spent exactly as if you purchased an item from an NPC, and you toss a silver coin.

You can now add this to the suggestion don'ts, because it's already fixed.

🙃

[lucid quartz]

appreciate the fix

[hearty yew]

confirmed, it works

it's very funny

I can put 50 silver in my piggy bank and 50 silver in my void bag and then toss a gold coin from Midas Prime

[misty lichen]

wait so there’s no way to toss just a silver coin if you have money in the piggy bank?

[hearty yew]

Yes.

What you have just asked, is a reason to not do what I just did.

"if I have 80 silver in my inventory and (my entire life's savings) in my piggy bank, what if I want to toss a silver coin?"

If the item checks the piggy bank, then you cannot choose to toss only silver coins.

All 80 silver evaporates from your inventory instantly and 20 silver disappears from your piggy bank, and you toss a gold coin.

The alternative, is what Coin Gun does, where it DOESN'T check piggy bank, and it uses ONLY what you have in your inventory

[olive saddle]

ok but you must add the sevens striker eating platinum coins specifically from your piggy bank or whereever the most platinum coins is

[hearty yew]

The Sevens Striker is a direct Coin Gun upgrade and will follow the Coin Gun's rules.

[olive saddle]

😭

[novel belfry]

Wait, it was a bug?

So next update midas prime piggy bank coins will work? Holy shit

[whole tundra]

@lime lynx #1052323733961977947

[lime lynx]

I was confused if that was a bug or not

I am still not sure if it is

[north oracle]

It's an unintended interaction, I'd say it's a bug

Chalice has a few of them

[lime lynx]

Uh
Rework chalice of blood god

[north oracle]

Nah, it's a cool item
just wasn't exactly bugfixed very thoroughly

now you can report this

[hollow shell]

Which suggestion is this referring to?

[frail mantle]

from the conversation i'd assume titanium railgun synergizing with marksman rounds or whatever they're called

[fervent orbit]

i dont think u read the conversation at all

it was about crackshot/midas taking coins from piggy bank

[frail mantle]

oh yeah

[frail mantle]

i just saw this and defaulted to the railgun + marksman synergy

[fervent orbit]

[bold wave]

I feel like RoD is already powerful enough as it is

If you pay enough attention, it's possible to be pretty sure that nothing will hit you

I feel like that change would just be a crutch for people who don't want to learn to use RoD properly

And utterly busted for people who know how to take advantage of the iframes

[lime lynx]

Exactly

[frail mantle]

yea with all due respect i feel like the solution here is "just pay attention to where you're going"

[marsh grotto]

should give dashing 2 seconds of full iframes because something onscreen kills me whenever i do it

[fossil finch]

Look at where you're going?

[fervent orbit]

gsd should have extra iframes after the dash ends

[drowsy plank]

ah yes

rod

well known for being too weak

[bright crag]

If you teleport into a projectile, that's kinda your fault man

You just need to actually think about where you teleport

This suggestion doesn't break any rules, so I won't flag it, but the chances of it being implemented are null

[umbral gazelle]

make gsd replace normal dash

[grim tusk]

@lime lynx
Use Spectral Veil

[fervent orbit]

damn

demolished in the words

[grim tusk]

We are never going to add iframes to RoD
It would be busted as hell, might be IL edit hell (on RoD, NR it would be just copying and pasting veil code)
And we have spectral veil already which used to have around that amount of iframes and it was busted as fuck

[civic ruin]

we all talking about rod of discord, while we are on discord, when we probably have a rod of discord in our hotbar

[royal tapir]

Hey Shade did you know that Spectral Veil got its iframes buffed this update

[fervent orbit]

shade is going to kill you in 7

[fervent orbit]

i know smart people congengrate here so id like to ask

what was the reasoning of the astral biome chest not having a key

[golden sonnet]

technical limitations

[fervent orbit]

ive heard it was because of technical limitations, but thorium managed to do it one year prior to the astral chest being added

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/1.4.2.001
https://thoriummod.wiki.gg/wiki/1.5.0.0

@golden sonnet see above

[golden sonnet]

There are also mods that made lava slime not drop lava after calamity had massive issues with it

and even in the next update Fab made an entirely new entity replace lava slime to be safe

so it could just be a matter of the implimentation

[fervent orbit]

yea but it cant be technical limitations because it was done BEFORE calamity did it

[grim tusk]

Ik, at least its not as busted as when it gave way more

Pretty sure at one point it gave like 3 seconds

[fervent orbit]

180 frames

wtf

[golden sonnet]

it was only 150

which is still 2.5 seconds and fucking stupid

but not 180 at least

[sturdy basin]

I feel like there isn’t much of a reason to have an astral key anyways, since cal already adds keys to the drop pools of bosses. So chances are you would be getting the key from aureus anyways

[drowsy plank]

arent keys being removed from most bosses next update?

i know a few are being moved to minibosses

[golden sonnet]

these were the mentioned plans, unsure if it's in next update tho

[golden sonnet]

@drowsy plank just remove the stuff about dying on enemies

[drowsy plank]

true

[golden sonnet]

it wasn't reproducable, and exactly as you said, if it is then it's a bug

besides that good post

[drowsy plank]

yeah

[hollow shell]

The fact that the tooltip says "spectre healing" is weirdly... anachronistic? Is it the only place in the mod where an effect is described by comparing it to a vanilla item that does that effect?

[drowsy plank]

no idea, regardless the tooltip is bad and the item is worse so both should be changed

[hollow shell]

mm

[drowsy plank]

also wow those visuals

fucking suck i just noticed

how easily you can see spectre vs. mana polarizer's

[ashen warren]

#suggestions-posting message
I can do this right now tbh. It's needed something for a while.

[misty lichen]

long range healing is not the answer

like the range can be buffed i guess, but please don’t make it just identical to spectre

[ashen warren]

Range should not be just be Spectre, no. But it should have at least a little more distance.

[drowsy plank]

yeah like the range rn is so nonexistent it might as well not have it

[sand marlin]

Can you make its cooldown outside of boss fights consistent with RoD and NR too 🥺 (5s)

[proper granite]

its always felt a little weird that mana polarizer is just completely useless against the boss that you fight immediately after getting it (spectre bolt spawns on wof, wof moves almost as fast as spectre bolt, it immediately despawns like two feet from wofs mouth)

[proper granite]

im a big fan of the overhaul approach of forcing you to get aggressive to get health and mana pickups, maybe they linger around for a while and you have to actively run to them to pick it up?

[olive saddle]

#suggestions-posting message wasnt this reverted? i swear it was but idr

[misty lichen]

@wintry gale not only is it better than diamond, it’s better than serpents which is still hardmode

it is not barely better than diamond, it’s still better by a lot. before 1.3 its pull speed was as strong as lunar hooks is now

[wintry gale]

ok

[median scaffold]

#suggestions-voting message
What does the green outline mean?

@noble sand
#suggestions-posting message
This should have a name for the suggestion, but otherwise — it is reasonable imo

[noble sand]

Uhh, I didn't know how to create suggestion

[median scaffold]

I would do smth like this:

Change Fearmonger debuff tooltip

Fearmonger is a tank-like summoner set, granting "immunity to all forms of frost and flame" stated in the tooltip, which is wrong. It is even worse since Fearmonger is craftable post-DoG and, at the same time, doesn't grant immunity to Yharon's fire-based debuff. This could confuse people to think that Fearmonger is much better for Yharon than it really is.

[noble sand]

Buh

Yuh

[median scaffold]

[bold wave]

#suggestions-voting message

[fervent orbit]

it never got into dev

[bold wave]

Yup

But the author can take something from it if they want

[prisma isle]

i know its a direct request but a having a underwater sea type for the biom blade would be neet

[buoyant idol]

That already exists.

Gesture for the Drowned.

[fervent orbit]

it alr has a sunken sea attunement

[prisma isle]

maybe i didnt look into the types enough i know there is a water one with the beach and the void but i guess i missedd that one

[grim tusk]

And it sucks lol

Curse of UseTurn

[prisma isle]

could get an upgrade with the underwater sea, (wink wink nudge nudge)

[drowsy plank]

what

[fervent orbit]

huh

[drowsy plank]

why would it only get an upgrade in the sunken sea none of the other attunements work like that

[bold wave]

Apparently they reflavored Vulnerability Hex, yay

[prisma isle]

i meant the drowned mode getting an update

could call it tides and troubles

[fervent orbit]

mercurial tides alr exist for true biome blade

[fossil finch]

Any artist tasked with animating more providence would probably rather die

[fervent orbit]

i cant even argue with that because its probably true

just reverse the animation that will totally work

[drowsy plank]

i mean i dont see why that wouldnt

it effectively would just be the existing animation in reverse would it not

[fervent orbit]

is there anywhere with the animation as like

a gif or an mp4

i could try reversing it to see how it would look

[drowsy plank]

no idea

[fervent orbit]

"why is there just a bunch of rocks"
me looking at the gore sprites:

nah

[royal tapir]

What

No

[fervent orbit]

its adequate enough just to show there isnt an anim for going out the cocoon despite having one for going in

also why is there 2 pngs for provis defence animation

[sand marlin]

The field of holy flame is good enough an indication in cocoon

It encloses when in cocoon

As far as my experience has led me to believe at least

[fervent orbit]

huh

[sand marlin]

Was tryna do night prov a lot like a couple weeks ago in thorlamity and it always appeared closer when in cocoon

[wintry gale]

kind of
even the normal>>cocoon is pmuch simple
make one for the opposite thing wouldnt take much i think

[fervent orbit]

wat r u talking about

like seriously

[sand marlin]

Her holy flame border

[fervent orbit]

thats

thats not what this is about

[sand marlin]

How so?

[fervent orbit]

its about provi having an animation for going into her cacoon state, and not having one for getting out of it

[sand marlin]

I guess it's just for visuals and not gameplay reasons

Not quite clarified

[fervent orbit]

theres a second set of sprites, but she only does this when going into cacoon state but not out

[sand marlin]

Just fleshening out the transition so it looks better is a fine reasoning

[fervent orbit]

yes

[sand marlin]

I was thinking more about how it'd be a proper indication moving forward since you don't know when the cocoon phase stops

[fervent orbit]

guys i think i messed it up

there i managed to reverse the animation

heh

ok nvm thats a discord thing

ok yea discord doesnt like it when i post it as a gif so instead have mp4 on white background

[sand marlin]

I think the flames should reappear from the body not farther away

[drowsy plank]

looks fine tbh

functional enough if they want to implement the idea

[drowsy plank]

@slow basin that's... not a suggestion

did you mean to send that in here?

just deleting it because you asked that in the form of a question when that channel is supposed to be for submissions

[slow basin]

ah

i apoligize, i thought it was for suggesting stuff, but nvm, i read though the rules too late, and found out the submission was invalid

[drowsy plank]

i mean it is for suggesting stuff but

yeah you are

REALLY out of the loop

the version of astralgeldon in catalyst is

nothing like what he used to be

[slow basin]

catalyst? it's now a boss some else is working on?

[drowsy plank]

yes

[slow basin]

aaaah

[drowsy plank]

i have to assume this is the version you are talking about because

[slow basin]

yes

[golden sonnet]

Old astrageldon kinda sucked ngl. Coming from someone who really hates when people say calamity bosses are the same as vanilla ones, it was literally king slime 2

[drowsy plank]

the original astralgeldon got turned into aureus

yeah

ive seen it too it was really bad lol

[golden sonnet]

My first ever calamity playthrough I went in blind, got the summon for geldon right into hardmode, not knowing any better summoned it, and beat it as my first hardmode boss by running one direction

and that was in the highest difficulty at the time

Catalyst geldon is cool though, I'm glad they kinda just ignored what old geldon was

[slow basin]

for me, i never knew it was part of the Catalyst mod, but a friend had it in a list of mods, so i assumed that was the version that was later removed

but it seems i was wrong

[drowsy plank]

yeah lol

behold! original astrageldon!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYLosco8czI

also that old cloud elemental sprite

[golden sonnet]

oh god, unpaused the video and old cloudy sprite hit me like a brick wall

[golden sonnet]

this

[drowsy plank]

mhm

[slow basin]

wow, that was it?

i can see why it got removed

[golden sonnet]

Yes

Aureus is cool though, massive improvement

[drowsy plank]

mhm

[golden sonnet]

while still keeping quite a few of the original concepts

[misty lichen]

ouh its so so peak..

look at the beautiful dust

[drowsy plank]

hey it's in voting so just curious if you did end up doing anything with this btw

i love dust!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[slow basin]

he is definitely cool compared to that Astralgeldon

however i like what catalyst did to it.

[drowsy plank]

yeah catalyst geldon is great -w-

[ashen warren]

Not yet. Been dealing with other things and haven't been working on much.

[drowsy plank]

all cool, just lmk if stuff does end up happening so i can mark it with the correct reaction

[golden sonnet]

Imo the best part of Catalyst geldon is that they didn't try to keep it the same as old geldon, as old geldon eventually morphed into auerus, so making new geldon based on that would have left it feeling too similar to aureus

[drowsy plank]

yeah

[frail fox]

Not to mention the even older versions where I’m pretty sure you could just stay behind a wall and it couldn’t do shit

[novel belfry]

i still really hate aureus

but admittedly, they did eventually make the spawn a lot more interesting by being able to friendly fire aureus

[golden sonnet]

@vagrant spindle @velvet iron @thin hill Kill the sinner.

[novel belfry]

they should buil upon that

[drowsy plank]

https://tenor.com/view/exodia-yu-gi-oh-anime-summon-gif-17959838

[novel belfry]

dear god

[golden sonnet]

TRUE

[novel belfry]

could you imagine what would happen if that wasnt a slient message?

[golden sonnet]

Left left leg of Astrum Aureus
Left leg of Astrum Aureus
Body of Astrum Aureus
Right leg of Astrum Aureus
Right right leg of Astrum Aureus

[drowsy plank]

shouldnt it be left left leg, right left leg, body, left right leg and right right leg?

you know, just to make to make it more convoluted

[golden sonnet]

true

[golden sonnet]

None of them would care because we are all homies (I barely know borb)

[vagrant spindle]

speak for yourself motherfucker

[golden sonnet]

@vagrant spindle

[golden sonnet]

And people still say they miss this weapon

[fervent orbit]

its not even the weapon

geldon was spamming dust too

[golden sonnet]

they both do yeah

[novel belfry]

theyre making terratomere good again

i really really disliked the rework because it felt half-baked

[drowsy plank]

mhm

@robust acorn this is not the purpose of this channel, you probably want #help-advice-read-pins if you even actually have an issue at all

[gaunt needle]

you can already just stand near wulfrum pylon (without killing it) and wait for wulfrum enemies

[fleet grotto]

Lure makes it much faster since they actively spawn

It doesn't really do much, but it's kinda an exploit of intended mechanics

[golden sonnet]

I'm going to be honest, wulfrum farming is not super enjoyable, if you go through the effort of having a lure on you, having a core to activate it, finding a naturally spawned pylon, and are able to farm the wulfrum enemies without accidentally killing the pylon, you earned it

[fleet grotto]

Box it

[gaunt needle]

i would say exploiting intended mechanics is the best part of sandbox games

and yeah that is very specific scenario

[drowsy plank]

yeah i see no reason to do this lol

[fleet grotto]

Tbh

If anything it's more just an observation I made

[fossil finch]

this is good actually

you should be able to get cores

[novel belfry]

i mean, they're gonna add a lot of exploitable mechanics around auric ore's rejection mechanic

[golden sonnet]

how so?

it's just NPC's and golf

[glass arch]

yeah not even hostile npcs

its nothing more exploitable than whats already in game

[olive saddle]

calamity when it was peak

[grim tusk]

We should clearly make golf balls deal damage

[drowsy plank]

yes

[glass arch]

if you think about it they're just bullets 🧩

wtf discord i did clueless not clue

[crude geode]

You did it you found the clue!!!!!!!

Finally we can be free from this discord channel

[proper granite]

isnt this feature from the fandom wiki

[lime lynx]

The one that's actually good

Also is it

[gaunt needle]

Clueful

[warped vector]

interesting suggestion

[lime lynx]

(This suggestion can also be used for challenges because of exo mech duo being both able to get enraged)

[hollow shell]

#suggestions-posting message

I thought that was the point?

[fleet flume]

That was added on later. (like this note at the end here)

[proper granite]

i mean what are you going to do with infinite energy cores you just like make the weapon and maybe the armor and then move on

their sell value is 80 copper so maybe best to just leave it as an interesting interaction

[buoyant idol]

Energy Core Eject Wulfrum Blunderbuss.

[sleek turret]

The silver coins in my pocket:

[buoyant idol]

Nailgun upgrade post ML, fires magnets that stick to cursor with good homing.

[lucid marsh]

You're supposed to get infinite energy cores. That's the point

[waxen ruin]

If they made a CD version of the soundtrack i'd 100% buy ngl.

[buoyant idol]

#mod-announcements message

[golden sonnet]

yes, that is what they are referring to

[fervent orbit]

those are vinyls not cds

dummy

[waxen ruin]

i know

[golden sonnet]

why u bully

[waxen ruin]

im saying if they make cds

read

[fervent orbit]

im not. gearsaw is objectively a dummy

[buoyant idol]

True.

[fervent orbit]

[buoyant idol]

Someone should really cut off my access to Discord and trap me in a basement with my legs removed only able to make Minecraft content.

[fervent orbit]

wat about theres a demand for leg only minecraft challenges

[buoyant idol]

I make tutorials, no issues.

[fervent orbit]

tutorial on leg only minecraft

[buoyant idol]

[novel belfry]

Same energy as “I only upload high quality rips”

[buoyant idol]

@thorny brook Use a shift+enter to line break or else the suggestion breaks.

[thorny brook]

👍

[cedar moth]

How many stars is needed for a suggestion to be added

[golden sonnet]

top 20% of the batch

all the details are explained in the pins

[cedar moth]

O alr

[grave zinc]

@restive wharf - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a map icon or marker for Yharon's arena borders]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@novel belfry - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rename the Earth Elemental.]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@serene vapor - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a use sound for Martian Distress Remote]

It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@cobalt pewter - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add an upgraded variant of Power Cell Factory later in the game to boost Power Cell production.]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[serene vapor]

hooray

[cobalt pewter]

fair

[serene vapor]

martian distress remote not having a use sound is just very weird

[fleet flume]

That's probably why they want to add it

[serene vapor]

maybe an edited version of the abombination sound

since they’re both remotes used to summon

[sleek turret]

peak

[median scaffold]

Why, tho

Oh, wait, probably because they already became infinitely tall, yeah?

[sleek turret]

could be a good idea if the spawn item for yharon gave info regarding what even are the fire walls..,.

[distant gyro]

well

intuition tells you its a wall of fire and it does damage

so you should probably... avoid it

idk what map markers achieve in that regard

[sleek turret]

ok I agree with this

[distant gyro]

you could get cornered but also thats most probably by design to keep you aware of the surroundings

i mean the infernadoes do the same things and yharon spit those out every once in a while

[sleek turret]

I mean yea because yharon itself throws a ton of projs especially later in the fight

[buoyant idol]

I was thinking there could be map icons by using invisible entities that lock their height to each player.

[sleek turret]

something like a player ui on the sides of the player that has a warning sign if you're getting close to the fire pillar

[fossil finch]

We think that the big wall of fire is already enough indication

And we don't need an UI clutterer

[sleek turret]

yea

[distant gyro]

yeah thats basically the rundown

[restive wharf]

Why tho...

[sleek turret]

altix explained it above

[restive wharf]

Still would be helpful...

[sand marlin]

Explained why it would actually be negative*

Indication doesn't mean anything if the player isn't aware. I used colored pillars as indications in my own arena for getting close to borders and still often just didn't pay attention lol

[restive wharf]

I use the version of the minimap that is transparent and covers the screen, so I'm always aware

[sand marlin]

That's not actually what it means to be aware

Even if you have that map on, you can be paying too much attention to the boss and not look at the map itself at one point

That would make you unaware of your surroundings for that moment

[grave zinc]

@wide river - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add an in-game way to determine enemy debuff resistances/vulnerabilities]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fossil finch]

Lmao

[sand marlin]

Any examples ?

[royal tapir]

King Slime

[misty lichen]

zamn

[sand marlin]

Oh so it is bestiary

Well at least one part of it as far as we can see

I'm banking on some arsenal scanner item tbh

[ripe owl]

Eh, probably, probably not

I'm banking on... Not

[fossil finch]

It'll probably just be like the rest of stats

[dense ravine]

yea

kill enemy [number] amount of times and you can see

[grave zinc]

@novel belfry - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rename the Earth Elemental.]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fervent orbit]

huh

[distant gyro]

send mitosis

[wide river]

I don't think the devs got the suggestion yet, hopefully it gets sent next week

[fervent orbit]

❓

[grave zinc]

@novel belfry - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rename the Earth Elemental.]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[royal tapir]

The suggestion so nice, it was rejected twice

[golden sonnet]

3 times now

[distant gyro]

🦐

[novel belfry]

Insane

[novel belfry]

But honestly this ain’t the most important change

“Earth Elemental” after all, is still a better fitting name for its enemy than “Dragonfolly” is for its enemy

[crude geode]

Wasn’t dragonfolly literally the result of a vote

Or am I misremembering

[sleek turret]

It was

[golden sonnet]

I'm gonna say it.

I want him gone.

Just remove earth elemental

[grave zinc]

@olive saddle - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a way to see Calamity world difficulty on the World Select screen]

It has been reviewed by the devs, and for one reason or another they decided it would be best not to implement it.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[misty lichen]

oh

[novel belfry]

I even wrote a sugg about this days later: #suggestions-voting message

[wide river]

What implications does this have for #calamity-update-talk message

[fossil finch]

didnt they literally implement that yeah what

[misty lichen]

?????

lying ass bot

[wide river]

Implementn't

[novel belfry]

Wait a minute, the sugg bot is up to something weird

It already had some weird responses to me based on my (rejected) suggestion to rename earth elemental

[distant gyro]

stupid ass bot

[golden sonnet]

Nycro going to kill you

[grim tusk]

Wut

[olive saddle]

I was gonna say this was literally implemented already what the fuck is this mfer on about

[sleek turret]

Nycro probably after seeing the bot malfunction again: "stupid ass bot"

[golden sonnet]

True, they also hate how it has a mind of it's own

[olive saddle]

How the fuck a bot with four buttons sentient

[royal tapir]

@grave zinc

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/998216133129814016/1188247723980357692/ezgif.com-video-to-gif-converted.gif

[crude geode]

https://tenor.com/view/courage-the-cowardly-dog-eustace-mallet-angry-its-go-time-gif-4845999

Nycro rn

[grim tusk]

Gfb suggestion lol

Should we ❗ ?

@brisk burrow idk if the suggestion is valid but the point of gfb is to be silly and not fair

Heck you progress break already

EoC dropping Optic staff

EoW dropping Light discs

Mfing Perforators dropping Bloodfins

[brisk burrow]

ok

yeah i get that it's supposed to be silly

i just find it annoying getting oneshot within 0.5 secs

[grim tusk]

Lemme guess glass cannon?

[brisk burrow]

yeah mage

[grim tusk]

Regardless of class you can be defensive

[brisk burrow]

taking 200 damage with 10% dr

[grim tusk]

Not a valid excuse

Theres a lot of defensive gear at that stage even without mythril anvil

(Which you should have at that stage due to shimmer)

Also 200 dmg, are you getting hit by destroyer’s head or smth?

(was the destroyer hitbox being x3 big on gfb ever fixed? I think it was)

[brisk burrow]

just for reference:
I used another character with post golem loot against revengeance mode mechdusa (with buffs and all) and still got insta wiped 😅

[brisk burrow]

not to my knowledge - the body was basically slam tackling me lmao

[grim tusk]

Get a video clip, follow #1052330262492631071 and I’ll send it to dev so that someone can handle it

If you get hit by thin air then its 100% not fixed

[brisk burrow]

okee will try

[brisk burrow]

uh it looks to be bugged yah

[grim tusk]

Make the bug report then

[brisk burrow]

done

feel free to delete the suggestion ig

[lime lynx]

Isn't ftw seed is literally just a one giant and unfun bug

[grim tusk]

Apples and oranges

This one was due to an actual BAD bug

Shit like Bloodfins from Perforators is for shits and giggles which is intentional

[olive saddle]

#suggestions-posting message post plantera buyable rod of discord

[misty lichen]

cope imo

this one’s getting 4 votes but we rock

[olive saddle]

true

coping hard rn

im a serial rod abuser

shit gets me out of so many stupid binds

to actually have to play the game is so difficult as a calamity player

[misty lichen]

🔥

[olive saddle]

wrong, rod of harmony replaces counter scarf in clothiers shop

[misty lichen]

wrong, it’s in the surface shrine chest now

(5 copies so everybody in multiplayer can get one of course)

[lime lynx]

Make Rod of harmony post mech bosses

[umbral gazelle]

make rod of discord drop from primordial wyrm

[lime lynx]

Make Rod of discord unobtainable

[golden sonnet]

Make it shimmer decraft into air

Didn't think of the effect that would have on shade's mental health

So sad we can't make it do that

[misty lichen]

make rod crafted from air

[grim tusk]

[buoyant idol]

When the funny Jakita emote:

[olive saddle]

THE LORD(e) is EATING GOOD TONIGHT

[fleet grotto]

the chaos fish crafting recipe was much better

[sleek turret]

that was a peak recipe

I don't really understand why the recipe was removed to make it purchaseable via Wizard with a very accessible price and even with like 10 plat price you could get it easily with less than 1 hour of grinding

[uneven adder]

why is it sold by the wizard anyway, just keep the crafting recipe and call it a day

RoD should be at least somewhat hard to get

[sleek turret]

Yeah I don't understand that in particular

Why can it be purchased?

[thorn dock]

Why does my suggestion have a mark?

[ripe owl]

Something is wrong then

[buoyant idol]

Don’t reference other suggestions in suggestions.

[thorn dock]

I did not

Iz was a nerf request

Balance issues/ report

[buoyant idol]

I don’t think pinging people is good practice though.

[thorn dock]

Let me remove that ping, I see

[fervent orbit]

thats not why

balance suggs arent allowed. issues with items regarding balance go to #1178515062030348308

[thorn dock]

Thats not a balance sugg at all

[fervent orbit]

u r literally telling how to balance it

[thorn dock]

Schmoov made the balance sugg.
I threw in something to consider, that if the generic Star damahe will be hit, a cartain aspect of the item will break away

[thorn dock]

Not all all

The last part was an example. The one could ..

The main part is consider that if x, y will happen

[fervent orbit]

ok then. then its about future changes, which cant be a reasoning for your sugg

[thorn dock]

I was soley refering to schmoovs balance report where he soley pointed out the Star damage beeing a problem. Means he litetally points at the Star samagw for balancing it, not me

[thorn dock]

See

Thats why I continued there

[thorn dock]

I dont understand that. Pointing that an item might loose lots of its value holds no value for a sugg? Well ok then

[fervent orbit]

yes

and what other users have stated, u cant use another suggestion as ressoning for yours

[median scaffold]

I'm still waiting

[fervent orbit]

for?

[misty lichen]

schmoov#0

[median scaffold]

Atlas Beacon change I made. It probably didn't yet / won't get into the game or changelogs don't have the change

[boreal olive]

blade of justice when

[haughty salmon]

Omg gd reference????

[grave zinc]

@buoyant idol - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rework the way Plaguebringer Goliath is spawned by using Draedon related items]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@ashen warren - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Increase Reaper Tooth drop quantity or reduce amount needed for Omega Blue armor]

It has received enough votes to be passed on to the dev server for voting! You'll be notified again when a verdict is reached.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[buoyant idol]

I thought that didn’t make it.

[olive saddle]

Bot is probably having a heart attack

[random talon]

@civic ruin Specific Rework Suggestions aren't allowed in #suggestions-posting, sorry bro.

[civic ruin]

ok

no wonder no suggestions that go to voting are good

[random talon]

tho I do like the idea of having an NPC or enemy that drops power cells, you may want to try that idea

[civic ruin]

there are

[buoyant idol]

Have you read the Don'ts document?

You've posted more invalid suggestions than I can count at this point.

[sleek turret]

this suggestion is peak

unironically

[umbral gazelle]

#suggestions-posting message mechanism*

[dense ravine]

that suggestion is crazy

[dense ravine]

cause suggestions are meant to be small issues/tweaks that players notice

[sleek turret]

the sugg is more MoR lab oriented but in general I'd love a really interesting lab expansion with like cool ass unique turrets for each lab and enviromental storytelling and shit so good

[dense ravine]

massive suggestions arent likely to be accepted beause the devs already know what they doing with big stuf

[olive saddle]

its called a suggestion, not an idea, you know. bad wording, but you can probably understand what i mean

as in its usually small shit

[dense ravine]

ya

[olive saddle]

its like "you can change this, it may be unsatisfactory, this is why" not "this is bad. here is what i would do"

still sad my gem tech armor thing diditn get in but it also didnt get approval from the donor so its probably a good thing

[dense ravine]

plus the devs are already busy enough

they dont need more big content to add

[olive saddle]

the backlog of shit to yharim is insane yea, perpetually adding stuff is only going to make shit take longer

[eager jetty]

Make a potion called Redbull and give you wings for 16 minutes

+10 speed

[median scaffold]

Can I see it?

[olive saddle]

#suggestions-voting message

[grave zinc]

@gritty acorn - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Staff of Regrowth work on Astral Dirt]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@slow hound - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Let Staff of Regrowth / Flower boots etc work on Scorched Remains (Crags)]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[gritty acorn]

lesgo!!

[quiet kernel]

@foggy yarrow first off all infernum is NOT an offical addon, its not made by the cal team

second of all im pretty sure the devs dont plan on adding more difficulties

But yeah this is a dont I think (idr maybe I should reread the doc)

[north oracle]

@foggy yarrow

1. Infernum isn't officially affiliated with calamity
2. Please read the suggestions guidelines document before posting suggestions, this would be disallowed under a extremely effort extensive/broadly scoped expansion.

[grave zinc]

@median scaffold - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Atlas Munitions Beacon resummonable]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[stable kiln]

idk this suggestion is kinda chaddic i wanna add it now

[north oracle]

Rare Done W ngl

[median scaffold]

Uhh, which one?

[stable kiln]

the latest in posting

[median scaffold]

MALICE RETURN

[north oracle]

you should let me make it Done you know it would be good

[stable kiln]

i wouldnt trust you to change a weapon's damage value

[median scaffold]

Noice. Now, Atlas is the sentry?

[lime lynx]

Rare w suggestion

Return malice

[umbral gazelle]

yeah they need to readd maurice mode

[dapper apex]

Combo of 4 invalid suggestions

[terse crypt]

lol i did not see the rules im stupid
lemme delete rq

ill actually make a good looking suggestion tho

[olive saddle]

fuck malice mode. it sucked.

[sand marlin]

Nah

[honest siren]

[olive saddle]

[uneven adder]

and that's why I want it

people don't play unfair difficulty modes for the balancing man

[olive saddle]

unfortunately for you calamity has an extremely egregious tone on balancing

also they kinda do..?

people play harder difficulties to feel more challenged, not because its unfair

[errant wind]

Gg

[distant gyro]

i understood why it wasnt done at first

because it was buggy as hell

the stages of bugs

infinite cannons
no longer infinite cannons -- picks up the cannon. resummons the sentry instead of using it
both of those fixed, but you can no longer replace the sentry
instead of replacing the sentry if you deploy the cannon first then any other sentry it just accepts staying there
okay all of those are fixed how about the sentry no longer scales with your stats at all

[north oracle]

How the hell

You go from normal sentry issues to "yeah it doesn't scale with stats now"

[distant gyro]

also you can do this but lets just take this as a feature

[sand marlin]

How does it work with other sentries? Does it just use the last slot

[distant gyro]

the oldest living sentry goes away

the same way other sentries are also summoned

[sand marlin]

Oh that makes more sense

Being one use only kinda fits it tbh

[distant gyro]

having multiple of that sentry is probably a nightmare so one will suffice

apparently the only other sentry that does that is pulse turret

[north oracle]

Endgame summoner now probably uses one more weapon than before

[gaunt needle]

does the landing deal damage?

[grave zinc]

@worldly sparrow - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rename the Tyrant's Fury buff]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[distant gyro]

5 months late go

[royal tapir]

[grave zinc]

@fleet flume - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a border around Providence]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[distant gyro]

ditto

[fleet flume]

That was months ago

[sand marlin]

[fleet flume]

And is it not already in the game?

[sand marlin]

Yes

[fleet flume]

This is the second time?

[grave zinc]

@random talon - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add Auric Bricks or similar]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@fervent orbit - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make the tooltip for the Murasama clearer]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fleet flume]

Now it's 4

[distant gyro]

i enjoy my scroll of really old suggestions accidentally getting implemented

it ended there

[grave zinc]

@marble cosmos - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a crafting recipe for magic conch]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[distant gyro]

i lied theres more

[grave zinc]

@cobalt pewter - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Remove Rover Drive from The Absorber's recipe, and add it to The Sponge instead with inherited effects.]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@small timber - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Rework The Absorber's Recipe]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[distant gyro]

the follies of the suggestion system being super old

[fleet flume]

2022 now

[grave zinc]

@vale locust - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make Ninja Dodge Not Activate With <1 Damage]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fleet flume]

I guess reworking The Absorber's recipe would be accomplished by moving the Rover Drive from it to The Sponge

[grave zinc]

@bitter drift - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[add the ability to remove the sniper's scope zoom out ability by disabling the visuals on the accessory slot it's on]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[bitter drift]

wow i suggested this about two years ago! that's old

but thanks anyways, glad to help the mod.

[fleet flume]

Yours is the 9th in a row for old suggestions

[grave zinc]

@ashen warren - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Increase Reaper Tooth drop quantity or reduce amount needed for Omega Blue armor]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[sand marlin]

Nice

[distant gyro]

cit so silly for doing that

[grave zinc]

@ashen warren - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Increase Reaper Tooth drop quantity or reduce amount needed for Omega Blue armor]

It has been voted upon, and the devs decided it would be a good idea to implement it. This doesn't guarantee implementation, as plans may change/alternate plans may be made, but it does highly improve chances!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

@ashen warren - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Increase Reaper Tooth drop quantity or reduce amount needed for Omega Blue armor]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[ashen warren]

what

[distant gyro]

now you get triple

[royal tapir]

https://tenor.com/view/milk-gif-15983354

[sand marlin]

Which one is it btw

I'm assuming less mats needed?

[olive saddle]

Probably

[royal tapir]

Both

[olive saddle]

The mats needed for the cheapest peace of omega blue was i think the same as one weapon

Oh shit nice

[sand marlin]

Oh.

[olive saddle]

Thank christ

[sand marlin]

Well Omega Blue users are eating good Ig

[royal tapir]

Reaper Shark drop amount increased from 3-4 to 6-8
Omega Blue cost decreased from 8-12-10 to 3-5-4

[olive saddle]

Holy shit W

[sand marlin]

Oh god that is huge

[olive saddle]

Finally I wont have to spend 8 years grinding reaper sharks for one piece of omega blue

[sand marlin]

So two sharks guarantee Omega Blue

[olive saddle]

This is definitely a right step in the direction for niche armor sets as I dont see many people using them cuz it feels like you have to go out of your way to get them. Gem tech is an example, why would you not save it for damomshade? Its literally just better. This is probably more of a recipe conflict tbh but I'm sad gem tech gets almost no use

[fervent orbit]

holy shit after over a year

[sand marlin]

I'm waiting for Gem Tech to not be reliant on avoiding hits

Same as Drataliornus

They're cool in a nohit setting but

Not so much in casual

[olive saddle]

Their use case is so niche but I love the style that the armor is going for