snow fulcrum
I'm sure there's hundreds of posts just like this but I am being completely serious when I ask for harsh criticism
I want to know what flaws my videos have and what I need to work on, if somethings just boring/not engaging/just straight not funny, please let me know because I want to improve, the same applies if you think something does well please lmk, I want 100% honest criticism on my video
wheat monolith
Hello! I watched your vid and I have a list of pros and cons. Keep in mind, I’m a fairly casual gamer and it’s from my perspective.
Those are my cons, but here are my pros! Your editing was very impressive btw!
snow fulcrum
Hello! I watched your vid and I have a list of pros and cons. Keep in mind, I’m ...
i really appreciate the feedback, thanks a ton man
I should have probably tried to reduce to length of the video tbh
you've listed more cons than pros but if Im wondering if you think the video is bad or good?
like if it was a scale of 1-10 what would be an honest rating
Idm if its a low rating I just want to know if its more positive or negative
ill still take all the feedback ofc and try work on it
like reducing video length and what not
also when you said the objective of the game wasnt clear, that wasnt because of a poor editing decision, the games just not very clear at all lol
theres just items around and you just sorta figure it out from there
but still I really appreciate the honest feedback, ill try work on it
if you can give an honest rating of 1-10, and if you personally enjoyed the video, it would make my day (even if you rate it low and didnt like it lol)
I just want honest feedback if its still entertaining with its flaws
wheat monolith
Not a problem! I respect the desire to improve man! I listed more cons than pros because I was in the mindset of a critical eye, but the fact the pros brought me out of that mindset means it’s a good thing.
snow fulcrum
Not a problem! I respect the desire to improve man! I listed more cons than pros...
I really appreciate it, the more flaws with the more I can improve so I'm not hurt about it or anything, I'm just curious if the flaws did actually outway the pros
wheat monolith
Keep in mind, I typically don’t watch or seek out many gameplay videos, so I’m not your target audience, but I’d give it a 6.5 out of ten. I think that if you had a better game to play (imo) it would’ve improved it, but you guys were essentially making chicken salad out of chicken crap (I mean that in a good way!)
snow fulcrum
Keep in mind, I typically don’t watch or seek out many gameplay videos, so I’m n...
I feel like I shouldve probably cut more tbh
in hindsight
if thats hows it spelt
I can see what you mean about it getting repititive
wheat monolith
Since I also incorporate humor in my vids and I feel that what you and your friend are also doing here, it really helps to watch comedians or podcast clips that appeal to you
And no worries man! We’re all trying to improve here and I’m just giving my two cents, but what I love is that you can feel the authenticity of your vids which give it its own charm
Not saying stealing jokes, but when I consume that content fairly often, some tendencies of those funny clips come out in my own voice overs if that makes sense
snow fulcrum
my videos have to be authentic because I am awful at planning and script work 💀
Idk if you can tell by my intros
but I keep them short cus theyre just
idk it feels off
wheat monolith
Bro, I don’t even have a script for my vids either
But, I’m a shorts creator. So also different ballpark
snow fulcrum
fair enough
but I'll keep working on my videos
ill try keep them shorter if they get too repititive
ty for the feedback, it rlly helped
ive got my next video recorded already and I'll try use what I've learnt here
wheat monolith
You’re on a good path man! Don’t get too bogged down by the feedback.
snow fulcrum
tysm
snow fulcrum
You’re on a good path man! Don’t get too bogged down by the feedback.
its all helpful anywya
knowing what you do right and wrong in a video just makes better ones in the future
wheat monolith
Oh absolutely! But the more you do, the better you get with anything really