check check
#Questions about the new feature
hot epoch
trim junco
reddit moment
pale bluff
What
alpine dawn
i realize itd be best to indicate how itd work in the guidelines actually akdjshsys
but this is basically like reddit
dim heath
can we make forums with subforums? Eg: music prod split into music prod feedback (people can make forum posts for each demo) and music prod discussion (forum threads for different things like new techniques, new plugins, learning advice etc.)
pale bluff
The thing about this is if nobody speaks in it for a week it goes away
alpine dawn
respectfully general will never be a forum channel
tired venture
what about the hobbies catagory 😟
alpine dawn
can we make forums with subforums? Eg: music prod split into music prod feedback...
o im not sure what u mean?
plush thicket
oh
dapper igloo
respectfully general will never be a forum channel
i was joking
pale bluff
This channel and meetups are fine as forum channels
plush thicket
new forum channels :O
dapper igloo
Id never pray on the downfall of prd general chat
alpine dawn
i was joking
oh 😭 im so dense sorry
pale bluff
We don't need all of them to be forum
dapper igloo
it’s ok !
sinful hinge
hey
dim heath
o im not sure what u mean?
Is it possible to have a forum channel with separate threads of forum channels?
alpine dawn
oh like threads in forum channels post?
bitter field
can we make forums with subforums? Eg: music prod split into music prod feedback...
it doesnt let you do that i don't think
dim heath
yeah something like that! so forums in forums
dim heath
Ah okay
bitter field
now you could just get multiple forum channels together in one category on the channel list
and pretend those are subforums in a forum
pale bluff
Questions about the new feature
dim heath
I think the main channel that comes to mind that could benefit from being a forum is the music prod feedback channel
So people can reply directly to demos as opposed to people talking over each other in one channel
dapper igloo
maybe
alpine dawn
yeah the music prod feedback channel could maybe work
dapper igloo
although idk if people give that much feedback to be necessary for every single demo to be a separate post
Although would be easier to search thru
alpine dawn
also u can set default reactions for posts so should we just have the posts in this forum channel be 
or something
lost mango
maybe it could help get rid of the issue where people post but dont give any feedback
idk its definitely worth thinking about for sure
pale bluff
Yeah
dapper igloo
also u can set default reactions for posts so should we just have the posts in t...
ya
dim heath
Have to see how much the forum feature gets used
sinful hinge
Honestly waffles over pancakes
pale bluff
Oh yeah the emote changes if it's the most used
React to me with that
Now tap
Go above 5
Has to be a single one
6
Hmm
What
dim heath
Godspeed mods 🫡 every month discord evolves I wonder what discord will be like in a year lol
summer trout
I wonder if it's only for the first message
pale bluff
Oh yeah let's try that
alpine dawn
might be for the first message yeah
pale bluff
Yeah
pale bluff
Yeah it's the first message
alpine dawn
i think theyre just rolling it to random servers
and we just happened to get it
madeoncord still doesnt have it lmao
alpine dawn
dam.
tired venture
i hate the searching feature on mobile
it does not get past like page 8 for me
or i have to go extremely slow
dapper igloo
im hoping there’s not that many channels with forum posts enabled
like i want the talking channels to be as chaotic as they r right now
but maybe nmd can be a forum?
yeah
alpine dawn
nmd im not 100% sure i worry it might kill conversations but potentially it could also work?
yeah
dapper igloo
i mean we do have threads
dapper igloo
nmd im not 100% sure i worry it might kill conversations but potentially it coul...
actually yeah it might discourage talking
pale bluff
How many people are active in nmd
dapper igloo
we just need to use threads more often in there for bigger drops
dapper igloo
How many people are active in nmd
a lot of the server
olive trellis
it does not get past like page 8 for me
Yuuuuuup it gives up 😂
tired venture
i stopped using it when nmf stopped 💔
deft hill
i dont think forums would work very well for general discussion channels where people just talk anyway it would just be confusing and split people up
heady trail
Wtf is this
naive plover
anyone in this forum smoke weed
deft hill
having it for music prod feedback is a decent idea though i think that makes a lot of sense
vale thunder
we need to turn general into a forum channel
Finally some good ideas in this joint
tired venture
Forum
quasi granite
no seriously what is the point of this
lmao
isn't this just the same as threads?
tired venture
no
deft hill
the point is you make a new post per suggestion
ur not supposed to all just chat in it like a channel
deft hill
like that
ember crystal
discord please stop doing this
I mean no harm done, you dont have to use it lol
chilly shale
Rise of gru is the best movie of all time
deft hill
and then people can discuss the suggestion
quasi granite
I mean no harm done, you dont have to use it lol
but i must know why it EXISTS
deft hill
the suggestion channel is taken down instead of this
austere socket
ember crystal
but i must know why it EXISTS
I’m sure some people find functionality out of it!
pale bluff
Lightyear was mid af
ember crystal
Even if we don’t necessarily
alpine dawn
a week with no activity
vale thunder
I think 1 week with no activity
vale thunder
That's how threads work so I'm sure that's how this works
quasi granite
what so some doofus can just keep posting in one of theses and they last FOREVER?
WHY DISCORD. WHY.
pale bluff
Hmm
tired venture
what so some doofus can just keep posting in one of theses and they last FOREVER...
or the mods can just .. delete it
dapper igloo
any1 can start threads too and they’re more spontaneous than forum posts id say
deft hill
ryan thats the same as threads
quasi granite
ryan thats the same as threads
THEN WHY IS THIS A THING? WE ALREADY HAVE THREADS.
I AM CONFUSED
pale bluff
I understand threads and meetups but that all it should be for
quasi granite
i just do not understand what the practicality of this is
pale bluff
I think
vale thunder
because threads are like sidebar conversations in a chat
this is like a forum board
deft hill
LOOK OUTSIDE OF THIS FORUM
vale thunder
they serve different purposes
quasi granite
but what's the actual difference
deft hill
THERE ARE MULITIPLE POSTS
dapper igloo
this is a forum board which is way different
deft hill
ANYONE CAN MAKE APOST
dapper igloo
omg
summer trout
I'm pretty sure threads were pretty chaotic when they first came out so just give this a week or so and then we'll see how useful forums are
vale thunder
I literally just explained the difference
dapper igloo
because it’s easier to search and you can actually find each individual post
quasi granite
I'm pretty sure threads were pretty chaotic when they first came out so just giv...
THANK YOU
deft hill
its like reddit mcq
quasi granite
SO THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE A BETTER VERSION OF THREADS
FUCKING THANK YOU FOR
EXPLAINING THAT
dapper igloo
omg
quasi granite
UNLIKE EVERYONE ELSE HERE WHO'S LIKE
vale thunder
not necessarily
quasi granite
"WAAAH, WAAAH, DONTCHA GET IT, BOOMER?"
ember crystal
Thats what people have been saying bro 💀
dapper igloo
girl not this
forest remnant
??
ember crystal
LMFAO
lost mango
you're acting like a boomer rn
vale thunder
This isn't like a better threads bro
forest remnant
McQ chill .
quasi granite
okay.
vale thunder
it's a different thing
deft hill
u are mcq
dapper igloo
Jesus Christ
alpine dawn
????
quasi granite
...
deft hill
forest remnant
?????
quasi granite
sorru it's uh
ember crystal
???
forest remnant
okay uh, this is getting uncomfortable
deft hill
LOL
quasi granite
understood! :3
ember crystal
Discord just implemented a funny new wacky feature 
vale thunder
Okay #997913478608199890 is a great use for the feature actually
forest remnant
but yeah, I assume this will most likely be a test run to see if this can work for suggestions and meetups.
We'll see what we can use this for exactly after prob a few days of it existing
vale thunder
Being able to just search for your show is a great use of this
tired venture
whats hapopoening
ember crystal
Being able to just search for your show is a great use of this
True
vale thunder
a lot easier than threads
dapper igloo
To be y2k nostalgic
vale thunder
for that purpose
deft hill
yeah its way better than someone sending a meetup request or suggestion and it just gets buried
vale thunder
To be y2k nostalgic
LOL
vale thunder
turn gaming into one so we can remake gamefaqs
dapper igloo
maybe movies and tv forums ?
ember crystal
Also temporary chats for like livestreams and stuff
vale thunder
nah this doesn't work for that
dapper igloo
idk i wish discord made it so forums could exist inside a text channel
frigid path
This is still weird af lol
vale thunder
ehh
dapper igloo
no i don’t think live stream needs it
forest remnant
i doubt two livestreams would happen like that so i think our livestream channel should stay
vale thunder
it's weird cause we're using it as general rn lmaoooooo
quasi granite
so should we even...bother with threads?
vale thunder
yes
dapper igloo
too clunky
ember crystal
nah this doesn't work for that
Really? I feel like it would be good cause after an hour of inactivity it deletes itself
frigid path
it's weird cause we're using it as general rn lmaoooooo
Tru
pale bluff
The only channels I see this working in is suggestions and meetups
vale thunder
Really? I feel like it would be good cause after an hour of inactivity it delete...
Nah it just auto archives
deft hill
or movies if they get a ton of discussion
ember crystal
Ah fair enough
dapper igloo
threads are still useful because they collapse within a channel
this is like replacing/making new channels
deft hill
i also think threads are good because if you just have a ton of forums everywhere everyone would make them and it would become cluttered
vale thunder
Like a said earlier, threads are great cause they're like sidebars in a main conversation
pale bluff
If I wanted I could kill this forum rn
dapper igloo
who just used that cursed retweet emote im scared
ember crystal
this is like replacing/making new channels
Temporary ones at that
quasi granite
i already feel like the mere existence of this is cluttered, but SOOOO BE IT.
dapper igloo
omg
frigid path
If I wanted I could kill this forum rn
Do et
deft hill
i think for movies and tv and gaming and stuff its better if a mod makes a thread only when needed than having a ton of forum posts with no one talking except one person
pale bluff
No
quasi granite
anyway. i am going back to #general so i no longer have to deal with this nightmare realm
dapper igloo
i think nmd everyone should be able 2 make threads ill be real…
tired venture
especially porter .. he gets super overshadowed ..
ember crystal
Yeah maybe for second sky channels
vale thunder
i think nmd everyone should be able 2 make threads ill be real…
for reall
alpine dawn
ok so tl;dr
- threads: sidechats for main convos
- forum posts: chats for channels that dont need main convos
dapper igloo
literally
deft hill
more or less
forest remnant
TL;DR
Threads are basically: Channel is about fruit, make a thread about berry discussion
Forums are basically: Forum is about fandoms, make new posts for different fandoms
dapper igloo
i don’t think any channel with a standard flow of conversation should be forumised
tired venture
yeah see he gets overshadowed 😟
dapper igloo
this is for stuff where u just post not start convos
and then people engage with the post
not engaging in a main conversation
ember crystal
this is for stuff where u just post not start convos
I think it could be both depending on the topic
Like what was said before, about specific Nurture Live shows
forest remnant
Also unlike threads, they aren't hidden! When you click the forum on the server, you can see all posts to see what you want to join in
deft hill
i feel like the majority of channels still work better as normal channels
ember crystal
People can share their photos and videos and talk about a specific ahow
Without cluttering up main chat
dapper igloo
i think nurture live meetups is a bit dead and specific for just a forum
maybe it should be combined with omega’s idea?
ember crystal
i think nurture live meetups is a bit dead and specific for just a forum
Not just meetups, like just shows in general lol
But I think mainly its a decluttering tool
dapper igloo
like u can post about meet-ups, post show pics, etc i feel like a nurture live forum would be good
because ppl still definitely talk in that channel and has a main conversation flow
but it could benefit a lot from the forum structure
deft hill
everyones downvoting u ryan
quasi granite
but i tried my best
ember crystal
Ratio moment
vale thunder
McQ about to lose reddit karma for this
deft hill
trueeee
tired venture
😟 not the karma
dapper igloo
They should add discord karma to this
quasi granite
McQ about to lose reddit karma for this
:(
ember crystal
thats the next step
After they add the read receipts theyve been talking about
silk cypress
they should make it that if you have negative discord karma you get killed
deft hill
After they add the read receipts theyve been talking about
if they do that im deleting discord forever
ember crystal
LMFAO
ember crystal
Damn how many people you leaving on read 💀
ember crystal
read receipts are just for freaks and i stand by that
Valid
deft hill
its like having location on
naive plover
if ppl have them on i dont trust it
deft hill
same
naive plover
tho i do kno ppl who have it on so they dont forget to respond to things cuz then the pressures on
deft hill
it honestly feels really unhealthy for everyone involved
quasi granite
where did my forum post go :(
naive plover
sometimes i dont wanna respond to something immediately!! and i dont want that to make ppl feel bad!!!!
deft hill
exactly
alpine dawn
exactly !!
forest remnant
wait, just a test to see if you can link the post like a normal channel #997921244148150323
u can, cool
dapper igloo
they should make it that if you have negative discord karma you get killed
YASS😍
quasi granite
i was starting to like this feature and now i don't
dapper igloo
idk i luv it
vale thunder
yeah!
quasi granite
idk i luv it
but you deleted my forum 
dapper igloo
i what
forest remnant
i assume anything on the server's channel list can be tagged
vale thunder
it's pretty cool
quasi granite
well not you specifically but
vale thunder
I think
alpine dawn
nah u cant filter by tags i dont think
deft hill
i dont see an option but ig if they auto archive it doesnt really matter
vale thunder
no you can
alpine dawn
jk u can
vale thunder
I just checked a different server
deft hill
the tags would help alot if you made all of nuture live forums
alpine dawn
that will be useful
deft hill
bc then you can tag like meetup vs discussion or whatever
dim heath
Another use case for forums is spoilers for specific new things in all the entertainment channels - though idk whether normal threads are better
vale thunder
The Discord JS development server has this for like making support tickets and it's really handy to filter by tag
alpine dawn
actually u know i could do "EUROPE" "USA" "CANADA" tags for nurture live meetups
vale thunder
actually u know i could do "EUROPE" "USA" "CANADA" tags for nurture live meetups
yesssss
pale bluff
Slowmode for 6 hours 💀
dapper igloo
me walking into a new forum post like “.. u-uh.. hewwo?? it’s so lonely in hewe… ‘u’ “
alpine dawn
ill do that
forest remnant
yeah, that'd be rlly useful!
pale bluff
Bruh
vale thunder
maybe festival also since that's different?
tired venture
me walking into a new forum post like “.. u-uh.. hewwo?? it’s so lonely in hewe…...
thats me
vale thunder
I think you can do multiple tags
deft hill
nah
alpine dawn
yeah u can do multiple tags
deft hill
this is a good complimentary feature
alpine dawn
only the first one u set shows though
tired venture
we should just delete every channel and have only 1 forum thing
jagged siren
👍🍞
deft hill
we should just delete every channel and have only 1 forum thing
true
dapper igloo
We should just delete every channel
quasi granite
We should just delete
forest remnant
prd is over folks, just porter robinson forum
alpine dawn
ohhh u can require ppl to add a tag before posting
deft hill
thats sick
ember crystal
ohhh u can require ppl to add a tag before posting
Oh nice
dapper igloo
omg the squished potaro
forest remnant
ooh that'd be super useful for the meetups
alpine dawn
meetups yeah, suggestions ill leave it so that u dont have to
dapper igloo
should remakes have a forum setup ?
alpine dawn
hmmm
ember crystal
Maybe for different songs or types
alpine dawn
not sure for this one
forest remnant
there's already so much in the remakes channel tbh
alpine dawn
actually yeah could be cool
tired venture
oh wth
dapper igloo
i feel like i only see short bursts of conversation
tired venture
you cant get rid of a ping until you type a message
deft hill
what happens when its archived do they disappear for non mods
deft hill
because you wouldnt want your remakes to be archived and go away probably
forest remnant
i feel like remakes isnt active enough with multiple convos to warrant a forum tbh
vale thunder
oh wtf archive does take them away?
forest remnant
mods can still see it (we just never got an archive role,,,,,,,,,,)
deft hill
i was thinking for #you-might-like too but then if you cant scroll down the list past like a week i feel like people might not like that
alpine dawn
for #you-might-like it would be cool but honestly i havent found a way to see locked/archived posts
so they would just disappear
dapper igloo
ok nvm
dapper igloo
unless discord adds an archive feature to forum posts then we shouldn’t change the remakes and yml channels
dapper igloo
perfect for nuture live stuff tho
I love nuture live
deft hill
agreed
vale thunder
Wait they're right there lmao
dapper igloo
Guys I just sneezed
vale thunder
Once I took this chat out of side bar they showed up?
alpine dawn
huh where do u see them
forest remnant
we'll see if discord makes archives visible soon
forest remnant
Wait they're right there lmao
wai huh
dapper igloo
alpine dawn
i straight up only see them
vale thunder
I'm on desktop
vale thunder
I took this chat of sidebar and they showed up
forest remnant
based light mode
vale thunder
reload client?
dapper igloo
omg
vale thunder
well W
dapper igloo
jumpscare
forest remnant
oh wha t
deft hill
oh yeah i see them now
alpine dawn
well one of them atleast
vale thunder
archive jumpscare
tired venture
new discord updaet!
quasi granite
Hm, so this might still be a bit buggy
deft hill
nah its fine i just archived another one
deft hill
archive
vale thunder
I see it
quasi granite
Vince likes discord
alpine dawn
i locked the "uh, what is this feature?" one and it doesnt show up for me
deft hill
you can archive your own posts
vale thunder
vale thunder
i locked the "uh, what is this feature?" one and it doesnt show up for me
I see it but I can't talk in it
deft hill
wait
vale thunder
it's like mod archiving a thread
alpine dawn
I see it but I can't talk in it
yeah i locked it
but i cant see it
i can only see the other 2
alpine dawn
forest remnant
hmm
deft hill
bc when u interact with it yore added to it
alpine dawn
i wasnt part of test archive
tired venture
i wasnt apart of the two that are there
deft hill
bc i ony see 2
vale thunder
no that can't be right cause kyl is literally an admin
deft hill
oh hm
dapper igloo
another attempt by the corrupt mod team to stifle our need for thicctaro…
quasi granite
but you were able to full-on delete the post i made as a test right?
alpine dawn
that too
vale thunder
they have to be able to see everything
alpine dawn
yeah u can full on delete
those will be gone forever
but the ones i locked or archived arent supposed to disappear
lament arch
Wow I love Reddit!
tired venture
I do toO!
forest remnant
this reddit skin is dope
quasi granite
I mean, akshuuaaalllltltllllly this isn't like reddit
dapper igloo
new discord lore
lament arch
Kyl you can’t do this to me I have a test to study for
alpine dawn
😭
dapper igloo
Can we have more dogeposting in prd
alpine dawn
nah but fr its kinda annoying that they just disappear
lament arch
Stop making me play around with new features
forest remnant
idk where it is
thinking its like archive and its still slowly being fully implemented in all servers
deft hill
im gonna set the thicctaro one to archive in an hour and see how it goes
deft hill
see i locked the "test archive" post and now its just
it looks like only mods can lock though i cant even do it on my own
alpine dawn
ohh
forest remnant
the way the meme thread just disappeared
deft hill
on my own post i can only archive
alpine dawn
multiple ppl reported the issue in the partners server so i assume its a known issue
deft hill
ohh yeah probably then
at least they dont dissapear from archiving that would be worse
lament arch
So Kyl how long before we change the GFF and ARG channels in madeoncord to this format
alpine dawn
visibly theres still a lot of issues lmao
alpine dawn
Y'know this *could* be useful for event night chats.
actually i dont think it is ngl
quasi granite
Hm
deft hill
yeah me either
quasi granite
Then threads are better?
alpine dawn
i like the "mess" having a single chat does (+ ppl have to join them still to talk etc)
nah just having a main chat
deft hill
yeah theres no real benefit to it not being
alpine dawn
just better for ppl reacting too
deft hill
its just like a twitch chat
alpine dawn
So Kyl how long before we change the GFF and ARG channels in madeoncord to this ...
gff nah, gff meetups definitely, arg channels probably
but would be whenever we get them and we dont so 😭
quasi granite
even though I understand this feature kinda I don't entirely get what this is gonna be useful for aside from wanting a "thread" that looks a little different from a normal thread
alpine dawn
its just like a twitch chat
exactly !!
quasi granite
guess it'll just take some playing around with
deft hill
say i wanna meet up with people at a porter robinson show in chicago
a small fraction of the server is in chicago or the surrounding area
lament arch
even though I understand this feature kinda I don't entirely get what this is go...
Easy place to see all the treads relating to a specific topic without having to join the threads
deft hill
i can post in a normal channel and ask but the relevant people probably will not see and my message will get buried
if i make a forum post instead not only does it make it much more visible for the relevant people but it also give a place for us to talk about it
quasi granite
if i make a forum post instead not only does it make it much more visible for th...
but what I don't get is why you wouldn't just make a thread (I made a Red Rocks thread in the meetup channel and it worked fine)
dapper igloo
basically this is like if discord channels could be joined via subreddit feed vs threads where discord channels are being joined via twitter timeline
dapper igloo
but what I don't get is why you *wouldn't* just make a thread (I made a Red Rock...
because these just work better for that specific instance
deft hill
yeah a thread still isnt as visible its really just another channel
quasi granite
then why the hell are they keeping threads lol
I assume this would be a replacement
deft hill
i get what ur saying that theyre not Super different but they are still and have their purposes
alpine dawn
bc theyre useful for side convos in a main convo channel
alpine dawn
i get what ur saying that theyre not Super different but they are still and have...
^ yeah i get u too
dapper igloo
because they’re more spontaneous
alpine dawn
also is this good for #997913478608199890
quasi granite
maybe I just don't see people using threads so often idk
dapper igloo
this is a formal forum
deft hill
because for example when a new pog movie comes out and everyones talking about it we dont need 10 different people making different forum posts
we just need a mod to make a thread
dapper igloo
but threads are supposed to be spontaneous and short and very hyperspecific to the moment, like a conversation that gets too long
deft hill
exactly
quasi granite
but threads are supposed to be spontaneous and short and very hyperspecific to t...
I guess the problem is I don't see people use threads that way lmao
dapper igloo
yeah because discord doesn’t show threads lol
quasi granite
we still have the thread for the Russia-Ukraine Situation from months back
dapper igloo
threads also are useful for decluttering the channel list
deft hill
we still have the thread for the Russia-Ukraine Situation from months back
see thats a good example that would be worse as a forum
its good as a thread
dapper igloo
like if we didn’t have #963891956142985256 and #wordle in threads it would be a mess
deft hill
true
tired venture
i am getting it completely 😄
deft hill
theyre still like fairly vague discussion channels
dapper igloo
yeah the russia ukraine channel is best as a thread because it’s not rly a permanent discussion but it’s also a conversation
lost mango
also is this good for <#997913478608199890>
yeah this is good
dapper igloo
omg
alpine dawn
ohhhh true actually omg sorry
lost mango
swag
alpine dawn
it is Renamed™️
quasi granite
alright I understand now
mystic lantern
omg what is this
outer slate
where is home ?
dusty charm
this is actually so cool tbh
frigid path
Why does it?
alpine dawn
where is home ?
home not available for us unfortunately :(
atleast for now
actually ill try requesting for it rn
dapper igloo
what is home
alpine dawn
not sure how to describe it tbh, we have it over in madeoncord if u wanna check
just basically a like "highlights of the server that happened recently" tab basically
dapper igloo
the algorithm seems a bit messy right now but i like this feature
are mods able to move stuff around and add/remove messages from the home tab?
alpine dawn
yeah ! i think its taking replies or reacts as proof of engagement to show ppl messages
yes
add no but remove yes
nor move
actually we can only remove stuff from it LOL
but we can pin messages to it
mystic lantern
this is so weird
what is the purpose of this said feature, other than randomly selected highlights
main schooner
this is really confusing wtf
one of the most unnecessary additions i've ever seen Discord make
dapper igloo
no i love this
it’s like if u wanted to like. Catch up on big moments in the server
Although it needs work
i don’t think it should be putting rly depressing and personal messages up there lol so they need to figure out something else other than reaction count based sorting
deft hill
yeah theyre basically just taking starboards that a lot of servers have
the only difference is those use a specific emote for reactions so people can intentionally vote to put stuff on the board
honestly if they just make it so you can set the emote im down for that its fun
boreal perch
am I the only one that always has to re-read all of the forum threads on the server so the server isn't marked as being unread anymore even when there's no new messages?
alpine dawn
i think u can edit it here
oh actually nvm im not sure
but i think right clicking on the channel and clicking "mark as read" should work? unless thats what ure already doing idk
lament arch
You can always right click the server and mark as read
alpine dawn
that too
boreal perch
You can always right click the server and mark as read
that somehow does not fix it
its still marked as unread after and only when I go through every forum thread on here it goes away