#the_ukraine_situation

1 messages · Page 46 of 1

split aurora
#

and human rights violations from both sides

viral junco
#

They could likely hold em in the west and have them be big bargaining chips

split aurora
#

mhmm

#

no doubt russia will attempt a breakout

copper monolith
viral junco
#

Spread them out

paper cedar
#

Can't they send POWs back to their country or something?

#

or try to use them in a good way

viral junco
#

I read a thing in the kyiv independent earlier

split aurora
#

there are very strict rules for how POWs are held

viral junco
#

Apparently they're sending back the corpses of Russian soldiers for Ukrainian pow's

split aurora
#

They can be released back to russia, but russia would just draft them straight back

#

Best solution just to humanely keep them as prisoners till the wars end

paper cedar
#

Yeah but too many of them is also not a good thing

viral junco
#

Offer repatriation to those who are willing and jails to those who are war criminals

#

Is what likely will happen

#

But whataboutism never got anyone anywhere

paper cedar
#

hmm

#

I wonder if there is a chance to make POWs into their own army if they are willing to

#

like Russia POWs to Ukraine soldiers

viral junco
#

I mean there are a lot of soldiers who hate russia

paper cedar
#

yeah so convincing them to fight against them might work

viral junco
#

Like the conscription stuff then being sent to be made into meat shields

split aurora
#

I don't know if international law permits it

#

id be very surprised if it does

viral junco
#

I mean it is clear that international law is being thrown out the window

split aurora
#

due to the worry of coercion

split aurora
#

Both sides breaching international law is bad.

paper cedar
#

What could also work is to have russian POW sent back to Russia army and make the russian a spy for Ukraine

#

I wonder if that's already happening

viral junco
#

Yeah double agents have existed

#

In the past so it is likely to happen

copper monolith
split aurora
#

that sounds suicidal

copper monolith
#

ye

viral junco
#

If Russians shot him what happens then?

keen sorrel
#

Lots of angry words

copper monolith
#

maybe a couple inconsequential sanctions

keen sorrel
#

Plenty of twitter debate on whether any random nato articles apply

paper cedar
#

If that happens then Russia will have even higher consequences

split aurora
#

Lot of words, tensions rise, nothing really happens

#

imo

#

also if he was to die it'd be more likely just collateral damage then targeted

#

from riding into a city being shelled

clear creek
#

Hope this day wont be rememberd for another trategy in europe

copper monolith
#

hm?

clear creek
#

Brussels airlines atack of 22 march 2016

copper monolith
#

oh

viral junco
split aurora
#

standard response

viral junco
#

also somewhat good news

scarlet crown
#
#
leaden grove
leaden grove
#

Cf. the report by the AP

#

Well, it‘s a city under siege

#

The city does not exclusively consist of combatants

split aurora
#

no, but a huge part of it is

limber jolt
#

very easy to risk it going this far

copper monolith
split aurora
leaden grove
limber jolt
#

while neither side wants this, both sides will threaten it and push each other to a point where it's quite likely one might actually do it

#

that's the danger

leaden grove
#

Are you referring to a nuclear strike or something else?

limber jolt
#

first one

scarlet crown
#

probably yea

limber jolt
#

responding to someone who pinged me a while ago saying it was just fear mongering

#

the risks when two nuclear powers are in direct conflict are very real

scarlet crown
#

It is fear mongering

leaden grove
#

It is a valid concern

#

But at this point I don’t think the US will engage in any way

limber jolt
#

if there is an actual war between NATO and Russia, it may not escalate further, but it may also be the end of civilization as we know it

split aurora
#

"Saying a cop will shoot me after I slap him is just fearmongering"

limber jolt
#

and there's no way to know

split aurora
#

and with that imma go

leaden grove
split aurora
limber jolt
#

especially considering Russian plans that have since been declassified from the Cold War for an invasion of Europe literally involved using nuclear weapons and praying NATO wouldn't retaliate

leaden grove
#

Sadly I imagine this happens fairly often

split aurora
#

a Florida court recently defended a retired cop shooting a man dead

#

because the man threw popcorn at him

limber jolt
#

what the fuck

leaden grove
#

How

scarlet crown
#

It's Florida

split aurora
#

'murica

limber jolt
scarlet crown
#

Everything you'd think would never happen, happens in Florida

limber jolt
#

if any NATO member starts fighting that's dragging basically all of NATO into the war

#

if it's offensive it's not as certain

#

iirc

#

nothing in the treaty for NATO actually says that countries have to support each other if they attack first iirc

#

but it is a defensive alliance

scarlet crown
#

still would be a very coward move to just leave a member hanging

limber jolt
#

the reason our civilization has come so close to destroying itself in the past is because leaders didn't want to take actions that would make them look "weak"

split aurora
#

nato members never supported eachother agressively

#

you didn't see germans marching through derry, or italians in algeria

limber jolt
#

NATO doesn't want to look like the aggressor, individual members can, but the organization as a whole doesn't

scarlet crown
#

so attacking the aggressor makes you an aggressor?

split aurora
#

yes

#

thats.... just how the meaning of the word works

#

you may be justified, but you're still an agressor

#

if you didn't have an alliance/guarantee with the original defendant

limber jolt
#

^

#

basically if you're the one attacking first, barring any other war that's going on, NATO doesn't guarantee that other members will help you

#

as in, regardless of who started a conflict, if a NATO member gets involved without being directly attacked the rest of NATO isn't obligated to help

#

when people say that the idea that a war between NATO and Russia could destroy civilization is fear mongering, my response is that, if that's true, how come both sides were so afraid during the Cold War from directly fighting?

#

that's the situation we've gone back to here

#

the only difference is that in pretty much every other way Russia is far weaker than it was when the Cold War started

leaden grove
split aurora
#

agressor simply means

#

the one who started the hostilities

#

Russia started hostilities between russia and ukraine

#

but if nato fired the first shot between nato and russia

#

then nato would be the agressor

#

as our shot changes the situation from peace to war

#

if you invaded a fascist state to stop a genocide

#

you'd still be the agressor, as you invaded them

#

even if theres a very good chance you'd be fully morally justified

leaden grove
#

But who’s seriously talking about invading Russia

split aurora
#

A no-fly zone counts as an act of war against russia

#

and that's being talked about!

#

That would make us agressor

zinc talon
#

@scarlet crown hey, how are things going for you?

leaden grove
#

There‘s a difference between invading a country and a no-fly zone

split aurora
#

Of course, but both are acts of war

leaden grove
#

If a full no-fly zone were imposed, that would at most mean taking out air defenses on Russian territory

scarlet crown
leaden grove
#

And that‘s assuming you go for a full no-fly zone which seems unlikely at the moment

#

From what I‘ve heard even Poland‘s suggestions don’t call for a countrywide military mission

zinc talon
leaden grove
#

Btw ein, do you still have school? How‘s that being organised?

hushed magnet
#

make sure you look after yourself and take breaks if you need to

scarlet crown
scarlet crown
#

ehhhh

leaden grove
#

Fairs

#

I’ve heard of a lot of Ukrainian refugees here still taking part in online lessons at home

scarlet crown
#

Yea that is true

#

only thing is most people don't really take it seriously

#

especially graduating grades

leaden grove
#

I can imagine

hushed magnet
#

yeah i imagine itd be hard to take it seriously

leaden grove
#

Though I’ve heard that supposedly people will be able to take their final exams from abroad too

scarlet crown
#

It's an odd feeling to try and sit there to learn while knowing what's happening in the other parts of the country

#

hearing air raid sirens

leaden grove
#

Yeah…

scarlet crown
#

ministry of education still can't decide how they'll remake final exams and uni applications in these conditions!

leaden grove
#

Probably all a bit chaotic right now

scarlet crown
#

first they say they will cancel them

#

then they say it'll be online but without computers..

leaden grove
#

hmm, weird

scarlet crown
#

it's a mess that I'll look into when dust settles

#

for now it's just a blur

#

I try to at least be present for most classes, but aside from that, there's nothing truly mandatory

#

homework you can do if you wish to, but even that varies from teacher to teacher

copper monolith
#

how many pupils attending school rn?

scarlet crown
#

so yea

scarlet crown
#

RIA news making a post about destroyed ukrainian tech and using a picture of ruined occupant tech...

#

they're not even trying anymore

#

well that's interesting..

#
copper monolith
limber jolt
#

@scarlet crown I hope things get better for you and your country

#

out of curiosity, do you speak only Ukrainian and English, or Russian too?

scarlet crown
#

they will get better pal, this war claims our rebirth

limber jolt
#

I ask only because I speak some Russian, and my family comes from a part of Russia pretty close to the border with Ukraine, we have family in both countries

scarlet crown
limber jolt
#

makes sense

scarlet crown
#

i don't remember how I learned english, just blame unsupervised internet access

limber jolt
#

I've been able to sometimes piece together a bit of Ukrainian but not that much

limber jolt
scarlet crown
limber jolt
#

well both sides are Russian, grew up in the USSR, I guess a mix of Russian, Ukrainian, etc.

#

we all hate Putin and have for a while

leaden grove
#

My grandparents grew up in Stalin’s Soviet Union so it’s been a bit harder to deal with them

limber jolt
#

my parents grew up under Brezhnev in the USSR

limber jolt
#

my dad was actually drafted into the Soviet Army at one point in the 1980s

#

they moved to America in the mid-late 90s

copper monolith
#

my dad brought up his service in the soviet army earlier today, how they would wake up early in the morning and exercise in the -30C cold... no thanks

limber jolt
#

he was in the Soviet Army around the time they were invading Afghanistan, but wasn't actually sent there

leaden grove
#

My grandpa was born in Kyiv but spent WW2 in Kazakhstan as a child before returning, my grandma is from a small town near Vladivostok but later ended up moving to Kyiv after a brief stint in Odesa

limber jolt
#

apparently other family members were involved in the cleanup at Chernobyl

leaden grove
#

Oh wow

#

Back when my grandpa was young he was more or less excused from military service because he was a university student

copper monolith
limber jolt
#

my grandmother lived in Rostov

#

grandmother on my mom's side, the only surviving grandparent I have

#

she lived under nazi occupation when she was like 4

leaden grove
#

He told me that they only received very basic training and were then sent to repair various electric stations across Ukraine (he studied electrical engineering)

limber jolt
#

her father was killed fighting in the war

leaden grove
copper monolith
limber jolt
#

not that I know of

copper monolith
limber jolt
#

involvement wasn't actually being at Chernobyl, but more iirc one of them was an engineer decontaminating vehicles and such

copper monolith
#

ah

leaden grove
#

Oh yeah

limber jolt
#

and my dad's side of the family was in a village near Kursk

#

during ww2

#

you may have heard of the battle of Kursk

leaden grove
#

Yeah

limber jolt
#

the village they were in was occupied by the Germans, although his dad was saying that those soldiers were just German Army and actually kinda... nice?

#

as in, they treated them like actual humans

#

not like the SS would

#

lots of people from former Soviet countries here wow

leaden grove
#

My dad‘s side of the family is Baltic German/Estonian though I know a lot less about that since both of my grandparents on that side are dead, though I still get to have an Estonian last name

limber jolt
#

and since I speak Russian, I was listening to Putin's speeches when the war started and can confirm that he has gone completely insane

stark inlet
#

Uh oh

leaden grove
#

Yeah, but his essay last year was like that too

stark inlet
#

Iirc maersk controls 30-35% of port logistics in russia

leaden grove
#

It‘s all about his legacy and whatnot

limber jolt
#

tbh I think it's more a vague "justification" for a strategic move that really doesn't care about the people in either country

#

because he's a dictator now

#

he just doesn't care anymore about the people

#

probably never did

leaden grove
#

Yeah

#

I really don’t think there’s any rational explanation for this war

#

It’s mainly based on him projecting his fears and historical ambitions onto other countries

limber jolt
#

the only explanation I can think of is Russia was trying to make a strategic move of some sort, as an example, gaining control of Black Sea ports, or Ukraine is one of the largest food suppliers in Europe, so it's entirely possible Russia's trying to become completely self sufficient

#

so that economic sanctions hurt them less

#

what Putin didn't expect if that's the case was uh... the West instantly destroying Russia's economy as well as the Ukrainian military being actually good

leaden grove
#

Yeah, but they could achieve that food-wise without any extra land

limber jolt
#

not if your entire country is so corrupt it's kinda funny

leaden grove
#

The main thing that can’t produce is high-tech goods, which mainly affects various vehicles and the military

limber jolt
#

yeah more likely this is just straight up imperialism

leaden grove
stark inlet
#

Russia wanted to resurrect the soviet union geopolitically

leaden grove
#

If he wanted to back away he would have

stark inlet
#

Turns out theyll only rez it economically lmao

limber jolt
#

not necessarily, but return themselves to the influence they had in the world definitely

stark inlet
#

Back in the 70s

leaden grove
#

And if he really cared about what Russians think, he likely would have only invaded the entirety of the Donbas and called it a day

limber jolt
#

that's what I thought he was going to do

#

like, that's still bad

leaden grove
#

Yeah

limber jolt
#

but it's not largest land war in Europe since ww2 bad

leaden grove
#

But Russian propaganda has been drumming up for war against the entirety of Ukraine for a very long time

limber jolt
#

my mom has described pretty correctly imo the current Russian government as being pretty much fascist

#

full blown totalitarianism and nationalism

leaden grove
#

I mean, they are returning to Stalinist-like measures

#

Such as the new laws and the denunciation website one party launched

limber jolt
#

I wouldn't call Stalin fascist, not really

#

fascism is a form of totalitarianism but not totalitarianism itself

#

it's as if they went to Stalinist measures but on the far right instead of left

leaden grove
#

The boundary is a bit blurry

limber jolt
#

like they went the complete opposite economically

#

but exactly the same politically

leaden grove
#

I assume you‘re referring to Nazi Germany?

limber jolt
#

when talking about Fascism, yes

#

or Mussolini's Italy

leaden grove
#

Their main economic goal was becoming independent from other countries

limber jolt
#

there's a joke I have told about Stalin before

#

"Stalin was egalitarian, everyone had an equal chance of going to the gulag"

leaden grove
#

Lmao

limber jolt
#

some Russian political jokes are genuinely the funniest thing I've ever seen

leaden grove
#

They‘re pretty great

limber jolt
#

because whoever is saying them knows full well that they could be arrested and put in jail for telling those jokes

leaden grove
#

Oh, there‘s this amazing short story called Grandpa and the Partisans

limber jolt
#

oh I don't think I've heard this one

leaden grove
#

It’s set in 1950s Estonia and deals with the narrator‘s grandpa, who is a Kolhoz chairman by day and spends his nights building bunkers for the local partisans and then watching them

#

It’s very funny but also touches on partisans in general as well as Soviet security services

limber jolt
#

there's a joke I remember seeing

leaden grove
#

It’s like eight pages, I might scan it someday

limber jolt
#

"A judge walks out of a courtroom: 'I just heard the funniest joke ever!' 'What was it?' 'I can't tell you, I just gave someone 10 years for it!' "

leaden grove
#

🤩

#

I‘m gonna get ready for tomorrow but thank you very much for the convo!

copper monolith
scarlet crown
#
#

Honestly not many believed he'd come so far

copper monolith
#

👀

split aurora
#

Most influential person in Europe

#

I'd say putin for starting the war is significantly more so

#

lmao

copper monolith
#

shh as of the 24th Russia is detached from Europe

split aurora
#

lol

#

First the UK now russia

#

Europe's challenging australia for smallest continent

scarlet crown
#

Zelenskiy's influence is actually inspiring

#

we've never had a president yet that raised Ukraine in the eyes of EU so much

split aurora
#

rather then positive/negative

scarlet crown
#

I get that, but still

#

don't want to attach any awards to putler

#

fuck the guy

#

fuck him

split aurora
#

hence why....

scarlet crown
#

yeah yeah we get it

#

it's always easy to move the world just by being a ruthless dictator, cool, ok

copper monolith
split aurora
#

They claim its as its purely "the most influential person of that year"

#

though.... take that as you will

copper monolith
#

sussy INFLUENCE sussy THIS sussy

split aurora
#

lmao

scarlet crown
#

Uniting people, urging the whole world to put an end to this ridiculous war

#

besides all odds and risk, still choosing to stay here with people

#

very inspiring

copper monolith
#

and inside the biggest target of a city, and after several assassination attempts by """highly trained""" assassins he still stays there

scarlet crown
#

With him, the whole world knows what Ukraine is, what we're made of

#

not again will we be asked "Ukraine? is that in Russia?"

#

this is a big turning point for us as a nation

#

perhaps once this war ends, we'll finally be able to get on EU standards of life

split aurora
#

Let's hope a recognisable ukraine comes out in other end

scarlet crown
#

rephrase please

copper monolith
#

like, not too destroyed

split aurora
#

Not too destroyed physically, or politically

scarlet crown
#

No one has guarantees for it, but I know for a fact that no matter how much damage will be done, we will repair

copper monolith
#

hopefully with both Russian and EU money, let me tell you the infrastructure upgrades we've had here in Lithuania are quite nice

split aurora
#

I can't see russia paying reperations

scarlet crown
#

yeah it is doubtful

copper monolith
#

while the tsar is sitting there, probably not

scarlet crown
#

I honestly have a feeling at times, that even if we win, they'll just go for the nuclear option

#

they don't know how it is to lose

#

it's beyond their pride

#

Facing reparations would essentially mean breaking the facade of propaganda

#

people will be in utter disbelief

split aurora
#

Ukraine has no leg to stand on to demand reperations

#

it could only do that... if russia had an incentive for a peace deal beyond just pulling out troops

#

eg: if ukraine was marching into russia

#

which I can't see happening

#

Russia marching all troops out of ukraine is the same as a peace deal "to go back to pre-war borders"

#

so Russia won't take a deal worse then that

#

unless ukraine is marching into russia, which again, I don't believe possible

#

sooooo Europeans poorest country will have to try and rebuild with its own money alone

grand pier
#

Europe's poorest country is Moldavia though

split aurora
#

Ah, moldova and ukraine are pretty much tied exactly

#

GDP per capita less then 1% apart

#

...though Kosovo is far lower, the source saying ukraine lowest must not recognise :/

scarlet crown
copper monolith
#

EU membership for Moldova and Russian army out of pls

grand pier
#

i know i'm going over there to volunteer in helping the rebuilding efforts

split aurora
#

gonna be honest as soon as this war ends, I expect them to refuse to give shit

#

the west doesn't care about ukraine

#

they care about being anti-russia

#

(west as in, western governments)

scarlet crown
#

damn sounds very similar to some kremlin narrative my guy

split aurora
#

It's not lmao

grand pier
split aurora
#

the west has had hundreds of proxy wars

#

against russia

#

I struggle to see how Ukraine is different

#

then say, afghanistan in the 80s

split aurora
#

as it drags ukraine firmly out of their sphere

grand pier
#

as a bonus yeah

#

have you considered they might actually care

split aurora
#

yes

grand pier
#

and just take the hurting of russia as a bonus objective

split aurora
#

and I consider the chance of that very unlikely

#

as it would contradict so much of the last 70years of european politics

grand pier
#

Almost as if in those 70 years a lot of things changed

scarlet crown
#

doesn't mean they shouldn't do something because they haven't done it earlier

split aurora
#

okay but

#

If theres a pattern

#

of dozens/hundreds of events

#

going the same way

#

consistently

#

for 70years

#

and a new event comes up

#

I'll believe it will go the same way

#

until proven otherwise

grand pier
#

there is never a guarentee it will go the same way

#

and thus i will believe it might not

split aurora
#

I want to see proof first

#

before expecting the end of the expected trend

scarlet crown
#

Then we just have to wait

grand pier
#

and i expect the trend to end and will just be dissapointed when it doesnt

split aurora
#

Plus, the west doesnt care about any of the other ongoing global conflicts

#

right now

#

some of which being far more destructive then ukraine

#

if the west suddenly cares so much about humanitarianism

#

why do they only care about 1 of the many ongoing conflicts

grand pier
#

ah, the good old whataboutism

split aurora
#

It's not

#

You're argument is, the west has changed

#

but

#

every piece of evidence

#

suggests

#

they haven't

#

I am citing evidence lmfao

#

whattabouitsm has become a word for "i dont want to hear your argument"

grand pier
#

And what things is the west not caring about according to you?

split aurora
#

The genocide in Yemen

#

The genoicde in Palestine

#

the tigray war

#

the mass humanitarian crisis in afghanistan

#

the wars across the sahara

split aurora
#

British jets sold to the saudi's are involved in the deaths of thousands

#

all of these are ongoing events

grand pier
# split aurora The genocide in Yemen

condemned and objected to by at least my government and i'm pretty sure several others but also very little to be done about it while the world economy still depends on the saudi oil

split aurora
#

the USA and Uk are the backbone of it

#

UK jets and US military guidance attack civilian targets daily

grand pier
split aurora
#

Yes of course it is, but I still class it as a genocide, that the west is supporting

#

🤷‍♂️

#

anyway, this is wildly off topic

grand pier
split aurora
#

imma hop off now

grand pier
grand pier
# split aurora the tigray war

Pretty sure both parties declined help from the west in this though i'd have to research it more, have not really followed the news on it beyond headlines

hollow hollow
#

nations really only care about humanitarian crises that have strategic value to them, sad but it’s the truth

#

europe and the us need ukraine to win this, but they don’t really care about yemen

scarlet crown
#
copper monolith
#

god damn fucking animal

hushed magnet
#

jesus christ

icy ridge
#

Fucking hell

#

Also does this mean World War II is basically back on for just Russia and Japan?

viral junco
#

@icy ridge its regarding the kuril islands

copper monolith
#

technically those 2 countries never signed treaties, so WW2 technically didn't completely end

#

its dumb

copper monolith
hollow hollow
#

did anyone ever find those il-76s that supposedly got shot down? i think us intelligence confirmed at least one of them, and they’ve been pretty reliable so far, but i also have difficulty believing that no one found a flaming fucking cargo plane wreck in the middle of a field

copper monolith
#

feb 26th

#

oh fuck it's just an archived live page

hollow hollow
#

yeah that, it’s a little hard for me to believe it without hard evidence

#

a wreck like that would be a really easy find

#

but who knows, maybe the russians got to it first and didn’t let any images out, idk

copper monolith
#

hm, so far seems that all sources point to Ukrainian officials

#

the top google search for il-76 shot down

#

but considering how fucked the Russian tech is, and how much modern NATO armament is flowing into Ukraine, I wouldn't be surprised

copper monolith
fierce arch
#

ukraine is a european country

#

with strong ties to the west

#

no shit that its been getting more attention

#

are we all supposed to pretend this isnt happening and go focus on yemen

#

many of those conflicts have been dragging on for years if not decades. are you surprised when they get less attention

fierce arch
limber jolt
#

yes but Russia and Japan have a history is my point, and I'm not sure if either really liked the treaty signed from that

#

specially considering Russia then collapsed a few years later and Japan was invading Russian territory during the Russian Civil War iirc

limber wagon
limber wagon
#

"no u"

#

In other news

#

New boat. Lots of UAV's today and yesterday. over 100 planes lost.

#

Also it feels like there has been quite a bit of artillery lost in the last week

viral junco
#

Another boat down

scarlet crown
#

how can he even be a minister of foreign affairs

limber wagon
#

I assume its mostly for internal reasons, and has barely anything to do with talking to foreign countries. It would look weird if there is one government official that talks very differently than the government mandated propaganda

nocturne osprey
scarlet crown
scarlet crown
#
clear pebble
#

Tomorrow is the 1 month mark... just so weird to think about

copper monolith
zinc talon
copper monolith
limber wagon
#

it always reduces NATO to just the US and then pretends as if they 'conquered' or strong-armed or whatever those countries in to joining.

copper monolith
#

gee I wonder why NATO expanded by accepting the countries that gained independence from the USSR

#

why would they join nato instead of russia's economic union FlushEyes

limber wagon
#

Instead of ya know, joined themselves because they thought it was a smart idea.

#

This take

limber wagon
# limber wagon This take

And this is kinda what I mean. They're talking as if NATO is just the US, as if a verbal agreement from the US, not NATO has any meaning and as if the USSR is the same as Russia

copper monolith
# limber wagon This take

kremlin should've hired someone that actually speaks english instead of putting this text through google translate

#

too cheap to even ask their RT division 😔

limber wagon
#

Hang on, I've got another incredibly based take

#

Oh, and my dad actually unironically shared this in our family group chat

zinc talon
copper monolith
copper monolith
split aurora
#

also like

#

Hypothetically speaking, if we were to accept that (and I'm not saying we should accept it outside the hypothetical) NATO agreed not to expand, and they violated that, and that they provoked russia against nato

#

in what fucking world would that justify an invasion

split aurora
#

even if you give the maximum possible hypothetical beliefs to these guys

#

the idea instantly breaks down

zinc talon
limber wagon
split aurora
#

because he brought a knife into bed

#

lmfao

fierce arch
split aurora
copper monolith
zinc talon
#

i can't listen to people justifying this anymore. There are so many contradictions and false claims..

split aurora
#

Also I love their flip flopping between justifications

#

"Ukraine is producing WMDs at Chernobyl!"
Captures Chernobyl
Never mentions the issue again or provides a shred of evidence

mighty tusk
#

NATO and America might as well be interchangable in this kind of convo

limber wagon
#

I wont deny that the US largely leads NATO, but its not just the US

mighty tusk
#

America is the leader of the West and is the major reason NATO can exist

#

NATO also therefore almost never does something we do not want

split aurora
#

the USA breaking a promise isn't the same as NATO breaking a promise

#

lmfao

mighty tusk
#

It might as well be the US Allies Club

limber wagon
#

and also they are different entities

mighty tusk
#

yes it is, because anything NATO does is kind of what the US wants and is definitely approved by the US

zinc talon
mighty tusk
#

by your definition shadow govts can never exist

split aurora
#

California is one of the most powerful states in the USA, but california doing something is not the same as the USA doing something

in the same way, the USA doing something is not NATO doing something

#

NATO doing something, if it was authorised by X member, would be similar but not the same as X member doing something alone

zinc talon
split aurora
#

^

mighty tusk
#

USA doesn't listen to most authorization period

We are an imperialist militarist country with the biggest military budget

We break shit all the time

#

Saying that the US actually needs other NATO countries to agree on their own is kind of naive imo because it doesn't look at outside factors

#

for instance, bribes, takeovers of countries, threats on their own, things we do not see in international conflict

zinc talon
mighty tusk
#

and the fact of the matter is, if US wants it, it is usually going to go for it

limber wagon
#

I swear, what is this take

#

The difference

#

Yeah, the US has a lot of control and power, but they are not the same

mighty tusk
#

omfg you dont read

#

You don't need them to be the same thing for one to basically control the decision making

limber wagon
#

And those countries that joined NATO, they did not join the US, the US didn't pressure them, they joined on their own volition.

mighty tusk
#

because turns out not being allies with a super giant militarized country is not a great idea yeah

#

I don't get the take that that is a good thing

limber wagon
mighty tusk
#

I don't think the ally system is ever a good idea

#

And I always believe there is centralized power in the end

#

ah yes the organization says that

which is a great thing to do

"Hey (organization), are you an asshole?"

"No"

#

my take is naturally more conspiracist than "oh what do they say on their page" frankly

limber wagon
#

what even are you rambling about?

#

its making no sense

mighty tusk
#

Uhuh

zinc talon
copper monolith
#

@mighty tuskpls cease

mighty tusk
#

bruh

copper monolith
#

anyways, a thing from #872103408285417534 that was posted a couple days ago, Rogozin managed to get 2 rivals in the space industry to work together https://twitter.com/OneWeb/status/1505892782224904196

We are pleased to announce that we have entered into a launch agreement with @SpaceX that will enable OneWeb to resume satellite launches.

The first launch with SpaceX is anticipated later this year.

Find out more about the announcement at:
https://t.co/qvSAOIP04n

Likes

5085

Retweets

732

#

manchild proceeded to have a meltdown

limber wagon
#

Happened on the same day

copper monolith
#

thank u rogozin for moving extra funding for ur space agency to another private one owned by some 50 year old meme lord

mighty tusk
#

i think countries are trying to make way for a more capitalist "competitive space system (and eventual economy), which sucks

zinc talon
#

one can only love german twitter. People keep debating about azov and right wing groups being equipped with german weapons

limber wagon
#

Oh yeah, I can imagine

#

Things must be pretty ... spicy there lol

copper monolith
#

luckily only half of german weapons work haHAA

split aurora
#

double your odds

limber wagon
split aurora
#

I like how this is just a showdown of soviet tech

#

russia has soviet tech

#

ukraine has soviet tech

#

eastern europe is sending soviet tech

#

this is just a dumping ground for the worlds excess soviet tech

limber wagon
#

It makes sense, less totally new and unfamilair stuff or some things even very similar as the current stuff

split aurora
#

plus a lot of its in the process of being phased out

limber wagon
#

Otherwise you would need to train people in how to use your stuff. So if you've got stuff they already know how to use, then thats great

split aurora
#

might as well send it to someone who will use it rather then landfill

limber wagon
#

Yeah

split aurora
#

and hey in warfare, older reliable kit can often be better then newer flashy stuff

#

theres a reason every 3rd world nation and or rebel group uses ak patterns

limber wagon
#

When in doubt, use rock

#

and when you think about it, a bullet is just a fancy rock

split aurora
#

Rock but shiny

#

and fast!

copper monolith
#

then find better alternatives to energy asap you loser

limber wagon
#

Wasn't there some deal with Qatar? dunno the specifics

zinc talon
queen valley
#

Nuclear plants may have a bad vibes
But atleast they aint using gas and oil from russia

split aurora
#

still working out specifics

#

likely no gas will flow for a while yet

limber wagon
#

Nuclear power isn't really a short term solution though. it takes time to build a nuclear power plant. or even restarting closed ones can take months

split aurora
#

40% of exports come from those top 3

limber wagon
#

Honestly, one of the only short term options is either somehow reducing oil/gas usage or getting it from a different source.

#

short/immediate term

#

I wonder if Norway could temporarily supply Europe with extra oil

#

Since they are a tad closer than Qatar

split aurora
#

thats gas specifically, not oil*

#

both the UK and Norway still make quite a bit of oil iirc

#

norway makes 1.7mn, uk 0.95mn barrels per day, as of 2020

limber wagon
#

Just trying to install a shit tonne of solar panels in a relatively short time might also be a fairly quick thing to do.

#

They're relatively cheap, a lot get manufactured already and they're simple to install

zinc talon
split aurora
split aurora
limber wagon
#

Yeah

split aurora
#

this could cause either a mass pullout, or a big stabilising force on the ruble

limber wagon
#

But from my understanding, doesn't he want more foreign currency? to actually buy stuff?

split aurora
#

He wants payment in ruble, to push the value of the currency up

limber wagon
#

My understanding of the economics of this is kinda limited, so I'm not really getting how this would work

split aurora
#

Consistent massive payments in rubles for gas/oil will do wonders of the value of a ruble

#

I think!

#

Economics weird!

limber wagon
#

Ah, that could make sense

split aurora
#

I Think as like, it builds confidence in the currency

#

people know there's gonna be continous mass usage and spending of rubles

#

which makes value go up

limber wagon
#

But then those countries will burn through their reserve of Rubles right?

copper monolith
#

value already going up, fuk

limber wagon
#

And with all those sanctions I can imagine its kinda hard to get more

split aurora
#

Honestly I know fuck all about economics

limber wagon
# copper monolith value already going up, fuk

I wouldn't worry too much about that value tbh. Those sanctions are in a way preventing it from changing, and no doubt Russia is also doing whatever it can to prevent it from going in to freefall

split aurora
#

I've tried to understand it but my brain just refuses to grasp it

limber wagon
split aurora
#

yeaaah

zinc talon
#

on that matter

split aurora
#

I think part of the this issue as well is quite how asymmetrical cutting off gas imports would be

#

Turning off rhe gas would hurt german companies a lot more then American ones, and Germany doesn't want to see domestic brands replaced by American competitors

#

issues like that have to be patched before united decisions on more sanctions can be made

zinc talon
copper monolith
#

but can your face be defended from my fist

viral junco
#

Nato needs to get in now since they said they'd be involved should chemical weapons be used

split aurora
#

I don't think its classes as chemical warfare internationally

#

as white phosphorus is used in every tracer round and smoke bomb

#

its just classes as a standard industrial chemicalb

limber wagon
#

It does if its used as a bomb or weapon

#

How its used is very important

viral junco
#

WP literally burns off skin Charlotte

limber wagon
#

e

split aurora
#

I was just searching for that lmao

#

sooo depends how its being used

#

and against what targets

copper monolith
split aurora
#

we don't know either of those

#

I hope its not civilian targets

#

though In this war it very likely could be

split aurora
#

so that's a lot of collateral damage

#

:/

#

a civilian firing out of their house makes that a valid military target, but the precision of russian weapons could wipe out the whole street aiming at the 1 valid target

limber wagon
#

We learned today that companies do give in to demands after they've gotten hacked

split aurora
#

good

#

I'm glad they are still selling medicinal products, as well

copper monolith
#

mhm

#

they should like, lower their prices so that the taxes that go to the government are insignificant

hollow hollow
limber wagon
#

I agree Russia

split aurora
#

lmfao

#

these people have zero self awareness by god

limber wagon
stark inlet
split aurora
#

wat

limber wagon
stark inlet
#

Iirc it more or less was about using wp on civilians

limber wagon
#

"Ethnicity based pandemics"

stark inlet
#

Pretty, uh graphic stuff was included there

copper monolith
queen valley
#

That literally sounds like the plot to a metal gear game, complete insanity to be hearing like this

split aurora
#

Russia's made extensive use of chemical warfare in Syria

#

I pray the same isn't brought to ukraine

viral junco
limber wagon
#

I saw this OSINT map from about 20 hours ago, so it seems possible I think?

split aurora
#

There was a few uncomfirmed reports of this the other night

hollow hollow
# stark inlet Iirc it more or less was about using wp on civilians

a little off topic, but i honestly thought that scene was really poorly executed because it literally forces the player to use the wp and then directly attacks the player (not the character) for doing so, i thought it was a really cheap move that kinda ruined the game

limber wagon
#

But that most be at least a few thousand soldiers I imagine

hollow hollow
limber wagon
#

Found another very accurate map lol

split aurora
#

lmfao

copper monolith
#

wtf is that near Lviv

limber wagon
#

I assume those are all the areas where conflict is happening according to them. Since there were a few missiles there

#

But then there is transnistria, a very real and existent front

scarlet crown
split aurora
#

theres russian troops on the border but I don't think nay have crossed into ukraine

#

might be wrong

scarlet crown
scarlet crown
#

yeah there hasn't been any movement recorded from there

limber wagon
#

There are 1500 static troops stationed there iirc.

scarlet crown
#

literally wasteland looking

#

burnt and broken buildings, grey terrain

lilac sparrow
scarlet crown
#

russian news yell all around that famous canadian sniper Wali was killed, he posted this pic in response

copper monolith
#

lmao

split aurora
#

what are the bets he gets poisoned before the decade ends

scarlet crown
#

the odds are hella high, but this is a big move

zinc talon
zinc talon
scarlet crown
#

The fuck is ethnicity based pandemic

#

A fucking ukrainian-only virus??

limber wagon
#

A virus that would only infect a certain group of people

lilac sparrow
#

Literal plot to metal gear V

limber wagon
#

But its a thing that doesn't exist, and likely isn't possible

scarlet crown
#

So ridiculous

#

They're just not gonna stop with "WEST FOUNDED BIOLABS!!!" are they

limber wagon
#

Because "ethnicities" aren't a yes/no thing. Its a gradient.

lilac sparrow
#

It is technically possible, rather the antibodies need to be present in some parts of the world rather than the other

limber wagon
#

And with the way virusses evolve there is also no way to stop them from infecting the rest after a while

#

So thats just stupid and no one wants to develop something like that

split aurora
#

yeah its fantasy technology

#

It was literally the plot of Sapienza in Hitman

limber wagon
split aurora
#

plus "ethnicity" is a very hard thing to categorise or measure

lilac sparrow
#

Yea

limber wagon
#

Or the fact that you would be targeting civilians as well and people of the target ethnicity living in other countries

limber wagon
zinc talon
split aurora
#

https://twitter.com/jseldin/status/1506646337856675842
Jeff Seldin, poster, is a security correspondent for the USA state owned Voice of America radio broadcaster

BREAKING: 7,000-15,000 #Russia|n troops likely killed in #Ukraine, per a @NATO official briefing reporters on condition of anonymity

Total losses -including wounded, captured or missing- could be in the 30,000-40,000 range

Estimates based on #Ukraine intel, observations

limber wagon
#

So those are the official USA™️ estimates?

scarlet crown
#

Which are heavily relying on ukrainian intel

split aurora
lilac sparrow
#

Damn, Russia has lost more soldiers in almost a month than america has while in war for 20 year

zinc talon
lilac sparrow
#

I think the 7-15k are casualties which sometimes involve the wounded personnel

scarlet crown
#

I'd count wounded as killed too since it's very common for them to leave soldiers behind

limber wagon
#

There is a lot of arguing to be had about the terms. I think 'losses' generally means anything killed, destroyed, incapacitated or captured.

#

And big enough injuries can fall under that

split aurora
#

30-40k losses

#

losses is anything that puts a soldier out of the fight

#

Death, major injury, capture, surrender

limber wagon
#

Kyiv Independent uses the term losses as well, and the 7k-15k figure seems to correspond to Ukraine's 15.6k estimate

#

But thats killed vs losses? So thats quite the disparity

zinc talon
split aurora
#

terminology is... vague

#

we wont know the full story till long after the last shot is fired

zinc talon
split aurora
#

"Man, this is a shit plan"

scarlet crown
#

god, the way he tries to speak english

zinc talon
#

that smudge smile

scarlet crown
#

there, he just fucking said it, the main goal is to get rid of ukraine's military

#

another question is, why?

#

who gave them the right for it

#

why would ukrainian military be an issue in the first place

zinc talon
scarlet crown
#

jesus

#

they really believe these damn lies

#

god his fucking lies about Mariupol

#

sickening

#

i'll stop watching, i can't

#

to see this old deranged fuck say all that with a smile

#

I feel like the cnn reporter is really trying to hold herself together too, no one likes to be told genuine fucking lies in their face while you know the truth

zinc talon
#

I'd be better getting of twitter for today..

scarlet crown
#
scarlet crown
#
copper monolith
#

Use code WENDOVER16 for up to 16 FREE MEALS + 3 Surprise Gifts across 6 HelloFresh boxes plus free shipping at https://bit.ly/3ekejvZ

Watch Extremities at http://youtube.com/extremities

Buy a Wendover Productions t-shirt: https://standard.tv/collections/wendover-productions/products/wendover-productions-shirt

Subscribe to Half as Interesting ...

▶ Play video
icy ridge
#

How is Kyiv, Mariupol and Odessa doing?

copper monolith
#

almost W

scarlet crown
#

Odesa is calm, occasional explosions but most of the rockets get struck with air defences

#

Kyiv seems to be fine, shelling still continues on residential areas

#

Mariupol is still in a blockade, although there's been some progress with evacuating people

#

russian forces make it near impossible to solve the humanitarian crisis there

#

from intel service of Ukraine, it seems that syrians are being hesitant on fighting in Ukraine after hearing about high russian losses

copper monolith
#

lmao

scarlet crown
#

previously promised 300-600$ don't sound all that exciting now

copper monolith
#

⚡️ Swedish Defense Minister: Ukraine to receive 5,000 anti-tank weapons.

The TT news agency quoted Swedish Defense Minister Peter Hultqvist saying that the country will provide additional anti-tank equipment.

Likes

763

Retweets

148

⚡️ Baerbock: further Strela missiles are on their way to Ukraine.

According to German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock, the country will provide Ukraine with Strela surface-to-air missiles, after weeks of delivery delays.

Likes

6668

Retweets

1158

limber wagon
#

Thats quite the ratio

#

87.3% of all buildings destroyed in Kharkiv are residential

viral junco
#

Peace keeping btw

limber wagon
#

of course

#

I'm sure there were Neo nazi's or equipment in all of those buildings

hollow hollow
scarlet crown
#

wheeezeeee

scarlet crown
# scarlet crown from intel service of Ukraine, it seems that syrians are being hesitant on fight...
limber wagon
#

I guess they don't like dying, starving and/or getting frostbite

viral junco
hollow hollow
#

if anyone ever sees or hears from sergei shoigu again after his recent “”””heart problems””””, i will eat a stop sign, no cap

scarlet crown
#
stark inlet
#

Heart stopping after jumping off a window/getting shot/whatever is still a heart problem

hollow hollow
stark inlet
#

Aww how cute they were good friends

scarlet crown
#
limber wagon
copper monolith
#

is that a Ukrainian version of Rammstein's Sonne

hollow hollow
scarlet crown
#

👀 what do we have here

#

now this

#

this is cool

#

i think someone already sent this here before

copper monolith
#

fricc

stark inlet
copper monolith
scarlet crown
#

needs some gas and a lighter

copper monolith
#

hell yeah

hollow hollow
#

gyas

latent willow
copper monolith
#

gaming

stark inlet
#

Gamers rise up

scarlet crown
#

hell yeah gamers

#

to help ukraine, get your moms credit card and write us numbers on the front, don't forget the funny numbers on the back!

stark inlet
#

Lmao

#

One of the major polish banks is already reporting that companies that left russia are making more money

#

Than companies that didnt quit

split aurora
low rover
#

Like you can’t make this shit up

#

How fucking insensitive can you be

scarlet crown
#

bruh

#

Honestly it's internet, no wonder people will try to hype on a fucking war

hushed magnet
#

yeah i mean i dont think its worth giving the attention atm

stark inlet
#

im pretty sure one of those graphs is leroy merlin vs either castorama or obi

#

afaik other than auchan there arent any significant chain stores staying in russia

#

that are also widely available in poland that is

#

btw castorama left russia in 2020 and obi did so 6 days ago

fierce arch
#

who are you criticizing im so confused

low rover
fierce arch
low rover
#

???

#

There’s no irony in this article

fierce arch
#

what the fuck do you mean

#

did you read the entire thing

low rover
#

Why are you being so apprehensive

#

Oh fuck i’m dumb

#

Nvm

#

Look it’s hard to detect when something is fake when you read literally the first four lines

#

I’m just gonna stay out of this channel from now on, i say nothing but shit that is wrong

hushed magnet
#

why would you post something here before even reading it???

low rover
#

Idkf

#

Im already having a bady day

scarlet crown
#

My guy it's better to stay offline then

low rover
#

I’m just gonna stay out of this channel, don’t @ me

scarlet crown
#

Forest fires are probably the last thing we'd want to be dealing with

hushed magnet
copper monolith
#

man

stark inlet
viral junco
#

thats only moscow though

stark inlet
#

there was nothing about avtovaz (Lada), which belongs to the renault group

#

and iirc its the largest carmaker in russia

viral junco
#

it is

#

soviet era car dealership bought by em during the privatisation

split aurora
#

if they shut lada it'll like 90% be nationalised tbf

copper monolith
scarlet crown
copper monolith
#

a month already hollow

split aurora
#

we did it reddit

#

90 people are dead

copper monolith
#

man...

scarlet crown
# split aurora

It's officially a crime here now to share pictures/locations of military forces

#

About 8-9 years in jail for it afaik

split aurora
# split aurora

sadly stuff like this is the issue with volunteer forces and reservists

#

Sure you can teach them to fire a gun

#

but opsec, weapon maintenance, working as a unit, keeping cool under fire

#

both ukranian and Russian forces are struggling with the higher requirements of combat as the war drags on

hollow hollow
#

according to this website, ukraine has 520 confirmed vehicle/equipment losses, but has captured 652 confirmed equipment/vehicle captures. although unlikely, it's entirely possible that ukraine started out with less equipment than they currently have. https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-documenting-equipment.html

Oryx

By Stijn Mitzer in collaboration with Joost Oliemans Kemal , Dan and Jakub Janovsky     A detailed list of destroyed and captured vehicle...

copper monolith
scarlet crown
#

-1 ship

viral junco
#

More threats as per usual

scarlet crown
scarlet crown
#

Putin pressing on the button seems pretty real, but I doubt the commanding will allow the launch

#

It's just utter madness

limber wagon
#

They just want to remind us that 'hey, we have this thing'

#

The vagueness of what "feels" and "existential threat" means in this context is kinda telling

viral junco
#

The more one threatens the less threatening one sounds

limber wagon
#

Same with threatening every country that wants to join NATO. Sweden, Finland, Bosnia herzegovina

scarlet crown
#

I feel like this is going into another nuke discussion so all I'll say is that the threat is very minimal but we should take certain precautions

limber wagon
#

Yes

viral junco
#

Yes

scarlet crown
#

a little step away from the news to relax a bit: check out this cat I found

limber wagon
#

Kitten

#

Average daily since the 24th

viral junco
#

I presume special equip. Is about comms etc

limber wagon
#

Just a 'misc' category basically. With things like that and the bridge laying vehicles included

limber wagon
viral junco
#

Zelensky to speak to dáil éireann on the 6th

scarlet crown
#

wasn't everything going according to plan?

#

didn't sanctions only boost Russia and allowed it to focus on economy?

split aurora
#

the feel

zinc talon
split aurora
#

bye bye boat

scarlet crown
#

русский военный корабль, иди нахуй!

scarlet crown
#
copper monolith
#

Language genocide

scarlet crown
#

A ukrainian old man stole a russian supply truck and brought it to ukraine's military

copper monolith
#

охуенный дед

scarlet crown
#

they basically just spoiled the location of the ship

copper monolith
scarlet crown
copper monolith
hollow hollow
#

Deputy Defense Minister of #Ukraine Anna Malyar said that the destroyed warship in #Berdyansk could carry up to 20 tanks, 45 armored personnel carriers and 400 paratroopers.

Likes

2765

Retweets

470

copper monolith
#

holy fuck

#

so up to 400 troops + servicemen died on that ship

hollow hollow
#

it was in port, prob a lot less were on board

copper monolith
#

hm

scarlet crown
copper monolith
#

Ukraine's army did what no NATO army did before, utterly humiliate Russian forces

split aurora
#

I mean...

#

its not a bad thing that NATOs never had that chance

copper monolith
#

true

split aurora
#

quite the opposite

split aurora
#

The taliban defeated the USA in afghan

#

does that mean the taliban has a competent nato standard army?

#

defeating a powerful foe doesn't automatically mean you have a very powerful army

fierce arch
#

the taliban filled the power void when the us left afghanistan

split aurora
#

I mean - I do personally think the ukraine army is more then upto standard

#

I just don't think Zelenskys argument here is valid

fierce arch
#

and this is a full scale invasion, not a "us sends some tanks to a random country"

scarlet crown
#
clear creek
#

So like evry news outlet here is calling out the falure of Russian planning and logistics

copper monolith
#

we've been doing that for a month as well

clear creek
#

Well a month is a lot for a special miletary operation issend it

#

Espetialy for one of the greatist milletary powers on the planet

scarlet crown
#

british defence intelligence posted a map as of 24th of march

stark inlet
copper monolith
# stark inlet https://mobile.twitter.com/nexta_tv/status/1506977167003070474

from the footage of the alleged meeting of Security Council, person notes that the first and last 4 seconds of this clip are the same https://mobile.twitter.com/prof_preobr/status/1506973819822555145

Гостелеканалы показали (без звука) кадры якобы сегодняшнего заседания СовБеза, где присутствовал Шойгу (он в верхнем левом углу путинского монитора).

Ролик - 100% консервы.
Просто обратите внимание: первые 4 секунды и последние 4 секунды видео - это ОДНИ И ТЕ ЖЕ кадры.

Likes

2659

Retweets

518

▶ Play video
hollow hollow
#

he dead for sure

scarlet crown
#

or just fled

viral junco
#

Some refugees have arrived in my town

#

My school is going to be bringing in 2 new students tomorrow

hollow hollow
viral junco
#

They aren't in my year, but I hope things can be good for them

hollow hollow
copper monolith
leaden grove
copper monolith
limber wagon
#

I'm sure it will work this time /s

copper monolith
split aurora
#

wouldn't be too surprising

#

the west's continued pressure is required to stop russia

#

and the west's unity is fragile

copper monolith
leaden grove
split aurora
#

I saw an image of him in a video call the day before he resigned, man looked absolutely broken

#

can't blame him <3

viral junco
#

thread above

leaden grove
#

This is a really good investigation

copper monolith
#

good video

hollow hollow
copper monolith
#

call of duty

scarlet crown
#

https://t.me/verkhovnaradaofukraine/1878 The legends are set free!

leaden grove
copper monolith
split aurora
scarlet crown
#

but probably far away from the body

copper monolith
#

brutal

unreal path
scarlet crown
#

It's barely even funny at this point

unreal path
#

Russia brought up NATO's intervention against Yugoslavia -_- yeah...and your point is?

#

oh and they said why didn't you guys vote in favor of our humanitarian resolution at the UNSC....I wonder why

copper monolith
#

Therefore it's fine for us to bomb children 5Head

scarlet crown
#
unreal path
#

like is Russia condemning NATO? then okay then we can condemn Russia ablobthinking guys they uses cruse missiles against Yugoslavia so why can't we use cluster bombs :/

#

a lion and a wolf? O _O

unreal path
scarlet crown
paper cedar
unreal path
#

I found a part where Denmark is speaking on the behave of the Nordic and Baltic countries

paper cedar
#

hmm

paper cedar
unreal path
#

basically it was something to do with humanitarian action but there was nothing in it about Russia and Ukraine wasn't even part of the forming of the draft realted to L3