#Good second video?

82 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

strong oracleBOT
#

Nice feedback post! Please keep in mind that all feedback is provided out of the good will of the community, so it may take some time for you to get a response.

Please avoid reposting or begging members in other channels to check out this thread.

If you receieve no feedback at all, consider that as feedback in a sense.

winged pebble
#

If possible please review the entire video 🙂 Thanks

noble hatch
#

Okay so for me i got to the 1 minute Mark before i got bored and clicked off.
With no commentary its gonna be hard to keep people interested. I Had no idea of what is going on for most of the video

winged pebble
#

Maybe not niche for you?

#

@noble hatch

#

do you knwo the game minecraft?

#

ive had vids blow up in this niche before just testing miencraft instead of roblox

#

Btw average view duration is 3:12... soooo

#

which is pretty good for a 5 min video

#

Similar vid in my niche

#

nearly has 1m views

noble hatch
#

I know the game minecraft, yes 😬

But seems like you know everything so i wish you good luck with your perfect 7 view video 😬
Also… it looks like you just straight up stole the Thumbnail from that video, which is…. Not cool

winged pebble
#

You said “you clicked off after one minute” then said “you had no idea what was going on for most of the video”

#

you clearly have no idea what you’re talking about gang

#

😂

winged pebble
#

you defo think u know everything when i have an instagram reel that has your entire channel views combined lol

plucky nebula
#

why did you ask for feedback if you dont even want feedback, they werent disrespectful or anything

winged pebble
#

This guy has been literally targeting me on this discord since i joined

#

Everytime i ask for advice from other people hes just constantly begging for attention and being condescending asf

#

When i didnt ask for his input

#

Its this dude specifically as well

#

Everyone else has been 100% chill

plucky nebula
#

i also watched your video and i would say the same thing really, you took a video idea and tried to recreate it basically 1:1 but less engaging and in general feels less polished. Also the whole stealing thumbnails thing is not a great look

winged pebble
#

Yeah i hear it

#

But so many people take each other’s thumbnails

#

I just dont get what this one guy has a problem with me bro its just sad behaviour atp

plucky nebula
#

its smart to look at well performing videos you want to take inspiration from, adding your own twist and thumbnail will probably get you more engagement over time anyways

#

because people dont have anywhere else to go for that specific content

winged pebble
#

Right thanks

plucky nebula
#

so just do that

winged pebble
#

Funny thing is i didnt necessarily copy the thumbnail i just recreated it lol

iron olive
winged pebble
#

@plucky nebula can u check this video

#

Any feedbsck would be appreciated 🙏

winged pebble
#

If its engaging then its fine

iron olive
winged pebble
#

bro i made it in canva 😂

#

i did not download it bro

iron olive
#

That's not the point

winged pebble
#

jesus christ

iron olive
#

Doesn't matter how you did it, the fact still there, you just copy it 1 by 1, every pixel is identical

winged pebble
#

Ok so what if i copied?

#

It brings views and it is an engaging thumbnail lol

iron olive
winged pebble
#

ok well its a good thumbnail

#

so i copied it lol

#

nothing wrong with that bro

#

😂

iron olive
#

well, you think there is nothing wrong

winged pebble
#

whats wrong with that

#

Is it against youtube TOS?

#

literally everyone copies thumbnails brother

iron olive
#

not doing the same picture

winged pebble
#

i made it myself bro

#

😆😆

#

so its my own style

iron olive
#

it doesn't work like that wat

#

Nevermind

winged pebble
#

Ok

#

I copied now what

#

Am i gonna get banned

#

I dont get it

#

What’s the capital sin ive committed

iron olive
#

Just want to agree with another guy, if you cannot analyse the criticism, don't ask for feedback

winged pebble
#

You cant tell me why stealing a thumbnail is bad lol

#

even tho a lot of successful channels actively do it

iron olive
winged pebble
#

Btw youre stealing the other guy’s opinion

#

Just saying

winged pebble
#

You copied his opinion

iron olive
#

☠️

winged pebble
#

im trolling dw

iron olive
#

I cannot believe what I just read, I don't want to argue

#

Just... do whatever you think is right to do