#Community Species Suggestions
1 messages · Page 3 of 1
Is the refusal to add alt genera to existing species on behalf of the devs rooted in the fact that they take up one skin slot
So adding something like Centrosaurus would functionally give Styracosaurus 4 skins
They don’t want to go back
There are some creatures with 4 skins, which we trike, so I don’t think a creature with 3 skins and alternate genius is off the table, but I also doubt they are going back
Girant e m o
Tarchia, Saichania

ngl I think the ankylosaurid roster could be expanded
Euoplocephalus as its own thing and then Tarchia tumanovae and teresae with a Pinacosaurus alt
Who wants Alamosaurus in Prehistoric Kingdom???
I think that he would skyrocket in game
it def doesnt come to mind when i think of sauropods I want
Little info abt him:
That should light everything that why is he needed anyways
Worldwide Alamo
Nigersaurus
its only from north america
That was joke ik that he is N.A
Bustingorrytitan from Huincul formation should be expansion animal
Same here, there are a lot better options
pmuch the only sauropods i want are diplodocus (maybe with baro alt), amargasaurus, and mamenchisaurus
Argentino who has low material is in game
Archelon is a must have 🔥
the sauropods we have currently cover a lot of ground in the types of sauropods
the thing is pmuch no one knows those species im ngl
gotta strike a good balance between known names and uniqueness
What are any of these animals lol
chakisaurus looks pretty similar to dryo so i dont see the point in adding it
I genuinely don’t know half of the animals people mention anymore
That’s probably a good argument for why they shouldn’t be added
I mean, if I had to compile a sauropodomorph list? Eoraptor, maybe Melanorosaurus, Shunosaurus, Mamenchisaurus, Diplodocus, Nigersaurus, Amargasaurus, Saltasaurus
All of those would be cool, but there are definitely creatures I would prioritize first instead of sauropods
Sivatherium and Bramatherium as Alt + Extra Pachy Giraffe Discokeryx
Who agree with this
3 giraffes that would Fit insanely good in game
3 giraffes are good for Balance
For balance?
This is a park builder not a survival game
Why do we need three giraffes when there are unique animals made with those resources
People won’t get bored with one, if the roster is diverse to begin with
We don’t need literally every single prehistoric creature
I choosed the best ones
So not every single creature
From Elephants: Deinotherium, Stegotetrabelodon, Platybelodon, Arsinoitherium will be highly unique
That is max
no paleoloxodon or mastodon spotted smh
Been watching lanzas recent video
What a goated terrarium species necrolestes would be
Do you have a link for that video?
Bit late to the convo but the only animals with 4 skins are animals like Tyrannosaurus, Triceratops, Spinosaurus
It’s more due to extreme popularity
Being able to have more alts is just a bonus
They on post EA ideas list
doesnt guarantee they are in tbh
Less famous animals like Styracosaurus aren’t popular enough to warrant that sort of stuff
Ironic for this kind of game
I am more of a fan of the humble talarurus
3rd kitty for Prehistoric Kingdom must be Homotherium
Due to its popularity I think Carnotaurus is honestly soft-confirmed. I would love if we could get either Pycnonemosaurus as an alt
We have it's permafrosted cub discovered
i dont think carno should have any alts
Pycno being fairly fragmentary works in its favour as we could take away its horns if people want a more generic looking Abelisaur
I mean, there would be no forcing you to use it
Nah
Rugops when?
Alts are a great way to add extra species, and in-some cases genera here and there without a tonne of extra work
also ngl the only abelis i actually really want are carno and majunga
they cover both extremes well
Rajasaurus where?
theoretically could be a majunga alt but majunga is cooler anyway
Nothing stopping you from just having Carno and Majunga in your parks my guy
Rajasaurus is unique
not saying there is something stopping me
Pycno could work as it’s closely related to Carnotaurus while still being frag enough to make it look somewhat similar enough to Carno to justify it as an alt
Then don’t create one?
well if it gets in the game then we will see but as it stands it isnt
so i can say id rather it not be in the game lol
I don’t really care for anything in the terrariums (except grandad) doesn’t mean I don’t want them for the game
For others to enjoy
idk if im in the minority of opinions but personally I feel at least one or two reps from a group is good enough
Horned Gopher in good?
like honestly argent is good enough for titanosaurs
i really have no desire for visually similar things like patagotitan or dreadnoughtus
the only exception to a lot of this imo is if something has a neat quirk to it or helps flesh out another existing formation
Bit late
If we did get another giant titanosaur (which I don't really want), I'd want one with a smooth appearance with no osteoderms to contrast with Argent's gnarlyness
(which would mean not Alamosaurus)
I'm in agreement
also i just dont like scrappy genera unless there is something genuienly unique there
or if every member of the group is scrappy lol
cough megaraptorans
Hey there's some decent ones in there
true they arent terrible all things considered
Could certainly be worse
It is not
The one thing Raja has is location
But that's not enough to justify it
I wouldn't mind It as an alt to a more interesting abelisaurid tho
Early Cretaceous Europe expansion with Polacanthus, Concavenator, Pelecanimimus, Neovenator
Huh what kind of Inostrancevia is that
This is comparison of Arctodus and Arctotherium
They are 2 different species so they should be separate species
you mean genus?
idk but they 2 separate species I think ok
I mean, Tyrannosaurus rex and Tarbosaurus baatar are also 2 distinct species?
Arctodus simus belongs to the genus Arctodus.
Arctotherium angustidens belongs to the genus Arctotherium. They are separate genera, not just separate species.
Paraceratherium bugtiense, Paraceratherium transouralicum, and Juxia sharamurenensis are 3 separate species in 2 differente genera, but there we are
I don't think you understand the argument?
May sound like a silly question but what is genera and what is the difference between species, genus and genera?
Genera is the plural of genus; one genus, two genera
thank you
Grecolatin words are a bit weird in English
who
if we take the post-ea leak as a hint for things to come i think it's safe to see most new animals being "clones " of existing ones, so giganotosaurus and things like that are coming
because with the rigs being there it's easier to make newer dinos
ea dino roster so far looks targeted to add as many rigs possible to make updates easier to fill up with new species
Stegosaurus
Kentrosaurus
Huayangosaurus
Wuerhosaurus
Gigantspinosaurus
pentaceratops (image is wrong)
Stegosaurus is already confirmed
pentaceratops*
Eotriceratops and Torosaurus
If we're gonna get more ceratopsians i'd rather not waste slots on Triceratops clones like Eotriceratops and extremely similar species like Torosaurus.
If we're gonna get more ceratopsians there are numerouse species that are actually worth adding.
Just off of the top of my head Kosmoceratops/Pentaceratops/Chasmosaurus are all visually impressive and distinct from Triceratops, and that's just looking at chasmosaurines
Miragaia
Why did you delete it?
I get that, but unfortunately devs wont go back and make it an alt, if it were ever possible.
Cuz i regret saying it cuz torosaurus could be a simular genus as trike
If we get more chasmosaurines they should be more distinct
Sorry for being harsh, everyone has a favourite dinosaur.
yes my fav dino is sauroposeidon actually
It would be cool to have if the devs had unlimited resources, but unfortunately it would probably not be the best choice, its not even guaranteed that we'll get another ceratopsian im afraid.
Add Nigersaurus and yeah, that’s basically the agreed missing sauropod roster
Nigersaurus (image may not be fully accurate)
The 3 sauropods I would love to see are Amargasaurus, Diplodocus and Saltasaurus.
But I personally would like to see more thyreophorans particularly Kentrosaurus, Miragaia, Euoplocephalus and Polacanthus
okay yes
This is comparison of Megatherium and Eremotherium
Me want
Looks like my sister
wasn't expecting my art to be used as ref lol
Tyrannotitan
Ah yes another Carcha
Acro and Carcha plus Concavenator are all the Carcha we really need
"We"
Inostrancevia and Scutosaurus
Desmatosuchus
name a more iconic duo ill wait
Edaphosaurus and Dimetrodon
Yes
What’s wrong with this one?
When will the results be posted?
Life on our planet
I don’t remember Inostrancevia and Scutosaurus in LOOP
they're in episode 3
The poll closes on the 30th and I’m making a video on the results that should come out before the end of may, just because I have finals at the begging of may
Permian animals is need...
How could y’all forget Bulbasaurus?
Nothrotheriops shastensis. We got Manny and Diego, and now all we need is Sid.
Shasta ground sloth?
chalicotherium, bramatherium, macrauchenia and sivatherium would all be great for some funky mammal representation
obviously not all of them since they're all quite similar
Dude Discokeryx, Prolibytherium also neat
Discokeryx a pachycephalosaur giraffe
Prodeinotherium as Alt sp for Deinotherium is must
We need that
Monoclonius
it isn't
but I wanna hear your reasoning on why it is a must
pretty pointless
wdym?
Trying to understand EZ is like trying to understand a
something
I can't think of anything
you mean because he just lists genera without further elaboration on why they are a good addition?
He's just confusing
very confusing
hmmm hmmmmmm....
well I dont check this chat much sooooo
you know PZ had a pretty good system with the meta wishlist
I'm not gonna say it was flawless, but it definitely reflected better what the playerbase wanted in the game
in case you don't know what the meta wishlist is, it was basically a forum thread that compiled the votes for a specific animals, people made their top 20 most wanted animals in the replies, and then they would be added to the wishlist by OP, the animals that were more frequent in those top 20 lists get higher on the list, while the ones that are only requested by a few users remain low
That sounds pretty neat
Yeah it was pretty cool, in fact frontier used the wishlist as guideline for their content packs for quite a long time
and it worked quite well
of course though it's not flawless as it only reflected the desires of a specific group within the playerbase
but still it worked well as the people who participated were more knowledgeable about species and generally popular animals in the end get a high number of votes regardless of the demographic
maybe you guys can do something similar and start posting top 20 animals you wanna see added to the game so the team can gather said info more effectively
otherwise I don't really think this thread is gonna be that useful for the devs to know what animals would be considered worth being added
Dubious
I think i remember it being there yeah
but honestly ceratopsian diversity rn is good enough
we got the most iconic ones
- nasuto
If i wanted a ceratopsian itd be like
Penta and Udano
Other than that its good currently
Sinoceratops is good, because it is from Asia. Everything else kinda meh
Funny I was thinking exactly about those two lol
I mean yeah but personally id prefer Centrosaurus over it due to the massive amount of material
It could be Centro + Sino
Udanoceratops is a good option to use on the protoceratops rig
Much like Para and Charono
cuz its funky lookin
It looks funky plus its absolutely huge
Yeah
do we know if miragaia was coming? I don't really remember the confirmed species rn
Now as dacentrurus
Dacentrurus was featured in post EA idea list
Priorities....
Koolasuchus
Its true, but ceratopsians are a slippery slope
There's always ooone more interesting one that could be added
Like diabloceratops
Then you remember kosmoceratops
and then you remember wendiceratops yea
but you know, as much as they are unique and cool looking I dont think they are downright necessary
No not at all
I could maybe see like one more ceratopsian added post EA
My vote would be on diablo as another smaller early-mid game animal, but still a weirdo
unfortunately with nasuto in the game diablo loses points
Favourite ceratopsian but he’s right
and trust me I think diablo is cooler as well
Eh true true
Oh shit I forgot pentaceratops
If we need any more ceratopsians it should be either Kosmoceratops, Chasmosaurus or Pentaceratops
No not chasmo itself
We only have one Chasmosaurine and all 3 I stated have at least one other animal from their formation in-game or planned
Abbreviating the group name my bad
Meant chasmosaurine*
But my suggestion was penta
I mean could Chasmosaurus and Kosmoceratops work as alts? Both have short body frills, one just has very weird horns?
If so I’d say them just so we can get 2 in 1
idk tbh
Eh feels like kind of a stretch
There are too many
Giga, Giga, Giga, Giga, and Giga
lol
All with slight variations of the Carcharodontosaurus
I mean giga is aight (personally I think it doesn't add anything new but)
I’m joking
if they add giga it gotta be gnarly looking otherwise it's just gonna be carch 2
I mean tbf its just too popular an animal not to include right?
yea
They should actually add a second Carcharodontosaurus model to the game, give it a chin, call it Giga and see how long it takes for people to realise it’s just Carcha 
I get that another carch in any other circomstance is mid pick
so the devs might even consider mapu as well despite how ridiculously similar all three are
But the giga namesake, just too publicly known
yup
but giga aside
allo and bary as well since they are p much confirmed
what u choosin
I mean giga alt realistically, pull a rex tarbo situation
Would be nice to have someone alongside argent
They should use it as a DlC bait to rinse fanboys and get 5-6 other animals actually worth adding in-game
yeah I'd be totally fine with that
I think Ceratosaurus, Carnotaurus and Australovenator are almost guaranteed to get added
ceratosaurus and carnotaurus because they are super iconic, australo because it adds megaraptoran rep and is the big australian predator
honestly I dont find suchomimus all that appealing, people like to pretend it's so much different to bary when it really aint
It’s certainly has differences anatomy wise
but if they add it I kinda dont care
And behaviour wise it it was certainly different
Most terrestrial Spinosaur
But I digress not necessary for EA
For general theropods, probably just the iconic ones
Carno, utahraptor, cerato, therizino- and I'd personally pick gigantoraptor
gigantoraptor would be nice
Because I like the big chicken
Just one megaraptor would be cool, australo a good one
I could see maip or one of the other weird ones
But australo would make the mesozoic aussie sections feel complete
yeah australo is a bit of a compromise
what it misses in weird it compensates in australian rep
also the devs can just get some liberty on it and just make the claws cool looking still
I’d say Australovenator plus 1 other Megaraptorid as an alt
Then you get weird and Aussie rep
The upside of megaraptorids in-General being quite frag is that’s it’s easier to make them alts
ngl I kinda undermine the alt potential sometimes
but any case I rather focus on og species instead of discussing what alts can be made from what
like australovenator maip or giga mapu
That’s why I don’t like Maip/megaraptor/australo idea floating around
1 alt is fine but 2 and suddenly the og species has only 1 skin
let it just be australo for now
like it's obviously the top 1 contender, everything else is just icing on top
I do it reasonably, more or less
I always look at the phylogeny first
the phylogeny would be minimal
i think
anyway
what else...............
also besides utah I think austroraptor would be the best raptor addition evah
Hesperornis
baryonyx is also confirmed
you're gonna hate when allo drops
Hey im not the guy arguing against alt species here
Yep
Ground sloths like Megatherium and the even larger Eremotherium would make for more large mammals in PK.
Megatherium and Eremotherium were about the same size, with megatherium being more robust while eremotherium having longer limbs like arms and feet and tail etc
Dang I I didn’t know that thanks
Look at this image
no problem
Anomalocaris and trilobite
No shade at my pookie wookie Inostrancevia though
Tbh Anoma didn’t even eat trilobites
Jaekelopterus
For the sole reason of a dumb ai video saying it liked human flesh and it makes me laugh
HMS Hood and KMS Bismarck
Do we know what the next creatures are gonna be?
Gallimimus is coming next update
whos we
Sane people
You know who I would like to see? Andrewsarchus.
Viatkogorgon
so the ontogeny of rex being based on nano for younger stages, does this mean nano is probably off limits for coming to the game
Best namea for anything for a history loveing person as i
I have made three lists, organized by Dinos/Cenozoics/Paleozoics and non-dino mesozoics
Haven't caught up with Palaeozoic stuff in a while but wouldn't the Tapinocephalus Assemblage Zone stuff be boreal compatible?
Recall that area being fairly close to the poles and the permian even having icecaps.
It was comparable to Mongolia albeit a bit wetter
So it depends on if you would consider Mongolia 'boreal'
I believe it does have some taiga to its north
but really I think anything suitably cold should be counted
just based on how the strictest definition of the biome will get basically nothing beyond what it has now
Quite on the contrary, nano is already in the game
:)
I'm gonna get you...
Don't be silly, if nano is in the game how is he supposed to make the music???
how it feels to be in the pk discord and think dinosaurs are lamer than the rest
Set t rex neoteny to 20-50% there you go, nanotyrannus
Boreal is just not really diverse biome. From list provided above arctodus and macrauchenia also would get one and maybe megatherium, if we are pushing it.
yup, that
I may be wrong but it's planned
is it?
yeah it'll be great
Mmm, while IMO Penta and Lepto+Udano are the better ceratopsian additions, Turano/Zuni could be neat lil' dudes
Nothingburgeratops
Very strange animal yea
Aenocyon when?
Hyaenodon when?
Mee6 when?
If anyone here hasn’t taken the poll
If they do give us the recently extinct expansion I just want the Passenger Pigeon as an arboreal terrarium animal
definitely gonna be a terrarium animal if it comes
There were too many choices so I picked a few random ones
Hope we have many of these
There are a lot of creatures on this list that I would like, but it’s probably under 30 of them
Because a lot of these creatures are just unnecessary
Hot take: I think any creature that has a decent fossil record and/or we have a good idea of how it lived could get in the game
lukewarm take
Not for some
Ehhhhhhh
When will the poll results be posted?
May ish, as I’m making a video on the results
Why?
Can't you just like post them
Itd be a lot more convient for people who took the questionnaire to see the results
Rather than watching a full video
1: I spent way too much time and effort on this not to get any benefit
And 2: A Video can ultimately be more entertaining than a list
And if I make a good video, I would have added more to the community than if I just posted a list of the top 10
I genuinely think having basically almost modern animals in this game will be fun
dimetrodon and great auk, could hardly be more different in age but united in extinction 🙏
Great Auk, more like Goat
But hesperonis walked so the great Auk could run
cohabiting these two in game would be so sick oh god
Could def be a giga alt
I didn't realize you were doing this for your 'benefit"
Would take Concavenator over Giga unironically
It’s a juvenile
Hmmm...
Zuniceratops
Tryna find a good size chart
Best I can get is this image
... Nevermind, its probably either a sub-adult or a juvenile
Maybe Mesophryne and Liaobatrachus, two mesozoic frogs of the cretaceous
Been saying that for a long time
Well known, more complete fossil should be the priority
Including the small one like scelido
We got confirmations It would be one of the first, and unless they want to add Haast's and steller's imo it's gonna be the first dlc, we also have confirmation than a Wild Horse and Quagga Will be in It.
A wild horse is so slay
I mean could yes, but should? Like when we get like 3 differently sized trilobites i wouldn't want another in place of another more unique animal just because the trilobite is more complete.
I'm hoping for Occidental (american) Horse with the Quagga alt
Quagga being the main species would be weird af
Personally i think It could fit, but some people Will argue it's too old
wdym too old
I don't remember Who It was but when i proposed Mekosuchus (which i retrospective i don't want since i want It in a dedicated island DLC) as a candidate (3.000 years old) someone (one of the regulars) said It wasn't recently extinct, and a lot of people seemed to agreee, Hippi is 8.500 years old
huh ah yeah I dont mean it as part of the recently extinct pack
the recently extinct pack should be historical times
also it doesn't really need any tweaks
maybe 1 mini exhibit would go well
(passenger pigeon)
or the hawaii o'o
Imo anything as old or more recent than Mesopotamia is fair Game.
honestly I think they better keep it simple, the island extinction slope is far too great for them to manage
😵💫 😵💫 😵💫 😵💫
and how old is that
5.000
didnt mammoths go extinct like more recently than that
I’d say the opposite, any creature that has a poor fossil record or is very fragmentary should be disqualified as an addition, exceptions are if they are very popular or are already in-game
For example: Nanuqsaurus which is literally just a piece of jaw
a lot of popular species are very fragmentary
including some that are yet to be added I think
for exampol
UUUUUUUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
honestly I could only think of brachy and carch
and those already in lole
Kelenken
Thats probably most fragmenty future addition I can think of
hmmmmmmmm
spinosaurus
Hence why I said already in
Around that time, but those were the wrangle survivors, at that time there hadn't a mammoth on Siberia for like 8.000 years
So the game's mammoths went extinct like 12.000-15.000 years ago
If I were a clinically insane person I would say something deranged like
we sooooooo need Sardinian pikas (prolagus sardus)
no we need the sardinian otter 

Hodari? Kinda ig? He is a good artist but his artworks are often on the fantastical side
rather than the down to earth side
like no megalenhydris would not try to hunt a hammerhead shark, it wasn't big enough and was a specialized benthic forager
people using that artwork for reference is just warping their perception of what the actual animal was and it's annoying having to clarify
fair enough
I just used it because it's the most recognisable art of it
yeah and I hate that
it shouldn't be
but awesomebro artworks sell ig
not that there are many megalenhydris artworks unfortunately
on the topic of sardinia it looks exactly like the scrubland map
parts of it at least
I mean it is similar since it's in the same region
u know what a good addition would be
Myotragus 🔥
hell yeah 
I really hope it's not too small tho...
like
myotragus is quite small lol
it would be one of the smallest animals in the game if added
excluding terrarium animals of course
Terrarium?
I know but ontogeny would be a bit hard for mytragus
I doubt that
why would it be hard to begin with
it would be no different from any other animal already in
Prop myotragus when
no >:(
Myotragus was actually multiple small Myotraguses together as one
i wanna know why u said ontogeny would be hard for myotragus
I guess since the babies would be way smaller than velo I suppose
what makes you think that

baby myotragus would be bigger than baby velo
they didn't come out of an egg
Yeah but for a cold blooded mammal I doubt they'd be that big
As a zoologist, never fucking underestimate mustelids
They would be big
Ungulates need to come out of the womb walking
Ah, valid
As a hobby zoologist, Erior is right
Even specialist mustelids will eat anything under the right circumstance
What's disturbing is they're not just this opportunistic with food
trust me
I don't underestimate them, I'm being realistic
trust me bro, you shouldn't underestimate bears
Sea otters have been observed catching sharks, stoats will hunt rabbits and hares, wolverines and ratels will confront the apex predators of their environments
It is not this kind of stuff, it is mustelids being observed to consistently be insane
Bit too insane
Never ask what a sea otter can do to an unattended penguin or sea lion cub
In addition, hammerheads are not a single shark species, but a quite variable clade
This is what I'm talking about
what you see there is a small shark
not a hammerhead
Yeah, it is a nurse shark being caught by a sea otter
Scalloped hammerheads are that size
scalloped hammerheads are that small?
A meter and a half long on average
Smooth and great hammerheads are the ones that get to 5+ meters
Males
then the one in the artwork is clearly not a scalloped hammerhead
Females get larger
But still, blue shark sized roughly speaking
Still, can see an otter tangling with a shark its size
What is it's a pleistocene hammerhead species?
megalenhydris hunting a mid sized benthic shark species I can buy
megalenhydris hunting a pelagic 5+ meter hammerhead shark is pure fantasy
and no, stoats hunting rabbits is not a justification for it
please show me a giant otter eating a caiman that doubles its size
I'll wait :)
funny you would consider a small caiman not on the level of the benthic shark
When a caiman attacks the otter cubs, the whole family comes together to defend them.
Subscribe: http://bit.ly/BBCEarthSub
Watch more videos from BBC Earth:
Planet Earth http://bit.ly/PlanetEarthPlaylist
Blue Planet http://bit.ly/BluePlanetPlaylist
Planet Earth II http://bit.ly/PlanetEarthIIPlaylist
Planet Dinosaur http://bit.ly/PlanetDino...
Black caiman I believe
This is scarier than being mauled by piranhas
The paper constricting Megalenhydris to a benthic diet is also, honestly, quite bare bones; it finds out it had quite robust and pointy teeth, but it is 5 pages long and basically just has throwaway lines about niche partitioning
The thing is, they WILL fight larger predators and consume them
but the size difference is similar to the artwork of mega
no??? In the artwork it is fighting a shark thats clearly much bigger
in the picture the nurse shark is smaller than the otter
similar
how is the size difference similar?
Biology also runs on exceptions and weirdness rather than on rules, despite the intentions of internet people who want to tell others that they are wrong...
dude that is not what similar means in the slightest ._.
also regarding this another good indicative of the benthic lifestyle is the hip bones and vertebrae showing signs that it was adapted to go down and up quickly
so basically
forage on the bottom
go up for air
go to the bottom again
Good, specialized, but that doesn't mean constrained
anyway I think the convo is extending far beyond the point of this thread
and honestly I have better things to do than insist on such a fruitless topic
if you wanna believe on that absurd artwork be my guest
but I rather think of animals realistically
Again, stoats hunting hares
I don't directly believe it but I'm not against it
Animals are ridiculous, mustelids in general are even more ridiculous, and the main issue with paleontology has consistently be ignoring living animals
If only we could examine it
Fucking Spinosaurus holotype is more accessible
Carcha holotype was the basis of 2 genera, the second one 80 years after its destruction
Meanwhile, Pelecanimimus remains out of sight because Spanish academia is this weird chestbeating autofellatory circle
Concavenator got a neat description and good pics of the holotype, but Pelecanimimus is an awesome animal that has been locked away for 30 years
Oh yeah, it is insidiously hard to approach
why is it?
No images allowed
Hence why the spino debates are dumb
I feel like Spinosaurus could've had varied fishing styles
Cuenca Museum I believe?
https://rac.es/ficheros/doc/00019.pdf These remain the only images of the specimen I think
thats an article from freaking 1994
Yeah
Original description
Again, the Spino holotype remains more accessible
And was blown up 80 years ago
and is like the cuenca museum against it being studied or what exactly
I believe it is an issue of a single scientist or something
Our uni professors are... weird as a rule; I know you are from Spain but don't know if you started Uni here, as a single week of class with the average prof will tell you everything you need to know about their selfcenteredness
that's in every uni
yea thats every uni
I mean, even worse when they don't know a bit of English and decide that the entire world is just what they can understand lol
Concavenator in 2010 had thermorregulation as an explanation for its neural spines, in the same paper that there was mention of feathers
That's a literal fossil professor pushing something decades outdated
Buuut, yeah, I'll keep pushing for a Barremian Europe roster of Iguanodon, Baryonyx, Polacanthus, Hypsilophodon, Pelecanimimus and Concavenator; some wiggle room in Conca's size, due to Altispinax likely being closer and being a bit larger than the holotype of Conca, and I believe that's a neat roster
Istiodactylus once large pterosaurs are viable; the cookiecutter vulture is awesome
we should raid depalma's house
GET DOWN
GET DOWN ON THE FLOOR
WHERE THE FOSSIL DE PALMA
And Horner's place
There are a few good mesozoic European species to pick from, conca and peli, europasaurus, tethyshadros
I'd really like to see megalosaurus in the game some day
isn't torvo the cooler megalosaurus
Round out the crystal palace representation
Yes, that's who we're sending
They're so physically similar I'll just be using a neotenic torvo in game for now
I'm pretty sure Megalo got changed up
But idk it's such an important dino, the other half to iggy
Really? I'm out of the loop
Just a small goat, if we have velo and psitacco i really don't see why myo would be a problem
I mean it's culturally significant but it's not a popular animal in itself
like you dont see kids saying megalosaurus is their favorite dinosaur
it's the basic bitch dino for those who minimally learn about the history of paleontology
Europasaurus would be cool ngl.... dwarf sauropod
there are so many cool sauropods, its kinda unfair lol
Got a more Monolopho-based design
Yep, Conc is there iirc
Neotenic brachy to cope for now, but yes would be dope
Thought that was purely speculative
Europasaurus, Nigersaurus, Amargasaurus, Diplodocus, Mamenchisaurus 💀
You forgot shuno
But you did forget the alamo
you don't need shuno no more
Always remember the Alamo
I used to be in this boat but it's not the same, like one is a lil tail nodule, the other is a thagomizer club
Like full on weaponry its so cool
I don't care, devs can take the artistic liberty to make it a thagomizer
the shunosaurus discourse brings me memories
Plus same formation as yang
Honestly, Magyarosaurus is IMO the better dwarf sauropod, because a Hatzeg pack would go hard
where isisaurus.............................
Shuno's entire formation definitely deserves lots of rep
Seeing as Shaximiao is like an asian version of the Morrison
Literally not knowing a bit about sauropods
tryna find the image I made years ago
Actually I have no idea if the thagomizers are still accepted knowledge, seeing more modern reconstructions without them
Oh I found it
But anyways agree to disagree I just think it'd be cool to have both mamench and shuno
from freaking 5 years ago 😭
He's made me the soyjack... I have lost...
honestly if they decide to add it I don't mind but it is the most boring small sauropod of the ones that are usually suggested lole
Seeing as it has a good theropod rep, tons of stegosaurians, and unique sauropods
Honestly I think my most niche sauropod pull would be sauroposideon (which isn't niche nor that crazy)
But it kinda is just... longer brachy
But it'd just be cool cloverly rep, maybe throw it in some pack themed around animal sizes with shantung or giga or smth
also shaximiao has mamenchi so what makes you think shuno would be added over mamenchi 🤔
mamenchi: the cooler shuno
I think they're both cool B)
I prefer Yang
but like I know it will never be added 😔
I will protect my nothingburger dinosaur at all costs
The neotenic system allows for a lot
I think you could definitely fake it with one of the allosaurs at like 15% growth
gasosaurus' only job is appearing in artworks being mauled by shuno
When shuno needs to maul something in paleoart
but he does an excellent job so I love him
also it has a funny name
and honestly you gotta appreciate how basic of a dinosaur it is.... so humble.............
gasosaurus is the very essence of humility.... in dinosaur form......
I like the bulldog feel new Yang has
if we're getting any metriacanthosaurid it should be Yang
Eh, metri with a yang alt
Metri is fragmentary asf and at one point Yang was actually planned for the game
they're not even each other's closest relatives, terrible alt potential
unless theres a more recent family tree later than 2013
Basically just proof of dinosaur fans just being megatheropod fans
Metri is ass, literally
As in it is just an ass
Every single Metri recon you see is Sinraptor
^only popular because it was onscreen a couple seconds in JP which led to it being in JWE
for Metri
Name would be ignored if Paul didn't lump everything into it in PDotW and thus snuck as a filler name in JP
literally clout for no reason
Sinraptor is the most vanilla theropod ever according to theropod workers lol
tbf the skull is a bit basic
Unlike the Yang
It is vanilla, never said it was bad
Who has the coolest Metricanthosaur skull
Younger yangs would likely look more like Sinraptor after all
neither did I, I said basic
So use em as baby alts
Since that seems to be a trend nowadays
kaikaifilu and mosasaurus hoffmannii
Could Tullimonstrum be a viable addition as a mini or an ambient animal?
ambiet? what do that mean?
we need that lol
what dis ambient mean?
we shall never know
like
He mean ambience animal
well lets say they add aquariums
what do that mean?
Like squirrel in ZT2
some things are a little too small to be added singularly in and they dont make the cut for terrariums either
so you just add say
a school of them
say a bunch of ammonites for example
An animal that randomly appeared and we can't control it
my wording on that wasnt exactly great
ah oke
I think it's a bit early to talk about aquatics
I think jwe2 has this with the fish from the aquatic fish feeder but im uncertain
"Ambient is an adjective used to describe an aspect of the environment that completely surrounds you, but in a mellow way, like ambient music played softly throughout a restaurant, or the ambient orange glow during a setting sun."
but in this context an ambient animal is like a prop, not a fully functional animal, just something in the background
If you use the biggest estimates (25cm) then yes
Eh it's similar in lenght to something like micro so maybe
tully is (sadly) too small
we're gonna miss out on the PEAK that are cambrian animals cause the vast majority is too tiny even for terrariums
Amargasaurus🙏
Did this guy just say amogusaurus............. 
Biggest estimates are 35cm long, tbh i wouldn't mind if they went for those
Also mini Aquariums will probably be smaller than mini exhibits
Since due to them be "3d" the space needed for animals would be lower
yeah but most cambrian animals are REALLY small
alongside being very complex to model
don't think devs would bother adding anyone aside The Endless
Anomalocaris is a giant by Cambrian standards and it was lobster sized
On the topic of early paleozoic animals, Endoceras as an exhibit creature would be neat to see
but yeah Omnidens is obscure, large and cool enough to be a very good addition
endoceras being vertical all the time would be interesting to see
speaking of paleozoic species i had a few ideas in my chart here #1360542295228944414 message
I submit crassigyrinus scoticus as an exhibit animal, would love to have him as a nod to Prehistoric Park and give us another water fellow alongside Tiktaalik
I want the Diplocaulus for terrarium
Please add my glorious king beezlbufo as anything but a terrarium creature.
please add fish but don't make them swim
Wut
rude
go on
No
but bufo is pretty small tho
honest
You don’t get to hear it
Exactly
therefor it would be a terrarium animal
People keep modern day frogs in terrariums
Beelzebufo, if it came, would only come as a terrarium animal
It's too small and ontogeny is too difficult for otherwise
like, just barely bigger than the goliath frog
You understand
Beelz is very cool, but he'd be a very cool terrarium animal
I want my glorious king diplocaulus
diplocaulus would be slay
diploceraspis is the cooler diplocaulus
who
i felt that
mau said it's not coming
nope
It was on the list Mau killed
Ok I finished typing my idea in the enrichment thread
in u16
u mean the list with compsognathus and stuff?
he publicly announced mononykus' death in main
mono was never confirmed
fr?
yeah that list
wasn't it quite clearly in the list he posted
????
like I know it was blurry but it was fairly clear
which means diictodon and peltephilus are probably out too
he only said the speculation for u16 roadmap image was 100% wrong
????
Mau said no to Diictodon, Mononykus, Peltephilus, and Beelzebufo
(i huff hopium everyday for it being real tho)
or just u16
didn't we quite literally get simosuchus right
bullshi
bitch ass castorocauda ain't got anything over the Bufo
so they could potentially come after u16 at some point?
I dont recall the image quality being this bad
yeah ath the end of the day nothing is out
then you remember wrong haha
That is a heavily upscaled version, not the original
can you link me mau's original post of the image
ty <3
HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
maybe its my mind but I still can at least see compsognathus being there
Which would make sense considering Compsoganthus was known beforehand anyways
Mau presumably meant that pkdino's list was wrong, not all the animals we'd guessed
Simosuchus was confirmed afterwards though and it was fairly clear in the focalized image
Also possible plans changed since then anyways, we did go from 5 to 9 animals in update 16
kinda sad he disproved mono 😦 it's a really good pick
can't really think of much regarding minis
Ok so while I was le brushing me teeth i thought of da possible contenders
They said there would be 3 mini exhibit types right?
Yes
If i recall arboreal, amphibian and burrow
They’re also a arboreal lizard, a fuzzy Triassic thing, 2 weird dinosaurs, and a semi aquatic mammal
Essentially
When they said this?
MAU after he deconfirmed pkdino’s list
also we know the diets too
im assuming the fuzzy triassic thing is prolly thrinaxodon
Because of wwd right
Makes sense
Also, semiaquatic mammal...
Small semiaquatic mammal
There's also just not a ton of other options tbh
Like I guess other creatures in the same family but why not choose the best known at that point
Castorocauda and Didelphodon are the two most common guesses so far
Any reason why it wouldnt be indohyus?
Indohyus would work
Idk the size refs on google are all over the place lol
If you search for size refs you get pakicetys
Ah
Indohyus was around the size of a cat
Its kind of a mouse deer in many ways
I think it fits
Way better than something like castorocauda lol
Indo would def be a contender
I think a weird little jurassic or cretaceous mammal would be cool tho
Just from like a variety standpoint
The arboreal lizard defo gonna be either drepanosaurus or coelurosauravus
Especially if we do get Ambulocetus in u18
Possibly the later as drepano is most likely too small
Could be Longisquama imo
Longisquama is 15 cm long
I don't see how Drep is too small
And there are larger species in the family
Hypurnecton or whatever
Have you seen the size of the mini exhibit?
Hmmmm still kinda small, not as small as I thought tho
Drepenosaurus is the largest out of it, Coeluro, and Longisquama, by a very significant margin
Its like the size of larger chameleons iirc
Coeluro is smaller?
Yeah
Oh yeah
Finding anything on coeluro that isn't Peters is painful lmao
Gonna be kinda funny having such an humongous box for a tiny lizard
Wait
Lemme think
Throw in like 15 of the buggers
Drepano/coeluro: insectivore
????: herbivore
Thrinaxodon: carni
Indohyus: piscivore
????: carnivore
Well
Indohyus could be the herb lol idk what its diet was
So for the 2 weird dinos
Google lists it as omnivore
But I think the game could easily call it a piscovore
One is either pisc/herb and the other is a carnivore
I think i know what one is gonna be
What was it called
Liaoningosaurus
Thats one
That's also a juvie
Herbi is most likely heterodontosaurid of some sort
That's not a bad bet
Tianyulong would make sense there imo
Tiny guy, even among heterodontosaurs
Honestly almost every heterodontosaurid, even heterodontosaurus proper, could work as a terrarium
Heterodontosaurus itself would be on sort of the cusp
Could yeah but most hit a weird spot of being kinda weird to fit?
Dinosaur options:
- sinosauropteryx
- kulindadromeus/fruitadens
- micropachycephalosaurus
- liaoningosaurus
Idk imo there's an awkward spot in terms of sizes
Imo most heterodontosaurs kinda land there
Or wait, maybe switch kulinda for fruitadens idk
My personal really weird want is Manidens
So we can have a non-flying/gliding arboreal dinosaur
Who
Me think:
Terrestrial: simo, compy, thrinax
Arboreal: yi, drepano, manidens
Aqua: tikt, castorocauda and carni dino
Manidens, seemingly arboreal heterodontosaur
That would be fun
probably fruitadens on account of being Morrison, but tbh both are very very obscure
The only reason people would known Fruitadens is on account of looking at the Morrison formation species list wikipedia page
Morrison huh
Nah I actually recall seeing news abt fruitadens
like i didnt get to know about it from wikipedia
Wait
What about heterodontosaurus
Maybe cause it is the smallest ornithischian
There was that one paper a few days ago that called basically every small ornithopod in the Morrison besides it and dryo nomen dubia so
Actually checking het is like around compy in size
Heterodontosaurus would also work, depending on which specimen you use it's kinda into the size range of full exhibit but in theory could be either
Then my bet is on heterodontosaurus
And like, we got Tiktaalik as a terrarium, despite some specimens getting up to the size of an American alligator
True
I guess size isn't that much of a constraint
Especially cause minis won't have size variation (or at least don't afaik)
So whatever the devs decide is the average is what we get
Excited to see what it is
Same