#protection

1 messages Β· Page 3369 of 1

uneven mason
#

overall vs targeted burst.

jagged pier
#

bsc in aoe anyway it big πŸ“ˆ

north pecan
#

Looking forward to reprisal so Kor can be the god soulbind choice

unique osprey
#

Hmm.. so pure ST venthyr maybe is better.. but NF for overall aoe and shit

uneven mason
#

Kyrian or NF

#

for AE

jagged pier
#

yer but you play with an organized group

uneven mason
#

both are functional

merry kestrel
#

@patent osprey as prot or fury???

uneven mason
#

"yes"

jagged pier
#

he plays both

#

specs

patent osprey
#

both ^.^

jagged pier
#

your pushing keys tho now raids over right? @patent osprey

#

as prot

patent osprey
#

i mean i play for like 3 hours a night during push weeks

#

so I try to haha

#

hard to compete with the guys playign liking 8 T_T

#

the work life 😦

smoky wave
#

@patent osprey planning to play around it in m+? Oooh I'm looking forward to seeing this

patent osprey
#

Yeah ^.^ I like to test new things out when raid prog is over

#

so imma try necro for a few weeks, to a month

#

probably till sanguine quaking is over

#

then i might swap to kyrian to try that

barren socket
#

Emeni or Plague Deviser Marileth?

astral crystal
#

can't wait for the slew of "the top rated m+ warrior is kyrian but i thought necrolord was bis????" questions

#

wish they would've made covenants fully cosmetic

hexed rune
#

yuss

urban bane
#

For NL Veteran's Repute conduit seems kinda strong, no? 10% strength every 2 minutes.

ornate sky
#

correct

shrewd elm
#

Hey guys what is the warrior perception of tank balance in 9.0.5 as it stands now, will prot warrior be wanted ?

hexed rune
#

it'll change with 9.0.5, but I doubt very much

#

maybe necro prots will be asked for. maybe

uneven mason
hexed rune
#

prot can do pretty much all content.

uneven mason
hexed rune
#

correct

shrewd elm
#

The reason i asked is because our guild is 1 tank short, we running a VDH and i probably end up taking the second tank spot. How ever i also want to be good in M+

uneven mason
#

Warrior is fine

#

unless you're trying to push +23s

deep steppe
hexed rune
#

you can do everything as Prot, and I think Prot is the most fun as well

uneven mason
#

We're incredibly beefy for raid as well

shrewd elm
#

it looks fun, im just a bit scared as it is the only tank without any selfhealing i believe

hexed rune
#

who needs to heal when you don't take damage?

shrewd elm
#

haha

#

that must be the best answer

ornate sky
#

indomitable and fueled by violence lul

urban bane
#

Ya fwiw re: self-heals, I've had more healers say they appreciate a slowly falling health bar than a ping-ponger

hexed rune
#

Bdk life

shrewd elm
#

i have a 180 ilvl bear but feels so boring xD

#

tanky but boring

deep steppe
#

thats cause it is lmao

ornate sky
#

only thing more boring than bear is paladin 8-)

mighty cairn
#

owl/cat weaving is p interesting

#

at least conceptually

hexed rune
#

press iron fur

shrewd elm
#

o, paladin would have been my second pick because of bonking shields

ornate sky
#

press sotr πŸ˜„

uneven mason
#

I've beat our paladins "self healing" on a regular basis

#

damage prevented > damage restored

shrewd elm
#

aight thanks guys i feel so excited to start leveling !

uneven mason
distant crystal
#

DK's are tankier than pink prot

deep steppe
#

strong disagree

#

DK's just selfheal better

uneven mason
#

DKs are very tanky

deep steppe
#

prot paly with SOTR is only like

uneven mason
#

60% mit ><

deep steppe
#

5-10% weaker than prot war with shield block

distant crystal
#

the self-heal is part of their tankiness

#

you don't need to mitigate if you can just yoyo from 10% to 90% hp by yourself

wind surge
#

dk when they goes to 10% to 90% to 10%

uneven mason
#

quite a bit actually, its just that on average they block enough on top of it that they have a higher mitigation %

#

but if block doesn't RNGesus up at the time they get smacked with a tank buster, their HP drops like a rock

uneven mason
#

But yeah like, sludgefist under 30% Is scary on a BDK when you're used to warrior

deep steppe
#

Sloot literally did a math breakdown of all this last night

#

paladin is close to war

distant crystal
#

oh well if sloot did napkin math

uneven mason
#

yeah, in overall mitigation

distant crystal
#

🀣

uneven mason
#

like my paladin co tank is generally only 3-5% behind me in mit, when you factor in IP smoothing (since that's counted as healing and not mitigation) 5-10% is where it lands.

deep steppe
#

I mean i trust a main tank in BDGG

uneven mason
#

they easily have 5-10% more self healing than us

#

so its very balanced between the 2

#

external healing required for us is basically neck and neck

#

I could probably turtle up a bit more and watch my SB uptime and increase that gap a few % more, but, hit to hit, paladins get slapped harder than warriors and bears

deep steppe
#

Bears are the extreme tanky bois lmao

uneven mason
#

10% when you're dealing with a boss like, Sire or Sludge is a big chunk of change

distant crystal
#

bear is kinda unfair to compare to anybody atm

#

facetank kings

uneven mason
#

butt tank too

#

since their armor doesn't care what direction

#

ours does.

deep steppe
#

what a life

#

and i mean

uneven mason
#

IF my raid didn't need battleshout I'd be Bur

dapper coral
#

I'm probably swapping from BAER to Warrior

deep steppe
#

I did say pala was /close/ to war

dapper coral
#

Bear life is ez

deep steppe
#

not the same as war

uneven mason
lunar jackal
#

Havent been here in a long time. We gonna be swapping talents in 9.0.5?

uneven mason
#

at least in raid settings

deep steppe
#

v-true. You can do pretty much all content as any tank

uneven mason
#

so, my statment of Paladins are the squishiest

#

is like comparing 10 to 10.5

deep steppe
#

outside of that i think Mwahi is doing testing

lunar jackal
#

So no so far?

deep steppe
distant crystal
#

so the reprisal nerfs just mean warr isn't gonna be broken

#

but still strong?

jagged pier
#

this was a fun run

deep steppe
wooden radish
#

prot pal is only "squishy" if you're bad and don't have experience playing it

uneven mason
distant crystal
#

Endless nameless warrior

uneven mason
#

but thats just feelycraft I guess

thick rover
#

Im sure it has been talked about already but I'm new here so here goes,any chance necrolord prot warriors are gonna be viable now with the updated signature/covenant ability?

dusty mason
deep steppe
#

jakey is here to lay down the law

amber herald
#

yeah it's viable but the patch is putting them on par with the other three

dusty mason
#

Ah extra addon gotcha

amber herald
#

because right now necro is bad

#

so play what you want pretty much

#

it's not like necro is suddenly omega bis or anything

jagged pier
twilit jay
#

im playing all specs, think i should stay kyrian or swap to NF?

jagged pier
#

ithers good for that dpends where u arms and fury and where u prot

dusty mason
#

Gotcha thanks jakey

uneven mason
twilit jay
#

sounds good, my guild is pushing me towards kyrian saying that its the only good one lol

lunar jackal
#

Your guild is dumb

jagged pier
#

well it depends if u can in raid and dps m+ and pvp i would say kyrain, if u dps raid and tank keys id say NF

torpid cliff
#

I may be crazy, but fortified weeks seem a lot more difficult that tyrannical weeks. At 15 people just YOLO trash mechanics.. stand in shit, no kicks..

jagged pier
#

nah it sway easier if interupts happen

twilit jay
#

probably be DPS raid and tank as a backup, lots of M+ and pvp

torpid cliff
#

At least they do shit on bosses

jagged pier
#

but its more noticable on higher keys where bosses take like 5mins on tyran weeks

astral crystal
#

dps prefer fort weeks, tanks and healers prefer tyran

#

packs living longer = BIG NUMBERS

jagged pier
twilit jay
#

its a close call lol

jagged pier
#

yer

deep steppe
#

im unsure what the NF equal is but, dont forget Kyrian has pot

jagged pier
#

just pick your favourite id say

deep steppe
#

I know its not dam related but, pot can be pog

barren socket
#

kleia on necrotic weeks really good too

twilit jay
#

guess ill wait a bit to see what content i end up doing most and go from there

barren socket
#

I think I will roll necro just to spice things up

uneven mason
barren socket
#

a little change

#

like 4 months pressing spear already

covert cradle
#

I'm having a hard time trying to decide if I should swap to nec for raid. I know my RL is gushing at the thought of having that mastery on our dps.

uneven mason
#

I'm not swapping because I'm tired of grinding renown on my warrior lol NF was my 3rd cov

#

I need to catch my Bear/BDK/VDH/Pal up

deep steppe
uneven mason
#

the valor changes will be a nice change.

covert cradle
#

I already swapped just to give us battle shout.

floral pewter
#

Does Reprisal make mastery better enough to change stat priority at all (eg, crafting the leggo as haste/mastery), or am I just overthinking it?

smoky wave
#

I hope so, the game seems determined to only give me high mystery items.

deep steppe
mighty cairn
#

vers prob too important in higher keys

ornate sky
#

crit gets better from best served cold too

sweet summit
#

how so?

ornate sky
#

parry is more value?

sweet summit
#

nah its still 3rppm

lunar jackal
#

Bsc? Is that a thing now?

ornate sky
#

oh damn revenge! 😦

sweet summit
#

the Revenge! buff got changed from BFA to SL

#

curse blizzard!

valid zodiac
#

That moment when you think legs legendary will already start climbing in price but its actually dropping massively in price

sinful aspen
#

In like 3 weeks which will be better and more useful for raids blood dk or prot still cant choose :(

#

Im thinking prot would be best to add more ranged dps and replace our melee

chilly brook
#

Doesnt matter

#

You're gonna be better off running whatever you play best on

brave jetty
#

do we know if Reprisal is going to be a damage loss compared to Thunderlord's right now?

chilly brook
#

Probably not

#

Since reprisal means you run AM

#

And potentially BSC

deep steppe
#

and potentially UF

brave jetty
#

yes assuming all the correct talents for TL

deep steppe
chilly brook
wanton condor
#

doubt

fallow beacon
#

Sorry I'm sure its been asked but can't find an answer with search - does necro banner target 2 nearest and lock the buff on for 15 sec, or is does it change to different targets as different people move closer?

deep steppe
sinful aspen
#

I have exp with both

wanton condor
#

I'm not quite sure how simc does charge and intervene else I'd write up an apl to test it

ionic fern
#

Test what?

wanton condor
#

if UF is good now

deep steppe
#

with reprisal

ionic fern
#

Why would you need charge/intervene for that?

#

πŸ‘€

#

Oh.

wanton condor
#

for reprisal triggering revenge stuff

ionic fern
#

I'm still in the process of implementing Reprisal.

wanton condor
#

awesome

deep steppe
#

nothing to do now but jam

chilly brook
#

I can't wait for Mwahi to implement UF

#

Kekw

ionic fern
deep steppe
ionic fern
#

I'm still waiting for Mwahi to implement Shield Slam.

chilly brook
#

Lol

#

How goes the key pushing btw?

wanton condor
#

the main change I made to the apl I use right now is that there's some futzing with shield block usage

ionic fern
#

Will do more tonight tho.

wanton condor
#

thinking about how I would write in intervene/charge use

chilly brook
#

A 20 is a 20 tho

#

My guy Mwahi going for that r.io clout

strong forum
#

Did someone say cloud

sonic tangle
#

Question: is there any way to make the tank adds from Hidden Desires on m-Darkvein more noticeable? I turned my graphics down and it helped, but when there's a bunch of shit going on its hard to see where they're spawning at times

strong forum
#

Install eyes patch 1.3
Idk, I run at low particle setting, rest on ultra and I see them just fine

#

Gotta focus a bit

rain lava
#

arent they part of the boss frames too?

strong forum
#

It's about the facing images ability

jolly thistle
#

play with headphones, you can hear where they spawn peepoHappy

ionic fern
strong forum
#

Just gotta look real close idk, never seemed an issue :/

sonic tangle
#

My eyes are focusing but my brain is like too much red where are things

strong forum
#

F

wanton condor
#

same reason I get hit by every single volcanic when playing ele shaman

#

looks the exact same as a lvb cast, red on red

#

(also my WA is probably too high up on the screen)

sonic tangle
#

Its not much of an issue until further in, just seeing if there's anyway to make it easier. Ill just get my zoomer eyes on

signal plover
#

Also a weak aura that shows the duration helps a bit

chilly brook
#

Very distinct sound when they spawn and its directional

sonic tangle
#

I noticed that, and it helps. Im just having issues at times later on when there's a lot going on. Maybe I should just hard focus on that instead of everything else too

fallow beacon
#

I guess slight follow up on my necro banner question - anyone know of a weakaura that would track your two nearest party members?

chilly brook
#

Just spin in the direction of the sound

#

You dont have to be directly facing it

#

Just within a pretty generous cone

fickle timber
#

Got KSM before buffs

#

Pog

sweet turtle
#

Do you think prot is going to be a bigger contender in M+ after the buffs?

fickle timber
#

Yeah

#

1000x

sweet turtle
#

I miss tanking on my prot warrior

fickle timber
#

I think it’ll take a few for it to catch on

#

I love prot now

#

Can’t wait for buffs

chilly brook
#

Nothing is stopping you lmao

sweet turtle
#

My Veng outperforms my prot warrior

chilly brook
#

Ok

fickle timber
#

Meta brain

chilly brook
#

I guess we better tell the dudes doing 20s and above as prot to reroll now

jolly thistle
#

πŸ‘‰πŸšͺ

chilly brook
fickle timber
#

Hahahaha

deep steppe
outer bronze
#

lol

#

is a jab at meta slaves, incase anyone reads that as serious

#

πŸ‘€

rugged finch
#

Prot go necro now?

uneven mason
#

Many of us were prot at the start of BFA when we were sleeper 🧱

chilly brook
#

Like my BrM "outperformed" my warrior in EP I still fought like hell to be able to play it because I like prot

uneven mason
#

tier lists are clickbait for smoothbrains

chilly brook
#

And most people aren't even at a level where the "outperforming" even matters

deep steppe
ionic fern
#
  • the "meta" people following them
deep steppe
#

if you arent in those categories, then Kyrian/NF will prolly be better

outer bronze
#

cant wait to simp for my boomies 😩

deep steppe
outer bronze
#

my prot war has such shit gear tho. considering buying boes

#

only done weekly vaults for a few weeks

#

still want some gear for my guardian dru this tier before i take prot to reclears D:

strong forum
#

28% haste in regular gear and rising

outer bronze
#

zooming

deep steppe
chilly brook
#

Smh

#

Outside emotes when

deep steppe
#

^ Nom with all that haste

potent crypt
#

necro gona be worst 9.0.5?

jagged pier
dusty warren
#

I'm thinking of rerolling from DK to war in this patch because the buffs. We will probably fight with dh for the meta or is it too early?

jagged pier
#

we are brought up going to be meta to early to tell

rain lava
#

and DK seems to be fine, no?

twin scarab
#

DK was already fine but im excited for the lego changes

hardy canyon
#

Hey, I looked at the pins but there is no mention of Thunderlord leg, is it not worth anymore?

sterile moss
#

reprisal is better now with the changes

rain lava
#

yeah, and DK was nearly always fun. So dont really see any reason to reroll, except for personal preference of course. But then, its always a yes if you dont enjoy your current spec, no matter the meta*

*might not apply to world first raiders/m+ leaderboard

hardy canyon
rigid elm
#

Is reprisal on a 190 better than Thunder lords at 235? That soul ash grind is rough

sterile moss
#

is reprisal worth an ilvl loss of ~2.5? probably

shrewd elm
#

any zandalari prot warriors here?

#

wanting to know what blessing to take xD

modern brook
#

gonk or bust (paku for basically every class ever)

waxen cradle
#

What are we looking at uptime wise for SBlock, upwards of like 90ish % or so with Reprisal

#

granted of course without Bolster we would easily have 100% uptime, but I am talking in terms of AM usage

rain lava
sterile moss
#

it should be virtually 100% at the times that you need it, accounting for downtime in m+

uneven mason
waxen cradle
#

Yeah figured that would be the case, been setting on Soul Ash for well a long damn time so r4 reprisal here I come

strong forum
#

80%++ with reprisal

#

Of raw uptime

potent crypt
#

if thunderclap buff maybe we can go BFA mode with Anger Management + Unstoppable force?

#

reprisal maybe dont need cap haste

#

i think

strong forum
#

You will still want haste Detective

#

UF will be less bad, yes

uneven mason
potent crypt
#

and build? with Anger Management + Unstoppable force?

#

big dmg

waxen cradle
#

I still do not feel UF will be worth it as with Reprisal BSC will actually see a lot of play from me

strong forum
#

Am + Rav + bsc

#

But UF is competetive

#

It's just gonna be less rage

#

But sameish dmg

mellow gorge
#

wait the 10% aura buff, what is it exactly for prots? i'm confused a bit

strong forum
#

+10% dmg

mellow gorge
#

ah

#

that is nice

potent crypt
#

all spell 10% and thudner clap 10% more

#

?

#

is a 20%

strong forum
#

Everything +10%

#

And ontop of those +10%, TC gets another 10%

waxen cradle
#

all 10%, TClap a additional 10%

mossy sluice
#

700 damage thunderclaps

#

hyuge

stiff osprey
#

does it make sense to switch to NF/Kyrian for prot if im venthyr due to Fury?

#

based on all the upcoming changes

strong forum
#

Yes if you plan on maining prot

waxen cradle
#

does make me wonder if Crit will see higher value than it has now in a BSC build, I would not imagine it would make a huge difference, but it does make me wonder

strong forum
#

Crit will have the same value

#

The revenge proc is 3rppm

sterile moss
#

you'll be happy with nf as fury in m+

strong forum
#

Getting more parry won't change that

waxen cradle
#

Yeah true forgot about the 3 rppm

#

well did not forget so much as not take that into account when I said what I did earlier

waxen cradle
#

@uneven mason Yeah true, I try and stack on as much Haste, and Vers as I can but as I do not play Arms or Fury much and pvp, I do not have access to that vers so I get more crit/haste gear than I would like

potent crypt
#

haste > versa > crit?

strong forum
#

For raid yes

#

For m+ haste > vers=crit

potent crypt
#

anyway versa if yo go high keys i think

#

?

strong forum
#

Ultra keys

waxen cradle
#

I still would like to have more Vers, but that would require pvping and I rarely dps so no weapon or good dps trinkets

uneven mason
strong forum
#

I dropped 4% vers yesterday

#

Felt nice

uneven mason
#

I hate that corruption stacking meme

jagged pier
#

im at like 13-15% vers and feel fine in 17 keys i know that isnt high but that is for me

potent crypt
#

xD

waxen cradle
#

I set anywhere between 10 to 13% vers on average

jolly thistle
#

21% crit πŸ“ˆ

strong forum
#

Bruh I wish

#

I had 21% crit, I have fucking 10

waxen cradle
#

honestly losing haste feels way worse than losing vers so I am ok with it

jagged pier
#

bruh i was i had 10

#

i have like 6

strong forum
#

8 is minimum no?

#

No 5

#

5 is minimum

jagged pier
#

i dunno

wanton condor
#

you can check how competitive UF is compared to the rest now, just run a sim and add another 10% of the TC damage as I don't think it changes the priority list

#

see if that moves it up

jagged pier
#

i know i have less than 10

barren socket
#

I think i got mastery in all my pieces 40% atm lmao

strong forum
#

I had 9 for the longest time, but inerva ring saved me

barren socket
#

223ilvl

mellow gorge
#

is night fae for 15+s better than kyrian or is there little to no difference?

strong forum
#

Little to no difference

#

Kyrian is more defensive

#

NF is more pump

mellow gorge
#

Alrighty

strong forum
#

Pwar covenants are disgustingly versatile and I hate it

waxen cradle
#

The only places I play around with my secondary's are on rings, and neck anyway, that is where my vers/crit tends to vary or swap around

strong forum
#

Necro for max raid dmg
Venthyr for max personal raid dmg
NF for max m+ dmg and solid raid dmg
Kyrian for overall use, good m+ and raid dmg and most defensive

#

I hate it

#

Just make 1 thing absolutely best

austere stream
#

Just don't take any?

mellow gorge
#

best option right there

waxen cradle
#

But but choice *ahem... fake choice" but choice

dense flame
#

Well, I hope Prog raid for dps/tank align.

hardy pawn
#

Ursols and get rid of dots > everything else in M+ for me

#

Can't trust these pug healers to dispel me

dense flame
#

Gonna swap NF soon as sire dead.

strong forum
#

NF is still huge raid dmg

wanton condor
#

if you're just gonna raid you don't even need a covenant

uneven mason
strong forum
#

Venthyr is overrated for dps, unless you're arms

wanton condor
#

just yolo mercenary it

dense flame
#

Yeah arms prog on sire for P3

uneven mason
waxen cradle
#

I have considered going NFae many times, and literally the only reason for me to go NFae would be for the damage

dense flame
#

Padlord of remoria

uneven mason
#

its not padding

#

since the sword dmg is delt to Sire

dense flame
barren socket
#

so which necro soulbind would you guys recomend? emeni or plague advisor

strong forum
uneven mason
#

losing phial hurts the most

dense flame
#

Yeah sucks man. Wish renown transferred

barren socket
#

man emeni conduit path kinda suck

#

like only 1 potency and 3 defensive

wet compass
#

so anyone here good at wow addons?

potent crypt
#

necro vs kryrians?

wet compass
#

I'd legit pay someone 50 bucks to get bejewled working again

waxen cradle
#

@strong forum Well yeah that is also a big part, but if I made the swap I would just commit to the grind. Plus I am DiD alliance so I have that cleanse

wanton condor
#

potency conduits kind of suck for prot though

#

pot/def/def/fin is probably the best

iron totem
rain lava
#

are there any other mobs where phial is as nice as for the bear dots in HoA and the dodgeable gargoyle dot in sanguine depths?

strong forum
#

Yeah that's too much

patent osprey
#

I may or may not be at around 33% verse unbuffed

jolly thistle
#

nasty

patent osprey
#

def not too much ^.^

wanton condor
hardy pawn
#

Last boss of plaguefall

patent osprey
#

Gimme 6% more πŸ˜„

strong forum
#

40% is the real breakpoint, before that ain't worth

patent osprey
#

yeah still have 6% to go πŸ™‚

rain lava
#

where the bonecarvers at?

strong forum
#

Can't get more this patch

wanton condor
#

NW

strong forum
#

Sooo. Yeah

patent osprey
#

gotta survive last boss PF some how man

strong forum
#

33% is max vers you can get

patent osprey
#

u see

#

i run my SLG trinket

#

and 4 others run it in my party

#

then itll be like 36% or something

strong forum
#

Big 0.3% more!

rain lava
#

huge!

strong forum
#

Or well, 1%

patent osprey
#

with food buff

#

honestly ive never been slapped around more as a prot war, and felt more helpless than a 22 PF before it was nerfed

strong forum
#

That requires Str and agi users tho

patent osprey
#

on the last boss

hardy pawn
#

The only part of Plaguefall I like is the timer

#

Everything else can fuck off

strong forum
#

Kyrian πŸ“ˆ cleanse the debuff when dicey

patent osprey
#

see that would work @strong forum but every phase feels dicey as prot war on that last boss lol

strong forum
#

How, p1 is pride, p2 is lust p3 is AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH

jolly thistle
#

just stoneform... deswind

dense flame
#

BFA rise up

hardy pawn
#

Let me spell reflect the dot onto her πŸ™

patent osprey
#

u dont do pride on high keys for last boss

waxen cradle
#

I play DiD so having 2 cleanses feels amazing for dungeons with a lot of cleansable debuffs.

patent osprey
#

If u try to pride last boss, ull use all ur cds just to kill hte pride lol

strong forum
#

On 22 I'd say it's well worth it

#

Ah tru I guess

#

The thing has to Die...

potent crypt
#

wwhat covenant go prot in 9.0.5?

rain lava
strong forum
#

Necro for max raid dmg
Venthyr for max personal raid dmg
NF for max m+ dmg and solid raid dmg
Kyrian for overall use, good m+ and raid dmg and most defensive

waxen cradle
#

Also I like the feeling when I heroic leap as a dwarf. It feels like a midget being fired out of a cannon

midnight stone
#

Yeah but a strong midget

hardy pawn
#

I feel like as a Panda I should do more damage or a stun or something when I land

waxen cradle
#

A very hairy, pissed off, manly, and likely drunk midget

strong forum
#

You forgot manly

#

And not a midget

#

But a man

hardy pawn
#

Vertically challenged

waxen cradle
#

Probably as a Panda or Kul Tiran when you hit something it should go flying off, like you just hit it with a wrecking ball

strong forum
#

No

#

All you do is flab your fat around

waxen cradle
#

lol

strong forum
#

You're like a real life gummy bear

snow lance
#

Has anyone messed around with seismic-reverberation?

waxen cradle
#

Of course there is something to be said for getting something that has that much extra weight flying through the air. Makes 100% sense why the ground cracks when we land.

jolly thistle
#

still laughing at "vertically challenged" peepoHappy

lavish raptor
#

Does anyone know what the numeric difference is between a ilvl 200 shield and 220 shield? What am i missing out on

snow lance
#

I think it should pump.

sterile moss
#

lots of valuable armor and even more importantly block

snow lance
#

Block*

#

The most important part

lavish raptor
#

Whats the differenc ein block chance? Im not familiar with the values

snow lance
#

It’s block value

rain lava
#

does anyone know how block actually work now?

snow lance
#

It blocks more dmg

#

Higher block = block more dmg

rain lava
#

i mean the formular

snow lance
#

All you need to know

#

Higher ilvl shield

uneven mason
#

scales about the same as armor iirc

snow lance
#

Will always be better then lower ilvl

rain lava
#

guys, i understand the concept of block

snow lance
#

Regardless of stars

#

Stats*

uneven mason
#

IDK if we mathed out what the new k value is for the exact calc

snow lance
#

Don’t think it matters

sterile moss
#

i think 20 ilvl is something like 3% more block value

snow lance
#

Higher ilvl will always be better. All that matters.

uneven mason
snow lance
#

What we should be talking about is

#

Is this seismic buff

sweet summit
#

9.0.5 brings a new k formula? Detective

uneven mason
#

No

snow lance
#

And running it with best served cold

#

For the fat deeps

uneven mason
sterile moss
#

it is meme dps though

sweet summit
#

oh we have SL values

#

Level 60 K-values
Base/open world: 2500
M0/M+: 2455.0
Castle Nathria LFR: 2500.0
Castle Nathria Normal: 2662.5
Castle Nathria Heroic: 2845.0
Castle Nathria Mythic: 3050.0

uneven mason
#

kk

#

thx

#

last time I had looked was back in beta

distant crystal
rain lava
#

what are the k-values?

uneven mason
#

never felt the need to dig again, as it just as Aisnator said -doesn't really matter for practice

jolly thistle
#

block reduction [%] = block / (block + K value)

distant crystal
#

it's a variable that sets how good block is, basically

snow lance
#

Sure

lavish oracle
#

@rain lava it's a constant used for a bunch of defensive calculations

uneven mason
# rain lava what are the k-values?

When DR from armor is calculated, it uses K value as the NPCs "attack" more or less, so its a mitigator on our damage reduction, harder content will hit harder.

lavish oracle
#

Changes depending on what content you're doing

rain lava
#

and they made that content specific? so my block is actually stronger in m+ than in raid?

quasi orbit
#

So that new 10% prot warrior aura

#

Is that gonna be like a stance thing or like a passive ability ?

uneven mason
#

Yes XaV

rain lava
#

wtf

snow lance
#

Math is hard.

rain lava
#

thanks for the info btw. couldnt find it anywhere

distant crystal
#

it's kinda necessary

uneven mason
quasi orbit
#

Ohh ok

uneven mason
#

Aura is a "hidden" buff attached to your spec.

distant crystal
#

if block was the same everywhere it would be busted af in raid

quasi orbit
#

But I'm cofused @uneven mason because they have a list of abilities from other classes/

#

So does that mean warriors overall are getting buffed?

distant crystal
#

so rather than make it balanced for raid and doodoo in m+, enter K

quasi orbit
#

Cause it says Prot Warrior Aura

uneven mason
quasi orbit
#

ohhhh ok

snow lance
#

^

uneven mason
#

literally grabbed every warrior ability spell ID and dumped it in, in the past they "prune" abilities that shouldn't be attached to the spec

#

from the list

quasi orbit
#

Ok now it makes sense

snow lance
#

But does it matter?

uneven mason
#

but when you dont pay people what theyre worth that is what you get

snow lance
#

Idk about that.. it’s not really a high priority detail.

uneven mason
#

Blizzard used to be extremely anal about details and quality

rain lava
lavish escarp
#

Hi guys:) frustrated ex-prot here, does anyone know what blizzard planning for us next patch/tier?

snow lance
#

The game used to be a lot less complex

uneven mason
snow lance
#

Buffs!

distant crystal
#

@uneven mason now imagine if K value didn't exist and it was even better!

uneven mason
#

RIP single roll combat system

distant crystal
#

same

#

but i was a bear 🐻

snow lance
#

Fuzzy wuzzy was a bear.

uneven mason
#

TBC to Cataclysm, 100% unhittable warriors, may you be mourned

median tulip
distant crystal
#

but M+ didn't exist in cata so dungeon mitigation tuning was less of an issue

uneven mason
#

you either Missed/dodged/parry/block

distant crystal
#

pushing crits off was like, bare minimum to be a tank

snow lance
#

I miss armor pen

distant crystal
#

but the gods would push plain hits off too

uneven mason
#

mostly it was because we were pushing block so high that we were like 50% critical blocks

distant crystal
#

CTC, i miss ye

uneven mason
#

pushing Crits off was required and very easy todo as a warrior (Press shield block)

median tulip
#

I quit at the end of TBC and only came back with lockdown in BfA, so...

dense flame
#

No you don’t miss AP

uneven mason
#

but our original mastery in Cataclysm was so OP for blocking

#

that instead of nerfing block

dense flame
#

That was degenerate system

uneven mason
#

they literally just put block on its own check

dense flame
#

Especially if they ever brought back AP and AP trinkets

uneven mason
#

ArP with SBV stacking PVP Prot, patch 3.1 to 3.3

dense flame
distant crystal
#

oh you mean ArP

uneven mason
#

"LOL Yes keep hitting me, oh did I one shot you?"

distant crystal
#

i was like what's so bad about AP, we still have that in a roundabout way

uneven mason
#

the gnomergan auto blocker on use SBV infusion

#

made shield slam hit harder than mortal strike

snow lance
#

guys the new meme is revenge

#

Trust me

distant crystal
#

memba when prot was the only viable warrior spec

#

for either role

uneven mason
#

No

distant crystal
#

glad stance baby

uneven mason
#

I wouldn't have called prot "Viable" in WoD

#

not until like, HFC

#

maybe mid BRF

#

Fury was ok in Highmaul after the initial fixes

chilly brook
#

Wtb glad stance pls

uneven mason
#

I mean, they'll give us glad stance back

chilly brook
#

In WoD classic?

uneven mason
#

and leave our dmg values the same "LOL Now you can be as shitty as the community thinks you are!"

chilly brook
#

Kekw

cloud tide
#

guys how good are new warrior changes?

uneven mason
#

"Tank like a DPS, DPS like a tank" #Warrior

#

They're good and address some of our QoL issues.

cloud tide
uneven mason
#

Don't expect us to be the 2nd coming of Thor though

#

Reprisal legendary changes remove our issue of chosing between aggro or defense on engage

#

giving us a large rage income and 2 free procs

#

so we have SB for free, and can revenge for free on engage for snap aggro

#

in addition for providing us 40 rage for either IP or, 2 more revenges for more pumps

cloud tide
#

is that for m+ only?

uneven mason
#

Yeah

#

We're already strong in raid

cloud tide
#

ah

uneven mason
#

don't need addressing there.

#

10% more damage to

distant crystal
#

i doubt warr is gonna dethrone vdh but it'll close the gap bigly

uneven mason
#

so that'll be nice.

cloud tide
#

is wall still best for raid?

potent crypt
#

vdh get nerf in 9.0.5

#

big nerf

#

xD

uneven mason
#

Nothing will dethrone VDH until we reach a point where face tanking large packs and DPS reach a equilibrium point.

cloud tide
#

is it really that big?

potent crypt
#

conduits fire mark conduit nerf

uneven mason
#

its actually a minor buff

#

in a round about way

#

but you know.

sick sentinel
#

Okay so is kyrian go to for new players? It seems most safe option with the potion and spear. Necrolord sure is strong but not for pugging keys right?

uneven mason
#

It doesn't address what makes VDH the meta tank

distant crystal
#

the dh discord is calling that a buff but

uneven mason
distant crystal
#

seems like not much of a change either way idk

uneven mason
median tulip
potent crypt
#

i read conduits change

#

for me is a big nerf for fire mark build

#

and nerf all covenats

sterile moss
#

people are going to start expecting us to be necro, but it's not the play for pugging m+

uneven mason
rancid ember
#

The VDH Conduit change is a buff for sure.

potent crypt
#

necor dh is strong

#

but kyrians GG

rancid ember
#

More uptime on Fel Dev is huge

potent crypt
#

ye but

#

kyrian seal nerf dmg

rancid ember
#

Demon form > Fiery brand

potent crypt
#

and conduit

uneven mason
#

Ok?

#

They deal a bit less burst

rancid ember
#

Necessary nerf it was too strong

uneven mason
#

but are still capable of dealing a lot of burst from range

#

and can use 6s of meta every 1min to build massive aggro with breath

rancid ember
#

Now every 49 - 50 sec πŸ˜„

uneven mason
#

combined with spreading brand

#

right

#

like, they didn't do anything to adress VDH, they literally made it so more smoothbrainers can actually execute what makes it meta

potent crypt
#

necro is gona be strong dmg

uneven mason
#

Not going to be shocked when demonic sees a "2.4 Divine Storming" level nerf

potent crypt
#

when demons explote

uneven mason
#

in 9.1

potent crypt
#

i wachint trill last night trying dmg with havoc

cloud tide
#

im suprised that prot pala still didnt get any mitigation buffs

potent crypt
#

24k hit dummie demon explosion

#

i wwanna back my war 😦

dark lark
#

for the banner buff, players just have to be next to me on application, and then they can go back into range right?

#

or does it change dynamically

dark lark
#

ty

signal plover
#

Yeh that seems to be the consensus

distant crystal
#

oh i thought it was an aura

potent crypt
#

mage on my raid say em i will tank with you ^^

#

combustion fan wwar

distant crystal
#

so everyone would be fighting to be in the warrior's model

dark lark
#

@distant crystal i was low key hoping that would've been the case for the meme

deep steppe
potent crypt
#

i dont know if change necro this week or wait patch

cloud tide
#

closest person gets buff?

#

2

dark lark
#

man, banner + conduit + emeni trait will be giga strength too

potent crypt
#

yes

#

mages love you

#

mage slove banner

dark lark
#

I heard fire mage's best stats are haste vers now, not mastery anymore

distant crystal
#

they're a bit of an all-statter now

brittle elbow
#

Depents

distant crystal
#

but mastery is prob the worst

potent crypt
#

when they combustioning

#

mastery is god gift

signal plover
#

Not as strong as it is for boomy/hunter/uhdk

hardy pawn
#

Fire mage players smell bad Frost all day baybee

potent crypt
#

UHDK fan your banner xD

distant crystal
#

ignite is below fireblast

#

for most mages in ST

brittle elbow
#

Yes

distant crystal
#

it was never really a great stat for fire even in bfa

#

it's just that blaster master was a thing, and then masterful was a thing

#

bm made masterful good, and masterful made mastery good

potent crypt
#

people inv prot if you ahve banner πŸ˜›

#

new PI priest

#

banner war

#

xD

uneven mason
#

Probably not

#

people are apes and have no idea what is used why.

hardy pawn
#

PI the tank pls thank you

distant crystal
#

things venthyr pinkprots say

#

unironically

sweet summit
hardy pawn
#

Honestly I'm surprised Ret's didn't get a buff

#

Getting out dpsed by holy paladins keksquad

uneven mason
cloud tide
#

ret is pretty decent no?

uneven mason
#

ST crap - AE Burst is strong

hardy pawn
#

I do miss playing fury sometimes

#

The survivability was so nice

cloud tide
#

but bros

#

isnt bad that prot has to depend on legendary to be good in m+

jagged pier
#

we are good in m+ already

uneven mason
cloud tide
#

reaLLY?

uneven mason
#

yeah no CD on Brand

#

stacking big CDs with no CD

distant crystal
#

eh

uneven mason
#

same with Guardian

distant crystal
#

fiery leggo is great but vdh is still p nice

#

aside

uneven mason
#

I mean, we're good in M+ already, this just addresses QoL (that is, newb traps)

#

We can grab aggro without worring about geting shit on in the first 3 seconds due ot not spending rage on block

cloud tide
#

i mean

deep steppe
#

prot war is not bad like people like to meme about it

cloud tide
#

i was playing vdh without conduit firey brand and i still felt really strong

deep steppe
#

and you can play prot without reprisal and its still really strong

#

or without the wall

patent osprey
#

^

distant crystal
#

vdh utility fits nicely w/ the dps meta

cloud tide
#

what about wirlwind and execute?

deep steppe
#

You never press whirlwind as prot

austere stream
#

I don't even have WW on my bar.

deep steppe
#

literally never

uneven mason
#

WW Isn't an ability ever for prot

#

execute is pumpers

austere stream
#

The only time I ever use WW is when my SS procs it in Torghast.

hardy pawn
#

There are people that actually press ww?

jagged pier
#

apprently

jolly thistle
cloud tide
#

i didnt use it never i just asked

#

for confirm

plush tendon
#

What yall talking about, WW is great! Sure it costs more rage then revenge and does less damage, but its great!

jagged pier
#

☝️

deep steppe
cloud tide
#

but why did they even add it

#

then

hardy pawn
#

Doesn't it even hit less targets than revenge?

coral crest
#

Hello !!

deep steppe
coral crest
#

The change from kyrian to necrolord is confirmed ?

deep steppe
#

no

hardy pawn
plush tendon
#

More in the position of play what you want πŸ˜„

#

which is ideal

coral crest
#

oooh ok sorry

plush tendon
#

I joined the banner club last night; I personally wanted to get a headstart on that renown regrind : ^)

#

but hey, if it turns out that I hate it, I can always go back

distant crystal
#

renown is so fast

#

might as well grind all 4 up

hardy pawn
#

Stick around for the bug mounts then go back :^)

cloud tide
#

what about shield cast for necrolord is that good?

plush tendon
#

I think its interesting, not as good as phial though

deep steppe
#

the shield is /ok/

plush tendon
#

More balanced now, but Phial is really strong

deep steppe
#

I personally think phial is like

cloud tide
#

but phial doesnt remove sht in mythic raid

deep steppe
#

busted

jagged pier
#

it does

cloud tide
#

on slg

prime nymph
#

kyrian is just so good.

cloud tide
#

it doesnt

deep steppe
#

it removes the same stuff in mythic that it does in heroic & normal

prime nymph
#

necro seems ok. kinda.

plush tendon
#

yea, but Necro tmog is fire

prime nymph
#

this is true

plush tendon
#

also, there are not enough of Necrolords

deep steppe
prime nymph
#

necro lord is the simp cove

#

simping for balance druids

deep steppe
#

^

plush tendon
deep steppe
#

you dare questions my completely subjective opinion on this matter sir?!

#

how dare you

#

😀

plush tendon
#

At least we can both agree they are better then the Kyrian set XD

hardy pawn
#

If you're not using the exiles reach set as plate you're playing the game wrong

deep steppe
#

you mean you don't like having giant cup holders on your shoulders?

hardy pawn
#

I wish the Kyrian set wasn't so bad man

plush tendon
#

I dont like being a lamppost

hardy pawn
#

It could have been so cool

deep steppe
#

^kyrian armor wearers

prime nymph
#

does anyone know the range

#

of the banners mastery effect

uneven mason
#

2 closest people

deep steppe
#

infinity range?

plush tendon
#

yea, so first youll have walk to your nearest boomy, give him a smooch, then charge in

distant crystal
#

tooltip just says 2 nearest but probably 40yds or something

hardy pawn
#

Or, kick the boomie and get a feral

#

:^)

uneven mason
#

I don't see a range limit anywhere

plush tendon
#

IDK man, I like trees

uneven mason
#

like normally there is a range on those things

#

even in the spell data

#

like, theres nothing lo

distant crystal
#

big brain play keep 20 warriors in oribos while you mythic raid

deep steppe
#

^

distant crystal
#

and have em pop banner to blast

uneven mason
#

have Mwahi test it on PTR, stand on one side of Oribos with party on the other and cast it

deep steppe
#

widebrain strats

flint wraith
#

What soulbind do you chose with necro?

sand condor
#

mawhi simmed them earlier

rancid ember
#

Potency Conduits are being added to Nathria in 9.0.5 right?

remote dawn
#

any have fast a macro for speer cast @ mouse

plush tendon
sand condor
#

thats it

distant crystal
#

@remote dawn idk spell name but

#

/cast [@cursor] spear

flint wraith
#

Any racials that is more neat than other?

#

vulpera seems hella huge

#

But is it a bait

sand condor
#

dwarf

#

is prog

#

pog

remote dawn
distant crystal
#

i use that for heroic leap too

sand condor
#

like its legit awesome

distant crystal
#

any ground effect where i care more about speed than precision

flint wraith
#

Horde slave :/

sand condor
#

yikes

#

i played zandalari

#

tauren is neat

#

cus aoe stun

fickle shadow
#

Any thoughts on NF priest CDR and prot warrior with the wall in M+? Could have some crazy high uptime

distant crystal
#

dorf gang

#

imagine simping the tank

#

yikes

uncut juniper
#

Guys how do you outrange the Chamber Sentinals Frontal Cone Bleed in Sanguine Depths? I mean i can jump once and maybe intervene someone if hes standing safely and without turning the frontal into the melee camp... i find this hard in PUGs. So other then doing that? what else? if i run asap i still get hit oO

rancid ember
#

They nerfed it so much you don't dodge it just don't let it hit others

uncut juniper
#

on high fortified keys? you sure? :D

#

when did they nerf it?

deep steppe
#

define high

uncut juniper
#

18+

rancid ember
#

yeah it was nerfed hard

uncut juniper
#

mk

deep steppe
#

on 15's and 16's i just sit there so

#

idk bout 18's

uncut juniper
#

i always wondered because on my monk i just roll out eazy peazy

#

but on warrior :O

rancid ember
sterile moss
sterile moss
uncut juniper
#

yea thats what i do aswell but i find it hard to coordinate it with non voice keys

deep steppe
#

you can phial the bleed if you're kyrian

raven nebula
#

Is there a good place to read some expert opinions about the changes in 9.0.5?

uncut juniper
#

true

rancid ember
#

Are you stacking mobs on top of a sentinal Bard?

sterile moss
#

you can soulshape the frontal if nf

deep steppe
#

Mwahi does guides/sims for prot

uncut juniper
#

allright ill see how it goes. thanks guys :D

sterile moss
uncut juniper
#

yea me2

#

this one is the hardest

sterile moss
#

if you're going to pull the one before the guantlet, feel free to use the zrali button

rancid ember
#

Idk I've never felt bleed damage to be scary but I only a 17 SD so far

sterile moss
#

sure, it's no big deal if the sentinel is by itself

rancid ember
#

I remember that pre-nerf and the initial hit was a slapper

winged ore
#

hiya! brewmaster main looking to roll a prot war after the 9.0.5 buffs, does race choice matter much? i've seen highmountain or vulpera recommended. I mostly play M+, so belf would be nice. Is the extra knockdown from highmountain worth it? seems like it could fill in the gap of utility prot seems to have?

austere stream
#

Bull rush is more than just knockdown, it's also the ability to get far enough out of range of your targets to get another charge off, and on an oGCD to boot.

ionic fern
winged ore
#

ohhh thats very neat

ionic fern
#

Or be a chad and go Dwarf.

deep steppe
#

No chads here

#

No chads allowed

jagged pier
#

chad dwarf or chungus panda

wind surge
#

Orcs have bigger should mog compared to body size

pine tangle
#

Ya'll probably recieve this question a lot. But with the new covenant changes to necrolord would it be wise to start necro as mythic+ tank? Fresh warrior so past progress is not important.

ionic fern
#

One downside to Taurens in general is that you can't fit through all the doors with a mount.

#

😦

deep steppe
#

heres a question

distant crystal
#

just like real life

deep steppe
#

are people really gonna re-roll prot for the dam buff

#

like

#

that seems odd to me

#

idk

sweet summit
#

banner

pine tangle
#

I started playing wow 3 weeks ago, and my main is in progress lock. And warriors seem cool πŸ™‚ Sorry for being a noob.

ionic fern
ionic fern
#

Welcome to the good side of being a tank and getting flamed for everything.

pine tangle
#

Atleast tanks get invited to groups, my Shadow priest is crying every time man.

ionic fern
#

The true reason why i'm playing a tank tbh.

rustic arrow
#

re: spear macro i kinda like:

/cast [mod:ctrl,@cursor] Spear of Bastion
/cast [nomod,@player] Spear of Bastion```
ionic fern
#

Cba waiting for que timers as a DPS with the limited time i have to play.

#

πŸ˜‚

wanton condor
#

hold control and target otherwise self target?

rustic arrow
#

yeah

signal plover
#

Tbh I just always @cursor spear

covert cradle
deep steppe
rustic arrow
#

i had it on cursor but i had a ton of times where i smooth brained threw it away from combat

ionic fern
wanton condor
#

I've been considering doing a mod for cursor, largely because in m+ I do want to see the target

pine tangle
wanton condor
#

but against bosses I don't give a shit

pine tangle
#

Like cmon 😦

signal plover
#

I've only thrown it into Africa like 10 times all xpac

wanton condor
#

I've hit new zealand a couple

deep steppe
ionic fern
# pine tangle Like cmon 😦

Best thing you can do is make your own groups. Tanks are in general the hardest to find so if you're filling that role already healers/DPS'ers will be flooding in.

patent stone
#

Guys, what do you think the new legendary and the buffs will do to the prot meta?

deep steppe
#

Mwahi does good work getting us all the info we need in a nice post

pine tangle
#

@deep steppe Thanks, did not see that. Some good reading, ty! πŸ™‚

deep steppe
#

❀️

#

We will rise to the top together bois

coarse kestrel
#

you can always be like me and make your own groups, pick terrible compositions with offmeta classes and terrible rio scores, burn up or 1 chest the keys but invariably finish them cause these people never leave no matter how bad it goes!

#

plus you get to outdps at least 1 dps that way and that's cool too I guess.

hardy pawn
#

Honestly thats my favourite part of pugging

#

I outdpsed a destro warlock yesterday

deep steppe
brittle owl
uneven mason
floral pewter
#

it might shift player perception though

brittle owl
hardy pawn
#

Might actually break 100k prot warriors on rio

floral pewter
#

tank balance was reasonably good to begin with, so if people just stop thinking warriors are F-tier, they might see a lot more play

strong forum
#

so in that regard we will defo pump more

signal plover
#

Damaj πŸ“ˆ

strong forum
#

in raid howver yea, just like you said, still on the low end

brittle owl
uneven mason
#

You'd be shocked

brittle owl
#

unless you're on top, people will generally think the class is shit

uneven mason
#

the IP off the GCD change in BFA

#

completely flipped warrior perception

#

and people were suddenly in awe of us

strong forum
#

dorki already said on his stream pwar is gonna be broken so theres that

brittle owl
#

it wasn't just ip vhange

strong forum
#

kinda cringe tho

hardy pawn
#

I mean people still think Feral is shit despite the fact they're giga pumping in ST

brittle owl
#

it was ip + vanguard buff + BoM

brittle owl
#

people keep forgetting those

strong forum
#

yup

#

very cringe

brittle owl
#

people predicting metas is cringe in general

uneven mason
brittle owl
#

predictions in general are dumb

signal plover
#

Does cringe make you lose weight

deep steppe
#

Losing weight? Cringe

brittle owl
#

kinda makes you fat i think

signal plover
#

Tru

brittle owl
#

gives you an acne neckbeard too

signal plover
#

Ty 4 your wisdoms

strong forum
#

losing weight is very cringe

#

unless youre fat

#

then its cool

fading quiver
#

how useful is avoidance warforges for tanking? like should i use a 220 neck with avoidance over a 226 with more haste?

strong forum
#

tertiaries are to be ignored

#

until equal ilvl