#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 161 of 1

rose plover
#

you need a commander for 5 of them

#

like this

glacial steeple
#

what is he doing

rose plover
austere roost
#

Also ai prediction is not necessarily correct

arctic stream
glacial steeple
#

not with that army most likely

rose plover
rose plover
#

and then you can add 4 more generals with right click on your commander

arctic stream
rose plover
# arctic stream thx

and than select only the commander for making lines, so all your generals automatically go to them etc.

candid abyss
#

i think i messed up with the fall back lines or my armies were just sht

#

i can reload again i guess i dont have iron man

glacial steeple
#

id restart

candid abyss
#

lol autosave is 27 days prior

#

kek

glacial steeple
#

you made various major mistakes

candid abyss
candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

no economy because you never changed your mobilization law for it

candid abyss
#

the civil war took so much time

glacial steeple
#

then dont do it

glacial steeple
#

go non aligned

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

youll be able to start wars later on

#

as non aligned

#

its fine

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

youre not gonna do early offensive wars

glacial steeple
#

finland is very strong

candid abyss
#

like i wanna play this pathway why make it so hard running around one division each chasing each other like ducks whats the point

twin kayak
#

how do I produce the flamethrower tank ? I researched it but I don't have a clue on how to get it in the army

glacial steeple
#

gotta give it the role

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

where it says medium tank

glacial steeple
twin kayak
rose plover
#

in this menu is an option with flame-tank support and thats what you want

twin kayak
#

I mave medium and light

glacial steeple
#

medium is best

#

but like any work

rose plover
#

china sucks for showing stuff like that xD

candid abyss
glacial steeple
glacial steeple
candid abyss
glacial steeple
candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

but its also because i know ill have enough manpower for them in time for wars

rose plover
glacial steeple
#

because the starting army is small

glacial steeple
#

/ flame

rose plover
#

yes

candid abyss
#

finland is depressing

#

time to restart

candid abyss
rose plover
glacial steeple
#

everything else is irrelevant

frosty obsidian
#

how do you enable diff colors per nation

glacial steeple
#

infra is more resources per state and some build speed and it pays off in like forever

#

civs also take like 4 years or whatever to pay off

candid abyss
candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

just make it on helsinki

#

you cannot let helsinki fall

#

if you hold helsinki and 1 vp next to it you wont capitulate

#

in the worst case

candid abyss
frosty obsidian
glacial steeple
#

your guns are better than artillery

#

and also units with more hp take less casualties so take note of that

tired moon
#

I CAPTURED MOSCOWWW

rose plover
#

thats a weird angle to take moscow as germany

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

look at the buffs

candid abyss
#

i rushed most of the military that i can now in the focus tree the rest are locked

glacial steeple
#

but theres good war support stab and factory focuses to the left

#

you should get those

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

yeah thats an issue youll face

#

hire the 200 weekly manpower guy ASAP

glacial steeple
#

also ban fascism and hire the guy who gives less communist support

#

also change your leader

#

in the balance of power

#

and play on slower than 5 speed because you need a lot

glacial steeple
rose plover
#

man finland sounds complicated when i hear you talk caseyKEKW

glacial steeple
#

you just have to read

#

same for every country really

candid abyss
glacial steeple
#

yes

candid abyss
#

ok

glacial steeple
#

your next guy is like

#

i hate fascists and communists

#

so you want to ban the fascist party in decisions

rose plover
candid abyss
glacial steeple
candid abyss
candid abyss
#

sigh

hoary glen
glacial steeple
#

without much eco pressure or multiple fronts etc

hoary glen
#

uhhh. Idk

glacial steeple
#

or air / tanks

#

every other nation sucks more

hoary glen
#

too much green and too many focus ways

glacial steeple
#

ok so you focus on manpower

#

like eco is not important in sp finland

#

you have enough

tired moon
#

currently i am democratic germany who is fighting alongside the fascist british against the fascist italians who are in the comintern and the japanese

glacial steeple
#

highkey so tired of talking to people rn, cya chatroom

rose plover
#

i´m stupid and try to bild a navy with china to challenge the japaneseKEKW

tired moon
#

and italy is in civil war

rain yew
#

I’ve lost my 3rd air invasion of britan, how the hell do I do this 😭

visual yacht
#

Idk if anyone answered you but brazil is noob friendly

rain yew
#

Yup

twin kayak
#

finland

twin kayak
rain yew
#

This is genuinely hell

#

And I suck at nay

#

Navy*

twin kayak
#

the only answer you'll get is from guys with 1 milion hours in hoi4 and tell you that it's easy

#

just give up asking

#

that's what i did

rain yew
#

So I

#

Sob*

twin kayak
rain yew
#

Like tf is allat in navy

twin kayak
#

but no one ever took the time to explain it to me

candid abyss
#

what is this and how do i activate whatever requirment that i cant read

rose plover
#

i learned by starting with germany all over again and after i knew some stuff i changed to other major countries and then the rest

twin kayak
#

Most people will tell you to navaly invade, but no one will understand that for a new player, the navy is a really complicated mechanic

candid abyss
#

whats the valtion whatever

rain yew
#

I quit on learning navy 200 hours ago

visual yacht
#

Build fighters and naval bomber planes.
Set them on the straight.
Once youve killed the entire fleet, set your biats on a patrol order on the straight.
Hit go on naval invasion general

pastel orbit
#

navy always pmo i just spam submarines now

twin kayak
#

you might wanna try to get a mod/helper to help you

pastel orbit
#

with air support

twin kayak
#

but they're not really usefull for this scenario

rain yew
rose plover
#

the way i do to conquer britain is to invade italy and france (not at the same time) and take their navy to use their navy to fight the british navy and invade the island

visual yacht
#

Or skip all that and just paradrop in

pastel orbit
#

i was able to cook italy's Carriers by spamming submarines lol

#

i destroyed their whole navy

rain yew
#

That’s why I’m trying naval invasion again

visual yacht
#

Are you specced inti right side paratrooper doctrine?

#

Into*

pastel orbit
#

italy ai is always bad i was able todefend greece with 4 divisions even tho they had 13 divisions atleast each tile

#

i only sent 4 mountainers

rain yew
#

Ima be honest with you, I dunno how to get to the doctrine menu without the notification and I ain’t got the notification

pastel orbit
#

and u will see how

visual yacht
#

Bottom of officer corps(last tab) yeah

glacial steeple
#

large fleet good

rain yew
#

If that’s what u were asking

visual yacht
#

Idk what that is, right paratroopers lowers enemy troops org when you land on them

#

I forget what its actually called

tired moon
#

STALINGRAD TAKENNNN

rain yew
#

Uk lowkey got 13k dominance in the channel

visual yacht
#

And dont make shitty width paras, i make mine to match the terrain width

rose plover
tired moon
rain yew
#

Omg

#

britan has 3.5k fighters on their mainland

#

How do I make stuff cores?

rose plover
#

you dont

rain yew
#

That’s sad

rose plover
#

only if you play a country that has a historical state and can integrate land like the roman empire, ottoman empire

tired moon
#

the soviets have 1 percent left to capitulate 🎊

patent forge
#

does my fleet need to be same speed to be useful or it can be like some heavy ships 20 knots and some light hulls over 30?

#

for a single task force

rose plover
#

can be difficult, but will always go as the slowest can be

#

at least thats what i would assume

visual yacht
#

Ya one of the reasons why subs should be in their own fleet

#

They slow everything down to 20km

candid abyss
patent forge
#

i meant if I build like a super heavy battleship that goes like 20 knots while rest of my fleet is 30-40 knots should I make a separate fleet with all the slow ships and put on strike force?

hoary glen
patent forge
#

ah, thanks for clarifying

patent forge
#

navy larp >

hoary glen
#

Do what you enjoy :)

rose plover
#

half of the indian army ded

hoary glen
# twin kayak Most people will tell you to navaly invade, but no one will understand that for ...

I just did a sp game where I've only build starting destroyers with one more Torpedo launcher as Germany, just build them and engaged the UK in 1940 with my doomstack completely wiping out their fleet. Unfortunately it's actually that easy.

Navy is imposing bc you have a lot of options, however most of them are not good, so it's more like knowing the few things to look out for. Biggest issue with Navy most likely tho is that you can't fix things. You can't start building a fleet in 1940, you need to know what you want to build and when to from the start.

#

If you have any questions tho feel happy to reach out to me :)

twin kayak
#

and what no one wanted to explain to me

pearl tapir
#

Hello guys, i am pretty new at this game. When i take over most of the european countries i am faced against the UK, which has a strong navy and soviet union, sweden, norway... I dont know how i would get to the uk. I have the la resistance dlc but havent got to make a civil war or something because it needs 20% fascist popularity and below 70% stability, which never got under 97% as far as i got.

so, how do i go against uk?

I thought about that strategie making a navale invasion but it never worked, i am making something clearly wrong. i dont even know how really plane's work.

Pls help

copper mason
#

What are the basics of the game I should learn in order?

austere roost
austere roost
#

are you following bittersteel's guide?

rain yew
#

Why is my naval strike efficiency 0%? I have air superiority(English Channel)

pearl tapir
candid abyss
#

Finland is unplayabe

tropic seal
#

@thin nebula what are the best naval subdoctrines?

candid abyss
#

1942 guns, level 2 hospitals, level 2 logi, standard 16w defensive templates, maxed out army and industry tech tree, throwing bodies at leningrad to attempt and take it for just 30 days, fail, get encircled like rats, 300k dead, no men, 900k soviets dead but it doesnt matter, keep throwing bodies gg

tropic seal
#

uh dont get encircled

candid abyss
#

hell i even spammed forts across the entire front

#

level 3 forts everywhere

#

on every single tile

#

doesnt matter, throw more bodies

candid abyss
# tropic seal uh dont get encircled

is the ai stupid? like the field marshal ai or do i have to attach plans to each and every division and keep babying and microing 2 and a half armies across a front that spans miles

tropic seal
#

its not hard to micro 60 divs

candid abyss
austere roost
tropic seal
#

then lower the gamespeed

tropic seal
versed rose
#

pushing with small widths

#

you make 2 big divs and push with those

#

rest can remain small

candid abyss
candid abyss
versed rose
#

yea too small

visual yacht
#

Also put supp arty in before line arty

tropic seal
candid abyss
# versed rose yea too small

apologies, trying to defend against a nation that threw 1 million human beings to die in the finnish frozen rivers with 300 thousand men over 60 years old

tropic seal
candid abyss
versed rose
#

yea, you're going to lose more with smaller divs

tropic seal
#

you dont need field hospitals or logi to hold

versed rose
#

that's how this game works

candid abyss
versed rose
#

but its finland so its fine, just push with bigger divs next time

austere roost
versed rose
#

pushing with small divs is how you burn manpower

tropic seal
austere roost
#

but tbh 9/0 and 8/0 difference is smll

candid abyss
#

this is just giga omega rage bait

austere roost
#

just play germany if you want to get a hold of the game first

versed rose
#

also hospital is fake on small divs

tropic seal
austere roost
#

i remember it took me so many tries to learn hoi4 because I started with ussr

candid abyss
#

ahhhhhhhh WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT how convienient the reload was just 1 day before

tropic seal
#

thats not ragebait thats just how supply works

tropic seal
#

if you stack eighty divs in a theatre with terrible supply they will perform terribly

slender lodge
#

do anyone know in which days steam gives discounts on HOI4 DLC’s?

slender lodge
austere roost
tropic seal
slender lodge
#

what are the closest lne?

visual citrus
#

Is this a good Infantry Design?

austere roost
#

no

tropic seal
#

and add aa

#

then itll be fine

austere roost
#

any inf design with line art can be improved by removing the line art

slender lodge
austere roost
#

technically if you are in green air you don't need aa

#

but ofc in sp aa is also the piercing weapon

candid abyss
#

1942 guns, 1942 arty

tropic seal
candid abyss
#

seriously what was the population of the soviets back then

tropic seal
#

soviets can take 30mil casualties before starting to collapse

candid abyss
tropic seal
#

dont try to out manpower the soviets it never goes well

versed rose
tropic seal
visual citrus
candid abyss
austere roost
#

the goal for art research is to build better tanks. If you don't need better tanks there's not much need to research non-aa artillery

austere roost
tropic seal
candid abyss
# tropic seal sure thats how youre meant do to it mate

it's boring tho, just like trying to have a civil war and a fascist leader, spend an entire year runnign circles with a singular division against a singular division playing tom and jerry until one of us claimed more land

visual yacht
# versed rose yea, you're going to lose more with smaller divs

Is my understanding of large vs small divs correct here?

Small divs lose more equipment and manpower per strength lost, but have higher soft attack and org in TOTAL across a combats width (as long as you reinforce almost immediately)

Large divs have lower org and soft attack in TOTAL across a combat width, but have higher stats per supply?

austere roost
candid abyss
#

like i want to shape it i dont want to be forced to do the same thing or lose

tropic seal
#

simple

#

if you play a minor that gets invaded early like finland

#

you have less options

candid abyss
austere roost
tropic seal
austere roost
visual citrus
tropic seal
#

ion get it

austere roost
#

support art is fine if you have small divisions

tropic seal
austere roost
#

on big divisions support art can be replaced by other things

tropic seal
#

its actually quite good

versed rose
tropic seal
#

i did an 18w infantry all majors conquest but i gave up in china

#

cuz 18w infantry CANNOT push into mountains

versed rose
#

smaller divs dont necessarily lose more men and equipment per strength lost, assuming its a naked 12w vs a naked 36w (no supports)

visual yacht
#

Right ok, i got shrekt last night in my brazil SP against USA in 1939 using 18w vs their 40w or whatever infantry they have. Adding more armies with small divs is better than upgrading existing to 30w right?

#

If i dont plan to attack with them

austere roost
#

kind of

#

if you can produce enough stuff it doesn't matter

#

but for brazil, you don't border usa

tropic seal
#

they have a massive industry

austere roost
#

do you mean guarding the coasts?

visual yacht
#

No pushing into usa

#

Ulasr run

candid abyss
# tropic seal dude then dont complain about minor nations having specific things you need to d...

its not that, it's just that i dont understand what im doing wrong, the first playthrough i tried to have a fascist leader and could never build the army on time, so i did the non allied or whatever build, lost miserably, did it again but with forts spammed across the front line to stop losing ground so quick and try to take leningrad, again failed miserably even though the divisions attacking leningrad had like guns 3 years in the future and were 1.5X the size of the army protecting the city. then you open youtube and there's a guy just not losing a single tile and defending everything with 12 divisions

#

it just feels borderline impossible

#

and im playing on civillian difficulty too

#

like

#

couldnt get any easiier

austere roost
#

maybe the problem is that you built forts instead of mils that produce guns

candid abyss
#

and still the playthrough gets ruined

tropic seal
tropic seal
#

if you screw up a build you will lose

austere roost
#

lol you don't have enough

candid abyss
#

i had everything in stock

#

and no men

tropic seal
#

i dont know how else to explain it

candid abyss
#

i wasnt down on any supplies whatsoever

tropic seal
#

youre playing on civillian

austere roost
#

it's very hard to play finland

#

just play germany first

#

or usa

tropic seal
candid abyss
versed rose
#

did you get desperate defence as soon as you went to war

tropic seal
austere roost
visual yacht
candid abyss
#

still got clapped

#

1m soviets dead and they're still pushign

tropic seal
austere roost
#

also forts are not as good as they used to be

candid abyss
#

the only shortage was manpower

visual yacht
#

Yeah for the front, ty

candid abyss
#

but ok

austere roost
#

it's very easy to pierce through forts

candid abyss
#

i wont build forts

#

i'll try again tomorrow

versed rose
#

i mean, we dont have the save file so we cant point out every thing that was wrong, but the images you sent looked like you were defending empty space

#

the north of Finland is useless

#

leave it

candid abyss
# versed rose leave it

happened the first playthrough i made lines behind rivers and lakes and got annexed, i'll just go to sleep maybe tomorrow my head will be more clear

austere roost
#

also, 31 factories by the winter war is certainly not too many factories

#

that's like ppl complaining that they can't defend against barb when their ussr has 180 factories

visual citrus
#

I am NOT gonna invest time into trying to actually learn how ts works imma just search on google optimal Division designs lol

candid abyss
candid abyss
versed rose
candid abyss
#

three times actually

#

forget it and make templates according to your manpower and equipment

versed rose
#

or general misinformation

candid abyss
#

all you need is to know what combat widths are good i think

#

and to keep good organisation

austere roost
#

so you need more factories to provide equip for more troops

candid abyss
#

the rest is just whatever you can do

versed rose
#

googling hoi4 is like so ass, especially with ai not knowing how to sort by date, and how effective things really are

austere roost
#

and figure out a line to defend

versed rose
#

so it pushes garbage into the uninitiated

#

and they go and use line arty

candid abyss
versed rose
#

rip bozo

candid abyss
#

goodnight

austere roost
#

without expansion finland can't defend the entire line so give up the north, no one cares about northern finland anyway

tropic seal
visual citrus
versed rose
#

weekly asked question

candid abyss
#

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZSrbWaEvq0&t=392s then there's dudes like this with half my infantry, worse equipment, didnt lose 1 singular tile, took leningrad and finished the war by 1944

ESG

This video will show you how to hold against the Soviet Union as Finland during the Winter War with the Hearts of Iron IV Arms Against Tyranny DLC enabeled. Cheers!

Focus Tree Build-

  1. Finnish Neutrality
  2. Political Unity
  3. Align the Agrarian League
  4. The Finnish Swedish Peoples Party
  5. Railways and Infrastructure
  6. Reporpose Small Indust...
▶ Play video
#

lmao

#

im actually so bad at this game

austere roost
#

can you follow what he did then?

tropic seal
#

whats the best naval MIO btw

austere roost
#

try to recreate it

tropic seal
#

battle line shipbuilders?

austere roost
#

except for carriers which needs sortie efficiency

candid abyss
tropic seal
#

it was yeah

austere roost
#

fleet subs are op because you can get sub visibility to 1% so they're pretty much invisibile in the whole battle

tropic seal
#

dd being locked behind a war now is a pain

tropic seal
visual citrus
#

dd?

austere roost
tropic seal
#

ah aight

austere roost
#

subs don't have much freedom in design

tropic seal
#

ight

tropic seal
austere roost
#

max out torpedoes

#

so 3 maxxed out torpedoes, the tiles, and aip engines

tropic seal
#

or is it only for sub spam

austere roost
#

no raiding is best for all non-carrier ships cuz they give best visibility buff

visual citrus
#

also people are saying hoi3 was harder in hoi3 i literally spammed random things in the division designer and i won wars

tropic seal
austere roost
#

just use two different mios

tropic seal
austere roost
#

Iirc carrier mios are better but I haven't checked in a while

versed rose
#

isnt the only mio that buffs carriers the taskforce one

glacial steeple
#

isnt raider for all

#

i forgot and im kind of out of playing hoi for a bit

versed rose
#

raiding doesnt buff carrier

glacial steeple
#

WHAT..

#

what about the uh

#

the mio that like italy and ussr get

#

refurbishment

#

idk if ussr gets it i lied

versed rose
#

no carrier buff iirc

#

its capitals which doesnt include carrier im 90% sure

rain yew
#

How do I check what ships my naval strikes/naval bombers sunk

versed rose
candid abyss
# glacial steeple WHAT..

yooo i got clapped again, how do u actually win? just throw everything at leningrad and defend it for 30 days?

versed rose
# glacial steeple WHAT..

lmao i went in-game to look because this reaction made me curious, Raiding Fleet doesnt buff carriers, but Japan gets a special Raiding MIO that replaces the capital buffs with carrier buffs

#

also holy, light task force + raiding carrier mio is -30% visibility for carriers

rain yew
#

I’m using naval bombers over the English Channel but they have 0% efficiency, anyone know why that is? I have air superiority

austere roost
devout jasper
#

any recommendations on how to get started learning the game?

light knoll
serene karma
#

Click on the base

rain yew
tropic mirage
rain yew
tropic mirage
#

YUCK!

tropic seal
#

do carrier planes automatically exercise when you exercise the ship?

vital geode
tropic seal
#

yeah i did that

last arch
#

i also can't see the airport size, its possible you're overstafcking (putting more planes than the airport can handle)

rose plover
serene karma
#

Why do u think they are 0% efficient tho

#

I can see some naval strikes

#

Also you have enough fuel right

#

And u designed navs with enough range?

rose plover
#

think the left one has 800 cap and the other has 1k by default

#

so the left is overstacking by 100 then

last arch
#

i dont remember france having a 1.8k here by caen

rose plover
#

but i mean just build the airport up and its fine

rose plover
last arch
#

maybe

#

i dont remember that but its possible

rose plover
#

not sure either, but everytime i conquered france there was a 2k airport on the canal xD

#

ah

#

the 2k airport is at calais

rose plover
last arch
#

there you go

serene karma
#

Oh yeah dont overstack airbase too

thick storm
#

How do you beat hte soviets as poland? Whenever I try, they always hold really well or throw these giant doomstacks of divisions at me that I can't breakthrough. Any tips?

uneven bay
#

why am i not able to get this achievement if i am the dominion of canada?

timid drum
#

Would anyone be willing to help a lowly yankee figure out how to play America 🙏

#

I’ve tried YouTube but it’s never in depth enough

civic hare
#

since I have a non agression with germany can I just attack vichy france (they aint a puppet for some reason)

civic hare
#

hell yea

keen hemlock
#

But they might break their pact

keen hemlock
#

You can do whatever

#

You what

#

And be op

timid drum
keen hemlock
timid drum
#

how?

keen hemlock
#

You have so many factories you don’t really have an industry tree

#

Just build infrastructure until you get rid of some of the debuffs to mil construction then spam mills and be fine

#

You don’t even need to build civs

#

You have tons of manpower and resources

civic hare
#

how do I stop my puppets from giving me useless expeditionaries

#

is there a faster way for me to absorb these idiots

visual yacht
civic hare
visual yacht
#

Allows what? Lend lease?

#

Can you not do it whenever?

#

The autonomy is easy to get rid of with civs, the PP is the bottleneck

civic hare
#

you can do a focus and then do decisions to annex em

#

wondered if italy had something like that

visual yacht
#

Oh to annex, right yeah

#

Im not sure sorry, but the autonomy is easy to lower as long as you have 350 PP for annexation

#

But i agree, some way to auto decline certain popup requests would be nice

keen hemlock
thin nebula
keen hemlock
#

but yeah annexing them is the only for sure way

thin nebula
#

Also you asked doctrines theres only one that really matters and its the carrier one that reduces time between strikes by 2 hours

tropic seal
tropic seal
thin nebula
tropic seal
thin nebula
#

which light cruiser

tropic seal
thin nebula
#

ok then its good 10/10

tropic seal
#

i found out too late that turret 3 costs an arm and a leg in steel

tropic seal
thin nebula
#

They dont in the beta

tropic seal
thin nebula
#

It is but you have enough ships to not care

#

You can play the beta right now

tropic seal
#

ah fair yeah they just dfie before my capitals do

tropic seal
#

what else changed other than shiups becoming much cheaper?

thin nebula
#

Select it from steam

#

Its in properties and under betas and sonething or another

thin nebula
#

Open balance beta

tropic seal
#

aight thanks

#

is there a list of changes in the beta

thin nebula
#

Yeah should be under a steam post

#

Doesnt make ships cheaper necessarially just makes modules cost no resources

tropic seal
#

aight

tropic seal
#

on every ship?

thin nebula
#

If you want, bit expensive

tropic seal
#

🥀

thin nebula
#

Funny thing is that the level 4 turret costs steel and the aa main battery (same as level 4 with aa bonus) didnt cost steel

#

Ive been trying out something where i dont fill some module spaces on cruisers and refit them later, not sure but i think its less time spent on them?

#

Since refit should be faster due to other bonuses

tropic seal
thin nebula
#

Yeah in the normal

tropic seal
#

ah

#

well i can build a big navy to my hearts content now in the beta

#

no more being hamstrung by steel

thin nebula
#

Its like 30 per basic light crusier line so

tropic seal
#

is integrated ops good

#

for screen doctrine

tropic mirage
tropic seal
#

is it mased carrier fleet

#

whys it red though

thin nebula
thin nebula
#

Goes from 8 to 6 hours iirc

#

Mabye its 6-4

#

Yeah 6 to 4

#

Also if you want go base strike as the main doctrine to get CAG night fighting your planes will attack during night

#

Otherwise they dont sortie

tropic seal
#

ah aight

visual yacht
#

Cohesion set to rigid or balanced doesnt change how the AI wants to reshuffle the front right? It just forces more steps for it to take to reach the same division distribution?

#

Only true way to prevent reshuffling is to have an overabundance of divisions already in that tile ( by having shorter front lines), or is the distribution based on % of commanded divisions

#

Also ive just noticed that shift clicking an FM frontline presents a cleaner to look at front, but your armies are all mixed. Compared to normal FM frontlines where assumably each army is assigned a section, which would prevent wasted command abilities since you know that army is going to be in that battle

#

I wish there was a mix of the two, sections with specific army assignments but visually only showing 1x frontline 😔

slender lodge
#

guys

#

why is germany AI so op?

tropic seal
#

its garbage

slender lodge
#

like i had austria all militia bonnuses + 60 good militia (max supplies, good org, defensive plan)

#

and a 50% defense on core state & atacck

#

but i lost agaisnt like 15 divitions of gemrant a rmy

tropic seal
#

then you were doing something very wrong if youre playing vanilla

#

i usualyl dont use militia though

slender lodge
slender lodge
tropic seal
#

the german ai

#

actually the entire games default ai is garbage

slender lodge
#

it isnt

tropic seal
#

🥀

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

ask literally anyone whose played the game a decent amount

#

they will all agree the games ai is a brick

slender lodge
#

a brick that killed 60+ militia divitions using less than 15 default divitions

#

my militia was something like this but alot better

tropic seal
slender lodge
#

with more national and minister bonnuses + good generals and field marshal

tropic seal
#

the ai is absolutely terrible at doing anything except feeding encirclements

slender lodge
#

its just impossible what they did

#

i have seen it alot of more times

tropic seal
#

try using normal inf

slender lodge
#

they easy kill +100 good divitions ussr with like 24 divitions

slender lodge
#

or they just kill britain canada and usa with 20 divitions

tropic seal
#

the ai ussr is also garbage mate

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

A PLAYER

#

AS USSR

slender lodge
#

like germany has a glitch or something

tropic seal
#

LOST TO AI GERMANY?

#

?????????????

#

nah this is actually diabolical

slender lodge
#

it keeps happening to me in multiplayer roomjs where some AI cant be destroyed

tropic seal
#

no

#

the player is just straight dogwater

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

it is genuinely hard to lose to ai germany as the ussr

slender lodge
#

i had +300 infantry divitions with max supplies (good template) and alot of good tanks divitions

#

but germany is somehow diabolical as ai

tropic seal
tropic seal
#

no its not germany is garbage

slender lodge
#

germany in my rooms plays like if they were so good

tropic seal
#

you can literally cap them as france easily in a non rushed playthrough by like 40

slender lodge
#

i think its a bug bc i cant even destroy them if its ecircled or something

tropic seal
#

do you use normally

#

what are your inf and tank templates

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

brother you cant just say good ones

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

what are the templates

#

yes i know

#

what are your inf templates

#

and what are your tank templates

slender lodge
#

i use those one that pro ppl in this servers recommends

#

@francis

#

@franciscossaucion

tropic seal
#

send a screenshot?

slender lodge
#

well he left

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

is it 18 width infantry

slender lodge
#

no

tropic seal
#

how wide is it

#

do you have line artillery in it

slender lodge
#

but its still stupid how germant can just beat my room

tropic seal
#

no germany is garbage

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

what they wre doing

#

line artillery is bad

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

its so bad that there are maybe only like a single digit amount of builds where its good

opaque wing
tropic seal
tropic seal
slender lodge
#

d

tropic seal
#

no its not mate

#

dude

slender lodge
#

even with air superiority

tropic seal
#

this might be the first time ive seen someone complain about german ai being overpowered

slender lodge
#

dude you cant just defend this

tropic seal
tropic seal
slender lodge
opaque wing
tropic seal
#

germany is ass

slender lodge
tropic seal
slender lodge
tropic seal
#

10 german divs are not beating 300 holding soviet divs

slender lodge
#

its just impossible or bugged in my room

opaque wing
tropic seal
slender lodge
#

it is

tropic seal
#

youre not paradox's son or whatever

#

we all play the same version of the game

slender lodge
tropic seal
#

yeah i give up man

#

have fun continuing to do whatever youre doing

slender lodge
#

germany ai is made to win

opaque wing
#

It literally sucks ass

slender lodge
# opaque wing German ai is ass

then tell me how less than 20 german army default divitions beat up this (image) militia +60 divitoons with good bonnuses, good supplys and in defensive posture

#

also with core state defense (20% atacck 20% defense) and another ministers with good bonnuses

#

and they did it all with just some default sh1t diitions

tropic seal
#

just let him be

slender lodge
#

germany ai its made to win

slender lodge
#

do i go back into the past to film it?

opaque wing
#

Hm

slender lodge
#

and it keeps happening on my forkin rooms

tropic seal
slender lodge
#

i had a run till 1948 and germany was invencible

#

how is that gonna be fair

opaque wing
slender lodge
tropic seal
#

which is like a solid 90% of players

opaque wing
slender lodge
#

even when 99% of the battle is on green thing ( winning ) it just cancels after some seconds

tropic seal
slender lodge
tropic seal
#

send a recording of this next time it happens

slender lodge
#

i will

opaque wing
#

First of all

slender lodge
#

and ill show yall that my rooms are forking bugged

tropic seal
opaque wing
#

Germany rarely defeats uk

slender lodge
wintry snow
tropic seal
#

clash royale is the limits of their strategic prowess

tropic seal
opaque wing
tropic seal
#

if he wasnt trolling this is genuinely sad

slender lodge
slender lodge
opaque wing
tropic seal
opaque wing
#

Makes sense how you suck so bad

tropic seal
#

ai germany too btw

#

🥀

slender lodge
#

ok im done iwth yall

#

f4ck yall

#

f4cking idiots

wintry snow
#

👍

slender lodge
#

not believing my f4cking room is bugged cuz yall have 1000 hours at a freaky game

tropic seal
#

@glacial steeple erm casey hes bypassing the censor 🤓

slender lodge
#

go f4ck yourself yall

opaque wing
#

Oh what f4ck is banned

#

Sad

#

:(

opaque wing
#

I did a wc as luxemburg

wintry snow
#

dont slime me bro

#

im a nice guy

slender lodge
#

@kingvon

wintry snow
#

you are king von

tropic seal
slender lodge
#

dude im hanzvonwolf

tropic seal
#

not sweden

#

hungary

wintry snow
#

i thought u were king von

opaque wing
slender lodge
#

WHO IS KING VON

#

IM DONE

opaque wing
#

Austro hungary? Or u went for that 1 tree

tropic seal
tropic seal
#

romanias just funny when you swap teams

opaque wing
opaque wing
tropic seal
#

it wasnt too bad

#

this was before the dd change

#

so i actually had manpower available to go on offensive wars

opaque wing
#

I challange you to do nsb while rejecting both hungarian and soviet demands without joining either axis or commiterm

tropic seal
#

just hold the bessarbia riverline and watch out for naval invasions

opaque wing
#

And no puppeting hungary n bulgaria

tropic seal
#

didnt reject hungary though

#

ill try that next

tropic seal
#

🥀

opaque wing
#

All the times failed nsb

tropic seal
#

you can get together like maybe 4 full armies

opaque wing
#

5

#

But you gotta go fascist for 5

tropic seal
#

oh five? zamn aight

#

ah

opaque wing
#

U need extensive conscription

tropic seal
#

id play romania more if its focus tree wasnt boring as hell

#

its got like three interesting focuses thats it

slender lodge
#

ok im done

#

WITH YALL

#

YALL

#

JUST

#

INSULTING

#

ME

#

FOR NO

#

REASON

tropic seal
#

hi done im dad

opaque wing
slender lodge
#

hi dad done im

opaque wing
#

🥀

slender lodge
tropic seal
slender lodge
#

YOU INSULING ME

#

bro

#

bro

#

im gonna cry...

tropic seal
#

ok dont cry here

#

head to tech support at least

pearl vessel
#

Is it possible to win against germany as a soviet during operation barbarossa when you have no air superiority,not much tank division and not good navy only plenty of infentry division?

slender lodge
#

yes

#

yes it is possible

#

u need to make their supply go down and start making more divitions

#

Also Make a defensive posture and wait them to get weak

#

and Accept all lend léase cuz u gonna need

#

Also move Industry to urals bc u rlly gonna need it

inner sparrow
slender lodge
#

Clown The art

inner sparrow
#

the only reason why u might fail is not being good enough at managing your stockpile pre war

slender lodge
#

Your tips are the only one that worked for me

tropic seal
#

tahts actualyl the best way if you arent good at micro

neat widget
#

special forces with 4 aa be like

slender lodge
#

Any tip for using militia as Austria?

slender lodge
pearl vessel
slender lodge
#

When i enter the chat, every one that is chatting in just leaves

slender lodge
neat widget
slender lodge
#

Cuz more land they move = more zone they need to pass through

#

i would say, cancel all your train rails in the front but idk if that will work good for you when they start to retreat

slender lodge
pearl vessel
#

Actually I was doing good but romania somehow naval invaded me.i thought you don't need navy for soviet

slender lodge
#

borntofly u have been writing for like 5 minutes just to say all that small text

slender lodge
#

Navy is the most useless as USSR

#

just let them to advance and then resist

neat widget
#

navy can be used as limited shore bombardment

#

or to block off kerch strait

slender lodge
#

i am tuff

neat widget
#

that said

#

you probably want to focus most of your production on land and air

pearl vessel
slender lodge
#

hand = 👌
some = 📦 (something)

Handsome = me

neat widget
slender lodge
#

Hey liva

#

As Austria: militia or inf

#

Ok

#

No answer ok

neat widget
#

yeah that isn't an easy question tbh

#

you can't add more militia in template

#

so it becomes costly eventually

slender lodge
neat widget
#

but on a battalion per battalion basis militia is better than inf i believe

#

with doctrines that is

slender lodge
#

yes

#

Why you playing zzz

twin kayak
#

I'm playing russia once again

#

how can I invade the uk ?

#

and why is belgian congo a major xD

languid trout
glacial steeple
neat widget
#

hi casey

glacial steeple
#

hru? :D

opaque wing
#

You got 2 choices

#

Either navy or paradrop

#

Both options work fine for germany

#

Oh wait ur russia

serene karma
#

What template did he give

river oxide
indigo sapphire
#

how many divs should i recruit as estonia?

dusty sandal
serene karma
#

U play prison architect?

serene karma
dusty sandal
#

Yup, a lot

serene karma
serene karma
#

Quite fun

dusty sandal
#

Yeah, i used to do a lot of community help on the discord since 2020

mild oriole
#

hi

serene karma
dusty sandal
#

Still do regularly, but there's less demand since 2023 and since all the delays with Prison Architect 2

serene karma
#

Theres a prison architect 2??

#

Havent touched the game in yrs

glacial steeple
#

hii francis

dusty sandal
dusty sandal
mild oriole
dusty sandal
#

No worries, we just did general chat too, I just assumed you didn't dare interrupt us as is often the case

winged ravine
#

why this guy is capable of leading 72 divisions? is this normal? KEKW

dusty sandal
winged ravine
#

defend area and garrison not the same, I thought

dusty sandal
#

You have frontlines, fallback lines, invasion (naval or paradrop) and garrison. The zoned one is garrison but can be used as an alternative frontline with the new "border" setting

winged ravine
#

thank you🍻

unreal prism
#

I have 100hours on the game and my devisions always suck. what are the best tank devision template?

random shell
#

I have scowered the internet for guides on how new navy works, but there is still absolutely no info on new carrier stances. Does anybody know what stances ACTUALLY do? What do naval bombers do when they are in 50% defensive sortie? In my tests it simply reduces their damage by 50% compared to 100% aggressive. Fighters obviously try to shoot down enemy planes while in offensive stance. But do they try to disrupt in offensive or defensive stance? Do they try to escort your bombers while in defensive stance?

unreal prism
dusty sandal
dusty sandal
tropic seal
daring gorge
#

why do people in mp use alot of line artillery but in solo its stupid?

unreal prism
#

Alr

tropic seal
unreal prism
#

thx I found it

tropic seal
#

most of the reasoning boils down to that players arent stupid

daring gorge
dusty sandal
tropic seal
#

not vanilla

uncut narwhal
#

mods like tfb or smth

daring gorge
tropic seal
dusty sandal
#

Line arty isn't good, and it gets worse in multiplayer

tropic seal
#

i havent taken a look at it in depth

uncut narwhal
#

than vanilla in there mods

#

especially combat width

#

in most pvp mods its 30w

#

like hearts of oak

#

iirc

dusty sandal
daring gorge
dusty sandal
#

Line arty in mp, if not played between new players only, will be an insane waste of equipment and resources
In singleplayer it'll just be "meh"

tropic seal
#

line art is good in some mods trash in others

visual citrus
#

Is this a good Tank Division Design?

daring gorge
dusty sandal
tropic seal
dusty sandal
tropic seal
#

everthing is wrong

daring gorge
visual citrus
tropic seal
glacial steeple
#

hi derpy

tropic seal
#

howz ur day

dusty sandal
glacial steeple
#

i was gonna shower but there is just no warm water

tropic seal
glacial steeple
daring gorge
#

is there any way to ignore special forces cap in vanilla?

tropic seal
daring gorge
#

how

tropic seal
#

one put a single infantry div in it

#

2 width

#

the other put as many as possible

#

train like a bajillion of the 2 width templates

#

deploy them

dusty sandal
#

Water in a boiling pot, then with a laden (then big spoon used to serve meals)

daring gorge
#

as many regular inf?

tropic seal
#

train a bajillion of the 2w

#

deploy

#

convert them into the brick of inf div spam

daring gorge
tropic seal
#

then boon special forces cap raised significantly

#

yes

#

dont train special forces you wont have the mp

#

you have to convert

inner sparrow
inner sparrow
#

the more mp your army has in theory, the bigger ur cap

daring gorge
glacial steeple
daring gorge
#

isnt that a big waste of stuff

visual citrus
inner sparrow
inner sparrow
#

same thing

glacial steeple
daring gorge
#

btw is a full brick of mountaineers a good idea

glacial steeple
#

they dont need manpower

inner sparrow
#

if u up batallions u up mp in theory aswell

inner sparrow
#

as I said

#

?????

glacial steeple
#

?????????

#

its unrelated to manpower

#

or equipment

inner sparrow
#

yes

#

but it’s easier describing it like that