#Can "geht um" be used to imply death

20 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

acoustic vigil
#

I have thought for some time that "umgehen" can be used to describe someone "going under" in a sense. Coming out on the bottom, possibly resulting in death. I don't remember when or where I started thinking this, nor can I find any sources saying it can be used this way. But when I use it that way in a sentence, DeepL translates it as I expect. Am I making stuff up?

Example sentence: "Er geht durch den Dolch um."
Translation by DeepL: "He is killed by the dagger."

zinc crow
#

In other words: Don't translate from German to English, and assume that the English is what the German means. The German could just be nonsense that DeepL is trying to make sense of.

acoustic vigil
#

I want a native speaker or a level C speaker to confirm this.

#

(that the sentence is wrong; it's already well known DeepL will be able to correct mistakes given context)

zinc crow
#

"zu Grunde gehen" means "to die" or "get destroyed"

#

or "untergehen" = to perish or fall to something

acoustic vigil
#

I very likely somehow mixed "umgehen" up with "umkommen", but I can't figure out why that happened.

zinc crow
acoustic vigil
#

I'll accept Argus' explanation as quite likely and proceed on the understanding that the answer to my thread is "no". 👍

#

Thank you for answering, Argus!

iron drum
# acoustic vigil I'll accept Argus' explanation as quite likely and proceed on the understanding ...

tbh i am to lazy to read it all, but i am native and nobody would say "geht um" . I don´t even think it is right.

Normally you would say "geht drauf" in that context. It is not formally and doesn´t bring any respect. You would use it if a friend or somebody you know is about to do a dangerous action, then you would say "Der geht doch drauf" witch 1 to 1 translated means "He is going to go on top" But is used as "He is going to die" in a funny sense.

Another way to say it would be "umbringen" witch would translate to "(to) kill somebody".
For example: "Ich werde ihn umbringen" "I am going to kill him"
another example: "Er hat sich umgebracht" "he killed him self"

Both of these words are not formal and will normally not be used in a tragic situation

And then there are of coarse also the well known once like "sterben" and "töten" (To die and (to) kill"

acoustic vigil
#

Vilen Dank, Zitrone!

past iron
#

@acoustic vigil were you thinking of kommt um? i think that's one that @iron drum forgot to mention (or i didn't spot it)

iron drum
past iron
#

my apologies

acoustic vigil
#

Yeah, I likely mixed up a bunch of other expressions. 😄