#protection
1 messages · Page 1867 of 1
yea, War is fine
but shattering throw is a 45 second CD? and Disrupting shout is 1:30
Paladin AS is low CD, Divine Toll is a 1:00
perfect for a 10s
AS not only interrupts, but damages 5 other mobs so good snap threat
Making me wanna level my pally tank
Im a Prot Paladin truther as the best tank to alt and to do weekly content on
but to main.... ehhhh
not sure about that
Main, no
lol
i suck. someone help me learn how to avoid turning my back to packs in multi pulls
this feels like someone just posted a key and wrote a reddit rage post on it

im precast shield wall
if its big pull
that man may or may not have a manifesto
me, i simply, do not give a singular fuck, i am just a vualt filler
at BEST
pugging as prot and being half way done with the res 18's, i feel the anger. I'm at the point where im praying for a tuning patch
Dear yogi,
have you tried strafing?
Walk backwards/strafe
Is it true you must play with 2 crafted items and don't go full 298 ilvl because of Arcanoweave lining ?
Hw we feel with bleeds and burn damage? Having trouble with those apart from ignore pain and cds
Bleeds - Dwarf, burn dmg - SR dmg DR
Race swap Dwarf is broken this season. And I think it will be like this through the expansion
Will not betray the horde
You will suffer then xD
been like this for years now
Ever since the faction barrier was removed, if you really cared about max M+ preformance for top end play, it was either Nelf or Dwarf
What if you a human
Also, and correct me if Im wrong, even before the removal of factions, I think most MDI teams played Dwarf or Nelf anyways
in like BFA/SL
Just Dwarf solves the only problem warrior has - Bleed
Does dark iron dwarf have it too?
Also some frost magic DR and gives Crit
Yes but their racial increases strength instead of dr so u want use with cds instead of the cleanse
it does; you actually get more Prim stat on-use when you use their version (if you remove a debuff, the duration of the prim stat buff increases which is neat)
they also get some increased move speed inside and 1% phys damage reduction
personally, I prefer normal Dwarf
2% more crit damage and phys damage DR when you stoneform (so if you know you dont need it, you can actually use it as a mini CD for phys damage)
but if you dont like the look of Dwarf, just stay your current race. Human has their bright spots to! 2% more stat and a stun break can actually help a lot
or cover mistakes
Using human racial is hilarious, prime example is last boss of WRS
You can negate the stun and the puddle once
Like the fear in MT, AE zerker 
I play a human War right now, but I do like Dwarf War as well
You can clean Fear anyway
Budget shammy totem
just depends on the key level you are doing; casual pushing I would never ask someone to spend the $25 bucks to race change (and, also, people should enjoy how their character looks unless they have to start min maxing)
you 100% dont need to be dwarf for AA, but youll have to play it differently
I leap out at 5 stacks with wall and let it reset
Id also say that with how easy it is to gear, if someone doesnt have the attachment to a character they can just level and make another character
On Seat second boss, is there an advantage to eating some of the orbs as tank before the clear thing goes out? (i.e., the circles that let us clear the orbs). I usually just eat any orbs we miss after the clear, but I heard today that you're actually supposed to clear some before that as tank
They should all be able to be cleared with the circles
No need to tank any
Unless unlucky
Yes, understood they are clearable with the circles - what I heard today (which seems to make sense with the dungeon journal description) is that each void bomb cleared with it does damage w/ Umbral Nova, so clearing some first will stagger the damage over time more
I havent heard about that nor seen, maybe somebody else here has
yeah some DPS told me to do it in the 17 we were in. Healer was struggling so maybe to help that
SR and 🙏
an hour later but what key level are you having issues with and what dungeon
this is correct
the more you can soak as a tank, the better, but this isn't an issue in anything under 18s
at 17 you can probably start transitioning strats
any orb that you can soak as a tank
is less damage the group will take when they clear with their circles
again
this is not something you should consider under 17s
just do it natty
yeah i find just planting yourself and the bosses in the center where you can eat the most circles yourself and letting them figure out the rest makes it simpler for pugs especially. people do weird shit when the tank is leaping around trying to min max
agreed
Or the DPS doesn't wanna move because it will lose a lot of dmg
as a tank thats our job
so that dps minimizes movement
we want to guarantee uptime
this isnt a "oh im dps its my fault for not moving" thing
as tanks we're expected to control positioning taking into consideration things like that
and if anyone here isnt doing that, then they should
can warrior leap over the line on the last boss of Windrunner Spire?
thx
that is true
That's true. I am talking about Seat second boss.
so am i
we should be allowed to leap to save a friend from a projectile
and it should be heavily dharamtized in game
LOST REFERENCE

:nodders:
intervene
Good to know about that seat thing
Honestly just worth doing some as long as you can afford to without swinging the boss around too much
Man ive seen some tanks just moving that boss like crazy
Annoying af
Hard to keep uptime without walking into balls as mdps
It's ophera, "and you geta frontal"
Frontal is a funny term
Haha
New dk name unlocked 
is 1/4 phalanx the way to go? keep reading its bait but it's up on the top keys for atleast 2 weeks already
so weird
if you want LS, Indom, etc you have more than enough options without dropping 4/4
and anyone running 1/4 is severely outdated
outdated to beta versions even
been at the top for weeks
and 5 of the top 6 warriors are 4/4

one is logged out as arms
Even the build I run is sus, but I don't fall over in 14's
I play a prot war with no talents
to prove talents are a crutch
We pulled a 14 like it was a 10 to test talents last night. Boi was that an experience
Is that for the upcoming borrowed power?
Yes.
Ahhh true. I read it as “we are getting rid of it.”
That’s the pvp version of the voidforging shards
Apparently they’re bugged or something and don’t work
So they’re probably canning them and rolling the functionality into the voidcores
But that’s PvP stuff so it’s beyond me

I wait for a wowhead article with a fancy title like “Gain infinite power for free” or something
"exploit early, and exploit often"? 
I just like the clickbait titles 
I usually hear about any form of exploit worth doing from some friends
They tell me about it and say i should do it
And i dont because im way too lazy
If you get there before wowhead, you won* in life 

Idk where people actually hear about a lot of that stuff though
Like is there a discord all the tech comes from
And then word of mouth
I remember my guild wanting me to go the 1/4 route about 2 weeks ago 
I tried it for literally 1 key
i wonder why blizzard didnt make a 2 target dummy pair in silvermoon
always failing with the dummies
as soon as they make workable dummies for houses, ill get a house
Last 3 pair I know of was SL or WoD
Is the silver moon training dummy item not a dummy?
I'll look tonight for you, I have like 4 of em
I feel like i wouldve heard if they were actual dummies, but then again nobody ik still does housing
Thatd be pretty nifty
I go there to chill about 1 time a week
I copy pasted archon talents try to getting the one with indom and last stand, did some keg that gave me IO and only after I saw it was using 1/4 felt basically the same i actually thought it was 4/4 
ffxiv has workable dummies
why doesnt wow have house ones reee
one of my favorite things is punching dummies for an hour outside my house in ffxiv
I havent done much wow housing myself and ive heard from everyone it’s super good, but i just vibe with ffxiv housing more or something
Ya ive heard that too
forever uncompleted until dummies
You must do housing for free heroic currency
Me and my gf chose plots when it came out in preseason or whatever
And made basic houses
And i havent been back
4/30 i got hero of the dawn
They should add some decor rewards in m+
if they are usable dummies, im all in

Similar to portal for 10, imagine like a trophy at 12 and a portal at 15 or somethinf
WoD garrison level trophy 
Imagine if this housing came out back then instead of garrisons how they were
Wouldve been wild
Its ok Nim, home ownership isnt for everyone
hey

thats cool! You have a house in Japan
only for the dummies
is that for vacations?
I always forget I have a house in ff
I dont understand why ppl like housing.. but maybe im the wrong demographic since I already have a real house so dont need virtual
i hope youve been checking every 30 days lmao
I have a house in irl and in game to flex on people
It’s auto pay so I hope so, I just quick log in and out

Until my homies say it’s okay for them to carry me in ults or whatever
i need to finish dawntrail's story
I think housing in games is cool even if i dont interact with it
Bro I zoom through that til get to end game so fast
Honestly my creativity is just bad and i cant create a cool house to hang out in
i havent played anything that came out after heavyweight
but not for lack of interest
its just i didnt have time with dune awakening and WoW and bf6 and monster hunter
If I struggle on keys at 12 and up, how likely is it that I am mistiming shield block?
HR?
heavy repercussions
follow the icy veins builds
and dont talent into the fray (ITF) if you dont have the required haste -> read pins
Oh, I have one from wowhead when the season launched.
we dont support wowhead this season
Ugh, I might have a stat issue too then
I only have about 7% vers so I know I need to improve that
Haste is also low I am around 680
Is that bare minimum?
Like BARELY
Not a defensive factor
It's the value at which you can reasonably switch to itf
And manage to still keep sb up with proper play
it's not automatic
run the icy veins build, it has heavy repercussions
i have 1300 haste and still play hr because i'm bad
thats fine
i just don't feel confident enough yet to switch, i was able to manage sb with itf on a dummy but
as you said it barely works with full itf buff and 100% uptime
With less you need to put in breaks
at good points in time
uhh
So vers isn’t the second highest stat required?
i was able to keep sb up with itf on the dummy group nim
the only season where this was true was in BFA s4 due to versatile corruption, no other season we've geared vers 2nd
ever
Icy has stats listed as haste then vers equaling crit
its always sim+highset simming
vers second is a bear or bdk thing
crit = vers is a signal to sim
but crit always sims higher
it tends to work out that crit and vers sim very similar
Vers means you take less damage
Ok so they don’t mean equally important
correct
Misunderstood that one
whatever sims higher after haste, thats what you gear
Another common problem people have other than SB uptime is backshots btw
which is usually crit
Oh back shots I know to avoid, tanked as a Druid for 3 expansions.
Learned about them the hard way
a druid that avoid back shots is rare
its not nearly as punishing for Guardian
i like you
as it is for warrior
Druid cant dodge but pwar you get mega fcked if they stab your butt
not trying to be mean
im praising you
yea, Nim is a big meenie
lol

apparently im mean when im nice
Admittedly, I did make a boo boo early on with Warrior tank. I thought heroic leap would take me out of melee range and tried to jump over a pack.
It was an…..interesting experience
yeah

at least that's how it feels
Yes, my healer told me I got Johnny caged
Bleeds and spells cannot be dodged, parried, or blocked is that right?
Spells you can
if its applied on a parriable hit, yes they can
Just use spell reflect
fiery talons are parryable
Not talking about sr
and im pretty sure the heal absorbs in NPX are as well
but i could be wrong
fiery talons are 100% parryable
Ur sating that some spell casts can be carried but not dots that you gave already right?
Can the bite in algaleth academy be blocked?
Imagine parrying a lasher bleed
Vile bite? Don't think so.
Phooey
So, spell reflect?
no
How do yall handle the fire claw stacks in skyreach?
its a casted bleed
Shockwave one round. Jump away for another
If still up, intervene to someone a short distance away from the mob
I think vile bite is dodgeable tho bc AA so much easier on my brew
Oh that’s clever
Bleeds scary me
Brew doesn’t count, they are like a God walking amongst mortals.
kill the mobs before I die
Hmm idk why it's easier on brew then maybe better mobility so easier to kite
How many stacks of bleed is too many? Yes
All the heavy ticks are easier on a brew because of stagger
nothing to do with kite
smooth dmg intake is the healers jam
and brews excel at it this season
unless stagger ticks slower than bleeds, no
Don't they?
depends on the total stagger duration vs the lasher bleed duration ig, but idk the numbers
it will still ramp up slower even with same tick times
Anyone else's graphics just casually reset themselves in silvermoon?
i mean they purify
yeah that too
but if they are red staggering that whole pull... it doesnt necessarily mean its easier to deal with
the high dmg intake phase would just be shorter and more in the middle
no
ramp up, full dot, ramp down
Idk if it’s still the case but brew wanted to always be red stagger in tww
hm, i'll look up stagger again
its not about stagger
Just death strike
Y I didn’t fully read all that
the bleeds + back hits = no dodges = dead brew
yeah okay i can see that
Back hit on any tank = dead tank
or maybe he just got lucky with a party that actually prios the big lashers instead of padding aoe for no reason
which is
more likely?
That is fucking rare
literally how that pull is done
no prio targetting = youre kinda fucked as any tank
anyway lashers are not really the danger of AA
Every AA I've ever done I get 5 stacks and have to leap
look at it this way
there are 3 lashers
you pull, basically one of their packs at a time
if you mark the first one you pulled as skull
and your group correctly prios it
cast 1 goes out
cast 2 goes out
cast 3 goes out
wait time
dead 1st lasher
bleeds fade, stacks restart
and you win
its that simple
if there's no prio targetting you need to play it smarter
and leap at <5s duration BEFORE the third cast
or just dwarf/caut 5 stacks
and stagger the leap
its outplayable, and always has been this season
now battle axes...
spell reflect on cd
what's the gameplay difference with colossus other than pressing demolish on cd?
colossus prios revenge
after SS
thane prios blast into SS into TC and revenge is not used unless those 3 are on cd
you just SS > Revenge as colossus
and use TC if you need rage and SS is down
and of course to proc an SS reset
rage management is a lot different as colossus

i see! so, for colossus you try to spend as much rage on revenge unless you need ignore pain. and tc is for gathering and rage gen. and execute is still a joke and note worth pressing lol
you still ip at 70 rage as colossus
the IP usage does not change
#protection message goes over colossus use cases
but yes you dont press execute as colossus, its def NOT a joke as thane
so idk where that "still" comes from
at the start of season, pre 0.5
we still executed
same use case as now
post execute buffs
straight ST = you execute
okay it seems i missremembered some stuff, thanks for the correction. will remember
yup, i got that. i like colossus because it adds a cool button (and makes you bigger, very important.) so i will be checking it. thanks for all the info, now i got the rage management IP stuff
I find Apex for Colossus useless since you need Thunder Clap to activate it
What I do now is using Phalanx as AOE instead of Revenge
Maybe you just use it once to get DR and then spam Revenge
Yes sir
you do still end up having to press TC, we're not flooded with s3 levels of rage to always be revenging just yet
Where should I be getting mainstream m+ routes from? I often take routes from key pushers in the 18-20 range but they seem to not be accepted by the pugs.
look up keys to your level
not 20s
if youre dong 20s, sure look up 20s routes
go through the ladder in r.io
I’m currently doing 16-17s
Check Topicx
I have been using Topicx usually lol. But thanks I’ll look back at the 15s
If you ask me just use your keys to progress and give 0 fuck what others think
Has anyone tried Collosus no apex ?
Some one told me some streamers said class tuning incoming today?
Any word on if that is fake news
I don't remember a time unless it's a emergency hotfix that class tuning came out other than a Tuesday/Wednesday
some rank 1s chinese players are playing 2/4 or partially into it
or did for a bit
i havent actually simmed any of it since thane is just better dps
Will try 18 today and see how it goes
Ymmv but I found colossus clunky with the lack of TC refunds
Colo is just a different playstyle
Just gotta embrace Revenge and fondly remember the days of IP uptime
Colossus is king, dont let anyone tell you otherwise. (I am woefully bias)
I only ran it in a pos.. but holy hell the dmg
Prob tomorrow if any is coming, in my opinion at least. Usually announced on Fridays
This makes no sense
You just lose 20% increased crit for shield slam -> less demolish using -> less dr and haste uptime
You will see the difference, if you play it without apex
There's no reason to run colossus or thane no apex
i dont know where people got the colossus 2/4 builds but ive been looking for an hour just to get sims done
ok i found one
on an 18 
Why
oh no hes 1/4 not 2/4
1/4 gang!
I dont want to set the world on fire.
lol

also just a heads up, i swear to christ there's no sub 4/4 colossus builds
that was just the one guy
also my icy veins build was outdated so it should sim higher
here we go
crushing force into barbaric training does add quite a tad
Hey guys ive been wanting to complete mage tower, but I think I could do better with my talents. Anybody know of a good guide or small advice? Time ran out last time, was going steady but low dps
uhh
that doesnt sound right but i did it in legion, isnt the SL one just easy at 90?
i mean 226 is still way over
Probably need better talents for that run. Im just using my M+ build
are you reflecting?
mind sear yes, or should I be reflecting drain life?
sorry doing a key
No problem! Gonna give it another try
you should be reflecting twisted reflection on kruul
variss is whatever, but i assume if youre saying time is running out youre already at kruul
i dont remember reflecting drain life at all, i just kicked
Do golems die on their own?
iirc they do but also the heal orbs blasts them
crit blocks and ap
the block chance portion doesn't matter because SB has 100% block chance
but you can get that info in game
do we use any crafted armor pieces?
pins
wowhead says bis is boots craft but also has boots of unformed
icy-veins guide
oh ok lemme check it
ok got it ty
i have little macro's set up, tell the team to 'lust' or what have you.
some ppl have an option i nchat that turns off macro text . . . .
why?
Because some people are little gremlins and like to use macros to spam chat
I literally have all chat bubbles turned off because my raid would just spam like crazy
I didnt know that’s a thing
If i have it, it’s automatically done through an addon
Wouldnt be surprised if qol addons have it or something
Base blizzard can actually turn them off now
Options > search for chat bubbles
Oh like literally just chat bubbles?
I thought he meant like chat filtering out text from a macro somehow
Ya i havent had chat bubbles in years
thats what i meant
chat bubbles are off for long time,
but ppl are now tuning out text macros
Afaik no addons can read and/or filter chat
Or maybe they can idk, i remember that being a point early on when they were restricting addons
I'm gunna quick craft a 1H/Shield with sparks since I offspec prot, which bases are ideal? Rebuke for shield, ??? for 1H?
O.o HOW
Meh I normally have chat on the damage while raiding so it's not distracting

GLADIATOR BACK?
rebuke and any weapon is fine
weapon type doesnt matter
as long as it does not have a permanent embelish
i fucking wish
we all pray for wod classic to play gladiator 🥬 🙏
I was gonna say retail it
but if they brought it to retail it would just... have issues
are warriors always sitting in defensive stance in keys? or stance dancing
You can dance
Don’t really get much
Typically you just stay in d stance unless you’re trying to squeeze out like .1% extra dps
Which tank spec has the easiest gameplay ? Rotation ?
And is there any tank that is good at gathering mobs?
I feel like prot warrior lacks gathering tools for casters for instance, 40 sec throw interrupt is awkward
Gathering would probably be dk tbh, but warrior toolkit is great too.
Disrupting shout is wonderful
Both of your questions can be answered with druid. Big range, big aoe, Roar for every pull and easy rotation
Druid
Druid
Damn now I know what to level next, heard feral is top contender for most fun spec too
Before switching to guardian lol
Have you ever played assa rogue? Basically same thing
Colossus is different, but I did feel the rage difference in aoe.
Assa rogue is great
hey guys what embelli are we after again? double arcanoweave?
It should be less in AoE than in ST.
I've learned to enjoy a key or two of Colossus after the changes they did for Demolish CDR.

maybe the last boss of skyreach just gave me extra rage or something. I never really felt in danger in a 10 as Colossus, and I like the variety.

is it a dps gain to use eyes enchant on rings or just stay haste for prot?
depends from person to person. everyone has different stages & stats for gear, so the most accurate and repetitive answer you will get is to visit https://www.raidbots.com/simbot and compare
The easiest way to use SimulationCraft. A resource for World of Warcraft players.
I guess better question is it worth it since it doesn't have defensive benefit for prot.
I don't think it's even an offensive increase unless you're overflowing with haste.
hmm, simmed better for me by a decent bit but I'll check once I get myth 1h and shield going
I am down to the sword/shield, the gloves, and the tank trinket from skyreach lol
yes backl and bracers
voidcores are so nice
weapon and shield acquired, now to grind the shards
sorry another question wouldn't sudden death be better to use over bloodborne in single target situation, to get free deep wounds on the target when execute procs? it would require dropping bloodsurge and losing the rage buff but i think in a single target it wouldnt really proc that much. simc just aint simming the change im theory crafting
SD>BB for ST with Deep Wounds talent. Bloodsurge rage gain isn't that big against one target and worth swapping imo. If the encounter is trivial you could even drop Defender's Aegis and keep Bloodsurge that way, though that is very situational.
i totally agree, thanks for your help!
Does anyone know if there is a list of mobs for each dungeon in m+ for priority in targeting?
i stance dance a ton, usually on bosses, notably npx 2nd boss, crawth burn/haste, lura dmg amp, as well as on weekly 10s/12s 🙂
Hi guys new warrior here, just curious as to why a majority of people are playing mountain thane vs colossus if colossus does more? Like what are the pros and cons of both?
it doesnt they do the same
and thane is techincally slightly more defensive and easier to gather with
i would play thane and take a look at awoo's prot warrior midnight starter
helped me a ton + tactycs for m+/raid guies
in that video he pretty much says to ignore Revenge and use all rrage after SB for IP
yea when you are learning prot warrior surviving is #1 so focus on that then as you get more comfortable you can work in additional dmg
You do zero damage when dead, and when tanks die usually it wipes the group in m+/raid
ye if you are not using defensives. Otherwise IP dump is not gonna make you more rage for another buttons and for cdr (of those defensives)
Anyone got any hot tips for Algathar? Im consistantly dying to the trash after 2nd boss on the way to Veximus, the melee hits hurt so damn much even with shield block up...
Those are your defensives, wdym? You dump all of your rage into IP keep shield block up at all times, whenever IP falls you dump into it. You will do less damage but it is a pretty foolproof way to survive. It also simplifys the kit to 4 button rotation, so you can focus on all the other things that come with m+/raid/tanking.
ok, it is true that it is simpler. Im just trying to say that revenge is not only extra dmg 🙂 I think he even argues in the video, that it does low dmg, But the resets for rage gen buttons and CDR makes up for it. And the extra rage ends up in IPs anyway. Correct me if Im wrong
No no your right I am mainly just saying for the sake of picking up prot tank that the kit should be as simplified as possible. Revenge can reset shield slam, which extends shield block, which gives more rage, which also can proc phalanx.
its a good idea to solo stun battle axes to try and desync their magical attack. AOE stops are great as well, of course.
popping spell reflect is a good idea during those pulls.
cylce thru demo shoult and shield wall as well,
finally, keep IP up
problem is that new warrior tanks hit revenge to much. so taking it away for a little bit is a good thing, as they get used to dmg intake and how long their mitigation stays up
I find it weird because im needing to hold my shield wall for the tripple pull on the veximus trash
don't do triple pull. do a double (side packs) (and btw, wait for a good time to AOE stop, then do your aoe silence, and wow your group with prot war awesomeness) then simply do the last pull of the platform solo, to let ppl recharge dps and defensive CD's
Don't triple pull, pull 1 pack over the wall with the ravager
Piercing howl and just walk them a bit when out of cds
yea I do that with the stop into silence 😄 I have to keep telling them dont interupt at the start hahaa
Shockwave then as soon as it ends disrupting shout, it insta interrupts all
yea its a beaut, do it all the time
might try that tbh
Also every boss in that dmg has a magic dmg component that you can dr with spell reflect, poison on tree boss, crawth beak, vexamus frontal, echo bomb/blast
yea, might spec into the extra MD DR for it
I can +15 a seat or PIT or WRS any day but damn AA sucks after the 2nd boss
Can maybe watch some vods of 20+ keys to see what they do for movement. If you can make the first pull+second boss it's a pretty free dungeon.
me rn
but this guys a noob, never uses spell reflect XD
https://twitch.tv/yodatv - come watch me live! I stream all the time.
eww pally
not a brew/guardian so actually can use the skills here xD
iv never tanked before this expansion and iv only ever played TWW S1 before 😄
so Warrior is my first and only tank
I was a mm hunter main 😄
same, so i feel ya xd, first season doing mythic+ and myth raiding coming from havoc dh
im proud im doing +15's tbh
dumb
tell me u dont know how the play the class without telling me u dont know how to play the class is all ppl that say that scream to me
to be fair when your learning, its kinda true
learn how to not die, then learn when you can spend on damage instead of defence
Pressing revenge is also not dying
Its more rage gen which is more not dying
Ip will never save u and doesnt keep u alive
not sure how it gens rage as it spends it
Revenge is rage gen because it procs shield slam which is rage gen
okay, I must have missed something, how does it do that
honestly if you arent using revenge you are heavily inting urself
☝️
for others 🙂
to be honest, iv been using revenge when theres nothing else to press anyyway so kinda been doing this naturally
Also doing dmg is a big part of survival
cant die if theres nothing to kill you


and as jake said overspending rage into ip is just useless and will prob kill you more than spamming revenge
if your over spending into IP you need to up your key level
you can be pressing ip when not needed people do it a lot
- anger management that gives you more cdr of wall and cdr of avatar that helps again with more rage
and violent outburst that giver you free IP, 50% more rage from next shiled slam ect 🙂
sometimes Revenge does not even consume rage
always press glowey button 🤓
especially shield slam
U can over spend on ip in highest keys right now btw
Has nothing do woth key lvl
Just to do with how much rage u have
ye its what i meant when i said overspending prob shoulda worded better
Nah i was jist saying the statement of if u are overspending on ip u need to raise key lvl
Means nothing cause thats not what decides where your age goes
yerp
appreciate the help lads o7
Its wuite shrimple fo thane if u are over 70 rage u press ip
I want to keep 30 for shield block at all times
And then if u cannot press tc or ss u revenge
Just follow those rules and u gucci

and do not get hit in the booty
i mean from a person who learned prot war this season this is just a lie xd, i was way overcasting revenge as i was learning and I died more frequently because i lost rage spent on IP and Shield Slam. If you are learning the class you shouldn't touch it
If you grasp the class then it is an important press, but not until then
That isnt a problem of spending rage on revemge but not spending on ip and probably wasting rage, also wild to say u pressed revnge instead of ip when one if one the hcd and one isnt
Not where in this discussion did anyone say its a choice
U press both
Rage and what spells u have available are what dictates thag
idk it is a problem that i personally had and a few other prot wars that started this season also had the problem
Was talking about this
overcasting revenge, undercasting sb/ip
Yer its a strimmer that doent play the class roid what do u expect
Honestly you think I’d understand by now but I just can’t
Just delete all streamers please

I’ve yet to find one that gives any sort of advice grounded in data
Because its all feelycraft
Hence y they all play itf instead of hr with low haste
But i get told its the most defensive build every season

i mean for people learning the class the whole thing is feelycraft...
Is it because the guides we have are very solid and base in the stats of everything
And covers things like when to revenge
I mean what if someone wrote a guide that was based on knowledge and data and math
That a person learning could read
That’s crazy
idk im just speaking from personal experience as someone who started learning the class a few weeks ago, the traditional here is everything dumped at my face didnt work for me or a lot of others
just taking revenge and execute off my bars, focusing on keeping shield block/ip up and learning how to tank with a shield helped me learn way better
Did you read the guide?
Because basically everyone will tell you to read the guide
my problem was the exact opposite. I used to press IP too often and as it is offGCD, I tent to starve myself often. It sucked even more considering how little the IP helps with survivalbility
And I’m not typically this guy but taking revenge and execute off of your bars doesn’t help you learn to tank better, it helps you to learn to tank wrong
And ip doesnt help u doing that
Its a rage dump
Literally a rage dump
Its not our active mitigation
Its not our iron fur
Its not our bone shield
Its not our shield of the righteous
Its not our demon spikes
Ty yes. It’s better
Gj @broken marsh
and when red bar fills up too high, use IP?
I’m sure that removing those skills does reduce cognitive load and it works for you, I’m just saying you are forming muscle memory around something that is not going to do you any favors down the line
i mean it was literally just until i had shieldblock up all the time, wasnt getting hit by mobs, and was able to gather that i added them
That being said if you know you only wanna run 10s and you’re content to run at 75% then by all means send it
and now im 3.5
Ngl this is kinda hard sometimes lol
Ignore Pain
Ignoring 50% of damage taken, preventing # total damage.
12 seconds remaining
That is by definition active mitigation
Yea? Active mitigation that is a core part of your rotation?
U should play colossus if u think ip is our active mitigation and not shield block
Is all ill say

I think Jakeys point is that we press it because of its rage spend not because of the mit
If they removed the mit portion and replaced it with a button that says “spend 30 rage” it would not change how we use it whatsoever
Can you not have more than one piece of active mitigation
The absorb portion is not enough to meaningfully impact your survivability
I dont think u understand how close to damage cap warrior is with out ip
Ip is a sprinkle on top
Its not a main thing
As roid said if it jjst spent 30 rage
We would press the exact same
U barely press it as colossus
For that reason to because u have far less rage
U cant just spam ip
Yet colossus is pretty much as tanky as thane
Go do a key and take IP off of your bar
Compare it to a key where you play normally
Look at your hp graph across the key
It will have no meaningful difference
i mean im looking at a log of my most recent 17, ignore pain contributed 17.2k hps
I’m all for blizz redesigning ip to be meaningful mitigation because I think it’s a trap right now
that is quadruple my leech
Completely irrelevant though
How much hps did your healer overheal
Healing isn’t zero sum like dps, that 17k isn’t a factor because
- your healer would probably have otherwise healed it but it went to overheal
- that’s an aggregate across the entire key and if you look at the ehp impact at any single point it’s extremely low
Because it breaks so fast?
Because it’s based on size of independent hit and it only absorbs 50% in a first past the post so when you’re going to die, it’s gonna take 50% of a bunch of smaller hits and fall off then you still get clapped
Even if you spam it
Like I said go do a key and don’t press it at all, your survivability will not meaningfully change, only your damage
but if you were for example tanking a vorasius slam it would act as active mitigation correct?
Yes but realistically how much is left for it to absorb? A single large hit would be a best case scenario for IP but those also tend to overlap with shield wall
of course it absorbs stuff, the people here just argue compared to the dps you actually mitigate by blocking, dodging and parrying it is extremely low
And if you are playing properly you’re taking those hits with proper redux mit up
And ip again, is largely meaningless
The data is all there man
I mena I have pulled ahead of my healer sometimes, or if they dc and the combination of my defensives keeps me up
notably ip
Ok you are clearly not comprehending why hps is not relevant lol, you’re doing 17s please just carry on
like first pulls of dungeons often go well into 100ks hps for tanks, even prot war
Your also saying it did 17k hps
Yea and I can rip 400k hps on my monk
When its an absorb for 50%
overall, in a 30 minute dungeon yes
Haven't logged a key since I've fixed my sqw or UI so I can't gauge a proper fix
idk, regardless my point of mental load = less when execute and revenge arent on ur mind and its just learning how to tank as a prot war. it is not optimal, at all, but it is good for learning. Especially since people learning will be struggling with routing/dungeon mechanics/backhits/etc.
That button is about as meaningful right now as raging blow is to a thane fury warrior, it gets pressed like a forgotten red headed step child
There like no difference
as a teacher i tend to agree to your point, but only if you substitute something for it, for example you could add a sound cue to execute being available
and replace revenge with it then
Idk I'm on about 2 hrs of sleep so 
i mean you could take ignore pain off ur bars
but then you have no spenders, ip is off the gcp so you can just scroll wheel away while keeping shieldblock up
Revenge/40 rage execute are spenders?
but they are on gcd are frontals which for me was a substansial bit more brainpower
well apart from execute which is lol
Still execute in ST
but then the problem arose of I would press revenge/execute when ss/tc are off cd
Granted I only do 14's and don't have a group to do higher
you dont need a group to do higher
i mean i honestly still have the problem of casting execute when ss/tc are up
which not only is a damage loss but also a major defensive loss
yet another reason to take it off the bars for learning
So you’re saying you agree with everything I just said over the past 30 minutes that ip isn’t meaningful mitigation and only valued for its rage spend to drive violent outburst 🫠
Does it come up mid cast or like you cast it instead?
you can solve the issue of missing too many ss procs
yea but like the only spells on the bars for learning are ss/tc/ip/sb
By binding it after ip or sb
Which is fine because it only casted when they are down
no he said when they are up
that happens to me with revenge sometimes
q=shield charge e=revenge 1=charge 2=ip 3=ss r=tc f=sb
because my fingers remember revenge from old times when ss and then revenge was prio
And tc was only used to keep up tc debuff
and i for the most part just spam r - 3 - e when r/3 down
Like I have the more important casts on the center of my ui
i have that too, but you should only glance at your main spells not focus on them
The nameplates changed last night 
Else you will only look at those
and not the actual situation
that's why we train muscle memory
Sit on a training dummy for about 30m 💪
I used single button assistant for a key, it was quite hilarious what it tried to do
need to run way more keys
like my cpm of ss is alright
but i tend to overuse revenge over tc/tb
i will check if i can add a sound cue to 2 tb stacks
will help for both fury and prot
Smack keyboard harder 
S tier DK name
:3
instructions unclear
I just spam and let the haste carry me, but that leads to a ton of bad revenge casts

Oh i thought he ment like he wanted to oress it but they other 2 were off cd
Which is fine
But also u only press execute in st so should be easy
To fit anyway
bro, there are times right now where it feels like I hit SS 4-5 times a row
XD
And yer u get a reset with a spell queued it hapoens
Does our autos still chance proc SS?
So autos, Tclap,execute?
Yeah
Reve
If we want to talk about bad habits when I tank weekly 10s I macro ignore pain to thunderclap and shield block to shield slam and live my best Netflix watching life
Jakey don’t hit me
I knew I was missing one didn't quite know if it did
is pressing revenge instead of execute to spend in st that bad
Depending on rage I'd think
as thane and in ST? yes its bad and youre losing dps
but like how bad
considerable
Well, 20 vs 40 rage and an AE vs ST button
execute is 20-40
if ss/tc not up do u just wait or hwat
you press execute
so the rage doesnt matter then?
you dont press it when ss/tc are up you do when they arent
it doesnt, you just want to ideally hit it at 40 rage
mm ic
if youre at 20 rage when SS and TC are down, it means you either got unlucky and had to press it more than once and didnt get reset
or youre mismanaging rage horribly
is there a macro that casts execute if able, revenge if not?
no
🙁
Are macros the new "there's a weakaura for that?"
no
No
people have been looking for shortcuts even before midnight
i hit glad on fury in df with a BIG DAM macro that was basically all of my dmg spells
Not a jab, just noticed more people recently looking for macros
macros make the game easier, less skill expression, but easier
That sounds like a cast sequence macro?
pot,blood fury, avatar, reckless, banner
The swifty macro it is
it fucking works ill tell u what
Ohh, you pop all non gcd abilities together. Yeah I have one of those
That macro is just common knowledge at this point
i had one for defensives as well but that was NOT a good idea xd
#showtooltip Ignore Pain
/use Ignore Pain
/use Spell Reflection
/use Berserker Rage
/use Rallying Cry
/use Healthstone
/use 13
/use 14
/use Die by the Sword
/use Bitter Immunity
idek how it worked
but if stupid shit gets you that far it makes you wonder what is happening below...
That looks sus
Like you have to be below 40 rage sus
thats the dumbest macro ive seen in a minute
I don't think I ever actually used spell reflect properly until I hit 1800
I normally have the "is it a magic and is SR off CD?" Smash it
i mean u saw the macro lol
in pvp it was kinda cool figuring out i could spell reflect spells and not just on accident
like chaos bolt or smthn
That macro is a growing pain
When prot had recklessness, that plus SR was fucking hilarious
the good ole days
this aint a pvp channel
well gn gotta sleep b4 raid tn 🙂 was fun chatting
i read all of this due to ping glad we established IP is just a button to spend rage 
Huh?


what ping
like 150 msgs up

i got pinged
lol
oh

Winning
@lusty grotto don’t resub to ff it took me like 3 days to max out gear and finish everything now im bored again
saving money aint worth your time anyways
damn, Nim got that full time employment money
I bet he fills his car with gas without comparing prices
You can/should actively think about IP usage considering big unlockable damage spikes tho.
oh i complain about gas prices alright
Dont they are the lowest they will ever be again

Don't we all. 🙁
bro, it was crazy
I drove from Boston to the Bronx last weekend
gas was cheapest in the Bronx
at like $4.50
ill just die but nah I was mainly telling someone they are probably overspending on ip of they think pressing revenge at all is bad
it was like $4.60 in CT which is dumb

then a big discussion on ip happened
hmm 
Also management being deaf to their employees
when you can work remote
so essentially everybody got a pay cut this year just on gas prices.
1/4 GANG! HYPE!
I dont like remote work for myself... but damn do i wish all of yall just stayed home
Nim sitting there, gnawing at his cheeze cracker, being annoyed I wasted 0.1 to 0.01 % dps potential

imagine if blizz let us use lucky embellish on that
sure cat, but it'd be funny if you cant equip due to your other pieces
made that mistake once
I wont drive on the interstate anymore
I got mythic gear for days, all slots
too many untrained truckers out there now also
noone can stop me
My days subscribed is like 5000 or something
I too like to burn my money

Im so glad I dont commute all the way into Boston anymore
actual nightmare
30 tons of death machine looking down at their fucking phone
Close but younger 
Fuck you got me
I could be pashs dad
better question, what Millennium were you born in
Scary

perfect math done without caffeine, i need to do this more
All of our GitHub tokens were revoked by accident last night so I’m on my second pot already
If you were my dad you’d be driving cross state lines to gay marry his two lesbian former coworkers 
And by that I mean he’s ordaining the marriage or whatever it’s called
Unfortunate
supply chain attacks are terrifying
Hey I’m non judgmental, my 13 year old has been straight, pan, bi, lesbian, and back to straight again this year
I support all the colors brother
Sexuality speedrun





