#ask-for-help-here
1 messages · Page 202 of 1
Hover over mp
hover over the manpower
ehh no idea
who are you playing as
hover over the manpower and send ss
fully mobilized
go to extensive
as germany
your usually fine on extensive
wym by extensive 😭
extensive conscription lol
your conscription law bro
rn your on limited
to up to extensive
100pp
where do i do that 😭
Nws
also dont go up a law while not fully mobilized
Make sure you dont go above extensive until you mobilized everyone
alright
Cz going higher on the conscrip law dosent change how fast you get mp
okay got it thanks
Wait when getting license from a ally is there 25% debuff on production of it ?
yes
Does anyone know the conditions for the Aden transfer event?
I want to skip the war with Poland and make it fascist (I want to do the Focus Danzig for Slovakia instead of Danzig or War) should i do that i have never done that
you should try to boost their fascist support and start a civil war with a coup
Question, When launching the HOI4 Launcher not the Paradox V2 Launcher, but the Hoi4 launcher i get the error ''A JavaScript error occured in the main process'' what does this even mean and what can i do when this pops up everytime when launching the hoi4 launcher?
I'm pretty sure there are no conditions, you always have to transfer away from Raj. Although I might be wrong.
I remember playing once as king's party UK and I didn't get the transfer.
how do i use nukes
is conc industry arguably superior if i know what im doing
just used missiles at the end but still didn't figure out how am i supposed to do it with bombers
where you can select all the raids, there is a symbol for nukes
press it
kaiserredux
play malta rome path
Hey I have an issue where i reloaded to a past save now when i start the timer the game shuts down entirely evrytime
Anyone know what to do ?
Save is corrupted
Start new game
Hi I get javascript error when opening Victoria 3 and HOI4 can smn help me :((
Hi guys
Got a clear surplus of medium tanks but
Why isn’t it being added into my divisions?
wait for it to be delivered
Kk
where are your divisions located
I dont believe that im going to say that ever in my life but as sowjet union im going to run out of manpower... anything I can do except going for even more expensive conscription law or agitrop (already did)?
garrison laws
change it to one cav template & local police force
& look up manpower in focus tree
Are tactical bombers like CAS but stronger?
what width would be better, 35.7 or 30.6
thanks but didnt help alot and there are no more focuses i could do. should i do the next conscription law or just having too low manpower?
yeah you can do that
whats the difference between and
so the fact that the "+" is missing, doesn't mean anything?
Would anyone be down to hop in call and I can screen share to help me out with the basics?
its from a decision
what width would be better, 35.7 or 30.6
10+5 by modifying
how can you get a field marshall rulling the soviet union and ow do you choose ich one its gonna be?
but its two different decisions which are feeling like they are excluding each other
read, the left modifies the already existing one. You have now danish produce with 10 percent con goods, the left picture modifies that bonus by those stats on left
If you would go with right you would lose those bonuses but on +side you would get-10% con goods
How many divs should I use when trying to take ethiopia
get everything from the homeland
just split them kinda equally
put the mountaineers in the north
i do like a 60/40 split
want more in the north usually
dont forget air
i see thank you!
only cas tho
you don’t beed to change the template
the starting units are sufficient
And should I like assign all homeland units here?
yes
whats the best mountaineers div for a really REALLY bad nation like afghan
because i fear flame tanks arent really viable early afghan
25w if not then go lower
what are the support divs i should get
like
in order from most important
to get this if you have the resources and research
Suppiort art -> Support aa
mountain rangers if you can get them it would be good to
what research do mountain rangers even need
is it just the doctrine?
then like support equipment and trucks?
basically first mountain doctrine unlocks them
and then there is another mountain buff for it
gl!
hopefully no civil war
because
theyre really
really painful
idk if ive ever won one
hi how do i learn hoi4
i just bought hearts of iron would anyone be willing to help me learn some basics?
youtube
Uhm
Why can't i research paratroopers
I don't even see the option
how do I get them
I don't see them in infantry research
look down
Yeah
screenshot
yes haha
no problem
did you mean 24w here
also german volunteers are so broken in afghan war
so happy i did that focus
- one line AA so you wouldn't need support one. 24w is fine too
like this?
AA not arty
If i am in the middle of a treaty and select terretory to puppet and stuff, can i save there and i am going to be at the moment again, if i load the save or will it automatically close?
why not support AA?
in teachers here for beginners ?
dm me
ah
add more mountaineers
actually remove 1?
25w is ideal for actual mountains
no 32 width is
remove the line arty
mountain width is 50+25x ...
iirc you could squeeze 1.33x more width into the division
yes, but you get combat penalties that are (slightly) bigger than the extra stats you squeeze in
ideally you want to match the width, but being off is not too bad since the rework, apart for a couple specific widths that work worse than most.
But if you are optimizing for one specific terrain, you should definitely try to conform 1/2 of its base width
Can someone help me with this game? It’s been 2 days and I can’t even move my soldiers
The yt tutorials are so ha d
How exactly does it work with using spies to increase trade and get more resources per trade ?
to clarify, spy trade mission doesn't give you more resource per civ
watch bittersteel
Oh ok only puppets give more per civ ?
yes, apart for some specific changes in some focus trees
when i only got active templates with modern tanks should i use medium or light tanks or cav for Garrison? Production isnt an issue
if production is not an issue, light tanks (WW1 chassis, everything as cheap as possible, easy maintenance if you have it)
i dont have that dlc
well, unless you chase absolutely minor MP saving for a significant IC increase, then heavies
well, cheapest light tank you can make even if outdated
but you struggle with losses more because your division is smaller
32w is typically the ideal for mountains for this reason
plus mountaineers will be used in non-mountain non-marsh terrain too
I have a question, is there a way to make use of the motolov ribbentrop pact and force the ussr to take poland for me
I want to know how to make the ussr invade poland, like is it with the treaty or do i have to wait for the 17 of september 1939 and then demand it
never appens in game
the ussr never attacks poland
will "naval mission efficiency" buff cas if its deployed from a carrier?
Wow.
Guess i can't invade early
on top of the fact that overwidth has grown more and more of a joke with how many bonuses you can apply to offset the penalties, and since the bonuses are %, they work better the more stats you have. i.e bigger = better
no you can. you can solo poland as germany alooe
with every major patch, divisions get ever so slightly larger, its like paradox wants the divisions obese or something /s
I know but i also want to invade the balkans
Divisions should be reworked to be smaller imo. It's overpowered, unrealistic, and silly.
invade them later in 1941
guess that works
is there an optimal stormtrooper template
like do i just replace scout for stosstruppen
yeah that works remove the support at for support arty
Bet
that one is old
there isnt a doctrine that gives -0.4 cw anymore
modern inf bricks would be using recon tank at minimum, super heavy arty, flame tank etc.
statbloat from those support companies too big to ignore for inf
add flame tanks and shh if you have nsb
idk if what im asking for applies because im asking help with a mod
but what is the best templates for TFR american civil war im playing as NSM
Where do i get that occupation modifier?
Have compliance be 90% i believe
Hi guys, I saw someone say line artillery is mid but I like to pair them with infantry for defending. Is this not ideal?
Like in my historical France game I'm using 7inf2art
9/0 is quite good for defending
More org and defense
Artillery provides a nice amount of soft attack, but doesn't give much else stat wise
Also it is 3 width instead of 2 width
Say you start running low on manpower does it make sense to use line art in place of infantry or does it make more sense to use tanks or some other unit for defending?
just build spgs
line artillery is horrible and there's a video in pins talking about why
i been trying to take mexico for a full week, i become communist, destory the civil war then i attack mexico. Once im half way into mexico then italy and germany send troops and i get into a stalemate, then my troops get tired without alot of supplies and its like 1946 and i cant break through
and also 7/2 is from pre-COVID
any help???
Thank you!
who is the best infantery template?
just read above comments to see
whats a good spg design? im a bit confused i just got nsb all the new tank stuff is kinda confusing
max out soft attack, that's it
get a three men turret and the only other two "good" modules that don't buff soft attack but can be put on is lvl3 radio and easy maintenance
alr how about tanks? im assuming using mediums still?
how the hell do i win as the german empire? what do i do?
ive tried multiple times
before gotterdamerung i conquered the whole world
they full equiped?
wdym? its germany just don't get surounded on two fronts
they never want full equiped i only need 43 all time i doing this
handle the russians first then the allies
only this game happen this
uh not sure then ig austria is pumping out a bigger army
and they don't want to intergrate
is this an attacking or deffending?
yeah cz i was gonan say if this is a deffending template its way to big
i mean personally i think against the ai and with the right doctrines it should be good enough but i'm sure someone else is gonna tune in
is grand battleplan right or mobile warfare?
imo gbp is better cz of the planning bonus
but if you value high speed then mw is better
what about this for tanks? use medium tanks when research is done
and add logistics
do you have no step back?
what does that mean?
its a dlc
mm alr imo you don't need this many tanks
and you don't have enough mobile inf
remember tanks take away from your organization
so strip it down to 6-8 tanks but also balance it with motorized inf too
you wanna aim somewhere around 20-30ish orginization
thats kinda the problem
It probably would work well enough. Maybe add a flame tank if you have it
Oh, no dlc
30 width and 30 org now
what is it?
i take paris from fascist france, italy joins. then britain bc its also fascist. then the US apparently joins bc its guaranteeing belgium
its the stupid shit
thats what ruins me
Light tanks are quite mediocre, but the speed might see some use
ofc i cant naval invade britain bc their navy got buffed and idk jack shit abt navy
theyre beyond useless
lmao
use mediums only
perfect if you have the land resarch facility swap out the regular shovels with assualt enginiers
gonna replace em with medium as soon as research is done
They aren't great, but they can
they are good for smaller industries
That's good
and support for fast divs
also get mechnized inf
and by themself its like if motorized and tanks had a baby
can work but i see mediums are more successful from what i have seen
heavy tanks dont give much higher breaktrhough than mediums
theyre just better @ piercing
wrong reply?
alr thanks
ah and then the russians come in yeah?
Oh 100%
yessir
well actually
this time the ussr offered for me to join its faction
Light tanks are quite sad since you cant put medium guns on later chassis
but i already had a big european alliance
You should be able to, but you can't
so i didnt know what joinig the comintern would have done ot my bloc
alright brother here is my suggestion
redo the run
but this time militraize and get ready for the russians
they attack in about 1941ish cz thats when they invade poland
Who doesn't like a good run where you live after almost capitulating
by the time thats over you should have a big enough military to take on the rest of europe
FACTTSSSS
Those are some of the most fun games I have had
i love managing to pull my self out of horrible disaster
I was playing liangguang or whatever in kaiserreich and had the whole Qing empire on me, but i eventually was able to unify all of China singlehandedly
by the time the ussr is defeated (1942-43), going against virtually any nation in europe is going to result in a huge western/allied coalition that stacks divs
perfect
thats why i knock france's jaw into its brain in 1940
they overstack themselves
cz if they have a huge coalition right
yh
yh but im going to need divs with insane breakthrough
The reinforce meme is your friend
their supply hubs rails and airfrields
Theoretically not opening up combat width can be your friend
And you meme them out of a tile
ive seen it work before in the african front in my last run
= no enemy or = knife thru butter
what's the best flame tank design
not if you have total air domianice
just a couple strat bombers say 500 or more
will criple their supply
plus with god tier air force means cas will ruin them
- invade belgium and luxembourg in 1936
- civil war + kaiser + rearmament + see to the eastern front (non aggression pact w britain)
- cap ussr when it invades poland by 1942/43
- invade france by 1943 and use air force + divs with absolutely insane breakthrough
- twiddle my thumbs
how tf do i make a good air force tho
should i spam cas or fighters
how do i fight the allied air force
do you have bba?
whats that
its a a dlc by blood alone
yeah
kaiserreich ?
for fighters get the best light air frame and strap on as many 4x hmgs as your best single engine can afford
and add self sealing fuel tanks and cockpit armor
for cas get the best air frame and single engine and strap on as many bomb locks
spam out fighters first you need to maintain air domiance first
since cas dont rlly work that well if the skies are contested
for bombers best air frame best 4 engin add as many strat bombing moudles
if you need a more indepth guide plenty of air guides
yeah its a germany path
I'm having trouble trying to navel invade Britain as France, I started with a civil war and wanted to take over Britain to get navel superiority and to be able to invade Belgium and Netherlands with no trouble, but every time i try to do so they wont go, and i watched videos on how too but when i try to replicate it, it wont work. im a new player btw so i don't know all the stuff so I'm just asking for help.
When you puppet a state there is a bar that fills to Satelite the country. Whats the pros and cons of that?
as the puppet master you want the autonomy of your puppet to be as low as possible so you can gain the maximum amount of resources and factories from them
as far as I can think unless you trying to let your puppet go free there is no pro to letting your puppet's autonomy to rise
its proably because you don't have naval domiance over the british since yk biggest navy and all
make sure your entire fleet is there set your patrol and strike force fleet
and make sure your navy is trained and experinced
does it make sense to not give germany sudentenland as british and fight?
Go to the paradox forums and make a bug report thread
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/forums/hearts-of-iron-iv-bug-reports.951/
thanks
how do i get rid of obselete armed forces as norway
Yes to defeat germany
But it also defeats fun game
so dont do it
Monarchism
yeah for sure
since it gives germany a tough target with the level 8 forts on the chec boarder and plus by then france should be in alies
so its easyish to push thru the rineland
rip im already super facist
Does making someone a field marshal have any adverts effects other than the 'recently promoted' time limited debuff?
how good is this medium tank for 1938?
nope
plan to use it until 1940
uh perhaps make it faster? its only a tad bit faster then your infantry
perhaps up to 8 kph so it can keep it with your mechinized inf?
what speed would you suggest is optimal?
ok cool
thanks
other then that i suggest some minor upgrades thru out that time as they become avaliable/afordable to ur industry
hows this?
think this is as fast as i can get it
increased engine by 1 to 4
now at 7.5 kmph
if. i leave it at 6 we have 7.9 kmph but only 60% reliability
yeah i reckon that will have to do
drop it a bit more if need be too
but i think yeah you found the right balance
is that negligible?
New here. Learning. Holy crap this is next level complicated. It’s glorious.
Got crushed in my first campaign but … kept playing after(?)… 2 hours later I’m trying to figure out how to launch a war when I realized I’ve been playing as a puppet state or something since getting crushed.
Biggest Q: is optimizing for tile width actually that important? (Like, would a “too big” battalion be more than 10% worse than optimized one?)
u got enough synth refineries?
not particularly unless you trying to try hard against players
i don't think so
might be worth building some?
Ah. Not at all. Campaign only
eh its an okay amount of fuel usage just keep an eye on it
def
yes
right in witch case for your infantry stick to around 18 or so
lemme guess, paused trait glitch ?
(promote, pause the game while opening the trait menu, assign trait, close : you now have both traits)
(also head to paradox forums for bug reports)
18 width is usually the best for line holders, 36 is the best for offensive
no, you can take the focus, "install auftragstatistik," give both of them the assault doctrine, then take "defend the vaterland," and give them both the defending trait with the buffs of that focus
oh, not even an exploit
bruh
you're lacking convoys, not trains nor trucks
dang
ports that don't have a railway connection to your capital will require convoys
you can fix that by connecting a lvl 1 railway to said port
nope! thats why i was wanting to report it, but i got the information i needed to do so
i been trying to take mexico for a full week, i become communist, destory the civil war then i attack mexico. Once im half way into mexico then italy and germany send troops and i get into a stalemate, then my troops get tired without alot of supplies and its like 1946 and i cant break through
help pls
as what
america
How are you losing to mexico as usa
thats actually harder then beating them
what exactly is the problem here
is there a big red box on ur units
italy and germany intervene half way of me in mexico
then i get a stalemate, they stackk 30 units each tile then eventually we cant get anywhere
Do you have a navy
yes
soimeone said that but i do like patrol with my fleet and they some how dont kill the germans its like they come from south america
and d day germany they dont have enough units to cover that and soviets
shipping from vichy france africa probaly
or just from germany proper
just convoy raid
and destroy all their divisons in transit
if thatdoesnt work then naval invade them
idk what year it is but if they have 30 units in one tile in mexico they dont have neough units for that and soviets and coast guard
wtf is a convoy raid
Convoys are naval supplies
They transfer troops, matierels, and supplies
U have submarines to raid these convoys, but u can also do it extremely uneffectively with surface ships
If u make small groups of submarines and put them on convoy raid in the navy tab u can destroy the convoys
So if a german div is in cuba and u convoy them on the way they wil lget destroyed
damn ty
didnt know you can do that
ima try
because mexio weak as shiz normally
just germany are fat and intervene
are basic subs good enough? @blissful nova
yes but make new ones
as usa u have massivei ndustry
so make the most and newest subs possible
while building surface ships too
u can choose ur priority depending on if ur fighting a big navy like uk or small navy like germany
ty ty
So is the general single player army strategy just to use infantry plus some support companies for defence?
Is there any time you put anything other than infantry for defending?
who is the best template of infantry for new players?
i am novice, and trying to starting with a chill infantry for invade uruguay, brasil, paraguay, etc
I saw a vid of a guy trying to make OP tank divisions and he had flammpanzer in his experiments but i dont, how do i get this.
yep, i saw a lot of videos where ppl make a full divisions of tanks
but idk how to get tanks hahaha and im so stressed because i cant progresse
am new too. its fun though i will learn and so will you
That's if you can't provide offensive troops for every tile
If you can fill the line with offensive divisions then you don't need any defensive
Requires gotterdamureng. If you just have nsb it's in 1939 engineer tech
You don't need tanks in sp it's just for style points and less casualties
You should prepare some naval invasions in central Mexico and probably declare in 1940
Mexico isn't that hard to take IMO, they should have like 30 divisions and they will be spread thin by your naval invasions
At least that's how I conquered them as Chile
What's the meta for capital ship to screens ratio?
Depends on your screening efficiency
around 1 to 4 sounds fine
Cool that's what I usually try for
Seems like most countries start with more than enough screens so it's building all capital ships
Build carriers
Even for Mediterranean?
yeah carriers are good
Carrier naval bombers do the most damage among all types of naval attack
what should i do now
im very close but these rats just stack
take the ports and they'd starve
how to take port
but yeah more naval invasions
what do your marines look like and if you have air what does that look like too
oh damn i have no air and no marine
Air is very good
A big part of getting better for me was making sure not to lose the air war
you're fighting in mexico btw
you can't just rely on normal infantry and tanks because it's mountainous and filled with jungle
ty i sent some bombs and air
Special forces are very good at those sorts of terrain
hello liv, hello crab, hello catholic
indeed marines, forest rangers and mountaineers are pretty good especially big special forces divisions
what module allows tank to be artillery
It should have an icon next to it I forget the name
heavy howziter
Like an explosion icon maybe
close support guns, medium howitzers 1 and 2 and heavy howitizers
that allows your tank role to be a normal tank or a Self propelled artillery
Is there a way, when playing as Belgium, you can ask a 2nd time for nations to join in the EU? or do I need a mod to do it. Had several runs when they dont wanna join in the EU faction and then im locked out of forming the EU nation
End Date So Far: July 3, 1936
Ironman on Normal
66 Hours on HOI4 So Far
Any tips for improvement?
If you share your divisions designs im sure youll get some good pointers
And your production screen/stockpiles
i just changed my infantry and panzer divisions for right now
Infantry: 9 Infantry and a Cavalry Recon Detachment with the usual support
Panzers: 6 light tanks and 2 motorized infantry with the usual support
usual support
can mean alot of things
for me that means med flame tank, assault engineers, arty, aa, light tank recon
for armor divs
okay, so like the ones you start with in the beginning of the game
so recon, engineers, etc
6 light tanks and 2 motorized has too little HP and too little organization to function properly
quite a few nations start with no support companies in their templates
i started as germany
how do i reassign fleets to new ports
alr
also light tanks aren't that good, you should try medium spg
alright
ctrl alt right click iirc
so this is infantry
How do I increase casualties?
By destroying more enemy units
How can I add more manpower to the enemy unit?
You cant
Looks fine I like to set uo my support companies for infantry as engineers, support arty and support anti air and optionally 2 of the three ranger recon, field hospitals, and logistics
alr
What's the meta div types/ designs? It feels like whatever i put out the AI always beats me? Esp as the Soviets
take a look at the pinned posts. There should be one on army divs
you cant unless you switch to them and edit it yourself
Alright I am editing the templates
How do I make this raise alot so that I do not have too many divisions
add more units
battalions
Is their a mod where I can get more battalions?
uh mabye
yk actually it could be production tho i'm pretty sure most of the time my divs are fully equipped?
Like battalion slots
i know theres one for support companies
It's annoying cause ik i'm doing something wrong cause i keep getting beaten but i just don't know what
you have red air
i keep forgetting air 😭
that's your problem
ok i remember now i keep forgetting to research them
Yeah you might want to start again, this time focus on planes eariler.
what are the best ones to go for?
light planes and medium planes and make fighters, cas and heavy fighters use the 1936 or 1940 planes
ok so like range and that?
check pinned for planes
Like combat companies
you should ask yourself how many factories you can get before barb
300 is a good goal if you do historical expansion
your meta templates mean jack shit if you can't produce them
@worldly ridge this is what the plane designs should be and i recommend using the range mio
ussr doesn't have range
how should they be dished out? like how much for support eq and for tanks etc
idk bro
Ohhh
first of all you get to 300
then you can just calculate how much you need and allocate factories based on that
then just use the fighter mio smh
how i can get here this is so impossible lol
also by 300 I mean beginning to build mils in the first half of 1938
ok so 300 mils all on guns then gotcha
fire punch smile
wait i remembered segl made a 10 minute soviet guide
oh yeah that one
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZP43rdLDTE here you go
segl's good but you need to learn to first count how much equipment you need
i can't follow youtube videos i never retain the information thats why i went here
okay fair enough
he lost againist grisha the other day in a 7 vs grisha tfr game lmao
i never said segl is the goat
it wasn't segl's fault iirc but yeah it was a botched game from what i heard lmao. Didn't watch the stream tho
among english ytbers I like 71cloak more but he quit a few years ago
yeah cuz you're supposed to follow him instead of watching it and remembering it which is impossible
i think i'll try and do it myself then we'll see
selg kicked me from his discord after a trolled him
kind of agree judging by my experience watching his streams
i asked if he needed 1 for a game and i said "good luck finding one"
good luck finding one girl to talk to
Gotterdamerung
The one that gives Belgium a focus tree
What mod is this
Roma invicta mod
Thanks
np
Kind of a lot to cover, probs easier to highlight what youre stuck on or dont understand
Basically team gunther completely threw the game on air and got strat bombed into oblivion
Fundamentals imo are designing a division, and producing equipment for your divisions to use, id ignore air and navy specifics for now
I assume you dont have dlc? Air is simpler if you just have the upgrade pips
You are paused (casey tech ™)
Yeah and you can up the speed in the top right, although during combat 2 or 3 speed is good
You can click a green/red bubble and hover over your units attack number to see the multipliers in effect. Learn what multipliers you have to deal with and figure out how to negate the bad ones and amplify the good ones
ethiopa is winning
Winning the battle or are they pushing you back, you dont want to attack if your green or brown unit bars are low
They kind of act as your health bar the regenerates over time
therew pushing me back
Probably hit the square stop button above your general, let your units dig in and then focus attack a single tile from multiple sides
I assume your units are just low hp and theyre countering instantly
how do you stop them were is the button
Since your using cheats anyways:
Type debug in the console (press the ~ key)
Hold tab and press the enemy country
Type in manpower [number]
If they're also low on equipment type in add_latest_equipment or ale [number]
ok i stopped them
You can also give them the buffs you get from that cheat mod you installed. That's how I gave Britain 5000% dockyard output
how do you tell if there tired
is that a even a thing
im killing ethiopa
all of ethiopa
I FEEL POWER FULL
Isn't that button from the La Résistance DLC?
It is
Then he does have a DLC 😭
He could have gdr too
You get faculties in base game most projects are locked to the dlc tho
completely wild outcome there rip
How do I decrease the population of a enemy country?
Does mechanized infantry count as an infantry division
towards modifiers?
like ferdinand schorner's buff
You cant
not for that i believe
Pretty sure there's an icon at the left of the hardness bar on the template designer that tells you what the division is made out of (e.g. infantry, cavalry, etc)
@native gorgecan you tell me
Press the button left side of the anvil, you can trade resources with civilian factories
OH WAIT
WAIT MB
I thought you meant resources like iron
ok i was confused
Not supply
Aight uh
So like click an Army
Find an icon with a horse on it
And press it
That'll hopefully increase the supply
You'll need trucks tho
Check stockpile
does anyone have tips for sea lion
i followed the bitter steel germany guide all the way up to this point
and my ships get obilitered the moment it thinks about touching an atom of the sea that makes the english channel
I dont play germany but its much easier if you invade from north of amsterdam via north sea into Hull
Alr I’ll try that out thanks
Tell me how it goes chuddles
Speaking of, is militia doctrine better or irregular doctrine better for militias?
irregulars
by far
irregulars for militia is basically like having large units tactics and assault infantry in one doctrine
and you also get 2% pop and 2×50% research bonuses for support equipment
not at this stage of the game no
just use pure militia
You usually need to build up ships until like 1940, then you're strong enough to sweep the UK fleet
I followed a bitter steel guide and only got 60 ships compared to the British 300-400
spam destroyers with light attack and torpedo in the torpedo slot
that should work
it doesn't matter that the British have more
the ai doesn't use its navy efficiently
navy xp is like really easy to get by training ships so do your naval doctrines
I thought no compromise no surrender made destroyers useless and you have to use cruisers
They AI never has more than 10-20 Ships in one Task force. So as long as you beat that you'll win
DDs are meta rn
nah, the doctrines and the last navy update made destroyers the meta
Pure Torps works as well
that's an option yeah
Don't build subs
subs don't really matter much
don't build them
use your starting ones to convoy raid until they're dead
Just raid with the ones you have at some place the Brits can't easily intercept. Subs are like the worst ship you can build currently
Ok I might have a very skewered view on navy but I thought subs were required to have ship detection
subs will slow your fleet down significantly
because the speed of the fleet is the seed of the slowest one in it
also don't use subs in places like the English channel
its a shallow sea and they'll die immediately pretty much
The guide had me put navy in three sections: the general task force where I’d strike force, then the subs where I use the green option I forgot the name of and then I had a thing of light cruisers where I also use strike force
Is that not the way you do it?
put everything on patrol
Outdated guide
Strike force might as well not exist anymore e
It’s bitter steels 2026 Germany guide
it was never correct to begin with
Ok so what I’m getting is just only use DDs with torpedoes on never repair and instead of invading them from the channel do it from the east from Denmark or maybe even the Netherlands
I mean does Bittersteel still use 8 full width Tanks in one tile and just right click Moscow? Like I swear he used to be better 😭
I mean exclude navy there was some nice stuff in there like how I was able to Anschluss in late 36
I personally would patrol on always engage in the channel bc it's easier to provide air cover and use your CAS to Naval Strike
Though I will admit following the guide put me in more debt than Germany coming out of ww1
Gun debt wise
CAS actually does stuff in the ocean?
he got some stuff right
tho late 36 is kinda late for anchluss still lol
you usually do it as your 5th focus
so mid 36
yeah
What does it do
advice: just don't uae tanks
really, if you're not some expert at micro, using pure inf will be way way better for you
than tanks
focus on building guns and air
If you use normal Bomb locks yeah, Heavy no
All I do is build upon the base inf template and then pump out a trillion of those and make med tanks as fast I can and then I’m able to take out Poland and France and Norway good
And so I try to take out the uk and I fail so then I think “maybe I’ll have better luck with the ussr” and then I get flattened
it'll really just be better and easier to spam out more inf instead of focus on tanks
rush gun techs
having later gun techs is a huge difference
do big, 36 width infantry
So I should make tanks but don’t make them a huge priority?
no just completely ignore them
outside of flame tanks/light tank recon support companies
For Barb you want to have around 250 of those Inf on the front and as many Tansk as you can build. Remember to put up green air + CAS and if you have it build some railway guns or the super heavy one.
I’ll try this out
Honestly now that I think about it I don’t even need to actually invade the uk to win the war
I have this mod called festung Europa where you get to do a scripted peace with the allies if you complete a bunch of requirements like instead of invading the uk you can send a nuke to them
@astral anchor What haafy is saying is that there is basically two approaches how you can play. You can go ahead and micro single strong Tank divisions where you have to micro a lot etc. or you just build big infantry that will still out stat the AI and you have a lot more free mils you can put on CAS bc CAS annihilates AI troops. So that is the other path, just have a massive, unstoppable wall of infantry just moving forward
I should try both of those out and see which is more effective
But anyways since I’m talking to you guys I might aswell ask
Do you guys know how to make a good template in TFR
Specifically the American civil war template
I was losing it playing as the NSM because the Patriot Front was just so incompetent
Why do you care for peace? 😅 There is no post war content 😆
Didnt even reunify New England until after I made the national front
They actually have a thing where after you beat Russia they collapse and then the west russian communists fight you in the west Russian war submod
It’s supposed to be like the TNO lore
It's honestly just personal preference, you can even win the game with some stuff SP Youtuber guides recommend
I’m gonna do a completely new game tommorow
Try the brick wall strategy and do the navy tips you guys gave me
And I’ll see what happens
Thanks for the tips
ask in tfr server
Nah, I'm fine with you losing as them 🤣
Better than atomwaffen honestly
All TFR ACW mini factions are cringe
I have this fear of these kinds of servers because they kinda harbor the schizos
yea they do
Debatable
Are they doxxing schizos though
from what i heard in rb the meta there is also inf+air
Like TFR is all about full mech and Armour Divs from what I know. If you have no fuel you probably need to make big Inf
someone was saying that in the chat
no clue how true is it
Those divs can only be achieved if you’re not playing as an ACW contender
MP meta =/= SP Meta. Everything that is good for MP is as well for SP, but it's mostly overkill
Maybe you can get it from the federal factions
Lol, backslash wasn't working. Tbh true either way.
Maybe it’s for the best I don’t know how to do that mod anyways it hurts my head
You need Heavy Tanks to break anything in MP. But yeah, they build CAS as well. Inf kinda only bc you don't have enough IC to get mechs everywhere
First country I tried when I played it was atomwaffen and I’m pretty sure I got annihilated by the Union
Tbh I played like two games of TFR, but dropped it bc it had only content for like 7 Nations. And from what I got to know of the devs etc this mod honestly is just there to feed fascist Ideas and Movements. I thought it's light hearted and based, but the more you get to know of it the more you realize the devs are serious about the stuff.

The devs are actually politically motivated?
yes
I mean to be fair try to find one mod that doesn’t have politically motivated devs
I heard TNO devs are left wing biased ironically
i will take devs that are biased towards democracy over devs biased towards fascism and nazism
Avg hoi4 players ideologies:
And TNO gets enough shit on regardless, but TFR is about current events and movements which makes stuff a bit more iffy. It's the same reason why paradox will never make a modern day 4X game. It's way to politically charged.
yeah this is way oversimplification of the ideologies but. you get the idea
supersonics yes
but they take very long to get
so like
only if you play until like the 50s
they'll be useful
bad
wdym
Probably could be done in good taste if the extremist organizations are fictional
just worse than the advanced medium/heavies
alr
you can't have extra turrets on them
alr
extra turrets were bad irl so you can't put them on modren tanks but in game they're cracked so
yeah
totally historically accurate battle moment
alr
yeah, something like that
Basically anything researched after 1941 is useless because efficiency is a thing and moderns require 3x chassis cost and 5 XP each battalion so it's no wonder moderns are the worst tank chassis in game
alr
guys what to do when i start someone else mod for example kaiserredux or road to 56 it perfectly works but when i start with my mod it dont work
Its the best
what does a civilian nuclear plant/reactor do for me?
Did you create it with the mod creation tool in the launcher?
infinite fuel?
you can achieve the same thing, just dont add anything that needs fuel and add helicopter brigade as you support company
whats does thisw mean
Priority
The division is the last of its kind to receive reinforcements
Like guns, tanks infantry
how to fix it?
Look in the top middle of the division designer
And change it
how many divs do i need for Barbarossa
@scenic nacelle
there isnt an exact number
just have enough
if you have green air with cas its pretty easy
alr
As the soyviets I usually shoot for about 300
should i invade ussr alone as estonia or with my german allies?
your estonia?
yes
how many divs do you have and whats the template?
well atleast over a couple a few thousand in both armies
just send ss
what
ss of the div
what is ss
screenshot
bro just screenshot it normally
sorry
and turn off nato symbols please
sorry
alr
afterr 19 tries i have won the german civil war
@uncut narwhal do you want a SS of the div template?
yea lets see
alr hold on
shot on what? lmao
does your phone have its own watermark
the mp in ur navy alone can destroy the soviets
like holy what mod are u using?
at that point i feel sorry for the soviets
hoi4 crashed again for me
prob because of the divisions
alr
are u using mods?
1 mod yes
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3265939166&searchtext= try this mod its great for beginners
try the mod i send below
Aside from cryptologi and collab governments is spying even useful at All ? With all the other stuff you can do
will hoi4 work without mods or will it still crash?
the mods are the ones prob crashing ur game
alr
should i make a new estonia save without mods
if u do it without mods its better for learning but not very fun
if u use mods u should use light ones that give u slight buffs
alr
not overpowered ones
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=699587979&searchtext=cheat+menu use this ones i just remembered the name it helped me when i was learning u can set the buffs u want
nice
if u want to learn faster u should watch some tutorials about the basics
When i puppet a country, how do i get its cv and military factories?
does that only work with götterdämmerung dlc?
Hello guys!
Im trying to finish the Negotiate Sphere of Influence as pro-facism Czechia (in the newest dlc), to attack Hungary and Romania.
However, Germany keep declining it, despite I have 100 relation with them and am in faction.
Any idea how to make them say yes? I tried realoding a save multiple times, but they still decline:(
it depends on the puppet level
also depends if you used the war reparations in a peace deal (By blood alone DLC)
💀
Ur gonna make him quit the game
son
Hey guys i have run into a small problem while playing Hoi4. Its my First Playthrough and i cant assign my regiments to attack. Also my right click isnt working. Anny Tips?
look into a beginners guide to get familiar with the controls and mechanics, it will help a lot
something thats not oudated preferably
Will do thanks!
your regiments or your divisions?
The little humans idk what their name is
divisions
yes sorry
most of the time assigning your divisions to an army and drawing offensive orders is better than making them attack manually
divisions are composed of regiments
okay thanks
a regiment is a column in the division designer if you're curious
and each column is composed of battalions
why do we need regiments anyway
Are spies useluff for anything else than cryptology and collab government what about those other operations like steal blueprint etc ?
researching military intel gives you some actual buffs against enemy
in the regions you have spies ofcourse
ig resisstance missions are useful in countries like Poland with high resistance growth
blue is batallion
pink is regiment
red is division
reloading save doesnt reset event RNG afaik
How many days do I need to reset to reset the RNG?
Or is it like from the start of the game?
Not really sure
so is there a difference between 3 regiments of 4 batallion or for say 4 regiments of 3 batallions?
not really
the only thing I can see worth noting is the tour de france achievement that says you need 20 regiments, not divisions or batallions
from the time i settled the ethiopian war as italy (March), i feel a bit lost as to what I should be doing. Felt like i wasted some time.
Since then I took Austria in 1938 and did research on industry and engineering as far as i could. National focus unlocked the 5th research slot. Is anyone able to tell if i’m on the right path or I could have done something/achieved more?
I ACCIDENTALLY RIOGHT CLICKED THE PROVICE HOW DO I STOP MY TROOPS FROM GOING THERE HLEP
Press H
H
Press h
for halt
Whats different between modern and advanced medium tanks ? Should I resseach the moderen ?
basically the buffs from medium tanks dont apply to modern tanks, staying on advnaced is better
Modern is worse
you also cant get secondary turrets on them
So way worse stats
both are bad but modern is the worst and advanced is just bad because you get it in 1943
whats the vetting voice chat for?
I have been stuck on jet engine since 1943 it’s taking very long I don’t know why it’s been stuck on that bar for long time
Multiplayer
To make sure the person that plays a major country
if i wanna chill in a vc
Is good at that country
what vc
k
it does, for most events
you need the focus to end on a different date from my observation
Hey guys how do i deploy reinforcements over sea?
either he learns trough the pain or he doesnt learn
u mean troops in training?
move them to a port
then click on another port
as long as you have convoys and access they will move
Is there nothing I can do to make axis naval power much better ? It’s very frustrating I build whole day navry for my small country that I built up to find Japan loosing navry to USA even when USA only had half navry left after ww2 and they aren’t building much ships either
Is no mod or something that can fix this issue it’s very boring not having much navry battles except against Allie’s
Im not playing axis im playing against and want naval challenges from them
I guess you could tag switch and buff their navy
Hi guys
What’s the best way to take over ussr
R there any video tutorials or gameplay I can follow?
As Germany btw
Max out doctrine, spirits, and officer corps
Trying to blitz properly
There’s one by btter steel that’s I’ve heard good things about
Interesting
Thanks
Wait
Is there a big difference between
Attacking ussr in 1942
Cuz he’s doing it in 1941
Maybe that’s why I’m struggling
They get to build up more
Cone on is there no real mod that fixes is this it’s frustrating all these stuff that don’t make sense

Idk about mods