#hoi4-general
1 messages · Page 320 of 1
You're supposed to prioritise
Or the ones that I actually finish
what country
Russia is a good one
so the turkish one is out
Frances is well balanced
Yes 💀
russia is good
yes but incredebly borning to play
Is the US dollar that shit now
EXACTLY
Cause you're getting scammed
Polish, Baltics, Netherlands, Brazil, Argentinia
USA or UK is good too
Though USA only the hist branch
Bulgaria hits hard too
get dalmatia first then you won't just get stuck
Just complicated
Or naval invade
Some of them are just really short. Like look at the UK communist path and tell me thats a path youd enjoy playing
I mean, if the political branch isn't bloated you got time for other stuff
japan communist path is very good
uk communist path is unfortunately terrible
As it does nowadays
Ye flavourless
I like Frances tree design. Short trees, so u get to do everything
And then don't have to worry about focuses
What’s dalmatia
no need for taht
I thought hoi4 players are good at Geo 😭
But yeah it's that part of croatia that takes up all of the coast
The thing is, with the UK, their industry path basicly doesnt exist. Most times I sit there and dont know what to do because im already finished with the path
It's short but good
It's not filled with 35 day nothing burger focuses
getting albanias 3rd research slot
Unfortunately doesn't scale as well anymore since their coal is mid
They're fixing that
The French economy in older updates was a snowballing monster
Yea
I always caught up to the US factory count as France
Then that means there are buffs that decrease tension
Uh no
Or decrease the amount of tension you get when you do stuff
Tension just stays for a long time
yo lads is mechanized infantry worth it?
For tanks ye
for coastal defense, absolutely
For any defence honestly
wait why are they good for defense and tanks
yeah, true.
i understand tanks but why defense
defense stat is really high
They have high base defense and good org and hp
Hp is very important
Mech has the highest base defence in the game
ooh
if you place it in normandy, D-Day will fail
are they good for attacking as well?
Only one to probably compare to them are rangers when you finish the sf doctrine to stack defence
Nah not really
Not by themselves
I dont have their stats infront of my eyes but I think the attack stat wasnt good
As in, not pure mech
what about with tanks lets say?
36w pure mech gets like 400 soft
Only good attacking trait of mech is their breakthrough
currently only 8 factories with albania
yeah thats the problem
So ye only for defense and in small numbers
oh shi
Unless you wanna produce 200k mech
@eternal palm Whats your opinion on the Yugoslavia tree?
Fine
Very forgettable
Due to its age
it is kinda overpowerd if you release puppets, let them do their focuses and then annex
The yugo tree sits on pretty fast air research buffs for a minor
Is it op? In relation to other minor trees
Imo very convoluted compared to other minors
ik you guys say mechanized is good for defense but is there smth i can do which can specialized in both offense and defense? Because the allies regularly naval invade me and I just wanna fight back against them
yeah I would say so, you get a lot of industry from letting the puppets do their focuses
Spgs
whats that?
How come I cant push through china at all? I was able to do it yesterday
Well Lithuania can annex Russia by 1940
Whar can yugo do? Get puppets.
whats that artillery thing?
In relation, not that strong
is that mobile artillery?
yeah but the Yugo tree doesnt require any skill at all, wich is good for everyone who isnt good
Just have a seperate 24 div army of mountaineers heavy on arty as a response force if you want something cheap
They blast with soft attack alone
actually great idea
Well we're not considering skill are we?
Just comparing the trees, yugo falls off hard
Let's take the Netherlands. Gets a formable early, annexes 2 countries
Much stronger than yugo
oh yeah one more thing should I take the mobile infantry sub-doctorine?
Yep
ok goated
kinda, lithuania annexing soviets by 1940 might be possible, but not something most people can do. Also, does it have to do something with the tree?
cheers for the help
It's general disposition makes it possible. It gets plc, a lot of cores, manpower, good spirits
If you do your doctrines right for your special forces and the artillery subdoctrine, you can have your mountaineer division with around 650-700 soft attack per div
And then killing Russia is enabled by its strong focus tree
when does mussolini join hitler
at some point before anschluss
38
and what if he still hasnt joined
Is it relevant to you?
then he might be going monarchist path
am albania
If you're allied to Germany already, Germany would kill Italy for you
oh yeah lads should i make some amphibious tanks for marines?
what country?
germany
never
Never seen the need for amphib tanks against AI
im never able to invade the uk
theyre very expensive for less soft attack than SPGs now
just build many ships to destroy their entire navy and then invade
Basic marines with pioneers and 1-2 arty battalions can already trash their garrisons
I thought arty was bad for naval invasions?
Heck I'm too lazy to train proper marines and usually invade people with mountaineers because they're seasoned or veteran for me
So they already have gigantic bonuses
same
Often they are just not needed
how do i even get more special forces capacity?
you could also just paradrop into UK and then flood in more divisions
i forgot about paratroopers
easy way to kill france. Cheating, but technicly legal
Special forces doctrines gives you bonuses for certain special forces using less capacity
done
Plus you get more capacity with a bigger army
Everytime I finish the mountaineer doctrine, more than half of my army just gets converted to mountaineers lmao
love being in the axis and not joining wars
The axis will eat everything around you so idk why you wouldn't do anything at all
Is it possible for Poland and lithuania to unite?
Yes
2 Ways
One of which is much stronger than the other
Polish PLC is weak
Lithuanian PLC is mega strong
Poland is usually stronger as Habsburgs
what the poles do...
You steal the czech forts, industry and units and kill Germany very early
Polish superpower
bcs am albania
realistically my non existant army isnt getting 1 point
Whats the best minor in the game

Which one would y'all choose
Prolly Netherlands
Gang actually playing as albania
Hmmmmm maybe I should do a Belgium run
What nations have you played before?
Belgium is painful
Nah
Who
That's a fire nation
The guy i replied to the message before
Only till I invade the Netherlands
what can albania do in ww2 realistically
It can die to italy
The Netherlands doesn't even have to invade, they annex Belgium and Luxembourg diplomatically
am still alive
thank you to PDX for the wonderful opportunity to do this completely stupid and pointless achievement
Nuclear subs?
Civ-maxxing
Alright this is either your information, or you're doxxing someone
2nd prob
yeah I love sitting here and waiting until 1956 when all my special projects are done 💀
I did that 2 days ago and instantly sent 100 missiles to China out of spite
i have two achievements to go after this
did i just read the british banishing the royal family bruv
the beat China and Japan after declaring <1940 one and the stupid Japanese one where you have to go dem and capitulate Hitler
Cuba simulator
Thats what happens when you choose non-historic
The brits are communits
the spanish are communist
make good mountaineers, underman your land border and go "oh no! I guess you have to cycle charge me!" then when the Turks are exhausted just send in your mountaineers
You only rush for the balkan diplomacy and keep relations up with them for free civs, that has you enough economy to scale with mils off the bat
you take Istanbul and then kill all the troops in the tiles north and south of it inside Edirne, then fall back and let the AI walk back in and repeat
And then rush for the war
thanks any good mountaineer divisions?
how can i get garrison support to be needed
I use 8/3s cos mountains are 75 width and 25 goes into 75 evenly
that + go down your mountaineer doctrine
right + right
Whats the best doctrine/subdoctrine for rangers
Turkey can be easily broken in the edirne pocket trap
You encircle, retreat
Rinse and repeat
booooo I said this stop stealing my words
Until they're left with like 5 units and you run them over
I'm blind
1st one depends on your location
do you have a picture cause im dumb and dont understand these terms 😭
if you're fighting in Asia/Latin America pick Jungles
Division design is 8 mountaineers and 3 artillery battalions
Belgium fascist burgundy defending against the axis and allies
use mountaineers
yeah go left then right
left right right
ohhh
thanks
Rangers give more buffs for forests
yeah but recon rangers + 4th mountaineer doctrine means soft inf goes bye bye
Rangers only know how to defend
Attack wise they're mid
Exactly what ima be doing
Yo i started out as Lithuania got the king, then poland, livonia and russia and now i got 6million ground army all dying out of attrition while idle help
don't put 200 divisions in the same tile
attrition problems solved
far out am I Napoleon or something
All my divs are 24 each and generals and everything assigned
Nun like that is happening
Hmm try increasing motorization in supply hubs
Someone threatening my spot?
Do any main infantry doctrines do anything for special forces?
@tepid nova how dare I claim I am Napoleon when king Space is around
all inf doctrine boosts also add to special forces
but not art obviously
true
not true
Not true indeed
anything that says inf mot/mech does things for special forces
I usually have 4 arty in my mountaineers for Europe
Outside of it, I go pure mountaineers or just 1 arty
Ahhh okay which would give the most defense buffs?
btw i got the experimental land facilit as albania
i mean it's probably better just to go pure mountaineers tbh
probably GBP
not the worst decision
oh boy, we have an IC calculator in chat
either you expand or you put a lot of quality into your divs
Okay what subdoctrines
not even ic
basically adding artillery trades org for soft attack, and it doesn't make much of a difference in that respect
I like the soft attack stacked plus I still maintain terrain bonuses to a lesser extent as long as I keep rangers as a support company
its 1940
also yeah mountaineers obviously have better terrain bonuses than artillery
bcs i couldnt figure out shit about it
plus better composition bonuses (you know advisors + generals)
guys how much time did you need to play HOI4 to undertstand it?
mech albania be like
am doing 1944 gun research rn in tech
nice
but how does the experimental facility work
I mean my doctrines decrease the combat width for both mountaineers and arty so I have fat templates anyway
They blast anything in sight
Plus the arty helps me with the sf limit
Means more overall divisions
Instead of having shitter infantry
this is accounting for the artillery decrease
from 3 to 2.2
infantry just gets so much better buffs
Mind if I ask how does a experimental facility work
I was hoping to make Albania a bit more advanced in military
so what you want to do is research flame tanks and absolutely nothing else
hope this helped
basically first you need research points
you get that from the facility with idle scientists
and research
and then once you do you need to unlock prerequisite techs
It's pretty self-explanatory, if you can't find it just click on the facility
Am Albania, too broke
what does scorched earth do when it is blocked in custom game settings?
It has guns does it?
no but it does take supply
for albania probably military engineering vehicles instead
So my infantry focused ass should've have gotten a air one since I have a air force instead?
An air force as Albania is a brave dream
i mean the air ones are typically less useful than the land ones
Only the more advanced air tech like axial jet engines and supersonic jets are useful
So just support stuff?
But that's endgame stuff
Am in 1940
Jets are 1945 stuff
yeah and it takes 7 to get all the way there
you can get them earlier than 1945 though
true
1941/42 for US
guys how do i do naval invasions im new to the game
im producing convoys and gave my troops orders
but nothing is happening
do you have supremacy?
ah i need naval supremecy?
yesss
and then you should be good to go :)
ok ty
yes they should
no problem
who are you trying to invade?
Uk...
as germany I assume?
Yes
How are you trying to invade? Like, from where?
would anyone be down to show me how to play hoi4?
ask Chak, maybe he wants to play hoi4 with you
whos chak?
just ask @ chak
So I saw the patch notes and it said they will release soon and I hope that's later today soon.
Games kinda broken rn
guys will 36 divisions be enough to hold the soviets as finland?
@tepid nova its time for war.
Get more. The Soviets start the game with 138
do they have skis?
this man boutta loose everything
operation barbarossa
ANGETRETEN!
I can already tell you lost that shit
how should i plan it
Zurück
thats what i did
all armies attached to field marshal and frontline
its 2 field marshals
Oh
place the other one in romania then
Unless you didnt ally with them..
You did right?
one second
no way
theyre democratic
Wasnt it that the AI cant deal well with 2 fronts?
they constantly switch sides
Romania
they are like italy
March 41, Historical
yeah... totally historical...
@tepid nova this aint good
Hist mode, the joke didnt land
how bro looks at me after almost having a crash at 175 KMH
pardon? THAT is historical?
Historical mode.
Hist focuses enabled.
jesus
its so boring to play
in vanilla
how do people do it
I always play vanilla but historical focuses off
I see why
You have no equipment
aww come on
nevermind I kinda figured it out and the uk is mine
do you have -10 000 tanks? 😭
good job
Ty
not far off
😭😭😭
💀
show me your logistics please @split fulcrum
bad
-7k tanks
Your troops be using their fists
Wait hold on @split fulcrum why do you have anti air in your garrisons
Change your garrisons bro
your tank divisions would smoke them
how
Click on your flag and go to occupied territories in the row under your focus but above your laws/advisors and change it there
ohh
im using the infantry template for it
which has anti air in it
Well you should have more aa now
im changin it to cav template
i dont think so
the more you look at it the worse it gets
u should be able to push through that if u had guns
why do you have aa in a garrison div
i changed that
china is kinda broken
Am playing albania and I haven't expanded
Holy pp
i could probably go to 4.50 pp
Wanna play albania
(Losing 40 full med tank divs)
nah
Proceeds to replace them with 80 a month later
Why not, you seem like a pro
busy playing china
also uh
i am not the best in hoi4
Albania has no special tree so it's not hard to understand it
but tbf i have 2.3k hours in hoi4
Play canada
They have a special tree, thats pretty simple and easy to understand
yooo u got it
Am just playing albania cus it seemed in a ok spot to attack greece
yo guys will the ussr ever stop attacking finland in the winter war if they're holding?
Wanna play albania
I am part of the axis
hmmm
hmmm
Same with italy
You can cap enemy nations
peace treaties
Steal
You get a % of their stockpile
is that it?
You can also use equipment capture ratio
germany
paratroopers
or js delete ur cheeks divs
The higher it is the more guns you gain from battles
dont attack on low equip
i can only attack norway
its ass basically
Btw what's a good experimental option for infantry based army
You don't have 250+ hours gng
huh
Mb, talking about experimental facilities
steam
oh
you click on the game in library
Land experimental facilities, I just need to know what is there that's good for infantry
Yeah
I am gonna be getting night vision
so this is a thing now
Export cheese internationally?
in any case the enemy's equipment is probably worse
no you turn a port into cheese
the way to win as germany is too spam medium tanks and pray the uks navy doesnt do anything
i need equipment
how do I get more range for my ships? why is this area red if I have their HQ port close by?
You export cheese with that port
What you playing?
germany
How many mills
set your supply base to one of the islands
you're probably basing your ships in japan
I have the hq in truk on one of them
huh
pov me when converting 100+ divisions to special forces
it aint enough
i need more
way way more
i need those x5
to become x10
Maybe you change some civs to mills
maybe drop the destroyers too but idk
add them back later on once war starts
What weapon is that
Can I see tech for it, am curious
it should be gun 2
gun 3
well it's labeled basic, gun 1, and then gun 2 in game
and the last is gun 3
hmmm
so yeah confusing
so gweher 98 is gun 0
This in theory stronger than gun 3 in like latvia?
printf("quite interesting")
but at the same time latvia doesn't have much steel
therefor
I mean the gun alone
i feel like this requires testing
Pretty sure when it’s f string it’s like print (f”..”)
with a gun
i dunno
May I know the year
in C its printf
Oh for python it’s print(f”)
Am in 1940 with max guns in infantry but my dumbass went a plane route without jets
I went with heavy fighters
comrades, what Nation should I play this time?
Albania
What me to give a serious pick?
yes, and dont you dare say estonia
I don't know but is south Africa bad
they have a worse focus tree than estonia
Estonia has the basic one
Then I don't have the dlc
maybe without dlcs
i don't think they're much better actually
Wb chile
You would need no step back
as in jet engine ~ engine 3
Okay
the one with more green
I'm colorblind
see
fair
go with the green choice
I heard Chile has a huge ass formable
is this like the ottoman navy in 1903 or something
you can kick out the colonisers
No, custom nation
And own south and north America?
Worst part is it's a naval major 🥀
if you win
But it has a path for it I believe
Is it with ur mod which looks like a really big Denmark
Mayhaps
Perfect path for you my friend
No. i am gonna play the communist path to unify south america and there is nothing you can do to stop me
I am not gonna conquer the USA and Britain
Happens to me, doesn't corrupt any fikes
*files
@azure palm can Chile afford a airforce
if you win
airforce is required
if you want to win
The first battle?
all of the war
He also needs physic experimental facilities?
physic?
Nukes
physical?
Different thing
i dont think you need nukes
physics?
not at the start
I have 2 mils
Wb civs?
I am inside and still cold
yeah
It has 2 mills tho
make more
Does it have lots of civs?
take uruguay and brasil
dont battleplan
Do you have dlc?
dont waste gun on bad garrison
Like the south america one
Am not doing it rn, someone else is
@azure palm is doing it
noo brooo
Anyone else find state borders that perfectly follow a river satisfying or is it just me
I do
Like this for example
My current limitation is the lack of civs rn
One of the main reasons why I think the rhineland should have better states
Should I build civs
no
But it's my only limitation
Just conquer them
With Albania?
I love HOI4 logic
take them from yugo, and greece
"Why make it yourself when you can just STEAL!" 🗣️
Well if you in the axis just take yugo
Ok
Naval Speed is one of the most important stats in naval battles, it isn't just about how fast your fleet moves but it is also a factor to naval damage
the right one is better, -20% naval speed is way, wayy too heavy
not to mention the other debuffs lol
And I won't die cus I am barely militarised due to size?
Minor setback 🗿
They get some decent bonuses in their political tree tho
So ig that helps to make up for the sheer lag-behind
What's the country
Playing albania when your a new player is crazy
Custom, doesn't exist
so probably
Ok
Why, it's Albania
The yugo army will wipe the floor with you before germany and italy destroy them
Albania is very very weak
Usually minor countries for new players, especially ones without content is very difficult
I have Hitler on my side
low factory count, very few building slots and low manpower
Also Albania gets pressured by Italy even in the Axis
Italy will still try to annex you
I am a fascist and I did the boost of relation with them
If it's historical they won't care
It isnt
PDX doesn't really make checks for opinion
High relations dont do anything in hoi4
God help you
Why
Your PC will be screaming in an hour or so
In what year?
With Non-Historical, any honestly
We have communist British here
just got all china achivements in one run
The uk went communist 💀
Also @tulip thorn, this look like a decent early civil war tree?
its over for your cpu
yeah
It's more for flavor rather than actually necessary to live
Spain as well
Spain being communist dont matter
the british decolonize when communist
Us is as well I think
The us is just weak when communist
thats about it
The british communist ai decolonize
And that makes the game very very slow
Because more nations are free
And that doesn't ruin my save file?
They still haven't fixed not being able to make proper frontlines against commie china
even after releasing a dlc about asia
Also creating factions feels a bit useless
How do i get rid of a country naval blockading me?
you ask nicely
You dont
thanks paradox!
Btw what if I wanna make a airforce as Albania
Like heavy fighters 3 type of navy
Good luck
How do i add specific traits to generals (console command) which isn't using "Allowtraits"?
Like that's why I wanna build civs
Have enough to buy resources and produce planes
Albania just doesnt have the build slots and industry to build planes at all
I have max infrastructure in some places
They Def can have like a spot or 2 left
That just boosts construction speed in that state
Ik
But I got all the national focus civs and mills
And that gives like 3-6 spots right?
Just play a dif nation if you want to learn better
Am already at 1940
Albania is not it
But at least I wanna end the run
Well good luck
+isn't like 4 civs enough to make a airforce
For a nation like mine
not even close
Against someone like greece
Greece is weirdly strong sometimes
Communist Greece
They have forts and a big army
And a big airforce?
They are still strong
I can gain air superiority on them maybe?
You are not building all that many planes as albania
After all am using heavy fighters 3 against normal fighters
Does the tech difference not make a change?
Don't think a nation like Greece has heavily developed airforce
I dont know anything about air before bba
Before what
Ooh
Well, does the AI develop navy or planes usually?
Twins ✌️
Like AI can't develop navy or airforce can it?
it can
I guess I will find out
I love the Spanish Civil War. Its so easy to train up divisions.
Hows playing Chile?
Actually fun. I am micromanaging the spanish civil war and winning it.
We're debating if Albania can make a airforce strong enough against Greece, what do you think
albania cant beat greece
No
Wont happen
@tepid nova i seem to have done something
no longer in an infatry eq deficit
my troops now actually have guns!!!!
i still need to get that tank number up
I have up to date planes
you need to stop offensives, change garrison template or remove support companies because you are running out of it all
also i managed to lose more troops to greece than to france
garrison template is cav template
base cav
Greece just goated
the ai cheesed that athena defense so hard
Does Greece have strong airforce?
Cus am gonna prep heavy fighters 3 against him as albania
Nah
Like up to date 1940s heavy fighters
Idk how many
Am in 1940
what did you do in those 4 years then
because youre albania
Tech, national focuses, not die to itsly
Trying to increase manpower gain
The issue is that divisions train slow
And Albania has 1 at the start
i dont doubt
One singular division
with all the money we are giving paradox why cant they make a hearts of iron 4 movie
thats called a ww2 documentary
Cus that's just any ww2 movie
mate i said a hoi4 movie not a ww2 documentary
like
ww2 documentary
Unless you wanna see communist British and democratic soviet somehow
with hoi4 map
Viva España!
Japan and Germany just killed the soviets
I DID IT! I SAVED SPAIN
paradox pls gotta make a hoi4 movie
British is communist here
Dont tell me they formed the "British Communist Alternative"
Nah uk is democratic
Not here sir
PLS HOI4 MAKE A MOVIE
guys can anyone help me?
@split fulcrum heavy fighters 3 are 1944 tech
yes
@tepid nova oooo
i have a single actually good panzer division
this is not good
So like I think I stand a small chance
ok
you have way too many panzers compared to equipment
you are overextending you're capabilities
i can merge em
Its the worst faction name there is
Ok
Guess the amount of divisions I have rn in albania
lowk imma try siberian tiger or whatever that one badge is called
Also fun fact, Albania has no starting airforce
wait where did conversion tech go
Integrated into other techs
ohh
@tepid nova its getting late...
september 1941
i havent started barbarossa
problem is
How are you so slow
i basically dont have panzers
Then go without them
20?
hmmm
Bye what does special forces do more exactly?
Half cus it's slow as hell
in this game
ahh
Also, what does special forces focus tree do?
It's in the army effort
Are militia useful with People's militia doctrine along with this focus?
Turkey getting cooked by Greece
oof the casualties
You can't edit Japanese militias i believe
Ah ok
But the communist chinese militias are editable, so it is very useable for them
So I'm better off picking some other infantry doctrine?
i accidentally invited allies against yugo and now i only got kosovo
Yeah
question, do you want to build tank forces
What if I say yes?
mobile infantry would be good in that scenario, assault infantry isn't bad either
Alrighty then
DId you not make airplanes?
JUst surrender 💔
should i try beat kingdom of hungary without allise
I am losing against Argentina
someones a imposter
Tannu Tuva is on demon time this game, wtf.
Yes I enabled localised city names, so all cities have their local names instead of english
hey im playing temu tuva!
@tepid nova i think imma go to bed
I can savescum that again
I need to rebuild my panzers too
And a ton more planes
The soviets have so many troops
Every time i win a battle they come with more
Goodnight my little Napoleon
Super fair WW2
@dusky burrow wth do i do to fix this
You basically always want to start south and work your way up the coast when fighting Argentina as Chile
Better supply
Easier to get encirclements
Yeah, well, it was the first time I tried
Did you lose? That was a lot of red 😭