#arms

1 messages · Page 25 of 1

shadow ibex
#

the amount of bosses that throw out random stuns that would stop a cast of that is very very small

#

the amount of players that can however is just about any spec

gaunt owl
#

thats clearly something you wouldnt use in PVP

shadow ibex
#

its a pvp hero spec

gaunt owl
#

just to get the lego cast off you have to CC people

#

and most people gonna have something ready to avoid the last hit

#

there is no such thing as a pvp hero spec

#

blizzard dont design anything around pvp

shadow ibex
#

colossus is a pvp hero spec

gaunt owl
#

just because this exists in Slayer tree

#

its gonna be the spec played for PVP

shadow ibex
#

colossus has better shockwave and huge nuke

#

charge movement speed is for pve bosses

empty sluice
gaunt owl
#

tell me you never pvp without telling me you never pvp

empty sluice
#

what did I just read 😄

shadow ibex
shadow ibex
# empty sluice huh

to stop bosses from running out of melee range when they get pulled and you charge

#

and ur chasing them out of melee range for 2 second

empty sluice
#

you can just use normal charge

#

idk

gaunt owl
#

he never played against an ice mage

empty sluice
#

yea lol 😄

gaunt owl
#

that gonna make your life miserable

shadow ibex
#

idk if you dont think warrior has enough tools to get out of movement imparing

gaunt owl
#

you have so much possibility to get rooted

shadow ibex
#

compared to shockwave knocking x2 targets up in 3s

latent moss
#

why are we even talking

#

about pvp

#

pvp in skyhold???????

gaunt owl
#

because he fixate on his stupid take of saying its a pvp spec

shadow ibex
#

you'll get a thousand % more value out of longer shockwave CC than im faster after i charge a mage who is gonna blink anyway

gaunt owl
#

when blizzard never design anything for PVP

latent moss
#

im pretty sure they explicitly said

#

hero talents arent focused on a specific mode

slow saddle
shadow ibex
nova marsh
#

As they say

#

Another week another ember

#

SIGH

teal fossil
#

1 more week

nova marsh
#

LOL no

teal fossil
#

i mean

#

im fairly sure this is the last week until you get garuanteed heroic drop

#

its either next week or the week after

nova marsh
#

Based on what, the wowhead graph?

#

The one that was proven wrong?

gaunt owl
#

source that got it wrong ?

#

better back it up 😄

spring basalt
#

Hello boys

#

which build should i use for Arms M+

wind vault
#

Which build do You think will be played in S4? Cause I think double bladestorm is really lacking DMG on bosses

spring basalt
#

well i dont raid so, i dont about ST as much as i care about my aoe

wind vault
#

I am really thinking about m+, forgot to mention that

misty iron
#

i like to do a bit of gaming Condemned

gaunt owl
#

wtf is that kill time ?

#

@spring basalt @wind vault

#

its gonna be one or the other most likely

astral yarrow
#

Double BS MBG or nothing

#

I came to do overall and 0 boss dps

gaunt owl
#

all and nothing at the same time

cinder ocean
#

On PTR, is the legendary still 496 when you turn in the quest?

misty iron
nova marsh
#

You HAVE to get the upgrade item

astral yarrow
misty iron
#

full ST 🙂

gaunt owl
#

looking at kill time its 2 burst phase no ?

hazy flower
#

we had

#

same kill timer

#

in last reclear during jan

#

nvm it was 20sec faster xdd

misty iron
viral garden
carmine fossil
#

question.. do we use embellishments?

gaunt owl
wispy tiger
# carmine fossil question.. do we use embellishments?

Every class in the game uses embellishments. Most warriors are running either two Shadowflame embellishments or one Shadowflame and the Wristguards of Companionship. I've also seen a few running Elemental Lariat because it can outperform shadowflame in AoE.

carmine fossil
wispy tiger
#

Yup np

teal fossil
misty iron
#

abandoned warrior mid tier then came back for some alt raids stuff while guild is still progging smolderon

#

blessed logs

hazy flower
#

@ornate eagle

gaunt owl
#

have you tried dying less ?

hazy flower
#

i died twice

gaunt owl
#

thats interesting that with that many death

#

you could have timed it actually

hazy flower
#

easy yeah

#

we had scuffed start

#

and yazma took actually very long

#

even with good reflects

#

I put ret on add duty

#

because adds were a bit annoying in 28

#

so he was full on aoe there

wicked aurora
wispy tiger
#

congrats?

wicked aurora
#

I figured you meant shadowflame and lariat

wispy tiger
#

Naw never give up the Wristguards stats are perfect for Arms

wicked aurora
#

Shadowflame kinda mid tbh

#

Lariat was a sidegrade in single target so it was an ez swap

wispy tiger
#

Well from what I've heard Lariat shines in M+ (Idk I don't run it no point in crafts this late into the season)

#

Shadowflame is def better in ST raid fights but we got like two this tier

hazy flower
#

not really def better

#

with full sockets lariat should outsim shadowflame in st

wispy tiger
#

I'm full sockets and shadowflame was simming higher (disclaimer: I played fury all season)

gaunt owl
#

skill issue

wispy tiger
#

Naw I just think Arms is in this weird place where it's both easy to play but hard to play because of how disjointed it feels

#

Unless you meant the sims then yeah skill issue I guess lol

gaunt owl
#

push button

#

stuff dies

#

people just think too hard

wispy tiger
#

I know I called it easy for a reason but it really does need another way to spend rage. Spamming ignore pain felt bad but at least it worked. Then they took that from us for no reason whatsoever lol

wicked aurora
#

There’s not much disjointed about it

#

Press MS on CD, press OP, press WW, press slam if all on CD

gaunt owl
#

they took ignore pain out because it was unintended

wicked aurora
#

Spam execute in execute

#

That’s really it

gaunt owl
#

the only diff we have with Shadowlands S3 gameplay is that they cranked the rage gen to 11

wicked aurora
#

Yep

wispy tiger
#

I know how to play arms and literally called it easy twice idk what else to say

gaunt owl
#

its not that we cant spend rage

wicked aurora
#

But you also just don’t care about the rage until execute phase

wispy tiger
#

I just think it could FEEL better to play

gaunt owl
#

its we get too much of it all the time

wicked aurora
#

It’s cosmetic until then

gaunt owl
#

Fury got the same funny rage bar that is useless

#

you can disable it too

#

Rampage highlight itself when you can push it

wispy tiger
#

Don't even need the highlight you just press it every other GCD for the most part

#

Shit is too easy it's why I gotta swap mains. Would be falling asleep in my chair during raid because it's three buttons outside of your burst. And dying as fury is borderline impossible unless you royally fuck up.

#

We just need a rework for all specs tbh. Fury is braindead, arms feels like shit to play, and Prot has some of the worst button bloat in the game.

gaunt owl
#

even Arms has the button bloat problem

reef mauve
#

Dear blizzard. Delete fatal mark and give us damage elsewhere. Sincerely a warrior progging mythic smolderon with a bunch of apes.

gaunt owl
#

its literally the only fight where you can giga snipe it

reef mauve
#

Can't snipe shit until 30% lol

smoky kayak
reef mauve
#

Smolderon does that pretty well

#

Them boys love some balls

#

Lol

gaunt owl
#

its the balls raid

#

be happy its only 3

#

but well people need to use their eyes to do it properly

reef mauve
#

What trinkets we looking at next patch? Whispering/anvil?

#

Or is it too early to tell?

gaunt owl
#

we can expect some trinket tuning

boreal quartz
#

whispering + brand for 5 min sims

#

but tuning

prisma heart
gaunt owl
#

with an unknown embellishment

untold trench
#

Meanwhile your dps:

smoky kayak
#

BSL is the real parse strat though, just gotta pray for god RNG

gaunt owl
#

only need 40% to beat Lariat

#

doable

misty bridge
#

BSL?

smoky kayak
# gaunt owl only need 40% to beat Lariat

Yeah it's mostly a matter of when you get that 40% though; there are so many encounters where the high incoming damage is also where you want to use your own cooldowns

smoky kayak
misty bridge
#

Oh okay

latent moss
#

next season

#

u basically have 4 aoe buttons that do the same shit

#

similar shit*

#

cleave op ww tc

#

and then tc slam bloat

#

arms for sure has too much bloat imo

smoky kayak
#

S4 playstyle is pretty cluttered yeah, basically playing a game of keyboard whack-a-mole

#

but it does work so 🤷‍♂️

latent moss
#

y it was that way in s1 as well

smoky kayak
#

not so much, S1 was very cleave focused

#

but there have been a lot of baseline changes since then

latent moss
#

i meant like

#

cleave if 4+ targets ss exe if 2-3

#

etc

#

ss op if x targets etc

smoky kayak
#

didn't happen initially because Sweeping Strikes was a talent until 10.0.5

#

the initial Season 1 playstyle was very much "rotate cleave & OP, weave in WW and maintain Rend"

latent moss
#

i mean everyone talented into it

#

and u talented into it on st to get sos iirc

smoky kayak
#

not with the original builds, SS was often skipped because you spent most of the time cleaving

latent moss
#

oh true

#

i rember now

#

when imp ms was a thing and shit

smoky kayak
#

after 10.0.5, that's when it started getting more complicated, because SS going baseline meant you didn't lose anything by using it

teal fossil
#

Wish cleave could gain a 25% bonus with ss up

#

Like how blade rush and killing spree gets stronger with blade flurry up

#

In aoe ofc

#

Don’t want to be sweeping on st

smoky kayak
#

that's the hard part with doing anything to sweeping; unless you give it a power cost, there's a lot of potential for it to suddenly become a ST button

hazy flower
#

@ornate eagle

#

6 rio

crimson charm
#

Imagine doing +30 keys, and only having 6 rio score

#

Impressive!

ornate eagle
#

grats!

#

im still sittin on that eb29

hazy flower
ornate eagle
hazy flower
#

report

ornate eagle
#

im afraid i have to

hazy flower
#

snitch

#

snitches get stitches

ornate eagle
#

i can come on enha and die to every mechanic!

#

cuz no defensives

hazy flower
#

average shaman moment

#

press bl and die

ornate eagle
#

real

dull siren
robust scaffold
somber cove
#

hey all, i simmed 5 min, 5 patchwerk bosses. And then I did 5 min on the cleave dummies and got 12k less than what I simmed. Is that ratio good or no

dire hinge
somber cove
#

oh thanks

dire hinge
#

that said, you'll never quite catch a sim, since it's a robot doing a perfect rotation

somber cove
#

true, just wondering what ratio of actual dps/sim dps is considered good

dire hinge
#

there's not really a benchmark to shoot for there, just keep practicing 🙂

somber cove
#

ok sounds good 🙂

fathom shoal
#

how many ppl are in the skyhold server?

#

i cant see it

quasi torrent
#

atleast 69

gloomy summit
#

150k

dire hinge
fathom shoal
stiff rune
#

so whats the interaction for fyralath where we bladestorm? use blademasters and pop avatar during rage to use bladestorm at the same time?

#

is that actually worth doing?

dire hinge
#

nah not really worth doing, but neat that you can

reef glade
#

eh i mean if youre running bladestorm wouldnt it be more worth to just stack both abilities when you would otherwise use em seperately

#

not that u even use bs much current season i think but if you did cant imagine its like, a downgrade to do so

zinc python
#

Pretty new to Arms war, but anyone got any insight on thunderous roar and why most online rotations are placing it outside of damage buff windows? I.E. Using it before the avatar burst window. To my understanding Warrior bleeds have snapshot but I could be wrong.

strange perch
#

No snapshot

hexed saddle
#

snapshots dont really exist outside of feral

strange perch
#

Casting it outside the damage is because no snapshot, the initial damage isnt the bulk of the damage, and we have tom and cs rolling constantly anyway

#

God i hate tom

zinc python
#

Ahh guess I got bad info from someone then, claiming that arms had snapshot

#

Was saving my roar till all my buffs were up but that definitely simplifies things a bit

strange perch
#

Pretty sure it grants rage so try not to overcap with it

zinc python
#

A sliver or rage but some at least haha

zinc python
#

Myself? No, just a friend that probably didn't know better

rare kite
#

No i meant the friend, if he's a classic player

merry stone
#

You just need to understand how Thunderous Roar works as well

teal fossil
#

capping rage doesnt matter either

dull siren
sacred zodiac
#

:3

quasi torrent
#

meow

astral yarrow
#

It’s just real cringe

gaunt owl
#

ultra cringe

#

cursed with knowledge

quasi torrent
#

perish immediately

gaunt owl
#

end me

misty iron
rare kite
gaunt owl
#

badly bad

latent moss
#

its evil

#

very evil

wary raft
#

my timbers have shivered

rare kite
gaunt owl
#

its not worth it dont worry

rare kite
#

i assumed not, just very curious

gaunt owl
#

the idea was to use Puzzlebox to apply a big ass DW debuff

#

and once PB is over

#

you dont refresh DW

rare kite
gaunt owl
#

but our mastery is too shitty anyway

random ibex
#

question: whats the thought process behind using lariat? all my sims have allied wrists and SFP as better

untold trench
#

Lariat is sometimes better on mass AoE Sims, seldom on ST. It also is a proc, so feast or famine. So procs right on example smold, and it is big value, if not - it is lower value. Procs on Tind shield is good value, so on and on.

It procs quite reliably, but no guarantee. In m+ it is just a nice AoE DPS bump.

random ibex
#

ahh ok, so essentially; run SFP on pure ST and Lariat on anything with AOE

astral yarrow
spark mango
#

Gonna miss the tierset we have right now

#

both arms and fury, i mean i get how fury players dont like where they are on meters due to priority focus

#

but arms tier right now is so fine with single blade storm build, you always have damage in every situation

gaunt owl
#

nah you shouldnt miss it

#

awful tier set with 2 different trigger for SD proc

#

not helping us with our full rage bar

#

and even making Execute spam

spark mango
#

From M+ pov the fact that u doing same aoe with exuce talents as full aoe build is very nice

rare kite
gaunt owl
#

and you gonna do far more better next tier

hazy flower
#

I grew fond so much

#

of free thunder claps

spark mango
#

i hate cleave

hazy flower
#

probably not double

#

just single

spark mango
#

its the problem child of my rotiation

rare kite
#

single target always matters in keys

hazy flower
#

ye

#

also arent u dropping ep for mbg

#

so no eb no massacre and u do beans dam xd

#

on st

spark mango
#

if u going 1 bladestorm no MBG

#

i think fury is superior

rare kite
#

i guess you can drop 1 bb point for mbg? idk if that's worth tho

hazy flower
#

lemme check

rare kite
#

you can

gaunt owl
#

people that pick double bladestorm

#

i'm gonna come knocking on their door

#

and kick them in the balls

hazy flower
#

double bladestorm is overkill

#

unless u have

#

specific comp

#

(enha)

#

in specific dungeon

rare kite
#

you can come knock on my door when i play it on algethar academy to see how big overall i will get ppaw, the biggest pad build

hazy flower
#

ask warlocks

#

about their overall in academy

#

I saw one do 8m burst on lashers with aug

spark mango
#

right now you play arms with 1 bladestorm because fury does no aoe whatsoever

#

next season if u play current build fury is ahead

rare kite
#

that's just not true

hazy flower
#

ye that's not the reason at all xd

#

there are more fury warriors in top keys

#

than arms warriors

#

fury brings better st, prio

gaunt owl
#

and going double bladestorm just kill your prio and ST dmg

hazy flower
#

and mass aoe is really not that needed

#

since most dungeons dont have large pulls

#

outside of maybe 1 pull per dungeon

spark mango
#

the reason there are more fury vs arms in keys comes down to pug experience

#

rather than damge

hazy flower
#

eh

#

not sure what it even meeans

#

but ok

spark mango
#

fury simply doesnt die and has shockwave

rare kite
#

no, it comes down to fury being more popular in general

#

fury has always been more popular

hazy flower
#

u can play shockwave as arms

#

nobody is forcing u

gaunt owl
#

its popularity

hazy flower
#

you lose like 2-3% overall max

rare kite
#

and if the specs are even remotely close to eachother more people will play fury. fury is very popular

spark mango
#

i play both and most of the time arms simply dies with random healers

hazy flower
#

where do u die

#

what bosses

#

what key level

#

unless the healer is so trash whole group dies I dont struggle surviving in keys

gaunt owl
#

dont expect your random healer to be decent

spark mango
spark mango
#

but for example area around second boss of fall or many instances in waycrest manor

#

you fold as arms or you need to be peram DS

hazy flower
#

you really dont

spark mango
#

if i get cheeky reflect on Sands i dont if i dont get the reflect you pretty much dead, you tick down

#

and you need to go a lot of versa in contrast to your dps sim

#

1 month ago i was playing rageheart in 28s

hazy flower
#

the lots of versa is barely 1% loss

#

and I dont die in keys on high forti

#

unless whole group dies

#

because the healer is that bad

gaunt owl
rare kite
#

i bet even if arms was tankier than fury, you would still see more fury players in keys. just because it's more popular, always has been and prob always will be

hazy flower
#

fury is tankier sure but arms shouldn't struggle in 28's

gaunt owl
#

Critcake said it best too

#

you have to think as Arms

#

and stack your IP

#

most player cant use their brain to save their lives

spark mango
#

pressint it on cd?

boreal quartz
#

ye

spark mango
#

1 is always enough for most mechanics

hazy flower
#

depends on your comp

#

in 30 ad I did yday I needed to double stack my ip on yazma every time since we only had devotion aura as dr/hp increase

spark mango
#

with dstance?

hazy flower
#

yes

#

but check noteven every time

#

IP should be implemented anytime soon

#

if you have disc priest and ret you should be fine with single stacking on 30 tyra yazma

#

20-25k hp left is enough since your group shouldn't be blasting the adds insta

#

so save iv for every single one to use insta

spark mango
#

i like this better than keeping warpaint then leaping out

hazy flower
#

it gets a bit cringe

#

once you have to double stack ip

violet steeple
#

Can someone DM me the arms M+ PTR build so I can become an arms cranker in prep

chrome lichen
#

the camera is auto focus and i am not able to look around unless i am clicking the mouse, this is very annoying

how to disable this ?

dire hinge
chrome lichen
merry pecan
#

it is worth using baldestorm and TR before Avatar cds? since In For The Kill makes me have BS and TR like 30 secs before it

#

and then holding avatar for the new BS and TR cds

frail pagoda
#

sim tier set

gaunt ginkgo
finite ginkgo
#

guys coming from fury, can anyone tell me why arms scales so insane with haste?

gaunt owl
#

because AM exists

rare kite
#

and ToM

#

remove ToM

wicked aurora
cinder remnant
#

Do we go for more crit with s1 tierset?

prisma heart
#

We will easily hit crit and haste soft caps with S4 gear so expect to push vers and mastery more

cinder remnant
#

Great, thanks

prisma heart
#

Yes

teal fossil
#

Hopefully we can reach 40/40/40/40

buoyant pulsar
#

Hello warriors, I used to play Arms Warrior a LOT in Cata, it was my main back then and I haven’t really played Warrior since Legion.

I geared my Paladin because I heard the ret rework was great but I find the spec boring as heck so i was thinking to pick up Arms again. How close to the Cata playstyle are we now ? I loved how methodical it was back then. Thank you

gaunt owl
#

we are so far from Cata gameplay

buoyant pulsar
buoyant pulsar
#

I like slower/methodical specs and Ret is not cutting it, I don't get any satisfaction from building holy power. My other alternatives are Arms, WW monk or maybe Assassination or possibly Arcane mage, these are the specs I consider methodical but ideally it would be something close to Arms was in Cata 😄

teal fossil
#

Assassin is relatively slow

latent moss
#

arms is quite farm from methodical atm

#

far*

proud plover
#

Cosmetic rage bar for the most part removed alot of it, lots of haste made the rotation alot quicker but it is still fun - minimal rng focused with a fairly simple rotation and alot of bleed damage

shadow ibex
#

Doesn't get fun until execute

#

Then you get to think some pay attention to overlaps

proud plover
#

^^ most fun spec in the game in execute

shadow ibex
#

I wish pressing avatar and CS above 35% felt like Im hitting hard

opal folio
#

@shadow ibex how’s fyrakk going?

shadow ibex
#

not good

latent moss
#

range wasnt

#

from 100-500

#

and was 200-400 so cds felt impactful but it also did some damage baseline

#

and ngl

#

ava and cs feel hard in exe cause of the reck

#

allowing me to mash execute like a monkey

#

condemn animation makes it feel a lot more impactful as well

#

every single exe feels like u are destroying the target

shadow ibex
#

using SS to hasten the execute animation

#

TECH UNLEASH

latent moss
#

that animation is so good

shadow ibex
#

so u get the side swipe instead of slow ass overhead shit moves out of

#

yea its cool but that moving out of range shit is unforgivable

latent moss
#

there was a lot of spotlight on that

#

on 10.2 ptr when critcake was talking about it

#

but they did nothing

shadow ibex
#

just unware

#

you have to play warrior to know

latent moss
#

maybe they will do something about it with the rework

shadow ibex
#

its very subtle and seems like minor complaint

#

but in practice its cringe as fuck

latent moss
#

idk i have hope for warrior rework

#

slayer tree that move speed after charge

#

gave me hope

#

cause thats a VERY annoying warrior thing

#

like i cant think of anything more annoying than that

#

as a warrior

shadow ibex
#

the movement after charge thing is nice yea

#

to catch speedy bosses

latent moss
#

that should be baseline

#

or a talent that we take

#

always

shadow ibex
#

give me bounding stride in heroic leap

#

i want it free

latent moss
#

same

#

leap is criminal without it

opal folio
#

I’m exhausted after every raid night now

shadow ibex
#

we've carried people thru the tier because they been here forever and now on a boss u cant do that on

#

no tindral health nerf to carry us to the kill this time

opal folio
#

Too real

#

We’ve been progging p2 for a couple of nights, hopefully done in like 3 weeks

#

But yeah, the last two bosses expose the weak links real bad

shadow ibex
#

yeeeeeeeeeep

latent moss
#

how do you get gear on ptr

#

vendors are selling it for the dinars and i have none

#

first time playing ptr idk

robust ridge
#

You can just pick up gear from the vendors in Stormwind / Orgrimmar

hazy flower
#

I really like uproar but it you want shockwave you drop that

dry frost
#

I’m kinda an arms newbie, is it likely we run cleave in aoe with S1 tier?

teal fossil
#

Probably

#

We ran cleave in s1 but everything else got buffed more

#

So we’ll see

dry frost
#

I really liked the little bit I used it for the little bit I played arms S2

#

I really liked the SkS build

shadow ibex
#

would be surprised if it made a come back in raid without major changes

#

pretty expensive to pick up in talents

smoky kayak
dry frost
#

If not my main arms is likely gonna be my most played alt

#

I really don’t like this variant of fury so most of my War playtime has been prot/arms

#

I need to get all my portals on my war before season end too

buoyant pulsar
#

I thought Arms voted for the T31 to come back (S3 set)

#

Did I read that wrong ?

minor gust
#

no the real Arms gamers voted season 1

teal fossil
#

its like voting for an aura buff

prisma heart
#

S3 set deadge

#

Have good rotation and get targeted by 0 mechanics but get bad rng on SD procs deadge deadge

bleak jasper
#

if we're not running reaping, would we still run uh

#

improved sweeping?

boreal quartz
#

SoA

wind vault
#

How to manage CDS with S1 build? Do You want to hold roar/warbraker/bladestorm to line up with Avatar or press on CD?

boreal quartz
#

CDs on cd with AM

#

Roar ideal with a wb/ava(if no 1 min roar)

hazy flower
#

if youre not playing uproar you should have everything aside from bladestorm synced

#

if you are then use the uproar

#

and press it on cd

#

overthinking when to pop stuff too much is detrimental

#

you're playing cdr, use cdr

boreal quartz
#

CD on CD xan

hazy flower
#

as it should be

hazy flower
#
  1. bloodmallet is using ideal gear
#

which 99,9% of players will never see

#

even if they're running highest content (best vaults since day 1 and multiple 3 slot mythic reclears)

#
  1. augury is rng trinket
#

if it highrolls its best

#

generally

#

like I mentioned augury is rng

#

so top logs are gonna be running it

#

because if it highrolls then it's gonna pop off insanely

#

I would still run augury over rezan if it sims similar ish

gaunt owl
hazy flower
#

wdym

#

arent they using highest simming gear in their profile

gaunt owl
#

no

#

they yoink the simc profile that's all

#

and nope

buoyant pulsar
#

I understand that S1 tier is maybe more consistent but it’s a damn shame we lose the SD procs on bleed ticks imho, I thought that was a fun mechanic. Not the best but it was something.

gaunt owl
#

chasing the highest sim is a fool errand

uncut shard
#

Also idk what you're on about gear

#

Or rather augury being rng

#

Kindoff a worthless statement

quasi torrent
#

that goes for every single trinket that isnt a stat stick really

#

even that is inherently rng

#

say you got a trinket that procs mastery (crab) and you get unlucky (you dont crit) you will get less value

uncut shard
#

Crit stat stick xan

quasi torrent
#

even that is rng
you may not crit anyway!!

#

holy fuggggg

gaunt owl
#

just to mess with people and bis gear thinking

#

i got this laying around

reef glade
#

please god

#

alter your mog

quasi torrent
#

no u

hazy flower
#

disparity between 4% and 10% augury kills definitely doesnt prove its rng as hell

#

oke

dull siren
dull siren
#

he was naked b4

reef glade
#

that would be more preferrable

#

than whatever that is

gaunt owl
#

fucking full tmog enjoyer

#

dare judge

halcyon breach
#

At least you know full mog will look good and match

dull siren
#

ththththth...

gaunt owl
#

my mog match

#

you are jumping to conclusion !

quasi torrent
#

just put on egirl mog

#

?

warm bronze
#

What are the best trinkets currently for the PTR? Can't find any info anywhere.

gaunt owl
warm bronze
#

I understand S1 tier set

quasi torrent
warm bronze
#

for arms

hazy flower
#

puzzle box, augury, pips

quasi torrent
#

icon

hazy flower
#

icon ye

#

oce

warm bronze
#

hmm

hazy flower
#

all are

#

good trinkets

#

oce prob not with icon being around but just use it if you want

quasi torrent
#

icon with all buffs is built diffy

warm bronze
#

Good ol puzzle box

#

I'd play fury, but damn do I hate the S2 tier set

hazy flower
#

beacon might be the play too

#

rather doubt in anything other than bh but idk yet

wind vault
#

I guess I'll go with icon and augury cause I like these

halcyon breach
tardy crag
#

Beacon ur friends

quasi torrent
halcyon breach
#

meow

quasi torrent
#

regular neow

halcyon breach
#

nya

quasi torrent
#

man im am tired

#

im am

halcyon breach
#

i am am

quasi torrent
#

as u can see

#

im am tireededed

halcyon breach
#

go sleep noob?

quasi torrent
#

Cant

#

stupid family thing soon

halcyon breach
#

ff

uncut shard
#

no way

boreal quartz
#

famous hunter spell: feign schwächeanfall

hazy flower
#

kindoff a worthless statement

quasi torrent
boreal quartz
fast forge
#

i know certain fights can effect stats but as an overall providing you are not swapping alot inbetween boss fights why may a gearset that sims 5k lower be better

dull siren
#

You don't really swap anything but 1 talent this raid as Arms, Unless you wanna pad on Tindral

#

Council Long sweep that's it

#

xdd

fast forge
#

ye

#

but like

#

oh wait it was warrior sim before you

#

talking about how 'bis gear thinking' is bad

dull siren
#

I mean, BiS gear thinking should be the priority.
That is right, But I've reached a state long ago where I can't get a single upgrade so I just keep milking

fast forge
#

in all fairness every list and sim i have ever seen runs like shadowflame emb on cloak, however you got silk line necking

dull siren
#

Shadowflame

#

is worse than Lariat

#

Lariat is worse than BSL

hazy flower
dull siren
#

yes

hazy flower
#

whats the %

dull siren
#

52%

#

and I sim with 45% rn

hazy flower
#

yeah for me 45% bsl outsims lariat

dull siren
#

Smolderon Fury Warrior 60%

fast forge
#

fairs, it shows no where in any gear recommendation ive seen all xpac tho

#

so confused me a lil

dull siren
#

Well, In all fairness

#

the suggestions for warriors were dog shit.
Just gonna say it...
As well as the raid trinket coil or w/e

#

👎

#

Very low effort in research just a quick gear dump and went into a post

fast forge
#

im swapping to arms in next reset or 2

#

so just seeing differences in gear

#

figured i really needed that nymue neck as it shows up everywhere has super high crit

#

but top logs seem to run it lol

#

no top logs*

dull siren
#

Don't need crit since you run Crit Phial + Buzzing Rune, To reach 40-42% crit
with 42% haste baseline and then you just want to even out vers + mastery

fast forge
#

ahh i see

#

and as far as your rings

#

i imagine its larodar one unless you get that one you have in vault

dull siren
#

Yeah, I mean.
You'd go for the larodar one unless u get the vault one and you'd just have to change some of the enchants to vers I'd imagine

hazy flower
#

my gm would murder me if I were to use it on prog

fast forge
#

but you got haste mast i guess as a result of the dungeon ring

dull siren
#

I gave you a DM with some APL stuff @fast forge

#

that might help you out

visual fern
dull siren
visual fern
#

Gm

dull siren
#

want a kiss?

visual fern
#

🌊

wind vault
#

I guess with S4 we would want around 50%+ haste, and 50% crit ?

dawn sphinx
#

Or, hear me out, instead of hard focusing on specific stat values, we do this ancient technique called sim

wind vault
#

Spimming is styupid 😅 but You might be right

hexed canopy
#

To get the legendary, does it matter if u do LFR and normal before doing heroic to get the extra increased rep tokens, or can i only do heroic and get the same chance?

dawn sphinx
#

so doing lfr->normal->hc->mythic is the same as just doing mythic

hexed canopy
#

Okay thanks, will stop doing LFR and normal, and only do HC. Mythic is out of reach and not an option for me

dull siren
#

Just abuse like the World First kill chatting

#

The guys who always show up with Torghast powers

steep osprey
#

Some specs look a lot better in s4 because of some trinkets

boreal quartz
#

clueless

finite mantle
#

blueless

quasi torrent
#

fluless

#

(healthy)

rare kite
#

wonder how long i was "typing" in chat, just noticed i typed a "w" here

quasi torrent
#

It times out after a few seconds

finite mantle
#

we were waiting for days

gaunt owl
#

i was dying of old age

fresh spire
sage badge
#

Arms owns

gaunt owl
#

Arms owns

latent moss
#

Owns arms

velvet vessel
zinc wolf
velvet vessel
#

archi didnt paid the hosting 😄

crimson charm
#

That was Collision who did that

warped spade
zinc wolf
#

I mean the original link

#

It also had music

crimson charm
#

Yea, it doesn't autoload the music. :(

zinc wolf
#

World we have known is no longer there

finite ginkgo
#

guyys sandglas > augury in keys for arms?

olive nest
#

Doubtful

smoky kayak
# hazy flower yeah for me 45% bsl outsims lariat

BSL will always outsim everything, but it's not always practical which is why it's not universally recommended - it's pretty hard to maximize on later fights not because it doesn't get decent enough uptime, but because it's always down when you're using cooldowns

smoky kayak
zinc wolf
#

Can i bash you if i buy you burrito afterwards ?

dull siren
#

Wish I saw these trinkets in Season 2.

smoky kayak
#

Coil is, objectively, one of the better raid trinkets this expansion

#

that doesn't mean it's a particularly great trinket compared to better options, but it is one of the higher ones on the overall list

#

if you didn't have access to stuff like augury, brand, couldn't get a good rezen to drop, there's no reason you couldn't use it (as several people have)

dull siren
#

It's 2k behind, Branch is ever better than it and Branch isn't suggested

smoky kayak
#

neither is sandglass or butcher's block or anything else; there's a whole trinket listing right underneath that gives hard numbers for people who want them

#

Coil is listed with a line of text that describes why its listed - it's perfectly understandable that it's a passive trinket which won't require players to do anything (which is a more sought after prospect than one might think)

dull siren
#

It doesn't have any situational usage, It doesn't fit in anywhere to the current state of Arms.
It's just a bad thing to have under "Best Trinkets."
Branch has situational usage and isn't there?
Idk it's just a very badly suggested 👎
Just being honest, It isn't even bashing. It's just honesty.
If I'm not allowed to have my own opinion on how I see your post, Like I've not been allowed to have before. I understand.

smoky kayak
#

You're right, it doesn't have any situational usage - it's recommended as a completely passive, easy to get trinket, which has very little competition and is still among the top 10 best trinkets available this patch

#

and don't be dramatic, nobody can stop you from having an opinion, but there's a difference in having an opinion and being overly critical or using it as a pretense to bash others, as you frequently do

#

it's fine not to agree with something, but a reasonable person should still be able to see the logic behind it

dull siren
#

I don't frequently bash people, You are the public face of Skyhold and warrior on wowhead.
You are going to get feedback, If you don't like the feedback nor like the way i communicate it feel free to ignore my message.

modest moss
#

Top ten trinkets when there are ten isn't saying much. Unless we're talking like Wquest trinkets as well.

smoky kayak
#

you didn't give me feedback lol, I approached you

dull siren
#

I said, It's bad cause it's bad?
You decided to approach the subject of the topic.
I'm allowed to write my own opinion no?
As well as there's been feedback for this b4 👍
But eitherway time to slayyy Fyraka 🎃

smoky kayak
dull siren
smoky kayak
#

(ignoring the part where you moved the goal post from "it's bis" to "well its mentioned on the page somewhere")

quasi torrent
modest moss
#

I went and counted just to be an ass. There are 13 str trinkets in the current rotation. (But you are right with what you say).

#

CORRECTION 14

hard cobalt
smoky kayak
#

no it's not

quasi torrent
hard cobalt
quasi torrent
#

💀💀

smoky kayak
#

oh that page

#

yeah I talked to someone about it the other day (more like a few weeks ago, but w/e)

hard cobalt
#

That’s the one I look at first/most frequent when I just want a quick non sim answer

smoky kayak
#

that's not my page 😆

modest moss
smoky kayak
#

the cheat sheet things were put together externally and I fuckin hate them

#

WH uses a lot of automation embeds, obstensibly so that writers don't have to keep updating the same thing across multiple pages

#

which those abominable cheat sheet tools also use

#

and something causes them to keep auto-updating with really old versions

quasi torrent
smoky kayak
#

like you notice the Fury one doesn't even have Fyr'alath on it anymore, when it was added the week after RWF

hard cobalt
#

unfortunate

smoky kayak
#

the tool is such trash, I hate it

hard cobalt
#

I reference that page a lot esp with newish friends

smoky kayak
#

considering you've never brought it up before, somehow I doubt that, but I'll get it fixed

#

until it decides to break again anyway

hard cobalt
#

My friends that play are not all in discord but, yes I don’t post about it much

#

If it’s bound to be broken tho, I def don’t need to think of it as a good resource

smoky kayak
modest moss
smoky kayak
#

but also I mean consider both when wh guides are written and who they are written for

#

can take that as a cop out if you want, but they are, by design, written for a pretty low level approach to the game - sure there are tools and information to point higher level players toward (BM embeds, raidbots), but the vast majority of people either have absolutely no experience with a spec and need extreme hand holding, or they just want very quick info at a glance

#

in both cases, neither tend to play at a particularly high level, or be the kind of "power user" that frequents discords

teal fossil
#

thats why stat prio page exists right? it's just as a very LOW level guide for players

smoky kayak
#

that's why half the pages exist

#

BiS means nothing in modern wow

#

Stats too

#

you could argue that maybe stats give people an idea of what to look for (and if you've actually looked at the page over the last several years, you may notice I've put more emphasis on "here's why these stats are good and when they fall off" rather than going for hard numbers like "get XYZ amount"

#

If it were up to me, I'd straight up delete 3/4 of the pages in the guide; pair it down to maybe 4 pages of no shit straightforward information

#

which is both A) easier to keep updated and B) easier for people to parse and quickly find the info they need

gaunt owl
#

people love easy access to info

smoky kayak
#

but unfortunately, we live in a world of google analytics and even relatively good websites like Wowhead have to care about SEO to stay competitive 🤷‍♂️ (it's also not up to me in any way)

modest moss
#

We're all simple minded zugzuggers the shorter guide the better.

gaunt owl
#

if i dont find something in 3 clicks

#

i give up

smoky kayak
#

Yeah, I know; I feel the same way most of the time

#

I have argued endlessly against SEO baity policies and projects

fresh spire
#

inb4 another whole page just for hero talents

smoky kayak
#

probably 2 tbh, at least

modest moss
#

Good lord

smoky kayak
#

one for like "best hero talents" another for breaking down general hero talents... maybe 1 for each hero spec? idk

visual fern
#

Seo =

#

🤔

smoky kayak
#

I mean why in the fucking world is "Cheat Sheet" a standalone page at the same time that "Season 3" (which is mostly comprised of the cheat sheet") a page?

modest moss
#

Make your own blog on the side that you link in the discord or have you signed a non-compete contract?

boreal quartz
#

Cheat sheet is a good page

smoky kayak
#

And to be clear - this is not a Wowhead problem, IV does the same thing, Noxxic, Method, whoever else is making guides all do the same thing

prisma heart
#

Yo weird place to ask but anyone know if the new easter event boss mount has reduced drop chance after first kill

smoky kayak
#

because if you don't have SEO, you don't have visibility, and if you don't have visibilty, nobody is reading your guide anyway

prisma heart
#

Like on alts

smoky kayak
boreal quartz
#

Is this sim adjusted item stuff or just formatting being cringe

smoky kayak
#

I mean some things were sim/knowledge adjusted, but mostly formatting and something causes the cheat sheet to be replaced with an old version

steep osprey
#

Minor edits

smoky kayak
prisma heart
#

Thank u 🥹

smoky kayak
# steep osprey Minor edits

that's just the placeholder when I can't be assed to put in an actual edit description - regular users can't see this page anyway

#

the actual "cheat sheet" page users see is just an empty page with an embed in it, so its update history is like... 2 lines

steep osprey
#

I read about SEO a few months ago

smoky kayak
steep osprey
#

Interesting stuff...

gaunt owl
smoky kayak
#

modernizing this discord is something I've wanted to do for years, but certain people were against many changes - reason we don't have auto-respond bots and stuff are because Marok didn't want them, not because of me

gaunt owl
#

can do some really cool stuff that are far better to handle

fresh spire
smoky kayak
#

Yeah, I wasn't really going to talk about it in public channels until there's something ready to show people, but I did recently get permission from Vel to overhaul Skyhold's format, and it's a side project I've been working on for a while

fresh spire
#

threads are fun as you can unsub from channels and clear clutter so its super condenced

gaunt owl
#

@hexed saddle i blame you

hexed saddle
#

not my fault

gaunt owl
#

i need a scapegoat

smoky kayak
hexed saddle
#

only SF that does SF things

rare kite
hexed saddle
#

deswind and arma do things too peepoBlush

smoky kayak
#

and I've looked at all of them to get ideas from

fresh spire
#

I've not even seen the forum cards on discord

rare kite
#

ye, just the one that stood out to me

steep osprey
#

They're so good tbh

smoky kayak
#

but I didn't have permission, nor capability to simply make unilateral changes to the format of this discord

steep osprey
#

It's a boomer server

smoky kayak
#

there's a lot of shit in here yall blame me for that I actually have nothing to do with 😆

rare kite
#

druid discord confuses the shit out of me

fresh spire
fresh spire
#

That's just druid in general

rare kite
#

real

smoky kayak
fresh spire
#

They speak on riddles

gaunt owl
#

i'm stupid

daring heron
#

same

pure otter
#

warrior class ened simple instructions

quasi torrent
modest moss
smoky kayak
#

also blame @hexed saddle for not updating the FAQ 🙃

steep osprey
pure otter
#

non tier havers lmao

steep osprey
#

Xan catching strays

modest moss
#

Non-tier havers sounds like a slur for non-raiders.

hexed saddle
#

NOT MY FAULY

gaunt owl
#

Xan exposed

hexed saddle
#

ONLY SF THAT DOES THINGS

smoky kayak
#

Deswind and Arma do things

hexed saddle
#

(arma and deswind are safe)

astral yarrow
#

📸

daring heron
#

i only yap

astral yarrow
#

Yapcake

smoky kayak
#

Which reminds me, we should probably clean out the SF before next expansion

pure otter
#

Be me, wake up, stub toe, fall to knees screaming at the sky at how this is archis fault

pure otter
#

man is it bad that i like that yapping has returned to our vocabulary, swear we used to use it a lot more be4 it faded outa existance

fresh spire
#

deswind owns

fresh spire
pure otter
#

skyhold besthold

fresh spire
#

i find it odd how the term YAP has just exploded out of no where

#

we stay it all the time in raid like telling people to stop yapping in pulls

#

fukin weird

fresh spire
#

:no::yappin:

pure otter
#

yaptastic

fresh spire
#

it sounds more pleasent that going "shut up"

gaunt owl
#

these youngsters

#

i can hardly keep up

fresh spire
#

paaw u yap the most

smoky kayak
hard cobalt
fresh spire
#

lets not talk about turtle

#

hes the kind of yap

modest moss
#

Buncha freeloaders

hexed saddle
smoky kayak
#

so you're telling me

#

you updated the FAQ last month

#

and it still looks like this?

#

smh

hexed saddle
#

😭

fresh spire
#

:kekw

smoky kayak
#

way to make it worse for yourself

hexed saddle
#

i didnt want to redo the entire format myself!! i even asked other SF for help!!

#

and what did i get!

modest moss
#

Shoulda been silent.

smoky kayak
#

I didn't see you ask that

steep osprey
#

can i update faq

hexed saddle
#

it was a while back

#

i think closer to aberrus than amirdrassil

smoky kayak
#

so more than a month ago

#

🤔

hexed saddle
#

yes much more

fresh spire
#

Xan is banned from yapping

hexed saddle
#

why!

fresh spire
#

last time he yapped he got warrior nerfed in sofo

smoky kayak
hexed saddle
#

I DIDNT EVEN PLAY THAT XPAC

fresh spire
#

neverforget

smoky kayak
#

how easy something is to maintain goes hand in hand with the quality of updates

hexed saddle
#

yeah current faq sucks to update i cant lie

gaunt owl
#

long ass wall of text

smoky kayak
#

the state of the FAQ isn't @hexed saddle's fault

gaunt owl
#

probably too hard to navigate properly

smoky kayak
#

it's the fault of the tool used to update it

#

and that tool was nice several years ago when Marok created it

#

but there are far better tools now, and this discord simply hasn't modernized with the times - yay for beauracracy!

steep osprey
#

Did you guys see the rogue FAQ? it's glorious

smoky kayak
#

But yeah, I recognize that it has been flagging and have been working to get it modernized (more in prep for next expansion more so than S4)

#

it's just not as easy as updating a discord run by one person and only used by 20 people

hard cobalt
#

I’m so curious how existing better models exist, worker bees who want to use those models ask for and show them, and bureaucrats still keep things dinosaur age levels of bad

steep osprey
#

change skyhold icon to show a notification icon

#

for april 1st

smoky kayak
#

We used to, but that's not something I control

hard cobalt
#

especially since this is NOT a business

smoky kayak
#

but like I said, I did talk to Vel about these things, discussed some of the things I want to do to modernize, and already have some plans drawn up

#

I was going to first share them with the mods and other SF for input before branching out into the public channels for public feedback, but doesn't really matter - I'm happy for yall to know that it is something I'm concerned with and actively trying to improve

hard cobalt
#

that’s good to hear

hexed saddle
#

🥳

gaunt owl
#

so can we go back to blaming Xan for the half assed job now ?

smoky kayak
#

Sure, I think we can all agree that @hexed saddle is the real problem with Skyhold

hexed saddle
halcyon breach
#

@hexed saddle

smoky kayak
#

I'm just saying, this was considered one of the best class discords until he became yellow...

hexed saddle
#

why am i bullied by everyone i know

#

get @ocean pond in here hes great at bullying me

hard cobalt
#

on twitter

dull siren
#

@quasi torrent

#

i took my 4th lego

smoky kayak
hard cobalt
steep osprey
dull siren
steep osprey
#

chill

fresh spire
#

offhand ez

gaunt owl
#

you loved the quest so much

#

you wanna do it again ?

dull siren
#

hold quest until fated

gaunt owl
#

smh roleplayer enjoying questing

fresh spire
#

what does it even say if you try to put it in offhand

steep osprey
#

imagine you can

#

it's unique eq

fresh spire
#

one is one isnt

dull siren
gaunt owl
#

unique but not the same weapon

fresh spire
dull siren
#

as when you put on ur first one

#

ye but it just

#

sucks you off

fresh spire
#

break game

dull siren
#

and gives u a quest

fresh spire
#

use two

#

:ez:

#

Do the quest up to last stage

#

Hand it inside of s4

#

Skip upgrade item

quasi torrent
#

surely that's how it works

smoky kayak
#

there's been no confirmation that the legendary will even be obtained at a higher base item level in S4; as far as I recall, the Sylvanas bow wasn't

#

but at this point, there's not much reason not to wait and hope for the best anyway

untold trench
#

I would not wait, as you could risk blizz doing an oopsie and suddenly BLP has been reset

gaunt owl
#

can hold on the quest item

untold trench
#

Quest item got a starting ilvl tho

random gazelle
quasi torrent
#

thats a direct drop though

#

and not a quest :3

smoky kayak
#

but I don't have any personal experience, so 🤷‍♂️

#

doesn't really matter for most of us, since you can't loot Fyr'alath a second time anyway

fringe moon
#

imagine looting the quest item and being on the quest only to have it revoked by Blizz at the start of S4..

smoky kayak
#

gotta loot a new one 🙃

fringe moon
smoky kayak
#

the legendary is actually bugged on PTR atm, even if you use the dinar item, it doesn't have the awakened tag, so you can't upgrade it beyond 503

quasi torrent
#

new cap is just 503 suck it up

smoky kayak
#

I finally got a few free minutes, and the cheat sheet stuff has been updated (again) @hard cobalt
I actually made entirely new sheets this time and binned the old ones, maybe that will help prevent any weirdness in the future - feel free to lmk if you notice anything odd in the future

hard cobalt
smoky kayak
#

it's not extra work, I don't mind updating or fixing things as they're noticed
I only mind if people notice something wrong and don't mention it

hard cobalt
#

I would’ve thought TG with Gorehowl would be better or smth

smoky kayak
#

For Fury you mean? Gholak actually has some cursed tech if you have it at a comparable item level, but not anything I'd recommend people fuck around with - it was originally there because SMF crowd but I guess with the legendary being so available now, you could make an arugment that it's kind pointless now

nocturne moth
#

Looking at the wowhead guide, what would you recommend dropping on the bladestorm m+ build for IP?

smoky kayak
#

although you actually can pair gholek and the legendary if you wanna do some real dummy shit

gaunt owl
#

forbidden jutsu

smoky kayak
#

I'll take it out though, if for no other reason than because SMF is the devil

hazy flower
#

there is not

#

there was something about 0/2/4 pc at the start of the season but it was for all classes

#
  • rre buff
smoky kayak
gaunt owl
#

both ability should be baseline for Arms

#

change my mind

smoky kayak
gaunt owl
#

do they even use it in pvp ?

fresh spire
#

I'd love a world where we had ip and fueled

smoky kayak
#

lol no, it's mostly IP

fresh spire
#

Ip has some super good uses