#protection

1 messages · Page 1549 of 1

strong forum
#

like, sure they can survive but theyre literally making it harder on themselves

warm plinth
#

My personal favorite is the one I saw where they were running bloodborne but no shield spec and no ravager node

strong forum
#

yeah

#

incomprehensible

clever heart
#

gotcha ! so do you think the best talent tree build is still the wow head one ?

deft vessel
#

😄

strong forum
#

yes, you can swap bloodsurge for something else if you wish

clever heart
warm plinth
#

bloodsurge I assume you meant?

tribal rover
#

I didn’t read through all of this but I have all trinkets and if your going for damage I found Tomb being used with a weak aura for max up time with ceaseless ire gives me the most dmg on my play style.

strong forum
#

and if you want to pick up cleave execute or massacre, you drop enduring alacrity for that

#

cuz that talent is the weakest in the 3rd gate

strong forum
neon elk
#

I just wish they would allow us to play thunderlord without needing LS

strong forum
#

LS aint bad

#

it literally buffs your IP cap by 30% and is a heal

neon elk
#

Not saying its bad but i find myself pressing it very rarely

strong forum
#

i recommend changing that!

#

its great for gathering/once gathered, to stabilize

deft vessel
#

LS?

strong forum
#

as it lasts vastly longer than SW

deft vessel
#

oh the hero talent

strong forum
#

last stand

deft vessel
#

oh nvm xD i see

tribal rover
deft vessel
#

last stand is goated, even without the buff node to it

strong forum
#

i wouldnt say goated

#

but it serves some purpose

deft vessel
#

I dunno, I like it 😄

clever heart
strong forum
#

that happens a lot when a spec gets popular

#

for DPS its more 1dimensional and consequential

tribal rover
deft vessel
#

trust in the guide writers 🙂

strong forum
#

for Tanks, theres more leeway

tribal rover
#

What level keys you running?

deft vessel
#

I'm somewhat late to season so mostly running 6s/7s right now

warm plinth
#

I'm doing 13s/14s and I'm still using the weekly build on wowhead

clever heart
warm plinth
#

Haven't felt in danger yet

strong forum
#

never hurts to ask

#

data evaluation is a critical skill many people do not possess

#

which is why tierlists are so popular

clever heart
tribal rover
strong forum
#

i personally would probably run the execute damage build until idk 15/16s cuz im a wh ore

#

fucking automod hitting me cuz i wanna insult myself

warm plinth
#

LOL

clever heart
#

LOL

tribal rover
#

Yeah I run straight up max dos setup until 13’s then I start to change it a bit for pug groups

strong forum
#

im also not a fan of BSV cuz cheats are for the weak

jagged pier
#

well someone died the other day because the server tick hadnt happened for them to get the buff

dry skiff
#

i'm putting alot of faith into my To-be-had weapon and Antenna + consumable to make up for the 1m dps sadge currently have a 704 weapon

dusky canopy
#

What did you craft?

dry skiff
#

not weapon because i was sure i would get 1st boss mythic weapon

clever heart
dry skiff
#

it did drop but a frost dk ninja looted it and asked for 400k gold. couldnt afford it and he said he would transmog

warm plinth
#

No, but it's dynamic and realistically it's going to save you from the vast majority of things

clever heart
#

kk that's wat I thought. just checkin

warm plinth
#

It's pretty safe to consider it a cheat due to how it functions, even if it isn't really a cheat

deft vessel
#

what fiber do you lot use

#

I see so many different ones in the top ranks on r.io xD

strong forum
#

Mostly plant

deft vessel
#

lmao

#

valid

strong forum
#

Oh you mean for cloak

deft vessel
strong forum
#

Whatever your Sims says, or just haste until you have too much

deft vessel
#

what's "too much haste"

strong forum
#

More than 26k

deft vessel
#

unbuffed I assume

strong forum
#

Well you shouldn't be running haste flask

#

Cuz that's like the only buff

deft vessel
#

i guess food is a bit only

strong forum
#

Food is Bearxd

tribal rover
#

Veratility atm but it again depends on your current stats and how hard your pushing. We are tanks so don’t worry about sim too much.

deft vessel
#

I'm nowhere near, okay, haste it is nodders

strong forum
#

Stats beyond having good haste practically don't matter

tribal rover
#

I run 21k crit 22.5k haste and 19% vers

strong forum
#

So yeh don't break your head over it

frosty mango
deft vessel
#

me with 8k crit and 13k vers

frosty mango
#

You’re too wholesome nome you gotta shame the populace into submission

strong forum
deft vessel
#

doing my best okay

#

I can swap one of my rings actually probably worth buying a socket for it even if it's champion

tribal rover
#

What’s your haste at?

strong forum
deft vessel
frosty mango
strong forum
#

Or rather, nice is just the little brother of asshole

frosty mango
tribal rover
#

Yeah your gear is your problem. Run 6-7 for keys and get gear you need. Wowhead bis is perfect world senario if you have every piece that’s why the one ring is a mastery ring because you’ll be maxed on the other stats

frosty mango
#

Use the item twice

deft vessel
frosty mango
#

With your current gear it would probably behoove you to farm streets for the ring and then halls, which has a solid haste neck, that would prob sort out your haste issue

#

Halls also drops a good m+ trinket

tribal rover
#

Dawnbreaker has a good ring

deft vessel
#

actively farming 6s and 7s rn

tribal rover
#

For trinkets if your not raiding yet I would use tomb and sac

deft vessel
#

yeah, doing that already

tribal rover
#

For my play style I got until soft cap and a little build for haste. 21-22 ish. I do the same thing for crit.

tribal rover
# deft vessel yeah, doing that already

If you want advice one on one I don’t mind helping. I was in the same boat not to long ago and a warrior took time to work with me. It’s all about stats and rotation.

deft vessel
#

I'm good, thanks, I'm neither new to the game, nor to prot warrior, so I think I can find my way around things 🙂 thanks though

tribal rover
#

No problem was just trying to help.

blazing shuttle
#

Why do people shit on Last Stand? It's a free 30% heal and +30% HP. On big keys when starting a big pull, or after a buster, it can be a life saver.

#

Sure it's not BROKEN, but...

deft vessel
#

because it's not damage and it's on the path to damage I assume

tribal rover
#

I use it

deft vessel
#

so people grumble that they need to take non-damage (albeit useful non-damage) for damage

tribal rover
#

Not in raid but in keys

blazing shuttle
#

Also LS is the node for Thunderlord.

#

And Thunderlord is bae

mellow bridge
#

because in any content that actually does dmg, 30% hp is super weak

blazing shuttle
#

In raid, I would agree, it feels like shit

mellow bridge
#

it's a 3 min cd that gets outclassed by demo shout

blazing shuttle
#

But in keys, damn do I love it

mellow bridge
#

lmao

blazing shuttle
#

Also, Thunderlord in keys <3

#

Demo shout, less than 20 seconds later, it's back.

hollow python
#

for weekly keys is colossus or MT preferred currently

frosty mango
#

I’ve been switching to hunker down in later keys and myth raid

#

Some of those spells are scarrrry

blazing shuttle
#

Does HD really help?

#

Actual question.

frosty mango
#

Helps a lot on fights like soulbinder imo

tribal rover
#

It’s good for king when you have to mitigate the beam

frosty mango
#

That mystic lash, espec if you take multiple

blazing shuttle
#

Just bring back spell block.

frosty mango
#

Dawnbreaker I also find it useful

blazing shuttle
#

Oh yeah I can imagine

frosty mango
#

Where you’re constantly getting ass blasted by shadow

#

The rest of the keys I’m not super sold on yet

#

As of now I only think dawn

blazing shuttle
#

Priory?.

frosty mango
#

And I didn’t really feel in danger until 17

tribal rover
#

I don’t use it on dawn but haven’t had a surv problem there yet.

frosty mango
blazing shuttle
#

Yeah

frosty mango
#

And you generally have wall up

blazing shuttle
frosty mango
#

And then the shadow blade guys after first boss, the big pull by the miniboss there

#

Imo that big pull in the building near the first miniboss is the scariest pull in any key right now

#

For tanks

tribal rover
#

Yeah I use spell reflect there just don’t think hd is needed but I’m only on 13-14 keys atm

hollow python
#

is it just preference for Colossus or MT for Mythic+ or is there a clear better performing spec?

frosty mango
deft vessel
#

from what I understand colossus is better early on at lower gear levels, but after mountain thane is clearly better?

frosty mango
#

Colossus is still viable but aoe damage will be less

#

A lot less

deft vessel
#

I see

#

good thing I like playing M+ and I like playing mountain thane 😄

tribal rover
#

I played colossus last season it was fun. Running mt this season

blazing shuttle
#

I wish Colo was better ngl.

#

Love playing full on bleeds.

deft vessel
#

I'll be damned lmao

frosty mango
#

in the church

#

its scary but efficient

blazing shuttle
#

Oh my goodness what in the masochism is that

#

I used to do it S2 but iwth the mobs in the back

frosty mango
#

honestly depending on timer

#

I think it may just be better split it

blazing shuttle
#

Yeah depends tbf

frosty mango
#

lose effiiciency but also reduce a lot of risk

blazing shuttle
#

Cause DB's timer is all about remmbering you remove 4 minutes because fo that last fuckiing boss

#

"Land already! LAND!!!"

mellow yoke
#

you do a pack

#

in the intermission

#

to save like a minute

blazing shuttle
#

Call me stupid, but I never thought of it.

#

Nor really checked higher level keys that do that.

mellow yoke
#

acidic eruption damage is meaningless

#

even if he casts non stop

pseudo wasp
#

whats better crafted 720 longsword or Oath-Breaker at 704 4/6 hero track from raid?

blazing shuttle
#

Oh yeah agreed.

mellow yoke
#

he wont kill your group

blazing shuttle
#

Boss deals little to no damages.

mellow yoke
#

so after he flies out

#

you go do a pack

blazing shuttle
#

Interesting.

mellow yoke
blazing shuttle
#

Thank you.

mellow yoke
#

p14 for example

#

cause it's a small pack

#

and if you blasted CDs on the

#

mob before boss

#

your CDS will align

#

for the pack

#

then mid p2 boss you have CDs again

#

and BL

blazing shuttle
#

I don't see P14

mellow yoke
#

the red one

blazing shuttle
#

Found it.

#

Yep.

#

So you land on P14

#

Or just body pull it to boss

mellow yoke
#

land there

#

and kill i

#

normally

blazing shuttle
#

Gotcha.

mellow yoke
#

it's just a little more AoE damage

blazing shuttle
#

Fair.

#

Thank you mate.

mellow yoke
#

but you save like a minute

blazing shuttle
#

Yeah it's enormous.

high latch
#

Wait, you do p14 inbetween p1 and p2 of last boss? It that a thing?

mellow yoke
#

it's been a thing for

#

2 weeks

high latch
#

Haven't done Dawn for 2 weeks, so that's a eureka moment for me

#

Thanks!

onyx spruce
#

What u guys suggest for crafting for prot warr is best ? i see some recommandations for belt and bracers with crit embelishment and on another i see wep and shield?

high latch
onyx spruce
#

well considering my current gear i will go with belt and bracers..

high latch
#

If you already have myth track shield and weapon, that is probably a great choice.

slow viper
#

Guys what rotation do we use to maximize dps?

high latch
slow viper
#

I play MT sometimes i feel like im pumping and some other times im at kind of low dps

high latch
#

I would check the Wowhead guide to see if you are making any obvious mistakes, but aside from that you'd need to link us a log or something to help you in any meaningful way.

slow viper
#

Kk many thanks i will check it out

#

What values of hast crit vers mast we should aimimg for?

high latch
# slow viper What values of hast crit vers mast we should aimimg for?

The only really important thing is to have enough haste. That means 21-25k so you can run ITF without losing too much Shield Block uptime. Before that you instead run Heavy Repercussions.
After that crit and vers is about equal for us, and mastery is slightly behind those. But ilvl is king, and mastery is not a bad stat.
You can also just sim your potential upgrades to get the correct answer each time.

slow viper
#

Thanks boys

fathom oasis
high latch
fathom oasis
#

In case you want to check it out

high latch
#

I will, thanks

fathom oasis
#

Boss cast does nothing if no one is close

high latch
#

My plan was to just send it in a key, but probably a good idea to see a clip.

fathom oasis
#

If you want to be safe, tank goes first in case a cast goes off while approaching, kicks and then everyone lands and goes ham

high latch
#

Sounds pug-safe to me. At least if I clearly communicate it before we start.

fathom oasis
#

Yeah, looks pretty safe

deft mortar
#

halls is ez now after nerfs

#

just stomped 14 despite inting resto

warm plinth
#

got on my hunter (war is close behind)

#

ezpz

rough egret
#

Ggs

#

Im nearly there too missing like 34 rating 😄

solid sun
fathom oasis
#

Even now so many routes skip a few slashers and it just kinda feels bad

neon elk
#

Halls feels weird now like its easier than before but somehow i have worse succes rate there..

fathom oasis
#

If anyone has a spicy new route please do share

solid sun
#

I’m so tired of pugs. Did 4 keys this morning and it’s time for a break for like a week

neon elk
#

Yea just failed streets 15 because 3 people decided they will brain freeze on last boss and not take portal ..

#

Pugs are wild

solid sun
#

Failed a gambit because the healer couldn’t dodge the circles on the ground on the last boss

#

Well there were other issues but that stuck out the most to me since it happened multiple times

neon elk
#

Yea and then u do a random 12 or 13 key where your pugs perform like mdi players out of sudden xd

solid sun
#

Two starred an ED

#

Then dps wanted to shit talk my route for 5 minutes

#

Like idk man we two starred it why am I getting shit on rn

neon elk
#

Some people are just different idk , bitching about everything doing bare minimum ..

deft mortar
#

after 1st boss

#

its so fkn easy

#

the 2 patrols are gone

neon elk
#

Those last 2mofos in flood are skiped by pulling them to one side and group huging the other , or is there anything special to it

warm plinth
deft mortar
#

I can't wait for them to make solo queue M+ and have a separate rating for it

urban portal
solid sun
#

I don’t really have fun without my friends

#

So I doubt I’d use it

strong forum
#

soloQ would cause more harm than good

#

sure it might get you into a key more often on average

#

but getting compliant teammates?

#

in a game where most pugs cant think for more than their arm is long when it comes to group comp

#

aint gonna go down well either youre gonna be held at gun point, get griefed or see more keys abandoned than ever simply BECAUSE you get so "quickly" into a new game (itll quickly have the same issues as solo shuffle pvp where a dps queue will be 10-20x longer than tank and especially healer queue)

frozen berry
#

Yeah healers and tanks have no point in soloqueing

#

You get in groups fast enough as is

bronze wraith
#

Is symbiotic ethergaze any good? the trinket puts up HPS similiar to my ignore pain at 710

high latch
bronze wraith
#

I am having a hard time with tank trinkets this season.

high latch
#

I can't see it matching your IP though.. I checked my last log when I used that trinket early in the season and my IP was ~50% of my "healing" and the trinket was ~20%.

strong forum
#

the secret is not pressing IP

#

and then doing very low keys

bronze wraith
#

What trinkets should I be aiming for?

mellow yoke
#

Brand is your n 1 bis

strong forum
#

your best trinkets come from raid

mellow yoke
#

and antenna is really strong

#

from M+ it's tome and pacemaker

high latch
bronze wraith
#

I have a 704 atenna and a 691 brand

high latch
#

Those are solid

bronze wraith
#

I have been using 710 ethergauze and 691 brand.

high latch
#

I'd use Antenna over Ethergauze 100%

mellow yoke
#

whatever that is

#

dont use it

high latch
#

It is a decent defensive trinket. But Antenna is much better.

bronze wraith
#

Is it just that good for damage?

mellow yoke
#

i mean

high latch
#

No, the crit gives you parry chance too

mellow yoke
#

3 orbs from antenna

#

is like

#

16k crit

#

which is a lott

strong forum
#

you get tanky from playing well

#

not from gear

high latch
#

Pretty much.. There are more defensive trinket and talent choices compared to pure damage, but the vast majority of your tankiness comes from your core gameplay.

strong forum
#

treat gear like the gas for your car

#

yeah you need it

#

but if you use the wrong gasm youll brick your motor, and even if your run premium gas, if a grandma is driving your corolla it aint going nowhere

#

but get a rally driver and hes shredding

high latch
#

Wise words. Never let your grandma tank your keys.

warm plinth
#

How did Nome know I drive a corolla 😱

warm plinth
#

That's a good show

bronze wraith
#

Nevermind. That is such a huge amount of crit

high latch
#

Yeah it's nuts.

strong forum
bronze wraith
#

Alsom why is champ gear 6 items level under heroic max?

high latch
#

Because Blizz doesn't want the gap to be bigger

strong forum
#

cuz hero gear is 6 ilvl below myth max

warm plinth
#

Hero is 13 below

#

Not 6

oblique quarry
#

Isn’t hero max 710 and myth max 723

strong forum
high latch
#

Yeah, the gap to myth is quite a bit bigger

warm plinth
#

Found the noob who doesnt play wow smh

strong forum
#

okay well

#

to my defense

#

i dont have one

warm plinth
#

I still love you

mortal cypress
warm plinth
#

True

high latch
#

True

mortal cypress
#

True

cerulean tusk
#

True

serene wave
#

Sorry what talent is ITF and what does it replace once I got enough haste?

high latch
serene wave
#

Thank you, I'll keep an eye on it as I think I have enough!

vital vale
high latch
#

Some people choose to just run HR regardless of their haste for easy SB uptime.

vital vale
#

yeah, shield charge fills in the blanks spaces

high latch
#

No, you're limited to about 95% uptime

vital vale
#

yeah but its enough

high latch
#

It is. I run ITF myself. It's just a misconception that running ITF with 21k+ haste gives you 100% uptime.

lime urchin
#

95% uptime in details or logs?

warm plinth
#

You won't hit 100% in either one. Will be less in logs ofc because it counts out of combat time

high latch
#

And for the sake of a complete argument: The important thing isn't actually the SB uptime. It's about maximizing how many melees you block.

lime urchin
#

Exactly

warm plinth
#

I have like 26k haste and I still have a moment or two now and then where I can't shield block or shield charge

high latch
#

Sure, you'll have a few milliseconds in the beginning of combat while charging in where it's not up, but it's practcally 100% with HR.

lime spruce
#

what's the min ilvl to feasibly tank a +10, working on my VDH alt and I'm at a modest 667 but climbing just fine

#

about to rip a +7

warm plinth
#

You could tank a 10 at that ilevel but getting invited is another story

lime spruce
#

well it's my key lol

high latch
#

Yeah.. It would be tough if everyone in the party was at that level, but you can tank it if you have decent people with you

warm plinth
#

Getting people to apply is also a bit sus

lime spruce
#

right on I'll keep on keeping on, got a pretty phat group for my +7, seems like if I offer my key I can get carry groups around me

urban portal
#

+3 the 7 and ask the guys if they wanna do the 10

pulsar epoch
#

guys is my haste a bit high ?

blazing shuttle
#

I'm more concerned about your ring not being enchanted.

pulsar epoch
#

i will enchant it xD

strong forum
#

cant tell if 42% is high

#

need a haste rating number

#

cuz we have so many multipliers it might even be low

pulsar epoch
high latch
blazing shuttle
#

`Don't go above 25k

#

And you're gucci

pulsar epoch
#

thanks

high latch
#

I've also heard it's fine to go to 27k, but I personally recommend 21-25k.

pulsar epoch
#

so how much crit is ok for rating

#

currently have 9700

high latch
#

I prefer to focus crit after I have enough haste so I would consider 10k crit a bit low, but it really doesn't matter much. It just means you have more of vers and mastery which is also good.

remote hollow
#

like... i feel like 30-35% of crit is good with flask up, about 18k crit ish? or so

high latch
#

The real answer is sim it. It'll tell you what stats are most worth to you at that moment.

remote hollow
#

yeah if u aim for as much dps

high latch
#

If you blindly focus on haste/crit then mastery and vers will suddenly be really good

remote hollow
#

but if u aim for "feeling good" then i might say 30-35 crit, about 15-20% vers and 40% haste

#

but again, its not sim and MY ONLY preferences

#

as dan say - sim if u aim for as much dps as possible

high latch
#

If you don't care about min-maxing you can just make sure to aim for 21-25k haste then chase ilvl.

pulsar epoch
#

thanks guess i need some crit items

#

as sim says

frosty mango
#

I like to live dangerously

high latch
#

Watch out or you're gonna get a speeding ticket

frosty mango
#

I read somewhere more haste lets me get my antenna orbs faster

#

-# that’s sarcasm don’t hit me

#

Wtb 90s str mastery trinket tho

#

Araz is my only real troll burst option and I am not here for it

slim egret
#

Hi, I have a question. How much damage does the combat stance do compared to the defensive stance?

strong forum
#

3%

slim egret
#

3% overall dmg?

strong forum
#

best case, yea

slim egret
#

in a dungeon?

strong forum
#

overall

#

everywhere

#

its just 3% crit chance

idle copper
#

is a 691 Brand any good against a 704 Pacemaker?

high latch
#

Brand is probably better, unless it's a short fight

strong forum
#

thats a sim question dracthyr_nod

mental charm
#

so i got a question for y'all

idle copper
#

ty

mental charm
#

what is the best overall time you should have on the uptime of your defensives? (i.e ignore pain, shield block, shield wall, etc.)

strong forum
#

yes

high latch
#

Agreed. Yes.

pallid quiver
#

As much as you can as long as they're active when you absolutely need them

strong forum
#

SB uptime should be yes
ignore pain should be yes, SW should be used frequently on mechanics and when gathering packs

#

the game aint as easy as "okay you want 93.5% exact uptime on this"

#

you want to ensure to always have SB up when actively tanking

#

IP to smooth damage intake, it should be up 80% rotationally anyway from just playing

#

SW is an 8sec defensive, use it as you are about to take large damage

#

you aint trying to fill a bar or file your taxes

mental charm
#

okay. i appreciate your answer. i've just been going over trying to optimize my gameplay

viral grove
#

Just got AOTC thanks to stuff I learned here

lusty grotto
grim pilot
#

You should strive to rotate your defensives actively on packs

#

Almost always u should have something running

#

Demo shout, wall

#

Uptime is w.e

cerulean tusk
bleak breach
#

How do I sim for using d stance vs battle stance? Or does anyone know the rough difference?

lusty grotto
#

youre always in battle stance in sims

#

do you want to sim def stance?

bleak breach
#

Just curious of the damage difference

lusty grotto
#

1 second

#

actions.precombat+=/defensive_stance,toggle=on try this in the custom apl

#

but im not sure if it'll work

bleak breach
#

Ahh yep

cerulean tusk
#

Ya telling me that our sims are inflated?

lusty grotto
#

if i got the key wrong it wont, i gotta check whats the specific name

cerulean tusk
#

3% aurabuff when to compensate?

fathom oasis
latent steppe
#

is it best to play colossus or mountain thane for the keys above +15??

lime spruce
round pendant
#

wtf is with hoa final boss

#

+9 on my alt

#

it almost one shots everyone

strong forum
#

He's the final boss, clearly supposed to be hard!!

pallid quiver
#

i'd recommend them to press a defensive at the single point where he pumps notable unavoidable damage out

warm plinth
#

What almost one shots?

pallid quiver
#

There's other aoe pulses when statues get tossed, but it's minor in comparison

warm plinth
#

I didn't even die to that on 13 though

#

Without a defensive

#

On hunter XD

cerulean tusk
#

HoA last boss got something that kills?

pallid quiver
#

I wager most people are heavy undergeared who are running +9s at this point

or are the special kind of bad where they just somehow take more damage

warm plinth
#

Well it does significant damage

#

But it's also somehow bugged

cerulean tusk
#

I just stand in all the mechanics, doesnt bother me

warm plinth
#

Because sometimes you take the aoe from every statue, sometimes just one or two

cerulean tusk
#

get knocked? Free chrage

warm plinth
#

And sometimes not at all

humble relic
#

Would anyone happen to have a Shield Block WA that shows how much duration you have on the shieldblock?

warm plinth
#

You can make one with a template

#

New pre-made aura, choose if you want icon/ bar/ whatever, choose shield block and then when you want it shown

humble relic
#

tyvm!

cerulean tusk
#

play BDK they said, it is fun they said

#

I miss shieldblock

warm plinth
#

I really want to know who at blizzard thought ms effects were a good idea when blood dk exists lol

pallid quiver
sharp gale
#

Or that it is SO FUN bdk rotation consumes his armor mitigation

cerulean tusk
#

its fine, the more damage you take, the more you heal!

#

Oh wait...

warm plinth
deft mortar
#

what is good M+ score

#

with pugs

humble relic
#

For a fresh warrior what gems do I use for Cyrces?

lusty grotto
#

no idea why you would run it

#

since veteran gear is better

#

probably easier to just run weekly events than getting that ring atm

#

and/or the hollowfall thing

silk apex
grim pilot
sharp gale
#

I feel like over 3k a safe score territory / you get few rotten apples

prime sphinx
#

somehow got all the jewelry from my deathless taza runs - haste/crit neck, haste/crit ring and now haste/vers ring

fathom oasis
fathom oasis
#

had a dude with 3.2k who refused to do a +10 after wiping on the first pull

#

even as the other 4 wanted to continue. After 4-maning 4 packs easily people refused to continue because they didnt want to 4man the whole dungeon and have said person get loot from it

fathom oasis
# sharp gale

this has nothing to do with DK effect, it has to do with people who consider themselves very skilled sometimes look down on people who don't have a rating as high as they do

sharp gale
solid sun
#

Today I had someone with 2700 io shit talk my friend who also has 2700 io for being a “low io child”

#

:D

#

Everybody out here wildin’ out

fathom oasis
#

nah, the DK effect is about how you overestimate your abilities when you have no knowledge in a specific field

sharp gale
#

They don’t see how vastly not that skilled they are so they are over confident / toxic

fathom oasis
#

nah, they are skilled

#

just assholes

#

in the case i'm outlining at least

#

you can be both skilled and toxic

sharp gale
#

3k900 plays a game I couldn’t comprehend the scale

solid sun
#

Don’t be so hard on yourself

#

You’re so skilled dude

fathom oasis
#

there's always people that are more skilled than any particular person, but I wouldn't say people over 3.2k rio are not skilled (in general) as they are within the top 1% of players

pallid quiver
#

gottem

sharp gale
solid sun
#

I just got so owned

sharp gale
#

above average is my motto keks

fathom oasis
#

you can recognize your skill without being an asshole, in fact i think it's healthy to realize what you are good at, and what needs improving

round pendant
#

Ha this conversation again

sharp gale
#

Nop, to me, recognizing I’m a good player mean everyone who are under me are bad, so I wouldn’t touch this path too close

pallid quiver
#

I couldn't care less what I'm good at, just what there is to improve

#

being good will happen eventually as a result

round pendant
#

I got called an elitist last time this came up

#

Even tho I was just saying 3k is way more accessible than people think, effectively

sharp gale
#
  • that
pallid quiver
sharp gale
#

Time spent gaming is the skill most people fashion in wow

#

I don’t fashion time spent

round pendant
#

Top 10% or whatever 3k is ATM isn't that much when most of the player base isn't trying

fathom oasis
#

no way 3k is top 10%

#

i think 2.7k is 10%

round pendant
#

Top 10% amongst players who put in time and effort? Yeah that's a good player

sharp gale
#

Rocking your head in 12s-13s 3 hours everyday, you will get your 3k, I don’t see as skill, but I acknowledge if you pick someone over 3k, you have more chance to find someone « good »

round pendant
#

Rio is just not a good metric of skill outside of the high end

fathom oasis
#

where is the line drawn between a player who puts said time and effort

#

and how could you even measure it

sharp gale
round pendant
#

80 20 rule

#

20% of the effort gets you 80% of the way there

#

And the way rio works

#

Since you can't lose it and keys that'll take you to 2500 or so don't require much skill

#

Since objectively they're easy enough you can get to that rating by just hitching a ride with puggers

#

You don't even have to kick and 1 button rotation is enough

#

So that's where I'd draw the line personally

fathom oasis
#

what does objectively easy even mean

#

my grandma would not be able to reach 2.5k

round pendant
#

Low failure rate, you can ignore most mechanics and still pass as nothing is all that punishing

fathom oasis
#

ease is not something objective, it's subjective by its very definition

#

in any case, 3.2k is the top 1% of all m+ players. Even if you think only 20% of people try, that's still the top 5%

solid sun
#

Difficulty is not a good discussion or descriptor imo

#

Some people say dark souls games are very difficult and other people do hitless no armor runs like it’s nbd

round pendant
#

3.2k is notably harder than 3k

fathom oasis
#

yeah, that was the rating from the guy i had a bad experience with, that couldn't be arsed to do a 10 because of a single wipe

#

i'm sure the guy was skilled

round pendant
#

It is kinda of the sweet spot for arrogant people I've noticed too tho

#

So you're not wrong

#

They're just ahead of the curve of people who try to push and it gets to their head

#

But they're awful compared to 3.5k+ players

fathom oasis
#

for sure

round pendant
#

3k players are chill

#

Hope you reported that guy

fathom oasis
#

yeah, but the system is kinda crap, you can only report for having an unappropiate name (not applicable) or for unappropiate communication (which only allows stuff like: spam, scam and stuff like that)

round pendant
#

Yeah I noticed that but apparently if you click their frame and report you get different options

solid sun
#

^

round pendant
#

Doesn't work for me but I figured it was a Cell issue

fathom oasis
#

nope, only displayed those 2

#

and trying to report for any reason in the "communication" field threw back an error, indicating it could only be done from a chat line

neon elk
#

Try to click their name in chat and report it that way

fathom oasis
#

i guess those reports need to be associated to the actual chat

#

yeah, that's what we did in the end

nocturne spindle
#

uhh

#

theres like a vaguely gameplay one under communciation i think

#

which is what i report them as

fathom oasis
#

but 2-4 reports for what would be considered the same as spamming probably amounts to nothing, sadly

#

the /abandon system has been a huge success imo, hopefully they implement ways to "punish" people who refuse to follow the vote in the future

nocturne spindle
#

thats what there for me

fathom oasis
#

Maybe because once you enter a m+ dungeon the contextual menu sort of changes? (like, you can't kick people from the group, for example)

#

Next time you enter a key, try and see if you get the same options inside

#

Because if that's the reason we shoulda dropped group before reporting I guess

round pendant
#

I don't think the abandon system really does anything

#

If one guy really doesn't want to play he's not gonna

small steeple
warm plinth
# nocturne spindle thats what there for me

Sadly this set of options is not consistently shown. And it's only available on the target frame of the person (not the party frame), and even then it's not always there. For example right now, I can't report either of my party members for that (even using their target frame), but if I target a random person in Dornogal, I can.

tacit viper
#

whose a good prot warr youtuber / streamer i can watch to improve my gameplay

frosty mango
#

The wowhead guide is well vetted and has great info

tacit viper
#

I'll make sure to keep that up then, thanks 🙂

reef junco
#

@tacit viper Plenty of streamers in Promotion channel, but if m+ is your thing Yodatv and Kira both do high keys and explain routes, cd rotation, party composition and encounter strategy.

shrewd grove
#

Please do not come in here asking why Yoda does weird shit, though. The answer is because he's a weirdo, and he's VERY frequently wrong about Prot Warrior

vestal epoch
lusty grotto
#

but warrior takes on that level, we really cant talk about since some of it can be feelcrafty

#

so class/spec specific

frosty mango
#

Streamers tend to do things that align with the level of content they are doing

lusty grotto
#

Sense and Plka are usually the ones we recommend the most @tacit viper

frosty mango
#

(No offense) you are not yoda or Kira and if you try to do what they do in your 12

#

It’s gonna end quickly and badly

lusty grotto
frosty mango
#

Also people like yoda and Kira play with set groups who are very good at pressing their buttons

#

Also they are just better than us

#

At the game in general lol

lusty grotto
mortal cypress
frosty mango
#

We need to get yoda in this discord

#

So we can have a 3 way death match between yoda, Kira, and sense

#

Nome can officiate

lusty grotto
#

and plka (but plka has been around forever as well)

lusty grotto
#

and dorki

#

since naowh has been around

frosty mango
#

Gillick too?

lusty grotto
#

since pretty much forever

frosty mango
#

How deep do we go!

#

It’s a royal rumble

mortal cypress
latent badger
#

corn.

#

King of pop - corn.

lusty grotto
#

"is that the weekend?"

toxic pewter
#

Wat every1 doin

mortal cypress
#

questin

hot dome
#

ok nvm i dropped shield block for .1 seconds and got instantly deleted, completely on me

mortal cypress
hot dome
#

🙁

lusty grotto
#

reflect shadowblades

#

look at our pinned blockable/reflectable guide, always updated

#

it will help reset stacks

frosty mango
#

They also enrage

#

Depending on key level you gotta kite

#

Tacticians are scary scary

fathom oasis
#

heroic leap is the best defensive keks

solid sun
#

Did you know that heroic leap resets the CD on taunt

lusty grotto
#

every single time

solid sun
#

@frosty mango do you have an updated halls route

sinful copper
sinful copper
solid sun
sinful copper
#

Chat is this Photoshop

lusty grotto
#

sorbitol youve been here so long

sinful copper
#

Jk

lusty grotto
#

oh thank god

sinful copper
#

Nim u know we've crossed paths before?

#

Irl (in-game)

solid sun
lusty grotto
#

have we

solid sun
#

Otherwise I'll do some weird W route

sinful copper
#

Yeah I joined a key with u, 13 halls I think, on my frost dk

#

And it failed in first 10 min

#

So it was fleeting

#

Also, my friend is your guild leader

frosty mango
#

for pull 8 (first boss) the 2 guys are technically extra but I pull them for funnel

#

if you dont have an arcane or dh just skip them

#

make sure you do pull 2 before 3 (second shard) bc doing back 2 back shards is misery for the healer

lusty grotto
solid sun
#

You fight the dudes channeling onto the boss?

fathom oasis
frosty mango
solid sun
#

holy guacamole

fathom oasis
#

usually see 9 and 10 together

sinful copper
lusty grotto
frosty mango
sinful copper
#

Like 3-4 days ago

frosty mango
lusty grotto
#

before or after the nerfs?

sinful copper
#

After

frosty mango
#

if youre running like a 10

lusty grotto
#

lol

frosty mango
#

id prob do 9/10/11 together tbh

lusty grotto
#

well small world

#

its a good guild i like it

sinful copper
#

Yeah it is haha

#

To both

lusty grotto
#

but i need to pull my weight a lot more

#

going from arms to fury has been kinda rough for me

#

and relearning havoc to boot

frosty mango
#

halls is pretty w key now really the only thing I think people consistently miss is you can pull the trash into the third boss easily bc it doesnt do anything and taking a class with mortal strike makes a massive timer difference bc the miniboss at the end dies like a billion times faster if you do

lusty grotto
#

which is... a lot more complex than i remember in BFA lmao

#

at least pre-s3 tier

#

now its just

#

seems complex, but is fucking easy

frosty mango
#

pwar/rsham/dh/arcane/fdk is prime halls group
dh has mortalstrike and funnel
fdk has mass aoe
arcane funnel nukes shards

lusty grotto
#

yeah

#

agreed

fathom oasis
lusty grotto
#

this is mine

#
#

oops

#

the three collectors in front of first boss

#

as long as you tag em

#

they literally come back to life

#

and you can funnel into the boss

#

they do nothing, the cast you use a stop on

fathom oasis
#

ye, but they heal back up to full

lusty grotto
#

free count

#

yeah

fathom oasis
#

so timing is kinda weird

lusty grotto
#

not really

#

that benefits a funnel team

sinful copper
fathom oasis
#

like, you need to get there before they get sucked

#

but if you are there too early, you are wasting time

lusty grotto
#

eh

#

not really

#

but if you do get there late, your dps is just fucking sucking

frosty mango
lusty grotto
#

you use them to build resource

#

and for free funnel

fathom oasis
#

that's why i was planning on doing funnel with other packs

frosty mango
#

ret is great in dawnbreaker

lusty grotto
#

nah dude

#

collectors dont do shit

#

literally

#

easiest caster in the dungeon

#

dunno why people even kick them

#

you just play a dumb stop

#

thats it

frosty mango
#

you pull collectors in the beginning

#

its literally free %

fathom oasis
#

i just told you why i dont like it haha, it has nothing to do with them being dangerous

lusty grotto
#

i love it

fathom oasis
#

i understand tho

lusty grotto
#

so im doing it every time

#

especially with funnel

#

plus if you let halkias nuke em without tagging

#

they arent worth count

fathom oasis
#

when i was starting out this season, i had an arcane mage flame me for pulling those 3 with the boss haha

lusty grotto
#

but if you do tag em, and funnel into boss, they are worth count

fathom oasis
#

how the turn tables

#

yeah

lusty grotto
#

that mage is an idiot

#

especially if hes arcane

fathom oasis
#

he was, but this was a 6 or so

lusty grotto
#

lol

fathom oasis
#

actually, it mightve been a 10

lusty grotto
#

low key people are toxic af

fathom oasis
#

it was my 2nd day on pwar duty lmao

#

all i remembered from HoA back in the day was invis potting after Halkias

#

and now every mob on that patio can see invis lol

lusty grotto
#

i think we're probably 1 week into the period where 10s become infinitely more difficult than 14+

fathom oasis
#

it's a matter of timing

lusty grotto
#

not only cause of the io curve, but because these people are super toxic

fathom oasis
#

i feel like wednesdays (eu) 10s are free

#

tuesdays, however...

lusty grotto
#

oh last day is always cursed, its sunday for us

fathom oasis
#

i remember a 3h weekly grim batol 10 from S1

lusty grotto
#

err monday

#

not sunday lol

fathom oasis
#

10s now are so easy in comparison

gentle oracle
#

hey, super new to prot and tanking in general. I've timed a couple 7-10s with guildies relatively smoothly, but what's general order of actions people are taking for gathering a big pack alone?

like for instance grabbing everything in the streets mailroom to LoS back outside. I had shield wall and ignore pain up but it felt super sketchy

lusty grotto
lusty grotto
#

and not SB

#

SB is your biggest and most important cd

#

it is the one mitigation that needs to be up

#

not IP

#

IP will be up with proper play

#

i.e. hitting it at 70 rage regardless of its value, keeping track of it is not important

#

that being said, you just taunt and heroic throw out

#

thats it

quaint fossil
#

is warrior threat weak, i keep losing aggro?

lusty grotto
#

not even close no

#

whats your weapon ilvl

#

do you have 4pc?

#

are you thane?

gentle oracle
#

I think it's three unique packs in there, just heroic throw one, taunt another, charge to the third and then heroic leap out?

lusty grotto
#

no

#

i just heroic throw and taunt all 3

#

and run out

#

and then just massively aoe in the door lmao

warm plinth
#

It's 4 packs no? 2 to the immediate left, one far left, one right

lusty grotto
#

yup

gentle oracle
#

man, why did I think throw had a cooldown???

lusty grotto
#

well yes and no

fathom oasis
#

shattering throw does

gentle oracle
#

ah, because it does on arms lmao

lusty grotto
#

and in fury

warm plinth
#

I've definitely split some of those up magically before

gentle oracle
#

silly me

warm plinth
#

XD

gentle oracle
#

that makes WAY more sense

lusty grotto
#

yeah so sometimes the right pack

#

you pull a mob and the rest just stay there

#

they have weird social agro

warm plinth
#

Same though

fathom oasis
#

the problem with that strat is that they always free the chicken right?

warm plinth
#

No, the chicken is random

#

It's either a smuggled animal or the chickens

#

Just depends what's in the cage the mob goes to

solid sun
#

Hey @frosty mango

quaint fossil
solid sun
#

A+ route. The whole squad gave me mad props for coming up with it myself

lusty grotto
fathom oasis
# lusty grotto not even close no

tbf, if I'm going into a pull with 3-4 separate groups and Avatar is not up (and don't have a banked thunderblast) aggro gets real sketchy when the DH and the arcane mage decide to focus 2 separate mobs x)

lusty grotto
#

a weapon's ilvl dictates its damage, and it damage directly goes into your abilities

#

in the form of AP

#

it is the single most important boost to DPS

#

and thus threat

gentle oracle
#

weapon ilvl is massively higher value than another piece

quaint fossil
#

ok even with shield slam and thunder clap, i struggle to hold aggro in raid

lusty grotto
#

similarly how shields are the single most important boost to defensivness

lusty grotto
#

not for us

#

but its only 2nd to that

gentle oracle
#

or, for attack output

#

yeah, shield good

lusty grotto
fathom oasis
lusty grotto
#

you shouldnt have a 691 ilvl weapon at this point in time

quaint fossil
#

just an alt

warm plinth
#

not my rogue rn

lusty grotto
#

alts can craft too

#

use those sparks

warm plinth
#

Nim no bully I haven't had the chance yet

lusty grotto
#

im talking to the other guy lol

#

i know thats a recent alt in your case

#

anyway thats not a warrior specific problem

#

any tank loses agro with a huge disparity in weapon ilvls with dps

#

and there's a huge disparity with an ilvl 691 weapon vs 720ilvl or 723 ilvl weapons

solid sun
fathom oasis
#

don't bring any dps, that way they can't pull threat 🙂

frosty mango
frosty mango
solid sun
# frosty mango wa

A+ route. The squad loved it. They gave me mad props for coming up with it myself

frosty mango
#

hey theres enough to go around, just rename it in 3chest and pretend its yours

frosty mango
#

when my dk and dh friends are doing 50m dps

#

and I have to wait to pull the next pack until I have a thunderblast proc

#

its wild living in a world where youre doing 15m dps as the tank and losing aggro

mortal cypress
frosty mango
lusty grotto
#

not the same situation at all

#

he was specifically talking about raid

#

and..

#

we have absolutely no idea hes playing with the same caliber of players

#

but im willing to bet

#

hes not

#

or they

onyx prairie
#

#showtooltip
/cast Ignore Pain
/cast Shield Slam

#

is this a macro that i must use to make it eaiser?

lusty grotto
#

no

#

thats a macro intended for people that know what they are using it for

#

which is NOT to Shield Slam

#

you need a separate bind for shield slam

#

you only use that macro to IP

#

its not intended to reduce key bindings

onyx prairie
#

is there macro to use to make things easier like this one ?

#

im just really new

lusty grotto
#

that one isnt

#

to make it easier

#

and no, there's none

#

at best you can only do targetting mods aka cursor macros for targetting reticules etc

#

but there's no such thing as macros to make it easier

#

other than that

shrewd lake
lusty grotto
#

its not not optimal

#

it will work against you as tank

#

its worse than not optimal

#

you flat out shouldnt use it, if youre going to use that way

frosty mango
lusty grotto
#

🤷‍♂️

#

i forgot how fucking wild pugging heroic raid is

#

LOL

#

massive amount of critters in them groups

solid sun
#

That's me every Tuesday, partner

fathom oasis
#

what i hate about doing the raid in a pug is how when you reach soul hunters suddenly every ret/frost/fury are all tanks in disguise

lusty grotto
#

and me

#

on my DH

fathom oasis
#

goddamnit

#

i suck through all the earlier bosses so i can do it as tank

lusty grotto
#

to be fair i pull my weight well on DH

fathom oasis
#

does it have a greater chance to drop if more people have tank spec selected?

lusty grotto
#

nah

fathom oasis
#

on my last run i counted a total of 9 tanks or so and it didnt drop

#

isnt loot tied to people in the raid tho?

#

like, can mail drop if there are no shaman/hunter/evokers?

pallid quiver
#

Ye

#

Mail can drop if there's no mail classes

fathom oasis
#

oh really

pallid quiver
#

Yeah, since raids are no longer personal loot

fathom oasis
#

i thought we were still riding on some sort of personal loot hybrid

pallid quiver
#

The closest to that is the warbound drops

#

which are just entirely separate from the drops from bosses

fathom oasis
#

ya

torpid dome
lusty grotto
#

HEH HEH

pallid quiver
lusty grotto
#

dw i dont ever win rolls

pallid quiver
#

so you don't even have to be in disguise

#

In fact, prot loot spec gives you more things you can roll on on Loom

torpid dome
#

But alr, then I can stay prot

pallid quiver
torpid dome
#

Ither than antenna i dont need the other stuff from hc raid

pallid quiver
#

If you ever pug mythic, it should be notable, since that's the only crit/haste shield this season that's not crafted iirc

torpid dome
#

Yep

#

Were starting myth progging tonight

frosty mango
#

im feeling like antenna is sim bait

#

uptime is m+ is so suspect

#

pacemaker feeling like a better functional choice

lusty grotto
#

didnt drop

#

forever brandless even on alts

frosty mango
#

im rocking a lfr brand

#

i know the pain

lusty grotto
#

bro what is up with the 100 rolls

#

this chinese warrior

#

rolled 100 on netherprism AND 98 on the SECOND netherprism

#

i swear to christ the roll hacks are real

#

oh sorry no

#

95 and 100

#

the 2nd one got won BY ANOTHER 100

#

fucking wild

#

bootless and brandless

#

the worst of both worlds, for dps spec and tank spec

restive oak
#

get good

quiet pagoda
glacial socket
#

what sim you use for prot? 5 target patchwerk or? :>

high latch
#

Personally I do the first 2.

cerulean tusk
#

I just do 1t 4m, and 8t 4min

No buffs

livid hill
#

hey folks i have question. i noticed im having sometimes a hard times tanking mythics, im losing aggro from time to time and its kinda hard to get it all back. i noticed this on my recent +11 floodgate. (3krio s2 prot warrior here, 710ili)

blazing shuttle
#

I was told this section is bad. What could I change?

#

(Note: This is with BL.)

jagged pier
#

Isnt it standard to do everything in the room with lust

#

Then the 2 packs on the stairs after?

blazing shuttle
#

Idk.

#

Mage cried out because it was 'trash route'.

vital oak
#

mage should play tank then

pallid quiver
#

Mage can cry that they're dum and probably not even pressing defensives on divine toll

blazing shuttle
#

(I did not go for the pack of the lft directly cause hunter lusted on the first boss.)

torpid dome
blazing shuttle
#

Also, first pull:

pallid quiver
#

really there's not much you can do there; if you lust and people don't die, you can do whole room or an extra pack

blazing shuttle
#

Mage died, and said it was because of 'trash route'

high latch
blazing shuttle
#

Note: I got everyone in the corner, boss did NOT move me an INCH.

pallid quiver
#

mage should stand in melee instead of narnia

vital oak
#

sounds like a whining mage, that first pull looks fine

pallid quiver
#

so there's no traps at their feet

blazing shuttle
#

Also:

#

Mage did not stack on first boss.

#

And put pools everywhere.

torpid dome
#

Ye whiney mage, that first pull is standard

high latch
#

Yeah, just ignore the mage

blazing shuttle
#

(He was also 6.71M DPS.)

#

(Arcane, too. Third.)

livid hill
#

hey folks i have question. i noticed im having sometimes a hard times tanking mythics, im losing aggro from time to time and its kinda hard to get it all back. i noticed this on my recent +11 floodgate. (3krio s2 prot warrior here, 710ili) does prots having problems with threat holding?

pallid quiver
blazing shuttle
#

Thank you fellas.

pallid quiver
#

so if it has trouble holding threat, every other tank spec would be unviable

blazing shuttle
#

Prot war is the DPS who has the best snap aggro in the game rn.

torpid dome
#

Have crafted weap? Or mth track weap?

blazing shuttle
#

Is he playing colo or MT?

livid hill
#

have crafted weapon and shield

high latch
#

Yeah, weapon is important

scenic hearth
#

Hey, that a good idea to macro shield slam + ignore pain ?

torpid dome
#

Crafted 720 weap you should not be losing aggro

livid hill
#

i have it

blazing shuttle
#

In that kind oif case, Intimidating Shout.

#

I hate burning it like that, but sometimes?

#

No choices.

livid hill
#

yeah...

torpid dome
#

Yeah i pref to keep it for aoe interrupt

blazing shuttle
#

Is he playing MT or Colo, though?

blazing shuttle
torpid dome
#

But some pulls I need to use it to solidify my aggro

high latch
pallid quiver
pallid quiver
#

which is very likely to happen

blazing shuttle
#

DPS need to understand a tank needs like.

#

One second, perhaps two at a first pack/not chaining to just.

#

Set up a bit but like you guys said:

#

The typical ret paladin that will throw everything right as the pull starts and will be surprised they died.

torpid dome
#

Make sure tho while building your pull that you thunderblast everything

blazing shuttle
#

Yep.

#

And make sure to not waste Thunderblast charges by activating Avatar with Thunderblast charges available.