#fab

1 messages Β· Page 97 of 1

merry field
#

It has not happened yet to my knowledge

#

It should be in approximately two weeks

midnight gazelle
#

ah ok. I've been out of the loop for a while i thought i missed it.

merry field
#

That node graph seems cool, but I think it would just annoy me too much by arranging the nodes in a different way than I would arrange them

delicate dove
#

i thought the same, but its often a good base to start with after the innitial node setup/testing

#

and it saves time, so im happy, client happy

merry field
#

Though, looking at a random blueprint, my organised blueprints don't exactly look that tidy either

#

One thing that bugs me about Blueprints is that somehow, some nodes have their first pins at different heights

#

So if you have one type of node hooked into another, you can't get the lines straight

delicate dove
#

there is a keyboard shortcut for that, i think. I remember @heady moth showing it to me once

merry field
#

Ah-ha

#

Wow that's awesome

#

Really off-topic for Marketplace I guess, but the description of how to do it is here: https://allarsblog.com/2015/11/11/align-nodes-like-a-pro/

midnight gazelle
#

WHOA! am i in heaven? the marketplace has changed and it has more new free stuff!

midnight gazelle
#

Is the free for the month permanently stay in my library or will it go away after a month?

#

I hope it stays there.XD

nocturne scaffold
#

wait therr is a keyboard shortcut to alligh execution pins on the node?!

sullen lion
#

probably

ebon leaf
#

Iby - Once you added the monthly free content in ur library...it will be forever in your library

quaint cedar
#

Of course you keep them afterwards...

#

Pretty sure Epic has that on the blog post that covers the topic.

hollow zephyr
midnight gazelle
#

@ebon leaf Oh good. I thought there would be some sort of a catch or something.πŸ˜†

wooden falcon
#

as long as you "buy" (at $0) the free for a month, it's yours to download forever

#

the other 15 or so packs that are part of the "permanent collection" are free forever...you could pick them up now, or in a year if you want, they'll still be free

merry field
#

@hollow zephyr seems like a nice enough model, so why not?

hollow zephyr
#

@merry field I'm not sure if there's enough demand πŸ˜…

lucid osprey
#

you dont loose tho

#

you either put it up for sale

#

or not

#

what can you loose πŸ˜„

merry field
#

The only thing you lose is the time it spends to package it

hollow zephyr
#

I have to clean it up, study the docs

#

yeah

merry field
#

Which took me a few days to work out

#

I was actually thinking of writing a quick guide to submitting Marketplace content

delicate dove
#

mpTeam: please do

lucid osprey
#

oh god XD

#

i imagine cedrics compedium now

merry field
#

That is apparently a 112-slide document on Unreal networking

lucid osprey
#

pls dont do a 112 slide guide πŸ˜„

merry field
#

I thought I said a quick guide, not a "put a classroom to sleep" slideshow! πŸ˜€

lucid osprey
#

;D you said that

hollow zephyr
#

@merry field that would be really helpful. i'll release more stuff too. it's just intimidating when you read up those guidelines

merry field
#

Yeah, and they were so long that I missed some important stuff in the middle

median goblet
#

If i had money to burn and wanted to buy the best assets on the marketplace to make an fps game for singleplayer game like Half-Life 2 or something which asset pack(s) is the best?

merry field
#

If you had money to burn, you'd probably hire an artist to make your own, unique assets

median goblet
#

w o a h

#

where can i find said artists

lunar fractal
vale olive
#

holds up sign Will art for programming

median goblet
#

gotcha

merry field
#

Any reason why I wouldn't be able to include the full checklist that Epic send you about your submission? Not sure if that list is public or not

merry field
#

Okay, I'm done

#

I'll probably post it somewhere actually useful later, like on Reddit

#

Because no one is going to find it there

north stirrup
#

Nice!

#

Might be worth a pin @delicate dove ?

merry field
#

Proofreading welcome!

zealous ibex
#

Nice work @merry field πŸ‘

delicate dove
#

CC: @shadow inlet @idle arch ^ ^ ^

idle arch
#

BCC: Lous

delicate dove
#

*uo

#

BCCC: Wrong email ad, who dis?

idle arch
#

New phone, who dis

fervent token
#

So it’s NOT frowned upon to buy code from the market place?

hollow zephyr
#

@merry field very cool, going to follow it for the airplane 😁

nocturne scaffold
#

@fervent token beliwhy would it be frowned upon? Its there to help you get started. :) Like I said, 1/2 of my entire game core is from a template i purchased. However its been so modified I cant even contact him for support anymore. lol. But the purpose is to adapt it to your project. 90% of the time your never just going to straight up use assets without some kind of modification.

delicate dove
#

but it can give you a head start

red wagon
#

There's coding on the marketplace? It's time for me to invest in assets and stuff for my own dark souls like rog game I had in mind

modern perch
#

I've used a few things like specific algorithms in the past

#

most of the 'game templates' are pretty inflexible, so I'm not actually sure they save you much time

wooden falcon
#

you might not get exactly what you need, but you might get close....and you'd get something to learn from

vale olive
#

It's not frowned upon at all, but I will say I am 1000% more comfortable buying blueprints. Maybe that's just me though because I'm completely illiterate when it comes to code

nocturne scaffold
#

jRPG game template is rather flexible but very specific to target game.

flat pollen
#

why does my marketplace language keep getting changed to japanese... -_-

#

fixed when I delete this cookie... let's see if it happens again

lunar fractal
dark matrix
#

what happen to my message, did they got deleted

quaint cedar
#

If they got deleted, then probably because you posted something here that wasn't meant to be here.

red wagon
#

Hmm is there a marketplace template for inventory system, or RPG template like class system and target system or boss template for multiple phases?

merry field
#

There are several inventory system templates

#

There's even one currently free this month

red wagon
#

Oh really what is it?

#

I'm not home an I'm at work

#

Can you give me the name of kink so I have it and when I get home I can download it?

merry field
#

If you go to the Marketplace and filter by "Free", you'll see it

dark matrix
#

@quaint cedar I just asked for help, like how can i put my 2d artwork on marketplace, as they need to be UE4 ready , just this thing

lucid osprey
#

we have a guide pinned to this channel

#

i didnt red it yet

delicate dove
#

marketplace submission guidelines

lucid osprey
#

but it is supposed to be great

quaint cedar
#

@dark matrix I wasn't the one removing it and I can't see who did.
Maybe it wasn't clear that it was about the MP but sounded like a #looking-for-work post?

#

Probably just a mistake then.

delicate dove
#

7-8 scrolls up

red wagon
#

@merry field thanks

delicate dove
lucid osprey
#

Isnt there star citizen?

delicate dove
#

<_< it even mentions using specular instead of roughness. ggwp

merry field
#

They do look extremely boxy

wooden falcon
#

They should have a gameshow: "Is it a gun or is it a spaceship?"

lucid osprey
#

or a box

wooden falcon
#

is it a spaceship?

#

πŸ˜ƒ

lucid osprey
#

its clearly a space carrier...

#

you blind?

merry field
#

Water boats

next patrol
#

Does anyone know of any good marketplace assets for effects when opening loot boxes? My search has turned up empty. The sort of big, splashy rain of coins/other particles you can for instance see when opening a card pack in Hearthstone. I'm not making a game with microtransactions, but I would still want to add such an effect to add some juice when finding loot.

modern perch
#

I'd be surprised if there isn't such a thing, though couldn't name one as I'm not familiar with the content

next patrol
#

yeah, I feel that would be an obvious asset to make. There does not seem to be an asset specifically for this, at least. Perhaps it is hidden within one of the bigger packs

pliant forum
#

Checked under particles, within 10~ sec I saw "Loot FX Pack"

next patrol
#

yeah, I found that too. not what I'm looking for, though

#

it is more for loot on the ground of your game, with only minor effects when picked up

#

I'm looking for the sort of effect that has an explosive shower of particles all over the screen

#

thanks for searching, though

#

well, for the fx creators in this Discord this seems like a good niche to exploit. A loot box FX pack would likely be quite sought after.

#

good as time as any for me to properly learn Niagara, I guess

dark matrix
#

@quaint cedar no problem , it's ok , i was not looking for work , i was just asking about how to do that, if you got confused, or anyone else, but thanks guys, as you guys help us a lot in everything πŸ˜ƒ πŸ˜„

#

I really appreciate it πŸ˜„

thin barn
#

My asset pack with 6 melons 3D Scans got rejected by the marketplace team for not enough content, because it's less than 20 meshes. So I suggested adding 6 more scans to have 12 and that suggestion got rejected again for still not enough content. Apparently it should be at least 20 3D Scans to be considered. So I'm wondering is there a new marketplace rule that I missed?
I remember that packs had to have at least 5 unique meshes which I had to begin with. So will 20 be the new standard now? Or was that more like an opinion about my pack by whoever reviewed it?
Did anyone else encounter the 20+ unique meshes rule yet? ^^
That 7 space ships pack certainly didn't. πŸ˜„

wooden falcon
#

less than 20 meshes?

#

since when has that been a thing...used to be less than 5 meshes

thin barn
#

That's exactly what I thought when I read the email.
It just seems so random. πŸ™ƒ

delicate dove
#

@idle arch ^ please read that πŸ˜ƒ

forest prairie
merry field
#

Isn't that a cable component?

candid rivet
#

cable component is pretty limited. i wish i had this 4 months ago, i just finished a vr training app largely based around a hose

idle arch
#

So to give you an answer without giving you the response you want (because I don't have it)

#

That said - I recommend contacting support and having a conversation there about it.

primal epoch
#

@merry field it’s more fleshed out than the cable component.

I developed it for a game being worked on that relies heavily around both physicalized + cuttable and static ropes, problem with the cable is that you can’t make intricate spline patterns and the physics implementation is pretty limited

#

it’s closer to what say cryengine has in how you can easily design levels with power wires that can be shot down and interacted with

lucid osprey
#

ue4 has cable component inbuilt tho...

#

most people dont know about that

primal epoch
#

yeah that’s what I mean, the default one is super limited

#

we couldn’t use it for our setup

lucid osprey
#

yee but we still have it πŸ˜„

primal epoch
#

oh yes

#

it’s nice for some things

lucid osprey
#

i found it to have bugs

primal epoch
#

yeah

#

I wish it was more fleshed out

#

but we use ours now, just figured we could put it on the marketplace since it works pretty well

#

there are some things we miss from CE, so adding stuff when we get the chance

#

mostly smaller details across the engine, for iteration

#

I might do a pass on the actual creation of spline points later as well, it feels a bit slow in UE - I remember in CE you could just drag the spline (or spline rope) in and just start clicking to paint it out

#

is a bit more finicky here

merry field
#

You can shift-drag the last point of the spline

#

To clone it and make the spline longer

primal epoch
#

yeah, it's more about the first moment when you add a spline to something - this feels a bit clearer in CE to me, in that you see the spline point previewing and you just click to place - and double click to end

#

but with the shortcuts it's alright

modern perch
#

that physics cable component looks pretty neat

delicate dove
#

"3.2.d Publishers must not publicly disclose their Marketplace revenue information." didnt Tim Sweeny revoke that one?

#

on that note, @idle arch what is up with people discounting their pack the moment its on the marketplace? I thought there was a rule against that?

wooden falcon
#

if I squint my eyes, each of the tumbnails looks like a duplicate

void prawn
#

Damn thats.. alot of packs

vapid tundra
#

they're also extremely similar.

#

imho those packs look like an 5-10 min job in SD

#

but thats just my 2 cents

hollow zephyr
#

can i include a cc0 hdri image in the project I want to sell? It's only used in the showcase map

thin barn
#

Damn it's frustrating to spend 40+hours on a models pack only to have it rejected for not enough content.
Meanwhile a couple textures even I could create in SD in 4h get accepted seemingly without question.
Ah well I'll just add 6 more models to my pack and submit it again.
Who knows, maybe I will get a nicer reviewer next time who doesn't have some new 20+ unique meshes rule in mind. πŸ˜„

hollow zephyr
#

@thin barn what are you creating? πŸ€”

thin barn
lucid osprey
#

well

#

you creeated 5 objects

#

and tbh they dont look really great :c

#

they seem to be missing proper shading

#

and the light in that scene isnt helping

#

you should scan a whoile fruit palette

#

with like 25 objects

#

then epic can sell fruit pack

#

melon pack is very odd

ocean summit
#

melonn

#

who would buy only a melon pack?

lucid osprey
#

prolly people

#

but not a whole lot

ocean summit
#

yeah

thin barn
#

The reason I picked melons is because there is no pack available for that yet. It's 6 objects in this pack. Will be 12 with the updated submission.
The more common fruits packs are already available on the marketplace. I generally focus on niche stuff that noone else scanned yet.
They all have proper albedo, normal, roughness and Metalness (black obviously) textures.
So why do you think the shading isn't right?
Is there an example scene with a good lighting setup for marketplace product presentation?
I think my lighting is fairly standard tbh... but who knows, always room for improvement. ^^

wooden falcon
#

I'd work on the roughness map a bit

#

on the melons

#

most things are "shiny" to some degree, with variations across the surface to make them more interesting

#

I suffer from the same problem when scanning, of course, since all you get out of the scan is a diffuse/normal/ao, and not a roughness...Substance Painter is good for adding in roughness detail

thin barn
#

Yeah I really wish there was some sort of guidance for correct roughness values.
What do you use to get the correct values?
I think the fruit pulp roughness values are already pretty good, or at least it looks good to me.
Also there is a good amount of details in the roughness there, but not sure if that can be seen in the video, as it's pretty fine details.
However the fruit skin could definitely be less rough and more "shiny". I double checked with my images and it makes sense to make that part more shiny.
I already did that for the Canary melon a few days ago. But I'll also do it for the other melon, now that you mentioned it. ^^

wooden falcon
#

the full skull with jaw needs better roughness detailing (my bad)

#

the partial skull, I went in to SP and added some detailing to make it more interesting

lucid osprey
#

almost dark messiah quality

#

can you pick these skulls up and throw them at enemies?

wooden falcon
#

i was messing with making a skull gun at one point πŸ˜‰

#

and you can turn physics on and kick them around...not that fond of UE4 physics though, doesn't seem very realistic

#

but it's fun to spawn a whole bunch in editor up in the air, then run simulation to let them fall where they may, then bake the positions

#

a little mottling in the roughness can really improve interest

#

the melons would be fun to program as destructable

#

throw then against a wall and spawn some chunks and particles

lucid osprey
#

in a half life 2 fashion ofc.

#

they have to look and break better as the game that came out 2005 XD

thin barn
#

Yeah there is already a pretty good scanned watermelon on the marketplace I think. That's why I went with other types of melons.
I'm not aware of other melons that are red, but there are tons of different types, so I'm sure there are some. ^^

Hah funny that you mentioned that. I'm making a game for a client atm with melons getting sliced into pieces by sawblades! πŸ˜„

wooden falcon
lucid osprey
#

You actually googled it

wooden falcon
#

yes

#

πŸ˜‰

hollow zephyr
#

I remember Dark messiah looked amazing at that time, but now, not so much haha

lucid osprey
#

you are not fucking around eh

wooden falcon
#

because I know you're quite sarcastic on occasion

lucid osprey
#

i do feel abit extreme offended that you dont trust me blindly 😐

wooden falcon
#

I was like "wait a sec...that wasn't a compliment"

lucid osprey
#

i was trying my best 😐

delicate dove
#

@thin barn
"They all have proper albedo, normal, roughness and Metalness (black obviously) textures."

then dont add those, no metal input <> black texture

wooden falcon
#

once you get the roughness improved, it should look a lot better...I mean, compared to that pack Luos linked the other day, I don't see why this wouldn't get approved

#

the weird dayglow materials pack

thin barn
#

yeah don't worry Luos. I have no actual metal texture. just a variable set to 0 in the material. πŸ˜‰

#

The roughness is a texture ofc, as there are variations in it.

wooden falcon
#

would be interesting to see the shader complexity view

#

sometimes roughness can be too subtle though

#

what looks like details when you look at it in photoshop can just look completely matte ingame

#

maybe hook a parameter with a multiply to the roughness to play around with it

delicate dove
#

also, in some cases (fruit is a good example) playing a bit with the specular along with roughness can give a nice smoothness to it

thin barn
#

Yeah I think what you mentioned might actually be my problem with the fruit skin. It just looks completely dull in the editor unlike the detailed texture in PS.
I'm mostly happy with the fruit pulp and the details in the roughness there. The only issue I see is that it looks a bit like plastic.
But that seems to be the case for almost all ingame screenshots of fruit, also for other marketplace assets, or it's even much worse there sometimes. hah

#

I like how you can see that I suck at cutting melons into pieces though. By the fine details on the left side where the knive got stuck in the melon and I had to try to cut it again. πŸ˜…

nocturne scaffold
#

hold up. wait these are real objects that get turned into 3D by scanning them?!

candid rivet
#

yes, it is called photogrammetry. you can do it yourself if you have a camera, feed photos into a program like meshroom (that's the only free one i know)

#

I'll never understand the millions of material packs in the marketplace that don't have a single in world screenshot in context of the material....like if you want to sell me a wall material, put it in the world...y'know...on a wall...let me see what it looks like...i'll never buy a single material pack on the mp because of it

delicate dove
#

lol

blazing harbor
#

@candid rivet yep. i also dont buy anything with "vol x" in it either.. 26 volumes of materials later... what am I missing vs what I have etc. πŸ™„

candid rivet
#

ya, i feel like material pack peeps don't actually gamedev or something

hollow zephyr
#

what kind of assets do you want to see in the marketplace? I have some time to work on something πŸ€”

lucid osprey
#

is the plane on there yet?

hollow zephyr
lucid osprey
#

πŸ›©

merry field
#

I'd be tempted to make some more blueprint/utility type stuff, if I had any good ideas

lucid osprey
#

why not do the light

#

thats just bad if you dont do it XD i clearly didnt started on it

merry field
#

That thing we were talking about, with different lighting effects, flickers and so on?

lucid osprey
#

yee

#

you can do quite alot with that :3

#

could go 10

merry field
#

I think I'd make a set of really customisable ones where you can adjust all the settings

#

Strobe, flicker, different settings for timing

#

Could be useful for my own game as well

lucid osprey
#

its all in your hands to make it good.

merry field
hollow zephyr
#

it would be cool to have a visual gradient that shows exactly what happens. like fade from black to white; 3 black lines, 3 white lines - flicker, etc

lucid osprey
#

that looks "ok"

#

can you tell me where this anim light menu is from?

#

is that an editor?

#

tool?

#

game?

merry field
#

It's from the Thief level editor, DromEd, circa 1998

lucid osprey
#

wow

#

very very good found

#

can you show more

#

we need to study this

#

in detail

merry field
#

More of what, exactly?

lucid osprey
#

dromed

#

i cant get it to work for me

merry field
#

Well, yes, I have it installed and know how to use it

#

It shouldn't be that difficult to get it to install and run with NewDark and the various fan patchers/installers

lucid osprey
#

i tried dat :c

#

i didnt try the thief 3 editor

merry field
#

Me neither, though that's Unreal 2 isn't it?

lucid osprey
#

mhhhhhhh

#

its a special version of unreal 2

#

inherint of deus ex 2

merry field
#

Right

lucid osprey
#

errr

#

dromed tutorials?

#

is that a thing?

merry field
#

Yes, I wrote a few back in the day

lucid osprey
#

show

#

i searched on youtube

merry field
#

Ah, no, text ones :)

lucid osprey
#

can you believe that?

#

we have super advanced tools

#

and they had badshit in their days

#

and still created games that made up till today...

#

what is our excuse XD

merry field
#

Yeah, that editor was beyond buggy

#

But in a way we're also expected to have much fancier graphics these days

lucid osprey
#

i feel a bit inspired now

merry field
#

Though we should probably move to another channel, this isn't very marketplace-related

wooden falcon
#

it was a lot easier to make levels back then too

#

all bsp, no static mesh (well, I guess unreal 2 had static meshes, right)?

lucid osprey
#

thief 3 used bsp yes. but they were also handling alot with the better system

delicate dove
#

unreal 1 even had meshes

#

just extremely painful to get them in, mostly small props too

#

__
More and more sellers are complaining (elsewhere) that the sales are dropping quite hard these last few months. Regardless of their marketing, interacting with (potential) buyers, and keeping their content up-to-date.

I know its just evolution, but its sad to hear them talking about the mp probably not being worth it anymore, lots are moving back to working for clients or at companies.
Some quite sad that they cant work on their own content and games anymore because well.. money.

wooden falcon
#

it's cause the marketplace is exploding in size

lucid osprey
#

yee

#

were getting close now to unity asset store

wooden falcon
#

I don't even bother putting my stuff on sales most months now...doesn't make a difference

#

I just wait for the big holiday sales

lucid osprey
#

we have the origin wishlist fullfilled now

#

and theres not much differcing us from unity now

vapid tundra
#

imho the sales are dropping partially because the overall quality has fallen as well.

lucid osprey
#

can i realese my assets now πŸ˜›

wooden falcon
vapid tundra
#

calling Dr. Hofmann πŸ˜„

wooden falcon
#

perfect for horror games

lucid osprey
#

?!?!

#

What

#

what garbage is that XD

#

that is disgusting

merry field
#

I wonder if people make alt accounts to praise their own products

lucid osprey
#

🀦

#

he you back from work πŸ˜›

merry field
#

Because that duck had more "this is great" contents than my stuff

#

No, I have discord on my phone πŸ™‚

sullen lion
#

Well I mean. It is great

#

I love that something like that is on the MP

lucid osprey
#

it costs 11 dollares...

#

that is highly offensive ._.

sullen lion
#

that just adds to the greatness.

lucid osprey
#

i mean would could one do wih a real character...

sullen lion
#

You could make a religion out of this.

lucid osprey
#

a religion of hate messages yes

#

you are absolutly right

#

the comments just mirror the truth

vapid tundra
#

for me rubber duck win item of the year award the 2nd time in a row

#

best item on the marketplace

lucid osprey
#

if its that easy to make 11 dollares

#

i mean

#

come on

#

how can QA argument this

vapid tundra
#

Does Epic get a cut from all sales?

quaint cedar
#

Yop

vapid tundra
#

Well, that was an rhetorical question πŸ˜„

#

as answer to owls comment about QA

sullen lion
#

well, the mesh didn't manage to crash the engine, and technically meets our paper requirements, approved

lucid osprey
#

🀦

#

they didnt said that to my meshes 2 years ago

sullen lion
#

should make and submit a duck then

#

get on the right track

wooden falcon
#

more ducks!

#

and it's PBR (as in, Pretty Baddass, Right?)

#

πŸ˜ƒ

#

yah, that duck was quite the topic when it first came out

delicate dove
#

not to mention the unicorn hehe

wooden falcon
#

lol

#

yah, how could we forget the unicorn?

#

fits into any game!

#

first comment on page: "wow that is some funny stuff. not sure how this would fit in any game."

#

lol

#

those should have been the free packs...the box pack, unicorn, duck and dayglow cubes...now build something unreal!

#

like Chopped...your basket contains an apple, sardines, and a hammer...make us a dish

delicate dove
#

I can already see stuff like

wooden falcon
#

πŸ˜ƒ

subtle abyss
#

Some marketplace sets have foliage like trees added to the demo (but not part of the set) - anyone know are they sourced from UE4 free demos?,what are the rules on using them?

split iron
#

What's the proper avenue for reporting a plugin on the MP from a dishonest author

nocturne scaffold
#

MP support. its on the same screen. however most parkerplace items are vetted by MP Admins before entry

north stirrup
#

What kind of dishonesty?

split iron
#

Their vetting process is hardly sufficient in this case, it's also an 'external link' if that's relevant

So this plugin is motion matching, basically a system for character animation that draws information from a set of animations 'intelligently'. It comes with a demo project and works fine, but soon as you use any other animations it doesn't work. Two people have reported this and he's extremely dismissive of the issue. However we contracted the same guy to make an enormous mocap pack specifically for this plugin and had the same issue with even their animations! They kept blaming us; custom engine source, differing input setup, etc, despite us insisting that we were testing with the same setup and launcher engine that their demo uses, and when asked to setup a demo project showing the custom animations working they started quoting contract "we did not agree to this level of support" and "the animations work for ue4 therefore we aren't required to fix anything" (untrue, we specified working with the plugin but nm that for now)

north stirrup
#

Yeah definitely send a mail to the MP team

split iron
#

They're aware their plugin is broken, but their solution is to fault users and defer from any actual issue

delicate dove
#

sounds like they are pro's :p
/me looks at microsoft and autodesk

wooden falcon
#

looks like about 7 new ones

delicate dove
split iron
#

@delicate dove Actually not so much, their contract fucks them

#

It states that it has to be to customer's specifications and of acceptable quality

#

Now here's some ultra shady shit they pulled, we gave them permission to pin messages in our animation channel, and he used that permission (manage messages) to go through and delete our logs

#

Because he wanted to get rid of any evidence of our conversation where it stated the purpose of the animations

#

There's proof

#

They full on scammed us and tried to cover it up, hopefully we win the paypal dispute

split iron
#

If you're curious about what happened

#

It looks like they posted artificial reviews on their own website too

lean venture
#

@split iron Something wrong your thread? Unless there's some dark corner of the forums I don't have access to, it won't load for me.

split iron
#

Epic deleted it 🀷

lucid osprey
#

ofc they did

#

i support that 200%

#

this is not something you post so lightly... They need to look into this and judge it themselves

#

what did you think...

void prawn
#

Has epic ever 'ruled' in favor of the buyer before?

#

Related to this marketplace case etc

lucid osprey
#

i think they do that all the time

void prawn
#

hmm alright. Just had a feeling they liked to hush things down. Hope it works out for Vaei. πŸ‘Œ

quaint cedar
#

@split iron They do state that they refunded.

#

No idea if you are aware of that.

split iron
#

@quaint cedar After the fact; they worded it like that on purpose

#

I guess 🀷

modern perch
#

@split iron - the moderation log for your thread says it was removed by your request?

split iron
#

Nope

modern perch
#

hmm, I'll follow that up with Quinton

split iron
#

I just figured they deemed it too witch-huntey

modern perch
#

Epic doesn't normally delete these threads tbh

quaint cedar
#

To be fair, you should never post something like this openly.
Not even in the comments of the marketplace.
If you have a problem with the seller, you'll have to do it privately with them and then notify epic.

#

Even if all you say is true.

#

If it all turns out in your favor and you have something to back all of this up, then you can probably post it, but even then I would be careful.

delicate dove
quaint cedar
#

Asking as a non-graphics person: These things have to be power of 2 or?

delicate dove
#

yup, else no proper compression, and no mipmaps

split iron
#

They identify as a "CG Master" which says it all πŸ˜›

modern perch
#

sprites don't usually want mip-maps, but it does depend on your application I guess

delicate dove
#

you'd want mipmaps in case the effect is far away, not having compression or mipmaps is just stupid. especially since it claims to be working on mobile where non-power-of-two textures, especially non-square textures are typpically a no-no.

#

also its about time a "link to thread" should be mandatory

#

especially since sellers still dont get them emails.

modern perch
#

2d games don't care about distance, hehe

delicate dove
#

this would work in many games, not only 2d though

#

and even then, it helps to have em for lower settings.

delicate dove
#

got the package I mentioned before for study reasons nontheless, and I have to admit I was wrong.
its not a spritesheet flipbook, but sets of 256x256 images set-up as a flipbook trough paper-flipbook. and thats actually the first time I have come across them.

#

there are no textures in the size the author mentions, but he just added the combined 256x256 textures sizes

#

<_< then again, those dont work in cascade

delicate dove
#

the detail on those handles

#

looks like old ut/doom maps

lucid osprey
#

thats your own fault if you look on cg market πŸ˜„

#

yee its very blocky.

delicate dove
#

was posted on ue4 project & promo group

lucid osprey
#

dafaq

merry field
#

The backdrops are excessively busy as well

#

Do I even want to ask how the hollow one is supposed to actually do anything useful?

#

Anyone could just put their sword inside yours and pull it out of your hand

delicate dove
#

and grate your hand with that hilt while they are at it

merry field
#

It does look a bit like sandpaper

nocturne scaffold
#

so what are mipmaps.

delicate dove
#

if a texture is 512/512, at a certain distance itll be shown as 256/256, and even further away 128/128

#

but if its an image thats not able to divide by two, it cant mipmap

wooden falcon
#

the lower res textures are autogenerated, and as Luos says, can't be autogenned if not a power of 2

#

mipmaps have been around since at least Quake 1 πŸ˜ƒ

wooden falcon
#

salty

#

lol

delicate dove
lunar fractal
#

#professional

delicate dove
#

not going to reply to that with a 10 feet pole hehe

wooden falcon
#

is the handle made out of charcoal?

delicate dove
#

no, leather

#

well researched

nocturne scaffold
#

Wow Yoeri way to be so salty on your professional review

#

XD

wooden falcon
#

you can grate cheese with the handle? what's the problem? Seems like an excellent feature!

nocturne scaffold
#

mmmm parmesan. tbh where the blade connects to the hilt right over it looks so weak.

#

one good twack and it would snap

#

especially because the "scratched metal" looks like manufactured block steel that was CNCd

#

but thats just my uneducated opinion from working with steel for a decade. XD

delicate dove
#

lol

mighty yacht
#

If you turn the sword upside down and scale it up, the handle can be a medieval castle tower. But if and only if you are a certified content re-user ><

delicate dove
#

hehe

wooden falcon
#

plus, with all those holes in the blade, it's gonna be hell to keep clean

nocturne scaffold
#

uh the blood trails

#

fracture a bone and it gets stuck when trying to pull it out. now your dead.

#

tldr; -1/10 will end up dead and laughed at for using sword

#

as for Mipmaps thank you i was not aware thats what it did. Is that why you have to set your imported textures to mipmap world or whatever

delicate dove
#

yes, that way a user who changes quality settings can seperate quality for effects, world, characters, etc in most pc games

torpid dove
#

I'm trying to use the Soul Cave map from the marketplace but my Character keeps spawning outside the map and falling forever. I changed the gamemode and everything to my own and placed new player starts inside the map. What is causing this?

delicate dove
#

no collision on the env?

nocturne scaffold
#

^

delicate dove
#

it was for mobile, so they probably used a custom collision?

torpid dove
#

I'm not even spawning inside the map. I'm outside the map?

nocturne scaffold
#

Move your characters up higher and make sure the landscape has collision for pawn set

torpid dove
#

I tried moving them up and I even placed a solid cube under them to see if they could stand on it. Thing is my character is not even spawning where the player starts are.

#

I got it..... I feel stupid. So in my gamemode I forgot to hook back up my spawn point transform so it was just spawning me at 0,0,0. 😐 sorry. Thanks for helping though

merry field
#

Sounds like you have some code putting your player in the wrong place

torpid dove
#

Yea it was my spawnpoint transform. I must have changed it when I was on my test map and forgot to hook it back up. Whoops

wooden falcon
#

I mean, it doesn't look tastey to me, but it does look real

#

most of those shots don't look rendered in ue4 to me, though

delicate dove
#

hmm @wooden falcon those images are rendered in redhift? according to video

wooden falcon
#

ah, that explains it

#

πŸ˜‰

merry field
#

The crusts look a bit strange

#

They almost look more like stone than bread

#

Is it dwarf bread?

prisma talon
#

artists are terrifyingly critical of each other lol

vapid tundra
#

bread connoisseurs = best critics hehe

wooden falcon
#

oh, I'm not being critical of the break...it's some of the best scans I've seen

#

bread*...why the fark can i never spell bread lately :/

lone mountain
#

Synty Western is sweet looking...but they made a strange omission in their pack... Where are the horses?

wooden falcon
#

no horses?!

#

πŸ˜ƒ

pearl ocean
#

does the release date time make a difference in sales in the marketplace? πŸ€” (day of the week, hour of the day, etc.)

wooden falcon
#

dunno...we don't have a lot of data to go by

gaunt flicker
#

no data

unborn dirge
#

Is there any good package for Anime characters on the marketplace?

delicate dove
#

i wonder if people keep asking about if pack X is available because search is still meh, or too lazy to search :p

unborn dirge
#

Lazy πŸ˜›

#

Well I searched, but the asset got only 2 and a half stars

#

So I doubt if it's worth the money

modern perch
#

I'm not sure the rating system is all that reliable tbh

#

3.5 stars

unborn dirge
#

Dayum

drowsy jasper
#

I see the Fall sale is in full swing.. When is the last day of the sale ?

quaint cedar
#

As soon as I open any form of UE4 website, my Browser stops loading websites unless I restart it

#

So. Annoying.

delicate dove
#

try opening 50 marketplace pack pages at once.

#

just plain refuses to load the prices

quaint cedar
#

I don't even need to load 50

delicate dove
#

I did :p

quaint cedar
#

OPening the marketplace, the forums, the blog

#

whatever it is, afterwards nothing loads anymore

#

Clicked on the Voronoi stuff -> loads -> new tabs don't work anymore

#

Only have that with ue4 pages

wooden falcon
#

oh, I thought the sale was next week, doh

#

oh wow, gridblocks 30% off!

#

πŸ˜‰

delicate dove
#

Here's hoping for a good sale period.
^5's a imaginary drink

vapid tundra
#

only €48.42

modern perch
#

there are several volumes of that now, IIRC

delicate dove
#

need their email and ask epic mp team

quaint cedar
#

If I had the time I would make similar grid blocks and submit them for 99cents

#

Would probalby be blocked cause of already existing on the mp

vapid tundra
#

wait.. they still block too similar products?

quaint cedar
#

Idk

vapid tundra
#

aye

delicate dove
#

sorta

#

when its already oversaturated, like rocks

#

though.. saw a new rock pack recently

vapid tundra
merry field
#

Considering those grid blocks, I think I must be grossly under-charging people

azure tundra
#

Anyone knows malberS personally? all his assets are 30-50% off except the wolf, maybe they missed it?

modern perch
#

jesus christ those texture packs

#

diddle settings in substance
submit 20 times

wooden falcon
#

I doubt they sell

#

of course, I could be wrong...the gridblock guy could be sipping his martinis from his gold plated swimming pool while he laughs at our dumbasses

merry field
#

Be interesting to see how well various things sell

delicate dove
#

there are people and some companies that just buy everything.

oak fiber
#

I feel like i should substance design this week and put out a free pack with all the sbs open sourced to get rid of thaat stupid idea of selling material packs at 15$ a pop for something that is free on the internet.

#

there is not a single redeeming texture in any of those packs

hasty nexus
#

they just try to make some money. it's not like they're selling much...

#

let them be, you don't like, you don't buy, you don't have to b*tch about other people's work. no matter what quality you think it is. you don't pay them...

#

it's just rude

delicate dove
#

when something at a restaurant is rotten, even if its one dish, less and less people will want to eat there.
so as fellow sellers we worry and talk about it, dont like it, dont react to it

vapid tundra
#

thats not the point tho

#

those packs saturate the marketplace and with epics policy....

modern perch
#

it's the Steam thing - when Steam became saturated with low quality entries, everyone suffered

hasty nexus
#

so what they saturate? it's ok, people have things to buy if they want

modern perch
#

the ability to discover quality content by chance dipped to nearly zero, and as a result decent content isn't being sold

hasty nexus
#

therefor the rating system

modern perch
#

the rating system only works if people can find it to rate it in the first plce

delicate dove
#

which people abuse if the seller doesnt want to help them

hasty nexus
#

decent content, decent rating

modern perch
#

there are hundreds of decent games on Steam with a number of owners in the two-digits range

#

they're buried

#

if people can't find quality content, they won't buy it, and fewer yet will rate it

hasty nexus
#

that's fine, equal rights, they payed their fees, then it's about the advertising. those decent games should advertise better if they compete with crappy games

#

there is a rating system on steam as well

modern perch
#

and that rating system doesn't work for the exact reason I just described

#

(and numerous other problems)

delicate dove
#

lol

modern perch
#

if your marketplace is full of shit, people will just stop using your marketplace

#

everybody loses

hasty nexus
#

i bet people are gonna still using the marketplace, especially when they have so much to choose from. they can spend hours of searching for what they like

modern perch
#

people don't want to spend hours searching?

#

I certainly don't

hasty nexus
#

then let's have 5 products

vapid tundra
#

Epic will deny possible quality packs due to those "shovelware" packs. Which in return can only make the marketplace suffer in the long run.

modern perch
#

why would I sift through shit for hours when I can go elsewhere?

delicate dove
#

I get paid by one client so he doesnt need to search hehe

hasty nexus
#

so they won't spend time searching and deciding what's best

#

5 products and EVERYBODY will be happy, no crappy content, no time spent browsing for assets

modern perch
#

if there are only 5 quality products, so be it - nobody benefits from 20 almost identical low-quality stone wall packs

hasty nexus
#

i appreciate luos work very much and i bought one of his assets, but excuse me, i payed for it like 80 bucks. and that because i'm one of the lucky indies that can afford those 80 bucks. some other 15 years old, would go for the 15 bucks one, that looks crappier, but he can use it

#

be fair

delicate dove
#

there is a difference between low value and low quality though.

hasty nexus
#

i don't agree with you guys b*tching about those projects that are crappier, not AAA and such

#

it's just my opinion. don't want to make anyone mad

delicate dove
#

yea..

#

soo

#

13447597 polygons

hasty nexus
#

basically, if epic put it there, then it's fine

#

πŸ˜„

delicate dove
#

I thiiiiink someone added all the verts instead of an average

#

thing is, sadly the mp team sometimes misses things, and especially in the past they have had some people employed who couldnt tell pixel from poly.

#

much better now, but there are still some cracks.

hasty nexus
#

sincerely, i'm so happy that there is such a huge amount of assets on MP. i'm a developer and i prefer to have to choice. sometimes i'll pay 10 bucks for placeholders. when i see something good, i'll go even 150

#

but it's nice to have options

merry field
#

The more rubbish there is that people don't even want, the harder it becomes to find the good stuff

delicate dove
#

but what if you pay 10 bucks for something that just doesnt work out of the box?
one thing that bugs me beyond.. well.. ill keep it decent.. is i.e. textures without proper compression or groups.

merry field
#

You need good search/filtering tools

#

And no one ever makes those

#

It's s big reason why it's hard to find things on Steam

#

Lots of rubbish, no good tools to filter it out

sullen lion
#

Well I take a look at some of the stuff I wanna make as a code plugin, and there's 30 BP packs that do it. Then I remember hearing so much about content being rejected because things have already done it. Then I don't make those plugins.

hasty nexus
#

hey, that's epic fault, and you should privately take it forward with them if you feel like you bought it and it doesn't meet your expectations. firstly, epic put it there. i understand that sometimes you pay for bad stuff, but that's not the publisher fault. he could've been denied by the marketplace. and even if he didn't and he's published on that mp, you should not just publicly trash that guy. this is where my problem lies...

sullen lion
#

Combine this with poor discoverability and its no longer a good idea to have open gates.

merry field
#

As a random similar example, not of rubbish in this case, but just of large quantities and poor search tools, I was idly browsing ArtStation, but was only interested in 3D / low-poly (e.g. Game assets), and you can't filter your searches to only show those

hasty nexus
#

my dog would be crying so much if one of you would be b*tching my work. good or bad, it's my work.. =))

vapid tundra
#

imho a lack of QA actually is the publishers fault

merry field
#

So I spent more time scrolling through things I didn't care about than actually looking at interesting things

sullen lion
#

If something I spend a week on wouldn't be rejected because of the existence of something somebody else spent 20 minutes on, then your point stands. I don't care about the "thrown together" pack at $5-10.

hasty nexus
#

guys, it's not like you spend days climbing a mountain. all of you spend like at least 12 hours in front the pc and you complain for some mouse scrolls :))

sullen lion
#

Yeah just don't fucking bother reading my point.

hasty nexus
#

:))

#

i'm good now. cya later

delicate dove
#

i get paid for my time working with ue4 though, not really productive to scroll a mouse the entire day to find the right packs :p

#

not even the seller decided to offset it a little with 5 stars

#

thats character :p

hasty nexus
#

it's them

#

that's no trash πŸ˜„ see who they're working with and some feedback there

delicate dove
#

previous client uses it, works fine.

#

hmm, just did some math to see how much itll cost me to purchase all the packs I want that are currently on sale.

#

973,-

hasty nexus
#

but if you add them to cart, you don't have to do the math

#

=)))

delicate dove
#

miiiight need to filter for now, what I need now and what can wait till I really need it

hasty nexus
#

it will shjow you there

#

:D:D:D

delicate dove
#

then I need to remove them from the cart as well hehe

#

I'll keep my limit at 500,-
so i'll probably make some peeps happy

#

buys all the brick wall packs

hasty nexus
#

hahahaha

delicate dove
modern perch
#

hahahaha

delicate dove
#

some bloat, but with 1k+ anims.. thats fine

hasty nexus
#

yeah, i also have my eyes on their packs. they're huge

#

and all mocap

#

even if you don't use them all

#

they're there

delicate dove
#

yea, mainly getting some anim packs to show off vfx better

wooden falcon
#

i'm fine with the "more the merrier" motto of marketplace pack acceptance, but Epic is a bit inconsistent with acceptance

#

I was talking with a well known pack author who had a pack dismissed for no good reason, even though it was better quality than much of what's been accepted lately...it's like a lotto draw with the reviewers

hasty nexus
#

that's some annabelle stuff

#

=)))

delicate dove
#

oh god, make a plugin with it and have the doll random appear in editor to creep you the ff out

candid rivet
#

it'll be like microsoft clippy, but jump scares

hasty nexus
#

i've never seen a clown pack, not that i've searched for, but never encountered one pack with clowns

delicate dove
#

"HEY!" I heard you like jumpscares

candid rivet
#

lol

wooden falcon
#

set it up so the doll only pops up in the editor after midnight

candid rivet
#

the killer clown pack i've seen that somewhere

delicate dove
#

or just suddenly when rotating cam stares at you

wooden falcon
#

Doll pops up "Hey, I noticed you haven't shit your pants? Do you need assistance?"

delicate dove
#

130,- left to spend. hmmz

candid rivet
#

really? i'm having a hard time finding anything worthwhile tbh

nocturne scaffold
#

have the doll put an editor crash screen and then show unrecoverable files. XD

sullen lion
#

throw $5 at my plugin for literally no reason

#

#shamelessplug

candid rivet
#

sadly MAWI assets will never go on sale

delicate dove
#

mainly plugins, some env's, and loads of anims

#

@sullen lion which one is it?

sullen lion
#

$125 is a nicer number anyway

#

Quaternion lib

nocturne scaffold
#

i ran our funds out a few weeks ago. i wanna gwt that medieval town pack however.

#

:) time for cround funding soon. lol

ocean cipher
#

hey kid, wann buy my UMG splines plugin?

#

it does a good wibbly wobbly bend

sullen lion
#

should pre-order my other thing that I have to wait for an engine PR to be merged while you're at it

merry field
#

I'm wondering if I should update my preview image to make it seem more interesting

pearl ocean
#

If I have a plugin in the marketplace can I give it to someone's epic account for free? πŸ€”

#

and if yes, how? πŸ€”

delicate dove
#

ask the email adress they use on launcher, send to mp team with the request, and link to your mp pack.

pearl ocean
#

thanks, will do

delicate dove
#

@sullen lion Y U NO discount :p

candid rivet
#

what would you guys say is the best photorealistic foliage stuff, photorealistic and good performance-wise. not counting mawi packs

#

no foliage fans eh?

delicate dove
#

havent touched it much, so cant tell

oak fiber
#
[10:07 AM] YakiStudios: let them be, you don't like, you don't buy, you don't have to b*tch about other people's work. no matter what quality you think it is. you don't pay them...
[10:07 AM] YakiStudios: it's just rude```

Dont like it, dont comment on it -- take your own advice.
hasty nexus
#

so many rock packs on mp =))

#

@! you sound pretty rude. you feel offended because you've been pointed out for b*tching for no reason? 😦

sullen lion
#

its not for no reason Β―_(ツ)_/Β―

hasty nexus
#

it is

hasty nexus
#

:))

oak fiber
#

I am not offended LOL

#

you seem to be

#

you dont like ppl talking in a channel for talking about the MP

#

you dont like it

sullen lion
#

you can fight strawmen all day

oak fiber
#

dont respond

#

take your own advice

#

or be a hypocrit

#

either way

hasty nexus
#

this channel as far as i remember is not about trashing people on mp

oak fiber
#

no one is trashing anyone

#

trashing the stuff that person posted as work to get 15$ of value from others. yes.

sullen lion
#

All I've ever seen is why is this allowed in the context of why are the rules inconsistent

delicate dove
#

"You Save EUR €316.13"

oak fiber
#

the only thing consistent in life, is the inconsistent.

hasty nexus
#

luos and you spend how much?

#

πŸ˜ƒ

delicate dove
#

just under 500
investment mainly in my case.
actually saved money for today

hasty nexus
#

oh, good value

#

300 for 500 spent

sullen lion
#

wait is there like a sale or something?

delicate dove
#

wish black friday did those kind of deals here in dutcherland

#

@sullen lion yup

sullen lion
#

Ah.

hasty nexus
#

here in my country, one month before black friday they raise the prices, and then on black friday they put it back

#

=))

sullen lion
#

See my actual content isn't on the MP so I've yet to be keepng up.

delicate dove
#

yea same, sometimes even more expensive than before

sullen lion
#

BQL was just sorta how does this process normally go

hasty nexus
#

yeah =))

delicate dove
#

<_< it crashed when i pressed "place order"

sullen lion
#

if you don't like it, don't participate in it. Why so negative?

hasty nexus
#

this one i like

vapid tundra
#

some sellers did that on the ue mp too btw πŸ˜„

#

totally not obv... kappa

delicate dove
#

"Sorry, validation failed." <_<

hasty nexus
#

i had some while back some troubles when paying with paypal if i remember correctly

sullen lion
#

just email them to place your order

#

actually, why not send a telegraph messge? #bringbackmorsecode

hasty nexus
#

and another time my bank blocked transactions to prevent frauds

#

when you do several payments online in one day, you might have that enabled by the bank

delicate dove
#

dm-ed Tim to see if it went trough, rather not be charged twice :p

merry field
#

Yeah, I've heard of banks blocking Marketplace because they think it's Fortnite fraud

#

Especially if you're suddenly spending 500...

hasty nexus
#

i don't think that was the case, i believe they blocked all transactions because i spent money online in several places. if i remember correctly

quasi blade
#

spot the bug

#

i mean, its summer in brazil technically... but im inthe US.. it seems to hav eupdated recently to fall sale...*

vapid tundra
#

i wouldn't mind if the prices were in brazilian real πŸ˜„

quasi blade
#

lmao

merry field
#

Says Fall Sale for me

#

which implies that it's intentional

#

Though if we're getting regional naming, it really ought to say Autumn Sale for people in Europe...

candid rivet
#

oh man, the price on that animal pack

wooden falcon
#

alright, I've definitely got click fatigue now with this sale

delicate dove
#

still waiting to get my issue sorted. Y U NO LET ME GIVE U MONAY

quaint cedar
#

@idle arch Hey, I got huge problems with the Marketplace Website.
As soon as I open up any page of it, e.g. the sale page, nothing else loads anymore.
I can see the initial page just fine, but I can't load any next pages, nor do totally unrelated websites load.
This only surfaced lately and it's only triggerrf by the UE4 page. Not sure if the Blog etc. also cause this.
Browser is Chrome on Windows 10. Would be nice if someone could look into that.

#

Restarting the browser resolves the issue until I open any Marketplace page again

#

Actually, the combination of AdBlock and the UE4 marketplace cause this (: not cool...

idle arch
#

Hmm

#

So is this something you can replicate?

quaint cedar
#

Lemme check

merry field
#

Have you tried using a different ad blocker, e.g. uBlock Origin, instead?

quaint cedar
#

No, also not seeing the reason to do that.

#

It seems like disabling AdBlocker on all pages, opening the Marketplace and then reenabling it got rid of it

#

No idea what that was. Could probably even be a random issue.

#

But well, better state that it somehow existed in case someone else comes up with it

candid rivet
#

i have adblock on chrome but haven't experienced the same problem

quaint cedar
#

Yeah I only noticed it due to the page trying to load AdBlock the whole time

#

But it happened on no other page. I have this for like 4 days now

#

Will see if it comes back once I startup my pc tomorrow

idle arch
#

Righto - we have not changed anything fundamentally with the way we the page displays or loads data at all

quaint cedar
#

Alright, just wanted to let you know what I experience. You never know :P

idle arch
#

Appreciate it!

#

I just tried it on my machine and I have a normal experience.

timber dragon
#

Anyone got suggestions on what I should get for the fall Sale?

merry field
#

People in here might tell you to buy whatever item(s) they themselves have on sale πŸ˜‰

#

But a more serious answer would be: wouldn't that depend on the kind of game you are making?

#

For example, there would be no point suggesting realistic assets if you are making something with a low-poly stylised look

candid rivet
#

we don't make games here, we make hundreds of abandoned projects, and they need all sorts of assets πŸ˜‰

delicate dove
#

cant go wrong with plugins that make your workflow better, or add new features you might want to play with.

dim pawn
#

oh god, a fall sale?!

#

if the page will load, I will be in trouble...

#

@quaint cedar I'm also getting a problem with the marketplace in chrome, its just stuck there saying "Waiting for extension AdBlock" 😦

quasi blade
#

@idle arch can I express a certain thing i really dislike about the marketplace: when you are searching the marketplace, and you are on page 3 for example of same priced items lets say 1.99$, when you press back from that item's page it will randomly shuffle the contents of page 3 with all of the 1.99$ content, so for example you've just gone thru page 1 & 2, but now you are on page 3 which has 1.99$ items shuffled in from page 1 & 2 as well, so you'd actaully have to go back to page 1 to make sure you didnt miss any items

#

i find that to be a design flaw of some sort, although i can see it was intentionally placed to give all marketplace assets a fair chance, it should only shuffle those assets maybe the first time i go to the marketplace website or in the marketplace section of the epic launhcer

dim pawn
#

yeah. I click next page and I get stuff from the previous page

quasi blade
#

thats always been there, and its always bothered me 😬

#

yeah interitus, even you dont have a filter and the next few pages or previous have the same price, it will shuffle items , so like you said, you click next and content from previous page will be there, AND you might actually miss content which got shuffled away from the page you are just on

#

so

#

some stuff will never get seen

dim pawn
#

It seems adblock doesnt like the Ue4 site at all, or its just adblock... keeps locking up

#

turned it off and now I can use the site

pliant forum
#

Throwing my voice in there too. I fully agree with Rei's statement.
Having stuff that I checked 2-3 pages back show up just makes me think a lot of stuff might be missed while scrolling through MP pages

midnight gazelle
#

Just saw the sale start and i was just wondering will there be a December sale? if so, should i wait for that?

dim pawn
#

I seem to remember there being a sale at the end of the year, but I dont think the deals will be much bigger than what they are now

#

if you need some assets or something for your project now, why wait?

idle arch
#

Thanks for the feedback, @quasi blade. We have a lot of room for improvement on the Marketplace, and we will continue to improve on it as time goes!

gaunt flicker
#

there is a sale?

ebon leaf
#

Hey! I'm looking for some suggestions on good visual effect packs for a Kart Racer type game

#

Mainly looking for a pack that's got a lot of variety in it if anyone knows of a good one

tiny thistle
#

sorry if it was posted before
I tried to do some shopping on marketplace and it kept rejecting my PayPal
it just didn't want to charge my wallet so - I went to paypal site, settings / payments and there was "Your preferred way to pay" - click change and choose "PayPal balance" and ofc confirm
after that shopping went smooth πŸ˜ƒ

ripe raven
#

@tiny thistle you're a bloody legend mate, thanks

tiny thistle
#

youre welcome πŸ˜ƒ

quaint cedar
#

@dim pawn @idle arch This is exactly the error I have

#

So I'm at least not the only one. Either AdBlock is broken on exactly the MP page, or the page does something that causes AdBlock to break or they both just don't get along.
I don't know enough about how AdBlock works sadly.

tiny thistle
#

disable it temporarily?

quaint cedar
#

Yeah, you have to disable it for all pages before opening the MP

#

And then you can reenable it after opening the MP to then disable it only for the MP

tiny thistle
#

maybe you can add unreal website to adblock exemption list

quaint cedar
#

I tried, but I was too tired to understand the syntax of how to add these entries

#

Usually you can do that through the dialog at the top right of chrome, but AdBlock doesn't properly load on the MP page, so the menu isn't available.

#

It's not a big deal and I don't need adblock on that page, but given how many users use AdBlock on Chrome and might run into the same thing should make Epic at least double check.

#

On another note: What's the Pack that hte UE Sale uses as a background?

#

Can't recall the name of the company behind the low poly things

tiny thistle
#

hmm I have AdBlocker Ultimate with Chrome but I didnt have issues and it was on

quaint cedar
#

Pretty sure it's also not happening for everyone

tiny thistle
#

btw I'm using win7

hallow wagon
#

I can't sign in on the MP lol.

ebon leaf
#

is there anything on the fall sale that you guys would recommend to buy?

lean venture
#

Sounds like a good opportunity to recommend my 40% off Steam integration plugin (UWorks)

delicate dove
#

<_< no response to my email and DM and I still cant buy stuff from the mp

lucid osprey
#

you own too much already

ebon leaf
#

@lean venture πŸ˜„

#

unfortunately i don't have plans for steam xD

lean venture
#

I'd advertise my upcoming mod support plugin instead, but... #upcoming

ebon leaf
#

a plugin to provide modding??

#

@lean venture did I get that right??

lean venture
#

βœ…

#

I need one for my game so...

#

Needed*

ebon leaf
#

do you already have something to show xD?

lean venture
#

I have something working, yes. I'm not going to show anything until I'm sure it will "shock and awe", no. I need to play a bit more with some commands.

ebon leaf
#

i see

#

do you have a youtube channel or w/e where we can keep an eye on?

lean venture
#

I used my personal account to showcase my first plugin, but I don't have any intention of "developing" it in the near future. I'll likely post an announcement on my Discord and the forums with a showcase video.

vivid tide
#

Is there anyway to see if your product is on sale or not?

#

Seems like a stupid question to ask but i genuinely can't see unless I create a dummy account -.-

blazing harbor
#

@vivid tide incognito mode and view?

vivid tide
#

No button shows up unless you're signed in :/

blazing harbor
vivid tide
#

Looks like it's not haha.. thanks!

wooden falcon
#

pro-tip for incognito windows: firefox ctrl+shift+p, chrome ctrl+shift+n, ie uninstall program

#

ok, checked sales report for first day of sale, and it was about what I was expecting

lean venture
#

Going for 90% off again? :p

wooden falcon
#

nah, I did 60%...might have been a mistake

#

oh well, least there's plenty of good deals...just tired of searching for them in the page heap

idle arch
#

Ultimately, if the MP is not loading because of an addon - there is not much we can do now, but I can ask the teams to look into it before the next sale.

modern perch
#

I've noticed I can't see any seller profiles etc

#

404s me

wooden falcon
vivid tide
#

Warren's great. Used to work at Epic I believe.

delicate dove
#

yup

wooden falcon
#

I chat with him now and again on his discord server...cool dude, always very helpful

ebon leaf
#

Hei

#

Salut

nocturne scaffold
#

so the KiteDemo trees....

#

could that be why my game is barely playable on lower end systems. since i have about 400 of them in the small starting village. πŸ˜‚

modern perch
#

I'm surprised it runs on any systems :p

candid rivet
#

probably overdraw, we tried to use the grass in a vr experience and it just killed it

nocturne scaffold
#

well time to wipe foliage and start anew

#

πŸ˜ƒ

#

ill wipe it out all together as the layer and cook the game for some testers see if they can run on low

#

is there a way to make your 1080 run like a 960

#

πŸ˜‚

candid rivet
#

just check the visualization buffers, should give you a decent indication

nocturne scaffold
#

not sure how that works

candid rivet
#

in the viewport the dropdown in the top, should have optimization views

nocturne scaffold
#

coder, not a mapper. haha

#

okay

candid rivet
#

give you a heatmap of how expensive your materials are

azure tundra
#

anyone here knows how to give a refund to a customer as a publisher?

delicate dove
#

contact mp team with the reason, url to mp pack, and email the buyer uses on launcher

#

(reason optional, but handy)

azure tundra
#

Thank Yoeri appreciate it

#

it is sad i need to refund since otherwise he will just 1 star me :p

nocturne scaffold
#

interesting. i will have to take a look at that heatmap

delicate dove
#

@azure tundra if buyer is threatening you, mention that (with proof) to the mp team.

#

Aaaand finally able to buy stuff again, some people will see a +1 on their sales list tonight hehe

wooden falcon
#

if I saw a +1, that would double my sales

#

my free pack is still selling well :/

azure tundra
#

@delicate dove will do thanks! so if he leaves a negative review and epic refund does the 1 star stay?

#

i really hope the rating system changes soon

sullen lion
#

its epic's marketplace. what do you think?

azure tundra
#

rip

lucid horizon
#

Anyone else getting a validation failed error when trying to checkout with PayPal?

delicate dove
#

had that issue, might want to contact the marketplace team

ebon leaf
#

god damn ue marketplace could use some design upgrades, even harder to navigate than in the new unity's asset store

mental dome
#

anyone use the CCG kit? been eyeing it for a while and very interested in picking it up at its sale price

candid rivet
#

anyone having login problems?

candid rivet
#

nm it's good now

hallow sphinx
#

Is there a way to sort products by number of ratings?

#

Often missed out on really good/popular assets because I couldn't discover them.

modern perch
#

@mental dome - have but don't use it

#

it looked reasonable, but organised in such a way that if you wanted something other than a Hearthstone / Magic clone you'd have a hard time pulling it apart

nocturne scaffold
#

why fall sale?!!!! i have like 60 tabs open. haha

merry field
#

Use Panorama View to hide them away for later

nocturne scaffold
#

hehe. but i wants to purchase them all now!

#

i need ab $300. lol

#

its all little tiny $3-7 props.

merry field
#

People seem to go a little mad in sales...

#

(I hope they go mad and buy from me too)

wooden falcon
#

link to your seller profile?

merry idol
#

Can someone help me? I textured a BMW, but I don't know how I can export it correctly so i can set the model on the marketplace. Anyone ideas?

delicate dove
#

you arent allowed to sell that since bmw is a copyrighted thing

#

it would be declined

merry idol
#

@delicate dove so sadπŸ™ . But is there a way to export it as a textured model. Because when i try to export or migrate my model my textures are mostly gone and the settings of the textures are mostly gone.

delicate dove
#

because you need to import textures, make a material out of it (or multiple) and apply to mesh accordingly.

merry idol
#

thank you Luos

wooden falcon
#

ok Luos, I didn't notice a +1 yesterday :/

delicate dove
#

:/
did purchase quite a lot of plugins and anims

wooden falcon
#

any that you would recommend?

delicate dove
#

@wooden falcon plugins?
Asset batch edit plugin
Linter (free)
Multipacker (free)
Node Graph assistant (cant live without it)
havent tried the others yet

nocturne scaffold
#

animations and props are what im after

merry field
#

@wooden falcon Mine? I'm actually a fraud, I only have one thing!

wooden falcon
#

what thing is that Nameless?

wooden falcon
#

that looks pretty useful

merry field
#

Yeah, I made originally made it because I wanted it

#

Then decided to polish it up and put it on the Marketplace

wooden falcon
merry field
#

A mad scientist playing with mannequin parts?

wooden falcon
#

and the comments look so legit πŸ˜‰

merry field
#

This is cool

#

I'm not sure I have any use for it, but it really does look like parts of Ireland

wooden falcon
#

that ai animated thing was creepy

lunar fractal
#

wow, that's some deep stuff right there

merry field
#

That seemed very peculiarly harsh

delicate dove
#

should have posted it in lounge, but the 6 legged one reminded me of the video. (not as much related to its quality, just made me remember the video)

#

and yea its a bit harsh, I do understand where miyazaki is coming from, and especially older people in a trade tend to defend their opinions a bit harder (though.. nowadays.. on twitter)

merry field
#

The people who made the experiment looked like they were about to start crying

wooden falcon
#

yah, I felt bad for them, lol

#

I mean, Japan is THE place that came up with creepy moving stuff

#

I'm sure a bit of his ire was the notion that ai could replace what he does, though

#

unfortunately, it's gonna happen with a lot of jobs, my own included, eventually

delicate dove
#

same

#

I woulnt mind telling an AI that I want X vfx, and just do the final tweaks myself

wooden falcon
#

yah, that's probably what it's gonna be like, at first

#

and someone's gonna have to train it πŸ˜ƒ

#

I mean, you don't want someone feeding gridblocks into it

delicate dove
#

oh god, one day we can make an AI making mp packs.

merry field
#

I notice that there don't seem to be any good packs of lava on the marketplace

#

There's some terrain packs with lava on them

#

but nothing for making actual lava

#

Apart from Lava materials Vol 35 :p

delicate dove
#

two of the learning packs have lava

#

one stylized-ish, and one rather well done.

merry field
#

Oh, the elements demo?

delicate dove
#

elemental yea

merry field
#

I'd forgotten about that, let me check it

hasty nexus
#

it's not bad

merry field
#

Hmm, very hard to tell because there's no video

#

Wait, who makes something that is (presumably) animated and doesn't have a video?

hasty nexus
#

there's a sketchfab

#

oh, not animated

merry field
#

Yeah...

#

Because the hard part of making good lava is the animated parts

#

It should have... bubbles and explosions on the surface and things

delicate dove
#

its not that hard with proper uv's and some vertex coloring.
bubbles isnt too hard either hehe

merry field
#

That elemental demo is cool, though I don't think it's quite what I had in mind, it's more thin streams of lava, I was thinking of a lake of lava

#

The kind of unrealistic things you get in game levels which ignore convection πŸ˜ƒ

wooden falcon
#

one of the comments in that lava pack's page: "Thanks a lot! The materials are not animated."

merry field
#

Well, I guess there's a suggestion for a pack that someone could make for the Marketplace

ebon leaf
#

I'm interested by The Maze Generator asset but it looks like it's not updated anymore

#

I need a tiled Maze with different simple shapes

#

Not complex procedural stuff with floors etc

#

I have QMaze on Unity but idk if I can convert it

wooden falcon
#

so why didn't they do a cyber monday sale this year? that one was awesome

merry field
#

What was awesome about the Cyber Monday sale, compared to the this one?

wooden falcon
#

it was one day, more focused

#

and didn't compete with a holiday in the us

#

and people are already primed to buy on it πŸ˜ƒ

merry field
#

One day? I'd be far too indecisive to buy anything there

lean venture
#

By now, I have sales data for 3 days and I can tell you during that one day last year I had about 15 times more sales than in these 3 days.

#

Granted, that ratio is going to drop until the end of the sale, but it certainly won't reach 1-1.

#

I don't know what the problem is, but it looks like the Marketplace has been pretty dead in the last half a year, not just for me.

wooden falcon
#

yup, this sale has been extremely mediocre for me

lean venture
#

Perhaps a little Epic advertising wouldn't hurt.

modern perch
#

I suspect a lot of people (myself included) don't really bother with it any more

merry field
#

I'd also suspect that it's just really hard to find anything because there's so much

#

If you are not looking for anything in particular, how do you find what's there?

#

There's no way to sort by any kind of quality, rating, reviews (there are no reviews), etc.

#

All you can do is sort by newest-to-oldest and by discount

#

Plus I suspect that even going through the list misses out on items because they all rearrange each time you change the page

wooden falcon
#

probably a bit of both

#

I found myself getting bored at about page 20

#

I did end up buying a few things, but not as much as in past sales

#

yah, and that list rearranging thing is really annoying

delicate dove
#

Im glad that I bookmarked things I didnt need right away so I could just open that list and buy what I needed.
(and put the ones I didnt buy in another bookmark folder)

pliant forum
#

As a buyer this was a pretty good sale. Spent around $500 ~.
As a seller I'm quite disappointed, I hear you usually sell multiple times more than you usually do when there is no sale. Can't say I personally have seen any difference

delicate dove
#

im selling about the same, so.. rather useless so far

wooden falcon
#

yah, the deals are great...cause there are so many packs on sale

#

which is why the sales are bad for the sellers πŸ˜ƒ

lean venture
#

@modern perch What's the reason for not bothering anymore?

wooden falcon
#

the only way to get visibility is to have bigger and bigger discounts

modern perch
#

just generally lost interest

#

mostly a quality issue, I think

#

something like half of the things I've purchased haven't really been up to scratch

lean venture
#

According to this year's GDC speech, the number of UE4 devs have increased drastically so I expected the Marketplace interest to rise, if not to remain constant, at the very least

modern perch
#

and finding anything now is basically impossible

#

I can't be arsed to sift through the whole thing to be aware of what's there

#

previously I was fairly aware and would grab what I needed as-and-when

merry field
#

I actually found a third-party custom Marketplace client that someone made, sadly I couldn't get it to work

#

It had extra search and filtering and sorting, but it was from 2015

lean venture
#

Link?

wooden falcon
#

was it allars?

merry field
#

Yes