#Carnivores (Series)
1 messages · Page 10 of 1
yeah my mistake there
Yo! Moderator here, knock this off
this guy's caused trouble in the carnivores discord before getting kicked out, so i'd keep an eye on em and be stern
It's all cool, willing to be a fresh slate here, just remember what this room is for is to discuss the games and propose ideas for what a remaster project can look like. Tangents from that can happen, don't worry about being smited for general excitement, but this is less of a hangout spot and more of a rally point, if that makes sense
I’m surprised no one tried to mute me for that pun
even this kid is back
Godzilla and Venator in the same room

No Venator you don't get to say anything this time
I dont know How to reply to your comment to be honest with you, Ive been staring at My phone keyboard for 37 minutes now thinking of a possíble answer that could be funny or that at least would make some Sense, but I didnt find any so im writing this instead
O wait
So im calling van Helsing, to free your soul from the devil (tatem) or something idk
When I tranquilize a dinosaur with missile launcher
hey, are y'all gonna be cool or do I need to keep a constant eye here?
Keep constant eye on those who keep constant eye on saga banned member
We're chill
Or at least I am
I haven't spoken here for 3 days
Keep Constant eye for sure
We could never know when some sneaky individual tries to troll us
I am too
Like people rather believe in aliens that in the fact that I changed
Btw hi NightMar
Made an JWD final battle resound with Carnivores sfx to like this one
I covered every single speech with death sounds of humans and i choked myself during the making
i died of laughter when making the people make the UAAGGHH everytime they talk
especially the one at 1:28
Ok
Why are you posting random stuff here?
He thinks this is saga 2.0
Man who is this guy?
Embrace ye sea shanties lad
Some kid who was being annoying on the Saga server
Genuinely thought the announcement that the Carnivores remaster came out and started tweaking
What
Btw I hope a carnivore fan buys the rights of the series.
Possibly Isachenko
So we could get Carnivores 4 : Return Of The Ancients
Nuh uh nightdive should buy the rights
Carnivores 2 multiplayer experience
Host bump up dinosaur health to 1024 just cause
Ngl C2 multiplayer will be an absolute disaster
please tell me this is sarcasm
So true
Absolutely zero reason to have multiplayer in carnivores
Only place it would fit would be cityscape
Imagine the entire server just activate debug mode
Imagine if there's a friendly fire
Meh
It would still be cool
We were waiting for multiplayer since Carnivores 2
Getting one in Remastered Collection would be nice
And host it on something that is not GameSpy
meh idk
they can always just disable some admin thing
multiplayer would be cool for the remaster
Hunting games nowadays seem to go for multiplayer too, and it’s fun
Would be Buggy as hell
really not
majority of modern multiplayer titles are fps based
to say a hunting game like carnivores multiplayer would die quickly would be an understatement
be cool yes
but it's a different question if it's - should we do it?
is it worth implementing it into the game
Only the community would play such thing for a long time
what
it’s a new thing atleast..
The multiplayer
it’s not supposed to be exaggerated
just a fun multiplayer in like js a duo or trio
wdym by new thing
plus it can always help expand the trophy rooms more
people can collect their different trophies or collect one for both
so only carnivores community will be on 24/7 with their friends just wasd left click
plus supply ships will be more of a clutch and very supportive
you may think it would be fun but trust me it would get boring quick
it would be fun for about 5 minutes
whatever
multiplayer will likely be done by modders nonetheless
you can’t really stop it from happening
it’s gonna be a thing eventually
i think it should be available as a mod not in the base game
it just doesn't make sense to have it
what’s the difference still
it being mod or not mod
it’s not forcing you to play multiplayer
it’s just another gamemode like Survival mode
Not say that, I Said that only the community would keep this multiplayer feature Alive until It becomes dead with zero players in one server
because the gameplay style of carnivores is primarily for singleplayer not multiplayer
there's no co-op involved
who says they can’t alter the gameplay
there's no campaign
well that's just your opinion
it’s better when you have freedom over the game
and not forced to follow specific tasks
like rust?
alter the gameplay in what way
do you even read..
it could help flesh out the trophy rooms much better
perhaps even add advanced traversal system through modding
how dotrophy rooms have anything to do with multiplayer
and what’s not fun in traversing maps with your friends
yes?
i never said it wouldn't be fun
plus the fact hunting is also gonna be more supportive
it would be fun yes but only for a bit
it would get repetitive and boring quick just running around shooting NPC dinosaurs with like 1 or 2 friends
you know you always got back-up
and it’s gonna be fun just planning some proper hunting strategy
that’s why mods exist… to expand weapons, dinosaurs, maps and so on
what are you talking about 'strategy'
it’s not gonna end quickly if the modding community will just go on and expand the game entirely and drop new content for people to play
this isn't a tactical fps
when did i mean it as some tactical fps lmao
where you plan grenade line-ups
I think we could make something Fun out of the multiplayer, like If friendly fire Is allowed, a player must be at Constant watch of other players in the map who would kill him and stole his kill, "poacher" mode, I would say
fym “grenade line-ups”
you are talking about it like one

you said 'strategy' so i'm curious what kind of strategies people would come up with to shoot a t-rexes eye
that's simply not how it works my friend
neither will i
literally you make it sound it like it fucking sucks
not even “didn’t mention i don’t like it”
no
straight up hate for it
nothing more
i never said it would fucking suck
i said it would get boring
not everyone will have the same thoughts of it being boring
quick
not everyone is the same
never said that either
some may find it boring afterwards, some may still find it fun to play from time to time
what hunting games have multiplayer?
even then the game doesn’t force you to play multiplayer
you can always go for singleplayer
as it’s the base gameplay type
carnivores' genre simply isn't meant for multiplayer
multiplayer can always be a fun gamemode like survival mode
Call of the wild perhaps
let’s see…
Call of the Wild
RDR (at some degree, it does encourage fishing and hunting at times, and the roster of animals is pretty big too for that)
Hunting Simulator
Monster Hunter can also count as one as the main goal is to basically hunt down monsters and collect their materials or some rare items; it also encourages you to play with friends for a more fun and easier experience
prehistoric hunt
and so on
there’s also hunting games on roblox but i’m not gonna count those for obvious reasons
still
TheHunter Primal had multiplayer
there’s a rather wide variety of hunting games that have multiplayer
and nobody complained
But is dead, unfortunately
Call of the Wild is more popular as of now
modern and all
there's no real reason to add multiplay into carnivores other than''it would be cool...'' and ''it would be fun...''
no real innovations or uniqueness is involved
Carnivores is also boring when you walking across the map Just to get a kill, It depends of the map
holy shit it’s as if you don’t understand that it can encourage the modding community to finally implement fully expanded trophy rooms that can be edited with your friends, as you expand the entire trophy map with different rooms or trophies around. It will also encourage for some actual traversal updates like jeeps and boats, with somebody always driving, one shooting and one making sure the vehicle stays up. Then it can also benefit against packs / herds of animals, as it’s easier to keep track on the surrounding and also make sure to get more targets in a faster time
and also you won’t feel lonely most of the time
even then, like Cecom said, singleplayer also gets boring
you walk and shoot, walk and shoot
same wasd + LC gameplay
what’s the difference?
you're just continuing to give random reasons like that would change anything lol
multiplayer atleast somewhat goes over that and opens up for more potential addons
Co-op carnivores would probably be the best idea
“random”
then fuck off, what can i say
it’s as if you don’t get the meaning of actual fun
go back to some fps then
tf you getting pressed over bro
chill
or back to staying in some lonely singleplayer gameplay loop
it's not that deep
Vehicles on the atmosfear engine, I dont think It would be possíble tho
“Lonely singleplayer gameplay loop”
Gonna be honest, it just seems like you hate singleplayer
you’re protecting singleplayer while it features the same issues as multiplayer from your perspective, but it’s just one player
not much, js stating how he said the gameplay loop issue was said in the multiplayer idea
but it’s not like Singleplayer lacks that
there aren't any real co-op mechanics in carnivores like puzzles, bosses,etc that would otherwise be very fun to play with friends
it’s gonna have gameplay loops one way or another
What do you mean “Not much”
Bosses were a thing in carnivores-
there’s a whole mod based around a boss battle
You only hate it a little bit?
although it’s still a concept
but modders can always bring in bosses and so on
the ideas aren’t limited as long as there’s a possibility
by that logic you can just take any game and add multiplayer and it would become 5x more fun
no matter what
“any game” 😭
that's not how this works
because the 'experience would be elavated you can do so much more'
not every game has the same hunting genre as carnivores
I mean when you think about it, are you enjoying your friends company or the game more?
yeah
it’s as if you literally don’t give a fuck about having fun with friends
and just sit all alone in the game
exact same thing you can say about all singleplayer games
doesn’t matter
do you literally enjoy playing with friends or being alone in a game
oh this singleplayer game is getting boring time to add multiplayer that'll make the experience 10x better im sure
yeah this sounds like a person that never had anyone to play with and have fun
that'll change a whole lot for sure
I mean this arguments going on for a hot minute so you seem to think it matters
stay in your lone gameplay then
not everyone wants to sit in the same gameplay loop and have fun by their own
some want to enjoy the game with their friends
company is also a thing for even hunting games
it simply isn't worth it other than ''it's cool''
even irl hunting can be done with multiple people
it doesn’t always have to be just you
Gonna be honest, if you can only get enjoyment from being with other people, then that says something, not sure what it is but it’s something
i wouldn't mind playing it actually
then why are you against it
but i don't expect to be entertained by it for long
if you wouldn’t mind playing multiplayer
Like I said
wouln't say i'm against it i'd say i prefer it not being in the base game
the only argument is that it will get boring afterwards, but like your argument, that happens for any game
people will tend to get bored by anything after they played for enough time
there won’t be nothing new unless some big updates or addons/dlcs are done
it would just be a one-time thing you do randomly then a couple days later forget about it
meh
i doubt EVERYONE is gonna forget multiplayer is a thing
after playing it a single time
they find enjoyment in it, they’ll play more

it’s about taking a taste, then deciding whenever or not it’s good
it’s just as optional as the survival mode in carnivores
and what happens if that enjoyment fades?
it’ll come back eventually, it’s never gone entirely
it’d still be nice to have a new gamemode that isn’t just survival mode where you look around and shoot through dinosaur waves
and again, multiplayer can always have new mechanics
i'm betting for sure it's not coming lol
doesn’t need to be traversal or new trophy rooms
also people say 'multiplayer was teased' in what way?
saurian target
it has always been a concept mod for C2, done by Ornithomimid1
even then the test went with just them playing on different devices afaik
huh
yeah i heavily doubt any Multiplayer was even teased
but it was never official
the only thing to have been done ‘officially’ on multiplayer was the C2 multiplayer test done by Orni
Well I guess we Will only know for sure when It becomes a thing, calm down fellas, is not even a thing within MEE yet
right now the only limit is just suggesting or wishing for it
it’s weird how Legacy has a multiplayer folder
i'm calm bro
just don't see it being an official thing done by devs
again, modders will always just do it ig
i still don’t see the difference between having it base game or modded
base game would just be easier to handle with modding as it’s in the game code and doesn’t need to be rewritten entirely
Here Bro, I made some cheese sandwiches, have one
if a remake doesn't have any kind of multiplayer modders wont do it it doesn't work like that
or have it done from scratch
unless hey have the source code which for sure they won't
Ornithomimid1 did a multiplayer mod test for C2, a 90s game
and there’s 0 codes for it
nothing
done from scratch
coding isn’t just about altering an existing code, it’s about expanding it too
tell me you have zero knowledge about game development without telling me
yeah sureelly the original Carnivores 2 planned for multiplayer, and just kept a multiplayer code within the game code
you're a bit too wild with your imagination buddy lole
despite the game itself solely being singleplayer, and nothing proving there was multiplayer plans for it
I’m not sure why you want multiplayer so badly
especially since canrivores is in such a neesh genre
Niche
whatever bro
i just want to have fun with my friends, that’s abt it.
I enjoy hunting alone since it gives more of a challenge but eh, i do want to have fun with friends at some point too
sure, it kind of just
You’re fine don’t worry about it
becomes too easy later on
because you’re hunting in a group of people, and the challenge kind of fades
well can say the same abt every singleplayer game
''man pepsi man is so boring but multiplayer will sure be a game change ill have so much more fun''
😑
cause multiplayer is always that special ingredient that will completely change the expecrience
different game genres grow different interests and gameplay
not “every singleplayer game” requires literal multiplayer
genre doesn't have anything to do with what you said
you literally keep mentioning every game, meaning you’re mentioning every single type of game genre
atp i could just mention tetris or pac man
yea exactly
not every single game on singleplayer forces multiplayer
literally it depends on how the gameplay is done and the genre on it’s own.
One can be more fun and balanced with singleplayer
another one the opposite with multiplayer
it’s about having options, not forcing it
Horror games for example are more enjoyable alone as they give the proper horror atmosphere better and you can follow through the gameplay without big distractions
then there’s Sandbox games that are basically just made to do whatever you desire, and there the atmosphere of the game is entirely dependant on you, which is where multiplayer also comes in clutch as it gets more fun
it all depends on the genre and base gameplay
but in horror games i can have lots of fun with my friends
so what's your point
maybe not every horror game will have a fun multiplayer
like Resident Evil or Silent Hill
yeah bro ur argument has no kind of purpose any more
your only argument was literally mentioning “every game” when the genre was solely hunting
and literally missed the point on the potential for new additions/mechanics for multiplayer
your points were weaker, i don’t see why they had any more purpose
eitherway i leave my thought: Multiplayer should be a thing, basegame or modded, whatever.
By the way, can MEE allow multiplayer?
🤷♂️
depends if Orni1 is gonna work on it more
the base ‘res’ is somewhat there
Hmm alright
but as of now Orni’s focusing on the more base gameplay than multiplayer
so we are probably never getting much progress until base MEE is more fleshed out
i’m more excited for new AIs anyway
the semi-aquatic and the aggressive fliers
Do we know roughly what it's valued at?
it’s not really the issue of the value
it’s how the creators can be reached
from what i’ve heard, it’s quite tough
exactly
what makes you think this wouldn't happen to carnivores multiplayer
TheHunter Primal got abandoned by the developers by alot of reasons, one of them is that It was a experimental spin off from the Hunter series, never was intended to have a long-term life span, It was created using the Hunter classic engine which by the devs perspective was Very limited, and It also didnt have any kind of mod support so There was no way the community could expand on It, also didnt have a stabilish big community unlike its older and New brothers, comparing to carnivores I guess you could say It has some similarities but Also are Very different scenarios, carnivores has a big active community and can expand on the engine via modding.
Initial release of the multiplayer feature could be quite bare bones and buggy, which I could see some people being turn off, but as time passes It could be improved on it and become a more polish experience
i dont think carnivores community is as big are you say it is
it's not small either but i don't think it's big enough to sustain a healthy multiplayer playerbase
not even close
trust me it's not worth it
just be happy with c2 multiplayer if it comes out someday which is never
Wait a Second Bro im having dinner
Its bigger than theHunter Primal thats for sure, which died because of the devs
Also carnivores is as big as a hunting game from the late 90s can be, which is enough to have 7 to at least 3 players in the same server, not including custom made servers, initially.
Hunting games would never be as big as fps and other genres, Trust. Me. Bro, the community Will keep It Alive in long term plus It has the Tool to modify every single thing to the better, you played the single player, you know what to expect from the multiplayer, Just its existence alone proves that we can do alot more than we expected, MEE Already proved this, and by achieving multiplayer Just add more to the Already know fact
Death will only comes when the saga dies, which we all agree, its not on the near future
the only reason people are still talking about it to this day is because of the modding scene, otherwise we wouldn't be here
so yeah, it's bigger than what YOU think it is
Mhm
not to mention a new release of any kind can bring in even more numbers
Not to mention carnivores is the most voted game to be remastered rn
So saying that the community is "not as big as you think it is" is a huge underestatement
Especially if it drops on steam
Its gonna gain attention rather quickly considering Carnivores was also known for it's mobile ports which were pretty popular back then
soo
I think the mobile ports did a lot of heavy lifting getting peopple interestedin the IP
But it's the modders that kept people around
Yeah
Modding saved Carnivores from becoming pure lost media
Anyways, it's obvious the guy has little to no knowledge on the community of carnivores
saying that the game is barely recognised and how the community is tiny js proves it
10 more votes for 600
yeah true
not a carnivores fan
he’d never get it
Implying multiplayer would be anything more then private hosting with like 1-3 other people
The MEE version of the game plans to eventually have multiplayer, which as far as we know would only be through private hosting and not some dedicated server/s or anything like that
Dedicated servers would be quite a pain to handle
A bunch of players in a single map and a few huntables is too much
It is supposed to be a hunting session nyway, not a whole ass school trip or whatever
The ideal would be to turn Carnivores into a Monster Hunter-like experience, with healthbars, non-playable characters, and other stuff I might forgot.
Yesterday I installed the carnivores 2 mod legacy, and it seems purty good. Does anyone have protips on making some points fast 
Stegosaurus
Or charge head first into a mouth of a hungry carnivore
I was thinking the bigger a dino is, the faster it is to spot 😛
And having no tools, but pick the tranq thang
Not the case
But I do miss the radar
Not the case.....
Tell me your wisdom, Majunga
Large dino are somehow harder to spot than smaller dino
But... theyre bigger on the horizon
🦒
Imagine if it got a remaster, and the level of detail and the draw distance wasnt awful 
You may say not the case again
I just farmed stegosaurus for a bit, unlocked the shotgun and farmed velociraptor packs with it
debugup
this is not An alt of someone
why do you keep thinking im a alt of some guy
Who are you to btw
are you the reason why i got banned in saga
im not you
who said it was your alt?
im different person
idk
ok ill agree with.. whatever or who are you i know about you a little from moddb
there are no mentions of that in here
but how would you have known if according to fan2025 here, they do not know you
in saga i said that i felt bad for godzila3012
me and goji guy have been talking about our saga bans and identity crisis

ye
there was no mention of you when i join
Untill G.M.R
@graceful ermine
he mentiond @rain hatch '
and i knew him from moddb
but not that much
because im a guest in there
yes
what is this south park gif's context
You may take one guess
We should really stop bring drama into a chat that doesn't need it
you know who else asked for context of gifs and pinged people
dude
no matter how hard you try hiding your emails you still behave the same
guess who else replied with "dude"
exclusive to people
things are not exclusive with one person
asscosciate something as a example
like anything
i'm not gonna continue this convo but the moderators should take care of you imo
things are not exlcusive to people
Funny
Whats the ages of everyone in here 
18
19
13
29
ok fine
zerer
and you
will accept me and you as one person
fine
ill accept that now
even tho we are not the same
16
She's 16 and she regret it
Man, if only gamers got senior discounts on steam
They especially make no sense, when im lookjing in here, and theres like 3 layers of drama going on by people with names like "Glob4006060x"
Fuck this shit im out of here
can you not
I am now Cactus as I use her reaction face irl
No
Don't ruin shite
Let's just play Fortnite
Shite drama
Was about to ask if this is 8pm pacific time
Can we ban everyone in here
Give carnivores remasters and then ban
Let's just play Fortnite boys
We don't need stupid dumb drama in a chat that doesn't need drama at all
Whats this about foreskin
Drama smells like a rotting lobster
Is that a server for only cis fortnite players
Am I close doe
What a time to be alive (you lost me)
Nobody care
Can we get this guy banned please
i think you've done more than enough exploding
i've been banned from the saga at some point too
get over it
because i made the effort to not be an ass
I don't even use pivot
What'd u fucking talking about
I don't even use sticknode
Not even that
Why do you want to know?
Draw cartoons 2
Nuh
Shotgun and Triceratops
Thats how I grinded at least
Need to watch the wind though
Carnivores was gonna get a steam port then Tatem failed us
peeps still want that steam port
Carnivores and the potential modding potential to come with the remastered visuals and bug fixes would give the community a lifelong tier dream
use the tranq darts to start off with and hunt stegos first and formost. Pachys are good too, but quite skittish. If you see something big running around the island, shoot it. It may be a secret huntable
you're younger than me? Holy shit I always thought you were like...25 or smth
aye, good luck! Legacy is really a great mod, you just need to get through the early game grind. Once you unlock Basmashee Rocks it's gonna be awesome
Well while im here, the legacy mod came with an "extras" folder, and im not sure where those files would go. Like the one music file. I didnt see a readme for the thing 
oh, that's bonus content!
I played carnivores 2 with the turok 1 and 2 soundtracks going in the background 
The music is a little track for you to listen to (it's used in the survival mode)
there are also some alt skins for you to put on the dinos, like some variants of the new dinos and higher quality replacement skins for some of the original animals
what you gotta do is rename the alt skin to the same name as the original, then replace them in the hunt dat folder
I see I see. Theres probably pics of them somewhere to compare which skins are coolest
What is the steam grid?
Alright, my patience is really running low with you here. After the rex skin drama I was the one who advocated for giving you a second chance, but man, you now being just as annoying here as you were on the Saga makes me regret my decision. Please just fly low, I doubt the moderators here are as willing to let things slide as those on the Saga
I fucking can't with you anymore. I know you are still a child, but you gotta have some boundaries.
here's an example of one of the OG replcements: the para
Dang, theyre all gorgeous 
The only differences between carnotaurus skins are the snout scales
Not sure if I should share the extra dinos' alts cause that would spoil em
Damn
You could perhaps use a spoiler tag on the pic 
Sorry I missed wake from the ping
I deleted the last six hours of Godzilla's messages, so that'll be fun to figure out what happened in retrospect
Time to sift through and see who else is getting banned
Two bans.
One spammer and one alt account that was created yesterday and joined here yesterday. Maybe same person, maybe someone else, either way trying to bypass something and being a nuisance
So the other ones are just unfinished versions?
Alternative versions moreso
Idk they just look less detailed
20
21
Did you make these?
No
finally the gremlins got banned
Either way this would look awesome in a ND remaster
Just with slightly better models
Golden Frog Studios made the allosaurus, parasaurolophus & dimorphodon skins, Daubeny made the pachycephalosaur skin and Inspector did stegosaurus and t.rex. I forgot who made velociraptor
the legacy alt skins are good for a base remaster
imo
especially the tyrannosaurus and stegosaurus
and the velociraptor
GoldenFrog should work with ND/hj

Also that allo reskin is still horrifying
Because it's not possible to make the Carnivores allo not scary
watch me

Do it
i’m gonna get that allo over the kawai level of unscary
I dare you Bugs Life mantis

I warned the mods during a vc session we had so yea
Not to surprised
Also what the fuck happened here
Anything from the saga should stay in the saga don’t let it be in another server that literally has no relation to the carnivores community
yeah but some people…. (godzilla) can’t understand simple common sense
I did the velociraptor
so saga stuff gets dragged in here
even tho this forum being obviously done to discuss the possible GAME REMASTER
Twenty one
Mhm
You’re always going to get these types for any Dino themed project tbh
Young kids or anti socials who don’t read the room
Same
subnautica mod reference
47
So apparently this is what Tatem is working on now
Yeah they do niche mobile games now
That's why ND should buy the license 
I swear either they’re not using a good part of their staff or a good part of their staff left
Tatem is a very very small team
Even smaller after the layoffs og like 2017?
They do what they must to keep the lights on
And I'm sure the Ukraine war didn't help in any way to make it easier on them
So you’re saying they’re on their last legs
From what I understand they seem to be doing what they can to survive
Also fun fact tatem has two separate accounts on the app store
One account has the 4 versions of dh and ic
While the other one has the rest of there mobile game library
Why
Don't ask me idk
So in this case, perhaps a nightdive remaster could also benefit them in some way?
Probably, could either give them enough money for selling the IP or get them back off the ground with shared sales with Nightdive
I don’t really want to share my work here but a lil concept sketch of a canon style quetzalcoatlus
Who was banned, and what i missed?
Two kids that were spamming
Names?
Godzilla and some other guy
They where banned how many times
So is a win-win situation
Yup
One kid that did a crashout
Crashout?
that's modern slang for a breakdown
they were two people who were previously banned from the Carnivores Saga discord for also being an overall annoyance with other members
need to put an * on that "two"
Huh
I thinked it was me back in 2022
Why *?
the other involved was very much likely an alt of the one who was crashing out
trying to pretend they weren't associating even though the whole reason that other got banned what because out of nowhere they mentioned and defend the banned user
then had the audacity to simultaneously say they don't know who they were yet was always in contact with them
the second person was a profile created the day they joined and one day before being banned. definitely an alt for someone, don't care whom, broke rules.
I also deleted 5 votes, 4 from confirmable alts, one from godzilla
Must pet the alien lizard bird who walks like a booby bird
so what now, will the game be considered to be remastered?
suppose so
What's happened now is that the fans of this game have displayed that there is a demand for this game.
I highlighted it to staff, but it'll be quite some time to find out anything from staff, given there are numerous existing projects
They also have to contact people and make a lot of deals. If the owners say NOPE, they just look at the next popular game on the list
Still hoping and praying for a Carnivores trilogy ND remaster
Then I guess we just wait for them to go bankrupt and then try again
Again, please do not vote on games if your account was created the same day you joined this server, as it is indistinguishable from an alt account.
Im going to audit every dinosaur game given I've had to delete 5 votes from accounts that fit this criteria
@thorny reef I sent u a DM
I guess being a lurker on Discord really pays off!
'fortell games'
ZAMN
I've seen a screenshot of Godzilla cashing out over JFK. He did an alt account ?
No drama update requests please.
I apologize
Ngl, i really wonder if animations will be polished in the possible remaster
i like the animations but sometimes they can look somewhat stiff if looking close enough
maybe giving them more fluid movement similar to some modded huntables would be nice
Could just port over Legacy since it is C1 remastered
the vanilla dinosaurs don't really have any refurbished og animations, just new ones for the new behaviors
they're effectively still the same ol' assets just with new addons
realistically they would/should refurbish/mimic the og animations.
mind as well allow all the ogs to have blink animations since only a handful of the new additions in c2 were given that originally
they could likely edit the eyes probably
give them an entire new part with proper eyelids
idk
i mean they're gonna have do anyways if they're making new models
they did that with the Thing remaster
where they js revamped the entire face for the humans
with actual eyes
really depends; people say the limit is like upscaling the textures
but if they overhauled the models in other remasters
i doubt Carnivores is being ignored
It is kind of the same objective as Carnivores : Legacy, if I understand it well ?
debatable. for full new content sure we go all out, but there's still some conflict on doing anything related to spicing up the vanilla content (despite doing 2/3s of that already)
it would be a good objective since realistically we would have to redo all the animations for any new models. (mainly because we don't have the original rawest animation files)
Made this for the 2 other people who like both Ultrakill and Carnivores
Still mad they changed the Rex's roar in Legacy
Hello everyone just wanna make a reminder to y'all to go vote for Carnivores Cityscape Remaster the fourth spin off game of the carnivores franchise
https://discord.com/channels/190583485826727936/1202725292435841084
Ye ye
Ion want a cityscape remaster so nah
But I still voted anyway
Cityscape needs a remake, not a remaster...
better graphics will not save cityscape
any fixes cityscape essentially needs is just remaking the whole thing
A cityscape remake is so slim to none that its not even worth dreaming of it honestly until this god-forsaken franchise can actually get some success under its belt again I can see something new being made
ctiyscape being remastered will not be that success i can assure you
Damn
Man i was really bumed out that Tatem's "pre Cityscape zoo game" got canned
Cityscape if it was made by Hideo Kojima
actually vivisector
What?
First time hearing about that
It's like polishing a piece of dog turd to make it prettier
Yea sure bro it looks nicer but it's still dogshit
Hey
What do you mean
Cityscape zoo game ?
So Tatem at one point was going to make a game where you would capture dinosaurs and put them in a zoo. I’ve theorized that, if the game went well, it would’ve lead into Tatem’s version of Cityscape
We aint getting the 600s 😔
You probably are, it'll probably be before April
idon't see how that concept has anything to do with cityscape
so i don't see how you thought of that theory
because the whole reason cityscape happened is because the dinosaurs that were on the ship that crashed were meant to go into a zoo
i see
but tatem of all people
unlikely
If memory serves right
Tatem called cityscape a failure
And redesigned ovi and Coelo and erased it from the timeline
I guess this new entry would of been there version of cityscape where instead of a tragedy it would of been a success story
Nobody is saying cityscape would be an overall success but out of the two options a remaster is far more likely then any remake
I still find Cityscape to be fun for what it is and a polished-up version with a maybe better dino campaign and extra levels would be great
And before you say that sounds more like a remake wish doom 1+2 had extra levels and what not just because so its not entirely far fetched to think Cityscape can't get that treatment
but see here's the thing. especially given the mindset of most of remasters. is that it's usually for games that have been able to have at least a solid form of success. cityscape by every metric is a failure and there really is no reason to even consider remastering it because it would remain a failure, which is very apparent considering no one in the community really wants to touch it unless their morbid curiosity overcomes them.
doom 1+2 can get away with it because doom was already solid and has been for decades. but cityscape fumbles throughout and the only way of saving it is by completely redoing it.
and if we're putting opinions in, i have played cityscape and while i think it had something of potential, but it is objectively bad in so many ways that i can't even consider myself playing it again unless it has undergone a complete remake.
nightdive is not gonna take the dive for a very lackluster and heavily flawed entry of the series
even if one argues that within the original trilogy, ice age could be considered a failure too, let it be known that it is still something that has solid ground within the community considering its heavy usage in the most prominent mods of old and even new, along with still accepted as a proper entry
I dunno, that description sounds like Trespasser and I feel like Trespasser has a decent chance
trespasser to some degree has a solid foundation, it's only issue was being quirky with its physics gimmick which is a big charm to it.
cityscape on the otherhand is plagued with bad weapon damage + needlessly spongey enemies, implied systems that don't even work or aren't even utilized at all (like stealth), weird level loading (2-3 levels using an entire loaded map but for some reason are completely different missions in a row requiring whole new loads despite using only a fraction of the active map), and generally how blatantly rushed the whole thing feels.
like boy let me tell you about coelophysis, those tiny feckers have way too much health for being swarm type enemies
Then there is the cityscape pistol
ohoho yea talk about something so useless that its just considered data bloat
Aka the only low tier enemy in the game
so that like +48 shots for on average 4> in a group
headshot damage doesn't exist if that wasn't apparent by the "12 shots"
True true 😔
it should also be more telling that the community tries to recreate cityscape outside of the actual game
no one has ever offered the immediate idea of "let's mod cityscape to make it better" and instead go for "let's make cityscape but in carnivores or in goldsource/source"
While this is not the most appropriate channel to say this but aside from the goldsrc/source remake of cityscape, the other cityscape remake I want to see is in the style of Republic Commando
A 4 player or so co-op game
Each player/bot play as a different or same class of agent
Replacing terrifying battle droid with dinosaur
I Heard that nobody has tried to mod cityscape because the engine is a pain in the ass for modding
the most i know about its engine is that it's the serious sam engine
So I suppose is not worth it modding since is more easy making a entire New game instead
basically
HMMM... I wonder if we'll get to 600 votes on this one lol
Look who's talking 😹😹
I agree majority of cityscape was a failure but absolutely not every metric
It excelled In some parts
Nah actually I shouldn't use the word excell
But some aspects were good
best to take those aspects and refine them in a new entry if there is ever one
Keep dreaming bro never gonna happen
Only way Cityscape remake is feasible is one made by fans
Nothing official is gonna come out of new cityscape content
okay and?
difference is the original system shock game wasn't dogshit
unlike cityscape
and in that example it's a remake and not a remaster
also the community would feel like they've been shafted if cityscape got a remake but not the original trilogy's flagship gameplay which is hunting
trust me it's never gonna happen whether it's a remake or remaster
it would be nice sure
but odds are impossible
even games 10x more popular than carnivores don't get remakes and y'all are discussing the possibility of the forgotten obscure mediocre spinoff game that flopped getting a remake lol
blame the ones coping for cityscape
omm pure carnivores fan cope
i think system shock is the only 90s game remake we ever got other than doom and uhhh
what else
it also wasn't obscure and was innovative/well-known
cityscape remaster/remake is smt that is really more like a waste of time
i mean idk what else you can do there except changing the entire thing
Last time I played I had a decent time with it
meme potential ^^^^
There's gotta be some merit to it
i mean it did get plenty of memes in the community anyway
something about the game is so unique it would be so amplified with a remake
but that's not happening
sounds like one right lol
that’s like the ONLY good thing abt cityscape, the fact it’s so bad it can be huge meme potential
also the cityscape ‘hunter’ design was also a good thing to come out of it
but that’s it
if you continue to play the game and play it for a while it grows on you
at first it seems so trash but there's something about the game you can't quite find in any other
aesthetic-wise
atmosphere-wise
same thing like watching movies/shows that everyone hates but you seem to find a specific charm to it that attracts you ig
exactly
but it was objectively trash
many games in post 90s were bad
than cityscape
other than half-life 2
not really
smth feels so off about them
Its simply just old game clunk
i guess the switch to a new century of gaming was damaging at first
half life 2 is 2004
90s will forever be golden age
that's post-90s
oh heck i read wrong
the engine cityscape uses
that game became one of the biggest ones rn
and it all started from the 2005 release
which was like 97 or 98
i’d say, as long as the games have proper effort them and do act like they’re making a franchise, they can be well
newgen headass game
which is pretty much the thing for HL
God of war only became popular thanks to like
gow 2018
😔
it’s a shame most fans are newgens
missed out on GOW1 and GOW2
even then it’s a good example of an early 2000s / post 90s game doing well
HL too of course
got 2 games with different spinoffs + a whole vr one
also y'all know atari owns the rights to cityscape
and grew a rather huge community that conflicts with tf2 or gmod
wait what
yeah they aqcuired sunstorm back in the day
dang
and they aqcuired nightdive studios in 2023
does that mean they can technically make a cityscape remake whenever they want or smt
without going through much issues like other IPs
well odds are slightly more but i still don't see it happening
yeah
but that's jus something crazy i jsut found out
gonna need citation on that because nowhere about sunstorm states this
unless you're talking about infogrames
in which case they're a publisher, not a developer
ohhhhhhh my bad
i'm trippin
yeah they aqcuired infogrames not sunstorm
eitherway, cityscape remake is like the least preferred thing from the community
are they still around?
false
quite the opposite actually
cause the original game is so badly executed
i mean Ice age is ig lower than both Carnivores and cityscape remake preferences
cause theres legit 0 CIA voting
even then it’s simply C2 with cenozoic roster and snowy maps
really it can just be remade when the carnivores remake/remaster is out easily
the only way a cityscape remake is accepted is if the original trilogy gets a remake since hunting is the core of the franchise's identity (which cityscape ditched entirely)
forget it bro it ain't happening
we'd be lucky if we get a remake of original carnivores
which is why this forum is and has been all about a remaster of the trilogy, a bare minimum the community has been wanting for a very long time now
nah i see a remaster happening one million percent
Remaster
We don't need a remake/reboot
We already had 3
A remaster would be better
technically 1
yeah i don't want a remake of original carnivores tbh
remaster is more fitting
Dinosaur hunt is getting mod support from the fans anyway, so wont be long until we could recreate OG carnivores games in it
I believe
screw dinosaur hunt
that was years ago
it can go piss off
who actually wants that shit
recreating og carnivores in dinosaur hunt
Dont ssay that bro
dogwater
Well, ok thats fair enough
That's true
I can't argue much for Hunt its just bad probably worse then reborn and hd
i swear to god it just kept getting worse and worse
The community is going to eventually mod dinosaur hunt
first we had the mobile ports which weren't bad
then we got reborn and hd which were kinda good but had tons of bugs unfinished mess and complete abandonment of og aesthetic
Which could allow the community to improve on It I believe
saying this while saying the original trilogy getting a remaster is fine and not a remake before an inferior entry gets a remake
Or doing something new with it
it's very difficult that's the problem
I'm not saying I dislike c2
Modding
Its fun
it would be very fun if it wasn't a lobotomy-inducing process with trashy animation and rigging software
I just prefer hunt because its something new and I'm the only guy tinkering with it so far
Along side a few others
that's what i'm saying
especially when your modding dhunt
because its something new
well then imagine if the originals got the remake, that'd be something new and certainly more than what hd/reborn/dh did
I honestly would be disappointed if I couldn't experience the original trilogy as close to its original form
old is gold
I honestly don't want to see a remake until these games are released
tatem is absolutely useless
rubbish
disgraceful
disgusting
simply not acceptable
we have been battered
And cityscape either gets a remake or remaster its one or the other to me its an important entry for modders as so many stories are set around or after the events of cityscape
If thats true, If its going to take years Before nightdive annouce something carnivores related
Until then...well, I dunno
years idk about years
i personally see them doing something with carnivores after doing turok: evolution
Yes its different it's a spin-off but it deserves to be released and given a second chance
i don't think carnivores is a particularly complicated game to remaster especially compared to their other titles
Hmmmm, I dont know about that
with full on campaigns and shit
Every game even c1 with the amount of c1 type mods have gotten chances to be exposed to everyone
so i don't see them taking more than 2 years to get back on track
main barrier is their other projects
Bundle once Said that nightdive at the moment is quite busy about business and stuff
they require to finish them first
and i think nightdives got alot on their plate atm
so it'll take them a while
it's gonna depend on how long it takes them to get those sorted
4 to 5, Thats My guess
🥸
Hunt is no different from HD and reborn
Aka it's not as good as the classics
what?
iit's literally just the same game ported to another engine
with a bunch of dogshit unity store models sprinkled in
absolute nonsense
Yea I'm not gonna deny that
Hd and reborn are far superior in many aspects except for path finding
I literally meant the classic Carnivores
now that i agree with
But hunt being moddable is enough for me
it's still catshit
game itself is bad

