#protection
1 messages Β· Page 3534 of 1
now i was in an SD 14 with a resto druid who was 2400 io last season. after the dungeon he messaged me on his own telling me how barely had to heal me and that he enjoyed actually being able to dps....but then i went back and looked at the log and it showed i only had an 8CPM on SS.
what would cause me to feel so tanky there with such a low cpm

but i can go into the same dungeon with another group and get dumpstered with the same cpm
and the healer screaming how squishy i am
how well the group stuns/kicks makes a noticeable difference for damage taken
^^
Guys, best anima powers for max damage on 1st boss?
yeah id really like it but i feel like you cant pass up that +26 weapon upgrade
i have a 220 scale and if we gonna run aegis instead its not as worth
the most logical and best choice is the weapon
but the scale just touches my heart cus i had to farm the shit out of that one last season
Yupp xD
i hate my vault
i would take BS BTW much rarer than a weprion
true but that wep is great as well and will p much last me the entire patch
I got Inscrutable Quantum Device 252. It sucks as tank in every scenario?
well this is my full vault could not be worse
its good dam
for what? Never looked into it
just say me where I can read about that shit
no need to explain it
pelagos until 57
opening as prot is a doozy
its not really great for tanks if you cant pair it with big CDs like ashen
it can do a dmg proc
but the 3min CD is just ass
viscera is not great not terrible, alright dps trinket
who
ah
id take weppy probably, a 236 scale / 246 when upgraded is already good enough
apparently a 252 scale absorbs 90k on 5 targets
but it also depends on if you are gonna kill the eye anytime soon right
or whoever drops 1h weppy
weppy seems logical
has anyone done the math on aegis vs scale
like
will scale be redundant with aegis
scale is better vs fewer targets
aegis better vs many targets
aegis does a fuckload more dmg in m+
realistically i see myself using aegis in the future
meaning at one point i would switch out the scale
sooo the logical pick would be weppy
I might be out of date, but wondering about which soulbind to have now that we are 48. I am choosing the more defensive side, but torn between Bron or Pelagos
Any tips?
^
Didnt see you wriet that - thanks ma dude π
And is it the 6% dmg reduction or the 5% dmg done? Thinking the dmg reduction will be lower than getting another Endurance, am I thinking clearly here?
That's Pelagos π
yes
im still wondering if I should stick with splintered heart. I like to run cheat cause it just feels more fun to play, but the new cheat in SOD is kinda terrible
actually
given that you get the next endurance conduit
itll outweigh the shield from mikan
That's what i thought
@strong forum if you could pick one bastion soulbind for raid and M+ tank what one would it be?
thanks
its really inconsequential on the last 2 on mikan tbh
So, I am guessing the 3% dmg increase + Endurance Conduit of Coindensed Anima Sphere outweighs 6% dmg reduction from Mikan
Also, more testing?
Yes, just trying to write it shortly here ^^
ya but 6% damage reduction is incredibly misleading for those who are lurking
cuz 6% free damage reduction is huge
That should proc on every pack, 1-2 times depending on CDs for M+?
the endurance is guaranteed ~4% heal every 10 seconds
so 12% guaranteed health every 30 seconds
whereas the shield is 8% magic shield and 8% physical shield every 30 seconds assuming you get hit by both
which isnt always gonna be the case
Heal as well only if ur below 100%
which is always
True
idk its literally a minimal difference
at the end of the day its "do you want the finesse conduit or not"
Exactly my thought π
but if the shield actually is 8% now, its gonna be better because thats an 8k shield
Says 6% on the tooltip
says 8 on wowhead π€·ββοΈ
but im guessing ur counting Phys + Mag
ya is 6%
asked the wowhead dudes
ya so left side is just better
unless you want that finesse
i picked saurfang soul trinket from Sylvanas, only good in raid, right?
guys am i stupid or is prot warri garbage for eye the jailor
feels fine for eye
Can't block shit on that fight so it's not optimal
true
i dont know why blizzard designs the boss that way
eye just feels like a weird fight
They really want you to use the wall leggo, clearly
On sylvanas im also thinking that you'd play the wall
Since like 70%of her dmg is just magic
Yeah, I swap to the wall for it
Fuggin dumb
If they just made piercing lens blockable, it'd be fine
Prolly just an IP fight, and use SB for damage
block the lance hit from abductor, otherwise IP
Do we know how many configurations of the tormented lieutenants there are?
Is it like awakened where there's just an A pattern and a B pattern or do they take turns rotating through all the slots?
does it matter
by the point that it would matter, it will be known i would think
rn we would be guessing
there havent been enough weeks to confirm anything
Or like some packs I'd feel comfortable pulling like Arkolath or Soggodon with but I wouldn't want to do with Oros
Did they rotate on PTR?
@spice crystal halp
oh hello
π
Sessa's here. π
I have updated maps on tanknotes with the new configuration, I'm praying π that it stays as tyr/fort not AABB like other affixes have been
but this should be the only 2 layouts
they were the only 2 that ever appeared on PTR
Oh, rad, good to know
and they flippy floppy with each other (weirdly the linear dungeons all have the same pairs and non-linear dungeons have different ones)
only weird one is HoA where the actual locations on top of the order has changed
this layout is much better though because it gives you barbs first in almost every dungeon
Thank you for your service o7
β€οΈ
Yeah, I was thinking about pulling the first lieutenant in wake with a big pack and was wondering that would be doable every week
I've noticed a lot of guides have brutal vitality for 3rd endurance conduit, is that really better than condensed anima sphere? Does it really even matter?
no and no
hello what is a decent overall uptime for shield block and ignorepain ?
look at logs and blocked % on your dmg taken melees
SB/IP uptime isn't the metric you want
Noticed on logs lots of Vers over haste prot tanks, guides all say stack haste, is vers better for mythic prog?
ilvl is better and they probs have pvp gear as its fast and ez to get which is stacked in vers
does haste generally sim more dam?
Raids have generally 2 tanks meaning you don't have to tank 24/7 and have enough downtime between taunt swaps to let Shield Block recharge. Vers also works against dot's and magic damage which generally is the spooky thing in raids.
It won't make or brake anything. You could enchant full mastery(or nothing at all) and still be able to clear mythic raids as long as you play properly.
@ionic fern mute me daddy
Never
:(
got the shield from tarragrue 

I did Tarragrue on N, H, and LFR
And they gave me the LFR Domination socket 
Fucking blizz
i thought they only drop from your first kill of the week
wowhead news just had an article about it
π
Players can earn Shards of Domination from any difficulty boss kill, including LFR. However, they appear to only drop on your first kill of each boss per week, regardless of difficulty, so players do not have to farm all four difficulties to maximize their chances of obtaining them.
np
some shaman gave it to me xD
Are dungeons generally faster right now with powers and the minibosses? Or is it around the same as pride
He's a mist perfectly fine to be muted 
Overall I think we're slightly less powerful with the 9.1 affix than 9.0
but hard to tell
someone smart will run the numbers
some early bosses are a real slog now, like ingra & droman in mists
Any prot warriors tanked M Tarrague yet? Seems like tanks should be soaking most of the fire and magic remnants, and obv that's bad news for us
Going to be tanking with a bear so he'll be soaking most of both of those but was wondering if anyone has done it differently (prot warriors soaking phys dmg instead)
I've had a better experience this tier with dungeon pugs, but that might just be because we have a tier of experience under our belts
hey guys, eye of the jailer's deathlink is no longer blockable?
It's not, no.
Not really.
Pretty sure RFDT isn't scalar to damage and hasn't been for a while.
Fuck me, when it was though, it was hilarious.
REEEEE
rfdt would make us busted
Stop talking about rage nerfs reeeee
any suggestions on first couple pulls on DOS? seem to get clapped
ran 12-13 mythic, and i get smoked
Gotcha, kinda what i figured
try and save shield block for the 2nd pull, it's the real hell one
must not kite enough
build threat with cooldowns then bail
i mean shield wall
First pull is LS + Lust
Then kite once shit runs out
2nd pull is tank aslong as you have CDs like SW and demo
Then kite once those run out
so i dont like lust first pull cause dps can never burn first boss
And never go back in until the small skellies are dead
you should have lust back with a good route
^
got a route you can share
You should plan your route so you get to 1st boss by the 10min mark
gotcha, usually i just do first 2 pulls then go 1st boss
but would make more sense to get more powers
think routes are still being tinkered with but last I did was... do first two pulls, get miniboss
U-Turn and go to miniboss in front of Ardenweald wing
Overall this new affix is worse in terms of power gain than Prideful was
So everyone is kinda less powerful tbh
then do ardenweald, then clear dungeon in reverse order from last season
@chilly brook we done
For DoS clear outside like it's old prideful, dip into mechagon to get mini boss, go to Ardenweald, do ardenweald with all 4 powers then work back
nah go left
You'll have lust for first pull and first boss
lmao you're hearing a lotta different option, but basically ya, you can always find a way to have 10 mins pass before first pull and first boss without wasting time
Since you're knocking out a lot of trash
And theres basically no reason not to grab all the anima powers before first boss since you're not going out of your way to get them
Ya love to see it
Meanwhile I haven't done it yet
I rerolled again

I only need 14 more keys for KSM!
I could easily get it on the monk though this week, just need to do keys on the pally soooo

Pugging it was a slog not going to lie
I don't doubt it, teams don't want me unless I have like 1800 score already and the ones that do take me are a nightmare

Nah i started today with like 1500
gotta lotta months to win this thing
lmao true
i'm basically just gonna be doing whatever 15s for vault loot and ksm will just happen sometime
and then push higher if i ever feel the drive
Earlier it's done the better tbh
Just because the nature of gearing
Yer i can upgrade to 240 whatever now
If you can fill important slots early in prog it's pretty big
Like if you're getting cucked on shield drops
Getting a big boi shield is dope

i think i'll get ksm by the time i have a pile of valor without tryharding pugs too much
I am gett cucked on all loot
but yeah... shield drop is one motivator
6 bosses yesterday, no loot
Hpally got the shield
Off mythic terragrue

8 bosses today i got a shard
did hm tazavesh, no gear except quest neck
only piece of sanctum loot so far? a neck
Hopefully get mine on monday
Ayyy nice, no painsmith wall for you
Well no we killed it went guardian and then the offices wanted to clear some normal for dom gear π΄
Which reminds me i forget to check how much that absord shard did
I'm gonna fish for a shield drop in m+ this week, but not going to upgrade if I get one until after reset
Im just gunna pray for one from vault

And the day i get it will be the day the tarrgrue drops one
Basically my hope, is that I get it from the vault or from terragrue next week
If not, I'll just upgrade
i've killed it yesterday, i did most of the soaking with defensive powers and my co tank had some offensive ones
honestly the power to look out for is the ethereal form one or something
the one that dispells you at random intervals
everyone should be getting it if they get the chance
Killed it yesterday, really only soaked the purple
yea i also focused on purple one, but if i saw one close to me not being soaked i got it as well
tarragrue MM with a shield from CN LFR was not fun
Tbh I'd recommend going for more defensive focused powerw. It's a pretty healing intensive fight to begin with and he hits like a truck. Granted I did it on my 223 prot pally so kinda undergeared for mythic but that being said I'd still just go more defensive powers, if you dont need them just reroll
yea
i believe i had like 3 defensives on our kill
my parse was shit but im running necro with glory so im already going support lmao
if you get the leech one or the one that spawns a worm or something it gives you like around 1k dps by itself
Kekw, dropped to #44 now

When I did have dps powers though I was like number 5 on our meters

Tarra...
Got it ty all. And yeah I also am necro with simp banner so idgaf about parses or I'd be sad hah
When do you guys taunt swap for heroic sylv
Just on arrows or when she drops stacks too?
a slightly dumb question but can you leap mechanics on painsmith or is it a no leap to death?
looks like good old community perception is still holding strong that we are shit M+ tanks, getting into a key as a Prot Warrior if pugging continues to be a pain
You can leap it's risky though
ah ok thanks may need to test it fully next raid
i wish TW would give renown
I haven't really had a problem. What faction?
make your own keys, i mean ppl want what is easy.
Make sure you jump and then leap while mid air, that will clear you from the spiked balls. The only problem is to execute this correctly in the heat of combat
Also, you can consider running bounding strides, that should give you comfortable uptime for leaps almost every weapon hurl
Shard of Beks or Rev if you only have one domination socket?
hello everyone,have a question: should i use alchemy trinket 230 or stone legion heraldry 220 with 44 avoidance on it?
pretty unsure about it
what can i do for make my stats better for M+ i think i gonna melt at some point?
Is Night Fae really the best covenant for M+?
It brings a lot of dmg, soul shape for more ability and what's more important it brings shockwave which is broken ability that interrupts almost everything. RN i think it lost a bit in value cuz of plumage, but still rly powerfull. Overall as warrior i am kyrian cuz before this season it was the most desirable covenant for tanks in dungeons cuz of bonuses, but now many more classes took kyrian so it's much easier to take NF
it is kyrain while night fae is close
alchemy trinket 230 for more main stats
i don't have problem so far it might be different factors like rio, gear, and etc
Am I better just getting 252 gloves with crit mastery vs a 246 ring with 74 haste 173 mastery just based off it giving actual strength on it from my vault?
Jk I just committed to pants
at renown 48 are we liking Pelagos or Mikanikos?
If I'm playing warrior, but jumping between arms and prot (raiding prot right now), is it worth switching to NF or just keeping things the same as a Kyrian? Is there enough of a difference?
If i have a coordinated group, is the damage boost provided from the necrolords (with or without Glory)worth running?
kyrian is probably where you want to be then as that will be the go to for arms shortly aswell
have a question on the same note as mirra kinda. Is the sim for necro banner with a venthyr boomy with leggo or is it nf boomy
Anyone have any tips on how they keep from tunnel visioning while tanking as prot.
Seems like I get too focused on one thing then the others really lack
haste >>>> all
It's a whole new world at 30%, for me at least. Died alil inside when i have to give up 3% haste for ilvl
Anyone else getting mad juked by loot ?
Gotten..1 heroic glove...1 normal mode aegis trinket, 1 old warrior soul trinket. 2 normal clears, 9/10 heroic clear, mythic terragrue, and got back up to guardian dead in heroic..will go back through 9/10 heroic and work on heroic sylv this week.
3 items..? in almost 4 clears? (and a few shards)
practice. simple as. focus on one thing till it becomes natural then move on the next thing
What mod is that you have that shows the soft cap?
Anyone playing venthyr prot here?
I am
Is it possible to do +15 to +18 with coordinated group?
Yea, definitely
Being venthyr wont stop you from being able to do any content
It just doesnt benefit Prot as much as the other Covenants
Cuz I would like to play both fury and prot but dislike other covenants look π
You can definitely do so as Venthyr, it wont stop you
Gameplay and skill will affect your ability to do higher keys far more then your covenant choice
In 9.0 even before reprisal and all that, the #1 pwarr was venthyr and did 23s and 24s
Its 100% doable to do way better as a venthyr prot now
yo guys is it worth using a 226 onehand with crit/mastery over my 220 haste/vers weapon as a prot warrrior in M+, or is it too much giving up on survivability? Especially on fortified now, and I'm Venthyr prot @jade yarrow ;)
Yes it's worth
offhand smh
those are for casters you wear a shield my guy
and ilvl alllllways
what changed and its way better now?
gear cap is bigger and we have better conduits and soulbinds now
honestly you could always do 15+ if you had no covenant at all
And no leggo
and also the general community knowledge about m+ has gotten a lot better
yea ok i get it its enough to do content . im asking what changed and its better now than it was before
Nothing really its just as capable as before
Just as harrow said lnowledge is more
And we pray that venthyr prots dont use condemn on 3+targets cause its useless there
so it was a lie / joke / bs ok ty
15-18 is just easier than it was than it was in 9.0 if you came into it with any gear at all
so it's even more true than it was before that you can be whatever you want to do keys at that level
I mean ita not bs or a joke, harrow is correct it is easier as venthyr prot now but it also easier for every other covenant like in a few weeks 20s will probably be like the 15s from last patch tbh, maybe not quite as scaing etc. But 15s aee pretty ez now and we havent even unlocked full soulbinds ot got alot of new gear
For instance i got ksm yesterday and ive got like 3 extra ilvls to what i had when the patch started
You have reprisal now
Has nothing to do with venthyr
ok so venthyr still trash
it wouldn't be my pick for prot especially in keys, no, but if you're a fury main and alt speccing
prot is fine on its own now because of reprisal
the covenant abilities are additional trimmings
w.e man keep being dense. go in keys without covenant and legendaries and trinkets and w.e because you can time 15 without those anyway right? pepegas in here
bb
good riddance

π you can't time 15s with being suboptimal and skill alone π
That's not how games work π
should see my Dos from last night then KEKW
forgot i was in raid talents
cant cope with ppl like that tbh like honestly what do they expect?
u can only do 15s as a kyrian with rep?
Na, must be the games fault
All I see is l33ch
Same but without shards

of course u did
Accretion is the shield shard?
yer upgraded a few times
Does the blood shard bonus seem a little underwhelming to anyone else? Not got it to test yet it just reads pretty weak to me
dont have it cant say
Fair, I'll have to wait and see then. The unholy bonus is looking real tasty though
Is it just me or does HoA feel like the nastiest dungeon right now? Timer is pretty tight, so I do need to combine some pulls, but I keep getting wrecked by wicked bolts. Any advice?
wicked bolts got buffed so its kinda meh if u dont intrupt now tbh
Just got a grim codex from ToP.. =\ I know the thing looks like doodoo but has anyone actually ever used one in a key? does it end up doing ok overall damage?
and the timers alwasy been tight
Jiru..yeah you gotta' blast/stun/kick..and if there's an inspiring mob with casters it's a nono, gotta' cc.
outside of optimizing the route and palying well theres not much u can do with HoA
Do you have a good route for this week?
I swear NW timer is also so whack but in the opposite way. 16 deaths and 2 full wipes with a missed orb
Still timed
nah NW is just easy cause weps
my route will have changed as they fixed the torment spawn points last night
? 'fixed' ?
yer
What was wrong?
2 were spawning in the first boss room yesterday
wait, I thought they were supposed to move around when switching from tyra to forti
which isnt supposed to be happening
...sure..that's cool right? lel~
They did. I hope they don't fix the snapping/pet pulling cheese on a couple of the obelisk mobs in various keys.
Like..those tricks are what you 'learn' to help push keys better...removing them just takes away some of the fun of it.
I got that shard of annhyldes aegis from our second normal clear; it's a really good defensive trinket but does nearly no damage... π¦
I've now used it in quite a few keys, 15/16/17 it does no damage. You can pop that shield on the biggest pack ever but overall it's just not adding barely any damage to the run; but as a defensive tool it's stronk..stonks are high. But I don't have a new scale yet either.
What's really surprised me is Codex of the first technique. It's mediocre in keys but it's insane in challenging raid content. In a normal run it'll do meh damage..in a heroic sanctum it'll often be my 4th highest damage source. (beating my cotanks 239 phial substantially)
I found out something cool today that i wanted oto share altho some of you may know that already
On spires, goliath boss, the stomp can be autotriggered by walking into other players and dipping away before the cast finishes and reflect it
And for as much damage as it does; it does that much healing...but if you get 'bad' proc rng on it..meh.
i got like 20 % extra damage just by reflecting the dot left by the stomp
and it drains the energy faster
Twinblade it used to be reflectable if you just GOT INTO the circle with the other player; then they made it so it HAD to be cast on you; making it a lot more difficult to reflect it.
Are you able to control the cast, or you have to just run 'out' and try and bait it to you?
Stomp can be triggered if you walk into other people
i walk int omy melee and it starts casting it 90% of the time
and obviously walk out before it finishes
OH oh sorry I'm not talking about stomp...the thing I meant you used to be able to reflect was the thing he targets on dps they have to run out with.
there are 2 damage components to the stomp so im not sure if a dps can take the stomp and reflect the dot for extra damage
the dot lasts really long and if you can get it to the damage amp phase its even better
Might have to science it and see if it can be baited and reflected reliably..I've had it happen but wasn't sure how to control it. ...makes me long for the 1? or 2? weeks we could reflect mythic Goroth's main mythic mechanic in Tomb of Sargeras.
With the double reflect pants in legion you could absolutely trivialize that entire mythic fight alone as a prot war.
Gotta aim properly
It's only a 90Β° angle
Whereas the Shield itself is 180
I'm tanking the mobs in front of me on my shield and they are going to spread out a bit if it's a lot of mobs.
like it's a 1.7%'ish of my damage type of thing..is it doing more for other folks? (in overall end of dungeon)
BTW
anyone having their invis pots insta break constantly in dungeons almost ALL the time now? Is it the adaptive armor fragment or something else?
is the one-time-free-conveewnatn change noch aktiv?
@sick sentinel you trigger stomp by walking inside the bosses hitbox
Not by going near other players
And you don't always want to trigger it, you don't want to phase early before damage cds are ready (unless the boss will die anyway during the phase)
interesting
most cds are usually kept for those anyway
very few classes can pop on pull and still pop on damage phase
and since nobody pops on the smallies Its best to drain the energy asap
so people can get off their cds
shard of cor or dyz for the 5th shard if i wanna take kyr as well for raid progression?!
I'm talking more about the second intermission i guess but on most key levels (esp on fort) if you're only getting one intermission then sure
Ugh, I got yhr Mythic Boots for Terra, now I need to move my Leggo grom my boots to legs
.<
they should be on legs anyway
Hey just wondering, i have a Mouseover macro for Intervene, but alot of the times, if a player is out of range it comes up like this... which requires me to right click and then try intervene again, which makes it really awkawrd, does this happen to anyone else?
is unholy the way to go for more damage as a tank? or blood is still better
π€·
If you don't put intervene as an @mouseover macro it works like heroic leap, you enter the "interact" mode thingy
Until you cancel that mode again
is there any way to split a log? like i have done yesterday tarrargue as rogue and the eye as tank, is there any way to get only one fight in the logs?

Ya
Literally says that in the bottom left when you upload it in the tool
"select specific raid" or smth
Anyone know if theyve change the aggro-range of the zolramus gatekeeper dude closest to the way to the 2nd boss? been going left side to 1st boss and you can just skip him but last time he aggrod
Just curious
"Split log" is done so the .txt isn't a 7gb big file but you get an individual file for every date
Is hunt exhilaration better than vorkai ambush on Korayn for M+?
That's precisely why I crafted reprisal on legs
What are the chances that the endboss of next patch is gonna have legs again with increased ilvl
I did it yesterday and ran by just fine hugging the βgate/portalβ blocking the stairs
Opened the vault to find 252ilvl Haste/Vers legs inside⦠P A I N.
i know i didnt play very well in that last dungeon, but geez people are quick with friendly tips
Yeah thats what ive always done and its always been fine for me. Someone usually pulls it so idk what causes it. Thanks
Safest bet is to just shroud over to the Goliath though assuming you have a rogue
Yeah probably
I like the quad pull - take spear - go left and kill miniboss then clear to boss and take goliath
But it doesnt really matter tbh
Been blessed with a blood scale this week
didn't get one at all last season. Even stacked m0 to upgrade it. Looking good for a start point
Yeah honestly kinda blessed with that first weeks vault
Although my Co tank did tell me to "sod off"
π
Tell them you used it to increase your Shield Slam damage. 
hehe
weapons item level +3 or prefer values?
Ilvl
Yeah it does the same for me but i kinda just click anyways so meh
big
like, is choosing BV over BSC a matter of survivability or is it also better single target damage
both
It's not detrimental
But you're just better off running BV in raid
Unless it's a fight with a ton of multitarget cleave
Yeah, how much is a ton
are we talking like eye 2 target cleave
or the nine
or like 3+ sustained
3+ sustained
right, thanks
What is BV and BSC again?
booming voice
(booming)
oh right yeah
At this point it's just commitment
its just what I remember it as ok
so what if I battle shout instead of demo shout sometimes
For high end m+, should I be stacking vers? I'm prioritizing ilvl > haste > vers and I feel like I'm getting clapped
Ilvl > haste > vers is correct
If you're getting clapped, someone is making mistakes
Either you, or your group
lol
Keep in mind, our mitigation is much much worse right now
Unless you already have a big dick shield already
Getting back into tanking some m+ for guild in the 12 to 15 range...with reprisal is bsc or bv the play? And is it AM last tier?
In m+ always reprisal + BSC + am
Thanks!
Does anyone have a Sanctum of Domination spell reflect list?
its in the pins
Pinned
I'm wondering if I should go for the left or right variant for prot hmm
when u got your 3 set yes
Ah okay, so the 37 leech is not worth 6 ilvls
Not alone no
but but...LEECH
hmm okay, so I guess the fact that it's haste versa vs crit haste doesn't change it?
stats dont really matter
okay
Better stat are mostly a nice-to-have, not a requirement
ooh today i came to think about that essence that snared mobs with TC. good times
idk i like to bully mobs π
thats why i like the vulcanic plumage now
satisfying to see the mobs bounce up and down
lowkey think BDK might become meta just because of plumage
is there a tbc classic specific warrior discord anyone knows of?
what would you guys spend your valor on? shield upgrade or weapon
scale & shield imo
oki
but weapon/good trinkets like scale/phial/anime and possibly ring with huge stats 
How is prot faring in keys so far this tier
Not any worse than last tier
So, pretty well
But nobody of the real pushers is pushing for another few weeks
Cuz you gotta get your gear and finish raiding first
This week I have found pretty punishing in keys for healers, those whom are not used to handling Grievous have had a hard time keeping up, for us its no different than any other grievous week, but some of the healers I have pugged with have had a rough time of it
Is 252 Quantum worth picking up from the vault? I do M+ only π
nope
Thanks π
Grievous ain't that bad without pride being a thing anymore.
I just want equality on tanks regarding grievous stack removal
Because soulcleave is a direct heal it removes a stack of grievous from dhs, so they can never get above 1 stack
would you suggest IP to remove a stack?
askin again if anyone knows if unholy has better damage than blood in terms of shards of domination
you could sim it in raidbots, but im pretty sure we'll have some general sims/info pinned over the weekend
Blood aoe unholy single it would seem
Honestly, why isn't Indomitable treated as healing? I hear it's not proccing that one shard either ("helpful spell" so you'd think, say, IP would count)
More like indom
hey guys is there a haste cap that we do not want to exceed?
39%
Hi, does anyone know, if a shard can be upgraded if it's inside an item?
alright, thanks
what do you use for deathlink? looks like there was some discussion in this channel saying to use shield block, but blockable speadsheet is listing it as not blockable?
pretty sure you just pray, that fight kinda sucks for us
IP and SW can keep you alive when shit gets hairy
and yeah SB still works for some damage so you dont want to ignore it
My god, prot is still busted AF, just finished second in overall damage in a TOP +12
I stack haste (1035) and ver(620)
Damn that's a bad group you had then
It was, but doing 4.7k dps is nothing to scouff at
Big fan of wake, most of its weapon pad but you can get some big numbers π
Easy 8k dps
Why is it that every prot warrior I run into runs the wall and sub 3k dps? Had a 229 warrior tank an SD+10 last night, so disappointed in his damage
my NW run without me using weapons 
cuz they bad
NW is such a numbers pad!
I would hesitate to let DPS use the orbs
orb doesnt generate threat
Yeah, but half the time they don't hit all the mobs because they're not paying attention to where they're standing
Ah, I still use orb on trash, I just use spears on bosses
I feel like Amarth is the only one that's troublesome, or a DPS dying on the last boss
3rd boss is ultra rippy
everytime its tyra
dps just love to miss hook
and its gg by that point
Yeah, missing a hook is bad
practically a guaranteed wipe
if a hook gets missed
cuz you will then get too many adds
what do you need a timesave for if you cant guarantee to kill the boss fast enough
like with the comps i run
boss dmg is whats always lacking the most
If it were me, I just simply wouldn't wipe on the bosses
idk NW always failed on bosses for me
literally always
either chain wiping to 2nd or 3rd boss
hate that dungeon
Anything after the 1st boss is easily wipeable
Tbh
i literally prefer SD over NW
I guess I just haven't had problems in there in a long time
I prefer any dungeon over spires....
Easily my best dungeon
just don't play tyr 4Head
though i am interested to see what kinda comps come out for the nosebleed pushers to get their tyrannical score
or if they'll even care and just focus on WF fort keys
Usually spear + hammer feels like enough for the bosses, orbs just do so much damage on trash I can't justify using them unless I'm about to wipe on amarth
yeah venthyr moonkin gonna be stonks
idk, my hammers and spears do literally 0 dmg
bosses always take longer than people take on fucking 25s
Me and my rogue friend crit 2 spears and a hammer on the last boss the other day in a 15, boss died in 17 seconds :D
No, sounds nutty, lol
it's already hotfixed tho
Aw
they showed it on the last titanforge pod i think
i think it's ok if they just crit based on your chars crit chance
and not wacky soulbind stuff
I guess, it just feels like such huge time saves from RNG
Bad look for a competitive format
wdym, on 28 its only a difference of 500k if you crit or not
25% boss hp variance is FINE

our mage crit with hammer and spear on stitchflesh in our 16 last night... 20s fight
I saw someone say theres a bug in how necrolord banner chooses its targets. is that still a thing? where can I find info on that?
its fixed for a while again
ok so its just the closest people right?
ya it works again as it should
cool thanks
when i can upgrade to max gear but got no gear to upgrade cause i dont get loot

when a rank 3 shard is nearly as powerful as a torment power
Jesus
Wow! 11% of your healing was from the leech shard alone???
how much leech do i need to do 20s?
17
ty
%
see i have a i lemma do i keep my 226 shoulders so i can have 7% leech or do i take 229 shoulders and go down to 4%

That leech seems very nice, what shard gives you accretion?
You're using both?
i have both yer but i do have leech on like 4 pieces of gear
so your also seeing that leech
Depending on goal and content, going for damage bonus could be better right?
well the main stats from full unholy
may be nutty for dps and the extra strength for the armour
when sims are done we will tell u guys im sure
Right right thats what I'm thinking

I see aegis as well
Have you guys compared scale yet?
well aegis isnt working correctly right now
its doing this damage right now
instead of its self
but the mitigation from it is insane
Oh nice it's none target capped it appeara
Does it give a basically full health bar shield like scale does?
More
its uncapped mitigation
Shard of Bek or Shard of Rev for the first domination socket?
And an ardenweald pull for a dh it absorbed 250k
In 1 use
"Your damage is increased by 1.9% when you have 50% or more health than your target" sounds strange. Does it trigger if I have >50% in front of a raidboss?
Wow!
It reads like it should only mitigate 10k??
Im not reading it correctly
It looks to me like the tool tip says up to 9900
Lmao brains fried to much work today
It lowers the damage of EVERY ATTACK by X amount for 8 seconds. PERIOD
Then it has a 2nd portion
If you mitigate X amount or more, you will deal dmg once the effect ends
Aka after 8seconds are over
so even a lower ilvl of that would be better than a max scale?
Depends on how big you pull
do I not need to chase a new scale? faints
Theoretically yes it seems like
Aegis can absorb infinite for 8 seconds yeah?
Basically, aegis gets better the higher keys you do
the more autos the better
Because on low keys, you don't take enough damage
With SB up you're literally immune to damage with aegis up
For 8 seconds
Easy pick now I just wait for it to never drop
I feel like we should get a pin to explain the trinket
Cuz reading comprehension isn't a strong suit of alot of people 
Me warrior, me no read
After you lowered the iq of the text for me I got it
Do you have a cool weak aura for the trinket?
the cool WA needs to make sure you cover the largest portion of your screen/character, so you intentionally stand in bad while it's active
I was reading this tool tip btw I just figured out why I wasn't comprehending what you were telling me @strong forum
Hah
Ya no that's just a garbage trinket
But aegis is bugged, so it doesn't do its own dmg, but it does that garbage trinkets damage
I'd appreciate it @strong forum. Even with your explanation I'm struggling to connect it with the text on the trinket. That could be because, like @dusky canopy, my brain is fried. I've been cleaning a cooling tower today and probably lost several gallons of water doing it.
hey guys someone can send me to th correct path, which conduits/tree route is best for venthyr, draven
like wowhead mentions for example this route, bud i dont think this is a good talent because we as a tanks dip below 50 almost every boss fight or big pull
Hello, will the blood shards remain bis for prot bois?
Will have to see what Sims spit out on the weekend
Kay, got it
are the shards like regular gems, where replacing one destroys it?
Yes
You should use the chisel to remove the shard
That way it doesn't get destroyed
what?
huh. i didn't know that existed
is solo soaking obliterate on guardian of the first ones just a monk thing? no way protwar can do that right?
Every tank should be able to solotank for 99% of time I think
But I guess CB + Zen med is quite OP on that
124k arcane dmg on heroic
Pally can soak it with bubble

And pwar with scale + SW / Demo / IP should be good aswell
yeah couple cds
120k isn't all that much if you count in some CDs
SW + IP should be enough tbh
If you're full HP
how good is the nerzhul trinket?
No clue I just know that i don't want it
Just want a better old warrior soul now; and Garrosh's trinket (looks cool) and a heroic/mythic of the aegis..that trinket @pale panther quality will be god tier in M+
and I guess a max upgrade or vault phial because..it's still good ST
Does that decanter of howling not do well, no one seems to even talk about it.
yeah trinket seem to work that it will periodically spawn a small one-hit ad
that you cant aoe
like explosives
then you kill it and get the stats
no not that one
1 global spent on damaging on it is wasted
I don't want that one; where you face your fear or whatever
OH yeah I know that one isn't good..I mean the one from garrosh ( basically..no one cares about that loot pinata guy..only the cut scene after π
it has only 1.5procs per minute
I love pugging keys.. was 2200 season 1, i'm 9/10 mythic CN, 9/10 heroic SoD, 1974 season 2 rating now (trying to get DoS 15+ so I can finish 2k achieve) 235 ilevel... and the guy with the 15 dos key is "I dunno if prot warrior can tank good?"
...? bruh..do I have to start pvp'ing too?
most people dont know that prot is good in keys
its pretty shit
no it's all good..I'll just push for gladiator as prot..maybe THEN people will go "oh prot war is ok?"
probably not
for every 1 of you
theres 45 people still pressing ignore pain as damage mitigation
Never even heard of it? Is it that thing that looks like a sword we got last night?
YUP
FUUuuuu
the guy who got that, was an officer who main heals so he put it up for trade in our heroic run (loot council)
of COURSE it went to an ACTUAL dps class..those LOOT WHORES.
imagine thinking tanks have loot prio
i dunno i got into a dos 15 fine last night an im 228 ilvl
Every time a dps trinket goes up for loot council I put the note "Nice DPS toy.."
I know jakey..it's randos who don't know lol (I just got into one actually)
i was inting the key hard was in raid talents still timed though
jakeys trollingsmh

People who are actually good at keys know warriors are fine; people who are barely scraping up to 15's are trying to get 'meta comps' because Naguura or Dratnos says so~
playing war and bear... i dont really blame people for wanting a safer tank
but atm i am certainly "scraping up to 15s"
does this work for you?
i had the same thought at first
it would kinda make sense with their usual philosophy for it to work that way too
they're saving you time and blood pressure by not taking you tbh
but apparently it's uncapped gigaDR
IF i get declined froma key cause "prot cant do 15s" im honestly the one winning there
It does. Thank you. I realize my mistake now. I was trying to connect your explanation to the other trinket, which is completely different from this one.
That font is atrocious

Don't make the outline so thick on it
bro i have to retype
You have like size 5 outline on it bro
smh nome
@modern brook what a weird thing to see. every tank class can do 15s. why would anyone say that?
Because people that play world of warcraft are actually the worst world of warcraft players in the world.
lol
i suppose we all have our biases. i tend to avoid priest healers because i just don't feel comfortable with them healing me.
what if it's higher ilvl?
itll obv be higher reduction
i played with a disc preist yesterday that just completely destroyed my notion that disc cant play on greivous
barely noticed it existed
very impressed
it does 2.8k or somthing to everything it is dependant on pull size i used it on all blobs in PF and it did like 80k 
i haven't met that disc priest yet. my experience with disc on grievous is pull slow and small
same
my go-to healers are shaman and druids
also my personal experience learning disc was to jump into a 15 atal dazar on grevious week
2 hours later i dont play the class naymore :^)
lol
my first (and last) experience healing as resto shaman was a +4 black rook hold back in legion.
my last healing experience was rsham mage tower
yeah, after that BRH, i was just "nope" to healing anything. i'm not suited for it, really. i enjoy tanking, and when i'm not tanking, i want to hit things with big axes, so arms.
Don't @ me about this trinket. I just make picture.
Disc priest gone prot warrior this patch. Grevious isnβt bad if your team doesnβt eat every mechanic like some like to do
a man after my heart
ah. White text
pug healing is great, you never know if you are walking into an LFR or mythic raid dungeon
with black border
IDK @errant thorn i liked it better with a 80pnt outline
