ask-for-help-here

[misty wagon]

ashould i do this

should i brign back my fighters then and bring CAS

[sinful vessel]

I think things are not desperate. Send more troop to your south front. You can send your troops settled in Italy. I don't know when, but the Aoussa Emirate will surrender, giving you a supply hub.

[viscid abyss]

I have naval dominance so why can’t I send my troops overseas

[misty wagon]

im gonna bring tac bombers now

[viscid abyss]

They are stationed in a port

[sinful vessel]

Have you waited the 50 days ?

[viscid abyss]

Huh?

[lost niche]

ok ok

how do i make them take the boat ?

[sinful vessel]

just select troop and right click to the choosen army. They will do the move by themselve.

[viscid abyss]

That’s a thing?

Why does the game not mention it 🥀

[sinful vessel]

My general have waited more then 50 days, so its 'gauge" is full. Yours should be mainly red

[viscid abyss]

Nah I don’t even have that thing

Oh wait

[sinful vessel]

you have these ?

[viscid abyss]

Naval invasion order

I see it thanks

The last time I tried it I couldn’t get it to work so just used paratroopers, didn’t notice the naval invasion button

[sinful vessel]

you should see how many divisions are affected

[viscid abyss]

Is there a reason why it’s a specific number

Due to the number of convoys?

[misty wagon]

how do i get rid of thjis stupid dvision thing i made

[sinful vessel]

6 divisions max per invasion (at the start of the game at least)

[viscid abyss]

Ah

Its may 1940 already and now im waiting 50 days to invade Norway

Should I just ignore it and invade France

[sinful vessel]

You mean the "little" division ? just send it back to Germany and take a bigger one ?

[viscid abyss]

Or does it not really matter

I may aswell wait

[misty wagon]

can i just remove it

delete it

[sinful vessel]

You may be abble to do both. Benelux and France should be fast with a good offensive army

[sinful vessel]

you should have a red cross somewhere

[viscid abyss]

I suppose

But I moved my tanks mainly to Denmark in order to invade Norway

[misty wagon]

what did i gain from this

[misty wagon]

ty

[neat widget]

assault engineers

[sinful vessel]

I've never invaded Norway with tanks, but i'm not an experienced player. If you just run a "chill" game, i'd say try whatever you like. It's probably suboptimal to wait too much for France, but shouldn't ruin your game.

[neat widget]

very good support company

helps deal with all the forts around you

but does well against other terrain types too

[static turret]

chat someone gimme cavalry template

[neat widget]

9/0 with aa and artillery or 18/0 with medium flame, assault engineers, light tank recon, artillery, and hospitals

[static turret]

what ab company

[sinful vessel]

To design CAS, should i go full bomb or stay with some guns ?

[neat widget]

guns as in anti-tank cannons or guns as in fighter armaments

[sinful vessel]

i'm early so i've bomb or fighter guns

[neat widget]

anti-tank guns on CAS aren't particularly more useful than bombs

but for the fighter guns question cas-navs do exist and you can try running bombs as main armament + hmgs as secondary

[misty wagon]

huh

hopw do i make them

[sinful vessel]

So smthing like that make sense ?

[misty wagon]

also im cooking in spain i did a focus tree thing and now can send 2 more volunteerrs

[neat widget]

Yes

[hexed parcel]

So - I'm albania. Germany attacked Italy on my behalf as I joined the axis. What do now?

[misty wagon]

sghould i befriend japan

[rain bluff]

Im at war with sweden but it wont let me invade because apparantly it's polish land and therefore I can't step foot in it. Any advice or console commands I can use?

[neat widget]

lmao attack modifiers for aura

but idk what's happening here tbh

maybe if you're a democracy

[misty wagon]

how do i set up those anchuss divisions u said

im a bit busy in spain tho

[rain bluff]

Fascist

[neat widget]

Huh then you should be able to walk in

[rain bluff]

And whys that happening

[neat widget]

also clearly you can walk into the rest of poland so idk

[rain bluff]

Yeah idk

[neat widget]

also rugen

is controlled by the british for some reason

[rain bluff]

Interesting game if yotu cant tell

[rain bluff]

Why am I getting no divisions on that naval invasion aswell??

Oh max supplied divisions 0

how do i fix that then

[neat widget]

go to the top left near the date, open up the naval tab

(i believe it is the middle, might be the right one)

Show me what shows up there

[rain bluff]

This?

[neat widget]

no these thingies

[rain bluff]

Oops

Huh

Love this game

[trail rapids]

playing a new game with Road to 56, what nation should I play?

[neat widget]

Yeah that's what I was thinking

Do you have another naval invasion set up

[rain bluff]

Probably one of my 500 mods

[rain bluff]

Absolutely not

[neat widget]

This is not a mod btw

You can send 2 orders of 6 divisions each

[misty wagon]

im doing good i think

[rain bluff]

Yeah thats why im confused why it wont let me naval invade at all

does it havbe to be off my land or?

[misty wagon]

@neat widget should i be invested in this war as much as i am?

[neat widget]

i mean it's nice, but make sure not to ignore other things

[neat widget]

Ah I see

[marsh trench]

Why are my ships staying docked instead of going to patrol the sea assigned to them?

[neat widget]

You have those sea lanes blocked off

[misty wagon]

what focus do i do rn

[neat widget]

Supply base might be too far away

[rain bluff]

Ohhhh whys that

[misty wagon]

do i gain anything from this war

[sinful vessel]

experience

[neat widget]

some xp, a potentially friendly spain, grinding in spain can be useful

[sinful vessel]

i've learnt that a well trained general in spain could help a lot later.

[misty wagon]

how does this production look

[misty wagon]

war taking ages

[rain bluff]

How do i fix that

[sinful vessel]

Yes. But that's what i like ^^.

[neat widget]

click on sea zone, there will be a popup in the lower left with allow, avoid, and block options

select allow or avoid

[misty wagon]

are these recruitments good guys?

@neat widget

[neat widget]

The Add Unit button puts them all under one header, so there's that

and it seems like there's not enough equipment for whatever reason

[misty wagon]

how do i fix that

[rain bluff]

Brah

[misty wagon]

ill fix it tommorow nvm

[neat widget]

oh

Maybe you have to push the Swedes from the Kiel canal or something

the new naval logistics system is weird

[neat widget]

also your fleet is being supplied from Ceuta

and with the swedes blocking the kiel canal and the danish belts no supply can get through into the baltic

change that to Rostock

[rain bluff]

Ohhh thank you so much

[vale basin]

Do I need generals or do they just give buffs?

[torn thorn]

does anyone know how to do well in peace conferences. I have like 80% of the war score, but somehow my ally which is an AI always contests me on the land, and ends up going many rounds until I run out of points. And then when the peace conference is over I end up with very little, and the ai ally, which had much less war score than me, somehow gets the majority of the land.

[pliant condor]

try to not have allies

[hushed bay]

how do you make a space marine division

[carmine scarab]

tank in infantry division

[hushed bay]

yeh i got 17 armour

[carmine scarab]

ok

[hushed bay]

well isnt it meant to be like 50

[carmine scarab]

yea

prob just make tank with more armor

[torn thorn]

But I want to be at least somewhat historical. So as Germany, would it be better not to have Italy join in the battle of France but rather have it join the war right before operation sea lion commences

[fading fern]

How do I do the collaboration government mission to increase compliance?

It says I need an intel network, but I can't do that on my territory

[tame igloo]

I litterally just bought the game and I was wondering if anyone could guide me

[fading fern]

With the add unit button you can train multiple units in parallel. So you'd just need one infantry line but with multiple units.

I haven't played Germany yet, only Italy, but you probably should train a lot more units in parallel (like 20-30? I do 12 or 24 with Italy). If your units are ready earlier, that means more time to exercise and reach lvl 3 before war.

No idea about the unit composition since I only used Infantry with Arty so far because Italy industrial base is shit

[pliant condor]

you do it on other nations that you have not conquered

not on your own territory

although there is a way for it to work on your own territory

[fading fern]

Which way? I need something to get compliance up faster. Right now the only thing I do is to use the resistance suppression op with spies and change to civilian oversight at 0 resistance

[iron harness]

what does equipment conversion exactly do? i never do the research because it seems a waste of a research slot but it may be important

i tried doing the research and converting my equipments but it shows i won't be producing any equipment of that category because I'm not consuming resources, i am confuse lol

[ionic ferry]

the hell happened with the navy did they change how it works completely??

[pliant condor]

when you capitulate a nation with a tag that cores your territory

e.g. when you cap china with full collab, you get the compliance on taiwan as well as japan

[pliant condor]

it reduces the overhead cost of converting stuff

you need to pay 90% of the chassis cost without any conversion tech and each one lowers it by 40%

[pliant condor]

you are

[iron harness]

then why does it look like this? when converting it shows you don't consume resources

i took that image from google since I'm on bed

[pliant condor]

yes

this is exactly why you convert

it saves resources

in fact this is an established method

due to paradox funny math

the resource cost per factory of converting is the difference in resource cost between the base and the final design

[sacred ginkgo]

is there going to be a new guide for the doctrines?

[iron harness]

ohh, i don't get why it won't consume resources because aren't you basically upgrading your existing equipment?

[sacred ginkgo]

It feels a little confusing now, or perhaps i have been too used to the old trees

[pliant condor]

yes, also doesn't make sense to me

it's just that paradox don't understand basic math

that they tie resource cost to factory, not IC

[pliant condor]

this

^

[iron harness]

haha thanks i get it now

sounds like an exploit or is it? lol

[pliant condor]

it is

or well it's part of vanilla

that counteracts with the crazy resource costs of stuff

[iron harness]

i hope pdx fix this, i didn't want to do it because it didn't make sense and now i don't want to do it because it's apparently an exploit

thanks you're a great help !

[pliant condor]

there has been a forum post about it a while back

but it's a good feature

to counteract how bad vanilla is designed

the fact that paradox didn't place enough resources in the whole world to make producing meaningful amount of anything impossible without constant conversion

it's like coal

paradox cannot comprehend how players can get massive industry

[fading fern]

So I have to build collaboration government while still fighting? Is there anything else I can do after annexation except rooting out the resistance?

[pliant condor]

no

you don't want to annex stuff without collab

plan ahead

or you can build before you fight

[twilit canopy]

If nation A uses a decision cores all the states of nation B, but nation B is a formable created by a decision after conquering nation C, does nation A get cores on nation C

Basically I’m seeing if I can get the Federation of Malayan Peoples/Association of South East Asian Nations that the Philippines can form to get cores on Papua New Guinea which the greater Indonesian confederacy formable can core

[fading fern]

Interesting. Do I need an intel network in every country to create the collaboration government? The spy agency stuff is completely new to me

[wintry matrix]

You need 50% network strength in the target nation to commit the collab mission, ye.

And two operators.

[tame igloo]

Could anyone help me learn the game I am new and would like some help the youtube videos arent helping a whole lot

[rapid urchin]

does anyone have a good hoi4 production calculator i could use?

to calculate how much mils i should have for each of my equipment needs

[carmine scarab]

just use excel bro

[wet topaz]

👁️

[pliant condor]

i do but not too hard to make one

just put in ic amount of equipment and their product then normalize the sum to 1

[rapid urchin]

can you send me it?

[final terrace]

Is there a console command to give country leaders traits?

[stuck garnet]

honestly i hope line arty is viable one day

[covert thicket]

genuinely what am i supposed to do

[clear echo]

how can i make france like me?

[sand ember]

maybe post another incomprehensible screenshot and ask a vague question

[copper arrow]

Is the China Japan peace event broken? I'm play as the communists, pushed Japan out, they release Korea but we're still at war?

[hollow eagle]

how to uncapitulate

[copper arrow]

take back enough of your land

[full nest]

guys

I need help fixing this bug

It pauses automatically at 2 PM each day

for some reason

it does it on its own

[sour wadi]

guys, i prolly gonna need some advice

[serene karma]

lmao

[sour wadi]

im playing historically, iron man, mapuche

somehow ive taken the america's without doing unified by will

however

wtf am i ment to do </3

[full nest]

…oh come on-

Does no one else have that bug…

[sour wadi]

my navy consists of the base south american navy, and a shit ton of fleet subs

[plush dagger]

Tell me there’s a way to automatically move aircraft into carriers

Without doing it manually

[sour wadi]

if i create a collab government in america, will i be able to do this decision?

[wild rune]

yes but i mean how much do you not have controlled rn

[sour wadi]

literally just alaska and hawaii, and some basic islands

[plush dagger]

How does the escort thing work..?

I’m stuck at 99% and can’t move troops out of the U.S.

[sour wadi]

wait

if i have max collab on the US

should i even do the decision

cuz then ill get less mp and industry, right?

[serene karma]

What bug

[full nest]

Game pauses on its own

like I dont hit the space key and it still pauses on its own

[sour wadi]

huh

sounds new to me

[full nest]

It started happening for no reason

[neat widget]

are you still in range of airbases

if so you can get some transport planes

[sour wadi]

i think i have to legit beat the US, like get the

war ended screen

idk what its called

[neat widget]

sounds like a mapuche chile playthrough

[sour wadi]

it is

cuz mexico doesnt exist anywhere, but i cant make a native government outta em

ima basically have to make an OP navy from scratch

with 3 research slots </3

[neat widget]

yep

rip

[sour wadi]

only navy i have that isnt bad is my max fleet subs </3

however against the british idk how effective they will be

[full nest]

@serene karma u there??

[cedar sky]

anybody know any youtube guides for Left Kuomintang China?

[narrow grail]

Yes but lowkey I don't think it's much worth at the point of having the rest of America puppeted, it will take too long time just to get USA cored, so I'd personally won't spend much time, you can try ofc

[sour wadi]

ehh i tried in a copy save

and it didnt work

[narrow grail]

reorganizing collab didn't work?

[gusty briar]

For motorized divisions im used to hold the line for my offensive spg, is it worth it to add logistics support? Or should I just do aa arti and engi?

[sour wadi]

the decision to make an indigenous puppet didnt work

even with the collab

whats a good screening ship?

[narrow grail]

I think light cruisers are still good

[sour wadi]

do early cruisers work?

[zenith thunder]

i finally managed to complete the german civil war but i completed in october 1040, did i take a long time iyo to do it

this is my first time to try and seriously play the game

[glacial steeple]

hi chat

[sour wadi]

ello

[narrow grail]

Why Argentina doesn't get annexed with last mapuche Chile focus in political branch?

And hello

[sour wadi]

you have to fight w argentina

you get a few cores on southern argentina, and a focus that puts you at war with argentina with a few buggs

[narrow grail]

I know it but like

You can core all of America but not the rest of Argentina 🤣

[sour wadi]

i think u can core the rest of argentina with the focus unified by will

atleast, id assume so

[narrow grail]

It's the focus I meant

I finish this focus, all puppets are annexed except Argentina

[sour wadi]

huh

weird

[sour wadi]

how did you finish off the allies?

[narrow grail]

I took the focus without reorganizing USA and Canada

[sour wadi]

oh

rip

[narrow grail]

At that point I simply got no building slots left in Chile itself

[sour wadi]

i own all the america's except for a few islands, but mexico n all that are in the allies, so i cant reorganize them

im just lucky i have max compliance

i got mp, industry, everything. the only thing im lacking is naval

[narrow grail]

I toon Mexico and somehow it didn't join the allies

[sour wadi]

lucky bastard </3

[narrow grail]

Many peace deals were generating negative world tension

With last dlc world tension seems to be reduced

[sour wadi]

i had to kill the US and canada with just my base mp alone </3

and mexico

[severe ledge]

how do i supply my units during battle

[narrow grail]

Or you can just invade Mexico first right after declaring crusade against imperialism. Ask for docking rights Guatemala or Nicaragua, it should provide enough range for naval invasion.

[sour wadi]

well i didnt know that

so i just fought mexico, US, canada, UK, all of em

and now china and japan cuz they joined the allies

[narrow grail]

To be fair you just better roll up slowly. Brazil has so much more population and rubber

[sour wadi]

i already did it

ive taken all the america's. i just cant end the war cuz of navy

[narrow grail]

Does uk still have oil?

[sour wadi]

i think, its basically the whole world against me and the soviets

and the soviets aint doing too well

[glacial steeple]

you cant restrenghten them while in combat/combat reserves

[narrow grail]

Well, then naval bombers

[sour wadi]

bruh the only airforce i researched for chile was fighters </3

i have 3 research slots

[glacial steeple]

license

change role

[sour wadi]

license from who? the whole world hates me </3

[glacial steeple]

now you have air tech wooo

[glacial steeple]

anyone

germany, ussr, japan, ideally uk

new zealand australia india

sweden idk

[sour wadi]

im at war with all of em

everyone

pretty much everyone joined the allies

EVEN TEH SWISS

OML

my subs are doing good work in all fairnes

[zenith thunder]

i finally managed to complete the german civil war but i completed in october 1040, did i take a long time iyo to do it
this is my first time to try and seriously play the game can anyone give me some tips on how to do it in a reasonable amount of time instead

all i know how to do i set a front line and then draw offensive lines and let my troops advance for the most part

[plush dagger]

If I attach an air wing to a unit, will they get air support?

[sour wadi]

how many spotting cruisers should i have in a single fleet?

[glacial steeple]

can i see?

[glacial steeple]

ohh youre fine

just get air tech from ussr

[sour wadi]

my main issue is navy

im having to make a navy from scratch

[glacial steeple]

cape verde is reachable with paratroopers

[sour wadi]

i own the azores

[glacial steeple]

okay?

how does that matter if you cant send units over

with cape verde you can

you can also create a puppet on the other side

either through peacedeal or giving a state to a capped puppet

[sour wadi]

wym? i can send troops over

[glacial steeple]

and then recruit divs from puppet manpower > turn into own

[sour wadi]

im boutta also capture iceland, to jump off to scotland

iceland taken

[tiny bough]

Do submarines that are spotted by patrol ships keep revealed during a battle or does the quick response strike force needs its own spotting average to keep engaging them?

[pliant condor]

they are initially revealed for 20 hours

then it use the normal mechanic of spotting

[tiny bough]

hmm

[pliant condor]

which against the ai they would always retreat

so you reengage them

patrol kill subs at a very high rate due to that

[tiny bough]

so depending how close/fast the response fleet is, I may not necessarily need any spotting on the strike force

[pliant condor]

no

it doesn't have anything to do with speed

they are revealed for 20 hours once they are engaged

[pliant condor]

and yes

you don't need any sub detection

on your destroyers

[tiny bough]

interesting

Thanks

[pliant condor]

in the new version escort seems to also work fine

since they tried so hard to buff destroyers

[sour wadi]

anyone got a good battleship design?

im on advanced </3

[pliant condor]

that's not good

means it's too late

[tiny bough]

lol

[sour wadi]

mate im in 1950 and im bloody mapuche chile

it was either late or never

[pliant condor]

but just use the highest armor(super heavy armor if you have it), 2 best gun, and fill the rest with dual purpose 3

oh if you have dual purpose 3 use that

also it's just generally not the best idea to build battleships

depending on how much of a fleet you already have

[sour wadi]

ive got none except for a bunch of subs

[pliant condor]

ok then definitely should not be building battleships

build the best light cruiser you have

is steel an issue?

[sour wadi]

chromium is

[sour wadi]

then how am i ment to get naval superiorty?

ive secured the america's

[pliant condor]

by building a navy that can kill enemy navy

which doesn't start with cruiser

[pliant condor]

do you not have cuba

[sour wadi]

i have 140 dockyards

[pliant condor]

ok then build whatever you like lol

just fill it with the best armor and with guns/secondary

[sour wadi]

i could take cuba

[pliant condor]

good news is that ai will keep building trash ships even into the 50s

so you have plenty of time

all you need to build is light cruiser and battleship

[sour wadi]

good

exactly what im making

[pliant condor]

you could have gotten shbb if you had naval facility

[sour wadi]

im making shbbs

got fleet subs, making shbb

[pliant condor]

yeah it's the best ship

you don't want too many battery on it

2 is enough

or at most 3

fill up the rest with secondary guns

they have great value for those

[sour wadi]

i assummme modern battleships aint worth it

CUBA WAS HELPING THE ALLIES

nah bro u dead

ill teach u not to give docking rights to my enemys

[pliant condor]

worse than shbb

[sour wadi]

u think iceland is a good enough naval base?

[neat widget]

Fortress Iceland

Soviets are never taking the island

[sour wadi]

i dont think the soviets are gonna be doing much at all

and the soviets are gone

its just me

chile vs the world

WHY DOES CHINA OWN HUNGARY

what is this bro </3

[young wyvern]

where is the button to micromanage ? ⁉️ one of my mod deleted the button :(

[pliant condor]

actually

you don't need to build so many high level naval base

just do 1 and connect the rest with it

then they give equal supply

[sour wadi]

i ment it as a joke. i had way to much industry ,/3

suffering from success

[thin zealot]

Auschina-hungary

[sour wadi]

that single statement, gave me more pain this this entire playthrough

[sour wadi]

ayo

would 4 super heavy battleships work?

[neat widget]

czechoslovakia but it's just slovakia

[sour wadi]

this world is cursed

hoi4 gets weird when chile takes over all of the americas and its 1954

APPARRENTLYY

for SOME REASON

"hmm yes"

we should make a provisional government of island

what island*?

we dont know

[neat widget]

island as in iceland

[sour wadi]

ik

[neat widget]

but yeah, it's funny

[sour wadi]

HAHA

i halfed the british fleet

we are so back lads

whats the best cas design

for like, the max airframe

[harsh sierra]

heavy bomb, armor plates; self sealing tanks, dives brakes, defence turret and no mg or cannon

[zenith sphinx]

where my achiement

[languid trout]

u need to have them in the peace deal

thats what it takes for it to count

[zenith sphinx]

that is not ,,capitulate,,

[fading fern]

Bottom right is a button to see your worldwide supply. If it is too low, either click the nearest hub for upgrading the rails leading to it, or build a new supply hub.

Naval bases are the cheapest supply hub.

[sour wadi]

is there a way to select every railway gun?

like how u can select every unassigned unit

cuz i have about 50 railway guns unassigned scattered around in unknown areas

[calm wigeon]

This is literally the hardest game ever….. 🫣

[fading fern]

That's why we love it

[hollow linden]

Don't confuse hard with complicated

The inputs by themselves aren't, it's just complicated. And sometimes not even

It just takes time

[calm wigeon]

I won’t lie man. I’m really interested in the game. I’ve just got zero idea where to go after completing one step. Watching beginners guides like hell, lol

[sour wadi]

i can help you if u need

feel free to give me a msg whenever ya want. the game is super annoying to get ya grasp on, but its easier when ya got someone there to guide ya

[glass aurora]

anyone has a good video on yt or any type of good tutorial for hoi4 i can’t even beat Ethiopia as Italy😭

[hollow linden]

Bittersteel has a good beginner guide for Germany from this year

https://youtu.be/LbpWbSD6hEY?si=CK-qdiStOXChiHUJ

[glass aurora]

is Germany a beginner friendly ????

[hollow linden]

It's pretty easy so yea

Just play the most broken nation in the game

[calm wigeon]

I’m trying to play as the U.S. and I’m 😵‍💫

[glass aurora]

thanks🙏

[hollow linden]

US is sleep sim

The Congress mechanic can be confusing

[sour wadi]

dont you just LOVE mega factions

gee, i love having 500k divisions at my border

[young wyvern]

US is "nothing ever happens simulator" until the end of the war 🙏 boring nation without mods

(but US strat bomber is pretty fun)

[devout ocean]

Germany is quite op, tank buffs, infantry buffs and strong MIOs.

So yeah its pretty fun to play as.

And strong national focuses.

[devout ocean]

Man.. how is the world map looking?

[sour wadi]

i own all the americas

mapuche path

[devout ocean]

How...

[sour wadi]

and this is the rest

[sour wadi]

its 1955

i started as chile, and i had to kill america </3

[devout ocean]

I mean destroying the US.

I struggle at that.

[sour wadi]

it was so, so hard

i had to micro every little movement

[devout ocean]

Nice.

[sour wadi]

i only really used mountaineers to kill off america

3 stacks of 24

the worst part was making a navy

im somehow holding in france

[hexed parcel]

Does anyone have any advice for Albania post-italy defeat? Invade Yugoslavia? Greece?

[wide ether]

invade yugo im pretty sure you could get a core on macedonia

[hexed parcel]

You mean eastern Illyria of course. What about Kosovë?

[wide ether]

idk probably

are there any formables you could do?

[hexed parcel]

Well changing to fascist led me to greater Albania.. but I don't feel great at the moment haha

So country name changed but no map changes yet

[covert thicket]

im boutta js give up atp

[empty latch]

Im looking to play my first ever multiplayer game this weekend, are there any kaiserreich games going on?

[misty wagon]

wait so like just press add unit like 20 times?

[glacial steeple]

ill dm you the weekly kr server

[young wyvern]

guyss fast

air recon

what template to use

i want max intel on my ennemies

nevermind found one

[sleek falcon]

Hello! Trying to get into the game, playing as Italy

The campaign for Ethiopia has given me two major issues, aside from some of my armies simply opting to not advance to the offensive line.

One: constant supply shortages. I have no clue how to get supplies to the frontline troops, as it seems supply hubs take several years to build and my troops are starved and short on resources

[analog maple]

is it possible to paratrooper snipe italy?

[sleek falcon]

Two: rebellion keeps brewing in the areas ive occupied and I have no idea how the garrison system works. A bunch of stuff tells me I need horses to uphold garrisons, but I have no idea what a garrison is or how to get horses to the Ethiopian one

[frigid harness]

how can I win against allies?

[warm garnet]

I'm attemping a battle of the buldge but i don't have any fuel or manpower, the fuel i can kinda manage but the manpower is really bad what can i do apart from scraping the barrel because im already having loads of equipment issues?

Also is there anything you can do with leftover army xp?

[fading fern]

Yup. That way you have pipelines for certain divisions who train in parallel. There's no disadvantage as long as you can supply the minimum equipment to keep them training instead of waiting

[scenic nacelle]

Officer corps

[fading fern]

Send all your divisions from italy to Ethiopia. Mountaineers and 2 inf to north, rest south. Ideally do this manually (send troops to nearest harbor then to ethiopia) because the AI will let your troops wander through italy instead of boarding from next harbor.

Put both armies with commanders in an army group to get field marshal bonus.

Send 200 planes to south Ethiopia, rest to north. Attach the planes to the respective generals.

Draw each battle plan to addis abeba. Change to aggressive execution.

While conquering build a railway to addis abbeba or the supply hub east of it. Depending on what you reach faster. Don't forget to put the railway into your top building slot, otherwise nothing happens.

Click execute plans and watch Ethiopia crumble under Italian boots

[scenic nacelle]

I would say delete some of your army

Stop garrisoning

Uhhh

[sleek falcon]

I have no idea how to do half of these things

[frigid harness]

sos

[sleek falcon]

For one, ALL my troops? SHOULDNT I have some at home for defense?

[scenic nacelle]

What are u defending from

At home

[sleek falcon]

Also, what is an army group? I thought you could only organize divisions into armies

[rain iris]

Does anybody think this is still possible? i am fighting against ussr but germany is losing on all fronts and i don't have enough divisions for the whole ussr.

[sleek falcon]

The threat of invasion

[scenic nacelle]

No one will invade u for 4-ish years dw

[sleek falcon]

You can attach planes to armies?

[scenic nacelle]

Pull back

[frigid harness]

yes

[fading fern]

Garrisons are troops that pacify your conquered lands. You don't see them as they exist in the background.

You can increase their priority in the deployment window. Adding a military police support to the cavalry helps them with resistance suppression.

[sleek falcon]

Battle plan is a line. How do I draw a line in one place

[rain iris]

where to?

[scenic nacelle]

Try ur best to keep Leningrad though

[sleek falcon]

Railways I can kinda understand, it's like building infrastructure, right?

[scenic nacelle]

Any good supply hubs or defensive terrain

Try not to make a bulge in the frontlines if ur defending

[frigid harness]

how can I win against allies, do I just wait and research the tanks or what do i do

[scenic nacelle]

Tanks will save u

[fading fern]

If you specify what exactly, I could explain more detailed

[frigid harness]

and what about inf

cant i do it only with it

[sleek falcon]

I just did

[frigid harness]

thats what im using

[fading fern]

You have peace with everybody except Ethiopia. It is safe

[scenic nacelle]

Take the line artillery off

Use infantry for defence

Tanks for offense

[frigid harness]

its a single player tho xd

[sleek falcon]

I mean UEAH but what if they declare war? Nothing's stopping France from deciding they don't like me

[scenic nacelle]

Principle is still the same

[frigid harness]

what width should i use

[fading fern]

If you click an army, theres an empty portrait left of it in bottom center. Right click it with your army selected and it gets attached to an army group or forms it if not existent before

[sleek falcon]

The big plus? I thought that was for making armies

[fading fern]

Yes, select the wing or wing group and then there's a little plus icon over your armies

[frigid harness]

?

[scenic nacelle]

Smth like 16-20 for inf

[scenic nacelle]

Replace the support arty with field hospitals

It’s way better in the long run

[frigid harness]

for inf also

?

[fading fern]

If you're playing tutorial, the game should explain how to draw your first battle plan

[sleek falcon]

Last time I played the tutorial it didn't explain anything, just told me "do this" without any explanation as to why

[scenic nacelle]

Hm

Replace inf recon with hospitals

[fading fern]

Railways connect supply hubs/naval bases. Everything needs a connection to your capital, either via land or sea. By connecting a captured Ethiopian supply hub via rail you make it usable for your troops. Otherwise it's useless

[scenic nacelle]

And maybe replace tank recon with rangers

[sleek falcon]

Ok but as far as I've pushed I've seen no supply hubs

So unless I'm blind there's just the one in Abyssinia

[lunar spoke]

helo

i hv visual bug where i cant see my fronline

how fix

[fading fern]

In this game countries need a justified wargoal. Nobody has that vs you in 1936

[sleek falcon]

Oooooooh

Ok then yeah I guess my Civ experience is going out the window

Cause I'm used to people declaring war on me because I looked at them weird

[fading fern]

The portrait on the right of your generals is for making new armies. On the left is to form an army group from armies

[sleek falcon]

...I've been forming army groups this entire time

Ok I guess I'm starting over when I get back to my PC

[fading fern]

Yea it's indeed shit. A battle plan is made by first creating a frontline. Then you select draw offensive line and rightclick drag from your frontline to where you want to go

[fading fern]

On the bottom right you can select a supply view. It will show you hubs and railways

[sleek falcon]

Oh you're supposed to right click and drag? I've just been drawing front and offensive lines then clicking the little check mark over the "army"

[sleek falcon]

I'll check that when I get back home cause I swear I haven't seen any supply hubs inside of Ethiopia yet

[fading fern]

I know that. In civ it's mostly when your military is less than 50% of the ais. Then you're food

[fading fern]

Yup. Maybe you find a short yt vid that probably explains it visually

[sleek falcon]

I did

That's how I understood to do frontlines and all that

They never mentioned dragging my troops after I've drawn the offensive and front lines

[rustic acorn]

frontline leftclick means all selected border

[sleek falcon]

Well yeah

Is that not good?

[rustic acorn]

click right and drag for a certain part of that frontline

[sleek falcon]

Imma have to start writing this down lol

Appreciate all the help

However, what should I do with the resistance?

[rustic acorn]

supress 🙂

[sleek falcon]

What button is that

[rustic acorn]

create a guard unit with military police

like an inf unit

under your flag in the upper left side you can manage your subjects

there you can choose which unit guards

also you can choose what level of supression you want

[sleek falcon]

Then just put that template in production and mail it to Ethiopia?

[rain iris]

I did fall back, but what to do now? germany will capitulate and then I will have 1 vs 4 divisions or something.

[rustic acorn]

ah oh you mean that focus thing, thats more complicated

[fading fern]

If you select your country in top left you can go to occupied territory (below Mussolinis portrait) and there you can select occupation laws.

[fading fern]

The default template is cavalry, which is ideal. So just research military police and attach it to the cavalry template for bonus suppression.

[winged panther]

for ethiopia, its prettu hard usually

[fading fern]

You don't have to produce garrison troops. It happens automatically as long as you have the equipment

[winged panther]

u can release that entire area as a puppet

italian east africa

so you dont have to worry about it anymore

[fading fern]

Yea, that also secures 5 rubber if you add the resource option to the puppet at the peace conference

[winged panther]

no i dont mean that

[fading fern]

Otherwise the amount of rubber you get is dependent on compliance/resistance

[winged panther]

i mean

not only ethiopia as a puppet

[rustic acorn]

I think he talk about that focus story, where you need to get some suppression goals

[winged panther]

???

[rustic acorn]

you need to get control very quick, didnt try it myself

[winged panther]

what focus story

[rustic acorn]

after you conquered ethopia with Italy you still need to fulfill some goals concerning the supression and stuff

not focus, I am wrong

[winged panther]

yeah

you dont need to complete that

if you click the event

establish africane orientale italienne or sum shi like thast

[edgy mesa]

generally how does war work in this game i made the italian republic and thought i made pretty good preperations buuut i lost aswell as when i did it on germany like make a democratic rebellion also just in generel attacking countries i have it hard just taking ethiopa

[glass aurora]

how does trade work? i dont understand it

[winged panther]

if its ur first time, itll be fine in a while

id suggest watch tutorials

on yt

[winged panther]

There are certain resources in this game

which can be extracted

you need these resources to produce guns, planes, ships and other stuff

if u dont have it

u can trade 8 units of a material for 1 civilian factory

with any country

[fading fern]

How do you do that? I got an Ethiopia only puppet and I don't like it

[gritty valve]

anyone know how to fix this in the mod

[glass aurora]

ok now i building civilian factory and when they done i can use them to extract the recourses i need?

[manic radish]

are frontlines bugged?

[glacial steeple]

click to trade

[rustic acorn]

you can trade that one building capacity into 8 of any other recourses

via trade

you can not build any building for rasing res, but you can forge some excarvation techs to improve

only building rasing is a refinery, gives you oil and gum

the amount depends on what you have researched in that field

[winged panther]

no see, each state has its own preset amount of resources it can extract

for example south east easia has a lot of rubber

[rustic acorn]

right

you can imp that by building infrastructure

[winged panther]

if u want to increase the number of that resource produced in ur own state, add infrastructure to it

yeah

but u cant create resources out of nothing

[rustic acorn]

nope, not in general

only building is refinrey

[winged panther]

yeahh

for fuel and rubber

[rustic acorn]

doesnt add it on map, but in production

oil and rubber

and in that way fuel

but you can not add anything else

no coal or steel or oro ro

[sinful vessel]

Are there "go to" medals to give ? I"m thinking about the -10% supply or +5 % attack

[glacial steeple]

chatheads

[empty latch]

Im looking to play my first ever multiplayer game this weekend, are there any kaiserreich games going on?

[glacial steeple]

i dmed you the kr mp server :>

[wheat talon]

Why I can't as the PHI invite Chile in my hispanic faction?

[glacial steeple]

maybe they went the french guy path? idk

[stark bough]

Medium howitzer is good to a medium tank?

I don't play multiplayer. I heard that when playing with AI, the most important thing for a tank is light attack. With a medium howitzer, my light attack is 45.

[summer nymph]

I haven’t seen chile as an option in the decision UI in any of my PHI historical runs, they aren’t an Hispanic nation apparently.

Chile and Brazil are never an option

[stark bough]

When I order my tactical bombers to bomb an area, the mission efficiency always remains at 0%, as if it never happened. What do I do?

[spark swallow]

Elaborate what you mean by “bomb an area”

Which order are you using specifically

[digital gyro]

whats a really good divison design for paratroopers against the uk?

im playing napoleon france

[glacial steeple]

this is fine

tho id do paralight recon or rangers

and smaller width

like 32

[spiral crag]

should i keep it like this or change the last two tanks with light or medium AA tank

[cold dawn]

hello guys can someone help me with install czech to hoi4

[stark bough]

Strategic bombing

[hollow linden]

There sadly is no czech Localisation for hoi4

[glacial steeple]

they added korean tho

[hollow monolith]

I've got a bit of a problem, I sent 3 panzer divisions to nationalist Spain during the civil war, now it's over and they won't return for some reason

[hollow linden]

Wait 2 weeks

[hollow monolith]

It's been 6 months

[hollow linden]

did they die?

[hollow monolith]

Nope, still alive, thought I could use them to attack France from the south but they couldn't enter the province anyways

Even with the war going on

[hollow linden]

Did u send them as volunteers?

[hollow monolith]

Yes

[hollow linden]

Do they still exist?

Like are they still in spain

[hollow monolith]

Yes

[hollow linden]

Then move them out?

Thats very weird

Manually move them

[hollow monolith]

Can't, they won't go anywhere else (aside from Spanish territory)

[hollow linden]

Try to park them on a port, while having those units selected, click on one of your ports

[bold lagoon]

Hi, I'm new to the game and since I started I still haven't been able to defeat any country. I play as Germany and when 1940 comes, I lose in the first Allied offensive.

[hollow linden]

Do they have the exile div thing?

Or do u have military access to spain?

[hollow monolith]

Not that either, I'll try the port thing and I'll let you know

[hollow linden]

Thats so weird

Never seen that

[hollow monolith]

I might have to declare war on Spain, I don't want to since they're useful navy wise

But oh well

[hollow linden]

That would tp them home

[hollow monolith]

It's weird because they would have been sent to my country since I declared war to Poland lol

[digital gyro]

hey why cant i join the axis as france? ik they changed factions but idk how

[hollow monolith]

Are you playing on historical?

[digital gyro]

yea

[hollow monolith]

Iirc you can't join the axis with hist mode on

[digital gyro]

im playing french empire tho

[hollow monolith]

Oh idk then, sorry

[digital gyro]

shame i guess the non agression pact will have to be enough

[stuck garnet]

hey fellas

question

i have no idea what's good for like a good civ industry

i wanna know when it's healthy to start building mils if i plan on not being involved in war much and sending vols

early at least

also i'm half tempted to invest in lights because i'm playing kaiserredux and last time i played it's like

so much happens during a year

[sacred patrol]

So I took a country but idk how to annex it

[edgy mesa]

i keep watching tutorials but what they do just doesnt happen to me like they win i loose even if i 100% follow what they do also is there another way

[pallid iris]

Why can't I add medium flame tank as support on my armoured division? I have the special project and I am producing flame tanks

[winged panther]

then id say do more runs

try and figure out what ur doing wrong everytime

[edgy mesa]

alright ill do that

[winged panther]

if its just the battle part

then start in 1939 with germany

[stuck garnet]

ss?

[winged panther]

figure out attacking and stuff

[stuck garnet]

i just want production lines, screenshots. also can i check your special projects?

[winged panther]

did u set the type of tank as flame tank in division designer?

[stuck garnet]

tank*

?

[pallid iris]

I forgot to do that, might be the issue

[winged panther]

?

[stuck garnet]

do you mean the tank designer?

i get it mized up

mixed*

[winged panther]

yeah tank designer

my bad

[pallid iris]

Yup thanks

works now

[digital gyro]

help for some reason i cant send my paratroopers to england

[stuck garnet]

like how many factories do i build before it's overkill (For civs pre-war)

[fading ibex]

arent medium flame tanks better

[glacial steeple]

dont work when paradropping

[rain iris]

Do you guys think it is smart to fall back here? Because I am trying to invade ussr but everytime I break through my frontline gets to big and my divisions can't defend it. Then i get pushed back again. Any solution?

[sacred patrol]

So I annexed Latvia, but it's allies are alive

Wth do I do

[glacial steeple]

whats the xontext

context*

[sacred patrol]

I have Latvia lands but I don't know how to annex them and end the war

[turbid pecan]

yo

[narrow grail]

Can I move only one task force to certain port and not all the fleet?

[turbid pecan]

what dlc adds the ship designer
because i googled it and it said gottendamburg and ive bought it and theres no ship designer

[glacial steeple]

as who?

[sacred patrol]

All my troops disappear no reason

As Estonia

So like @glacial steeple what can I like even do

[empty kettle]

Guyz..

I had no clue I needed to do this

I thought all I have to do was justify

Is my playthrough ruined

[stuck garnet]

what's a good mountaneer template?

its kaiserredux the tech is basically vanilla

[raw magnet]

Hey I'm trying to take over Europe as Italy, and watching all the tutorials that say place in like 10 naval invasions onto the uk coastline are obsolete as I can only place 2.

otherwise can I get some help on how to win as Italy, what steps I could do to win the game, I'm still fairly new otherwise.

[primal moon]

why cant i do a nuclear missile strike? i have missiles researched

do i need to finish this or smt

[versed rose]

depending on if you need more mountain attack stat or not, you can replace ranger recon with armored recon to stack more breakthrough

[stuck garnet]

uhh

what if my doctrines are bad and i don't have 5th slot

[versed rose]

get it to 32 width

doesnt matter how it looks in the designer

use 16 mountaineers, 18 once you get width reduction on mountaineer doctrine

[glass aurora]

why cant i continue researching industry sorry im new to the game

[stuck garnet]

all the xp i have

[versed rose]

you shouldnt even care about templates if its that early

all your army xp should go into unlocking your land doctrines

[stuck garnet]

i wanna send vols

[versed rose]

send w/e you have at hand, getting mastery for doctrines started is more impactful

[stuck garnet]

was this waste then

[ionic ferry]

which is the strongest country in the game between germany and usa? would it be germany because it has better weaponry in research?

[raw magnet]

USSR

[ionic ferry]

how?

[versed rose]

Comecon

drown the planet in ic

but Germany is stronger so its irrelevant, USSR mios are garbage, and so are US ones, and US industry isnt even comparable to German or USSR potential so that's not even a factor to consider

[sinful vessel]

Is it usefull to give medal ? It's my first game with BBA

[earnest notch]

I want to know how battles work. Do you need more soft attack than the enemy to win the battle?

[sinful vessel]

Afaik (but i'm quite new) soft attack win battle in single player yes.

[glacial steeple]

ussr MIOs are good wdym

ussr issue is just research slots

[versed rose]

gun mio good, but no focke-wulf and OKMO isnt quite henschel

[glacial steeple]

germany by far because the US is super weak

[glacial steeple]

you have tank refurbishment??

very good tank MIO

only 2 nations can even get it

[versed rose]

ik tank refurbishment good, but how much more do you get out of it compared to henschel + daimler (i dont actually know)

[glacial steeple]

a lot more

its by far the best production mio for tank

[versed rose]

but the schtats of henschel vs okmo

[glacial steeple]

best gun MIO is in afghanistan

[versed rose]

esports alta

[glacial steeple]

yes german stats are better but tank production if only comparing MIOs is worse

ussr is worse because slower eco growth bad tech

[versed rose]

USSR also has less effcap potential no?

[glacial steeple]

not enough IC to face entire axis on ground

no

its the same

[versed rose]

10% from gosproyeks, and what else, i forget

[knotty sandal]

how can I win the Reich?

[glacial steeple]

its same cap as ger with slower growth

the ussr isnt that weak

they just scale a bit poorly because of research slots mostly but also just cant out eco whole faction

and ger wins because they have OP grind

[knotty sandal]

help pls(

[glacial steeple]

crazy stats

[versed rose]

do they actually, i swear Germany gets like 20% from eco tree + loyalty to fuhrer, only Soviet one i remember is foreign experts +10%

[glacial steeple]

yeah they get 140

i dont play soviets much so i forgor where

[versed rose]

damn i need to recheck that focus tree then

[carmine topaz]

does having my divisions in the border matter in a focus ultimatum?

[sacred patrol]

can AI nations join factions mid war

[glacial steeple]

yeah

why wouldnt they

[sacred patrol]

a non alligned joined the democrats

a god damn not even close to 20% demo joined the democrats

[glacial steeple]

okay?

[versed rose]

i completely forgot that the soviet starting spirit is +5%, they get another +5% from finishing industry tree, and another 10% from the 2 starting focuses that cook growth in army tree, so they get 130% without mios and maxed industry tech (132% after ww2)

[sacred patrol]

is this like preventable

[glacial steeple]

by not declaring war on them yes

[upper dew]

strategic redeployment keeps turning itself off when I select it for my troops. why is this?

[versed rose]

Germany gets 25% total regardless of eco path, so yea, Soviet does have better industry huh

[sacred patrol]

...

ok ima stop playing batlic

baltic

[glacial steeple]

those arent that hard

if you want war then do it in like 1937

fast unification good

[sacred patrol]

ik

but they just seem to join a faction faster than the soviets

[glacial steeple]

as soviets?

you get a focus to annex them without war

[sacred patrol]

as a baltic nation

to unify the baltics

@glacial steeple as like latvia

not as soviet union

[craggy basin]

Can anyone help me play through a bit?

I just feel super lost. I watched the tutorial but I feel like I'm always getting stuck

[wintry matrix]

Could you try to be more precise, what troubles you?

[craggy basin]

basically I was playing as the dominician republic and I lose to haiti immediately

I building up factories or atleast I think I am

but then when I start the war I immediately die

I also didn't understand how to increase my supply lines with italy in the tutorial

or atleast that's what I thought my problem was

[wintry matrix]

I guess your units lacked some more punch.
Or were too small.

[craggy basin]

I thought I had enough because idk I have it on the easiest difficulty

I thought I would be able to steam roll them

I'm just not sure what I could be doing better

I also feel like it takes forever to build units

I feel like I'm waiting around for half the game to lose in 30 seconds

[stuck garnet]

is this good

[hollow trench]

How do you defeat turkey as facist greece? I'm trying to form the byzantine but turkey is impenetrable

[stuck garnet]

is small cannon 2s better

[wintry matrix]

You can run on 4 or 5 speed for the focusses and army training.
There is no issue in that. The waiting game isn't the issue.
I know DR lacks manpower, but try to make your units at least a 10w and support artillery and getting like at least 4 divisions.
Train them and you should be able to deal with Haiti.

Get better guns too.

[stuck garnet]

my arty tech is crap for for context

[craggy basin]

what does 10w mean?

[wintry matrix]

Width. Like the size of your army.
Different vegetations/tiles allow a different size of your army to fight effective.

[craggy basin]

Are you busy you can just watch me play now

[wintry matrix]

Kind of busy, playing with friends. Sorry.

[craggy basin]

what should I build?

[stuck garnet]

this is a main tank btw

"make meds" no it's 1937

[static turret]

you dont have alot of building slots so id say just go for mils directly

[craggy basin]

what are mils?

[stuck garnet]

and i have vols to usa

[static turret]

military factories

[stuck garnet]

i am playing modded kaiseredux

[static turret]

and civs are civilian factories for future reference

[craggy basin]

it won't let me though?

[static turret]

also if youre new dont start with an island nation

[craggy basin]

I thought it would be easier

[static turret]

because you dont have any building slots

[wintry matrix]

Realistically you won't be able to get sth built on time.
But otherwise mils.

Get your military factories from your focus tree.
And another civ to import iron for your weapons.
Produce all guns and one on artillery.

[craggy basin]

DR seems easier because it's enemy is next to it so it seems simple

also I'm protected I thought

[static turret]

no youre just gonna sit there by yourself and get bored because naval invasion is hard for newbies and alot of players

[craggy basin]

the european nations scare me

I played as slovakia and I got eaten alive

[static turret]

you can go for a country in south ammerica then

or central

but I really dont recommend starting with island nation

[craggy basin]

regardless my problem is just with setting myself up

I don't understand really how to build up units

[hasty mist]

How does the special forces cap work?

Is it like a percentage of deployed manpower or..

[wintry matrix]

You open your division designer.
You put 5 helmets/battalions of base infantry in there. And support artillery.
Get like 4 of them ready, when you start war with Haiti.
And you should be fine.

[worthy quarry]

is there any reason to take this?

only debuffs

[hasty mist]

What's the other options?

[wintry matrix]

If you're not using Cavalry and don't use these generals, this focus has no downside to you.

[hasty mist]

You lose stab if you pick the others.

Ig the devs though that equaled it out

But I never actually use cav.

[worthy quarry]

yeah but 2.50% manchukuo doesnt have alot of commanders to begin with

and u get 50pp which is helpful early on

[hasty mist]

Anyone?

[worthy quarry]

u start with 0 stab anyway

[wintry matrix]

Source: https://hoi4.paradoxwikis.com/Land_units

[primal moon]

Is 80 nuclear reactors enough

[hasty mist]

So ye, percentage of troops deployed-

GANG.

3 is like the max you need.

[primal moon]

Me?

[hasty mist]

Unless this is some like 1950's late game BS

You do not need 80 reactors

[primal moon]

But soviet union needs to outproduce the usa

and siberians are bored

[hasty mist]

Fair.

[glacial steeple]

batallions deployed

[glacial steeple]

make civ reactors

theyre better

also you outproduce the US anyway

[primal moon]

yeah im researching it

[glacial steeple]

its such a poor country rn

[primal moon]

i need to eviscerate the capitalists

500 thermonuclear bombs

if i nuke a port do the ships go too?

[alpine pivot]

is this a good light tank template for Romanov Poland

[pliant condor]

no

[alpine pivot]

how

i changed the cast armour to rivited is that better?

[vestal dune]

how to finish this? attacks are all lost

[night tangle]

is the british navy really unbeatable for a naval invasion

like i couldnt do it with frances navy

[pliant condor]

use medium tank

and role it as spg

[pliant condor]

fallback and let them walk out

[craggy basin]

bro I don't get it

[ripe escarp]

Can anyone help me? Im playingas japan and dont know how to organize my navy properly. I need to keep dominance over very vast areas

[craggy basin]

I get like 5 units and haiti still smokes me

what am I supposed to do?

[stuck garnet]

hey is this good

i know it's lts

"Mot gives no stats go mech" I'm not going mech for lts

[pliant condor]

using motorized is literally losing stats

but if you want it

at least make the tank spg

and add flame tank

[sinful vessel]

Can i take back my volunteer ?

[stuck garnet]

is this good

i could add easy maintennance when i have

[pliant condor]

it doesn't matter

you already have too much breakthrough

make your light tank into spg

ok, there are two things you can do actually

[pliant condor]

since you have this super good flame tank design for whatever reason

if you like, try to put a medium gun on your light tank

and use fixed turret

this will completely nuke the breakthrough on your light spg