ask-for-help-here

[sweet summit]

They're just literred on the borderline for some reason

[neat widget]

Ah great

[narrow grail]

I built more supply hubs near it and supply utilization got even worse..

[sweet summit]

I've just put my entire army on Afghanistan now..
Can't wait to blast em

[neat widget]

Huh, odd

Maybe you have a bunch of troops near Santiago

[neat widget]

Good luck

Also did you win

[narrow grail]

I exactly prevented that. Not a single unit in Santiago province.

[sweet summit]

Yeah 🥀
Lost burma though

[narrow grail]

You dont get it on peace deal

[sweet summit]

Grrr

[neat widget]

grrrrrr

[neat widget]

also strange

[sweet summit]

That's bad design

Might run the research slots

[glacial steeple]

trains

you probably just dont have enough trains

[narrow grail]

Lol

that's actually a thing

And I've been building trucks 😭

[sacred patrol]

Anyone playing albania

[narrow grail]

I played it in vanilla

too boring 0 content besides fighting Italy, the only fun thing

[sacred patrol]

Ooh

[sacred patrol]

I mean, maybe they would add a focus tree in the future

[narrow grail]

I don't think so

They will make separate dlc for Czechoslovakia

[sacred patrol]

Ooh

Maybe it's time for Albania world conquest

[analog maple]

guys is there any way to merge puppets? I accidentally balkanized Spain (they all my puppets)

[sacred patrol]

You could annex em by making them very low status

[sweet summit]

I have 45 civs and 10 mills 💀

Afghanistan was a paij

[indigo sapphire]

should i use Mods in hoi4 sp?

[cold bloom]

You can try base game first and then gradually use more expansive mods

[indigo sapphire]

alr

[narrow grail]

What are penalties here?

[sweet summit]

Soviet civil war 🔥

Finally some aluminium

[cerulean otter]

how much breakthrough is good for breaking through forts

[glacial heart]

idk how to fix it

[formal saffron]

im new to the game can someone help me learn it

[indigo sapphire]

hello

head over to Helping lounge 2

[formal saffron]

ok ill be there inna sec let me finish this round inn the game im in

[indigo sapphire]

alr

[sweet summit]

what

what do you mean unknown

[quick forum]

Maybe its the friends we made along the way.

[neat widget]

volunteers?

[sweet summit]

Yeah I'm so fuccckked

70k less infantry equipment 🥀

[neat widget]

How so

[analog maple]

how did uk guarantee turkey independence with only 16 war tensions?

[neat widget]

is it post jan 1939?

[analog maple]

no it 1936

7*

[neat widget]

huh

[indigo sapphire]

@formal saffron hello

[fathom thistle]

they always guarantee turkey no matter war tension apaprently

[analog maple]

no they dont last game they didnt

[fathom thistle]

is it iron mode or nah?

[analog maple]

yes

[fathom thistle]

ah nvm then

you could try to make them fasist if you have agencies

[plucky otter]

Demons

They are taking them

or maybe creatures from the shadow realm

[narrow grail]

Why is my nuclear strike getting canceled every single time?

I have a full wing of regular/level 3 strat bombers, a nuke and they just do nothing

[plucky otter]

Are you trying to launch them from air base access air bases

[indigo sapphire]

if anyone could maybe help me in helping lounge 1 then join

[narrow grail]

I found out what was the problem: in event choosing between 10% research on nuke or +1 free nuke I took one without finishing the project, which is requirement to execute nuclear strikes thus I couldn't.

[plucky otter]

lol

Understandable

Btw you should never take that one, the other lets you unlock them faster

With the 10% research

[narrow grail]

Well, I didn't know

[plucky otter]

Well now you do

[lone sigil]

they dont show up on the casualties

[sweet summit]

Yeah russia's an ass 🥀

365k dead but 98 divs

My front line's kinda collapsing so i restructured it

[lone sigil]

the generals bunos applies less and less

[sweet summit]

5m manpower but I'm too far to utilise it 🥀

Should get them by 1940, the Soviets

[lone sigil]

wait are you plaing as?

[sweet summit]

British raj left path

Got afganistan and sikiang

And then Soviets had a civil war in 38, joined it
It's July 1939 and we are still fighting

[lone sigil]

lol

[sweet summit]

I should use tanks

[sweet summit]

And the SSR could've taken moscow but they're just not doing it

I've literally traversed almost all of central russia 🥀

[lone sigil]

they grinding ahhh

[sweet summit]

They're like 2 tiles away 😭

It cannot be that hard

I somehow have 60% war participation 🥀

[indigo sapphire]

how can i win as ESTONIA?

[sweet summit]

Paratroopers

[lone sigil]

still wont be able to take anything caus its core

[lone sigil]

become soviet puppet

[indigo sapphire]

alr

[indigo sapphire]

no

[sweet summit]

Nah we'll have a peace conference and then I'll take their coal 🔥😀

[indigo sapphire]

i will stay NA

[sweet summit]

Plus i get .03% compliance per day so Collab gov

[lone sigil]

take the oil

[sweet summit]

I don't even have tanks yet 🥀

Well I haven't started producing them

[lone sigil]

air force?

[indigo sapphire]

i like NA

[sweet summit]

Nuh uh

[lone sigil]

bro

[sweet summit]

I have like 130 divs tho

[lone sigil]

alr

wtf

do airforce pls

[sweet summit]

My core pop is 400m 🥀

[lone sigil]

or do 40 withs

[sweet summit]

Nah I'm still building mills

[lone sigil]

huh

you can build mils and make a airforce?

[sweet summit]

Yeah the first year or two i was fighting a civil war

[glacial heart]

I need help, im at war with russia and dont know what Im doing

[sweet summit]

Nah a deficit on guns, support and art

[sweet summit]

Join the club

What year tho ?

[lone sigil]

what nation are you playing as?

[glacial heart]

germany

[lone sigil]

whats the problem?

[sweet summit]

Yeah just panzer them

[lone sigil]

or bash with your army

[sweet summit]

Unless you're fighting britain 🥀

[lone sigil]

works all the time

oh he got naval invades

[lone sigil]

here

[glacial heart]

yh and they just joint the allies

[lone sigil]

the soviets?

[glacial heart]

yh 😭

[lone sigil]

oh shit

you cooked

[peak elk]

I checked the internet forums for it but I can't seem to find an actually good guide for navy. Most of them yap about production costs and stuff. Can anyone recommend a good navy guide?

[lyric geyser]

Meta navy works in both mp and single player ships you build are Cruisers with max light attack, Carriers with max space, super heavy battleships and if your building a fleet from scratch build destroyers and try to have a ratio of 4 destroyers per cruiser

For combat have your entire fleet but subs in 1 stack have it on always engage and never repair

[daring jay]

after the peace conference can i see how many people i killed, how many ships i sunk etc?

[sacred patrol]

Is world conquest possible if I have just the resistance

[bright briar]

hello. Can I core the german empire as the united provinces when they are my puppet? youyour, the wilheminism path? Because I think I heard something like this?

[hidden reef]

I have a question i want to start a naval invasion from argentinia to portugal but i dont have any dominance in the regions. How do i change that?

[gleaming edge]

Older player returning after quite some time here. The last time I played, there was a bug where if you had a spirit of the army and spirit of the navy that grant the 50% chance to increase a stat on level up, only the army one would work while the navy one did nothing. Has that been fixed since or should I still only pick one of these spirits?

[spare depot]

TFB doesnt work for me it crashes my game talking abt map defition error

[half sparrow]

currently i'm playing nationalist spain and i've sent like 40 divisions to the germans to assist on the soviet front, would i get the war effort percentage for that or would the germans?

[indigo sapphire]

should i build any ships as Estonia?

[distant coyote]

Currently playing germany with historical AI focuses off. For some reason, on Apr. 22nd 1939, the USR just instantly annexes my ukraine puppet, totally encircling my offensive. Is this the result of some sort of focus for the USR?

[hasty mist]

How do paratroopers work?

[rustic acorn]

select your paratroopers, right click on airfield to use for take off, left click for destination

you will need green air for that operation

about 80 transport planes will be needed for a drop, depending on divisdion seize

[upbeat arrow]

how do imake it so my usa divisions dont collapse as soon as they hit combat?

[rustic acorn]

look taht your orga is not that low

more inf in your divs

but those with the crossed rifles arent bad, you got them from start

[half glade]

what templates are good for defending against germany as the Beneloux Federation?

[royal vapor]

there's this weird bug in my and my friend's save where if i try to get whitepeace of germany with netherlands and switch countries to do so, the game crashes the next time i try to switch the country i'm playing as (i also need to whitepeace ethiopia as italy)

[lyric geyser]

Ships you sunk yes you can click on a sea zone then there’s a button by it

and there’s also a menu for casualties somewhere but I don’t remember where it is

[viscid abyss]

Is it better to use canons or machine guns for fighters?

The canons have more air attack

[lone sigil]

heavy machine guns

[lone sigil]

you need anti air an engeener also i would try and get field hospital

[idle arch]

<@&846892247651057716>

[upbeat arrow]

org was tanked, but i had 20w infantry with supp. arty, eng, and logi, so i dont understand why

[languid trout]

mods, send him to the trenches

[lofty otter]

I was told I can find Red Baron guides somewhere on HOI4 Discord. Is this the right Discord ?

[lyric geyser]

You want to join the redbaron discord

[distant charm]

I have been trying to play multiplayer with my friend but our bracket versions are different, he has f303 and I have 2b48. It looks like I am the one with the problem since most people have f303 but I don't know how to fix it. In the startup window, I also have the bracket version f303, but when I start the game, my bracket version changes. Would appreciate any help!

[lofty otter]

Where would I find the link to it? I assume you cant post it here

[violet lintel]

Why are they not airdropping?

[wintry matrix]

Are you at war with the blue nation?

Are your paratroopers actually droppable?

[violet lintel]

lol, no

[wintry matrix]

You need supremacy above the sea too.

[lyric geyser]

You need to be at war to invade land

[wintry matrix]

And technically above the airfield.

[vital geode]

Well this explains the issue

[dusty sandal]

lack of enemy supremacy allows drop too

[remote pine]

For a minor country like Sweden can I just build infantry & Air. Do I need tanks?

[lone sigil]

no you dont but if you going high on cas try an do like 30 with inf

[remote pine]

Is 35/36 okay for an offensive inf? Also do I need to upgrade to motorized or mech or leave it as pure inf?

[molten needle]

guys yall got any tips for invading usa i defeated the allies before usa could join

im playing as germany

[peak elk]

Thanks but I what I asked for was an internet link to a comprehensive navy guide, not a paragraph of vague information about what stats I should focus on.

[lyric geyser]

1 you’re rude 2 what I said was a simplified guide to navy if you can’t understand the very basics of what I said you’ll struggle with the mechanics 3 there’s a good navy guide in the format of a video by Segl and Machivellientstrategist

[dusty sandal]

35-6 is the most polyvalent template you'll have (35 better than 36 in most cases but hard to get in sp)
you should never use motorized to begin with except for funny speed memes. Motorized is overpriced inf (2.5x the cost, not accounting for fuel and rubber for basically same stats but speed). Use cav/camels until you can get mech which is very good

[dusty sandal]

btw, the destroyer part is plain wrong
DDs are basically useless and you should never build any but escorts (if you don't know how to deal with subs with planes/can't do so). Otherwise, just build light cruisers only. They're screens anyway, they don't need other light ships.
In singleplayer just spamming light cruisers with armor and light attack is also enough, no need for capitals

[dusty sandal]

by guide do you want a template or mission/how to use guide ?

[peak elk]

1 I appreciated your effort in trying to help me 2 Your answer wasn't what I asked for

[lyric geyser]

Destroyers are needed for screening once you lose them your entire fleet dies

[lyric geyser]

Just say that then instead of being stuck up or rude

[dusty sandal]

light cruisers do the screening

DD are just here to take hits for others or kill subs (if you don't have planes)

[lyric geyser]

Atleast from my testing destroyers are needed a navy without destroyers gets obliterated in 2 seconds while the same fleet with them doesn’t

[versed rose]

destroyers are wasted ic

no armor, no hp, die like dogs

[peak elk]

No like there are so many guides on steam forums but most of them don't give you good designs or task force compositions etc. If there is a navy guide either a text based one or a youtube video (text preferred) it would be very nice of you to share it

[dusty sandal]

let's set this straight :
Capitals require screening ships^to prevent torp hits and keep their crit
DDs and Light cruisers are screening ship
Light cruisers are good while DDs suck
hence you only need light cruisers so you only build light cruisers

[peak elk]

That's why you build roach destroyers thats the main reason

[versed rose]

no, that's not why

[dusty sandal]

Segl did a good video explaining just about everything
gimme a sec

[pliant condor]

literally pinned in this very channel

[versed rose]

roach destroyers are a waste of ic, you make armored CLs for screen or you are griefing

or larping

[dusty sandal]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlzN1D3OK-w

[peak elk]

See you can just say that and not "focus on light attack on cruisers" and expect me to appreciate it as if its a navy guide

[lyric geyser]

I said segl as well but you ignored me

[dusty sandal]

roach DDs used to be a thing in mp but were never good since a single light atk cruiser will melt through dozens of them like butter

[peak elk]

Thank you so much I wish you a very nice day. @pliant condor you too

[lyric geyser]

you’re still being rude af

[pliant condor]

^

also very importantly, there's no such thing as a navy composition

[peak elk]

Oh it's not good anymore?

[dusty sandal]

never was tbf

[peak elk]

I said task force

[pliant condor]

you always put every surface ship in one fleet, regardless of what you build

[pliant condor]

yes same

the question is only what ships you build

[peak elk]

What if I want carriers?

[pliant condor]

same

put them in one fleet

[versed rose]

if you have a question about surface fleet task force composition, the answer is doomstack

there is no reason to split them up unless you're convoy raiding maybe

[dusty sandal]

unfortunately, contrary to what big paradox wants you to believe, hoi4 navy is still, at its core, a doomstack-wins mechanic

[peak elk]

Say, I have 200 surface ships and you tell me to put them on one group

[versed rose]

doomstack

split = die vs equal strength navy

[pliant condor]

yes

[lyric geyser]

I legit said the same thing bro what is this 😭

[dusty sandal]

I think the worst part is that they could add a coordination stat just like in land warfare to balance this

[peak elk]

I never knew that! So its like Eu4 combat mentality you just put 120k men on one army and wipe the enemy

[dusty sandal]

well, eu4 is more complicated than that but yes, essentially

[peak elk]

Thanks a lot guys

[dire dragon]

can i ask modding questions here

[dusty sandal]

sure but it'll probably get drowned in other questions before it gets answered

[dire dragon]

im tryna do this

but in hoi it shows this instead

[leaden jay]

is this a good mechanized?

[pliant condor]

there is one

just doesn't work as strongly as intended

[dire dragon]

i would add an extra infantory

[remote pine]

So basically either stick with pure inf until mech or cav with anti tank?

[pliant condor]

pretty sure stability_weekly is not an effect

it's a modifier

[dusty sandal]

I meant a coordination for ships concentrating damage on one ship. not the overhaul debuff they give

[pliant condor]

ships do prioritize targets with lower health

[dusty sandal]

no
missing core support AA
missing hospital
recon is useless at best

combat width must either be 16-8w, 24w if you're on a budget for offensive divs or 35-6w

[pliant condor]

but there's so many ships that the effect is minimal

[dusty sandal]

bruh

so minimal I never saw it happen clearly lmao
and I'm a navy lover

[pliant condor]

what you need to do is to make the decision to add a national spirit containing the said modifiers

you can't directly use them as an effect

[pliant condor]

https://hoi4.paradoxwikis.com/Naval_battle#:~:text=If the target is less than full strength%2C up to %2B100%25 bonus are applied to the weight. If the target is escaping%2C the weight is reduced by 50%25. If the target is actively fighting (i.e. not waiting)%2C a %2B50%25 bonus is applied.

[dire dragon]

that could work

[dusty sandal]

firstmost : AT in singleplayer is absultely useless. bottom of the barrel
then, you either use inf or use tanks with cav instead of mot until you can replace said cav with mech

[barren gulch]

im new and got no clue what my army stuff is

[winged panther]

whats wrong

why cant i declare

[dusty sandal]

I trust you, I meant I never realized that even though I look at naval battles as much as I can becausee I love navy

[dusty sandal]

https://youtu.be/QvHT121_lWQ

[winged panther]

help pls

[dusty sandal]

natonal spirit blocking you or mod issue

also, you must adress this red number or you'll stall very quickly

[pliant condor]

also if you ever make mechnized, make sure to fully cheapen the equipment(with 5 cost clicks) then it only cost 4 instead of 8 IC per piece

[winged panther]

im not playing a mod, and oh thanks

and idt theres any such nationalist spirit

OHHH its the faction rule

[remote pine]

What’s good support to go with inf or Mech? Apart from the usual like logistic, AA and Arty

Oh and hospital

[rustic acorn]

radio

radio for initiative

[remote pine]

I take recon is not that useful?

[rustic acorn]

it is

[molten needle]

can anyone recommend a good tank and infantry template i dont have any dlcs

[fathom thistle]

inf template for defending or for attacking?

[molten needle]

attacking

[rustic acorn]

inf is no good for attack alone

[dusty sandal]

logistic is fine but can be replaced
don't forget engineers
and if they're going to attack put a medium flame tank with maxed out breakthrough in the tank designer

[rustic acorn]

ogh yes, engineers!

[carmine thunder]

How am I supposed to push when I literally dont have the troops or equpiment to fill the frontlines 😭

[molten needle]

i only got one panzer division with rommel in it

[dusty sandal]

no dlc tanks

[molten needle]

thanks

[dusty sandal]

build more troops to push then

[molten needle]

yoo whats that weird tank with gun aiming up

[rustic acorn]

in earlier stage, let them come and run at your walls...

[molten needle]

i dont have tank designer bro

[dusty sandal]

the leftmost tanks are light SPGs
you'll get them by researching the explosion tech you can find on the light tank card in the research tree

[rustic acorn]

after a few month you can walk through butter

[molten needle]

uh whats explosion tech is it from the land facility thing?

[dusty sandal]

a good strat is either don't build tanks or build budget build tanks
build mils day 1
don't build inf too big

[dusty sandal]

no, open the research
go into tanks
on the light tanks research card (light tank 2 for example) there are 3 icons, click on the explosion and research it

should take ~80 days and you can get it day 1 as germany or france iirc

[vernal knoll]

is this like good?

[molten needle]

can u maybe send an image if possible i cant find it

[dusty sandal]

no

[vernal knoll]

how i make a good fighter

[fathom thistle]

this one is without tanks build

[molten needle]

thanks

[dusty sandal]

basic rules of plane design :
1 - If you're not using all the thrust, you're doing something horribly wrong
2 - small airframe = 1 engine, medium = 2 engine. Period. If you don't respect that, then you're doing something horribly wrong
3 - Air attack, range and air defence are to be maxed out in this order
4 - Light fighters always win against heavy fighters, except in the pacific. Heavy fighters are a waste in singleplayer
5 - Agility and speed are useful but not primordial
6 - Heavy MG are the gun to use before you get canons 2 (1944 tech)
7 - Electronics are always a waste, except for strat bomber meme

[molten needle]

ohh ok

thanks

[fathom thistle]

Are the first canons that bad? Or are they just not worth the ic?

[molten needle]

This is base no dlc right?

[rustic acorn]

the ratio is bad, so not worth the IC

[dusty sandal]

the first canons are ok for very early plane design
if you need to make a 1936 fighter you put :
2x canon 1, x4 light mg
1x engine 2, x1 light MG turret, range MIO

[dusty sandal]

yes

[molten needle]

my only concern is mp

how am i gonna get so much MP

[dusty sandal]

this gets outdated by the time you reach mid-late 1937 and get heavy MG

[dusty sandal]

manpower ?

[molten needle]

yes

[dusty sandal]

who are you playing as

[molten needle]

im playing germany

the allies are gone

[dusty sandal]

then it's a no issue

[molten needle]

ended the, before usa came

[rustic acorn]

focus tree and laws

[molten needle]

which part of fcous tree?

[dusty sandal]

don't go up to total mobilization (or do the women in the workforce decision), go up to extensive and you'll have way more manpower than you'll need

[rustic acorn]

total war for example

3% mp

with that working women law

[molten needle]

i did extensive

my man power stuck around 200k

[molten needle]

yep did that

[rustic acorn]

thats enough for start

it stuck at 200k?

[molten needle]

yea

barely moves

like a few hundred up

even ones

[rustic acorn]

did you build exessivly?

[molten needle]

i did use field hospitals

[dusty sandal]

hover over it
is there anything said about mobilizing ?

also change your garrison law to local police force/secret police

[molten needle]

i got 10 generals with all 24 divisions

[molten needle]

local police

[rustic acorn]

aha

[molten needle]

sorry my lights are out actually

cant use pc

[rustic acorn]

240 divs with what width?

[molten needle]

The basic 3 in 3 rows

i dont know what width would that be

[rustic acorn]

ok, round about 24k, something like that

[dusty sandal]

basically when you change a law, manpower takes time to arrive
it will be shown when you hover over it

[rustic acorn]

9x24k manpower is what?

and then x 240

[molten needle]

i did extensive conscription in 1940 and its 1942

[molten needle]

5,184,000

wwit what

what

[dusty sandal]

9x2 = 18
it's more 20 if they have support companies

[rustic acorn]

yes, but you see yourself

5184000

5 million

so you ask where your mp is?

5 million are there

[molten needle]

they are in the fields im talking about reserve

is it decreasing maybe due to reinforcements?

[rustic acorn]

ah, thats only an info that you are runjning out

yes

attrition

[molten needle]

Oh alright

thanks

[rustic acorn]

garision is killed by spies

and mobs

[vernal knoll]

alright thank you much

[pliant condor]

don't make heavy fighter

[vernal knoll]

yea i understood that but i dont know how make light ones

it automaticly become heavy

[rustic acorn]

you created as med

[dusty sandal]

light airframe + single engine = light fighter

[rustic acorn]

or with two engines?

[dusty sandal]

if you use multiple engine or medium airframe it's a heavy fighter

[dusty sandal]

NEVER

sorry, I reflex typed

[rustic acorn]

just asked myself...

but ok

[dusty sandal]

yeah thought you were replying to my above emssage

[pliant condor]

basically roughly how good a plane is is proportional to air attack * air defense / cost^2(if we only look at those stats), so if your heaavy figthter is twice as expensive, it needs to have 4 times the stats to compensate(which it doesn't)

[lone sigil]

300% research bonus as us and in situation wherer you airbase caped`?

[pliant condor]

usa is because you have 20% cost reduction from focus

[rustic acorn]

yes, as in the pacifics, there they are useful

[pliant condor]

which makes them not bad per IC

[dusty sandal]

cool buff, still a waste (can be argued about for MP but not for SP)

[vernal knoll]

aaaaa

ok

ok

[rustic acorn]

and in a way in terms of IC they are more expensive, but in manpower?

[vernal knoll]

sad economy moment

[pliant condor]

😂 running out of manpower from fielding the planes

[vernal knoll]

thank you all

[lone sigil]

alr didnt new it was about sp

[lone sigil]

not but realy you need max 100k for a big airforce in sp

[tight vector]

What is the point of artillery tanks? And should I use them?

[fathom thistle]

lot of soft attack

[tight vector]

Oh, okay.

[pliant condor]

you only make spg

assuming you have dlc

[lone sigil]

use them in singleplayer

[tight vector]

Alright that's all I play anyways.

[analog ferry]

I need help connecting in MP with a friend

can someone join helping 1?

I'll wait until confirmation before entering

[dusty sandal]

what's the issue ? "Host has another version of the game" ?

[analog ferry]

it says ''conection time out''

[dusty sandal]

is he already able to manage stuff in the country he's in ?

[analog ferry]

and his version of the game, at the end

it puts (s)

mine don't

[dusty sandal]

is the host already loaded in ? able to look at research and stuff ?

[analog ferry]

can you go to helping 1?

[analog ferry]

I am the host

like

not even begun the game

[dusty sandal]

any mods on your part or your friend's ?

[analog ferry]

none

he's on steam deck btw

I'm on PC

no mods

[vernal knoll]

who is the best ?

[dusty sandal]

HMG

[analog ferry]

base game, I got al the dlc's and he got none

[dusty sandal]

large canons are worthless

[vernal knoll]

the first

[vernal knoll]

oh alr

[dusty sandal]

that's not an issue

[vernal knoll]

and the others?

light

[analog ferry]

what could it be?

[dusty sandal]

LMG basically useless since you have HMG
large cannons are worthless

[vernal knoll]

alr thank you

[tight vector]

How do I get howitzers for my tanks?

[glacial steeple]

are large better than lmg

i wonder

[dusty sandal]

my guess would be a mod that's still enabled that one of you forgot (for the host has another version of the game) or one of you is on a beta/older version branch

As for the timeout it's either because you're loaded in and don't have hotjoin on (which from what you said shouldn't be the case) or you/your friend simply has bad internet/steam's having issues

[dusty sandal]

arty tech

[tight vector]

👍

[dusty sandal]

no, they weight and cost too much for the increase in stats

ok for heavy fighters ig

[analog ferry]

at the end of his game version it says (s) and mine don't, may that be the issue?

[dusty sandal]

the checksum must be exactly the same, yes

[analog ferry]

and why is his different?

[dusty sandal]

either one of you has mods still enabled, is using another version of the game
you should also verify the game files integrity

[analog ferry]

mine is: Musketeer v1.17.3.0.3a95 (f303) and his is Musketeer v1.17.3.0.3a95 (f303) (s)

the only real change is the final S

but the problem isn't ''another version of the game'', it say ''connection time out''

[twilit isle]

Heyo, sorry to ask this when its probably asked dozens or hundreds of times. How do you make "space marines"?

[fathom thistle]

you put tank with big armor stat into ifnantry division

boom, you got spacemarines

[twilit isle]

Thanks!

[remote pine]

Is it worth to make loads of space marine for attacking?

[analog ferry]

is there a problem if a friend plays hoi on the steam deck and I on pc???

[fathom thistle]

Yes and no. In late year they get pierced by most of enemies. You can do it in early years most of the time

[lone sigil]

if you do space marines you should do no other template

[reef quiver]

What’s the strategy for sealion now with the navy changes in NCNS (aside from using paratroopers instead of marines)?

Is it even possible without paras now and if so how would a newbie like me do it reliably?

[lone sigil]

the ai is worse so you dont neeed a big navy to sea lion

its easyer now

[stuck garnet]

how do i send air vols

[lone sigil]

click on air wing and then the should be a box on the nation you want to (beside an airport) that should show like 0/2 and than you send you airwing doasnt work if you have a to mall airforce

[reef quiver]

From one I’ve seen it’s extremely difficult to gain naval supremacy to the UK now with a small navy like Germany has

To the point every video about it suggests using paras instead now bc it’s “near impossible” apparently to do the OG strat as you can build supremacy in the channel for it?

[lone sigil]

huh they allways spiltt the navy up

[lone sigil]

no idea

[reef quiver]

Yeah that’s why I’m asking here about it bc I see some people say it’s still possible but some say it’s now impossible without plan Z levels of fleet build up (which admittedly with some Vichy france cheese might be doable?)

Trying to also see if there are any updated guides for Germany

[worn juniper]

whats the meta for navy cuz im not tryna learn all this bs

[lone sigil]

for mp or singleplayer?

[worn juniper]

singleplayer

[lone sigil]

do max lightattack lightcruiser

[worn juniper]

so just spam light cruisers?

[lone sigil]

also some cheap destroyer with trops

and aa battelships

[lone sigil]

ye

[worn juniper]

aa battleship, maxed lightcruisers, and shit destroyers

got it

ill try it next time

[inner mountain]

should i use destroyers or cruisers with torpedoes?

if im playing a minor nation

[glacial steeple]

why cruisers with torp

like theyre way better at light attack

obviously

but for torp they dont get more attack but are expensive

[glad imp]

Is it better to assign each army to one small part of the front or should i assign all of them to the entire front?

[tepid umbra]

I've literally never struggled to get supremacy in the english channel with very slight buildup

The trick is not focusing on the ships, but instead planes

[reef quiver]

So naval bomber/cas spam?

[tepid umbra]

That's what i do

I just do that and build a few light cruisers from the start of the game

And the uk crumbles

[reef quiver]

Ohlol light cruiser spam still hasn’t been fixed?

Also since Germany has the funny pocket battleships would spamming those be any better?

[final spindle]

I ned help with spain can some won help me

[tepid umbra]

No lol

[tepid umbra]

Idk

[sinful vessel]

I'm playing as France in 38, i've taken part in the Spanish civil war, i've also had my own civil war, but i'm not in war any more. Though i have few divisions.
I have taken the "Petite Entente" path, so war could knock at the door very soon. Would you have some advice before being nuked my Germany ?

[bleak plinth]

how do i deal with the kurdish rebels as turkey?? my rng is trash

[lone sigil]

i guess hold

[stuck garnet]

Dont attack unless youre 80% sure you will push

Build heavies i heard they were good for defense

[sinful vessel]

Ok. Things will start now, Germany just declare war against Czech.

[worn juniper]

is by blood alone worth?

[stuck garnet]

Italy ethiopia tree

Plane designer (strict meta)

[sinful vessel]

Plane builder

[stuck garnet]

Unit medals

[worn juniper]

i got the tank, navy, and spy dlcs already

[sinful vessel]

i love this ^^

[worn juniper]

so ig thats the next one

[stuck garnet]

Do you also get more peace conference decisions?

[stuck garnet]

I dont use

[worn juniper]

i think you can take navies if you buy the dlc

[stuck garnet]

Not even on tanks

Theyre cool and all

[sinful vessel]

i shouldn't, but i love looking at my divisions at the end, and the the medals ^^

But czech are at war, but don't call me, any idea why ?

[lone sigil]

absolutly

[sinful vessel]

Oh they just did

[hexed parcel]

Anyone know some good plane design that can crush the ai ? I can handle the ic cost i just want to wreck the ai as bad as I can

[serene karma]

Check pins

[hexed parcel]

I did that already but is thats as good as it gets?

[neat widget]

You can try advanced medium frame or supersonic jet fighters

[lone sigil]

is it normal that my admiral gets +11 attack

[neat widget]

But typically the game is decided by that point

[hollow linden]

Pretty normal, but rolls over 10 attack do nothing

[sacred patrol]

any heavy tank template?

[neat widget]

for multiplayer or singleplayer

[sacred patrol]

single, ik theyre ass but why not

[karmic terrace]

Playing as poland what inf template should I use for the fronts with russia and germany

And doctrine

[sacred patrol]

umm, is there any or

[hollow linden]

8/0 with aa and arty, large unit tactics, so grand assault and mobile recon

Tank doctrine doesn't matter for this

Oh grand doctrine sfp

[karmic terrace]

Ty

[lone sigil]

alr

[karmic terrace]

What id grand assault?

Operations?

[hollow linden]

Operations doctrine, the one that gives u planning

[hollow linden]

Ye

[sacred patrol]

@neat widget sorry to ping but theres none?

[karmic terrace]

Anti tank needed?

[hollow linden]

Nah

[neat widget]

If you're going large unit tactics you probably want a larger division

[hollow linden]

Oh right

[hollow linden]

If u get the doctrine that reduces your width, add 2 inf to the template for 17w

[neat widget]

an 8/0 with large unit tactics has a combat width of 13.6, which means that they can suffer from stacking penalties in plains or urban terrain

[hollow linden]

Precisely

[fringe stag]

Oh badboy

[sacred patrol]

thanks, but i also kinda need the division design if you have one

[lone sigil]

alr wtf

what do i do when i land in uk

and they constantly bash into me

they hove 180 divions

i just lost 48 div

32 withs

this is unplayable

[neat widget]

They have 180 divisions on Britain?

[lone sigil]

yes

1940

btw

[neat widget]

Just on the island itself?!

[fringe stag]

Can you send pic

[lone sigil]

uh nah on the iland prop 50-90

[neat widget]

Ah I see

Probably give your units good air cover to prevent the enemy from reinforce meming them away

[lone sigil]

i have all my are

[neat widget]

Do last stands

[lone sigil]

but they got 1700 interwarfightwe

[lone sigil]

cant

[neat widget]

And you can do it again

[lone sigil]

to lose my last 24 divs?

but i will try

dawng i allready lost 1.30m

[neat widget]

WHAT?!

Also do you have signals in your divs?

[lone sigil]

allright they have every tile covert with inf

[lone sigil]

yea i shoulve done

[sacred patrol]

ik its ass (and am gonna add the companies soon) but what could i change

[lone sigil]

make it like 36 with

nah thats it iam out

my marines died to

unplayeble

[lone sigil]

lol nah more tanks do like half tanks halt mech

yea try and get mec

[sacred patrol]

can i ask what did you just say

[lone sigil]

do haalf tank and halt motorised (try and replace them with mechanised inf)

[sacred patrol]

what if i reduce to 32 width

[lone sigil]

do one truck more for org

organisation

[sacred patrol]

and am all good?

support ima do a bit later since i need to research

[lone sigil]

yes do you have no step back?

[lone sigil]

support very imortaint

[sacred patrol]

no am using heavy tanks just bcs am bored

[lone sigil]

good somhone will porp say somthing else about it but thia ahould work

[sacred patrol]

ik, am gonna use hospitals engineer andsignal

am also turning the germans communist

[lone sigil]

you dont need hospital

[neat widget]

It should

But ethere's no support companies

[lone sigil]

he sad later

[lone sigil]

try and get a land facility and research miliatry engeenier vehicles

[neat widget]

But yes hospitals, assault engineers, flame tanks, either light tank or ranger recon, and then sure signals

[sacred patrol]

am getting mils so its gonna take a bit

[lone sigil]

oh yea light tank recon

and use the signal tank if possible

[glacial steeple]

land facility is day 1

before mils

dont do it as albania tho

[lone sigil]

yo can you help me

iam in kinda a sitation

i play as italy and conquert france and stuff

[sacred patrol]

not albania this time

also 25% german communism suppotr

[lone sigil]

but wenn i land in uk i get bashed to dead

alr he cant help

[neat widget]

Helo casey

[sacred patrol]

what happens if the germans reach 50% communism support

[lone sigil]

you can stage a coup or sum

[neat widget]

Yeah if those divisions have died we can't bring them back to life, sorry

Where have you been landing btw

[lone sigil]

dover

[lone sigil]

wait llemme scrap the barrel

[neat widget]

Also yes it seems like the AI has a very strong tendency to just bash you over and over and over again until you either die or they run out of steam

[lone sigil]

wat if i land all over the coast

[sacred patrol]

do the germans have to reach 50% or the party has to be the highest %

[lone sigil]

do you have the spie dlc?

[glacial steeple]

hiya hru

[sacred patrol]

yea

[lone sigil]

thrre is ,idsson stage a coup

[sacred patrol]

understanding 0

[neat widget]

Yeah you should basically land on as much of the British south coast as possible

[lone sigil]

alr

[neat widget]

RIP people's militia

[sacred patrol]

so what

like whats wrong witht his

[lone sigil]

it sas it

either its not a major not at paeca not less than 70% stability or less than 50$´% if a major

[sacred patrol]

so its impossible for me to do this

[lone sigil]

lol

[neat widget]

Basically what it is saying is
If non-major, you need less than 70% stability and for the country to be at peace
If major, you need less than 50% stability and for the country to be at peace
Or if the cuontry has less than 35% stability, you can coup them regardless

But for all of these cases you need 20% or more support for the KPD

[neat widget]

In short your problem is that Germany's stability is too high

[sacred patrol]

and i need to reduce it somehow

[lone sigil]

alr forget this italy run

never playing italy again

[neat widget]

Something known as the propaganda mission

[pulsar beacon]

how do i play as ussr i just starting playing this game yesterday

[lone sigil]

my laptop has not the power to go till nukes

[lone sigil]

should play as them

[pulsar beacon]

whenever operation barbarossa happens i get pushed back to moscow by august

[lone sigil]

id you just started

[neat widget]

That should be fine

[lone sigil]

try hand hld behind the river line

[neat widget]

How many factories do you have, and what are your division templates

And also how much air do you have

In singleplayer 300 quality infantry divisions should stop the Germans at the river lines

[lone sigil]

air as soviets in the big 25

[pulsar beacon]

ill load in my game to see exactly since i just quit but i had around 250~ around the time of invasion

150 civs 100 something mil

air was like 1300 but they where old 1936 air

[neat widget]

A little low on the mil count to be honest, but that...

Uh wait

[lone sigil]

civgreed

[sacred patrol]

om

[neat widget]

Yeah the general strategy is to civgreed until early 1938 and then switch to mils

[pulsar beacon]

ig i had too low troops, germany and friends had way more troops then me

or divisions

[lone sigil]

thats normal

[neat widget]

Yeah but the German divisions are bad

[lone sigil]

haha they go form bad in 1936 to 9/3 line arty in 1943

[neat widget]

As the Benelux (basically there is a path where as the Netherlands you can unite with Belgium and Luxembourg) btw I was able to get 35 19/0s by the time war kicked off

[neat widget]

Still bad

[sacred patrol]

Rip

[lone sigil]

lol

[sacred patrol]

in the span of 20 days btw

[neat widget]

Yeah oof

[lone sigil]

wtf

is it normal that the axis lose 400k guns?

oh yea they also lost 4m man

alr

[tepid umbra]

aren't the default starting ones good

[dusty sandal]

the inf is good, it just lacks support AA
the tanks are bad but to be fair, they are only the second worst one in the game as starter div

[tepid umbra]

oh yeah the tanks do suck

[sacred patrol]

time to play denmark but remain demo

[pulsar beacon]

despair

[sacred patrol]

very good statr

[modern merlin]

anyone want to explain to a noob why my units are nearly loosing even though I have a lot more of them and tanks?

[neat widget]

You don't have a lot of breakthrough, so their attacks are hitting harder

In addition, your tank stats for some reason are very low

Part of the root of this is low supply

At the same time if you de-org that first unit that can change things

[sacred patrol]

with japan isnt it supposed to be fascism

[rough hull]

what is the best strat to sealion uk as imperial germany?

[chilly lance]

Is it possible to put the autonomy of my puppets higher with the in game console?

[unique timber]

how the hell are you supposed to win as Communist China if you play historic? after 1.17 somehow EVERY piece of land conquered, despite i literally pushed with tanks, still belonged to China. Also isn't Manchuria supposed to be PRC's?? You can't even infiltrate it
also every single warlord work with chiang kai-shek wtf
i literally have only one choice which is to join comintern
the hell is this design, it is way worse than RT56
freaking CHI has 350 divisions

I have no trade route/convoy ships to get oil to fuel my tanks too, this is ridiculous

[cold bloom]

You can add autonomy score and then use other cheats or let the AI increase it themselves

[devout imp]

is this a decent light tank design? i dont have much experience with this, so im just trying to balance its effectiveness with the cost

also got no clue what the best template is for light tanks, but thats a problem for later

[cold bloom]

Theres tank templates and designs in the pins

[devout imp]

oh thank you!

[charred needle]

Look at the guy

Hes fighting for nothing

Holy

[edgy mesa]

i feel like iam loosing i keep getting held back

[paper nymph]

What path does Italy go in Historical, Towards a Greater Italy or Mare Nostrum?

[charred needle]

Tbh

I dont give a shit

Italy is a shit hole

[paper nymph]

Thanks this helped alot

[neat widget]

Your troops are underequipped

In general just get to Paris and then you'll be fine

[inner sparrow]

bc half of your divisions have 0 strength bc u prob have nothing in stockpile and the other half has 0 supply

[edgy mesa]

supply good but manpower keeps going to 0

[inner sparrow]

u will still push them and win eventually bc ai is same

[inner sparrow]

ur supply isnt good in the belgian part but its whatever, nothing major

if mp is low ur just too low on conscription

or you lost it all from battleplanning with inf into the maginot

[edgy mesa]

conscription?

[inner sparrow]

theres conscription law

next to your economic law

if you click onto your country where u assign high command and do all the stuff with political power, the one on the top left is conscription law

[edgy mesa]

?

[inner sparrow]

no

where yoo choose nearly all the political power stuff

[inner sparrow]

on the left at this tab

[inner sparrow]

yes

if u want more manpower u have to go up ok conscription

[edgy mesa]

and what about resistance how do i lower that i just saw that poland mostly is at 90%

[stuck garnet]

Is past service by requirement any good

[stuck garnet]

Do not use mp

For lower resistance

[edgy mesa]

i dont even know how to lower

[stuck garnet]

Suppression doesnt lower resistance

[edgy mesa]

first time seeing resistance is a thing

[stuck garnet]

Every state needs suppression to be garrissoned

Id reccomend local police force

[inner sparrow]

swap to civilain oversight from start of the game and change your division to a cav division with only cav in it

if its already too late go local police

or harsh quota

[stuck garnet]

With like

A mp

[inner sparrow]

no mp isnt needed

just any cav division with nothing else so u don’t waste eq is the best

[edgy mesa]

how tho

[inner sparrow]

in theory full template with cav is the best

[tepid umbra]

Iirc mp is good on 5+ battalion cavalry garrisons

[inner sparrow]

its waste of ic and not needed

[stuck garnet]

Less manpower and inf equipment in exchange for support equipment

Probs not the best but ehhh

[tepid umbra]

When i say good i mean it pays itself back

[stuck garnet]

Id reccomend full calv unless manpower or inf issues

Then add mps

[inner sparrow]

support equipment in exchange for less inf eq and mp is never worth it

[tepid umbra]

It literally can be

[stuck garnet]

"But if theyre struggling with inf equipment then why would they have support equipment on spare?"

Manpower is still good?

[tepid umbra]

If im spending 2 mils on the inf equip to garrison (underestimate) and im spending manpower

And i can swap thar for 1 on inf and 1 on support for less manpower

[inner sparrow]

if u struggle with inf eq and mp u have bigger problems than mp in your div

like hallooo

[tepid umbra]

Is that not a positive trade

[inner sparrow]

inf eq and mp is the easiest thing to have enough from

esp with new update

[stuck garnet]

Idk i was playing eaw but its probs different

Even with karl marx portrait i was struggling with my free griffonian territory run

So yeah only good for minor nations

[tepid umbra]

Did you have desp defence on

[stuck garnet]

Id reccomend military police for minor nations

[stuck garnet]

No

[edgy mesa]

also everything of mine keeps getting sabotaged how do i fix that

[tepid umbra]

Garrisons

[inner sparrow]

if u struggle with mp just click desp defence

instant 5% req

and u can even swap off it later and keep the mp if u bank it

[inner sparrow]

have garrison that is fully equipped

[edgy mesa]

can you join helping lounge 1 ? ill be muted and screensharing

[inner sparrow]

cant rn

[edgy mesa]

alr

[inner sparrow]

just make a garrison template with cav that hs any amount of pure cav in it

[edgy mesa]

wabu?

[inner sparrow]

and change to local or harsh quota

harsh quota usually is best on facist countries if you have enough compliance

which u prob wont have so do local

[edgy mesa]

2 things idk if it was a mistake attacking here and i understand about 15% of what you say

[tepid umbra]

Wouldn't be a mistake if you can win

[edgy mesa]

i really wanna understand but i have no idea

[inner sparrow]

click here in occupied territories, change the division that you have on garisson to one that is a horse, change the garrison law to local police force

then go to your templates and make sure that horse division you choose, only has horses in them, nothing else

[edgy mesa]

i cant find the occupied terri...

[inner sparrow]

its here

in the same screenshot

[edgy mesa]

so i set it to this?

[neat widget]

support equipment

that's not military police right?

[edgy mesa]

?

this right?

[tepid umbra]

It says it right there

[tepid umbra]

No

[neat widget]

support companies

[tepid umbra]

Edit the division to have one cavalry batallion

[tepid umbra]

Yeah

It says cavalry recon detachment

[neat widget]

Oh yeah

You don't want that in your garrison

[edgy mesa]

do i remove recon?

[tepid umbra]

Yes

[edgy mesa]

so like this?

[neat widget]

Yes

Also use that drop down to make a new division

First one, second one affects division names

[tepid umbra]

It'll be fine to just save it, no?

[neat widget]

Yeah but you're using 25 xp

you can make this with just 5 xp

[crystal fox]

okay so 2 questions

[neat widget]

yes?

[crystal fox]

1st of all, what's the best layout for infantry or wtv (like how much artillery or lookout or whatever whatever you get what i mean 😁🤌✨) and 2nd of all IF, entirely theoretically, the third reich took Moscow, Stalingrad and the Finnish people took Leningrad, is there any way to save it

[edgy mesa]

idk what i did but is it normal for soviet union to go to war with uk?

[wind cradle]

my hoi4 launcher is cooked it keeps popping up with this message

[crystal fox]

(yeah after a quick search i null my second question)

[tepid umbra]

There is no best, it's all situational but there are good ones (that i forget)

Yes it is possible to come back but maybe also not

[inner sparrow]

1st best inf division is either 16w pure inf with signals, logi, engi and aa if needed or any 36w with similar support companies. Yes no arty, because arty is shit at pushing, bit less bad at defending but overall bad and outclased by pure inf

and for the 2nd, yes even with 3 collabs (which ai never does) u wont cap and as long as you didnt build entire eco on the fronts this is still savable

especially against ai

[tepid umbra]

I mean you don't really need to push with inf

[inner sparrow]

as said infantry is also better at defending

arty is just more shit at pushing than defending

but gets outclased at both from pure inf

[crystal fox]

yeah uh i think it could be, but then again i lost to poland as germany, this is my second game of all time but imma try ig 🤌😭

[neat widget]

yeah arty doesn't give that much defense

[tepid umbra]

I wouldn't reccomend majors for your 2nd time playing

[inner sparrow]

its savable if yk what u do, if u don’t just go next game and try again

I do recommend playing majors, esp because you have a big eco

[crystal fox]

What would you reccomend then boss

[inner sparrow]

and smaller eco countries are too punishing if you play bad

[inner sparrow]

play germany and get a hang of the game

[crystal fox]

👍👍👍

[inner sparrow]

its the easiest country for new player, inflated eco, inflated and best stats

[crystal fox]

kay

[tepid umbra]

I'd reccomend a strong minor

[crystal fox]

imma tell you tmrw how its ganna go down

[tepid umbra]

Like romania or sumn

[inner sparrow]

no minor is „strong“ if you don’t know how to set it up

[inner sparrow]

romania is the weakest axis minor

[tepid umbra]

Im assuming they don't have dlcs

I'd say it's one of the stronger ones

Esp earlier on

[inner sparrow]

imo u just don’t play the game as minor, ppl that struggle to get divisions out as major will struggle even more as minors

[tepid umbra]

They never specified what the issue is

[inner sparrow]

if u lose to poland, production is always the issue

or one of them

u win with any starter template against ai if u have enough equipment for your divisions

[edgy mesa]

how do i invade england? i cant seem to get me troops to naval they loose once they get there

[tepid umbra]

What divisions are you using

And do you have air superiority

And what year is it

[edgy mesa]

and also is this a normal problem to have

[tepid umbra]

Naval invade with marines or tanks

[tepid umbra]

No but its cuz of your resistance

Put factories to repair at the top

[edgy mesa]

the list is over 1k

mb 1k is a bit of a high shot mb like 2-300

[tepid umbra]

Oh my god bruh

[edgy mesa]

is that bad?

[tepid umbra]

Yeah kind of

Wait lemme see your logistics menu

I wanna see if you're in a deficit

[tepid umbra]

Cuz that'd be another reason why you cant push

[tepid umbra]

Wtf

Do you have 2 mils

How many divisions do you have

[edgy mesa]

just under 200

[edgy mesa]

what is a mils

[tepid umbra]

Delete some if you're in a deficit like that

[tepid umbra]

Military factories

Civs or civvies are civilian factories

[edgy mesa]

okay

[edgy mesa]

okay i may have took some a bit extreme i deleted half bout 100

[tepid umbra]

Send a ss of logistics menu now

[edgy mesa]

also idk what this war has turned into, is this normal?

[neat widget]

That's if you have a coal issue

[tepid umbra]

Huh

You deleted 100 divs out of about 200 and half the deficit is gone

[edgy mesa]

makes sense

[tepid umbra]

Wait lemme see your inf equip production lines

[edgy mesa]

this?

[tepid umbra]

Yes

Why do you have it split like that

[edgy mesa]

wdym

[tepid umbra]

And i'd reccomend temporarily more mils on them

[tepid umbra]

You can have more than 15 per line

On military stuff

You can go up to 150

[edgy mesa]

so this is what i should do

[tepid umbra]

Yeah

Go back to logistics and hover over the number

[edgy mesa]

also i keep getting sabotaged this is right, right?

[tepid umbra]

Keep it like that

When resistance goes down sabotages stop happening

[edgy mesa]

alr

[edgy mesa]

also while we did that my navy got demolished and i lost all control of the channel

[tepid umbra]

💔

Do you have a good airforce

You can paradrop

[pliant condor]

one thing you always do

go to deployment screen

change the priority for garrison to the highest

[edgy mesa]

i like it

[pliant condor]

you always want to fill garrison equipment otherwise you enter deaths piral like this

[tepid umbra]

@edgy mesa do ts

[edgy mesa]

just did

[edgy mesa]

still at -80k

[tepid umbra]

That doesn't matter

It means the guns that are being made will go to the garrisons first

[edgy mesa]

i set to highest

[pliant condor]

disband some army if you have to

[tepid umbra]

They alr disbanded 100 divs

[pliant condor]

honestly this is another paradox issue where the game is completely different with/without dlc

oh

well

disband more ig

[edgy mesa]

so dlc makes it easier?

[tepid umbra]

Not necessarily

But definitely more fun

[edgy mesa]

should i do a 3 months sub?

[neat widget]

why does belgium have 73% resistance

Are your garrisons fully supplied

[edgy mesa]

iam tryna

[tepid umbra]

No

They're in an almost 80k deficit

[edgy mesa]

idk if this is better theres 2 red instead of 1

[tepid umbra]

That is better

54k is better than 70k

[edgy mesa]

aight

also i only have 48 divs left now

[tepid umbra]

Oh

That's bad

Maybe

Are you planning on declaring on the soviets anytime soon

[edgy mesa]

they are allied

[tepid umbra]

With you???

[edgy mesa]

or ish allied

[tepid umbra]

Or do you mean they're in the cominterm

[edgy mesa]

yes

[tepid umbra]

Yeah that's a fodder faction

It's made of the ussr, tannu tuva, and mongolia

[edgy mesa]

meaning

[neat widget]

commintern = free land for germany

[tepid umbra]

Besides ussr depending on the germany player

[edgy mesa]

iamm try invading something else

instead of uk i cant get to them

[neat widget]

Germany went around the Stalin line by invading Mongolia and Tannu Tuva

[tepid umbra]

Little did germany know, they were in for horrors

[pliant condor]

with dlc you can make collabs

so you get free compliance

[edgy mesa]

another thing why when i try to move 12 soldiers to one spot they automaticly go back

[edgy mesa]

nice

ill buy it after this war

[tepid umbra]

Plans

[edgy mesa]

thx

[pliant condor]

because they were assigned to another order

[edgy mesa]

ehm should i be concerned?

[pliant condor]

yes