#streamchat
1 messages · Page 311 of 1
im betting on DDOS + IP Spoofing. and Jagex DDOS protection auto DC'ing Thor
Thor living completely rent free in their heads 
Malicious intent isn't directly tied to stupidity, and it's easy to hate a username over the internet
But he can't have a life stalking Thor from 12-12
eh, Thor streams 9-21 CEST
its also a saturday
Sorry West coast
^ This
Doubt it's a coincidence that this suddenly started on a Saturday
This started yesterday or the day before
i wonder if its the dude that's been stalking Thor in game
Oh I thought we already thought that?
i wonder what that persons internal narrative is
maybe. i havent been here the entire time
Lots of ideas have been thrown around, and that has been one of them, so yes? lol
fair
how can someone twist their logic so that its noble to do this to Thor
What is their end goal? Like be on stream or stop it?
appears to be to stop it
get him banned.
generally believing every single thing anyone puts out no matter how absurd or utterly false; fully outsourcing decision making
my guess
Easy? "Stop Thor from playing/'tainting' OSRS"
as opposed to all the other people jumping over from WoW?
I'd wager it's more of trying to discourage him from streaming it, or even just purely to ruin his day/stream
i dont know
reports aren't handled right then and there
jagex can be a bit slow at times
also what Marlem said
I was thinking about that one viewer who came in and said “I heard a rumor that you were going back to work at blizzard” from a YT clip, but couldn’t identify who they got the idea from…. They can’t even remember who is making the rumor, but they remember Thor
I'm just repeating what thor says when I say he said something
There has been comments for a while now about how "the whole OSRS community doesn't want you" by trolls, after all
i once got support for something in less than 10 minutes, and was massively suprised (was product support, not gaming). usually have to wait at least 24 hours for support.
well yes, product support usually directly involves money
unless its some huge company like amazon
He's the one complaining idk
The small vocal minority will always be more outspoken than the silent majority
the 10 min one was a very small busniess. thats why i was surprised.
Hey. Just got another stream notification. Is everything ok?
Nope, stream all done for today
Totally! But it'd only take one or two of those to do something like this, if they have the knowledge and know-how
Done 🙂 or done 🙁
Thor's okay, he just ended the stream early because of issues with OSRS, so he's cleaning the house instead
Probably frustrated IMO
Absolutely
Things went sideways with someone making a way to directly affect Thor's ability to play when OSRS was on screen (No one knows the method) Thor decided to just call it a day while the issue hopefully passes
Have a nice day too, then
Wish he just switched games but I understand the runscape phase
Part of why this is so silly is it's getting to the point that people are watching years old content and coming in fresh from it. Like every time someone comes in asking about viewbotting I feel like it was likely generated by that actual viewbotting attack during the height of the craze where the top streamers were hitting 200k and it was obvious and people were pretending like the streamers were doing it themselves
oh well. time to go do shit. like go to the store. groceries aint gonna buy themselves
just have your ai connected fridge do it.... oh wait
thanks, i hate it
Do you guys always watch the stream? I usually listen to most of it
Yaa.. like.. why would a popular streamer speed run getting banned by obviously viewbotting. That is possibly the dumbest thing anyone can ever think
youre welcome
Fridge is too busy running Heartbound
I do both, depending on what I'm doing- I always have it on my second monitor if I'm at my PC, but I usually just listen if I'm on my phone
Yes, this is what I also do
hope so. In the end they are using a 3rd party launcher with 3rd party plugins. The devs of the launcher are trusted by Jagex. They review their available plugins, but people can make mistakes or don't know all/new exploits.
I would definitely restart the network to get a new ip again and then try with just the vanilla launcher. If the issue still occurs , it's most likely an osrs issue, otherwise runelite and/or a plugin.
I just recently discovered I can listen to twitch with the phone screen blocked... Yes. It took me this long....
That's actually a setting on mobile! All the way at the bottom lol
It took me forever to find myself lol
Thor reinstalled the game and loaded it without runelite, issues still occured
anyways
Wasn't he using Runelite after the stream restarted, though?
a bit after
The disconnect still happened on mobile while he was on wifi, so it wasn't the client
given i have no idea and nothing to add, im going to go do other things.... might try and continue grinding on RS3
Definitely wasn't the client causing it, but it might be how they're finding what to attack- I have no clue, though
Like finding the IP, if that's what they're doing
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Wait, what? I know I can slide the mini player off to the side
There's a setting for it, which you can change if it isn't set to "Always"
we all knew Gerald had it in him
"Shaye is exotic and was a vet assistant" 
Technically not wrong
I had to step away for a bit - Did Thor end up having to end stream due to the OSRS issues? Damn shame if so.
Yeah, took down the stream for about half an hour to troubleshoot, came back, and wasn't fixed
So he decided to just call it for the day
Damn that sucks just due to the fact that some dirt bag was able to achieve what they were (probably) hoping for. I hope it all works out.
wouldnt surprise me if Thor also tries to do some digging on his end
yeah, the glass half full side would be that it seemed like Thor was rather interested in understanding what was going on
It could just be whatever method he was going to use to track down the issue he didn't want to put on stream to potentially warn the attacker
that'd be weird since the attacker was only doing it while he was streaming
her a.i. bf defaulting to a serial killer. nothing to worry about i'm sure.
whats the OSRS issue?
im not tuned into the stream but i like to keep in touch
only them?
he could play just fine as long as it wasn't displayed
definitely
he did a bunch of experiments like he aimed the ant cam at the monitor and whenever the game was obviously in motion he would disconnect. He put up a runescape style image while playing and it did nothing
he'd openly talk about playing the game on his phone or just not on screen and there were no issues
that sucks
sounds like someone was being a but for the sake of being a butt bec of past opinions
yarg
I went back to look at the vod, and it sucks that this was over the course of several hours
understandable to end stream after all that
Wait so was the issue the game itself or the act of streaming it?
the issue was someone somehow breaking the connection when the game was visible on stream
Ohhh. Like a hacker attack?
something like that yea
the going theory is that somehow they were automatically visually identifying whether RS was on screen, and when it was, they'd start up some attack to cause thor's connection to break, something like spoofing IP packets to cause the servers to stop serving thor
I bet they set up the detection so that they're not spending compute when not neccesary
I question the wisdom of hacking a former cyber security professional who has friends who are current cyber security professionals
But then if they were wise they wouldn't attempt this crap in the first place
the next step once you know whats going on is how to counter it
Why he stopped early i lost my Streak of 150+
go rewatch the vod
I’m sad. I hope everything is okay
thought they allowed you to do that now
He kept getting disconnected from the game every time it was on screen for several hours
I’m not able atm to watch the vod
piratesoftware went live on Twitch. Catch up on their Old School RuneScape VOD now.
this one?
I think he probably means he's just not in a spot where he could watch it, not that he's incapable
So correct me if I'm wrong, but this is what I gathered happened: he started getting DCed from RuneScape. Seems someone was attacking his connection or something? He tried restarting his PC and the stream. It was less than a 30 minute gap, though, so any stream streaks that happened before are safe. The restart didn't fix it though, so he finished for the day.
Did I get that right?
sort of, it started after about 4 hours of everything normal though
Yes
targeting the IP connection because it did affect Shaye from what i heard
ah, sorry then
Humans. Why
Yeah, I caught the start of stream....partly because I'm paranoid of losing my streak when random stuff like this happens while I'm asleep 😭
you never know when a Shayensaw incident will occur
Hrrrrmh... I wonder if I lost my streak... 
Any good news?
all quiet since Thor stopp streaming
They're probably just hardcore wow players tbh bc that fanbase literally is that toxic to be singlehandedly (or at least be the majority) driving a hate campaign
Blizzard and its fanbase are in competition for the group most likely to drive someone to suicide
Except blizzard the company did actually do that and its fanbase just attempts to, so I guess blizzard itself is still worse
damn, that sucks. i wanted to ask him if he heard of Void/Breaker - that game is awesome, i can't believe it was made by a single dev
I missed the streams earlier, and the VODs stop playing after a few minutes for me - but did Pirate try running wireshark and seeing what is going on in his network?
I mean when that web drawing game page thing got defaced most of the vandalism was wow references so
Meanwhile on my end, I left one comment on a tweet pushing back against the derangement against Thor, and almost immediately a guy with an orc profile pic shows up out of the blue to call me slurs

he did yea, said the logs for his network had nothing special
damn, it's so weird. He removed the plugins he installed for RS too? I am not suggesting he do any of these things btw, just want to know if there was anything weird he found from that because the VODs aren't working for me
He tried playing it on mobile over wifi, and it was still the same
Turned off wifi and did it over data, no issue
Sounds like Classic Twitter.
Knowing thor and his love for puzzles i suspect he was just as thrilled at a new challenge to figure out as he was annoyed someone was interrupting his stream
I could be wrong though. The annoyance level could've been much higher
yeah, it's probably a combination of that and wanting to be sure to isolate what the vulnerability is
like if he just switched to BitCraft or Dune without solving it maybe it's not an OSRS vulnerabilitya nd things get worse
God if that really is the case, why are people so horrible 🙁
ive noticed it with more and more shorts
These people see Thor as the bad guy. By messing with him, they think they are doing justice or some crap.
i saw another vid about it this morning. man, they really have nothing better to do, do thtey?
Haven't got that in my recommendations so far. And if it does, I'll do the usual "don't recommend channel" option.
it's not like here's anything new to be said either. it's literally a copy of a copy of a copy
The other day, there were several people popping in and saying "Stop Playing RuneScape" or "you better stop playing RuneScape", shite like that
is that runescape people or drama people?
it's certainly drama people, they may or may not like run escape, too
you have people coming in in the middle of the game jam finalists stream trolling that there's nothing in the stream about game dev, you can't infer anything from what the trollss/bots say
I can imagine they also give guff to all the game jam people
it's been 8, almost 9 months now
how do they still have this much steam?
pretty soon someone could've given birth to an actual person if they got pregnant when the drama started
well that would be a weird thing to do when starting drama

i mean, they've already been metaphorically impregnated by filth
indeed
it's ironic in the worst way given how Thor's message that went megaviral was all about positivity
Unfortunately some of the harassment started when Thor's yt channel initially got big, and then more happened when the petition that shall not work harassed Thor into videos about it, and it's just snowballed since the WoW bs drama.
So some of these harassers have been at it since Nov 23.
i wonder if theres anything thor can do to shut em up
starving the drama farming is the best thing
go undercover as ferretmcferretface
cuz yeah, doing nothing and making it a war of attrition would work
Not really, and trying just...makes them worse, but not trying makes them even worse than that, because then they become smug and act like they've won the war
Thor needs money, thus Thor has to create content
anyone with 2 braincells knows that Thor is fine
yeah
those that are missing one or both are the issue
it just sucks that they have a monopoly on controlling the narrative
And unfortunately, the ones who don't are the loudest and truly believe that he should stop... existing, simply for disagreeing with their opinions
cuz we're taking the high road, we've given them access to the high traffic low road
just with the mob, although the mob is pretty devout at 'educating' people who don't understand what's going on with the latest randomly generated video they've watched -.-
it would be funny if Thor took all the drama vids, fed them to an AI, then created a vid of his own
people are constantly coming into stream thinking that the MeatCanyon vid is a gotcha of some sort and yet Thor likes it
Basically it's like this
Thor: gives different opinion
Them: screeching noises BAD PERSON! DESTROY!
and now, it's
Thor: vibes and just...exists
Them: Stop it, you're a bad person , you can't have a different opinion about anything from me, and if you do, you shouldn't exist, because it hurts my feelings!"
Remember these people are allergic to posting receipts so take this revengance meme
im going to post this and pretend that this has something to do with the convo
I wonder what'd happen if thor did more collabs, like maybe helldive with mouse or smth. How that angry mob would contend with another community of great size
loud minority issue
Or Kai
They would try and destroy mousey for daring to associate with Thor...and fail, miserably
that's what I'm thinking
if more and more people actually talk to thor
maybe the public will realize how dumb the drama is
that's an easy one, they'd attack everyone involved, try to make the idea of being in Thor's vicinity hostile by association, a method of trying to isolate him from other creators
They tried with Thor announcing about mousey fundraiser a bit ago, that comment section got really snarky in response to the drama folk
That was fun
The fact that they keep attacking the ferrets is all you need to consider there
the problem is, thor, publicly, is already kinda isolated from other creators. he mostly streams solo due to the kind of content he streams
and I'm not saying thor should do collabs just to lose some of the heat, that's almost as scummy as what the mob is doing
Which is usually, y'know, dev stuff, single player games...dune...
but i do wonder what'd happen if it happened
I'm trying to figure out why people are attacking the ferts like they are
beacuse a number of the smear campaigns are literally saying everything Thor says is a total lie, so every time he explains what's going on, it's complete fiction, I think it's that simple
at the end of the day, we can only theorize hypotheticals. I personally believe that if they attack other creators for being associated with thor, then that'd be a death knell to the dumb harassment campaign
there hasnt been any kind of "defense" from anyone as if choosing to not engage is taken as a means of conceding that every accusation is true
Best I can come up with: they can't fathom the possibility of someone who's opinion differes from theirs on even a singular thing being a good person and genuinely doing selfless things
people will realize "oh this is stupid" and zone out to the drama once it starts hurting people other than the one they're trying to villainize.
But it has, and they just go "they associated with that POS Thor, so they got what they deserved"
It's...mind boggling
I don't think it'll work out like that. It'd be same way that most people react when a creator would collab with Asmongold for example. Just look at the amount of shit Thor got for explaining something to him (although that was after the start of this whole drama, so maybe it just amplified it)
I doubt we're at asmon levels of animosity, at least not yet
That's at least the goal for the haters
I'm just worried because it feels like they just have total control of the narrative
Asmon may be a unhygienic shuthead, but if he gives advice about something like WoW, is honestly believe him on it, as the man is the closest thing to a WoW "Expert" I've honestly seen who isn't a complete "PvP or Nothing!" Sweat
But his opinions about people is something I just...completely write off as "most likely unhinged af"
I might look at it just to satisfy a morbid curiosity about how bad it is
But that'd be it

Oh, hai starr!
hi star

I'll take the blame for this one, I started it
Lots of drama talk today :3

Ay i had nothing to do with it! i think.
just kinda spiraly since the OSRS attack made everything wonky
stream ended early via mysterious means, makes sense we'd speculate
this is the tldr of the convo
probably shaye playing with her chain saw accidnetly cutting own the internet pole
if only TT
i wonder how many trees are left in america since it arrived
beaver rescue when
Quite a bit, considering it was just a stuffie chainsaw
Not a real one
Last I heard, it was being given to the ferts as a gift
Just observing how people respond to this latest drama. You can tell who supports Thor and who will take every opportunity to diminish these attacks on him
Drama sucks, man 
There's still trouble with the connection? I see the ferret stream is down.
power outage atm
the connection issues earlier was between Thor's OSRS account and OSRS
Aha, and a power outage on top of it
(actually not that bad im at work and cant watch anyways)
Feels bad, yall getting some bad tech rng
I am exhausted
Hi exhausted I'm Mel
Shut
Hi Mel of non-Projekt origins, how are you?
...why did I send that?

If only i was cool as her lol
Today was probably annoying for Thor but that Girl Dinner conversation was probably the funniest thing ever to me
I’m wondering if Thor is doing better
Dumb as this sounds i wonder if he got a little excited since this is a new issue or puzzle to solve he's never experienced
she's mostly just... awkward, most of the time, anyways, not entirely always on purpose
Girls in a nutshell
it's the quiet ones you have to "worry" about
you have to worry about chibi
I have 11older sisters
OH GOD
at least, idk what her actual username is
Worry about all types of girls
the one that usually has the eyes going opposite directions
ELEVEN?
and looks like a chibi character
Damn your parents were busy
that's a different kind of worry, Chibi's just an anklebiter, and she knows it
or bored
Remarried so its a few steps in that ladder
at one point a helicopter hit a powerline in the netherlands, so the power was out for a bit in some place
9 months later, birth rates were up

Lol
local lady whos the leader of what i call a Cult, but is officially a "Bible College", bought out the local movie theater and rollerskating rink, got rid of both, and then proceeded to wonder why teenage pregnancies went up...
It's because they literally have nothing else to do with their time that doesn't take at least an hour of travel to get to
Reminds me of that weird bit after twilight every kid for a while was named Bella
Anyway I hope tomorrow is better and he tells us all about the solution
I hope there's a solution
Probably on Jagex side but its the weekend soooo
mhm
Yeah
from what I heard yea
When I was doing my smiting earlier seemed like they were fine off strem
that makes it seem like it's Tagging their IP addresses
whenever the stream showed OSRS any account on Thor's internet would lag
This is ethere something incredible tricky or mind-bogglingly stupid
zaf throws thunderbolts in his free time confirmed
note exactly what i said
I have alot of free time too
Mining
Got 55 mining earlier
Hot
Uhhh 4....6? Smithing
Gonna stop making steel and start making gold
Supply the ironman group with ingots for jewelery
Not doing it for pure exp
Number go brrrrr
I see we've moved from, "Thor is finished!" to "Thor ended."
Although he only was able to pump ~600k views so they are getting bored.
End? Nah. Still streaming daily. 
It's 100% rehashed from everywhere else.
i sleep
also if this stuff really worked, then MrBeast would be out of a job
Didnt even have the self awareness that maybe a guy who published 15 videos about a guy in a month might not be the best source
At least it doesn't say "The PirateSoftware situation is crazy!" for the millionth time
They hate him so it's always those titles
naw, thats only Moist "watch 2 vids and is now an expert" Critical
No, no, you don't understand an audio expert analyzed Thors stream and determined he's using a voice changer
Honestly would be good if like, primeagen had a chat with charlie about skg and thor
that face makes me think thor is about to say something or is shocked.
At least get Charlie to make an apology
queue a clip from a live event where Thor CANNOT USE a voice changer and his voice remains unchanged
thats technically up to primeagen to decide

Starr
i hope you have a good afternoon/evening
im grinding away at RS3 crafting sooo i have nothing better to do for the next few hours
people talk about RS1 and RS3. but what about RS2?
Thor would probanly gladly talk to almost any of these creators personally if they came without ill intent, but I doubt any would be interested in a polite discussion.
is it the middle child?
one sec
3 main versions of Runescape
Runescape 1, Runescape 2, and Runescape 3
this is RS1
RS2
Ah but you see, here's another clip where he speaks slightly differently (but still within a reasonable voice range for a single person) so therefore it's all fake
RS3
do people play RS1?
OSRS is what would now be considered RS2
Runescape Classic was RS1, and I don't think it exists anymore
Old School Runescape or OSRS is based on a back up of RS2
or am i better off playing rs2
by the time OSRS was made, Runescape 3 was well into existence and thus the only version of the game existing
The Terrifying Truth About Human Stupidity – Bonhoeffer’s Forgotten Warning
What if stupidity isn’t about intelligence at all, but about surrendering the will to think?
In this powerful and thought-provoking educational video essay, we explore Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s timeless insights into human behavior — revealing how smart, well-mea...
Probably better to ask in one of the 20 new RS channels tbh
there was enough of a desire for RS2 to exist once more after the Evolution of Combat update for RS3 that the devs created OSRS as a whole
If I remember right, they had an old version of Runescape Classic (aka RS1) that was running for a while
The difference is that RS2 was still fairly well liked by the community, so RS1 didn't have much of a playerbase and was eventually sunset
personally, try both RS3 and OSRS and see which one you like more
Queueing that one up to listen to at work tomorrow
RS1 is rough from what i understand
RS3 was less well received and went in a different direction with its design philosophy, so RS2 has a strong playerbase and still gets its own completely separate updates to this day
even more so by today's standards
Evolution of Combat or EoC is the main thing that drove a LOT of players away from the game along side the first major MTX idea known as Squeel of Fortune
600 k is quite a lot
a precursor to Treasure Hunter
People were pulling millions on this
Yeah, that was kinda the breaking point
These days RS3 is so littered with MTX that it's borderline unplayable outside of Ironman
i disagree that its unplayable
A headache to deal with, at least
The last time I tried it a few years back
It just constantly bombards you with notifications about the cash shop
if you dont want to see it at all? then sure, its unplayable
Turkey Tom posted one really long one about 2 weeks ago and got 2M
if you are burned out from other MMOs as much as I am, its tolerable
Personally I've always liked the Ironman style, and played like that even before it was an official thing
i like RS3 because its still the core of RS as a whole,
And having it shut off the MTX entirely and prove that you earned everything you got is a nice bonus
so when RS4?
I know the original creator of Runescape went on to make another Runescape-like, but I don't think it amounted to much in terms of community impact
Brighter Shores
yea...
I played it for a while, it was alright
its FINE
Yeah
That's about the impression I had
Good framework to build on, but not much at the moment
there are other games that i would rather play than return to that
Ye
Lately I've been going hard on FFXIV again to finish up some of the completionism I'd been working on 😛
how about that Dawntrail expansion.....

Dawntrail is good, screw the haters
(I forgot the bad word isn't allowed here 😛 )
i think the main ideas are fine for the expansion
but how it was written is the issue
Eh
thats my stance on it
I think the writing was fine
There was like one iffy section in my opinion, but the rest of the expac was enjoyable
Hard disagree
Hard disagree
are we fine btw? or do you want us to shift topics
But yeah, personally I think the hate for Dawntrail is massively overblown, and largely stems from unrealistic expectations set by Shadowbringers and Endwalker before it
main core of it is fine, writing has issues here and there
Savage has been a hell of a time, the mechanics are fantastic
Alliance raid questline is interesting and I want to see where they go with it
Even casual content got a noticeable bump in difficulty
Occult Crescent is fun and fixes a lot of issues I had with Bozja and Eureka, though it does have some issues of its own (only some of which are unique to Crescent, some are just gameplay features themselves)
And Cosmic Exploration is great, and got a ton of QoL this patch to make it even better
Plus we're getting a whole new thing alongside the deep dungeon
(And no, Paladin still doesn't have a res, they're not getting one)
Oh and Chaotic Alliance raid was really fun, clearing that with my static was a blast
Hyped for them to add more of those
If they stick with the theme of it being the final boss of the Alliance sequences, next up should be Diabolos
game is unplayable

I gotta somehow find the time to get back into ffxiv
healer main
But yeah from what I've seen
The situation around Dawntrail is similar to the situation around Thor
The expansion isn't perfect and has some issues, and if you don't like it then you do you
But holy shit does it not even come close to warranting the response it's gotten
Feels like people can't handle their emotions at all anymore
Agreed
Anything they don't like is automatically completely horrible, and everything that wasn't an issue before suddenly becomes a problem
It's not just "I didn't enjoy this character", it's "This character should piss off and die so they aren't in the story anymore and we never have to see them again"
I have a voice and everyone must hear
And then anyone who did like the character gets Other'd and mocked
It's not enough that you don't like them, everyone else has to hate them too
It's not enough that you didn't have anything you wanted to do, the game just has to have no content because you didn't what's there enjoyable
as a concept, the character is fine
And in execution, she was still fine

Does "some issues" warrant the cavalcade of bullshit we've gotten about the expansion?
no
Or overlooking everything else that's been done right?
Every single flaw gets picked out and isolated, and that's all that gets discussed
Never mind anything else done right or anyone else who might enjoy it
Was Cloud of Darkness Chaotic a bit too punishing on some of the body checks? Sure
Was it still a fun as hell time with a new type of content we'd never gotten before? Absolutely
My view is DT has some of the worst writing and character development FF14 has ever had. The only reason I finished DT is because I had friends I wanted to play with at 100, but even with that I almost tried for a refund of the game and canceling my account.
That said, if you enjoyed it, great, I'm happy for you. I'm not going to say you're wrong for liking something, thats your choice.
But it's the new Thing To Hate, so nothing can be good about it
Every video I've seen talking about the positives of Dawntrail, whether the story or the gameplay, just has a deluge of dumbshit comments about "Woke Lmao should piss off and die"
Like, this is the kind of take I just don't get
Wuk Lamat had a good character arc, and I felt the growth she had along the way was deserved
Lyse overwrote an existing character with a reference no one outside of 1.0 will get, changed precisely nothing throughout the expansion, and then was handed leadership of the Resistance anyway because she was there when the previous guy died
I didn't say no character arcs, I said worst. Nor did I say anything about StB and Lyse.
I honestly feel like it's partially just recency bias and the community around it
Yes, you said worst
And Lyse was by far worse
I disagree.
look over there, nuance is trying to escape
This is the internet, there is no nuance here.
Like I said, it's just the kind of take I don't get
Not liking it, fine
Pushing that dislike to the extreme of it being the "worst", I absolutely do not understand
I don't think any game can compare to the hate thor has gotten. It's people complaining while refusing to listen. At least with a game people have to experience it firsthand, while with internet drama it's regurgitating the same conversation that would be debunked if thor spoke and refuted those people(both sloptubers and haters)
Its all personal opinion, you think Lyse is worse, I don't. Its no more complicated than that.
That's why I said similar, it kind of has the same vibe to me
An imperfect thing getting a disproportionate response
And basically anything good about them being completely overlooked as a byproduct, as well
Anyway
I highly recommend this video
It goes over and contextualizes a lot of my thoughts on the expansion's story when I went through it, and the community response around them
(Heavy spoilers for the entire base expansion and the whole game leading up to it, obviously)
https://youtu.be/4TXY0hlAHrs
This one is going to be quite the event.
Sourced Article about 43m in: https://jpgames.de/2024/09/final-fantasy-xiv-das-sagt-naoki-yoshida-zur-kritik-an-wuk-lamat/
Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/weskalber
Twitter: https://twitter.com/WeskAlber
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/weskalber.bsky.social
Discord: https://discord.gg/mbZkAgy3ej
Patreon...
Oo oo I can contribute to this convo
There's nothing specifically wrong with dawn trail I can name personally, it just didn't, hook me, like arr did. I did not finish base dawntrail
I just wasn't engaged playing it
Of course, people should chill
Yeah, that's more reasonable
And in that event I'd still suggest seeing it through to the end for the gameplay aspects
But starting a new story arc is hard, you've gotta engage the player all over again
Ye
Hey everyone, quick question, does anyone multistream here?
yea I saw this one too I think that channel is mostly past dramas so it's weird to see one done one someone who's still around
Probably no one to make content about
hello chat
o/
how goes the piratesoftware community
waait what? what happened?
someone had a very weird method of detecting when Thor was streaming Old School Runescape and would do a targeted attack which hit both him and shaye for as long as OSRS was shown on stream
thor was bamboozled, along with everyone else
queue the testing that occured and nothing was resolved
I'm kinda hoping this is another case where a kid is smart enough to do this but not so much to avoid getting in trouble. And Thor has to call the kids mom.
we will find out on the next stream
It'd be weird to happen twice but thor would have two nickles
streaming on net*
mobile on cellular didnt crash
yea...
there are many mysteries of the world i would love to know
and this might be one of them
How could that happen?
given what i know, i know it should be possible to detect OSRS graphics on screen
but the thing i do not know is how they managed to target OSRS specifically without affecting twitch
They'd need to target the osrs server he's connected to, wouldn't they?
it did affect Shaye's connection as well from what was said
did not affect anyone else
Huh, interesting.
Thor checked his internet, loaded up OSRS from a fresh install
he could play it without it being shown on screen
...
what if he reversed the screen?
mirror flip
I was wondering something similar a bit ago. A silly test but blacking half the screen at a time. Reversing sounds more useful to start with.
I wouldn't think that would effect it but it would depend on how well the software was built that is monitoring the stream
bingo
i think its a bot thats doing it
but HOW the bot works is the weird thing
also how to prevent it
It would need to recognize characters from any angle, which mirroring wouldn't solve but building and ui images wouldn't normally be expected to change
Thought I read someone mention he had to be moving before it started. Though the last one I think he was just clicking through dialogue.
Assuming someone built it after Thor started streaming, it's probably looking at only a few points to see if osrs is on screen.
wait that happened before?
I wonder if there's a network fix to prevent whatever attack is happening
I mean it still disconnected him from mobile when he held a shitty webcam up to it
so its pretty good whatever is doing it
That is assuming it's not just someone manually pressing a button
Oh should thor slap a grainy filter over it
The detection isn't what's wierd tho it's the attack vector
can we get black and white noir runescape gameplay
I have no clue how they're managing to interfere with his ips connection to a service without also disrupting other things
And without disrupting jagex servers
And he reset his router so his ip should have changed
You dont think maybe a jagex employee is doing it right?
Yeah. Unless he was too zoomed in when his phone was on mobile network they were somehow targeting his network with such a small amount if information it wasn't obvious.
Doubt, no one would risk thier job over a streamer surely
it wasnt affecting him when he was not showing OSRS
fair enough for that at least
it looked more like the server stopped recieving his packets
How tho
also how do you counter it
jagex probably needs to look on their end
How are they intercepting the packets from him and shaye specifically
Manually they could have had a bot that just sent screenshots or had the stream on mute.
Without thier ip
the fact that it persisted through a router restart/update is very interesting
Yes
trojan?
Meaning the IP changed and it persisted
I don't think shaye and Thor both caught a Trojan simulatenously
also again: it happened to mobile too
Simultaneously
fair
all we as viewers can do right now is speculate
targeting the accounts only when OSRS is shown on stream
Like actually bizarre
on net
Not the account but maybe all OSRS clients on a given network.
off net/stream worked fine
better way of phrasing it
I wonder if connecting via data would work
Zaf,
its seemingly incredibly specific
have you tried digging into the idea as a whole?
i have no idea on where to begin searching to resolve this
the conditions that we know are:
on stream
on net
thats not a lot to go off of
I've been wondering if his mention of an exploit in the client is the most likely. Something where someone has been able to inject something into the client where it loses that server communication.
I mean thor and some of his friends are the best equipt people k know to figure it out
wouldntve happened on mobile though
I know*
Mobile is a different client, official
i wouldnt be surprised if thor started stream sitting there like Dr Evil with meatball in his lap
"i have solved your Riddle, mr powers"
Depends on the exploit. If the information for all clients regarding a particular server is the same and has a vulnerability then it would be all clients, mobile included.
didnt happen when he disconnected from his net, and persisted through a router restart/update
It didn't affect when he went mobile using just his phone connection, only affected mobile when he was using his wifi
also: only started happening 4 hours into stream
so someone likely woke up and decided to start it
Persisted isn't quite the right word. Reoccurred is more accurate. The failure wasnt a permanent problem like modifying a permanent reference.
eh, same difference in this case IMO but thats semantics
anyways
with no idea on it as a whole, i shall mostly retire to RS3, if not the night thereafter
and i retire to sleep
My guess an AI enthusiast has a model / machine learning on stream data frames to detect OSRS coupled to an account based attack that hits Jagex servers or components of the network to Jagex. A custom twitch client possibly. When streaming, what sort of meta data does twitch send out, that could be used to narrow down needed information to coordinate the attack. Maybe there is a zero day issue with Run Escape? I hope there is an update and resolution.
Maybe a router on Thor's ISP is compromised?
tellin you, slap the anti ai grain filter on stream to see if that works 
any chance it could use the twitch extention to tell whether he's on runescape?
cos it's linked to his account isnt it? to show all his stats n stuff?
maybe the extension being on while he's on stream would be enough for something to tell what he's streaming without having to scan a screen and identify whether something is runescape or not?
he turned them off halfway testing it still happening
mmm gotcha
im sure he tried alot, wasn't there like a few hours of troubleshooting before stream ended?
yes
I know it's fun to speculate about elaborate ways to detect stream content but have you guys considered that you can just use the runescape API to tell when a player is logged in
In a similar vein, has anyone checked whether it's just Thor getting knocked offline or the entire playerbase? Because the game has been suffering stability issues for the last week or so (whether due to popularity or malicious DoS it's unclear)
Yesterday it was only Thor/Shaye as far as we know
it was only happening to him when he was streaming and not when he was offline though apparently
As long as he didn't show the actual game on stream it was fine.
But weren't there also some points where it was on stream and worked for a bit before getting disrupted again
From what I saw, everytime he revealed the actual game it would be mere seconds before a disconnect.
Of course, I was working yesterday, so I didn't get to see everything.
Picked up most from chat and VoD.
Honestly sounds like confirmation bias
Somewhat random behaviour that seems reactive to something else because the human brain craves to find patterns in things
Was anyone else actually logging in and trying to play at the same time to check?
We'll see if he discovered anything since the downtime.
It only happens if he's streaming it, not when he's logged in
I think he's replicated it about 10 times
Also, streaming an old VOD did it too
Even using a crappy webcam to stream the screen
Yeah, a whole battery of testing happened for hours. I'm hoping they figured it out.
I think without jagex support its not gonna go far other than changing how the game looks on the screen
Could try inverting the colors
Maybe that'd work
That just lends credence to the idea that it's not targeted and is just part of the general instability the game servers are experiencing atm
What
It's stable if the game isn't getting streamed
is it though
This whole thing sounds so bizarre.
I mean yesterday like 3 times back to back as soon as he showed it, the connection would die
Yes, he's shown this multiple times during testing.
but the game is in fact not stable as of just a few days ago https://secure.runescape.com/m=news/game-status-information-centre?oldschool=1
and they think they've resolved it but aren't certain in this last status update
Did you even watch the latter half of his stream or are you just doubting him because it's thor/the screen was black/whatever
and it's the weekend so they probably won't look at it again until monday
No I'm just commenting on this as someone who's read the discussion around it and can think of more plausible reasons than "someone has gone to the trouble of developing a custom solution that detects when runescape is playing on a stream"
yo mods! how many keys I would need to throw at Pirate to make him play Vintage story? 😄
If he changed his network IP, then it'd just be until whichever dunce it was that was intentionally kicking him off, found his IP again, that he'd be able to play
all of them.
Whilst it's not impossible with today's off the shelf technology, it's still a lot more time consuming to autodetect stream content than it is to query runescape's servers to check if a specific player is logged in
Here's what i just said in stream chat: new idea: because you stream at an absolutely wack time for your timezone, i'm wondering if it's someone hitting west coast server on jagex's side and you happen to be the biggest fish who is being affected
with that in mind, does this mean there's some specific reason why a hater would want to only target stream presence rather than generally intervene with thor's ability to play the game?
It's not checking if he's logged in
It's checking to see if the game is played on the stream
Because it affected Shaye too
what does the attacker lose by preventing thor from playing whilst he's not streaming?
"I don't like thor" is the only reason these people have
Right but the reason Shaye could be affected is that runescape as a whole is getting DoSed and becomes unavailable to everyone, or at least the specific world they're playing on
No you misunderstand me
Or because they have similar IPs because they're using the same network
Im not saying specialised haters don't exist, I'm saying why would one spend vastly longer making a more elaborate solution just to allow thor to play the game when it's not on stream
Because they're that batshit insane
That's it
There ARE people who try their damndest to be villains, thinking they're the hero, believe it or not
right but what's villainous about allowing thor to play the game whilst not streaming
Pettiness seldom operates on logic.
Still, I understand where you're coming from, @shell osprey.
Don't apply logic to irrational actions. Whoever is doing this either has some kind of vendetta against Thor and some kind of parasocial relationship with OSRS.
At any rate, next time this happens I recommend everyone to try and log into the game, ideally the same world, as thor and see whether they can maintain a stable connection throughout
but uh, not so many people that it accidentally DoSes...
There are folks in chat who are right next to him and not getting affected
a healthy number of people 😂
Whoever it is, it's clear that their intent is to get Thor to stop streaming the video game.
he should try modern RS to see if still happens 😄
idea is to test if the attacker is true fan of RS or not
Undoubtedly, more testing/troubleshooting will happen, we'll see what comes of it.
Oh there actually were people unaffected during this then?
but then you gotta play modern RS 
that is true, and that is considered heresy
clearly some hardcore hater there
For now, Thor should get his IP changed, and contact support about the malicious user. The person is definitely using a bot to detect whether Runescape is on screen somehow, perhaps even sending large quantities of packets for Runescape to get him kicked off the server.
Yknow, to trip the anticheat and bot prevention. Which may even be an attempt to get Thor/Shaye IP-banned, who knows
That...
Would make sense...if they also prevented Thor from playing when not on stream
Well, they don't know when he's playing the game. So it would be suspicious for Runescape to get packets from Thor's IP when he's not logged in.
That's why they set up the bot, to check if he's live, and playing Runescape
The closest I can get to making sense of the premise of "sending lots of packets" would be for an attacker to some intercept and repeatedly replay thor's traffic to runescape, which would mean at minimum accomplishing a man in the middle attack on him. Networking isn't my speciality but I'm all pretty certain that basic network protocols are designed such that duplicates are just automatically discarded before even reaching business logic anyway
I watched Vedal get DDOS'd while playing Subnautica, I don't think it matters if it's a duplicate
They just need to send an absurd amount of packets
Whom tf would DDOS Vedal!?
do you know what DDoSing actually entails btw
They kinda succeeded. But Vedal fought back.
I mean...I can think of three streamers that one shouldn't dare to DDOS
Thor, Primeagen, and Vedal
Two of those are actively developing personal AI
All three have connections that allow them to track you down and put things in your mail box as a warning...or call your mother
Vedal and his AI Vtuber Neuro-sama Deal with oncoming DDoS Attacks on his custom Subnautica Servers
►Twitch: http://www.twitch.tv/vedal987
►Twitter: https://twitter.com/Vedal987
►Editor: Paradomix
►Thumbnail Designer: fFrequence
#vtuber #neurosama #subnautica
i gotta find the timestamp where the dude starts messing w/ vedal 
I guess problems start at 3:40
Hmmmm... okay so, assuming thor's idea is right, logically, the person doing it has to be present in the world and likely the node in order to be able for any memory exploiting to affect thor. That would likely require cheat engine as well... switching to steam client may help or even stop it because of improved security against that specifically
uh okay well a quick overview then:
DoSing (Denial of Service) is when a server is getting more requests than it can handle at once, and depending on how it's set up it will either drop some and complete the rest or just grind to a halt and complete none. The term is usually referred to malicious attacks, but can also refer to the non-malicious instance of a service just being more popular than anticipated.
DDoSing (Distributed DoS) is the same outcome but specifically caused by lots of people doing it, and the term was coined when average servers got powerful that one man on one computer getting mad was no longer enough to knock servers offline. Instead, you needed lots of people on lots of computers, or better still a botnet.
The main point here is that DoS means the server is failing to work for everyone equally. You cannot DoS a server so that it only doesn't work for specific clients.
You've been suggesting that Thor is somehow being targeted specifically, which means that a basic (D)DoS attack isn't in use. Instead, an attacker could be pretending to be Thor and deliberately tripping anti-DoS protections that the server has. This would mean at a minimum the attacker would need to be sending traffic that is recognised to be coming from Thor's IP, which means either getting malware onto Thor's home network or a man in the middle attack - both of which are a lot harder to accomplish than I think plausible here.
.... wtf it effects instanced... but that... how the heck would that effect thor's mempry specifically? That makes zero sense unless jagex literally has exposed values that should NOT be exposed and this is a big, huge, very bad exploit
... honestly i think thor's idea is wrong and it's something going wrong/an attack on specifically jagex's side, and we're just viewing bias because we don't know about the "x" others who are also being effected.
Interesting. Downdetector reports a big blue spot of people saying they cant access runescape where thor lives.
I'm not screenie'ing it for obvious reasons.
Just the bunch who knows where THor lives making fake reports to get it to show in downdetector probably.
I doubt they're THAT smart.
downdetector bot reports wouldn't need many smart people - just a few unfortunately.
...what would tricking downdetector accomplish..?
who knows, seems a waste to me
I really think that's unlikely, and the number of reports is low. If they were botting the one website only boomers really use, then the numbers would be higher.
... i'm suspecting something even deeper. Jagex just recently started adding new worlds and i bet there's some issues arising from it- this post is them talking about hosting their servers https://secure.runescape.com/m=news/more-worlds-more-power-the-road-to-greater-capacity?oldschool=1
If it was a 'global' issue, it wouldn't just have an effect on Thor/Shaye, but other people aswell
Right but like... The past several days has been unstable for lots of players
My thought process is: it might not be a targeted attack based on memory exploits/bugs. My theory is; when thor joins a world, too many people siddenly join that world. Problems already present in the world is exasperated, causing that world to hang up specifically on communication between server and client OR just server side. But that theory doesn't explain everything...
But theres just no way thor would lose connection in an instance due to a memory exploit. Unless its a false instance, or he had invites on (but he said he didn't)... wack! This is wack
I just got off work, is the Extension gone?
It's off right now as there are still issues goin on
damn
Hmm. Im going to bed. I would laugh so hard if it turned out it WAS obs video codec not playing nice with runescape after all. But that's unlikely rue to it happening in the middle of his stream
oh well eepy... after i finish listening to sea shanty 2
but the camera on the mobile phone
He was still streaming though? On the same computer, just visually recording
Yea - streamed using the ant camera on the phone and if I remember right, it also lagged out once we started to see the screen play.
So by using the obs setup on his main comp, it's still encoding using whatever he has it set to. The ant cam was just sending footage to obs, obs was still running on the same machine as runescape unless i misunderstood what he was doing there
runescape was running on the phone
Ohhhh okay that changes things. Well, then not that for suresies.
... i am out of ideas, eepy time
sleep is the best idea
A bug buster's best friend is sleep, but no programmer ever sleeps enough 
go to sleep thinking about unfixed bug
dream
dream of bug
dream of finding the perfect solution to the bug, it's so obvious how did you not think of it already
wake up
realise the perfect solution to the bug hinged on several things that don't exist and are impossible nonsense
sleep is not a bug fixer's friend
thats called lucid dreaming, if you train it then you can make it happen intentionally, thats how i "unlock" ideas for my monster modeling 😄
Having those circular dreams that keep restarting everytime I go back to sleep and the dream is hacking my brains os code... lousy night of sleep...
Morning everyone, what’s the status of OSRS ?, did the figure out how to play without being auto dc’ed?
Well in the example I have in mind it wasn't lucid, or at least not to the extent that it's useful for anything. I had a measure of awareness but zero control over the dream
I had lucid dream once - in color even. Still didn't stop me from launching my self over the hill down a 1000 feet... I think that dream in 30 some years ago ... I even remember some of my dreams from when I was 10.... yikes.
I've had only two lucid dreams.
First is when i was basically in an action movie, stopping terrorists and saving a girl while on motorcycle only to ask myself if i were in a dream which woke me up.
My second i realized i was in a dream and started flapping my arms like a bird to fly only to violently awaken from having flown into power lines.
I can relate to that
Any time of true awareness of dreaming the dream seems to instantly try to find any possible way to end it
The funniest was having me wake up only to still be dreaming but no longer aware it was a dream
Lucid dreams are really wierd. Expecially when you start to re
Has the “problem” been solved?
Not yet? But the abuse has stopped for now. Thor noticed his 2FA had too many attempts and timed him out of a few hours. So maybe the vector is related to 2FA, or that is coincidence. Maybe the attacker got in trouble with mom or something so there is a small reprieve?
There was a exploit when you try to change someone's password or something it boots them from the game
… was it fixed?
Soo idk how but I've developed the ability to lucid dream, but only in nightmares, and the only thing I can really do is force my self awake
My guess as to how. One too many nightmares as a child and watching videos on how to lucid dream
It is not fun nor does it feel good to do
I feel like death when ever I wake up that way. Heart beating out of my chest, drenched in sweat and prolly the worst part is being able to remember exactly why I was forcing my self awake
It's weird and sounds made up ik but I've genuinely done it multiple times
Just stopped happening
the key to staying asleep is to focus on yourself in the dream momentarily
before you sleep, spend a minute or so looking at the back of your hands, then the moment you realise you're asleep and dreaming look for your hands
you can maintain the lucid phase for a while if you just look for your hands whenever it starts to slip
Yeah I'm aware of the basic techniques to trigger it, I'm just too lazy to practise them
Essentially you just need to create a mental habit that you'll subconsciously repeat whilst dreaming but which will then trigger you to recognise it
When it happens by accident though I've found that the dream always progresses in ways beyond the influence I'm deliberately exerting that have the effect of leading to an end or loss of focus
On a different occasion I was momentarily amused at the realisation I had stumbled into a lucid state only for cars to suddenly veer off towards me until the constant distraction undermined the lucidity
the bee thing mentioned in chat
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2025/08/250822073807.htm
Scientists have developed a breakthrough food supplement that could help save honeybees from devastating declines. By engineering yeast to produce six essential sterols found in pollen, researchers provided bees with a nutritionally complete diet that boosted reproduction up to 15-fold. Unlike commercial substitutes that lack key nutrients, this...
Still unknown
fun
just seems to have stopped
Thor already sent all the information to jagex to see if they can figure it out on their end
came in to hear that just now
15 fold seems like way too much growth, but if it eventually makes honey a competitive alternate sweetener to HFCS I am all in and welcome our new bee overlords.
considering the main issue for domesticated honey bee right now is colony collapse due to too small of a population, it's great news and healthy growth
Yay beees
1500% is not healthy growth, it's breakneck runaway explosive growth. Maybe good in the short term for a dwinding population, but if that yeast starts growing naturally there could be an epidemic.
Dafuq?
its a Don Hertzfeldt classic, though the gif isn't playing nice to auto-play...
Does Thor play survival sandbox games?
IIRC, He's played Subnautica at least
some, like he plays Dune and said he's gonna check out the new update next month
Just woke up, did he end up finding a solution to the connection issues?
same
Not really, the guy who caused the connection issues apparently decided to stop for now
attacker seems to given up for now
Fair enough
So far no idea how hes doing it, thor sent all the information to jagex for now
waiting for a response
if the attacker was smart, he'd have seen how closely thor has been looking into the incident and decided to stop to prevent giving him more clues
Reminds me of this short https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQj2EFBABIY
Maybe don't. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Watch the stream here:
https://piratesoftware.live
#Shorts #PirateSoftware #Twitch
Last line always gets me. "So I called his mom" 
ive missed the last few streams. What is the “issue” i keep hearing about
Someone, Somehow found a way to cause Thor/Shaye disconnect from the game while it was being actively streamed
Yes.
Not that he figured out, But it's currently not happening, so We / he, hopes that the guy doing it gave up, or decided to give up
guy gave a flower from what I heard
Thats the guy who was teleporting cows and following thor around
We dont know if theyre the same person
I think the person doing it was wanting Thor to have an angry reaction, or rage quit stream, anything except rampant curiosity about an honestly fascinating method of trolling
if they want that, they havent watched thor at all
^
110% expected reaction imo
They don't care to, they take how they would react, and think it applies to Thor
classic blunder
And refuse to believe he's a genuinely good person despite his unfortunate past happenings with WoW and other things
Someone is really upset that their 45 minute video essay titled PIRATESOFTWARE CAREER ENDED FROM RUNESCAPE can't be released now.
I'm so tired of seeing those pop up in my recommended videos on youtube.
I haven't had one pop up in a while after setting all the previous ones to ''Do not recommend''
I'm not saying he had any part in what happened in The Run (which he did, but so did just about everyone in the group), but gotta admit, poor guy keeps having unfortunate things happen to/around him in games
And good
Thor is just the current scapeboat for the Internet
Well clearly he shouldn't make it so easy by being greedy and terrible by checks notes running a ferret rescue, donating unanswered TTS revenue and paying his mods wages and offering them real benefits /s
That's a very likely possibility.
I have heard people try to spin paying mods and giving benefits as a negative thing. Some serious mental gymnastics. Paying employees? What a monster.
Does the UN know about this?? Who do I call??
That's incredibly dishonest. Those are probably the first people to complain about volunteer mods being ineffective or unprofessional
imo it highlights how bias blinded some people are. Incapable of disseminating information and having glaring empathetic failings at the same time.
That's what happens when you start with a foregone conclusion and twist everything else to be proof
Imagine making a Discord, for people to have easy access to free and easy resources, and still be called Narcissistic
See, if you ignore 95 percent of the good things that thor does, you have the 5% left that they don't like! Troll math. 
Is it happening again?
Hmmm. Weird. I see this logic often. It comes from... narcissists who can never be wrong and wil move goalposts and harrass people and target people... how weird that works out right? That what they are accusing thor of being is what they are themselves? 
Even with my many years on the internet, I'm saddened to still be surprised by the depths of depravity, and the sad strange immature people who choose to act against other people, rather than acting for themselves.
At least by having someone more famous call out whatever is causing this, jagex is more likely to fix the attack vector, which benefits every good player.
One of the many, MANY lines of dialogue in the Legacy of Kain that is pure gold, and this one is surprisingly apt
I will say it is reconditioning me on how to not feed the trolls, such as the "don't recommend this channel" button mentioned earlier. rather than engaging, I just choke them out of my algorithm & move on with my day. what very little interaction I have with any trolls nowadays is a brief countertrolling back before muting notifs & never coming back to the post/reply/thread. I typically just block ragebait slop outright, tho
100% certain this vector has been used on other streamers who haven't had the benefit of experience, skil, or resources to figure it out/stop it from happening
so it being done on thor could turn out to be a blessing to the community as a whole
i haven't heard about it but i wouldnt be surprised
i was just speculating
Well supposedly it's happened to... another streamer that started with a c? But its very unlikely that this is the first time it has been used.
I mean on RS. I’m talking about the stream since he apparently was talking about it
No not quite, two different problems.
One problem is actual DDOS'ing of the servers (As by the DownDetector results)
The different problem Thor is experiencing is directly targeted.
Both can look the same at a glance.
The issue that Thor initially thought just now was the personally targetted attack, was actually the server he was on being DDOS'd it seems
Considering he's actively playing now on stream, the personally targeted attack isn't happening at the moment
One of the "rules of the internet" is;
"Don't feed the Trolls, otherwise they win" for a reason. I don't pretend to follow that rule all the time, but it does make sense
You can't barter words with someone who isn't trading fairly in the first place. I understand the impulse to meet their words, but yeah, best not to feed.
I mean we don't go on other servers or channels and defend Thor. We're just here. They keep on generating drama content and enough people on the Internet eat it up. They go on this server and these streams and bait, harrass and disrupt the stream and the chat
So Thor can't stream because he's getting attacked and I'm supposed to not feed the troll?
two quotes come to mind
you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into - Albert Einstein
and
90% of quotes on the internet attributed to Einstein are not, in fact, Einstein quotes - Albert Einstein
I just speak up against any bullying, if I speak at all, but in both cases I immediately disengage & give as little future interaction as possible
they can end up talking to only bots while I simply move on to better spaces
No you're not. Because 99.999999% of the people trolling, aren't the person that's decided to actually attack Thor's RS account.
Reminds me of this good old Sun Tzu quote.
"I never said this shit lol"
-Sun Tzu, The Art of War
Feeding trolls is bad, making fun of trolls after they get banned is great
What is even better, is out-trolling the troll to get them to leave
Obviously (and thankfully) the mods ban the trolls before that situation even occurs
@minor nymph
To disregard the funny shitpost, and to be blunt about it, the actual Sun Tzu quote of (and translating/paraphrasing);
"If you know yourself and the enemy, you need not fear the result of 100 battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle."
Carries a lot of weight in many aspects of life, especially when fighting trolls
And here's the best part, that quote isn't specifically dedicated to acts of war, or acts against enemies. It also applies to understanding all of humanity. If you understand yourself and your fellow man, you need not fear a battle in the first place, just a conversation.
has Thor done a playthrough of baba is you? started rewatching aliensrock's playthrough and wondered if Thor has played it?
On the topic of puzzle games, has there been any progress on blue prince in the past few months? I haven't really kept up to date with it really.
think it was said the game is completed?
ah ok, cuz last I remember people thought it was a fakeout
is Thor being attacked again?
yes
Anyone happen to know how thor set up his auto ad scene for streamerbot?
You can grab the streamer role in id:customize . They might have some info about it.
Yeah i did, i figured its better to ask multiple places though

Perfectly normal sized hands
with one giant finger
is the hacker back?
dudusmeller took an 8 hour sleep and came back
fun
he could use a web based VPN and then use webosrs.com to play it through a browser
its not a he, aparently the attacker pronoun is dudusmeller
ah my bad hold on

:3c
anyone elses stream just froze?
I cant wait to see if this continues until monday because most people are back in school. If it doesnt happen during his normal hours monday/tues/wednes then its probably someone either in highschool/college. and if it continues the entire time its a no-lifer
Test now with stream off
Was he not having trouble for 8 hours?

Nah. He started 2am my time, got hit a little bit for like maybe an hour or two, and then he said he was absolutely fine for 8 hours until about 12ish my time.
Thor said on Winky's stream he's calling ISP
What is weird is that FerretSoftware is still live
prolly on seperate network
Stream died?
ya
Can someone please have Thor do some basic MTU checks for the path he has a problem with
Testing RuneScape MTU with MTR:
-
Find RuneScape server IP (or use world servers like
world1.runescape.com) -
Test with large packets:
mtr -s 1472 world1.runescape.com -
If packet loss occurs, reduce size:
mtr -s 1400 world1.runescape.com mtr -s 1200 world1.runescape.com -
Look for:
- Sudden packet loss at specific hops = MTU bottleneck
- 100% loss after a hop = fragmentation issues
- Set your MTU to largest working packet size + 28 (IP/ICMP headers)
Quick test: mtr -s 1472 -c 10 oldschool1.runescape.com
If 1472 works, your path supports 1500 MTU. If not, binary search down until packets get through cleanly.
RIP stream, crazy
are you from jagex or just a ran?
Winky addicted yet?
fan even
Crash of doom
ferrets are fine though, which is weird
Yeahhh
I’m even better…. A network engineer lmao
I was thinking the same thing
Wqs he using the Jagex client at the time or runelite?
He tried both
lol.not sure if he'll mess with it, i doubt hes looking here atm
I mean at the time of the crash specifically
If it was the Jagex client the attacker could have used some longstanding vulerability in the client to crash his pc
My mom told me to always rule out normal TCP/IP shenanigans
Before blaming hackers 
What we have learn here is your mother is Mrs Roberts from XKCD
If he thinks it's a slight hitch or variance in his ethernet have him try this. https://test.vsee.com/network/index.html
it diagnosed an ongoing issue that never showed up between me and my ip
So the fun fact that stuff works fine over VPN means we can look at what VPN encapsulation / re-route traffic
Does to the packets
- If they are at 1500 MTU they get fragged
So that means 1 packet becomes 2
its not MTU
well, to be fair, the internet is unhinged. in normal cases I would agree with you.
So VPN works which is great he’s either bypassing a segment of internet transit that somehow was messing with the TCP session OR
One of about 10+ things lol
Could be upstream DDoS protection could be soooooo many things
if its an attack using crafted packets, then a VPN will help until they do the same with all the exit nodes of the VPN service Thor uses.
my guess is DDoS protection
But good old MTR MTU check is a really great place to start
The main problem is that the timeouts to the servers were happening whenever the game was being displayed on Stream. Whether it be display capture, webcam pointed at monitor, or webcam pointed at phone, while being directly on the network (via Cable or Wifi)
When the game wasn't actively being displayed, there were no problems.
MTU would not show up intermittently
Because in the last 15 years when stuff like this has happened it’s been MTU related on a specific service (one fun one was ICMP traffic was fine but TCP oh boy)
oh boy
It’s rare but I’ve been on cases
Upstream transit in Germany had the issue but the Swedish path was fine
Anyway long story I need to get my kids to bed brb
Thor, by his own words, was playing the game off monitor or toggled off game capture just fine, but as soon as it was being shown, that is when the timeout happened, and was reproduced multiple times. It is highly unlikely*to be something that was software, or network-based.
or its just a guy hatewatching and wanting to ruin Thors day
One of those “I’ll make him pay” types and when you ask them why, their reasons are based souly on YouTube essays
he even mentioned after about 2 hours into the stream it stopped for awhile, which could indicate the attacker probably left to go do something else before returning.
I’m wondering why Cisco/HPE juniper hasn’t been sponsoring “high profile” streamers with some their SD-WAN / whatever gear
A SSR120 or some lovely application aware router would be a smart move when stuff like this is mission critical
I dont think its an attack tho, i feel like its just towards runescape specifically on that ISP on that hour
Yea, I smell someone watching the stream and just hitting "attack" once its on stream
He tested it multiple times to the point where it wasn’t a coincidence
If that were the case, surely it would have happened in the 4 days previous of streams
Didn’t it also happen when he showed a video of his gameplay yesterday morning?
Yes, what im saying is in that specific hours, the isp prob block the game...
ALTHO
If he plays another mp game, does it suffers the same problem?
Thor sure has one interesting puzzle infront of him now.
Heyo!
Wait you think the ISP is doing it?
They are not hitting my infrastructure directly.
They are hitting the ISPs Switch just above us.
The ISP is now mitigating and will be getting back to me tomorrow for ongoing mitigation from their end.
This is why nothing was showing up when we looked at our level.
oh thats interesting
This is where we normally bust out the white board and slice up
The network traffic path into sections and use
The “divide and concur” method for all these fun theories
so i assume your default gateway?
So that's, like, a crime or smth yea?
in the UK it would be
Took awhile but atleast you figured it out.
computer misue act
CFAA probably covers it in the US
it probably is in the US. getting the info to track them down and prosecute is another story.
So one fun fast work around
Grab a 5G router
Connect it to a second Ethernet link on the PC
Using the “ROUTE” utils in windows
Point default 0.0.0.0/0 out the normal network next hop ( the current router)
And point just the RuneScape server ranges out via the 5G GW
No vpn needed just split on the PC
Pc needs to stream with home network...
Yeah that’s covered by the default
ok that was some strange spam
Yep!
lmao tf was that for a second
Ooh ye soz i didnt read the default
Is it even worth trying to find and prosecute someone because of runescape?throwing justification out the window for a sec I’d imagine it’d simply just be EXPENSIVE
Is the Ferret stream being affected?
ferrets were still live
doesn't look like it is.
This is “host level windows routing” which you wouldn’t do normally but this is one use case
i dont know how much it affects Thor. thats the real question.
btw there aparently is a web based osrs client called webosrs.com
there are some browsers with built in VPN that only affect anything on browser side (as exaple OperaGX has one iirc)
Ngl, not worth pursuing, but the runescape guys could sue the attacker, cos stopping their business on that specific isp
oh sht I hope I disabled the ping XD
atleast his ISP is onto it.
good luck Thor! hopefuly you can get to the bottom of this and lock off this thing in future
Actually the fastest kit would be just a starlink (has everything needed) and then route only RuneScape IPs via that path (if this was my PC and I had to get it working in the next 40 hours without running to the store)
disruption of business or something like that (at least I know its a proper case where I live)
the lengths people would go to, to literally sabotage your business, surely this is criminal enough to get sometime done
wonder if that guy harassing him ingame osrs can be prosecuted as well 🤔




