#protection
1 messages · Page 3555 of 1
ineffable ravager
@ionic fern run another later and let me come on my 242 ele. i want to seea rearl warrior tank vs my alt
Speaking of necrotic, how big a damage loss is kleia vs 57 mikanikos?
In keys
Probably not worth going kleia for the 8s invuln anymore, huh
ive never used kelia in necro weeks anyway
I did just because it felt so minor vs pelagos
can I proc this on myself with anything?
I've seen it proc while just dpsing maybe it was my trinket procing it
I wonder if IP procs it
I've seen a clip of it proccing from you mounting up. IDK if that's still a thing but its dumb.
weapon 📈
weppy
Do you do mythic sod?
the wep is better stated than the mythic one
But you get it off the 2nd boss.
I don’t raid
Then prbky take the wpn
Oof my vault was pretty bad this week
Snagged a weapon, as it gives the biggest ilvl gain over my other choices
yo guys im getting back into my prot war and im doing fine on most keys around +15 but how tf do i tank hoa? its like everything just slaps me regardless of shieldblock/ip
Kick and stun the casts, side step Deadly Thrust. 😄
i am used to tank on my druid and the dogs just dont slap as hard even on higher keys is it non blockable damage?
If you're talking about Gargon bleeds, it's not blockable, no
Kyrian pot can clear it which is nice.
is it true warriors can solo tank the boss ability on guardian?
the physical one yes. You can comfortably solotank normal but due to the buffs to the magic hit its impossible to solotank past that.
Thunderclap procs the unholy aura
Because it slows, it counts as a "helpful" spell
252 warbark greathelm or 252 inscrutible quantum device
Iqd pretty bad helm gets replaced by dom socket but guess can be worth until then
I feel like I see that hat all the time
I'd almost say IQD just because you don't see it a lot in vault
I already have a 236 trinket i could upgrade if i cared
coin flip here prob
I don't really raid though, so helm might be the play
If dont raid helm is easy choice
What's the new affix set?
storming sanguine
thx
so is mikanikos the way now since we r 57?
I cant bring myself to take the auto phial with mikanikos tho :\
Imagine not playing night fae

What's important when I'm analyzing my logs as a prot warrior? So far I looked at block% I had on melee hits and damage. What else is a key factor?
Is losing the potency conduit by not taking auto phial a big hit?
Yes, Mikan owns
No, the only potency you care about is spear
haha my lowest one
Casts(should be around 60-67+cpm in raid, 55-60+cpm in m+), resources -> rage (to assure you haven't wasted rage aka overcapped)
...... When your vault is SO BAD, your viable choices are a 252 crit/versa ring, or 252 slimy consumptive organ trinket.
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/character/id/58936565 those are my logs right now. I got declined by a raid today because of my terrible logs and I'm wondering why
like..we had 3 mythic kills so; I got 252 weapon..too bad I got one first week that was better. So it was only a xmog choice =\
Like..Sylvanas shoulders from norm/heroic PLEASE?!?!
people were being boolies for no reason
How about IP uptime? Usually I have lone 10-15% and I guess I need way more?
Your logs arent terrible at all lmao
They just didn't want you
@weary cipher did you have a look at my logs?
And used a dumb fucking excuse
He was very offensive so I'm wondering why
On the nine you have 87%blocked hits, wasted close to 0 resources, did good dmg and your cpm was aight
He was just being a cunt, nothing else
He said my spell reflect usage sucked and I don't use IP as it is my main "heal"
Yeah okay
And this also sucks lol
He's dumb
Looking at healing is just dumb
Now while it is true that you don't use SR at all
i mean u only spam IP if u need it to stay alive
so if u have decent healers u wouldnt even use it
It's not smth I'd bully you for
the dude was bein a douche
I'm using SR for some things like the axe on painsmith, but not enough I guess
guys Signet of the false accuser or death's god signet?
signet is a bit higher ilvl and with socket
Death's God is BiS afaik
If you use SR on CD you're already using it 90% correctly, it's off gcd and costs nothing
Just use it whenever smth looks like magic dmg
Idk what false accusers stats are
Basically on CD since you're supposed to play BV in raid
If you don't play BV, you can use it on mechanics or just on CD aswell when you're tanking
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/character/eu/thrall/fenitaw#difficulty=4 he's from a good guild of my server and he's using IP way more often than me, so I'm curios if I should do it as well?
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/7HLbRGAnFPVgy69Y#type=casts&boss=-2&difficulty=0&wipes=2&source=4
The dude that declined me today posted this one and said I should just do everything like him (OP etc..)
rip halcyon
Moet is good yes, but I don't see the difference?
He had like 40% IP uptime
I checked his old HC logs as well
In mythic you actually take dmg compared to heroic
Okay
Yeah his CPM is higher than yours, which means he generates more rage
So he can spend more on IP
This is basic math
Looking at IP uptime is dumb
Yes I myself also have 30-40% uptime on IP
But that's because I can afford to spend the rage there, on my mythic farm kills I had uptime of less than 2% on IP on some bosses because I was just spamming for dmg
The other dude was just mad that you have better parses than him
You didn't waste rage, so you don't need IP uptime on heroic of all things
How can I increase my CPM, I basically use something immediately for every GCD, so the ony thing that I can improve is off GCD things
More haste
The warrior I liked was not the one that declined me, its just a "good warrior" from my server
And, maybe you're actually not pressing it ;)
Often people say they do
But then they don't
It's as simple as that
Yeah need to record myself and check
That "good" warrior, has basically the exact same logs as you
But I paid a lot of attention to if I really do this
So wtf is that other cunt on about
No clue
🤣
I guess I need to check if I can get more haste, I collected most of the things from the wowhead bis list lol
I'm kinda unsure about my warrior performance since I die more often than my Monk mate
It's incredibly simple
Warrior is the tank most prone to dying because we have no failsafe mechanics
Don't get me wrong, I farmed all the bis stuff and it's my highest item level gear
If you fuck up as warrior, you are the most likely go die unless you scream for help quick enough
I spammed a huge amount of m+ to get 236 ilvl bis gear before the raid
You gotta play to each tanks strengths, if there's something your cotank can do better let him deal with it
And you deal with w/e else, plan who takes what and where if need be
If you die to mistakes, stop making mistakes :^)
The amount of effort you're putting towards itemized would infinitely be put to better use doing deep dives into your prog fights so you can plan cds and fight timinga
Warrior is 90% homework
Sounds dumb but is kinds true, as tank you're supposed to play every fight exactly the same so your healers and your cotank have a perfect rhythm of the fight
Same positioning, same CD usage and so on
Being consistent is better than playing your class perfectly
Cuz everybody knows what to expect
Add on what nom was saying about how war doesn't have the stagger/deathstrike/healing/being a bear net od the othe tanks
@modern brook do you have some notes about how you approach bosses?
And knowing fight patterns is a magnitude more important
Easy don't raid tank it's snoozville
Tanknotes is a great source to read up on stuff
Yeah I usually read tank notes before the fight
Dps is even more snooze fest tbh... Even less mechanics to deal with
Just grug
There are no warrior specifics there sadly
Wow is snoozevill if we're being real
Facts
Most important thing is to figure out what on the fight is going to kill you
Lost ark is the new hype
Watching other people do fights is also very helpful
Esp from prot war pov
@chrome falcon true, I always look at deaths
Melee swings should be basically nothing in your mental bandwith because you're a warrior and you block all that shit so just assign cooldowns to tankbusters
The point is that by the time you get into the raid
You don't need to check why you died
(unless you're undergeared in which case melee swings are scary as hell but)
It sounds like your gear is fine so the only things that should scare you are tank busters
A) you shouldn't be dying and b) you should know when your life is actually threatened
Assuming you're playing with people at thwir keyboards
What level are you raiding at, HC or mythic
O think he linked hc logs but wants to get into mythix
No such thing as hype
Haste Mastery
Bro we gonna have skyhold lost ark launch party, bet
Can I be a big orc in lost ark
But low haste, right. But with the socket it might be slightly better than death gods
Yes || no||
Great ||game sucks shit||
You sucky shit
Bullyatur
Why the heck is [Show Of Force] valued higher than [adaptive armor fragment] in the mik tree
Adaptive seems so much better
^
Within 0.5% margin
I bet sof gets more value with haste tbh
I'll throw that into the universe with no math or thought to back it up
@ionic fern can have fun fixing the ramkfications
:(
I'm never invited to anything
Thats iy
I'm coming out of retirement
I'm getting storm forhead
Highest aoe damage lego?, to amaze guildied on 15s every eeek
SR
@chrome falcon im raiding HC right now, because my guild doesn't go higher, but I want to raid mythic and have CE as a goal
Nf leggo> em> reverb probably
@chrome falcon I'm learning how to play warrior right now, always played tanks, just not warrior
Maybe glory over reverb just to justify playing nerdcrolord
It's SR
glorygang
S.r
SR is miles ahead of NF, but you're gonna get more ST value from NF leggo
So it's good for mix fights.
But in M+ SR is gonna dunk on NF
SR is the venthyr one?
Still not used to warr lango
Reverb is chungus thicboi damage
But it has absolutely zero defensive value
Literally none.
You give up your right to a legendary in order to not give a shit about any other decision on the xlass
You just play reprisal
How do heal?
Rallying cry
That no heal, class shit. Bdk heal more 😠
Reprisal is gonna do more than enough damage even in +20 and onward keys.
So playing that is ideal.
I was 100 dps below my fellow mage in a mists, pretty sure I can top him with a bit better play next time
All true points
Yah you play reverb when you're slumming or doing boosts
Ye, not asking for ideal, that ones sorted. But not sure what to craft now. Reverb was already on the plans tho
Make sure to ask for consent first
If I spell reflect sylvanas heartseekers, only the first of the three shots is reduced right?
If you already have reprisal the answer is never do torgast again
Alternatively only do torghast when someone is paying for you to carry their Alt through it
How is the result from the b uffs so minor? (for shard sets)
I'm still kinda doing torgs to fill out my collection of rank 4s
are people switching to mikanikos after getting the last trait? or still pelagos?
Mika
Why Mika?
spear cd, i imagine
torghast is literally the last thing to do before reset. not feeling it tho
gotta give credit where credit is due, thanks to everyone in this channel who over the last weeks have been giving out tips and I've been picking on them even if just by lurking. Has been a nice transition tanking as a warrior for the 1st time in years and actually managing to do smooth high m+ runs (well 17s is high for me) and enjoying them
best tip is by far "press your buttons" 😉

I need help deciding
do i get this fatty 33 ilvl upgrade shoulders or hold off on it just in case i get the dom socket from raid
or do i go with minor upgrade ring?
I like to always take from vault after farm from raid unless it's ur absolute bis
oh wait
i know
i can just grab the ring replace the crafter one and get the crafted shoulders
That’s a good gameplan. Considering even LFR shoulders would be an upgrade if you have shards, the blue boe is a cheap placeholder. And you can upgrade that ring 2 more times
Well now what do I wait for all season and complain about lol
Congrats! Here I was content w getting a 239 Aegis
Thanks! Aegis seems pretty bad ass too!
Viscera of Coalesced Hatred, any good? It's that or a 252 helm with haste/mast which is a decent upgrade for prot/arms. trinket is 246
otherwise i'm wearing a 220 scale and the 226 garrosh trinket
What, you think people learn from your stream??
Just kidding I totally do
A shitload, actually

what's the go-to mikanikos build?
whatever it is, it's definitely not in the two guides on wowhead and icyveins that are 3 channels up
probably something like this
Do DRs like shield wall get applied before or after the Aegis trinket's DR?
If you run that you can setup the other paths for Arms too. ;)
Shard of Annhylde's Aegis?
It's an absorb, its applied after all "mitigations" are factored in.
looks sexy, combine with scale for maximum on use tomfoolery
makes me almost want to play agian.
when crafting first time legi on tank for m+, should i go legs or feet with reprisal?
I'm actually fucking stupid.
How do I check damage done exclusively during the Execute phase?
Legs is best for Reprisal, this tier anyway (also happened to be best last tier)
boy i sure do love the eye and all the things i can block 
I still got only 1 domination piece 🤡
Is this worth the ilvl decrease for the domination shard (not part of a set)?
Any NF prot warriors around and wanna link they’re soulbind tree 😛
S. Is there a way to even do that, without simply time stamping it and checking from that timestamp? (you looking through details or wclogs?)
We just did our heroic clear then tarragrue and will continue tomorrow..the Effusive anima thingie for mikanikos isn't as stunning as I thought it'd be in raids..now gonna' see how it does in keys.
Side note: I will give blizzard RL money for some heroic/+ dom socket shoulders...for the love of loot plz~
ugh..it happened... Shard bonuses are kinda' busted. Blood link was my #1 damage source on heroic sylvanas. My set is rank 4
You want to get cool stuff that makes you powerful but when a proc is your top damage..IE corruptions/blood link... it just feels kinda' lame?
It's blizzard man, they never learn.
Imagine being a DPS without the bonus right now
One of our stronger dps, a monk...just can't touch a helm for whatever reason, same way I can't get a shoulder (just for my 5th dom slot) So he cannot get unholy set.
Yup, we have 5 casters + 2 heal priests without helm.
if only feels lame if you decide it feels lame.
does any speed gems work in shadowlands?
Prot wars back boys. Lvl 15 dos after ardenweald https://gyazo.com/cff291cfaa2aa195641c69595b1fd0e2
Is Blood still better after the buffs?
yes
Jeeze. What ilvl are you?
There is one that gives you +13 speed for every other SL gem you have socketed. And also 2 from BFA that give +3 and +5% move speed
Yeah… pretend like I have to imagine that and I’m not missing an unholy gem 😅
Thats after aredenweld where u can just mass pull, and do loads of damage as its not bolstering or fortifed this week
Like u can pull the whole area if u want to onto the jat
Question still stands
Not really u could do close to that damage in that area before hand
do i use dom socket bonus with lower ilvl rather than ilvl pieces for m+ as tank?
Yes
236 in my tank gear, mik soulbind is fat
Yeah ofc it fell off as the dungeon went on but I still ended with 6.6k overall nearly beating the paladin dps
what pots do we use in keys? strengh?
Yes
thx
So Kyrian Mikanikos is now Bis?
u can sim it but i asume so since you can spear way more often
I mean hes been better for weeks now
Been simming higher and since ptr we knew he would be better because if the last trait
tbf it might be that pela was still simming higher for some i had a diffrence from 7 dps to mika
😄
I mean that depends on the path your simming he was like 50-100 more for me
Left mid left
Pretty much
god of chest please lil shield this morning
oh sanguine storming
well, not bad to push some lil keys
hm i was thinking about this with the 57 renown mikanikos
spear almost every min ?
its trash it only effects ur steward cd
oh 😦
i think atleast
Necrotic Wake tech if you're the only Kyrian in the group to get all goliaths without waiting 🤞
Very useless trinket
U can do that anyway
Really? I usually have like 3 Minutes CD when we get to the third
The steward is up for 5min
Dont dismiss him
And the CD is 5min
The stewards stays up for 4 mins
Ooooh
4min 
I'm not a smart man.
Did they change that?
🤷♂️ i just seems to have a min where he disappears or im blind
too busy spaming revenge
on storming do we have anything to counter them or jjust kite it out
i remember a nerf about it
Just move - it's also better for your melee DPS'ers.
yeah thats what i ussally did
head is the play here right?
if i where u yes
i havve issues aswell
basicly no really nice stuff since all m+ ones are dominations slots
and the trinket i dunnno if that is anygood
got terrible things too
lol after spending all valor on upgrading weapon for druid last week i get xav's pike in vault 🙂
Currently equpped: 220 scale + 239 endless howling, 233 bracers, 226 shoulders, 1x 229 ring with heavy on the versa + 249 gods signet.
Any recommendations?
You spent the valor to bribe the algorithm so it gave you the weapon on 252 :)
hehe feels like it
Jesus, the amount of domination slots in vaults is too damn high
I only had those in my M+ slots as well
If you play dps offspec, the trinket is great
For a tank, not so much I think
If you don't have a domination set piece, you might as well wear 252 in that slot until you get it
yeah thats what i will do
just will pick after my raid today
braacers or helmet then cause atleast bis stats on em
@ionic fern what do you think?
What item should I take?
239 w/ sockets or 252 item from M+?
either boots or gloves i would say
Imo the trinket is the winner here as you can get bis gloves from Archivists, the NW ring for Valor upgrading and the m+ choice are all on dom slots
Oh and those gloves are only 226 too, so only 6 ilvl behind the DA gloves that also have bis stats
the matrix fucking slaps too
Give up socket for ilvl?
Yeaa after a hot coffee and a good think I came to that realization. Justfeelsbad stuck with 220 scale for now 🙂
I know the feeling but I've got nö matrix either :D
Sanctum of Domination
Defeating Sylvanas on any difficulty will now always drop a Shard of Domination for players who do not yet have all possible Shards.
will dis give me the leech shard??
How good is the matrix? Thought it was "undertuned" read it on icyveins or something
cuz the fucking world boss wont drop it
The 239 matrix is a solid 200 dps and hps for me on basically everything
I think they updated the sylv drops for the world boss gem too but I'm not 100% on that
Definitely not on IV..atleast not under Prot Warrior guide.
It's solid in AoE.
have 252 shield-belt is just better stats and no socket compering to my current belt so hands and head are upgrade which one ?
my bad was on wowhead
Ive loved having the matrix since I got it. It's great dps and hps
If your shield is lower item level - shield, otehrwise, whatever you need from the rest
head or hands any opinion ?
Do you already have a gloves Dom socket?
I don't know what stats they are, if i recall the helmet had haste
No i don't have
no
hands haste/versa head haste/mastery
i have no dom socket on both slots
Dom sockets are worth more than pure ilvl, maybe if going for pure efficiency wait for when you reclear raid to not waste it but impossible to go wrong with a Dom socket
Especially if it will get you the set bonus
I think the gloves would be safer though since you'll eventually get the helm Dom socket too
Its a good and sad feeling
other than blood the frost kyr shard rocks
its pretty good hps for just existing, i think like almost 200 or so at later ranks
not sure on exact numbers
can someone help me? is the ring still an upgrade? (i have 223 crit haste + socket on it) boots = legendary equiped
after all the season spamming mists and necrotic wake with no lucky shield drop I finally got a shield at the vault
lazy vault, but haste ring
252 shield on third m+ choice replacing my old 9.0 220 shield
well if that socket would be your third one it would be important to form a set, if not, I'd rather take the ring
☠️
I have a shard of dyz (purple) and zed (also purple)
so yeah, not too keen on the domination socket system lol
think I'm taking the ring, at least it's an upgrade over my non-haste 233 ring
Rings can be tricky so - Sim yourself. 🙂
but its so rewarding not being able to use gear because you didnt get a different drop 
Cant wait to open my vault in 8 hours and get nothing

Pray for tarragrue shield or a mythic dom socket 🙏
🙏
ive already accepted i wont get tarragrue shield or shard for half the tier
took me half of last tier to move from a 213 shield
same lol
I literally yesterday got a 207 shield from a korthia rare (one of the rares near the world boss, so technically the maw?) that I was able to upgrade to 220
was running a Raid 213 shield for the whole previous season and until yesterday
we have a gamer in our midst
wicked
pog 252 piercing verdict from conduit roll
252 blood spattered and 246 phial in the same day .. lets go boys!
ylva? the big guarm offspring dogger?
@carmine rain 😡
yeah, it's what dropped the 207 upgradable shield
whomst'd've
can somebody help look at log
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/6PNjv9C3dZgbck2T#view=rankings&boss=-2&difficulty=0&wipes=2
why two bosses missing big number? too dumb
some of those have a rank 1 parse, 1 is a very low number and thus must be bad
i took many math classes
that sound too hard me just going uninstall ty
fair enough have a nice day sir
that's hard 😄 i'd take the helmet anytime but my arms second spec is very sad. guess I wait until we clear HC and pick afterwards.
Dom socket
Hey, having a tough time here after so many weeks of shitty choices. I have the same shield but at 246 and a 236 weapon would i still go shield or would the 16 ilvls on weapon be better?
Shield is a better item piece for us than weapon
chances of you doing tarrague mythic? @last yacht
would wait till you kill it if your guild does
Quite high, but possibly not this week due to holidays
"shitty choices" with weapon and shield 252 
Hi. Another advice request on choice. Shield looks good for now, wont be doing mythic Tarrague for a while yet. But the ilvl upgrades on the other items are turning my head. Urgh.
I guess its worth to pick a dom-socket right off the bat instead of waiting for reclear considering i will switch out that 252 for the 239 eventually anyway right
Nah fuck it imma wait considering i can get the same slot but with better stats from raids
I keep the haste ring despite ilvl right? xD
I would for sure. 7ilvl difference isnt big at all and you got good rings
Sockets add like 6 ilvls what I heard
Can I ask you? Does shield block makes all blocks critical blocks?
No
any thoughts on switching to Mikanikos now that we have renow 57??
tried to look for a chat regarding this in the channel
found nothing specific
go mikanikos
wait you can get renown 57 this week?
laughs in korayn
i still have 48 as dungeons don't give me anymore 

^^
Put ashen in the left middle tree and use that fro raid u get like no benefit out of the haste in the raid tbh
true
13ish
Nice
Poggers
Sockets add ilvl? what did I miss
In value, not in "ilvl" itself.
To jewelry
Ah okay, makes sense, was like what for a sec
Should i drop a socket for a 6ilvl upgrade? (same item different ilvls)
what slot what stats
Helm: Darkfrost Helmet(haste vers) 252 vs 246 with socket
You drop the socket and take the 252 because you get more main stat which is always gonna be better than more secondary stats
252
head is big slot and it has good stats
so its a win-win situation
higher ilvl and great stats
Cool thanks!
as a general rule of thumb you should be comfy dropping ilvls for stats on jewlery, maybe think twice on cloak, seriously consider it on bracers/belt, and be absolutely fucking sure you know what you're doing everywhere else
what's general opinion on Soul Cage Fragment ? Is it okish or bad ?
very underwhelming
I dunno, where is it on the extensive trinket list on the wowhead guide?
looks like flaming garbage to me
especially since it's from worldboss so iLVL is meh
ye i guess so, i just cant push myself to farm phial ... i guess i will have to
Hey - what is best for us? chaos or blood set bonus
blood set







Just rock with what ever you have..cause you know..when you have 4 warriors in the group and 3 of them have Phial and 1 doesn't then we still wouldn't do PF.

😦

Also, i've read about aegis on this disco, and when i dropped it 252 i was quite happy, but it feels VERY situational ? Unless u are doing gigantic pull it's much worse then Scale and its pretty much useless on bosses. Usually at the end of dungeon it has like 100-150k more healing than scale but much less dmg. Am i missing smth ?
lower cooldown
uncapped mitigation
y its all good but in practice, there are like 2/3 pulls where i healed for more then scale, which i dont think is that amazing, the lower cd is nice, but imo its not worth it
8 seconds of each hit you take (from in front) being reduced by x. Bigger you pull better it is
ye i know how it works, but there arent many dungeons where u can utilize it to maximum, Halls, Dos and maybe NW seems like good dungeons for this trinket but otherwise i dont think its better than scale
You do you.
The lower CD alone is what makes it better, you can use it every pull instead of every other pull
Its a good start but, can be more now with cap stonr
Sometimes twice a pull
@strong forum U dont need that much mitigation every pull + on "recovery pulls" it does like 30k healing and no dmg. u might as well not use anything here. While with scale, whatever happens u get the same dmg/mitigation
*almost the same
Whats a recovery pull?
Does anyone know If the Painsmith trink is good?
i assume it's when you dont have a lot of cd's up etc
im just saying what details said
Scale wouldn't have done any more in that scenario because you didn't take dmg to begin with so you'd just sit on scale CD for even longer
Are Domination Socket items (HC Version) still better as 252 itemlvl ? Even for m+? (I only Tank m+)
according to icyveins, yes
I have a Phial, and just got that one.
Thinking about farming the postmaster one though, since the Painsmith one is only 226 (got it from TW chest).
Its okay for damage
But why wouldnt u rotate cds so u have 1 for every pull?? 🤔
But scale has a dmg part to it, that is much more powerful then aegis. So using it on smaller packs have much more value then aegis, while aegis ONLY shines on big pulls, that's my problem
OK thanks! Was Not Sure If i should drop my HC bracers for 252 itemlvl
If your relying on scale for damage you usig it wrong
great question i just assumed thats what it meant LUL
@jagged pier I dont, but when i can i use it for dmg. Also the lower CD on aegis assumes u use it on CD then cuz otherwise CD doesnt matter if u hold it
then scale has more value, cuz its more consistent
Look u use scale we aint stopping you, your just never gunna convince me that and absorb is better than pure damage reduction
Scale also gets eaten by necrotic where ageis doesnt
Idk why you are creating instances where 1 trinket is better than the other instead of just looking at the grand scheme.
Generally you can do pulls big enough in almost any dungeon/affix combination where Aegis excels - now a whole other questions is if you feel comfortable enough to do it or not.
Absorbs (like Scale) also get reduced by things like Necrotics etc while DR's (Like Aegis) are not affected.
thought someone said aegis outshines scale at equal ilvl when it eats 12-13 hits? which is super doable over 8 sec
let's take 12 minute span, we used scale 6 times and aegis 8 times, all of the scale uses gave me the same value, while aegis like what 4-5 ?
@ionic fern The necrotic point is very good, and i will definetly use in necrotic weeks now ^^, but i dont think u can do big pulls every 1.5 min in every dungeon. Mists, Spires, Theater, in Dos u can big pull only in Alrdenwead really, and that's my problem that ppl say just slap this aegis on ur character and its better then everything while in reality, there are cases where u should swap from it
for the people that like aegis, would you drop 252 scale for 226 aegis?
is it the same value within the same time frame with aegis you always get the full 8 seconds with scale not always
Yes, its better
u get the full 8 seconds, the thing is one time the 8 seconds are amazing the other u get nothing
Is IQD any good for prot?
brain says weapon, heart says aegis 😔
dont take anything until you clear raid is my opinion
might get lucky and loot aegis
i could get aegis any week in raid but... its right there👀
I would go for trinket because I think they're more fun
any advice for my disgusting vault?
Take currency and buy korthia crystals for gold
the tank in our guild has stamina thinkets and goes for vers rings
chad
damn, playing tank makes you a control freak
i play healer in raids and i can't stand people being wrong on these things
Playing tank doesn’t make you a control freak. He probably came that way
Kick him
can't cause she is the one that keeps people coming to the guild
well
it is
its not the kind of guild where we kick people for being bad but its just very annoying when you know you are right and people are just: my opinion is better than all of yours
Eeh.
It's a game..chances are it's some mediocre guild (no offense) so the tank running some X things won't make or brake anything.
If the guild cared enough they would kick the tank.
If the player cared enough they would do more research.
We are mediocre, the only thing we take pretty seriously is mythic plus, But there you know who to invite or not
I've given up on arguing with people in game when i see a warrior tank running some wild things.
Most of them don't listen to reason and just end up doing what they want anyways.
"YOU DON'T KNOW WARRIORS! I AM THE PROT WARRIOR HERE!!!".
Ok frend.
as mythic plus is more of an individual archievement
hehe
it happened to me often, but with resto druid
when i tank and i see the resto druid with bad talents in a 17 there is no way to convince them
Jep, impossible.
I've defaulted into ignoring it and not arguing as it makes my head ache.
The reasoning they come up with is just..ugh
Probably rings with
High vers / what ever else stat.
And no, haste/vers is not a bad ring.
i think it was crit / vers ring
then complains to me that has trouble holding aggro in mythic plus with stamina thinkets 
To be fair...that sounds more like a gameplay issue.
Yes, that's 100% the reason why i died yesterday all the time.
Where do you even end up w a stam trinket in SL. I saw some leveling but they must be 20-30 ilvls below current tier.
Best thing SL did with trinkets is make so many primary stat baseline and not muddy things up
there's one from plaguefall
and from tazavesh
Plaguefall drops trinkets?
its supposed to 
the fucking organ, worst trinket in the game

Eww
🔧
🛡️
You keep that away I got that in my box
But luckily lfr gave me aegis so I didn't have to cry myself to sleep
whats wrong with rings with vers? 🤔
https://gyazo.com/8429853dbbdd5fa0446439d84140f0e4
My options are: 6 ilvl upgrade on shield (going from ok stats to ok stats), replacing 246 KT neck with 252 Sin-stained (with a socket), or a 3 ilvl upgrade on chest which gives me blood link and my third socket. Ring from the Nine is also slightly better than something I have rn but like... seems worse than the rest
nothing wrong with vers rings.... if they have haste
psure blood link chest is de wae
If its a haste ring with vers good, if its a vers ring with no haste bad
My current thought process is that I'm clearing all of HC every week and progging 5/10M, so I should be getting a blood link chest this week anyway. The shield upgrade is nice but... again, I should have no trouble getting a 252 shield from Tarragrue soon anyway.
But the Sin-Stained Pendant is literally not going to be replaced until Mythic KT, which is quite a way off. So... I think I want the neck?
cause you build up a taunt rotation 😄
I think anything from the raid you guys have on farm is devalued a little bit since theres a much higher chance you can get it to drop naturally at that I level

to me, belt and neck seem to be the play
that's my thought process too
since shield you can get from Tara
Not going for belt because i'm banner gang and wearing the legendary
(apart from in fortified m+ but eh that's a whole week away)
Looks like we narrowed it down then 🙂
gonna wait until we clear 9/9hc and 2/9m tonight regardless
yea, neck or shield would be play, but you can actually just walk into Tara and kill him every week
Yeah i'm doing that anyway but legit anyone at all can do that
I still don’t know how we had 3 wipes on H Tara then 1 shot Eye and Nine easy peasy
man it feels so good after a week of bolstering to just pull freely
Ive been told by my guildies that their 'casual' friends are currently progging on Normal Tara
storming sanguine

i wanna push 20s this week because it's so much easier than last week but
20 tyrannical 😴
does overwhelming power crystal boost parry?
yes
damn, how you gonna let that DH beat you
hello everyone o/ quick question: how bad is it for warrior to be rage capped? i feel i am swimming in rage all the time. Icy Veins Guide says we shouldt use Revenge outside of procc and IP is only a supplement for Shield Block, however in yesterdays LFR i felt like IP was immense whereas SB didnt do much, so I dumped my rage there, but outside... i can imagine in m+ that IP dies more quickly and i guess to keep up aggro i would spam revenge more? thoughts? tips? mockeries? :D
You never want to be rage capped.
You will lose either:
1)Damage
2)Defensive value
Parry is converted based on the raw Stat value of crit. So any time you get a buff thats in the form of 100 Crit, it goes towards parry, and time you get a buff in hte form of 6% crit, it does not
And IV says:"Revenge only if it is free, OR as a Rage dump".
except for the severe corruption 😦
I talked to the IV writer and he mentioned that you should never-ever be in a situation where you are sitting on 100 Rage.
So either use Ignore Pain (even if it means you overcap it) or Revenge for it.
severe wasnt raw stat
Okay so then i am doing it corrctly, i guess? i wasnt sure if i reall should use it. but okay :) nice. I guess i should also take care to not overcap with BV talented
it was
nah it was a percentage of your raw stat given
it added crit rating to your char sheet
it just, didn't count for parry for some reason
i mean, i guess for obvious balance reasons but still
Pretty sure parry also has mean diminishing returns
Yes, you have to be careful about when you're using BV. Ignore Pain is off the GCD meaning you can use it pretty much when ever.
The majority of your excessive rage should be going into Revenges to increase your damage (after you're set with SB and don't need to dump into IP for survivability purposes)
nice, thanks! and about Ignore Pain usage? is it a thing again or are we still priorising SB over ignore pain?
ip sucks
SB > IP.
if you're getting melee'd, SB > *
I again talked to the author of IV and he said and i quote:
"Shield Block is your primary mitigation ability. It takes priority over Ignore Pain assuming you are taking blockable damage (which is almost always)."
And
"Ignore Pain reduces damage by a flat amount, and with its current tuning, is much weaker than Shield Block . As such, it should be used in addition to Shield Block, not in place of it."
i am using Bolster anyways, since i thought having a 3rd shield block might come in handy
okay, nice, thank you kindly for all the tips and explanation! :D then i guess i need to work more on my Shield Block usage but i am glad that i wasnt too far off with my rage dump usage

"Unfortunately Bron, summoned by Bron's Call to Action Icon Bron's Call to Action, acts like a Guardian which means that he can aggro additional enemies so this is something to keep in mind."
So he pulls uncontrolled?
That's actually changed now afaik.
I don't think Bron pulls anymore. 👀
Even just like, proximity?
Like if you invis pot or shroud while he's out, all good?
I'm not 100%..but i vaguely remember them changing Bron.
Yeah I think originally he would just go start punching stuff
I did an invis skip with owlfriend out the other day though and he also goes invis, handily. Bron might do the same now
hm
But as I cant hae mika as arms and prot I have to descide anway
to chosse mika for the one and one of the other twos for arms
Why? 👀
Yes u can
I think some scientists have figured out a route that you can share
they have totally different conduits?
by just swapping a couple routes
You use Piercing Verdict as 1 Potency
And the second one..just swap for w/e arms one you want (if they have a good one) as the 2nd prot Potency is trash. 🙂
wait... arent you the Icy Veins writer?
Just swap the red one out for w/e.
Arms: https://www.wowhead.com/guides/kyrian-arms-warrior-covenant-best-soulbinds-shadowlands
Prot: https://www.icy-veins.com/wow/protection-warrior-best-covenants-soulbinds-and-conduits#choosing-the-right-covenant
same way, but totally different conduits?
Learn everything you need to know for your Kyrian Arms Warrior in Shadowlands. Best Soulbinds, Conduits, Talent Changes, Rotation, and more. Always updated for Shadowlands
@jagged pier The m+ one looks similar to @ionic fern one
https://www.wowhead.com/guides/kyrian-arms-warrior-covenant-best-soulbinds-shadowlands#80r-mythic
But I dont run m+ as arms, only raid
auto-phial choice also hurts my soul...
Ima soul shape outta here
I'll put it like this:
I doubt running the route i linked for both prot/arms will hinder your progress in any way or reduce your damage done by a significant amount.
You can obviously sim yourself as i might be wrong due to me lacking serious knowledge about arms.
You know I totally trust you Mwa-looking_over_my_shoulder_hi ;D
Just sim both routes in your Arms setup and look at the damage difference.
And then you'll know.

Both of the choices on that row hurt my soul ::(
i'm unsure if the other trait is worth losing a potency conduit
You only have 1 good potency
That said everything above the spear cdr and the haste buff is basically a tax
How you lighter blue bois enjoying the CDR
Do we go bron or pelagos for raid? Seems like Last trait from pelagos is a little fucky but idk thoughts?
Sim yourself - generally Mika.
i've been out of the loop for about a month now
9.1 give me depression, and so i stopped lol

@ionic fern I was ain the wrong channel with the ping, sry 😦
mika still better in raid/ST over pelagos?
Should i go for a 239 domination socket head or the 252 shield in my vault?
Yep
Nope
Only got wrists and gloves for domination sockets atm.
Well then.
would be nifty with a thingamajig that would let you put a domination socket on an item of choice
naw, they cant do that
that would improve the player experience
but would be a good one for m+ runners
where only the sockets matter anyway and not the bonus
or they remove them at all 😄
Idk why they added them at all
the question we all have... :/
Game would be better without them
#daretoreject
Did you already figure out a clever way how to put the conduits to mika when having arms as second spec :D?
I'm new to Warrior, can someone tell if Battle Shout needs to be re cast if you join a new group? Or does it affect whoever is in range of you?
needs to be recast
ok thanks! So if I was in a raid and a new character joined i would need to recast it to affect them as well?
yes
Ty ^^
Even with Mika's capstone trait unlocked this week, is Kleia better for raid?
just sim it
No u
something like this id say
could potentially throw in ashen jugg instead of mortal combo to have effectiveness on both specs, depending on what you raid as since youll only take that slot in raid
the auto phial is satan
is it tho
I run it
no but i want to overreact to the one time it was annoying me
Mika is only good for dps in raid I guess?
you only pick soulbinds for dps
pro-tip delete them from your bag when running towards end boss of pf
and mika is by FAR the best m+ bind now with 57 renown
then call your boy in for the rain when you need it
I hit my first 100% dps parse ever on SD last night because of Mika.
40s spears that do extra damage makes the chain pulls easier to manage and spike the meters. Hit 20k dps on pull in Mists last night too.
This week is a good push week
So far, yeah
I got a 15 Halls key outta the vault, gonna see how far I can push it
why is Mika so good now? just adds lots of dps?
it lowers the cooldown of your spear b y 5 sec for each enemy hit up to 4
And makes it deal more DPS on cast
And makes it last twice as long which, if used for kiting, is nice
if i have 246 wep + shield, should i still open vault in Prot for a 252 wep/shield?
You're hitting the point where it's preference
252> 246 so you should probably stay port
But if your trinkets suck getting organs feels bad so
Grats on ur 252 2hander
U can also open in Fury
guess cape it is
ye would rather get a 2h for offspec then
Fury also keeps 2h chabce
Haste/Versa Cloak
ye its good cloak
one of my lower ilvl pieces (229 cloak)
just rly wanted a trinket 😄
got 223 phial
i literally got like 10 rings this seaosn
its starting to get ridiculous
so much fun playing the campaign on an alt...
Crit Mastery ring any good for Prot? no right?
that cloak is insane
dunno why you feel like you got pure bullshit when it's literally the bis cloak :p
ye just looking at DPS increase for Arms its only a +0.4% dps increase 😄 guess i should just fuck that and go with BIS Prot cloak yeeee
What do you guys see as the pick for kyrian? Pelagos, kleia or mikanikos? for m+ and raiding
currently I'm using pelagos because the others are taken by DPS, but you can reconfigure mika to fit prot and arms together if you want
i don't really see kleia being the choice
only tanking, so not into arms
it's still pretty much pelagos and mika, with mika being the m+ choice
or the choice if you don't want to deal with pelagos's minigames
quick question with mika as kyrian with the 20% reduced dmg after falling would it be worth to get into storming at some point ?
No
like taking a sotmring near end of a pull to have the reduced on the next pull
1 ur crazy for not taking free gold from being healed
2 think of it more as a cushion for when you fuck up or need to eat storms
well i dont really care about the gold part 😛 but the 2 seems legits since im not a pro and i do fuck up quite a bit 😛
orc zug zug
How good is reactive defence matrix?
Is there any weak aura for the pelagos 55 trait? this one is just for the balls
and the manifestation is pretty hard to see
thers some that tell you when its up
anyway once you face it it give the buff right away its not like inerva where you had to face and way for a dash.
once you see the flying arcane ball animation coming out of it the buff is on the way you can go face whicever way you want
I'm confused on mikanikos's last soulbind slot, specifically where it says "dealing x arcane dmg split evenly between all targets over 8 seconds" testing on training dummys at elysian hold there is no damage taken past the 4 seconds of normal spear.
did you verified if the dmg got increased
i watched the meters and at 4 sec the dmg stops
its a seperate dmg proc
it doesnt increase spear dmg
its just a seperate dmg proc
the dmg name is Effusive Anima Accelerator (Dot)
ty for help

the dmg increase is ncie but its the 20 second off spear that is the butter 😛
yup 20% cd reduction is huge
haven done a key yet with it im excited about trying it
assuming you hit 4+ targets, and its 33% if my maff checks out
^
^
^
yah thats why i use mika only in m+ pelagos for raid 😛
im big dumb this has been established
but if you take mike you dont get minigames distracting you from the fight
Pepegos owns 
our healer aint top notch i prefer pelagos only for the survival increase
why would you turn down warioware: kyrian
pepegos survival gain is very very very very low
hmm
the budget 10% bom is nice QoL, but not an actual surv gain
well, it is a surv gain
but not a noticable one i reckon
but with nearly 100% sb uptime the mastery should make a difference on the blocked amount ?
Well it does increase your chance of a crit block by flat ~10%
ok
So yes, the argument is to be made, but is it worth it losing the massive dps gain that mikan is?
so you would go mika and only change maybe some soulbind for m+ and raid ?
Year of the slam
You only pick soulbinds for their dps, not for the negligible amount of surv gain
ya
As 98% of survival comes from playing well
i would change SoF for AAF in raid i guess
The other 2% are shield and aegis
Or just, don't care about it, the difference is 0.5% or less
The only potency conduit besides spear that has a slight impact on dps is ashen jugg in raid

F
maybe they checked the pins
Haste
@patent osprey haha i asked the question and then i regret it instant, found answer in the pins 😄
❤️ ty
xD faster to ask here
I like skyhold discord cause I get to chill with the Bigboy names 🙂
What shard set bonus would you recommend for progression? unholy, frost or blood?
Blood if you can
Sweet
just depends though
on what you get
Ideally Blood, but if you never get the chest, just get unholy
depends on how fast you wish to prog though
i got all the blood shards but only one socket so no reason not to use blood right?
Or depends on the set bonus-item i guess
your gear choices should always be based on how fast you want to prog. So either work with what you get, or chill till you get BIS
Thanks
I mean, right now it’s not really dependant on me how fast we’ll prog : (
We have very casual players amongst us
So i probably have time to just chill for the right pieces
yeah, if your a casual player, then def hold out for BIS
but if you plan to go for like Hall of fame, you have to pull the ripcord at some point
and just play unoptimal long term, but play for the moment
Im more a m+ guy or used to be at least
big true
haste
when weould you say haste is enough since theres a diminishing return past 25%
I know this has probably been asked but I don't see it in the pins. Thoughts on Pelagos vs Bron for Kyrian since we're renown 57 now?
we just had the discution a bit earlier
Consensus is basically Mikanikos for everything.





