#Community Species Suggestions

1 messages · Page 3 of 1

heavy scarab
#

Are there any armored dinosaurs that could be alternate genera for Ankylosaurus like maybe Pinacosaurus

slim flare
#

No

#

Also Ankylosaurus is already in the game, it’s not getting alt genera

feral cedar
#

Is the refusal to add alt genera to existing species on behalf of the devs rooted in the fact that they take up one skin slot

#

So adding something like Centrosaurus would functionally give Styracosaurus 4 skins

slim flare
#

They don’t want to go back

limber nexus
deep lake
#

Girant e m o

slim flare
feral cedar
#

ngl I think the ankylosaurid roster could be expanded

#

Euoplocephalus as its own thing and then Tarchia tumanovae and teresae with a Pinacosaurus alt

low bridge
#

Who wants Alamosaurus in Prehistoric Kingdom???

#

I think that he would skyrocket in game

slow shoal
#

it def doesnt come to mind when i think of sauropods I want

low bridge
#

That should light everything that why is he needed anyways

slow shoal
#

i dont agree its needed

#

id much rather more unique sauropods

low bridge
#

Worldwide Alamo

low bridge
slow shoal
low bridge
#

That was joke ik that he is N.A

#

Bustingorrytitan from Huincul formation should be expansion animal

limber nexus
slow shoal
#

pmuch the only sauropods i want are diplodocus (maybe with baro alt), amargasaurus, and mamenchisaurus

low bridge
#

Argentino who has low material is in game

scenic lava
#

Archelon is a must have 🔥

slow shoal
#

the sauropods we have currently cover a lot of ground in the types of sauropods

low bridge
#

Bustingorrytitan has 4 specimens and hated by this

#

One Chakisaurus when?

slow shoal
#

the thing is pmuch no one knows those species im ngl

#

gotta strike a good balance between known names and uniqueness

hollow furnace
slow shoal
#

chakisaurus looks pretty similar to dryo so i dont see the point in adding it

limber nexus
#

That’s probably a good argument for why they shouldn’t be added

ancient ibex
#

I mean, if I had to compile a sauropodomorph list? Eoraptor, maybe Melanorosaurus, Shunosaurus, Mamenchisaurus, Diplodocus, Nigersaurus, Amargasaurus, Saltasaurus

limber nexus
low bridge
#

Sivatherium and Bramatherium as Alt + Extra Pachy Giraffe Discokeryx

#

Who agree with this

#

3 giraffes that would Fit insanely good in game

limber nexus
#

We only need one

#

Preferably sivatherium

low bridge
#

3 giraffes are good for Balance

limber nexus
#

Why do we need three giraffes when there are unique animals made with those resources

low bridge
#

Bc people can get bored with only one

#

That's the reason

limber nexus
#

We don’t need literally every single prehistoric creature

low bridge
#

I choosed the best ones

#

So not every single creature

#

From Elephants: Deinotherium, Stegotetrabelodon, Platybelodon, Arsinoitherium will be highly unique

#

That is max

slow shoal
#

no paleoloxodon or mastodon spotted smh

plush nacelle
#

Been watching lanzas recent video

#

What a goated terrarium species necrolestes would be

junior glacier
autumn plover
#

It’s more due to extreme popularity

#

Being able to have more alts is just a bonus

low bridge
slow shoal
#

doesnt guarantee they are in tbh

autumn plover
#

Less famous animals like Styracosaurus aren’t popular enough to warrant that sort of stuff

left spear
sharp dock
#

I am more of a fan of the humble talarurus

low bridge
#

3rd kitty for Prehistoric Kingdom must be Homotherium

autumn plover
#

Due to its popularity I think Carnotaurus is honestly soft-confirmed. I would love if we could get either Pycnonemosaurus as an alt

low bridge
slow shoal
#

i dont think carno should have any alts

autumn plover
autumn plover
slow shoal
#

i just think carno should have 3 skins

#

alts are less special if everything has em

autumn plover
#

Nah

low bridge
#

Rugops when?

autumn plover
#

Alts are a great way to add extra species, and in-some cases genera here and there without a tonne of extra work

slow shoal
#

also ngl the only abelis i actually really want are carno and majunga

#

they cover both extremes well

low bridge
#

Rajasaurus where?

slow shoal
#

theoretically could be a majunga alt but majunga is cooler anyway

autumn plover
low bridge
#

Rajasaurus is unique

slow shoal
#

not saying there is something stopping me

autumn plover
#

Pycno could work as it’s closely related to Carnotaurus while still being frag enough to make it look somewhat similar enough to Carno to justify it as an alt

slow shoal
#

im just saying i dont really like pycno

#

its kinda a nothingburger of an abeli

autumn plover
slow shoal
#

well if it gets in the game then we will see but as it stands it isnt

#

so i can say id rather it not be in the game lol

autumn plover
#

I don’t really care for anything in the terrariums (except grandad) doesn’t mean I don’t want them for the game

#

For others to enjoy

slow shoal
#

idk if im in the minority of opinions but personally I feel at least one or two reps from a group is good enough

low bridge
#

Horned Gopher in good?

slow shoal
#

like honestly argent is good enough for titanosaurs

#

i really have no desire for visually similar things like patagotitan or dreadnoughtus

#

the only exception to a lot of this imo is if something has a neat quirk to it or helps flesh out another existing formation

left spear
#

Alamo?

#

As an alt

autumn plover
#

Bit late

hollow furnace
#

(which would mean not Alamosaurus)

slow shoal
#

also i just dont like scrappy genera unless there is something genuienly unique there

#

or if every member of the group is scrappy lol

#

cough megaraptorans

silver steeple
#

Hey there's some decent ones in there

slow shoal
#

true they arent terrible all things considered

silver steeple
#

Could certainly be worse

ancient ibex
left spear
#

The one thing Raja has is location

#

But that's not enough to justify it

#

I wouldn't mind It as an alt to a more interesting abelisaurid tho

low bridge
#

Early Cretaceous Europe expansion with Polacanthus, Concavenator, Pelecanimimus, Neovenator

trail gyro
#

Viatkogorgon Campeign movement 9

#

Viatkogorgon for PK

#

!!!

sharp dock
#

Huh what kind of Inostrancevia is that

loud lark
#

This is comparison of Arctodus and Arctotherium

#

They are 2 different species so they should be separate species

lean hound
loud lark
#

idk but they 2 separate species I think ok

ancient ibex
#

I mean, Tyrannosaurus rex and Tarbosaurus baatar are also 2 distinct species?

loud lark
# lean hound you mean genus?

Arctodus simus belongs to the genus Arctodus.
Arctotherium angustidens belongs to the genus Arctotherium. They are separate genera, not just separate species.

ancient ibex
#

Paraceratherium bugtiense, Paraceratherium transouralicum, and Juxia sharamurenensis are 3 separate species in 2 differente genera, but there we are

#

I don't think you understand the argument?

lean hound
ancient ibex
#

Genera is the plural of genus; one genus, two genera

ancient ibex
#

Grecolatin words are a bit weird in English

inner wedge
#

if we take the post-ea leak as a hint for things to come i think it's safe to see most new animals being "clones " of existing ones, so giganotosaurus and things like that are coming

#

because with the rigs being there it's easier to make newer dinos

#

ea dino roster so far looks targeted to add as many rigs possible to make updates easier to fill up with new species

ebon python
#

Stegosaurus

#

Kentrosaurus

#

Huayangosaurus

#

Wuerhosaurus

#

Gigantspinosaurus

#

pentaceratops (image is wrong)

lean hound
smoky spear
loud lark
#

Eotriceratops and Torosaurus

autumn plover
#

If we're gonna get more ceratopsians i'd rather not waste slots on Triceratops clones like Eotriceratops and extremely similar species like Torosaurus.

#

If we're gonna get more ceratopsians there are numerouse species that are actually worth adding.

#

Just off of the top of my head Kosmoceratops/Pentaceratops/Chasmosaurus are all visually impressive and distinct from Triceratops, and that's just looking at chasmosaurines

sage gull
#

Miragaia

autumn plover
#

Why did you delete it?

#

I get that, but unfortunately devs wont go back and make it an alt, if it were ever possible.

loud lark
#

Cuz i regret saying it cuz torosaurus could be a simular genus as trike

autumn plover
#

If we get more chasmosaurines they should be more distinct

loud lark
#

i got mixed of different trike lookalikes

#

sorry

autumn plover
loud lark
#

yes my fav dino is sauroposeidon actually

autumn plover
ebon python
#

Amargasaurus

#

Diplodocus

#

Mamenchisaurus

slim flare
#

Add Nigersaurus and yeah, that’s basically the agreed missing sauropod roster

ebon python
#

Nigersaurus (image may not be fully accurate)

heavy scarab
#

The 3 sauropods I would love to see are Amargasaurus, Diplodocus and Saltasaurus.
But I personally would like to see more thyreophorans particularly Kentrosaurus, Miragaia, Euoplocephalus and Polacanthus

ebon python
#

okay yes

loud lark
#

This is comparison of Megatherium and Eremotherium

glass snow
#

Freaky whale

naive storm
sharp dock
sage gull
#

Tyrannotitan

trail gyro
#

Ah yes another Carcha

low bridge
#

Concavenator

#

Better

trail gyro
#

Acro and Carcha plus Concavenator are all the Carcha we really need

toxic oriole
#

"We"

wanton panther
#

Inostrancevia and Scutosaurus

heavy scarab
#

Desmatosuchus

sharp dock
heavy scarab
#

Edaphosaurus and Dimetrodon

sage gull
wanton panther
steep crane
#

When will the results be posted?

feral cedar
#

what are those from?

hollow furnace
#

Life on our planet

feral cedar
#

I don’t remember Inostrancevia and Scutosaurus in LOOP

hollow furnace
#

they're in episode 3

limber nexus
desert flame
wary nacelle
#

How could y’all forget Bulbasaurus?

solemn cedar
#

Nothrotheriops shastensis. We got Manny and Diego, and now all we need is Sid.

loud lark
#

Shasta ground sloth?

lean hound
#

chalicotherium, bramatherium, macrauchenia and sivatherium would all be great for some funky mammal representation

#

obviously not all of them since they're all quite similar

low bridge
#

Discokeryx a pachycephalosaur giraffe

#

Prodeinotherium as Alt sp for Deinotherium is must

#

We need that

sage gull
#

Monoclonius

sharp dock
#

but I wanna hear your reasoning on why it is a must

lean hound
sharp dock
lean hound
#

something

#

I can't think of anything

sharp dock
lean hound
#

very confusing

sharp dock
#

hmmm hmmmmmm....

#

well I dont check this chat much sooooo

#

you know PZ had a pretty good system with the meta wishlist

#

I'm not gonna say it was flawless, but it definitely reflected better what the playerbase wanted in the game

#

in case you don't know what the meta wishlist is, it was basically a forum thread that compiled the votes for a specific animals, people made their top 20 most wanted animals in the replies, and then they would be added to the wishlist by OP, the animals that were more frequent in those top 20 lists get higher on the list, while the ones that are only requested by a few users remain low

hollow flower
#

That sounds pretty neat

sharp dock
#

Yeah it was pretty cool, in fact frontier used the wishlist as guideline for their content packs for quite a long time

#

and it worked quite well

#

of course though it's not flawless as it only reflected the desires of a specific group within the playerbase

#

but still it worked well as the people who participated were more knowledgeable about species and generally popular animals in the end get a high number of votes regardless of the demographic

#

maybe you guys can do something similar and start posting top 20 animals you wanna see added to the game so the team can gather said info more effectively

#

otherwise I don't really think this thread is gonna be that useful for the devs to know what animals would be considered worth being added

hollow flower
#

Well put

#

Thankfully we have that poll to look forward to

outer moth
sharp dock
#

Einiosaurus was part of the old old old outdated old roster

#

iirc

hollow flower
#

I think i remember it being there yeah

sharp dock
#

but honestly ceratopsian diversity rn is good enough

#

we got the most iconic ones

#
  • nasuto
hollow flower
#

If i wanted a ceratopsian itd be like

#

Penta and Udano

#

Other than that its good currently

plush nacelle
#

Sinoceratops is good, because it is from Asia. Everything else kinda meh

sharp dock
hollow flower
#

I mean yeah but personally id prefer Centrosaurus over it due to the massive amount of material

#

It could be Centro + Sino

sharp dock
#

Udanoceratops is a good option to use on the protoceratops rig

hollow flower
#

Much like Para and Charono

sharp dock
#

cuz its funky lookin

hollow flower
#

It looks funky plus its absolutely huge

sharp dock
#

Yeah

#

do we know if miragaia was coming? I don't really remember the confirmed species rn

plush nacelle
#

Now as dacentrurus

sharp dock
#

Stegosaurus, Allosaurus, Gallimimus

#

potato potahto idrc

plush nacelle
#

Dacentrurus was featured in post EA idea list

sharp dock
#

cool

#

hopefully we get a surprise diplodocus :)

hollow flower
#

I would love to see Dippy back

#

The length of it is just really cool

sharp dock
#

Priorities....

sage gull
#

Koolasuchus

runic tiger
#

There's always ooone more interesting one that could be added

#

Like diabloceratops

#

Then you remember kosmoceratops

sharp dock
#

and then you remember wendiceratops yea

runic tiger
#

Then einioceragops

#

And so on

sharp dock
#

but you know, as much as they are unique and cool looking I dont think they are downright necessary

runic tiger
#

No not at all

#

I could maybe see like one more ceratopsian added post EA

#

My vote would be on diablo as another smaller early-mid game animal, but still a weirdo

sharp dock
#

unfortunately with nasuto in the game diablo loses points

autumn plover
#

Favourite ceratopsian but he’s right

sharp dock
#

and trust me I think diablo is cooler as well

runic tiger
#

Oh shit I forgot pentaceratops

autumn plover
#

If we need any more ceratopsians it should be either Kosmoceratops, Chasmosaurus or Pentaceratops

runic tiger
#

A chasmo would be cool

#

Round everything out

sharp dock
#

Chasmo is so basic tho...

#

penta is like the cooler chasmo

runic tiger
#

No not chasmo itself

autumn plover
#

We only have one Chasmosaurine and all 3 I stated have at least one other animal from their formation in-game or planned

runic tiger
#

Abbreviating the group name my bad

#

Meant chasmosaurine*

#

But my suggestion was penta

autumn plover
#

I mean could Chasmosaurus and Kosmoceratops work as alts? Both have short body frills, one just has very weird horns?

#

If so I’d say them just so we can get 2 in 1

sharp dock
#

idk tbh

runic tiger
#

Eh feels like kind of a stretch

sharp dock
#

anyway

#

lets discuss more important matters

#

like

#

theropods feesh

runic tiger
#

There are too many

sharp dock
#

but think about

#

which ones we reaaaaaaaaaaaaaaally need

#

like pick 5

autumn plover
#

Giga, Giga, Giga, Giga, and Giga

sharp dock
#

lol

autumn plover
#

All with slight variations of the Carcharodontosaurus

sharp dock
#

I mean giga is aight (personally I think it doesn't add anything new but)

sharp dock
#

if they add giga it gotta be gnarly looking otherwise it's just gonna be carch 2

runic tiger
#

I mean tbf its just too popular an animal not to include right?

sharp dock
#

yea

autumn plover
#

They should actually add a second Carcharodontosaurus model to the game, give it a chin, call it Giga and see how long it takes for people to realise it’s just Carcha devs

sharp dock
#

(unfortunately)

#

also the mapusaurus crowd is getting louder these days

runic tiger
#

I get that another carch in any other circomstance is mid pick

sharp dock
#

so the devs might even consider mapu as well despite how ridiculously similar all three are

runic tiger
#

But the giga namesake, just too publicly known

sharp dock
#

yup

#

but giga aside

#

allo and bary as well since they are p much confirmed

#

what u choosin

runic tiger
autumn plover
sharp dock
#

I think Ceratosaurus, Carnotaurus and Australovenator are almost guaranteed to get added

autumn plover
#

Hopefully Suchomimus and Albertosaurus but they’re less secure

#

Both classics

sharp dock
#

ceratosaurus and carnotaurus because they are super iconic, australo because it adds megaraptoran rep and is the big australian predator

#

honestly I dont find suchomimus all that appealing, people like to pretend it's so much different to bary when it really aint

autumn plover
#

It’s certainly has differences anatomy wise

sharp dock
#

but if they add it I kinda dont care

autumn plover
#

And behaviour wise it it was certainly different

#

Most terrestrial Spinosaur

#

But I digress not necessary for EA

runic tiger
#

For general theropods, probably just the iconic ones
Carno, utahraptor, cerato, therizino- and I'd personally pick gigantoraptor

sharp dock
#

gigantoraptor would be nice

runic tiger
#

Because I like the big chicken

runic tiger
#

I could see maip or one of the other weird ones

#

But australo would make the mesozoic aussie sections feel complete

sharp dock
#

yeah australo is a bit of a compromise

#

what it misses in weird it compensates in australian rep

#

also the devs can just get some liberty on it and just make the claws cool looking still

autumn plover
#

I’d say Australovenator plus 1 other Megaraptorid as an alt

#

Then you get weird and Aussie rep

#

The upside of megaraptorids in-General being quite frag is that’s it’s easier to make them alts

sharp dock
#

ngl I kinda undermine the alt potential sometimes

#

but any case I rather focus on og species instead of discussing what alts can be made from what

#

like australovenator maip or giga mapu

autumn plover
#

That’s why I don’t like Maip/megaraptor/australo idea floating around

#

1 alt is fine but 2 and suddenly the og species has only 1 skin

sharp dock
#

let it just be australo for now

#

like it's obviously the top 1 contender, everything else is just icing on top

outer moth
sharp dock
#

the phylogeny would be minimal

#

i think

#

anyway

#

what else...............

#

also besides utah I think austroraptor would be the best raptor addition evah

plush nacelle
#

Hesperornis

lean hound
lean hound
autumn plover
solemn cedar
faint snow
#

Ground sloths like Megatherium and the even larger Eremotherium would make for more large mammals in PK.

loud lark
faint snow
loud lark
#

no problem

trail gyro
trail gyro
#

No shade at my pookie wookie Inostrancevia though

slim flare
quaint plank
#

Jaekelopterus

#

For the sole reason of a dumb ai video saying it liked human flesh and it makes me laugh

leaden hedge
next saffron
#

Do we know what the next creatures are gonna be?

hollow furnace
#

Gallimimus is coming next update

trail gyro
#

Sane people

next saffron
#

You know who I would like to see? Andrewsarchus.

trail gyro
#

Viatkogorgon

median relic
#

so the ontogeny of rex being based on nano for younger stages, does this mean nano is probably off limits for coming to the game

deep lake
plucky mantle
#

I have made three lists, organized by Dinos/Cenozoics/Paleozoics and non-dino mesozoics

open heron
#

Haven't caught up with Palaeozoic stuff in a while but wouldn't the Tapinocephalus Assemblage Zone stuff be boreal compatible?
Recall that area being fairly close to the poles and the permian even having icecaps.

plucky mantle
#

It was comparable to Mongolia albeit a bit wetter

#

So it depends on if you would consider Mongolia 'boreal'

open heron
#

I believe it does have some taiga to its north

#

but really I think anything suitably cold should be counted

#

just based on how the strictest definition of the biome will get basically nothing beyond what it has now

sharp dock
#

:)

median relic
hollow furnace
inner wedge
#

how it feels to be in the pk discord and think dinosaurs are lamer than the rest

sharp dock
plush nacelle
sharp dock
#

Id like too see several ground sloths tbh...

#

they have a lot of variety after all

deep lake
#

Girant moa

#

Elephand birb

#

Anzu

sharp dock
#

da moer

#

I think recent extinctions would do a great dlc

sharp dock
#

yup, that

lean hound
#

I may be wrong but it's planned

sharp dock
#

is it?

lean hound
#

pretty sure

#

or devs want to do it

sharp dock
#

I didn't know we got confirmation

#

I'm all for it

lean hound
ancient ibex
#

Mmm, while IMO Penta and Lepto+Udano are the better ceratopsian additions, Turano/Zuni could be neat lil' dudes

sharp dock
#

Nothingburgeratops

late bobcat
#

I mean it's really unique guy

outer moth
#

Very strange animal yea

low bridge
#

Aenocyon when?

outer crater
#

Hyaenodon when?

low bridge
#

Mee6 when?

limber nexus
heavy scarab
#

If they do give us the recently extinct expansion I just want the Passenger Pigeon as an arboreal terrarium animal

lean hound
outer moth
#

Hope we have many of these

limber nexus
#

Because a lot of these creatures are just unnecessary

buoyant zephyr
#

Hot take: I think any creature that has a decent fossil record and/or we have a good idea of how it lived could get in the game

buoyant zephyr
#

Not for some

runic tiger
limber nexus
runic tiger
#

Why?

#

Can't you just like post them

#

Itd be a lot more convient for people who took the questionnaire to see the results

#

Rather than watching a full video

limber nexus
#

And if I make a good video, I would have added more to the community than if I just posted a list of the top 10

median relic
# lean hound

I genuinely think having basically almost modern animals in this game will be fun

#

dimetrodon and great auk, could hardly be more different in age but united in extinction 🙏

median relic
lost saffron
runic tiger
sage gull
#

What I need is the concaventaor

#

My favorite dinosaur

autumn plover
#

Would take Concavenator over Giga unironically

sage gull
#

Bambiraptor

#

Lol

slim flare
#

It’s a juvenile

toxic oriole
#

Hmmm...
Zuniceratops

#

Tryna find a good size chart

#

Best I can get is this image

#

... Nevermind, its probably either a sub-adult or a juvenile

#

Maybe Mesophryne and Liaobatrachus, two mesozoic frogs of the cretaceous

safe kestrel
#

Well known, more complete fossil should be the priority

#

Including the small one like scelido

left spear
# sharp dock is it?

We got confirmations It would be one of the first, and unless they want to add Haast's and steller's imo it's gonna be the first dlc, we also have confirmation than a Wild Horse and Quagga Will be in It.

sharp dock
#

A wild horse is so slay

left spear
left spear
#

Quagga being the main species would be weird af

sharp dock
#

Equus is cool

#

but please oh god hippidion

left spear
#

Personally i think It could fit, but some people Will argue it's too old

sharp dock
#

wdym too old

left spear
# sharp dock wdym too old

I don't remember Who It was but when i proposed Mekosuchus (which i retrospective i don't want since i want It in a dedicated island DLC) as a candidate (3.000 years old) someone (one of the regulars) said It wasn't recently extinct, and a lot of people seemed to agreee, Hippi is 8.500 years old

sharp dock
#

huh ah yeah I dont mean it as part of the recently extinct pack

left spear
#

Oh

#

Well yeah Hippi is cool

sharp dock
#

the recently extinct pack should be historical times

#

also it doesn't really need any tweaks

#

maybe 1 mini exhibit would go well

#

(passenger pigeon)

#

or the hawaii o'o

left spear
#

Imo anything as old or more recent than Mesopotamia is fair Game.

sharp dock
#

honestly I think they better keep it simple, the island extinction slope is far too great for them to manage

#

😵‍💫 😵‍💫 😵‍💫 😵‍💫

sharp dock
left spear
#

5.000

sharp dock
#

didnt mammoths go extinct like more recently than that

autumn plover
#

For example: Nanuqsaurus which is literally just a piece of jaw

sharp dock
#

a lot of popular species are very fragmentary

#

including some that are yet to be added I think

#

for exampol
UUUUUUUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

#

honestly I could only think of brachy and carch

#

and those already in lole

plush nacelle
#

Kelenken

sharp dock
#

keleneken is very fragmentary?

#

it's a full upper skull

plush nacelle
#

Thats probably most fragmenty future addition I can think of

sharp dock
#

hmmmmmmmm

lean hound
autumn plover
sharp dock
#

I guess utahraptor is kiiiiinda fragmentary?

#

so thats one

#

theri as well ig

outer moth
#

Theri definitely

#

Seeing as most therizinosaurs can't preserve too well

left spear
#

So the game's mammoths went extinct like 12.000-15.000 years ago

sharp dock
#

If I were a clinically insane person I would say something deranged like

#

we sooooooo need Sardinian pikas (prolagus sardus)

lean hound
sharp dock
#

hate that artwork

#

but yes megalenhydris is very cool

outer moth
#

Is the artist controversial?

sharp dock
#

Hodari? Kinda ig? He is a good artist but his artworks are often on the fantastical side

#

rather than the down to earth side

#

like no megalenhydris would not try to hunt a hammerhead shark, it wasn't big enough and was a specialized benthic forager

#

people using that artwork for reference is just warping their perception of what the actual animal was and it's annoying having to clarify

lean hound
#

I just used it because it's the most recognisable art of it

sharp dock
#

yeah and I hate that

#

it shouldn't be

#

but awesomebro artworks sell ig

#

not that there are many megalenhydris artworks unfortunately

lean hound
#

parts of it at least

outer moth
#

I mean it is similar since it's in the same region

sharp dock
#

u know what a good addition would be
Myotragus 🔥

lean hound
lean hound
sharp dock
#

I really hope it's not too small tho...

#

like

#

myotragus is quite small lol

#

it would be one of the smallest animals in the game if added

lean hound
outer moth
#

Terrarium?

sharp dock
#

ugh

#

I mean habitat animals

#

sorry

outer moth
#

I know but ontogeny would be a bit hard for mytragus

sharp dock
#

I doubt that

outer moth
#

So terrarium myotragus

#

lol

#

jk

sharp dock
#

why would it be hard to begin with

#

it would be no different from any other animal already in

outer moth
#

Prop myotragus when

sharp dock
#

no >:(

outer moth
#

Myotragus was actually multiple small Myotraguses together as one

sharp dock
#

i wanna know why u said ontogeny would be hard for myotragus

outer moth
sharp dock
#

baby myotragus would be bigger than baby velo

#

they didn't come out of an egg

outer moth
ancient ibex
ancient ibex
#

Ungulates need to come out of the womb walking

outer moth
#

Ah, valid

outer moth
#

What's disturbing is they're not just this opportunistic with food

#

trust me

sharp dock
#

I don't underestimate them, I'm being realistic

#

trust me bro, you shouldn't underestimate bears

ancient ibex
#

Sea otters have been observed catching sharks, stoats will hunt rabbits and hares, wolverines and ratels will confront the apex predators of their environments

ancient ibex
outer moth
ancient ibex
#

In addition, hammerheads are not a single shark species, but a quite variable clade

sharp dock
#

what you see there is a small shark

#

not a hammerhead

ancient ibex
#

Yeah, it is a nurse shark being caught by a sea otter

#

Scalloped hammerheads are that size

sharp dock
#

scalloped hammerheads are that small?

ancient ibex
#

A meter and a half long on average

#

Smooth and great hammerheads are the ones that get to 5+ meters

ancient ibex
sharp dock
#

then the one in the artwork is clearly not a scalloped hammerhead

ancient ibex
#

Females get larger

#

But still, blue shark sized roughly speaking

#

Still, can see an otter tangling with a shark its size

outer moth
#

What is it's a pleistocene hammerhead species?

sharp dock
#

megalenhydris hunting a mid sized benthic shark species I can buy
megalenhydris hunting a pelagic 5+ meter hammerhead shark is pure fantasy

#

and no, stoats hunting rabbits is not a justification for it

ancient ibex
#

Giant otters eating caimans is tho

#

Bwhaha

sharp dock
#

please show me a giant otter eating a caiman that doubles its size

#

I'll wait :)

#

funny you would consider a small caiman not on the level of the benthic shark

ancient ibex
#

Black caiman I believe

sharp dock
#

thats a full family of otters

#

not a single otter

outer moth
ancient ibex
#

The paper constricting Megalenhydris to a benthic diet is also, honestly, quite bare bones; it finds out it had quite robust and pointy teeth, but it is 5 pages long and basically just has throwaway lines about niche partitioning

ancient ibex
lean hound
sharp dock
#

in the picture the nurse shark is smaller than the otter

sharp dock
#

how is the size difference similar?

ancient ibex
#

Biology also runs on exceptions and weirdness rather than on rules, despite the intentions of internet people who want to tell others that they are wrong...

sharp dock
sharp dock
#

so basically

#

forage on the bottom
go up for air
go to the bottom again

ancient ibex
#

Good, specialized, but that doesn't mean constrained

sharp dock
#

anyway I think the convo is extending far beyond the point of this thread

#

and honestly I have better things to do than insist on such a fruitless topic

#

if you wanna believe on that absurd artwork be my guest

#

but I rather think of animals realistically

ancient ibex
#

Again, stoats hunting hares

lean hound
ancient ibex
#

Animals are ridiculous, mustelids in general are even more ridiculous, and the main issue with paleontology has consistently be ignoring living animals

sharp dock
#

Pelecanimimus is cool

#

Pelecanimimus + conca would be a nice combo

ancient ibex
#

If only we could examine it

#

Fucking Spinosaurus holotype is more accessible

#

Carcha holotype was the basis of 2 genera, the second one 80 years after its destruction

#

Meanwhile, Pelecanimimus remains out of sight because Spanish academia is this weird chestbeating autofellatory circle

#

Concavenator got a neat description and good pics of the holotype, but Pelecanimimus is an awesome animal that has been locked away for 30 years

sharp dock
#

really?

#

I didn't know that (about pelecanimimus)

ancient ibex
#

Oh yeah, it is insidiously hard to approach

sharp dock
#

why is it?

ancient ibex
#

No images allowed

sharp dock
#

where is it stored

#

I shall take my own hands on the matter

#

🗿

outer moth
ancient ibex
sharp dock
#

thats an article from freaking 1994

ancient ibex
#

Yeah

#

Original description

#

Again, the Spino holotype remains more accessible

#

And was blown up 80 years ago

sharp dock
#

and is like the cuenca museum against it being studied or what exactly

ancient ibex
#

I believe it is an issue of a single scientist or something

#

Our uni professors are... weird as a rule; I know you are from Spain but don't know if you started Uni here, as a single week of class with the average prof will tell you everything you need to know about their selfcenteredness

sharp dock
#

that's in every uni

safe kestrel
#

yea thats every uni

ancient ibex
#

I mean, even worse when they don't know a bit of English and decide that the entire world is just what they can understand lol

#

Concavenator in 2010 had thermorregulation as an explanation for its neural spines, in the same paper that there was mention of feathers

#

That's a literal fossil professor pushing something decades outdated

#

Buuut, yeah, I'll keep pushing for a Barremian Europe roster of Iguanodon, Baryonyx, Polacanthus, Hypsilophodon, Pelecanimimus and Concavenator; some wiggle room in Conca's size, due to Altispinax likely being closer and being a bit larger than the holotype of Conca, and I believe that's a neat roster

#

Istiodactylus once large pterosaurs are viable; the cookiecutter vulture is awesome

safe kestrel
#

GET DOWN
GET DOWN ON THE FLOOR

#

WHERE THE FOSSIL DE PALMA

outer moth
runic tiger
#

There are a few good mesozoic European species to pick from, conca and peli, europasaurus, tethyshadros

#

I'd really like to see megalosaurus in the game some day

sharp dock
#

isn't torvo the cooler megalosaurus

runic tiger
#

Round out the crystal palace representation

runic tiger
#

They're so physically similar I'll just be using a neotenic torvo in game for now

outer moth
#

I'm pretty sure Megalo got changed up

runic tiger
#

But idk it's such an important dino, the other half to iggy

#

Really? I'm out of the loop

left spear
sharp dock
#

I mean it's culturally significant but it's not a popular animal in itself

#

like you dont see kids saying megalosaurus is their favorite dinosaur

#

it's the basic bitch dino for those who minimally learn about the history of paleontology

#

Europasaurus would be cool ngl.... dwarf sauropod

#

there are so many cool sauropods, its kinda unfair lol

outer moth
left spear
runic tiger
runic tiger
sharp dock
#

Europasaurus, Nigersaurus, Amargasaurus, Diplodocus, Mamenchisaurus 💀

runic tiger
#

You forgot shuno

sharp dock
#

I didn't

#

add the tail mace to mamenchi, done

runic tiger
#

But you did forget the alamo

sharp dock
#

you don't need shuno no more

runic tiger
#

Always remember the Alamo

runic tiger
#

Like full on weaponry its so cool

sharp dock
#

I don't care, devs can take the artistic liberty to make it a thagomizer

runic tiger
sharp dock
#

the shunosaurus discourse brings me memories

runic tiger
#

Look at him nar

#

He so cool

sharp dock
#

I don't care

#

literally camarasaurus with a tail knob

runic tiger
#

Plus same formation as yang

ancient ibex
#

Honestly, Magyarosaurus is IMO the better dwarf sauropod, because a Hatzeg pack would go hard

sharp dock
#

where isisaurus.............................

outer moth
# runic tiger

Shuno's entire formation definitely deserves lots of rep
Seeing as Shaximiao is like an asian version of the Morrison

ancient ibex
sharp dock
#

tryna find the image I made years ago

runic tiger
#

Actually I have no idea if the thagomizers are still accepted knowledge, seeing more modern reconstructions without them

sharp dock
#

Oh I found it

runic tiger
#

But anyways agree to disagree I just think it'd be cool to have both mamench and shuno

sharp dock
#

from freaking 5 years ago 😭

runic tiger
#

He's made me the soyjack... I have lost...

sharp dock
#

honestly if they decide to add it I don't mind but it is the most boring small sauropod of the ones that are usually suggested lole

outer moth
runic tiger
#

Honestly I think my most niche sauropod pull would be sauroposideon (which isn't niche nor that crazy)

#

But it kinda is just... longer brachy

#

But it'd just be cool cloverly rep, maybe throw it in some pack themed around animal sizes with shantung or giga or smth

sharp dock
#

also shaximiao has mamenchi so what makes you think shuno would be added over mamenchi 🤔

#

mamenchi: the cooler shuno

runic tiger
#

I think they're both cool B)

sharp dock
#

fair :p

#

ngl I unironically think gasosaurus is cool

outer moth
#

I prefer Yang

sharp dock
#

but like I know it will never be added 😔

#

I will protect my nothingburger dinosaur at all costs

runic tiger
#

The neotenic system allows for a lot

#

I think you could definitely fake it with one of the allosaurs at like 15% growth

sharp dock
#

gasosaurus' only job is appearing in artworks being mauled by shuno

runic tiger
#

When shuno needs to maul something in paleoart

sharp dock
#

but he does an excellent job so I love him

#

also it has a funny name

#

and honestly you gotta appreciate how basic of a dinosaur it is.... so humble.............

#

gasosaurus is the very essence of humility.... in dinosaur form......

outer moth
autumn plover
#

if we're getting any metriacanthosaurid it should be Yang

left spear
autumn plover
#

Metri is fragmentary asf and at one point Yang was actually planned for the game

#

they're not even each other's closest relatives, terrible alt potential

#

unless theres a more recent family tree later than 2013

ancient ibex
ancient ibex
#

As in it is just an ass

#

Every single Metri recon you see is Sinraptor

outer moth
#

Yang is simply better

#

Has better recons

autumn plover
#

^only popular because it was onscreen a couple seconds in JP which led to it being in JWE

#

for Metri

ancient ibex
#

Name would be ignored if Paul didn't lump everything into it in PDotW and thus snuck as a filler name in JP

autumn plover
#

literally clout for no reason

ancient ibex
#

Sinraptor is the most vanilla theropod ever according to theropod workers lol

autumn plover
#

tbf the skull is a bit basic

outer moth
#

Unlike the Yang

ancient ibex
#

It is vanilla, never said it was bad

autumn plover
outer moth
ancient ibex
#

Younger yangs would likely look more like Sinraptor after all

autumn plover
outer moth
ancient ibex
#

Honestly, that will likely be a source of mods down the line

#

Good

deep lake
#

kaikaifilu and mosasaurus hoffmannii

hollow flower
#

Could Tullimonstrum be a viable addition as a mini or an ambient animal?

deep lake
#

ambiet? what do that mean?

sharp dock
#

p sure tullimonstrum is around the size of a potato

#

sooooo doubt

deep lake
#

what dis ambient mean?

sharp dock
#

idk

#

truly a mystery

deep lake
#

yea

#

atleast for me

sharp dock
#

we shall never know

hollow flower
#

like

safe kestrel
#

He mean ambience animal

hollow flower
#

well lets say they add aquariums

deep lake
safe kestrel
#

Like squirrel in ZT2

hollow flower
#

some things are a little too small to be added singularly in and they dont make the cut for terrariums either

#

so you just add say

#

a school of them

#

say a bunch of ammonites for example

safe kestrel
hollow flower
#

my wording on that wasnt exactly great

sharp dock
#

I think it's a bit early to talk about aquatics

hollow flower
#

I think jwe2 has this with the fish from the aquatic fish feeder but im uncertain

sharp dock
#

p sure the fish are individual, they are tuna

#

and they swim around separatedly

hollow flower
#

Either way they wouldnt really be on the same tier as like

#

a Mosasaur

lean hound
# deep lake what dis ambient mean?

"Ambient is an adjective used to describe an aspect of the environment that completely surrounds you, but in a mellow way, like ambient music played softly throughout a restaurant, or the ambient orange glow during a setting sun."

#

but in this context an ambient animal is like a prop, not a fully functional animal, just something in the background

left spear
left spear
inner wedge
#

tully is (sadly) too small

#

we're gonna miss out on the PEAK that are cambrian animals cause the vast majority is too tiny even for terrariums

tired storm
#

Amargasaurus🙏

sharp dock
#

Did this guy just say amogusaurus............. feesh

left spear
#

Also mini Aquariums will probably be smaller than mini exhibits

#

Since due to them be "3d" the space needed for animals would be lower

inner wedge
#

yeah but most cambrian animals are REALLY small

#

alongside being very complex to model

#

don't think devs would bother adding anyone aside The Endless

ancient ibex
#

Anomalocaris is a giant by Cambrian standards and it was lobster sized

inner wedge
#

hear me out

#

omnidens

#

actually man sized

hollow flower
#

On the topic of early paleozoic animals, Endoceras as an exhibit creature would be neat to see

#

but yeah Omnidens is obscure, large and cool enough to be a very good addition

inner wedge
#

endoceras being vertical all the time would be interesting to see

hollow flower
#

True

#

just walks on the floor all the time

inner wedge
#

speaking of paleozoic species i had a few ideas in my chart here #1360542295228944414 message

junior glacier
#

I submit crassigyrinus scoticus as an exhibit animal, would love to have him as a nod to Prehistoric Park and give us another water fellow alongside Tiktaalik

inner wedge
#

i want this dude for terrariums

#

elginia mirabilis

sage gull
#

I want the Diplocaulus for terrarium

junior wasp
#

Please add my glorious king beezlbufo as anything but a terrarium creature.

lean hound
junior wasp
lean hound
#

it makes no sense

inner wedge
#

rude

junior wasp
#

Tysm

lean hound
junior wasp
#

No

inner wedge
#

but bufo is pretty small tho

lean hound
junior wasp
#

You don’t get to hear it

junior wasp
lean hound
#

People keep modern day frogs in terrariums

hollow furnace
#

Beelzebufo, if it came, would only come as a terrarium animal

#

It's too small and ontogeny is too difficult for otherwise

inner wedge
sharp dock
#

don't care

#

beelzebufo is cool

inner wedge
#

no qualms about that

#

everyone loves the bufo

#

if he's not in u16 we riot

junior wasp
hollow furnace
#

Beelz is very cool, but he'd be a very cool terrarium animal

lean hound
sharp dock
#

diplocaulus would be slay

inner wedge
#

diploceraspis is the cooler diplocaulus

sharp dock
#

who

inner wedge
#

i felt that

sharp dock
#

good

#

anyway

#

mononykus was confirmed as mini wasnt it

inner wedge
#

mau said it's not coming

hollow furnace
#

nope

sharp dock
#

huh

#

streng.............

hollow furnace
#

It was on the list Mau killed

junior wasp
#

Ok I finished typing my idea in the enrichment thread

sharp dock
#

huh wdym

#

mau killed the list?

lean hound
sharp dock
#

u mean the list with compsognathus and stuff?

inner wedge
#

he publicly announced mononykus' death in main

lean hound
sharp dock
#

fr?

inner wedge
#

yeah that list

sharp dock
#

wasn't it quite clearly in the list he posted

#

????

#

like I know it was blurry but it was fairly clear

inner wedge
#

which means diictodon and peltephilus are probably out too

lean hound
sharp dock
#

????

hollow furnace
#

Mau said no to Diictodon, Mononykus, Peltephilus, and Beelzebufo

inner wedge
#

(i huff hopium everyday for it being real tho)

lean hound
#

or just u16

sharp dock
#

didn't we quite literally get simosuchus right

hollow furnace
inner wedge
#

bullshi

sharp dock
#

can somebody repost the image

#

of the list

hollow furnace
inner wedge
#

bitch ass castorocauda ain't got anything over the Bufo

lean hound
sharp dock
inner wedge
hollow furnace
sharp dock
hollow furnace
#

That is a heavily upscaled version, not the original

sharp dock
#

can you link me mau's original post of the image

hollow furnace
sharp dock
#

ty <3

#

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

#

maybe its my mind but I still can at least see compsognathus being there

hollow furnace
#

Which would make sense considering Compsoganthus was known beforehand anyways

#

Mau presumably meant that pkdino's list was wrong, not all the animals we'd guessed

sharp dock
#

Simosuchus was confirmed afterwards though and it was fairly clear in the focalized image

hollow furnace
#

Also possible plans changed since then anyways, we did go from 5 to 9 animals in update 16

sharp dock
#

kinda sad he disproved mono 😦 it's a really good pick

#

can't really think of much regarding minis

#

Ok so while I was le brushing me teeth i thought of da possible contenders

#

They said there would be 3 mini exhibit types right?

hollow furnace
#

Yes

sharp dock
#

If i recall arboreal, amphibian and burrow

hollow furnace
#

They’re also a arboreal lizard, a fuzzy Triassic thing, 2 weird dinosaurs, and a semi aquatic mammal

hollow furnace
hollow furnace
#

MAU after he deconfirmed pkdino’s list

slow shoal
#

also we know the diets too

#

im assuming the fuzzy triassic thing is prolly thrinaxodon

sharp dock
#

Because of wwd right

#

Makes sense

#

Also, semiaquatic mammal...

#

Small semiaquatic mammal

silver steeple
#

Like I guess other creatures in the same family but why not choose the best known at that point

hollow furnace
sharp dock
#

Any reason why it wouldnt be indohyus?

silver steeple
#

Probably too big?

#

Well maybe not

hollow furnace
#

Indohyus would work

silver steeple
#

Idk the size refs on google are all over the place lol

sharp dock
#

If you search for size refs you get pakicetys

silver steeple
#

Ah

sharp dock
#

Indohyus was around the size of a cat

#

Its kind of a mouse deer in many ways

#

I think it fits

#

Way better than something like castorocauda lol

silver steeple
#

Indo would def be a contender

#

I think a weird little jurassic or cretaceous mammal would be cool tho

#

Just from like a variety standpoint

sharp dock
#

The arboreal lizard defo gonna be either drepanosaurus or coelurosauravus

hollow furnace
sharp dock
#

Possibly the later as drepano is most likely too small

silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Longisquama is 15 cm long

silver steeple
#

I don't see how Drep is too small

#

And there are larger species in the family

#

Hypurnecton or whatever

sharp dock
#

Have you seen the size of the mini exhibit?

silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Hmmmm still kinda small, not as small as I thought tho

hollow furnace
#

Drepenosaurus is the largest out of it, Coeluro, and Longisquama, by a very significant margin

silver steeple
#

Its like the size of larger chameleons iirc

sharp dock
#

Coeluro is smaller?

hollow furnace
#

Yeah

silver steeple
#

Oh yeah

hollow furnace
#

It's like 35 cm

#

~2/3 the length of Drepeno

sharp dock
#

Hmmm

#

Well either of the two

silver steeple
#

Finding anything on coeluro that isn't Peters is painful lmao

sharp dock
#

Gonna be kinda funny having such an humongous box for a tiny lizard

#

Wait

#

Lemme think

silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Drepano/coeluro: insectivore
????: herbivore
Thrinaxodon: carni
Indohyus: piscivore
????: carnivore

#

Well

#

Indohyus could be the herb lol idk what its diet was

#

So for the 2 weird dinos

silver steeple
#

Google lists it as omnivore

#

But I think the game could easily call it a piscovore

sharp dock
#

One is either pisc/herb and the other is a carnivore

#

I think i know what one is gonna be

#

What was it called

#

Liaoningosaurus

#

Thats one

silver steeple
#

That's also a juvie

sharp dock
#

The other one

#

Idc hes a funny guy

plush nacelle
#

Herbi is most likely heterodontosaurid of some sort

silver steeple
#

That's not a bad bet

#

Tianyulong would make sense there imo

#

Tiny guy, even among heterodontosaurs

hollow furnace
#

Honestly almost every heterodontosaurid, even heterodontosaurus proper, could work as a terrarium

#

Heterodontosaurus itself would be on sort of the cusp

silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Dinosaur options:

  • sinosauropteryx
  • kulindadromeus/fruitadens
  • micropachycephalosaurus
  • liaoningosaurus
silver steeple
#

Idk imo there's an awkward spot in terms of sizes

#

Imo most heterodontosaurs kinda land there

sharp dock
#

Or wait, maybe switch kulinda for fruitadens idk

silver steeple
#

Kulinda is a decent pick imo

#

I could also see Fruitadens tho

hollow furnace
#

My personal really weird want is Manidens

#

So we can have a non-flying/gliding arboreal dinosaur

sharp dock
#

Who

plush nacelle
#

Me think:
Terrestrial: simo, compy, thrinax
Arboreal: yi, drepano, manidens
Aqua: tikt, castorocauda and carni dino

hollow furnace
silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Which one is more known

#

Fruita or mani

hollow furnace
#

probably fruitadens on account of being Morrison, but tbh both are very very obscure

#

The only reason people would known Fruitadens is on account of looking at the Morrison formation species list wikipedia page

sharp dock
#

Morrison huh

#

Nah I actually recall seeing news abt fruitadens

#

like i didnt get to know about it from wikipedia

#

Wait

#

What about heterodontosaurus

plush nacelle
#

Maybe cause it is the smallest ornithischian

silver steeple
sharp dock
#

Actually checking het is like around compy in size

hollow furnace
sharp dock
#

Then my bet is on heterodontosaurus

hollow furnace
#

And like, we got Tiktaalik as a terrarium, despite some specimens getting up to the size of an American alligator

silver steeple
#

True

#

I guess size isn't that much of a constraint

#

Especially cause minis won't have size variation (or at least don't afaik)

#

So whatever the devs decide is the average is what we get

sharp dock
#

Excited to see what it is

silver steeple
#

Same