#protection
1 messages · Page 3377 of 1
NOw this XPac is a bit different
there are some outliers that are just WAYYYY to overtuned
and blizzard didn't address them at all
but we don't know if it overrepresents skills or overrepresents the GM's brother who mom makes him let raid with him
rather they doubled down on "we don't want to shake things up"
the problem is that they have a general rule of no big buffs once a tier has started, so you don't get screwed one week to the next
which unless they're going to hand out free rerolls is probably for the best
Right, the issue is they should have addressed all of these issues heroic week
and htey didn't because that was holidays
the other issue is that some spells are just awkwardly designed
like starfall is kind of a wat
strong start of expansion but with 0 effective haste scaling
they basically released SL, made sure it was stable and then sent everyone on Christmas vacation
tbf, did you want blizz to cancel xmas vacations for their employees
"scrooge in hostile takeover of activision-blizz"
I Mean, Kotick is in charge now
so it wouldn't have surprised me
But nah, class balance doesn't make you any money
no one is going to quit the game because their favorite spec is garbage, they'l just complain that its garbage
meanwhile someone locked the survival hunter designer in their locker years ago and hasn't checked back since
you know what i think is wild
if you look at the class writers on wowhead saying "What covenant is best for your spec in 9.0.5"
Prot war and Frost DK are the only 2 with 3 options in M+
like everything else is so pigeon holed
I guess Havoc and Resto Sham are "any"
but even then, 4 specs in the whole game have 3 or more choices
Havoc is "Lol you're there to simp for the fire mage"
"do whatever, it doesn't matter!"
true 
horribly enough, I've been looking for a HDH for a few weeks now.
non one plays it
trying to hint to my paladin co tank that he could totes go Vengeance..
ew pink bois
eh, he does alright
ignore the fact my RL is a Pink healer
hdh is just a big sleep class
I have a holy paladin that carries me through Sire phase 3
so I can pump 
my healing intake on P3~
getting tunneled so I can execute, big 👍
How prot is looking at 9.0.5 on m+?
muy bien

More protty
Just levelled my warrior up and got its weekly m+ this week, do I open my first chest as prot or fury/arms?
We're quite protty already, but with the changes to reprisal and our DPS Buff, we'll be even prottier.
prot boi, get that phat shield
Are you going to tank?
If so, always shield
yeh
Big protti boy
on my dk always made complete sense to open as unholy, but seems less sensible on the prot warr though both have its pro's and cons I guess
Our biggest upgrade will always be 🛡️
whats the word on meta with the soulbinds for Necro and talents then with 9.0.5? for raid and m+?

I mean, VDH will still be meta
for M+
because flappy boys can run and go pew pew from far away
how does dh pew pew from far away?
Decree, glaive, brand
fuck im dumb
what about warriors tho
is Emeni or whatshisface best for Necro?
They do big pre pea
i 100% deleted how vdh worked in my mind
Lol
Emnem best
I mean it requires 0 brainpower to pilot a dh
the i dont like friends princess
AM taking over Bolster too? seeing as reprisal is pumping extra SB in for us?
they engage with devastation and grind some aggro for the duration of demonic then poop decree and jump out
Yeah, no point in Bolster with reprisal giving us 90%~ block uptime.
dont exist weapon and shield in GV
more avatars for more deepus
More deeps = higher in meta

i forget the mane, but the legendary who gives SS plus 5 rage is not goos?
good*
name*
hmmm
its currently the leading lego for M+ and raids
but Reprisal addresses our QoL on engage issue
no more choice between offense/defense and getting trucked on engage.
QoL?
quality of life
quality of life
ah, thx
engage? like on pull?
It covers up a lot of the newb traps and bloopers that can happen on pull for prot
yes
okies
that is what engage means
thanks, wasnt 100%
has anyone tried ascended vigor as prot and does it seem to work well? or should i go with lightless force
Unbreakable Will is not very good, no
too high of an opportunity cost, and it only affects your party, not the whole raid
Its not good because The Wall gives us more personal uses of shield wall in an encounter, and a ton more rage.
And the "group" effect is limited to your group, not raid, so its not even a solid CD
aaaah, i dont know that
The charges are also recharged consecutively rather than simultaneously, thus, if you use them back to back, even with AM you're looking at close to a 6minute wait for both charges.
if is raid buff, this will be broken, btw
IF its raid buff it would be better than Holy paladins major CD
yeah lol
so, no that won't happen.
bether of any healer cd, maybe
we already have Rallying Cry which is an insanely powerful raid CD since it can be used proactively or reactively.
( its better to be used proactively)
(sorry about my english, i'm not native english speaker)
Its ok.
Some of us are native English speakers and can't formulate a coherent sentence.
i'm portuguese native, maybe the most difficult linguage....
I can confirm, I was a cop for 5 years..... my co-workers could barley formulate sentances
this is true lmao
Just gotta say, ya'll talk too fast 😄
hi all, is there a way to soak orbs at 43th boss SoA?
brazillian or portuguese?
yer
can do it at 18
lvl at least if u have last stand and sw ready
and the healer actually heals u
instead of damage
ok , ty ,
one of the times you actually do want to spam Ignore Pain
oh boy they removed the valor cap
well i ran into an issue wherei was soaking them while still hitting the boss for rage and ppl thought i wasnt soaking them
so next time i just saved spear and rav for rage gen
☝️
time to farm bois
ascended vigor or lightless force on weapons, mainly tanking m+?
🤘
I use Lightless Force
not sure slightly more aoe dmg feels like it would be helpful
splitting hairs that have been split
use whatever is cheapest

what keystone have i in vault when i make a 15? i read its not downgrade?
how long before people complain that "now I'm expected to run m+ nonstop for 220 gear"
did you time the 15
ruining it for everyone
if you timed a 15, you will get a 15
yeah if you make it that's what you get
Better than running it non stop for 210 gear that never drops.
ye time
what leggo should i craft if im serious about pushing m+ as a prot come 9.0.5?
talking keys around +19
reprisal but also 
I feel like if you're doing 19s you should know, or am I being silly?
☝️
☝️
I check io on prot warriors lmao, none of which run reprisal which is intersting lmao
because its getting changed literally tomorrow



👆


maybe everyone in prot hard stuck on level 5 keys idk

Maybe asking for advice with an attitude isn’t the best way to start off around here
lmao
But to answer your question, 
Or in any class discord I imagine
Is anyone switching to Necro for raids after the buff?
It seems now having a prot warrior >>> dps warrior
I am not sure if it is the play or not as of yet
anyone? yes. Me? no
prot warrior was already better, or less bad, than dps warrior outside of a few fights
has a good breakdown @violet dome
necro would pretty much only be if you have a coordinated strategy and the right classes to benefit
maybe

I looked at the pin and it doesn't really answer my question. I understand the function of the banner, just not sure if I should swap from Kyrian
i would go as far as to say if you're not sure if you should be switching to necro, you will gain nothing by doing so
If your group is organized and is gonna play around it specifically then yes. If not, then no
Apologies for not
immediately like a 5head prot warr like all in here. Pins do me as great as icey veins tells me to not click to move or use a track pad in raid lmao
buddy just stop while youre behind
a little humility goes a long way
eat your humble pie and be thankful you were given helpful answers
You okay there?
they straight up told you reprisal, they told you why
and then they told you to check the pins for more
Mwahi has awoken
I have a guild that I raid with but I also PUG raids a lot so it sounds like staying Kyrian is best for both circumstances unless my guild says otherwise
because when i literally scroll up
and read the chat
they both gave you the answer and the reason
Just was about to go off, smh.
if you pug a lot i would stay kyrian personally, if necro isn't played around specifically it loses a lot of its value
Yeah, and that makes sense. If I switched, I'd do it for my guild raids.
if you pug raids NL banner buff is gonna be wasted
you may depart us once again, he appears to have fled
been thinking about swapping to Night Fae for prot warrior, or should i wait to hold off and see how necrolord does? (i usually just pug +15 and +16s)
i wouldn't really switch to necro for m+ at all
it might be a niche thing but nf/kyrian are still gonna be dominant there
Just ping me if needed. 👀
same as my previous statement, if you pug a lot i wouldn't go necro. If its not played around it loses value
Ok, thanks for the info, guys. I'll talk it over with my guild and go from there.
❤️
thanks i kinda figured
also it's not a prot thing but if you are looking at warrior holistically
nf is going to be better as dps
neither arms nor fury wants to be necro even with the change
yeh i like to go fury warrior offpsecing sometimes and everyone runs night fae in that case
yeah if thats the case I'd for sure go NF
@patent osprey if you have a moment I did some creeping. How valuable is that cardboard assassin belt enchant?
^ fucking broken
i expect them to nerf it really really soon
since everyone is starting to pick ti up
I wouldnt of been able to time a 22 dos without it i think
at least not with our route
its basically trees right, so you hit trees, then cardboard x 5 and then all ur cds are recharged again and you can trees again soon
its busted

i never even thought to look at old engi enchant
thats wild
i'm gonna use that lmao
Is that the same thing they used on the spirit breaker in s4 bfa?
Brown hard paper 
engi belt enchant that makes a dummy that taunts
If you get 5 people to drop them at the same time you can buy the tank some time
i thought about going back to the bfa shield or knockback one
but i never even thought of going older
How hard is it to farm up this cardboard thing? 😄
Im curious towards necro too but i think its not yet appealing.. lets stay Venthyr prot atm its a good flex covenant
And does the whole group have to have it?
And im afraid going back to NF and getting it nerfed
its engineering from cata
believe so yes
so i wouldn't say its a pug saver, move of an organized group thing
just guessing
yeah unless you're like, super planning to play around the banner i wouldn't worry about switching asap or anything
@deep steppe Hmm, and it doesnt replace the invisibility belt right? Just a shared CD with it. I might get it for myself just to help out a little tiny bit then if there's really no drawback.
you can only have 1 enchant on your belt as far as i know
so it'd replace it i think
that's probably a no then. invis too useful
Just means you'll go back to using invis pots.
Yup syncing with OffCds and so.. meh. But damn necro should be busted like their plate sets
But hell yeah reprisal is gonna be so cool
every time i see a mage combust. i get anxiety
im bustin
Nah its because the xmog
If your main tank looks cooler the raid bosses die faster
hey boiz, fury here, is 9.0.5 gonna be any better for prot on +15's?
I really wanna spec tank also
Prot warrior is gunna be meta next match 
Prot has been omega fine for 15s already

i dont get the first pin. what reprisal nerf?
From 6 to 4 seconds of block
everything is omega fine for 15
honestly
is thunderlord just bad or something?
+16 dos, prot warrior pulls first instadead.
lol no
we're platers, yet leather classe 3x survivability
That’s bevause that prot warrior was bad
First 2 pulls are scary for every tank
^

not even enraged.
Then use shieldblock and kick scribes
Is Necro Banner the biggest DPS when it lines good with ur mates ? Any sims out there already ?
You litterally just group it up
like legit 1shot by second cluster
Don't tank the cluster
Shockwave
Like...
dude i wasn't tanking i was laughing
i mean
just hold s 
i mean, i have a VH DK also and that feels way better
you leap in with heroic leap -> all enemies perfectly synced autoattacks
cg
you played yourself
DH*
bad player does some dumb shit and dies "prot is non viable"
by cluster do we mean lotus?
Dude prot is really good on physical dmg
yeah prot is actually insane on that first pull
but magic dmg legit instadeletes
b/c if so yeah, why are we talking about prot being bad when the issue is between keyboard and chair
shield wall, demo shout, ignore pain
ez pz
boys im a warrior myself
we're superior
but legit prot tanks nowhere to be found
you can also outrange little skele boy frontal
I saw a screenshot of someone 2nd on their realm for prot with 1100 rio (lol)
oh the cd's mate... i mean pushing a 18 key you're gonna spend sum time on the mobs this week
i miss thinking i was top shit for being rank 1 my realm back in 8.0
with like 1300 lol
As somone who loves tanking M+ and hates Vangance I am want to play prot after the buffs. You think it's going to vaiable damage wise?
yep
Dude i'm fury and I admit that we suck overall in comparison with some other classes.
Pwar dmg will be comparable to a regular vdh
you mean all lol
Atleast in m+
What js a regular vdh
A dh not using spb
someone timing 25s
fotm reroller
you have no idea mate.
Spb?
Spirit bomb
i pushed my own NW 17 key with 206 ilvl ^^ was sec dps afaik
Yuh
Fury is still best overall in m+ and insane at it
I love the fun button
ye with max ilvl
does it tickle you in the funny spot
I don't wanna make this about fury it's prot chanell afterall
It does yes
ah yes, the old dead realm days lmao
yeah... I'm on a dead realm and well. yeah.
Dont think you can
okay
now you got incentive to push
im almost breaking into top 10 for my realm
soon(tm)
What ? 😄
I depleted a HoA 17 because we didnt have Venthyr and I blame that, it was going to be over for 1 min then we lost focus on last boss because of it and wiped there
Oh oops i answered the wrong guy, sorry! : P
There was almost no downtime in the threat timer
i'm currently top 1 in my server with 1580io lmao

whats typical avatar cd with AM? 🤔
arround 45-55 seconds i think
~50 seconds depending on your stats.
😮
i thnk that's actually th ebest part of reprisal, beeing able to use AM instead of bolster is going to be great 😄
Not for you
well
huge for a tank i guess
avatar + unstoppable force + banner conduit + emeni + mastery from banner scaling up the inc str gain from prev 2 things even more

which soulblind will be best choose for mythc on 9.5.??i think that guide from wowhead not clear
soulbind preference wouldn't change in this patch
on rio i found only 1 guy from china who play witth
maybe someone can confirm with that?
maybe this soublind this player pick for some sort of pvp
emeni is the best necro soulbind
whats the best slot for the reprisal legendary?
legs for stat budget, but ymmv if you have really badass legs and crappy boots
sweet, and crit haste?
What about seismic? Helm?
@dense burrow haste vers
sweet thanks
i didn't see it in the faq but may of missed it, is there a covenant choice for prot/fury split with a focus on raiding, not M+?
I would think necrolord now
Mastery is nice for fury
but honestly if it's just heroic you can probably do anything you want
About to swap to Necrolord is there anything I should do before swapping covenants?
Just that the banner requires coordination
necro it is, thank you
to use it well in pug mythics you might want a cooldown tracker, mark the dps you are trying to use the buff on so you can make sure people are near and that they have cooldowns to use with it
necro banner is probably something you want voice comms for
I don't like pugging - but if I did I'd probably stay kyrian
cause I don't want to have the experience of feeling like my banner did nothing lol
I'll be swapping from kyrian to necro wednesday after my guilds raid night
don't have the time to grind renown before raiding
so I'll swap later
going to be more hipster than ever to be a venthyr prot warrior
gonna tell my guild im swapping covenants. theyll be so punked when its to night fae
gottem
A rank 6 on time is 165 or around in there. It scales according to the level and if its timed or not
I don't think the amounts have been put in yet
You also get 50 valor for every calling you complete
rank 6 i.e. a +6 key will give you ~165? source for that?
People were saying the other day it doesn’t scale with the key at all, so I’d take all info with a grain of salt atm
warrior best tank soon?
Quick q for necros who tested it on ptr, does conq banner refresh nearest targets or do the two nearest to the Warr on cast just get the buff for the full duration?
is there a way to tell who will get the buff when u drop the banner or u have to see who closest ?
Hah sup rei, cheers
Is emeni really the play for m+? You won't get but maybe 2 other people in range for it, depending on your comp. Heirmirs buff isn't reliant on proximity.
You can get everyone in if you’re playing in a premade
If you’re playing pugs, good luck
Is my off tank trolling if he stays venthyr vs going necrolord
for raid? nope
But what about that masteryyyyy
Not being a stat stick for the raid is not trolling when it’s not the best cov
If you’re pushing wf sure
For US 100 that'd be something you'd have to talk about with your guild
Yea. Warriors dont need to simp
US Alliance top 100 is basically just going for CE so you should be fine with whatever?
I know that Tanks use Versatility. I feel like I have trouble find that a lot on gear. I know that PVP gear has a lot of it. Should I be going for that gear to add more Vers?
ilvl is king, if you like pvp go for it
Fair enough. 🙂 I'm 213 atm...
if you're choosing between two same ilvl pieces then haste > vers > the others but the gap is not huge
Does anyone have a charge / intervene macro that I can use? if im targetting friendly it will intervene ... simple one?
#showtooltip Charge
/cast [target=target,help,exists,nodead]Intervene;Intervene
/cast [target=target,harm,exists,nodead]Charge;Charge
i think that's it?
cheers
I'm on the cusp of pushing 15s; how should I prioritize gearing? ilvl, or secondary stats? I have a few pieces of gear where I could swap to higher ilvl/stam/str but I would lose vers (I'm at like 28% vers iirc)
thoughts?
Gotcha.
Should I use pawn's default stat weights for prot, or is there better ones around here?
don't use pawn
Haven't heard anyone using pawn personally and you can't really sim for tankiness
Don't use pawn? So... is there some alternative? Considering you can't sim tanks very well.
Just go on priorit pawn very unessisary
priorit?
You can look through your logs, or post them here and usually someone can point you in a good direction if you feel something is off
Reprisal > Thunderlord for m+?
Pins
Yes to that
i see the pins, just curious why, seems like thunderlord would have better damage
Pawn at this point is a relic of an era where sims weren't as thorough or as well-maintained, and you could never sim 'tankiness' anyway so Pawn is guessing at best when it comes to that
Reprisal gives u free rage which will add up to more dmg
And free revenge which is more dmg than clap
20flat 30off block 20 off revenge proc
Gotcha.
The block prob closer to 25rage as it's only 4sec tho
So reprisal > the wall tomorrow?
Ah ty
what are our best trinkets? do we value the same as mentioned above (ilvl > function)?
trinkets for tanks are a little more nebulous and personal
My options are:
Splintered Heart (200)
Slimy Consumptive Organ (203)
Blood Spattered Scale (194)
Grim Codex (210)
Stone Legion Heraldy (207)
IQD (223)
Barghast's Leash (213)
basically you can go for more defense, you could go for more offense, you could go for general tankiness or for an on demand cooldown
the kael'thas one is an example of something that's either insane or useless
entirely based on you your group and your needs
unlike dps trinkets i would advise just
trying them out
and seeing what works
Blood splattered is insane in m+
that's the main standout
Is IQD worth using given it's wild effects?
Any Nighfaes have preference between Korayn or Niya? Which pumps more?
Plka has been running korayn due to first strike iirc
I'm trying to decide between The Wall, Thunderlord or the reworked Reprisal.
Currently using the Wall, but it's maybe not optimal
Check pins
what is a pin?
👍
I literally mod my guild's discord and I didn't know about that 😅
His discord just got 87 pins put in
Lol I believe it
well, my GM does have a bunch of pins up talking raid times and stuff. TIL this is even a thing
is reprisal gonna make avatar/unstoppable force/best served cold the new build?
TFW you have AoTC but have 6 new people come in and have to relearn phase 2 and 3 ><
UF still 🤮
BSC and AM are solid choices.
do we know yet if BSC > BV?
ahh ok, i thought uf would be better with more avatar uptime and the thunder clap buff
I'm going to start off with talents 1112331
My working assumption is that Ravager for more Rage generation means more Revenges and more Avatar uptime.
impending victory? Never take that
its just worse than indom
It's not, but I CBA having that conversation again tonight
Especially when you consider all the rage you can just be dumping into revenge
how relevant is it if I put reprisal on feet instead of legs
Feet will give less stats - slightly - than legs, but if your existing legs are a higher ilvl than your existing feet, the difference is probably null. If you are capable of killing mythic Stone Legion Generals the legs from there are the highest ilvl you can get - no feet match them - and are outright better. But that's only if you can clear mythic Nathria.
yeah my prot warr alt has 226 verse legs and only 210 boots lol
For ppl wanting to try necro prot next reset, which soulbind is the way? Emeni or heimir? And banner conduit still better than the one that buffs clap?
Emeni will be better if you're coordinating the str increase, which if you're swapping to necro you should be doing anyway
on the topic of necro banner, the prevailing thought seems to be it's only worth over kyrian if you can coordinate with your group, but even in pugs, typically the big pulls are obvious no? drop at a the start, drop at the next fat pull following the CD, so on?
I imagine the group dps increase even suboptimal would outweigh the benefit I alone get from spear
The benefit from spear isn't necessarily just the damage
but yes it largely depends on group coordination
true, but I can run fast, leap, intervene
Spear is a god send for leapers I will say
It's more about coordinating who's getting the mastery increase, and if it's a significant improvement. The bonus will be for the 2 closest, which in a pug could be for a healer and some random DPS who's sitting closer than someone who would gain more benefit.
If you can guarantee who's getting the increase then obviously that isn't a problem
yeah... I suppose I'm probably not going to be by my mage or whatever
Just leap on them 4head
Also lot of pulls your image should be close so they can db interrupt
Fmage
Other thing is how many classes actually use kyrian currently since the bonuses are kind of big in those 2 dungeons
Necro representation is super low
So I. The larger sceme might be the play
Thars a good point
uh dks and shamans use necro don't they?
priest was real nice this week though can't lie 🙂
side note why do the slimes at the start of plaguefall burst? Nothing else gets really crazy stack wise but those slimes are pain
like if SD followed those rules dear god it would be so horrible
Sd gauntlet dogs won't apply necro after patch thank god
for mythic council should i run reprisal next week?
So anyone do the math on booming vs best served cold and AM vs HR in M+ with reprisal yet?
Oh and UF vs rav with the clap bump
RAv > UF
Rav just too good I. That row
Put it in booming row and we might have a decision. To make
Not that that would be good for us but yea
See, if you end up taking AM/UF gains value.
you will take AM
but UF still not as good as rav
Mwahi has done it
Where
It’s just hard to just listen to non TCer’s who I’ve never heard of (no offense) provide an answer without reasoning. Sure rav is good, but it’s good right now due to the on demand rage, not due to damage output.
What have I missed that wowhead lists Reprisal as best raid after patch? Thought in raids the wall is still better?
With the change to reprisal rage issues on pull are sort of alleviated meaning you may be able to shift your focus and talents elsewhere. AM provides a positive feedback loop with more rage gained, and TCLAP buff may make UF worth using in it’s place for damage and rage.
The reason nobody ever went UF was bolster was too strong compared to other options in the final row.
if ravager had same cd as avatar it would still be better jfc why are half the questions about it
What I mean by non TCers are people who don’t do the testing on PTR, the math to prove what is better vs the alternative or haven’t written an article with their name on it with scientifically tested info as to which options are better in which situation. Again, no offense but you’re just some person in discord.
Theorycrafter
I mean fair, I am just a discord boi. But if you search back through the last few days. You're not the first to ask that questions, and everytime before you people who do the research/spend the time say rav is the pick. Even if the dam did come out the same, rav would generate more rage/give you more GCDs
And why do you think that. Where’s your reasoning? Are you certain avatar will in fact have the same CD as ravager? You’re not dealing with BFA levels of rage here anymore.
Mwahi has awoken!

That’s single target, right?
Yes
How much rage generation difference between them
is that sim counting ITF at 5 stacks or 1?
5
There are mythic bosses where you lose value on reprisal where you really don’t want to move them or you are unable to move them. Or when the bosses are casting and not doing damage to you anyway. Sludge, Huntsman if you tank boss, Inerva, Hungering. Sure you get charge of on pull and intervene but with boss positioning is scuffed at least for me. When you don’t tank the boss you get damage part out but i don’t personally see any huge benefit in the way my guild plays the bosses. Maybe i’m bad so i don’t totally get it
5
no lol i am saying even if they greatly increased the frequency you could use UF it would still be worse than ravager. its the lowest dps tanks lowest dmg spell and absorbs huge gcds with UF, as opposed to ravager which floods you with rage for 1 gcd
Didn't Reprisal give us Shield Block and Rage? The tooltip I'm reading on wowhead now says Ignore Pain and makes the next Revenge cost no rage + 200% damage?
thats until tuseday reset
As of 9.0.5
That’s pre 9.05 reprisal
theyre reworking it
ahhh okay
Hey, is this an answer to my question? If yes this means Reprisal does more Singletarget-dps now and thats the case to use it in raids too?
Im not sure you should be evaluating Legos for prot on a dps value vs a defensive one especially of you are on progress tho that can depend on some things
Dito, that‘s why I ask if this was an answer to my question
Reprisal is more damage if you can use charge and intervene often. Tho youll probably still run the wall on most bosses
If you can use Reprisal properly and on CD it will be a DPS increase on ST as well, yes.
The question is if you can use your Charge and Intervene on CD in a raiding environment.
where is this data from?
sims
ok sure, but is it a custom algo with simc?
It's the default APL + i have reprisal implemented locally (will be available on SIMC/raidbots on reset hopefully)
just saw on wowhead, that reprisal is now the go-to for both raid and m+. quite nice.
i wouldnt trust everything written on wowhead
it is if u can charge and intervene on cd
which isnt likely
but i trust what Llarold writes
Yeah, if you can do it properly it will be a solid DPS increase.
The defensive value is dependant on the fights damage pattern.
sure, you need to get use to it.
wasnt he the guy who wrote the guide? which made everyone think they should run UF 🤔
That's one thing but it's also if the fight allows such movement.
sludge is a no-no 😄
Yes
very trusted source then 
For raids you would still be looking to run The Wall in general unless there are fights that fit Reprisal.
ill stick to mwahi if he says WM and thunderlords should be run i run that
Reprisal 100% can be the "go-to" for raiding as well - but you just have to know the fight and figure out if you can make good use of Reprisal.
and i think many fights will allow that movement
Reprisal might be really op op on the last 4 fights
wait for a fist, tell other tank to taunt, leap away and charge. EASY
doesnt it procc also from intervene?
every roar, you can charge
Yes.
yes but on sludge i already have block up all the time as its scripted to fuk
see
and on slude u cant intevene as u will take the othertanks hit
im not arguing with u
Rerolled to prot 2 Weeks ago, dont have reprisal yet. Anyone a clue what are my chances for upper reaches. 😦
but, for starters, i would craft the wall first
What's rage generation difference on st between reprisal and wall
Upper reaches? 👀
Ah, yes, I remember when I first started my boomie, having to wait 4 weeks for Balance of all things
The Floor where reprisal drops
Ooh.
in completely unrelated news, both the wowhead and icy-veins orc guides have the old definition of blood fury where it reduces healing taken. I happened to read it half an hour ago in bed, went nuts second guessing myself thinking I've been gimping myself for weeks.
i kow but have to go up to +3 there and then fish for it
being lucky would be better
What's the dps gap between AM and HR?
is it random every time you enter twisting corridors? Because I need Reprisal as well
can I just enter and leave over and over again until I get upper reaches?
Big
why would u run HR repirsal gives 90+% blocked hits
not better you are right. I like the normal tower runs now after the changes but twisting feels super long...
~200 from the log i linked (+19 free Revenges + 19 free SBs).
In favor or reprisal?
Yes.
Decent ty
St?
With Reprisal I assume you should be using Intervene a lot, is there a specific person you should be intervening, like melee over ranged? I never use Intervene now so I have no experience with it
Intervene/Charge both.
If you are using it for a DPS increase just use it on who ever (perferably melee)
If you are using it for also defensive purposes (with Safeguard for example) then who ever needs it.
ST usually means Single Target
@ionic fern ok thanks, gonna need to find room for a keybind for Intervene now 😄
even without reprisal, intervene has been great for escapes. surprised you don't have it bound.
Wowhead saying reprisal now bis for raid? That true?
@torpid hill I am not good 😦
warrior is only an alt and I haven't been serious about prot until this expansion, it's mostly been fury
scroll up to about 20 minutes ago and read
welcome to the funzone
@delicate thorn just use the macro with intervene and charge on one button
@torpid hill thanks 😄 The warrior is actually my oldest char too. Created on day 1 of WoW release
still on the same realm with the same name
@woeful trellis ohh gimme
#showtooltip Charge
/cast Charge
/cast [@mouseover] Intervene
@sweet summit so if I mouse over a friendly char it will cast Intervene instead of Charge?
Yep
Will Necrolord be worth swapping to from Kyrian?
It can be
Check the pins but i personally stay kyrian
Isn’t that a bit dangerous though?
Like I use intervene on hungering to get out of consume
Will you consistently be buffing specs that benefit a lot from it?
If I miss the mouse over I’m gonna end up slamming back into the boss
You can just hit escape to untarget hungering, or even just face away from the boss as you cant charge backwards
with repirsal u would do it anyway as u are wasting the leggo effect
and wasting the sb it gives u
/cast [@mouseover,exists,help] intervene; [@target,exists,harm] charge
Yo this shit takes too long to type o phone
I leveled a second warrior just to tank as necro and have BiS transmog for once :)
Prob don't need help/harm either
Ye that macro is probably safer, i havent had any issues with mine tho
You can also put #showtooltip before so you know what one its going to cast
@ionic fern Thank you!
My guild had me swap from arms to prot warrior for last few bosses of mythic
Btw any 2k rio prots here?
Probably.
https://raider.io/characters/us/emerald-dream/Plka is around sometimes
We got @patent osprey
Yeah i know That man 😍
Is NF bis for overall?
@ionic fern plka says reprisal should allow around 80% sb uptime is that with bolster?
Without
☝️
umm not overall that would be kyrian but nightfae is very close behind and does more damage
In bound: "Reprisal sucks! I hate Charging 24/7"
And I am surfing into mah first 17s tonight!
ohaiyo !
To be fair I do actually dislike being forced to use mobility to do damage or trigger things that youd need for normal play
Same.
It can potentially still be wonky.
You will 100% get the benefit in the beginning of each pack but when in the middle of a pack (especially with Double Time) Charging becomes ..interesting.
Morning
Considering that a lot of damage is currently done by "ground effects".
I think the initial charge + a intervene somewhere inbetween already is fantastic for shield block uptime, right?
Anyone know if it’s channeling fleshcraft counts as a defensive cd not sure if 20% reduction mitigates more than blocked attacks
Yes it's good period doesnt mean I like using my mobility in exchange
You can block while channeling.
Oh damn ty
In general you can't but this channel is "Special".

I honestly cannot wait to play prot tomorrow
Imma zoom around
I’m so close to 38 renown I can see the light end of tunnel
1-40 renown very time consuming
My melee gets aggro? Intervene for free shield block
I just learned from plka's stream that his vulpera racial accounts for ~10% of self-heal/absorb. nuts
Vulpera have racials?
I still think fleshcraft is just 'okay for tanks, mostly
is cuteness a racial?
it's the best m+ tanking racial on horde side
Jep, Vulpera is awesome.
I legit have never read their racials
My panda racial saves me from killing myself on tirna scythe I'd call that a win
Time to research
It's secret tech that I've been praying since s4
Vulpera racial that is
It's free 100+ hps
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/LqdgD37aWJH1QKnY#fight=34&type=healing&source=261
just picked a random parse of his
And the 40 yard on ability is also nuts
How's that stack up against Kul Tiran?
It's about 500% better than kultiran
almost as much as ignore pain and it's entirely passive
Damn
Maybe more even
The phial is also nutty
Can crit for a 20k heal
On a 1.5minCD
And again, 40 yards range to pull is also omega nice
sounds pretty neat
Yo what the fuck are vulpera racials
So with Vulpera you get health pot, health stone, Kyrian phial and Vulpera phial?
Hey dudes, brewmaster main here looking to level a tank alt. What is like, the quintessential badass prot warrior moment? What is it that prot warrior does that makes you go, "holy smokes this class is incredible I did something no other tank could do!"
On my guardian druid, its incarning and pulling like 7 trash packs at once. On brew its cheesing the shit out of mechanics with stagger and using all my shit to kite. What do warriors do that make them sick?
How is this news to you guys <.<
So i change from zandalari on vulpera 😅
Who has the keybinds for that
Rerolling rn
Not taking dmg when SB is up
We block physical damage
We spell reflect big DMG sometimes
Spell reflect do make you feel like big pp
Syncing up all casts on mobs and watching them kill themselves
Spellreflect is My bff
But nothing compares to a druid with incarn up
On huge pulls, nobody can do that like bears
Thanks for the responses <3 excited to try spell reflect out
Ngl..bear with INcarn is stupid fun with the lego.
After that you afk for 3 minutes and then do a pull with INcarn again.
Yup
Honestly, just any time I get to use a tanks full kit feels good, when I'm cycling through AoE stops to line up casts for spell reflect or using intervene to help kite, stuff like that
One of the reasons why I considered leveling a bear
Bear has some fun stuff too with convoke, being able to gain some distance and use it for damage or as an extra healing cd
Just call treants or ele at pride, Go moonkin - convoke ez 200 iq
Thats why i Start gearing my farm char 😅
Barkskin + convoke and hope you don't die is more fun tho.
Yeah 🙈
Ursols vortex -> moonkin -> wild charge back -> convoke
50/50, you either die or you dont
Do we go Anger Management with Reprisal now?
ya
"Xira the Underhanded has been disabled on Mythic difficulty and removed from the Dungeon Journal" Is this only for M0 or M+ as well?
Great, cheers!
look like it
bear goes rawr
M0 and m+ is the same thing
🦀
Can’t have Ursol and moonkin though
But typhoon usually works for distance too if your mage isn’t in the middle of combust
let mage do dragons breath
and the frost root
make priest pull you out of danger
then convoke
that's a pug strat right there
weird question but do you guys know if there's a speed-stat requirement for the severing slice in SD? I can dodge it without intervene/heroic leap but i also have some speed on my gear
would be nice to know if it's possible regardless
Im fairly confident you can outrun it without any speed as long as you dont backpeddle
We're getting tons of damage tomorrow, arent we?
TONSSS
If youre NA, sure
WAT
Wait
NA is today
Nah tomorrow is EU
Its tuesday
haha
🤔
Wtf
Days are hard
NA ONLY BUFFS, NOT POOOOOG
we're still in the 2020 right
Sorry i think i had a stroke
He follows tho?:(
Maybe my dwarf legs are too short.
I have a stupid question, that I'm allowed to ask
Should I ever stand with my back to a boss?
if my fat panda can dodge then dwarf can as well : p
nope cus you cant dodge/parry from behind
Ideally never
block*
Jaina says hi.
inerva mythic u have too
But like on inerva youre forced to sometimes
He stops for like a split second as he starts the cast no? Or is my brain actually fried rn @ionic fern
I was just wondering how big of an effect it had, becuase I realize I have stood with my back to a boss quite a few times as of late, just wanted to know if Im screwing myself over too hard, Ill have to not I guess
Innerva all the damage comes when u have 2 stacks, barely dmg when tanking xD
Just running away works aswell, but you have to already be running when it's casting
Sometimes sidestepping also works
yeah luckily he's very scripted so you know when to anticipate it
If you're fast enough
I loved when I was progressing Innerva and every time I got that second stack I would shield block in anticipation of her melees inc ;-;
slice > craggy > stoneskin > craggy > slice
It's basically underrot 2nd boss but a bit tighter
Cuz he doesn't stand still
Cuz he's a bitch
tru
luckily pugs seem to know to stay behind in case
also kyrian pot for fuck-ups
Imagine being kyrian 😔
dont have to 😎
Would be nice tbh
i like the phial
Phial is 📈
true
Since it hits everything
nice to have on mobs that jump everywhere
not even leap? D:
Dwarf op
Alliance privilege...
Nerd
Dorf 😔
Nerf*
TAKE ME BACK
TO PARADISE CITY
Phone corrected me into rudeness
WHERE THE GRASS IS GREEN
Oof
The girls actually are prettier on alliance
Cross faction gaming when 
WHEN I ASK
Panda is a panda idk
mby


fuck banner, all my homies stick Kyrian
indeed
Its like the 2nd best stat for both dps specs
Think its good for fury though

Do banners overlap or stack btw
No idea
prolly not, do u expect them to let us have fun?
I guess they stack? xd
Can me and 10 warriors give a firemagss or boomkin 4000mastrry

That would be broken
I already sell pi
The warrior brothel, buy your banners here
I wanted to test banner stacking but no one wanted to join me on ptr.:(
Dont touch before u pay
As soon as we kill sire i can test it 😔
All warriors to Balance druids world wide
We stacking 5-10 warriors next tier of so
10 warriors with 10 uh dks on pull with army
Which reminds me,i have to start my nf quest
👀
I got bugged on into quests in venthur
So I can't use soulbinds until reset
I'm already rank 30 without soulbinds
Gg
Conduit will be ip over ls rage gen with reprisal or?
If id run 2e, id still take unnerving over bv personally
imma still take unvering for the rage pump every 3 mins
Exactly
What's the go-to Warlock m+ spec atm?
Aff i think
You playing warlock now? 
Not yet.
I'm debating which DPS alt to level up next.
Warlock has a soft spot for me since it was my first ever 60 back in Vanilla.
afflictions is coolest spec though
Shadows embrace 
destro is just wannabe mage and demo is just dumb
