#latest-updates
1 messages Ā· Page 43 of 1
oh ok, Belfast and all that jazz if i remember correctly
Yeah I am from Belfast
what can you tell me about Pro-Treaty and Anti-Treaty forces
i would like to more about Irish Civil War and Troubles
We don't learn much about the Irish civil war
Mostly about the troubles
And I'm ngl I don't know a whole lot
i am not from the EU , so we havent been really taught about this back here
i only know from outside media
I have stories from the troubles but not like knowledge
My grandad stole a British soldiers gun when he was detained š„¶
Well I mean
It was a war for Catholic rights
Catholics in the 1960s were treated like black people in the USA at the time
Treated unequally
So there were marches and protests and the british fired on the protesters
have you had any beef with Scots since they are predominantly Protestant?
Nah scots are chill
I don't have a problem with protestants
Only ones that are actively anti Irish
is it like a three way war
or more like united by disdain for British imperialism?
Wdym a three way war
It was republicans/nationalists fighting the british army and loyalist paramilitaries
Protestant Scots hate the guts of the Crown, historically i believe
but i suspect anti-Irish Scots were minority, yes?
Yeah
Well
Ulster-scots are kinda a thing
They are kind of just unionists
Gtg to school
so by HoI4 terms, they are vocal supporters of the BuF then
yeah take care man š
Cya
To put it very simply: pro treaty liked the agreement with Britain to get independence after the war. Anti-treaty is people that didnāt agree with the treaty since they wouldnāt have Northern Ireland
And they think they deserved more from their efforts
So right after independence they had a civil war
And they though it was a betrayal by their fellow Irish men
Germany + Navy Rework
Japan + Resistance/Occupation rework
Would be interesting twist
Navy rework makes no sense since itās apart of man of guns
If theyāre adding German merchant raiders & mutiny thatād fit
why would resistance occupation even matter
Japan should come with the navy rework and Germany resistance. While U-Boats were German, navy was kind of japans whole thing as an island nation
Yeah
Japanās occupation by the US after ww2ā¦
Japan was occupied and administered by the Allies of World War II from the surrender of the Empire of Japan on September 2, 1945, at the war's end until the Treaty of San Francisco took effect on April 28, 1952. The occupation, led by the American military with support from the British Commonwealth and under the supervision of the Far Eastern Co...
Occupation/Restructuring would be a huge addition to post-game
i agree
game desperately needs late-game content
I agree with late game content, but feel that would deal more with diplomacy and peace conferences than occupation. Germany would definitely make more sense for an occupation update
Especially since it was carved up post war by the different powers
Shouldnāt just focus on Germany situation. Something applicable to any nation would be best
Like the UK being split up.
Should HoI4 get minigames?
Navy Battle: Battleship minigame pops up
Spy mission: Have to solve a cryptogram
No that would be very annoying and doesent really fit in with the game
Yeh
If they ever plan of hoi5 i really want to be able to zoom into the actual battle, like actually seeing the soldiers shoot eachother and tanks rolling into cities, and if they also add a ww1 mode then it would be so cool to be able to see trench battles occur infront of your eyes, that single thing would make me buy the game even if it was 100$
Like seeing tank divisions role out onto the battlefield and destroy the enemy
Bro I am NOT going to want to play Battleship when I'm already trying to fight the Soviets and carry the Italians in Africa
Or at all in a MP game
clausewitz engine:
nah but it would unload everything else
like the front would be covered by clouds
well i guess it would still be laggy
but thats not my problem!
Navy doesn't really need a rework. The only thing I'm hoping to change is to make its research easier and maybe tweak a bit of its production.
maybe separate research slots for navy and air because personally i never focus on air and navy until like mid game
What about Minesweeper?
Would you want to play Minesweeper while microing the Eastern Front? Probably not
Hoi4 is a game about multi tasking
I mean like if you have a field to de-mine⦠you could do so via minesweeper
Hunting for battleships via battleship⦠more immersive
Instead of just clicking a button
Make something that starts at 1900 and goes to 2000
yes
Make spy agency better
add it some stories like CK3
Like your spy personally telling what did he got
What did he faced
How did he managed
During the process
Make officers a separate army mechanic
Balancing the army like that
If u train less officers
Ur army sucks
If u train officers but bad quality
They suck
If u train good officers and in correct Ammouth
Ur army and them is good
Officers would have decisions like
Assaulting together with the army
Attack bonus
But they can die easily
Inspecting the field closely
Attack bonus less
But less death chance
Etc
Monuments Men⦠etc.
Less the navy layouts and moreso how sea zones function.
for teaser lol
judging from the time frame between last dev diary and release dates, we can expect new dlc at December at best
hope they will surprise us and release DLC as soon as possible
Dev diaries start October 3rd, so not just a teaser
An actual confirmation
but dev diaries are sort of teaser/trailers on their own
just in text form
so we arent getting the real thing yet, that's what i meant
Not necessarily, they said dev diaries would come out quicker this time around
counting the seconds š¤
Soon...
Guys when next HOI4 DLC?
We get news on the 3rd of october that is the date which the first dev diary comes
Aight
So in this date we may get sneak peeks?
Prob so ig we will see which nations are in it etc like the last dlcs
Perf ty
no problem
I think we might get the Kaiser path preview on November 9th of this year
Because thats the day the Kaiser abdicated in 1918
You mean like the current path gets more worked out with focues etc?
Yeah
I hope we get mittleafrika as a puppet formable
Similar to Italian East Africa
And we can get unique formable puppets in Ukraine, Belarus, the baltic states, and finland
Wasnt ukraine a thing austria hungary wanted as a puppet if they would of won ww1?
Yes
Ngl thats sounds interesting and it would then makes sense to play as austria hungary cause then you got the focues you need for those things
Also I wouldnāt be surprised if Austria, Hungary, and Czechoslovakia are updated too
All 4 of them are related to each other historically
Germany annexed Austria in 1938
I mean those three are direct neighbors with germany so ig we get a germany rework, an austrian focus tree and for the other two you mentioned get also a rework would be cool if that happens
Hungary and Austria should both be able to form Austria Hungary similar to Poland and Lithunaia
Also Austria should be fascist
Yeah austria (my home country) has such a rich history with those countries
Yeah i mean the vaterlandsfront was in fact fascist but not that extreme as the german party i think
not sure though i never really read into it
Germany tried to stage a coup there in 1934
Italy ended up threatening war with Germany
Because the coup almost succeeded
Hitler ended up backing down
Germany wasnt ready for war in 1934
Even Italy could beaten have them
Well makes sense he wanted them as allies and not as enemies as they needed some for the war against the brits and france etc
Yeah they did have a strong army i think a bit bigger then the germans at the time
Germany only had 100,000 men in 1934
I see well makes sense i mean they where still building up
Wdym? like with the reason for the war?
Germany but they donāt go after the Jewish people could win
Getting rid of a lot of manpower is not usually a good decision⦠not going after Jewish people would helpā¦
A Germany focus tree where they become Jewish Germany would be interesting to see.
HAHAHHAHA
no
They wouldnāt have the manpower drain etc.
Einstein would have stayed in Germany⦠etc
They would have still the manpower drain of people dying first of all
Second of all them occupying other places would have still lead to manpower problems
not to mention fighting against the ussr britain and the americans
Germany winning has such a small chance even without the holocaust
Yeah and lets be honest invading the ussr was one of the reasons the germans lost in the first place
And the fact that Germany didn't have the economy for a long term war
Fr like they could of eliminated wave after wave but the quantity strat would of overran the germans either way and like you said their eco was build on a short term war
Like after france fell the germans wanted peace with the brits but they declined which marked the beginning of the end
That is something completely different than just not killing jews
thats completely alt hist
I agree that germany could have gotten rid of versailles democratically
So literally it didnt cause germanies defeat and germany still would have lost
thank you
It would have delayed it⦠if they did everything else the same
yea
so.....
nothing changed
Yea if the nazis wouldnt be nazis then they wouldnt have lost is a dogshit take
not to forget that the people still would have been needed to arm which I am pretty sure doesnt happen out of nowhere
nah thats cope
Iām just saying itās an interesting scenario.
So "Make Hitler not Hitler, and they win the war"
SO true
its so bad
and even then who is gonna feed and clothe all those different soldiers
the nazis had rations an materials, the main things that were needed were oil and manpower, though even then it wouldn't have made a real difference
Also Jewish Germany is just ironic
"guys its all hitlers fault. trust me bro if hitler listened to me it would have turned out different. the wheremacht werent nazis guys it was just hitler" -nazi general #4500000
it would be interesting if like
they would buff democratic germany by saying you could get manpower from soviet turncoats or smth\
It was definitely the major part of Germany⦠not just Hitler. Youād have to have some kind of event that radically alters German perception.
Germany should get military spirits like italy fr
Maybe an assassination attempt is foiled and the rescuer turns out to be Jewish. ā¦
Or werhmacht and ss balance of power
Thereās an alt history series where the protagonist are able to stop antisemitism in its tracks but thatās all the way in the 1600s⦠they even have an antisemitism kristalnacht.
Add in some pro-Jewish ww1 propaganda
An estimated 100,000 German Jewish military personnel served in the German Army during World War I, of whom 12,000 were killed in action. The Iron Cross was awarded to 18,000 German Jews during the war.
While strong attempts were made during the Nazi era to suppress the Jewish contribution and even to blame them for Germany's defeat, using the s...
Probably wouldn't change much tbh, Hitler liked some Jews, like the doctor who treated his mother
He would probably be like "Yeah, he's an honourary Aryan" or something like that
why was hitler such a characterš š
bro just handing out titles
Best division template for naval guards? Italy btw
Just use your normal infantry templates, 9/0
But stick a mountaineer on some important ports
Mountaineer is 35.2 width mountaineer block
Any guess which continent might receive next DLC?
I was thinking in Europe but there only remain Belgium Ireland and Luxembourg
And Listenbourg
So probably Asia
Or middle east
Rework on Germany focus tree really?
I hope so
probably
na
not even probabaly
%99.99
%00.01 is they only realese nuke rework and everyone gets mad
Why tho Germany already have a focus tree
I was expecting Saudi Arabia not gonna lie
it is outdated
brazil is stronger than germany atm
every country with pre-nsb focuses is really weak right now
of course paradox doesnt care about balance and a free patch doesnt bring money so they will re-release-remaked dlcs for older ones
the german DLC is also included with another countries
so those remains countries will receive as well a rework?
I think what the person means is that the german focus is to small and old then the other nations (take italy as a example they got a bigger focus now because of the by blood alone dlc) so ig they will rework them and after that we get a saudi arabia dlc
netherlands and USa has a poor focus tree
short
True but lets be real they should finish the european continent first then work on the rest like america, middle east, asia etc
so taking into account your point, after german rework we should get ireland and belgium DLC
yeah but would also be good to get them in a small dlc and not in a big dlc
but yeah america needs to be reworked aswell
same goes for the rest
i think belgium will probably be in the germany dlc
along with austria and maybe luxembourg
because they usually make 3-4 ish trees per dlc
germanic dlc
Prob so yeah would make sense tbh
yes
feeling like DLC after this one maybe the pacific war rework (usa + japan)
Germany but they didnāt do holocaust and so Einstein helps them develop nukes
or maybe country pack with USA, Canada, Mexico, possible Central America
Middle East imo would be next
could be middle east (since its wanted + it hasnt gotten anything since 2015), or it could be some other world region lol
though i hope to god that they'll get big trees, and not small ones (looking at rt56 with Iran + Iraq having small trees)
If this was a combined ww1/ww2 game all regions would be on the tableā¦. Africa/Middle East were more ww1 heavy
during WW2, they had to do smth similar to late 20th century iraq where the USA invaded it, but this time it was british + french resistance
The Anglo-Iraqi War was a British-led Allied military campaign during the Second World War against the Kingdom of Iraq, then ruled by Rashid Gaylani who had seized power in the 1941 Iraqi coup d'Ʃtat with assistance from Germany and Italy. The campaign resulted in the downfall of Gaylani's government, the re-occupation of Iraq by the British, an...
Lots of stuff happened in Middle East for ww2, but thereās not really a focus on it
should be one
Maybe by learning the history of a region people will understand the region a tad bit more
One could hope
The Middle East had Israeli insurgencies⦠they even assassinated a British guy. And the previous war in Iraq & Iran⦠I couldnāt find much about what was going on in Africa (other than the Italy/Ethiopia stuff)
although
Secret Belgium focus?
North africa campaign
I bet they could add egypt as a british protectorate
Or some french colonies could have semi autonomy
Because im pretty sure only north african france had a very tight grip of control
Most of the real bad stuff that happened in Germany happened after Einstein left to America
He left in 1932, before Hitler came to power
man are we gonna get any leaks on the upcoming dlc
october 3rd will be the dev diary
so basically a leak
Radiation leaks are not good
But landless adventurer mechanic for hoi4 looks really cool
should be a thing for Democratic š©šŖ only to make it more fun
Cause of the German castle and Wunderwaffe its going to be a Germany Rework
My theory is reverse waking thr tiger
Germany + European states, and Japan
i doubt it since next year is the anniversary of the nuking of hiroshima and nagasaki + surrender of japan
you rly think they gonna make a reverse waking the tiger, when they got perfect timing for a new japanese dlc next year with america?
Yes
Well maybe
I think they're gonna try to Give Focuses to all of the European starting Countries
Because remember Germany is the one famously known for "war ending weapons"
And adding a Japan rework would just be a bundle
japan probs will be in a different dlc
im hoping its with siam, indonesia, malaysia and philippines
Germany tree should just be prio for rework. They could go on and on with it, like they did Italy
italy and soviet trees are just a masterpiece
wish all majors were built like them
also wish that china was a major
Einstein fled in 1933
thats what she said
Devs said Japan has been modified with this dlc
Because Japan is ālosing more often to Chinaā
So, do with that what you will
This is what a dev said in a Reddit post
A Pacific war rework? I would imagine something like TFB
But the islands need to not be one tile
makes sense, japan used to push china all the way to 80-90 capitulation and then get stuck but now 1 out of 3 times japan either gets stuck on the yellow river for a year or simply loses manchuria and signs a peacedeal
i'd say they sould give japan some bonuses to make it easier to take the coast of china but give the inland states modifiers to make them harder to take
They canāt do that, remember that people play this game for ahistorical
Maybe provide naval bonuses/attack bonuses for Japan capturing the islands
Alt history where the Philippines become a state-thing of the US and Japan does too, avoiding ww2 pacific
Can u imagine if Japan became part of the USA?
(Pre-ww2)
maybe not
i would say the more islands japan takes the more usa and the allies have a debuff against germany
if japan gets attack bonuses against usa or vice versa then its impossible to even fight in the pacific
this makes absolutely no sense
i remember the hoi4 devs talking about how the mod they use for their multiplayer games does that
maybe what they could do is if democratic USA loses any core provinces in the mainland then they'd have the option to keep fighting with a massive war support and stability debuff which would almost guarantee strikes or make a scripted peace deal which would give the pacific to japan and kick them out of the allies
that completely invalidates the idea that "there would be a rifle behind every blade of grass"
then along with the war support and stability debuff also give them a defense in core territory modifier, the americans may be armed to the teeth but breaking the idea that they could not be conquered should have shook the nation quite a bit, at least enough for the people to demand an end to the war
this would also make the USA ai (or player) reluctant to fight for the phillipines and the european colonies with their navy since it could lead to the japanese player making a small invasion of the mainland to give them the debuff
you forget the sheer impact pearl harbor had on public opinion
American foreign involvement has always been America retaliating because someone touched our boats
literally
Except maybe Korea
even in 1940, 60% supported aiding the united kingdom in the war
pearl harbor angered the americans but hawai wasn't a state and it was a surprise attack, a full blown invasion of the mainland would have proven the japanese (or german) capability to invade them and it would make them more reluctant to keep the war going
pearl harbor happens and suddenly 97% are all for taking the war to the japs
^^^^^^
Even if they did. We would want to kick them out
Last time I checked, country's want to defend themselves
yes, that's exactly why an actual sucessful invasion may have scared the americans into a conditional peace
No, we would have simply tried to push them into the sea
no american would be scared of the japanese at that point
If we somehow lose LA, we would simply try to push them out
Japan was waiting for us to invade their home islands to bleed us dry for a conditional surrender
and what if that fails? i highly doubt is realistic for japan to have to fight all the way to new york just to make the americans surrender
You think it would?
The Japanese supply lines would be stretched
They canāt do that. That only works for historical games
Hawaii would have needed to fallen first
Japan may get like a morale buff at most as a national spirit
The IJN even then would be stretched to its limits
Even then I doubt this
i highly doubt is realistic for japan to have to fight all the way to new york just to make the americans surrender
it would be realistic
What
They were dying in China
How would Japan, a country already fighting China and having issues there, be able to cross almost 2k miles of a country on the other side of the Pacific
The American Navy must be asleep and not having new ships being built
it would be realistic for the united states to never surrender
read
I thought you were saying it would be realistic to cross the US
i feel like you're highly understimating the isolationism sentiment in america
i feel like you're highly underestimating the impact of pearl harbor
My dude, isolationism basically dies when your ships got bombed
you touch american boats and nobody cares about isolationism anymore
You may go back to isolationism AFTER the war
and it would be revived the moment the japanese cross the border from california into arizona
But otherwise you are a downer
^
no??
never even got to alaska
Most US casualties up there were from friendly fire accidents with us and the Canadians
i feel like you guys have completely forgotten this is a HOI4 discussion
The alutian islands or however they are spelt are Alaskan
yeah, the aleutian islands were the furthest they got
You forgot hoi4 is a total war game
You want 1 piece of land from a country 3 thousand miles away? Go to London
Or whatever the capital is
england is 1000 times an easier to invade country even though their historical resolve to fight the germans even in their own soil was greater than the americans, besides there is literally something that is exactly what im advocating for, it's called the sino-japanese scripted peace that happens when the japanese lose to china
wth
warsaw just switches from capital supply hub to a regular one
every few days in game
30 minutes of hel?
My first (failed) attempt at least
Went well until like late 1940
oof, a little more and the germans would have switched their attention to the russians
yeah, I think I would have done it if I could access the Katowice resources
What do you guys think of a thing like landless adventurers being brought to hoi4?
(Codename: Rise to Power)
mercenaries maybe? wouldn't make a lot of sense historically but it could be cool, perhaps they could be sponsored by countries to deploy their troops and gain resouces
Hitler was a private and rose through the ranks to be in charge of Germany. Itād probably be something like that
maybe but that would require a far larger timespan than the one the game currently takes place in
Probably⦠good reason to expand the dates though
Yeah but 1949 and onward isn't exactly the same period as the current hoi4, so unless they make actual cold war mechanics i feel like they shouldn't expand it
I mean more like 1910-1956
I'm pretty sure we (the people of this chat) already talked about why that big of a timeline isn't a good idea
Because one wouldnāt have much to do⦠However with a āLandless Adventurerā the amount of stuff to do would grow
Sus
17*
Nooooooo
Yeah sadly it is, October 3rd 2024
If September had 31 days it wouldāve been 18 days, but itās 17 days.
An invasion would only increase american resolve
And it would also never, ever be successful in any mind of way
It's straight up not possible
America is the world's biggest private gum market by far
More guns then humans, and it was so back then
The japanese didn't have enough resources, and they would have had no supply
If the japs landed, we would've just easily pushed them out
If for some ungodly reason they were able to advance
They would face extremely heavy casualties
And then maybe get a peace with like hawai and nothing else going to them
And they still lose.
To the other allied forces and such
China pushes them back
Eventually the UK and soviets would force them into surrendering
If you're giving the us that debuff, you might as well give the japanese a debuff of their own that destroys their supply's in the mainland and makes an invasion impossible to succeed
Least patriotic american
Wdym I'm from Jan Mayan
So... from norway?
No I'm a German Citizen
are your parents german or smthn
normally i would expect people saying that had german great great great grandparents lmao
Lmao
Well my great grandad was stuck in a gulag for 7 years
oh...
He saw things that I canāt say here
But
He was one of the few
To get out

peru dlc
My great grandpa was irish!!

Belgium has Uranium in Congo⦠think weāll get Belgium tree?
definitley
if paraguay gets a tree belgium better get one
I still think adding ww1 stuff would be š„
But thatās a BIG thing⦠this doesnāt feel like a BiG dlc
although ww1 had very different tech compared to ww2
and every hoi game was purely focued on ww2
ww2 is a direct result of the consequences of ww1⦠having both makes sense
I still feel like modding is the way to go
But i would like to see something like 1930 scenario
I do think landless adventurer would be really fun
starting as a private or mafia or etc and ārising to powerā
I honestly want another navy rework
I like navy but donāt see enough of it to know much about it.. what about the navy stuff is there to add/fix?
I want bigger production numbers tbh
like the way its now most nations cant build a navy
Me too!
My family escaped germany in the 30s for obvious reasons
All who stayed in europe except maybe one got slaughtered
But you get german citizenship
Which is why I'm one
Iām kinda German/Dutch too
Story is my family immigrated to the Netherlands⦠but recorded history shows a silk merchant in Amsterdam ⦠hard to connect things that far back
My grandma actually knows a lot of germans because her parents spoke german at home
My grandpa doesn't because his dad died when he was 4
But his parents were from austria and lived in vienna before moving later on
This is like early 1600s.
Where did your family go from there
Pennsylvania
we used to live there
dk where inside of pennsylvania but we lived there
then we moved to germany
Grew up around the Wheeling/Belmont area ā¦. But moved around so much I donāt think of myself as āfromā a state in particular
I was born as a German-American in Germany, then moved to the US for 2 years, then came back
I wanna move back, since I want to do my career in the air force
Couldāve phrased it way better ik
16 days
its the final countdown!
Svvn...
2 weeks 2 days
My predictions for this dlc are
Germany rework
Hungary rework
Czechoslovakia rework
Austria
And a mini Slovakia tree
Hoi4 seems to add or change 5 nations on average per dlc
Tgfv was 5
DoD was 4
Waking the tiger was 6
(Im counting the warlords as 1)
MtG was 4
BftB 5 (counting the minor rework of Yugoslavia and Romania btw)
No step back 5
By blood alone 4 (counting Aussa)
Arms against tyranny 5
And trial of allegiance 5
I hope they skip czechia and hungary and make a good japan tree instead
Thats not going to happen this dlc
Maybe next dlc
Or the one after that
Hungary really doesnt need it imo
Czechia yes
But hungarys tree is fine. Outdated yes but its still ok
Japans tree has got to change
It will
Just not right now
Hopefully along with naval combat
Pretty much
Id much rather get belgium focus tree instead of hungary rework
Next year is going to be a small regional dlc and Japan (hopefully I could be wrong)
I dont see much in Belgium just as much as Hungary
I mean belgium has nothing while hungary has a pretty fun path if yk how to migate the rngness of it all
Belgium only has the the congo and could only unite the low countries and take some land from France
Same thing could be said for basically any trial of alliagence dlc country
Thats the problem with Belgium, there quite literally is no history to be worked with
belgium is a hallucination
Dude if they can somehow make the king of chile some french dude who randomly claims hes the king they can do something with belgium
Except Brazil, Chile, and Argentina actually have more history
Brazil especially
Even if its a minor path id want it to have a path
Not ww2 wise as far as im aware
Who literally plays this game for ww2 larp
These days
Belgium actually kinda fought and for chile to get a bigger and better path than a european country who fought
Imagine playing historical Denmark and Belgium
Is kinda bizarre to me
Tbh belgium shouldve gotten something during la resistance
Focus trees didnt become decent until No step back
Agreed
But it would outdated now anyway
Yeah but then atleast it would have a damn focus instead of pure nothingness
Until then they were average
It would just be the Netherlands
Minus the Dutch empire
Really unfortunate though. Did portugal get a focus tree with la resistance?
Yes
Yeah Thats absolute bs shouldve given that to belgium
I like portugals path but belgium deserves something
They will get something
My theory is France and the Low Countries will all have their own dlc
But i dont see that for 3 years
Which disappoints me
Because I would like a overhauled Napoleon path
Its okay as of right now
But its missing some stuff
Best we have is road to 56 atm
I use that alot
And the france reworked mod as well
Which you can make Napoleon a more constitutional king
Wish it would be a axis rework generally instead of central europe rework
And it gives some crazy bonuses
Japan desperately needs a new focus tree. Sucks to see chile have a bigger and better tree than one of ww2s biggest players
Also its funny that the Tsar path has 100% stability
Dont like mods that much i should probs play more of em
Which one
The better one not the great war redux one
Not sure what its called
Japan is almost the same in Rt56
Really unfortunate icl
Monarchist Japan gets an alliance with Scandinavia and thats it i think
Why scandinavia out of all places?
Because the USSR
Monarchist japans whole point is to fight the USSR
Fair enough
Scandinavia is closer to the Russian heartland than Manchuria
True
And fighting in siberia is a pain
Monarchist and fascist japan should get an alliance with the tsar
Or Rodazaevsky
Last one makes more sense
Because Rodaevsky was operating in Manchuria
And was basically Japans guy until 1943
The only downside of tsar path in my opinion is that there are barely any generals
This
I wrote to paradox on their forums telling them to add more generals
Would love to be able to keep more generals as russia generally
I had a list of the whites who were still alive in 1936
As ussr i understand cuz u gotta nerf them somehow
Yeh i just dont like putting generics as my generals
Yeah same
Not the mention the generics still have soviet uniform
And the game refers to as the soviet union
Yeh
You get the soviet volunteer group in china
Molotov ribbentrop pact still says soviet union
Imagine being the tsar or Rodzaevsky
And getting that newspaper clipping
Rodzaevsky should have the option to ally with Japan for historical reasons
Only the historical path is viable
They rlly didnt give much to the fascist path
And they didnt even add a democratic path
Just 4 civs
But still solid path
Who would play as Democratic Russia
In the first place
Fair
Ive only willingly played democracybefore
And it was greece
Not the byzantine path
Well that sound boring
Yeh it was on historical
And i only did it for the achievement
Fair
Ig you can still become democratic
Also the french royal paths are all pretty lackluster
Even the napoleonic path just ives straight wargoals
Yet leaves out stuff like italy and spain
Also Denikin should be a level 3 at least in vanilla
Dude litterally command only 4k men for a while
And won
And avenge waterloo just makes everyone hate you if you take out uk
Early in the civil war too
Road to 56 and kaiserredux do Denkins stats pretty well
He got the closest to moscow out of all the white generals
I wish i could do some roleplaying too like reforming the finnish duchy and polish congressional kingdom
And he is the only surviving major one in 1936
Wrangle died in 1925, Yudonich 1930
You obiviously know what happened to Kolchak and Kornilov
Executed and killed in action
I want a proper democratic Russia path, myself
You would just sit back and wait for germany to fight you
I like to set every country with a focus tree to go democratic every new DLC
Maybe fight with the allies
And you would give your occupied subjects freedom
See who ends up at war
But whats the point of that when you can do it as the tsar
The Soviets not having a democratic path usually gets in the way of that
Even though the Tsar in the game collaborated with the Germans irl
Also Vladimir III is 19 in 1936
He was born in 1917
In Finland
A comprehensive list of what i would like for russian monarchist path.
.more generals
.reform puppets such as congress poland and finnish duchy
.ability to help reform countries like byzantium (historically tried to happen)
.zheltorossiya ( chinese russia)
. More for fascist tree
Agreed
Especially on the first part
I might make a mod for all this
I would use the right flag too
Yeh the flag is an interesting choice
Because the tsars flag is a naval flag
I would use that flag for the provisional government
Not the tsar
Maybe you can choose the flag for de stalinization
Good idea
But Kaiserredux has an interesting flag change option mechanic
You can change it in the descion screen at any time
nah i like russia flag in provisional
Sometimes I wonder if Russia went back to tsar itād be better
Like Monarchist Jerusalem
Not very fashionable to be a despot anymore
Good tsarā¦like constitutional monarchy like in the UK
That was never going to happen
The tsar squandered that chance twice
Once in 1905 and in 1917
I mean Tsar legit comes from Caesar who wasnt very consititutional. A king is always fun to have around but meh probs useless for russia
wonder who they'd elect as king though
Then what is the point. The UK monarchy doesn't do much
Wish the Anarchists got their own occupation law
I like that the ideologies all have their unique occupation laws now
Feel like itās a missed opportunity with them
the democratic occupation law is VERY nice
Right, like the extra compliance
yupp
i like the communist one too
i barely use the fascist one though dont see the point
Right
Feel like the anarchists should get something similar to the Democratic
Recently did a world conquest with them.
Would also be great to have a focus so that you can start other anarchy rebellions which in turn become your puppets and not get annexed by you
after the civil war
Waraw is always like EXTRA feisty
usually use it there one shut up already type shit
dont rely on it ver for compliance
They kinda have that through spies
just stfu button
Like can spark anarchy rebellions
Ik but if they win they get annexed almost in the first second after the civil war is over and it would be good to get a decision to deny that annexion and so on
Wish the whole spy agency rebellion thing was proportional to how many guns, civ factories, PP, and manpower youād commit
Would make alot of the spy work easier
Oh I see what you mean
Yeah politically the Russian exiles ideologies varied wildly and was not unified
when is germany getting a new tree
they said they would start talking about a new dlc on oct 3
3rd of october is the first dev diary
My guess is December st the earliest
Svvn...
2 more weeks
Rounded down yes
But in total 15 days
Its probably going to be historical stuff first
It always is
Because of how big germany is going to be
It will be split into 2-3 parts
After 4th one the Kaiser and other alternative right wing paths
A possible atternative right wing path??
I really wonder what new focuses there will be for the germans
I think me and Paradox dont want a ss alt history path
Would be too controversial
True would be weird to see that in game
My guess is that we get more infastructure focues and maybe some more focuses for reichskommisariate
Would be interesting to see
My logic is that Mussolini can get deposed in 1936
7 years ahead of schedule
If the player wants
So why not overthrow hitler right from the get go as the Wehrmacht
Like say rhineland went bad
Would be interesting if the alt germany path gets the focus which is almost the same as the reichskommisariat but only the monarch version of it like deutsches mittelafrika etc
I always thought that hitler should only be overthrown if Rhineland fails. There would be a decision that will force it to fail, such as making French and German soldiers fire upon each other. This would provide incentive for Hitler to be overthrown
I hope that they will buff Ethiopia African Union
So that u don't need to spend so much pp
South Africa should be able to core all its African puppets like what Mapuche Chile can do.
HOI4 Africa contents be like: UNITE AFRICA
I mean if Ethiopia can then South Africa should have something similar or atleast core a larger chunk considering it too has an anti colonial crusade and can puppet Africa
I mean they already have ss features
And they did add stuff like stalins purges and blackshirts
Problem is that the SS was uniquely evil and the blackshirts are more of a background thing
they may add the SS but censor it a shitton
I always thought an SS path should be a hard mode path where the Allies will refuse to appease.
No genocide mechanics of course
Hey so was just playing as Russia, did the civil war and went Fascist. Then the game let me go the third Rome route while allied to Germany/Axis. And shortly after had a massive fascist civil war. So I beat it, then the same civil war kept firing again and again. Ruined my entire playthrough. This was vanilla
Each civil war took half of everything I had including generals.
communist germany path
And rename itself
@solid gyro why isn't there a mittle afrika formable nation option if you play as monarchist Germany and conquer the necessary territory
Good question tbh this formable puppet Nation should of been in waking the tiger as the monarchist path for germany came in the game so my big hope is that it will be in it in this dlc
i would say make it like AGORA is lol
waking the tiger was released a long time ago so i guess the idea didnt come up at that time
Yeah thats why i hope its in the rework it would give the monarch path some fresh air etc
hopefully a habsburg path for hre
and reforming the puppets
Would be really interesting too see what paradox has planned for them
especially a communist path
Yeah, Germany is the only Nation in game (i think) which still doesnt have a communist path after all those years
the current democratic path is just making a huge alliance against russia
and if russia goes monarchist the whole purpose is defeated
would love to see it reworked into like forming the eu
So basically fascists but without war?
Yeah well i hope the new tree is as big like russia and italy cause does two got alot after by blood alone and NSB came out
ig
fascist is fun because you can conquer the whole world
nsb and bba are peak
Fr it gave alot of options for alt hist enjoyers like myself
even though they have huge ass trees they are still not overpowered which i rlly like
Yeah and the only thing i dont like in BBA is that italy has those not deleteable units
i guess its for lore
I guess so but if i play italy i dont really use them i mainly use normal inf with tanks and cas
i jsut use them for port duty in africa
Soon...
s o o n
2 weeks left just to get one look
when do y'all's think the new DLC will come
jeez, 3 months still!? damn...
Remember how long no step back took
Over a year
April 2019 for me
guess you're a veteran then.
pours tea into the boston for a second time
In hoi4 as of 2024 yeah
Poorly researched alternative history paths paths ā
Outdated focus tree ā
Its has one of my favorite alt history paths
The return of the Kaiser I suppose
Yes
You should have seen my face when I learned I could get the Kaiser back as Germany
I doubt I saw it. I liked that dlc, but warlords aren't interesting. They should rework politics
Oh totally
I think they should change parties from 4 to 6 and generalize the congress mechanic they added to usa in mtg
They should do āhow to mod hoi4 yourselfā series
They are
Maybe have a contest where someone writes an alt history and they turn it into a focus tree
Bad idea
Remember Minecraft mob votes
They did it for Imperator Rome & we got Pirate Illyria out of it
Yeah but who plays as Illyria in a Rome game anyways 
We even got a graveyard place for imperator
You know where Illyria is?
Yes
I still hope they'll resurrect it but this will not happen
SOON...
Itās doing pretty well atm.
Hearts of Iron but at different periods in history sounds coolerā¦
Like how Modern Warfare does it
Hoi: Napoleonic wars
Hoi: Alexander the Great
https://youtu.be/E7zIU3L2eUs?si=CIogL9ttWcen7Boo
Or
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLt_7vUaEvaGTJ0ISBqY2v4EyfmPALiVS7&si=iF64k1cOpSEw8Gs_
How do I mod Hearts of Iron IV? Hearts of Iron offers a unique sandbox experience which, with a little skill, you can adapt to include any scenario you could think of. Today we begin a series teaching you how to mod Hearts of Iron IV. This first video in the series covers how to get started modding Hearts of Iron IV. Stay tuned for part 2!
0:00...
The representation of war in hoi4 isn't accurate for anything before the late xix century
Not really
Also this
But seriously who cares about Illyria
Hoi4 isnt suited for ancient wars
Play Rome 2 with the divide et impera mod instead
that looks cool
I think itās shifted to more modern⦠but similar scenario only⦠which isnāt that bad.
I don't play eu4, too complex and too expensive to get in even with sales and I don't want to buy it because I can't spend all my few money. I play Hoi4, Ck3 and Vic2
I only play hoi4 and eu4
I dont play ck and vic
For me Vic2 is the best paradox game, you have to think what to do and as a minor you can't conquer the world
Hoi4 is fun in multiplayer
Yeah but vics time period doesnāt interest me
Its good just not my cup of tea
Also it doesnt work on my pc
I havenāt played any of them.., I just watch mostly
You may try ck2, it's free
<ā Chromebook
Yeah thats not going to work on that
Because Minecraft wont work on a chromebook
Iām happy with watching them though
Im gonna continue my tsar gameā¦
there wont be a Windows 12 according to MS
im still pushin windows 10
š
2 weeks š„³
Did anyone else get the Third Rome bug as Russia where the civil wars just keep spamming?
Nah
no
So if you go Fascist, join axis, then do third Rome. You get infinite civil wars
I don't do that path
why would you get rid of the Tsar for a old church guy
Not the Tsar path. Went Fascist, not monarch
that path is below average
also the south america thing is still broken
Well did fascist to align Axis in historical, then went Third Rome to help beat Japan in Asia post war.
And when I went third rome i just had repeat civil wars
doesnt mean someone shouldnt play it
Yeah
Soon...
13 more days...
The great reveal is soon happening.....
13 days is not that soon
Ik but they can go by fast if you dont think of it
ig yeh
312 hours
they will go fast
lately days go faster than we think
Guys if I declare war to the CCCP and I call my friend (who is doing the civil war) and I conquer Moscow. Do I eliminate him or he can get every territory of Russia?
If your friend is playing as a Russian faction then he can take everything as long as you aren't at war with him as well
Perfect
Thanks
Iāve done every path and mod at-least like 5 times in the 6k hours I have. I enjoy it as it can be challenging
do u know when new dlc for germany and japan is coming?
October 3rd is when they start to tell us about it. Iād guess November
ty
Np
imagine it comes out at november 11th
Would be awesome that would be one day after my birthday
I wish but I doubt it
Prob mid october to the end of october if the dev diaries come out fast in that month
I would prefer it if they took their time
so we don't have it be a disater at launch
Yeah
Well i mean they did say this year so could be december
I think it's 2 dev diaries a week or something
Yeah i think they show two things in a week from what i saw but as the Person said above, better to wait then to get a burning mess at launch
My bet release 11-11
Bout to go into hibernation till the Germany rework
Didn't Turtledove also make a book where the South wins the US Civil War because aparteid South Africa went back in time and sent them AK 47s?
Probably
Idk the details
ykw i just realized?
hoi4 edited their whole brand and art for the main stuff like mcarthur rommel zhukov etc. maybe there's a new art scheme coming soon?
soon...
this wait is boooooring
Gives you more time to live life before ruining it once it does become announced.
its for numbing the pain
with more pain (steam achievements)
XD
Paradox said that it will be dropped by 2024. Now does that mean the actual DLC will, or the introduction of the DLC?
Well they're gonna release the dev diaries in October so it'll probably release in December
or the unlikely reason why they are dropping dev diaries this late is to release the DLC almost immediately
Do we have any good ideas of what is to come besides the nuke rework, and possibly German focus tree rework?
0 idea
we wont know anything until 3rd of October
Is that what they've said?
yea
PDX announced nothing apart from roadmap
also noticed that we will get TWO dev diaries per week
its usually 3-5 dev diaries per DLC
either we will get smth VERY BIG (which i doubt tbh, its Paradox :D)
or they will wrap this up very quickly to get a release date
were you here when NSB was around
I mean it was huge
we litterally had 3 dev diarys on the USSR alone
Release date: 11/11?
i was actually
have to agree
would be surprised if they will make smth even BIGGER, content wise, than No Step Back
soon...
ok but october 3rd is like thursday lol
12 days left
so we'll start with a q&a and then get the first dev diary on 7th of october?
Reading between the lines...
They wouldnt call that "be-weekly" QnA if it was only once
Meaning its at least a month long affair.
Thats 8 dev diaries.
Even the fact that QnA exists is pretty interesting.
I mean, you wouldnt host something like that and so periodicaly over something small
Unless its something that HoI does anyway.
Not sure, Im kinda new.
Its like 20-40 per dlc if you look at the old ones
If thats the case then it will be bigger as NSB that means we will get alot of content for the nations like a bigger germany focus tree for the alt paths (democratic, Monarchist and maybe a communist path)
Dec 21 2024
Surely someone will buy it off my Christmas wishlist 4 days before Christmas right....
Theocratic Jewish Germanyā¦(for the lols)
this isn't EU4
I should also mention that theocracies other than the Vatican were largely a thing of the past
By 1936
Rule Brittania!
soon...
Iran and Afghanistan
oh I didn't know that
Britan rule warvrs
so on October 3rd there wont be dev diary right?
since dev diaries are on Mondays and Wednesdays
and oct 3 is thursday
that means the wait is way longer
2 more weeks
they said that's when they will come out tho...
so despite being Thursday, dev diary will come out?
hopefully?
I'm kind of confused since they said dev diaries start at Oct. 3 but the development cycle image they put says monday starts the dev diary which is not Oct. 3
So what date is it actually?
its probably oct 3rd for first week, then new schedule afterwards
thats what i said
yeah i checked the latest news on Steam and it says "Dev diary will release Oct 3"
so yeah, its likely that they will 1 diary for that week, and then it will go as usual (² dev diaries per week)
yeah

