#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 53 of 1

lone sigil
#

what about the research bonus?

#

and flame tanks right?

dusty sandal
#

buy Arms Against Tyranny before BBA, way better, the plane designer is a new player nightmare too

sacred patrol
#

Does heavy become good with any dlcs

dusty sandal
lone sigil
dusty sandal
lone sigil
dusty sandal
sacred patrol
#

But like

dusty sandal
sacred patrol
#

What if I get no dlc tank facility

dusty sandal
#

you get it too late and you don't need it. plus you get worse terrain debuff and it cost way more than it should for 8sa more

sacred patrol
#

(the building to make unique stuff with scientists)

lone sigil
dusty sandal
lone sigil
dusty sandal
#

it's good enough but not required

lone sigil
sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

and it's the only free special project for land warfare

dusty sandal
#

imo

sacred patrol
#

Since navy is too complex for my ass and nukes ain't gonna do much shit

lone sigil
dusty sandal
sacred patrol
#

So what research facility is like the best

tacit bison
#

Thanks advice.

  • What is "spearheading"
  • I know "Decisions" is a feature, but I don't know what it means, is that what you mean by picking air support bonus?
  • how do you send divisions from home army to Ethiopia
  • what do you mean by "keep pushing".

Apologies, I'm sure these are dumb questions.

dusty sandal
sacred patrol
#

Tanks maybe

#

But aren't nukes like ass rn?

#

Only killing 1 set of troops and doing no real land damage

dusty sandal
#

you don't get anything without the DLC with any of them

dusty sandal
sacred patrol
dusty sandal
lone sigil
sacred patrol
#

Aren't jets strong as hell?

dusty sandal
sacred patrol
lone sigil
#

on jet engin 1

sacred patrol
#

So just not get any research facilities unless I just want to?

lone sigil
#

yes

sacred patrol
#

Kk

lone sigil
#

you dont realy need any

sacred patrol
#

May I ask about special forces

dusty sandal
# sacred patrol What if I have a 50% reduction or 2 year penalty reduction

you need the special project for jet engines which is locked behind rocket rtechs so you can only start in 1941 if you hard rush it day 1 + with bonus. It takes 2+ years (870 days by default), then you need to research the plane (150 days more)
that means by the earliest, with hard rush and full on focus on it you can only get it by 1943-4 which, by then, the game's basically over

sacred patrol
#

Sticking to tier 3 planes I guess

#

So like, special forces

lone sigil
dusty sandal
#

and all that forsomething that's not even that good

#

only speed is good but that barely matters

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

at least inf gets good buffs from free doctrines

lone sigil
#

huh

dusty sandal
#

aand cost less

#

you basicallly only use marines with no DLC

lone sigil
#

you can use mountainers as cheap break through

#

for minor nations

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

para are still useful though, forgot about them. They're just inf that can drop

lone sigil
#

marines if you have a navy

sacred patrol
#

So just mountaineers if there's mountains and paratroopers anytime I have a chance to drop in a good spot

#

I think this is like all for now, right?

#

Anything you could ig reccomend

dusty sandal
olive tapir
#

what does it want?

lone sigil
#

heavy tanks if theres mountains

sacred patrol
lone sigil
dusty sandal
hasty belfry
#

Does the ai react to you fielding larger or fewer numbers of tank divisions?

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

already did but wasn't much fun

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

the figuring out how to win against germany when it comes for me

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

got the checz, poland, romania and hungary as puppets, called them all, watched germany declare on denmark and die to the allies then cored all of germany

sacred patrol
#

But for small nations is completely uselles if you're low on factorues

dusty sandal
#

I basically only play MP and have been doing so for about a year

lone sigil
#

like if you want to beat the ussr as a minor nation u cant get collabs

sacred patrol
#

Is building civs a bad idea always

lone sigil
lone sigil
#

to have 4 divs

#

when the sovies come

sacred patrol
dusty sandal
#

civs takes about 3 years to pay off
so unless you basically stop building civs about 2-3 years before war

lone sigil
#

what about early mils tho?

#

i mean as germany

#

civs arent wortg right

dusty sandal
#

germany doesn't build any (war in 39 and they get civs from others), japan doesn't build any because war in 37
allied minors build them until late 1937-jan 1938
allied/sov major build them until 1938 (jan for allied majors, up to mid-september for sov)

#

us doesn't build any because they build infra then mils

glacial steeple
#

if you look at MIC

dusty sandal
#

does he take into account construction buffs ?

sacred patrol
#

But why do people not like Albania

lone sigil
glacial steeple
#

i think so

dusty sandal
glacial steeple
wintry matrix
#

No formable nation for Albania and in the focus of Italian aggression.

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
#

ive played albania too

glacial steeple
sacred patrol
glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

And they could just do a naval invasion

glacial steeple
#

thats plenty of prep time

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

Having some forts for the water

glacial steeple
#

i usually like to play with non cheese strats

#

forts suck

#

coatal forts are kind of okay?

#

but you need mils

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

Just call in the British to do the job

glacial steeple
#

you can kill anyone with paras if you want

#

even players

sacred patrol
#

Or would the British disappoint me

glacial steeple
#

ai always disappoints

lone sigil
sacred patrol
#

Even if it's Germany?

glacial steeple
#

wdym even if its germany

lone sigil
glacial steeple
#

the german ai sucks

#

its just the best vanilla ai

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
#

which is a nothingburger

glacial steeple
#

given enough odds, small enough skill difference theyll win

sacred patrol
#

*bot

glacial steeple
#

youre not a bot thats just what vanilla ai is good at

#

they beat down fairly well

#

punching above their weight nah

sacred patrol
sacred patrol
#

Or should I just become technologically advanced quicker and rush em

glacial steeple
#

if you have a smaller manpower pool you should play somewhat aggressively

#

if against vanilla ai

#

kill as much as you can

#

defending is only out of necessity and usually temporary

#

if you dont attack while your eco + manpower is significantly lower youll lose

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

Then the soviets snooped in

lone sigil
sacred patrol
#

Total above 50

glacial steeple
#

you get like 40 civs or something when unified

sacred patrol
#

(that's how much I had I think)

glacial steeple
#

just unify ASAP

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
#

ignore everything pointless

sacred patrol
#

I wanna play albanja

#

But that's a bad idea

glacial steeple
#

yeah then play it

#

its a fine idea

#

zog or communist?

sacred patrol
#

Ima die to Italians

glacial steeple
#

then learn to use your terrain and win

sacred patrol
glacial steeple
#

learn how to properly mobilize your resources in time

glacial steeple
#

500 is from karl marx locked flipping communist

sacred patrol
sacred patrol
#

Rather than going fascism

glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

Unless I join the grrmans

glacial steeple
#

its not bad

glacial steeple
#

most people dont understand the game

#

and it isnt about hours

sacred patrol
lone sigil
glacial steeple
sacred patrol
glacial steeple
#

its the worst way of indicating skill

#

playing hours only make you micro better

sacred patrol
#

Also, are trucks just uselles in this game as a main army

glacial steeple
#

stuff like memorizing supply and terrains

lone sigil
versed rose
#

ive seen people with 2k hours think line arty was good

lone sigil
sacred patrol
#

Like imagine having a army where the main goal is to run over ofhers

versed rose
#

hours is a horrible indication of understanding

glacial steeple
sacred patrol
#

Ig ima play a bit later

glacial steeple
sacred patrol
lone sigil
#

watch the one guy on youtube

glacial steeple
#

thats half the game

#

possibly more than half

sacred patrol
lone sigil
#

wait lemme search

glacial steeple
lone sigil
#

and has like 3 vids

sacred patrol
#

It would be like interesting to try multiplayer

glacial steeple
lone sigil
#

teefeeraw

#

thid guy

sacred patrol
lone sigil
#

TeefeeRaw

lone sigil
#

he explains a lot about production and meta

#

usefull knowleage id say

sacred patrol
#

So wth are space marines

lone sigil
#

but its i think outdated

tribal fox
#

Is the UK able to guarantee below 25% world tension now? Just had it guarantee Sweden in a Germany run when I had only caused tension with a justification on Sweden, Rhineland, and volunteers to Italy...it was most disappointing.

remote pine
#

Hello! New to the game here. Play a couple of game and I’m absolutely fumbling about. I mostly play Sweden, any recommendations for playing the country? (Usually go monarchist route)

full nest
#

what should I change

lone sigil
#

also military engenier things

#

no arty

full nest
#

Remove all light tanks?

lone sigil
#

swich them with mediums

full nest
#

And replace?

#

ok

lone sigil
#

you want a medium flame tank and a assult vehicle as support

full nest
lone sigil
full nest
lone sigil
full nest
#

What dlc is the flame tank

lone sigil
#

no step back

full nest
#

Oh

lone sigil
#

you dont have?

full nest
#

I only got arms of tyranny, la resistance, and that one that gives focuses to south american countries

full nest
full nest
#

Im broke vro

#

🫩

lone sigil
#

yea but aat and the south arent as importait

#

as no stepp back and

#

blood alomne

bleak plinth
#

is this good enough land as mughal or should i restart

wind creek
#

i need some advice,as Germany should i annex all european territory and puppet overseas? i defeated the allies in 1939

rain yew
#

How the hell am I supposed to defend from the Soviets

full nest
#

@lone sigil ay sorry to bother u again but uh anything I should do with the infantry one?

lone sigil
vital geode
lone sigil
#

its just inf to defend and hold

vital geode
#

and give them a field marshal

rain yew
#

What’s a field marshal

lone sigil
vital geode
vital geode
#

Might as well have it

lone sigil
#

i mean

#

more supply use and less org

vital geode
#

Why shouldn't you have it

#

not by a lot

#

also supply is hardly an issue

lone sigil
#

also you need to build it

vital geode
#

oh no, 3 military factories

full nest
vital geode
#

maybe 5

full nest
#

I dont have that much tanks

lone sigil
full nest
#

Ok

lone sigil
full nest
#

Time to jump Brazil through the amazon rainforest… this will be fun, surely 💀

lone sigil
full nest
#

Dw I have a big ass slurpus

lone sigil
#

the lion doasnt care about supply and attrion anyways

worn juniper
#

yo im tryna make an mp with a friend and idk how to get him to join can someone dm me and help

open radish
#

Guys, im in 1940 and I still dont have reichkomissar option

#

Btw, can someone help with tank desings?

worn juniper
open radish
worn juniper
#

theres a search in that menu

#

try and search it

open radish
#

Nvm, I found

#

Thanks anyways

cobalt robin
#

is this template good for germany

open radish
#

Can you help me with taks?

open radish
#

Add some rangers

worn juniper
open radish
#

Lol

worn juniper
#

yo im tryna make an mp with a friend and idk how to get him to join can someone dm me and help

cobalt robin
#

i get no rangers

#

i always get the motorized,cavalry rangers

open radish
#

Is very worth

cobalt robin
#

okay thanks

#

and 1 more question

worn juniper
lone sigil
#

i mean if you dont do tanks you can but make sure to pick the right docktrine

worn juniper
cobalt robin
#

i f'ing hate this UK im naval invading it and when it lands i send my air there and just try to do something im getting dover and portsmouth supplys and all of a sudden they push me like they equipped supersonic jets behind them

lone sigil
cobalt robin
#

tried naval invading Hull and next to hulls tiles too

cobalt robin
#

same

lone sigil
cobalt robin
#

are these tanks good or bad too btw?

lone sigil
lone sigil
#

alr

lone sigil
#

land with marine tanks

cobalt robin
#

marine tanks?

cobalt robin
#

and I've got supply

#

in UK with it

lone sigil
lone sigil
#

i mean

#

they must havem like 40 divs per tile to push theses out

cobalt robin
#

the tank is not the problem

#

like my infantry lands on UK and gets pushed

lone sigil
#

oh

#

show you inf template

cobalt robin
lone sigil
#

dawng

#

this shouldnt get pushed

#

how is the air?

cobalt robin
#

green

lone sigil
#

do you have cas?

cobalt robin
#

yes

lone sigil
#

bro

cobalt robin
#

this is happening for the 5th time btw

lone sigil
#

than i cant help

cobalt robin
#

so thats like 10 hours of my life wasted on invading UK lmao

lone sigil
#

that must be some super uk churchill

cobalt robin
#

yeah lmao

#

or my planes are just not enough

#

here is the last photo of my planes after dying

#

maybe you find problem here..

lone sigil
#

show the design

#

of ur planes

#

also you got cas but no fighters

cobalt robin
lone sigil
#

wtf

cobalt robin
lone sigil
#

alr bro

cobalt robin
#

i've sent them to netherlands

#

to kill uk planes

#

atm

#

but when i land

lone sigil
#

this cas sucks

cobalt robin
#

i send to UK

#

yes help me

lone sigil
#

you all heavy or small bomb looks

worn juniper
#

can sm1 help with setting up an mp with my friend

cobalt robin
#

and fighter

lone sigil
#

add one more machine gun

cobalt robin
#

heavy?

lone sigil
#

ye

cobalt robin
#

done

#

can you help me with CAS?

#

cuz internet templates are like outdated and shit

lone sigil
#

uh i cant screenshot

cobalt robin
#

did that cas by myself

#

and fighter too

lone sigil
#

you got yt open?

#

watch the air guid

#

form segl

rigid grail
#

with the naval changes is it still 4 screens per capital ship?

cobalt robin
stuck garnet
#

show the secondary stuff

cobalt robin
stuck garnet
cobalt robin
#

and 1 engine 3

stuck garnet
#

the stuff at the bottom

#

you gotta add self sealing

#

and some armor

#

your air defense is bad

cobalt robin
#

maybe its because of air

cobalt robin
#

like youtube,websites

stuck garnet
#

ask casey

#

they probably know better than i do

#

like

#

you need that

cobalt robin
#

both for fighter and cas?

stuck garnet
#

if you're running cas then you shouldn't have to worry about air defense too much unless there's anti air or you're using cas wrong (using it in areas with fighters)

glacial steeple
glacial steeple
#

good channel

#

short videos

cobalt robin
neat widget
#

Yes

open radish
#

@glacial steeple @neat widget can any of you guys help me with tank design? Pls

idle arch
#

What support do u need in a tank template again (I don't have NCNS)

serene karma
idle arch
serene karma
idle arch
#

Ass eng???
Fh??

#

Pioneer??

#

Please explain

serene karma
#

U need to do the special project for it

#

Fh is field hospital

idle arch
#

Ok no special project support

serene karma
#

Pioneer is the special forces doctrine support company

idle arch
#

And no pioneer

serene karma
#

??

#

Why

idle arch
#

I kinda forgot to build research facilities

scenic nacelle
#

That’s like 3/5ths gone then

#

Lots of buffs gone too

bleak plinth
#

guys im doing the mughal raj war (the second one after the ceasefire) is there an automatic peace deal?

scenic salmon
#

Question, do you run both normal tanks and artillery tank templates together or one over another?

#

I see the template for artillery tanks in the pins, but wasnt sure if normal tank divisions are run along side them, saw the artillery get a -40% breakthrough when assigned that design

bleak plinth
#

is there not an automatic peace deal? <@&916727971820240976>

neat widget
#

You have to capitulate Britain

#

But you should be able to just rush them down in the first civil war

dusty sandal
scenic salmon
#

okay thx

sterile wave
#

why dont i see super heavy aritlery and stornghold networks in special projects

sterile wave
#

i have no step back

lone sigil
#

do you have gotterdammerung

stuck flint
#

i just watched an 1 hour and 45 minute video on the guide to germany

#

i believe i can take the uk out in 1939 now

sterile wave
lone sigil
#

than tahts the problem i belive

sterile wave
#

but im pretty sure i saw yestrday in special projects super heavy aritlery

lone sigil
#

lol

#

its super heavy railwailgun maby?

sterile wave
#

no aritlery

#

i have for railway gun

scenic salmon
lone sigil
#

soft attack

dusty sandal
scenic salmon
#

okay thx

empty latch
#

Why did my exiled government status as Netherlands just disappeare?

#

Is this a glitch

dusty sandal
empty latch
dusty sandal
empty latch
#

No mayor event happened acept maybe me closing my laptop and opening it after a long time

empty latch
dusty sandal
#

any mods ?

empty latch
#

R56

#

Fps and peace conference

dusty sandal
#

well their discord is most probably the place to ask then

#

rt56 changes way too much

wind creek
#

.

foggy rune
#

I really don't understand why supply has to be so important. like how is it that I can have 120 divisions attacking 5 and lose because I don't have supplies

glacial steeple
#

unless ur like fast

foggy rune
#

like I'm on civilian difficulty with a buffed Japan and I still can't even beat Manchuria because of supplies

#

I build railways and supply hubs but it tells me I have a naval bottleneck and I cannot find how to fix it

#

it's making me want to quit the game

dusty sandal
foggy rune
#

just a frustrated one

dusty sandal
#

just don't stack more than 5 divs on a tile and you'll be fine

#

stay close to supply hubs and don't mash your head against a wall if it doesn't work. Remember the "definition" of insanity
if something's not working, try another way

foggy rune
#

from someone who's having a hard time understanding the game, and trying to find answers, only for most threads I got to look for them in to be people saying "oh [blank] is so easy, if you can't figure that out just delete the game"

#

what about when the enemy has 18 divisions on one tile with no supply issues?

dusty sandal
#

basically

foggy rune
#

so how do I take that tile?

dusty sandal
#

but even dogshit bottow of the barrel div can hold an insane div with no supply

austere roost
sand ember
austere roost
#

and if you want breakthrough you make tds instead of tanks

sand ember
dusty sandal
austere roost
sand ember
austere roost
#

but since it's sp i doubt you need a lot of breakthrough

#

even with the malus the breakthrough is enough

sand ember
#

ok but you get more breakthrough with normal tanks

austere roost
#

breakthrough is a useless stat once you have enough of it, which is why old mw doctrine was a useless doctrine

foggy rune
mortal flame
#

How to change your political style, i mean i want to change from dacism to something else

austere roost
dusty sandal
# foggy rune so how do I take that tile?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QvHT121_lWQ
it's a bit outdated but will do the job just fine for what you need right now

I'm also gonna copy-paste a comment I make for every player that ask for advice :
"Best advice I can give to any new player is READ. See something you don't get ? Read the tooltip. See a red bubble ? Ask yourself why, click on it and read the tooltip. See a popup ? Adress it, don't let it hang around, it's there for a reason. See a red icon that seems weird ? Hover over it and read what it says, it's probably nothing good. You get the point

That's what will make you get better. Don't just look at a mess and start malding. If something's not working, then you're doing something wrong and pausing + reading will almost certainly tell you why. Rince and repeat until you understand and start to learn, and you will learn if you read the tooltips"

Hearts of Iron IV can seem complex and sometimes overwhelming, but today @hammotimee will guide you through the basic concepts that will rank you up from Cadet to General in no time! In this complete beginners guide, They'll be covering everything from setting up production to divulging the secrets on "How Navy Works". Study the guide general - ...

▶ Play video
foggy rune
#

yeah in this case I got frustrated because my supply says it has a naval bottleneck and I couldn't find an explanation anywhere including online

austere roost
#

do you have enough convoys

#

your capital as japan is tokyo so all supply to other parts of the world require convoys

foggy rune
#

my logistics screen says I have a surplus of 356

austere roost
#

does it say 100% supply on the top?

#

that means you have enough trains, trucks, and convoys for current logistic systems

dusty sandal
#

we've all been there, you just have to ake your time, don't rush things out. It's ok to struggle or get frustrated but if this happens, just take a break or start on another, perhaps easier country

Good starter ones are Germany or soviets (watch basic guide for soviet focuses) or USA. Stick to historical behaviour and don't manually justify. Only do war through focuses and the wargoal you get.
You can also pla with minor nations such as canada and hungary

dusty sandal
foggy rune
#

yes it says I have 100%

austere roost
#

if you're at full logistics and still have supply issues then you'll need to upgrade your logistic system

foggy rune
austere roost
#

anyways again you should at least give us screenshots of your divisions and battle screens

foggy rune
#

ok one sec

#

I doubled the infantry count on the division template but I don't know how to upate existing divisions

dusty sandal
# foggy rune

you have too many big divs on a single tile too far away from supply hubs basically

dusty sandal
foggy rune
#

how do I see how many units are actively in a div?

dusty sandal
#

so, let me run you through some basics

mortal flame
austere roost
#

you open your division template in the template editor, which is located in the same screen where you recruit divisions

austere roost
# foggy rune

100% means you have enough trains, trucks, convoys for the existing logistics infrastructure, but your infrastructure is not enough to support all the divisions on the frontline. you need to improve your railroads and the ports that handle the logistics transfers

foggy rune
#

I know how many are in the template, but in the template the division has 190 soft attack, and even my fully supplied divisions have 80, so I think they haven't updated their manpower

austere roost
#

also you can naval invade manchuko to open a second front

foggy rune
#

I tried that and I got kicked out because I had no supplies

austere roost
#

they're half equipped

#

you need to invade a port

#

like all your troops are half equipped so they begin with half the stats

foggy rune
#

half equipped with what? like inf equipment?

dusty sandal
#

The yellow circle shows you the condition of your troops. The green bar represent organisation, if it reaches 0, your troops lose the combat and stop attacking/retreat if attacked. The orange bar shows strenght which means the equipment and the manpower in that division. If the orange bar's full, the division is fully manned and equipped and has all the stats it's supposed to have. If it isn't at 100%, the stats will decrease accordingly to what's lacking (manpower affects HP and the rest is from equipment)

You can see the details in the green cricle

Now if you want to attack, make sure that you only use divisions with at bare minimum 80% strenght AND full manpower, except if the enemy is non-existant or less equipped han you are

foggy rune
#

ah ok so I need to fill my arty

austere roost
#

also undermanned

#

you need to stop the offensive and wait for manpower to recover

foggy rune
#

oh ok

pliant condor
#

don't swap template like this

#

or like template is not the correct place to look at

#

people say use whatever but it's really not important

#

you want fully equipped and fully trained division

austere roost
#

also change the click on the horse button in the field marshal tag and change it to three trucks so you use maximum amount of trucks to supply your army

dusty sandal
austere roost
#

like basically everything is wrong here

pliant condor
#

build a port on the coast and connect it with railway

#

and motorize your supply

foggy rune
#

I already have half progress on the hub should I still cancel it?

pliant condor
#

still cheaper to build a port

austere roost
#

revert to a save before you started buildign the hub

pliant condor
#

before you change the template ideally

foggy rune
#

I'll see if I have one

pliant condor
#

don't ever change template like this

#

you lose all veterancy

#

just use one template and deploy division in the field whenever you have equipment

austere roost
#

in the construction tab you can hover over a project to check how much cost the building is

dusty sandal
#

In this situation you basically have to stop all offensives and wait for the oraange bar to fill up, produce trucks and motorize your supply lines (red circle, click on it once to swap to partial, twice to swap to total, three times to go back to normal).
then once it's done, you can attack again, and don't forget your airforce

foggy rune
#

I do have full air dominance, I learned that lesson the hard way as germany in russia lol

dusty sandal
#

well, not the learned the hard way part, but you get my point

foggy rune
#

assigned all my air force to the army and did not realise I actually had to give them directives to gain air superiority, so they were just sitting in the airfield drinking coffee lol

pliant condor
#

don't assign

#

move it yourself

foggy rune
#

is there a big difference?

#

cause that's a lot of micro

austere roost
#

it's not

pliant condor
#

easy

#

it's just a bad habit

austere roost
#

ai might send your planes to an airport that exceeds capacity

pliant condor
#

could work sometimes

foggy rune
#

ah ok

#

I sometimes get overwhelmed and forget either naval or air force entirely so I will work on it haha

austere roost
#

like you get 5k planes running by barb, it's not overwhelming since you just select 1k fighters to fly over belarus or something

pliant condor
mortal flame
#

Does anybody know how to change my country from a facist one into a different type?

austere roost
#

or just be like me and build 120 36 width spaa divisions and ignore air and wait for motherships

foggy rune
#

it's less the game speed and more just that there's so much to do that I end up forgetting something

austere roost
#

you'll get more used to it when you play more games

foggy rune
#

I get the feeling democratic Japan was not an easy choice lol

austere roost
#

tbh any nation that needs a lot of navy is not a beginner friendly nation

#

except usa maybe since you can beat every other navy just with your beginning navy and uk does a lot of the dirty work for you before you enter ww2

foggy rune
#

I feel like I'm so late to start taking territory so by the time Germany starts the war I'm still in Manchuria

foggy rune
mortal flame
austere roost
#

you might have already picked the fascist path

#

other paths get locked out once you stick with mussolini

foggy rune
#

I haven't played Italy but I imagine so

austere roost
#

it depends on the ethiopian war

mortal flame
#

i ended wthiopian war on a peace treaty

austere roost
#

was it the fast victory or slow victory option?

mortal flame
austere roost
#

might want to start a new game and check the focus tree to see the conditions of going democratic/communist

foggy rune
#

alright I think I've made the decision to try a different nation and attempt to put what I've learned here into practice regarding supply, any recommendations on a good nation to learn with?

austere roost
#

maybe try usa

#

watch a guide on how to fix the great depression and get out of isolationism asap, and then the game is easy mode

#

you have 130 civs to begin with, a navy good enough for late game, and 5 years to prepare for war

foggy rune
#

ok I'll give it a try, I might be back to ask more questions later but for now thanks for all your help! I'm glad this resource is here so I don't pull my hair out lol

vernal knoll
#

guys do you think hoi5 will even come out?

pliant condor
#

kill china

regal marlin
#

It won't let me clear my user directory, can someone help me fix that?

maiden cobalt
#

Does anyone know why on earth this happens?

#

there is literally nothing else i can do to increase my contribution by the looks of it

#

only 1938 on historical

#

i searched it up and i cant find any solutions

#

it just keeps going down every few days it goes down by about a hundred each month

cerulean otter
#

hows this

inner sparrow
#

shit

cerulean otter
#

rip

inner sparrow
#

line arty is bad pushing

#

bit better for defending but still not that great

#

just do pure inf and if u have enough eco tanks with mechs

inner sparrow
vital geode
maiden cobalt
#

nobody is lend leasing anyone, we arent at war yet

vital geode
vital geode
maiden cobalt
#

neither

inner sparrow
vital geode
inner sparrow
#

using mechs without tanks in singleplayer is questionable tbh

vital geode
#

But even then, you'd have speed

inner sparrow
#

yeah

vital geode
maiden cobalt
vital geode
#

Mobile cavalry subdoctrine, mobile inf subdoctrine, and others actually really buff mech

inner sparrow
#

mech is great but pure mech is good for defending and not pushing

vital geode
#

The speed is insane too

inner sparrow
#

and you don’t need defence

vital geode
#

It can push

maiden cobalt
inner sparrow
#

but any mech div that is 10/8 0r even less tanks is fine

vital geode
#

And take minimal casualties

inner sparrow
#

nearly anything can infact push vs ai with cas

vital geode
inner sparrow
nocturne cloak
vital geode
inner sparrow
#

barb front is soviet speed run simulator

vital geode
#

Yeah, but they literally disappeared

#

Because I overran them

inner sparrow
#

overrunning is fun vs ai yeah

#

u can do funny armored car builds or fast light tanks for it

vital geode
#

I actually did

cerulean otter
vital geode
#

Mobile warfare UK gives fun speed buffs

#

They also have the armored car designer, but it isnt the greatest

#

And I speced entirely for speed

inner sparrow
#

I think ger had a good one for armored cars

vital geode
#

But do they have the +15% division speed guy

inner sparrow
#

u do from military advisor

vital geode
#

Really?

inner sparrow
#

idk how much tho

vital geode
#

I thought Germany only had a 10% one

inner sparrow
#

maybe its only 10

vital geode
#

UK has Alan Brooke for 15% division speed

#

And it's peak

inner sparrow
#

yeah

maiden cobalt
#

yo unrelated again but im trying everything i can but my contribution to my own faction still wont go up

#

its at -1300 contribution now and im only giving it 875

#

so im getting no contribution

#

and im at 0% influence still

tepid umbra
#

and start giving manpower

maiden cobalt
#

there arent any facilities

#

but ill give manpower

#

wait i cant even give manpower unless they request rigjt

maiden cobalt
tepid umbra
#

no

#

you can

#

you contribute to the manpower

#

and they can take it whenever they want

maiden cobalt
#

how do i do that

#

there is no option to add manpower to the faction

tepid umbra
#

cuz you don't have the section unlocked 💔

maiden cobalt
#

damn 🥀

#

what section is it

tepid umbra
#

the army section

maiden cobalt
#

the military one

#

ah i see i see

#

thank you

tepid umbra
#

go to the pie chart and try and find yourself

#

and hover over it

#

it might tell you why your contribution went down

maiden cobalt
#

the faction needs 60 more diva to unlock

maiden cobalt
tepid umbra
#

I thought it didn't

vital geode
#

So I thought it could apply with contribution

tepid umbra
#

iirc contribution is the stuff directly in the faction menu

vital geode
#

I dont fully understand the new system

junior light
#

do yall know how to use nukes, i have them researched and i got all the reactor and that stuff done, as well as that i also have air superiority and i have nukes and strategic bombers, but whenever i look at a video showing how, they have a nuke option whenever they click on a province, but i dont have a button. Any solutions?

vital flax
#

look at the bottom left panel for raids and you will see a nuke option

junior light
#

oh

#

i see

#

thanks

sonic wasp
#

basic medium tank for flametank or improved?

vital flax
# junior light i see

bottom right panel, my mistake, I had the same problem, looking in a province like before, but is an option in the bottom right panel, related to raids

junior light
#

yea i found it thanks

trail reef
#

does diplomatic pressure help with focus demands?

maiden cobalt
leaden jay
#

a few of my divisions are stuck here what do i do?

native gorge
#

Guys does the "having overseas borders with UK makes them put a lot less troops on the mainland" trick still work?

edgy mesa
#

why am i loosing this i got more divisions

nocturne cloak
#

then press go!

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

Cause there are only 17 on it

#

half of your army isnt attacking

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

thats just planning

#

wait till its full then go

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

The second line to the right of their level

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

they will stop when taking large loses

#

you can always push back without planning

#

but its just better with planning

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

there are emtpy tiles

#

your troops will push back

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

You can reload a save

#

Draw one simple field marshal frontline

#

get the planning then attack

#

its okay to lose!

edgy mesa
#

iamma try to let it run

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

they arent even covering the full frontline...

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

okay wait

#

look @edgy mesa

#

Those yellow exclamation marks means they arent assigned to an order

#

You arent setting up the frontline properly!

edgy mesa
#

they are on a order

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

Select him

#

And hold shift

#

Whilst holding shift

#

Place his frontline order

edgy mesa
edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
edgy mesa
# nocturne cloak brev

okay so when the civil war starts
have field marshall
Make a frontline while holding shift
make a attackline while holding shift?
press go when they are prepared
?

nocturne cloak
nocturne cloak
#

You finally got it!

#

Good job!

edgy mesa
nocturne cloak
#

You learned alot from this simple war!

#

Thats all that matters

edgy mesa
edgy mesa
#

also now that they almost reached the line do i delete the order or just make a new one

nocturne cloak
#

You can if you wish

edgy mesa
#

aight

nocturne cloak
#

🔥

edgy mesa
daring ivy
#

I see in many walk throughs the YouTuber manufactures a civil war. Why does this make sense?

stone pollen
#

Hoping someone can explain what I'm doing wrong. I'm trying to naval invade Estonia. Naval invasion is planned and main fleet is set to strike force or naval invasion support but it refuses to fire. Any ideas what I need to do differently?

languid trout
#

its the one that uses 2 arrows

languid trout
languid trout
#

select the divisions

#

and then right click the army u want to put it into

languid trout
#

id be surprised if u dont know how to do that

edgy mesa
#

do i need a dlc to eliminate mossulini?

harsh galleon
#

I'm having trouble invading the USSR as Germany, I know I'm doing something wrong but I'm not sure what it is. Can someone help me

stuck garnet
#

Can i give advice?

#

Build railroads🙏

#

Please

#

In general

#

Not talking to you

#

Im talking to whoever will listen frfr

edgy mesa
stuck garnet
#

Supply is everything

#

I was on eaw

stuck garnet
#

Not what i meant

#

Like

#

Its good to prepare beforehand

#

But if youre in a combat

#

And your divisions are not being supplird

#

Just build a lvl 1 railroad

edgy mesa
stuck garnet
#

How is their river lines?

harsh galleon
# stuck garnet Build railroads🙏

does this mean that all the railroads between the supply hub and my capital should be a high level, Will this increase the bandwidth of my supply hubs?

harsh galleon
stuck garnet
stuck garnet
#

No mots

#

Mots = no stats

#

No hardness

#

Also spgs

#

Med flame tanks are better too

#

No mot recons

edgy mesa
#

iam new is this a good division to keep?

harsh galleon
#

mech is expensive for me at the moment, Will mots work. I was told that SPG's don't give breakthrough or something like that

stuck garnet
#

Armored recons if youre going cannons and not howietzers

stuck garnet
#

Even then slap on a radio youll be find

#

Fine*

#

Why the hell do you need support arty

#

Add a hospital

stuck garnet
#

If you can produce mediums, you can produce mechanized

#

Also

#

Just reduce the cost via mios and upgrades to mech

harsh galleon
#

so replacing the mot with mech will make the template "good" to use against the USSR

harsh galleon
stuck garnet
#

Also youre playing as the german reich

#

How many facs you got

sweet summit
harsh galleon
#

Yes i am Germany i have 337 factories, When I say mech is too expensive I mean I haven't made any up until now and i would have to make hundreds to replace the mots i have in my tanks

#

~170 mil ~170 civ

daring onyx
#

I am in the process of the learning the game( just purchased off Steam). What are the most important DLC's to buy for a new player? I appreciate any help!

primal igloo
#

My first 30 mins of playing the game. Is there no way to change the number of civilian factories working on each construction besides changing the order? And why is 15 the max? As in how is that number derived/can it change?

left glacier
primal igloo
left glacier
#

Correct

rapid umbra
#

what are the best infantry templates?

#

especially for playing as a small country

#

i play a lot as hungary to form austria hungary and i have a lot of problems when i have to defend against germany and italy and i think its because my units are really bad

left glacier
#

16-20 width + support companies (engineer, artillery, anti air) is usually minimum for holding/defensive infantry

#

Offensive infantry like your special forces go for higher combat width

#

Like these ones for example

rapid umbra
#

so 14/4 and 7/2 are no longer good?

left glacier
#

I believe 7/2 is still good for minors. Not too sure about 14/4 with the latest version of the game

#

Does pair well with fire concentration arty-SD

daring onyx
#

Are their dedicated Youtubers to HOI IV?

rapid umbra
#

oh alr ty man

#

how abouyt tanks?

primal igloo
left glacier
#

Our beginners guide were made in collaboration with a few hoi4 youtubers

daring onyx
tepid umbra
quick forum
daring onyx
tepid umbra
#

I also learned a lot of good strategies here

daring onyx
#

Have a good evening everyone! Thank you for the help!

rapid umbra
fossil rain
#

how do I use this in my only infantry army

#

i am going superior firepower anyway

#

and I wanna use arty

tepid umbra
#

I mean if you really want to you can put it on but it's quite expensive

lyric geyser
glacial steeple
glacial steeple
glacial steeple
tepid umbra
#

do the benefits outweigh the costs tho

glacial steeple
#

i think its 3 actually

glacial steeple
#

and is rlly good

#

at the cost of what anyway?

#

using your mils?

tepid umbra
glacial steeple
left glacier
#

@glacial steeple A curious thought. I've started noticing that some hoi4 youtubers have started splitting off their screens on patrol missions from their main strike force, mainly destroyers for sea zone naval dominance. Do you think that is something viable or would you rather keep your destroyers in a strike force death stack?

fossil rain
glacial steeple
#

once you start losing ships you lose pretty badly

#

splitting your fleet up makes that much more likely to happen + they wont insta join battle

daring jay
#

this might seem like a dumb question but how do you "analyze" your build and their performance? i mean what stuff do you look at. for example if i build a panzer division template. how do i analyze how good the template is, where i might be going wrong with the design be it the tank design itself or the template design

tepid umbra
#

and for mp hard attack and breakthrough

daring jay
tepid umbra
#

I usually just do 18/36 width for infantry and 36 for tanks

#

but that's cuz im lazy

#

it depends on how you wanna play

daring jay
#

ahh got it. thanks

cerulean otter
#

I finally took france after 200 hours, then lost cuz italy couldnt hold the line

narrow grail
#

Why facilities consume supply?

winged panther
sweet summit
#

Hallo

#

Uh ive taken over British burma during the princely bs

#

Do I get to keep it ?

narrow grail
sweet summit
#

.. shit

#

100 days left and I'm wondering or not to naval invade British malaya

narrow grail
#

Why?

#

What is Malaya gonna do to you?

neat widget
#

As a minor you do like three things first

sweet summit
#

Uh i dunno
Prolly nothing

sweet summit
neat widget
#

Max out your conscription law, take the desperate defense doctrine, and add things like hospitals or individual excellence logistics

narrow grail
sweet summit
#

Oh yeah I use 12/2

neat widget
#

And only then you start adding artillery

sweet summit
#

Wait I can go up to 12/4 ?🥀

neat widget
#

12 * 2 + 4 * 3, okay that's permissible that's 36

#

14 * 2 + 4 * 3 = 40, so you'd struggle in forests

sweet summit
#

Uh some of my generals have 72 space

#

Why is that

neat widget
sweet summit
#

Yeah defensive one

#

Area defense of coastline

neat widget
#

Yeah that's the reason

sweet summit
#

They keep coming for Gujarat

narrow grail
sweet summit
#

Oh💀

narrow grail
sweet summit
#

Do I even bother defending British burma ?

#

They just landed there

neat widget
#

In singleplayer yes

narrow grail
#

I think it's easier than allowing them move so they don't have a chance to take some east India provinces from you on a peace deal

sweet summit
#

I sent 2 mountaineer division 🥀

neat widget
#

Which country is this?

sweet summit
neat widget
#

Ah I see

sweet summit
#

Well British burma

neat widget
#

Where are your armies

sweet summit
#

I'm fighting the allies in 37 🥀

narrow grail
#

You still can't fulfill Mughal uprising?

sweet summit
#

Oh i did

#

But I accidentally saved over the last one

neat widget
#

Ah I see

#

If you got all the way to Burma

#

Then I don't see why you need to even be at war with the Allies

sweet summit
#

I have like 30 left 🥀

narrow grail
neat widget
#

Ah I see, what does the map look like right now

narrow grail
#

even though it's basically a civil war

neat widget
#

Do you control all of India or do you not own a state

sweet summit
neat widget
#

So you have Burma, then yeah just defend all your points and coastal VPs

sweet summit
#

I might annex burma using cheats if I don't get it in the negotiations 🥀
This shi is not fair

neat widget
#

2 divs per port and coastal VP should be fine

#

Yeah it's a lot of micro over a vast space

#

Just make sure not to lose a state

sweet summit
#

I've put like 10 each

#

Cuz I somehow have 3m manpower

neat widget
#

You have the equipment?

sweet summit
#

.4% of my core population

sweet summit
neat widget
#

Ah I see

#

Cool

sweet summit
#

5k

neat widget
#

Yeah you should live

#

Do you have a screenshot btw

sweet summit
#

Wait I'll share

neat widget
#

Oh that's amazing

#

You're in a good place rn

#

Also cape comorin is a key area

#

So place two divs on the Kochin VP

#

And 2 on Madras

#

If you lose one of those VPs you lose the entire south

sweet summit
#

WPed