#challenge-questions

1 messages ยท Page 7 of 1

naive wyvern
#

but they're all ended in 37 so didn't took much time

glacial stratus
#

very impressive man, i congratulate you ๐Ÿ˜„

#

surprisingly i followed the almost same tactic, in my case i went unhistorical instead and attacked ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง when they were at their weakest

#

are the submissions closed now Chak?

#

usually its always 1 hr before closing

solid gust
#

They closed at 10, correct

glacial stratus
#

10, like , 7 minutes ago?

solid gust
#

(its 10:17, sorry forgot time zones lmao)

glacial stratus
#

yeah right right

glacial stratus
solid gust
#

I live in Canada

glacial stratus
#

its 18:18 from where i stand, GMT +4 timezone

#

when the announcement , btw?

solid gust
#

30 minutes, doing assets rn for it

empty lintel
#

it's incredible how you can do that in 2 years lol

solid gust
#

Espera un Minuto challenge rules:

-Ironman must be enabled, and achievements must be possible. When submitting your entry, you must hover your mouse over the Trophy Icon to show the drop down menu like in the following screenshot #challenge-submissions message
-Graphical mods are allowed, but you cannot have Swastika's within the screenshots, or the submission will be INVALID The server rules still apply within these challenges
-Screenshots required are a picture of conqeured Spain, and showing your faction includes one of the required nations (can be in the same screenshot or two in the same post)

-Starting in the 1936 scenario, start and end the game as Mexico. Any Ideology is allowed.
-You must create a faction with any Spanish speaking country. The countries you can form a faction with to fulfil this challenge are: Peru, Honduras, Colombia, Guatemala, Cuba, Nicaragua, Paraguay, Puerto Rico Bolivia, Costa Rica, Uruguay, Chile, El Salvador, Ecuador, Argentina, Venezuela, Equatorial Guinea, Panama or the Dominican Republic.
-There is NO time limit to this challenge, simply fulfil the requirements for the entry to be valid
-There are NO unit restrictions this time around. Have fun with it
-Winners will be chosen at random, via a random number generator, so as to make the drawing fair.
-This challenge will run for 2 weeks, same as normal. Submissions will close at 10am EST on September 5th

glacial stratus
#

hmm no 2nd and 3rd place winners this time?

solid gust
#

not this time no, sorry

#

@naive wyvern make sure to dm @brittle mortar to claim your prize please (so I can request the given key)

glacial stratus
#

this one is also one and only winner, right?

or its the same as usual

solid gust
#

this one is same as usual

glacial stratus
#

what if i dont want to be allied with someone

solid gust
#

you have to create the faction with one of the listed countries, but it doesn't have to be only them

but it is necessary that one of them be within it

lethal prawn
glacial stratus
solid gust
glacial stratus
tame fulcrum
#

What are the standard rules ( difficulty, historical y/n, video required or just a picture)

glacial stratus
lethal prawn
#

honestly itd be really funny if someone (or I) could destroy spain with equatorial guinea

glacial stratus
#

make a screenshot with F12 and hover over the achievements icon

#

no gameplay changing mods, Ironman only

#

you can use visual mods

#

that's it

glacial stratus
#

like its not forbidden, right?

solid gust
tame fulcrum
#

Do i need the dlcs for it to be valid?

solid gust
#

just need to be mexico

tame fulcrum
#

cool

solid gust
#

(I keep trying to find/make challenges everyone can do, sometimes I have to put people on countries without a dlc tree ikeepitSHRUG )

lucid cliff
solid gust
#

no

glacial stratus
#

rly dude

#

its main game only

solid gust
glacial stratus
solid gust
#

its more of a general (ha) statement

still dagger
#

Yeah, but I would argue it gives us who would Man the Guns an unfair advantage

solid gust
#

since there is no time requirement, its an equal chance

#

this is one of my 'easier' challenges

glacial stratus
#

you can strech out to 1948 if you desire

lucid cliff
#

Can the other Spanish country be an ai

glacial stratus
#

winners will be picked by randomizer, doesnt matter if you do it in 1936, given that whether its possible or not

glacial stratus
#

you cannot do this in multiplayer

lucid cliff
#

Ohhhh

#

Mb

glacial stratus
#

its single player, Ironman mode, achievements must be compatible with the save

#

that's it

#

and start and finish as ๐Ÿ‡ฒ๐Ÿ‡ฝ

#

no switching to other country or tag

solid gust
still dagger
glacial stratus
#

This challenge will run for 2 weeks, same as normal. Submissions will close at 10am on September 5th

@solid gust , text which timezone you mean, even ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ has multiple zones

still dagger
#

Since there would be no way to realistically lose unless I collapse into civil war

solid gust
#

let me fix that, i deleted it apparently though i dont remember doing it lmao

glacial stratus
#

yeah i mean just text EST in the rules, so you wont be bombarded with questions

#

i made you avoid one and nineteen more questions by doing this simple trick JuiceCat

brave inlet
#

do you must have man the guns dlc for the mexico focus tree?

solid gust
copper anchor
#

would puppeting a Spanish-speaking country and making an alliance with it be considered correct with the alliance thing?

solid gust
#

nope, have to be equal not subjugation in this one

#

well, I say 'equal' but you will probably be the much stronger nation

fickle river
#

cool, but where did you fight the french and british in Africa, you mentioned nothing about it

naive wyvern
#

when i delcared on britain i encircled a couple of divisions in botswana

fickle river
#

and you took the east indies?

naive wyvern
#

annexed, yes

fickle river
#

where did you get enough men to do that?

naive wyvern
#

to annex dei or fight in africa?

fickle river
#

to fight in Europe and Africa at the same time

#

with 16w

naive wyvern
#

did you read my explanation?

#

italian divisions

#

then when i annex britain and dutch, i had a lot of guns

fickle river
#

but you disbanded the faction quite early

naive wyvern
#

and noncore manpower

#

disbanded after capitulating uk

fickle river
naive wyvern
#

why?

fickle river
#

i mean, play a weaker nation

#

take division from countries around you

#

reminds me of those old no casualties german runs

naive wyvern
fickle river
#

I never said it was

naive wyvern
#

ah, ok

fickle river
#

I only said it should not be there

#

killing the challenge

naive wyvern
#

i mean thats why i asked

north garden
#

congrats bro w1zardj

fickle river
#

just like puppeting countries only to obtain unlimited divisions

#

shame

#

anyway, what dlc did you pick?

naive wyvern
#

i had all except toa so

fickle river
#

its the best

#

I hope next dlc will give focuses to rest of SA, because right now, it is cursed

naive wyvern
#

yeah, in general old trees are jus too outdated

fickle river
#

or rest of Europe

#

the only 2 good options

naive wyvern
#

focuses end too early also

#

after 1940 or even earlier there is just nothing to do

fickle river
#

it makes playing in SA unnatural

naive wyvern
#

i hate the fact that you can't go free with democratic path

#

and also cw mechanics only open when you go free if youre fascist

#

it kinda makes sense because the other path is about civil war but still

fickle river
naive wyvern
#

fascism on the rise

#

to make a referendum or go civil war

fickle river
#

(its fascism)

fickle river
empty lintel
#

no units limit?

#

so i can use para

glacial stratus
hazy dune
#

dope challenge

clear bramble
#

can we have more than 1 spanish speaking country in a faction?

golden tinsel
#

just fyi brazil wasnt spanish colony ๐Ÿ™‚

solid gust
clear bramble
#

wow i got really good rng for my first run

fickle river
empty lintel
solid gust
short wraith
#

@solid gust is it okay if I redo my submission by deleting the old one and just adding new screenshot with my faction on it

solid gust
#

you're only allowed one submission, but if you delete your previous one, you can resubmit

short wraith
#

okk

empty lintel
#

guys any tips to invade spain?

#

โ“

clear bramble
# empty lintel โ“

Iโ€™ve currently (without much success) tried to help a side in the civil war by directly declaring war on the enemy and using attaches and military access, hopefully getting enough war score I can get a good foothold to invade

empty lintel
#

i could think about invading portugal

clear bramble
#

I tried that originally and subs give the range, I just made a trash template and I spammed it out as much as possible

clear bramble
#

my naval invasion plans was declaring on Spain and going Rio de Oro, Canaries, and Tangier

empty lintel
#

(it didn't go well)

clear bramble
#

Iโ€™m pretty sure you donโ€™t have to just have only the one Spanish speaking nation in the alliance, so my first plan was to get range in that area through inviting Brazil into an alliance via focuses and decisions

clear bramble
#

mk

empty lintel
clear bramble
empty lintel
short wraith
clear bramble
short wraith
#

dunno

solid gust
#

its fine to have brazil in it

clear bramble
#

phew

solid gust
#

you just have to make sure one of the listed ones is in it

empty lintel
#

i have venezuela in it

#

so it is fine

#

and considering that iberian union existed

empty lintel
#

ong i did it

solid gust
#

missing a screenshot

#

need to show your faction members

empty lintel
#

ok i did

solid gust
#

looks good, good job

empty lintel
#

took me 3 tries tho lol

#

little complex, but i had some fun

gilded quartz
#

What decisions do you choose to get rid of the threat of a uprising

gilded quartz
#

This thing

empty lintel
#

arrest caudillo

signal frost
#

In focus tree

empty lintel
#

i usually rush to arrest him

gilded quartz
#

oh ok

#

thanks

glacial stratus
#

why is everyone splitting Spain with other Latino country, can't you just annex it all for yourself?

is there a rule for doing so? i am not seeing it anywhere

#

i understand that they have to be in war with you, but if you manage to get the most participation score, do you have to deliberately give them territory in peace deal or what?

glacial stratus
#

@solid gust whenever you see this โ˜๏ธ

charred timber
#

Equatorial Guinea best

steel cargo
steel cargo
charred timber
#

Dont even, just have to defeat nationalist spain while they are in cw and the republic

steel cargo
glacial stratus
steel cargo
#

As Mexico of any Ideology, team up with another
Spanish speaking country and conquer Spain to
show them who the real Spanish Power is!

#

with ANOTHER spanish speaking country to conquer spain

glacial stratus
steel cargo
#

what are other people submitting

glacial stratus
#

young man

#

at basic levels of English communication, this indicates you must be at war with big daddy ๐Ÿ‡ช๐Ÿ‡ธ with your fellow-Spaniard partner

#

this raises question, what if your war score participation is so high that other state can't take any territory of ๐Ÿ‡ช๐Ÿ‡ธ

should you give it to them personally or can you have them all while they get nothing

solid gust
#

Hey guys, let's be nice, its not that serious. Its just a challenge.

You do not have to split the territory with the other Spanish country but its implied to do so at least to some degree

glacial stratus
#

is it viable or should i restart from 0 to give them at least 1 piece of Spanish land?

#

that's the part that confused me most tbh

#

not my fault my AI partner was so useless ๐Ÿ˜„

solid gust
#

Its fine to not split it, that is no issue

solid gust
#

if anything, give em a part of france or something, consolation prize lmao

glacial stratus
lapis python
#

Can I submit a challenge entry multiple times if I complete it multiple times?

glacial stratus
lapis python
#

Ok thanks

lapis python
#

If another faction member takes over as faction leader of a faction I create does that still count towards the challenge

solid gust
#

you just have to make it, doesnt matter if they get stronger and take over

fickle river
#

I am not here once and chat went wild

clear bramble
#

My submission is hopefully valid ๐Ÿ™

solid gust
#

looks good to me

lunar saffron
#

Alr before i start this, can i even do it with generic focus tree?

lunar saffron
#

also, can the "partner" be a puppet through war? because im struggling to find a country to create faction

empty lintel
#

if you go fascist

solid gust
lunar saffron
#

yeah

glacial stratus
#

he doesnt need to get MtG, he can pull this off very easily regardless of historical/unhistorical

#

let him figure it out on their own

#

why passive-aggressiveness?

#

it looked like one tbh, but that's fine, don't worry

#

what i am trying to say is

#

Latin America is basically at his disposal ๐Ÿ˜„

#

lots of contestants to be best buds with)

#

i would try on Unhistorical personally , wink wink*

#

oh hell yeah, bro, go for it, do wacky shi โœŠ

#

random winner challenges are not for me honestly, i always go out of my way to make the playthrough most interesting

end up getting no place anyways lol

#

i am much better with timed challenges ๐Ÿ˜„

#

in your defense, you are not losing nerves and braincells for the tough challenges, so that's definitely a victory ๐Ÿ†

#

you'll get to live longer ๐Ÿ˜„

lapis python
#

Do I have to be at peace to win because Spain joined the axis

#

*complete the challenge not win

solid gust
#

Have to resolve all wars, yes

lapis python
#

Ok thanks

carmine sage
#

So my submission is invalid, even if the war is against a completely different faction?

solid gust
#

if you still have the save just try to resolve the war as best you can and resubmit

most challenges (for future reference) require the wars to be resolved

glad vector
#

i think he posted a new one - I see no problem there

sinful flower
#

Play as Albania

idle sequoia
#

what's the current challenge

solid gust
#

its the top pinned message in this channel, and you can scroll up in #challenge-submissions to find the most recent post by myself in it

frank umbra
#

Purposely lose core territory as Italy, and all your colonies, so you descend into civil war as the Italian Social Republic. Try and reclaim all your lost territory and win ww2

#

Cool suggestion

glacial stratus
#

probably won't work without By Blood Alone

challenges are specifically designed for non-DLC users

frank umbra
glacial stratus
ocean elk
#

Can Balearic islands be Italian (as they are in their focus tree)?

glacial stratus
idle sequoia
#

but you can ask for them and if u helped nationalists in the civilwar they will 100% say yes

glad vector
#

@pliant kelp who is that general in your screenshot?

glacial stratus
craggy jacinth
#

do we have to ally with another spanish speaking country or its not neccessary?

#

also all of spanish cores or colonies too?

#

i want to ping chak so much bcause he always responds but ill get ahold of me and wont do it

empty lintel
#

but if you want more go ahead

solid gust
#

ty for not pinging me though, its appreciated

craggy jacinth
#

thank you

pure dock
#

Can I suggest a challenge

solid gust
#

you're always allowed to suggest a challenge, but i do not give out a prize if it's chosen, there's no finders fee so to speak

glacial stratus
#

โš ๏ธ i can still vouch for this challenge suggestion

cinder lintel
#

Hello

fickle river
glacial stratus
#

hoi4 never changes

fickle river
#

yeah

#

i wonder how many other people have more versions of their portrait

fickle river
#

xdd

glacial stratus
fickle river
#

like, why him?

glacial stratus
#

Fascist Chile El Jefe has different portraits when leader and general

and there is Wladyslaw Anders , one when he is in ๐Ÿ‡ต๐Ÿ‡ฑ and the other is el generico

glacial stratus
fickle river
glacial stratus
#

its a mish mash of info from Wikipedia in earlier DLCs

#

later DLCs have some sort of historical research in them, which i am thankful lol

#

for example, ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ท has the best research done so far in the game, in terms of historical authenticity

even though the focuses are infamous for being too long

#

i extremely dislike late game content in this game(or therefore, lack of)

i almost always drop my games around 1941-1943
(unless its nuke achievements, which are all trash by the way)

but ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ท and Soviet Union are the 2 only countries in this game that has enough content for 1945

#

and that's good for me

hopefully next DLC will rework nukes (they are so useless) and late year content in general

umbral cipher
glacial stratus
#

true

charred timber
#

he can be leader of mexico

#

@glad vector

glacial stratus
charred timber
#

They are the same person

glacial stratus
#

Mexican is not even close to young KGB Putin

#

big forehead must've confused you

charred timber
#

why you sending a picture of putin again?

solid gust
#

Hey now

#

why we posting irl pics

#

HMMMM

charred timber
#

antasil asked question

#

i answered

solid gust
#

fair, but you can't post pictures of Putin considering he is still a current political leader (even his young pictures)

solid gust
#

@pulsar vault imma need you to resubmit, friend, you have to show your faction in the screenshot, please

#

same as you @pliant kelp

#

can't accept it if you dont show the faction

charred timber
#

Its hoi4

solid gust
#

technically no but also technically yes

it may be a mod but it is not vanilla, and the only things explicitly allowed are vanilla assets, all other modded content is subject to the rules

#

I allow some leeway with modded content but for certain leaders, since they are actively politicians rn, are still prohibited

solid gust
#

ty friend, I would rather you get an eligible entry instead of being disqualified over something minor

jaunty shell
shut axle
#

Can a AI country without elections change into another ideology if popularity is high enough?

pliant kelp
pliant kelp
charred timber
#

not necassarely

#

it depends on what country it is, because for many it is deactivated

#

monarchist france for example can never switch

naive wyvern
#

if elections are activated, when support reaches 60% nation gets a decision for 100 pp to convert in any ideology besides non-aligned

charred timber
naive wyvern
#

yeah right

#

for most minors they are activated

charred timber
#

btw

charred timber
naive wyvern
#

unfortunately no

charred timber
#

sadness ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

naive wyvern
#

i think you should check PoliticalEvents.txt in events folder

#

but its only events

#

found it: common\scripted_triggers\00_scripted_triggers.txt

#

there are checks like check_has_focus_tree_to_switch_to_democratic and for communism and fascism and then countries that can't do a referendum for a particular ideology

solid gust
#

Not tryna derail the discussion here but going to mention that a new challenge will be announced tomorrow at 11 am EST tomorrow ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿป

glacial stratus
#

what continent?

#

we know at least its on planet Earth spymaster

glacial stratus
glad vector
#

well now, there is a 1939 start date. hardly anyone uses it ofc

#

would be a good one. Survive as Poland/ France/ Netherlands etc in 1939 start date. I mean its very well possible in the 36 start because you can direct the buildup and/ or politics. In 1939 you're days away from invasion.

glacial stratus
#

nah bro, its always much more fun to go from 1936

#

besides, challenges are all about "doing it fast"

#

would be weird to start from 1939

naive wyvern
#

i don't think its a complete list though
for example there is no italy in communism checks, but in game italy can't do communist referendum

#

but for the most part i think this is it

charred timber
#

its a start

#

i need that for testing many strategies

charred timber
#

thx a lot

charred timber
naive wyvern
#

it mentions countries that can't switch from what i remember

glacial stratus
#

so far these countries have been used for challenges:

๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ท , Andalusia( ๐Ÿ‡ฒ๐Ÿ‡ฆ / ๐Ÿ‡ฑ๐Ÿ‡พ / ๐Ÿ‡ฉ๐Ÿ‡ฟ / ๐Ÿ‡ช๐Ÿ‡ฌ ), ๐Ÿ‡ช๐Ÿ‡ธ , ๐Ÿ‡ฒ๐Ÿ‡ณ , ๐Ÿ‡ฉ๐Ÿ‡ช , ๐Ÿ‡ต๐Ÿ‡ฑ , ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ , ๐Ÿ‡ฟ๐Ÿ‡ฆ

#

let me know if i missed a few, cause i definitely did

charred timber
#

lol

naive wyvern
#

xd

glacial stratus
charred timber
#

exactly

#

latvija best

#

thats why pdx needs to fix it

#

so many bugs in the tree

glacial stratus
charred timber
glacial stratus
charred timber
#

latvia cant core minsk, even tho dev diary said, they can

#

latvia got scammed

#

justiceforlatvia

glacial stratus
#

i still want my ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡ฟ challenge ๐Ÿ™‚

#

but i can understand Chak wants it to be accessible to everyone, without DLCs

#

by it, i mean the challenges

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

how the Yugoslav Regent got there?

charred timber
glacial stratus
charred timber
glacial stratus
#

is it only with this guy or can be done with anyone?

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

oh man, 2016 Paradox was wild

to this day, i wonder what they smoked to get "Fire Horse Clique" and "Empire of Fire" names KEKW

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

D04 doesn't pop for Yugo?

#

or is it like you have to be 100% ideology popularity and the opposing tag doesnt pop?

charred timber
#

later, if you win and some other nation exists as d04 (cw, collab, peacedeal result etc) if you then do the focus, sign triparte pact, prince paul because leader of the new d04

glacial stratus
#

does new D04 has to be brown ideology or any ideology?

charred timber
#

so, prince paul can be leader of literally every nation

charred timber
#

so, only thing you need to do is, d04 needs to be brown so he is the active ruler

#

just click my discord bio, look on my challenge, look for my video with the most views, i show it there

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

its so bizzaro but so creative lol

charred timber
#

greatest meme in hoi4

glacial stratus
#

Tenth Crusade for fash ๐Ÿ‡ฒ๐Ÿ‡น

#

or Fourth Reich for West ๐Ÿ‡ฉ๐Ÿ‡ช lul

charred timber
#

you cant get it anymore since BBA

glacial stratus
charred timber
glacial stratus
#

F

charred timber
#

its just cheaper puppet prices for the allies in the regions in peacedeal

#

so, well you can be fourth reich

#

but you cant have klaus klauser anymore

#

cause at least germany gets wgr cosmetic tag

glacial stratus
# charred timber

is this vanilla? how do you get the True ๐Ÿ‡ธ๐Ÿ‡ช name?

glacial stratus
#

what path of ๐Ÿ‡ธ๐Ÿ‡ช gives that name?

solid gust
#

just over 15 minutes until entries close

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

or only via console commands?

#

as if set_ruling_party f

charred timber
#

All you need is commie support and low stability before you go down the tree

#

So, cw happens

#

You win

#

Then you do focus to become fascist

#

And commie support you get from strikes

#

Which would require that you have too high consoriction law, which is onky possible after you won a war. Which means pratically, sweden joins allies, gets invaded by germany, turn the tides, only then you do focus

#

Would be a great video idea tho. I think i will do that some day

solid gust
#

Alright, submissions are closed.

Winners will be announced in an hour alongside the newest challenge chakerSip

glad vector
#

Random draw, right?

solid gust
#

yes

glacial stratus
subtle scroll
#

is it possible to do anything in this game without dlcs

signal frost
subtle scroll
#

if i get one dlc what should i buy

signal frost
subtle scroll
#

what does it add

empty lintel
#

and spirits of the army

subtle scroll
empty lintel
subtle scroll
#

and poland?

#

baltics

empty lintel
#

yes

#

and soviets

subtle scroll
#

does it have a discount

#

like 5 euro

empty lintel
subtle scroll
#

when will it have again one

empty lintel
#

like before on 1 september

#

quumn

#

autumn

solid gust
#

The Sand Of Time Challenge Rules:
-As with all challenges, this one must be completed in Ironman, and be achievement compatible. (Which means normal or higher difficulty) You can use Graphical mods (portraits/icons etc) but NO mods that change gameplay
-This will be a 1936 start, as with most challenges, and you cannot change your country at any time.
-You must start as Iran, and be Democratic to fulfil the challenge. You have to form the Persian Empire. There will be a basic image attached showing the required lands. Essentially you need all of Turkey, Iraq, Afghanistan and Bulgaria with smaller portions on the others
-This challenge will be Timed with the Fastest run being the winner.
-As with many of the Difficult challenges, you must conquer these lands yourselves, so take screenshots often!
-For Submissions, there will need to be at least 1 image of you hovering over the trophy icon to verify Ironman+achievement compatibility, and 1 or 2 of you conquering the land that is required.
-1 Screenshot must be showing your country ideology, it can be the same as the one to verify your ironman
-You need to Screenshot when you flip democratic as well to ensure that you do not flip at the very end.
-You are allowed puppets this time around, but they cannot be in the required lands, outside of it is fine
-Unit restrictions in place will be no Paratroopers, and you have to have some form of Cavalry/Camels
-I reserve the right to add/edit rules at any time here, but it will not be unit restrictions or a change to how the winner is chosen.

glad vector
#

Ow awesome, me winning a dlc. I made a video on my mexico run, now i can combine it with a dlc giveaway!

empty lintel
#

well i didn't have luck this time lol

naive wyvern
solid gust
fickle river
#

what does that even mean?

#

flip asap

naive wyvern
#

but how do we justify on iraq, turkey and afghanistan if we are democratic

signal frost
#

Alright, to do the challenge truly democratically, you have to have the Soviets and Allies declare war on you via focus, defeat them, and then you can justify on the axis because they generated world tension

glacial stratus
glad vector
#

I see no problem there

signal frost
#

Or do my gigachad method

glacial stratus
hushed stag
signal frost
#

Soviets and allies have focuses to invade you

glacial stratus
#

like a lot

signal frost
#

And then you justify on the Axis because they generated world tension

#

I know

glacial stratus
#

no sooner than 1943

naive wyvern
#

they're gonna do it in like 1943 at best

signal frost
#

But it is the truly democratic way

foggy sage
#

This challenge reminds me that when forming the Persian Empire, Gibraltar gets cored for no reason ๐Ÿ˜‚

fickle river
signal frost
#

It isn't about winning, it is about being a gigachad

signal frost
glacial stratus
hushed stag
#

Also turkey Afghanistan and Iraq don't generate world tension, how do you get them? Also can this challenge be in non historical?

signal frost
#

I am not giving winning strategies, only gigachad ones

solid gust
#

also i went in game to grab a rough screenshot instead of the map I provided at the start for the people who can't discern the required lands based off the other map

foggy sage
glacial stratus
signal frost
#

They can flip communist though

solid gust
fickle river
naive wyvern
signal frost
#

They happen 100%

signal frost
#

I'm not saying you are winning with this strat

hushed stag
solid gust
signal frost
#

When does that happen

glacial stratus
#

unless you want screenshot when 1) we are democracy first and 2) when we have all of the lands

naive wyvern
glacial stratus
#

thats the only way i think its remotely possible

fickle river
signal frost
#

Wait turn off BftB for quick Turkish justification

tacit sapphire
#

Is the Persian empire a decision?

glacial stratus
fickle river
signal frost
#

Flip fascist, justify on necessary countries, then flip democratic

glacial stratus
tacit sapphire
naive wyvern
glacial stratus
signal frost
#

Wait until ww2 starts I guess

naive wyvern
#

bruh

solid gust
#

hm alright, so let's do it this way

You have to flip democratic before forming the Persian empire, but before that you can try different strats

#

sound fair?

tacit sapphire
#

Should I force my friend to do this

signal frost
solid gust
fickle river
#

i would say, just dont flip to anything else than democracy

naive wyvern
# solid gust sound fair?

so basically we can do whatever we want, but before clicking the formable decision, we need to be democratic?

fickle river
#

is the most simple and still doable rule

solid gust
signal frost
#

Technically it is as democratic Iran, click the button

#

But the true challenge is non aligned and democracy only

vale cedar
#

i have a question.can we do this with some grafical mods?

vale cedar
#

alr

empty lintel
fickle river
solid gust
#

nothing like RT56 or Kaisserreich, but things like fps map mod and stuff is perfectly fine

signal frost
#

And Ironman compatible

glacial stratus
signal frost
#

We can justify as non aligned, technically possible to only flip once

glacial stratus
naive wyvern
empty lintel
#

is this time based tho?

tacit sapphire
#

Donโ€™t non aligned have the same restrictions as democratic?

vale cedar
#

does unhistorical count?

tacit sapphire
#

With war goals?

empty lintel
hexed rain
#

IS THIS GOOD AGAINS GERMAN EMPIRE ? (i play as Lutzemburg and have 10 bunkers)

empty lintel
#

world tension

hushed stag
hexed rain
#

ou

#

okey i am sorrY

vale cedar
#

no problem

glacial stratus
fickle river
tacit sapphire
#

50% would be a pain

#

I think the wt happens in 39

glacial stratus
fickle river
tacit sapphire
#

Imma study this more than I studied my test (it had a back)

glacial stratus
empty lintel
hushed stag
#

Do we have to be at peace?

glacial stratus
#

that was always the rule

fickle river
hushed stag
#

Damn, this is going to be hard

glacial stratus
empty lintel
#

also being the fastest is pain too

hushed stag
#

I have an idea

glacial stratus
fickle river
#

ALWAYS HAS BEEN

empty lintel
brave inlet
#

how tf we bring turkey to war ๐Ÿ’€

glacial stratus
#

it would make much more sense if we are allowed to Form Persia first and then switch to ๐Ÿ—ฝ

tacit sapphire
hushed stag
#

So wait , if the axis cap the soviets and Im also in the peace deal, does it count?

fickle river
#

you dont have to really go first democracy if i understand properly

empty lintel
glacial stratus
#

given that its Historical mode on

fickle river
#

you jsut have to be democratic when clicking the decision

hushed stag
#

Yeah

fickle river
glacial stratus
#

you just waste time

glacial stratus
#

oh goodness, i realized Democratic Iran has generic portrait and non existent democracy

solid gust
#

Historical is not required, unless stated which in this one it is not

You may flip to non democratic ideologies but you cannot only flip at the very end, you should be flipping at most somewhere near the middle of it (hopefully)

Flipping at the very end kinda defeats the purpose of the challenge which is to accomplish it as democratic, but I can see the usefulness of flipping to another ideology first

#

I am also slow to reply because I am doing more than one thing at once, apologies

glacial stratus
#

and i hate generic portraits oof

obtuse mauve
#

How would you reform persia tho, Iran doesn't got focuses right

brave inlet
#

I give up ๐Ÿ’€ good luck boys.

zinc parrot
#

What countries are needed to be conquered

glacial stratus
zinc parrot
glacial stratus
# zinc parrot Can't rn

i got u bro

its basically ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ท , ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ถ , ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡ซ

glacial stratus
#

you dont have to invade Soviet Union

#

like ironically you cant have Azerbaijan haha

zinc parrot
#

Any colonies?

empty lintel
#

isn't that required

glacial stratus
#

yep

#

still no ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡ฟ hahahahaha

#

we are free from invading Soviet Union

zinc parrot
#

So Egypt

glacial stratus
#

that's a relief ๐Ÿ˜…

solid gust
#

the persian empire lands were fluctuating constantly, the map I've given was the one for 490 BC i believe

signal frost
#

Just be able to click the decision, right

#

I think that is as easy as it gets

empty lintel
glacial stratus
#

remember how you needed proof with invading Cuba and PhIllipines as Spain?

solid gust
#

I can add the screenshotting of democratic flip

glacial stratus
#

do the same reasoning

#

otherwise there will be monikers lying about flipping to Democracy very early but they in reality did it very late

#

i think its more than fair

zinc parrot
#

ACCORDING TO THE WIKI: we need Libya, Syria, Egypt, Iraq, Afghanistan, Cyprus, Palestine, Jordan, and turkey

#

Sighs for the 2947395037264940826495th time

naive wyvern
empty lintel
#

able to do

#

nothing

naive wyvern
#

right

glacial stratus
naive wyvern
#

yes, thats what im asking, stay non-aligned, then switch when you justified and declared on needed countries

glacial stratus
#

Democracy sounds like shooting yourself in the foot for no reason

glacial stratus
empty lintel
wet iron
#

isn't it possible to declare war on everyone you need to conquer and then flip?

naive wyvern
empty lintel
#

since it raises faster

naive wyvern
#

in unhist it could be even worse

#

but can be better

#

its a big rng

glacial stratus
#

@solid gust are you really sure about democracy? i get the challenge thing, but i think nobody here agrees with it tbh

#

like guys, don't you think we should ditch the Democracy and just make challenge to be Non-Aligned only?

naive wyvern
#

it really doesn't make sense that we need to do a conquest being democratic

#

it's doable but can be achieved on historical only in 1943+
which is kinda weird for time based challenge

glacial stratus
#

let's do a democratic thing then (lol)

not sure if it will change your decision Chak, but i will try nonetheless

Challenge should be to form Persia and stay Non-Aligned, who gets it the earliest

will put emotes for voting
๐Ÿ‘ - yes
๐Ÿ‘Ž - no

#

you are the boss, regardless

obtuse mauve
solid gust
#

the democratic portion has to stay, respectfully

changing that part makes the challenge too easy imo

yes the democratic portion makes it difficult but I do not want a flip at the end, and a stay of non aligned does not achieve the same thing.

Just dont flip to democratic at the very end and do whatever before then

glacial stratus
#

no paratroopers and tanks can be rule as well

solid gust
#

tanks have to be allowed since there is an ideology restriction

#

(i try not to put too many restrictions on the challenge)

naive wyvern
#

so when is the latest we can flip?

glacial stratus
#

will it be a rule?

#

like we need proof of flipping first

solid gust
#

its already been edited into the rule set

glacial stratus
#

and conquering 2nd

#

ok great

#

oh and nice Prince of Persia reference, i just realized lol

solid gust
#

considering this is a timed run I cannot say exactly what date you can wait until a flip to achieve it since everyone will have different dates

I'd say before conquering everything (as would be required by the screenshot rule added in) but if you conquer, say, Iraq before the full flip to democratic that is fine

naive wyvern
#

alright, that sounds good

tacit sapphire
#

For submissions does it have to be a screenshot? Or a video?

glacial stratus
#

screenshot

#

no video

#

make sure that you hover over the trophy icon

tacit sapphire
#

Then how would Chak know when we flip

solid gust
#

there are multiple screenshots required

#

the harder challenges (like this one) typically require 2-3 screenshots at a minimum

tacit sapphire
#

As in the default showing map time and achievements

#

What would be the 2nd?

solid gust
#

you need one proving you have everything required at the very end
one proving ideology and the date of it
one required showing you have troops in the different lands
and one that shows you have ironman+achievements avaialble (which can also be one of the previous ones)

tacit sapphire
#

How do u prove date of ideology? A normal screenshot with the country tab open?

solid gust
#

yeah

tacit sapphire
#

I feel like Iโ€™m answering too many questions

#

Ok

fickle river
pine niche
#

I only have starter pack and mtg, so this at least looks achievable. Thing is, how DO you expand as democratic Iran?

tacit sapphire
#

U donโ€™t

pine niche
#

Oh I see, so an expansionist ideology then flip democratic like the CIA kicked in?

tacit sapphire
#

Idk

pine niche
#

Should be fun I guess.

tacit sapphire
#

Itโ€™s hoi4

pine niche
#

Iโ€™m thinking I go fascist for manpower and thematic โ€œneo-persianismโ€; then flip to democratic once the empire is restored. Will that work?

#

Oh wait, I canโ€™t flip at the end, I have to flip in the middle.

#

Either way, should be a fun challenge.

glacial stratus
#

you have to prove that you flipped to democratic in a screenshot

#

like before and after images, so to speak

pine niche
#

Sounds complicated, will be safer practicing USA or Germany

wet bone
solid gust
#

its part of the additional rules for the challenge

#

pinned in this channel

charred timber
minor lion
#

if i cant flip how would i ever be able to justify on peaceful contries like afganistan and iraq?

tacit sapphire
#

yknow

#

I thought the persian empire was smaller

#

imma try to make a hoi4 version of this map rq

glacial stratus
#

so basically get the map version of formable and not the in-game one

and make sure to be already democratic before pressing the decision, got it

tacit sapphire
#

this should be the needed provinces

#

not 100% accurate

#

hi gustavo

empty lintel
#

i didn't even write

tacit sapphire
#

U were typing right before i said hi

empty lintel
tacit sapphire
#

prob means u clicked on the channel

#

I know all

#

my intelligence is beyond ur comprehension

solid gust
#

they're in your walls, gustavo

tacit sapphire
#

fr!

lethal prawn
solid gust
#

essentially yes

#

you can take more is perfectly fine

#

its just that you have to form the persian empire

empty lintel
#

does this mean i need to have some cavalry?

glacial stratus
#

@tacit sapphire check if your friend used paratroopers or not to cap the ๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ท

#

(ofc they can always lie and we will never know lol)

empty lintel
glacial stratus
#

they had to work really fast then

since it takes a solid two years at least for world tension to grow to 50

#

given that its done on historical, impressive

empty lintel
#

6% world tension rn

#

lol

glacial stratus
#

even then this runs question of how did they even join Axis

#

and why Italy is still alive as fascist, not puppeted even

empty lintel
#

you can see soviets inviting

glacial stratus
#

oh i realized

#

they are at war

empty lintel
#

so it's invalid

#

lol

glacial stratus
#

ooooof

glacial stratus
#

its usually the rule in timed challenges where you have to be at peace

#

they have to either finish them real quick or go for restart and get a faster time record, so there you go

#

a reminder

tacit sapphire
#

@solid gust peace is required right?

solid gust
#

@dire pivot I have manually verified you, don't do any funny business and follow the rules are you will be fine

dire pivot
dire pivot
#

@tacit sapphire told me it is required to be at peace for my submission to count?

solid gust
#

correct

dire pivot
#

I saw a picture with a red line, is that the required area, or am I only supposed to form persia/click the disicion?

solid gust
dire pivot
#

Okay, I will defeat the axis and the soviets tomorrow and re-send my run ๐Ÿ˜ตโ€๐Ÿ’ซ

#

Should be fun...

empty lintel
dire pivot
#

I used some cav during my invasion of Iraq, but I dont have a screenshot of the battle, will that be a problem?

dire pivot
solid gust
#

I would have verified you earlier but I was finishing up the last of my 2nd job's tasks

dire pivot
#

Everything went south pretty quick

empty lintel
#

weird

#

i played to 1938

#

and 12% world tension

dire pivot
#

ye

#

Historical is super bad

empty lintel
#

no

#

i played on non hist

dire pivot
#

I like the caos xD

empty lintel
#

and 12% world tension

dire pivot
naive wyvern
dire pivot
#

The map and forming persian empire

empty lintel
#

so i will do this to make more world tension

naive wyvern
#

bulgaria and parts of soviets are not needed, part of libya and dodecanese are missing

#

also a part of raj which is not needed for persia and one more state of egypt is missing

solid gust
#

there is the part of the in-game requirements to form persia, but the challenge was made with the pinned map in mind

naive wyvern
#

so is it the map, the decision or both?

solid gust
#

the map, you just have to trigger the persian empire to submit

you can expand further than the required lands but you need to have the required lands + form the persian empire

naive wyvern
#

because it makes it 10x harder

solid gust
#

this is the harder challenge for a reason, everyone keeps telling me the challenges are too easy even when hard ikeepitSHRUG

dire pivot
#

Debating doing an all-nighter... Its 2 am currently ๐Ÿคฃ

empty lintel
#

ok then

as jan mayen, conquer all of europe

#

real

solid gust
#

your studies come first

#

then HOI

dire pivot
dire pivot
#

๐Ÿ˜ญ

empty lintel
#

it's 7:57 pm here lol

#

so i got plenty time to do it

solid gust
#

a totally not me part of the twitter account has already said that a Studious general is more effective than one who is not

dire pivot
solid gust
empty lintel
solid gust
#

i cringed typing that out

empty lintel
#

lol

solid gust
#

Ur just the opposite of east

#

dont worry about it

dire pivot
dire pivot
#

January 2-7th

empty lintel
#

lol

#

spanish chilean accent

dire pivot
#

I know 2 spanish words...

#

I hope english and/or german will be sufficient ๐Ÿ˜Š

empty lintel
tacit sapphire
#

non historical moment

dire pivot
#

Non Historical >>> ๐Ÿคฃ

tacit sapphire
#

sleep

charred timber
#

Gibraltar is the best persian core state

glacial stratus
charred timber
dire pivot
fickle river
fickle river
ornate thunder
#

do you need Grecce

#

do i need this part

charred timber
charred timber
# solid gust

For full transparecy and clearification, could you pin this make with the hoi4 provinces? Thats a bit confusing

ornate thunder
#

I guess I need to restart

charred timber
glacial stratus
#

attacking Soviet Union is out of the question

ornate thunder
#

is that ok

naive wyvern
#

i'm talking about this map

solid gust
glacial stratus
#

oh so you need to invade Caucasus as well

#

that's the hardest challenge so far

ornate thunder
#

damn missing 2 states because i didnt know

#

do i need to get them so my run counts? im not fighting germany

naive wyvern
#

@ornate thunder have you ended all your wars? its not visible on your screenshots

ornate thunder
#

i have a smal one with etheopia

#

didnt even notice

glacial stratus
ornate thunder
#

done

#

is my run valid now?

glacial stratus
#

to be even more specific

naive wyvern
#

saudi arabia included?

glacial stratus
#

long story short, you need Thrace of ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ท, 2/3 of ๐Ÿ‡ง๐Ÿ‡ฌ , Dobrudja from ๐Ÿ‡ท๐Ÿ‡ด , Dodecanese Islands from ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น , bits of Pakistan from British Raj, the Entire Middle East, all of Transcaucasia and 2/3 of ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ฒ , ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ฟ and all of ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ฏ

ornate thunder
#

Im waiting for an official to say something because im really confused rn

glacial stratus
#

these are the lands you need for challenge

#

no exceptions , and yes i know, this is evil. but that's the whole point of the challenge ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

ornate thunder
#

๐Ÿ‘ kill germany it is

glacial stratus
#

but everybody else

ornate thunder
#

i need to because the own 2states i need

glacial stratus
#

your enemies are ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง , ๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ท , ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ท , ๐Ÿ‡ง๐Ÿ‡ฌ , ๐Ÿ‡ท๐Ÿ‡ด , Raj ( ๐Ÿ‡ต๐Ÿ‡ฐ , ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ , ๐Ÿ‡ง๐Ÿ‡ฉ ), Soviet Union ( ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡ฟ , ๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡ฒ , ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ช , ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ฒ , ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ฟ , ๐Ÿ‡น๐Ÿ‡ฏ ), ๐Ÿ‡ธ๐Ÿ‡ฆ , ๐Ÿ‡ด๐Ÿ‡ฒ , ๐Ÿ‡พ๐Ÿ‡ช

#

so yeah, have fun ๐Ÿ˜„

#

@ornate thunder dude your submissions are unreadable

#

just press F12

ornate thunder
#

im deleting anyway becauser my run os not complete

glacial stratus
ornate thunder
#

๐Ÿ™ thanks

glacial stratus
#

@dire pivot you also miss few territories, like Middle East , Bulgaria , Caucasus and Central Asia

solid gust
#

they're in school

glacial stratus
solid gust
#

I pinned zerkangar's as that was the most accurate representation of the required states

charred timber
dire pivot
#

My save local save of the game deleted itself... ๐Ÿ˜ญ
Is this a bug or can you find saves elsewhere?

#

Guess Ill have to do it all again ๐Ÿฅฒ

ornate thunder
#

How long until challenge ends?

solid gust
#

all challenges run for 2 weeks, unless I mention an extension

#

but as of now I do not have an extension in mind

glacial stratus
#

you have time until 19th of September

glacial stratus
#

Chak, will there be 1 winner slot or 3, as usual?

solid gust
#

3 as usual

inner orchid
#

is ok to swicht ideologis or i need to stay democratic the entire game?

ornate thunder
#

I think you need to stay democratic

bitter thistle
#

๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ

#

Chat I gotta win this challenge for that birthday dlc

glacial stratus
glacial stratus
inner orchid
#

oke

dire pivot
#

Go fascist/commuist ASAP with civil war, justify wargoals and flip dem

#

Thats the way

inner orchid
#

i am gonna do this challeng with peak music!!!๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ

fickle river
#

oh man, another insane challenge, another exploit stacking

glacial stratus
inner orchid
glacial stratus
empty lintel
#

the game i was currently doing i waited for 50% world tension

dire pivot
# empty lintel it seems hard to flip 2 times

Go for the two PP focusses first (Both politcal, cant remember names) hire fascist demagogue first, start civilwar and fire demagogue and hire democratic reformer. While fascist get alle your wars done, go for france & uk early, if you are good at micro you can defeat both before 1940

empty lintel
#

you need to be at peace

ornate thunder
#

naval

dire pivot
empty lintel
dire pivot
#

You only need one ship, if you declare war while they are at peace

#

It takes the AI 1 hour to deploy their navy

#

5 divs for france and uk the moment you declare

ornate thunder
#

this

dire pivot
#

Its hard to pull of, both invasions have to go well

#

And you must have extra divisions to help the invasions

empty lintel
dire pivot
empty lintel
#

lol

#

i'm going to try that later

dire pivot
#

Cant steal navys ๐Ÿ˜ฆ

#

It should be a part of the base game imo

naive wyvern
#

so its allowed to switch to anything other then democracy?

solid gust
#

you just cannot switch at the very end

#

to democratic

#

before then go wild

naive wyvern
#

for example we start non-aligned
switch to fascist
then in mid-run to democratic

#

is this ok?

dire pivot
solid gust
#

yes

empty lintel
#

does this count

dire pivot
#

18 jun 1942 ๐Ÿ‘€

solid gust
dire pivot
#

There are still ways to improve it tho

solid gust
#

its not the completed challenge but you're on the right path

dire pivot
#

Got pretty lucky with the RNG both the poish and japanese invaded the soviets

#

But I dont have La resistance so I cant make collabs on the soviets :/

dire pivot
solid gust
#

gustavo's

dire pivot
#

So mine is fine? Or do I need all of arabia?

solid gust
#

i didnt look at yours yet, i am working my 2nd job rn so poking my head in every now and again

dire pivot
ornate thunder
#

respect

empty lintel
#

i think my run is pretty screwed

#

lol

#

uk is on axis

dire pivot
dire pivot
#

So there are still room for improvements, but I sadly dont have the DLC ๐Ÿฅฒ

empty lintel
#

i literally have a 7k weapons deficit

#

lol

dire pivot
empty lintel
#

yes

dire pivot
#

Build ww1 riffles

#

and use them for your garrisons

#

And have a line of your better guns for your actual army

solid gust
#

burgers > work sometimes

dire pivot
solid gust
#

I work 3 jobs

#

I am a workaholic

#

I enjoy working too much

ornate thunder
#

anything missing?

dire pivot
#

Or how did you get their territories?? Damn.

empty lintel
#

is it necessary to get the territories as the image said

#

or you can just form persia and it should be valid

naive wyvern
dire pivot
ornate thunder
#

Justify on Soviet Union in the civil war

dire pivot
#

I used WAY too long to cap the soviets

ornate thunder
#

Good luck