Which thumbnail do you like better? Any feedback would be appreciated

[bold zealot]

The title for the video is going to be something along the lines of "Are these indie games on game pass any good?"

I'm kind of leaning towards the green one, mostly because it conveys the message pretty well and fits the title. Whereas the other one is kind of random.

One thing I could fix with the green one is I could upres the xbox background so it isn't so fuzzy

[ashen axle]

I definitely think the second one is more suited cuz it stands out alot more especially when it's actually on youtube and everyone sees the thumbnail smaller than what you would do blown up on here.

[barren bough]

I like the left one. But maybe you could include box art and put the game pass logo in the background

[bold zealot]

Haha we're at a 50/50 split so far. Thank you for both of your input!

[urban rose]

I think I'd prefer something that was in between the 2 thumbnails; the green xbox background and game pass logo from the right thumbnail, and the mascots for the games from the left thumbnail ; I'd say find a way to combine those things and see what it looks like

[bold zealot]

I've got these, however I feel like the monkey gets a bit washed out from the background

[ashen axle]

Is there a different more vibrant coloured power wash sim character? Having blue and green/turquoise doesn't really mix well

[barren bough]

I like the one on the left

[bold zealot]

I might be able to find something. There are other colors, however I think for promotional art it was all blue

[ashen axle]

Ahh okay. that one definitely jumps out more and is potentially more recognisable as a palworld character

I would definitely make a couple different ones you're happy with cuz I always find when they are actually on youtube in that smaller format what looks good bigger doesn't always come across the same when it's thumbnail size

[bold zealot]

That's a good idea, thank you for all your feedback, I appreciate it 🙂