#streamchat

1 messages · Page 260 of 1

golden latch
wicked schooner
kindred sedge
#

cat spiders would be absolute menace's to ecosystems

#

I mean, domesticated cats already taking out bird populations, then you add spider?!

wispy plover
kindred sedge
#

apex predator, total S tier, would keep as a pet

golden latch
kindred sedge
golden latch
indigo wadi
#

Man, what a stream

kindred sedge
indigo wadi
#

Now to go and watch khronos' vod

kindred sedge
#

Isnt he gonna be doing unban bingo at some point this week?

indigo wadi
kindred sedge
#

OOp

lyric venture
#

Yeah he ran through like 600 bans earlier today

kindred sedge
#

Whelp here is to hoping I catch him live

jolly sky
#

Good lord

wicked schooner
kindred sedge
#

they def do

indigo wadi
lyric venture
#

He left the queue at 250 but its up to like 500 when he checked it a little earlier.

#

I think Khronos just logged off a few minutes ago

indigo wadi
#

Ya

kindred sedge
#

and im betting another 2k have filled up the requests too just from today

tribal canyon
#

100%'d the bingo

jolly sky
indigo wadi
#

Lol

kindred sedge
indigo wadi
#

I think he feeds off it

wicked schooner
kindred sedge
#

my guess was the first 5

lyric venture
#

Hes turning it into content so at least something comes out of it ;p

#

Its just insane how unoriginal all the people who get banned are.

tribal canyon
flint sinew
#

YOSHI DISTRACTION

jolly sky
#

Starr YarrSalute

jolly sky
#

Y'all can distract better than that

#

Like this

wispy plover
#

Thanks, I hate it

jolly sky
flint sinew
gloomy forge
#

Dunno why but that made me wanna play pizza tower peepoHappy

jolly sky
flint sinew
gloomy forge
#

gigapog

flint sinew
gloomy forge
opaque raven
#

I wanna trade this rare Notorious B.E.E.G.Yoshi card for something cool
What you all have to offer?

gloomy forge
#

Nothing but a bunch of comfy vibes peepoHappy

glossy cedar
#

Sorry if this is the wrong place for this kind of discussion, lead me to the right place if it isn't
(maybe the gen programming chat?)

A lot of the issues that he's addressed have been data structure issues, which is a very generic thing, and can be applied to a lot of things, if you have experience in coding at all I don't see how you wouldn't see what I mean. My first intuition if I were to make a game is to use something similar to a DAG (assuming time is linear) to represent the narrative (or multiple graphs if needed, say if the player has freedom of choice). Basically just a tree, but the branches can join. Like that isn't specific to any area of programming, that's just general CS.

I've RE save files and pretty much the first thing I would expect would be a tree structure of some kind. I don't see how making an unusual choice relative to standard game practice would make RE easier, but I would have to read up on the ARG a bit more so I could specifically know what it's about.

I'm actually kind of interested how PS have structured their code, I'm assuming all of it is not public so we can't know; I can't actually interpret the "giant array thing" (like it literally means nothing to me, is it just global flags?)

I'm not going to say anything about anything else though. Like dogging on the lighting thing, because I've written GLSL shaders and I will definitely take the lazy route if there's enough hardware performance. As long as it's just pixel art it shouldn't be an issue. I come from the world of JavaScript where doing the simplest things requires megabytes of code lol

Again, sorry if this is the completely wrong place (and for the wall!)

opaque raven
gloomy forge
# golden latch

its literally scorpion ferretPog whose subzero in this case? just an ice cube?

#

wait hold up.

jolly sky
gloomy forge
#

there you go, heres an ice cube.

calm ember
#

Disagreements happen sometimes. You don't always have to win.

gloomy forge
#

guy made banger hip hop back in the early 90s

opaque raven
# golden latch

Cool, you can have Notorious BEEG Yoshi and I will even add this sticker just for you

dapper ravenBOT
#

Send me stuff! The weirder the better! yarrHeart 15613 Olson Drive NW #65, Vaughn, WA 98394

opaque raven
golden latch
#

They would appreciate the gift

mellow oracle
#

anyone by chance hear the answer for TTS? Was on a conference call for work and missed the answer (and the link isnt working......i think i know why it isnt working)

#answered-tts message

earnest cove
#

oh, there's no vod...

#

vod got taken down

mellow oracle
#

yea, thats what i figured

brazen drift
opaque raven
brazen drift
#

cuz he wanted to vibe for his birthday

opaque raven
#

But....idk

brazen drift
#

but obviously the future isnt set in stone so there could always be another one, at least After summers done and all the kiddies go back to school

glossy cedar
# jolly sky Maybe if the guy went in with even an attempt to understand why things were done...

why things were done in the way they were
Where is this information
What I've heard is that it is to make the ARG easier for the people who are in to that, but I don't see how doing something out of the ordinary would make it easer. Even if it is conceptually simpler, doing something unexpected means it's not going to be the first thing people are going to think of.
Example, if someone is serializing data I'd expect JSON, protobuf, XML or YAML, if you're going to do anything else, it means spending extra time on finding out how and what was used

Not going to comment on the latter as I am purely interested in the code itself lol

jolly sky
earnest cove
#

Ugh is this way chat became so insane towards the end of the stream?

jolly sky
lyric venture
#

That and some other streamer guy who has been farming content

#

So its just shitty people being shitty.

#

Unfortunately 😦

brazen drift
#

wheres that

earnest cove
jolly sky
brazen drift
#

Drama farmers on youtube be like

earnest cove
#

They forgot Undertale and Fear and Hunger exists

jolly sky
#

It's like the Youtubers that "Fix other peopls art" unprompted

#

Absolute mega ultra cringe behaviour

lyric venture
#

Yeah its real weird for people to be commenting on code when so far as I know there is no current issue with the game that has issues with it running (and considering it runs on a fridge computer which probably has no power..)

#

Yeah, "I dont like this painting someone did so heres why it should be this way". Those people have lost the plot.

earnest cove
#

Funger has actual features that don't work and i don't see people picking apart trashing the game maliciously because they don't get clout for doing so.

glossy cedar
twilit crystal
jolly sky
#

He's doing writing (the story) for the game off stream

earnest cove
glossy cedar
#

I see

#

That doesn't explain the slow down though

earnest cove
#

dialogue writing, character acting, not really a thing to do on stream

earnest cove
lyric venture
earnest cove
#

Are you familiar with visual novels?

glossy cedar
lyric venture
#

And he has apologized that he wasn't as communicative about the reasons why that was then he perhaps should have been. But he has explained it on quite a few occasions.

glossy cedar
# glossy cedar Yes

Progress on them should be linear (as in content, not in timeline) unless you're working in higher dimensions of time

brazen drift
#

Yeah. I mean he wanted to pay his moderators which is a lot of paperwork since some of those arent even in the USA so theres EXTRA shenans

lyric venture
#

When you have a community that goes from like 50-300 viewers to 5-15k viewers, and so you make a business out of it, and do the ferret rescue and working on getting that up and running and growing, its a lot of work.

earnest cove
# glossy cedar Yes

Yeah so imagine visual novels that take into account of every little action. Fight has started? Dialogue and consequence for having full health, dialogue and consequence for 25% less health, dialogue and consequence for 50% health, so on so on. There's even an event if you don't move at all.

opaque raven
jolly sky
# glossy cedar That doesn't explain the slow down though

You know what does?

Creating a Business (so he could pay his mods)
Creating the Ferret Rescue
Managing the Ferret Rescue
Doing the job he held at Offbrand
Doing his mushroom farming
Normal Streaming stuff
Managing his stream
Enjoying any downtime he has when he isn't working

etc etc

lyric venture
#

And yeah, its even crazier to set it up with people across the world because pay and benefits and everything else is a nightmare even in the US and different state rules, nevermind other countries

earnest cove
#

oh the year and a half missing? All paperwork yes

#

setting up a company, writing employment things, so on and so on

#

Currently, the bottleneck is writing all the dialogue and consequences of actions

brazen drift
#

Yeah. paperwork, legalees, securing things, contacting police to warn them he might get swatted (which he has been several times)

lyric venture
#

But he started putting up updates every month and as he has stated a lot lately, 98% of it is writing which is a slow process when you are doing it from different characters and different paths. The code/implementation is very easy. Writing story is not.

earnest cove
# glossy cedar Yes

The game is supposed to have 7 endings, 1 non-ending (it loops back into the game), so he has to write all the paths to get to either one of those seven.

muted robin
hollow eagle
#

I would say they're equally difficult depending on who you are

#

And if u have a team

brazen drift
earnest cove
#

Fate stay Night was like, 1 million words i think. That's just 3 endings and i think 18 bad ends

#

bad ends meaning player take the wrong action

#

so, just 3 proper endings was 1 million words

opaque raven
#

Save the animals

earnest cove
#

technically 6 because the proper endings have an alternate variation as well

glossy cedar
golden latch
#

And thor isnt a writer by trade so its not his strongest skill so it takes even longer

earnest cove
#

just like a visual novel

jolly sky
brazen drift
#

Visual Novel meets RPG

golden latch
earnest cove
#

I don't know how FAR the stuff carries over tho i'm not the dev

#

In his ideal mind, it should matter all the way to the end

golden latch
earnest cove
#

so, so much thinking and writing there

golden latch
#

There are now 7 worlds

glossy cedar
opaque raven
brazen drift
#

It's an incredible project for like. One dude to take on writing/code wise (since he contracts out the art and music) so of course it's gonna take a good while. Nobody's screaming at the star citizen guy and those people release ships worth 5k REAL Dollars

golden latch
earnest cove
brazen drift
#

GOOD

#

i hope the game comes out for the people who paid into it but looking from the outside that game is bait

lyric venture
earnest cove
#

Thor himself called it Store Citizen and probably got a lot of flak for that

brazen drift
#

well he wasnt wrong

golden latch
hollow eagle
#

I've played Star Citizen the flying is fun

#

Other than that it makes my brain hurt

glossy cedar
jolly sky
#

I mean, if you're spending millions on a studio for a game that hasn't even released (early access) and is unproven to work in its final form of their "idea", then some questions need to get asked

brazen drift
#

now imagine thor doing that for heartbound where he kept putting out different colored costumes for the MC at like dollars a pop, for a game in Early Access.

earnest cove
#

star citizen is having the same issue. scale huge. long time. people get suspicious. One of my friend has preview of the alphas and it has a smooth transistion from space to landing. no loading screens

hollow eagle
#

It's a functioning game tho KEKW

brazen drift
#

games in early access that get DLC infuriate me to no end

hollow eagle
#

True... it's also ships that u might lose when it goes out of alpha too

earnest cove
#

It's the kind of loading i think most pcs can't handle it. It's ambitious tho

hollow eagle
#

Think about that

lyric venture
#

If you are legit upset that a game you bought for $10 is taking a bit to get finished, I personally think you need to reevaluate some things.

brazen drift
#

The best thing is its like 99% chat hoppers who didn't contribute to the kickstarter complaining about the game.

earnest cove
brazen drift
#

I mean dang, how longs Project Zomboid been in early access?

earnest cove
#

Sad reality but people do

jolly sky
glossy cedar
# jolly sky

It doesn't seem to be "getting more complicated"
Like sure it's hard as it is but do choices made in the very beginning matter later?

#

That's what I was kind of getting at

jolly sky
#

So yes, it has gotten a LOT more complicated

golden latch
lyric venture
#

I haven't personally played the game (though I did buy it) so I couldn't tell you but from what I understand things you do at the beginning can make a difference down the line.

earnest cove
#

Oh dwarf fortress

#

I played that.

#

the game was in development for 30-40 years and some peopel DID complain

brazen drift
earnest cove
#

most of the complaining is after it became official on steam

dire burrow
golden latch
dire burrow
#

losing is fun

brazen drift
#

Also i feel like theres a difference between "game with no end" and "developers are satisfied that the game is as feature complete as they want it to be"

jolly sky
# glossy cedar That's what I was kind of getting at

There are a lot of choices that effect the relationships between you and other characters in the game. There are even dialogue and relationship changes that occur depending on how much HP you have left after a fights with certain characters. And its just one small aspect of it.

dusky grove
#

I mean, you'd think after until dawn and all the other games by that studio that people would accept that in some games your choices do matter

gloomy forge
#

Hence the !!FUN!!, it was written like when you step into poison in dark souls so you can mentally prepare yourself losing your souls already KEKW sometimes games do be like that.

earnest cove
#

Dwarf fortress many people getting darn salty that they didn't have Adventure Mode done by the time of Steam release

#

i think they actually implementing that again

golden latch
dusky grove
#

Like ffs, we've had branching paths in games since chrono trigger, maybe earlier

brazen drift
golden latch
#

I think it just has been in development for 20+ years and gamers dont know how game dev works Goblins

brazen drift
#

wait till code jesus finds out about dwarf fortress KEKW

jolly sky
brazen drift
#

I'd LOVE for that guy to go look at Byond code

gloomy forge
#

Crysis had to walk so Dwarf Fortress can run.

brazen drift
#

touch something mech related in byond code it kicks the entire game square in the tortellini's.

jolly sky
glossy cedar
# jolly sky This is only 3 worlds out of 7

Yes but is that complexity in the six first worlds reflected in the seventh?
Here, this should explain it, where each rectangle is a major segment in the narrative, be it worlds, chapter, etc

glossy cedar
void kiln
jolly sky
brazen drift
golden latch
golden latch
glossy cedar
glossy cedar
earnest cove
golden latch
jolly sky
# glossy cedar Basically if you're working with relatively constant information it should not b...

Well, you don't meet all the characters at the beginning. More get introduced as the game goes on, and their behaviour can be based of how you've interacted with other previous characters.

All it should really take is looking at that screenshot of the (old version) of the map to get an idea of how complex the writing is when you're having to write dialogue, and the behaviour and emotions of the characters in the game when there are multiple different "timeline" versions of each character in the game

golden latch
#

There are 4 completely different story ends (not including you died wish to start over? Ending)

brazen drift
lyric venture
#

Yes, though lately he has been working on configs for Blockgame (when he does dev streams)

golden latch
#

He does code for certain things. for heartbound since there isnt much coding left and its all writing he doesnt stream it anymore but on blockgame his side project he does do some occasional

earnest cove
brazen drift
#

Because he's one man who also runs a Business rescuing Ferrets.

#

fug

ionic sleet
#

didn't blue prince take 8 years to complete?

jolly sky
#

Read up, and you will see that Writing is a LOT of work,

ionic sleet
#

writing and puzzle making takes time

glossy cedar
ionic sleet
#

Covid, setting up a business, working out the ferret rescue, etc. shit takes time

lyric venture
brazen drift
#

i had my artist glove on it hit enter 😭

#

every day except wednesdays and thursdays for 12 hours

golden latch
#

Here is just three areas choice map (incomplete maps mind you) this game is about 100s if not thousands of paths and choices you can make and all of them effect gameplay its a experimental rpg not based around combat or puzzle solving but story telling (they have a hidden arg if you want puzzles)

ionic sleet
#

the war making the russian translation dead at this point. logistics for everything

lyric venture
#

5 days a week generally, Friday-Tuesday. Takes Wed and Thursday off.

brazen drift
#

He also explained he doesnt do much gamedev work on streams because the majority of his audience thinks its boring.

lyric venture
#

So yeah roughly 60 hours a week if not more.

brazen drift
#

is what youve seen just... shorts? from the past year?

ionic sleet
#

and you cant exactly force writing

kindred sedge
#

This week he is streaming on Thursday for his birthday and game jam start

brazen drift
#

or from hateslop on youtube

jolly sky
kindred sedge
#

Is your pfp Patrick but with the final boss of earthbound 2?

lyric venture
#

Well, He has. Lately between Dune and other games he works on Blockgame, his Minecraft mod MMO. Much of that works is YAML configuration tweaks.

brazen drift
#

yeah thats also true

golden latch
#

Remember game development isnt just “coding”

ionic sleet
#

but is it evidence or is just nonsense wrapped in a fancy bow making you think that way

gritty tartan
kindred sedge
#

Totally off topic of the epic le owned moment your trying to set up but I'm just curious

jolly rock
#

Did Thor delete his live for today? I usually play catch up but i cant see today's one 😔

lyric venture
#

But yeah, gave dev is "development of game". Code, music, configuration.

brazen drift
#

It takes george RR martin forever to write a book, aint nobody tryin to swat george rr martin

lyric venture
brazen drift
#

No

#

He has An Artist, and a Musician

#

on contract

lyric venture
#

He has an artist and music person but beyond that for Heartbound no. For Blockgame he and Jake work on it.

gritty tartan
jolly sky
#

Only for music and art. He does the coding. He does the story.

golden latch
#

Yes he has a artist and musician that it

ionic sleet
#

3 person team

kindred sedge
#

Ugh you expect us to answer all your questions but you can't answer mine?

jolly rock
golden latch
ionic sleet
#

3 person team still does not mean fast dev work

golden latch
#

We try to be a pg 13 server

lyric venture
ionic sleet
#

I think people are just spoiled. creating a game can easily take 5+ years

brazen drift
#

also did you buy heartbound? just out of curiosity

earnest cove
#

A bunch of new anti Thor videos dropped

jolly sky
#

It was, absolutely insane garbage

golden latch
kindred sedge
#

And they gone

golden latch
#

Ops

jolly sky
#

Oh lmao they're gone

brazen drift
#

hey i was talking to that :(

jolly sky
#

I saw the angle they were going for

#

Fortunately, it didn't come to pass

brazen drift
#

i mean yeah they wre clearly just here to start manure so

kindred sedge
#

Yea they were trying to set up an epic le gottem thing

golden latch
lyric venture
#

Yeah it was clearly they were just here to stir things up

ionic sleet
#

trying to lead a convo but we aern't falling for it

jolly sky
#

Thanks whoever got that shot off

brazen drift
#

When the development angle didnt work they pulled out "Ol Unreliable"

hasty grail
#

man its like weve been through all these angles before, welcome to Geometry 201 everyone

kindred sedge
#

Their profile picture was neat at least. Earthbound 2 final boss on Patrick

brazen drift
hasty grail
#

ive been fishin, game is good

glossy cedar
# lyric venture At this point im curious on what you are trying to get to?

On why it's more complicated to add content now, even accounting for characters, relationships the work needed for writing shouldn't increase the way it seems to be doing (not the constant complexity, I get that choices matter, but . Again, probably missing something

I would understand the increase if it worked similar to something like the stanely parable where the narrative is almost two dimensional, but looking at these graphs they seem to be more one dimensional. Just a broader kind of one dimensionality, as in different choises will lead to different outcomes but you will (or won't) eventually go to the same kind of areas as you would with other choises

At this point though I might just not continue as this wasn't my initial point of interest, but rather the code, then it transitioned into this I guess

jolly sky
twilit crystal
#

Its just the "god of the gaps" over and over.

trim crater
#

People that compare mainstream companies that have 100's and+ devs, to a solo or small group of indie devs are insane.

hasty grail
#

i hope everyone here has a good July 18, because that appears to be a date with a number of free to play games getting updates or major devstreams

brazen drift
hasty grail
#

mechabreak, the horse gacha, and warframe to name a few

golden latch
trim crater
#

True and real, especially if they cant afford assets or outside help. + has day jobs etc.

ionic sleet
#

it just hilarious all this crap over heartbound when gta6 and ES6 fans are waiting longer

hasty grail
#

which i respect them for

brazen drift
#

I was gonna say we all know the people coming in here yelling about game times arent old enough to remember when skyrim released.

ionic sleet
#

they announced it years ago though

brazen drift
#

the FIRST TIME-

brazen drift
#

forgot that skyrims been re-released like 80 times

golden latch
#

Speaker blow out KEKW

brazen drift
#

God

golden latch
#

They eventually fixed it… after like 7 years

ionic sleet
#

I bought the thicc book for skyrim that listed all the quests etc. my first ES game. I put 7 years into that damn game

#

and it had a shit ton of bugs

#

cant wait for UE skyrim lol

#

while waiting for ES6

soft vector
brazen drift
#

nono, ES6 is just UE skyrim

brazen drift
golden latch
#

Im waiting for skywind and skyblivion Goblins

ionic sleet
#

I thought one of those were cancelled

hasty grail
#

Skyblivion got delayed due to the devs getting Oblivion remaster keys

brazen drift
#

"we are delaying FF14 reborn because like all of you, i too wish to play eldenring"

ionic sleet
#

omg skywind has been going on for 10 years now. wow

golden latch
#

Most games i have, have been developed for more then 5 years as a base line (or they are a small basic arcade game that took 1 month KEKW)

jolly sky
golden latch
ionic sleet
#

even with a headstart of pre made assets

golden latch
#

Its a hobby 100%

split tulip
#

Yah, modding is a hobby for most people

golden latch
#

Cant make money off the product only support as donations if that

split tulip
#

Also you can have team members just disappear due to IRL stuff

ionic sleet
#

spent a year modding every skyrim town like JK/dawn of did with new models etc. but when i was finished my PC couldn't even play the remaster that well

reef geyser
# soft vector Almost everyone asking when heartbound is getting released isn't asking because ...

Yep. Unfortunately an effective troll tactic is to take something that can be framed in a sort of genuine way, but the intentions behind the choice of doing so are nefarious ones. So while asking for info on a project's release date is at face value a normal question, 95% of the people bringing it up in the past couple weeks aren't doing so out of genuine interest. It's as a side-way of prodding and insulting about "game dev taking long you bad dev".

split tulip
# golden latch Such as dead

Eh it's usually because they graduated collage, got a job or a kid. Something taht takes up their time. Also people just lose interest over time

golden latch
split tulip
#

I used to work on some multiplayer mods but lost interest after a while

glossy cedar
hollow eagle
#

I've had ppl in my college game-a-week course make full games in 1 week

sleek seal
#

psst, @spice hearth you want to be here

#

probably

spice hearth
#

i dont agree with hating on thor for having an opinion

sleek seal
#

right, and I will show you his side of things

spice hearth
#

but how is letting people access the product they paid for a bad thing

hollow eagle
#

True

golden latch
jolly sky
hollow eagle
#

That's for the multi billion dollar $$$$ studios to decide

sleek seal
golden latch
hollow eagle
split tulip
sleek seal
#

@spice hearth before you continue, let me give you a bit of context

split tulip
#

and it's kinda been debated to death here

golden latch
#

And even then since you give the corporations control to “decide” okay they release a “playable” version with no assets a placeholder player character and a white open map. They have fufilled the requirements

hollow eagle
blissful imp
golden latch
#

Or hey the skg is put into place were everything is put perfectly into law, now all games are subscriptions congrats

hollow eagle
#

They already are

brazen drift
#

Expedition 33 begs to differ

hollow eagle
#

I'm being dramatic

golden latch
nova bough
#

why are we discussing the thing ™

hollow eagle
#

I don't know but this is funny

#

It's going to pass. We will see how things unfold

golden latch
spare topaz
#

do we really have to do this dance all over again?

split tulip
#

when we could be discussing how to spread Democracy yarrDemocracy

hollow eagle
#

We cannot change the outcome

#

Exactly

blissful imp
nova bough
split tulip
hollow eagle
jolly sky
hollow eagle
golden latch
# hollow eagle Exactly

And why we dont want to discuss it cause there is nothing we can do till lawmakers deal with it. So the discussion are pointless and just drama stirring and why we ban it normally.

jolly sky
golden latch
#

Sauce time

hollow eagle
#

Send me the article

split tulip
#

someone has the link saved, I'm sure of it. It's from video games Europe

golden latch
#

It takes action a moment but he will bring the dets

jolly sky
golden latch
split tulip
#

I knew someone had it on speed dial

jolly sky
#

Take the time to read it. Again, this group are Experts in EU law, and every developer from AAA to Solo developers can sign up for their protections, as is their right.

trim crater
#

Too meme-y

#

sorry

hollow eagle
blissful imp
jolly sky
#

'cause you didn't read it entirely in less than a minute

brazen drift
#

Keep talking about it in DMs then

blissful imp
#

i actually don't know if its ai. i just searched up Quakka on Startpage

split tulip
brazen drift
#

:(

jolly sky
#

I'm leaving the conversation there, as the document says all that needs to be said really

split tulip
golden latch
#

They are real

twilit crystal
#

What happened to the stream last night. I had to go to bed as it was 2am here, but then went to catch up this morning and it was privated 😦

brazen drift
#

drama

wet storm
jolly sky
brazen drift
#

i thin about 2thousand people were banned this last stream

wet storm
#

Sides successfully taken off

#

Dunno why I found that so funny

golden latch
twilit crystal
#

I did see that ban counter. Thats insane

blissful imp
twilit crystal
#

Is that a wallaby?

golden latch
twilit crystal
#

Ahhhh

sleek seal
#

let's consider the following: Thor has been extremely pro-indie, and very anti-government. US govt is known for absolutely massacring good ideas, and EU govt is not that much better when working with not so well established topics. Hell, let me take this a step further: how would you feel if a bunch of old farts monkey-pawed SKG into an abomination?

With that in mind let's talk about the bad parts of SKG:

  1. While having good intentions at its core, it's very loose, leaving a lot of ground for interpretation by people who couldn't care less about the goal.
  2. Lawmakers are, generally, in their later 40s, 50s and 60s. Do you trust these people to make a good decision about a thing they haven't bothered to even consider until this point?
  3. There is already significant pushback from the industry.
  4. The whole movement was sold on a populist slogan, with a couple more sprinkles hidden in the FAQ.

Now, I am a gamer, with a long, long history of gaming. I now work for a software company as a... let's say Cloud IT person. I've tinkered with and hosted community servers for MMOs like WoW, Lineage 2, and now hosting Minecraft, Valheim and w/e else servers for my friend group and sometimes communities I am a part of.

I have the server capacity for it, because I own a server, and I host servers designed to be end-user-hostable. Back in the day, you could host a WoW or a Lineage 2 server emulator fairly easily, on your own machine. But larger, more stable servers for L2 were hosted on actual server hardware, and required multiple servers to host.

I'll continue in the next message

blissful imp
twilit crystal
#

Yep. Checks out. Australia land has the coolest animals 😛

brazen drift
#

NO NO NEXT MESSAGE

spice hearth
#

theres like way too much details in everything

brazen drift
#

THUNDERDOME IS DEAD

split tulip
#

I wonder how much mail going to Australia ends up in Austria

wet storm
split tulip
wet storm
#

Meanwhile back at the thunderdome

blissful imp
# twilit crystal Yep. Checks out. Australia land has the coolest animals 😛

All rights to the Broadcasters - We're not making Money
Credit to Darcy F1 for the Footage: https://www.darcyf1.com

Don't forget to Check us out at:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MotorsportMoments

▶ Play video

There was a spikey intruder at the Repco Bathurst 1000.

The Repco Supercars Championship (formally Australian Touring Car Championship) is the premier motorsport category in Australasia and one of Australia’s biggest sports. Globally, it is recognised as the best touring car category in the world and a leader in motorsport entertainment.

Rea...

▶ Play video
split tulip
#

some things don't need a sequel

wet storm
#

The horse is dead, don't beat the dead horse

#

It's deader than dead

twilit crystal
golden latch
wet storm
#

It's been turned to glue and used to close the barn door shut

spice hearth
#

i mean im not tech savvy in the slightest

golden latch
analog sphinx
#

hey!

sleek seal
analog sphinx
#

whats being discussed here

spice hearth
#

but i dont get if people disagree with the specifics or overall message that massive companies shouldnt be allowed to shut games down completely

golden latch
vocal crystal
#

where's this doc? I'd like a gander aswell

wet storm
brazen drift
analog sphinx
blissful imp
jolly sky
wet storm
trim crater
blissful imp
#

i wont say it tho

vocal crystal
trim crater
#

Peppers too

kindred sedge
kindred sedge
#

IM A BASIC BOTCH!

wet storm
#

You want basic b?

spice hearth
#

mushrooms feel like eating a stress ball that tastes like its been coated in feces

wet storm
#

I like pepperoni

split tulip
#

they do heavy sauce too?

trim crater
muted robin
# spice hearth but i dont get if people disagree with the specifics or overall message that mas...

the majority of people who disagree with skg only disagree with the specific wording/implementation and aren't straight up against the idea of preserving games. it's kind of insanity to think that the average Game Enjoyer would go "no i hate being able to play games after they stop being sold/having access/etc"

but i think anything more and we might go too far into discussing thunderdome territory

trim crater
golden latch
wet storm
#

Once I ordered a pepperoni pizza. It came with tomato slices

spice hearth
muted robin
#

that's just what i've gathered from people in this chat

twilit crystal
wet storm
#

I asked if they could substitute the tomato slices with more pepperoni

#

They did

trim crater
golden latch
wet storm
#

Mamma Mia they burned down the pizzeria

spice hearth
twilit crystal
spice hearth
#

and id rather just get chinese food anyway

split tulip
#

car tyres are not a pizza topping

golden latch
trim crater
twilit crystal
flat root
golden latch
sleek seal
# sleek seal let's consider the following: Thor has been _extremely_ pro-indie, and very anti...

When Lineage 2 was a big thing, there were generally 2 types of servers: server emulators written in Java and leaked PTR servers, hosted with binaries stolen from devs.
The PTR binaries required you to stand up Microsoft SQL Server, run on Windows Server OS and it had major hardware requirements. You couldn't just grab an .exe, double click it, and have your buddy join you. Wasn't a thing that was considered. Normally, private servers using these binaries were hosted by someone in IT, who snagged a used enterprise server and had a space in the rack for it.

The WoW servers consist of two separate independent servers: auth server, which checks your password and subscription, and realm server, where people are actually playing - this is the absolute minimum, but generally you would have multipole realm servers, separate DB servers and also battleground and dungeon servers. Things are complicated.

All that wall of text above was just to show you that simply publishing server binaries for an MMO wouldn't work for most cases.

For the live-service games a bunch of the same complications would apply: they are designed to take on tens of thousands to possibly millions of players.

spice hearth
wet storm
#

Omg dude stop vomitting essays

golden latch
trim crater
spice hearth
# trim crater

if ur insinuating that you dont like chinese food you need a neurological exam

spice hearth
spice hearth
#

sweeter

winged knoll
#

Why do we talk about redacted again

wet storm
#

HYDRATE NOW

spice hearth
#

the americanitis here is horrifying

winged knoll
#

Mod twist his testiculars

golden latch
trim crater
dire burrow
#

Chat.

spice hearth
#

then how would you access discordKEKW

golden latch
dire burrow
#

We're not discussing SKG here anymore.

brazen drift
#

Mod please

dire burrow
#

Cease.

brazen drift
#

thank u 😭

trim crater
split tulip
brazen drift
#

what is your favorite bread ill sneak you some

wet storm
#

What if I wanna go to Greece and have to land in SKG?

trim crater
#

Garlic olive one

golden latch
trim crater
#

Good bread

spice hearth
#

'hey waitress, givus sum o dem tater tots and 112 ounces o dat bootiful brisket ya gots smokin back der, and i wants me sum whiskey to wash out me gullet and keep me singin voice gud'

golden latch
wet storm
#

And they're typing another essay

golden latch
#

Gonna get eaten by wolph

wet storm
#

In case you missed it

trim crater
sleek seal
#

welp

dire burrow
#

What did I just say.

trim crater
#

look at that bad boy

dire burrow
#

We are not discussing SKG here.

spice hearth
#

yeah but texans seem to make a religion out of it

#

as far as i know

brazen drift
#

Exodia Obliterated

edgy oar
#

You were repeatedly told to not discuss it anymore and ignored eveyone. No surprise it got deleted.

wet storm
#

Oh you said it's brisket

spice hearth
#

with my only source being young sheldon

trim crater
wet storm
#

I never had it

#

I hear it's goooood

edgy oar
#

Man now I want brisket

trim crater
#

Yeah Brisket up Chat

vocal crystal
brazen drift
#

Take it to DMs if you're that passionate about it

brazen drift
#

also pls, not the food porn its going to make me hungry nooooo

edgy oar
#

I think all the brisket just caused my Discord to reset

winged knoll
trim crater
#

Pudding of chocolate for everyone

dire burrow
winged knoll
#

I ceases to exist

spice hearth
#

what animal does brisket come from

vocal crystal
#

beef

winged knoll
trim crater
#

or veal

#

ye

split tulip
#

The Briskador

spice hearth
#

o thought it was pig

vocal crystal
#

it is the from part of the cow, think of the pectoralis muscle

spice hearth
#

ive never eaten beef or pig

trim crater
#

So tender

spice hearth
#

chicken is the superior meat

spice hearth
#

chicken soup

#

fried chicken

spice hearth
#

grilled chicken

#

chicken kiev

wet storm
#

That's a highland coo

spice hearth
#

chicken balls

#

chicken nuggets

#

tenders

wary saffron
vocal crystal
toxic rampart
#

I'm daily Pesce-pollotarian but will do borderline vulgar things to a slow cooked Boston shoulder

spice hearth
#

chicken thigh

wet storm
#

They become this

#

And then brisket I suppose

dire burrow
#

thats incredible

#

+2

golden latch
#

The brisket cut is notorious for being tough and stringy and the only way to make it palatable and delicious is the butcher way of long low cooking

split tulip
#

beef is my favorite animal too

wary saffron
idle hill
#

beef is my favorite animal

vocal crystal
idle hill
#

very taste

golden latch
#

Do i tell them beef is the actual name of the animal as cow is the female bovine and the bull is the male KEKWait

spice hearth
#

the only thing that americans do right is that arizona tea

jolly sky
#

Important news, some genius Metal Gear Solid Modder has made it possible to use the HF Blade from the beginning of the game, fully implemented;

spice hearth
vocal crystal
spice hearth
#

america pussy footed around while the real gaffer stepped up to the plate and hit a home run

golden latch
#

Oh come on

dire burrow
#

what did you expect bluedragon

golden latch
#

Auto mod 😡

vocal crystal
golden latch
spice hearth
#

a god arrived

golden latch
#

Atleast you can read it wolph

vocal crystal
dire burrow
golden latch
dire burrow
#

for anyone asking what bluedragon typed.

spice hearth
#

an omnipotent being, sent us from a higher life form in our darkest hour

trim crater
#

Anways gn, goblins.
have a good one!
See ya tomorrow YarrSalute

spice hearth
#

dont recall america ever winning a world cup?

#

1966

#

never forget

golden latch
#

I was explaining how beef is the actual name of the animal normally called cow

late bane
#

Lol deef

wet storm
#

It's important

vocal crystal
dire burrow
wet storm
#

Crazy I know

golden latch
wet storm
#

And shocker

#

Chicken comes form chicken

spice hearth
#

i just know england are always the good guys

wet storm
#

Why doesn't chicken have a name for it

#

Chork

#

POULTRY

wary saffron
#

lmao

late bane
#

Birb

wet storm
#

It does I forgot

vocal crystal
spice hearth
#

ay

#

theyd be years behind if we didnt help them

#

it took some sacrifice on their behalf

#

but look where we are now

vocal crystal
spice hearth
#

someone had to say it

indigo wadi
spice hearth
#

but no

#

the pc police would be all over it

indigo wadi
#

But maybe let's step away from world politics

spice hearth
#

this isnt politics

vocal crystal
spice hearth
#

were delving into a country with a culture as rich as kerrygold butter

wet storm
#

It's history memes

indigo wadi
wet storm
#

It's only politics if you're stuck in the early 80s

#

If that's the case uh

#

Wait 50 years?

#

:p

#

It's polandball level memes take it easy

wet storm
split tulip
#

So it's the stuff before the old version of "we didn't start the fire"

vocal crystal
#

dont do anything too crazy now

split tulip
wet storm
#

Pay no heed to the bonfire behind the curtain

tight bramble
#

Im just popping in while at work to say that I have an overwhelming sense of foreboding as of today's stream. I hope thor is ok. I've done what I can to show my support, and I will continue to do so, so I really hope he sees that he has friends. Idk.....I've seen too much in the service, when the strongest men I've ever met stopped being strong. Always keep fighting. Don't be afraid to reach for a shoulder to lean on.

indigo wadi
winged knoll
#

I think he’ll be okay but man keep repeating himself is tiring

hazy storm
wet storm
#

Did something happen today?

vocal crystal
wind raven
wet storm
#

I saw that Heimdall was going NUTS

hazy storm
#

Almost 2000 chat bans today

wind raven
#

The mob has a new criticism every day

#

its being fueled by an industrial complex of slop youtubers farming clips day and night

ivory schooner
#

there was a new video, 500k views in 8 hours, easiest "dont recommend channel" of my life

wind raven
#

if anyone deserves shame its ironically the slop tubers

late bane
#

Oh someone made a video now I can make a video using that streamers content and react

wind raven
vocal crystal
#

*without i mean

wind raven
#

that literally human centipede sloptube

#

the code review is just nit picking

#

as a developer i can say it definitely nit picky especially considering the overall popularity of the game

#

who cares if he had a useless comment

vocal crystal
#

its just a witch hunt

wind raven
#

IMHO its the worst kind of developers who get hung up on arbitrary coding standards rather than being able to see the value the product is driving

spiral bane
#

I think they just find it strange it’s taken so long to finish the game

wind raven
#

people have the same criticism of the game of thrones guy

#

who cares

#

high expectations makes delivering hard

late bane
#

I bet 95 percent of the comments don't actually care at all about the game. They are just doing it for trolling. Nobody was doing this before the drama.

wind raven
#

thats why we will never get half-life 3

#

just let people live their lives and be imperfect humans

muted robin
#

from what i gather they're two separate critiques, unless ppl are unironically arguing that thor putting too many comments or using == instead of = is why the game has taken 9 years to make

opaque raven
#

I cant find the context, my discord mobile doesn't want to scroll up anymore

kindred sedge
#

You lost the game

opaque raven
#

Some yes, and they have normal worries and questions about the development, as it is now it becomes very obvious very fast who is actually interested and who just wants to add more drama

exotic forge
exotic forge
hazy storm
#

And those slop tubers would be the first ones to cry foul of anyone tried doing it to them

spiral bane
#

I think those YouTubers just think his ego is bigger than his skills. I have no idea though and don’t really care

wind raven
#

the wow drama was exhausting

#

this is so much worse though

opaque raven
wind raven
#

just glad i found the discord

winged knoll
wind raven
#

was losing my mind on youtube

winged knoll
#

XD

exotic forge
winged knoll
#

Tbh i think everyone should also somehow try not to get pissed when people attacking Thor online

#

It’s not good for your mental

#

Just block, unrecommend and move on

wind raven
exotic forge
wind raven
#

every single video is the same

winged knoll
hazy storm
jolly sky
#

I never go into the Youtube comment section, It's just rage farm bait and a cesspit

#

Even on videos where seeing rage bait is rare, like for example on Tested videos

wind raven
#

i just miss before 2025

exotic forge
#

If you go into a forum and see lots of sexist and racist comments. Can you just tell people to ignore them and let them be?

#

You can't ignore that stuff

opaque raven
#

Roblox's global chat is the last bastion of drama free media

wind raven
#

yeah it does pretty much ruin the comments section as a platform

jolly sky
#

"You cannot reason someone out of a place they didn't reason themselves into"

indigo wadi
winged knoll
river cargo
opaque raven
river cargo
#

you can't slop sloptubers from farming

#

but they should've known better than to blast thor

exotic forge
river cargo
#

especially when they take their disagreements out of dms and into the public

jolly sky
winged knoll
indigo wadi
exotic forge
indigo wadi
winter sierra
#

I think charlies old videos are better. I dont like his internet drama vids, i think he should have stayed out of that. It doesn’t fit his style of content

exotic forge
spiral bane
#

@river cargo didn’t Thor leak Charlie’s dm though

distant rapids
#

Welll charlie was very... inciting. Mutahar wasn't nearly as bad, but charlie, oh man he went full hypocrite on that video

indigo wadi
spiral bane
#

Ahh gotcha

winter sierra
#

charlie went full redditor, something he swore against

#

Tbh he does it a lot (nowadays)

exotic forge
#

Eh just because they didn't directly say on camera to go bully and harass Thor doesn't mean they aren't complicit

warm trench
#

At some point the only way to moderate this is to platform wide make it a policy not to allow such content, regardless of First Amendment rights... No one will stand down/stop the behavior, no will like the heavy arm of a platform preventing content - but it's the only way. This of course will not happen and quite frankly - I seriously have been loosing and will loose all faith in humanity.

jolly sky
#

Not directly no, but Coding Jesus literally called Thor a fraud in his thumbnail, which emboldened his fans to come and say the same, and that has happened almost ad infinitum with plenty of other content creators

brazen drift
#

friendly reminder that your first amendment rights only protect you against the government, not from citizens

winter sierra
#

^

warm trench
#

I know, but the peanut gallery in my head agrues with me @indigo wadi

hazy storm
#

I can't change the minds of commenters and trolls but i can and do talk to my daughter about internet drama between her favorite creators.

I always tell her to not believe the first source she says and to be aware of which channels are known for drama baiting. Fortunately she has a good head on her shoulders and i have gotten her comfortable with taking to me about that stuff. Especially because i put it in the context of cyber bullying -- which it is and which she hates

late bane
#

The next adpocalypse will be because of React/Slop tubers

muted robin
winter sierra
#

First amendment is not say whatever you want about ANYTHING its about the government

indigo wadi
#

Stop.

No need to post drama videos

winged knoll
jolly sky
#

Except it was done in complete bad faith from the get go.

exotic forge
#

Coding Jesus said more things than a simple 'code review'. Come on now, no need to play dumb.

indigo wadi
#

Except CJ completely misunderstood the code

muted robin
#

if first amendment rights only applied to the government and not businesses/private citizens then by that right employers could fire people for being a religion they don't like or people could get discriminated against by coworkers/business people/etc and it would be legal. but it's not so

hazy storm
silver vapor
#

Sheesh

jolly sky
#

He didn't even attempt to understand why things were done the way they were, and didn't attempt to realise that he wasn't even looking at GM code, and thought he was looking at C++.

And he tried to implement his own experience in Finance programming onto Game Dev, and he would be shocked to see how code is made in multiple game dev studios/Solo developers

exotic forge
#

Yakety joined this server today fyi

dire burrow
untold seal
#

Where is that tweet of the 20 year Microsoft software engineering dunking of CJ "code review" kekw

winged knoll
#

If the goal is to do a code reviews, CJ wouldn’t make multiple video on the matter

muted robin
winged knoll
#

He makes exposé disguised as code reviews, aka slops

brazen drift
#

If you didn't buy heartbound you have no right to comment on how long the game is taking.

late bane
winter sierra
#

gone

flat root
muted robin
#

man i'm gonna get so much mileage out of that image

muted robin
#

among other things, but yeah, politics

onyx gate
exotic forge
flat root
#

If the 1st amendment didn't exist, those laws could still be in place. The basis for those laws is more based on the 14th amendment.

distant rapids
#

If someone can't recognize the code as not being the language they SUPPOSEDLY have 20 years in experience in, well i put them firmly in the "has experience but learned nothing" category

jolly sky
#

There's a lot of content creators that don't even attempt to try and understand, and just go straight for the shit-talk. It's so disappointing on almost every conceivable level.

Understanding is Crucial for being a damn human

#

Understanding and trying to see the perspective of other people

muted robin
#

honestly as someone who's only tentatively dipped my toes into coding i feel like these guys dipping into drama kind of gives the "online coding community" a bad name. like as a newcomer i basically have to wonder "okay so if i do something that's cringe or that someone with a large enough platform thinks is Bad Code does this mean i'm going to get farmed for drama content too"

#

that's mainly what pisses me off about this whole situation. it's not really just that it's happening to thor (tho it's obviously overblown) but it's what this whole thing does to validate toxic behavior online as a whole

flat root
#

Also, just because one rule doesn't prevent a specific action doesn't mean there isn't other rules that do what is needed, or that the rule is somehow wrong.

There are rules on how to do En Passant in chess, and nothing in that section of rules strictly forbids me from punching my opponent in the face in response. It's other rules that forbid that, and it's nothing wrong with the first rule.

winter sierra
#

Is the coding community toxic?

#

I dont know ive never been in it

brazen drift
#

no, drama youtubers are toxic

warm trench
#

Honestly, there has been a growing concern that coding community in general (especially in the enterprise arena) is in fact getting more and more toxic.

exotic forge
muted robin
late bane
#

Thor tries to get people with no knowledge to try to create games. People like Coding Jesus would gatekeep these same potential creators from doing so.

distant rapids
#

Also the idea that coding in general has to be done a certain way is laughable. Coding is a many-headed beast, with pros and cons to doing it one way vs another. Why is the enum so long? For modability. Why do "x" instead of "y"? Because the benefit of using y is not what I'm looking for, i want the benefits of x.

warm trench
#

Now throw in the billions of dollars applied to AI, corpo will have their pounds of flesh

muted robin
#

a la the clickbait "worst most hated most evil streamer who ruined his career eveeerrrrr!" thumbnails

exotic forge
#

We're supposed to encourage people to build things, not make whole videos nitpicking, attacking the character of someone showing their code online

jolly sky
idle hill
exotic forge
#

I see you joined today as well. Welcome to the server!

brazen drift
#

which is incredible because his career hasn't ended. he may have lost a bunch of subs but he still has a pretty massive community of GOOD people.

vocal crystal
#

is CJ an actual quant?

distant rapids
#

Amd honestly, thor doesnt really prioritize youtube. He's mainly a twitch streamer.

hazy storm
#

Yeah 2.5 million yt subs is still nothing to sneeze at

brazen drift
#

This isn't some hard accusation "dude got arrested for his crimes" career ending move. its Petty Drama

warm trench
#

As I said in stream, pointing out how undertale was "crap" code with the mega if/thens isn't really about sh*ting on the code, but instead commenting on how "experts" would see his code vs the concept what I believe Thor really means: It doesn't matter how beginner you code is, just do it and make the game - just make the game and enjoy doing it.

exotic forge
bronze parcel
#

I think you can do better than attack someone's character.

winter sierra
#

huh?

vocal crystal
exotic forge
winter sierra
#

I just think its a little odd

dire burrow
#

At the end of the day, if your code works and it doesn't kill the performance of your game, no one cares what it looks like.

brazen drift
bronze parcel
jolly sky
#

5 years of Finance experience and then offering $350 Resume reviews is, questionable at the very least. And then trying to use his Finance experience in a Game Design "review" is just like, HUH?

brazen drift
#

If someone calls themselves the "God of COD" Im already inclied to believe they're not the greatest of people.

#

unless its a fisherman

bronze parcel
#

It's ad hominem.

muted robin
#

also my understanding is that the code isn't just meant to be A Game but it's also tied to an ARG where people are looking at the code for metagame reasons and thus the code has more purposes than just making a game runnable and needs design features with more than one purpose in mind

bronze parcel
#

I look more poorly against ad hominem than I do against people who choose silly names for themselves.

winter sierra
muted robin
#

that and i haven't heard thor say anything about the ARG being made in mind that only experienced coders should be able to access/understand the code KEKW

vocal crystal
#

better guarantee they get the job

warm trench
#

We can't talk religion, but something like this is so revolting to me on a personal level (Not when it's ethnic, that's understandable/fine) that I would never take the person seriously or with any credit.

jolly sky
flat root
tight bramble
muted robin
#

so with that in mind it makes sense that the code would be less efficient in terms of raw programming as a tradeoff for it being meant to be more accessible to people who are in it for the story/ARG and not as programmers

earnest cove
#

haaaa (big sigh) youtube keeps trying to feed me thor slander because i watched his channel....

muted robin
#

kdslflkjds yeah dude here's a hint, you don't need to worry about being banned for having a differnet opinion, you need to worry about being banned bc you're strawmanning

brazen drift
#

not that i even live near the ocean in the first place anymore

bronze parcel
muted robin
#

if you come to this server for more reasons than to troll, incite arguments, or repeat talking points from youtube, you'll find that there's actually people of all stripes and opinions here who care or don't care about thor as a person to varying degrees

flat root
#

~~Is Posiedon a fisherman? 🤔 Either he fishes in the sea, which is just hunting, or he gets out of the sea to fish which is like leaving your house to order takeout that's made in your house anyway ~~

vocal crystal
muted robin
#

"Thor good, CJ bad."

warm trench
bronze parcel
distant rapids
#

If they attack thor's character and then say "you can't attack my character!" They're just bullies who pull the victim card when they get consequences.

muted robin
#

if that's the best argument you can muster out of the multiple perspectives and ppl who have participated, you're strawmanning

#

or you just can't read

winter sierra
#

More of a first impression if i know nothing about them

wind raven
earnest cove
vocal crystal
#

which field?

earnest cove
#

I don't know by now if his programming got better or he's still primarily musician. I do think his main talent is music.

wind raven
exotic forge
#

Hey, I know you just joined today but so far all your takes seems to defend coding Jesus. Now you're being a reductionist against any critique towards Coding Jesus

jolly sky
#

No, not even that really. Actions speak for themselves, and the continuing actions are proving who is acting in bad faith,

CJ may be doing good actions in the Finance area of programming, but stepping into the Game Design field to capitalise on the drama while having no experience with the code he's even reviewing, is bad.

Like every aspect of life, its multi-faceted and layered.

earnest cove
#

oh some very interesting background history about him

#

Robert F. "Toby" Fox (born October 11, 1991) is an American video game developer and composer. He is best known for developing the role-playing video game Undertale, which garnered acclaim and has received nominations for a British Academy Game Award, three Game Awards and D.I.C.E. Awards. He is also the creator and head of the ongoing developme...

#

Fox has stated that as a child, he took music lessons, including piano and trumpet; when he reached middle school, he decided to start playing piano again, performing gaming soundtracks by ear

#

he already had natural music talent

wind raven
#

if CJ was the only person working on a passion project he would probably have inadequate test coverage

#

thats an easy slam dunk you can do on anyone

#

its really not that hard to make code criticisms out of context or even in context

#

a lot of code that runs youtube is probably less than perfect

flat root
#

Reminds as well about Touhou, which has similar notes of Toby Fox's journey into game development.
The developer, ZUN, was already a programmer, but also a musician and wanted an avenue for his type of music, and decided on developing his own sequence of games called Touhou.

Amusingly, ZUN was hilariously bad with art at first. Like, some of the images of the characters, while all having creative and gorgeous character design, are generally quite awful with bad anatomy as if some limbs were broken, faces that looked goofy, and just generally not all too good. Nowadays though, ZUN's art is quite pleasing and works well.

warm trench
#

I'll throw a unpopular opinion - I think tests are really not a good thing to do/

vocal crystal
bronze parcel
#

Thor doesn't have a lot of code to criticize, not much actually verifiable code outside of what he shows off in stream. He doesn't have any significant background of open source contributions as far as I'm aware. That said, nobody is perfect and even if Thor is just a "mediocre" coder, his background and experience is enough to land him a 6 figure job practically anywhere he wants.

wind raven
exotic forge
#

I think your true colors are showing

warm trench
#

But if it costs thousands of dollars everytime you compile, something has to be done

earnest cove
#

I really hate the whole "My critique is valid he should listen to me"

muted robin
#

you're saying that as if thor is personally reading this and hates you personally and not that you're coming into a discord server accusing people of thinking "CJ bad thor good"

brazen drift
#

it's not criticism when someone comes in and says "mana" or calls him a "roach" or first-time-chats "lol bro ur code is bad lmaoooooo"

earnest cove
#

Only people who're close to him like his friends and family should do the critiquing not rando strangers online

indigo wadi
#

He can when it's actual criticism

wind raven
#

tests are so so so important

muted robin
#

you're getting pushback bc you're being a jerk and mischaracterizing people in a chat that you clearly haven't bothered to explore in a non-confrontational/judgemental way. you so obviously came here to start beef and accuse people of being suck ups to thor

wind raven
#

unit tests, integration tests

warm trench
#

That's fine.

flat root
#

He has apologized for things already in the past. But if he genuinely doesn't believe he is doing something wrong when others claim it, why should the assumption be that Thor is wrong?

jolly sky
#

Except that isn't the case. If the criticism is coming from good faith and actually makes sense, he's more than happy to listen and take it into account. If its coming from bad faith or you're copy-pasting Reddit/Youtube opinions then of course you're going to get yeeted.

brazen drift
#

Criticism would be "Hey I think hes right on some points about your code, have you ever thought about X take"

wind raven
#

guys please relax

late bane
#

I've seen him take criticism a bunch of times, the trick is not being an absolute ass about it

indigo wadi
tight bramble
earnest cove
hazy storm
#

You're deliberately ignoring all the trollish things people are doing and defending someone who took potshots at him in bad faith.

I have to question whether you're here for an actual discussion or just another drama hog

exotic forge
#

I didn't know harassment, bait, death threats and concern trolling now counts as valid criticism

earnest cove
brazen drift
#

Also all the "raid" messages that were just a bunch of spammy emotes...

jolly sky
flat root
#

As well, criticism only makes sense if it actually works towards achieving the intended goals. Since the code is being built not just for a game but for an ARG, criticizing it only on the basis of the code misses half the point.

distant rapids
#

Okay so, my critisicm for you: you come in here with opinions that you state as facts, that's unacceptable behavior and invalid. If i go into your twitch i should be allowed to shittalk you as much as possible. If you disagre with me you are simply doubling down. Now where's your apology to me? I'm waiting. You better take my criticism.

flat root
#

No one will implement your ideas if it completely misses the point.

wind raven
#

Thor just needs a mental health break guys

indigo wadi
#

Criticism also has to make sense

earnest cove
#

Also, drop the attitude that "He should listen to me."

wind raven
#

he doesn't need dog pilling now

indigo wadi
#

Those don't count

flat root
brazen drift
#

Criticism is supposed to be Constructive; you need a valid reason and you need to be able to explain that reason. Whats happening rn is just bullying at its finest

indigo wadi
#

He's not a 20 year game dev...

wind raven
#

he was never a dev

late bane
#

I feel a big issue in general now is how people talk to each other, feels like the going mood is i know what's best and your an idiot if you don't agree with my take

indigo wadi
wind raven
#

never claimed to be a dev

earnest cove
jolly sky
#

Dude was bringing arguments based on things he learned from Reddit or Youtube and not Thors LinkedIn

bronze parcel
#

His dev experience is more recent, but he does/should seemingly have significant industry experience.

untold seal
#

Once again normies ruin everything. They think when someone says they have been interested industry for 20 years they automatically assume they mean developer.

Peak comedy

dire burrow
#

ohp

#

BrBoa was a ban evader

late bane
#

I've been a professional driver for 12 years

so you build cars

brazen drift
#

oh?

dire burrow
#

They came back and called me a slur KEKW

jolly sky
#

OH. Well.

brazen drift
#

LMAO

jolly sky
#

LMAO

#

Nice shot

distant rapids
#

LOL

wispy plover
#

Jeez

earnest cove
#

aaaah repeat offenders

brazen drift
#

I mean im so sorry but that's incredible

late bane
earnest cove
#

All these people man, coming in insisting their """"""critique"""""" is the holy grail

winged knoll
indigo wadi
muted robin
#

brand new user only joined today
was rude to other users even in earlier conversations today
started argument by citing/bringing up a notable YT drama video
accuses everyone of believing "CJ bad thor good" the second they get pushback
starts concern trolling the definition of strawmanning upon being called out for it
starts bringing up the exact meme replica repeats of "can't take criticism"
thinks thor personally is arguing with him and going to ban him

Lads I think we've got another case of

dire burrow
#

I instantly was sus of them as soon as they seemingly joined on a new account and was already involved in the conversation.

late bane
brazen drift
#

People really have nothing better to do huh.

earnest cove
frozen sonnet
#

Wolp on the case

brazen drift
#

Go learn game dev if you have time to make an alt on the place you got banned from

frozen sonnet
#

Wolp protect yarrLove

winged knoll
#

Take some bread

bronze parcel
#

I might not agree with Thor on the recent controversy, but I have no illusions about my privilege in this server lol. A lot of people seem to think they're entitled to air their unfiltered criticisms.

late bane
late bane
#

Treat everyone you meet like its your grandma at first

dire burrow
#

Its really hard to take what anyone is saying seriously when they will ban evade to harass over and over.

muted robin
#

I think another issue about criticism from drama farmers is that actual critique comes from a place of good faith and lack of bias. I can't trust most content creators to give valid critique bc a lot of them have conflicts of interest re: dumping on Thor to conform with public opinion would get them a lot of clicks and money

earnest cove
frozen sonnet