So I'm currently tied with about 1000+ people on the Custom Show but I'm relegated to outside the Platinum cutoff despite having the same amount of votes as those up to 3899th.
I think it's only fair for everyone that ties in votings are handled like they are actually ties where everyone with, for example, 9 votes are placed 3899th instead of being randomly shuffled in the leaderboard and missing out on a potential reward through no fault of their own.