suggestions-discussion

[royal tapir]

Sorry

[fervent orbit]

shush

[wintry gale]

[drowsy plank]

didnt i already make this suggestion and get it passed? or am i forgetting

[royal tapir]

I mean either way, what this suggestion is asking for has been implemented, and evil island dying is 100% in devplans.png

[wintry gale]

hmmm
looks like my wish wasnt so selfish as i thought it was
just because i didnt want to fight hivemind before eow in my crimson world

[drowsy plank]

okay so just gonna flag it ig since it is already implemented 😇

[wintry gale]

https://tenor.com/view/waah-waa-sad-wah-waaah-gif-25875771

[wintry gale]

is it?

Guess i cheated in for nothing then

[royal tapir]

Not yet

[wintry gale]

Oh

I assume that both evil chest will coexist in dungeon once island gets removed

[glass arch]

yes kill it kill it make it DIE

[bright crag]

Dryad selling the Seeds at any time (in a Graveyard) has been implemented but not released
Evil Island deletion hasn't been implemented yet, because we plan on replacing it with something else

[regal willow]

ok the one about starting at crag is cool
of course "cool" isn't the determined factor so, eh

[novel belfry]

at least its better than a gfb suggestion whose reason is just meme

my only issue is that it wouldnt be under the upside-down abyss/sulphur sea

[regal willow]

ah shit
that is true, fuck

what a shame

[novel belfry]

but eh, center brimstone crags would really sell the idea of GFB being the stupid difficult seed, with emphasis on "stupid"

[primal cairn]

I don’t like making brimstone crags the center tbh I like it being a safe hell biome

It’d also make fighting brimstone elemental a pain if ppl have set up houses and stuff there

[south bolt]

Your not supposed to like the seed

It's supposed to suck by design

It SHOULD be a pain in ass to fight the brimstone elemental

[primal cairn]

?????

Mentally deranged

I haven’t played gfb zenith calamity but I really enjoyed my gfb vanilla playthrough

It’s not supposed to be easy but it’s not supposed to be shitty and intentionally unfun either that’s just kinda bad

[wintry gale]

Yes it is
At least cal's one

[drowsy plank]

10 HP hive cyst

sorry but yes gfb is a meme seed

[primal cairn]

What’s the point in the seed at all if it’s meant to be unplayable tbh

[novel belfry]

the suggestion did propose that the crags should be the "safest area", so...

[golden sonnet]

GFB is made to be miserable

[wintry gale]

Masochism

[primal cairn]

It’s good for like shitty terraria YouTubers and not much else

[small timber]

Gfb is the "stop trying to minmax difficulty setting" difficulty

[novel belfry]

as a person who had the unfortunate pleasure to go through the whole thing with a class specific* playthrough, i can assure you that its still a legitmately interesting mode

but its also a stupid difficult mode, with emphasis on "stupid"

if that tells you off, then its probably not for you

[small timber]

You likely have to cheese or outright outgear most of the bosses yes

[novel belfry]

fortunately enough, calamity GFB pretty much encourages this sorta thing

[small timber]

Or play in multiplayer and realise the mod is easy because you just cant die if you dodge semi nicely

[novel belfry]

by giving the player ample opportunity to outgear the bosses

planetoids have spikes and cobalt/palladium from the get-go, allowing you to get the Metal Monstrosity quickly and Cobalt items too as soon as you get a molten pick/reaver shark

and EoW drops a Light Disc, which can be shimmered into... Hallowed Bars

[small timber]

If you play gfb with a character named Samuel Rodrigues your murasama base damage is locked at 10 damage and all gfb alternative boss drops are disabled

[novel belfry]

Interesting

[golden sonnet]

Really? That's actually so based

[small timber]

No it is not real, but someone can make it happen

[buoyant idol]

The Sam easter egg was removed

(Also the Murasama is pretty mid design wise, should be remade into a more Omniblade style weapon)

[small timber]

Murasama is an omniblade style weapon

[buoyant idol]

Terragrim styled, omniblade is quite different

[small timber]

Uniqueness of the weapon or interesting design is not everything

Usability is also a large part of it

We already have executioner for the super short range, cant change attack direction TM sword in post yharon

[golden sonnet]

Unfortunately it was not

[buoyant idol]

True

[buoyant idol]

Mandela effect moment

[small timber]

Wait not executioner, I forgot what does the postDOG TM called

[buoyant idol]

The Enforcer

[small timber]

Yeah that one

[drowsy plank]

ive literally never had this issue and also how would that help your problem at all

[wide river]

Bot down?

Latest suggestion in voting has the lock reaction but nothing's come up here about it...

[drowsy plank]

also yeah i did notice that

[worthy parrot]

by giving the most recently pressed key priority it'd make it so you dodge in the direction you intended

since right now if both dodge directions are pressed then it just uses your current velocity to determine the direction

[novel belfry]

the lock reaction means that

"Separate plans that clash have already been made, or a modified version of a suggestion is to be implemented instead."

[wide river]

I know what it means, but normally:

When the reaction happens, a bot message comes up here telling you that. I don't know about you, but I haven't seen that message

The suggestion in voting also lacks the normal light blue outline that it has when that reaction it placed

[stable kiln]

yes

[stable kiln]

also ifthats a problem why would you keep holding the button you wanna stop going in

just stop holding it and dash the other way

there is 0 reason to keep holding a button of a direction you dont wanna go in

[wintry gale]

forgets the button pressed

(this happened to me alot)

[worthy parrot]

as i said in the suggestion it's only for a very brief period as im trying to switch directions

ideally i'd release A and start holding down D on the same frame but that's not how it usually goes

so there's like a few frames as im switching directions where im holding down both, and if i attempt to dodge during that period then i end up dodging the opposite direction i intend to

it's not something that's constantly happening the entire game or anything, but it does happen once or twice per boss attempt and it can really screw over the attempt

[drowsy plank]

i want to flag this but im not sure if it's really breaking a rule

[north oracle]

that was my instinct too

[drowsy plank]

like this is objectively just a fucking horrible idea celestial shell was scal viable a couple updates back so this is just wrong but i dont feel like there is an explict reason to flag this beyond "it has really bad reasoning" but like

that's what voting is for, ig

it's like just on that edge of almost having no reasoning at all beyond "it's bad eventually" (which it really isnt) and "it doesn't have an upgrade" which is like.

a nothing reason

[north oracle]

It’s not an objectively terrible idea, just a complete and utter balance nightmare and not really necessary

[tidal epoch]

:v

I'm not saying its necesary, its just that I saw that it is untouched

ಠಿ⁠_⁠ಠಿ

So I sugested it

[drowsy plank]

i mean if you'd need to nerf cshell to make room for its upgrade then i dont really see a point and considering cshell is still close in power to egaunt (i forget did its melee speed die yet? i think it did so it still just has solid damage stats at least) the last thing it needs is a more powerful form

[tidal epoch]

I mean, it has some potential for being a mobility one or adding stuff that its not damage or regen

[north oracle]

Melee speed died a while ago

[drowsy plank]

okay that's a plus at least

[north oracle]

It’s now a slightly better destroyer emblem for melee and worse than destroyer for everything else

[drowsy plank]

lol
also why is it slightly better on melee still?

[north oracle]

The night buffs only affect melee

[drowsy plank]

oh it has melee crit

that's dumb

lmao

[tidal epoch]

I remember the night buffs affected summoner

[drowsy plank]

they do not

[tidal epoch]

At least on vanilla

[drowsy plank]

the melee speed is dead

so

[tardy geyser]

I think it always gives minion knockback?

[tidal epoch]

Yeah, it does

[drowsy plank]

that's at all times yeah

[tidal epoch]

I think...

[drowsy plank]

because minion knockback is such a strong perk

[tardy geyser]

[north oracle]

So tru

[tardy geyser]

byeah not every accessory needs an upgrade

[drowsy plank]

so yeah i mean i guess there could be room for it but like
why tho
you could just make something actually cool and original instead of being stuck with the world's jankiest combo accessory

[north oracle]

I think the big issue is that it just needs reasoning for why it should get an upgrade
It’s fine finishing where it does

[drowsy plank]

also true

[tidal epoch]

I mean, Lycans jump at you, so it can become a dash accesory with buffs instead of a dodge

And there is the moon and sun stones, is there a buff related to those objects?

[drowsy plank]

what

[lavish condor]

attacks inflict holy flames and nightwither at their corresponding times is all I can think of

[buoyant idol]

Lycans are Thorium

[tidal epoch]

I mean, you asked how you can make upgrades

[drowsy plank]

slimes jump at you too we should slap a dash on royal gelatin

[tidal epoch]

Werewolves them

[lavish condor]

werewolves are fighter ai

[drowsy plank]

that is not what we asked we asked why

[tidal epoch]

Yeah, of course, and we forget thats the most emblematic jumpscare of werewolf movies

[lavish condor]

Cog is asking if there's more reasoning for adding an upgrade

[drowsy plank]

okay i dont watch a lot of werewolf movies so maybe you're right but i object to putting a dash on celesital shell from a moral standpoint, and that still doesn't answer the question of why this thing needs an upgrade

[lavish condor]

becoming useless after a point doesn't really work because a lot of accessories do that

[buoyant idol]

Read through, there’s plentiful amounts of multiclass post moon lord

[drowsy plank]

and it isnt even true because dest emblem, and henceforth cshell (if it really is just a better melee dest emblem) is entirely endgame viable

[tardy geyser]

Isnt cal trying to move away from big accessory crafting trees? like cshell is already the combo of 4

[drowsy plank]

also true!

[tidal epoch]

I mean, dash accesories have 2 variants

Shield: Mandatory and gives inmunities

Belt: Dodge and damage items/projectiles

It can be interesting/useful to have an offensive dash that makes you stronger but its shorter than the belts

[buoyant idol]

I’d ❗ it for false and no reasoning

[drowsy plank]

that's not rule breaking

like i said it isn't breaking the rules it's just really bad

voting would sort it out

[tidal epoch]

Added "Useful" on "interesting" here

[drowsy plank]

that's
that's not a reason cshell should get an upgrade you're just creating a problem for it to solve (and one which doesn't even exist because currently bash dashes outclass belts so badly it's barely even funny [also there are multiple types of shield dashes like bonk, bash, etc.])

[north oracle]

Bonk, bash, and “get hit bitch”

[drowsy plank]

LOL

[tidal epoch]

I mean, a dash that does not give you inmunity or bash is pretty much a nice exchange in my opinion

No dodge but better stats/just celestial shell stats with extras

[drowsy plank]

calamity already has a default dash like

also you're still focusing too much on celestial shell

[tidal epoch]

You mean the ultra short and realistic like

[drowsy plank]

if you want a third type of dash accessory that should be the suggestion, not to make celestial shell one

the point of a suggestion is to find a problem and come up with a solution to that problem

you're just finding something cool you want to do and trying to come up with a problem to justify why calamity should add it

[tidal epoch]

I was suggesting a upgrade cuz it was untouched

The idea of the dash were just my point on how you can make it into something worthy to choose, there are more ways, not only dashes

My bad

[drowsy plank]

that's not a problem that's just how terraria works
i still want an upgrade that puts toolbox and toolbelt into hand of creation but we don't all get what we want

[tidal epoch]

Yeah, still, the sugestion is not a must be tho :)

It is just that I saw it like that, and if the devs wants openings, welp, why not?

[buoyant idol]

Why not opens a large hole since anything can use that

[tidal epoch]

I mean, not all can?

But meh, I mean, just a sugestion, not a recomendation, lets ignore me

Then

[novel belfry]

i like a celestial shell upgrade, but i can't exactly think up of any reason that isn't "Why does its line end far before the Endgame"

and trying that for the Absorber did get a lot of stars from the community, but the devs weren't as receptive to it (Read: rejected)

[drowsy plank]

the devs dont want openings, the point of this channel is for people to report actual gameplay issues with calamity and help the devs identify and solve them; something not having an upgrade isn't a problem it's just a fact of powercreep in the game

i mean just look at the suggestion rules doc and i felt like that was obvious

like say, idk exodium is really hard to get right now or something so i suggest that moon lord drops exodium alongside luminite or something. that's a problem (exodium is hard to get) and i provide a solution (moon lord can drop it), but overall the main focus should be on the problem

[novel belfry]

mind you, exodium is actually super duper easy to get, but cog's point still stands

[drowsy plank]

erm yeah but what if the exodium meteorites don't spawn in (this is a bug and not a good basis for reasoning)

[night jolt]

Yeah I was about to ask if they removed the meteors or something

[novel belfry]

for instance (#suggestions-voting message)

item suggestions are pretty difficult to come up with, mainly because you have to be generally vague about them

you cant try to be too specific

[buoyant idol]

Sadly, this includes anti grav hook that works on enemies

[tidal epoch]

I mean, we moved too far from the sugestion
The thing I want to say is just an idea they can use randomly

I was not saying the shell should become a dash especifically, but say that it can become viable to use it if you add an extra that does not affects stats and all of that, like a debuff to enemies or just an extra thing like a dash or inmunity

[drowsy plank]

yeah they dont want that

[night jolt]

Wait when did a dash on the Celestial Shell ever get brought up?

[drowsy plank]

again we're still ignoring that cshell is entirely viable

he used it as an example of something the upgrade could do

but this doesnt explain why it needs an upgrade

[tidal epoch]

I was trying to bring some examples to it, we focused on the dash by random stuff, I mean, the first example was a debuff

[buoyant idol]

Profaned theming could be used for it, merge with blazing core

[tidal epoch]

I said it was not needed, just that it was there

Sorry

[drowsy plank]

you don't need to apologise, the point im trying to make is that this just isn't what we're looking for

[night jolt]

You don't need to be sorry, suggestions are hard and good suggestions are even harder

[drowsy plank]

is that not made clear in the rules? because we just did a big rewrite to try and avoid this kind of confusion again

if it isn't clear id like to know what we could change to make that more obvious

[night jolt]

It takes experience to know what makes a suggestion good, and this is just a little bit of experience

[drowsy plank]

also true

[buoyant idol]

Idk how my first 2 suggestions got 180 and 210 respectively now that I think of it

[night jolt]

I haven't gotten to endgame in a while, is the Void Scarf still lame compared to the Aegis?

[north oracle]

Yes

It’s more viable now that Elysian guard is gone

But in general you just want the ram, or counter scarf for the short cool-down dodge on SCal

[ashen warren]

add nuclear warheads

supereme calamitis is too hard

[drowsy plank]

thanks man

[north oracle]

So true

[drowsy plank]

also wait we already have those

tfw mini nuke I real

[ashen warren]

u have nuclear?

omg

[drowsy plank]

that's a vanilla thing dude lmao

[ashen warren]

oh

ok i need to update game

[north oracle]

We need a new post DoG rocket that’s just Nuke 1

[drowsy plank]

LOL

[buoyant idol]

Legalize Nuclear Bombs

[ashen warren]

ya

wait nvm

[drowsy plank]

look im all for more rocket ammos but i know the hell that making them is

[ashen warren]

sorry

[errant wren]

why are we suddenly talking about nukes

[north oracle]

Imagine the sheer level of destruction that Scorpio with Nuke II could achieve

[drowsy plank]

cause some dude mentioned nukes

[ashen warren]

supreme calamitis too hard :(

[errant wren]

i stopped looking for 5 seconds

[drowsy plank]

GOD

[ashen warren]

i need quick and easy solution

[drowsy plank]

that's just fryzahh's chicken cannon rework

[north oracle]

TRUE

[ashen warren]

ok what if u add

anti matter

[buoyant idol]

Jousting lance

[ashen warren]

so anti matter and regular matter

combine

to make explosion

like

anti dirt

or anti supreme calamitis

i summon regular sc and anti sc

thye combine and they both die

i win

[errant wren]

what

[drowsy plank]

you should try this really cool tool called cheat sheet butcher tool

[north oracle]

No wait, he’s got a point

[ashen warren]

pair annihilation

or something idk physics

[drowsy plank]

i know this is just an elaborate shitpost but anti-matter rockets would be really fucking cool

[marble moat]

why can we not legalize nuclear bombs

[north oracle]

That is true

[drowsy plank]

too bad adding new rockets sucks ass bc u need to make new rocket types for every explosive weapon

[ashen warren]

people die :(

[drowsy plank]

truly a terraria moment

[marble moat]

what

[ashen warren]

why dont we just

put anti matter

in my PC

so everything in terraria is anti matter

[marble moat]

ain't they just damage values and explosion radii

[drowsy plank]

look at the vanilla page for rocket launcher and snowman cannon

NAH BRUH

NEW PROJECTILES FOR EACH

[errant wren]

oh fr?

[ashen warren]

y

[drowsy plank]

this is why cele mk2 doesnt work with some types of rocket

[marble moat]

that's terrible

[ashen warren]

ik

[ashen warren]

water rocket

it doesnt work with that

[drowsy plank]

incredibly

[ashen warren]

and its so fucking annoying

because i drained out

[errant wren]

wait so

[ashen warren]

the abyss

and i cant fight

the scourge thing

because theres no fucking water

im so stupid

[errant wren]

you have to make projectiles, for every rocket launcher individually?

[drowsy plank]

just use scorpio instead that one still works with wet rockets

[north oracle]

I feel like if you drain the abyss that’s your own problem

[drowsy plank]

correct

[ashen warren]

i was using

fargo mod

[errant wren]

WHY

[ashen warren]

city buster

to make arena

idk it destroy water :(

[drowsy plank]

red code!! ! !

[errant wren]

understandable

[ashen warren]

calamity developer should NOT nerf sand dollar

[ashen warren]

calamity developer should LEAVE sand dollar alone

because calamity pre hardmore is a BREEZE with sand dollar

[errant wren]

i can't believe that's actually the reason why

[worldly sparrow]

guys whos gonna break the news

[drowsy plank]

im pretty sure sand dollar already got nerfed and there is a very real question on if it will even exist still with the sunken sea rework (there are too many repetitive sunken sea weapons)

[worldly sparrow]

ok cog is gonna break the news

[drowsy plank]

oh wait right

[ashen warren]

wait

its nerfed

WAIT

WAITTTTTT

[drowsy plank]

bro is still on those old ass updates

[worldly sparrow]

yeah

[drowsy plank]

lmfao

[ashen warren]

WAITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

[errant wren]

kill the sunken sea weapons i hate them

[north oracle]

It’s been nerfed for a while

[ashen warren]

FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

[worldly sparrow]

its been nerfed for like a month now

[ashen warren]

IM GOING TO CRYYYYYYYY

[worldly sparrow]

maybe 2

[ashen warren]

😭

[buoyant idol]

https://tenor.com/view/crying-emoji-dies-gif-21956120

[ashen warren]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

WHYYYY

[drowsy plank]

god forbid we nerf a weapon which entirely invalidates the game

[ashen warren]

THIS GAME SUCKS ASS

[north oracle]

So true

[ashen warren]

HORRIBLE

0/10

NEVER INSTALLING

[errant wren]

aren't we off topic here?

[drowsy plank]

skill issue

a little

[glass arch]

calamity players when one singular item gets nerfed

[ashen warren]

true

[drowsy plank]

but i allow it for the joke

[worldly sparrow]

cal players when balance

[ashen warren]

literally

cal players when they cant oneshot SC

unfair :(

[north oracle]

Traitorous biofusillade my beloved

[errant wren]

i forget about half of the weapons this mod adds

[ashen warren]

cal players when the difficult game they play becomes difficult

[glass arch]

pre nerf*

[north oracle]

Ofc

[ashen warren]

ok serious question will more sub worlds be added

[buoyant idol]

When death mode kills you 😢

[ashen warren]

those r pretty cool

[drowsy plank]

what are your opinions on depth crusher this is important

[worldly sparrow]

but honestly i love how they're gonna keep a free skip to all of hardmode unnerfed purely because the ammo is never worth getting

[glass arch]

there are none in the mod as of now

[ashen warren]

when onehit one shits you 😥

[errant wren]

what's that?

[buoyant idol]

Need better sprite, DS destroyer before riptide

[drowsy plank]

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Depth_Crusher

[ashen warren]

o wait must be some addon

[glass arch]

theres gonna be at least 2 subworlds though

[ashen warren]

litttt

[glass arch]

infernum

[errant wren]

oh that one

[ashen warren]

yeah thought so

infernums fun

[small timber]

You know, if celestial shell is unchanged in calamity, I have this amazing idea on how to change it

Make celestial stone combined at post-golem, give neptune shell a buff (in stats) or something, then add uelibloom bar or something to Celestial Shell combination

Now you cant complain it has no upgrade because it is post-ML

[errant wren]

depth crusher's alright

[buoyant idol]

I know practically every weapon in this mod

[errant wren]

i never get around to using it though

[ashen warren]

just curious is fargos and cal worth playing

i heard its overpowered af

[drowsy plank]

dc is one of those weapons i hear people constantly forget exist

idk fargos made a compatability mod so

[worldly sparrow]

just make sure to use the dlc for fargos

[drowsy plank]

it's probably not awful

yeah

[north oracle]

Perrenial ore ranger weapon name
Go

[glass arch]

ngl i completely mixed this and valediction up

[north oracle]

[errant wren]

i get too many of them sometimes

[drowsy plank]

||bladedege railbow?||

[buoyant idol]

Bladedge Railbow? I know it shoots venom arrows

[ashen warren]

was abyss wyrum jumpscare a intentional feature

[worldly sparrow]

bladedge railbow

[glass arch]

yes

[drowsy plank]

🐌

[ashen warren]

thought so

[north oracle]

Excellent

[ashen warren]

i shidded my pants

when i use

discord rod

[buoyant idol]

Moar

[errant wren]

i feel like i'm one of the few players that like actually takes the time to enjoy the game instead of treating calamity like a boss rush

[drowsy plank]

i love how it's bladedge too instead of blade-edge railbow

[ashen warren]

https://tenor.com/view/jumpscare-aeden-aeden123-yt-aeden-aeden-yt-gif-25487787

[north oracle]

Yeh XD

[glass arch]

now whats the name of the uelibloom melee weapon

[drowsy plank]

i love my bleghed rainbow

[buoyant idol]

https://tenor.com/view/minor-spelling-mistake-major-spelling-mistake-spelling-mistake-gif-25140477

[tardy geyser]

lifehunt scyth

[buoyant idol]

Nettlevine greatbow

[drowsy plank]

melee

[buoyant idol]

Wait

[glass arch]

i said MELEE YOU FUCKING

[tardy geyser]

funni darksouls weapon

[north oracle]

Verdan-

[drowsy plank]

lifehunt scythe or?

[glass arch]

lifehunt yes

[worldly sparrow]

now whats the name of the aerialite classless weapon

[drowsy plank]

do you mean aetheticus or

[worldly sparrow]

yes

[drowsy plank]

lol

[ashen warren]

i dont recognize 99% of the weapons mentioned here

i think im stupid

[drowsy plank]

no a lot of them just suck

[worldly sparrow]

ok scoria spell book

go

[drowsy plank]

from a design standpoint idk about viability

ah fuck that's like fucking steam eruption or some shit

[glass arch]

now
what is the ranged weapon sold by the archmage after all 3 frost moon minibosses have been defeated

[worldly sparrow]

no

[ashen warren]

pulse bow

[worldly sparrow]

not steam eruption

not pulse bow

[ashen warren]

no im just saying

pulse bow

i like

it do bouncy

[drowsy plank]

oh my god wait i know the bow one
fucking
I JUST WAS USING IT IN GFB
it's not abs zero that's the sword it's like winter's fury or something dumb

[buoyant idol]

Scorched Sun?

[worldly sparrow]

nope

[ashen warren]

wait im stupid nvm

[buoyant idol]

Arctic Bear Paw

[ashen warren]

chlorophyte arrows

[glass arch]

that is a mage weapon

[buoyant idol]

Ranged, my reading comprehension is bad

[drowsy plank]

||eternal blizzard|| (i had to look it up)

[buoyant idol]

That's too similar to the removed cryo bow

[drowsy plank]

what was cryo's bow

[glass arch]

it also is post mechs and not post frost moon

[ashen warren]

has anyone fought la ruga boss at all?

[worldly sparrow]

now whats the post-cryo shortsword

[ashen warren]

i cant find anything about it on youtube

only the theme music

[glass arch]

considering it doesnt exist, no

[buoyant idol]

Effluvium Bow or something similar

[buoyant idol]

Coldheart Icicle

[ashen warren]

alright that makes sense

[drowsy plank]

i dont think eblizz and effluv bow are similar at all

[ashen warren]

looks horrifying tho

[worldly sparrow]

👍

[buoyant idol]

https://tenor.com/view/cat-cute-happy-jumping-gif-26555219

[glass arch]

its hoarfrost bow and it still exists

[drowsy plank]

FUCK

[buoyant idol]

https://tenor.com/view/cringe-ultrakill-minos-prime-minos-dies-gif-27598686

[drowsy plank]

i hate you

[worldly sparrow]

ok what was the only ranged dart weapon cal ever had added

[buoyant idol]

Let's remove it

[drowsy plank]

i hope you melt into a fucking puddle you piece of garbage

[ashen warren]

dart weapons r so good

[drowsy plank]

charged dart blaster

[ashen warren]

in vanilla

[glass arch]

charged dart blaster

[drowsy plank]

that one is easy

[buoyant idol]

Charged Dart Blaster

[worldly sparrow]

goo job

[ashen warren]

how come there isnt more in calamity

they r cracked in vanilla

[drowsy plank]

goo job more like goobow

[buoyant idol]

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/753329460278984715/1163987492073127936/image0-3-1.gif?ex=654192d3&is=652f1dd3&hm=49644d71ce18a7f242fdf039eb4ac68e0fdcd40b5a4753016b3e6a34f8a33aba&

[glass arch]

there was one
but it was horribly not unique so it got killed to death

[ashen warren]

:(

[worldly sparrow]

and the removed vile shard upgrade

what is that one

[ashen warren]

cal developers killing off a weapon because only 0.0000000001% of the community used it

(it was meaningless)

[glass arch]

wasnt that like
hells fury or something like that

[drowsy plank]

hell burst

[worldly sparrow]

no

[worldly sparrow]

yes

[ashen warren]

vanilla weapon upgrades r cool they should keep them in

[buoyant idol]

Name of the Muramasa shortsword

[ashen warren]

i like most vanilla weapons

[drowsy plank]

and also it used none of the flamelash parts it was just a firey version of crystal vile

it was very silly and bad

[glass arch]

yeah it was just

cvs pharmacy but arson

[ashen warren]

unless im playing rouge for the most part im using vanilla weapons until post moon lord

[worldly sparrow]

oh yeah, replaced post-aureus star cannon upgrade

what that

[drowsy plank]

for the love of god please make shifting sands a flamelash upgrade i beg

[buoyant idol]

Star sputter?

[drowsy plank]

do u mean star cannon ex

[ashen warren]

do cal devs actually check this channel

or is it just hopes and dreams

[drowsy plank]

sometimes

[ashen warren]

that die

oh ok

[worldly sparrow]

yes

[glass arch]

star sputter still exists and its a deus drop

[drowsy plank]

but the actual system is #suggestions-posting and #suggestions-voting

i still confused super star shooter and star cannon ex

[buoyant idol]

https://tenor.com/view/crying-emoji-dies-gif-21956120

[drowsy plank]

star cannon ex just feels more natural at this point

i associate the name with the vanilla item to the point where i still call it that

[ashen warren]

does getfixed boi seed work with normal calamity

[drowsy plank]

yes

[glass arch]

yes

it is hell dont do it

[ashen warren]

too bad

:)

after my exams

imma play get fixed boi

[ashen warren]

works with infernum?

[glass arch]

no

[ashen warren]

:( ok

[drowsy plank]

isnt there a patch or is that just for gfb and master

i mean ftw

whatever

too many seeds

[glass arch]

just ftw and master

[drowsy plank]

and acryonyms

very silly

[glass arch]

inf completely breaks on gfb

[drowsy plank]

lul

[ashen warren]

:(

i like infernum

[drowsy plank]

so why not play it the intended way

instead of trying to shove it into gfb

[ashen warren]

already played it :(

[drowsy plank]

lmfao

try another class or something idk

[ashen warren]

ok

i will do

mage

[errant wren]

guys i need suggestions on how to sue an unknown person for crashing into my family's car and fleeing the scene

[ashen warren]

bomb

their house

(in terraria)

(but u dont have to do it in terraria im not suggesting anything but you can do whatever you want but its an idea that you can persue again not suggesting anything violent but it exists in the grand scheme of everything)

[lucid marsh]

ask a lawyer

don't ask on discord

dummy

[errant wren]

ah yes my mistake

(but in all seriousness i am going to lose it)

[ashen warren]

https://tenor.com/view/gun-mechanism-gun-meme-ak-47-ak-47-gun-how-does-an-ak-47-work-gif-15027477959625649464

[bright crag]

;)

[livid coral]

🙂

[bright crag]

(Yes, a few devs show here regularly)

[royal tapir]

Calamity development

[ashen warren]

i fucking hate supreme calamitis screw you guys (i have major skill issue disorder)

[south bolt]

Play classic

[ashen warren]

i have allergies to that

[south bolt]

Expert

Or heros mod

[ornate kestrel]

Yeah

Just play with god mode

Fixes all skill issues

Just don't tell anyone

Or else we will all decide you have a really bad skill issue

[bright crag]

:c

[grim tusk]

#help-advice-read-pins

[ornate kestrel]

You really did them dirty

[ashen warren]

:c

[ashen warren]

now i feel bad

[bright crag]

You don't need to :p

It's alright that you dislike the boss

[ripe owl]

Just be constructive and rational

[buoyant idol]

Be destructive and irrational like me

It's gotten me two suggestions into the mod

[ashen warren]

i actually like the boss i was jst shit posting bcuz it took so many attempts

bruh now i feel really bad wtf

[ripe owl]

[ashen warren]

aight no more shitposting for me

[ripe owl]

Yeah do not do that

[small timber]

just be mindless, got it

Suggestion: Move Rampart of Deity to Earlier in Progression

Deific Amulet just feels so bad and there are bosses like DOG that are very hard, and Rampart of Deity is too late into the progression to be useful. I think making Rampart of Deity available at like Post-Providence will make it much more useful against projectile heavy boss like Yharon and DOG, and of course the hardest boss in the game: Polterghast

but yeah, Celestial Shell definitely don't need an upgrade if you look at the stats (it practically is still basically a post-Golem Badge of Bravery but better)

so just tier shift it instead

[wide river]

Dark Sun Ring would technically be a Celestial Shell upgrade (however indirect)... if it had any of the stats that made Celestial Shell actually useful

[drowsy plank]

didnt we already get monoliths passed but are just waiting on sprites or something

[small timber]

yes, pretty recently iirc

[wide river]

Indeed

[lucid marsh]

it would make more sense for dark sun ring to be a celestial shell upgrade

[novel belfry]

yeah that would be a lot better honestly

[regal willow]

rampart of deity to earlier?
didn't they just move it post yharon because people said it is too OP or sth

[north oracle]

Not just because people said it was too op
Because it was too op

[glass arch]

yeah rampart is

stupidly good

[regal willow]

and... it still is, right?
or did they nerf it so that xpc said it should be post provi viable

[north oracle]

No lol, he was joking

[regal willow]

I am laughing

[north oracle]

the hardest boss in the game: polterghast

[regal willow]

wdym
it is the hardest boss in the game

[stable kiln]

celestial shell never gets useless ngl

it's EXTREMELY good from when you get it until you beat polterghast, and then it falls off because the debuffs it helps with are not relevant anymore and the stats are overshadowed

but I don't think it needs an upgrade

[small timber]

what it need is to add Uelibloom bar to Celestial Shell combination cost

and make Celestial Stone post-Golem -> Pre-Providence, upgrade into Celestial Shell post-Providence
in this way you can buff the (non-offensive) part of Werewolf form and also give Merfolk form stats/other unique property without the accessory going batshit insane

[tardy geyser]

The yharmy's return

[ripe owl]

[ashen warren]

i suggest adding an uber accessory that combines every single possible accessory from both vanilla and calamity

(very balanced)

[drowsy plank]

verboten one

[novel belfry]

Soul of Eternity

[stray warren]

@elder cedar suggestions about future content are prohibited

[bright crag]

^

Besides, Yharim's army is mostly disbanded

[worldly sparrow]

not a good day for the yharmy

[wintry gale]

unless someone decide to make an addon where you travel back in time and fight against it

[buoyant idol]

Does that one get outright deleted?

[bright crag]

The suggestion?

Suggestions with ❗ get deleted automatically after 24 hours with the reaction

[umbral gazelle]

wait, if you somehow block every single moderator and every developer does that mean you technically cant get the ❗ since its reaction made by person?

[golden sonnet]

Blocking people doesn't stop them from seeing your messages

[umbral gazelle]

but they cant react to it iirc

[buoyant idol]

Gets deleted moment

[drowsy plank]

^

i WILL just delete your suggestion if you do that

[fervent orbit]

that sounds hilarious let me do that

[golden sonnet]

Noobs final stand

[stray warren]

[royal tapir]

Of course noob would say that

[fervent orbit]

shut up im blocking you rn jk im not actually doing that

[royal tapir]

Boutta make fun of you for Reimu catgirl pfp again

[fervent orbit]

ok and?

[royal tapir]

Feel bad or something

[swift frigate]

lmaoo

that'd be insane if that actually worked somehow (worked as in suggestion would get passed)

[eternal escarp]

if that happens the sugg will be instantly deleted

like, its not some kryptonite

[swift frigate]

yeah sounds about right

[fervent orbit]

whatttttt??? mods have message delete permissions???? noooooooo

[eternal escarp]

youre right, the sugg passes due to their incredible wit and cleverness

i was lying!

[royal tapir]

Mods can we delete these messages

[fervent orbit]

no you only get to react to them

because you are weak

[royal tapir]

I'm not a mod

[eternal escarp]

caught in 4k

[bright crag]

@native merlin You need to provide better reasoning than that. Why should a station like that be added? What would it accomplish? That's the type of questions you should aim to answer with your suggestion

Also note that we're making Tombstones craftable next update

[buoyant idol]

Me on my way to change my suggestion last minute to add among us with proper reasoning.

[wide river]

(There's also the fact that you can put a single Tombstone into a Magic Storage crafting interface to let it craft Graveyard recipes)
(Most people play with Magic Storage anyway so I'm pretty sure this counter is valid)

[native merlin]

i did not know that

I changed it

[bright crag]

We're already adding tombstone crafting....

[bright crag]

.

And in Hardcore, NPCs drop Tombstones when they die

[native merlin]

k

[wintry gale]

https://tenor.com/view/monkey-monke-neuron-activation-neuron-activation-gif-20850506

[drowsy plank]

you could probably much more easily just shift the whole line tbh

spectre staff already has its own upgrade anyway

just do like Magnetic Meltdown post-ML, Voltaic Climax is now post-Sentinels instead, and Void Vortex is still post-Yharon

[wide river]

That was a concern of mine
I have another suggestion to get rid of the Spectre Staff from that whole recipe tree, but I thought that'd only enforce the instant upgrades that I'm trying to get rid of here

[drowsy plank]

like why tf is voltaic made with darksun anyway

[modern rapids]

how so
spectre staff and magnet sphere are the same tier

[wide river]

Those aren't the problem

Magnetic Meltdown -> Voltaic Climax -> Void Vortex line is the problem

[modern rapids]

yeah this sounds good

[wide river]

My personal solution to the whole thing would be to make Magnetic Meltdown post-Polterghast to serve as a better counterpart to the other 3 Dungeon magic weapon upgrades (all of their upgrades are post-Polterghast except for the Magnet Sphere's upgrade for some reason...), remove Voltaic Climax, and keep Void Vortex the same

[worldly sparrow]

me agree

[drowsy plank]

Magnetic Meltdown - Post-Moon Lord
Alula Australis
Magnet Sphere
5 Luminite Bar
5 Galactica Singularities

Voltaic Climax - Post-Polterghast
Magnetic Meltdown
2 Ruinous Souls
3 Armored Shells

Void Vortex - Post-Yharon
Voltaic Climax
5 Auric Bars
5 Darksun Fragments

i have fixed the weapon line

[wide river]

Alula Australis...?

[drowsy plank]

aureus staff

[wide river]

I know that, but why would it be part of this?

[drowsy plank]

replaces spectre staff but still gives it a staff part

[worldly sparrow]

not a bad solution tbh

[drowsy plank]

plus it makes a funny shape and MM makes a funny diamond so that's where that comes from since MM doesn't really have any spectre staff aspects beyond the staff part

[novel belfry]

looks nice

[drowsy plank]

i also think a nerfed MM would still go brazy on Provi so i think it would be a fun change as well

[drowsy plank]

oh also a-doy
the thematic reason is aurora borealis is the magnetosphere interacting with solar wind so it actually has a connection to the whole magnet thing since the weapon fires aurora beams
also aurora australis is also a thing and exists for the same reasons i think

which makes way more sense than fuckin

ghosts

[worldly sparrow]

anyways imma suggest to retier barracuda gun brb

[wide river]

Spectre Staff should definitely be taken out of the line in any case

The line inherits absolutely nothing from it and it already has an upgrade through Phantasmal Fury

It's also time for a more controversial one
Resuggesting something from 5 months ago with a rewrite to better fit my standards

[modern rapids]

maybe add jungle key to the vernal pass then

actually maybe not
you're basically guaranteed to find vernal pass since (i think) it always spawns above the temple

while that's not the case for other shrines

[wide river]

That would still leave the issue of the Hallow Key, which would either be an inconsistency, or require worldgen to be added for the Hallow besides block conversion (which iirc is a bit finicky due to the position not being guaranteed)

[fervent orbit]

iasejdgv9posejdhbo9gja9so0ebgh9oeasjh

i have no idea how to write

[wide river]

Hence the keysmashing

[fervent orbit]

SHUHS

[golden sonnet]

Nothing new there

[royal tapir]

That was noobish

[eternal escarp]

based biome key sugg

[grave zinc]

@dim snow - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Buff the skyfringe pickaxe's power]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[golden sonnet]

Hell yeah

[wide river]

(Ok I'm gonna be away from Discord for a couple hours so I'll respond to any feedback I may get when I get back)

[fervent orbit]

smh ench ding dong ditching

[dim snow]

[wide river]

Hey at least I'm not going offline
(Ok actually going now will be back soon)

[drowsy plank]

smh conflacting sickness debuffs and potion and mana sickness

something should really be done about that in general

[buoyant idol]

Disease debuffs

[fervent orbit]

but poison isnt a disease

[golden sonnet]

you could just say "sickness type debuffs"

but debuff types aren't exactly explained in game so idk

doesn't starlight river have like a definition function? something like that could possibly be done for debuff types?

[grave zinc]

@drowsy plank - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make the Profaned Guardians Drop Unholy Essense]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[fervent orbit]

💥

[drowsy plank]

lol nice

[dim snow]

fire

[grave zinc]

@modern rapids - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Make night Providence drop more Divine Geodes]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[modern rapids]

nice

[dim snow]

poggers?

goated week

[wide river]

:perhaps:

[dreamy trellis]

Title is kind of shit but uhhhh, I think this works

[wide river]

I'd have to do a little bit of testing but from what I can see, there's nothing particularly wrong about this

[royal tapir]

Yharim’s Insignia got reworked and will no longer be used in Elemental Gauntlet
Elemental Gauntlet will also inflict the new Elemental Mix debuff instead of Hellfire

[dreamy trellis]

ah

I see

I suppose I missed that one in the changelogs

[royal tapir]

I don’t think the latter is directly in the changelogs actually

So not your fault

[wide river]

The rework was there but yeah the Elemental Mix part isn't directly stated

[dreamy trellis]

I do still think simplifying the Recipe would be worth it

since it seems just a little bit odd to use luminite post-DoG

I could see Cosmilite + galactica Singularities being a bit of a better simplification if Galactica Singularties are the 'Elemental' part

[royal tapir]

Galactica Singulairities and Luminite Bars were added to all 5 of the post-DoG class accessories in 1.5, I was not a dev back then so I don’t know the exact reason why
The theming of items with “Elemental” in their name has admittedly been up in the air for a while now

[dreamy trellis]

huh

it might be time to take a look at them and figure out whats up with them then

because Luminite + Galactica Singularities feels so Pre-DoG

[wide river]

There was a suggestion to rename the Elemental Gauntlet/Quiver that passed a while ago
As for the remainders, it's just the "Elemental" set of post-Moon Lord weapons which admittedly needs a separate looking-at

[dreamy trellis]

I remember talking about leaning into the Post-DoG aspect and renaming it the Cosmic Gauntlet like, 10 seconds before I made the suggestion

So thats good to note

will agree with the elemental weapon set needing a look through

I think they lack some kind of identity other than 'oh its multi-colored and has ALL da fragments' or whatever

[wide river]

Y'know actually
Sorry to change the topic back but I just noticed
Every single part of the Elemental Gauntlet line (starting from Mechanical Glove) has differently organized tooltips

Le

[dreamy trellis]

hate this

pls fix

[drowsy plank]

if it's already getting a new debuff anyway, then asking for it to become a cosmic glove so it can inflict god slayer inferno seems a tad repetitive, so shouldn't this be flagged then? this also feels a bit like asking for something the team already knows is pretty boring to be reworked for the sake of it just being boring and not much else, so im unsure. like this feels like the kind of suggestion Ozz wanted to avoid getting since it isn't really helping much, but maybe im just not looking at it the right way and there's some other reason you didn't flag it yourself

[royal tapir]

If you want to flag it for conflicting plans and reworking for just being boring, then go ahead

[fervent orbit]

cog we have a thing for conflicting future plans that have been revealed

its called 🔒

[drowsy plank]

aight someone remind me to lock when it gets into voting then ig

[fervent orbit]

i will

[golden sonnet]

excuse to harass Cog spotted

[glass arch]

everyone always forgets about 🔒 fr

[fervent orbit]

i dont need an excuse to harass people i can just do it anyway

[dapper apex]

Yeah yeah whatever

[golden sonnet]

don't you get permad after one more offense

[fervent orbit]

AI(EOGJV(OPAWJGKUBV(OAWJUOSBHGJ(OAWSZEBHJG(O)AWJSZEO)BGH(JKAO)PWSJBHGKO)ASWEZBHOGASWZO(PBGHAJK)OPW_{BHGJ

[fervent orbit]

look

i need to be warned first

[buoyant idol]

Same

Anyways who saw the new Ultrakill teaser?

[fervent orbit]

no

[buoyant idol]

Yes

I am the ultimate annoyance, relegated only to this channel.

[frail mantle]

no

[crystal cedar]

holy shit noob jumpscare

[wide river]

Ramen jumpscare

[golden sonnet]

Ench jumpscare

[odd geyser]

Raesh jumpscare

[buoyant idol]

Primalzius Jumpscare

[worldly sparrow]

freddy jumpscare

[glass arch]

pusheen jumpscare

[golden sonnet]

moderator warning jumpscare if we do not stop

[odd geyser]

https://tenor.com/view/malzeno-griddy-monster-hunter-monster-griddy-dance-gif-9484817062756907632

Anyways discuss about suggestions guys

[novel belfry]

[regal willow]

[drowsy plank]

does

would this just fall into the same caveats as the. almost identical eglove sugg

[short warren]

?

[drowsy plank]

the suggestion literally like 3 messages up

[short warren]

I don’t know what you’re referring to

[drowsy plank]

we were talking about how it lacked reasoning, but furthermore, that it conflicts with the fact they just gave it elemental mix, but im not sure

[short warren]

Ahh

Yeah I see what you mean by near identical sugg now

I still think it’s a valid suggestion, both of these

The theming just doesn’t fit the placement, neither distortion themed nor unique

[small timber]

can always just put a 🔒 if devs feel like it

[grave zinc]

@wide river - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Remove Biome Key drops from bosses and increase their standard drop rates to compensate]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[drowsy plank]

oh?

[fervent orbit]

memes?

gonna explain orrrrr?

[inner anvil]

I'm supposed to?

🧐

[fervent orbit]

no its just better to leave some sort of explanation

[inner anvil]

Okay.

We're moving it to minibosses / uncommon (Or elite if you like that name) enemies.

[fervent orbit]

ah so like gss

[torn oak]

Now delete that explenation, so nobody can know.

[inner anvil]

This guy knows, gentlemen, this guy knows what he's saying.

[novel belfry]

you're like that chad meme

[eternal escarp]

tbf the sugg did infact, pass technically

byeah thats nice

less boss focus is goated

[drowsy plank]

i guess mimics prolly get evil keys and frost mimic gets ice key, but idk what jungle enemy is gonna get jungle key. at least we have gss for desert key ig for now

[wide river]

Plaguebringer (enemy), maybe?

[drowsy plank]

oh maybe

awfully late compared to the rest tho

[worldly sparrow]

too late

you supposed to open biome chests post-plant

[wide river]

Well it's that or freaking Angry Trappers so

[worldly sparrow]

what about turtles

[wide river]

Could be a Moth, now I think about it, actually...

[royal tapir]

Lemme find the plans again

Desert -> Sand Elemental
Frozen -> Ice Golem
Crimson -> Crimson Mimic
Corruption -> Corruption Mimic
Hallowed -> Hallowed Mimic
Jungle -> Uncommon drop from Jungle Temple mobs (this is definitely the one most subject to change)

[north oracle]

the solution is clearly to add a temple miniboss on the exact same tier as the actual boss

[royal tapir]

❌

[north oracle]

hey it worked for PBG

[worldly sparrow]

did it?

[royal tapir]

I'll infect YOU with the Plague.......

[north oracle]

[fervent orbit]

ice golem crying rn

[eternal escarp]

just move it to moth yeah

they are the rare enemy of the jungle

jungle mimics arent real in normal game

[drowsy plank]

moth miniboss AI when

[eternal escarp]

[fervent orbit]

just make them real in normal game smh

[modern rapids]

jungle -> plantera tentacle

[novel belfry]

Why not Plantera?

[north oracle]

because plantera is a boss

[crude geode]

It’s trying to not be connected to bosses

Yeah

[north oracle]

and these are being moved away from bosses

[novel belfry]

oyeah

[torpid glen]

Add yharim

[novel belfry]

they're minibosses but still

plantera is the boss that makes these keys usable so

[crude geode]

eh

it puts more of a focus on plantera which is already unnecessary

plus it feels redundant at that point, why even have the jungle key if you could just say the jungle chest is unlocked after plantera's death (shut up about the astral chest)

[crude geode]

moth would be cool

[modern rapids]

make atlas drop astral key

[crude geode]

lmao

[buoyant idol]

@hot leaf Improper Format + It already is

[fervent orbit]

ban him

[north oracle]

noob

chill

[worldly sparrow]

nuke him

[hollow shell]

Just gonna delete that

[worldly sparrow]

aw man

[grave zinc]

@dreamy trellis - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Update the Gauntlet Line]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[drowsy plank]

remembered to do this for once

[dreamy trellis]

yay

[drowsy plank]

anyway as CIT mentioned earlier it inflicts elemental mix now so

sugg cannot really pass

[bright crag]

The Great Bohldohr

[glass arch]

Great Lihzahrd Brick Shark

[north oracle]

lorde

[glass arch]

TRUE

[short warren]

Wouldn’t it be funny if
Jungle Mimic dropped the Jungle key?

And could spawn in all worlds

[potent flicker]

make vanilla yo-yos relevant in calamity

they all get immediately powercrept to the point where i can’t think of a single yo-yo besides the terrarian that’s actually good on tier

[north oracle]

see this is funny because terrarian is only mediocre on tier, in comparison to several of the op vanilla yoyos

also, #1042197406776827914

[marble moat]

which are the op vanilla yoyos would you say

[north oracle]

Code 1, Code 2, Valkyrie, Red's throw

there were a couple of others, but i can't find the tests to know for sure

ah, artery and malaise are strong too

[frail fox]

Yelets, The Eye of Cthulhu, even damn Kraken

[north oracle]

hive five is above average too

there's barely any that are bad

and several that are very good

terrarian is one of the worse vanilla yoyos

[marble moat]

it's a shame that it's like the only one that looks cool to use

[random pasture]

Its funny because almost every vanilla yoyo is identical besides number changes

[dapper apex]

Simply make jungle mimic spawn in regular worlds and give it jungle key

Simply make jungle mimic spawn in regular worlds and give it jungle key

[stray warren]

Simply make jungle mimic spawn in regular worlds and give it jungle key

Simply make jungle mimic spawn in regular worlds and give it jungle key

[dapper apex]

What happened

My discord just died

Wh

Mobile discord sure is an app

Also I'm unfunny because people already joked about jungle mimic so I'm cringe now

[north oracle]

throudon what happened

[dapper apex]

I don't know

My discord lagged and then closed itself

And sent message twice

For some reason

[fervent orbit]

@drowsy plank can u lock the other ele gauntlet sugg

[drowsy plank]

im unsure if that one is entirely invalid

[modern rapids]

has something about ceaseless void's contact damage been posted before

like it doing contact damage before its dark energies can is kinda stupid

[wide river]

Closest I can find is #suggestions-voting message

Oh wait there are more

[modern rapids]

yeah basically that

[wide river]

#suggestions-voting message
#suggestions-voting message

[fervent orbit]

its talking about retheming ele gauntlet and quiver, which wont be happening evidently

[drowsy plank]

hm

fair i guess

[grave zinc]

@short warren - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Retheme the Elemental Gauntlet and Quiver to be Godslayer themed]

It has been decided that your suggestion can neither be passed nor denied; either the devs have already made plans that conflict with it, or they have decided to implement an altered version.
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[short warren]

Close enough 👍

[grave zinc]

@golden sonnet - Your suggestion has received an updated status!

[Add a Visual Indicator for Providence's Holy Inferno]

It has been add to the devs' to-do list and planned for implementation!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

[golden sonnet]

hell yeah

[wide river]

Now people can rest easy and not suggest it more

[royal tapir]

Amber has been cooking (literally)

[ashen warren]

[umbral gazelle]

this is my 2nd suggestions about rover drive i hope its ok

[wide river]

I realize I've posted this at a poor time considering I'm gonna be going to sleep in like 5 minutes :hdflr:
I'll post it again tomorrow morning when I can actually respond to feedback, for now I'll delete it though

[eternal escarp]

@cosmic jungle youre the online mod currently

#suggestions-posting

[ripe owl]

So true Suggestion Bot...

[cosmic jungle]

bruh

[ripe owl]

Hi Omega

[cosmic jungle]

@pulsar carbon I'll just warn you for that, don't post stuff like that in suggestions posting

[wintry gale]

🤔

[golden tulip]

im getting a deja vu

this has already been posted has it not

[wintry gale]

Whats a flavor tooltip btw

[wide river]

A small bit of text in a tooltip that (generally) isn't there to describe its function

So in the case of Solar Fragments, its flavor text is 'The fury of the universe lies within this fragment'

Mainly flavor text serves as a minor touch on an item that usually holds no bearing in its actual use

Sometimes it can be used to give more exposition into an item (take Cosmilite Bars' A chunk of durable and highly resilient cosmic steel)

[buoyant idol]

Perhaps I should suggest that to be more concise in the form of A chunk of highly resilient cosmic steel

[wintry gale]

oh
thats what i thought lol
basically a tooltip text that basically gives more life to the item and sometimes can give hints about lore

[drowsy plank]

what

no lavafishing is possible in preHM what dude

oh hotline isnt

lavaproof hook

why is a fishing pole called fishing hook

that's so fucking dumb

[wide river]

✨ vanilla choices ✨

[drowsy plank]

it's fucking goofy

fishing is a disaster fr

[wide river]

Look Golem exists the bar isn't that high

[drowsy plank]

TRUE

[tardy geyser]

You can lava fish pre hm with the underworld bait cant you?

yeah

[wintry gale]

What are you talking about

also
calamity's brand new angler quest rework allows you to have hotline prehm

[drowsy plank]

i thought you were saying calamity made lavaproof fishing hook preHM when it always was but then i realized u meant the fishing pole

[wintry gale]

i see

cant blame anyway lmfao

just like.

[dense ferry]

@wide river jeez man you didn't need to go this hard for flavor text

I will do that eventually, even if this doesn't pass

[wide river]

The minor details are nice
Also felt a bit weird that Meld was just there so I thought I'd throw this out here

Worst-case it doesn't pass, but even then it still helps other suggestions in

[dense ferry]

Worst case it gets added in the game because I'm doing it

[wide river]

:ah:

[dense ferry]

I just have to discuss what will be it

[wide river]

If it's already planned should I just remove the suggestion?
It'd just get hit with ye olde "planned for implementation" reaction anyway I assume

[dense ferry]

Leave it there, I'm busy now

And knowing myself, I will forget it

And it's good to let other Devs know that this is going in so they can come up with their own things

[crude geode]

Meld’s lore should simply be denying it is the 5th fragment

[wide river]

Mmk, then I'll just leave it
This suggestion feels way too much for what is going to be a single line of text but here we are

[novel belfry]

Meld's defintions:

1. (Verb) - blend, or combine
2. (Noun) - a thing formed by merging or blending:

[grim tusk]

[user that does not exist anymore] - Your suggestion has received an updated status!
[Display debuffs above Super Dummy]

It has officially been implemented into the game, and will be available in the next update!
You can check out your suggestion again here: #suggestions-voting message

(i literally had this one done 4 months ago, just forgor to push it)

[golden sonnet]

I'm sure [user that does not exist anymore] is very happy

[grim tusk]

that sugg was OLD

[wide river]

Nearing 3 years old, huh

[grim tusk]

it was also literally just fucking adding one line lmao

[regal willow]

[hollow shell]

@near topaz

(^ User's still here actually, bot just didn't embed them)

holy shit it's the silksong news guy

[near topaz]

ty devs

[hollow shell]

👍

[dapper apex]

WHAT

The world is so small huh

[fervent orbit]

@olive saddle ram is a type of dash which lets you gain invincibility frames when you hit an enemy during the dash

[glass arch]

yes

and the line directly above that tells you that you can do that

[marble moat]

BRINGING YOU YOUR MULTI-YEARLY CALAMITY MOD SUGGESTIONS

[fervent orbit]

fuck

[grim tusk]

oh imma add it to regular dummies too (done)

[fervent orbit]

💥

[drowsy plank]

@turbid gull how does this make the game less wiki reliant?? now you need to go to the CALAMITY wiki to see how we changed the recipe instead of just using the default vanilla one. arguably your change produces the opposite effect of what you intend, and also hay really isn't that hard to get

[grim tusk]

^

[turbid gull]

Is assuming that players play with recipe browser not normal

[grim tusk]

its also dirt cheap already

[grim tusk]

even with the guide NPC you can see the recipe with a wood block

[turbid gull]

true but neither of those sources explain how to get hay

[drowsy plank]

i mean if you know what a scythe/sickle is..,.,.,.

[grim tusk]

but still you'd go to the Vanilla wiki, see it doesnt work in Cal, then you'd have to go to the Cal wiki...

[drowsy plank]

also true!

[turbid gull]

ig

[drowsy plank]

this is just overcomplicating something and creating a problem where there was none

it's not like terraria tells you the axe cuts trees and the pickaxe mines stone; if you have a basic understanding of what the tool is, it's quite obvious how hay is obtained

[bright crag]

(You'd also render an item useless and confuse the people that expect hay to be obtained that way)

[small timber]

dummy is also not integral to game progression

you don't need dummy to play the game

[bright crag]

It's in Merchant's shop so it's definitely not that invisible of an item

[golden sonnet]

Also, just by reading the item in the shop you know how to get hay

[drowsy plank]

lol

[golden sonnet]

If you were to say, make it crafted, you would have no idea how to get hay without looking up the recipe or the guide

[drowsy plank]

the obvious solution is we should add dummy to the starter bag

[golden sonnet]

Which would also require either the wiki, or a different npc

[errant wren]

is the mod based around higher level players in terms of game knowledge or whatever? asking for future reference

[grim tusk]

No, that's a misconception from Calamity versions from way back in early 1.3 versions.
The mod is intended to be friendly to everyone although it is recommended the player first completes a vanilla playthrough (preferably on expert) first so they don't get overwhelmed when they see way too much content as well as to grasp the basics of combat, exploration, construction, management and other things you'd do in base Terraria.

[golden sonnet]

I'm not a dev so I obviously can't speak on design philosophy, but as shade said, in channels such as #help-advice-read-pins the community as a whole heavily encourages completing a vanilla playthrough before doing calamity, and encourages expert, but doesn't expect you to be a pro or anything

[glass arch]

yeah its fully possible to do cal without doing expert

[fervent orbit]

i think the modded community of any game encourages you to complete said game first

[glass arch]

i was an extremely low experience player when i started cal (never did even classic, i had only done .5x journey) and i was able to do rev

[small timber]

not really

in theory the game is balanced around beta testers who are relatively high skill

however, there had been active effort in making the mod easier to account for player who are to certain degree much less skilled than beta testers (who often are nohitters)

so the tldr is:

if you are not super good at the game, just get the best gears available (wiki or not) and you probably will get pass everything

if you are super good at the game, you don't even have to get proper gear because the gears (even off tier) are generally powerful enough

or you know, regardless of if you are good or bad, just use full warding full defense instead of full menacing + dimensional soul artifact and omega blue armor because "damage make the game easier"

[errant wren]

so, knowledge is helpful but not entirely necessary. got it

[stable kiln]

we usually try to balance around not high skill

[drowsy plank]

@slow sparrow please speak english so we may moderate properly, and don't post memes in this server. again. you have been warned.

[slow sparrow]

bro, where i can post memes? sorry

[hybrid steeple]

nowhere in this server

[slow sparrow]

oh no

its so bad

[buoyant idol]

It’s a moderation nightmare to deal with memes