hello everyone. Been tanking since expansions and ages past. ditched prot in favour of bdk around end of wrath,had a prot phase in mists but that was it. bdk ever since. i want to get back into prot properly now as an alt. I heard/read ignore pain is now only a supplement and we now only have shield wall as a full mitigation/DR ability, rest is just physical mitigation only. how is the playstyle then? esp. in raid and m+?
#protection
1 messages · Page 3546 of 1
Usually just use IP to dump excess rage I know I can't dump just on revenge or when I feel like I have no defensives left at all. The later also comes with a feeling of either I messed up or this pull/boss is just taking longer than it should
and u rotate cds on deathlink tbh on the eye
in m+ its different and u kind of always want a cd on cooldown
Ignore pain is enough for piercing lens?
I felt like I was getting destroyed by it last week
Shield Wall / Demo Shout / Ignore Pain.
Ignore Pain is still used as needed - generally in Mythic+ you don't really NEED it and Rage is better spent on Revenge for the damage. But there are times where you are better off using Ignore Pain depending on the damage you are taking.
Only to find out post raid that you can't block piercing lens
i mean we've known that for a while its in the sheet
i believe so
i mean if your playing AM and wall which u should u can probs use SW in the intermission
In that case, if I'm running AM/TW, would it be something like demo shout first death link, then wall the next death link, then demo shout the third death link?
so demo shout is now cire part of our rotation. i see! thanks. I guess rage is then more of a secondary usage to prot since the mainabilities are all cd based. How is rage generation faring atm? esp. on single target. Are prot inst rage starved atm?
they are all part of our rotation
u dont hold onto SW unless your gunna take a big hit within like the next min
🤷 not done the fight might be doing it tonight
Alright heh. I think I found sense's vod so I'll check that out
I wouldn't say rage starved, we have a lot of burst rage currently from Avatar, Ravager,Booming Voice, Spear/AA.
And outside of those we are still fine with Rage gen - The Wall and Reprisal both also help in this regard.
Thank you very much! Yeah, covenants would be my next question. I really like Necrolords, but think they are heavily dependant on your group and correct usage of the banner, otherwise it's wasted, right? it's not so uch a fire and forget ability as spear and aftershock are
yes
I'd say kyrian if you're raiding/m+. NF if your focus is m+ and maybe fury offspec. Necro if you got a solid pre made grp
is there some sort of spreadsheet or anything that shows the dps gain/loss per covenant ability? i know this is only theoretical and the margins are bigger depending on useage. i am just interested in how bad a misused banner could be compared to a spear/aftershock
Kyrian is also really good for mythic+..the tether from spear can be a lifesaver when kiting and the phial clears necrotic stacks
A misused banner is a wasted CD pretty much, as kyrian/nf you'll even pump as prot in keys and the rage generation is lovely
iirc, feel free to correct me, but even the banner is only good to use on certain classes to outweigh the dps from spear/AA
I pulled 6.1k in a mists key as prot...thats basicly another dps
As kyrian*
does the spear tether work list a druid's taifun (or watever its called)?
Yeah
But only if it has hit the targets
If a target you didnt hit walks through, it does nothing to it
and aftershock does a conical knockdown, right? that's plenty cc togehter with stormbolt and shockwave
I'd say if you want to rely on yourself as much as you can, kyrian is better. If you have a decent pug grp or guildies, NF deals alittle more dps, the knockdown part on it can be useful
so the mastery gain from banner really is worthless in terms of defensiveness compared to the cc/utility/dps you get from the other two?
If you are using reprisal, which you should in keys. You dont use stormbolt, but double time to have more uptime on shieldblock
Wouldn't say worthless as you still gain some defensive value from it - it's just RNG.
^
AA/Spear are both just excellent in M+ compared to Banner.
AA provides a ton of rage/damage and the knockdown is honestly a huge QoL , especially in caster packs which tend to be the most dangerous. Soulshape is a solid kiting tool and also helps with using Reprisal as you can Soulshape out and Reprisal in if there should be a need.
Spear is also a ton of rage/damage (especially once we unlock Mikas last trait that allows us to spear every ~40-50s). The tether is solid utility but you generally use Spear on CD for the damage/rage part rather than planning to use it for the Tether. Phial of Serenity can be a life saver against bleeds/dots/necrotic.
i guess then it's question of wether i go kyrian or nf
They just provide you a lot more personal flexibility/control over your own survivability.
thank you kindly for the explanations everyone!
GL and welcome to the club
i just felt that ever since prot lost their self-sustein (in terms of heal) back in the day, prot felt very squishy/cd uptime dependant, hence why my first thought was to go with necro due to added defensiveness from banner mastery gain and fleshcraft
yeah, as a BDK main i can understand this fully, i am considering to let my offtank (guardian druid) to jut do all the main tank stuff xD he outdps and outaggros me all the time but he wants to flex his catweaving skills
He shouldn't outaggro you. 🤔
If you're both playing your classes to an equally solid level.
^^
incarn burst dps is just more than i can pump with my standard rotation
same for any tank combo
maybe i am doing sth wrong, but BDK anyway needs more ramp up time than guardian druid
Can't comment on BDK but something does sound weird. 🙂
no worries, i am working on that seperately ^^ thanks still for all the input! now i just need to figure out if i want to have yet another kyrian or yet another night fae character since necro is out of the question now for my warrior
If you want to play through NL campaign or enjoy the asthetics of it then you can still go for NL obviously. It won't stop you from doing your keys/raiding. 🙂
Hello guys, someone have time to check some log i want to understand why my parsing is so low i cannot figure how to raise it.
you guys use shadowcore oil or the sharpening stone ?
ok
ok i get it! thx
u arent pressing revenge
u arent using all dps conduits or the dps soulbind
your casts are low
Thx what about dps conduit what you mind?
well if u want to dps in raid
u run PV ashen and AAF
if u want to dps in m+
u run PV SoF AAF
but conduits and soulbinds are a small increase
u literally are pressing revenge
your also running rav which is worse in raid
ITF is better
less ignore pain more revenge got it.
on the nine u cast revenge 26 times in 6 mins
on my kill im looking at i cast it 76 times in 4 mins
i press IP 4 times u pressed it 47 times
but honestly
dps is the least of your worries
u are not managing shield block at all
the parsing is just dps?
u need to get eh basics in terms of defensive play down first
before u can start to think about dpsing
anyone here with ThreatPlates can help me with a setting? 😄
what's the issue?
and this, yes
ah sorry @jagged pier
so the persing in the log is not only dps right?
it is only dps
parses are only able to measure dps, nothing else
but we can see other things in your logs like your very low blocked hits
ho wow that painfull im so bad.
as i said work on the basics of playing before u care about dps at all ever
for instance
thats my blocked hits, where im not even tracking shield block
i don't really care about dps i was in the idea that the parsing see mitigation stuff also.
it was my bad.
Hey, as Night fae, if I'm using Niya for arms in raid, is Korayn the go to for prot m+?
@jagged pier thx for the help will try to fix this. also how much mit should i aim?
dont look at that its useless
look at blocked hits
if your wasting rage
and your casts to make sure they are up to snuff
korayn is big for m+ damage
like for instance u could have had a few more casts of SW on the nine log i was looking at as its a 6 min fight
and SW has a 1:30 min cd which the leggo and talents your running
and theres no big hit on that fight u can just use it as general mitigation
yeah i keep sw for emergency but it might be a bad way to look at it.
you should have emergencies
we are preemptive 100%, u need to plan so there arent any
which boss drop the new gems for domination socket?
any
chance on first kill of each boss per week to get one
and the world boss drops a blood one
but it isn't shown within the adventure guide?
nope
because its random which out of the 8 get in the raid
world boss is alwasy the same one
hello can i know for mythic + phial of putrefaction( 236ilv) or old warrior's soul (233ilv) better
both are great
run both
phial is more dps and soul is more defensive
if u want to choose between the 2
hm, but how can i find them if i got one?
my first one is blood-spattered scale ilv236
they will be in your bag
meh i would use the other 2 over that tbh
you mean old warrior and phial combo is better than blood spattered?
in my opinion yes
max dps i guess?
ok will give a try in low dungeon
see how it feel
because this week necrotic a bit worry if not much denfensive
i mean if your relying on blood scale your doing somthing wrong u should never be relying on a trinket its just a nice bonus
okay, it seems i havn't got the gem from world boss yet-.-
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/N2pQ1qLDRWAGV348/#fight=32
I'm trying to get better at reading logs and using M tarragrue as an example. My cotank died and I'm trying to figure out if I didn't taunt, he didn't have meta up, or if he got hit during an enrage. Can anyone point me the right direction? All I know is that he got meleed.
i mean the boss had a phyiscal damage increase because the circles werent soaked
and the dh had no defesives up i think spikes would have run out by then
How did you know what to look for? I just want to get a primer on what to click because I feel like that's a big block for me in learning to read logs.
i watched the replay around his death
and looked at the buffs on the boss
and opened his death to see when he last used somthing
yer the dh didnt have it
but he didnt have spikes up
unless they last longer than 8 secs i have no clue
he got melee hit for 84k without the crush so something was not right.
yer
so he used spikes 8 seconds before he died
so he wouldnt have spikes running
and the phyicals damage buff was out on the buff because the circle wasnt soaked
the dh is dead
You should be able to see it on the right side also as in which buffs he had active (unless you're on phone).
how long is fel dev cd?
1m baseline iirc
cause he hadnt used it for 111 secs
48s
Ty guys. I have some clue what to look for, like if meta was up or if boss buffs were up, but it's still not intuitive with the way logs are designed
fel defender conduit reduces the cd
^
does BSC give reprisals free Revenge the +50% or just 20%
50%
One extra thing on tarragrue, does the boss still gain a dmg increase while the circle are being absorbed or only when they are not soaked?
Also is fiery brand was not use for the last 2min pretty sure he got overwhelmed and forgot is rotation. (also is legendary is based on that spell)
So you pretty much gotta use a cd when there's a black circle out then
if your a dh yes
Ya. Ty
shield block does alot of work for us
yes dh need CD up all time
you can go there to see the fight replay
filter on him and you see is spell
Ty! I'll try it
Is it abnormal to have a lower SB uptime if treaty’s are pretty much being used every pull or should I still be using SB when treats are tanking for the extra SS dmg
no definitely not
Dont SB when trees are up; but also, getting tress on pull is kind of troll
use trees to get sb charges back
your effective uptime should be the same with or without treants
even higher tbh
should you guys be in coms or slightly organized
Trees should be treated as a tank CD and not a DPS CD, which means YOU call for it and the druid just doesnt hold or at least asks if youll need it soon
Had two sets of a trees last night in a SD on my BDK; it was the most glorious thing I have ever had 🙂
still hate druids though
but trees aight
Where in logs do you see effective? Seems details only shows me actual.
Go to warcraftlogs; pick the dungeon you did, click your character. Go to damage taken. Youll see melee damge taken (its gonna be the biggest bar) hover over hits and that will give you your effective block uptime
^^
'
Thx
shard are already busted on their own
exactly
sets would make m+ a joke
could you imagine 3 dps with chaos bane max rank
So in my quest to determine which covenant I'm swapping to.. I have a question for you Kyrians... does it ever get tiring or annoying to play the mini-games for some of the soulbind stuff?
minigames?
? I have been kyrian but I don't remember any minigame
Mmm in the Pelagos tree, the Combat Meditation says you gotta run around and pick up the memories to extend your increase by 3sec... and I guess we're not there yet, but the final ability in Pelagos tree is to face the direction of your doubt to get a stat increase.
i mean the spawn really close and u dont need to run over them just near
and next week u would run mik anyway
Is that for the Effusive Anima Accelerator?
I'm just trying to be diligent in understanding of Kyrian vs Night Fae before I commit to the swap from Necro. 😄
so im just waiting for that other endurance slot to unlock which is next week
Team NF

Reasons to be NF: 1) AA slaps 2) You get to have a customizable soulshape 3) More Kyrians then ever before! Someone has to bring NF buff 4) Better for Arms and Fury M+
Spear does less then AA per cast, but you get more spears
so u get more casts so it will prbs give more rage as well
But also, ever tank a M+ and wished you could just lock a pack down for 12 seconds. Well look no further then AA!
Spear generates a flat 25 rage, AA generates between 16-80 rage based upon targets hit
This is a main pull for me to NF honestly.
right but u get far far more casts of spear
Either is good; im sticking with the NF cause we have a lack of NF now with the people going Kyrian for Arcane and Hunter
and AA>Spear imo
but I wont lie, if owl bro is just broken with Spear CD, itll be hard not to swap back to Kyrian
But you cant go wrong either way
and reason 6; NF currently the better preforming raid Cov for Prot War when looking at personal DPS performance (subject to change with new soulbind traits being unlocked in the next couple of weeks)
But try both, pick the one that works for you
Either is better then Necro
😛
I simmed a lot of the soulbinds with my current stuff, trying to predict a b it of the future and NF comes in slightly ahead for me.
Are you playing with Korayn @plush tendon ?
when bron knocks the pack away so throw cleaver hits the mage 😍
Listen, I get to have a Lion Soul Shape on my store bought flying Lion mount. Now all I need is a Lion Tmog as Horde and I will be set

Knockback sounds frustrating. lol
mages aren't human so it's all good
it's not too bad, sometimes it'll knock out of aoe but it's not a huge knock
they have Ice block
they fine
just turn back time stupid
The only downside I'm having with NF is that I want to match my Cov color (dark blue) but I cant find any really good dark blue mogs that work
with Kyrian you can at least go light blue or white
so thats a downer
lol the hardest part for me is I like the Necrolord theme, but the class abilities are disappointing me since I can't coordinate as well as needed.
<- same
I think NF is better in m+ anyway
NF is better personal power right now and kyrian is better for group power because of the dungeon buffs
they're really not far apart though
have you not experienced the NF exodus in your M+ group?
Our fire mage-> Arcane Kyrian, our MM hunter-> Kyrian, 1 of our Hpals Kyrain, Druids going Venthyr
I don't get to play with a lot of meta classes
it's a choice between holy priest or resto druid when it comes to healers 😢
Yea, I play with those also
theres like a group of 12 of us and we just mix and match groups XD
but for consistent push is literally.... just the gamers who dont have a social life XD
Disc Priest is now Kyrian, Our holy priest is still NF, or VDH is NF, and our Resto/balance druid 2 is NF
its really the Necrolord Cov that got shafted... hoping to convince our WW to give it a go 😛
I just think the argument that Kyrian>NF for dungeon buffs no longer applies as it did in 9.0
In all honesty, given how close they seem, the difference between Kyrian and NF seems to boil down to personal choice given needs, environment, and preference of play style.
Pretty much
this game is a fucking joke
after doing TOP mythic 10 times, i get the shield the first time i do it HC for Calling....
why wouldnt u just run a m+ for the calling
I'm still stuck on the kyrian vs NF thing I've played both and I honestly prefer NF but it's hard to give up the utility of kyrian
Decisions decisions
Plus NF feels better when I off spec fury as well
I'm heavily leaning towards switching back to NF again
I guess the only down fall of NF is I'll have to kite like the rest of the tanks again if I switch lmao
LOL Kiting
good one
Well, I guess if you need to kite, at least you can soulshape
you don't ever save spear for kiting it's for pewpew
sometimes you might but... (not really)
i hate saving my spear for kiting this week 😦
i want to pewpew
kyrian only benefit is Necrotic week
if u saving spear u are literally playing wrong and initng
literally the only reason why i miss Kyrian is Necrotic
Kyrian + Night elf.. what is necrotic?
with mikanikos it should be easier to get some use out of spears utility
but spear is for the pump 
Hello , some prot war who have kill Eye of Jailor in mythic for a question pls ? 🙂
I more or less ment being able to remove poisons and bleeds with phial instead of kiting to drop stacks
I use spear on cd for damage not for kiting
But losing phial will be noticeable imo
one of us one of us
it would be extremely nice to have a root as a warrior though but 🤷♂️
bring back conflict and strife
'Shifting through bags looking for Heart of Azeroth'
and avatar was boosting def with the heart.
Im a Dark Iron Dwarf so fire blood already clears necrotic stacks…

there's always weeb fantasy 14
I have more than 14 fantasies
how many involve catgirls
😳


sounds like content to me
Question about trinkets, currently running the rubbish 200 armor one at 233 ilvl (new ish player and loot last teir was rubbish) I just grabbed the version boost one from the covenant table is that better?
blizzard don't want you to know this buy you can ignore all of their systems and remain at 99% effectiveness 🤷♂️
honestly the fact that cat ears havent been a cosmetic item yet
huge failure on their end
there are alot of cosmetic items theyre missing
which would generate them alot of revenue
at least pet battle gets continued support
but its an NA game, so you know plot armor is gonna get some bad reception
When your Co-tank tells you hes going on vacation in 2 weeks and now you gotta turn one of your meathead melee into the backup tank 
this. killed danny on M and never once did anything related to the maw
not on my shitty warrior though lol
"the wall" is so amazing
Shield wall has gone from "save it. I may need it", to "use it. I can get it back in around a minute"
i mean u should use it like that anyway
and in most content m+ u should run bolster with the wall
which makes it 1:30 cd which is the same as when running rep and AM
I find I get more use out of the additional sheild block uptime from reprisal myself.
I upgraded my leggy reprisal legs. 235 to 262. Is it normal that there is no socket? others from my guild who have rebuilt theirs always had a socket.
yes u dont get sockets on legs
Only slots that can have sockets get sockets.
Wait so we get free domination socket from leggo??
just normal socket
they should let you feed your dom socket leggos a dom socket piece
and the leggo gets the socket
change my mind
and let u have both sock and dom sock on same item
i feel like they're prob gonna do that
i swear people were linking double socket pieces week 1, maybe i got trolled by fake item links
xD
pls remove dom shards from the game
i have not seen that what
people were linking normal raid dom socket pieces with a primastic socket too

That was ptr I think with the double sockets.
Question about trinkets, currently running the rubbish 200 armor one at 233 ilvl (new ish player and loot last teir was rubbish) I just grabbed the version boost one from the covenant table is that better?
yes
Tips for doing mdi style quadra pulls?
which trinkets you speak about
Coordination is key for dungeons where its needed, like hoa. Interrupts and cc needs to be on point. Talk beforehand about if youre gonna bl or not. Some dungeons are easy to pull big, like NW, SoA or mists and all you really need is a defensive or so
As with anything in m+ just get the experience and see what works.
what should you do with Wailing Arrow when on last platform at Sylvanas?
move away
raid in one corner
the raid should be stacked
ah ok
arrow in the opposite corner
make sense
and can the arrow people stand on top of each other?
if theres 2 people with arrows?
no
they can but they will probably die
u have to move and drop it in turn
ah the wailing arrows dont go off at first?
at the same time i mean
3 go out and they expire in sequence
^
you send 1 at a time to the other platform to pop
then they come back and the next goes same time
ah ok
if healers are struggling/don't have CDs, have the courage to order a DPS to jump to their death
execute your raid for wailing arrow crimes
"Harrow, kill yourself, in a videogame"
When doing open world stuff, do y’all stay in prot spec or swap to arms/fury?
anyone have a way to track the aegis trinkets dmg reduction in logs?
I have 2 questions, one not so much to do with prot warrior. Do I need to have my loot spec picked before the mythic + key starts or can I change to what I want at the chest.
Second question is if I am a venthyr as prot and use bolster talent. Does the condemn increase just last stand time or also my shield block from bolster?
I think you can switch loot spec right before chest, but like, might as well make it part of your pre-key routine because you’ll probably forget later
@near sundial I think it shows up as healing?
And the last stand extension doesn’t extend bolster SB no
Basically the venthyr legendary doesn’t do anything exciting as prot
yeah you gotta swap before chest spawns
so many people seem to think you can just swap before looting chest
icy veins
Harrow
No we confirmed it with a priest in guild the other day
You have to change your loot spec before key starts.
She was on shadow loot spec; key started...before popping chest she asked if caster in group wanted INT trinket, he said no (this was plaguefall btw) so she changed to holy, opened box..got the dps trinket that is ONLY on shadow loot spec; it's not on her holy table.
You have to do it before chest 'pops' so either before key, while doing key, or during last boss
Yeah the chest was up so it had already checked her spec.
I forget half the time so now it's just a 'pre key' routine, CBF to be trying to swap during the last pull or boss.
umm
that's not accurate
i've definitely switched loot spec during last boss and got stuff specific to that loot spec
^^
Then it's before chest spawn; but either way..I'm locking it in before key start so I never have to think about it again.
Which just means opening the box is irrelevant; when the key 'completes' game looks at your class/spec and sets the items for when you 'interact' with the object that spawns @the chest location.
My fav are the absolute cheesedicks who wait for everyone to loot, know they got something..then drop group and hearth.
and now that there's nothing from dungeons I want that much any more...I still hate those people.
Because what it means is "I'm an enchanter and want to break down that item into a shard..and don't care if it's an upgrade for anyone else"
100g is 100g
If your loot gets mailed to you it becomes untradable right
I vaguely remember that happening in a WCM and I couldn't give branch to the mage
they were big sad
btw what's the calculation for extra loot? same as bfa? every key above 15 is 20% chance for extra item?
ye
figured..when we started doing 17/18 and were getting 3 actual items and not just conduits
HOW TF my guildmates were still getting conduits from keys...bruh..
they prob have a stack of em in their bags
if you don't learn it it keeps dropping
"You didn't buy the 226 upgrade thing from venari during S1??"
"Dude I hate the maw"
"FKN CASHUUL!!!...I hated it too but, I wanted dem conduit upgrades"
who's venari 
Whats the maw?
our conduits are weak as hell, why would I do a daily grind for forever when I can catch up easily now
233 bladancers armor kit vs 194 flame of battle.
nither
get better trinkets
I'm trying! My loot luck is awful 😢
Is that better that both the others?
EASILY
^^
Awesome. Thats an easy fix!
I cleared a 15 dos this week so I'll wait for the reset and keep fingers crossed for vault first
Poop
but ye, gl
Guess I'll have to be very lucky then
God damnit
Tbh I don't mind putting 10 dungeons a week
Bss at any ilvl is gonna be better than what I already have
Harrow our conduits aren't fantastic but what I was honestly grinding for, to get 226 in S1 was Piercing verdict..and it ended up being 1 of the last 3 to upgrade to 226...then I just finished 'em out. I would constantly upgrade the arms/fury ones lol.
Is that the dungeon loot table for prot nom? 100 items?
thought it would be more than that.
Hobbitfeet also you can hit up tazavesh; HM taz is really not hard, you don't need MLG players to clear it on hard, just people that are willing to learn mechanics and aren't bad at their dps rotations.
so wf raiders
That being said..the beginning of that dungeon makes it appear harder than it is; the 'broker' trash mobs are actually angry AF and if you get dotted up with their rotating beam, or get disoriented etc...it can go sideways quick.
..and it's ALL WORTH IT when you hit dem SWEET GUITAR SLIDES~ You'll be Marty McFly'in johnny B' Goodin'.
I mean..the game just makes a little harp 'ding' sound..but in my head; I'm a rockstar.
If you do HM tazavesh; one tip..don't do what I did this week. The dais that ports you up to the boss with the playstation symbols, and the 'first technique' ..don't pull all the spiders+the broker mobs with them all together and say "we got this..just use coolies and pop off.." and then get bounced around and decimated =\
in necrotic weeks should i tank crackling thunder or bounding strides? and as a new tank pugging lower keys (in which necrotic IS an affix) how many stacks should i run on?
you should be out by 30, so start planning when you reach 20
Do we even use ignore pain?
I’m so new to this, trying to learn rotation and everything I just feel slow and squishy compared to my bear
well yeah theres alot more to pwar than just press thrash and spam IF
Yea, which is why I’m trying it out due to wanting a little more complexity. But I feel like my rage generation is poor and that I’m sitting around 50% HP constantly. Is gear and not having a prot legendary the main reasons?
yes
we absolutely rely on ilvl and reprisal to be properly tanky
unless youre already experienced
biggest issue of alot of people that are rage starved is them not actually pressing enough buttons
which may sound stupid
but is a reality
Gotcha
they think theyre pressing buttons, but arent actually properly doing so
Yea so my rotation is charge, shield block, SS, spend rage on IP if in need of def and on Revenge if I’m ok. Popping demo shout and avatar on CD
opener is basically
ravager->charge->SB+TC+Avatar->Revenge->SS/spear->revenge
in m+ atleast
when youre finally running reprisal you should seek to intervene early to get the CD rolling
keep up SB and use IP as defensive rage dump to avoid capping rage or when taking heavy damage
Really just this
Being worried about openers is such a dps brain thing
Just press your buttons
yes
Ok, I guess reprisal is the big thing cause I can’t keep SB up a bunch and that’s why I feel so squishy, that and maybe that I have a 229 weapon and a 168 shield
oh god
that shield
shield is the issue why you take damage
its the single most important item


Yea I just started gearing him last night and today so by tonight I should have a 225 reprisal and a shield
I’ll check back in tomorrow, also I have trash trinkets. Scale still good?
Smh
What’s best now?
2nd best nom
aegis
Where from?
aegis is soooooo freaking good
raid
The Nine
Ahh
aegis turns you into budget bear

Ahhh
immune to damage for 8seconds
Hot tbh
ya kinda jelly
So that and scale like top 2?
That’s what I’m looking at for right now till I get more comfortable

It's worth noting
Trinkets won't fix bad play
A better shield goes a long way in that regard
Yea I feel like the 168 is not ok
turns your shieldblock into a 10% dr
Maybe not 15s
I have been timing 10s and 11s
Yeah that sounds right
yeah any other piece of gear, skill >
but your shield can often literally mean living and splatting with good play
With a good babysitter you can probably push 15s
Lol some high dps and heals I could maybe
Yah if your healer is OK with ignoring the team and your dps can handle kicks you shouldn't be dying to melee attacks
But yeah
Just do like 3 arenas and buy the 450 conquest one
Easiest 70ilvls of your life
Would y’all say it’s difficult to gear for both prot and fury due to optimal stats?
Prot = equip high ilvl
So, not at all
Fury wants haste aswell anyway
So you're easily good to go
Awesome, thank you. Kinda nervous since I’m being thrown into tank for raid but I’m so used to fury lol
The extra block is worth way more than the haste you lose
ilvl on shield is worth everything
Like 10%
damn
straight to 242 it went 😄
only 100 rating away from 246 ❤️
wtf, my block % went down when i put it on?
ah but the dmg blocked % goes up by like 3%
Mastery increases block percentage
But who cares, you have 100% block rate most of the time
ye so the only thing that means anything, is how much % dmg a block blocks i guess?
went from 31% to 34%
whats 2nd item to upgrade then after shield?
Thoughts on the haste trinket from windrunner?
Old warrior soul
old warrior soul is insane
https://www.wowhead.com/protection-warrior-gear-guide
old warrior soul S tier
prot warrior is always fun
the raid is less exciting than CN tho
seems kinda rushed
bosses are a bit undertuned
Yes prot is always fun ( I mean, except for that time in WoD.)
Oh so they went full reverse from early CN?
you can basically just watch Limit Maximum thoughts on the raid tier
that should explain it all
the damage we do right now is insane and the rotation is fluid
the raid itself is like other said a bit lacking
in terms of lore
So, insane, like, BFA 8.0 insane?
but the fights themselves are fun
or "better than we were 4 months ago"
yeah if you do it right
80% of your groups damage in a M+?
i only did DPS in raid, so i cant really tell too much, other than what i heard from Limit Max
😄
i average around 4.5- 4.8k dps in keys as prot
ye same
but i havent learned the tech for 3-4 pulls
sometimes im #3 dps 😄
target capping hmm
no lie anything under a 10 key i end up beating atleast one dps
if i invite plebs for a +12, im sometimes #1 or #2 dps
well if the raid is boring.
i resubbed for 1 month, only to get KSM, but ended up doing the raid anyway
for me it is ok, as i mainly subbed for M+, and the Raid is just a side offer
but if you wanna sub for mainly raid, im not sure tbh
the raid is decent, its the lore that is disappointing to me
sylvannas fight was the let down for me
Actually, yeah nm I already spoilered my way on that
the lore makes it seem like theres 1 more raid this xpac, and then thats it 🤷
"Sylvanas redemption inc"
probably gonna be a raid with Anduin as 9th boss, and Jailer as final boss
Sorry but Bolvar/Thrall/Jaina should know enough to just cave her cabbage immediately.
"oh you were mind controlled all this time? i guess we are friends now"
watch it happen 🤣
we get to see garrosh be our boy again
they have the same sexy hair
"Dude who literally created the lich king convinces my undead ass is exercising free will"
"Sounds legit"
Varian got turned into a lock cookie
plzno
I want an alliance leader to die for once
like forever
Who's the only leader to stay dead so far? Cairne?
my boy saurfang
I mean faction leader, and Saurfang legit just died, give it time.
Usually takes like 2 full patches
whats best to spend my Valor on after Shield?
weapon
weapon or dmg trinket
whatever drops from a 15 you need
Legit after you have a high ilvl shield
weapon because aggro
and then "its all gravy"
sounds like he's new ¯_(ツ)_/¯
if you're using a blue junk weapon you won't hold aggro vs triggerhappy DPS
reprisal stops all aggro issues lol
https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-gb/character/eu/sunstrider/Pandafar
i have 220 Stone Legion, should i go Tazavesh to get the 233 Soleah?
https://www.wowhead.com/item=185818/soleahs-secret-technique?bonus=6805
going to say that you're still not going to hold aggro with a garbage weapon vs appropriately geared DPS
i have 233 wep, i guess i can up it to 242
soleahs any good?
it gives perm 100 haste i guess? seems kinda nice
@ erga, they'll answer you
Soleahs is an ok trinket
but there is better out there
you just got to remember to apply it to someone who gives you your top stat
How good's decanter of endless howling? Seems alright
nice offensive trinket with a little bit of defensive benefit
I use it but thats because i do not have a scale or old warriors soul
I have a scale, was thinking of maybe swapping my 220 phial for it
if you are looking for raw dps i would sim it
the damage is very close, phial is very slightly ahead on ST
and with hectic cleave?
but I figure a potential heal's not a bad trade off
Decanter is like 1% 3+ targets
are yall using wall or reprisal in raid?
eh as a tank you shouldnt be dipping below the 50%
Tank is the only role that should be dipping below 50%, haha
ehhhh
consistently, anyways
what type of content are you doing?
M+, mostly
ok so yeah you would be a bit more hitting the 50% but
BUT
healer is also going to focus you more
its really a choice at that point based on your healer
i personally focus more dps with the phial
I'll give the decanter a trial run
the extra parry is nice this week anyways, in keys
whats the ilvl of your decanter?
239
yeah really this sounds like a personal choice, if you are struggling with healers the extra hps will help
Hi guys, anyone have a recommendation on which one of these two helmets I should be using for M+. Running Reprisal but not sure how to gear when it comes to dom shards. Have a Shard of Kyr on my gloves.
any other tank besides warrior this is true.
in necrotic weeks should i tank crackling thunder or bounding strides?
i assumed it makes it easier to hold agro.
it's also the recommended talent at wowhead.
somethingsomething 🧠
crackling thunder is very good, i never take bounding strides, not even on necrotic.
@uneven mason ... if it's a shit question you can just assume im new (which i did state earlier on) and not be an arse about it.
Not attempting to be an ass 😄
o'rly
Kidding before I get nuked.
jesus christ
thx.
thats what i roll with, just switching stormbolt and rumbling earth sometimes, depends how much cc we have in the group
thx. i have the same but use double time and anger management.
appreciate you sharing your build.
anger management is fine, but i kinda prefer bolster, its such an good talent with reprisal. when you go with bolster, you have to use last stand much more frequently and not just as an "oh sht" button
especially with unnerving focus conduit
if you're using reprisal I'd highly suggest AM over bolster because you tend to just not need that extra 15s of SB every min, and LS as a CD itself is pretty "meh"
yeah UF combined can make it nice.
choices >< toomany for my brain this expac
I like using bolster because it gives way more up time on SD + it makes last stand a better oh shit who butt pulled button
trust me, you have to go away from that mindset when u take bolster. use it much more frequently. its sooo good. and if youre renown 51, take as the last defensive conduit unnerving focus.
Thinking about switching to necrochad from kyrian to help out my M+ group to fill all covenants. Does anyone have any resources regarding which specs/classes benefit the most from conquerors banner?
Apologies for the rookie question but why are the big boy RIO warriors running heavy repercussion? Are they just raid spec rn?
eventually keys get to a point where you'll die from a single hit without sb up
and hr gives you more uptime
haste values are up pretty high so you can get more resets on shield slam into more up time on SB
Pika does a break down of the talents in one of his videos i will see if i can locate it for you
Thanks lads, makes sense 🤘🏻
Thanks!
How meta is prot warrior for mythic +
Damn 2nd to last
sorry iasagne replied to wrong person 😄
thats for all key levels
you can actually change the key level to see where you want to be at
all key levels isn't going to show the meta I'd go for 15< at least
prot warrior just isn't popular to begin with
we are pretty much another dps
I want to get into tanking for mythic + but not sure if warrior is the way to go
depends on what you really want to do
if you want an easy free win and sleep through keys
go guardian druid
if that's the tank you want to play then it'll be more than enough unless you're going for world first keys
pretty sure it's also because it's better single target SB uptime
also pretty sure all tanks are so close now that any clown that wants to deny you based on class is a clown you're better off ignoring
unless you're pushing top keys
in which case you wouldn't be asking
Honestly your tank is based off nowadays your dps
Running a caster comp? DH running a melee comp? Warr, and brm, running a bunch of uncapped? Druid with incarn pulls
Every tank is so close to each other it’s a matter of what you can play better and more comfortable with, if you can do all of em play the one that’ll fit your team better
And the one you actually like of course
is soleahs secret technique worth using? its about 26 IL higher than mine other trinket it would replace (Gluttunous spike)
i simmed soleahs and it was higher deeps so i use it
ok do you just find someone that stacks haste and use it on them?
yeah either haste or vers
got ya thank you
are you guys using reprisal on the first 2-3 mythic bosses
It's not good on The Eye
ok, so what do you use, the wall?
Yeah
I just still have Wall from when Reprisal wasn't a thing
eh, i'm not planning to recraft it since I barely use it, so don't mind being suboptimal for one fight
but maybe eventually
Never did understand the whole let’s waste gold and recraft our rank 4 leggo mindset
Trying to decide how bad I care about 16 haste, lol. What, 0.5%?
Wouldn't you want to recraft it if it was shoulders so you could use a Dom socket? And we are swimming in soul ash now too
Jeah, preferably. But it's by no means necessary to down a boss.
did someone ever testet if you can perma shieldwall your full group in torghast with it?
https://www.wowhead.com/spell=335629/unbreakable-will
I just use seimic in torghast, or signet if im doing it as fury that leggo has no purpose anywhere tbh
Yes you can
It's also a waste
Well Hello
I joined the discord just to look up for some information about prot warrior, I already check the pins and they clear up some doubts ,so I made my prot warrior just to tank and to have a necrolord so hello everyone 💚💚💚
Hello. 
If anything from the pins needs clarifying feel free to ask. 🙂
Confused.
Why is that a question?
Both have dom sockets and one is higher ilvl. 👀
With a 20 ilvl gap there’s basically no question… except if you’re comparing good trinket to bad trinket
is it possible to have charge and intervene in one keybind?
Yes
Hey, does it go for tank the same way as for DPS. Setbonus is better then any Ilvl - e.g. 226 gloves with Dom socket are better then 252 m+ great vault ?
Yes
Ok
This game is weird state atm
2-3 days i spammed keys nothing lootwise
Yesterday 4 keys and 3 specific items i needed
It's been like that for a while. 
that's called "statistics"
Its monkaS
I got the scale the other day i am wondering if it was a mistake to upgrade it with valor maybe shouldv waited u till reset 🤣
it's called gambler's fallacy actually 
How to outplay your priest and get PI as prot (he has no clue I cut out the top 2/3 in each of these)

A solid 1k of those is Gino's mercenaries 😂
W/e I'm getting PI till my RL finds out

PI = prot infusion
First boss of ToP, how do you clear necrotic stacks? The melee guy is on me all the time and even if i leap away he chases me fast.
Dessia is the melee boss?
You cant let dessias enrage go undispelled
And have dps kite
Yes its the melee one
But its a wonky fight
ok so basically as tank i just face tank him and hope for the best?
(im a very very new tank in case you hadn't already guessed)
If you kite while he casts slam or whatever it’s called, you gonna sacrifice a dps. And he runs faster than you :D
Nuke and pray is the way in pugs since often he gets instant soothed, rule of tbumb if you want something dispelled it wont happen if you dont want it dispelled it’ll happen, same if you want something kicked go ahead and press reflect itll get kicked every time
haha true
ok friend just told me i coudl have used night fae blink to get away
i didnt thnink of that - as i only just became night fae
Be a dwarf
the price is too high.
This was (for me as a bad player) probably the easiest season to get ksm (or equivalent) so far. Anyone else that feels the same? A lot easier to do keys now
m+ is alot easier now yes
Rlly like the new affix as healer and tank
Pride being gone, dungeons being nerfed
having passive buffs 24/7 that increase average dps and survivability
Idk if its the dungeons or new rio score but m+ is just boring asf for me now
I feel like i have no reason to do anything over 15s
Not that there really was a reason last season either
Idk man

Looking for pug routes - dratnos the ones to get? i got some from 'plka puffs' too but seems a few mistakes in them (of course im probably just reading them wrong).
dratnos ones looked a bit convoluted at times.
Guys i have to build up my alt Warrior for back up Warrior buff in raid, probably i Will play tank/dps, in this case NF are the best option ?
yes
Problem is there are no new du girl a, the new affix doesn’t really change anything, your gear scales too well and there are 0 rewards todo anything above 15.
Kinda sad
What do you mean 0 rewards over 15
This is the first patch ever where there ARE rewards over 15
do you get KSM at 2000 rating? or still need to do all on 15?
yes
So … there’s no reason to go above 15
some dungeons seem impossible to get in as Warr Tank
Yeah I got KSM while missing a tyrannical NW because I had some 17s
As I said :D
??? You get the dungeon portals and FoS for doing +20
For what. If Doug want them sure. Do they help you? Not really
If bragging rights and convenient portals aren’t enough reward for you then idk
how much score does a +15 over time give?
About as much as a 14
depends on how much you overtime
hm ok
Maybe a 13 if you REALLY botched it
is there a way to see what rating one dung gave?
if you miss it by like 2 seconds score is the same
if you miss the timer by 2 minutes its bascially a +7
PF +15 41 minutes, i guess thats like 4 minutes over?
FoS ?
the only people that care about achievements are those that barely get them or barely miss them
imo
Uh…. Sure? I mean that seems kinda self evident, people who struggle to get something are the ones who care most about them
exactly
Achievements serve basically no purpose which is a shame, kinda wish they’d made them an actual system rather than just… nothing
Still it’s just nice that there’s an in-game recognition of doing everything on +20, kinda feels like something that should have been in for years
there should be more but yes its a start
Yeah it’s a bit of a crime that the systems around m+ are still so pitifully barebones after like 5 years of it being way more popular than pvp
Anyone else think it’s kinda fucked up that ignore pain doesn’t work on necrotic but the Druid legendary does? Thanks for coming to my TED talk
Wish they would bring back the reward system from the og m+ dungeon runs
Or do you get any transmog from fos?
no
Considering how low the effort was on the “new” mount, I think whole transmogs from m+ are very unlikely
But would be cool
bro we barely got transmogs from the dungeons lmao
Right?
Just blizzard continuing their habit of having something that worked incredibly well and is universally liked (transmogs from challenge modes) and then just not doing it anymore for no reason
A covenant specific transmog from doing +20s would be a cool feature for a future patch tho
9.1 gear seems to lean really heavily towards Haste, I think probably close to 35% by the time i get some decent end-game gearing, is that overkill and inefficient stats because of DR? I could maybe try to replace a Haste/Mastery ring with something like Vers/Mastery?
I wouldn't worry about DR until you hit 39% from gear
^
I forgot to pick my vault stuff last week......
Fking work
how can you forget the pinncle of modern wow
It's crazy to me that 226 Dom socket pieces are better than 252 vault gear...
Thanks blizzard
I imagine the 226dom>252vault only applies if you gain the set bonus by equipping it correct?
I mean it was the same BS with corruption
does anyone know if the functionality exists in Details to show per spell information like this screenshot from skada? Details shows total damage blocked, but I want to know WHAT I blocked, and how much of a particular spell (like melees here) I blocked.
I'm progressing mythic eye and having some trouble surviving in the intermission. Is it true that you can't block Piercing Lens from the boss + small eyes?
There's a block list pinned somewhere. Can't block it from boss but can from adds. I think the one from the adds is the only blockable ability on the whole fight
found the block guide thanks
only in logs, not on details
explains a lot
I did eye last night the fight sucks but i wouldnt say i had much issue tbh, just need to plan for when the raid runs away in intermission and u go a few seconds with heals
well now that i know i was wasting half my rage on shield block i think it should go smoother next time
true that
well that's depressing...having that information available with a mouseover is just too good
is it?
Lol
spell school, is it blockable, and did you block alot or were your shield block casts scuffed, right there in game reference, to me it is
hmm i thought ion said that wasnt supposed to happen with vault items
ion wouldnt lie, would he?
was that something that could happen in bfa?


