Didn't reply back since I resolved the issue (I think?). I was able to get some reliable prints since then.
However, I've ran into a new issue today where for some reason prints just aren't sticking well in the center of the bed. Brim prints nice and I think my z-offset is correct because it can print well in areas of the bed away from the center, but when it has to fill anything near the center it just doesn't stick.
Tried cleaning the bed with some alcohol and re running the mesh several times, even had to factory reset just to make sure it wasn't some config issue, but I wasn't able to resolve the problem.
I'm using PETG and the nozzle temp is at 240C, bed at 80C.
I wouldn't say the roll is the driest its been, but I don't think it's an issue since it can print well in some places but just craps itself in the center.
Uploaded picture for reference.