suggestions-discussion

[eternal escarp]

oh yeah i forgot to actually exclaim that second one

[drowsy plank]

lol

[wide river]

I really need to play Calamity again to think of new suggestions

All of the ones I've currently got saved are previous ones

[crude geode]

never play calamity, biggest mistake of my entire life

[drowsy plank]

ive been playing and stuff has been pretty solid tbh, like my one grudge was not being able to get molecart and teles in preHM but 1.4.4 will fix that so

oh and also the evil V wof spawning being shit as usual but

not really much you can do about that one

[wide river]

The dreaded hardcoded vanilla features

[drowsy plank]

if it was just two columns instead of a V it would be

so much better

at least then you wouldnt have stuff like two of my pylons getting hit by crimson in hardmode

[wide river]

Kinda like how the Remix seed handles the hallow spawns?

[drowsy plank]

on the plus side cal at least adds axe of purity so you have early HM evils management

also i think so? i dont remember despite playing it lol

[wide river]

It generates on the Jungle side of the world in a column

Honestly I'd prefer if that was how it always worked

[drowsy plank]

YEAH

...maybe i could suggest that in 1.4.4 since the code will already exist

[wide river]

Yeah, do that

The only part that might need to be changed is the coordinates, but aside from that it could be copied for the most part

[dense ferry]

What's up with people just wanting to save this one inventory slot so desperately recently?

[wide river]

@vivid kraken Why does a teleport need to be in the grappling hook slot?

[vivid kraken]

To save space, and it makes sense.

[dense ferry]

It doesn't

[wide river]

Well then, the suggestion is invalid

[vivid kraken]

Why?

[dense ferry]

Your reasoning is "I want to save 1 (one) inventory slot and no one uses hooks on Endgame (false)"

[wide river]

If "It makes sense" is the only reasoning, then it's not a good suggestion

[vivid kraken]

Wait ppl do use hooks?

I’ve never seen one play through where ppl use hooks in endgame bc the wings get so good

[wide river]

Here's what the dont's says

[crude geode]

bobbit is why

have you not heard of it

[golden sonnet]

For yahron and old duke arenas I don't even use platforms, just minecarts to hook onto, and if that isn't "really" using the hook as it's just a flight reset, they allow you gain a massive momentum increase or reversal, perfect for dodging dashes like yharons, and especially old duke.

[crude geode]

also yes that

[vivid kraken]

Ok, but that’s not the main reason

[wide river]

They can also be used to reset momentum

[vivid kraken]

Ig

[crude geode]

you don't even need that one inventory slot post ml, most of the time you're after like one or two things in either exploration or events. and otherwise it's boss fights where you have like 20 extra inventory slots.

[golden sonnet]

I literally use hook of dissonance until bobbit hook because of how broken the momentum is

[vivid kraken]

Maybe it’s just me but my inv always gets extremely cluttered

[wide river]

Besides
Void Bag
Money Trough
Defender's Forge
Safe

[hollow shell]

I don't think gaining one inventory slot is worth losing your whole grappling functionality

[wide river]

That's up to 160 slots

[hollow shell]

May I recommend AutoTrash mod

[vivid kraken]

Wait

Fixed it

[hollow shell]

guh

alright I shall delete it then

[distant gyro]

[wide river]

That is 10 times worse

[crude geode]

but safe, money trough, and void bag take up inventory slots!!11!!

[silver pike]

hey are bosses allowed to be disused now or is there still a massive update

[vivid kraken]

Ima leave now

[crude geode]

disused?

[wide river]

The 3 slots lost in comparison to the 120 items gained

[hollow shell]

You can suggest changes to existing bosses

You cannot suggest that any new bosses be added

[distant gyro]

put a safe and dforge in the trough

[crude geode]

do you mean discussed?

[silver pike]

so dose that mean like a crabulose but diffrent skin

[silver pike]

yes

[wide river]

Massive brain plays

[hollow shell]

Was your suggestion going to be adding a Crabulon variation that follows the orange-red surface mushroom theme as opposed to the beige-blue glowing mushroom theme?

[half imp]

that sounds like a fandom wiki change oh my goodness

[golden sonnet]

New fandom idea just dropped

[wide river]

Someone's frantically adding it there as we speak

[silver pike]

well no i mean crablouse but the summoning thing use to summon him was made from evil mushroom so eather red or purple

so bassicly

[half imp]

I will add it probably tommorow

[golden sonnet]

have it drop mario like giant clam drops amidias to fit with the fandom theme of being as awful as possible

[hollow shell]

That would be very unlikely to be added, evil biome skins for Crabulon if you summon him with an item crafted using the evil mushrooms
I also dunno what reasoning there would be for adding that other than "Well, they're mushrooms, and he's a mushroom too!"

[wide river]

I assume it's the same situation as shimmer bosses in vanilla

[hollow shell]

You could suggest an alternate crafting recipe for Decapodita Sprout using the evil shrooms I guess, though iunno how useful that'd be

[golden sonnet]

Shimmer skins for bosses could be cool, like for npcs. But at that point just get a texture pack. (also it's 1.4.4 content so can't be suggested yet)

[wide river]

I never said I would suggest it

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, I was just commenting on the idea, as I thought it may be similar to what the OP was thinking of or wanting.

[wide river]

Ah, ok

[silver pike]

can the mushroom biom be corrupted (i play with begon evil)

[glass arch]

no

[silver pike]

ah ok

[glass arch]

@opaque saddle no

[opaque saddle]

Yes

[drowsy plank]

@opaque saddle i am begging you to actually read the rules and stop uploading stuff from r/terraria

[glass arch]

it would be cool is explicitly a dont for reasoning

[opaque saddle]

I got permission from the creator of the suggestion.

Ok I’ll read the rules too

[drowsy plank]

[glass arch]

ok but that doesnt mean its a valid suggestion

[opaque saddle]

It’s valid in my eyes

[drowsy plank]

that's awesome bro lmk what the mods think

[glass arch]

well good thing you arent a dev then.

[drowsy plank]

lol

[opaque saddle]

The mods will love it

[glass arch]

trust me. they will not.

[worldly basalt]

just got here, let me guess it's that one 'time machine' image

[drowsy plank]

nah

[worldly basalt]

really? surprising

[drowsy plank]

hair styles for NPC near the stylist

[wide river]

That was brought up earlier

[drowsy plank]

got a nice 480p screenshot for it too

[glass arch]

with the only reasoning being it would be cool

[worldly basalt]

there's already the shimmer variants coming

[opaque saddle]

When?

[worldly basalt]

1.4.4

[glass arch]

in 1.4.4 when else would you get them

[drowsy plank]

anyway i think this guys is a troll or at least about as productive as one so i am just going to block him and wait a week for him to disappear like all people like this usually end up doing 👍

[opaque saddle]

Why?

I’m not trolling 😡

[worldly basalt]

do you even play terraria

[opaque saddle]

Yes. I think it’s a good idea

It’s not all about the bosses

[worldly basalt]

alternate npc styles are literally already coming

[glass arch]

well unfortunately it doesnt matter if you think its a good idea or not

[wide river]

Your suggestion has been deemed invalid by the Discord hive mind and the rules

[worldly basalt]

does it count as a hive mind if its like 5 people

[drowsy plank]

i think the rules are the more important one here

[opaque saddle]

I’ll have a talk with the mods personally.

[glass arch]

what matters is if the devs think its a good idea
or if its explicitly banned by the rules

[wide river]

If those 5 people are suggestion channel regulars, then I think so

[worldly basalt]

ok have fun

[glass arch]

the mods aint gonna do shit

[opaque saddle]

Where are the rules?

[glass arch]

in the pins

[wide river]

Pin number 4, to be precise

[frosty trellis]

What in the hell happened

Why is every suggestion breaking the rules

Why can't people read

[worldly basalt]

its hard 😢

[glass arch]

its calamity what did you expect tbh

[frosty trellis]

I didn't expect shit

Just dissapointed

[drowsy plank]

people cant even read the caption on pwnhammer let alone server rules

[worldly basalt]

i would expect calamity players to be good at reading considering the mutliple paragraph-long tooltips

[glass arch]

the stereotype that cal players cant read does exist for a reason

[glass arch]

and yet they still dont

[drowsy plank]

you think people actually read those? hilarious

[frosty trellis]

I mean

[wide river]

We have had one valid suggestion all day thus far

[worldly basalt]

i do 😔

[frosty trellis]

.... i did

[opaque saddle]

My next suggestion will be mind blowing

[glass arch]

i swear to fucking god

[worldly basalt]

dynamite already harms the player if they're too close

[frosty trellis]

I am a cal player and I actually read the multi-paragraph ark tooltips

[opaque saddle]

And I’ll follow the rules

[dense ferry]

You don't even really need to read

[drowsy plank]

well yeah that's why we're still here, we're the exception

[frosty trellis]

That should not have made me laugh

[glass arch]

evidently you arent the average cal player

[crude geode]

was gonna say

[frosty trellis]

Fair enough

[dense ferry]

I figured out everything but the Big Rip without doing so

[frosty trellis]

True, I do test far more things than is probably good for my health

[half imp]

so true

[golden sonnet]

You need reasoning to why something should be added, and additional reasoning on why calamity specifically should add it. Saying "it would be cool" is not reasoning. I do think everyone should try to bandwagon less when confronting people, I understand it's frustrating when no one reads, but when you are immediately met with like 7 people telling you your idea is dumb it comes off as a bit toxic.

[crude geode]

@hollow shell "it would be cool"

[worldly basalt]

they should make polterghast pink it would be cool

[opaque saddle]

Yeah stop hating 🤬

[wide river]

^

[glass arch]

enraged polter:

[frosty trellis]

Was about to say

[opaque saddle]

Can I suggest a mount? I’ll give good reasoning too

[hollow shell]

hello you need more reasoning than "It would be cool" this is an official rule in the Don'ts Doc

[drowsy plank]

this is true, we should stop bandwagoning, but sometimes it's easy to forget when you get suggestion so absurd you know for a fact they didn't even try to read the rules. it's pretty funny to make fun of those sometimes. still, it isn't an excuse

[opaque saddle]

Chill out Jamal I’ve read them now

[worldly basalt]

its funny though 😢

[frosty trellis]

SIS

[hollow shell]

well depends on how it's suggested

You could suggest a new mount without it being a Specific Item Suggestion

[half imp]

^

[frosty trellis]

True yeah

[golden sonnet]

Yeah, it's fine to suggest a mount. Try to explain why the mount should exist though, like a lack of flying mounts in a specific part of the game, or a unique thing the mount could do to add a reason to add the mount rather than just "I think it would be cool to ride a _____"

[half imp]

you could suggest a mount to accomplish a new thing

[drowsy plank]

if it's another image from the subreddit i am going to explode, though

[opaque saddle]

Ok

[crude geode]

It really is a bit hostile when you get ten regulars here confronting you about the same thing

[half imp]

like maybe an antigravity mount or something to solve... Idk what issue

[wide river]

This is honestly why I don't comment on suggestions most of the time
I really don't like to see people ganging up on someone else for simply suggesting an idea

[crude geode]

people are also really hostile with wording

[hollow shell]

I do indeed dislike dogpiling in general

[wide river]

I think the reason why people do it here is because they've seen a lot of people who simply would not listen, but that doesn't mean everyone who suggests an invalid idea is like that

[crude geode]

I think that a large number of people also don't like seeing invalid suggs when. it's the whole point of the channel. to filter invalid suggs.

I do get it if it's a post in voting that somehow slipped through that's usually a valid complaint

[wide river]

This is still comparatively tame, compared to when the 1.4 port happened
I think the invalid suggestion streak hit 12 in a row during that time

[drowsy plank]

fun times

[crude geode]

indeed

[golden sonnet]

Oh, btw are the armor reworks in the next batch of suggestions, or did they fail in the one that just happened

[drowsy plank]

uhhhh

[worldly basalt]

i think the next one?

[wide river]

They were in the last one

[drowsy plank]

nah armor reworks are in the next batch, cause the last passed suggestion was from the previous day

[crude geode]

I don't think so

I think they were part of the last batch.

[worldly basalt]

SIS

[drowsy plank]

does the bot still upload on fridays? cause i know we had a couple outages so im not sure if it just used bigger batches after it did or if it moved the upload date...

[glass arch]

its supposed to

[drowsy plank]

wait why did he include "SIS" in the suggestion... bro...

[crude geode]

I don't think they've ever adjusted it even without outages

[drowsy plank]

huh

weird

[glass arch]

bruh

seriously with this new sugg

[golden sonnet]

@opaque saddle Why did you include SiS in your post when it's specifically stated those are against the rules? and why is a way to get snow needed when all the enemies in the event already drop snow?

[glass arch]

in the suggestion itself you pointed out that its against the rules

[opaque saddle]

I quit

[golden sonnet]

I'm trying not to do the exact thing I complained about and dogpile, just trying to give so specific feedback on what is wrong with the suggestion

[drowsy plank]

does he just not understand what the rules mean? i mean we did have a guy talking about not understanding them recently so i guess that's a possibility

[crude geode]

Suggesting to add more to frost legion would be...fine. It wouldn't go against the rules, and I'm sure a lot of people here would dislike the idea, but it would completely valid.

But you can't be specific.

[worldly basalt]

maybe they should make a version of the 'don'ts' list with just a summary

[crude geode]

we did discuss that recently

[golden sonnet]

I think that was done already

[worldly basalt]

is there even any way to summon frost legion at any season without fargo's?

[drowsy plank]

cal adds a recipe

[crude geode]

no

[drowsy plank]

which is weird

[crude geode]

it's still just as long and annoying to read through each individual rule

[glass arch]

ye
if just in vanilla you gotta complete frost moon to get the christmas event active

[crude geode]

which is fine if you want the details, but like.

[worldly basalt]

i forgor

[crude geode]

kinda hard to get a grasp on stuff.

[drowsy plank]

im gonna be honest if they just made frost legion drop essence of eleum id probably bother doing it

[worldly basalt]

snowman boss when

[drowsy plank]

cryogen

[worldly basalt]

he is a hexagon not circles 😡

[glass arch]

fuck it ill suggest that

[drowsy plank]

it's because he's pixelated

[worldly basalt]

and we already have the reason too

[drowsy plank]

based. gl

[golden sonnet]

Make them drop cryonic ore post cryogen and buff their stats, remove cryo slimes

[drowsy plank]

yoo??

wait these are actually good ideas

[worldly basalt]

frost legion will now be epic

[drowsy plank]

wtf frost legion is awesome now.,.,.,...

[opaque saddle]

You’re welcome guys

[crude geode]

@hollow shell Is it possible we could get a brief "summary" of each individual don't, in a list, without the individual details under each one? It would make the document easier to read and let people glance over things if they're just looking for things not to do and not the specific reasoning behind each rule.

[golden sonnet]

any removal of ore slimes is based to me

[worldly basalt]

when will they add tin, copper, iron, lead, silver, tungsteon, and platinum slimes

😢

[crude geode]

(apologies if this is planned, I just remember it being brought up and nothing coming out of it)

[crude geode]

silt slime when

[golden sonnet]

@crude geode isn't this kinda that?

[crude geode]

VERY few people are going to ever see that

[opaque saddle]

Why is Danny Devito and Pokemon a pet?

[crude geode]

dedicated items

[golden sonnet]

Donator items

[worldly basalt]

if it were put somewhere people would actually see yea

[opaque saddle]

How much do you need to donate

[worldly basalt]

discontinued i think

[crude geode]

you need to go back in time yeah

so you can't

[opaque saddle]

How many donator items are there

[golden sonnet]

Donator items are no longer done yeah, there is some backfill though, so some are still being added

[worldly basalt]

probably too many

[crude geode]

too many

[wide river]

Lots

[opaque saddle]

Is there a list

[hollow shell]

The devs got so many donations and have SO many donator items in their backlog to implement

still

even though it's been like 2 years since donator items stopped being a reward

[golden sonnet]

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Dedicated_content

[opaque saddle]

Thanks

[golden sonnet]

not all dedicated content are donor items, but all donor items are dedicated content

[hollow shell]

(I should say, Fab got so many donations, to be accurate.)

[opaque saddle]

If 1.4.5 is the final update how will that affect Calamity?

[hollow shell]

It won't be.

[drowsy plank]

LOL

[bright crag]

We need to add Cosmilite Slimes first

[drowsy plank]

[hollow shell]

Also the end of vanilla updates is nothing but good news for modders because having to update tMod for them is a nightmare

1.4.4 has been out for months and tMod still isn't on it yet

[opaque saddle]

How long do you think Calamity will go on until their final update?

[wide river]

To be fair it took the tMod team like 2 years to port to 1.4 so

[bright crag]

Hard to tell, really

[drowsy plank]

im really hoping terraria 2 will actually end up being a thing so tmod doesn't have to play catch up for like 3 patches

[hollow shell]

Well 1.4 was a massive update

And involved moving tMod to the workshop too

1.4.4 is just like an update

[crude geode]

at bare minimum we're gonna have to deal with the crossover update this year and probably more

[opaque saddle]

1.4.5 is adding pufferfish, shimmer water gun, seeds menu, moon lord tentacle whip and Hallowed and Aether furniture

[wide river]

I'd argue that 1.4.4 is of a similar caliber in size to 1.4
Considering 1.4.4 added a whole new liquid, difficulty, biome, three seeds, a boss and a whole new mechanic

[worldly basalt]

dead cells 😍 😍

[drowsy plank]

do you think the cryonic ore dropping from frost legion should be a separate suggestion or

[golden sonnet]

@glass arch how do you feel about adding this as well? Or should I just make that a suggestion of my own.

[worldly basalt]

cant wait for cursed sword in terraria

[golden sonnet]

lmao, was just gonna ask that

[worldly basalt]

its the same idea so i think it should be included

[drowsy plank]

i think it'd faire better if it was one but idk if that's invalid
ye agree there

[wide river]

The frost legion can only be accessed in hardmode, can't it

[glass arch]

the summon can only be obtained in hardmode but you can summon the event pre hardmode if you bring the summon to another world

[worldly basalt]

i think so

[wide river]

Ye, the Cal recipe requires souls

[worldly basalt]

so it wouldnt really cause problems anyway since you'd still have to get the thing from hardmode

[swift wharf]

they are hardmode

[opaque saddle]

Does Deerclops drop it?

[drowsy plank]

it'd be like pirates lol

[swift wharf]

they drop from presents in hardmode

you don't need to specify that in the suggestion

[glass arch]

though is there actually anything able to be crafted with essence of eleum and a regular anvil aside from like cryo key

[worldly basalt]

cores

[glass arch]

those need ecto so

[worldly basalt]

i didnt read the regular anvil part

[wide river]

Elumplate is the only item that can be crafted without any other hardmode items

[drowsy plank]

elumplate and frigidflash bolt

[wide river]

That'd require another essence

[drowsy plank]

and i guess frozen turtle shell

[swift wharf]

also im 100% sure that the npc hairstyle sugg is from reddit and i dont even use it anymore

[worldly basalt]

correct

[golden sonnet]

No need to lock it hardmode, you can also bring HM boss summons to a Pre HM world, no need to have conditional drops to prevent something you can only do intentionally

[swift wharf]

bruh

[hollow shell]

mm, maybe
I don't know how big those are behind the scenes

[drowsy plank]

ok but he just said crafted with it at an anvil so nbd

yeah legion is softlocked to hardmode anyway so this isn't really an issue

[swift wharf]

that is correct

[worldly basalt]

if you bring souls to a pre-hardmode world you can have souls in a pre-hardmode world 😨

[glass arch]

i think making the frost legion dropping cryonic ore would be best with a different sugg because it seems like it would be a bit of an info overload

[swift wharf]

would be better than fucking cryo slimes

[wide river]

Agreed

[drowsy plank]

i guess? i dont think it'd be that much i could write it compactly if ur worried about it being too wordy

[worldly basalt]

just add (and cryonic ore after cryogen) in a couple spots

[golden sonnet]

ok, Ill work on a writeup

[swift wharf]

however

i'd have to fight the event twice...........

[blazing kettle]

is thus penguin kid just pulling stuff from reddit now?

[swift wharf]

one time before cryo and one time after cryo . . . . . . . .

[bright crag]

I'm of the opinion that Cryo Slimes should be reworked into a more thematically interesting enemy
And Eleum is enough for Frost Legion

[drowsy plank]

fair enough

[worldly basalt]

the snowman thing is original i think

[opaque saddle]

It is

[swift wharf]

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Cryon

[blazing kettle]

but all of these ideas dont really fit in cal

[swift wharf]

how about we just remove cryo slimes

[frosty trellis]

Frost legion for elium yoooooo yes please

[blazing kettle]

they much better fit as their own mod

[opaque saddle]

We have Danny devito

[swift wharf]

it's a dedicated item

[glass arch]

as dedicated content

[swift wharf]

to a former dev

[half imp]

Frost legion elum makes so much sense please

[opaque saddle]

Oh rip

[wide river]

I think out of the five ore slimes that exist, Uelibloom, Astral, and Perennial are the only ones that work

[swift wharf]

please read the pins

[drowsy plank]

perennial listed twice

[swift wharf]

i think that all ore slimes should be removed except aero slimes because prehardmode sky is 🪦

[wide river]

oh frick

[crude geode]

This enemy is so unnecessary when there's already like ten other ice biome enemies that hardmode adds

[drowsy plank]

aero slimes have looped back around to being cool again

[crude geode]

including ice elementals

[swift wharf]

cursed please stop opening cans of worms

[crude geode]

no

<3

[half imp]

where is scoria slime

[opaque saddle]

Do you think they’ll change shimmer when it releases

[swift wharf]

DEAD

I ATE IT

[drowsy plank]

that's just cursed puffer

[swift wharf]

devil fish

[worldly basalt]

rod of harmony will be boss rush tier

[glass arch]

dead

[drowsy plank]

chaotic puffer
him
he drops scoria

[half imp]

not a slime

[opaque saddle]

What about town slimes?

[swift wharf]

https://calamitymod.wiki.gg/wiki/Devil_Fish

[half imp]

not a slime

[swift wharf]

GOOD

[half imp]

gimme scoria slime

[swift wharf]

THAT IS THE POINT

[half imp]

alliteration

[swift wharf]

NO MORE SLIMES

[worldly basalt]

they should add a slime for every single block, that would be very good game design i think

[swift wharf]

ILL KILL YOU

[worldly basalt]

living leaf slime 😊

[swift wharf]

[glass arch]

chaotic slimes were killed when scoria was moved to the abyss instead of being in hell

[drowsy plank]

slimes have a 0.0001% chance to drop any item

[half imp]

... oh my goodness I wonder if I could make a mod for that

[swift wharf]

LIVING LEAF SLIME

🔥

[blazing kettle]

its good as is

[swift wharf]

common thorium W

💪

[drowsy plank]

thorium slime

[opaque saddle]

I watched a video where Calamity had a giant cactus. I can’t find it in the game though?

[swift wharf]

pre-game summon W

[worldly basalt]

rolling?

thats undergroun

[blazing kettle]

thats from joostmod

[drowsy plank]

we add it when calamity and thorium are active at the same time

[opaque saddle]

Oh

Is Joost any good

[swift wharf]

Yes

[blazing kettle]

yeah

[wide river]

My reasoning behind this statement is that the Perennial slime removal suggestion got denied, Uelibloom is somewhat difficult to farm, and Astral can only have more if more meteors hit (not counting the slimes, that is)

[swift wharf]

It has a quest system

[blazing kettle]

but iirc its 1.3 exclusive

[opaque saddle]

Oh

[half imp]

not named scoria slime

L

[swift wharf]

scoria slime has vents the sussy slime i am not ok

[blazing kettle]

chaos slime is a remnant of the ancient days

[worldly basalt]

doesnt clentaminating normal ores turn them into astral ore? or am I misremembering

[drowsy plank]

oh joost died in the port? sad

[blazing kettle]

that or im out of date on info

[opaque saddle]

I hope we get a Doom Cannon on Calamity

[wide river]

Yes it does, I had just forgotten about that since it's new

[drowsy plank]

uh no i think that's only on generation

[half imp]

Also astral slimes make sense thematically

[drowsy plank]

oh wait does that happen now

cool

[worldly basalt]

you're talking about uberdanger's video arent you

[worldly basalt]

i thought it does

[drowsy plank]

astral slimes make sense because of astragelddon my beloved

prolly

[worldly basalt]

but i have no idea where i heard it

[opaque saddle]

Yeah

[drowsy plank]

i mean it makes sense if generation does it

[wide river]

I'm just dumb

[swift wharf]

astral slimes do make a bit of sense because astral infection

[drowsy plank]

HA

i knew it

[swift wharf]

the problem is that

astral infection enemies are mid........

[blazing kettle]

thats also joostmod

plus uh

[crude geode]

factual.

[drowsy plank]

astral infection when 3 of its enemies do the exact same thing

[golden sonnet]

ok, so should I post the write-up about the frost legion dropping cryonic, or make a post just about removing ore slimes in general

[worldly basalt]

slimes:

[swift wharf]

astral infection if it was an actual cosmic horror

[drowsy plank]

shhhhhh not important

[blazing kettle]

celebration mkII

[worldly basalt]

my favorite non-slime enemy, toxic sludge

[swift wharf]

toxic sludge....

[half imp]

they should not drop Cryonic

[swift wharf]

inflicts poison....

[half imp]

only eleum

[wide river]

The latter won't pass
I think it got suggested before and it failed

[drowsy plank]

yeah

[swift wharf]

just make one of the 10 hardmode ice enemies drop cryonic zzzzzzz

[crude geode]

stop stealing my thoughts

[wide river]

That's called the cryo slime

[opaque saddle]

Do you think Calamity will ever allow fan made paintings to be added?

[drowsy plank]

nah we need to bring back cryo's minions to make them do it

[swift wharf]

or add a cryonic freezer that turns water into ore

[blazing kettle]

theres already a mod that does that

[crude geode]

mmmm popsicle

[drowsy plank]

calamity's vanities exists and also the art server does too

[wide river]

Cryonic Freezer
Based idea

[swift wharf]

your front door is not locked.

[wide river]

Jokes on you I don't have a front door

[golden sonnet]

I am curious what slimes specifically have been rejected to be removed, as I have seen a general consensus among people that they shouldn't exist. And it is worth noting that with the shift in Devs previously rejected things might be reasonable to suggest again

[swift wharf]

guh

[blazing kettle]

calamity fans try not turn their mod into the everythibg all at once mod challenge

[wide river]

Mm, perhaps

[worldly basalt]

starbound all over again

[drowsy plank]

nah guys we really need aurora spirit, cryon AND ice clasper despite the fact two of them don't do anything at all!

[worldly basalt]

i dont even remember what the first two even are

[swift wharf]

isnt aurora spirit a cryogen minion

[drowsy plank]

it is now a normal enemy :)

bc cryo has no minions now

[swift wharf]

ugh

[drowsy plank]

YEAH

[wide river]

Aurora Spirits once spawned during cryogen, and Cryons are just there

[swift wharf]

crayons

[laugh]

[drowsy plank]

we really needed more collections of blue triangles bc ice elementals just weren't enough

[wide river]

This is truly a humorous moment

[opaque saddle]

I hope they add more furniture sets. I like building

[wide river]

Insert Marge Simpson saying "I just think they're neat"

[worldly basalt]

they already added like 15 of them

[swift wharf]

my honest reaction

[drowsy plank]

you should try calamity's vanities tbh it's made by a dev anyway

[blazing kettle]

we will be getting two more biomes at some point in the future

[worldly basalt]

slime dimension??

[drowsy plank]

noxus

[blazing kettle]

thats the distortion

[bright crag]

Maybe it's just me, but I find that enemy incredibly mid
Permafrost's magic has much more potential than just funny ice man

[swift wharf]

add gup from risk of rain 2 it's more unique than all slimes

[drowsy plank]

i know he is not a slime anymore

[opaque saddle]

Candy biome?

[blazing kettle]

no????

[wide river]

I can suggest to remove them if you want

[blazing kettle]

thats a different mod

called the confection

[bright crag]

Feel free too
I'm indifferent

[crude geode]

I hate gup he says go white boy go as my computer dies

[worldly basalt]

when will they add swamp biome as alternate jungle

[opaque saddle]

They could still add it

[half imp]

Dragon's aerie in question

[blazing kettle]

they wont

[golden sonnet]

I only just now realized that an ore slime removal passed, granted it's been like almost a year since.
#suggestions-voting message

[blazing kettle]

theres only 2 more biomes confirned in the mod

both being subworlds

[opaque saddle]

Do we know what they’re called?

[blazing kettle]

and not hallowed bione alternatives

distortion and dragon arie

[swift wharf]

I FORGOT HOW DISCORD EMBEDS IMAGES

[wide river]

Icon jumpscare

[swift wharf]

NOOOOO

[crude geode]

[opaque saddle]

Will they stop working on the mod after the biomes are all added and weapons are all balanced?

[crude geode]

trolled by discord updates

[swift wharf]

this is so burning_sound_effect.mp3

[crude geode]

weapons all being balanced

[worldly basalt]

reaver explosion

[blazing kettle]

uh, no?

what makes you think that

[swift wharf]

OUÆÆÆÆÆÆ

[crude geode]

this is not the chat for random questions unless they're in regard to making a suggestion

[swift wharf]

sisyphean task

[bright crag]

After everything is balanced, all the planned content added, and all the content in a satisfying state... yeah, we will

[opaque saddle]

Nice

[crude geode]

whenever all weapons are balanced a single blast barrel falls into the code and destroys it instantly

[fossil finch]

bro shitposted

[opaque saddle]

Take a look at my suggestion too please. I know it breaks the rules but it’s a good one

[blazing kettle]

damn i forgot tlwhat this place was

[worldly basalt]

ror2 chat

[swift wharf]

if it breaks the rules it isnt good

lma

[bright crag]

That doesn't really change anything :p

[blazing kettle]

the stylist suggestion is too much work for one little detail

[opaque saddle]

What about the snowman

[blazing kettle]

and the mount is a specific item suggestiob

[drowsy plank]

make the magic scarf and hat drop from frost legion

[crude geode]

actually kinda true and based tbfh?

[worldly basalt]

move everything from hardmode ice into frost legion 👍

[swift wharf]

you'll have to get permission from the de

wait

[worldly basalt]

cryogen is now an event boss

[swift wharf]

[drowsy plank]

where's the lie tho shrimply turn all cal ice content into cal frost legion content

[swift wharf]

cryogen the final boss of frost legion......

[opaque saddle]

They should add an air fryer

[drowsy plank]

acid rain tier 3... 2!

[swift wharf]

pyrogen the final boss of fire legion.....

[drowsy plank]

FIRE LEGION

[swift wharf]

😈

[drowsy plank]

yo anyone remember demon invasion

[worldly basalt]

real

[blazing kettle]

yall ever make a joke but think it sucks ass?

[worldly basalt]

thats called "building a hellbridge

[worldly basalt]

no, all my jokes are always flawless, no exceptions

[wide river]

"Then, everything changed when the fire legion attacked"
"Calamitas turn down avatar"

[drowsy plank]

ok but fr i remember they were gonna add a demon invasion that spawned when using the now removed demon trophy

[wide river]

Oh yeah that thing existed

[swift wharf]

the real calamity permanent upgrade

[atomic shell]

I love the actual good frost legion suggestion next to the other one

I can be your angle or your devil

[worldly basalt]

second was inspired by the first

[drowsy plank]

dont forget the real ones

[wide river]

It's funny because I cannot remember anything that gets removed after about a month passes

[swift wharf]

"TO THE OTHER ONE"

[crude geode]

pensive dog cowboy causes me head injuries

[wide river]

We do not speak of it

[worldly basalt]

spectre rifle? whats that?

[golden sonnet]

All good things have their cheap copy

[wide river]

Again, forgot that existed

[fervent orbit]

a removed item cuz it was spectre staff but ranger

[half imp]

terra edge is already vanishing

[worldly basalt]

i know thats why i mentioned it

[atomic shell]

who the hell is terra edge…

[wide river]

Generally an item that gets removed isn't noteworthy in the first place
Maybe that's why

[crude geode]

calamity is vanishing and we will all forget it on september 22nd at 4am EST

[swift wharf]

then why are the other items still in the mod

[drowsy plank]

heart rapier :)

[swift wharf]

😭

[worldly basalt]

2022

[worldly basalt]

oh hey thats the dragonfolly-looking item

[half imp]

Charged Dart Blaster and Coldheart Icicle:

[swift wharf]

@ ender

charged dart blaster got done dirty

rip the single dart weapon in the mod

[half imp]

why did cdb get killed

why are darts not done anything with

[wide river]

Oh yeah, that thing that caused a large argument over if it had the color scheme of dragonfolly weapons

[half imp]

they're so much cooler

than flamethrower

[crude geode]

are we going back to dart vs flamethrower discussion

[wide river]

Please direct your attention to the very first word in that sentence

[worldly basalt]

that was started by me 😊

[swift wharf]

we need more candy corn weapons

[drowsy plank]

candy corn sword

[swift wharf]

RANGED sutpid

[worldly basalt]

what about normal corn

[wide river]

Candy Corn Candy Corn

It's just more Candy Corn

[crude geode]

epic corn from minecraft orespawn

[half imp]

charged?

[wide river]

The sentence you had replied to

[half imp]

candy class when

Oh

[drowsy plank]

combine candy cane sword and candy corn rifle to make the diabetes gunsword

[worldly basalt]

auric-tier weapon

[swift wharf]

🖋️ 🔥

[half imp]

The heartslayer doomsword

[swift wharf]

omg youre so good at writing donor weapons

[ripe owl]

You are so right

[drowsy plank]

lol

[worldly basalt]

'an'

[drowsy plank]

ok but fr why can't i craft candy cane items from candy cane blocks, huh

[worldly basalt]

god i hate the new embeds

[wide river]

I think they're fine

[crude geode]

bc redigit hates us

[drowsy plank]

this is incredibly important to the game my immersion is totally broken

[swift wharf]

why cant i eat the candy corn......

[wide river]

Prevents a massive text wall from forming with 6+ images

[swift wharf]

😭

[worldly basalt]

clicking is so much work though

[crude geode]

bc redigit hates us

[drowsy plank]

candy corn gives 1 minute of well fed next update

[swift wharf]

no it doesnt

[half imp]

Maybe?

:)

[swift wharf]

THIS IS TINY

[half imp]

I am so mixed on them

[wide river]

Please check your mailbox
Something is waiting for you

[half imp]

I'm not at home

L

[swift wharf]

i post 5 of it and boom the screen is filled

[worldly basalt]

theyre fine for like giant image collages but if its only like 3 small images its completely messed up

[drowsy plank]

why dont they just

let us choose

[crude geode]

cuz it's pisscord

choosing implies it would be wrong in any way in making a change

[wide river]

That will happen when they give us the toggle for reply pings by default

Which is never

[drowsy plank]

[half imp]

I mean

Shift + press reply button

have the ping start off

mobile users take an L though

[wide river]

I wouldn't consider that a toggle, as you have to consistently select it

[half imp]

yeah but it's the closest well ever get :(

[wide river]

Unfortunately so, as I prefer turning off the reply pings at all times

Anyway back to suggestions
Here's the prototype for my next suggestion

Remove Aurora Spirits and Cryons

These enemies were once tied to Cryogen's defeat, but now they just exist. The both of them have no unique drops, have almost identical AI to other enemies, and do not serve to benefit the mod as a whole.

It's rather short, but I can't think of what else to add

[drowsy plank]

nah i mean it's a removal so like
what else can you say

[wide river]

I suppose

Especially because they're rather unnoteworthy enemies

[half imp]

remove or rework maybe, add the potential for them to drop Cryonic ore

then cryo slime can die

[drowsy plank]

Venus already said they'd rather just replace both outright so i think it's fine

[north oracle]

why are so many suggestions not reading the rules atm... it's normally bad but there's loads recently

[drowsy plank]

no idea, usualy it's bc there's an update but now it's just...???

[ripe owl]

Everyone's dumb and we can't solve it

[north oracle]

XD

[drowsy plank]

lol

[ripe owl]

[wide river]

I heard that people are debating past vs passed, so it might just be a people problem

[north oracle]

yeah, normally when things get bad it's right after a large update

[wide river]

The process around that time is generally
Player sees update
Neuron activation
Go to Discord
Suggest something immediately
Does not take advice
Refuse to elaborate further
Leave Discord

[crude geode]

ding dong ditch moment

[wide river]

And repeat

[wide river]

Unfortunately even adding a "Read this before you can chat" thingy would do absolutely nothing

Because if they aren't gonna read the rules anyway, then why would it help?

[fossil finch]

i mean

itd mean nobody who doesnt read the rules will not interact the channel at all

so lol lmao

[ripe owl]

I remember joining some server, it either was Shadows of Abaddon or Thorium, where every single of ten of "Read before you join" was "Mod is not updated to 1.4"

[fossil finch]

Making Things Painfully Obvious does help to make people interact with them

[wide river]

That's
Concerning

[worldly basalt]

it was not updated to 1.4

[ripe owl]

At least it's working

[wide river]

At the very least, yeah

[novel belfry]

shadows of abaddon had a weird incident like that

[north oracle]

I wonder if there’s a way to, before you gain access to #suggestions-posting, make you answer a multi choice quiz lmao

Probably not without actual human moderation

[ripe owl]

Yep

[wide river]

Just have a page long instructions to filter out the people that don't read

[distant gyro]

pass an iq test

[wide river]

True!

[north oracle]

They just scroll to the bottom and press done

[wide river]

If they skip the instructions, then they won't know how to pass the test

[north oracle]

True

[swift wharf]

make the bot ping the person if their suggestion gets a 🗜️

[wide river]

People who have do not disturb on:

[swift wharf]

well get prepared to get more pings

[wide river]

So true

[grim tusk]

#suggestions-posting message
Wait they still exist?

[golden sonnet]

lmao

[frosty trellis]

(I don't even know what they are)

[royal tapir]

idk...

[worthy lintel]

aurora what?

[hollow idol]

cryons are cool and were never directly cryogen related, dont hurt them : (

aurora can die tho

https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/459252132068065280/587329910142664704/CryonWalk.gif

[royal tapir]

Technically Aurora Spirits are cool too

[ripe owl]

What else are they, warm?

[crude geode]

I mean cryons are kinda just differently flavored icy merman

[ripe owl]

Invisible Icy Mermans covered in blue glass

[hollow idol]

they have a neat design,

[ripe owl]

They do

But do they need to exist as a mob?

Maybe you can keep them as a cosmetic for the player or something?

[drowsy plank]

ayo wait

cryo stone turns the player into a cryon

finally the interesting Cryo Stone functionality

[ripe owl]

I don't think it'd be useful on the grand scheme

Maybe just as a visual

The current effect is still nice, even tho it's just a more expensive Tesla Potion

[drowsy plank]

tbf it could just be visual but adding a couple other effects with the cryon transformations could help push it over tesla to be more deserving of the accessory slot

[wide river]

Just add a dedicated item like how Calamity's Vanities has the Cosmic Cone for Cosmic elementals

[ripe owl]

Yeah but Calamity ain't CalVal

[wide river]

Cal isn't Alch NPC and they've added potion shops
Cal isn't Fargo's Mutant Mod and they've added recipes for hard to get items

[ripe owl]

It was added for players to not overload their modpacks with QoL mods

CalVal is, well, vanities mod

It's not QoL

[wide river]

Do you really think that vanities are any different than QoL in terms of overloading modpacks

[ripe owl]

Nope

But Calamity still ain't gonna add a shitton of vanity items just because

(meanwhile legacy helmets, Ancient God Slayer, etc)

[wide river]

I never said to add a lot. I literally only suggested a dedicated item for Cryons

In any case, we could also turn the Daedalus Golem into a Cryon

[ripe owl]

That's a thing

[wide river]

Do you mind telling me what that is?
I'm not meaning to sound rude, I just don't know what you're talking about

[ripe owl]

Just me being dumb

I meant more "that might be a thing", not what I ended up writing

[wide river]

Ah, totally fair

[wide river]

If the suggestion somehow reaches the devs, feel free to ignore the Cryon part if you wish

[hollow idol]

considering how the voting system works, the sugg vote will be to keep or remove both

[ripe owl]

Just 🔒 it

[wide river]

I do like the Cryon's design as well, so I'm somewhat hoping that it doesn't pass

[ripe owl]

:wires:

That's us

[grim tusk]

@brisk stream no joke suggs

[ripe owl]

@brisk stream first of all, that's unreasoned suggestion. Second, even if it was to be added, do you have any idea how tedious it would be to get every single item in the game with Calamity?

[brisk stream]

Yes

[grim tusk]

Cheat sheet

[ripe owl]

Good, why did you suggest it?

[brisk stream]

Because I know someone would try to obtain it

[ripe owl]

That's uh

[grim tusk]

Why not delete the sugg then since you suggested it after all?

[ripe owl]

Not a really good reason to suggest it

[grim tusk]

Yea the 1/[googl] of players

[brisk stream]

Still better than the suggestion to add Pizza Hut

[grim tusk]

Worse

Go to horny jail

[hollow shell]

Bad. Don't suggest that. @brisk stream

[brisk stream]

Killjoy

[grim tusk]

A

[ripe owl]

B

[hollow idol]

Z (chain break)

[ripe owl]

Yeah?

breaks a chain
calls a person
refuses to elaborate further
leaves

[kindred skiff]

Tf was the sugg

[grim tusk]

Horny

[kindred skiff]

Was it like “add sex to calamity” or smth

[ripe owl]

Add Maid Calamitas

[kindred skiff]

Ah

That’s stupid

[ripe owl]

Exactly

Not only that

The condition to get that Maid Calamitas was

Drumroll

Get every single item in the mod

👍

[blazing kettle]

so is this whole maid thing a meme or do people genuinely get a particular emotion when peoole wear maid dresses or what

[ripe owl]

They do

They get horny

That's all I'll say

[blazing kettle]

gross

[ripe owl]

Oh well

[kindred skiff]

I still don’t get the maid thing

[ripe owl]

Let's not discuss it here though

[hollow ridge]

Great day for suggestions

I wanna make one but its kinda a small thing

[north oracle]

At this point if it follows the rules…

[swift wharf]

this is so true

[small timber]

if blunder booster is an accessory that have visual to begin with the suggestion will make more sense, but in this case blunder booster never have a sprite
it is just a red lightning aura
so before you suggest to "allow blunder booster to be equipped as a vanity item for wings & tracers" it need to have a sprite on its own in the first place, let alone for wings and tracers

and also your suggestion lacks any reasoning as to why we need this, why not just have a wings/tracers instead? or are you suggesting blunder booster to have a wing/tracer-like sprite? which also do not make much sense since it is not a wing

@thorn dock

[thorn dock]

Why not beeing able to choose to fly/ float in a sphere rather than having to look for wings that match your Outfit.
Just for overall improved cosmetical reason.

[swift wharf]

so you want it to disable wing sprites when it's in the vanity slot

[thorn dock]

Yes

[swift wharf]

why

why not just make it give a vanity sphere because there are people who want to keep the wings

[thorn dock]

If u pull it in rhe vanity left to wings it disables, if u pull it into a vanity not besides a wing/tracer it wont

[small timber]

regardless you still need to put an actual reasoning to the suggestion

currently it is just a recolored tesla potion sprite, nothing even indicate that it is supposed to "make you float", so it will just make it so your character is flying for no reason for most people

[thorn dock]

Why are you flying for no reason if u have wings equipped?

[small timber]

because blunder booster is not a wing?

so to the (most) player it will just look like "you are flying without a wing" rather than "you have this floaty sphere that makes you fly"

[eternal escarp]

tesla potion will give you the electric field effect thing i think

[thorn dock]

Floating/flying in a sphere is not rare in games or movies

[eternal escarp]

but yeah i mean its not a sphere its a
electric damage aura im pretty sure

[swift wharf]

it is a sphere

well it's a circle in a 2d world but you get what i mean

[eternal escarp]

its not a sphere in the sense i think they mean
but yeah i mean shape wise jts a sphere

[swift wharf]

o yea

by that definition tesla potion should also make you fly

[eternal escarp]

inferno ring flight

potion*

btd6 brainrot

[ornate kestrel]

Lol

[drowsy plank]

just use yoraiz0r's spell dude

[ornate kestrel]

^

[junior tendon]

(it's not

people still ask for it despite there being 500 hints that tell you

tmodlets are dumb

[ripe owl]

Like I said

We live in such time where everyone knows how to write but nobody knows how to read

[junior tendon]

byea

[drowsy plank]

tmodlets

lmfao

[wide river]

Ah, true that. I just thought I'd put it out there

[atomic shell]

great sugg I want to go to hell

[hybrid steeple]

10/10 sugg

[hollow ridge]

6 reacted suggs in one day

[small timber]

is this the 2nd time?

ok so yes this is a 2nd time I think
forgot if it is the same person but iirc the same suggestion was posted before, so with context I will assume is the same person

[drowsy plank]

we already have the 9 rings of hell; it's this server

[stable kiln]

[swift wharf]

cmt
lore discussion
other mod talk
gen talk
balance suggestions
suggestion posting
suggestion voting
spoiler talk
and wiki discussion. . .

[wide river]

The only place that's worse than here (that I can think of) is the Fargo's Discord art channel

I've seen at least a couple dozen instances of people getting off topic, four instances of people getting warned, and various other... interesting behaviour in there

[hollow ridge]

Another suggestion

[wide river]

Specifically from the lore chat

I really do like this new suggestion
It's really well written, it has good reasoning, and makes thematical sense

[fervent orbit]

cool and all but i hate not knowing the actual full hp of a boss ingame

[frosty trellis]

I mean it's a don't regardless bc no re-adding old content

[golden sonnet]

Calamity Moon Lord:

[cobalt pewter]

@novel timber

• to my knowledge the name is meant for eventual Yharim fight in 2069

where birb lad is revived there

[tiny oyster]

Regarding this suggestion

[cobalt pewter]

interesting

[tiny oyster]

in order to make the fight fair

while keeping the regen concept

I'd also suggest reducing Yharon's max health to half of its current

in order to "deceive" the player

[novel timber]

it'd have to be reduced anyways because the rebirth shouldn't actually change the fight length

[small timber]

@inland zenith vote on this instead, it is basically the same suggestion

[tiny oyster]

Yes that's what I'm taking about

[cobalt pewter]

it'd still be against the rule of returning content suggs, but sure it seems like there are conflicting opinions even in dev

I'm not in the correct headspace to discuss about berb tho so

[small timber]

and trust me mage don't fare much better, melee have mostly vanilla stuffs and the only melee accessory is just bloody worm tooth

[cobalt pewter]

https://tenor.com/view/mario-bed-tired-gif-13097259

[small timber]

summoner and rogue dont reallly count because they are so accessory dependent that they have to have a lot

[cobalt pewter]

I wish rogue isn't as acc dependent

but it is what it is for now

[glass arch]

yeah mage has like 3 main accessory lines (and one of them isnt even really a line its just a bunch of mana flower upgrades)

[polar pine]

ceaseless void

[drowsy plank]

lmfao glad to see this place in as much disarray as i left it

i know infernum is already readding yharon rebirth, and i suppose its removal is from pre-22devcident, so i suppose opinions could change

on the plus side at least we've completely killed off % damage before this sugg came to be

[small timber]

I think I tried to propose an idea to "keep the revive without hiding the true total HP of the fight" which is to just have a 2nd health bar below the first (eg: instead of disappearing like usual, the lost HP bar is instead turnt red) which then turn into the "true hp bar" of the 2nd part of the fight

but yeah it completely depend on whether the dev wants to readd the revive anyway

[golden sonnet]

Tbh I miss when DoG was separate health bars

It actually surprised you and was unique

[drowsy plank]

it was never supposed to be like that tbh it was just technical limitations lol

it's the same as cal clone having her twins phase tbh

[bright crag]

@novel timber Sorry, I hadn't noticed it broke a rule
I'll bring it up myself

[bright crag]

Keep in mind that nobody can break the rules in this channel, even if recommended by a dev

My intention, as stated, was to get an idea of how many people actually want the regen phase to return

But I'd forgotten that sughesting this would break a rule

[drowsy plank]

@west creek you can already get them from fishing

[bright crag]

^

[wide river]

Wasn't there also a suggestion requesting this exact thing a few months ago?

[drowsy plank]

i think so

[wide river]

I don't know if it ever reached voting, but I remember seeing one with the reasoning of "You can run out of them"

Which was entirely incorrect

[glass arch]

there was one from a few years ago that got denied but nothing recent in voting

[drowsy plank]

yeah im pretty sure most get killed in posting because it's just

dumb

[wide river]

We don't need a recipe for items that already can be obtained in other methods, yeah

[fervent orbit]

isnt an extractinator in the hell lab too

[wide river]

Ye

As well as in Desert houses

[fervent orbit]

amazing suggesting

[drowsy plank]

about as good as making the shrine items craftable too

[fervent orbit]

no this is worse

because atleast the shrines are 1 per world

this is like

6 per world

[drowsy plank]

and is already renewable

[swift wharf]

well you see but the crafting recipes

[golden sonnet]

un momento de SiS

[wide river]

Suggestions have been very interesting today and yesterday

[bright crag]

Ok nvm I don't think there's a good chance of Yharon getting his revive back

At least, not as much as I had thought

[drowsy plank]

@errant inlet

1. this should go in the art server
2. this is a specific item suggestion
3. this makes like. zero sense lore wise. and also why does ark need ANOTHER upgrade

[errant inlet]

Not ark of the cosmos, but the one ark you make using the fractured ark and a broken hero sword

Also, you're telling me that other shadowspec weapons make any sense lorewise?

[drowsy plank]

okay you're ignoring the fact that this is against the rules completely

it's a specific item suggestion

[errant inlet]

Damn k i removed it

[drowsy plank]

you could go post it in the art server if you want to share the art

[swift wharf]

shadowspec weapons are dev weapons

[drowsy plank]

oh right shadowspec item suggestions are also banned xd

[errant inlet]

So only devs can get shadowspec shit in game?

[swift wharf]

yeah

[errant inlet]

Whoops

[drowsy plank]

so this is like triple against the rules

[swift wharf]

if you're not named fabsol ingame you cant use dev items : )

[errant inlet]

Then there's gonna be no shadowspec bars in the recipe, just exo prisms and those 2 other swords

[drowsy plank]

okay please just

read the pins

[swift wharf]

^

[errant inlet]

I deleted ittttt

But before i go post it in the art server, wherever that may be

Does the sword art look good at least?

[drowsy plank]

yeah the art looked fine, color might've helped and at the end of the day the only submissions the mod accepts are pixel art but
over all it was neat

[errant inlet]

Imma try and make a pixel art version of it then

[swift wharf]

i didnt see it

😭

[drowsy plank]

https://discord.gg/CKByxd5

anyway here

[errant inlet]

Are there any rules regarding the resolution of the item sprite?

[swift wharf]

i dont think so

[errant inlet]

I can send it here if you wanna see

[swift wharf]

sure

[errant inlet]

Aight just a sec

[drowsy plank]

idk check sprite submissons in the serv lul

[swift wharf]

as long it's not exo mechs spritesheet

and yeah it looks pretty good

[errant inlet]

Im not gonna take one of ares's arms and suggest that as a weapon 💀

[swift wharf]

no i mean that

hold on who has it again

[drowsy plank]

i still love how the arc is just
a fuckin block
me smacking you over the head with a metric ton of magic metal

[swift wharf]

this works

[drowsy plank]

not even actually transparent

[wide river]

Is that the sprite sheet for a single ares arm

[swift wharf]

yes

gauss nuke

[wide river]

108 sprites for a single arm, wow

[drowsy plank]

this thing has so many frames for me to ignore while trying not to die!
fr tho that's a stupid amount of detail and i have to respect it but im wondering how many people just straight up do not notice these animations

[wide river]

Honestly while fighting exos I really am not paying attention half the time because I'm just looking at them

[drowsy plank]

based

[swift wharf]

you should see the others

actually just artemis and apollo

[blazing kettle]

thanatos shouldnt have a lot of sprites

right?

[swift wharf]

yeah thanatos has a normal sheet i think

this is why you should use procedural animations instead...

[cloud cloak]

There’s basically a weapon for that already

[half imp]

I mostly notice them with Ares Exoskeleton

[drowsy plank]

ah right lol

[half imp]

what about maybe on GFB or FTW?

[drowsy plank]

oh that's

actually a really smart way of doing it

[bright crag]

That's not unlikely, but another thing entirely

[half imp]

yeah ofc

fingers crossed, revive yharon was hype

but it makes sense to not be on the main difficulty

[hollow ridge]

Yharon dies

Bing bong boom

[swift wharf]

hollow knight boss death sound effect

[wide river]

I assume the suggestion is requesting something similar to what Scal has with Acceptance

[errant inlet]

Oh wow this discussion is still going

Lemme look up what the acceptance even is

Oh wait you ain't talking ab my suggestion 💀

[wide river]

What discussion were you referring to

[errant inlet]

Jesus Christ how hard is it to animate a few sprites together

[errant inlet]

Exo Ark thingmajig

[novel timber]

kinda like a victory fanfare

i think spirit mod has that on a lot of their bosses

[wide river]

Ooooh, that

[mossy badge]

i had multiple strokes reading that

[grim tusk]

@abstract forge @heady root please answer why in your suggestions

[eternal escarp]

or ill asnwer why not
adding them to a recipe doesnt make it usefull, it makes it fodder
instead, you should suggest to improve the accessories that are seen as lacking

just slapping them as a mini addition in an accessory line makes both the accessory more annoying to make, and the added accessory retain the same amount of usefulness

[novel belfry]

is it just me, or did the newest cal update remove the ability of the Mida Prime to use coins in your piggy bank?

[blazing kettle]

this is either a poor translation or a literal child

[novel belfry]

or yknow
||||

but anyways, im not sure why that Midas Prime change happened

[blazing kettle]

if it were a troll then it would be more obvious

[grim tusk]

@heady root still invalid

Also the accessories (except bloop pact lol) are still useful on their respective tiers

(Also what spine?)

[drowsy plank]

truly just

the worst suggestions this week huh

also the overbloated accessories didnt make their components good, it just made them an unnecessary grindy component of an item with actually good effects

[glass arch]

aint it like hote
take away the stat sticks and it sucks?

[golden sonnet]

The components weren't good before with a few exceptions, but I do agree a large number of accessories feel very mid with materials removed

[drowsy plank]

there are obvious issues with some of them, but ignoring this is a reversion sugg, adding a lot of them back in aint gonna fix it

[golden sonnet]

I agree, I think the materials and accessories that had them could use a rework, many of which have been suggested, as I completely agree with what Blast said, adding them as materials just makes them shit and annoying to get

[west creek]

yeah, same can be said to almost every accessory Calamity introduced crafting. Also, fishing doesnt solves the "hella annoying" part

[west creek]

but that is a good info, thanks!

[drowsy plank]

that's literally just not true, dozens of those are not obtainable in fishing crates at all or have no methods of sustainable obtainment at all, extractinator is not one of those
and the """hella annoying"""" part is called actually playing the game/exploring the world and actually just finding the extractinator

it's not like it's necessary for progression, unlike, arguably, several of the other actually craftable accessories are, due to how cal designs bosses