#ask-for-help-here

1 messages · Page 23 of 1

violet sinew
#

just look at the tuvan factory count, and you'll see they have like 50 mills at barb

tribal skiff
#

If you're Germany, get Ribbentrop and some faction goals which quicken Justifying?

hasty mist
#

No, I'm Italy...

#

Uhh

#

I'm about to defeat the Germans tho

#

And I better get good victory points.

scenic nacelle
violet sinew
#

they have. there are 2 states in the country now

sacred patrol
#

i mean like you cant justify early bcs of world tension and requierements

tribal skiff
#

Your spies are lying to you?😁

scenic nacelle
tribal skiff
#

But yeah, so no third SF branch for Germany, is that it?

violet sinew
scenic nacelle
#

Ignores world tension

violet sinew
#

even ironman

scenic nacelle
glacial steeple
#

finally i can start going down the political tree

violet sinew
sacred patrol
#

or like how

glacial steeple
#

justifications arent tension locked

scenic nacelle
robust viper
glacial steeple
robust viper
scenic nacelle
#

So I’m not crazy

glacial steeple
#

you are but its unrelated

glacial steeple
#

3.9 million extra core pop

#

when the current core pop is 5.4 mil

robust viper
burnt pewter
#

is it by design that as the USA I am limited to using my own naval supply hubs only and have zero access to the Allies ones? It kinda doesnt make sense why I shouldnt be able to support the Allies in Africa and Dday with navy

hasty mist
#

Y'all, why don't mods work?

#

lIke, ever.

violet sinew
violet sinew
hasty mist
#

I've reinstalled (multiple times)

#

verified files

molten plank
#

why cant I use german ports to run patrol missions?!?!?!

#

i tried strike force

violet sinew
molten plank
#

as shown in the picture but it didnt work too

hasty mist
#

Yeah, I tried Millenium.

#

ngl never tried RT56.

violet sinew
molten plank
#

it says out of range

#

"no accesible regions"

violet sinew
static gazelle
#

i keep trying to do holy roman empire and uk is declining to carve the congo pls help

violet sinew
molten plank
#

lemme load in and try that

static gazelle
molten plank
#

I’m the Roman Empire (Italy)

static gazelle
#

oh

still harness
#

How do I finish the UK?
I've paradropped and funneled around 50 divisions into 1 port close to London. I am getting constantly attacked. I am holding but the uk has probably 100 divisions right there. I cannot push and I do not have air superiority to paradrop again. I do not have the navy to beat the UK and I do not have nukes. (1940) I tried using a ton of cas, but cas just doesn't work.

umbral pewter
#

I have the same issue.

ancient epoch
#

Lads where do my convoys go after being produced I can't find em

spice cipher
#

My entire fleet just up and disappeared

#

All my carriers, battleships, etc.

#

What's weird is they still exist.

#

They just also don't.

#

They're winning battles where they were assigned.

#

Okay I clicked the right number of buttons and it popped back into existence.

remote bone
#

good mountain div?

glacial steeple
glacial steeple
carmine thunder
#

Heavy cannon or basic high velocity cannon

static turret
spice cipher
#

You need 95-100% reliability. 90% if you can produce a lot.

static turret
#

get your armor and engine down

remote bone
#

thats what i do

#

this is what i use in 39

#

then i upgrade to a close support cannon

carmine thunder
#

i am going against expert ai on challenging though not ai

remote bone
#

with the close support gun

static turret
static turret
#

current meta is soft attack go brrr

remote bone
#

well it is still pretty good

static turret
remote bone
#

and pretty good for after france

carmine thunder
#

there but which cannon is better

static turret
#

id add the maintenance thing andf change diesel to default

spice cipher
#

Reliability still too low

glacial steeple
carmine thunder
#

Reliability isn't real

glacial steeple
#

you just need it if you attrition a lot

#

which you kind of should be doing with exercising troops for mastery

#

but you dont do that with your main tank

glacial steeple
glacial steeple
#

40% cheaper if you do light

static turret
#

Wait so light tank is good now?

#

I mean the light tank damage still must suck tho

static turret
glacial steeple
#

which is good

glacial steeple
remote bone
glacial steeple
#

so if you have the same cost on design it is the same cost in div

#

assuming you use spg/td

#

thats not the case for normal tanks

#

which are 60-50-40

dusty sandal
carmine thunder
#

Its against competent expert ai though

#

and I wanna get used to it to get better at multiplayer

dusty sandal
viscid abyss
#

Will the uk ai try to launch a naval invasion into occupied France

#

I have historical mode on

fair pivot
#

can someone help me with navy

hushed bay
#

this any good?

#

it is good wow

glacial steeple
#

its okay

#

idk why youd ever do that as germany

#

but itll work

hushed bay
#

i mean i just punched through poland and france with it

sleek remnant
hushed bay
#

i have like 300 mil factories

sleek remnant
#

Probably remove artillery

sleek remnant
remote bone
#

think ima downgrade to the last version

#

i cant use the timelaps mod

unique ingot
#

how do i stop trotsky from dying when playing mexico?

stark bough
#

Is there anything special to know when designing a battlecruiser while playing PvO?

wet topaz
#

What is is PvO

#

Also battle cruisers suck

#

They are worse battleships

sleek falcon
#

I came by here a bit ago to ask for some help fighting Ethiopia as italy, and someone told me to build rails to supply points

#

this is my response

#

the only two supply points are all the way in the center of ethiopia

wet topaz
#

You can literally battleplan

#

Set up a frontline and click go essentially and you can cap them

#

You don’t really need supply because they don’t have it either

sleek falcon
#

issue is my troops never advanced in my last attempt

#

they were always "too disorganized"

stuck garnet
#

and tac

sleek falcon
#

???

#

what are those

stuck garnet
#

planes

#

close air support and tactical bombers

sleek falcon
#

oh

stuck garnet
#

have tacs bomb supplies and mils

sleek falcon
#

like assigning them to an army for air superiority and close air support?

#

how's this?

frigid harness
#

what to produce its 1941 i want to build ships so that i can invade uk playing as soviet union btw

sleek falcon
#

why are these guys not advancing?

#

I just stalled cause they don't feel like moving

vital geode
sleek falcon
#

welp, staring over for the third time I guess

vital geode
#

click and drag left click over the area which will select the troops

vital geode
#

You just need to manually tell troops to attack

#

You can click and drag over an area to select troops

#

You can then right click and tell them to attack

sleek falcon
#

ok new question, how do I see the names of provinces?

#

cause the game keeps telling me to take provinces I can't see

#

where are these

cold bloom
#

Zoom in lots so minor VPs show too

#

Or maybe use the search function in the bottom right

sleek falcon
#

oh they're the cities

#

yeah I'm starting over

#

shot waaaaaaaaaaaay past my intended target

cold bloom
#

Provinces are tiles yeh

#

States are the larger unit, what would be a province in some languages

austere warren
#

Playing with the current version with all DLC .... I have two fleets on patrol in the south china sea. I am not at war currently having recently taking out China and puppeted china's factions. Why is not naval dominance increasing in this sea zone ...

gusty briar
#

I puppeted Panama canal and japan puppeted regular panama, they control the canal not me, is this bc of an event or something? Or just a bug?

slender tapir
#

I won't lie I miss the MA-R infantry doom stack. Are we able to create something similar with the current doctrine system?

glacial steeple
#

especially as prc you have insane inf

winged panther
#

once ur troops push and reach till where u drew the offensive line

#

they usually stop

#

and also set ur battleplan to aggresive

sleek falcon
#

ok but when I last did that they just stopped dead after a bit

sleek falcon
#

do I need to like push them onwards by giving one direct order every now and then?

sleek falcon
# winged panther wdym

I set both lines up against eachother, like a pincer attack, but both sides wouldn't do anything

sleek falcon
#

at least after reaching a cerain point

#

they'd all entrench and do nothing

winged panther
sleek falcon
#

playing games with a friend

sleek falcon
winged panther
#

they stopped exactly there ig

sleek falcon
winged panther
#

and do you know how to set the battleplan to go aggresive?

#

usually does the job

sleek falcon
#

I played a few days ago and set the offensive lines right at the middle of Ethiopia

#

so each army would handle one half of the country

winged panther
#

oh and the thing is

#

sometimes

#

the army doesnt push

#

because if it does

#

it overextends

#

i can see u have very few troops

#

if u call every troop, even from ur homeland

sleek falcon
#

they're the ones provided in 1936

winged panther
#

thats going to be good enoug

sleek falcon
#

oh right

winged panther
sleek falcon
#

no domestic wars

winged panther
#

currently

#

present

#

in the area

#

there will be more troops in ur homeland

#

mainland italy

#

bring them too

#

once u get all of them

sleek falcon
#

I'm operating from Civ conceps of getting attacked at any moment, so I need to have boys home

hasty belfry
#

How good is line AT for an infantry only run for nations not economically strong enough to field many tanks?

sleek falcon
# winged panther ?

In Civ 6 anyone can declare war on you at any moment so you need to have some troops at home

sleek falcon
#

yeah someone told me

winged panther
#

in hoi4 u usually have an idea of whats going to happen usually

#

no one attacks ital

#

italy

sleek falcon
#

I just forgot

winged panther
#

yeah

#

nice

stark bough
frosty lava
#

Are space marines still good for singleplayer?

rapid urchin
#

how can one make a defensive SPA divsion? in MP

slender tapir
# glacial steeple

Ty for the reply but isn't this just limited to mao? Or are other countries able to get militia units?

foggy stratus
#

Someone can help me? i watched a lot of guides and i cant learn this game

gusty briar
#

So with the new naval dominance system say I have 55% dominance and the rest of the bar is red, does that mean my opponent has 45% or it just doesnt work that way?

vital geode
#

Are we dying to Poland or are we stuck in Benelux

vital geode
#

If it is red, it probably is bad for you

gusty briar
#

Well yeah lol I get that

vital geode
#

You can probably hover over the sea tile in naval mode and it should tell

#

It does break down who has naval dominance

#

And how much

gusty briar
#

I had a weird thing where I got naval invaded but when I checked the sea zone I was at 55% dominance. I know they only need to be above the threshold for a second to launch the invasion, but i only had subs in that sea zone so im dont think I could've gone from under 40% to 55% in the short time it took between them launching and me checking

#

And they still had about 30 ships in that zone as well

#

But im wondering if that means my screen could show im at 50%, but for my opponent, they could be above the threshold at the same time? Or does it always add up to 100%

vital geode
#

It should be same number of dominance for everyone. 60% for you should be 40% for them

#

If you have subs convoy raiding, it might decrease their gains by the time you noticed

gusty briar
#

Yeah thats what I thought originally

vital geode
#

Or they had a strike force suddenly multiply their dominance

gusty briar
#

If u move a strike force out of the zone though does dominance it adds automatically drop to 0? I thought it still ticked down overtime?

vital geode
#

I just know strike force is multiplicative

gusty briar
#

I had 3 convoy raider and 1 patrol made of cruiser subs, but other saves while doing that the most I've ever gotten was like 15%. I guess its not impossible but confused if maybe Im just not understanding the system

vital geode
gusty briar
#

Well i only do it so the cruisers attack normal ships as well. Once they have low enough visibility they can take out ships pretty well

vital geode
#

My patrol force (as the US) was an escort carrier, a heavy cruiser with floatplanes and a depth charges, and seaplane tenders with depth charges/normal destroyers

gusty briar
#

Everything else was early or basic subs

vital geode
#

So about 10-15 ships

#

Sometimes I had a light attack light cruiser

#

Subs provide low dominance, so not great at patrolling usually

#

Maybe a cruiser subs with planes

vital geode
gusty briar
#

Yeah well thats y im confused about the naval invasion lol, they shouldn't have been able to tick up dominance so high,

I have a regular fleet as well but it was active in different sea zones

vital geode
#

Yeah, if subs and a few cruisers are all you have to build supremacy, it won't be a lot

#

If the enemy has 1 capital patrolling, it will have a lot of gains much quicker than you

gusty briar
#

It was cruiser subs not cruiser ships

vital geode
gusty briar
#

It was just my sub fleet

vital geode
#

Remember that convoy raiding reduces enemy supremacy

#

But doesn't raise your own

gusty briar
#

Yeah, it wasnt for dominance i had a pretty big fleet somewhere else that was pretty standard some of every ship type

vital geode
#

Did you know sea lion is easy when you have the entire kriegsmarine surface fleet patrolling the channel

foggy stratus
#

never battle poland

#

and struggle in ethiopian war

vital geode
limpid atlas
#

Will this"Restructuring our debt" decision lead to another decision where I can fully get rid of the debt?

#

Or will I be stuck with half of it?

foggy stratus
#

i get it basic things

#

tech and research

#

focus tree

#

the UI in general

#

i dont understand army and micro

vital geode
#

Like you can click and drag an area and everything in the box you make is selected

#

Right clicking and shift right clicking allows you to tell troops to go somewhere

#

Shift right clicking queues a path

noble rain
#

whats the difference between a SHBS and a Modern Battleship?

foggy stratus
foggy stratus
#

like machiavellian

vital geode
foggy stratus
#

but i cant replicate

vital geode
#

And when the AI makes a breakthrough, you just watch it happen and do nothing

foggy stratus
#

i defeat the south and get smacked in north

foggy stratus
#

sorry for my english

vital geode
shrewd salmon
#

Hey there, so I am playing as Germany and I already did one nuclear strike on Hiroshima but when I try to do the second, it says that I don't have any, I have 219 in my stockpiles and I tried to nuke them again but it still says the same thing, what can I do?

#

I need to do it so I can end the war, I don't want to waste so much of my manpower and equipment by naval invading.

foggy stratus
#

idk what but im so bad at the game

vital geode
#

But you need to encircle and destroy units

#

And not tunnel vision

foggy stratus
#

idk how i didnt win ethiopian

#

quick

#

i thought it was just about pushing the troops

vital geode
#

You need to manually micro troops to pin the ethiopians

#

And make sure to never stop attacking

native goblet
#

Hello im a new player, ive been playing brazil a lot and have started a war with colombia yet i cant even take a single land with more than 60 division and instead get push back when they are outnumbered anyone know why? (Just a reminder i have taken uruguay and paraguay and build railway and supply hub to invade Colombia)

native goblet
#

Indeed i have been retried brazil 3 times because colombia beat me up

foggy stratus
vital geode
vital geode
foggy stratus
#

but what about the red and blue aarrow

#

to troops not going to tiles

#

support attack

vital geode
#

Ctrl click is support

#

They will attack but won't move into the tile

#

That is your blue arrow

native goblet
#

For the is just like for example tank divison full tank (heavy and super heavy tank) mechanized infantry full of truck

trail rapids
#

whsts the currency thing that looks like a chess piece that is used with colonies

serene karma
#

If they have enough they will move to a higher level of freedom

#

If they have 0 u can demote them

foggy stratus
barren sun
#

did they nerf germany in the update they barely make any advances in barbarossa now

trail rapids
vital geode
vital geode
noble rain
#

what do support and repair ships do again?

vital geode
noble rain
#

are they useful?

#

or are they like armored cars

vital geode
#

I think they cost as much as a few convoys

noble rain
#

i should watch a video on them

vital geode
#

I put 3 dockyards and I got quite a few of them

#

You dont need that many either from what I can tell

lean wigeon
#

Does anybody have a good Infantey division template and also a good tank division twmplate ? My divisions do good but they aren't stable after some time.

noble rain
#

oh my god i just realized im gonna have to fight almost 5000 ships

hazy root
#

Is there some kind of super-effective infantry template that allows you to defeat all the bots? Even in the later stages of the game?

#

And in general, is it correct to use infantry divisions for an attack?

alpine latch
glacial steeple
#

might be bugged lol

alpine latch
versed rose
#

for Operations subdoctrine, Infiltration, Desperate Defence, Deep Battle, or even Rapid Domination are decent alternatives. for Grand Doctrine, Superior Firepower or Mass Assault are also both good.

that combination is just the best for purely attacking.

Template-wise, you can replace support artillery with a breakthroughmaxed flametank or recontank for breakthrough stat, or recon ranger for cheap terrain buffs. Arguably can replace support aa with a line aa to have another slot.

#

Rush gun ahead of time, never not be researching guns. Most impactful research in the game, and single most important research to dumpstering ai with 0 brainpower. Ai doesnt like ahead of time research so they get high tech guns later which means their infantry are dogwater.

Have more better guns earlier = Win

neat widget
#

true

#

although if you face any terrain you do suffer

versed rose
#

could just reduce width to 32 and use ranger + flametank and continue turning brain off

neat widget
#

Fair

glacial steeple
versed rose
glacial steeple
#

smh

versed rose
#

i am innocent

#

you have no proof of your accusations

neat widget
#

Okay it probably does, but the effect is probably minor

weak moon
#

How do I do the Pearl harbor raid successfully?
Do I need to park the naval bomber carrier in the same sea zone as Hawaii?

I have tried it 5 times it always fails for me at medium or high risk setting.

zenith thunder
#

i started my my first campaign as germany and did the civil war and i did not finish it until 1940 so i was i was told that was way to long to finish it, now i restarted it and finished it by august 1937

#

is that ok iyo?

shut vapor
#

ideally youd finish it before the end of 36

#

you can do so by reaching the czechoslovak border asap and cutting off the bavarian pocket

#

once that is achieved, the rest of the civil war is a breeze

#

oh also, delete all your units before the civil war

#

and the moment it starts, start recruiting proper units

#

theyre 3x stronger than the civil war militia

#

but since im assuming youre a beginner, august 37 is fine

#

definetly better than 1940

glacial steeple
glacial steeple
glacial steeple
#

not great but youll live

hazy root
#

How can I win the civil war in the USA by following the path of fascism?

#

I tried four times, and it didn't work any of those times.

glacial steeple
#

then use them to hold/push

#

exploit gaps, divide their units and defeat them in detail

reef star
#

how tf am I out of manpower

versed rose
glacial steeple
#

but they probably died in garrisons

#

check occupied territories for yearly losses

thin zealot
reef star
glacial steeple
#

not instantly

#

anyway, i feel like youve been losing millions to garrisons

reef star
glacial steeple
#

its not too bad

#

still a lot

reef star
#

then where did my manpower go

alpine dove
#

Mass assault or sfp for defending as Soviet Union

reef star
#

taking this much casualties

glacial steeple
reef star
glacial steeple
sinful vessel
#

First time i see bicycle division. Are they usefull. If yes, why ?

glacial steeple
#

they however also cost a lot of support equipment

versed rose
#

As fast as horses, costs twice as much

#

Iirc they counted as leg infantry though, unlike horses

glass mason
#

Yes, they scale better than horses but you can't use large unit tactics with them so unless you fit them in a special forces build they are not the yellow of the egg as the Germans say

tawny turret
#

How do I prevent Chinese Soviet Republic from joining Comintern as Kuomintang China?

#

I read that Soviets won't let them in if I have at least 50 positive opinion with them, is that true?

elfin pasture
#

uhm i have a problem

#

game doesnt let me produce medium tanks

#

i try to add a medium tank everytime but it doesnt let me

sinful vessel
#

I may have set myself in a complicated situation with the russian border ? I'm fascist though not allied with Germany.

hollow linden
foggy junco
#

so. i suck at this game
but i want to get better.

as helpful as the video based guides are, i would like to see if theres any text based guides? those just seem to work a bit better. plus, i play at work so vids arent really great option anyway

sinful vessel
hollow linden
wise star
#

i have a question about yugoslavia, is it better to do devolved croatia or united autonomous croatia (i'm gonna be doing reunite the kingdoms as the end focus)

hollow linden
#

🤝

hollow linden
wise star
#

devolved gives only 3 militia but 2 puppet states, united gives 4 militia but only 1 puppet state

hollow linden
#

For some reason, AI will only do industry focuses if they have more than 1 state

wise star
hollow linden
#

Nah

wise star
#

like 2 at the same time

#

if devolved

hollow linden
#

They will be doing other stuff

wise star
#

oh ok

hollow linden
#

Not industry

wise star
#

welp, i guess i'm 90s-ing yugoslavia

#

(theyre gonna have 2 years of freedom max)

spark forum
#

Yo

#

Where do I play multiplayer

pliant condor
#

you just need to wait

#

(for the one-states)

wise star
#

so

#

do i reunite or do i not reunite

hollow linden
#

Reunite

wise star
#

i meant more like

#

when do i

#

cause 39 is kinda ww2

hollow linden
wise star
#

yeah sorry my brain is malfunctioning

hollow linden
#

Ideally before war and when all your puppets have done their focuses

wise star
#

gotcha

#

thx

glacial steeple
wise star
#

so

#

"within reason" is "before i get attacked by the axis"

glacial steeple
#

yes and in a time where you can use your mils

#

probably should go dispersed

wise star
#

btw if i have the states as puppets will they still produce everything im making for me

#

like equipment n stuff

glacial steeple
#

starting techs are NOT based on overlord its just whatever theyre assigned at game start

#

which often the devs try to have similar to overlord tech

#

but thats not always the case

wise star
#

i meant will these still be produced for me once the puppets split

#

in the puppet military factories

glacial steeple
#

you keep the mils in your territory

wise star
#

i put most into serbia cause serbia doesnt split until way later and i still keep control of it

glacial steeple
#

yugo is probably a dispersed nation in general

#

your manpower pool is really small and you dont really need the production conc gives

#

but having better equipment production first year may matter

#

especially when reintegrating puppets (0 efficiency mils)

sinful vessel
#

fighting with puppet troops give them autonomy i guess ?

hollow linden
#

It counts towards their contributed war score

sinful vessel
hollow linden
#

Best practice is to not use anything of the puppet and lendlease them convoys and build mils in them

#

If you can't annex puppets via decision, event or focus

sinful vessel
#

I'm a bit overextended as Italy here and i need my puppets troop in Ethiopia, where many allied troops are :-/. If i can't annex them, i'll have to declare war to them at some poin,t ^^

analog maple
#

what this?

sinful vessel
#

better coal use probably

forest yarrow
#

guys i just got no step back and by blood alone best desin for medium tank and fighter?

forest yarrow
#

pins?

glacial steeple
#

to smelt iron or like steak

forest yarrow
steady pecan
#

Genuine question, what combat width is optimal for armor?

dull flicker
#

About the new doctrines, can you switch doctrine late game and keep some bonuses from the previous one?

sinful vessel
#

if i have the old polish border as Italy, will (and if when) russia declare war on me as it does with german ?

hollow linden
#

As u don't own the land u just control

#

Though if you own bessarabia you might get an event

sinful vessel
#

I own it. But Germany also just occupy usually ?

hollow linden
#

It'll do it at random if it feels strong enough

#

So watch out for any justification

sinful vessel
#

My manpower will make the defense quite hard i believe ^^

hollow linden
#

The debuff is bad but better then not having manpower

sinful vessel
#

yes. i just did it. And still have 2 level possible if needed. I just need some time.

hollow linden
sinful vessel
#

If needed i could defend this line, with mountains and river. And Germany may be in war too when they'll reach their border.

hasty belfry
#

How good are escort carriers?

hollow linden
sinful vessel
sinful vessel
#

I would prefer kill UK first. At least they have nothing left but Gibraltar in my 'Mare Nostrum'

#

It's march 40 here, i may have the time.

glacial steeple
#

actually yes

#

but not really

#

its only for a few specific bonuses

#

and those arent combat bonuses

bleak plinth
#

guys how do i beat turkiye early as greece it took me until 1941 😭

glacial steeple
bleak plinth
charred fable
#

Can someone explain to me how people stack so many war justifications? Bolivia = 70 days then I do Peru = 155 days, then I go to do Ecuador = 400 days?!

wintry matrix
#

In older patches you let them naval invade you and keep killing them at the port without taking it.
Or letting them push in the borth and keep encircling them there.

wintry matrix
sinful vessel
#

I must miss smthing, i'm always at the maximum

charred fable
charred fable
wintry matrix
unreal pulsar
#

Does anyone have a Kaiserreich guide for Germany or should I play something easier and if so what

sacred patrol
#

Any advice about the AI not inviting half of europe to war

summer stratus
#

yo anyone

#

i have a question

#

hello

summer stratus
#

if anyone can tell me how to add mods for none steam and without a paradox account

#

i will be thankful

glacial steeple
#

the mod you are looking for might have a way for you to download it as a file

#

if they dont then you cant get the mod

pulsar surge
#

💔

glacial steeple
#

please do not mention that/talk about that on this discord

glacial steeple
dim kraken
glacial steeple
#

you have to download the mod files

#

sometimes available on their discord servers

summer stratus
summer stratus
glacial steeple
wise star
#

do i divide bosnia or protect (release as BiH)

#

yugo focus

summer stratus
#

where can i find Millennium Dawn A Modern Day Mod.zip

summer stratus
fluid wharf
#

Latest updates

#

Are filled with brain dead people I swear

#

I guess that’s why they arnt in ask for help

#

Because they can’t thing with their god awful tiny brain

summer stratus
#

so you want me to stop finding a link to download it

#

Moddie do you have the link

#

or the game

wintry matrix
wise star
#

so i should release them as the big BiH instead of Herzegovina and BiH

wintry matrix
wise star
#

gotcha

#

thanks

bleak plinth
#

guys why cant i send my navy here? i have port access

scenic nacelle
#

This is where u get supply from

#

And u get it from Athens

hollow linden
bleak plinth
#

it worked

naive verge
#

anybody know why rise of nations mod crashes on germany

marble temple
#

If I add a new Capital Ship strategy, will I lose Line of Battle?

hollow linden
#

You're replacing Line of Battle with something else

marble temple
#

just making sure.

#

thanks.

bleak plinth
#

is this a good template for late game?

wise star
#

yo my agent just got captured and it said "we must prepare a rescue operation"

#

did i just lose an agent💀

marble temple
#

lol too big. except for MP.

wise star
#

or can i somehow get them back

serene karma
marble temple
#

You can get them back

serene karma
#

But yes u need to rescue

wise star
#

how do i do that

serene karma
#

Dead agents are better than captured ones

serene karma
#

Same as others

marble temple
#

You will have a new rescue mission once you get the % high enough.

wise star
#

if i start a war with albania i'm gonna get deleted by italy

marble temple
#

& disagree re dead v. captured -- the 2 skill is better to save.

wise star
#

how do i "collect" a civilian factory

#

nvm i figured this out

heavy fern
#

hey there! what support companies should i use in ncns? I'm looking for general use infantry an tank division

left glacier
#

If you don't have that, then cavalry will do for the moment

#

Support companies wise, Engineer company, anti air if you expect not to have air superiority, field hospitals for less exp loss, and logistics company for low supply terrain

neat widget
scenic nacelle
left glacier
#

If you have No Step Back, you can implement support flame tanks for better terrain bonuses against rough terain and forts

neat widget
# glacial steeple apparently

I feel like the thing mastery most correlates with is the number of battalions, if you have 1 2-width you are gaining no matery

#

also super-heavy artillery is very good too + doctrine

bleak plinth
#

i replaced the artillery with paratroopers

karmic bramble
#

I am by no means a new player but does anyone have advice on when to build dockyards? Ive switched between mils and dockyards in the past and I don't really have a good pointer how much I should build of what when I want to make a navy

analog maple
#

guys how do i even air invade the uk? i just sent 10 parea divison on a single port and i coudnt even take it my division got viporised

neat widget
#

i see, but the answer is still no because you can fill the support slots with things like artillery and light flame tank

karmic bramble
neat widget
karmic bramble
#

support anti air might be wise too because in foreign territory you are going to get cassed

neat widget
#

well i do have this tbh, replace the arty or armored cars with aa or logistics if you're so inclined

#

or of course replace recon with ranger recon too

karmic bramble
heavy fern
#

oh how good are ranger?

hollow linden
#

Like going over 60 usually is nad

#

If you wanna build a navy, start early

#

You only need around 30-40 as say UK

karmic bramble
hollow linden
#

Because you already start with a lot of ships

karmic bramble
#

playing italy if that helps

hollow linden
neat widget
hollow linden
#

So I guess do both? And then stop building docks once you got your desired number of them

hollow linden
neat widget
#

you do want to also build mils as early as possible for efficiency as said

hollow linden
#

Cuz you can't have too many mils you can only have too many docks

karmic bramble
#

I guess I should just alternate between lines then and start with dockyards?

hollow linden
#

After building your 12 to 18 months of civs

#

Assuming you're a major

#

Cuz please don't build 40 docks as Lithuania 💀

neat widget
#

yeah

karmic bramble
#

thank you!

naive verge
#

my game crasher after i put time on max how to fix?

pallid iris
#

Where should the HCEG be placed?

glacial steeple
sand ember
#

The game would be better if all countries built dockyards instead of mils

naive verge
#

WHY DOES MY GAME CRASH AFTER I CHOOSE COUNTRY AND PLAY FOR LIKE 20SEC

glacial steeple
#

:(

#

crying rn

sand ember
#

Pick the sprit that reduces encirclement penalty

#

Everything will be ok

sinful vessel
frigid harness
#

huh

sinful vessel
#

there is a navy build guide

glacial steeple
frigid harness
#

or am I special

#

and its wrong

sinful vessel
glacial steeple
#

itll be like 800 less

frigid harness
glacial steeple
#

but secondary 2 is good yeah

#

itll always cost a bit but per attack its more cost effective

frigid harness
#

thanks

heavy fern
#

quick question should i use ranger or mountaineers for an elite attack infantry division?

hasty mist
#

Anyone know how I can fix my manpower problems?

bleak plinth
#

315k house is crazy though

frigid harness
#

bro its a hoi4 server

#

tf is going on

round night
#

Yo i started out as Lithuania got the king, then poland, livonia and russia and now i got 6million ground army all dying out of attrition while idle help

winged cape
#

i just instaled the game, how do i play?

hasty mist
#

Wait, you're serious?

boreal pecan
#

motorized divisions for SP?

winged cape
boreal pecan
neat widget
#

it seems like the game can be hard to learn, let them off

neat widget
boreal pecan
#

Shock troopers r good right

#

im running germany for context

#

prob some assault infantry build

winged cape
#

how can i start at the game?

heavy fern
#

there is one in the pinned messages

hazy root
#

What year is the best time to start making tanks? And is it a good idea to produce the very first medium tank in research, the 1938 model? Or is it better to wait until the 1940 model is studied?

sinful vessel
#

What's the best way to "block" Germany here ? I've just won early vs the allies.

quasi dagger
#

yo when does the winter war end?

glacial steeple
quasi dagger
glacial steeple
#

retreat and surrender or hold leningrad 30 days for a decision

quasi dagger
glacial steeple
quasi dagger
dusty sandal
glacial steeple
#

combine for best support company

dusty sandal
sinful vessel
#

So UK and France are conquered so i then will face Russia and USA. Do you know when USA could become a threat for the Duce ?

gusty briar
#

Is their any setting that ur task force repair priority automatically?

#

I keep having my sub fleets switch to never repair, and the really need to repair lol

sinful vessel
#

If i give convoy to a puppet to annex him, will i have my convoy back after the annexion ?

#

(Or any other material)

ivory wraith
#

how do I get more range for my ships? Im putting their hq port really close to these highlighted portion of ocean but its not letting them go and patrol in that zone

glacial steeple
ivory wraith
#

how can I see where my current hubs are?

#

and does underwater replenishment help with this?

glacial steeple
#

generally id say to not care about the pacific island war

#

theres no resources or population there, and its of little strategic value

neat widget
ivory wraith
#

how is this supply hub not enough to get them east

marble solstice
#

I need help...

ornate gazelle
ornate gazelle
glacial steeple
marble solstice
ornate gazelle
#

wats your law ?

#

mayby go one higher 🙂

marble solstice
#

extensive conscription

#

but I dont have enough to go higher rn

ornate gazelle
#

mayby stop pushing to norway

marble solstice
#

...

#

America is in Norawy and Swedene

#

Norway*

#

Sweden*

ornate gazelle
#

just fallback to Copenhagen

viscid abyss
#

Why do you have so few armies

ivory wraith
ornate gazelle
#

JUST SPAM MORE????

#

😂

viscid abyss
ornate gazelle
#

YEAH yeah

viscid abyss
#

Anyway is tanks the key to beating the ussr? Like 3 lines medium and 2 mechanised?

marble solstice
#

I only have like 110 hours

viscid abyss
#

The only reason I am beating it is because of my allies

viscid abyss
#

I got the game like 10 days ago 😂

marble solstice
#

I forgot to use Medium tanks 😭

marble solstice
ornate gazelle
#

i did a run with horses only and still beat them

glacial steeple
marble solstice
#

If I start over what should I do?

ivory wraith
#

I want longer ranged ships

#

I moved them over a little and got JUST enough

viscid abyss
marble solstice
#

fr

viscid abyss
#

And only my tanks can break through but it’s very slow and they never get far

#

I barely passed Minsk by winter

marble solstice
#

wait what difficulty should I do it on as a new-ish player

viscid abyss
#

But I don’t know what I do wrong

marble solstice
#

that game was on Regular

viscid abyss
#

I play on normal

marble solstice
#

Bonecrusher

viscid abyss
marble solstice
#

try to beat the allies?

viscid abyss
#

I have no idea how multiplayer works

marble solstice
#

just play with other ppl

#

its just like single player but with another player

viscid abyss
#

Wait so it doesn’t have to be against other people?

marble solstice
#

no

#

we could team up against the allies

viscid abyss
#

Oh cool

marble solstice
#

what country do u normally play?

viscid abyss
#

I have played like 3 games as Germany

#

And 1 as ussr

#

And 1 as Peru when I was figuring out how the game works

marble solstice
#

have u played italy?

viscid abyss
#

Never

marble solstice
#

We could do axis

viscid abyss
#

What countries do you like?

marble solstice
#

Germany is the only one ive played so far

#

And UK

#

I have an Idea

#

I could go facist Britan and join the axis

#

you be Germany

viscid abyss
#

Wouldn’t that make the game really unbalanced

marble solstice
#

it'd be fun if it succeeds

#

Should we?

viscid abyss
#

Sure we can try it

marble solstice
#

alr

#

ill dm you

viscid abyss
#

But historical is much more fun

marble solstice
#

it will still be historical everything but Ill go down the facist path

viscid abyss
#

How does multi player work with the game speed and do you have to play the whole thing without a break

#

Because rn every time I’m at war I’m pressing pause every 5 seconds 😂

analog maple
#

guys what the best template for iran?

sand ember
gusty briar
#

In the set up options, whats the difference between America deimperialised and America decolonized?

versed rose
stuck garnet
#

hey what kind of divisions should is end as vols

glacial steeple
versed rose
#

i still cant believe they made proper heritage gbp exclusive

#

haters

stuck garnet
#

hey when civs over mils in sp

trail rapids
#

Is there any way for you to increase a party pop

stuck garnet
#

uhh

#

focus tree

#

decisions tab

trail rapids
#

ok I'm playing route to 56 and France and I'm trying to rebuilt the French Empire but uhhhh I need a LOT more grey

nova gorge
#

quick dumb question would 30width beat 20with spam i ask since im fighting a person who does only 20width and i see guide that go 30-35 width

left glacier
#

20 width is usually typical for defensive infantry

glacial steeple
#

unless you wanna do a postwar build

left glacier
neat widget
nova gorge
pliant condor
#

it's not the correct way of thinking

pliant condor
glacial steeple
#

hiiii liv hiiii tails hii topazand

pliant condor
#

and more reinforce rate(obviously)

pliant condor
#

so if you just put your divisions on a front and want them to sit there and hold smaller ones are better

#

in terms of stats, the total stat you get has nothing to do with width

left glacier
pliant condor
#

but larger division always have an advantage in dealing/receiving damage due to targetting

#

and when you are attacking, org matters very little

#

so you just go for a large template

stuck garnet
#

how far behind does your technology have to be for planes/tanks for them to straight up not be worth building

nova gorge
pliant condor
#

any tank is worth building

#

just convert to a better gun

pliant condor
#

but it matters very little

#

compared to other stuff

nova gorge
# pliant condor but it matters very little

i figured i was just curious since he said anything over 20 is bad. this isa final question if you dont mind anwsering would mechanized be good agianst a naval invasion aka defending from one or is there something better?

versed rose
#

mech brick port guard lmao

glacial steeple
#

what context

nova gorge
pliant condor
#

mechanized is good, specifically when you last stand

pliant condor
glacial steeple
pliant condor
#

just make infantry brikcs

glacial steeple
#

the US is broke

pliant condor
#

also what the hell is usa vs japan

glacial steeple
#

its kinda common

#

its not too bad especially if bad japan

versed rose
#

how does Japan even get the range to go to US with new navy system

glacial steeple
#

if half decent japan theyll have a lot more MIC

glacial steeple
#

larp

pliant condor
#

ok i will annex half of the world as japan

nova gorge
#

mainly just us doing naval battle but i wanna guard my islands better

pliant condor
#

when usa is doing giant awakes

#

lol

glacial steeple
#

which is still not fair

#

but not as bad

versed rose
#

mech island garrison is crazy, you're overthinking that. Just do infantry bricks

pliant condor
versed rose
#

also that

glacial steeple
#

if you 1v1 naval war larp

nova gorge
# pliant condor then no

okay if thats the case may i ask why not mech? and what template would u suggest then for a guy who loves 20witdth

glacial steeple
#

look for islands that can have a level 8 port

#

protect/attack those

pliant condor
glacial steeple
#

ignore every other island

pliant condor
#

i won't garrison any island in the pacific

#

complete waste of ic

#

just garrison philipines

copper arrow
#

Japan white peace does not seem to work as communist china leading the united front. They released korea but we're still at war?

nova gorge
neat widget
pliant condor
neat widget
#

Imagine tiny little Japan outproducing the arsenal of democracy

#

Can the US survive?

pliant condor
#

more complicated answer is that you don't want to make mech in vanilla due to xp

versed rose
#

100 xp just to make mech real instead of an ic sink

#

yikes

pliant condor
#

and you need to do funny 100 gun convert

#

and another 150 xp for a template

neat widget
#

100gun convert?

#

Ah I see

nova gorge
edgy pendant
glacial steeple
#

earlier mils

#

but its not completely unfair ig if naval larp

#

still bad tho

versed rose
#

man US mils are so bad

#

too much effcap in newer dlcs

nova gorge
glacial steeple
edgy pendant
stuck garnet
#

why

glacial steeple
stuck garnet
#

for victory points

#

do i just no fighty

glacial steeple
#

free edit

#

otherwise just use largest available units

nova gorge
#

ah well good know. then could i ask for some help as complete newbie i wish to learn the tricks of the game and learn soi can properly beat him

edgy pendant
pliant condor
#

^

#

the most important thing on usa is if you can have enough war support when japan declares on china to get giant awakes

#

and do great depression focus whenever it becomes available

nova gorge
#

ahh i see i can use that but i mean a bit more of the combat units whats good whats not stuff like that since i tend to fail horribly at that part eco wise im pretty good just the fighting and learning proper counters not so much

pliant condor
#

it matters very little at the end of the day

#

idk what to tell you

#

there are correct answers just a bit hard to carry out in vanilla

nova gorge
stuck garnet
#

gonna mass produce this and then refit it later

pliant condor
#

that's what id say

#

i would rank the priority as having eco -> making air >> everything else

#

you can literally just use the starting infantry template and rush gun

#

probably win against most people

edgy pendant
pliant condor
#

the "meta" or whatever template is just pure mountaineer, but you need to exploit the special force cap in vanilla to have that

nova gorge
stuck garnet
#

it's 1936 mate

#

tke off engine and armor ticks?

glacial steeple
#

why not use howitzer and make it spg

stuck garnet
glacial steeple
stuck garnet
#

?

pliant condor
glacial steeple
#

youre france

stuck garnet
#

i do?

glacial steeple
#

yes

stuck garnet
#

damn

glacial steeple
#

in vanilla anyway

#

i assume in kr too

#

im pretty sure you do

stuck garnet
#

i have not enough exp

#

cause i don't know how to manage it lol

#

this would've been better spent rushing gbp but idc it's fine

glacial steeple
stuck garnet
#

do i like keep going or am i okie dokie

#

what

#

do i keep going or is this like

#

bad

#

minor mistake or am i cooked

pliant condor
#

if so probably just keep making the base

#

saves resources as well

#

convert later

edgy pendant
pliant condor
#

unless you need to use the tank now somehow

stuck garnet
#

i don't need to

pliant condor
#

yeah just make the base then

stuck garnet
#

i have my 6 lt divisions i start with

pliant condor
#

so you don't need to trade tungsten

#

also you have so many mils

glacial steeple
#

itll hurt

pliant condor
#

put more on tanks xd

glacial steeple
#

but prob be fine

stuck garnet
#

i took off the ticks so it's less

glacial steeple
stuck garnet
#

using calv divisions in combat yes it sucks as much as you think it is

#

i have no gaps in the frontline to exploit

#

ones a fort and the other's a mountain im cooked