#hoi4-general
1 messages ยท Page 602 of 1
just play more
Yes
Depends. Usually evolve it as I go.
i have 200 hours and cant win the spanish civil war bro 
is it over for me
This is my starter guys in Japan.
i couldnt do it on my first try at like 600h
just play and learn
what country do you find fun and not too hard
but like a tank division youd actuually use against good enemies
@heavy vigil i made an economical mobilization/demobilization system for the new mod im making :D
germany
ive played germany so many times
im so proud of you !!
minor into major
bored with sp? try hopping on a comp hist lobby
i actually did try this but i honestly didnt expand
we just beat japan
and i just remained
small
then expand
unite the nation
then join in against the germans
idk how the focus tree was confusing as hell
do the military side and manually justify
all i know was mao zedong cause hes not a very nice fello
you gotta get an actual good group to enjoy mp
left side is kinda not as important as like 4 mil spawn in
ill give ita try
depends
rb can be fun
stay away from fuwg tho
i tried doing like random matches and it was dead after like 1 hour
everybody left or just desynced
that's why you don't do random matches lol
chinese soviet republic right?
that's not how you play any serious hoi4 mp game
just get down to the mil spawn ins ASAP by any means necessary
Don't have a screenshot of my Tank templates.
...but if I was making up one on the spot?
7 Mediums. 7 Mech. One Armour AA. One Armour AT. Eng Corp. Log Corp. Rec Corp. Sig Corp. Mat Corp.
Don't quote me on that. But it works for me in single player and whenever I have MP.
and then go do politics whenever youre locked out
COME ON I'VE ALMOST GOT HIM
or are bored
what troops do i focus?
im gonna research AA
what else do i get
where is hoi1 dawg
medium spgs would work better, also making it 36w would be the best choice as its the best for offensive measures
is it even a thing
thats middle tree right?
and make them larger
right side
mil spawn ins are in the popular army branch
i need to go down left for that for militia buffs 
So extra Med and Extra Mech and a bit of Self propelled. Alright. Noted.
I will try it later in my game to see.
THANK YOU, BROTHER.
just go all the way down
youll find it
okay
i usually use 10 medium spgs and then 8 motorized/mechanized and dont forget to use flame tanks
theyre really good
and with your first like 80 pp justify on shanxi then the other dude
itll take like 100-200 days to justify
and will bypass foci
saves time at the cost of pp
Bc it is a very french thing to do
375...
nevermind i can do retake core state
w speed
PLEASE WORK
ningxia?
i need help
yes
why
you get unit spawn ins
they dont
you can encircle stuff in the north because desert works like plains
pin stuff etc
just make like 1 factory guns then 1 arty then further on guns until like 15
i also fear i dont know how different terrains work
2 on arty
then up on guns etc
dont need as much arty eventually
but small divs will use more
idk how im supposed to be getting these mils
none of the rightside focuses give them
how am i supposed to win this
i have 8 troops
what do i even do about this
im genuinely so clueless about what im supposed to be doing
Don't kill him
Or larp and send to the Soviets first
but didnt i wanna expand
so why did i ally with china
asia might be the most confusing thing in this game
You ally because otherwise you die
You can do infiltration and such so you gain land when you do declare war
arent they just gonna steal all the land when i declare war now
because their army is huge now
so theyll join my wars
Wdym declare war
and just take the victory points
You dont declare war
You have focuses to take some nearby states, but it is too late for that now
on shanxi
youre already late
bruh i got told to declare war
Why did you justify
you could be at war before you get the south thing
Read your focuses
thinking about playing hoi4
And know your focus tree
actually playing hoi4
Wait what
yeah
We not doing historical fun time
its faster to justify ASAP
but like
you can justify when you have like 30 pp
first month
gotta start doing it the first month
for you
I've just played 28 1/2 bolsheviks path and I didn't have a bad time
You can peacefully annex China with that path
You can do peaceful reunification
And win
Black text, dark background
here i explained the playthrpugh a bit in messages below @knotty vortex
Master of graphic design
ill try that
if you need it more in detail, i was texting as i did the gaming
@daring geyser @heavy vigil what should i do? they have like 45 million casualties should i wait or what am i even supposed to do?
where do i get the artillery from
wdym
you put your second mil on it
then after that everything new on gun
research gun
and what should my template look like
pllls @heavy vigil
maybe you like this better
brooooo imagine you are in this situation then
Do you want total war?
either the chinese people will gain victory or they will all die
what is that bro
<@&846894118219022336>
freaky ahh kiddo
you mean i like go in to full war and lose men but they lose more?
but they have india
Non core india
india is weak
if you take india
conscript all your non core panpower
how
scrping the barrel
never thought about that actually
what about i go strategic
i have 100% colleberation on the raj
then attack them
I find the production penalty is too high for scraping barrell to be effective
are u sure it will work?
It doesnt need to work
its 1974 and your china
i mean you have more manpower than them combined
so probably
Why are you at war
over a river into mountains
but what about the east
instead of the north where theres no river and no mountains
you leave it be until youve killed some guys
Youcan do a raid that removes all the enemy divs org and then immidietly do the decision to border war them
unless you see an amazing opportunity to push where its like 4v1
and even then youll probably lose
this is.. umazing....
do you feel educated
doesnt look promising
no i have dementia
youre pushing into a tile with 6 guys
which is great
but youre not gonna win the battle
encircle the 6 guys
thats massive
and dont battleplan omg
but no tiles are free
okay we're just losing tiles now
and keep the big stack in place with any attack even if its red, but still only attack with fully equipped guys
then PAUSE
this cannot be good for my health
im trying to lock in ๐ฅน
also idk you should have more divs out? idk how you manage to not deploy new stuff afaik you get spawn ins and stuff
Do a border war
you can do that but its like ough
nope i didnt get anything
you dont get the mil spawn ins in time
accept the army in events
and cooperate focus also gives guys
ill do that next
because i couldnt do any of the others focuses on your drawing
so i did that one
because it on there
you should be able to
i think
like cooperate
free units
or the political tree
im gonna restart cause china wanna make the united front
you can go back to the message i linked and i explain it like, to the best of my ability to play that nation
HMS King Arthur. Lead ship of a class of Advanced Super-Heavy Battleships built by the Royal Navy:
@woeful knoll i listened to u and look at ts
okay
i think you may need to research art 1?
i forgot tbh
if you ever want AA or trains just buy license for AA or buy trains from USSR market
theyll give like 10-15
the very first art one is done
ok then you have enough
buy license for AA?
how did paradox decine on focus day legnth ?
like why 70
I get 35 bc its like half of 70
but before that small focuses were 28 days
and there are also 14 day focuses
how do I unsend volunteers
ok whats up
this
also i advice you take care of your mental health and take a / tea / break if needed
you should always be zoomed in and looking to encircle/kill
i only did that for the photo
youre again kinda late with your action
im only manually moving troops
ive been trying to push though
but its so slow
and all your units should be militia
we end up getting stuck at like 70 green
turn the cav to militia
do i need to load hoi and show you live
i could even on call but cant talk
take your time
okay im ready
lmao i play with it on
yeah thats all good
don't ever give up gng
following or
yes i am
its rlly good
okay ill get it
here you get your second mil
yes i put that on art
so getting it ASAP is good
see how these 80 days left
so from here theres only time for 2 pre war focuses
also tbh that might be a mistake
then get that middle focus?
maybe its better to leave that mil on gun 0
and then new on better gun
but whatever
you can edit your unit and still pick this
1 arty first
but everything new
youll get more
now no focus
theres exactly 10 days left on justification, and focuses have a 10 day buffer
send me commies again i fing dare u
hard carried by usa
irregulars
easy
i was in a three year deadlock in defense
i was doing french empire
just extend maginot
and i was running 5 speed
tryna do heavy tank converision strat
but half ass
๐ญ
look at the stats you get for clicking a few buttons
oh what militia?
i love communist china militia
i made an entire army filled with japanese equipment
90% equipment capture
cas might be the most unfun thing ever created
both in warthunder an hoi4
if ur using tanks at least
literally i cant even take a single tile without getting pushed out
๐ญ
i would love to
if it wasnt for the brigade size BS they added after NCNS
or convert some tanks into anti air
what countrry
playing as poland in KR
i wish tanks were more
@knotty vortex are you following so far, sorry if its like fast
you stop force attacks by reassigning to frontline
yeah its okay
it ceases their attack order
I just wish anti air was more potent
what does force attack actually do
or cas was less potent
give you 20% attack in battle
anti air is good
base anti air can pierce ai tank divs
before NCNS cas was way less strong (but still insane)
also stops you losing org at the cost of losing hp
now its like they cranked that up to 10000
but its ok shanxi doesnt damage you anyway
okay i see
i can try again
see what i can do
micro is just super hard
maybe if ger ai wasnt useless and sent planes ๐ฅ
everywhere is red air on the eastern front
ger has prioteries
doing any sort of maneuver is extremely difficult when taking 1 tile takes 80% of ur org cuz of cas damage
every ai is coded to act differently
based on what u do
britain in base game is coded to not join in on france
yea thats true
@heavy vigil can i see your industry rq
i wish they were coded to make at least ONE air zone green tho sheesh
italy wtf
france go fascist
yeah that to
and lithuania
for whatever reason
you can take half of europe without war
attacks poland
getting poland cores for free
and core all of europe
napleonic france poland and lithunia team up
yeah it overpowered
but hitler germany is the most op path
also crzy holy roman buffs
for multiplayer games
almost ragebaited me
hes shit for wc
all land gets crazy res
i said multi
yes
if you watch any meta game
hitler germany also gets 10 spys
wasnt it 8
just killed lithuania
@knotty vortex as soonj as you get the territory you should get extra units and snake around
they decided to attack poles
okay ill try that
all the attacks are to pin the line and i split off so units get force attack (they will effectively have more org to continue longer)
itll probably take me a few attempts
ofc always try encirclements too
can i see your industry rq
u don't always have to speed attack them
you can get free land
this is what happens when you attack over river btw XD
havent touched navy since 1936 btw
you just dont win
convert those navies
base german navy if you put like 20-30 dockyards into it
can beat anything
into?
but i wanna naval bomb britain
with light cruiser
bro you gotta try bombers after this dlc
there so overpowered ๐ญ
i got 15 bombing a day before
with 1936 bombers
60% of german induestry was bombed
veyr nice
whenever i play an africa game as italy or germany
i just throw light tanks
with fuel tanks
and 16 width inf
okay im gonna try agaiin
on top of keeping first factory on bad gun i shouldve played for killing more in the north
you just retreat and start the "mobile" fight
again
what should you have done for industry?
because pushing east is like significantly more difficult
keep first factory on bad gun
and every new one on newer
its not a massive difference but a few hundred rifles
now you have 16 of these and can go down the path to the 4 mils
you should get it just before japan
ninxia is also possible to annex but they dont really have eco
its just nice to do
who do i attack before japan? if anybody
okay
and how do i get the rest of china
like whats the gameplan after
๐
im done with the allies not forming nato and inviting every single unrealistic country in the world, im done
Is this a good template for infantry?
just those 2
you dont have any other time
like my European Union that i did using the secret focus path (and yes, i did release every nation outside of europe)
its just practice
youre practicing micro
on a small front
so its just knowing terrain and stuff
and when theyre out of supply in the desert they move slower (your enemies but also you)
okay its probably good practice
and you can see even tho i only encircled like 3 guys you can still snake around
you just have to kill enough/pin all units
and push above the river in the north
the river is virtually unpushable
HELL YEAHHHHHH
is there an exploit that lets you get same amount of planning for immobiel as everything else
no
god why did they have to fix field marshal exploit
Because it was an exploit
But hey, new cohesion feature
alright but why did they have to replace it with this
They could have simply removed it and not put anything else in return
-50% planning speed for microing ur own units is dogshit
Also staff office plan exists
๐บ๐ธ ๐ค ๐ท๐บ
did they nerf subs btw?
This is where we clearly use planning speed bonuses instead of max planning 
lmao i guess so
Just attack now, why wait
yea i think sub visibility is broken rn
from what i've heard at least
I know the beta patch is changing things
ive seen people lose like 90 subs in 1 engagement
Trying to help out subs a bit
yeah cus subs dont dissapear like that ๐ญ
Or is it the beta patch where subs are getting rolled
i wish instead of nerfing subs which were already easy to deal with they nerfed cas
might be number 1 cas hater rn
pdx priorities...
in fact, they buffed cas in ncns lol
massively
deals like 3x more damage now
yea which is absolutely horrendous
cas was already crazy before ncns
why the hell was it buffed
but i actually approve of it cuz cas was hella important irl, but it's awful for game balance because most nations even a lot of majors already don't have the IC to build an airforce and tanks per se at the same time
in multiplayer
not a sufficiently large one
terrible
@daring geyser look at my progress, i have taken finland and pushed back india, they have lik 55 million casualties now
youre a maniac bro
yea i do know air was kinda broken irl lol
but it desperately needs balance
people dont see the beuaty in late game, so much cooler things that you dont ususally see happens. like one time when i fhought usa they liker turned to three civil wars
even if you have no air there should be SOMETHING you can do
u could legit get 18w battleplanned by cas and lose
might have to start doing AA cheese
why my hoi4 is not opening
there's roaching and outmicroing but the latter is really hard to do
but in general if you play mp and got red air you lost yeah
its just so disheartening to see my tanks get pushed out by inf battleplans with green air
i take 1 tile and run out of org
and this is just against AI
i cant imagine MP
good lord
if you want to beat them you fight fire with fire
sfs + air is the most ic efficient way to play the game
live laugh naval invasion
just close the pocket at konigsberg
to encircle them
i cant
wdym?
dawg it 1975
24 divs saved me
and france and uk still have colonies?
If they have 500 divs in konigsberg then close it immediately cuz they have no supply there
wdym do they lose them normally?
idk never happened to me
decolonize
USA did a d-day by themself
gng what
in my games india declares independence
they like get civil wars sometimes i know but not this time
they have total 500
do u have all dlcs?
usa is the best ai
yes
peak japan
Then still close it
i did
manchurkou better
japan is so fun to play
easily
untill u stop invading the actual countries and have to island hop
asia WHAT
โ
my favorite
in hoi4 mods where are the province tiles stored
dawg i can't even make a navy in hoi4 and ur asking abt mods
ask chatgpt or google dude
FINALLY INVADED THE UK AND ANNEXED IT FOR THE FIRST TIME AFTER 12 GAMES
not even they know
they'll give you a much better answer
thats the thing
neither can i
SCAM ALERT:
If your Steam account is linked to Discord, you might get a message claiming someone impersonated you and that Steam support was asked to ban you by mistake. Theyโll tell you to contact a fake support person on Discord to โfixโ it โ usually with a fake Steam link and a made-up moderator name like simonne.sup.
DO NOT FALL FOR THIS SCAM.
I just got hit with it. Stay safe and donโt give them anything.
i love scams
i use gemini
and thats wrong btw
bro im not making a mod
i need to find the province names
for the numbers
i need to use commands
whats tdebug
is it normal for revolutions to have revolutions
how to get tdebug
you literally type tdebug
and hover over a provence
and it tells you it
btw u were wording it wrong
there are 3 whats it
Imo stationary aa needs buff
totally
inf only germany is so tuff
wow
its currently ass
icl
make it an actualy viable alternative to towed aa so nations with bad industry can stand
not enough
when the ai has 10 thousand
which yee yee ass bombers are you making
that get shotdown 20 a day by static aa
radar and maxed out anti air
throughout all of england
๐ฅ
they get touched
eh ai doesnt really max out radar or AA on vanilla
multi
they dont even build it at all
yeah ok
i had a friend playing uk
but youre not getting green air over the uk on multiplayer hist anyways
in a modded map
i mean you could have italy and germany heavily invest into air day one
Surviving as ethiopia is now impossible in the latest patch
when youre bombing germany per se they cant put static AA everywhere without taking a huge hit
before war
thats a known strategy in comp/semicomp
called airgamble
that why bombers are banned
f2
and usually when they do that sovs smash cuz outmicro
sovs out micro ๐ญ
when does that ever happen it usually just roach build
it also depends on mods
because base germany is overpowered
if they airgamble they will have no tanks my man
if sovs roach builds against airgamble germany they are braindead
better kick that guy off the game
my hoi4 is not opening ๐
f0 spam
booting up hoi4 mp for the GREAT WAR EXPERIENCE CHALLENGE
airgamble sov trust
I summon french people
the united states joined american commonwealth
wow
im going to shove a microwave up britains ass
Italian units?
then you cant defend
wouldve been european union
nbopdoy CARES aboutt your opinnion:
no like not as opinion
ive played with the techs before
nbopdoy CARES aboutt your facct:
your offense is stronger than def
sonion
@heavy vigil heres what ive done
im still struggling a bit
so difficult to get through some areas
last time i played i fried china
its late
i know
just srestart and you really need to encircle in the north
i justified as soon as i could and started the war asap
and snake in the south tiles
How do u even get in a deficit so bad
make sure they dont move into the gap when it forms
its really really difficult
it takes practice yes
units always like reinforce tiles and i just cant breakthrough at all
just do like
attacks everywhere
so they cant move into the south gap
it doesnt matter if the attacks arent winning other than when its not over river
you want to take the north because no river
its so slow though
and you want to move across in the south because the ai never deploys units
like my units just dont win
you need to have units in training
after you get the soviet guns
like 5-7
you also need planning bonus, force attack, doctrine
the highest attack level general and FM
you need to stack battle modifiers as much as possible
yeah i did this
as you need to with anyone really
what now
i got the doctrine
and you deploy them when you get shaanxi shaanbei idk the name
the south
The Fall Of Nazi Germany
from the northeastern army?
its called endsieg
?
yes
okay
so you dont have to spend time yk moving units around
they can be essentially teleported there
gonna try this
Interesting Kaiserreich moment
@stone sinew @median juniper we need help in looking for mp 1
what do i do here
i just get caught like this
they have a ton of units
how do i clutch
attack the west the supply carries
try to reach any railways
they will experiate
okay ill try
move a unit
left=west
you dont need 2 on a river tile
they automatically move back
then turn it off
in the cohesion under the general
okay cool thanks
didnt know that existed
yo casey wanna play hoi4 tomorrow?
bro
Wtf happened
romania called italy to war and i guess paratroopers capitulate france too fast so everything went to italy
am i cooked if i play as northern ireland
yes very
its too late once japan has invaded
you do get less mil output tho
I believe in you โจ
thats all u need
no hope as well tbh
yeah im getting cooked
did i make france even worse?
im gonna try playing france i think
how to invade UK lol
i wanna make the french empire
Everyone join East Showdown
what units are the best for naval invasion if you dont have marines
something with bigger breakthtrough works
i wanna get an early naval invasion on the UK
amphibious tanks are pretty bad so you might as well nav invade with your spg template
i can sneak troops in by getting channel dominance before the war starts
but as soon as it starts
the royal navy turn up and things go bad
i cant get more armies in there
and we end up getting pushed out of the uk mainland
what do you use for your navy?
you can build up a decent one even early on
honestly the starting french navy
i let the production lines run
im aiming to invade by 37/38
yeah.. no, make your own designs asap, you can get a lot of navy experience by training your current whole navy
torpedo dd's
you got the design anywhere?
train it all but have subs seperate
just add max torpedos on it and fill out rest as normally
they are meh
this game never fails to amuse me
bad even
whole army group lost + whole fleet lost
why? because they didnt want to move to reinforce the landing
you dont really want them in your patroling task force
whats the rest?
and what torpedo tech do i need
armor, aa, fire control, just the basic fill outs
next to current torpedo research
yeah, the torpedo dd design needs like 45 navy xp
or something like that
how do i get better at hoi4
then you spam those
alright
ill do that
I mean having some decent capital ships would be also nice but if you want to invade that early you wont have time to make them
cuz the ai designs are pretty meh
yeah they suck
is there a good way to get good at hoi4
hows this @winged field
looks good
time to spam
you can cancel the rest of production pretty much
and focus on these
still try to train them to lvl 3 if possible
chat im gonna play half life but with a twist
and make sure you have air superiority
restart cro
cavalry good or no?
if you want to release your inner genghis khan? yes
for normal games? only for garrison
which country should i play in which mod (out of kaiserreich tno tfr and empire)
its doable if you get buffs for it
like a bermontian poland
do these count as space marines
yes
cavarly spacemarines are viable like if you are playing as Poland and you want to larp. They will shred the Soviets to piece
since their piercing is terrible
understatement of the century
i need hard attack
your playing mp?
then build hard attack focused tanks
use less tanks
and space marines are banned in most mp games
Never mess with the US navy
yes ik thats why i asked if those are spacemarines
space marines are infantry divisions that have armor in them
which country should i play in which mod (out of kaiserreich tno tfr and empire)
attempt 2 at making byznatium
i use 30 width calvary as soviet in winter war and win
russia in kx
dont attack over a river
๐
your missing equipment
alr
doing that to pin them
old wourld blues - lost hills, if you mean like any mod
Are making heavies destroyers worth it? i mean the hard attack difference really isnt that much but you get -40% breakthrough
in MP
what bro