#protection

1 messages Β· Page 3553 of 1

naive whale
#

mikanikos spear reduction seems kinda scary tho

jagged pier
#

just saying kyrian already pumping

uneven mason
#

Yeah, but flying smurfs

tired ice
#

You can also be a combat pigeon! Spear

cinder fern
ionic fern
#

?

sweet summit
#

did you just...

ionic fern
#

That's the dumbest thing i've seen in a whiule.

jagged pier
#

ooo wow guys he linked logs

#

πŸ‘€

cinder fern
#

It gets by, but I never said I was clever. I'm not trying to brag, I'm just trying to say it's not garbage.

sweet summit
#

neither did mwahi?

ionic fern
#

No one said it's garbage.

#

πŸ‘€;

#

If you like it/enjoy it, go ham. peepoHappy

cinder fern
#

Sorry for having seemed stupid, I'm fairly good at that. It is more work than just spear or AA.

#

You kinda have to go ham to get it to work.

ionic fern
#

Jeh, the others just do the same thing with less effort.
You do add more damage for your group tho so that's goood.

uneven mason
#

Going ham is what it is all about

craggy pilot
#

how is druid not OP as fk?
this is me on my shaman being outhealed in a DOS 13 by a druid... on bolster week

tired ice
#

Probably playing with Ursocs Fury Remembered, which pumps tons of absorb shield

craggy pilot
#

thats what i mean

#

how is that not OP as fk?

signal pulsar
#

that only happens with their legendary and while incarn is up. Outside of incarn that never happens.

craggy pilot
#

this is over the pace of an entire dungeon

amber herald
#

they're weaker than us outside of incarn I'd say

#

but a 30 second effective immunity is a 30 second effective immunity

craggy pilot
#

but still outhealing the healer seems dumb as fk

oak lotus
#

I always out heal healers in dungeons as bear druid

amber herald
#

was the ele shaman doing damage?

tired ice
#

It's so funny when I run M+ with my guardian cotank and shaman Heal and the shaman constantly complains in voice about being outhealed xD

craggy pilot
#

@amber herald what?

amber herald
#

resto

oak lotus
#

He sure as heck could have. he wasnt healing lol

craggy pilot
#

the resto was me, and i was trying to do dmg but not rly doing much πŸ˜„

#

guess i should have had Deeptremor on

oak lotus
#

Also boys. JUST GOT MY PHIAL LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

strong forum
craggy pilot
#

just feels weird being healer with a druid tank not having to do anything :<

#

guess thats why DPS Holy Paladins are popular

strong forum
#

well having a venthyr paladin work out requires the entire group not to require alot of healing

#

which is why in low level keys / pugs, venthyr paladin often doesnt play out even remotely well

craggy pilot
#

yea makes sense

#

when im playing sham with druid tank, im mostly healing the 3 dps standing in shit

strong forum
#

guardian druid doesnt require alot of healing in huge pulls because of their combination of incarn thrash spam + UFR, outside of CDs bears still require quite some attention

craggy pilot
#

UFR and Earthwarden was healing as much as i was as shaman..

strong forum
#

yeah thats kind of everything they have

#

lol

#

thats the whole shtick

oak lotus
#

But thing is @craggy pilot if you tank well on your warrior, you'll be the same way this druid is. Hardly need heals. You'll need a few riptides here and there but

uneven mason
#

Yeah, it's not like we're brewmasters

uneven mason
#

this is why reading healing logs/parses or meters is way more complicated then DPS

craggy pilot
#

yea ok makes sense thx πŸ™‚

plush tendon
#

So heres a brain exercise, I play 4 tanks Paladin, War, DH, and DK, and I want to play all 4 Covs. How would you set your characters up for this?

jagged pier
#

dk necro, paladin venth, dh nf, prot kyrian

plush tendon
#

that was sort of what I was thinking

#

Was playing around with Kyiran last night on War; its pretty fun... I do miss soul shape though

#

The issue of course is that elusive necro cov.... why is it so bad for so many classes 😭

jagged pier
#

i mean its great for dk

plush tendon
#

it trolls me

#

but I love it

#

but I also like mist

chrome falcon
#

necrolord isn't "so" bad for warrior but certainly kyrian is better

plush tendon
#

Im calling it 'bad' cause gameplay to maximize the buff is garbage

jagged pier
#

^^

chrome falcon
#

eh i dunno i find that gameplay to maximize the buff is fine

plush tendon
#

if it were group wide rather then two closest, we would be in business

chrome falcon
#

i just ask my ret if he has wings up and he says "up in 20" and i'm like. ok i'll just hold banner for 20 seconds

#

then i watch my ret one shot the pack and take all the credit

#

or he says "up in 40" and i pop it for myself and bathe in sweet delicious 27k execute crits

sweet summit
#

one question

#

how do you desync two 2 min cds

jagged pier
#

^^

chrome falcon
#

sometimes i pop it for my boomie

plush tendon
#

The dps I usually run with is a Havoc, MM Hunter, WW, Arcane Mage with featured appearances from a Demo Lock and Arms Warrior (usually 2 at the same time)

chrome falcon
#

if it's more than ret aoe cap

#

and he's starfalling

jagged pier
#

then u should sync wings and banner to ca

sweet summit
#

fuck boomkins, but fair enough

chrome falcon
#

hey i agree, fuck boomkins

#

in 7 years of raid leading i have met two boomkins who were stable and normal individuals, that spec is absolutely fucking cursed

plush tendon
#

We had a army of boomies last tier

#

4 for CN

chrome falcon
#

also yeah augusto your group sounds dogshit for banner

#

so fair enough

plush tendon
#

now we are down to 1, whos slowly losing braincells to Venthyr

sweet summit
#

we had 3 going into the tier, now we have 1 😎

#

wicked

chrome falcon
#

we also had 3 and they're all gone, our resident class-hopper switched to it though

plush tendon
#

I got mad warriors though

chrome falcon
#

idk what it is but boomies are just psychopaths

plush tendon
#

and not a single shaman of any kind

chrome falcon
#

my 2 boomies wanted to reroll venthyr from NF so they made new toons instead of grinding valour

plush tendon
#

I want to cry

chrome falcon
#

then came to our first SoD raid 10 ilvls lower than their previous NF characters

#

oh, and they also swapped names so communication was a nightmare, so they got their asses kicked

plush tendon
#

Yea, I had 6 people in my raid group reroll

chrome falcon
#

psychopaths.

sweet summit
#

LOL

plush tendon
#

not a single priest yet, not a single shaman

#

and recruiting is hard since server is kind of meh for it

chrome falcon
#

no i'm not even kidding i said to them "if you guys swap your names around i am not inviting you to my raid"

#

and they swapped names, so i didn't invite them to the raid

plush tendon
#

KEK

chrome falcon
#

and they cried on discord that i couldn't take a joke

#

psychopath class.

#

... anyway on topic, i like banner and it's very playable unless you're going seriously bleeding edge keys, but kyrian is definitely a much smoother experience

plush tendon
#

I tried banner for a while, I just came to the conclusion it wasnt worth it

amber herald
#

I wouldn't go venth pala it's hard to get aggro/holy power without DT

plush tendon
#

which sucks cause I love the Necrolord Cov

chrome falcon
#

i enjoy the gameplay a LOT more now that i have the legendary

#

getting an 80 second long banner uptime is πŸ‘Œ

plush tendon
#

Yea, but losing reprisal is sad

#

😦

#

but I guess with Bolster its ok

chrome falcon
#

Eh, true, you have to play with bolster instead of AM as well

#

But I've found that my damage keeps up relatively well

#

I'm normally a few 100 dps behind what the good kyrian warriors in here post but

#
  1. i'm just not as good as them in keys and 2) i think the banner buff is making up for it, hopefully
#

mikky buff might be too good to pass up on though...

plush tendon
#

I do, on average depending on dungeon, between 4.6k-5k taking out dungeon buffs and what not

jagged pier
#

that seems low

chrome falcon
#

If i have a good run i'm hitting like 5.5k in 18s

plush tendon
jagged pier
plush tendon
#

well, im only thinking about this current week

#

but yea, could definitely pump harder

#

Mists is a different story of course

#

that dungeon is stonks... but we aint running a lot of mists atm

jagged pier
#

6.1 in SD

#

like 5.8 in HoA today

plush tendon
#

I want to pull big in HoA..... but we dont do interrupts well

sweet summit
#

mood

jagged pier
#

^^

distant crystal
#

if people would just not kick the damned curse

plush tendon
#

and SD is easy pump though cause we do get that buff right

#

super fun

distant crystal
#

i swear that's most of the problem

plush tendon
#

Bolts literally 25% of my damage taken

#

super scary

short apex
#

the fucking bolts chunk so hard man

plush tendon
#

I just run in, rotate through my CDs, once thats up im out

short apex
#

i feel like i have so many disrupting tools with shockwave, aftershock and spellreflext

sweet summit
#

and why the fuck do the bolts have like a 90 yard range 😠

#

i swear

short apex
#

and when their done i just eat 3 bolts and im dead

sweet summit
#

they are hacking

plush tendon
#

gotta find a nice tree to hide behind

#

or stairs

sweet summit
#

the house or w/e on the left isnt even LoS!!?!?!

#

fuming

plush tendon
#

you also can interrupt with stuns+knockdowns, but they just immediately start casting again!

crystal iris
#

Heroic Painsmith, can you shield block to mitigate the hammer hit? of does it only work if youre in melee range of the boss

jagged pier
#

u cannot

#

u need to cd and IP

plush tendon
#

it doesnt hurt too much

crystal iris
#

yeah i usually demo shout and IP and its fine

short apex
#

just be vulpera to freely mitigate some p2/3 dmg lmao

#

afaik 2/3 phase hammers do some fire/magic dmg so you can spellreflect if u feel like u need to mitigate more

dusky canopy
#

Usually hitting 5k-5.5k in the 15-17s

#

I know it could be more if I pull bigger but I only pug so I try not to rely on the group as much as I can

jagged pier
#

i only pug

#

🀷

plush tendon
#

I never pug; the bois just be monkies

dusky canopy
#

In my experience it's most runs with overlapping stuns and interrupts and I'm taking way more avoidable damage than I should be due to bad cc

#

The only big pulls I like doing are in ardenwield dos and gauntlet SD I've had the most success there

#

I've tried the double bug pack towards the end of mots but it seems like those big shield casts get off everytime lol

shy coral
#

do you use the threat bar in elvui?

distant crystal
#

there's no shield casters in the normal doublepack

#

that's the staghorn

#

You can actually do a triple there and there's only 1 staghorn to kick

chrome falcon
#

spell reflect is a good and normal spell

sweet summit
#

buff spell reflect

plush tendon
#

Spell Reflect in Spires

jagged pier
#

make it reflect every thing for 6 seconds like it used to

plush tendon
#

Yesterday was the first time the bois didnt interrupt the ethers after I yelled at them for months

distant crystal
#

make it reflect everything on the whole party for 6 seconds deswind

chrome falcon
#

@jagged pier dude pls i miss that so much

#

reflecting 3 chaos bolts in arcway? mmmmm

jagged pier
blazing condor
#

Spell reflect being my 3rd highest damage in the previous spires i did

distant crystal
#

spell reflect being the highest dmg in the whole party on first boss ToS yep

plush tendon
#

Stonks

#

Spell Reflect in BFA was juicy

hallow smelt
#

Fastest way to renown farm?

sweet summit
#

think its torghast layer 9 spam

hallow smelt
#

just run / skip to end?

#

if I d M0 can i get renown from all bosses?

sweet summit
#

ya just speed run it
idk about the m0 one

plush tendon
#

take yo time, wait for resets and get big renown gains from Assaults, rescue soul quests, callings, and the two world bosses

#

world bosses give like 3 renown if you are low enough

hallow smelt
#

ty ty

jagged pier
#

yes

steady flint
#

does anyone have the numbers on average shield wall cd using the wall legendary?

misty charm
#

guys i have only been playing m+ so far and now gotta tank HC today, what talents do i take? i thought 3112231?

#

or do i take heavy rep?

misty charm
#

yea ive seen those on the wowhead guide but i wasnt sure because im using reprisal and also i thought heavy rep could be better?

plush tendon
#

Heavy Rep not necessary in raid

misty charm
#

also we only have 3 meeles, should i still take into the fray?

jagged pier
#

yes theres a boss

#

and your co tank

#

and probably a holy paladin

lean moth
#

Yes. You want as much haste as possible. Also AM gives you more uptime of avatar and more revenge procs of shield slam

misty charm
#

no holy's

lean moth
#

Deeps. You can be a pumper too

misty charm
#

did someone say

steady flint
# ionic fern ~1.5

is that together with anger management or is that just purely without?

misty charm
#

revenj? πŸ‘€

#

got it, im gona use seismic reverb

jagged pier
#

in raid?

#

seems a bit pointless

misty charm
#

wtb BSC vs BV?

misty charm
lean moth
#

Depends if you need damage or not. Typically in raid BV is better as far as I am aware

#

Unless you are progging and need to meet dps checks. You have to be very on point with reprisal use constantly to get the most value

plush tendon
#

Booming voice tends to do more damage in ST then BSC as far as I'm aware

merry ocean
#

πŸ€”

misty charm
#

got it ty

hollow sun
#

Haven't timed a single dos this week

#

From 17 to 13

blazing condor
#

Sylvanas is a Wall-fight right?

jagged pier
#

yus

blazing condor
#

fank u

nova surge
#

Is pelagos still the best tanking soulbind?

azure lantern
#

He's not a Soulbind for Necrolord so obvi not!

nova surge
#

It's Kyrian, why to tank as a necrolord and not as a Kyrian?

jagged pier
#

mikanos

zenith vigil
#

night fae gang rise up

azure lantern
#

I was joking. I'm only just now leveling my Warrior so don't listen to what I have to say. Although I AM going Necrolord for flavor so

nova surge
jagged pier
#

it does none of that

nova surge
#

Stat's overall?

zenith vigil
#

actually

#

the ability's cc is better

#

but barely

#

they're pretty much equal

nova surge
#

So Minakos atm is the best choise cause you can have a 20 sec cooldown redaction in mythics

#

I mean, i am using the spear on CD

amber herald
#

it sims 400+dps for me now too

#

the spear thing is going to send mikanikos to the moon

zenith vigil
#

stonks

amber herald
#

I can't quite remember but kyrian is better on less targets I think

#

nightfae needs to hit at least 5 targets to do all its damage

chrome falcon
#

What would you guys use for keys that actually hurt on fortified like 18+ out of a 246 scale, a 233 anima emitter, and a 239 aegis

#

I honestly might just go with the double on-use

amber herald
#

I'd run aegis and a dps trinket

chrome falcon
#

i've been going scale+emitter and the emitter does feel good but some of these packs are kinda just chewing me up

amber herald
#

I'd run aegis and scale in DOS this week

chrome falcon
#

yeah DOS 19 made me feel like i really wanted double on use that's specifically what i'm thinking of

amber herald
#

aegis is better it's functionally an immunity for 8 seconds

#

highest I've done is a 17 PF this week but I didn't notice my health go down at all with it active

chrome falcon
#

PF's real easy this week as long as you have a disease guy

amber herald
#

true (although I did it with 4 melee lmao)

chrome falcon
#

oof

amber herald
#

some random pug I joined

chrome falcon
#

i dunno i just think aegis in DOS is like

amber herald
#

the DH kept momentuming into packs and dieing lmfao

chrome falcon
#

oh ok cool you took the 35k shadowstrike down to 29k very nice i am still extremely fucking dead

amber herald
#

yeah

chrome falcon
#

so i dunno maybe nothing can save you from that shit

amber herald
#

that's why I'd run both (if I had both 😒 )

#

shadowcore needs group co-ordinated interrupts that's about it

#

otherwise it's floor inspection time

chrome falcon
#

what's a "group co-ordinated interrupt"

amber herald
#

interrupts

#

people interrupt in a sequence

#

it doesn't happen in pugs

chrome falcon
#

it doesn't happen in most runs in my experience

#

it's taken a while but i've just about managed to persuade my guild that they don't need to kick the first wicked bolt that Obliterators cast in HoA

amber herald
#

you either have instinct interuppters or people who never interrupt in pugs

#

both are bad for shadowcore

strong forum
#

A group coordinated interrupt is when every single dps uses their kick at the same time

chrome falcon
#

slam interrupt every cast you see so you have the "well MY kick was on cooldown" excuse

#

100% uptime

#

i really wanted to do a 20 this week but my group has 3 19 or 20 DOS keys

amber herald
#

nothing quite like watching the entire kick tracker light up on rebellious fist and then the entire party dying in the next 10s from casts

#

it's funny if you're not invested in the key weird

#

man... I think DOS is the hardest dungeon this week that's some bad luck

chrome falcon
#

HOA is probably harder if your group has bad kicks

drifting glade
#

do the shards of domination buffs affect anything for us

zenith vigil
drifting glade
#

oops, thanks

zenith vigil
latent pier
#

got scale on first DoS run, but still don't have a shield or mainhand

#

:(

drifting glade
#

wait which pins

#

this channel's pins?

#

does that take into account the recent buffs

jagged pier
#

i mean they buffed are best set

#

what do u think

drifting glade
#

i dont get paid to think

#

but i think i have received the message

#

thank u

dense gate
#

Is codex of the first technique trash? Stamina obviously very meh but the proc looks like it could be really good

obtuse monolith
#

Pug Tarragrue on every difficulty you can. Shield will come

strong forum
latent pier
#

Sadly my warrior is still a rat, so probably can only get normal for now.

dense gate
#

in keys essentially a 10% DR proc looks really good or am I missing something

strong forum
#

if its RNG its not good

dense gate
#

fair

strong forum
#

it doesnt save you in any way

#

getting the proc on 3 targets

#

then not getting it on a big pull

dense gate
#

Makes sense. Kinda dont wanna run double on use but scale+aegis looks so strong lol

strong forum
#

then just a regular human being and dont use scale when you have aegis

#

double on use is only for the omega dumbo tryhards in ultra keys

dense gate
#

I aspire to be one of them one day

strong forum
#

rip

lavish oracle
#

I kinda like double on use as a tank

#

It's nice to have a couple extra defensive buttons

jagged pier
#

i tried it once this season

#

it was a waste of a trinket slot

#

i never used scale

blazing condor
#

do we only taunt on arrows on p1 sylv? or any stacks on banshee's mark? I get 6 stacks and it kind of trucks me when i run out with arrow

jagged pier
#

when i wanted something i ither had cds or aegis

sacred timber
#

Holy paladins deserve to be shot

#

holy crap

#

2.1k hps in a +14

strong forum
sacred timber
#

trying to pump dmg instead of healing

#

"noob tank" with more healing than him

#

No tank trinkets, barely any vers.

lavish oracle
#

I mean, 2.1k is low even if they're dpsing the whole time, lol

next burrow
#

it do be like that @sacred timber and fellow upcoming tanks... theres a reason we have a " ignore pain " button for irl too

blazing condor
#

usually hpals just go full dam instead of healing

#

and still do like 3k dps overall

#

and 2k hps

sacred timber
#

I mean, he did "4k dps" but it should even count cause half of his dps was from javelins

plush tendon
#

we dont count weapons to damage

#

he did 2k

#

πŸ˜›

modern brook
#

Imagine bringing meters up in a nw

sacred timber
#

Also, I dont think Im doing that bad for a 230 ilvl tank with no vers gear or no scale

lavish oracle
#

you don't need vers gear

#

or scale

#

but you're doing fine

sacred timber
#

That ToP was close

#

we were 4 min off with no wipes

plush tendon
#

The biggest thing is just playing well; you can get KSM on any week by just pressing W through the dungeon

#

The only limiting factor is honestly how much damage can your dps do

lilac bloom
#

wow.. sylvanas heroic.. require ppl who are over ilevel 230.. some even require i level 235

sacred timber
#

especially with reprisal

#

cause all them free shield blocks

plush tendon
#

Prot is very good on the defensive and damage front

lilac bloom
#

yah reprisal is good

plush tendon
#

but you dont need a lego to get KSM either

#

hell, it may be time for one of us to level a Warrior with no Cov and no lego and get KSM to prove a point XD

#

like the BDKs

sacred timber
#

I have a lego for every warrior spec, arms (signet/enduring), prot (reprisal), and fury (signet)

jagged pier
#

i mean its what u find comfortable i already had KSM at 226 this season

next burrow
#

hmm guys been checking the pins but dont see any suggested secondary stats etc...

blazing condor
#

^^

plush tendon
#

Haste>everything else

jagged pier
#

ilvl> that everything

plush tendon
#

I level supersedes everything but rings and necks

next burrow
#

even for raid sir?

plush tendon
#

yep

sacred timber
#

My first key I ran this season was at 224 and we timed a +17, but it was fury which is my main spec, but I am tired of not getting into key on fury

#

cause 2010 io on week two i guess just isn't enough for people.

plush tendon
#

lol, pugs are dumb

#

we did a 15 PF the first week with 4 warriors and a holy priest

#

and it was Tyrannical; that first boss was a shit show but hilarious

#

lining up our spell reflects for stomp and then using fears for the adds XD

sacred timber
#

yea, just bought ksm 9 days after the patch you know? terrible player, only 2200 io in preseason and 1600 io last s1. fucking abysmal fury player

plush tendon
#

Pug life is just terrible

#

However, I will always recommend that if you can play tank for keys, do so

#

DPS are a dime a dozen, tanks are like gold for pugs

ocean yoke
#

every time i try dpsing a key i just get annoyed by something the tank does i would do different and go back

next burrow
#

i only know pug life thug life

jagged pier
#

@ionic fern 9.1 cheatsheet when Detective

ionic fern
#

9.1 Cheatsheet = Read the guides.

jagged pier
#

πŸ˜†

next burrow
#

@zenith vigil oops didnt see them on top ! soz~~

zenith vigil
#

smh this guy doesn't wanna do a bunch of work for no compensation whatsoever

#

boo mwahi, boo

ionic fern
#

Jeah, i'm a shameful person. 😦

zenith vigil
short gust
#

I am trying to improve my mythic plus tanking strategies and skills. Last season I mostly healed while I did get my tank to a 1500 raider.io score. While healing, I watched a streamer named Growl (yumy) who would post tip videos as well as analyze viewer submitted runs. With those videos, I was able to get KSM on my healers while pugging. I realize pug life is terrible, but it’s my only option as I can’t find players/guilds in my time zone (Hawaii).
All this is background to ask a question: is there a streamer who does what Growl does for prot warriors? I’ve read every guide and observed tanks from the healer perspective but cannot seem to lead successfully timed groups past m11 keys. Thanks!

plush tendon
#

If you like Growl, take a look into Dorki

#

for general tank help

#

Also, gotta give a shoutout to Plka if you are looking for Prot War specific stuff;

short gust
#

That’s awesome, thank you

distant crystal
#

bonus points if you find Dorki's stream by asking growl

#

"Does the bear stream?"

covert sentinel
#

do we have a lazy option for m+ for when you're tired of playing reprisal?

chilly brook
#

I mean you could run the wall and bolster

#

But its 100% worse

#

Like it really isn't much effort to intervene someone next to you every 30 seconds

#

And to charge every now and again

blazing condor
#

Does Veil of darkness spawn on players or not?

sweet summit
#

p1 and p2 spawns around players
p3 is literally ontop of players

blazing condor
#

ty ty

chilly brook
#

You want to stack in p2

#

And loose spread before it in p3

#

If everyone stacks in p2 its trivial to avoid

#

People getting hit with it in p2 is honestly bad news and pretty much can cause wipes

amber herald
#

that's pretty easy

wanton panther
#

Hey guys with the new domination set bonus buffs which do you think will work better ?

#

Currently I tried blood and the amount of dmg and healing was so little that I chose to use Dyz and Kyr instead.

blazing condor
chilly brook
#

And you can drop stuff like windrush totem to make it even easier

#

P3 is make sure your dispels are in order and that your arrows get out and then its just down to beating the dps check

blazing condor
#

we used roar for each one

#

But idk theyre always everywhere

#

Guildies just not doing their job πŸ™‚

ocean yoke
#

@wanton panther blood was already good and will be even better. do you have them upgraded? theyre already a huge part of my damage with just a few levels

wanton panther
#

They will for sure get better but I am thinking maybe frost will be better after the buff.

ocean yoke
#

ill be curious to see how it goes but i would guess blood will still be a bit above, kyr is definitely a nice gem on its own

#

as it stands on it own i had kills this week where blood link was my second/third highest dmg source at like 400+ dps

#

the upgrades might just buff it

#

a lot

jagged pier
#

@strong forum

strong forum
jagged pier
#

i may have pissed off a few melee

ocean yoke
#

we are technically melee too theyll get over it

brittle owl
#

melee dps are concave skulls anyway

woven bear
#

I'm at sylv hc and I getting a shitload of shadow dmg per second, also the heartseeker do a loot of damage. I guess you can't spellreflect those (at least you can't the wailing arrows), so I'm wondering if you have some tips there?

cold zealot
# woven bear I'm at sylv hc and I getting a shitload of shadow dmg per second, also the heart...

Physical component of her heartseeker is blockable, Shadow damage geht's reduced by reflect.
If you rotate Tanks between each Cast of that and you layer Block+reflect+ignore IT should barely be noteiceable on your healthbar.

As Form the wailing Arrow, communicate to be Topped when leaping Out late or use Last Stand or Wall or scale there.

If you have Problems with p3 wailing arrows, ots basically the Same but Fall your healers to Focus and top you More.
At least thats what i would do with 2 Tanks in heroic

#

Sorry for any spelling mistakes but the German autocorrect is weird.

ocean yoke
#

the wall is also a bit better for sylv because of all the magic dmg if youre not running that already

woven bear
#

πŸ˜„ you mean I can spell reflect the heartseekers?

cold zealot
#

True but a signifikant damage loss IMO.
I only use Wall, when solotanking syvalas hc

ocean yoke
#

nah just spell reflect for the magic dmg reduction

#

unfortunately

cold zealot
woven bear
#

okay I tried to reduce the damage of wailing arrow with spell reflect, maybe that's not worth it

cold zealot
#

Wailing Hits for Like 20-30k. No need

#

Use reflect For heartseeker.

ocean yoke
#

the triple hit is the real murderer for sylv over wailing

#

unless youre like 30% for wailing youre goodf

woven bear
#

okay. When I come back from wailing and get the heartseekers in my face thats where it hurts most

cold zealot
#

Yes heartseeker is big ouch If unmitigated but still surviveable with liek 25% at 236ilvl. At least ist was Like that for me today.

cold zealot
woven bear
#

we change after every wailing

ocean yoke
#

are you taking both in p3?

woven bear
#

we don't come to p3 πŸ˜„

ocean yoke
#

ooh so p1 then?

woven bear
#

yeah

cold zealot
#

Hmm almost. Dont have Timer memorized but the big swapper should bei heartseeker. Watch your timers, Sometimes taunt can bei delayed.
And wailing only in p3

ocean yoke
#

yeah for p1 definitely watch heartseeker over the wailing arrow

#

she hardly moves during p1 so it shouldnt be much of a problem

woven bear
#

okay. I'm just wondering why dbm want's the taunt on wailing then

cold zealot
#

As an example, start will ne:
Pull
Heartseeker
Wait dir wail to target
Swap
And after that you Swap when the active Tank would get 2 hearrseekers in a row.
IT ist heartseeker Info wail the active Tank Takes both.
Thus was you geht pretty Clean Swaps.

#

Fuck dbm or bigwigs calls. Learn whats Important amd Makes semse

woven bear
#

okay i'll try that next time as you said

#

was our first tries on sylc hc so it's still learning πŸ˜„

#

thanks for your input

#

do you get similar dtps as I in p1 (logs above)

#

that's the only fight where I take more dmg than our monk, usually i'm way below him

ocean yoke
#

yeah ive had basically one full night on it so far until later tonight and p1 definitely felt weird timings wise for me

cold zealot
#

Sadly i cant Post you logs where or is executes that was. Only Killer her 9n solotanking pulls

#

Youll geht the hang of the timers after a des pulls. Just Focus on when you can taunt after heartseeker + wail and also when ahe will use heartseeker Back to Back.

ocean yoke
#

our p1 pull wipes werent far off yours though from what i can tell, once you get used to p1 you move on quick

cold zealot
#

And Then dps and heals Stadt dying to arrows or rive and you Reset over and over again....

ocean yoke
#

ok we had one p1 wipe pull there we are pretty similar damage taken wise

#

youll be good just need more reps on the fight for everyone

#

remember if theres a wipe its usually the other 18 people fault

woven bear
#

@ocean yoke yeah but I can't change the others, so I look what I can change, and I feel like I'm getting raped by shadow damage πŸ˜„

#

that's why i'm asking

#

thatnks a lot for your input

ocean yoke
#

yeah totally

cold zealot
#

If you really struggle Fall for externals.

ocean yoke
#

its easily the toughest fight for us and the most tank centric really

cold zealot
#

Call

ocean yoke
#

cant block dots sadly

woven bear
#

yeah if I call for externals I don't get them usually, so I try to avoid it

cold zealot
#

If you are taking heavy damage the solutions Always Go. CDs...externals...Pump ip

cold zealot
#

Or even better their Name. Call 3s early, so they have time to react.

woven bear
#

@cold zealot yeah, been there done that πŸ˜„ no chance πŸ˜„

cold zealot
#

Whts the Point in raiding premade Then If you cant communicate together honestly....

woven bear
#

yeah different people have different skill levels πŸ˜„

cold zealot
#

If you want to success as a guild this ist crucial and can smooth Out so many issued.

ocean yoke
#

if you need one try to figure out a specific spot to ask for it each fight too

#

so they dont use it on their own intiative if you need it

pine slate
#

do i wanna craft reprisal on legs or feet? looks like people are split on raider.io

nimble laurel
#

Legs give more stats

cinder roost
#

@woven bear I would make the monk take all the wailing, can give you my rota for P1 and P3 if you want

woven bear
#

@cinder roost yeah i'm open to new strategies πŸ˜„

pale hawk
#

hey lads im trash at making my own decisions. 220 with haste vers or 236 crit haste. thanks in advance ❀️

lofty widget
#

ilvl beats everything if it's an armor piece

modern brook
#

Crit haste

#

It's more

plush tendon
#

@jagged pier are you proud of me

lavish oracle
#

ouch, that balance damage

amber herald
#

what was mr moonkin upto for that key

plush tendon
#

I think he was being carried by the dK

uneven river
#

So what's people's thoughts on the new shard balancing moving forward assuming blood still the way to go if you actually get the rev from wb what's second choice ?

cinder roost
#

@woven bear Still around?

tame sleet
#

can we heroic leap painsmiths spiked balls?

pearl pasture
tame sleet
#

ty

pine slate
#

trying to decide between nf and kyrian for prot/arms

zenith vigil
#

read the guide

sick sentinel
#

For heroic guardian, you taunt before the second obliterate right? I've got people telling me to wait until the cast bar shows up

#

that seems wrong

#

we've only had a couple pulls last raid night and it seemed inconsistent?

fierce relic
#

i taunt during the cast on the other tank

sick sentinel
#

taunt during the first cast?

fierce relic
#

yup. tank gets hit, my group soaks, then i move out

#

first tank gets hit with sunder, obliterate is casted during which i taunt

sick sentinel
#

ok, maybe i was just late on the taunt then

#

i swear i got the taunt off before 2nd oblit but other tank still took two

fossil valley
#

how does SR interact with Ritual of Woe cast? just reflects 1 tick of dmg I assume? or can it stop the beam if used before cast ?

#

the halls last boss channel on statues

cinder nova
next burrow
#

anyone tried how much blood link actually heals fer?

real thunder
#

Stupid question, are there portals in santum that help you not have to run so far to get back to bosses? Like mirrors in Castle Nathria?

cinder nova
#

It varies based on the tier their set is, but you can check the healing in an encounter.

next burrow
#

man i feel so dumb to ask this but i dont get the wording for the set bonus for blood

#

i have helm, chest, gloves

#

Helm has unholy 3 bonus written

#

chest has blood 3 bonus written

#

glove has just dom sockets

#

so when i slot 3 blood nothing happens?

mossy peak
#

if you have the chest, then you have the 3 set, but are you currently in the maw or a maw area

#

it will only activate in those places

next burrow
#

omg....

mossy peak
#

same thing as set bonuses, they say

next burrow
#

i have been socketing and unsocketing but no clue that i wasnt in maw or sod

#

dear lord.

mossy peak
#

the gems themselves apply everywhere

#

so you can do whatever you want and pick your favorite gems

#

bathe in that .44% damage buff

#

feel its weight

sturdy sable
#

.44 stacking*

pine cypress
#

The upcoming tunings to the shards change what we should go for at all or still blood all the way?

ocean yoke
#

reprisal is a drug im never gonna be able to quit

#

good lord i feel so slow without it

delicate iron
#

You can also leap over the spikes but you probably know that

jagged pier
wide pilot
#

Anyone else seem to play a little sloppy in 15s with shield block usage? Seems like when I do 15s or lower my uptime is significantly lower than say when I do a 17

mossy peak
#

just charge n intervene more

#

unless you're using seismic in 15s and reprisal in 17s

#

in which case theres your answer

hollow sun
#

you probably focus less on playing optimally

#

is it possible to filter warcraft logs to be only from season 2?

urban portal
#

Wclogs should be season 2 only

hollow sun
#

every high key i look at is prideful

urban portal
hollow sun
#

nvm, that happened to me some days ago. Now i can't find pridefuls anymorre

urban portal
#

There's a filter

bronze forge
#

can anyone recommend a noob tank friendly plater xD

fringe marten
#

Adam, there's a pretty popular preset that I think is recommended along with the addon itself; I think most people use that as the 'baseline'

blazing condor
#

Alternatively you can get the ThreatPlates addon but maybe you want plater specifically

#

That addon does everything automatically p much

fringe marten
#

But yeah I went in raw and tweaked the begeezus out of it until I liked it; I would honestly recommend doing the same. Although it takes some time, and a little testing..reading each of the options while you set them up has you kind of considering real world settings and how you'd want to see it for yourself. Rather than slapping in a preset and 'going'

#

I haven't used threatplates in a very long time but I get the impression it's kind of a 'light' or easy version of plater similar to something like KUInameplates.

bronze forge
#

oh i didnt know that it was just to check for threat and etc

fringe marten
#

I used to use KUI, until I got plater.

#

You know how weak spined humans who play NOT prot warriors use things like...ElvUI ?

#

Plater is like our ElvUI almost.

#

It's dense AF, has a million options and is very granular...and is absolutely worth taking the time to tweak 'just' how you like it.

bronze forge
#

i'll give a few a go i used one beofre it took up half my screen in bars i didnt really like that too much

fringe marten
#

(all kidding aside plater does a LOT more than just have a nice threat indicator for hp bars; but it looks a little intimidating at first..but all the options are self explanatory and have real time adjustments so you can just look at mobs HP bars/players/etc and tweak until done..without reloading ui or relogging)

#

If you want lighter ui elements, but a lot of control over what you see...combine Shadowed Unit frames with Plater.

#

Other tank 'ui' tools I'd recommend would of course be the obligatory Weak auras, but also OPie, and OmniCD

bronze forge
#

ill have a good look now

fringe marten
#

OPie is almost explicity for world markers; but especially raiding you may need those..or in pug raids. You can also assign potions and stuff to it which is what I also do.

hollow sun
#

If i had to choose only one addon to play with, i would pick plater over weak auras

#

a good profile is this one

#

tweak it in the way you like, and disable the color scripts

tidal holly
#

guys

#

I got question about Piercing lense on boss Eye of the jailer

#

it is psychical dmg

#

but can we reflect it?

sweet summit
#

the add cast yes

tidal holly
#

ok

#

but also shield block is working against it?

#

i mean those adds

sweet summit
#

only the abductor

tidal holly
#

so on adds the best way is just spamming ignore pain +spell reflect?

sweet summit
#

ignore pain/demo shout/spell reflect/shield wall/externals are the only mitigation you have on those adds

tidal holly
#

ok

sweet summit
#

but you should not just spam ignore pain

tidal holly
#

thanks bro

flint needle
#

im new to tank warrior, what soulbinds we go as kyrian ?

sweet summit
#

mikanikos soon ℒ️

#

can go with pelagos until you get renown 57 to unlock the capstone trait of mikanikos

flint needle
#

okey, are there any important conduits i need to get ? or do i just use what i feel ?

ionic fern
sweet summit
#

<@&257983573498265600>

strong forum
#

πŸ”«

#

Die candygasm

sweet summit
#

toxic

ionic fern
#

$pb 461366924195004417

true pawnBOT
#

Done.

sweet summit
#

10q

blazing condor
#

I ran mikanikos in raid yesterday but imma have to swap from the auto-phial cus it pisses me off lol

obsidian rune
#

can Δ± run with elysian might as tank for more damage output ?

blazing condor
#

You can

#

But its not that optimal

rotund thicket
#

how are you guys suviving HoA this week in higher keys? I think i get a PTSD from those bolts

ionic fern
ionic fern
#

Surviving magic damage comes down to your DPS'ers being semi-competent and having Interrupt on their bars.

#

You can't survive that on your own - you might for a pack or two after rotating ALL of your CD's or kiting but after that's done you're still getting slapped.

jagged pier
rotund thicket
ionic fern
#

And again..interrupts.
You have to cordinate them on higher key levels or preferably call them out on voice.

#

DPS players are usually like tiny children, you have to babysit them and pretty much micromanage their interrupts/CC.

#

There are exceptions obviously but it's rare to find one when pugging.

blazing condor
#

Just make sure to press Spell Reflect if your DPS aren’t interrupting - as soon as they see it’s up they will for sure interrupt

trim basin
#

hi guys, im new to tanking as warri and my main problem is aggro, i feel like i cant hold aggro at all?

#

i played other tanks and never had any problems tbh

#

i feel like im missing a button when im playing the devastator talent

ionic fern
#

Simple answer.

#

Revenge

#

You should have 0 aggro issues.

trim basin
#

so should i "spam" revenge

#

i just used it for procs

#

could be my issue then, yes

ionic fern
#

First priority is survival so use your rage on SB. After that's done the majority of your rage should go into Revenges. ignore pain should be used as a rage dump to avoid over capping. You can obviously use IP at other times as we but this is a decision you have to do on the go.

#

For a better perspective..Revenge should be the majority of your damage in m+ (25%+ of your overall)

brazen timber
#

If you have the legendary that gives you SB when you charge in - then your first rage dump should be on revenge not on SB - you'll have plenty of time to get enough rage to cast a proper SB before the legendary-given one runs out

#

thats something i took too long to figure out

trim basin
#

makes sense

#

thanks

#

ill try to do that

mellow bridge
#

Or you just do both because charging with reprisal gives you a revenge proc anyway?

brazen timber
#

oh yeah duh

blazing condor
#

You should also pre-cast ravager into packs so it starts ticking as you charge in

#

Then with the charge if you got reprisal you get the SB and revenge proc

trim basin
#

ye, im doing that already

#

the problem was i was doing so little damage i could not hold aggro

#

prolly because i was just using revenge if it procs

#

never without xD

blazing condor
#

Yeah

#

Probably that

#

Dont neglect shield slam and thunder clap though cus you need that rage

#

But if you do all that it should be totally fine

trim basin
#

am i using the normal M+ build even if im low geared? im just 208 right now

blazing condor
#

you can always AOE taunt or use Heroic Leap to reset taunt cooldown if specific mobs start slipping

#

208 is fine but depends on the levels you do

#

If you do 15s then people will probably out-damage

trim basin
#

am i using the normal talents then?

#

kk sure xD

#

fair

#

how do i AOE taunt though?

sweet summit
#

use Challenging Shout

trim basin
#

omg game changer

#

thanks

blazing condor
#

Its a long cd

#

But nice to have

flint needle
#

what slot should i craft reprisal ?

#

idk aboutt he sockets on plate

jagged pier
#

legs

bold linden
#

Legst

flint needle
#

ty

#

haste vers right ?=

lean moth
#

I typically ravager, charge, TC, avatar, SS, revenge and then just use reprisal leggo to proc revenge while maintaining SB

ionic fern
lean moth
#

yes, hast to 39-40% per the experienced people on here

#

vers less important until higher keys

#

i guess

small beacon
#

hello fellas
i have never played any warrior spec
I dont know if any of y'all ever tried prot pally
but in prot pally's rotation depending on your haste there are times that 0 skills are available to press since everything is on cooldown which feels awkward and is not fun
Does that occur with prot warr by any chance?

brazen timber
#

never

small beacon
#

I wonna try prot warr, just gotta make sure

#

nice

amber herald
#

it can happen for a second or so

#

I think most tanks are like that

#

and energy classes

ionic fern
#

You can almost always press something..but the question is wether that's the smartest decision.
E.g you got 30 Rage so you can use it on Revenge..OR you can save it for SB (if it's about to run out in a few seconds for example).

blazing condor
#

Revenge

amber herald
#

revenj

ionic fern
#

Shield Block.

amber herald
#

revenge to proc shield slam to use shield block Pepexecute

small beacon
#

but im still confused
some of y'all say it never happens some of y'all say it never happens o_O

lean moth
#

@ionic fern, are you the same mwahi on the recent state of prot warrior video?

jagged pier
#

he is

lean moth
#

lol

jagged pier
#

πŸ€”

amber herald
#

it happens to me is all I can say

lean moth
#

cool, i feel like i am in the same room with a celeb hahaa

#

great video though

amber herald
#

but I don't find it to be bad

small beacon
#

thanks a lot you guys <3

ionic fern
#

But these times are very seldom so usually you are pressing something. πŸ™‚

small beacon
#

fast pased spec souds fun Pepexecute

#

and i heard Prot warr's also love haste

#

the more reasons for me to try it Pepexecute

lean moth
#

Is it work just spamming the first 2 charges of SB for when you know you are going to be face tanking just to get charges on cool down and extending the immediate duration, then fill in the gaps with reprisal procs?

jagged pier
#

no

#

u just keep it on cd

#

u should use up your sheild blocks before u start weaving

lean moth
#

Example, charge in (4 secs), do initial threat combo and then use 2 charges of SB, then as that runs out intervene and essentially repeat?

lean moth
#

if that makes sense

jagged pier
#

well yer but like the itervene will get u to the next shield block

ionic fern
#

Don't underestimate my sick Heroic Throw damage in m+.

#

Gotta get that +9.6 DPS.

amber herald
#

charge itself does damage?

ionic fern
#

Do you even Warrior.

obtuse monolith
#

Prot has high cpm because you can pretty much always be pressing something, and the more haste the better.

You end up w gcds where you look for the chance to leap out and charge in, or intervene and charge back, just so you never stop

jagged pier
ionic fern
#

Prot Warrior has high CPM cause we can spam Devastate.

mossy peak
#

you can

amber herald
#

I don't play with damage numbers on greenbear

mossy peak
#

the trick to cpm is just

#

macro off gcd things like revive pets and some toys

#

into your abilities

obtuse monolith
#

Eww devastate. I was so glad once I tried devastator

mossy peak
#

these do show up on logs

ionic fern
#

Gotta get that 99 parse on CPM.

lean moth
#

lol

jagged pier
#

fucking sense and squeak on all his logs

mossy peak
#

i got a r1 as arms, and i do genuinely have a cast of revive pets in that log

jagged pier
#

at like 90 CPM

mossy peak
#

the secret techs are real

velvet acorn
#

anyone know what stats are prio for prot tanks?

#

haste vers right?>

#

gonna make reprisal pants

mossy peak
#

can also swap in crit to be cheeky for damage

#

but otherwise yes

sweet summit
#

ilvl>haste>vers generally yea

north rampart
#

Would i be a fool to make my first 262 siesmic reverb?

#

That double revenge is so satisfying

mossy peak
#

if your primary focus above all else is damage

#

then having more stats on that does equate to more damage

tropic linden
#

Hey, is ZenTracker better than OmniCD? Always used omni, but noticed that omni don't work with VuhDo on more than 5 person

sweet summit
#

i prefer OmniCD for dungeons and ERT for raid content

ivory elbow
#

What are those addons i have both but no idea

blazing condor
#

I assume blood will be our go to still seeing as its getting buffed for dom sockets?

tropic linden
#

U can choose which one

sweet summit
tropic linden
#

Good to track the offensive spells to know if u can big pull

ivory elbow
#

Hmm 🧐 pog

#

I use zen i belive for tracking kicks also and spell relf

#

I made some tweaks to it so it would work with inafable truth thingy in bfa

blazing condor
ivory elbow
#

The name sounded familiar πŸ˜„

tropic linden
#

Yeah, it's the same thing

dim token
#

When does the nine cast the shield? It doesn’t seem to be on the bigwigs timer until he actually cast it

tropic linden
#

Just whatched a video from Max and he uses Zen to track defensives on the raid profile

#

pretty good as healer

tropic linden
#

it's random. He cast one of 6 skills on time, but which one is random

dim token
indigo pagoda
#

how do I get rid of rage when I'm capped, with a shield slam proc, shield block already up, 2xIP and not tanking? dump it into IP in favour of shield slam as quickly as possible or spam revenge?

sweet summit
#

press ignore pain

ionic fern
#

It's off the GCD and "overcapping IP" is not something you should actively worry about.

indigo pagoda
#

how should i handle non-blockable tank abilities such as deathlink and pierce soul? just IP? call of externals?

haughty sleet
#

I think with two ips deathlink only hits for like 11k

indigo pagoda
#

pierce soul average hit the other night was 31k with IP up (dunno how to check how much IP was up tho)

haughty sleet
#

Make that 26k

#

I was wrong

ionic fern
indigo pagoda
#

so on those bosses I use DS as a defensive rather than just popping it on cd? I thought both those abilities weren't reflectable? they're both physical

haughty sleet
#

Wall is strong on eye

indigo pagoda
#

yeah I only managed to craft one legendary so far (was in a rush to get the warrior up to speed for my guild)

#

playing reprisal

#

should be able to craft wall this week tho

#

how do I find good defensive and offensive players on wcl? high damage parsers seem to just be geared with a great healing team, while high heal parses are just IP spam

ionic fern
haughty sleet
#

Being good offensively is kinda tied to having good healers

ionic fern
indigo pagoda
#

mainly wanting to understand the class, but i had two raid nights so far and the issues i had was dying to sylvanas p3 while soaking puddles, taking a lot of damage to pierce soul on the nine and doing low dps (this is mainly because i would ragedump into revenge in order not to overcap ip while having shield slam up and casting thunder clap all too little)

#

I posted my logs in log review if you have some time to take a look

haughty sleet
#

Looking over it, I’m assuming you are missing the third unholy shard?

indigo pagoda
#

yep

haughty sleet
#

Unfortunate

indigo pagoda
#

could I DM you?

#

have some more questions, not sure if I should keep spamming here xD

haughty sleet
#

If you are talking to me sure

indigo pagoda
#

yep :D

ionic fern
indigo pagoda
#

np, appreciate the advice you've given already!

indigo pagoda
shy coral
#

do you use last stand mainly for the heal or for the max hp increase?

jagged pier
#

i use it for damage

shy coral
#

is it better to use it on a pull to increase your max hp vs using it when you're low to heal? how do you use it for damage?

jagged pier
#

^^

shy coral
#

outside of conduits how do you use it?

#

I've been pressing it when my health is low

jagged pier
#

your health should ideally never be low

inland raft
#

kinda want to swap kyrian but idk about losing aa utility in m+ has saved so many runs that had bad kicks

ionic fern
#

1)Before a big hit that you know is going to slap you hard
2)As a panic heal after a f*ck up

shy coral
#

how do you know as a tank if you should heal yourself vs letting the healer do it? I think I waste a lot of cooldowns panicking about my health when my healer could have easily fixed it

ionic fern
#

In a pug?
You don't know.
IN a raid? Ideally you would know the spikes of the fight and consistency of your healers.

#

ALso - our CD's are ment to be used BEFORE we take the damage to mitigate it not after we have already taken it.

#

The only exception is LS (without Bolster).

plush tendon
#

Miss my lion Soulshape and my 12 second knockdown

inland raft
#

Ya its what im scared of, nf has been sole reason for many keys being timed with bad kicks

modern brook
#

Oh wait bvm ur the guy leveling tanks

#

Just hammer that shit on cd

#

You don't gain more value for using it as a heal vs using it before you take any damage, as long as you're getting hit it'll find value

ionic fern
modern brook
# ionic fern ?Context

Spiffo's been in here for a couple of days asking for advice on tanking etc at ~ lvl 25?

#

so i corrected my advice, becasue saying "hey idiot run unnerving focus" to a guy playing a 30 something prot warrior isnt helpful

fickle prawn
#

Anyone had much success with the Guardian of the First Ones trinket 'Reactive Defense Matrix'? It seems like it could be solid for M+ if it has a high enough proc rate.

frosty holly
#

Just started tanking a bit again in M+ Any changes i should make to conduits?

ornate flicker
#

Go korayn and have some fun

modern brook
#

as i say:

frosty holly
#

Thanks!

modern brook
#

unnerving and Stalwart

#

if you get a 3rd, anima sphere

sweet summit
#

korayn πŸ“ˆ

modern brook
#

Also yeah korayn for m+ cause first strike

modern brook
frosty holly
#

I'm mainly Arms so using Dreamweaver for Raid and Kor for M+. That left Niya for Prot

modern brook
#

I wouldnt be surprised if niyais better for arms in m+ than kor is tbh

frosty holly
#

I got annoyed that when i don't tank, the tanks move out of Niyas burrs

modern brook
#

My entire reasoning is the mastery steroids

#

esp with the capstone

#

disclaimer: all feels listen to #arms not me

#

and also erga is a hackerman; just do that

frosty holly
#

Thanks for all the info πŸ™‚

grizzled forge
#

think 57 mikanikos spear gonna take over NF in damage in a key?

modern brook
#

pretty sure they basically even

grizzled forge
#

even now

#

or after mika?

#

last trait

modern brook
#

even now

#

and even after mika last trait

#

the omega secret of prot

#

is that no decision you've made has ever made the difference

grizzled forge
#

why would it stay even?

#

with spear esentially being 40 seconds

modern brook
#

Because NF also gets things

plush tendon
#

you need it to hit 5 targets for the 40 seconds

grizzled forge
#

ya when are you not

#

pulling 5 targets in a key

plush tendon
#

ToP

#

XD

modern brook
#

more generally; most boss fights

#

in general spear suffers from not trucking as hard as NF w/o the legendary

#

so yeah you get more casts

#

but its competeing with First strike AA

#

which already puts the bar pretty high

grizzled forge
#

most dont run first strike they run pod or grove

modern brook
#

who the fuck is running pod

inland raft
#

Arms runs niya or dreamweaver, prot runs korayn

#

First strike pumps and makes aggro simpler even on most aggressive of dps

jagged pier
#

also in raid it seems that kyrian isnt that far off in terms of damage even running reprisal compared to natures fury nightfae, its still behind but by like ~200dps in key u wont be running that

#

so boss damage is kind of the same

lucid pasture
#

holy fuck aegis is broken @jagged pier thank you for telling me to use it

modern brook
#

the only reason i can think of to run dreamweaver as prot is you're using korayn and niya for a dps spec

#

I've never played prot warrior and thought "dang i really wish i had a cheat death with a 10s delay that drops combat for my team if im the last alive

#

i mean i guess dw is a tier above the rest rn?

#

was enough to run in in CN prog

grizzled forge
#

ya if you use it well itll do alot in overall in a key

plush tendon
#

Also, does the mastery granted by Niya or Pelagos get applied before or after the damage from the Cov ability?

modern brook
#

at the same time

lucid pasture
#

holy fuck tho that trinket literally made my genitalia grow at least like 5 meters

modern brook
#

also both damages are dynamic

#

so it doesnt really matter

distant crystal
#

matters for some other classes tho

blazing condor
#

😳

ancient monolith
#

Is Aegis > Hakkar trinket?

strong forum
#

Yes

jagged pier
#

yes

ancient monolith
#

regardless if it's Tyr or Fort?

jagged pier
#

both

lucid pasture
ancient monolith
#

interesting

distant crystal
#

scale is better in raid

#

aegis is better in keys

lucid pasture
#

also kinda not bad dmg for a defensive trinket ngl

distant crystal
#

go figure

lucid pasture
#

goddamn

sweet summit
#

is it still doing world quest trinket damage?

#

@strong forum @jagged pier

jagged pier
#

thats the damage it actually does

#

just shows up as the trinket on logs

#

its not great

#

but to reduce that much damage i think the trade off is worth it tbh

distant crystal
#

guildy swore up and down that shard was better than aegis in all situations

#

now he begs me to run guardian loot spec to roll for an aegis kek

jagged pier
#

DR > absorb

ancient monolith
#

I have 252 scale so I figure that is better than hc version of aegis

jagged pier
#

nope

ancient monolith
#

I don't have any aegis btw

sweet summit
#

ah

#

cringe

#

thought there was hope

#

for a broken tank trinket

jagged pier
#

lfr aegis can be more damage reduction than 252 shard

ancient monolith
distant crystal
#

if you give it enough targets

jagged pier
distant crystal
#

now i've got jakey saying shard when he means scale

#

it's contagious

jagged pier
#

🀷

plush tendon
#

The only advantage of BSS is that its damage is instant; so if you are a blood dk struggling for aggro...

distant crystal
#

i wonder if aegis is extra busted for brews

#

since it counts as healing

#

i still need to check my theory that blood set dps scales with celestial

obtuse monolith
indigo pagoda
#

we swap on every Deathlink so our raid doesn't take any damage, but good to know if anything were to go wrong, thanks!

lucid pasture
#

and i never believed him

#

guess i was right...

plucky ember
#

For M Eye, I take 1st with SW and IP, for 3rd Deathlink I do Last Stand, Spell Reflect, Demoralizing, IP. Healers were much happier than when it was my co-tank BDK's turn to take Deathlink for 2 and 4.

modern brook
#

isnt death link phyiscal?

plush tendon
#

it is

modern brook
dusky canopy
plush tendon
#

The ability to lockdown a pack with AA cannot be understated

nimble laurel
#

Switched from Kyrian 2 weeks ago after being very worried about losing spear, and now I don't want to go back.

#

Soul shape cannot be understated

plush tendon
#

Im Kyrian right now, its just 'meh'

#

Strong, effective, and Phial is great, but NF was just a lot more satisfying for me

#

If it were last tier and you needed a Kyrian for your M+ group, I would stay, but we dont need to be Kyrian anymore with rise of Arcane, Kyiran hunters, and WW

nimble laurel
#

The biggest thing I struggle with right now is constantly switching conduits for arms and prot. I'm also out of the conduit coin things.

plush tendon
#

do you arms in raid and prot in keys?

nimble laurel
#

Arms in raid and both in keys

plush tendon
#

Dreamweaver isnt a bad option for arms TBH

nimble laurel
#

Maybe for ST? Can't turn down korayn for m+

ionic fern
plush tendon
#

Potential solution; set Niya for Prot in M+, Korayn Arms M+, dreamweaver Arms Raid

#

or what Mwahi suggested

#

hes so smart

nimble laurel
foggy meadow
#

I don't know, if I get something fundamentally wrong, but... Do I read the ressources linked under #268491842637660160 correct and is shield block without effect when tanking the eye of the jailor in sod? (i mean, when not tanking the add)

dusky canopy
#

It's super satisfying for me to charge into a pack spend a second or two grouping up the pack and then slapping them for like 15% of there HP with AA

sweet summit
#

the only reason to use SB when on the eye and not taking the abductor is for SS damage

foggy meadow
#

That's what i assumed, when i read it, but I couldn't really believe it. Okay... Thanks... Feels a little bit disappointing.

nimble laurel
#

is SB + SS > Revenge for single target damage when you aren't taking physical damage?

karmic plinth
#

if you get 2 shield slams in the shield block charge it beats revenge for rage to damage

nimble laurel
#

Good to know. I was just thinking about this recently with Coldheart in m+ since there is hardly any tank damage.

tropic linden
errant timber
#

Greetings, I have a question for Kyrian pals, is mikanikos that much worth over pelagos offensively, specially from next week, on raids?

blazing condor
#

You can definitely still play pelagos if you prefer. But mikanikos will be higher dam

chilly brook
#

Sim yourself for raid

#

It's entirely possible that mikanikos isn't a dps upgrade in single target

#

Certainly isn't for arms

plucky ember
tropic linden
#

I think u can cast the shout for every deathlink, right?

placid oar
#

Hi guys, can I ask if sticking to Pelagos is the better choice for tanks or actually better to swap soulbinds once we hit renown 57 for Kyrian?

Am trying to understand the thought process and whys.

outer solstice
distant crystal
#

you're not a real absorb

#

and you're not my real dad

lucid pasture
lucid pasture
#

Aswell as trying to maximize reprisal

#

Using shield Block as a damage enhancer pog plus its good rage n shit

#

And the and from chains can get tanked a bit easier with shieldblock up

plucky ember
#

Ive been going Wall on M Eye to squeeze an extra SW at the beginning of each add phase and then have it up for Deathlink after.

outer solstice
#

btw anyone knows if the spare meat hook sims correct?

#

or is there some problem with it?

modern brook
#

SMH is fatty damage

#

if thats the q

strong forum
plush tendon
#

better then anything else...

strong forum
#

If you use scale for dmg then πŸ‘‰ πŸšͺ

plush tendon
#

Its specifically for BDK

blazing condor
#

Scale for damage is the play

#

Idc

#

πŸšͺ πŸšΆβ€β™‚οΈ

next burrow
#

guys i dont get the timings for slyvanas H, you taunt after she jumps up to shoot the other tank 3 times right? i still feel her shots hurt when shes targeting me even with SB up..