#hoi4-general
1 messages ยท Page 568 of 1
insert coordination problems
probably make it 32 width since those still fit in marshes
i always use them in MP
only belarus has marshes
bro 16w is meta rn
Sure if I havent found a game then yeah
im rn busy i got plenty of school work
Your good!
thanks dude โค๏ธ
@dusky burrowthe reason 16w is meta is cuz it fits the most on the tile
you get 20% concentration from doctrines nowadays, 6% from radio research, and 6% from radar research, thus 32% coordination
Add that to the 35% base coordinated share, and you get at least 67% coordinated share
TD nations like Germany may also use armored signals, giving them 28% initiative, increasing coordinated share to 76%
yea but it doesnt really matter from what ive tested
so your single 16w is tanking 81% of a tank's soft attack
okay listen
so soviet roach builds what they are for
is that the german tanks will have to push out every single inf
one very single tile
so think if u have like
15 divisions per tile
and u keep pulling more
eventually that'll exhaust the tanks
esp if u pierce them
which is very possible in the current meta
ur point is to drag german IC
if u have 10-20 divisions per tile they will be exhausted
and if they bring in even more tanks their supply will worsen
which leads to attrioting
which leads to even more tank losses
this is from an MP game
german tanks overextended
so i punished it
are those heavy german tds?
how many htds and how many mtds
because the meta is 10 mech 9 htd
HTDs 40%
nah not rlly
heavy tanks are nerfed
nerfed?
the terrain penalties are too much
lol
Medium tanks are way better
heavy tanks are terrible for stuff like barb and stuff
sure west europe is fine
but east europe
never will work
they take up too much supply + insane terrain penalties
which is why people nowadays go w medium tanks
and armour doesnt really matter in this patch
because u will always get pierced
well your heavy td divisions have logistics companies anyways
armor might not matter that much, but what does matter is breakthrough, so your tanks have armor clicks
they dont really do much
breakthrough can be stacked w medium tanks aswell
like these tanks had 1.5k breakthrough
they are broken
and he had like
This is the German meta heavy TD btw
40 of these tank divisions on me
ye this is to click enemy tanks
but barb inf
easily holds out aghainst this
like
this is really good for enemy tanks
but it isnt good for eastern front
eastern front u always want SPGs
like the biggest mistake i see germany players do as a soviet player
is that they use TDs on my high org inf wall
sure u can take kiev minsk and maybe lithuania
well it depends on whether you're doing your 32w infantry roach or tanks yourself
im doing inf roach always cuz it takes less microing
and its easier
W
but note the almost 1300 soft attack
this is really good
brother listen
stats dont matter on the eastern front
eastern front is just attrition game
And almost 1000 of that soft attack will fall upon one 16w
u can push the soviets as much as u want
but the doctrine is
they can stack inf per tile
which drags ur tanks org
like this only has like
32 org
imagine u have to push out like
I've seen Germany push the Allies out of France before in MP scenarios
10-20 inf which reinforce fast asf
and the Allies have 35w special forces divisions
obviously thats france
tank template?
france has less terrain penalties
post d-day i mean
listen
france and soviet
is completely different
france is all plains
and sometimes forest
soviets are marshes, winter , and plains and forests and everything
what matters and what soviet players take to their advantage is
the insane terrain and depth of the soviet union
like the logic is
yeah true about france tbh, that said germans have air superiority on eastern front
so it sort of evens out
air superiority doesnt matter
again terrain modifiers make it that cas are virtually useless
and keep in mind
one Support company of anti air
I've been told multiple times that northern Soviets is unholdable btw
no longer
i always get pushed in the baltics
they've changed it
fr?
yeah you need 55 air attack now
thats fine
u can just have like
stacked air attack inf on like every tile
and keep them in reserve
hey did they also change how static aa works?
like there is an exploit
where u can just have anti air inf in reserve
and let ur normal inf attack
i don't think so
yeah that's fair
another thing that depends on rules though
for instance red baron, who i talk to the most about meta subjects like this, only allow max 4 per division
so that's not possible
and even 3 aa per division is sort of cancer
because i had my region maxed out on aa with radar and they shot down like 2 bombers every few days and i get bombed to bits
like i managed to hold out the axis till like 1945 i lost eventually becdause the allies did no D DAY
AND NO STRAT BOMBING
NOTHING
NO LEND LEASE
huh got to test that somehow
all of the axis IC was on me
oof
๐ญ
irl soviets be like
and you did that with just infantry
yes
i have my suspicions
i love my infantry
?
i can show u the game logs
if u want
the axis werent really competent either
like
yeah that probably explains part of it
there was no hungary player
no romania player
only italy and germany
it was a game w my friends
but what i'm saying is that 32w is probably better than 16w in modern day hoi4
ehhh
it depends tbh
like man
16w can fit everywhere
and it stacks
and the reinforce rate is higher
axis does 32w too
but u lose more equipment
bro the german player in my MP game server always does shitty standard game inf
like he does the starting template
๐ญ
so i just click his inf
all his IC goes on tanks
i mean meta axis would do that
yeah that is usually pushed to romania-hungary
but its understandable
axis minors need to spam out inf
while germany invests all their ic into tanks
also about the france point, since we're talking about special forces with some mech, and you're using normal infantry on the eastern front, we're talking about infantry that is tougher to break through, and you're under red air.
by contrast, yeah, the eastern front has bad terrain
if i may suggest so myself, western front post-1941 is more difficult than eastern front post-1941 for the axis
that is true
like allies have better
IC
eng and usa
so their divisions are better
soviet inf is just slop
lol
yeah
soviets almost always lose by 1943
or france is fully liberated by then
the two fronts are just too asymmetric
thats y i play hearts of oaks
its way better
than vanilla
hearts of oaks
makes line artillery better and soviets way stronger
it is in the border between black ice and vanilla
fair
if soviets are much stronger then yeah
that may be the difference between infantry roach being unworkable because of lack of air and competitive soviet air
all i do is clash clash clash no matter what
ai templates be like:
is left soviets?
yes lmao
vanilla
oh wow
soviet union's industry if stalin locked tf in
but can they beat the entirety of the euroaxis
bro i love air
so much
its my speciality
my tests about 30w inf
is this desireable?
thats unironically not as bad as the soviets tend to be in my games, i have seen the soviets once with over 20k fighters.
you might not be stacking all the proper modifiers on tanks
really?
yep.
also note how the soviet inf are getting 1000+ defense
and i had not 10k fighters
yeah those 100k fighters aren't being used
well yeah ai makes fighters and if you dont kill them, itll go up
until they run out of airfield space
because ai doesnt make those
they had like 20k fighers on tiles sometimes
at that rate you may assume that you have zero air superiority and push with tanks
it took 4 years before i could even think about pushing
why not just make AA or like your own air
i did
it took 4 years to deplete their air
AA bricks meta
this was a while ago before gotterdammerung
i did a lux run (as usual)
and i had a lot of territory and puppets and the major powers in the end was me, ussr and china
they had vastly more manpower and units than i did
and outscaled my industry by a lot
with almost 2000 mils on soviets
late game ai is scary until you see the air they make
the air they make is cooked
well, scary for vanilla ai terms
theyre still not great
Its not scary at all
All you need is a good army and you can literally battleplan anything atleast in europe
ik
Unless you talk LATE lategame so 1950s+
Until then you re fine
they make some units that are kinda cool
presumably we are talking about late game
ai doesnt lock in until the 1960s
Anyone wanna play a hoi4 campaign?
and then they make moderately reasonable units
Yes but i consider lategame to be 1947 or so at most cause by tjen the game is cooked
So late lategame is 1950s+ thats when its pure hell
its only hell if youre at war with everyone, its pretty chill when youre not
My pc can't make it past 1947 or so unless i want a year to take 7 hours
Israel has a custom name for missiles ๐
It still lags
the war lasted 1964-68
How does your pc make it to that year
It's cause the AI has a lot of divisions, air wings, navy, etc
yeah fair
Yes i know
Ironically the best way to fix lag is to go on a mass killing spree
But it sucks
simple
kill 90% of existing nations
then pray the pc doesnt explode
Mm well yeah
But it depends bro
I ain't taking over the world as uruguay or some shit by the time my game goes unplayable
depends on how many nations are at war
As Germany its quite possible
Usually its the whole world
๐ฅ
youve probably only played until then because theres a million nations at war
and youre locked in a long war
but like you can just not have that
i hate surface to air missiles in this game
theyre so baddd
legit like the single worst thing to produce
yeah first time i tried making them i was so stoked about it
until i used them
no air attack, no range
incredibly bad range
sorry
im dumb
i mean as in
you can only launch from rocket sites
so like 300 per state, and the range stat isnt just bad, you actively cant cover like, anything
no efficiency
and
if you forgot missile subs were added
"red october standing by"
What country path should I play next just played third Bulgarian empire
Anyone wanna play hoi4? Id lovs to run up a campaign
does anyone have a good infantry template for pushing/defense? i can never make good templates lol. i also dont fully know how tanks work so i stay away from em
turkey ottoman empire
I would but its focus tree is torture
hello yalls
have u played
polish Lithuanian commonwealth
Only greater lithuania
do that then
how do I make division
u can restore the byzantine empire as greece too
Yes but I usually kinda win by 1947 or so
I mean i take over europe because i only play europe and then thats it
Cause i cap Britain before the us joins so then its very easy to actually invade the us
I just collect flags dude its not that deep, its also just the naval ensign bud
Anyone wanna play hoi4 together?
canadians*
german too
Exactly i have to adapt to my next deployment
LMAOO ๐คฃ
So i can blend in
Tfr as the subject is crazy and not tno
what the actual hell are your flags ๐ญ
as my first order of businessi declare martial law ๐ฃ๏ธ
thats dumb as hell
They are sanctioned by the state of israel
wait let me share my flags
(sends picture of a perfect condition 3rd Reich Flag)
modern politics
we have to take out their families
DEATH PENALTY
SODA
my girlfriend made the Prussia one for my birthday
we are gonna bomb the shit out of them
ignore that they are unironed
if a boomer found ur room
they would think your a nazi
Lets make sure this guy dosent get into artschool mkay?
Or really fail artschool
i used to draw a while ago
imperial flag hre flag
If he gets in irs probavly fine
all the signs of a german faboy
now all i do is paint my gf
i am german
what did you expect
i dont hate my country duh
Future hitler there
U should know that thats the flag of Kashubia smh
banned in germany
kaschubien rahhh
U prob voted for the AdF
what?
you have a soviet n japanese flag so i wouldnt be suprised
i bet your bedsheet is the israeli flag
Yes
what word is banned wtf
U*
Either that or u live in saxony
Yea fake german over here
i am only like 8% german
๐ญ
Ur basically Frys
Holy Germany
denmark is cool, whats with the hate
i love germany
Potato language
Subscribe โบ http://www.youtube.com/user/kellyxkilljoy
Facebook โบ http://www.facebook.com/kellylouisekilljoypublic
Twitter โบ http://www.twitter.com/justkellylouise
Blogger โบ http://www.kellylouisekilljoy.blogspot.com
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR WATCHING!
Words and Questions for The Accent Tag:
Aunt, Roof, Route, Wash, Oil, Theater, Iron, S...
i also have a trans flag somewhere stowed away from a time in my life
i went trough it all gng
snagger du dansk?
i only have one flag in my home
what is this
u gave 3 small ones a medium and one big singapore flag
You sure?
redesign of singaporean flag
just a little
looks like starwars flag
๐
anyone wanto play?
your just a hater
ndp ๐ญ
used to be a german farright party
i think its been banned since 2011 or smth
fun fac
the singaporean ruling party logo
is based of the british facist logo
the lightning?
guys rate the larp
look good
THE LARP WILL EVER END
i want some pins as well
larp larp larp sahur ๐คซ
Lowkey just play it
its so complex ๐ญ
cant tell me ts dont look good
eu4 ahhhh
it does look good but if you wore this in UK you would get arrested
I have a few hours in it but it seems like every other total war game
i never played total war games
Just a different era/region
i only play hoi4 and vicky
we gotta start doing shit likes this again
I confused it with another Rome game
racist uk goverment arrest asian man for loving his asian country
only singaporean nationalist in existence
Woops
total war rome?
Yeah
i see
happens
good game if only the devs did smt
mine was last played 2025
thats why invictus exists
there was a new huge update i think last monthg?
1.11
last update was 2025 bro
march actually
๐ oh invictus
you need invictus to play imperator come on
i thought you meant the game
base game is unplayable
i rather just not play
They usually ban fun
You need more manpower in za field
No
i am paradox top guy
Negev ๐
Why such conditions
there is some leeway
Holy Larpmaxxing
negev >> you
son ๐ญ
Probably true
i am israeli and i love paradox
the larp never ends
Larp larp larp sahur
i am top guy
Anyone wanna play hoi4 now?
i have 500h from the mod launcher btw
why do you have so many frogs ๐ญ
Romanov Poland is the biggest piece of shit in this game and lazy ass paradox doesnt want to fix it
the blse exteder era
what mod launcher
blse
dk what that is
its the script extender
i c
i also do unpaid labour for paradox
i dont think blse works on linux
larp larp sahur
I wanted to send smth but it's better to not ion wanna risk getting banned
My friend ishi loves saying that
larp larp ishi
yo buddy aint a truecel
Honestly no clue what that is
Right?
Do you wanna play some hoi?
Yes. But have to go to work soon ๐
god damn
it can be better than coring btw
all i do is clash clash clash no matter what
Couldve answered 2 and a half months earlier yk
๐ฅ
lmao
guessing by SSRs name moving west they are getting railed by japan, you should totally double team them for fun
railed as in attacked
of course
could someone explain "chance of executing X tactics" to me, are they like random, non player controlled actions my units take when certain criteria are fulfilled or?
ive had multiple traits like that for my commanders but i dont notice any change in the behavior
guys how can my fleet reach that place
why is this chat so dead today
Reminder that an AR-15 is cheaper then 2 sticks of ram in America
depends on what sticks ๐ค
How did u find that year old message
silence
2 years old
i cannot be silenced
seriously tho
how does one actually get compliance
without wasting troops for garrisons
Is Darkest Hour or HoI3 more fun for a HoI4 player?
thanks sheep's mod devs
if we are gonna normalize the atomic bombings then the pearl harbor attack is normal as well
"we are at war.. but are we?" ahhhhhh
no one normalized either?
both of them are awful
You are fighting schizophrenia
south africa isn't looking very south
look at the image he sent
what'd he send
son ๐ญ
what did you send for this response
you think
what could you possibly have sent
well
he was talking abt
wait a min
i gotta
ss it
lol
someone sent imperial japan flsg before this I guess
both are iffy
i was saying proudly hanging the imperial japanese flag is the asian equivalent of hanging the nazi german flag
no just letting you know
both of you arent wrong
this is also the navy flag for japan now btw
both
why glorify the empire
yes because nazi japan is fantacized in the west
and why justify the atomic bombing
because kawaiii :3
yeah
btw imperial japan also used this flag at that time ๐ฏ๐ต
when it was at peace it did
no they were using it for a long time
both the rising sun
and thid
yeah cause they were at peace for a long time
this
1918 - 1937 is a long period
yes when they were slicing pregnant women open in korea and china they stuck the rising sun flag in their corpse
dont pretend its not evil symbolism
i wanna leave the faction but i cant because im fighting schizophrenia
we really cant be justifying the japanese empire rvo
vro
arguably worse than the nazis
you think germany would be allowed to use the nazi flag for their navy?
what kind of argument is this
arguing equivalency
you dont hold japan to the same standard as germany
still
yes exactly
that proves nothing
i find it quite interesting how japan so narrowly escaped its war crimes
so why u taking it seriously
and just doesnt mention them
because japan is so kawaii
wp
๐ฅฐ
japan is all anime and giggles right guys
yeah bro
ganbare ganbare
yes
Nah
type shit
konichiwa amirite
am i rite or am i rite
Surely Japan is the most overrated country in the world, not saying its bad or anything but the hype is massive
japan totally didnt have war crimes arguably worse than those of the nazis
chinese propaganda
there is no good country in the world
if u think like that
Yeh
switzerland
It just has the most hype I feel like so itd be very hard to live up to it
is lwk the best candidate for best countury
maybe
sorry I forgot about
albania
Albania*
๐
Fins are the happiest so even if I wouldnt want to move there (because I like where I am) I would give them the points
Anyway, we should be getting back to HOI IV topic
you lwk give me dutch vibes
am i right in assuming this
Yes
If I was living in finland I'd go to another country in first opportunity
i think you just looked at his bio
Or read my name
yea i was gonna say that too
how dare you accuse me of such bad things man
who wants to be neighbour of russia
i mean im not even scared of russia
nato is way stronger
yeah i did
just incase
๐คธโโ๏ธ
๐ฆฝ๐๏ธโโ๏ธ
You should build supply hubs instead
So at least you'll be well fed when the Germans occupy you ๐ฟ
...
need an idea for a playthrough, havent played in a while
Finland
something moderately chill, not sweaty
or napoleon
Gotta love HOI4 where the side with much more casualties also has way more fielded manpower still
BTW
on historical or
"you are not the war leader for the losing side"
finland is gonna win
๐ฅ
nah, play equatorial guniea, veteran
soviets have lost 2 million trying to cross my lines
just wait till winter comes
One naval invasion and it's so over
Ive got a million men defending the liens
i gave up all my land when my first line failed
What about the coastlines
First line was this
Ive got troops on my coastline
And i have 5 subs
and btw i never researched tanks or planes until 1945
this run was supposed to be just free lancing off of germany
to get my achiement
Sweden joined Japan btw
my industry is cooked
I lost nearly all of my civs and mils in estonia
Im gonna lose the war due to Soviet bombing but atleast ive killed millions of them
AMAZING
just looks like early game france to me
i've played france maybe 4 times their starting situation is a dumpster fire
zero stability zero PP infinite consumer goods and a giant unruly neighbor
its ok i have hope in the napoleonic path ๐ฅบ
Does the USSR surrender if i atom bomb moscow?
good luck have fun
Can i assasinate stalin?
nobody surrenders if you nuke them
i think only japan does under very specific conditions
So this isnt wolfenstein
japan does because its historical idk
i think most of their navy has to be sunk first
In endsieg i nuked britain 14 times
There's a mod to do so I think
Mannerheim line has been breached
Might be misremembering tho
ryckmans can you stop asking me for mil acc
No one left to surrender
with horse divs
๐ฟ
just realized its 1938
i need to get the little entente out quick
mr. hitler please do not meddle in my affairs
(my army sucks)
yeah hes dead
๐ง
wow germany decided not to remilitarize the rhine
pierre laval has saved the day
the classic trick of shaking your fist very hard at your foe
they already did anschluss they can't be far from the sudeten
๐ง
Why arent you doing napoleon
Does france have something else?
thats fun?
IM cheesing it so hard
i have already done a napoleon path like twice
here's a big map i ahve to prove it
is political violence the spirit that makes you do the civil wars ๐
if you ask me about manchuria or italy or africa i am not answering that
what is this
what about romania
fairly certain they're also at war with italy
south america found to be doing nothing yet again
๐ง
i think for the entire game all they have is
the peru and ecuador war
which ends in like
3 seconds
i took this like '46 btw
I cant believe
Paradox should remove planes
Im gonna lose this war due to bombings
Yup
make an infrantry only game mode
haha
Like war thunder, They should make a Ground only gamemode
are the soviets really this stupid?
they cant breach me and yet they try to breach me
Well hitler is dead
What is this
i actually have another map from '48 where it apparently never ended
Why does the german AI always faill at 1944/1943
why is austria still
anschlussed
that didn't come out of yalta for whatever reason
Stupid AI
i remember that
everybody who wasn't mao claimed they were the real china
The soviets really want me dead
amazing
and then i moved mao to manchuria
What nation should i play next
in Iron man
I want to start playing Iron man this is so fun
chinese soviet republic
๐ง
IM never touching anything in asia
albania
then hungary idk
Highly underrated start
That could work
Europe ain't all that anymore
last time i had half the world in m faction
๐ง austria hungary our goat
Said as a USSR main
Very strong focus tree
Lacks manpower but formable should ease that
ive played sweden a few times hwen the DLC came out
you can core all of the nordics
Yup
i know
you can do that with finland also
I couldve done it
but i went the wrong way when becoming fascist, THe slower way without a civil war
paradox should make it a game feature
maybe will take a shot at it next time
who told you stalin was in moscow
and not that he escapes to spain
he could be chilling the far east
make it a dice roll
maybe the in game News paper
higher chances if its a rocket
"Stalin escaped the nuclear blast on moscow by a few minutes"
make it so hitler tag switches to argentina when berlin falls ๐๐ฅ
yup
senor hilter
something like that
and not that he escapes to spain and continues to fight
Soviets really just throwing men
ive killed 5 mill
tag arg
set_ruling_party fascism
Game says that im still wining the war
Hitler isnt the leader
you're right it's Seรฑor Hitler
No
Seรฑor Hilter
No
dud
its not Hitler
its a random argentinian man
you cant just "set ruling party" and have him
doesnt work like that
dude no
ahistorical is strange the germans joined the 4th international โ๏ธ
whats that
i can never get over it
My entire industry is bombed
i hate it when usa just creates a faction and invites the whole americas in ahistorical
Why cant i just surrender?
no
to lets say to the US
oh wait the monroe doctrine is for
and negotiate a peace deal
oh yeah i had that once in an mp and i was wondering why im not producing anything
monroe doctrine isnt a faction its a system
But like
everything in my country is being bombed except the mils
I just dont have resources to make anything rn
if you declare on an american country usa gives u the choice to either sign a white peace or they declare
well for me EVERYTHING was bombed like even friggin supply hubs infrastructure and yeah everything basically
2 guys with maybe half a gun
is this scraping the barrel
finland had 2 million People in 1940s
Just switched to it
economy of doom and despair
๐ง